A NNALES DE L ’I. H. P., SECTION A
U GO M OSCHELLA
New results on de Sitter quantum field theory
Annales de l’I. H. P., section A, tome 63, n
o4 (1995), p. 411-426
<http://www.numdam.org/item?id=AIHPA_1995__63_4_411_0>
© Gauthier-Villars, 1995, tous droits réservés.
L’accès aux archives de la revue « Annales de l’I. H. P., section A » implique l’accord avec les conditions générales d’utilisation (http://www.numdam.
org/conditions). Toute utilisation commerciale ou impression systématique est constitutive d’une infraction pénale. Toute copie ou impression de ce fichier doit contenir la présente mention de copyright.
Article numérisé dans le cadre du programme Numérisation de documents anciens mathématiques
http://www.numdam.org/
411
New results
onde Sitter quantum field theory (*)
Ugo
MOSCHELLAService de Physique Theorique, C.E. Saclay,
91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France.
Vol. 63, n° 4, 1995, Physique theorique
ABSTRACT. - We describe a new
approach
to d-dimensional de Sitterquantum
fieldtheory.
Thisapproach
allows acomplete
characterization of thepreferred
de Sitter vacua for Klein-Gordon field theories in terms of theanalyticity properties
of thetwo-point function,
for which weprovide
anew
integral representation.
The latter relies on a natural basis of de Sitterplane-waves,
which areholomorphic
in tubular domains of thecomplexified
de Sitter
space-time. Finally
we discuss apossible general approach
tointeracting
de Sitter fieldtheories, which,
among otherproperties, justifies
the "Wick rotation" to the "euclidean
sphere".
RESUME. - Nous
presentons
une nouvelle methoded’ approche
a la theoriequantique
deschamps sur l’espace-temps
courbe de de Sitter en dimension dquelconque.
Cette methodepermet
une caracterisationcomplete
des « etatsde vide
preferentielles
» des theories de Klein-Gordon sur cetespace-temps,
au moyen des
proprietes d’ analyticite
de la fonction a deuxpoints,
fonctiondont nous donnons une nouvelle
representation integrale.
Cette derniere met enjeu
une base naturelle d’ondesplanes
de sitteriennesholomorphes
dansdes domaines tubulaires de
l’espace-temps
de de Sittercomplexifie.
Nouspresentons
aussi un cadreaxiomatique possible
pour F etude des theories dechamps
de sitteriennes eninteraction,
cadrequi justifie
entre autresproprietes
Ie passage a la «sphere
euclidienne »(analogue
de la « rotationde
Wick »).
(*) Based on an invited talk at the "Colloquium on New Problems in the General Theory of Quantized Fields", Paris, July 1994.
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique - 0246-0211
Vol. 63/95/04/$ 4.00/@ Gauthier-Villars
412 U. MOSCHELLA
Quantum
fieldtheory
on de Sitterspace-time
is asubject
which hasbeen studied
by
many authors over the lastthirty
years. The first historicalreason for this
popularity
is the fact that de Sitterspace-time
is the mostsymmetrical example
of curvedspace-time
manifold.Indeed,
the de Sitter metric is a solution of thecosmological
Einstein’sequations
which hasthe same
degree
ofsymmetry
as the flat Minkowski solution.Actually,
itcan be seen as a
one-parameter
deformation of the latter which involvesa fundamental
length
R. Thespace-time corresponding
to this metric may then be visualisedby
a d-dimensional one-sheetedhyperboloid
embeddedin a Minkowski ambient space The
symmetry
group inherent in the de Sitterspace-time
is the Lorentz group of the ambient space, and the very existence of this(maximal) symmetry
groupexplains
thepopularity
of thisspace-time
as a convenientsimple
model todevelop techniques
ofQFT
on a
gravitational background,
in view of anapplication
to moregeneral space-times (perhaps
with nosymmetries).
The interest in the de Sitter metric increased
tremendously
in the lastfifteen years on a much more
physical ground,
since it turned out that itplays
a central role in theinflationary cosmological
scenario(see [ 14]
and references
therein). According
to thelatter,
the universeundergoes
aphase
ofexponential expansion (quasi-de
Sitterphase)
in the veryearly epochs
of its life. Apossible explanation
ofphenomena occuring
in thevery
early
universe then relies on aninterplay
betweenspace-time
curvatureand
thermodynamics
and aprominent
role isplayed by
the mechanisms ofsymmetry breaking
and restoration in a de SitterQFT.
These reasons
explain
the enormous amount of literature on de SitterQFT.
Several different
approaches
have been used for the task ofquantizing
fieldson this
space-time, but, they
have left openquestions
either at the level of firstprinciples
or even at the morepratical
level ofdoing
calculations.Indeed,
thepeculiarities
of de Sitterspace-time
have not beenfully exploited
in thepast just
becausepeople
have beenlooking
at it as theparadigm
of a moregeneral
curvedspace-time.
Therefore the methods that have beenapplied
areclosely
similar to the ones that may be used in othercases. In
particular,
the mostpopular approach
to curvedspace-time QFT (see
e.g.[2])
follows the lesson of the canonicalquantization
of fields inflat Minkowski space. In the
simplest
case of a bosonic linear field oneconsiders the action
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
where p
(~)
is the Ricci scalar curvature. In thisexpression
there is acoupling
between thequantum
field and the(unquantized) background given by
the termçp (~)
besides thegravitational
effects due to the metricg 03BD (x).
The field satisfies a Klein-Gordontype equation
s
-f-M2
-f-~p ~ ( )~ cjJ
=0, where ~ _ 9 ( 9) - 2 ( 9) 2
One then introduces the scalar
product
where ~ is a
spacelike hypersurface
and d~ is the associated volumeelement,
and looks for acomplete
set(in
the sense of thegiven
scalarproduct)
of mode solutions ~i(x)
of the fieldequation.
Thefield (~
is thengiven by
modeexpansion
and canonical
quantization
is achievedby assuming
the commutation rules(CCR) cx~ ] = a~ = a~ ==
0 andby choosing
thecorresponding
vacuum. Theambiguities
inherent thequantization
of fieldson a
gravitational background
appear hereclearly:
in fact theprevious
modeexpansion
isgenerally
based on anarbitrary
choice of local coordinates(which
may or may not extend to the wholespace). Moreover,
since there is no suchthing
as aglobal
energyoperator,
it is ingeneral impossible
to characterize the
physically
relevant vacuum states as the fundamentalstates for the energy in the usual sense; what is
lacking
is therefore theanalogue
of aspectral
condition.These facts have
pushed
several authors to formulate various alternativeprescriptions
toselect,
among thepossible
vacua of aquantum
fieldtheory,
those which can have a
meaningful physical interpretation;
let usquote,
in view of theirimportance,
the adiabaticprescription,
the local Hadamardcondition,
and thecon,f’ormal criterion,
each of thesehaving
their ownrange of
applications (see [2], [13]
and referencestherein).
In a moregeneral conceptual framework,
one must also mention the localdefiniteness
criterion
(see [12]
and referencestherein).
Let us
briefly
recall thespecially interesting
case of Robertson-Walkerspacetimes.
Forspatially
flatspace-times
the metric is written asds2
==dt2 - a2 (t) ~ (dxi)2
= C(r~)
where 7y is the conformali i
time. With this choice of
coordinates,
mode solutions areseparable
intol-d d-2 -.
factors:
~ck
=(2?!-) 2
C 4(ri)
and the function x~ satisfiesVol. 63, n° 4-1995.
414 U. MOSCHELLA
the
following equation:
+~k2
+ C(Mz ~ (ç - ç (d)) p)]
xk(1])
=0, where ~ (~)
=2014-201420142014-.
The mode normalization is obtainedby
aWronskian condition:
xk. ~,~
xk -x~ ~~, xk
= z.Going
back to deSitter, by using
thefollowing
coordinatesystem
one can look at de Sitterspace-time
as an
exponentially expanding spatially
flat Robertson-Walkerspace-time:
(this parametrization
is the most often used ininflationary cosmology;
there are other
parametrizations
which exhibitparts
of the Sitter manifoldas
spatially
closed or open Robertson-Walkerspace-times,
see e.g.[14]).
In these coordinates the metric is written
ds2
=dt2 -
=1i
y~ (d~r~)~], ~ =1
Mode solutions are then obtainedi
in the form of a linear combination of Hankel functions.
For,
instance in the four dimensional case we have ~03BA(~)
=1 03C0 3 2 3 [ci (k) H(1)03BD (k~)
+C2(k)H(2)03BD(k~)] ]
withnormalization IC212 - |c1|2
= 1. The adiabaticprescription (see
e.g.[2])
may then be invoked to set Cl =0, 02 ~ 20141.
Finally
thetwo-point
vacuumexpectation
value of the field may be calculated as a mode sum and identified to aprecise hypergeometric
function. The
corresponding QFT
is mostfrequently
referred to as "Bunchand Davies"
[7]
or "Euclidean"[11] vacuum (representation)
and hasplayed
a central role in the
applications
of de Sitter fieldtheory
tocosmology, especially
for the aim ofcomputing
thespectrum
ofdensity
fluctuations in the observed universe.Very roughly speaking,
this is the common way to think of de SitterQFT,
and after the papers that haveappeared
on thesubject
in the seventiesno
deeper investigations
of the situation at theglobal
level have beenproposed,
eventhough
many mathematicalaspects
of these field theories have beenstudied,
inparticular,
in connection with ideas ofquantum
fieldtheory
ingeneral
curvedspace-time
manifolds([12], [13]).
For the sake ofcompletness
one has to mention the functionalintegral approach
to deSitter
QFT
that has been usedby
Gibbons andHawking [ 11 ],
whichgives
Annales de BBl’Institut Poincaré - Physique theorique
the name "euclidean" to the
preferred
vacua described above. As we will see, thisapproach
isfully justified only
in aglobally analytical approach
and this is what we want to introduce.
In the
following
we will describe a new and moreglobal approach
to deSitter
QFT
which has been elaborated in acontinuing
collaboration with Bros([3], [4], [5], [16]).
Thisapproach
allows tofully
characterize thepreferred family
of de Sitter invariant Klein-Gordonquantum
field theories and also opens the way to ageneral
treatment ofinteracting
theorieson this
space-time.
Our idea deals with thepossibility
ofdevelopping
ageneral approach
based on a set of fundamentalprinciples,
which shouldbe
completely
similar to theWightman approach
for minkowskian fields.This is
by
no meansobvious,
since in the latter manyimportant concepts
are based on the Fourier
representation
ofspace-time, namely
the energy- momentum space. Therefore onemajor objective
to be reached would be todispose
of aglobal
de Sitter-Fourier calculus. Thepossibility
of such anapproach
relies on theproperties
of thegeometry
of the de Sitterspace-time
and of its
complexification,
which make thisspace-time
so similar(although
with many
important differences)
to thecomplex
Minkowskispace-time.
Let us
briefly
recall some facts. The de Sitterspace-time
may berepresented by
a d-dimensional one-sheetedhyperboloid
embedded in a Minkowski ambient space whose scalar
product
isdenoted
by
x ~ ~ =~(o) _ y(1) - ~ ~ . - with,
asusual, x2
=1x . x ;
Xd
is thenequipped
with a causalordering
relation which is inducedby
that of~x
E~~ > ~(i)’ +...+~}
be the future cone of the
origin
in the ambient space;then,
for x,~/ E
Xd, x > ~ ~ ~2014?/GV .
The future andpast
cone of agiven
event x in
Xd
aregiven by r~ (x) _ -Xd ~ ~/ ~ ~(~ ~ 2/)}.
The
boundary
set ofr+ (x)
U r-(x)
is the"light-cone"
ar(x)
andit is the union of all linear
generatrices
ofXd containing
thepoint
x :
ar (x) _ {y
EXd : (x - y)2
=0}.
Two events xof y
ofXd
are in "acausal
relation",
or"space-like separated" r+ (x)
U r-(x),
i.e. if x . y
> -R2.
Therelativity
group of the de Sitterspace-time
is thepseudo-orthogonal
groupGd
==90o(l, d) leaving
invariant each of the sheets of the cone C =C+
U C- :The
Gd-invariant
volume onXd
will be denotedby
Since thegroup
Gd
acts in a transitive way onXd,
it is convenient todistinguish
Vol. 63, n° 4-1995.
416 U. MOSCHELLA
a base
point
.ro inXd
whichplays
the role of theorigin
in Minkowskispace-time;
we choose thepoint
~° _(0,
... ,0, R),
and consider thetangent
spaceIId
toXd, namely
thehyperplane IId
=~x
E==
R}
as the d-dimensional Minkowskispace-time (with pseudo-
metric
dx(0)2 - d
onto which the de Sitterspace-time
can be contracted in the zero-curvature limit.
Let us introduce also some crucial
geometrical
notionsconcerning
thecomplex hyperboloid
equivalently
characterized as the set= {(~r, y )
E xI~ d+ 1 :
x2 - y2 = - R2 , x ~
~/ =0}.
We define thefollowing
open subsets ofwhere
T:I:
== + i are the so-called forward and backward tubes in which are the(minimal) analyticity
domains of theFourier-Laplace
transforms of
tempered
distributionsf (p)
withsupport
contained inV
or in
Y ,
obtained in connection with thespectral
condition in MinkowskiQFT
in[ 18].
In the same way asT+
U T contains the "euclideansubspace"
=~z =
...,~) : (~’B
... ,of the
complex
Minkowskispace-time
oneeasily
checksthat
T+ U T
contains thesphere 3d
=~z
==x~1 ~,
...,x~d~) :
~(o)’ _p x~12
-p ... +x~d>2
=~2~
We callT+,
T- the "forward"and "backward tubes" and the "euclidean
sphere"
ofArmed with these
geometrical
notions we now follow the historicalpattern
and reconsider first the de Sitter Klein-Gordon theories. In thefollowing,
we will neither make use of anyparticular
coordinatesystem
on de Sitter
space-time
nor treat space and time variables on a differentfooting.
In thisrespect,
westay
closer to thespirit
ofgeneral relativity.
Since p
(x)
= p =12/R2
the de Sitter Klein-Gordon fieldequation
may be rewritten aswhere 2
=M2 + çp
is a massparameter,
and we look for anoperator-
valued distributional
[ 18]
solution for thisequation.
Instead oflooking
formode solutions which are factorized in some suitable coordinate
system
we will make use of an
important
class of solutions of theequation (Dd
+~) ~
=0,
where now A is real orcomplex.
These solutions haveappeared long
ago in the mathematical literature([8], [15])
and aregoing
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
to
play
the same role ofplane
wave basis as theexponentials
in theMinkowski case;
by
consequence,they
will be the essentialingredients
ofa de Sitter Fourier
analysis,
one of the issues which we want to discuss.There is however an
important
difference: in contrast with the minkowskianexponentials,
these waves aresingular
on( d - 1 ) -dimensional light-like
manifolds and can at first instance be defined
only
on suitable halves of thehyperboloid.
We will need anappropriate zc-prescription
to obtainglobal
waves. Here is the relevant definition:
let ç
EC+
and consider the functiondefined for those x E
Xd
such that.r . ~
> 0(same
definition(~, s)
for those x E
Xd
such thatx . ~ 0);
m is anauxiliary
massparameter
introduced here for dimensional reasons, but it will have also a minkowskianphysical interpretation.
One has thatPhysical
values of theparameter s
aregiven by
corresponding
in the first caseto -s(d-1+s)
=(
B201420142014 )
2 -}-v2
=/
,u2 R2
= +1203BE
and in the latter caseto -s(d -
1 +s)
=( 201420142014 ) - v2
=2R2
=M2 R2
+1203BE.
Theinterpretation
of thefunctions
~ (x, s)
asplane
waves in the de Sitterspace-time
is alsosupported by
theirlarge
Rbehaviour;
infact, parametrizing 03BE by
the wave-vector of a
(minkowskian) particle
of mass m,i.e. 03BE
=[k0, k, -m],
with~
=1~2
~-m2, gives
thatin this
equation, points
in the de Sitter universe must be describedusing
theminkowskian
space-time
variable measured in units of the de Sitter radiusR;
one can choose any
parametrization
whichreproduces,
in aneighboorhoud
of the base
point
xo, the cartesianparametrization
of thecorresponding
tangent plane
toXd;
note that also the dimensionlessparameter v
has to be takenproportional
to the radius R toget
the desired limit.Let us see how to use the
previous plane
waves to construct the two-point
vacuumexpectation
value of a Klein- Gordonquantum
field. The firstVol. 63, n° 4-1995.
418 U. MOSCHELLA
problem
is that ofextending
the waves to the whole(real) hyperboloid.
Inparticular,
we need tospecify
the correctphase
factors toglue together ~+
and
~~ .
The relevant solution for thisproblem
is foundby making
use ofthe
geometry
of thecomplex hyperboloid Xd~~ ;
inparticular
the tuboids~+
and T-play
here a crucial role.To prepare the
ground
let us examinate whathappens
in the flat case.The
two-point
function for the Klein-Gordon can be written mostsimply by using
its Fourierrepresentation:
We see from this formula that the
two-point
function is obtained as asuperposition
of theplane
wavesexp ( -ik . x)
andexp ( ik . y)
andthe momentum variable k is
integrated
w.r. to the measured~ _
(1 kO 8 (k2 -
this measure is chosen to solve the waveequation
and to
satisfy
thespectral
condition[ 18] .
As a consequence of thespectral
condition
(or by
directinspection
from the convergenceproperties
of theintegral
at the r.h. s. ofequation ( 13))
we have that the distribution is theboundary
value of ananalytic
function W(z),
which isanalytic
in the backward tube
T-,
where z = x - y, and theboundary
valueis taken from T- .
Actually
thespectral
condition isequivalent
to theseanalyticity properties.
Having
these facts in mind we now consider the de Sitter case. First of all we note that we can extend theplane
waves’lj;ç (.r, s)
toanalytic
functions in
~+
or T’.Indeed, when ç
EC+
is fixed and z varies inT+
or in ~- then the functionsare
globally
defined(uniquely
up to aphase)
andholomorphic
in z, because3
(z . ç)
has a fixedsign.
Theseglobal
waves allow aspectral analysis
ofthe
two-point
functions very similar to theprevious
one. Let us introducethe
following
function:where z1, z2 E and such that z1 E
T-,
z2 E~.
Theintegration
isperformed along
any basissubmanifold 03B3
of the coneC+ (i. e.
a submanifoldintersecting
almost all thegeneratrices
of thecone)
w.r. to acorresponding
measure induced
by
the invariant measure on the cone(the integrand
Annales de Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
in
(15) appearing
as the restrictionto 03B3
of a closed differentialform).
Forinstance, by choosing
as
integration
manifold we obtain that is thecorresponding
Lorentzinvariant measure while for the
spherical
basis 1’0 =={ç E C+ : ç(O)
=m}
is the rotation invariant measure.
The function
Wv
is a solution in both variables of the(complex)
de SitterKlein-Gordon
equation
which isanalytic
in the domain7i2 = {(~i,
z1 E
T-,~2
ET~}.
This is clearby
construction. A littlemore work is demanded to show that it is
actually
a function of thesingle
de Sitter invariant variable
(z1 - z2)2
=-2R~ - 2 ZI .
.~2. Thisproperty permits
anexplicit computation, by fixing
one of the twopoints;
this ismost
easily
doneby choosing
thefollowing points
and
by integrating
on thespherical
basis of the cone. It follows that(A)
isgiven by:
p (d~ 11 ( w ~
isproportional
to theGegenbauer (hypergeometric)
function- 2 +iv
( d-1 1
of the first kind C
d21 J (w ) [ 1 ] .
The constant cd, v may be fixedby - 2 +iv
Vol. 63, n 4-1995.
420 U. MOSCHELLA
imposing
the CCR’s and we obtainOne can see here how this
analytical
andgeometrical
intrinsic(no particular
coordinate
system
isused) approach
is also useful toperform
calculations:to derive the
integral representation
of thehypergeometric
function wehave made no use of sum theorems for
special
functions. We hadonly
tosubstitute in the
Fourier-type representation
of thetwo-point
function( 15)
asuitably
chosenpair
ofpoints
of thecomplex hyperboloid
and the relevanthypergeometric
function came outautomatically. Equations ( 15), ( 17)
and( 18)
show thekey property
of thetwo-point
function:Maximal
analyticity property:
Wv maximally analytic,
i.e. can beanalytically
continued in the "cut-domain" ð. ==z2 )
Ex Xd~~ : (zl - z2 ) 2 =
p >
0}. Furthermore, Wv (zl, z2) satisfies in 0394 the complex
covariancecondition :
gz2 ) = z2 ) for all ~ SO0 (1, d)C,
thecomplexified of
the groupSO0 ( 1, d) .
These
properties
characterizeWv
asbeing
an invariant/?nr/
([3], [6])
on with domain ð.. Thetwo-point Wightman
functionvVv(xl, x2) _ (SZ, ~ (~2) 0)
is theboundary
value ofWv (zl, z2)
from
?i2;
we obtain thefollowing representation:
B /
where we have used a notation introduced in
[ 10] .
The Fourierrepresentation
for the
two-point
function of the Minkowski free field of mass m is obtainedas the limit of
equation (20)
for 1-~ ~ m R. The"permuted Wightman
function" is theboundary
value ofz2 )
from the domain
?2i = {(~i~ z2 ) :
1T~,
z2 E~"’}.
This allows theexplicit
construction of the commutator and the Green functions.An
important
consequence of therepresentation (20)
is the introduction ofa natural Fourier transform on the
hyperboloid.
Given a functionf
E D(Xd)
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
we define its Fourier transform as the
following pair
ofhomogeneous complex
functions on the coneC+ :
More
generally,
we may introduce a Fourier transformdepending
on acomplex parameter
s :By using
this Fourier transform one can show that thetwo-point
functionis
positive-definite,
i. e.for any
f
ECo (Xd).
This isstraightforward
for real v and a little moredifficult for
imaginary
v.The maximal
analyticity property
also shedslight
on the euclideanproperties
of the fieldsconsidered;
infact, by taking
the restriction ofWv
to the euclidean
sphere
and obtain theSchwinger
functionSV ~2);
This is
permitted
sinceSd
xSd
minus the set ofcoinciding points
z2,is a subset of ð.. It is
perhaps
worthwhile to stress thatproperties
ofanalytic
continuation in all the variables must be at the basis of every treatment of de Sitter field theories on the functional
integral
on the euclideansphere;
this includes the constructive
approach
toQFT
on de Sitterspace-time (in
this connection see
[9])
or theapplication
that de Sitter theories may find in minkowskian constructive fieldtheory,
since the de Sitter radius Rprovides
a natural infrared cutoff
(the
euclidean space iscompact).
Without theappropriate analyticity properties
all results inferredby
euclidean methods would not be relevant for the real de Sitter universe.The maximal
analyticity property
can also be taken as thestarting point
for a
general analysis
of the status oftwo-point
functions of de Sitterquantum
fields(we
mean free orinteracting).
Thispoint
of view has been initiated in[3]
andfully developped
in[5].
One could also ask for a
physical
basis forpostulating
these maximalanalyticity properties.
It turns out that the thermalproperties
of deSitter
generalised
free fields(in
the sense of theGibbons-Hawking
Vol. 63, n° 4-1995.
422 U. MOSCHELLA
temperature [ 11 ] )
can be proveneasily
in ouranalytic
framework andthe maximal
analyticity property
of thetwo-point
function isequivalent
tothose thermal
properties (plus
anantipodal condition).
Let us seebriefly
how the
things
go. As in[11] we adopt
theviewpoint
of an observersitting
on the
geodesic h
of xo, contained in the(~~°),
The set ofall events of
Xd
which can be connected with the observerby
thereception
and the emission of
light-signals
is theregion u
={.r
EX: >it is bordered
by
the "future" and"past"
event horizons of the observerx(o) _
> O. Theregion u
is foliatedby hyperbolic trajectories parallel
to thegeodesic h (~° )
=ho (~° ), according
to thefollowing parametrization (T, x)
=(x(0)
=R2-2
sinh2014,
x =
, x(d)
=R2-2
cosh03C4 R); 03C4
is the proper time of our observer.The curves are the orbits of the
one-parameter
group of isometries of Ll(see [ 13 ], [ 17]
for ageneral
discussion of this kind ofstructure): ~)]
=x (t ~ T, jf) EE xt, t
E R. Thecomplexified
orbits ofTh (xo), namely
thecomplex hyperbolae (xo)
have
( 2 i 03C0 R)-periodicity
in t and all their non-realpoints
inT+
andT- . This entails a remarkable
property
of the time-translated correlationfunctions =
Wv(xl, ~2)
andxl ),
where Xl and x2 arearbitrary
events in ?~l. Infact,
fromthe above stated maximal
analyticity
property ofz2 )
we deducethat
x2 )
defines a 2 i 03C0R-periodic analytic
function oft,
whose domain is theperiodic cut-plane
where
Ix1,x2
is the real interval on which(j-i 2014 xt2) 2
0. One also checks that theboundary
values ofW v (x 1, x2 )
on IR coincide with theprevious
correlation functions(the jumps
across the cutsbeing
the retarded and advancedcommutators);
theseproperties imply
thatx2 )
isanalytic
in thestrip 0~2z7rR}
and satisfies thefollowing
K.M.S. relation at
temperature
T =1/2 71-.R:
The
"energy operator"
associated with thegeodesic
isobtained
by
thespectral decomposition
of theunitary representation
of the time translation group
Th (xo)
in the Hilbertspace
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
of the
theory, namely
whichyields
) =
Theprevious
K.M.S. condition is thenequivalent
to the fact that energy measurementsperformed by
an observerat rest at the
origin
on states localized in Ll areexponentially damped by
afactor exp
(-2 ~r I~ cv)
in the range ofnegative energies.
In the limit of flatspace-time
this factor will kill allnegative energies,
so that one recoversthe usual
spectral
condition of"positivity
of theenergy".
In the
general interacting
case one cannotexpect
maximalanalyticity properties
to hold forn-point
functions(n
>2);
we are left with the task offinding
a suitablegeneral approach
to de SitterQFT.
Let usconsider the case of a
theory
that can be characterizedby
a sequence ofWightman
distributions ...,xn) _
on The
properties required
for theseWightman
functions can besummarized in a set of four axioms. If the first three of these axioms are
straightforward adaptations
to the de Sitterspace-time
of thecorresponding
axioms of Minkowskian
Q.F.T.,
the fourth one whichplays
the role ofthe
Spectral
Condition is not so. Infact,
due to the absence of aglobal
energy-momentum interpretation
on the curvedspace-time Xd,
our fourthaxiom will be formulated in terms of
analytic
continuationproperties
ofthe distributions
Wn
in thecomplexified
manifoldscorresponding
to
Of course, the choice of such
global analyticity properties
maycertainly
be done in a
non-unique
way, and thecorresponding properties
of theGNS "vacuum" 03A9 of the considered theories will of course
depend
onthe
postulated analyticity properties.
In thegeneral
case, the thermalinterpretation
of thetheory might provide
a criterion of selection between severala priori possible global analytic
structures. Another feature that thisapproach
should assure is thepossibility
ofgoing
to the euclideansphere.
The axioms
The set of distributions
1Nn (n
>1)
is assumed tosatisfy
thefollowing properties (we
limit ourselves here to the case of a bosonfield):
1.
(Covariance).
Each1Nn
is de Sitterinvariant,
i.e.for all de Sitter transformations g, where
Vol. 63, n° 4-1995.
424 U. MOSCHELLA
2.
(Locality)
3.
(Positive Definiteness).
Giventhen
where ...,
xn+~ ) _
We shall now
give
a substitute for the usualspectral
condition of axiomatic fieldtheory
in Minkowski space, which will be called "weakspectral
condition". We propose under this name
analyticity properties
of theWightman
functions whichreproduce
asclosely
aspossible
thoseimplied by
the usualspectral
condition in MinkowskianQFT.
In thelatter,
it is known that thespectral
condition can beequivalently expressed by
the
following analyticity properties
of theWightman
functionsvVn [ 18]
resulting
from theLaplace
transform theorem in for each n(n
>2)
the distribution ...,
xn)
is theboundary
value of ananalytic
function
Wn (zi,
...,zn)
defined in the tubeWhen the Minkowski space is
replaced by
the de Sitter spaceXd
embeddedin natural substitute for this
property
can beproposed by replacing (for
eachn)
the tube C~dn by
thecorresponding
open subset= n of
is a domain of which is moreover a tuboid
(see [5]
for aprecise definition)
above we can state thefollowing
axiom:4.
(Weak Spectral Condition).
For each n the distributionWn ,
... ,xn)
is theboundary
value of ananalytic
functionWn ( zl ,
... ,zn),
defined in the tuboid of thecomplex
manifoldAnnales de l’Institut Henri Poincare - Physique theorique
In the case of the
two-point
functions these axioms areequivalent
to themaximal
analyticity property.
In thegeneral
case, in view of thelocality
axiom the n!
permuted Wightman
functionsWn, respectively analytic
inthe
permuted
tuboids7~_i
haveboundary
valuesWn
which coincide onthe
region 7Zn
ofspace-like configurations
By making
use of theedge-of-the-wedge
theorem for tuboids[5]
one seesthat for each n there is an
analytic
function~?n (zl ,
..., which isthe common
analytic
continuation of all the functionsW~
in the union of thecorresponding
tuboids7~_i together
with acomplex neighbourhood
ofFinally
we remark that this scheme includes thepossibility
ofgoing
to the Euclidean
sphere by analytic
continuation.A
point z
= ...,zn)
E is called euclidean if = 0and =
0,
1 id,
for allj,
1j
n. Euclideanpoints
in are
parametrized by
thepoints
of the manifold i.e.each zj
is associated to apoint
on thesphere
={(5, x)
Ex ==
~,
...,x~n> : s2
+x~1~2
+ ... +x(d)2
=R2}
so that =zs~
and = 1 i
d,
for allj,
1j
n. The set of euclideanpoints z = (z1,
...,zn) E
such that forall j,
1~ j,
1~ n, is called non-coincident euclidean
region
It ispossible
show thatindeed the non-coincident euclidean
region ~n
is contained in the extendedprimitive
domainBy analogy
with the Minkowski case, the restriction of the function...,
zn)
to the non-coincident euclideanregion
is called the(non-coincident) n-point Schwinger
function.Therefore,
our set of axioms may be onestarting point
for a fulleuclidean formulation of de Sitter
quantum
fieldtheory, and, eventually,
for a constructive
approach.
Asalready said,
de Sitter Euclideanapproach
is also of interest for the construction of
interacting
Minkowskianquantum
fieldtheories, giving
a natural moresymmetrical (rotational covariant)
infrared cutoff. Thepath
to construct aQFT
modelby
means of thisprocedure
then would be: introduce anelementary length
in the model at hand(curvature);
solve the model in the euclidean de Sitterapproach (i.e.
construct an euclidean
QFT
on asphere;
the associatedSchwinger
functionswill be
rotationally covariant);
reconstruct a de SitterQFT by
means of anOsterwalder-Schrader
type theorem;
recovereventually
a MinkowskiQFT by
contraction.Vol. 63, n° 4-1995.
426 U. MOSCHELLA ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was
supported by
EEC-humancapital
andmobility
program- contract n. ERBCHBICT930675.Many
discussions with R. Schaeffer and J. Y. Ollitrault on the role of de SitterQFT’s
incosmology
aregratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
[1] H. BATEMAN, Higher Transcendental Functions, Vol. I, Mc Graw-Hill, New York, 1954.
[2] N. D. BIRRELL and P. C. W. DAVIES, Quantum fields in curved space, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1982.
[3] J. BROS, Nucl. Phys., (Proc. Suppl.), Vol. 18B, 1990, p. 22.
[4] J. BROS, J.-P. GAZEAU and U. MOSCHELLA, Phys. Rev. Lett., Vol. 73, 1994, p. 1746.
[5] J. BROS and U. MOSCHELLA, Two-point functions and quantum fields in de Sitter universe, Saclay preprint T94/160. An axiomatic approach to de Sitter Quantum Field Theory, in preparation. Fourier Transform on a one-sheeted hyperboloid, in preparation.
[6] J. BROS and G. A. VIANO, Forum Mathematicum, to appear.
[7] T. S. BUNCH and P. C. W. DAVIES, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, Vol. 360, 1978, p. 117.
[8] J. FARAUT, Noyaux sphériques sur un hyperboloïde à une nappe in Lect. Notes in Math., Vol. 497, Springer-Verlag, 1975.
[9] R. FIGARI, R. HÖEGH-KROHN and C. R. NAPPI, Commun. Math. Phys., Vol. 44, 1975, p. 265.
[10] I. M. GEL’FAND and E. G. SHILOV, Generalized functions, Vol. I, Academic Press, New York, 1964.
[11] G. W. GIBBONS and S. W. HAWKING, Phys. Rev. S., Vol. 10, 1977, p. 2378.
[12] R. HAAG, Local Quantum Physics, Field, Particles, Algebras, Springer, Berlin, 1992.
[13] B. S. KAY and R. WALD, Phys. Rep., Vol. 207, 1991, p. 49.
[14] A. LINDE, Particle Physics and Inflationary Cosmology, Harwood Academic Publishers, Chur, 1990.
[15] S. MOLCHANOV, Math. Dokl., Vol. 7, 1966, p. 1553.
[16] U. MOSCHELLA, Quantization curvature and temperature: the de Sitter space-time, in Quantization and Infinite-Dimensional System, J.-P. ANTOINE, S. TWAREQUE ALI, W. LISIECKI, I. M. MLADENOV and A. ODZIJEWICZ eds., Plenum, New York, 1994, p. 183.
[17] G. L. SEWELL, Ann. Phys., Vol. 141, 1982, p. 201.
[18] R. F. STREATER and A. S. WIGHTMAN, PCT, Spin and Statistics, and all that W. A.
BENJAMIN, New York, 1964.
(Manuscript received April 30, 1995.)
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique