On the Behavior of Upwind Schemes in the Low Mach Number Limit

HAL Id: inria-00073529

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073529

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

On the Behavior of Upwind Schemes in the Low Mach

Number Limit

Hervé Guillard, Cécile Viozat

To cite this version:

Hervé Guillard, Cécile Viozat. On the Behavior of Upwind Schemes in the Low Mach Number Limit.

RR-3160, INRIA. 1997. �inria-00073529�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

On the Behavior of Upwind Schemes

in the Low Mach Number Limit

Herve´ Guillard , Ce´cile Viozat

N˚ 3160

Avril 1997


()*+' ,- !.0/213$546'7*+8$9: ;)<>=?A@CBED#FHGIGHJK=MLONQPSRT@>UVFHGI<XWYFIZ\[]J_^EN\N `badcegfihTjlk]mnepodqsrutvmxwVyYft'w{z|tvmxegms}~rt~mnw{y € f}~]}‚t~c8egf8}'ƒwVegzdqxf„|f8} ….†~w{‡ˆft‰k]Šˆ‹‰Œ‰k rzdzKw{†~t € fi†vf8ƒ:adf8†vƒ:adfŽyp{’‘8“{”6j–•A—]†~mnq.‘8˜V˜>™ij(š›z’r{œ{f8} žAŸ8 ¡u¢d£{ {¤ `badms}iz’rzKf†izd†vf8}~fy>t:}‰r{yCrV}‚]egz|t~w{t~msƒr{y’rqn|}‚ms}‰mxyCz_wu¥¦f†§w¨©t~adfªErVƒ:a«y]ode¬_f8†§w{¨ tvadfg­’o|„ € mx®Kf8†~f8y’ƒf}~zdqnm¯t~t~mnydœ«r{zdzd†vw°„]mne"rutvmxwVy«w¨¦t~a’f)ƒwVeTz’†~fM}~}~mx¬’qxf"±.odqnf†pf8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}imny+t~adfqnwu¥ ªXr{ƒ:a³y]odep¬Kf†qxmnegm¯tM´XµCf)zd†vwu—{fgtva’rutt~adf3}‚wVqxo|tvmxwVy’}w{¨bt~adf € mn}vƒ†vftvf)}~]}‚t~f8e¶ƒw{y>t:rmnyCz’†~fM}~}~od†vf ­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}w{¨#wV† € f†‰¸O¹)¥'admxqnftvadfpƒw{y>t~mny]odw{o’}zd†~fM}~}~od†vf}~ƒ8rqnf8}'¥'mxt~aXt~adfp}v²>o’r†vfºw¨#tvadfTªErVƒ:a y]ode¬_f8†8´E`badms}f„|zdqnr{mxy_}ºmxy»rY†~mnœ{wV†~wVo’}ie"rydydf8†¥'a]«tvadms}r{zdzd†vw°„]mne"rutvmxwVy6w{¨¦tvadf)ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}T¨Irmnqn}"t~w¼ƒwVegzdo|t~fE—Vf†v½}~od¬’}~w{ydmsƒ3­’wu¥º´¾µCfEt~a’fy¿}‚a’wu¥Àtva’rut)r+zd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmxy’œCw{¨ tvadfgy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq € mn}v}~mxz’rt~mnw{y«t~fy_}‚wV†ir{qxqnwu¥}Át~wY†~fMƒwu—Vf†‰r3ƒwV†~†vf8ƒt§}vƒr{qxmnydœ)w{¨Stvadfgzd†~fM}~}~od†vf{´`badfM}‚f tvadfwV†~ft~msƒr{qK†vf8}~odqxtv}'r{†~f§t~w{tvr{qxqn)ƒwVy|’†vegf € ¬>)y>o’eTf8†~msƒr{qÃf„|zKf†vmxegfy>t:}´

ÄEÅ>Æ\ÇvÈpÉ ¡uÊŸ{¤ Ë wu¥7ªEr{ƒ:aCy]odep¬Kf†MÌÍ­_o|„ € m¯®\f†vfy’ƒf}‚z’qxmxt‚tvmxydœ«odz]¥'mxy € }vƒ:adf8eTfM}̍'w]f}~ƒ:a’fegf{Ì z’†~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmnydœ

ÎsÏÑЂÒÔÓ8Õ'ÐbÖ×nÒÔØÚÙÛ

܉ÝdÞàßá:âäãsåæAçˆèêéçëìíMâäãäãîá:èHïðñHò·ó°ô°âîáMëâäõ°èIâîáMëöxè Ü·Ü ÝdÞàßá:âäãså÷\ç‚øˆâäãäç·ëù#âäò·ú‚ávûÔðñÚò·ó°ôMâîáMëâäõ°èHâîáMëöxè



 8$9·A6¦:À
p$543A23 ,- !.

 Ÿ ¤ f§z’r{zdmxf8†bzd†M}‚f8y>t~f§odydfiry’r{qx|}~f§rV}‚]egz|t~w{t~ms²>odf‰f8ytvf†veTf € o3ydwVep¬d†vf € fªErVƒ:a € f qrzdzd†vw°„|mxe"rt~mnw{yz’r{† € 8ƒw{egz_w>}‚mxt~mnw{y € f € mx®8†~f8y’ƒf € f¦­’od„ € fM}8²>o’rutvmxwVy’} € ±.odqnf†.zKw{od†.odyT­’o’m€ f ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfºqsrqnmxegmxt~f‰z_ft~mxtby’w{ep¬’†~f € f§ªErVƒ:aÑ´‹Áw{o’}©zd†vw{od—Vw{y’}S²Vo’fÁqnf8}¦}‚wVqxo|tvmxwVy’} € o)}‚|}‚t~c8eTf € mn}vƒ†vftpƒw{y>t~mnfydy’fy>t € f8}­’o’ƒt~o’rt~mnw{y’} € fzd†vf8}v}‚mnw{y’} € fqw{† € †vf € o³ydw{e¬d†vf € fªErVƒ:a+r{qxwV†v}º²>odf ƒfqnqxfM} € o½}‚|}‚t~c8eTf3ƒwVyVtvmxy]o½ƒw{y>t~mnfy’ydfy>t € f8}p­’o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’} € fz’†~fM}~}~mxwVy’} € f)qwV† € †vf € o»ydw{e¬d†vf € f"ªXr{ƒ:a6r{o6ƒ8r†v†V´ f8ƒmf„|zdqxms²>odf € fge"rydmnc†vf†vmnœ{w{o’†~f8o’}‚fpz_wVod†v²>odwVm.ƒft~t~f"rz’zd†~w°„|mne"rut~mnw{y € f8} M²>o’rutvmxwVy’}"zKw{od†qxfM}­’o’m€ fM})ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf8}"ydf6z_f8†~egft)z’r{} € f6ƒ8rqsƒodqnf† € f8}8ƒw{odqnfegfy>t:}gt~†vc8} }~od¬’}~w{y’mn²>odfM}´#‹wVo’}SegwVyVtv†~wVy’} f8y’}~odm¯tvf§²>oodyz’†Mƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydydf8eTf8y>t € o)t~fy_}‚f8od† € f‰qsr € ms}v}‚mnz’rutvmxwVy y]ode8†~ms²>odfpzKf†vegft € f†vftv†~wVod—{f8†Áody6w{† € †vf € fTœ{†:ry € f8od†‰ƒw{†v†~fMƒ·t € fpqsr)z’†~fM}~}~mxwVyÑ´ f8}§†M}‚o’q¯t:rutv} tvawV†~ms²>odf8}b}~w{y>tbt~w{tvrqnfegf8yVtÁƒw{y|Â_†~e8}¦z’r{†'qxfM}bf„|z8†~mnfy’ƒf8}by]ode†vms²Vo’f8}8´

;Ž

& <>=(?  8¡ É ÊA£ @É ? < ACBED Å £ É ?  @ ? É AŸ£{¢dŸ Å A F+BED Å ÊG@êŸM£¡ Å   Å £V¢dŸ Å H IKJ ¡ Å £ É ? ÊG@à @É ? ŠʾÊG@êŸ8Ÿ@ML¢| N@É ? <OI PKQ É ? £ ͟@É ? AF H g£R ? É]È Å ÊGS Å ?  MŸ ATI

pA"Y1)!S

ŠÔtims}‰¥¦fqnq]ydwu¥'yEtva’rutºmny6r €d€ mxt~mnw{yXtvw3ƒw{y]—{f8†~œVfy’ƒfpry € †vw{ody € Úw{® € mƒodqxt~mnf8}8ÌÃtvadfo’z>¥'mny € rz z’†~w°„|mnegrt~mnw{y’}bw{¨#t~adfTƒw{egzd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnfi­’odm€ ­’wu¥ f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}Á}‚o|®\f†Á¨ê†~wVe rVƒƒod†vrVƒzd†~wV¬dqnfe"}'mnyEt~adf Ë wu¥ªXr{ƒ:aYy]odep¬Kf†§qxmnegm¯tM´º`badf†vfr{†~ff„|z_f8†~mnegfy>tvr{qAf8—>m€ f8y’ƒfM}‰}~adwu¥'mnydœ"t~a_rutiw{y«rÂd„|f € egf8}~aÑÌ tvadf € ms}vƒ†vft~m f € }‚wVqxo|tvmxwVygw¨\t~adf‰ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnf¦­’odm€ ­’wu¥ f8²>o’rutvmxwVy’} r{†~f'ydw{tSryrVƒƒo’†vrt~f'rzdz’†~w°„|m e"rt~mnw{y3w¨t~adfºmny’ƒwVegzd†~fM}~}~mn¬dqxf§f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}If{´œ"}‚f8f ˜ h·´

• ƒwVegeTwVyf„|zdqsry_rut~mnw{y)w¨Ñtvadmn}©¨Ir{mxqnod†vf‰w{¨AƒwVeTz’†~fM}~}~mx¬’qxfo’z>¥'mny € }~ƒ:adf8egf8}©mn}©t~wTzdo|t¦¨êw{†v¥br† € t~adf †vw{qnfw{¨.t~adfTy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq € mn}v}‚mnz’rt~mnw{yÑ´§ŠyXodz]¥'mny € }vƒ:adfegfM}Ì_t~adfy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq € mn}v}~mxz’rt~mnw{yXrV}~}~w|ƒmsrut~f € ¥'mxt~a3tvadfitˆ¥©wgœV†~m€ ydw € fM}Ár{y € ms}bw¨t~adfi¨êwV†~e

  ! " $#&%'( % ) %+*   -,/. % ˆ‘0 ¥'a’f†vf  mn}'t~adfiegf8}~aE}‚m fVÌ ( % r{y € . % r{†~fi†vf8}~z_fMƒ·t~mn—{f8qxgtvadfºfmnœ{f8y]—°r{qxo’f8}bry € fmnœ{f8y]—{f8ƒt~wV†v}©w¨t~adf ‡‚rVƒwV¬dmnr{yYegrt~†vm¯„  Ì ) %+*   0, r†vfit~adfƒw]w{† € mny’rutvfºw¨t~adfÁ‡ˆodegz   ! ¬_ftˆ¥©f8fy3t~a’f—urqnodf8}Áw¨#t~adf ¨êo’y’ƒ·tvmxwVy¼ruttvadfœ{†vm€ ydw € f8}gry €1 mny+t~a’f¬’r{}~ms}º¨êw{†vegf € ¬]«tvadff8mxœVfy]—{fMƒ·t~wV†v}8´)Šy+tvadf)r{¬_wu—Vf f„|zd†~fM}~}~mnw{yÑÌ_t~adfg}~ode †~o’y’}§wu—{f†§rqnq#¥¦r°—Vf8}8´‰ŠÔ¨S¥¦fTmxy>t~†vw € o’ƒfr†~f¨êf†vfy’ƒfTªErVƒ:aXy]odep¬Kf†¸32¥©f }~fft~a’rtÁt~a’mn}§mneTz’qxmnf8}Át~a’rt§}~w{egfw{¨.t~adf¥¦r°—Vfp}‚zKff € } ( % ¬_fMƒwVeTfpzd†~wVz_wV†‚tvmxwVy’rqÑt~w546¸32u´‰`ba]o’} mny"tvadfqnwu¥¿ªXr{ƒ:a"y]odep¬Kf†©qxmnegm¯t©t~adfM}‚fÁt~f8†~e"}Sƒ8ry"œV†~wu¥ ¥'m¯tvadw{odt©¬Kw{ody € †~fM}‚odqxt~mnydœmnyry"f„dƒf8}v}~mx—Vf y]odegf8†~msƒr{q € mn}v}‚mnz’rt~mnw{yt~a’rtz_wVqxqno|t~fM}bt~a’f € mn}vƒ†vftvfº}‚wVqxo|tvmxwVyÑ´

µCfº¬_f8qxmnf—Vf§t~a’rt¦tvadms}'f„|zdqsry’rt~mnw{ymn}bwVydqx)z’r†~t~msrqnqxgtv†~o’fir{y € ydff € }¦t~wg¬Kfº†~f’ydf € ´87mn†v}‚t'¥©f †vfe"r{†+"tva’rutMÌ_mx¨#t~adf € ms}~}~mxz_rut~mn—{fitvf†ve"}r†vfºw¨.w{† € f8†94:6¸ 2 ̒t~adfpƒfy>t~f8†~f € t~f8†~e"}'mnyEt~a’fprzdz’†~w°„|m e"rt~mnw{y½}vƒr{qxf¥'m¯tva;4:6¸=<

2

H}‚f8f}~f8ƒ·tvmxwVy»š>´³`ba>o_}Tr{q¯tvadw{o’œ{a+t~a’f3r{eTz’qxmxt~o € fw{¨t~adf € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmx—Vf tvf†ve"}iegr°«œ{wt~wEmny|’ydmxtˆ{ÌÍt~adf8«¬Kf8ƒwVegfTy’fœ{qnmnœ{mn¬dqxfg¥'mxt~a+†vf8}~z_fMƒ·tit~wYtvadfƒf8yVtvf†vf € w{ydfM}ºr{}¸ 2 œVw]f8}©t~w? f8†~w_´.`badf†vf¨êwV†~fVÌVtvadfr{ƒ8ƒod†:r{ƒgzd†~wV¬dqnfee"r°r{ƒt~o’r{qxqn†vf8}~odqxt¦¨ê†vw{erpqsr{ƒ@w{¨Ay]odegf†vmsƒrq € mn}v}‚mnz’rt~mnw{y³mny’}ˆtvf8r € w¨†vf8}~odqxt~mnydœX¨ê†vw{ery¼f„dƒf8}v}w{¨y]odegf†vmnƒ8rqS—]ms}~ƒwV}~m¯tˆV´Ck]fMƒwVy € Ì#mxy»odz]¥'mxy € }vƒ:adf8eTfM}ÌKtvadfgy>o’eTf8†~msƒr{q € mn}v}~mxz’rt~mnw{yXms}ºrBADCEA)t~fy_}‚wV†?Imxy³š:GFHÁr{y € r{q¯tvadw{odœVa6}~w{egfTw¨ tvadf

(

%

œVw]f8}Ít~wimxyd’ydmxtˆ{Ìmxt.egr°i¥¦fqnq]¬_f¦t~a_rut#t~adf € ms}vƒ†vft~f¦f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}ͨêw{†:ƒf©t~a’fbrV}~}~w|ƒmsrutvf € ‡ˆodegz’}

) %+*   I, tvwgœ{wTt~w? f8†~w_´ J od†ºr{mxe mnyXtvadmn}i¥¦w{†KYmn}‰tva>o_}Átvwf„|zdqnr{mxy6mxyCr € ftvr{mxqnf € e"rydydf8†§t~adfTegf8ƒ:a’r{ydmn}~e ¬]E¥'admsƒ:a ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfiodz]¥'mxy € }vƒ:adf8eTfM}b¨IrmnqÑtvw)ƒwVegzdo|t~fp—{f†v)}~od¬’}~w{ydmsƒ§­’wu¥}8´¦`ba’fºt~w]w{qÍ¥©f¥'mnqnqÍo’}~fi¨êw{† tvadms}}ˆtvo € V̒ms}w{y’qx)r"}‚tvr{y € r{† € r{}~]egz|t~w{t~msƒºry’r{qx|}~mn}¦mnyEz_wu¥¦f†'w{¨tvadfpªErVƒ:a3y]ode¬_f8†8´MLwu¥¦f—Vf†MÌ tvadms}"ry’r{qx|}~mn}T¥'mnqxq'¬KfYz_f8†‚¨êwV†~egf € w{y½t~adf ! *($& (2@N&5 
T* mny’}‚t~fMr € w{¨ÁtvadfXƒwVyVtvmxy]odwVo’}Tw{ydfM}´ ªEw{†vf‰}~z_fMƒmxÂ_ƒr{qxqn{Ì]¥¦fÁ¥'mnqxqÃqnw]w>T¨êw{†©t~adfºrV}‚]egz|t~w{t~msƒ'¨êwV†~e tva’rut¦tvr>{f8}St~a’f € ms}vƒ†vft~fi}~]}‚t~f8e mxyt~adf qnwu¥ ªEr{ƒ:aYy]odep¬Kf†‰qxmnegm¯tM´`badfpr{y’rqn|}‚ms}b¥©fpz_f8†‚¨êwV†~egf € ms}Árg¨êo’qxqny’w{yÔqxmnydfMr†wVydfit~a’rt € w]f8}Áydwt †vf8²>odmn†vfbr{y]pqnmxydfMr†vm MrutvmxwVyw{¨_tvadfœ{wu—Vf†vydmnydœ‰fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}´#ªYw{†vfwu—Vf†MÌum¯tSr{zdzdqnmxfM}#t~wt~adf}‚t~fMr € T}ˆt:rut~f fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}br{}b¥¦fqnqÍr{}¦tvadfit~mnegf € fzKfy € fy>tw{ydfM}´#ŠÔt:}'e"rmny†vf8}~odqxt'ƒ8ryY¬Kfi}‚tvrt~f € rV}¦¨êw{qnqxwu¥}O Š yt~a’f§qnwu¥ ªXr{ƒ:a)y]ode¬_f8†'qxmnegm¯tMÌ|t~a’fi}~w{qno|tvmxwVyw{¨Ít~a’f ! *($& ( @N(5  
T* ƒw{y>t:rmny’}¦zd†~fM}~}~od†vfÁ­_o’ƒ! tvo’rutvmxwVy’}bw¨#w{† € f8†'ªXr{ƒ:aÑ´

}v²>o’r†vf§w¨t~adfªErVƒ:ay]ode¬_f8†8´

7’w{†At~adfb}ˆtvf8r

€

º}ˆt:rut~f©f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}8ÌurÁƒwVegeTwVyp}‚t~†:rut~f8œ{‰t~w‰wu—{f†:ƒwVegf#t~adfbƒwVy>—Vf†vœ{f8y’ƒf.zd†vw{¬’qxf8eg} f8y’ƒwVody>t~f8†~f € ¬]6ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf}‚wVqx—Vf†:}§mn}itvadfo’}~f"w¨  $8
!  

 ]ÌA“|Ì.™]Ì͐ Ú´D7dwVqxqnwu¥'mxy’œYr }~odœVœ{f8}‚t~mnw{y«mxy ä™: ¥©ft~†vmnf € mxy ›.t~wYo’}~fzd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmxy’œ3rV}§r3ƒo’†~fTt~wt~a’fr{ƒƒod†:r{ƒ3zd†vw{¬dqnfeY´ `ba’f†vf8}~odqxtv}T¥©f8†~ff„]t~†vfegf8qx³ƒwVy]—>mny’ƒmxydœ+ry € mxtgr{zdz_fMr†:}tva’rut"zd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmxy’œ«ms}Tr6zKwu¥©f8†‚¨êodq †vfegf € "t~wƒod†vf‰tvadfr{ƒ8ƒod†:r{ƒ"zd†vw{¬dqnfeY´SªYwV†~fº}~z_fMƒmxÂ_ƒr{qxqn{Ì]tvadf € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmx—VfÁtvf†veÀmny1‚‘0  ms}'ƒ:a’r{ydœ{f € mny>t~w 

  Hš>

¥'a’f†vf  ms}t~adfYzd†vf8ƒw{y € mxt~mnw{y’mxydœ6e"rut~†vmx„\´ LÁwu¥©f8—{f8†  &'T 
! $ (
&  !,&' *    3 ' 
 (' 
15
$&
O8!    
   $8
!  

"! ´½`badf8†~f¨êw{†vf{Ì#t~a’f3}vƒ:adfegfmn} r{qx¥br°|}'ƒwVy’}‚ms}‚t~fy>tÁ¥'mxt~a«t~adfpt~mnegf € fzKfy € fy>t‰fM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}Áry € w{ydqn)tvadfpy]odegf8†~msƒr{q € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmxwVyEmn} r{q¯tvf†vf € ´•qxt~adwVodœ{aCegw{†vfƒwVegzdqxf„Et~a’r{y6mny6t~adf"ƒrV}‚f¥'m¯tva6y’w3z’†~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmnydœ’ÌÃry+r{}~]egz|t~w{t~msƒ r{y’rqn|}‚ms}w¨ÁtvadfY†~fM}‚o’q¯tvmxydœ € ms}vƒ†vft~f3f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}gr{zdz_fMr†:}tvw+¬_f3t~†:r{ƒtvr{¬dqxfV´½ŠÔtzd†vwu—]m € f8}Tr € ftvr{m qnf € f„|zdqnr{y’rutvmxwVy6w{¨bt~adfegfMƒ:a’rydms}~e ¬]«¥'admsƒ:a³zd†vf8ƒw{y € mxt~mnw{y’mxydœYmny’ƒ†vf8rV}‚fM}§t~adfr{ƒƒod†:r{ƒ«w¨bt~adf }vƒ:adf8eTfM}´TŠ y+z’r†~t~msƒo’qnr{†8ÌÃmxtp}‚a’wu¥}Átva’rutz’†~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmnydœ 
%$&88 *(* tvadf"y]odegf†vmnƒ8rq € ms}v}‚mnz’rutvmxwVy tvf†ve"}¦rV}~}~w|ƒmsrutvf € t~wt~a’fiƒw{y>t~mny]odmxtˆgr{y € f8ydf†vœ{gfM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}S¬]rp¨Ir{ƒ·tvw{†O4:6¸ 2 ´ `ba]o’}8Ì|ƒw{y>tv†vr{†~mnqx tvwtvadfpydwVyÔzd†~fMƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydf € ƒr{}~f{Ì_t~a’fpydwVy € mxegfy_}‚mnw{y’r{q € ms}vƒ†vft~ff8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}‰ƒw{y>t:rmnyEydwtvf†ve w{¨ wV† € f†O4:6¸ 2 rV}¦mxyt~adfºƒw{y>t~mny]odw{o’}¦ƒrV}‚fV´ k]w{qn—]mxydœt~a’f8}~f‰fM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}©œVmx—Vf8}©zd†vf8}v}‚od†vf‰t~a’rt¦zKwV}v}‚fM}~}~f8} tvadf}vregf¸=<

2

}vƒr{qxmnydœ"r{}¦¨êwV†bt~adfƒw{y>t~mny]odw{o_}¦}~|}ˆtvfeY´

`badfbry_rqn]}~ms}Ñzd†vf8}~fy>t~f € mnyºt~adms}¥©wV†+§o’}~f8}'w]f}Ar{zdzd†vw°„|mxe"rutvfS'mnfe"ry’yp}‚wVqx—Vf†M´Í`badms}A}vƒ:adf8eTf zKwV}v}~f8}v}‚fM}Á}~w{egfpydmsƒfgrqnœ{f8¬d†:rmsƒi¨êf8rt~od†vf8}Át~a’rti}~mneTz’qxmx¨êEt~w3}‚wVegfpf„]tvfy>t‰tvadf € ms}~ƒ†~ft~fpfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}´ LÁwu¥©f8—{f8†8̒t~adfTry’r{qx|}~mn}Ámn}‰œ{f8ydf†:rqry € r{zdzdqnmxfM}tvwr{qxqAt~adfT}~ƒ:a’fegf8}Át~a’rt§ƒ8ryX¬KfTƒ8r{}‚t‰ody € f†‰t~adf ¨êwV†~e ‚‘0‰¥'mxt~a+re"rt~†vm¯„  t~a_rutºmn}‰tvadf#{rVƒwV¬dmnr{yXw¨St~adf"ƒwVy>t~mny>o’w{o’}‰­’o|„|fM}if—urqno’rutvf € rut}‚wVegf r°—Vf†:rœVf)¬Kftˆ¥¦ffy 3ry €  ´O`badfEw{o|tvqxmnydfXw{¨‰tvadms}z’r{z_f8†mn})r{}g¨êwVqxqnwu¥} XŠyt~a’fXydf„]t)}~f8ƒt~mnw{yÑÌ ¥¦fY†~fMƒr{qxq'adwu¥Àt~w € f8†~mn—{f3tvadfXƒwVy>—Vf†vœ{f8y’ƒfw¨§t~adfXƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfY± odqxf8†f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}tvwu¥¦r{† € t~adf mny’ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfw{ydfM}´‰‹f„]tMÌK¥¦fpr{zdzdqntvadf}vregfprV}‚]egz|tvwt~msƒf„|z’ry’}~mnw{y’}rV}ÁmnyEtvadfƒw{y>t~mny]odw{o’} ƒ8r{}~fTt~wYt~a’f € ms}~ƒ†~ft~f'w]f}vƒ:adfegfry € Â_y’rqnqxVÌAmnyCt~adf)qnrV}ˆtp}~f8ƒt~mnw{yÑÌA¥©f"f„|r{egmxydfgtvadf)ƒ8r{}~fTw{¨br z’†~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydf €3€ ms}~}~mnz’rutvmxwVyÑ´ $ % 2!¦p
p8
T1p1&!¦ &Í `ba’f§fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}bw¨#egwt~mnw{y3w¨mxy]—]ms}~ƒm€ ƒwVegzd†~fM}~}~mn¬dqxf‰­’odm€ }'¥'†vmxt~f?


   *    , " *  ¹ , 
    *      ,  " *  , 
   *    !  , " * " , ¥'a’f†vf 

mn}¦tvadfi­’odm€E€ fy_}‚mxtˆ{Ì





tvadfº—{f8qxw|ƒm¯tˆ)r{y €



t~a’fit~wt:rqÃf8ydf†vœ{ € f’ydf € r{}¦t~a’f}‚odew¨t~adf mny>t~f8†~y’r{qÃfydf8†~œV"zdqno’}bt~a’f>mnydft~msƒ‰f8ydf†vœ{V´  "$#!%'&  4 ( *  < ) < )* < , êh   ms}¦t~adfºz’†~fM}~}~od†vf € f’ydf € rV}  "  .& ¥'adf8†~f . ms}¦t~adfºzKf†~¨êf8ƒt'œVr{}'ƒw{y’}‚tvr{y>tbr{y € & t~a’fit~fegzKf  †:rutvod†vf{´.± ²>o’rutvmxwVy Ih br{y € tvadfºzKf†~¨êf8ƒ·tœ>r{}¦qsr°¥ ƒr{y¬KfƒwVep¬dmnydf € tvwg>mnfq€ 

 " * +-, 4 , *  , 4 (  *  < . < .* < ,+, > J y3t~adfºw{t~adf8†'a’ry € Ì]t~adfºmny’ƒwVegzd†~fM}~}~mn¬dqxfº±.o’qxf8†'f8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}'r†vf? / *   , "$ * 0¹ , 1 * 2
3  4/5 *  6   ,, 87 "$ * 0 , ¥'a’f†vf 1 mn}ºrYƒwVy’}‚tvry>ti†~f¨êf†vfy’ƒf € fy’}~m¯tˆ6ry € 7 tvadf € ]y’regmsƒpz’†~fM}~}~od†vf{´`ba’fTmny’ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf ­_odm€ f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}©r†vf ]ydwu¥'y"t~w¬_f‰t~a’f§}~mxy’œ{odqsr†©qxmnegm¯tbw¨Ãtvadf§ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfÁ±.odqnf†¦f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}©¥'adf8y ¸O¹:9



´+•‰}gry¼mny>t~†vw € o’ƒ·tvmxwVy³t~w6t~adfYƒwVegzdo|tvrt~mnw{y’}pt~a_rutg¥'mxqnq©¬KfYƒr†v†vmxf € w{o|tTmxy }‚fMƒ·tvmxwVy½dÌ ¥¦fg†~fMƒr{qxq a’f†vfTa’wu¥ŽtvwY¨êw{†vegr{qxqn € f8†~mn—{fTtvadmn}p}‚mnydœ{o’qnr{†ºqxmnegm¯tM´`badfg’†:}‚tp}ˆtvfz+w¨¦t~adms} € f†vmx—urutvmxwVy ms}ºzKf†~¨êw{†vegf € t~ad†vw{odœVa«tvadf"ydwVy € mneTf8y’}~mxwVy’rqnm MrutvmxwVy6w{¨©tvadfƒwVeTz’†~fM}~}~mx¬’qxf"±.odqnf†pf8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}8´ Ë ft

 % * ; , Ì   %+* ; , r{y €  %+* ; ,

¬Kft~adfmxydmxt~msrq#—urqnodfM}Áw{¨.t~adf € fy_}‚mxtˆ{ÌK—{f8qxw|ƒmxtˆEry € zd†~fM}~}~od†vfºÂ’f8q€ }8´ Ë ft

 2 "=<6>@?BA *  % * ; ,+, Ì  2 "C<>@?A *    % * ; ,  , ry € qxftTtvadfE}‚wVody € }~zKff € }vƒrqnf¹ 2 ¬Kf € f’ydf € ¬] 

 2 * ¹ 2 , < " +
¹ ; A *  % * ; ,+, ´ Š y>tv†~w € o’ƒmxy’œtvadfºydf8¥QydwVy € mxegfy_}‚mnw{y’r{qxm f € —ur{†~msr¬dqnf8}O   "   2   "    2   "   2 * ¹ 2 , <   "  * ¹ 2 , <   ; " ;  2 
"
 2  2 ڙ  ¥'a’f†vf  2

mn}.r{yTr{†~¬dmxt~†:r†viqxf8ydœtva"}~ƒ8rqnf{Ì¥¦fbw{¬|t:rmnyptvadf}‚|}‚t~f8e w¨\ydw{y € mnegfy’}~mnw{y’r{qxm f € f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}

 
  4/5 *     , "$ *  ¹ , 
    4/ *       ,  4 ¸ <2    "$ *   , 
    4/ *            , "$ *  " , ¥'a’f†vfg¸ 2 "  2 6¹ 2 ms}§t~a’f"†~f¨êf†vfy’ƒfgªErVƒ:a«y]ode¬_f8†8´"`badfgydwVy€ mxegfy_}‚mnw{y’r{qxm f € }‚tvrt~fTqnr°¥ > t:r Vf8}©t~adfi¨êwV†~e    " * + , 4 , *     , ¸=<2 (   *   <   <   * < , , I˜ 

µCfpy’wu¥ qnw]w>¨êw{†i}‚wVqxodt~mnw{y’}Áw¨.t~a’f}~]}‚t~f8e H› mxyEtvadf¨êw{†vew{¨Sr{}~>egz|tvwtvmnƒºf„|z’ry’}~mnw{yEmnyXz_wu¥¦f† w{¨ÍtvadfpªEr{ƒ:a3y]odep¬Kf†   "   1  ¸32     ¸=< 2   <       "   1  ¸32     ¸ <2   <       "   1  ¸32     ¸=<2   <       "  '1  ¸ 2     ¸=<2   <        "   

Š y>tv†~w € o’ƒmxy’œ‰tvadf8}~f'f„|zd†vf8}v}~mxwVy’}mxyTt~a’f'f8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}I› .ry € ƒw{qnqxfMƒ·t~mnydœitvadfbt~f8†~e"}#¥'mxt~a"f8²>o’r{q|z_wu¥¦f† w{¨#¸32i¥©fiw{¬dtvrmny1ꥦfºa’r°—{f € †vw{zdzKf € t~adf  ¨êw{†ƒw{y]—{f8ydmnfy’ƒf0! ‘{´ J † € f†4:6¸=<2  1 "$ ‚‘8” 

š|´ J † € f†4:6¸ 2   "$ ‚‘{‘0 d´ J † € f†  
 1   *  1  1 , "$ * 4 (B ¹ , 
 1  1 4/ *  1  1 ) 1 ,  < "$ * 4 (B , 
 1  1 4/ *  1  1  1  1  1 , "$ * 4 (B" , ¥'a’mxqnf§t~adf  ÚwV† € f8†'}ˆt:rut~fiqsr°¥Q¬Kf8ƒw{egf8}H  1 " * + , 4 , * 1 '1 ,

`ba’f)w{† € f8†4:6¸ <2 r{y € 4:6¸32f8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}mxegzdqnCt~a’rttvadfz’†~fM}~}~od†vfmn}TƒwVy’}‚tvry>tTmxy }‚z’rVƒfo’z¼t~w ­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}bw¨#w{† € f†¸=<2 ´ `ba>o_}b¥©fie"r°¥'†vm¯tvf  * ; 
, "  1 *
,  ¸ < 2  < * ; 
,

Š y¼t~adfzd†~fM}‚f8y’ƒf"w{¨w{zKfy¼¬Kw{o’y € r†vmnf8}8ÌÍtvadftvadf†vegw € >y_regmnƒzd†~fM}~}~od†vf

 1 ¥'mnqxq¦¬_ff8²>o’r{q t~w«t~adf f„]t~f†vmnw{†bzd†vf8}v}‚od†vf‰t~a’rt¥©fºr{}v}~odegf‰¨êwV†}‚mnegzdqnmnƒm¯tˆ3ƒw{y_}ˆt:ry>t¦mny3t~mnegf   
A 
"   1 
"$

µCf € f € o’ƒf¨ê†~wVe t~adf)ydw{y€ mnegfy’}~mxwVy’rqnm f €

 Ôw{† € f8†i}‚tvrt~f"qsr°¥ tva’rut  1  1 
" 81 '1 "  ry € tvadfºfy’f†vœ{"f8²>o’rt~mnw{y1ˆ‘°š|´ƒI € fœVfydf8†vrt~fM}©mny>t~w     1 "$

Š y>tv†~w € o’ƒmxy’œ+t~adms}†vfqsrutvmxwVy mny>t~w³tvadf«ƒw{y>t~mny]odm¯tˆ»f8²>o’rt~mnw{yÑÌ'¥¦fX}‚f8fEt~a_ruttvadmn})mxegzdqnmnf8}"tva’rutt~adf e"rt~f†vmsrq € f8†~mn—urutvmx—Vfw¨bt~a’f € f8y’}‚mxtˆCmn} f8†~w_´Y•‰}~}~odegmnydœE¨êw{†T}‚mnegzdqnmnƒm¯tˆ6t~a’rtTr{qxq©z’r†~t~msƒqnfz’rt~a’} ƒw{egf§¨ê†~wVe†vfœ{mnw{y_}©¥'mxt~a3tvadf}~r{egf € fy’}~m¯tˆVÌd¥¦fiƒw{y’ƒqxo € f§t~a’rt9

1 " #

r{y € t~a’rt't~adf  ÚwV† € f8†¦}~|}ˆtvfe†~f € o’ƒfM}©t~wgt~a’fi¨êw{qnqxwu¥'mnydœg}‚ftw¨AfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}
 1 " #
 * 4  ¹ , 1 * 
 1 / *  1 ) 1 , ,  < "$ * 4  , / *  1 , "  * 4 " ,  % 2Y&A!©¦A!¦ &Í J

o’†)rmne ms}y’wu¥Àtvw¼z_f8†‚¨êwV†~e r¼}~mxegmnqnr{†)ry_rqn]}~ms}"w¨it~a’fXqxwu¥ªErVƒ:ay>o’ep¬Kf†)¬Kfa_r°—>mnw{†)w¨it~adf ! *($& ( ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfi± odqxf8†‰fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}'¥'adf8yXrg­’o|„ € mx®Kf8†~f8y’ƒfo’z>¥'mny € egftvadw € ms}o’}~f € tvw)rz z’†~w°„|mnegrt~f"}~]}‚t~f8e H ·´ 7’w{†p}~mxegzdqnmsƒmxtˆ{Ì¥©fƒw{y’}~m € f†ºtva’rutp¥¦f"o’}~f)rY†vfœ{o’qnr{†ƒr†~t~fM}‚msryCœ{†vm € w{¨ o’ydm¯¨êwV†~e egf8}~a¼}‚m f  mny+tˆ¥©w € mnegfy’}~mxwVy’}8´ 

"

*





,

mn}itvadfmny € f„6w¨btvadfydw € f"¥'adw>}‚fƒw]w{† € m y_rut~fM}br†vf *     , r{y € ¥¦f‰o_}‚f‰t~adf§ydw{tvrutvmxwVy *  , " *  , 4   ,  *   4  ,  *    , 4 ,  *    4 , w{†  *  ,8"   

¨êwV†bqnr{¬_f8qxqnmxy’œptvadf‰y’fmnœ{a]¬_wV†v}©w¨At~adfiœV†~m€ ydw € fHM´ `badf§ƒfqnqÃr{}v}‚w|ƒmsrutvf € ¥'mxt~a y’w € f bmn} #  " *  , 4:6 ( ,   * B 4:6 ( ,  C  *  , 4:6 ( ,   *   46 ( , Ì   ms} tvadf‰wVo|tˆ¥br† € o’ydm¯tbydwV†~e"rq —Vf8ƒt~w{†bwVy # ry € ¥¦fiydwtvf     "        ´

`badf¼r{zdzdqnmnƒ8rutvmxwVy w{¨gw>f }«rzdzd†vw°„|mxe"rt~f+'mxf8e"rydy }~w{qn—{f†Emny r ’†:}ˆt+ÚwV† € f8†3’ydmxt~f¼—Vw{qnodegf }vƒ:adf8eTfi]mnfq€ }¦t~adfi¨êwVqxqnwu¥'mnydœ"}‚ftbw{¨#}~fegm€ mn}vƒ†vftvf‰fM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}I}~ffºrzdzKfy € m¯„3Š·´|¨êw{† € ftvr{mxqs}@ 



æÍç‚èIç Ãç§ô°á‚éçºï°çˆèIâéç‚ïûHô°çiñÚâäõ!·í°ãîá:è'ãäâäß'âû¦ò:öûÚô°ç§ø‚ò·ß'óMèHçˆñÚñHâ#"°ãäçiݒí°ãäçˆè'ç%$8íuávûHâäò·õ°ñÁí°ñÚâäõ!pûHô°çiøˆò·õ°ñHç‚èêé·ávûHâéç ç‚õMç‚è&!'ç%$8í°ávûÚâäò·õpá:õ°ïºûHô°ç©óçˆèêönçˆø û(!á:ñ#ñHûÚávûHçbãîá ë

&

õûHô°ç©ãäò*)ºá:øÔôºõ8íMß+"çˆèãäâäß'âûuò·õ°ç¦ø‚á:õñÔávöxçˆã'iá:ñHñÚí°ß'ç ûHôuávû õ°òbñÚôMò8ø,-Ñáˆéçˆñá:èIç.ó°èIç‚ñHçˆõûøˆò·õ°ñÚç%$í°çˆõûHã'§ûHô°ç.çˆõ°çˆè.!'‰ç%$8í°ávûÚâäò·õºá:õMï‰ûHô°ç ñHûÚávûÚç.ãîá%Xø~á:õ/"ç.èHçˆó°ãîá:øˆçˆï0"1'+243651798 ø‚ò·õMñHûÚá:õû‚ë

&

õ§ûHô°âäñAø‚á:ñHç1uûHô°ç âäõ°øˆò·ß'ó°èIçˆñÚñÚâ#"Mãäç.ãäâäß'âûÃø‚á:õ0"çSò"8ûÔá:âäõ°çˆï§öxèIò·ß ûÚôMçSâäñHçˆõûHèHò·óMâäøSøˆò·ß'ó°èIçˆñÚñHâ#"°ãäç.ç%$8íuávûHâäò·õ°ñ âäõºç‚ñHñÚçˆõûÚâîá:ãäã'ºûHô°çbñÚá:ß'ç:Ñá%'1>öxò·è.áÁèIâ#!·ò·èIò·í°ñ-;nõ°ò:û öxò·èHßá:ã=<Ñó°èIò8ò:öÑñHç‚ç
>X@?àë©æAçˆèHçAÃç¦ó°èIçönçˆè.ûHò‰í°ñHç¦ûHô°ç¦øˆò·ß'ó°ãäç ûHç õ°ò·õ§âäñHç‚õûHèHò·ó°âäø øˆò·ß'ó°èIçˆñÚñÚâ#"Mãäç#ñ.'8ñHûHçˆß»ûHòbóò·âäõûAò·íMûÑûÚôMçSïMâBVçˆèIçˆõ°øˆç‚ñCÍâûÚôÁûÚô°ç.ïMâäñÚøˆèHç ûHâäúˆç‚ïºç%$íuávûHâäò·õ°ñ

 2
'   4 ( # 
             4 ( # 
     *     ,     ¹ <   , )      ¹            ¹   "  * 4-A ¹ ,  2
'     4 ( # 
                *  A,   4 ( # 
     *     ,     ¹ <   ,    )      ¹          ,       *  ,      *   A   ,  ¹       )   ¹   *  A,      "$ * 4-A  ,  2
    4 ( # 
                *  ,    4 ( # 
     *     ,     ¹ <   ,   .      ¹                *  A,       *   ) ,  ¹       .   ¹   *  ,      " * 4-A " ,  2
     4 ( # 
 *       I,          4 ( # 
     *     ,     ¹ <   , *  <   . <   ( , .      ¹                       *   < ,  ¹       )   ¹          "$ * 4-A   ,

¥'adf8†~fi¥¦fºa’r°—{f§mnyVtv†~w € o_ƒf € t~a’fr €d€ mxt~mnw{y_rqÃydw{tvrutvmxwVy’}H

   *  , " *  , , *  ,  "       " ,   .  A

   "
    *    ,  € fy’wt~fM}¦t~adfw>fºr°—Vf†:rœ{f‰¬_ftˆ¥©f8fy3t~a’fi}‚tvrt~fM} *    , r{y € *    , € f’ydf € ¬]E  M"              *   ,  " *   ,    *   ,        ¥'mxt~a tvadf}‚zKf8ƒm¯ÂKƒify>t~a’r{qxz]œVmx—Vfy3¬]E "     `ba’fir°—Vf†:rœVf‰}~w{ody € }~z_f8f € ¹   mn}bœVmx—Vfy3¬>5 ¹ <   " * + , 4 ,   , 4 ( *  <   . <   , Œ‰}‚mnydœpy’wu¥»tvadf‰}vregf €

mxegfy_}‚mnw{ydqnf8}v}©—°r{†~msr¬’qxfM} r{}Smxy)}~f8ƒt~mnw{yšBI}~ffÁfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’} ԙ  ¥©fÁw{¬|t:rmny ¨ê†vw{e}‚|}‚t~fe ˆ‘h !

4 ( ¸ 2 #        ¹       
   4 ( #                  *     ,     ¹ <   ,  ¸ 2 ( #         ¹       "  * 4
 ¹ , 4 ( ¸ <2 # 
   *  A ,   4 ( ¸32 #    *   A   ,  ¹       )   ¹   *  A,          
'     4 ( #                     *     ,     ¹ <   ,    ,        *  ,       ¸ 2 ( #         ¹          "  * 4  , 4 ( ¸ <2 # 
    *  ,   4 ( ¸ 2 #    *   ) ,   ¹       .   ¹   *  ,          
'    4 ( #                    *     ,     ¹ <   ,   .       *  A,        ¸32 ( #         ¹         "  * 4 " , 4 ( ¸32 #      ¹          
'     4 ( #   *       -,          ¸ 2 ( #    <   ¹       .   ¹          .      ¹         

¥'a’mxqnf§t~adf

€

mnegfy’}~mnw{ydqnf8}v}bf8²>o’rt~mnw{y3w¨.}ˆt:rut~fims}'œ{mn—{f8y)¬] H˜ ´

7’w{qnqxwu¥'mnydœtvadfgegft~a’w € o’}~f € mxy6t~adfgƒwVy>t~mny>o’w{o’}§ƒrV}‚fVÌÃ¥©fTydf„]tif„|z’r{y € r{qxqt~a’fT—ur{†~msr¬dqnf8}‰mny zKwu¥¦f†bw¨t~adfº†vf¨êf8†~f8y’ƒfºªErVƒ:ay]ode¬_f8†Á¸32 *  , " *  , 1! ¸ 2 *  ,   ¸ < 2 *  , <     ‚‘8“ 

r{y € mny>t~†vw € o’ƒf‰t~a’f8}~f‰f„]z_ry’}~mxwVy’}©mxy>t~wg}~]}‚t~f8eˆ‘>·´ wVqxqnf8ƒt~mnydœptvf†ve"}©¥'mxt~a3f8²>o’r{q\z_wu¥¦f†¦w¨¸ 2uÌ ¥¦fiw{¬|t:rmny  ‘{´ J † € f†4:6¸=< 2  1 ,  1
"    1 ,  1 "$ ‚‘°™  š|´ J † € f†4:6¸ 2 Ir  wVy>t~mny>o’m¯tˆfM²>o’rutvmxwVy 4 ( #        1 ¹ 1   "  ‚‘8›  ê¬ )a’w{†vm 8w{y>tvr{qKegwVeTf8y>t~odef8²>o’rutvmxwVy 4 ( #    *  1  A   1 ,  ¹ 1       1 . 1   ¹ 1   *  A,      1  #        *  A , "$ ‚‘8˜  Iƒ0)—Vf†~t~msƒr{qKegwVeTf8y>t~odef8²>o’rutvmxwVy 4 ( #   *  1  ) 1 ,  ¹ 1       1 ) 1   ¹ 1   *  ,      1  # 
      *  , "$ ښ”   € )f8ydf†vœ{"fM²>o’rutvmxwVy 4 ( #  1   ¹ 1       1 "  ښ|‘0

‹Áwu¥ºÌ|qxfto’}}~w{qn—{f?ˆ‘°™>/!ˆ‘M› /!ˆ‘M˜  Hš{” /!Hšd‘0Ì>¥¦fºa’r°—Vf ©Å  +¢ F
<  !
!  !    ! 
!   ! !# '      1  " "
   J ¡ ÉÑÉ ¤ ‚‘°™ ©mnegzdqxmnf8}'t~a’rt  1

a’rV}'rp¨êwVod†b’f8q€ }~w{qno|t~mnw{y3w¨At~adfi¨êwV†~e € fzdmsƒ·tvf € mny)’œVod†vfT‘?

A

A

A

A

B

B

B

B

B

B

A

C

C

C

D

D

D

A

C

D

C

D

C

D

7mnœ{od†vfg‘>$7’w{od†b’f8q€ }~w{qno|t~mnw{y3w¨t~adf 46¸=< 2 w{†€ f8†¦fM²>o’rutvmxwVy ‚‘°™  `Aw)zd†vwu—{fitva’rut‰t~adfT}‚z’od†~mnw{o_}zd†vf8}v}‚o’†~fºegw € f  1 %  "    1 %    "   1 %    " #   1 %      " ms}§ydwtrVƒ·t~o_rqnqxYzd†vf8}~fy>timxy6t~adf"}~w{qno|t~mnw{yÍÌÑr{}v}‚odegf¨êw{†imny’}ˆt:ry’ƒfptva’rut  ms}Átvadfge"ru„|mxeode w¨©t~adf ¨êwVod†§—°r{qxo’f     #  

´ºµCfy’wt~fydwu¥Ot~a_rut§t~adfgƒw]f ƒmxf8yVt:}Áw{¨ ˆ‘M› r{†~fz_w>}‚mxt~mn—{fV´§`ba]o’}§rqnqt~adf tvf†ve"}ºmxy+tvadf}~ode ˆ‘M› ir†vf"zKwV}~m¯tvmx—Vfry € ‚‘8› ƒry’ydwtfM²Vo_rqS”Eo’ydqxfM}~} 

" " # " ´YŠ y w{t~adf8†Á¥¦w{† € }8Ì|t~adf € ms}~ƒ†~ft~fe"ru„|mnepode zd†vmxy_ƒmnzdqxfrzdzdqnmnf8}Ár{y € ydfMƒf8}v}vr†vmxqntvadf¨êwVod†Á—urqnodfM}mnyEt~adf }~ft     #   r{†~f§f8²>o’r{qH´

`badf8†~f¨êw{†vfi¥©fº}~ff§t~a’rt't~adf 46¸ 2 ÚwV† € f†begw{egfy>t~o’ef8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}‚‘8˜   ښ” S†vf € o’ƒf§t~w 

   ,    "  1   ¹ 1       1 . 1   ¹ 1       1 ښ{š> r{y €   ,  
"  1  ¹ 1     1 . 1 
¹ 1 
 
 1 ښ  `badfM}‚fÁf8²>o’rutvmxwVy’} !3

mnegzdqxt~a_rut tvadfÁwV† € f8†©¸ 2 zd†~fM}~}~od†vf

  ms}
% rƒwVy’}ˆt:ry>t8´`ba]o’} ¥¦fa’r°—Vf  J ¡ É L É ŸN@à @É ? F
<

)*&5
T*)  !*($&8& 5 (@N(5 
T*  "!!#*5 3 :  &* * 58$# 5$"% 5 
*6E8! ( ¸ 2'&  * ; 
,8"  1 *
,  ¸32   * ; 
, ښuh 

`ba’mn}bms}'mnyYƒqxfMr†'ƒwVy>t~†:r{}‚t¦¥'mxt~a3t~a’fƒw{y>tvmxy]odwVo’}'ƒrV}‚f§¥'adf†vfizd†vf8}v}‚od†vf§­’o’ƒt~o’rt~mnw{y’}'}vƒr{qxfºr{}¸=<2 ´ `badf8†~f¨êw{†vf{Ì_w{y«r
8! ' *    ƒwVy’}‚tvry>t!·ÌK¥©fpƒ8rydy’wtÁ†vf8ƒwu—{f†t~adfTƒw{†v†vf8ƒ·tÁ}vƒr{qxmnydœw{¨.t~adf z’†~fM}~}~od†vfT¥'mxt~a+tvadfªErVƒ:a+y>o’ep¬Kf†M´`badf € mn}vƒ†vftvf}‚wVqxo|tvmxwVy’}ºw{¨¦fM²Vo_rut~mnw{y ‚‘h §f„|admx¬’m¯tpz’†~fM}~}~od†vf ­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}'tva’rut‰r{†~fºeo’ƒ:aEqsr†vœ{f†btva’ry«mxyYtvadfpƒwVy>t~mny>o’w{o’}ƒ8r{}~f{´ªYwV†~f8wu—{f†¦tvadfp†:rutvmxw"¬Kftˆ¥¦ff8y tvadfy]odegf†vmsƒrqSzd†~fM}~}~od†vfg­’o’ƒt~o’rt~mnw{y’}r{y € t~a’ff„dr{ƒtpw{y’f8}º¥'mnqxq©mxy_ƒ†vf8r{}~f"r{}t~adfªXr{ƒ:a+y]odep¬Kf† œVw]f8}©t~w 8f†vw’´

Š yw{† € f†At~w§mxqnqno’}ˆtv†vrt~fSt~adfbr¬Kwu—{fSt~adf8w{†v{Ì°¥©fbƒwVy’}~m€ f8†r‰}‚fM²>odfy’ƒfSw{¨_ƒwVeTz’o|tvrt~mnw{y’}w¨|tvadf¦­’wu¥ r{†~wVody € rY‹Á• •Á”V”d‘°šr{mx†~­’wu¥Žrt € f8ƒ†~fMr{}~mxy’œEªXr{ƒ:aCy>o’ep¬Kf†wVy6tvadf}vregf
 ! eTfM}‚aÍ´ 7mxœVod†vf š¼}‚adwu¥}t~adfCzd†vf8}v}‚o’†~fY’f8q€ }wV¬|tvr{mxy’f € ¨êw{†t~a’†~f8f € mx®Kf8†~f8y>tmny|­’wu¥ªEr{ƒ:aQy>o’ep¬Kf†:}´Šy¿t~adfM}‚f ƒw{egzdo|t:rutvmxwVy’}Ì_t~a’fmny|­’wu¥ —Vfqnw]ƒm¯tˆ3ms} Vfz|tiƒwVy’}ˆt:ry>t‰fM²>o’rqÍt~w3odydmxtˆ3¥'a’mxqnfptvadfpmny|­’wu¥ z’†~fM}~}~od†vf ms}mny’ƒ†~fMr{}~f € ´Á`Aw)r{qxqnwu¥ rƒwVeTz_r†vmn}~w{yY¬Kftˆ¥¦ffyXt~adfzd†~fM}~}~od†vfºÂ’f8q€ }‰rut € m¯®\f†vfy>tºªEr{ƒ:aEy]ode¬_f8†8Ì 7mnœ{od†vf§š}~adwu¥} tvadfiydw{†ve"rqnm 8f € z’†~fM}~}~od†vf

  € f’ydf € rV}   "  ,   6   ,   ´ •Á} tvadf3ªXr{ƒ:a³y]odep¬Kf† € f8ƒ†~fMr{}~f8}8ÌÍtvadf)†vf8}~odqxtv}p¬_fMƒw{egf¥¦w{†:}~fry € tvadf}~w{qno|tvmxwVy’} € w6ydwtƒw{y]—{f8†~œVf tvw3r3†vf8rV}‚wVydy’r¬’qxfpr{zdzd†vw°„|mxe"rutvmxwVyXw¨©t~adfgmny’ƒwVegzd†~fM}~}~mn¬dqxfg}~w{qno|t~mnw{yÑ´•'ƒ·t~o_rqnqxVÌÃt~adf¸O¹ " "  4 }~w{qno|tvmxwVyEmn}‰ƒqnwV}~f†tvw"t~a’fpmny’ƒwVeTz’†~fM}~}~mx¬’qxfwVydfºtva’ryXms}'tvadfT¸O¹ " "   / 4}~w{qno|t~mnw{yÍ´`badmn}‰zKw{mnyVt ¥br{}br{qx†vf8r € "ydwtvmnƒf € êfV´œ ˜¦¬])}‚f8—{f8†vr{qKw{t~adf8†'mxy]—Vf8}‚t~mnœVrutvw{†:}´

PRESSURE: MIN = 71.0919 MAX = 73.5268

PRESSURE: MIN = 7138.77 MAX = 7159.34

PRESSURE: MIN = 714244 MAX = 714446

7mnœ{od†vfš¦Šˆ}~wu—urqnodf8}Áw¨#t~a’fzd†vf8}v}~od†~fV̒wVy«rd‘V‘h"ydw € fegf8}~aE¨êw{†i¸
"  4àtvw{z Ìø "    4 Iegm€d€ qxf:·Ì_¸
"$    4?ê¬Kwt~t~wVe ´

7mnœ{od†vf3«t~a_rut € ms}‚zdqsr°|}tvadfYzd†vf8}v}‚od†vf­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy *   ,   , 6   —{f8†v}~o’}pt~adf3mxyd­’wu¥ ªXr{ƒ:a"y]odep¬Kf†MÌ]f„|zdqsrmny’}©¥'a>Ttvadmn}©¬Kfa’r°—]mnw{†Sw|ƒ8ƒod†:}´Š y)zKf†~¨êf8ƒtbr{œ{†vff8eTf8y>t ¥'m¯tvat~a’fÁtvadfwV†~ft~msƒrq z’†~f € mnƒt~mnw{y’}8Ì|mxtmn}'fMr{}~mxqnƒ:adfMƒ@{f € t~a_rut't~a’fºzd†~fM}~}~od†vfÁ­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}r†vf§zd†~wVz_wV†‚tvmxwVy’rqKtvwgt~adfpªErVƒ:a y]ode¬_f8†8´¦`ba]o’}bt~a’fpr{ƒ8ƒod†:r{ƒ"w¨t~adfy]odegf8†~msƒr{qц~fM}‚o’q¯t:}bmxyYtvadfmny’ƒwVeTz’†~fM}~}~mx¬’qxfiqnmxegmxtÁmn}—{f†v)qnwu¥ r{y € t~adms}r{ƒ8ƒod†:r{ƒ € ftvf†vmxwV†vrt~fM}¦rV}¦t~adfªErVƒ:ay]ode¬_f8† € fMƒ†vf8r{}~f8}8´

1e-5

1e-4

1e-3

1e-2

1e-1

1

1e-3

1e-2

1e-1

1

(Pmax - Pmin)/Pmax

MACH

Order 1

Order 2

y = x

7mnœ{od†vfi.….†vf8}v}‚od†vf­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}¦—{f†:}~o’}Smny|­’wu¥ ªEr{ƒ:ay>o’ep¬Kf†
d}‚wVqxm€ qnmxy’f#wV† € f8†‰‘VÌ € r{}~adf € qnmxydf .wV† € f†š|´ 7dwV†ƒwVeTz_r†vmn}~w{yÑÌ>tvadfƒod†v—{fi  „ms}'†~f8zd†vf8}~fy>t~f € ¬])r € w{t‚t~f € qxmnydf{´

J ydfb¥br°§t~wi†~fMƒwu—Vf†#rÁ¬Kft~t~f† rVƒƒod†vrVƒºƒwVodq € ¬Kf¦t~wio’}~fbr{ypmnegzd†~wu—Vf € }‚z’rt~msrq|rz’zd†~w°„|mne"rut~mnw{yÍ´ J y«Â’œ{o’†~fTms}§r{qn}~w)z’qxw{t‚t~f € tvadfg†~fM}‚odqxtv}‰w{¬dtvrmnydf € ¥'mxt~a6r3}~f8ƒwVy € wV† € f8†iªXŒ‰k ¦Ë tˆ]z_fg}~ƒ:a’fegf{´ •Áq¯tvadw{o’œ{aÑÌ©t~adfEz’†~f8—>mnw{o_}Tt~adf8w{†v € w]f8}gydw{t)}ˆtv†~msƒ·tvqx»rzdzdqn¼tvw+t~adms}ƒ8r{}~f¥'adf8†~fYtvadf € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmx—Vf tvf†ve"}Ár†vfºw¨#¨êwVod†‚tvaEw{† € f†'¥'a’mxqnftvadfºt~a’fw{†v3a’r{}'¬Kff8yXzKf†~¨êw{†veTf € ¨êw{†‰}~f8ƒw{y € wV†€ f8† € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmx—Vf tvf†ve"}Ì]mxt'ƒ8ry3¬_fº}~ff8yt~a_rutbt~adfizd†vf8}v}~od†~fÁ­’o’ƒt~o’rt~mnw{y’}'}‚t~mnqxqÑ}vƒr{qxfirz’zd†~w°„|mne"rut~f8qxT¥'mxt~a3t~adfªErVƒ:a y]ode¬_f8†r{y € ydwt¥'m¯tva³m¯t:}}v²>o’r†vf{´Y`badf†vf¨êwV†~fgtvadfo’}~fw{¨'}~f8ƒw{y € wV†€ f†}vƒ:adfegf8}pœ{mn—{fM}ºw{ydqn6r e"r{†~œVmxy’r{q\mxegzd†vwu—{f8eTf8y>t¦¥'mxt~aY†vf8}~z_fMƒ·tbt~wgtvadfi’†:}ˆt'w{† € f8†¦wVydf8}8´   A'!¦p
3·
)' Y&A&A i#p
Š yt~adms}©}~f8ƒt~mnw{yÑÌ>¥¦fÁzKf†~¨êw{†veTf € r}~mxegmnqnr{†©}‚t~o € gmnytvadf‰ƒ8r{}~f¥'adf†vfÁ'w]f } € ms}~}~mxz_rut~mnw{y"ms}©eTw € mx’f € ¬]Yzd†vf8ƒw{y € mxt~mnw{y’mxydœ_´‰k]zKf8ƒm¯Â_ƒ8rqnqxVÌ_qnft  *  0, ¬KftvadfTw>fe"rut~†vmx„YrV}~}~w|ƒmsrut~f € t~wydw € f8} §r{y €  Ì ¥¦fºƒ:a’ry’œ{f‰t~adfºy]odegf†vmsƒrq\­_o|„mny>t~w   *       %  , "   *  ,    * 0, (    %   4 (  *  0,    *  0,  *  0, 8  @ ښ >

¥'a’f†vf  mn}t~adf6zd†~fMƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydmnydœ¼e"rutv†~mx„ô µ¿m¯tva¾†vf8}~z_fMƒ·ttvw³t~adf6w{†vmxœVmxy_rqÁ'w]f«}vƒ:adf8eTfVÌ'w{ydqn tvadf € ms}~}~mxz_rut~mn—{ft~f8†~e"}ºr{†~fTrqxt~f†vf € ry € t~a’f†vf¨êw{†vft~adfgy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq.}vƒ:adfegfg†~f8e"rmny’}irƒw{y’}~mn}‚tvr{y>t r{zdzd†vw°„|mxe"rutvmxwVy«w{¨¦tvadf"tvmxegf € f8z_f8y € fy>tgƒw{egzd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnf"±.odqnf†fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}´Šy+t~adms}º¥¦w{†K\ÌÍ¥¦f"o’}‚f tvadfXzd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydf†"zd†vw{zKwV}~f € ¬]»`Aod†K{f8qmxy :Ô´ Š yt~f†ve w¨it~adf
ˆzd†vmneTmxt~mn—{f3—ur†vmsr¬dqnf8} 

"       *  6 *  , , ̒t~adms}bzd†vf8ƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydf8†'¥'†~mxt~fM}H  "   <     4     4     4   ¥'a’f†vf  ms}ir)}~egr{qxqA¨Ir{ƒt~wV†Áw¨St~adfw{† € f†‰w¨ tvadfTªErVƒ:aXy]odep¬Kf†M´H7dw{†‰t~a’fTƒw{y’}~f†v—urut~mn—{fº—ur{†~msr¬dqnf8} "      /    t~adfƒw{†v†~fM}‚zKw{y € mxydœ¨êw{†vems}H  * ,8"   *  ,  `Awgw{¬|t:rmny3r{yf„|zdqxmsƒmxtf„|zd†vf8}v}~mxwVy¨êw{†btvadf}‚tvr¬’mxqnm MrutvmxwVy)tvf†ve   *  -,    *  0,  *  0,    !

ƒqxw>}‚f3tvw+t~adfEf„]z’†~fM}~}~mxwVy»wV¬|tvr{mxy’f € ¨êw{†"tvadfEw{†vmxœVmxy_rq'}~ƒ:a’fegf{Ìb¥¦fÂ_†v}‚t € msrœ{wVy’rqnm ft~adfXe"rt~†vm¯„

 *  I,  *  I, ´ ŠÔt:}bfmnœ{fy]—urqnodfM} ( *  0, r†vf‰œVmx—Vfy3¬]E (  "     ( < "     ( " 4 ( * 4   < ,       ( " 4 ( * 4   < ,    ,    ښ“  ¥'mxt~a  "  * 4 ,  < ,   <  A  <ù <   ´E`badfzd†~w € o_ƒ·tpw{¨¦tvadff8mxœVfy]—{fMƒ·t~wV†v}iw{¨  *   ,  *   , ¬]  *  I,   †vf8}~odqxtv}§mny6f„]z’†~fM}~}~mxwVy’}'tva’rutr{†~fgƒqnwV}~fptvw)tvadfgf„|zd†vf8}v}‚mnw{y_}Áw{¨St~a’fTf8mxœVfy]—{fMƒ·tvw{†:}w¨©t~adf w>f }be"rt~†vm¯„ H}‚f8fif8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}êh_‘0©w¨.rz’z_f8y € mx„Š   .  *  I, "      4       <   ) <   (       . < *  0, "     , *  ,  *  A,          .  *  I, "    4    ! *  A,    " *  ,    !        .  *  0,8"    4    $# *  A ,    %# *  ,    %#        ښV™ 

¥'a’f†vf " (  ,     <ry € # " ( ,     <  ŠÔ¨p¥¦fXydwu¥ºÌÁmxy>t~†vw € o’ƒfEt~adfCƒw]w{† € mny’rutvf )  *    , w¨ºtvadf‡ˆodegz    mny¿t~a’f6¬’rV}‚ms}w{¨ºt~adf f8mxœVfy]—{fMƒ·tvw{†:}Sw{¨  * -  ,  * -  , ¥'a’wV}~f§f„|zd†~fM}~}~mnw{y’}br†vf )  *   @ , "     ,     ¹ <    ) < *   @ , "        )  *   @ , " 4       )         )  *   @ , " 4       , # ,          ښ›  ¥¦fiœ{ftH  *  0,    *  0,  *  I,    @ "  # 
 )  *   I,  (  *  I,  .  *  0,  wV†bmxy € f8—{fqnw{z’z_f € ¨êwV†~e   *  0,   *  0,  *  0, 8  ! H"                      8)  *   @ ,  <     ¹ <                8)  *    ,    ,         *  ,            ¹ <                8)  *   @ ,            *  A,           ¹ <               8)  *   @ ,  <   ) <   (                      ¹ <                           ښ˜  ¥'a’f†vf   "      4   <   < "  <      < , 4  ( ¹ <    <     H{” 

r{y €   "       *  A,  
   "     < , # *  A,    6  <   "      *  ,  
   "    < , # *  ,    6  <   "         
   "    < , #      6  <  
"  <     4 ,  <  (  <ѹ <    <     Hd‘0 r{y € ¥¦fÁa’r°—Vfo’}~f € >(9 " ( ry €  (   " , (  ¬Kf8ƒ8ro’}~f'¨êwV†Sqnwu¥¿ªXr{ƒ:ay]ode¬_f8†8Ì>w{ydf‰ƒry)f8r{}~mnqx ƒ:a’f8ƒ@gt~a_rut (   r{y € (  ´ ‹Áwu¥ºÌ‰o’}~mnydœ½tvadf³}~r{egf € mnegfy’}~mxwVydqnf8}v}—ur{†~msr¬dqnf8}3r{}3mnyQtvadfCzd†~f8—]mxwVo’}Yƒr{}~f8}8Ì¥¦f6¥'†vmxt~fCt~adf †vf8}~odqxt~mnydœ½}vƒ:adfegf6mxy ydw{y€ mnegfy’}~mxwVy’rqnm f € ¨êwV†~eY´ 7dw{†t~a’mn}8ÌÁ¥¦f«ydf8f € tvw½ydwVy€ mxegf8y’}‚mnw{y_rqnm 8f tvadf)z_r†:regftvf†  t~a’rtgr{zdz_fMr†:}ºmny¼t~a’f)zd†vf8ƒw{y € mxt~mnw{y’f†M´6k]mny’ƒf3mxy½zd†vrVƒ·tvmnƒf{Ìt~adms}Tz’r†:regft~f†pmn} ƒ:a’wV}~fy)w{¨Atvadfºw{† € f8†¦w{¨AtvadfpªErVƒ:a)y]odep¬Kf†MÌd¥¦f§tvr Vf?  " ¸32   r{y €   mn}r3z’r{†vr{egft~f8†iw¨bw{† € f†ºody’m¯tˆV´Šy+zd†vrVƒ·tvmnƒf{Ì  ms}ºw¨àtvfy³ƒ:adw>}‚f8yCƒw{y’}‚tvr{yVtºmnyCt~adf"¥'adwVqxf ƒw{egzdo|t:rutvmxwVy’rq € w{e"rmnyÑÌ'adf8†~fX¥¦f«ƒw{y’}~m€ f†"tvadf«egw{†vfEœ{f8ydf†:rq‰ƒr{}~fE¥'adf8†~fEtvadms}²>o’r{yVtvm¯tˆ ƒr{y ¬Kf«r{qxqnwu¥©f € t~w¼¬Kf8ƒw{egf«rC¨êody’ƒt~mnw{y¾w{¨it~adfXqnw|ƒr{qÁ—ur†vmnr{¬dqnf8}8´ µCf«rqs}~w³ydwtvfEt~a’rt)tvadfX—ur†vmnr{¬dqnf

 " * 4 ,  < ,    <  A  < ¹ <   ƒryY¬Kfºf—urqno’rt~f € r{}H  "  < 2    <  * 4 ,   < , <  A   < ¹ <   

r{y € ¥¦f)mny>t~†vw € o’ƒf)¨êw{†gƒw{y]—Vfydmnfy’ƒf"t~a’fydw{tvrt~mnw{y

"   <   * 4 ,   < , <  A   < ¹ <   ¥'adf8†~fms}r —ur{†~msr¬dqnf"w¨wV† € f†ody’m¯tˆ J y_ƒf)r{œVrmnyÑÌmxy¼t~adf3f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}º¬Kfqnwu¥ºÌ.¥¦f € †vw{zdzKf € tvadf}~]ep¬Kw{q  t~w }~mneTz’qxmx¨êtvadfºydwt:rutvmxwVy’}´#µCfit~adf8yYw{¬|t:rmny 

4 ( ¸ <2 # 
 (            
   4 ( #                  *     ,     ¹ <   , ,  <   ¹ <          )              ¸=< 2 ( #    < *                <   ¹ <          , "  * /(B ¹ , 4 ( ¸ <2 # 
   *  A ,    *   A  (  ,         2    
'     4 ( #                    *     ,     ¹ <   ,    ,        *  ,       *     A ,      (  <¹ <               <¹ <      *  A ,  ,     <          ¹ <    ¸=< 2 ( #     <  * -,   A ,                    <          ¹ <    "  * /(B , 4 ( ¸ <2 # 
   *  ,   *    ( ,            
'    4 ( #                    *     ,     ¹ <   ,   .       *  A,       *    ,       (  <¹ <               <M¹ <      *  ,   ,    <         ¹ <    ¸ < 2 ( #    <  * ,   ,                   <          ¹ <    " * /(B" , 4 ( ¸ <2 # 
 (              
'     4 ( #  *        ,          *    ¹ <   ,     <       ¹ <                    ¸=< 2 ( #       *     ,     ¹ <   , *  <   ) <   ( , .               < *    ¹ <   ,  <          ¹ <       < * ( ¹ <  ¸  *

wVegz’r†vmxy’œ)tvadmn}p}‚|}‚t~fe ¥'m¯tva6tvadfry_rqnw{œ{wVo’}‰w{ydf ˆ‘>‰w{¬dtvrmnydf

€ mny6t~adfƒ8r{}~fT¥'mxt~a+ydwYzd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmxy’œ’Ì’¥¦fºydw{t~fºtva’rutÁy’wu¥ºÌ € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmxwVytvf†ve"}w¨.wV† € f8†4:6¸=< 2 rzdzKf8r{†mxyXt~adfpƒw{y>t~mny]odmxtˆry € f8ydf†vœ{YfM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}‰r{y € t~a_rutrqnqÍtvadf € ms}~}~mxz_rut~mn—{fpt~f8†~e"}‰w¨SwV† € f8†46¸32a’r°—Vf € ms}~r{zdzKf8r†vf € ´i`ba’mn} ¥'mnqnq{¨êwV†vƒf t~a’f©zd†vf8}v}~od†~f ­’o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}Ít~w§¬_fb}‚e"r{qxqnf†Ít~a’r{ypmnyºt~adfbƒrV}‚f©¥'m¯tvapydw‰zd†vf8ƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydmnydœ_´Í`Íw }~ffbtva’rutMÌV¥¦f'f„|z’r{y € ydwu¥»t~adfÁ—°r{†~msr¬’qxfM}#mxy"zKwu¥©f8† w¨Kt~a’fÁ†vf¨êf†vfy_ƒfªEr{ƒ:agy]ode¬_f8†©ry € mny>t~†vw € o’ƒf tvadf8}~fif„|z’r{y’}‚mnw{y_}bmxyt~adfºfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}I>š>·´.µCfiw{¬|t:rmnyErut'w{† € f†H46¸=< 2  ‘{´ w{y>t~mny]odmxtˆf8²>o’rt~mnw{y #       1  1   "$ H{  š|´badw{†vm w{y>t:rq\egw{egfy>t~o’eÀf8²>o’rt~mnw{y #     1  *  A,   *  1  A  (  1 ,   1       1 "$ Hh  d´b—{f8†‚tvmnƒ8rqÃegw{egfy>tvodef8²>o’rt~mnw{y # 
  1  *  ,   *  1   ( 1 ,   1       1 "$ H > h’´bfydf8†~œVf8²>o’rt~mnw{y #     ( 1    1       1 "$ H{“  ¥'mxt~a  1 " *  1   , <  A  < * ¹ 1   , <V´ Ë

ftbo_}bqxw]w>g¨êwV†bt~adfº}~w{qno|t~mnw{y_}bw¨MH{  Hh / I>/ H{“ ·´.`badms}bmn} rg}~|}ˆtvfeÀw{¨A¨êwVod†adwVegw{œ{f8ydfwVo’} ˆf8qxqnmnz|t~msƒ  € mx®Kf8†~f8y’ƒfºfM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}¦¨êw{†bt~a’fp‹O—urqnodf8}'w{¨Atvadf  Ôw{† € f8† z’†~fM}~}~od†vf  1

rut¦t~a’f§mny>t~f8†~mnw{†¦z_wVmxy>t:}©w{¨Ñt~a’fiƒw{egzdo|t:rutvmxwVy’rq € w{e"r{mxyÑ´ J ¬]—]mxwVo’}~qxVÌ



1

ƒwVy’}‚tvry>t¦mn} r)ƒw{egegw{yX}~w{qno|tvmxwVyEw¨.t~a’f8}~fphfM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}´ LÁwu¥©f8—{f8†8Ì € fzKfy € mnydœw{yYt~a’f¬Kw{ody € r†vƒw{y € mxt~mnw{y_}Ì tvadf8}~fpfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}Áe"r°Yrqs}‚w)a’r°—{fy’w{y ƒwVy’}ˆt:ry>t‰}~w{qno|t~mnw{y_}‰r{y € t~a’fzd†vw{¬’qxf8ems}‰t~w)fM}ˆt:r¬dqnms}‚aEtva’rut tvadf¦mxy>t~f8†v}~f8ƒt~mnw{yw{¨dt~a’fVf†vydfqs}Íw{¨dt~a’f8}~f©h§f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}Amn}A†vf € o’ƒf € t~wiƒw{y_}ˆt:ry>tA—Vf8ƒ·tvw{†:}´ 7dw{†œ{f8ydf†:rq r{†~¬’m¯tv†vr{†~¬Kw{o’y € r†vƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVy’}ÌV¥©fÁa’r°—{f'ydw{tS¬Kffyr{¬dqnf't~wz’†~wu—Vf©tvadms} †vf8}~odq¯tM´ Lwu¥¦f—{f8†8Ìu¥¦fœVmx—Vf ¬Kfqnwu¥¾tˆ¥¦wgmxegzKw{†~tvr{yVtƒ8r{}~f8}¦¥'adf†vf§t~adms}'†vf8}~odqxt'ƒ8ryY¬Kfºf8}‚tvr¬’qxms}‚a’f € ´

7mn†v}‚t8ÌÍ¥©fT†~f8e"r†Ktva’rutmny I{ Ár{y € I{“ ·Ì\tvadfƒw]f ƒmxf8yVt:}ir†vfzKwV}~m¯tvmx—Vf{Ì\tvadf†vf¨êwV†~ft~adf € ms}vƒ†vft~f e"r„]mnepo’eÀrzdz’qxmnf8}'r{y € ry3mxy>t~f8†~mnw{†'zKw{mny>tƒry’ydwt¬Kfry3f„]t~†vfeodeY´ `badf†vf¨êwV†~fVÌ>t~adfºf„>tv†~f8e"rw{¨ tvadfzd†vf8}v}~od†~f§Â’f8q€ r{†~fºwVy3t~adf¬_wVody € r{†~V´©`badms}mnegzdqxmnf8}t~a’rtÁmx¨tvadfzd†vf8}v}~od†~fºms}ƒw{y’}‚tvr{yVtwVyYt~adf

¬Kw{o’y € r†vw{¨Ít~a’fƒw{egzdodtvrutvmxwVy’rq € w{e"rmnyÑÌ]t~a’fyYm¯tms}'ƒwVy’}‚tvry>t'f—Vf†v]¥'adf†vf‰mny3t~adf € w{e"rmnyÑ´ µCfy’wu¥ zd†~w|ƒff €

t~wY}‚adwu¥ tvadfT}vregf†~fM}‚odqxt‰mx¨ tvadf

€ fy’}~m¯tˆEms}§ƒw{y_}ˆt:ry>t‰wVyEt~adfT¬Kw{ody € r†v3w{¨ tvadfgƒw{egzdodtvrutvmxwVy’rq € wVegr{mxyÍ´•Á}v}‚odegft~a’rtit~adf  1 zd†vf8}v}‚od†vfpms}§ydwtºƒwVy’}‚tvry>tiry €6€ fydw{t~fit~adf zKw{mny>tS¥'adf8†~fbtvadfe"ru„|mnepode —urqnodfw¨Kt~a’fÁzd†vf8}v}‚o’†~fbms}Srut~tvr{mxydf € àtvadmn}Sz_wVmxy>t©r{qx¥br°|}#f„|ms}ˆt:}.¬_fMƒr{o’}‚f tvadf†vfms}ÁrgÂ_ydm¯tvfpy]ode¬_f8†Áw¨ ƒw{egzdo|t:rut~mnw{y_rqÍy’w € f8}@·´
¦f8ƒ8ro’}~fit~adfe"ru„|mxeode zd†~mny’ƒmxzdqnfpr{zdzdqnmxfM}Ì tvadms}zKw{mnyVtms}prYy’fmnœ{a]¬_wV†ºw¨rY¬Kw{ody € r†vXydw € f{´Y`AwYÂd„6tvadfm€ f8r’ÌArV}~}~odegfgt~a’rtt~a’mn}p¬_wVody € r{†~ ms}'tvadfqnf¨àt§w{ydfH}‚f8fºÂ’œVod†~fph ·´¦f8ƒ8ro’}~f{̒t~adfpzd†~fM}~}~od†vfºmxy5Áms}e"ru„|mnepodeYÌ_t~adf € m¯®\f†vfy’ƒf8} 

   1 ¨êwV†    6 r{†~fz_w>}‚mxt~mn—{fTry € t~adms}imneTz’qxmnf8}‰t~a_rut  1 *  ,   1  àt~a’mn}§ms}‰mny € msƒrt~f € ¬]Er   }~]ep¬Kw{qÃwVyÂ_œ{od†vfºh ´S‹wu¥OƒwVy’}‚m€ f8†'f8²>o’rutvmxwVy H{ Hêw{†I{“  ¦¥'†vm¯t~t~f8yYrtydw € f8}

 ¨êw{†'mny’}ˆt:ry’ƒf{Ì ¬Kf8ƒ8ro’}~f  1    1 *  , tvadf†vfiepo’}‚t'¬_frtbqnf8rV}ˆt'wVydfiydfmnœ{adwV†bw¨  ¥'adw>}‚f§zd†vf8}v}‚o’†~f§mn}bqnf8}v}¦t~a_ry3t~adf z’†~fM}~}~od†vf§mny  ´''f8z_fMrutvmxydœt~adfTr†vœ{odegfy>tb¨êw{†Át~adms}y’w € f{ÌK¥©f}~ffºtva’rut‰¥©fpƒ8ryXƒw{y’}‚t~†vo’ƒ·tÁrz’rutva  "     6         4     }~o’ƒ:aEtva’rut§¨êw{†ºr{y>  mxy«t~adms}§qxms}ˆt  1    1    ´pk]mxy_ƒft~adms}§z’rutva ƒ8rydy’wt‰e"r>{fƒqxw>}‚f € qnw]w{z’}8Ì\m¯tiydf8ƒf8}v}~r{†~mnqn3f8y € }§w{y«t~adfT¬Kw{ody € r†v{´ Ë ftio_}§ƒ8rqnq

 t~a’fTzKw{mny>t§w{¨ tvadfº¬Kw{ody € r†v"¥'adf†vfim¯tf8y € }8´ J ¬>—]mnw{o’}~qn"¥©fºa’r°—Vf  1 *  ,   1 *  , ´

A

B

E

i

k

k+1

7mxœVod†vf§h  …#rut~aEƒw{ydydfMƒ·tvmxydœgzKw{mny>tv}b¥'mxt~a € f8ƒ†~fMr{}~mxy’œzd†vf8}v}~od†~fM}

µCfº†vfe"r†Kydwu¥Qt~a’rt'¨êw{†Ár{y>)mxy>t~f8†~mnw{†'zKw{mny>t8Ìd¥¦fƒr{yY†~f8¥'†~mxt~f§t~a’f}‚|}‚t~fe IV HI{h G I  / H{“  mnyTt~adf¨êw{†veŽw¨Ãrº}~]}‚t~f8eŽw{¨_¨êwVod† f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}¨êwV†.t~a’f'¨êw{od†Sody]ydwu¥'y’} 

 



1

´.k]mny’ƒft~adfƒw>f-ƒmnfy>tv} w{¨Ítvadf§t~ad†vff§f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}HIV OI{h GH  Sr{†~f§w{¬]—]mxwVo’}~qx € mx®Kf8†~f8y>t'r{y € r†v¬dm¯tv†vr{†~ êt~adf8 € fzKfy € wVy tvadfº—{f8qxw|ƒm¯tˆ"Â_fq€ ·Ì|tvadfwVydqx)z_w>}~}~mx¬’qxfi¥br°"¨êw{†btvadmn}Á}‚|}‚t~feÀt~w"a’r°—Vf§rgy’w{y/ f8†~wg}‚wVqxodt~mnw{y3mn}btva’rut fM²>o’rutvmxwVy I{“ ims}pzd†vw{zKw{†~t~mnw{y_rq.tvw«f8²>o’rt~mnw{y H{ ´«`badms}pmnegzdqnmxfM}tva’rutt~adf)¨êw{od†—°r{qxo’f8}

1

  r†vf

fM²>o’rqÚ´ k]mxy_ƒf 1   ms}¦r{y3r°—Vf†:rœVf'w¨Ítvadf§—°r{qxo’f§w{¨ 1 mny‰ry € ¥©f§e"r VfÁtvadf‰†vf8rV}‚wVy’r¬’qxf§r{}v}‚odegz tvmxwVy)tva’rut'tvadms}'mxegzdqnmnf8}¦t~a_rut't~a’fi¨êw{od†'—urqnodfM} 1  r{†~f§f8²>o’r{qH´ ‹Áwu¥ºÌdƒw{y_}‚m € f†vmnydœTr{œVr{mxy)t~adfºz’rt~a  ¥¦fg}‚f8fptva’rutºtvadmn}imnegzdqnmxfM}Átva’rutitvadf}‚zKf8ƒm¯ÂKƒpf8yVt:rqnz] 1 ms}ºƒw{y_}ˆt:ry>tir{qxwVydœtvadms}iz’rutvaÑ´ ¦o|tºmxtºmn} fMr{}~mxqn)ƒ:adfMƒ@{f € ¨ê†vw{eÀt~adf  ,
wV† € f8†'}ˆt:rut~fºqsr°¥ t~a’rt't~adf  ,
}~z_fMƒmxÂ_ƒify>t:rqnz> 1 ms} € f’ydf € ¬] 1 " +  1 * +-, 4 ,  1 ´S`ba]o’}bmx¨  1 *  ,   1 *  , Ì 1 *  ,8" 1 * B, mxegzdqnmnf8}btva’rut  1 *  ,   1 * B, ¬do|t tvadms}'mn}bmnegz_w>}~}~mn¬dqxfº}~mxy_ƒfº¥¦f§a_r°—{fir{}v}‚odegf € tva’rut'tvadf € fy_}‚mxtˆms}ƒwVy’}ˆt:ry>t'w{yt~adfº¬Kw{o’y € r†v{´

µCfr{qn}~wY†~f8egr{†+«¨ê†~wVetvadfzd†vf—]mnw{o’}ºz’†~w]w¨ˆÌAt~a_rutpmx¨bt~adf)t~fegzKf†:rutvod†~fgÂ_fq€ mn}pydwtƒw{y’}‚tvr{y>t mnyCt~adfƒw{egzdo|t:rutvmxwVy’rq € wVe"rmnyÑÌÑtvadfyCt~a’f 1   ¥'mnqxqS¬_f € mx®\f†vfy>tpry € tvadfyCt~a’fr†vœ{odegfy>tºœ{mn—{f8y r{¬_wu—Vf§}~adwu¥}©t~a_rut't~a’f  1 zd†vf8}v}‚o’†~f‰Â’fq€ mn}'ƒw{y’}‚tvr{y>t8´#µ6fƒw{qnqxfMƒ·t'tvadf8}~fi†~fM}‚odqxtv}bmny1 ©Å  +¢ I
<
* *5') & (6  & !    , 8! (6 ('9T(  5  "! & 1 *6
% $8
T* 
  !    , 8! (  &* * 58  1 *E$8
T* 

,785
%!     !    , 8! (E! (
T*   1 *E$ 
*
 
2)785
!3   (
 4:6¸=< 2 @N&5 
T*  ! "!! %  ! %  !  '9  #   1  " "
  

k|mxy’ƒfptvadf†vfgr†vfydw 4:6¸ 2itvf†ve mxy«t~adfgf8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}I>š>Ì_tvadfTw{† € f†4:6¸32ºfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}tva’ruti†vf8}~odq¯t ¨ê†vw{eÀt~adfºf„|z’ry’}~mnw{y1ˆ‘8“ br†vf§t~wt:rqnqx)m€ f8y>t~msƒrqÑt~wgt~a’fw{† € f†H46¸=< 2 f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}b¥'mxt~a  1 †~f8zdqsr{ƒf € ¬]   ´ `badf8†~f¨êw{†vfÁtvadf}vregfºr†vœ{odegfy>tr{}¦¨êwV†bt~adfºwV† € f† 

zd†~fM}~}~od†vf§ƒ8ry3¬_fºo_}‚f € r{y € ¥©fia’r°—Vf

J

¡ É L É ŸN@à @É ?1I
<

G
! (E) *8*5' 
* (' ' !  *(5
*E !*($( &  @N&5 % 
*6     $ 
%! 
 !!* * 
* 5 3   * *5  # 5$&5 
*6  !3& ¸=<2 &

 * ; 
, "  1 *
,  ¸ < 2  < * ; 
, H>™  Å +¢d¡R7¤ w{egz’r{†~mnydœYt~a’fƒrV}‚f)w¨bt~adfzd†vf8ƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydf €³€ ms}~}~mxz_rut~mnw{y³¥'mxt~a¼t~adfw{ydfw{¨'t~adf wV†~mnœ{mny’r{qэ'w]fp}~ƒ:a’fegf{Ìd¥¦fºydw{t~fºtva’rutÁmnyYt~a’mn}Áqnrt‚t~f8†ÁƒrV}‚fVÌdtvadfB4:6¸32§fM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}bqxmnyt~adfz’†~fM}~}~od†vf € m¯®\f†vfy’ƒf8}¥'mxt~atvadfb—{f8qxw|ƒmxtˆ € mx®Kf8†~f8y’ƒfM}´#•»ƒw{y’}~f8²>odf8y’ƒf¦ms}Ítva’rutt~a’f¦wV†€ f†.¸ 2 zd†~fM}~}~od†vf





$ 
%
% ¬_fÁƒw{y’}‚tvr{y>t8´ J ygt~adfw{t~adf8†Sa’r{y € ÌV¨êw{†.tvadfÁz’†~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydf €g€ ms}v}‚mnz’rutvmxwVyÑÌtvadfÁwV† € f† 46¸=<

2

ry € 46¸ 2 f8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}.mny]—{w{qn—{f € wVydqnt~a’fzd†vf8}v}‚od†vf € mx®Kf8†~f8y’ƒfM}´#`badfzKwV}v}~mx¬dmnqnm¯tˆpt~wœVftSriydwVyԃw{y’}‚tvr{y>t z’†~fM}~}~od†vfmxy«t~adms}§ƒr{}~fpms}§†~f8qnrt~f € t~wt~adf¨Ir{ƒtÁt~a_rut§t~adf{f8†~ydf8qn}Áw¨ tvadf € m¯®\f†vfy_ƒfpfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}Áe"r° ƒw{y>tvr{mxy6ydw{y+ƒwVy’}‚tvry>tº—{fMƒ·tvw{†:}´T`badmn}ims}ºr3¥©f8qxq ]ydwu¥'y6zd†vw{¬dqnfe ¨êwV†it~adf"r{zdzd†vw°„]mne"rutvmxwVyXw¨¦t~adf mny’ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnff8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}Áw{yXƒwVqxqnw|ƒrt~f € egfM}‚adfM}tva’rut € w)y’wt§}vrutvmn}‚¨êt~adfTmxyd¨Ô}~odz«ƒ†~mxt~f8†~mnw{yÑ´ÁŠy }~w{egfº}~fy’}~f§t~adfr{zdz_fMr†:ry’ƒf‰w{¨Ítvadmn}'tˆ>zKfºw¨zd†vw{¬dqnfe¥br{}by’wtodydf„|z_fMƒ·t~f € ´

PRESSURE: MIN = 71.2413 MAX = 71.907

PRESSURE: MIN = 7142.67 MAX = 7143.33

PRESSURE: MIN = 714285.5 MAX = 714286.2

7mnœ{od†vf ¦Šˆ}~wu—urqnodf8}Áw¨#t~a’fzd†vf8}v}~od†~fV̒wVy«rd‘V‘h"ydw € fegf8}~aE¨êw{†i¸
"  4àtvw{z Ìø "    4 Iegm€d€ qxf:·Ì_¸
"$   

`Aw3ƒw{y’ƒqxo € fTt~adms}i}‚fMƒ·t~mnw{yÍÌÑ¥©fT†vft~o’†~y«t~wt~adfgy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq#f„|zKf†vmxegf8yVt:}§z_f8†‚¨êwV†~egf € mxyC}‚fMƒ·tvmxwVy ’´ 7mxœVod†vfgzd†vf8}~fy>t:}'t~a’fzd†vf8}v}~od†~fiÂ_fq € }¨êwV†Átvadf}vregfºtvad†vff € f8ƒ†vf8rV}‚mnydœ"mny|­’wu¥ŽªErVƒ:aEy]odep¬Kf† rV}¦mxy 7mxœVod†~fºšpw{yt~adfº}vregfÁ’„]f € egfM}‚aÑ´#Š yYƒwVyVtv†vrV}ˆt¦t~wt~a’fº†~fM}‚odqxtv}¦wV¬|tvr{mxydf € ¥'mxt~at~adfºwV†~mnœ{mny’r{q w>f}vƒ:adf8eTfVÌA¥¦fydw{t~f"ydwu¥t~a_ruttvadf}~w{qno|t~mnw{y_}ƒwVy>—Vf†vœ{ft~w«rYo’ydmn²>odf}‚wVqxo|tvmxwVy I•'ƒ·tvo’rqnqn{Ìt~adf ms}~wu—°r{qxo’f8}i¨êwV†ptvadf8}~ftvad†~f8fªErVƒ:a¼y]odep¬Kf†:}pr{†~f)r{qxegw>}ˆtpo’y € ms}ˆtvmxydœVodms}‚a’r{¬dqnf0·´ 7mxœVod†~f“Xzd†vf8}~fy>tv} tvadfºzd†vf8}v}‚o’†~f‰­’o’ƒt~o’rt~mnw{y’}b¥'mxt~aE†vf8}~z_fMƒ·tbt~wTtvadfpªEr{ƒ:a3y]odep¬Kf†M´ •Á}mxy3t~a’fºzd†~f8—]mxwVo’}b}‚fMƒ·t~mnw{yÍÌ|t~adf r{œ{†vff8eTf8y>t¥'m¯tvaXt~a’fptvadfwV†~3mn}‰†vfe"r†Kur¬dqnfBbt~a’fpzd†vf8}v}‚o’†~fº­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}‰}vƒr{qxfpf„dr{ƒt~qn3¥'mxt~a«t~adf }v²>o’r†vf§w¨t~adfªErVƒ:ay]ode¬_f8†Ár{}bmny)tvadfƒwVy>t~mny>o’w{o’}'ƒ8r{}~f{´

1e-07

1e-6

1e-5

1e-4

1e-3

1e-2

1e-1

1e-3

1e-2

1e-1

1

(Pmax - Pmin)/Pmax

MACH

Preconditioned dissipation order 1

Preconditioned dissipation order 2

y = x*x

7mnœ{od†vfi“.….†vf8}v}‚od†vf­_o’ƒ·tvo’rutvmxwVy’}¦—{f†:}~o’}Smny|­’wu¥ ªEr{ƒ:ay>o’ep¬Kf†
d}‚wVqxm€ qnmxy’f#wV† € f8†‰‘VÌ € r{}~adf € qnmxydf .wV† € f†š|´ 7dwV†ƒwVeTz_r†vmn}~w{yÑÌ>tvadfƒod†v—{f
" ; <ims}'†vfzd†vf8}~fy>tvf € ¬])r € wt‚tvf € qxmnydfV´  ;Žp
! 81)&p

Œ‰}‚mnydœ§ryprV}‚]egz|t~w{t~msƒSr{y’rqn|}‚ms}Ãw¨’t~adf € mn}vƒ†vftvfSodz]¥'mny € r{zdzd†vw°„|mxe"rutvmxwVyiw¨|t~a’f¦ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnfS±.odqnf† fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}Ì|¥¦fizd†vwu—>m€ fºr € ft:rmnqxf € f„|zdqsry’rt~mnw{y3w¨t~adfºegf8ƒ:a_rydms}‚et~a’rtzd†~w € o_ƒf8}¦tvadfº¨Ir{mxqnod†vf§w{¨ ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf)ƒw € f)t~wCƒw{egzdodt~f3—{f†v+}‚od¬_}‚wVydmnƒ"­’wu¥}´CµCf}~adwu¥7†~mnœ{wVod†vw{o’}~qx«t~a’rtmny¼tvadfqnwu¥ ªXr{ƒ:a)y]ode¬_f8†bqxmnegm¯tMÌ|t~adf € ms}vƒ†vft~f§f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}b}~odzdzKw{†~t'zd†~fM}~}~od†vf­’o_ƒ·t~o_rut~mnw{y_}bw¨Ñtvadfiw{† € f†bw¨At~adf ªXr{ƒ:aCy>o’ep¬Kf†º¥'admnqxf"mnyCt~adf}~w{qno|tvmxwVy’}iw¨¦t~adfƒw{y>t~mny]odw{o_}‰fM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}ÌÑt~adfz’†~fM}~}~od†vfT}vƒr{qxfM}‰¥'mxt~a tvadf *-N&5   w¨At~adfªErVƒ:ay]ode¬_f8†8´.`badf§t~a’fw{†v"ms}¦t~wt:rqnqxƒw{y|Â_†~egf € ¬]"y]odegf†vmnƒ8rq\f„|zKf†vmxegfy>t:}´ µCf"ydf„>tºf„|r{egmxydfTtvadfƒrV}‚fT¥'adf†vfTt~adf"y]odegf8†~msƒr{q € mn}v}‚mnz’rt~mnw{yCmn}ºr{q¯tvf†vf € ¥'m¯tva6tvadf"adf8qxzCw¨¦t~adf z’†~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmnydœ³e"rut~†vmx„»zd†vw{zKwV}~f € mny :Ú´ 7’w{†"tvadmn}qsrut‚tvf†3ƒr{}~f{Ìb¥¦fX}‚a’wu¥tva’rut)t~adfC}‚wVqxo|tvmxwVy w{¨Stvadf € ms}~ƒ†~ft~f"f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}§zKwV}v}‚fM}~}~f8}iz’†~fM}~}~od†vfp­’o_ƒ·t~o_rut~mnw{y_}iw¨¦t~adfƒw{†v†~fMƒ·tiegr{œ{ydmxt~o € f{´•ÁœVrmnyÑÌ y]odegf8†~msƒr{qKf„|z_f8†~mnegfy>tv}ƒw{y|Â_†~e7tvadf§t~adf8w{†vftvmnƒ8rqÆvf8}~odq¯t:}´

!g
'
'$%
pA&

µCfr{†~f)œ{†:rut~f¨êodq tvw F‰†•p´8F‰f†v—]mxf8o|„C¨êw{†¨ê†vodmxt‚¨êodq € ms}vƒo’}v}‚mnw{y_}¥¦fa’r € ´«µCfrqs}~wEt~a’r{y1FÁ†g±'´ `Aod†K{f8q¨êw{†3mny|¨êw{†ve"rut~mnw{yQadf«œ>r°—{fXo’}w{y adms})f„]zKf†vmnfy’ƒf«w{yQzd†~fMƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydmnydœ¼egftvadw € }8´ `ba’mn} †vfzKw{†~tSms} z’r{†‚t©w¨Ãt~a’f‰}~f8ƒwVy € rodt~adwV† }#t~a’f8}~mn}©¥©wV†+¥'admsƒ:aa’r{}S¬_f8fyº‡ˆwVmxy>tvqxg}‚o’zdz_wV†‚tvf € ¬] ‹Á±Sk r{y € ± ‹Á•'Œ Ë `i´

 L/L Å ? ÊG@
=
ÉÑÅ ŸT¢TL/LA¡ É @+¢|  Å  @ Å +¢ ?/? Ÿ É  Å ¡ Ë

fto’}'¥'†vmxt~f§t~adfpš/F ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf§± odqxf8†f8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}H ¦mny)tvadfƒwVy’}~f†v—°rt~mn—{f‰¨êw{†ve

2
     * ,8"$    * ,8"    * ,  < * ,   H{›  ¥'a’f†vf "       ! !       * , "        < 4   * !  ,       < * , "    !    <  * ! 4 ,     H{˜  Š y>t~f8œ{†:rutvmxydœt~a’f8}~fºf8²>o’rutvmxwVy’}bw{yYrgƒwVyVtv†~wVq\—{w{qnodegf #  ¥©fiœVft  <   
 #      *        I,8"   IhV”  ¥'a’f†vf  *   -     0, ÌÑt~a’fy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq­’o|„6¨êody’ƒ·tvmxwVy¼rzdz’†~w°„|mnegrt~fM}                  ´B7dw{†w>f }vƒ:adf8eTfVÌ]t~adms}b¨êody_ƒ·t~mnw{yYms} € fÂ_ydf € ¬]E

 * -        , "   *  ,    * :, (       4 (  *        , >    ¥'a’f†vf‰tvadfºe"rutv†~mx„  *        , }~rt~ms}ˆÂ’fM}¦t~adf§¨êwVqxqnwu¥'mxy’œTz’†~wVz_f8†‚tˆ   *       0,   ! H" *   *  , ,   * 0,+,      ŠÔ¨#¥©fºmny>t~†vw € o’ƒf§tvadfºfmnœ{f8y>—Vf8ƒt~w{†:}©w¨Ae"rt~†vm¯„  *       I,  .  *  0, "      4       <   . <   (       . < *  0,8"     , *  ,  *  A ,         .  *  0, "    4     ¹   *  A,     ¹   *  ,     ¹          .  *  0, "    4    , ¹   *  A,     , ¹   *  ,    , ¹          Ih’‘0

¥'a’f†vf   "    *  A,  .   *  ,     " ,    *  ,  )   *  A,   tvadf8}~fTfmnœ{fy]—Vf8ƒ·tvw{†:}'¨êwV†~er3ƒwVeTz’qxft~fT¬’r{}~fw{¨
.  r{y € ry]Y—{f8ƒt~wV†  " *     <       ,  ƒr{y ¬Kfº¥'†vm¯t~t~fyYr{}H  "  # 
 )  *  ,.  ¥'a’f†vf‰tvadfƒw]wV† € mny’rt~f8} )  mny3t~adms}'¬’rV}‚fºr{†~f € f’ydf € ¬]5 )  "   ,  ¹ <    ) < "  )  " 4 (   ¹ <     ¹     )  " 4 (   ¹ <   ,  ¹    Ih>š> ¥'mxt~a  " * +-, 4 , *   ,     ,     <   <   . <   (   ,   " *  A,    <  *  ,     ,       " , *  ,    <  *  A ,     ,      IhV 

•‰}b†~f8e"r†K{f € ¬])•¬dœV†vr{qxqÃmny1 šÚÌ]¨êwV†ry] "$ tvadf    w{zKf†:rutvw{†bw{¬Kf|}¦t~a’fi¨êw{qnqxwu¥'mnydœT†~odqnf8}H    * ¹  ,8" ¹          ¹ ¥'mxt~a ¹ " ¹    ¹  4     ¹ " ¹    ¹  4   ªEw{†vfwu—{f8†©mx¨  "   6   Ì|¥¦fºa’r°—VfÁtvadfr €d€ m¯tvmxwVy’rqÃzd†vw{zKf†~tˆ   ¹ "   ¹ Ih{h  `ba’mn}'}~mxegzdqnmx¨êt~w}~w{egfif„]tvfy € t~adfºf„|zd†~fM}~}~mnw{y)w{¨Atvadfºy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq € ms}v}‚mnz’rutvmxwVy3}~mny’ƒfi¥¦f§wV¬|tvr{mxy  )  *   ! , "     ,     ¹ <    ) < *   ! , "        )  *   ! , " 4 ( ¹        ¹  )         )  *   ! , " 4 ( ¹        ¹  ,         Ih>

µC†vm¯tvmxydœTtvadfºy]odegf†vmnƒ8rq € ms}~}~mnz’rutvmxwVyody € f†btvadfi¨êw{†ve  *       0,    K 9"  # 
 )  *   ! ,  (  *  I,  .  *  0,  IhV“  ¥'mxt~a3tvadfºfmnœ{f8y>—ur{qxodf (  *  -, œVmx—Vfy3¬>5 (  "     ( < "     ( "     ¹    (  "    , ¹    Ih]™  ¥¦f§t~adf8yYw{¬|t:rmny   *  0,    ! H"                     8)  *   ! ,  <     ¹ <                8)  *   ! ,  %  ,         *  ,            ¹ <                8)  *   ! , %           *  A,           ¹ <                8)  *   ! ,  < %  ) < %  (                      ¹ <                            IhV›  ¥'mxt~a   "    ¹    < " ¹     "    ¹       ¹   *  A ,    " ¹   *   A   ,   "    ¹      ¹   *  ,     " ¹   *   . ,    "    *   ¹    ¹  0,  " ¹   *   < ,  IhV˜  'u'
)!¦'&

n‘ 
iqsrmnydf†ve"ry³k\´ªXru‡€ rY•´ w{egzd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnf"ry € mny’ƒwVegzd†~fM}~}~mn¬dqxfT­’o’m€ }8´  ' '  58
   02  Ì_ “Vš{˜|“ ’Ì’‘M˜{›Všd´

äš: 8egm •¬dœV†vr{qxqÚ´•Áy6f„>tvfy’}~mnw{yCw¨©'w]f }iodz]¥'mny € }~ƒ:adf8egfptvwYr{qxœVf¬d†:rmsƒfM²>odmxqnmn¬d†~mnode†vf8r{q#œVr{} egw € fqs}8´  '95( *E 
%!
5! * ÌёM˜&ښ>!n‘°™|‘ \‘8›Všd̒‘M˜{˜d‘V´

T´GL´ adw{mSr{y € ´ Ë ´ªYf†K]qxfV´`badfr{zdzdqnmnƒ8rut~mnw{y+w{¨¦zd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmxy’œ3mny³—]mn}vƒwVo’}§­’wu¥}8´  '     *Ì͑M” š{”>™ šVšdÌ\‘M˜{˜{’´

h •p´T´§w € ¨ê†~f8{Ì_´_µ ´KµCr{q¯tvf†:}ÌKry € §´_—°r{y Ë f8f†M´b… †~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmnydœg¨êw{†Át~adfp‹‰r°—]mxf8† ˆk>t~w {fM} fM²Vo_rut~mnw{y_}b¥'m¯tvaÂ_ydm¯tvf Ԇvrt~fºƒ:adf8eTms}‚t~†v{´


 (%  Ì‘8˜V˜{’´

:±'´Ñ`Aod†K{f8qH´p… †~fMƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydf € egft~a’w € }Á¨êwV†º}‚wVqx—]mnydœ)tvadfgmxy_ƒw{egzd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnfr{y € qnwu¥Ž}~z_f8f € ƒwVe zd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnfif8²>o’rt~mnw{y’}8´  '     *ÌљšäšV™V™ š˜V›dÌ\‘8˜V›>™|´

“±'´`Ío’†+VfqÚ´'f8—>mnf¥ w¨'zd†vf8ƒw{y € m¯tvmxwVydmxy’œEeTft~adw € }º¨êw{†º­’o’m€³€ ]y’r{egmnƒ8}´

3  ! 465' &$  02 ('  $* Ì͑°šäš >™ š›{h’ÌÑ8˜V˜{’´

î™0±'´Ã`Aod†K{fqÚÌÕ´ 7m¯tvf†ve"ryÑÌÃry € §´\—°r{y Ë f8f†M´º….†~fMƒwVy € mxt~mnw{ydmnydœr{y € tvadfqnmneTmxtit~w)t~adfTmxy_ƒw{e zd†vf8}v}~mx¬dqnf§­’wu¥QfM²>o’rutvmxwVy’}´#`Af8ƒ:adydmsƒr{qэ'fzKw{†~tÁ˜{ Úh]š|Ì>Š

•‰k|±Ì͑8˜V˜{’´

› ´Ámnw> MrutM´ÍŠ egzdqnmnƒm¯tbodz]¥'mxy € }vƒ:adfegf8}S¨êw{†bqnwu¥QªEr{ƒ:a)y>o’ep¬Kf†'ƒwVeTz’†~fM}~}~mx¬’qxf'­_wu¥}´`ÍfMƒ:adydmsƒrq 'f8z_wV†‚tV”{›h_Ì]Šˆ‹Á'Šˆ•pÌё8˜V˜>™]´

˜T´.w{qnzKf{´#…Af8†‚¨êwV†~e"r{y’ƒf‰w¨Aƒw{egzd†vf8}v}‚mn¬dqnf­’wu¥¾ƒw € f8}brutbqxwu¥ ªEr{ƒ:ay]ode¬_f8†8´


 5
% Ì ’‘ ˆ‘:!hV˜  “’ÌV˜Vd´

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopoˆle de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique,

615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LE

` S NANCY

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rhoˆne-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA ANTIPOLIS Cedex

E

´ diteur

INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)

ISSN 0249-6399