• Aucun résultat trouvé

When Local Search Goes with the Winners

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "When Local Search Goes with the Winners"

Copied!
15
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

!#"%$ &%')(+*-,)./"0*213(2! 4 '5"76 8:9;! 9;!#"

8<$-$="%16

>@?BADCAFEHGJILKM?NO?P%EHGJIRQTSVUVUV?W@XYADZ\[^]_?CC`Z\GJS

a`bHcedfchgij:k:l<monOcFpFqsr:l<tHuwvyxwz{v|bHk:v}xwz~€k

‚„ƒ†…ˆ‡Š‰‹ƒ

k:lŒŽceejhi

‘’…”“•‡Ž–B—‡Š˜–B—‡Š‰™…š‡œ›

iOfž<žfŸ kl<gwj¡c„¢wchrˆ£}gHev}lf£}cerhi

ž<¤f¥<ž

–

l<twuHvyx

›

bj:v}t\l<£|v}ršhce¢Hc§¦Oi\¨™z

ƒ

z©¥

˜

iªk¡xfbHec

«­¬<®¯±°Ž²h³:¯

´0µe¶±·+¸±¹º¼»h½µh¾Ž¿€¹À€½{¾ŽÁ¹:Âe¿€½º_½ܾŠ¿€½{¹µÄº_¶±¿V¾ŠÅ|Æh¶Ç§À€½{ÈÉ¿€½{¸Ê˸¾ŽÁÁ{¶ÌÎÍÐÏÑÓÒ­ÔÖÕØ×

ÕØ×hٚҒÔÖÚhÚ`ÙÛ܊ÝwÞàßá¡á§âwÆh¾È©»`¶¶µ’ÂeÀ€¹Â`¹:ÈжœÌ’»ã†äå½{º_½æ¿ÐÀ€½¹:Ç­¾µh̒ç}º_¾Žè:Á½{¾Ãù¼½{µ

éœê:êë§ì ßá:á庆¾Žµ¾è¶ÈfÈж±í¡¶±ÀV¾Á¡¸±¹:µ§îè:ǧÀV¾Ž¿€½¹:µeȾŽ¿¿€Æh¶BȀ¾º_¶B¿€½º_¶:ʜÇeÈжȾH¿€ÆeÀ€¶ÈÐƧÅ

¹:Á{ÌY¿€¹_¶Á½º_½{µh¾Ž¿€¶¿€Æe¶·H¹À€ÈÉ¿¸±¹:µ§îèÇeÀV¾Ž¿€½¹µhÈÊ`¾ŽµÌY½µh¸±ÁÇÌe¶±Èå¾¼ÀV¾ŽµÌe¹º_½ܾŽ¿€½¹:µ

ÈÉ¿€¶ÂY·©Æh½{¸€Æ¾ÁÁ¹œ·©È¾¼Çeµh½æïÖ¹ŽÀ€º+Ìe½ÈÉ¿ÐÀ€½»hǧ¿€½{¹µ‘¹ï¿€Æe¶í½Èн¿€¶Ì‘¸±¹:µ§îèÇeÀV¾Ž¿€½¹µhÈ\½{µ

¶í¡¶±ÀÐã’ÈÐÇh»§Å|ÂeÀ€¹:»eÁ¶º

ì

ð Æh½ȩ¾Â`¶ÀÂeÀ€¹Â`¹:Èжȿ€¹JÀ€¶±ÂhÁ{¾:¸±¶¿€Æe¶OÀV¾ŽµÌe¹º_½ܾŽ¿€½¹:µ­ÈÉ¿€¶Â’¹ïBßá:á_»ã’¾JÁ¹¸¾Á

Èжœ¾ŽÀV¸€Æ‘½µ‘¹ÀV̧¶±À©¿€¹¼ï¾œí¡¹ŽÀ\»`¶±¿Ð¿€¶±À©Èй:Áǧ¿€½{¹µhÈOÌeǧÀ€½{µeèJ¿€Æe¶Èжœ¾ŽÀV¸€Æ

ì

´Oµ½µhÈÉ¿V¾µh¸±¶Y¹Žï忀Æe½{ȼÆ㧻§À€½Ø̄¾ŽÁè:¹À€½æ¿€Æeº‘ʸ¾ŽÁ{Á¶œÌñßá¡áhòœó¡ô:õÊH½{ȼÂeÀ€¹:Â`¹ÈжœÌ

ì ´

ÈÐÂ`¶œ¸±½{¾Áw¾Ž¿Ð¿€¶µ¿€½¹:µs½ȾŽ½{̔¿€¹‘º†¾ö:¶÷½æ¿J¶ø†¸±½¶µ¿3¹:µ”À€¶¾Á½ÈÉ¿€½Ø¸†ÂeÀ€¹»hÁ¶º_È

ì_ù

¸±¹:º_Âh¾ŽÀ€¶Ìe½æúD¶±À€¶µ¿F·¾ã§È¿€¹Á¹œ·H¶±À¿€Æh¶¿€ÆeÀ€¶±ÈÐÆh¹:Á{̽µ3¾µ¾Ìh¾Â§¿€½í¡¶·¾ã

ìù

¶¾:ÌhÌ

¹:µhÁæ㔹:µe¶÷¾ŠÀV¾º_¶±¿€¶±Àûïü¹À3¶ºJ»`¶œÌḩ½{µeè­Á¹¸¾ŽÁwÈжœ¾ŠÀV¸Vƙ½{µˆ¿€Æh¶÷¶ýe½ÈÉ¿€½µhèYȀ¸VÆe¶º_¶ ì

ù

¶ûÈÉ¿€ÇÌã†Æh¹œ·ûÊh¾µÌ­½{µ’·©Æh½{¸€Æ‘¹ÀV̧¶±ÀœÊe¿€¹J¿€Çhµh¶O¿€Æh¶Âh¾ŽÀV¾º_¶¿€¶±À€È

ì

´Oµ¶±ý§Â`¶±À€½º_¶µ¿V¾Áw¾Âh§À€¹¡¾¸VÆƾŽÈ¼»`¶¶±µñÂ`¶ÀÐïÖ¹À€º_¶Ì¹µÆ¾ŽÀV̄½µhÈÉ¿V¾Žµ¸±¶±ÈÊ˶±µeÅ

¸±¹Ìe¶œÌo¾È÷·w¶½è:Æ¿€¶œÌoþ‘´OÿOÅÈÊw¹ïèŽÀV¾ÂeÆĸ±¹Á¹À€½µhès§À€¹:»eÁ{¶±º_ȑÞäçÐþ‘´

¸VÆh¾ÁÁ¶µh越âO¾ŽµÌYïüÀ€¶Çe¶µ¸V㑾ŽÈÐÈн{èµhº_¶µ¿OÂeÀ€¹»hÁ¶º_ÈÞั¶Á{¾ŽÀâ

ì ð

Æe¶»`¶ÈÉ¿åöµe¹Š·©µ

»`¹:ÇhµhÌeÈÆh¾Ší:¶»`¶¶µYïü¹:ÇeµÌ’ïü¹Àå¾ÁÁD¿€Æh¶½µhÈÉ¿V¾Žµ¸±¶±È

ì

! #"!$&%'(' )$&*+,-%' ./ #01$%' ."32+ #"!/,4*.56%758$&*.9(' #%':4<;=2?>@A@265=*.$(B,4(74*.5<;=2

9(7$,4:C*.(7 #"!9

D EGFHIKJ<LNMPOHKQ6JRF

SUT (+VW('XB );+!$;Y51Z["C%':45\^]_”a`cbC`cbd_™F<Še$&*.9(' #%':4gfh>@A@4iW,4(75=;'5"%75=Z[ #"kjml1npo>@A@

5q-,4*#('51;rZ- tsG5(75"%u6"-v!9 T (7$&%' ."!;Kw!%':!5x;'5=$(7:y;Y,$65+$&%K%7:45+;'$/5W%7 #/5+Az{<$&"$&9 ."49|$},~,4

T *.$&%' ."<&w€;'*T %' .";u$*#*.5=Zy4‚ƒ`y|6„üœƒou…?%u%7:45}~59 #"4"! #"492,$&('%' )6*.5=;u$('5+($&"!Z4/*#zyZ- );^%7(' . T %75=Z

."†%':45d;Y51$&(:‡;',!$5N$"!Zˆ$d%':4(75=;':4*)Z‡ .;<,!*.$65=Zˆ$&%<%':45‰;Y%/wU%7:45V?(;^%<,!$(Y%7 .*#5o‹Šx:45

wŒ*#*.V+ ."49/,4:!$;'5=;}$&(75 #%'5=(7$&%' .Ž5=*#zB,~5('wŒ(7/5=Z T "%' .*3"!<,!$&('%' )6*.5('5=<$& ."!; T "!Z-5=(+%':!5%':4(75=;':4*.Z

(2)

fŒ:!5"!5‰%':!5d"!$/5dw%':45k$&*.9(' #%':4Bi6“ $ (75=Z- );^%7(' . T %75=Z ,!$&('%' )6*.5‰ );C(75,!*.$65=Z‹V+ t%7: $

Z T ,!*# )$&%'5|&w$&"4%':45=(x,!$&('%' )6*.5|(7$"!Z-/*.zP:4;Y5=" T "!Z45(+%7:45|%':4(75=;':4*.Zo

o3KŒUŠx:! .;},4:!$;'5 );‘,~5('wŒ(7y51Z[wŒ(‘5=Ž5=('zC,!$&('%' )6*.5{$&"!ZN ."%'5="!Z4;+%7';Y5=,-

$&($%75P,!$(Y%7 .*#51;V+:! .:ˆ$&(75C$&%y%7:45;'$/5C*.-$%7 #"‡Z

T

5P%7d%7:45N('51Z- );^%7(' .

T

%7 #",4:!$;Y5o

5=Ž5($&*(7$"!Z-y .0=$&%' .",4:$;'5=;$&"85RwŒ

T

"Z‰ ."‰%':!5R*. t%'%'5=(7$&%

T

(75oŠx:45=z‰$&(75$&*.*r!$;'5=Z

"$/($&"!Z4’Vx$&*.XB&wu;',516 #v!5=Z[*.5"49%':€o! Ž5=('z[;^%75,N&wr%7:45(7$"!Z- Vx$&*.XB9A5=;+wŒ(' $

6"-v!9

T

(7$&%' ."<%7B$y"45 .9:A~(+V+:4 .*#5%7('zA ."49y%'<(75<$& ."

T

"!Z-5(x%7:45|%':!('51;Y:4*.Z€o

"

o+Šx:45|Ž$&*T 5&w%':45|%7:4(75=;':4*)ZP );+*.VW5=('51ZBAz o

 :!5" %':45/,4(7!*#5= :!$;|9AAZd,4(7,~5('%' .5=;<fc;Y5=5 5=ƒ%7 #"

iƒ2K>@A@‰ );|%':!5(756%7 .=$&*.*#z‰$4*.5R%7

v"!Z $N51;^%y;Y*T %7 #"k #" ,~*.zA"4/ )$&*%7 #/5BV+ #%': $N:4 .9:k,4(7$&4 .*# #%^zo$#‘V?5Ž5(12€ #" ,!(7$ƒ%' )652

v(7;Y%<56q-,5=(' ./5"%7;/<$Z-5C"†5*)$&(<$&"Z9(7$,4:‡*.(7 #"49d #";^%$&"!5=;/9 .Ž5[V?(;Y5C,5=(YwŒ('<$&"65

(75=;T *#%7;r%7:!$&"<$;Y%7$"!Z4$&(Z&%N56%7(',*# );u$&*.9(' #%':!’j" nfc$;Y . T *)$%75=Z/$&"!"45=$*# ."49|V+ t%7:B$6"!;^%$&"%

%75/,~5($% T ('5 iƒo

'"‰%':45R(7$"!Z-/ .0=$&%' ."N,4:!$;Y5R&w%':!5R>@A@N$*#9(7 t%7:4N2!~56%Y%75(|6"-v!9 T (7$&%' ."!;‘$('5"4&%,4('5

wŒ5=('(75=Z$"!Z‰$<,$&('%' )6*.5$" #"!Z4 tsG5(75"%'*.zN9 T ,‰(Z-V+"€o‘Šx: T ;=2!%7:45"45=5=ZN%7P<$&X5{,4(79('51;';

."B>@A@R );uZ T 5‘"4*.z%7|%':45‘<$"!$&95/5"%u&wG%7:45+%':!('51;Y:4*.Z€o(' "/%7:4 .;W$&('%' )6*.52VW5+5qA,~5(7 .y5="%7$&*.*.z

;':4V %7:!$%}>@A@B$"C~5|/$Z-5|/(75U5*)< #5="%‘V+:45"[('5=,4*)$6 ."49%':45($&"!Z4/ #01$%7 #"B,4:!$;Y5|AzP$

*.-$*€;Y51$&(:€oKŠx:! .;x9 #Ž5=;W%':45{>@A@,+-/.y$*#9(7 t%7:4 V+:4 ):CV+ .*#*~5{Z-51;'(' .51ZP ."NZ-56%$& .*.;?w

T

('%':!5(1o

Šx:!5/$ #"N6"%'(7 #

T

%' ."!;+$('5U%':45|wŒ*#*.V+ ."49!“

0 '"B,4(75ŽA . T ;VW('X-;=2>@A@y:!$;~55="P$&,!,4*# .5=ZB"<%7:45('5%' )$&*/AZ45*);“K"<%7:45U*# 21 T 5},!('-

*.5g$"!Z " %':!5<9($&,4: 4 );Y51ƒ%' ."k,4(7!*#5=43oC…}*#*%7:45P(7('51;Y,~"!Z4 #"49[Ž5=(7;' ."!;&w+>@A@

$;7; T /5=Z8%':!$&%%':45<($&"495Rw?,~;7;' #4*.5B6;^%;| #"6*T Z-5=Zk$N;'/$*#*" T ~5(&wx ."%7595(;23;'

%':$%|%':45/%7:4(75=;':4*)Z8Z-5=*t%$[V?$; $&%|51$:d t%75($%' ."3oyŠx:4 );| );|"4&%%7:45<$;'5RwŒ(" T /5('

T ;,4(74*.5<;;T :<$;u%':45UVW5= #9:%'5=Z5%…76‘98 : ~5"!:!/$('X-;,!('51;Y5="%75=Z/ ."/%':4 );W,!$&,~5(1o

;4(|56q4$&/,4*.52%7:45=<>?A@ABDCC5="!:4<$&(7X%^zA,4 )$*#*.z #"6*T Z-5=;6"4v!9 T ($%7 #"!;UV+:4;'5<6;Y%

($&"495=;wŒ(7

"EA"AFFF

%7&GDHJIKAL oŠx:45=('5wŒ(752%':! .;x$&('%' )6*.5},!(',;Y51;W;'5Ž5($&*!Vx$ z-;u%7R*.V?5(

%':!5W%7:4(75=;':4*)Z ."/('51$&*. .;Y%' )W,4('4*.5<;2$&"!ZR,5=(YwŒ(' 56q-,5=(' ./5"%7;K%76/,!$('5W%':!5 51$:

&%7:45(1o

0

>@A@M+-.x<$&"$&951;3;'5Ž5($&*&,!$(7$/56%'5=(7;=“~%':45W" T ~5(N‹w4,!$&('%' )6*.5=;=2$‘,!$(7$y5%'5=(O T ;'5=Z

%'*.VW5=(€%':!5%7:4('51;Y:!*)Z2 %':45?*.5"49%':4P[&w4%7:45xV?$*#XG2$&"Z$Z!Z- t%7 #"!$&*,!$(7$y5%'5=(7; #"AŽ*.Ž5=Z

." %':45k;'5*.5=ƒ%75=Z *.-$*U;'5=$&(: fŒ5o9o#2‘%':45d*#5="49&%7: &w$ %7$

T

*. .;Y%=2‘([$Q%75/,5=(7$&%

T

(75

$&*.*.V+ #"49B%':45/;Y51$&(:[%'[5=;7$&,~5{wŒ(7 *.-$&*K/ #"! #<$i6o|d5y,4(7,~;'5$&"‰ ."!;Y%7$"!65R&wu%7:45

>@A@M+-.N;7:45/52K$*#*.5=Zk>@A@M+SR/BTfh>@A@dV+ #%': § UVÐ'‚f §XWZY‚„\[6iƒ2rV+:4 ): *# ./ t%;%7:45

" T ~5(+wK$Z4Z- #%' ."!$*~,$&($&/56%75(;%7 o'"C(7Z45(?%'// #"! #/ .05|%':!556sG('%x(751 T .(75=Z<wŒ(

% T "4 #"!9%':45U,!$&($&/5%'5(;=256q-,~5(7 #/5="%;;':4Vˆ$:45 T (' );^%7 .‘,*# )6zy%'{%T "45}%':45U,!$&($&/5%'5(;

&wr>@@,+SR/BTGo

0

rq-,~5(7 #/5"%;C$('5d,5=(YwŒ('/5=Z‹"‹Ž5(7z†:$&(Zˆ #"!;Y%7$"!651;Pw{wŒ(751 T 5"6z $&*.*#-=$%' ."‹$"!Z

9($&,!:†*.(7 #"49 ,4(74*.5<;=o‹>@@,+SR/BT$&"‡v!"!Z†%7:45~5=;Y%dfŒXA"4V+"iy~ T "!Z4;/wŒ(B$&*.*‘&w

%':!5 $"!Z[6/,!$(' );'"!;?V+ #%':>@@P$"!Z=%N56%7(',*# );+$&(75|9 .Ž5"3o

]_^`a\bcdfeghdi`Sjkb\lmconfcqpMnfrms9g chsut*vqb\lSwxSyus9w{zhxS|vqeghdi`SjSz}p(bchj~chjSsz€dis‚zhb\ƒ9s‚zhxSy€j~chjd„cd!b\lSb\!x…l*xS†|sug

ni‡Ds9wes9z(a\b\lSˆlSn*wSsuz}‡Jgn‰chjSs‚cqp,nfzox|vqeghdi`SjSz_Š

(3)

"

."!;Y%7$"!65[&w|>@A@,+-.‰ );/Z-5=;76(7 #~5=Z #" 51ƒ%' ." E o rq-,5=(' ./5"%7;/$&(75[('5=,(Y%75=Z ." 5=ƒ%7 #" o

5=ƒ%7 #" o ,4('51;Y5="%7;;'5Ž5($&*WV?$ z-;%7d<$"!$&95<%':45C%':!('51;Y:4*.Z #"‡('51$&*. .;Y%' )B,4(7!*#5=/;=o 5=6

%7 #" o" 9 .Ž51;x${v!(;Y%x:!5

T

(7 .;Y%' )U,*# )6z<%7y%

T

"45%7:45wŒ

T

(+,!$(7$/56%'5=(7;W&wr>@@,+SR/BTy ."C,!(7$ƒ%' )65o

5=ƒ%7 #"!; oE $"!Z o ;Y:4V‹%':45,5=(YwŒ('<$"!65U&w>@A@,+R/BTy$"!ZB(75,~('%+6/,!$(' );'"!;V+ t%7:C>@A@

$"!Z=%N56%7(',*# );o

PIKJ HJ

?5wŒ(75C,4(75=;'5"%7 #"49d%':!5N>@A@$&*.9(' #%':![2VW5Z-5v!"45$ӊ‚ƒb@'‚ƒ!b8$;y$"†$!;Y%'($ƒ%7 #"w$

R4 #"$%'(' )$&*G,-%' ./ #01$%' ."N,4(7!*#5=[o?Šx:45"4-Z-51;+&w$<;Y51$&(:C9(7$,4:N$&(75U%7:45Z- #sG5(75"%}6"-

v9 T ($%7 #"!;|fŒ o5o#2-,~&%75"%' )$&*€;'*T %' .";7i?$&"ZP51Z-951;W*. ."4X<%^V?/"-v9 T ($%7 #"!;V+:! .:N$&(75fY"45= #9:-

~(;u2 co5o.2wŒ(?V+:4 ):P$;'<$&*.*~:!$"495U$&*.*#V‘;u%',$;7;uwŒ(7 $"-v9 T ($%7 #"R%7%7:45}%':45=(=or 5

$;';T /5y%':!$&%%':45<Ž$*T 523({6;Y%=23&wx5Ž5=('z"!AZ45< .;{$"d ."%'5=95(1o<Šx:45<9$&*r&w+64 ."!$&%'(7 )$&*

,-%' ./ #01$%7 #"C );x%'yv!"Z[$y"4-Z-5w/ ."4 # T 6;Y%=o

Šx:!5!{V+ t%7:<%':!5}V+ ."4"45(;u‘$*#9(7 t%7:4 :!$;5=5"Bv(7;Y% ."%7('-Z T 65=ZB #"‰j npouŠx:4 );$&*.9(' #%':!

:$;5=5"kZ-5=;' .9"451Z‰%7Pv!"Zd$NZ-5=5, *#51$w ." $C%7('5=5oR…?%|%7:45/5=9 ."4"4 ."49!2€;'5Ž5($&*K,!$&('%' )6*.5=;|$&(75

,!*.$65=Z $%%7:45<(7%wW%7:45/%'(755o&'"d%7:45<($&"!Z-/ #01$%' ."d,4:!$;Y52€5Ž5(7z,!$&('%' )6*.5/ .;/Ž5=Z%7

$P:4 #*)ZN"4-Z-5RV+:4 .: );}:!;'5"($&"!Z-/*#zo!' "N%7:45(75=Z4 .;Y%'(7 #

T

%' .",4:$;'524%7:45,$&('%' )6*.5=;+V+:4 ):

:$ Ž5|('51$:451ZP$y*.5=$w$&(75|('51Z- );^%7(' .

T

%75=Z“r%7:45z[$&(75(75,!*.$65=ZPV+ t%7:‰$/Z

T

,4*. .=$%75&w$&"4%':45=(?"!"

*.5=$&wu,!$&('%' )6*.5($&"Z-/*.z[:4;Y5="€o|Šx:45,4(7-651;';U;^%7,!;UV+:45" $&*.*3%7:45,$&('%' )6*.5=;$&(75{,4*)$651Z‰$%$

*.5=$&w^oUŠx:45R$ T %7:4(;‘:!$ Ž5Z-5%'5(7/ #"!5=ZN%7:45" T R5=(}&wu,$&('%' )6*.5=;‘V+:! .:‰ );U"45=5=;7;'$('zP%'<v!"Z8$

Z455,~5=;Y%‘"4-Z-5V+ #%':$y:4 .9:[,4('!$&! #*. t%^zCZ-5,~5"!Z4 #"49<"[$y/5=$;T ('5&wK%':45|%7('5=5| #R!$&*)$&"!5o

Šx:!5‰>@A@ˆ$&*.9(7 #%':4 Z4 .;7 T ;7;'5=Zˆ ."ˆ%':4 );<,!$,5=(C$&"Z‡ ."-wŒ('<$&*.*.z,4(75=;'5"%'51Z† #"ˆ%7:45‰ ."%7('

Z T ƒ%7 #"€2u );,4(75=;'5"%75=Z ." jml1npoQ'p%/ );y$8/AZ4 tv=$%7 #" &w‘%7:45Cv!(7;Y%RŽ5(;Y ." ;'‰%7:!$%/ #%/=$&" ~5

T ;Y51ZZ- #(75=6%'*.zPwŒ(}64 ."!$&%'(7 )$&*,4%' .y .0=$&%' ."€oxŠx:45%7('5=5{&wr%7:45v!(;^%UŽ5(;' #"C- T (;+ #"‰$"Az

,-%' ./ #01$%7 #"‰,4(74*.5 V+:45"8/$"!$&9 #"!9P$<%7:4('51;Y:!*)Zo ' "!Z-5=5=Z2~%7:45y;'5=$(7:N9(7$,4:‰$"‰5R:4 #

5=(7$(7:! .=$&*.*#zZ- .ŽA .Z-51Zk #"%7N;'5Ž5($&*;T -p9($&,4:!;|$6(7Z4 #"49C%'N%7:45 .(;Y%7;=o5%(75y,!('516 );Y5=*#z2$

"!AZ45{&wK%':45{%'(755{ );+<$Z-5&w$<;Y51$&(:N; T -p9($&,!:CV+:4;Y5Ž5('%' )651;x:!$ Ž5$B;Y%}$%‘( T "!Z-5=(U$

%7:4(75=;':4*)Zo|Šx:45%7,‰wu%':! .;U%'(755y6"%$& ."!;+%7:45yV+:4*.5R;'5=$(7:9(7$,4:fŒV+:!5"%7:45%7:4(75=;':4*)Z );

%7:45:! #9:45=;Y%i6o€V?5(7 #"!9/%':45%':4(75=;':4*)ZZ- .ŽA .Z-51;U$P;Y51$&(:[9(7$,4: ."%7P;'5Ž5=(7$*fhZ4 .;76"4"45=6%'51Z!i

"4"!5=ƒ%75=Zk6/,"45"%7;{V+:4 .:kwŒ(' $N:4 .5($&(:z85%^VW5=5" $[%'(755<"4-Z-5C$&"!Z #%7;;'";o[Šx:45

wh$ƒ%‘%7:!$%}%^VW<(759 #"!;x516y5{Z4 .;76"4"45=6%'51ZNV+:45"[%':!5%':4(75=;':4*.ZNZ-516(75=$;'5=;x/51$&"!;‘%':!$&%‘"4

($&"Z- Vx$&*.Xfh;Y%7$ zA ."49N$%( T "!Z45(|%':!5/%':4(75=;':4*)Z!i$"8/Ž5/$[,!$&('%' )6*.5ywŒ(' $C('5=9 ."‰%7

%7:45&%7:45(1o

U .y #%'(7 .

T

$"!Z '/,!$9*. .$00=(75*)$%'5d #" j n%':45 ,~5('wŒ(7/$"!65 &wy>@A@ˆ%'ˆ64 ."!$&%'(7 )$&*

,!(',5=(Y%7 #51;}w%':45/,4(74*.5No u;',516 )$&*.*#z2G%':45=z,4('Ž5%':$%%^VW[; T )B #5="%6"!Z- #%' ."!;U<$&X5R$

,!('4*#5= ;'*.Ž $4*.5 ."N,*#zA"4/ .$*%7 #/5{V+ #%':$y:4 .9:[,4(7!$4 #*. #%^z~“

0

Šx:45‘"

T

R5=(Ww3:4 .*.Z-(75"<w3$|%'(755U"4-Z-5}

T

;Y%5,~*.z"!/ .$*#*.zy

T

"!Z-51ZoŠx:4 .;W/5=$"!;

%':$%+Z-5=('51$;' #"49{%':45%':!('51;Y:4*.Z8fŒAz iWZ-A5=;?"4%?<$&X5U$,4,51$&(x$&"C56q-,"45"%7 .$*"

T

R5=(

&wZ4 .;76"4"45=6%'51Z‰(759 .";o|Šx:4 );U9

T

$&($&"%755=;}6"AŽ5(795"65{ ."8,~*.zA"4/ )$&*%' .y5y #w5Ž5(7z

Z- );'"4"!5=ƒ%75=ZC('5=9 ."C:!$;+$y,!$(Y%7 .*#5o

0

‚„-‚Dœ|k:4*.Z4;=2%7:!$%/ .;=25=Ž5=('z ;'5=$&(:; T -p9($&,4: :$;/$$'; T )B6 .5"%uP" T R5=(

&w‘"!5 .9:A(7;=odŠx: T ;=2u$8;T )B6 .5"%7*#zk*."49d(7$"!Z- Vx$&*.X ."$89 .Ž5"('5=9 ." 5"; T (75=;y$

T "4 #wŒ(7 Z- .;Y%'(7 . T %' ." w|%':45‰,$&('%' )6*.5=;<V+:4 ):‹$&(75 ."!;Y )Z-58$"!Z Z-A5=;P"4&%C('51;^%7(' )ƒ%<%7:45

(4)

,!$(Y%7 .*#51;W,!(',(Y%7 #"!$&*~%'< #%7;+;' .05o

Šx:!5v!(;^%C"!Z4 t%7 #"†:! #9:4*# .9:%;<%':!5‰ #/,~('%7$"!65‰w|%':45‰" T R5=( N w{,!$&('%' )6*.5=;=o Šx:45

;'5="!ZC"!5 );+(75*)$%75=ZP%'y%':45*.5"!9&%': P &wr$/(7$"!Z- Vx$&*.XGo

U #s~5=('5="%‘($&"Z-/ .0=$%7 #"P,4:$;'5=;WwŒ(‘>@A@C$&(75|Z-5=;76(7 #~5=Z[ ."P%7:45*. t%'%'5($% T (75&“

0 '"‰jml1np2-${($&"!Z- V?$*#X/&w€*.5"!9&%': );?,5=(YwŒ('/5=ZP$%W51$:P;Y%'5=,€“KwŒ(?5Ž5(7zy,$&('%' )6*.5}V+ #%':

6;^%23$&*.*r%':!5y"!5 .9:A(7;|$('5yŽA .;' t%75=Z $&"!Z8"45/ );:4;'5" $&/"!9P%7:4;'5R:$ Ž ."49N$N6;Y%

I<fŒ( I ."$y/$&q- #/ .0=$%7 #"C,!('4*#5=Biƒo

0 '"8j np24$($&"Z- Vx$&*.Xyw3*.5"49%':=P .;?,4(7,~;'5=Z€oKŠx:4 );?V?$*#X<$*t%75(7"!$%75=;W"4-Z-5=;?&wK6;Y%

$&"ZC;Y%‰Io

0 j" nr$"!Zkjn,!('51;Y5="%$B;Y ./,4*. tv!51ZŽ5=(7;' ."NV+:45(75%7:45($&"!Z4 V?$*#XC&wu*.5"49:%kP‡:!$;}"4

&%7:45(}('51;^%7(' )ƒ%7 #"N%':!$"('5=/$ #"! #"49B$&%}( T "!Z-5=(‘%7:45{%7:4('51;Y:!*)Zo+Šx:!$%} );=2~$<"!5 .9:A(‘ );

$=65=,-%'51ZP #wK #%7;}6;Y%+ .;+;Y%'(7 )ƒ%'*.zP*.5=;7;?%':$&" Io

Šx:! .;$(Y%7 .*#5/ ."%7('-Z T 65=;%7:45B>@A@M+-.[$&*.9(' #%':4 wŒ(V+:4 ):8%7:45<(7$"!Z-y .0=$&%' ."d,4:!$;'5/&w

>@A@ .;(75,4*)$5=ZAz$C*#-$*K;'5=$(7:8V+:45(755=Ž5(7z;^%75,d&wu%7:45RVx$&*.XN('5=<$& ."!;U$&%( T "!Z-5(%7:45

%7:4(75=;':4*)ZoŠx:!5?Z- #sG5(75"!5W~56%^V?55="%':45W%^V?U$&,!,4('$:451;€ );%':!$&%r$}*#-$*;'5=$(7:|%75"!Z!;3%7U<$X5

,!('9(75=;7;V+:!5(75=$;3$x(7$"!Z- V?$*#XZ-A5=;"!&%=oKŠx:4 );%'5="!Z4;€%'+wh$;^%75(€4(7 ."49‘Z-V+"%':45,, T *)$%' ."32

T %UŽA .*)$%'51;+%7:45 T "! twŒ(' Z- );^%7(' . T %7 #"&wu,!$(Y%7 .*#51;‘ ."8$B"4"451ƒ%75=ZN(759 ." fcZ- .;Y%'(7 . T %' ."8"

V+:! .:%':45C*#-$*W5q-,!$&"!;' ." ,4(7,~5('%^z .;y T .*#%iƒo #}VW5=Ž5(12K%':45[9A-Z 5qA,~5(7 .y5="%7$&*?(75=; T *t%;

V+:! .:[$&(75U-%7$ #"451Z

T

;' #"!9y>@A@,+S-.<$&X5

T

;?~5*. #5=Ž5U%':!$&%?%':45=(x;

T

)B6 .5"%+6"!Z- #%' ."!;WwŒ(?%7:45

"AŽ5=('95"!5{ ."8,~*.z"!/ .$*K%' .y5/V+ #%':k$P:! #9:8,4(7!$4 .*# #%^zN56q- .;Y%=oR… ,~;7;' #4*.5y:zA,~&%7:45=;' .;U );

Z4 .;7

T

;7;'5=ZC #"[%':!5{6"6*

T

;Y ."3o

3O?IrQPHKQ6JF J

>@A@,+-/.R );xŽ5=('zB*#;Y5%'y%7:4556q- );^%7 #"49<>@A@P$&*.9(' #%':4No#‘V?5Ž5(12A>@A@,+-/.yZ- #sG5(;?wŒ(' >@@B ."

%^V?/, #"%;“

0

bY §ŠŽ±Ž!`û{`hb``cbeŠb„ü šÖR‚e ‚~`}

51ƒ%' ."

o

Z- );7 T ;7;Y51;‘$&"Z6/,!$('51;+;Y5=Ž5=(7$*V?$ z-;x%7< #/,4*.5/5"%U%':45 - T >AB<wT "!6%' ."

T ;'5=Z[%7P*.VW5=(+%':45%':4(75=;':4*.Zo"!}"-wŒ('% T "!$%75*.z2%':4 );}(75=$*# );Y%' )<$&"!$95/5="%‘ ./,4*. #51;‘%7:45

$Z!Z- t%7 #"Cwr$y"45=V ,!$(7$/56%'5=(fO %7/%':45>@A@M+-./;7:45/5o

0

b Y‚„\[Ö_f&`\'‚f eW#

Šx:45%^V?%$ ABB*.A,!;xwr…}*#9(7 t%7:4 Z-51;'(' .5$yVx$&*.X~“5=Ž5=('z<,!$(Y%7 .*#5|<$&X5=;+$yVx$&*.XB&w

*.5"49%':QP?o‘…U;U$*#(75=$Z-zP/5"%7 #"45=Z2~$<Vx$&*.XCwr*.5"!9&%':P‡ .;}"4&%|;Y,~5= tv%'P>@A@,+S-.<$"!Z

);‘$&*);Y T ;Y51ZN #",4(75ŽA . T ;‘Ž5(;' #"!;x&wu>@A@ fh;'55Pj

"

2&nŒiƒo#‘V?5Ž5(12A%':45R<$('^(‘Z4 tsG5(75"!5

*. #51;x #"[%':!5%)+*D>-,<wT "!6%' ."€o

'"R>@A@26%7:4 );3wT "!ƒ%7 #"(756% T ('"!;$‘"45= #9:A(3&w-%7:45/.{,!$(Y%7 .*#5?6"4v!9 T ($%7 #"€o(%N('5,4('516 );Y5=*#z2

$*#*10%':45/"45= #9:~(;}$('5RŽA .;' t%75=Z8 #"k$B($&"!Z4 (Z-5( T "%' .*"!5 );;'5*.5=6%'51Z‰V+:4 ):8 ); T "!Z-5=((

$&%U%7:45R%':4(75=;':4*)Zo 'pw?$*#*%':!5/$&%Y%75/,-%7;Uwh$ #*2G%':45/

T

('(75"%"-v9

T

($%7 #" .;(756%

T

('"451Z2~%':!$&% );=2

243l7cojSsb\lSbchbdiaArmsugzob\nl6587:9;d†`Sdigchb\yua\s b\zzhb\`Sa<n_rmsuw con d y€jSb\a\wŠ

(5)

,!('9(75=;7;V+:4 .*.55=;7$&,! #"49RwŒ(7 *.-$*y ."4 .<$4o

²°ü¯ ßá¡áò\ÚVÙÛJÑ ŽÛ±ÕÖÔ"!# ${ÙÜ&%(')*+$,-${ÙÚ/.:ÕØ×0213OÕØ×ۀÙÜÉ×eÑ+$543 ŽÛ67_Ù±Õ|ÙÛ8%:9<;

)*+$,= Û67_Ù±Õ|ÙÛÜ?>7@!€ÑÚBA.7§Û:ÕÖÔàÑÚ

C ¶µh¶±ÀV¾Š¿€¶DTÀV¾ŽµÌe¹º^¸±¹µeîèÇeÀV¾Š¿€½{¹µhÈO¾µhÌ­ÂhÁ{¾¸±¶û¶í¡¶±ÀÐã’Âh¾ŽÀп€½{¸±Á¶¹:µY¹µh¶¸±¹µeîhè:ÇeÀV¾Š¿€½¹:µ

¿€¹À€¶¿€Æe¶Â¾ŠÀп€½{¸±Á¶ÈO½µY¾µ¾ŠÀÐÀV¾œãFEG:ô+H IKJ+L+M/N

H7Oô/MNOPKL7QSRUT

V WYX

H7OôKMNBOPKLQZR[ PŽõMô:\]H7OôKMNBOPKLQ:^_1F^-EG:ôKH I+J+L+MN`

acb MNH:\dE/G:ôKH IKJ7L+MN`_efH7OôKMNBOPKLQ ¯ hgi„°g¯jF°+i Þb MNHeòBkPlKm/Qâ@nKo¼¿€Æh¶3»`¶ÈÉ¿û¸¹:µeîhè:ǧÅ

ÀV¾Ž¿€½¹µYïÖ¹ÇhµÌYÌeÇeÀ€½µeè¼Èжœ¾ŠÀV¸VÆ_on

p

M+QIKNH¡ô IqKlH/M2\?EG:ôKH I+J+L+MN`=nKo©þY¹Ší¡¶¶í¡¶±ÀÐã徎Àп€½{¸±Á¶Ëƾœí½{µe詾O¸¹:ÈÉ¿<º_¹ŽÀ€¶¿€Æh¾µ@H7Oô/MNBOP+L7Q

¿€¹¼¿€Æe¶û¸±¹:µ§îèÇeÀV¾Ž¿€½¹µ‘¹ï¾Žµ‘¾Á½í¡¶ûÂh¾ŽÀп€½{¸±Á¶ûÀV¾µÌ§¹:º_Áæ㒸€Æh¹:Èж±µ_o7n

a?°-g rYg°s

Û±ÕÖÔt!${ÙvusÔÖÚxwŽÛ±ÕÖÔ"!${ÙÜ@y

a?°Dz{a|°Y}|¯ 'y

m MIŽóOKqPôxR~NH/M€\u{^Z9<;3`



P7‚/M\?€^?m M/IŽó7OKqPŽô`-n+oJ´Óº_¹Ší¡¶¹ŽïWu­¿€¹_¾Jµh¶±·Ó¸±¹µeîèÇeÀV¾Š¿€½{¹µ_o7n

gi y€ƒ

gi

y

gi y*ƒ

gi y*ƒ

„†…"‡ q+ˆŠ‰xŠx:45{>@A@M+-.y$&*.9(' #%':4

‹ PIKJ HJ {Œ3=Ž

 5x"4551Z%7|Z45=;' #9"$%*.5=$;Y%r"45x$&*.9(' #%':4 Z-51Z T 5=ZwŒ(7 %7:45+>@@,+-.}$"!Z;':4V #%7;K5*)< #5="!6z

."‰,4($6%' )65o} 5%7(' .5=Z‰;'5Ž5($&*3;Y%7$"!Z4$(7Z*.$;';' .=$&**#-$*;'5=$(7:‰$*#9(7 t%7:4<;+%'C #/,4(7Ž5{>@A@o

 5-%$& ."45=Z/9-Z<(75=; T *#%7;V+ t%7:C$ %N5%'(7,~*. .;W$&*.9(' #%':4 fh$5,-%7 #"49y;T ('5=*#z/${"45= #9:A(V+ #%':

%7:45{;7$&/5|(‘$/~56%Y%75(};Y%=24$"!ZN$5,-%7 #"!9/$yV?(;Y5"45= #9:~(+V+ #%':$y,4(7!$4 .*# #%^zPZ-5=,5="!Z- ."49

"$‘9 #Ž5"7^%'5=y,~5($%T (75Yiƒo(#}VW5=Ž5=(=2 $&" ./,(Y%$&"%V?(7XU:$;*#51Z|%';Y ./,4*# #wŒz #%K ."%^V?}Vx$ zA;=“

/ ."4 .y .0 ."49%7:45}" T R5=(u&w,!$(7$/56%'5=(7;=2$"!Zyv!"!Z- ."49{:!V‡%7% T "45+%':!5 /(75 1 T .XA*.z2V+:! #*.5

."!('51$;' #"49y5m)B #5="!6zo

Šx:!5}6*)$;7;Y )$*!>@A@y<$&"$&951;r%^V?{,!$&($&/5%'5(;=“%':45U" T ~5(fN &w€,$&('%' )6*.5=;$"!Zy%':!5}*.5"49%':

Pw%7:45{($&"!Z-’Vx$&*.X~o‚' "N,4($6%' )652!$y%':4 .(ZC,$&($&/56%75(O "4551Z4;x%'<~5{$Z!Z-5=ZN$&*.*.V+ #"49y%7:45

%7:4(75=;':4*)ZN%'P"4&%Z-5=('51$;'5|%'AC;'/A&%':!*#zo SUT (U"45V $*#9(7 t%7:4 >@A@,+SRBTdfc>@@NV+ #%':ħ UV

7‚f eW Y‚&„\[ƒi}$Z4Z!;‘"!*#zC"45{,$&($&/56%75( o+Šx:4 ); T "! 1 T 5{,$&($&/56%75(‘ ); T ;'5=Z[AzN$<,!$&('%' )6*.5

%7,4(79('51;';Z4V+"%7|%':45U51;^%x;Y*

T

%' ."!;V+:4 #*.5}~5 ."49$4*.5+%'R5=;7$&,~5+wŒ(7 *#-=$&*!/ ."4 ./$!oŠx:45

,$&($&/56%75( .;u%':45+<$&qA . T " T

R5=(u&wG"45 .9:A~(;rV+:4 ):B$&(75?ŽA );Y #%'51Z/AzR$|,!$(Y%7 .*#5‘Z

T

(' ."49

%7:45 )(*D>-,w

T

"!6%' ."€2%':$% );2V+:45="B$,!$&('%' )6*.5+/Ž51;rwŒ(' $"-v9

T

($%7 #"%7$&"4%':45=(=o x$;'5=Z

"$<

T

(7('5="%+"-v9

T

($%7 #"†‘24%':!5{6/,

T

%7$%7 #"N&wr%':45"!5V 6"-v!9

T

(7$&%' ."P(756%

T

(7"45=Z[AzB%7:45

)(*D>-,<w

T

"!6%' ."N&w>@@,+SR/BTy );+,~5('wŒ(7y51ZC$;?wŒ*.*#V‘;=“

o" ’ >“’ >•”SR–— Bf‘˜ @K™ ’R *– >š ’ > )›– @ ) @ <- )(*f— > * *D>AB AB >œ @/? *– @ ’ *– >

<- )+* $S‘ ž P3XŸ‘h˜

o ’ “’ >h”R–— AB @+™ ’R *–D> ’ > )›– @ ) @ <- )(*f— > * *D>AB AB >œD@? *– @ ’ *– > <- )(*

$F‘$ ’ >“’ >h”SR–— AB-‘h˜˜,@K™’R *– >F ’ > )š” ) @ * ABš’W¡>AB *– > *–/BD> )K– /?¡

(6)

"

Šx:!5Nv!(7;Y%P$;Y5($Z4 .=$&*.*#zZ4 tsG5(;/wŒ(7 %7:458;Y%7$"!Z4$&(Zˆ>@@o‚'p%P(75,!('-Z

T

5=;y%7:45‰~5:!$ ŽA .(

w}%7:45:4 .*#*#p*# .! #"49 $"!Z

…Š j n$&*.9(7 #%':4<;=“C$ "45 .9:A~(< );<$=65,4%'5=Z‡"!*#z V+:!5"† t%;

;Y% );|~56%Y%75((51

T

$&*r%7:!$&"d%':45<

T

('(75"%|"45oRŠx:45/*)$;Y%|%^VWN$;Y51;U ."!Z- )$&%'5y:4V %7[;'5*.5=6%

$"-v9

T

($%7 #"dV+:45=" "4‰ŽA );Y #%'51Zk"45 .9:A~(:!$;5=5"$5,-%75=ZoNŠx:45z8wŒ*.*#V %':!5B(7$"!Z-

;'5*.5=6%' ."

T

;'5=Zdzd/;Y%|w%7:45B$&*.9(' #%':4<;!$;Y51Z8" $C%':!('51;Y:4*.Z€2€5o9!o.2>@A@2%7:45`cbeŠb„ü

‚e±^`yh?$"!Z|%':!5VY‚&„eœa`hbW‹Z- );'

T

;';'5=Z{ #"

5=6%' ."6!o}'"{,!$(Y%7 .

T

*)$&(12=%7:45W;'5="!Z$;'5W$*#*.V‘;

,$&('%' )6*.5=;%'N5qA #%{*.A=$&*/ ."4 #<$!o /5/,!$&('%' )6*.5=;|<$ z‰9 T ,kŽ5(7z:4 #9: Z T (7 #"49[%7:45B;Y51$&(:€2

T %+%'A<!$ZC"-v!9 T ($%' .";W$('5Z- );'=$&(Z-5=ZCAz<%':!5|%':4(75=;':4*)Zo

Šx: T ;=2€,!$(7$/56%'5=( $ Ž )Z4;ŽA .;' t%7 #"!9N$*#*r%7:45<"45= #9:~(;$&"Z8zA .5*)Z4;$[%'($Z-5s 5%^VW5=5"

<$X ."49B,!('9(75=;7;‘$&"!ZN5q- t%7 #"49C*#-=$&*3/ ."4 ./$!oUŠP; T T ,€2>@@,+SR/BTP<$&"!$95=;+%':45wŒ*.*#V+ ."49

,$&($&/56%75(;“

0 … " T ~5(4N w,$&('%' )6*.5=; T ;'5=Z‡%' 5qA,!*#('5C%':45‰;'5=$(7:†;Y,$65N ."ˆ,!$&($&*.*#5=*c“N,!$(Y%7 .*#51;

;':4 T *)Zy5 T "4 #wŒ(7y*.zRZ4 .;Y%'(7 # T %'51Z/V+ t%7:4 #"/%7:45}"4"451ƒ%75=Z/6y,~"!5"%7;u$,4,~5=$&(7 ."49| #"/%7:45

;'5=$&(:P9(7$,4:PV+:!5"[%':45|%7:4(75=;':4*)ZP );x*.VW5=('51Zo

0 … *#5="49&%7: P &w€%7:45|V?$*#X-; T ;Y51Z<%7y;'5,!$(7$&%'5}%':45|,!$(Y%7 .*#51;W$&wa%'5(x9(' T ,4 ."49!2A$&"!ZB%'/$&*.*#V

,!$(Y%7 .*#51;%7<,4(79(75=;7;?Z-V+"%'R%':45~5=;Y%};Y*

T

%' ."!;=o

0 … ,!$(7$y5%'5=(!O

T

;'5=ZC%'/<$&"!$95%':!5|%':4(75=;':4*)ZC #"[('51$&*,4(7!*#5=/;fc;Y5=5

5=6%' ." o i6o

0

…‘"/$Z!Z- t%7 #"!$&*A,!$(7$/56%'5=(  V+:4 )::$;$6(

T

6 )$&*A(7*.5o(;K .(7;Y%=2&%':4 ); );r"45=5=;7;'$('z%'*. #/ #%

%':!5R"

T

R5=(UwŽA .;' t%75=Z8"45 .9:A~(;‘ ."8,4(74*.5<;}wŒ(V+:4 ):8 #% );Ž5(7z[4 #9N$&"Z‰Z- );'=$&(Z4;

$&"[56q-:!$

T

;Y%' .Ž5|;Y51$&(:€o

5=6"!Z2Wg

T

;Y%+5{;

T

)B6 .5"%7*#zB*)$&(795U%'<$*#*.V‹,!$(Y%7 .*#51;%7/9

Z-V+"["%'y~56%Y%75(};'*T %7 #"!;fŒ ."$R9('5=5=Z-zPV?$ z4iƒoŠx:4 .(Z2W T ;Y%‘5{; T )B6 .5"%'*.zC;'<$&*.*

%'<$*#*.V‹%7:45|,!$&('%' )6*.5=;?%7<56q- t%+*.-$&*/ ."4 ./$/ ."$y(7$"!Z- V?$ zo

Z\[ JU€?ûS€C=Z

Šx:!5<VW(7;Y%Y$;Y5y6/,4*.56q- #%^z‰&w+>@A@M+-.C({>@A@,+R/BT('5=<$& ."!;%':45B;7$&/5<$;%7:45<"!5<&w?>@A@2

%7:!$%U .;=2KhN P  "!,O$#'2!V+:45(75%!,O .;+%':45R"

T

~5(‘wK%7 #/51;+%':!5{%':!('51;Y:4*.Z[ );‘*.VW5=('51Z2

N );?%':!5"

T

~5(‘w,!$(Y%7 .*#51;+$&"!Z P .;?%7:45V?$*#XP*#5="49&%7:€o

& ')( +IrQ ‘FH

Šx:! .;U;Y51ƒ%' ."‰;':4V‘;x5qA,~5(7 .y5="%7$&*('51;

T

*t%;o?d5R;Y5=*#51ƒ%U$<Vx$ z<%7B<$&"!$95|%':!5%':4(75=;':4*.Zox 5

9 #Ž5<9

T

)Z-5=*# ."45=;{%'N%

T

"45B%7:45<wŒ

T

(,!$(7$/56%'5=(7;| ." ,4($6%' )65o=;K #"$&*.*#z2r>@A@,+SRBT‰ );{6/,!$&(75=Z

V+ #%':N5qA );Y%' ."49<$&*.9(7 #%':4<;=“%7:45{;Y%7$&"Z4$&(ZP>@A@P$&"!Z %N5%'(7,~*. .;=o

*,+.- >@?ËG0/1J[ EwA2W43÷?G5/<ZIJSVG0673¼S[ JU€?Ë[ ?ËG\C`EwCDS€Z\G

 5‘:!$ Ž5x,5=(YwŒ('/5=ZR56q-,~5(7 #/5="%;"<Z- J)B T *#% ."!;Y%7$&"65=;u .;7; T 5=ZRwŒ(' %^V?{$%759(7 #51;w~,!('-

*.5<;{$"!Z $&*.*u5"!-Z-5=Zk$;|V?5 .9:%75=Z%… 6}u8 :

;,4(74*.5<;=“9($&,4: 6*.(7 ."49C ."!;Y%7$"!651;|,4('

,~;'5=Z/ ."/%':!57'9%‰…78

:!$&*.*#5="495?%75"<z51$&(;$&9<j l=n2$&"!ZywŒ(751

T

5="!6zy$;7;Y .9"!y5="%u,4('4*.5<;.8o

9;: jdilSˆ*zconfchjSs=<?>Msul*chgs wA@B9a\suychghnlSbDC*xSs wSs‚aE@Fgsusul*cHG€Š

(7)

 5|:!$ Ž5;Y5=*#51ƒ%75=Z<%7:4(755UZ4 )B

T

*t%+9($&,!:P6*#(' ."49 ."!;Y%7$"!651;uwŒ(7 %7:45%^VWRy;^%+Z- J)B

T

*#%‘$%'

5=9(' .5=; ."/%':!5U$&%7$*#9

T

5“€%':!5 ?> D<+V+ #%': E XF "4-Z-51;$"!Z F 51Z-951;2%':45k?> <

V+ #%':

E XF

"4-Z-5=;<$"!Z l

E

5=Z-95=;=2W$"!Z‡%':45/(75Z-5";Y5 $D?@-* 8 #";^%$&"!5[V+ #%':

"AFF

Ž5('%' )651;{$&"!Z

D

51Z-951;o$' " $&*.*u ."!;Y%7$&"65=;=2r$N51;^%R;'*T %7 #" );{:! .Z4Z45" V+ #%': (75=;',51ƒ%' .Ž5=*#z2

2

$&"Z

<6*#(7;=o!'"N%':4 );},$&,~5(12!9($&,!:N*.(7 #"!9y ."!;Y%7$"!651;}$&(755"6-Z-5=Z$;7%…76‘98 :

."!;Y%7$"!651;“‘Ž$(' )$&4*.5=;$&(75{%7:45yŽ5('%' )651;} ."d%':45y9($&,4:‰%'[5/6*#('51Z~%':45/" T ~5([&w?6*.(;

V+ #%':<V+:! .:y%':!5‘9($&,4:/ T ;^%u~5}*.(75=ZRz .5*)Z4;uZ4<$& ."!;($&"49 #"!9UwŒ(7 %'Ž5('%' )651;r*# ."4X5=Z

AzP$"N5=Z-95 T ;Y%‘5{*.(75=ZBV+ #%':Z- #sG5(75"%}6*#(7;=“3%7:45{6('(75=;',~"!Z- ."49yŽ$&(7 .$4*#51;? T ;Y%+%7$X5

Z4 tsG5(75"%PŽ$&*T 51;o 8W*.(7 #"49 $k9(7$,4:‡ ."*.(;<$&/ T "%;/ #" / ."4 .y .0 ."49 %7:45‰" T R5=(B&w

ŽA .*)$%75=Z[6";^%7(7$ #"%7;x$"!ZBv"!Z- ."49B$/;Y*T %7 #"CV+ #%':;Y%

F o

…- 41‡ k h3 A

 58:$ Ž58$*.;' ;Y5=*#51ƒ%75=Zˆ%7:45‰%7:4('5=58/;Y%CZ- J)B

T

*#%N #"!;Y%7$"!651;Bw%':458wŒ('51

T

5"!z†$;';' #9"4/5"%

,!('4*#5=<;“G%7:45 <>?@B!26%7:45 <>?@ABC‘$&"!Z|%7:45 <>?@AB +,4('4*.5<;oŠx:45=;'5u ."!;^%$&"!5=;$&(75u('51$&*. .;Y%' )

;' ."!65+%7:45zy:!$ Ž5‘$&*.*45=5"B T #*#%uwŒ(7 Z- #s~5=('5="%?; T 4,!$(Y%;&w€$|(75=$*4,4(74*.5NorŠx:45k<>?A@AB!|:!$;

FF

Ž $(' )$&!*#51;}$&"Z

"

"!;Y%'($& ."%7;"~%':45 <>/?@ABDCB:$;

EAFF

Ž $(' )$&!*#51;U$"!Z

-

6";^%7(7$ #"%7;"

%7:45&<>?A@ABR:!$;

RŽ$&(7 .$4*#51;+$&"!Z

l EE

6"!;^%7(7$ #"%;o

Šx:!5}Ž$&(7 .$4*.5=;$('5}%':45}wŒ('51 T 5"! #51;u%7~5$;';' .9"451Z<${Ž$&*T 5V+:4 .:P5=*#"49{%7R${,!('51Z-56v!"!5=Z

;'56%‘wK$*#*.VW51Z<wŒ(751 T 5="!6 .5=;fcZ-<$& .";Y .05$ T % EAF iƒoŠx:456"!;^%7(7$ #"%;+$&(75Uw%7:45|wŒ(7$#‘%

‘&#('*)<(+#‘% ‘&#-,.)‰fa%7C$ Ž .ZN ."%'5=(YwŒ5=('5="!651;7i6o SUT (5"6-Z- ."49P );|;^%$&"!Z4$(7Z$"!Z‰('51$%'51;

"4*.z<%':455=Ž5="CŽ$&(7 )$&4*.5=;? ."C%7:458 : $&*."!9yV+ #%':N"4*#zB%':45 ."451 T $*# #%' .5=;0/&o

Šx:!5P '^5=ƒ%7 #Ž5Bw

T

"ƒ%' ."%' 5[/ #"! #/ .05=Z .;/$8VW5= #9:%75=Z ; T w}ŽA #*.$&%'5=Z6";^%7(7$ #"%7;=o

Šx:!5{6";^%7(7$ #"%7;?~5*."49y%7RwŒ

T

(}=$%'5=9(' .5=;WV+ t%7:Z- tsG5(75"%};Y%7;?&wrŽA #*.$&%' ."€“

0

8W";^%7(7$ #"%7;?w <>?A@ABR:!$ Ž5$yV?5 .9:% 2 2 " ( E o

0

8W";^%7(7$ #"%7;?w <>?A@AB!R:!$ Ž5$yV?5 .9:% 2

F

2

FAF (

FFAF

o

0

8W";^%7(7$ #"%7;?w <>?A@ABDCR:!$ Ž5$yV?5 .9:% 2

FAF

2

FAFFAF

(kIK1o

2/‡ ˆMuˆ3€3

Šx:!5 T ; T

$&*€Z-5v!"4 #%' ."N&wK"45 .9:A~(7:4AAZ

T

;'5=ZPwŒ( 8 :

;+ .;}:4;'5"[:45(75“$y"45=V "-v!9

T

($%' ."

‘˜K .;|$B"!5 .9:A(}wu%':45/

T

('(75"%U"-v!9

T

($%' ." ‘ #w%':d:!$ Ž5%7:45/;'$y5RŽ$&*

T

5=;=2G56q465=,-%UwŒ(

"45Ž$&(7 .$4*.5[V+:! .:†%7$X51;<Z- tsG5(75"%BŽ$&*

T

51;< #"ˆ~&%7:‹6"4v!9

T

($%7 #"!;=o %(75Ž5=(=2uwŒ*.*#V+ ."49

% #"%'"43;:45

T

(7 .;Y%' ){j np2%':45|

T

('(75"%Ž$&*

T

5U&w%':$%xŽ $(' )$&!*#5‘,$&('%' )6 .,!$%75=;%7R$R6"5! .6%W ."B%7:45

"-v9

T

($%7 #"_‘324%':!$&%‘ .;=2- t%‘ŽA .*)$%75=;+$%+*.5=$;^%‘"456";^%7(7$ #"%=o

67 …kDŒM

…}*#*3%':45R$&*.9(7 #%':4<;+:!$ Ž5|5=5"‰Z-5=Ž5*.,~5=Z[ ."‰$B;7$&/5{;Ywa%^V?$('5/j npo SUT (‘,4*)$%'wŒ(7 );+ .y,!*#5

/5="%75=Z< ."$8988 $&"!ZP$&*.*4%':!5‘%'51;^%;u:!$ Ž5+5=5"B,~5('wŒ(7/5=Z/"P$:D> ’ *2”+ ™ ;;;=<>–?RV+ t%7:P$

3 #" T qN,~5($%7 #"!9B;Yz-;Y%'5No+…‘*.*%':45$*#9(7 t%7:4<;+~5*."49/%7P$<:4 .5($&(:AzB&wu6*)$;7;'5=;+V+:4 ):‰$& .<;

$&%};Y:$&(7 #"49/6-Z-524;Yy%7:!$%+wh$ #(‘/,!$&(7 );Y"!;W=$&"N~5/$Z-5|5%^VW5=5"C%':45=No

@ F |SbAsuyuchb\nl~stb\zhchz|s cqp,susul n*wSw dilw~s rmsul rdigbdi|Sa\suz_Š F zob\`Sa\s}`Sgn`diemd„chb\nlkni‡cojSs‚sC*xdia\bchb\s9z}dia\a\n9p(zxSz

confws9wxSyuschjSs‚rdia\xs9z}ni‡chjSsnwSw7rdigbdi|Sa\suz_Š

(8)

*,+

SUT

(Uv(7;Y%56q-,5=(' ./5"%7;|;':4V?5=Z%7:!$%*.VW5=(' ."49<%7:45/%':!('51;Y:4*.Z8Az‰$[;Y% $%51$:8 #%'5=(7$&%' ."

Vx$;U .('(75*.5Ž$&"%}"d5*)$&(},!('4*#5=<;‘wŒ(UV+:4 ):‰%7:45/6;Y%U($&"!95{ );Ž5(7z[*.$('95o Ž5="8"89($&,4:

*.(7 #"!9‘V+:4;'5? '^51ƒ%' .Ž5w

T

"!6%' ."y .;K/(75 5$%92V?5-%7$ #"!5=Z{5=Ž5="~56%Y%75(r(75=;

T

*t%;3Az,!$ zA ."49

$&%Y%75"%' ." %'[%7:45/%':4(75=;':4*.Z <$&"!$95=y5="%=o 5Ž5($&*r,~;7;Y .4*.5/%':4(75=;':4*)Zd/$"!$&95/5"%;U:$ Ž5

%7:45" ~55="Z-51;Y .9"451ZoNŠx:45zkZ- #s~5=({wŒ(7 51$:k&%7:45( #" %7:45PZ-5=*t%$ fŒ ."k%'5=('<;&w+6;Y%i|%'‰~5

; T -%7(7$ƒ%75=ZP%'/%':!5{ T (7('5="%W%7:4('51;Y:!*)ZC$&%‘5Ž5=('z< #%'5=(7$&%' ."€“

o% ' I k%7:4('51;Y:!*)Z$O%

o % ' I Z- );^% hN #k%7:4(75=;':4*)Z O %

" o% ' I Z- .;Y% # ' I Z- );Y%hN # IKK c6;^%hN # ;Y% #.# #

E o ' I Z- );^% hN # O 6;Y%oN #k6;^%9I# #

o ' I Z- );Y% oN # Œ%7:4('51;Y:!*)Z "!$#%&('*),+-!.0/ #$O1

O %2O % 2O ƒ2O 2 {( x .;‘%':45R,!$&($&/5%'5(‘%'P~5(

T

*.5=Z[%7P<$&X5%':45%':4(75=;':4*.Z

/('5?(*.5=;7;;Y/A&%7:€oŠx:!5xv!(7;Y%KwŒ

T

(,!$(7$/56%'5=(7;r$('5?(7$&%' .;"Z- );^% # .;K%7:45‘Z- );^%$&"!5fŒ o5o#26;Y%

Z4 tsG5(75"!51ir~56%^V?55="/%':45}%':4(75=;':4*.Z/$&"Zy%':45"

43

51;^%?,!$&('%' )6*.5%': T ;=2N .;u%':45‘V?(;Y%}fŒ:4 .9:451;^%ƒi

,$&('%' )6*.5/$"!Z8Z4 .;Y% #x );%':!5/Z4 .;Y%7$"!65fh;Y%{Z- tsG5(75"651iU~56%^V?55="8%7:45y%':4(75=;':4*)Z $&"!Zd,!$&('%' )6*.5

NPou6;^% 5#u .;?%7:45{6;^%+w%7:4565 43

51;^%‘,!$(Y%7 .*#5o

Šx:!5Wv(7;Y%Z-5*#%7$%75=;Y%'51ZRVx$;7% oŠx:45+&%7:45(uZ-5=*t%$;$('5+$Z!$&,-%7 #Ž5x$"!ZR%7$X5x #"%7|$ T "%

%7:45{Vx$ z<%':!5{,!$&('%' )6*.5=;‘9<Z-V+"€oxŠx:45z$1 T 5=;Y%' ."[%^V?B:!$&($6%'5(7 );^%7 .=;Ww8% “9% <$ z

~5|%'A<;'/$*#*$%x%':45~59 #"!"4 #"!9/$"!ZC%'A/*.$('95$&%+%':45|5="!Zo'"!Z455=Z€“

0

…?%{%7:45<v!(;^%%7:4(75=;':4*)Zk/AZ4 tv=$%7 #"!;2%':!5B,!$&('%' )6*.5=;{9‰Z-V+" $N*.&%R;' #"65B/ŽA #"!9C%7

~56%Y%75(u"-v!9 T ($%' .";3 );rŽ5=('z51$;'z{$&"!ZR5Ž5"{%7:45+V?(;^%r,!$&('%' )6*.5?/$ z~5+Ž5=('z|wh$( T "!Z-5=(

%':!5|%':4(75=;':4*)Zo

Šx:45Z- );^% f+ix6/,"45"%‘&w%':45|wŒ T (+*)$;Y%}Z-5*#%7$;x .;x<$& ."4*.z T ;'56wT *#*€ ."C%':4 );‘$;Y5o

0

…?%%7:45[5"!Z2V+:!5" %7:45B%7:4(75=;':4*)Z $&,!,4('$:451;|%':!5C~5=;Y%y;'*T %' ."32r%':45NZ-5*#%7$8('5=<$& ."!;

*)$&(795 #wu%':45R51;^%;'*

T

%' ."‰;Y%U );}5=Ž5"9('51$%75(+%7:!$&" F fa%7:4 .; );‘%7:45R=$;'5wŒ(U%':!5R65=*.$(

,4(74*.5<;iƒo

)>B(— ’W¡ );x$R;'5="!ZP,!$&($&/5%'5(?"45165=;7;7$&(7zwŒ(W%

T

"4 ."49: 2 o'p%‘6('(75=;',~"!Z4;u%'<$

*.VW5=(u T "!ZC;Y,~5= tv!51Z<Azy%':45 T ;'5(WZ45,~5"!Z- ."49y"<%7:45},!('4*#5= fŒ5o9!o.2

""

wŒ( <>?A@AB!

;' #"!5x%':4 );~ T "Z/:!$;~55="<,4(7Ž5"yAzR/,4*.56%'5x%75=:4"! 1 T 51;7i6o; .;r%75=;Y%'51Zy%'{:451X

%':!5 #"%'5=('51;^%+w:!$ ŽA ."49<$y;'/A&%':C%':!('51;Y:4*.Z[$%+%7:45|5"!Z€o

Šx:!5}6"!6*T ;' #"!;&w%7:45‘%75=;Y%7;('5=,(Y%75=Z/~5*.Vˆ$('5‘*#51$&(1o;K .(7;Y%=2 #%W );u95="45($&*.*.z ."%75(75=;Y%' ."49

%7ywŒ(65U%':45%':!('51;Y:4*.ZB%'/~5 T "!Z-5(?%7:45|VW(7;Y%?,$&('%' )6*.5oŠx:45;Y516"!ZP"!*T ;' ."C"%'($Z4 .6%7;

T (uv(7;Y% ."% T #%' ."!;=“,$ z ."49$&%Y%75"%' ."/%7%':45UV?$ z%':45}%':4(75=;':4*.Z<Z-516(75=$;Y51;u$%u%7:45}5="!Z< );u"4%

wŒ( T #%YwT *.*oŠx:!$&%U );}V+:AzNV?5:!$ Ž5{$Z-,-%'51ZN%':45/;' #/,4*.5RZ-5=*t%$B<$&"$&95=/5"%< % o }5%7$& .*);

$('5|9 #Ž5"P~5*.Vo

==% % T ('"!5=Z T %%7 1 T .XA*.z "AŽ5=('95/%' V+:4 #*.5P~5 ."498wh$&(R$Ž5<%':!5P~5=;Y%y;'*T 

%7 #"!;=o ' "!Z-5=5=Z23V+:45" <$&XA #"!9C,4(79('51;';U~5=6/5=;|Z- J)<

T

*#%=2€%7:45/,!$&('%' )6*.5=;|$('5y"4&%

T

"4 #wŒ(7/*#z

Z4 .;Y%'(7 #

T

%'51ZCfh #"y%'5=('<;rw~6;^%ƒi€~56%^V?55="%7:45x%':!('51;Y:4*.ZR$&"!Z%':!5?~5=;Y%u,!$(Y%7 .*#52y('5x$&"Z/(75

T

(9)

;' ."!656;^% hN # ;Y% 9I#u516y51;x" T *#*3"4*.zBV+:45="N>@A@,+-/.%75(7y ."!$&%'5=;=o

;K ."!$&*.*.z2%':45U!$Z/(75=; T *#%7;u-%7$ #"!5=Z/Azy${/$"!$&95/5"%$;'5=Z/" $9$ #"!;Y%%':!5U;' #/,4*.5

% " ."!;Y%7$"!651;‘V+ #%':‰"4" 5$&%U6(7 t%75(7 .$B:!$ Ž5*.5=Z

T

;+%'[6('(75=6%+%':45R*.$&%Y%'5=(=2G$&"ZNVW5{:$ Ž5

Z45=;' #9"45=ZC$&"!ZB$Z-,4%'5=Z % ouŠx:45|;Y5=(' .5=;W&w%75=;Y%7;?*.5=$Z4 #"49R%'R%':! .;x:4 .5U$&(75}9$%7:45(75=Z< ."

ŠK$&!*#5 o

! !"$#%$&'#)(

7*+ ,7.-//)0 /SŠ12-/$1$0 *Š34-/$1$0 56798;:=<> ?

! !"$#%$&!@#)( A * 7 7Š/4-13$0 7*Š14-+1$0 7*Š87.-+7B0 7*Š87C-D+7B0 ?

E)!F!G$H%%$&!@I

7 71 +Š

A

-/$J$0 +Š/K-/$J$0 +Š,4-/$J$0 +Š

A

-/$3$0 ?

(L $!F!M$I

7N/$* +*+K-7*+$0 ++OP-71+$0 +*,P-D33$0 7QRS8N<5T> +*+4-7*!/)0

(L $!F!M$U

7*1 +O*!/4-/$3$0 +O7OP-,!/)0 +OO

A

-/$+$0 V:XW<Y8;:R> +O+

A

-/+7B0

(L $!F!M$Z

7+O + A

171OP-7+J$0 ,1

AAA

/[-7O1$0 /$11,7,P-7+O$0 +

AA

17N/[-7N/+7B0 VX\]5\]Q]:^8<VQX>

ŠK$&!*#5 “{Šx:!('51;Y:4*.Z8<$&"!$95/5="%1o<Šx:45<65*.*);|('5=,(Y%|%':!5B$ Ž5($&95R;'*

T

%' ."k6;^%BfhVW5= #9:%75=Z

; T w}ŽA #*.$&%'5=Z6";^%7(7$ #"%7;i-%7$ #"!5=Z Az >@A@M+SR/BTd ."‡$89 .Ž5"(

T

"!"4 #"!98%7 #/5[ #"†;Y516"Z4;

fc;Y516"!Z6*T /"i ."%'<,!$('5="%':451;Y51;2-%7:45R$ Ž5($&95U" T R5=(‘&wr%':!('51;Y:4*.ZN/-Z- #v$&%' ."!;=oxŠx:45

~5=;Y%‘(75=;T *t%;+$&(75|*.ZAwh$5=Zo

;!(x5Ž5(7z< #";^%$&"!52

F

%'(7 )$&*);W:$ Ž55=5"[,5=(YwŒ('/5=Z[$&"ZC$ Ž5($&95}Ž $*T 5=;+$&(75('5=,(Y%75=ZB ."

%7:45R%7$&!*#5_&oŠx:45R5*)$&(U #"!;Y%7$"!651;}:$ Ž5{~55="8:!$"!Z-*.5=Z‰V+ #%': N 'a`K8fN ' GXKAK/wŒ(<>/?@AB!Aiƒ2

P7' GXKK!2 'cbAK4orŠx:45U9($&,4:<6*#(' ."49 ."!;Y%7$&"65=;W:!$ Ž5+5=5"P;'*.Ž51Z/V+ t%7:N ' GK42DP ' GXKAKK

$"!Z[;Y5=Ž5($&*GŽ$&*T 51;?wŒ( o

;K .(7;Y%=2&%':45x%75=;Y%7;r"4?> D<+$&"Z $D?@ * }$&(75x"4&% ."-wŒ(7<$%' .Ž5o 516"!Z2 ==%

);uwa%'5="/%':45UVW(7;Y%$&"!Z: }95="45($&*.*#z9 .Ž5=;uVW(7;'5+('51; T *t%;r%':!$" %oŠx:4 .(7Z2 %

);+"45=Ž5=(?$ZN$&"!ZC );x&wa%'5="[%':45~5=;Y%=o

*,+ed X‘PJG3SVG060C13? JEwAFEH[ ?C`?BAW

…}"B$Z-Ž$"%$&95WwG>@A@,+R/BT .;%':!$&%u5=$:y&wG #%7;rwŒ T (u,!$(7$y5%'5=(7;r;'55<;r%7:!$ Ž5x$;',516 #vx('*#5o

#}VW5=Ž5=(=2%7:4(755B$&/"49[%':45<wŒ T ({,!$(7$/56%'5=(7;$('5<$N,4(7 .(7 "4&%51$;'z%'~5<%T "45=Z€o '"!Z455=Z€2

(75=Z T 6 ."49 O( #"!('51$;' #"!9}%7:45+Ž$&*T 5x&wN $"!Z5P8$*#Vx$ z-;3*.5=$Z4;K%'|~56%'%'5( T "!Z4;V+ #%':<$V?(;Y5

,~5('wŒ(7<$&"!5o~'p% ); #"Z-551Z‰"4%;Y%'($& .9:%YwŒ('Vx$&(ZC%'C;'5*.5=6%|$PŽ$&*T 5R ./,4*.z ."49[$&"d$;YzA/,-%7&%' )

~5:$ Ž .(y(R%'kZ-516 )Z-5CV+:! .:‡,!$&($&/56%75(%'dwh$ Ž(R%' .y,!('Ž5B T "!Z4;=o #‘V?5Ž5(12u$‰Ž5(7z

v"45<% T "4 #"!9‰&w?%':45P,!$&($&/56%75(;;Y5=5<;"4%{%'~5 T ;'56wT * ." ,4(7$ƒ%7 .52r$&"!Z V?5<:!$ Ž5B$*#(75=$Z-z

-%7$ #"!5=Z[,4(7/ .;' ."49y%T "4 ."49B,!('-651Z T (75=;=o SUT (‘5qA,~5(7 .y5="%7;‘$"!ZC%':45*. t%75($% T ('5*.5=$ZC%'/%T "45

%7:45,!$(7$y5%'5=(7;? ."C%7:45|wŒ*.*.V+ #"49y:45 T (' );Y%' )UVx$ z8fh #"N(Z-5=(i6“

ogf< Šx:45R$;YzA/,-%'%' ){~5:!$ ŽA .(U&wO );‘%7:45y5=$;' .5=;Y%‘%'C!;'5(7Ž5o7'"‰

T

(U5q-,5=(' ./5"%7;=2

%':!5P($%' . O %N$"!Z O % PV?5(75C$*#Vx$ z-;{:4;Y5=" 5%^VW5=5" F oh $"!Z h u%':!5P($%' .

O ‘~56%^V?55=" F oh $&"!Z Fh o ? #995(($%' .;*.5=$Z%'NŽ5(7z!$Z8

T

"!Z4;$"!Zd;'<$&*.*#5=(

($%' .;Z-["4&% ./,4('Ž5{%7:45/ T "!ZdV+:4 #*.5/V?$;^%7 #"!9[$C*#%w%7 #/5o/Šx:45=('5wŒ(752;^%$&('%' ."49

V+ #%': $N(7$&%' .NV+ t%7: Ž$*T 5

]h

2$[wŒ5V %'(7 )$&*);Bfa%^zA,4 )$*#*.z

E

i|$('5<; T )B6 .5"%%'‰;'5*.5=6%{$&"

$=65=,-%7$4*#5Ž$&*T 5io

j F cogbdiav dilSwvqsughgng`Sgn*y9suzhzb\zlSsuyus9zhz€dig <~chnzosua\suyc(chjSs diwSsCxSd„cosrdia\xSsni‡ d!chjSgs9zhjSna\w `dighdis cosug(a\s_diwb\lSe

cond†ebrms9l~d9rmsughdies chb\sŠ\Š\Š

(10)

"P%':45,~5('wŒ(7<$&"!5o'"%'5(75=;Y%' ."49/ ."C,4($6%' )652%^V?/(?%':!('5=5U%75=;Y%7;xV+ #%':NZ- #s~5=('5="%};'<$&*.*

Ž$&*T 5=;xwN $"!Z P‡$&(75; T )B6 .5"%+%'BZ456%'5=('/ ."45{$&"$65=,-%7$4*.5Ž$*T 5wvgwŒ(U$R9 #Ž5"

."!;^%$&"!5o

"

ou ;4*#*.V+ #"!9B%':!5/;Y% T Z-z,5=(YwŒ('/51Z‰ ."‡jnp2%'51;^%;|Z-5=;76(7 #~5=Z‰wT ('%':45=(VW T *.Zd$&*.*#V T ;

%'BZ456%'5=('/ ."45{$/Vx$&*.XP*.5"49%':; T )< #5="%'*.zP*."49/%7 T "4 #wŒ(7y*.z[56q-,4*.(75U%7:45;'5=$(7:C9($&,4:

; T - 6/,~"45="%7;=o

E

oC S "65y%':45<,!('5=Ž . T ;U,$&($&/56%75(;U:$ Ž5y5=5" % T "!5=Z2N $&" ~5< #"!('51$;'5=Z T "%' .*$

9A-Z[;Y*T %7 #"C );x4%7$& ."451Zo

S w T (;'52%':4 );|;^% T Z-z‰;':4 T *)Z~5y"!;' )Z-5(75=Z$Bv!(7;Y%$,4,4(7$:€o SUT (56q-,~5(7 #/5="%;}<$X5

T ;5=*# .5Ž5+%':$%% T "4 #"!9{O†$"!ZZ .;u5=$;'zor… Z-5=5,~5( T "Z-5(;^%$&"!Z4 #"49w%7:45}>@A@,+R/BT{~5:!$ ŽA .(

;':4 T *.Z‰56q-,4*)$& ."V+:zN T (‘v!(;Y%U$%'%'5/,-%wŒ(}% T "! #"49 Pˆ$&"Z N’ );U$65=,-%7$4*.5$&"!Z8;Y:4 T *)Z*#51$Z

%7B$yy('5|$= T ($%75%T "4 ."49<,~*. .zo

ff} ‡ 

3400 3410 3420 3430 3440 3450 3460

10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Average quality

N Tuning N on celar6

B=500, S=200

400000 500000 600000 700000 800000 900000 1e+06 1.1e+06

10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Average quality

N Tuning N on celar7

B=20, S=1000

302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312

20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Average quality

N Tuning N on celar8

B=20, S=1000

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160

Average quality

N Tuning N on coloring problems

le450_15c: B=20, S=2000

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160

Average quality

N Tuning N on coloring problems

le450_15c: B=20, S=2000 le450_25c: B=20, S=2000

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160

Average quality

N Tuning N on coloring problems

le450_15c: B=20, S=2000 le450_25c: B=20, S=2000 flat300_28: B=20, S=2000

;K .9 T (75 “‰Š T "4 ."49k%':!5 ,$&($&/56%75(1o‹Šx:45Ž$&*T 5=;<:4;Y5="wŒ(<,!$&($&/5%'5(;5N $&"Z P $&(75

."!Z- )$&%'51ZC ."[%':45|v9 T (75=;=o

;K .9 T (75 ;':4V‘;{%':45[ T (7Ž51;{4%7$& ."451ZkwŒ(% T "4 ."498%':45C,!$&($&/56%75(x " %7:45C:4;Y5=" #"4

;Y%7$"!651;o‘Šx:!5Ž$&*T 5{w  .;U9 .Ž5="[ ."8$!;' .;7;7$<$&"!Z[%7:45(7Z- ."!$&%'5=;}9 .Ž5|%7:45R;Y%}&w%7:45~5=;Y%

;'*T %7 #" fc$ Ž5($&95}"

F

%7(' .5=;iƒouŠx:!5|"!*T ;Y ."!;+$('5U%':!5|wŒ*.*#V+ ."49!“

0

'p%U );‘"!&%Z4 )B T *t%%'<%T "45S ;Y ."!5{%':!5R T ('Ž5=;‘V+"‰$By ."4 . T No '"!Z-551Z2G tw  .;‘%'A

;'/$*#*2!,$&('%' )6*.5=;‘=$&"4"4%}<$&X5,4('9(75=;7; - #wu #%U );+%'A<*)$&(79524,!$&('%' )6*.5=;U$"4"4&%‘5q- t%UwŒ('

(11)

0

%'N$&*.Vx$ zA;6*#(U ." 6*.(;k?A> < ." / #" T %75=;=o S "4*.zN%':!5 <>?@ABCP ."!;^%$&"!5

Z-A5=;x"!&%‘;Y5=5 %'/5Ž5(7zP;'5"!;' t%7 #Ž5}%7/%':4 );+,!$(7$/56%'5=(=o

 5/;Y:4

T

*)Z/5"%' ."8%':!$&%=2GwŒ($*#*%'51;^%75=Z‰ ."!;Y%7$"!651;2~%':!5/

T

(7Ž5=;}-%$& ."45=Z8V+ t%7:dZ- #sG5(75"%

,$&($&/56%75(; N $&"!Z=Pk:!$ Ž5}(7

T

9:4*.zR%7:45;'$/5U;':!$&,~5$"!ZB9 #Ž5‘%7:45;'$y5Y51;^%9}Ž $*

T

5UwŒ(  o

Šx:! .;‘;'55=<;?%'//5=$&"C%':$%+%':!5Ž $*

T

5&wv );x #"%7(' ."!;'51

T

5%'<$/9 .Ž5="P ."!;Y%7$&"65o

ff} ‡ P

 5:!$ Ž5[$,4,4*. #51Z %7:45N%'51:4"4 21 T 5NZ45=;76(7 #~5=Z† ." jn+wŒ(/%':45‰;Y%7$"!Z4$&(Z>@A@o‚' "%7:!$%P$(Y%7 .*#52

%75=;Y%7;?:!$ Ž5}~55"C,5=(YwŒ('/51ZBV+ #%':CZ4 tsG5(75"%xŽ $*T 5=;?&wP T %+$R"!;Y%7$"%WŽ$&*T 5UwŒ(N P?“K%7:45

Ž$*T 5&w‚Pk9 .ŽA #"!9{%':!5U~5=;Y%‘;Y*T %7 #"8fŒ"C$ Ž5($&95 ir );?;'5*.5=6%'51ZoŠx:4 .;x$,4,4(7$:< );'T ;Y%' #v!5=ZPz

%7:45ywŒ*.*#V+ ."49C #"% T t%7 #"€o{'"k>@A@2Pˆ T ;^%~5y; T )B6 .5"%'*.z‰*."49P%'N$&*.*#V %7:45/,!$&('%' )6*.5=;U%7C~5

T

"4 twŒ('/*.zZ4 .;Y%'(7 #

T

%'51Z #"%7‘%':!5W;'5=$&(:|9($&,4:;

T

-6y,~"!5"%7;=oŠx:

T

;=2 V+:45"|%7:4 .;MYy ."4 .

T

*.5"!9&%':N:!$;x5=5"N(75=$:!5=Z2%':!5(75 );+"4/ ."%'5(75=;Y%x%'BZ- #s

T

;Y5/('5o

Šx:!5x;' #%

T

$&%' ."y .;/('5x6y,!*# )$&%'5=ZwŒ(u>@A@,+SRBTV+:45=('57P‰ .;

T

;'5=ZR%7|Z4 ts

T

;'5x%':45+,!$(Y%7 .*#51;

V+ #%':! #"8%':45y6"!"45=6%'5=Z86/,~"45="%7;‘ T %|$*.;'<%7P<$&X5{,4(79(75=;7;+Z-V+"%'B%':45y51;^%|;Y*T %' ."!;=o

…}*.;'!2%':!5‘%'51:4"4 21 T 5}Z-51;'(' .51Z<$&~Ž5+:!$;u~55="P$&,4,!*# .5=ZywŒ(W>@A@yV+:4 ):<:!$;u"!*#zR%^VW,!$&($&y

5%'5=(7;N $"!Z P?24V+:45=('51$;? T (x%7:4(75=;':4*)Z[/$"!$&95/5"%+$Z4Z!;‘$R%':4 .(7Zkfhy"4&%7"4 )=i?,$&($&/56%75(

O fh$;'; T / ."49y%':!$&%D :!$;x5=5"$&*.(75=$Z4z/% T "451ZN$&"!ZCv4q-5=Ziƒo

…}"AzVx$ z2VW5R:!$ Ž5y$&,4,!*# .5=ZN%7:4 );}% T "4 ."49C$,4,4(7$:N%'C>@A@,+SRBT2!$"!Z‰-%7$ #"451ZN%^V?BXA #"!Z!;

wr T (7Ž5=;|fh"4&%‘(75,~('%'51ZP:45=('5Z T 5U%7B$y*.$XB&wr;Y,!$65 iƒ“

o;4(%7:45|65*)$&(W #";^%$&"!5=;=2A T (7Ž5=;9 .Ž5}%':4551;^%+6;^%?V+:45" Pk );W/,4(7 .;'5=ZB5%^VW5=5"

FF

$&"Z

EAFF

2$&"Z/%':45U;'$y5}Ž $*T 5‘ .;W4%7$& ."451ZywŒ(Z- #sG5(75"%WŽ$&*T 51;u&wN &PxoKŠx:4 );W*#51$Z4;r%7

$Z4,-%$}*)$&(795WŽ$&*T 5!N fc;Y5=Ž5($&*%':! T ;7$&"!Z!;7i$&"!Zy$;Y<$&*.*AŽ$&*T 5Pf"AFF i€ ."{%7:45?wŒ*.*#V+ ."49

%'51;^%;o

o;4(%':!5P9($&,!:k*.(7 #"!9[ ."!;Y%7$"!651;2K%':!5B,4,~;' #%'5B~5:!$ ŽA .({:$;~55=" !;'5(7Ž51ZoNŠx:45

T

('Ž5=;Ry"4&%7 .=$&*.*#z Z-516(75=$;Y5[;Yd%':!$&%/%':45N~5=;Y%/(75=;

T

*#%7;/$&(75C$*#Vx$ z-;{-%7$ #"451ZV+ #%':ˆ$

*. t%'%'*.5"

T

~5(+&wr,!$(Y%7 .*#51;2A5o9!o F 24$"!ZC$y*."49/Vx$&*.XGo

Šx:!5=;'5|%'5=;Y%7;}6

T

*.Z[~5$/9A-Z[ #"!Z4 .=$%' ."Nw%7:45{(75*.5Ž$&"!5&w>@@,+SR/BTGoŠx:45 #"%'5=('51;^%+wŒ(

<$"!$&9 #"49d;Y5=Ž5($&*W,!$&('%' )6*.5=;R ."‡,!$(7$*#*.5*W .;/*#51$&(y #"%':45Cv!(;^%/$;'52V+:45(75=$;$‰*.-$*x;'5=$(7:

T *)ZC-%$& ."[~56%'%'5=(‘('51; T *t%;x #"C%':45{;'5="!Z[$;Y5o

*,+

_?BAZ©AF[ EG0/<?

ŠK$&!*#5 (75,~('%7;W%':45~5=;Y%‘~ T "!Z!;+-%$& ."45=ZCAzP>@A@M+SR/BT<"C%':45{:4;Y5="C~5":4<$&(7XA;=o

Šx:!5 $D?@-* N ."!;Y%7$"!65C:!$;R"45Ž5(y5=5"†6*.(75=Zk ." 8*.(;o Š3 T

(RXA"4V+*#51Z-952

"4*.z‰%':!('5=5< #"!/,4*.56%75B$&*.9(7 #%':4<;|;

T

65=5=Z-51Z #" 6*#(' ."49[ t%R #" "D *.(;“%':!5PZ- );^%7(' .

T

%75=Z

Ž5(;Y ."/w%':45 ;B™ , @ ) )X>{$&*.9(7 #%':4 j l=np2A$%7$&

T

;Y51$&(:Nj n2-$&"Z<${:45

T

(' );Y%' )+/ tq- ."49R$95"45%' )

$*#9(7 t%7:4’$&"ZC*.-$*€;Y51$&(:8jnpo

j n$&"!Z j n(75,~('%[/,4*.56%758$&*.9(' #%':4<;P!$;'5=Zˆ"‹9($&,4:4!$;Y51ZˆZ-5=/,;Y #%' ."‹$"!Z

Z4z"$&/ .y,4(79(7$/y ."49oyŠx:45<%':45=(|%^VW[ ."!;^%$&"!5=;$('5/(75=$&*.*.z‰:!$&*.*#5="49 ."49N$&"!Z :!$ Ž5R"!5Ž5=(

~55="8,4(7Ž5="AzN$C6y,!*#5%'5R$*#9(7 t%7:4oŠx:45R$*#9(7 t%7:4 #"j

E

n .;U!$;'5=Z‰"8$PŽ5(7z[% T "!5=Z

;: jSb\zy9dil |Xs‚st`Sadib\ls9w | < chjSszob\ƒusni‡

(L $!F!M$I

dilSw | < chjSs‚yughbchsughb\nlkni‡

(L $!F!M$Z

Š

(12)

! " # $&%&$('

)*+,-."/,0 13 i2 3 3/546#7 8:9; 3/546"7=<>@?#A 3 ?3 8:9; #B3> >2 >#>">2 >

)*+,-.C,0 13 i3 /546#7 8:9; /546"7=<3 ?8"A ?05D 3B3> >2>#>">">#>@23>">

E")FG#H--.CI 13i2!J2 3„33 03 46#7 D 6#KMLON 0i3 46"7=<3 ?0#A /?J58:9; #B3> >@2 >">">#>@2>

0*)F

#P

1

/2 3 /2 3 2 38"3 0 0 J 8:9; BD 0 0 J<0.8> /?i A J? 8:9; 8"B3 > /#>#>@2 >">28 >

0*)F

#Q

1

3 2 38#3 0 840 /"J 8:9; 0.8 0 /"J <0 8 /"J 8m3A /?i D 3B3> />">">20 >#>@2/>

0*)F I 1

3 2 38#3 L_ 8:9; L_ <B_i?8A 00 ?i58:9; #B3> 3>">">2 >#>@20>

ŠK$&!*#5 “R+5=; T *#%7;}"‰~5"!:!/$('X-;=o‘Šx:45(75=; T *#%7;U&w~5=;Y%XA"4V+"‰$*#9(7 t%7:4<;‘$&(75{(75,~('%'5=ZN ."

%7:45*.56wa%};' .Z-5w3%7:45|%7$4*#5-%':!5('51; T *#%7;xwK>@A@,+R/BT< #"[%7:45(' .9:%‘;' .Z-5o

95"45%' )}$*#9(7 t%7:4 V+ #%':C${ T %7$%7 #"B,~5($%7(u5="!6-Z- ."49y$ %=' : o-Šx:45U$*#9(7 t%7:4 Z45=;76(7 #~5=Z< ."

j

n3 .;+$y*.-$&*€;'5=$(7:P%7$X ."49y%':!5{6"5! .6%7;+ ."%'<$=6 T "%?%7<;Y5=*#51ƒ%+"45 .9:A~(;o

ŠK$&!*#5

(75,~('%7;%':45 #/,4(75=;7;' #Ž5}(75=; T *t%;-%7$ #"!5=Z<AzB>@A@M+SR/BTo3Šx:4551;^%xXA"4V+"B~ T "!Z!;

$('5-%7$ #"!5=Z[wŒ($&*.*€%7:45%'51;^%75=Z ."!;Y%7$"!651;o; T (Y%7:45(7/(7524%7:45%7 #/5(751 T .(75=Z[Az[>@A@,+R/BTB );

wa%'5="<Ž5(7z;7$%7 .;Ywh$6%'(7zoŠ3 T (uXA"4V+*.5=Z-952& #%u .;W$&/"!9U%7:45 1 T )X5=;Y%$&*.9(' #%':!/;KwŒ(u;Y*#ŽA ."49

$D?@ * !2?> D<<$&"Z…<>?@AB !o ;4({%':45/%7:4('5=5/&%':!5( ."!;^%$&"!5=;=2€%7:45/%' ./5<('51 T #(75=Z

Az[>@A@,+SR/BAT/ );+9(75=$&%'5(fh:4 T (;+$&9$& ."!;Y%x/ ." T %'51;?wŒ(+%7:4551;^%‘XA"4V+"N$&*.9(' #%':!/;iƒo‚#}VW5=Ž5(12

"!&%'5?%7:!$%>@A@,+R/BT T ;'5=;r"4%'51:4"4 21 T 5x(5"6-Z- ."49|V+:4 .:y );u;Y,~5= tv~%7|%':45x%^zA,~5x&wG,4('4*.5N2

$;x,4,~;' #%'5%'B$*#9(7 t%7:4<;?Z45=;76(7 #~5=ZC #"kj l2 *E npo

*,+?* Z\[ 3EHAFSVG06 3%43÷EG3ITS ?C`ADZ_Z\USVW

ŠK$&!*#5

"

9$%':!5(;<6/,!$(' );'"!;yV+ #%': %N5%'(7,~*. .;<$"!Zˆ>@A@"†%':458:!;'5"† #"!;Y%7$"!651;o Šx:45

*T /" >@A@VU<('5=,(Y%;<%7:458(75=; T *#%7;Bw>@@ˆV+ #%': %7:45d;7$&/5‰%7:4(75=;':4*)Zˆ<$&"!$95/5="%[$;<wŒ(

>@A@,+SRBTo SUT (k%N56%7(',*# );‘ );|;^%$&"!Z!$&(Zo7'p% .;U #/,4*.5/5="%75=Z8 #"8%':45/;'$/5;Ywa%^V?$('5Pj nr$"!Z

;':!$('5+/;Y%w~%7:45}AZ45‘V+ t%7:B>@@,+SR/BTR$&"!Z/>@A@oX'p%?;Y%7$(Y%;rwŒ(' $($&"Z- 6"4v!9 T ($%7 #"y$"!Z

$yVx$&*.XB&wK*#5="49&%7: P );+,~5('wŒ(7y51ZC$;?wŒ*.*#V‘;3“

0 … "45=V "45= #9:~(+ );+$=65=,-%'51ZP #wK #%7;}6;Y%+ .;‘5%Y%'5=(‘(x51

T

$&*G%':$&"[%':45{

T

(7('5="%+"45o

0 … "!5V "45= #9:~(}%':45y6;^%&wuV+:4 ):‰ );}V?(;Y5|%7:!$&"8%':45y

T

(7(75"%}"!5<$ zC~5/$5,-%75=Z

V+ #%':d$P,4(7!$4 #*. #%^z[Z-5=,5="!Z- ."49["d$P9 .Ž5=" %75/,~5($%

T

('5mo|Šx:4 );‘%75/,5=(7$&%

T

(75 );|6"-

;Y%7$&"%xwŒ(7%56%'(7,~*. );|jE npo

0  :45=" "4 "45 .9:A~(< );B$=65=,-%'51Z2?%':458"-v9

T

($%7 #" );<"4&%[:!$&"495=Z†$%<%7:458

T

('(75"%

#%'5($%7 #"€o

Šx:!5&%':!5(‘6*)$;7;' .=$&*G*#-=$&*;Y51$&(:C$*#9(7 t%7:4<;WV?5(75|"4&%‘/,5%' #%' .Ž5V+ #%': %N5%'(7,~*. .;x"P%7:45

:!;'5"[ #"!;Y%7$"!651;o

…}*#*W%':!5B #";^%$&"!5=;{:$ Ž5B~55=" #/,4*.5/5="%75=Z V+ #%': %':45[;'$y5<"!5 .9:A(':!-Zo S w‘ T (;Y52

:$&"49 #"49$*.;'|%':45}"45 .9:A~(7:4AAZR .y,!*#5=y5="%7$%7 #"//$ zy:!$&"!95x%':!5+9$&,/~56%^V?55="B$&*.9(7 #%':4<;

"C$9 .Ž5"C #";^%$&"!52A5o9!o.2wŒ*.*#V+ ."49 % #"%'"43;:45 T (7 .;Y%' );x$&*);'{wŒ(W%':!5Ž$*T 5|:4 .5} .y,!('Ž5=;

%7:45~5:!$ ŽA .(x&w%N56%7(',*# );?" $D?@-* o

Šx:!5R(75=; T *#%7;U&wW T (U%'5=;Y%7;|=$&"8~5/ #"%75(7,4('5%'51Z‰$;UwŒ*.*.V‘;ok;K #(;Y%=2%7:45R(75=; T *#%7;&w%':45y, T (75

>@A@8$&*.9(' #%':! fŒV+ #%': $B%7:4(75=;':4*)Z8*.V?5(75=ZAz $%5=Ž5(7z #%'5($%7 #"iU$&(75RŽ5(7z!$Z $&"!Z $&(75

"!&%(75,~('%'51Zd ." %7:45<%7$4*.5o

516"Z2K>@A@WU9 .Ž51;!$Zk('51;

T

*#%7;" 9(7$,4: *.(7 #"!9 #"!;Y%7$"!651;

$"!Z[ .;}$&*.V?$ z-;?VW(7;'5%':!$">@A@,+SR/BATo:R+51;

T

*#%7;}$&(75"!&%U;'/!$Z["5*)$&(+,4(74*.5<;=245=;',~5=6 )$&*.*.z

wŒ( <>/?@ABo

(13)

t_g¯°ü²6 i “g¯°YX:YÖ®

L+M /J ìê

Þâ

ë

Þ

é

â Þ â

L+M /J é ìé Þâ éìé Þé ¡â YÞ¡â

kL+G7H

ê §ìê Þ â

ëìë Þë â

éì

‘Þ

é â

JM/L+G:ô! é "‘Þ ê:ë â ë "Þ â # YÞ" ê â

JM/L+G:ô$ ë %'&() Þ*+, &() â " "Þ ëê:ë "¡â ë ""‘Þ é â

JM/L+G:ô é Þ â Žë Þ ë â ë Þ ë â

ŠK$&!*#5

"

“(8W/,!$(' );'"!;"{~5"!:4<$('X-;=o} u$:R65*.*A6"%$& ."!;%7:45W$ Ž5($&95;Y%&w-%7:45W;'*T %7 #"!;

-%7$ #"!5=Z fŒ"

F

%7(' )$&*);i A%':!551;^%};Y%+$,4,~5=$&(;? #"%7y,$&(75"%':451;Y51;o

%56%'(7,~*. );U:$;|4%7$& ."451Z‰!$Z8(75=; T *#%7;|"k65=*.$(|,4('4*.5<;o&;4( <X>?@AB!C$"!Z…<X>?@ABDC!2G #%

=$&"{~5x56q-,4*)$& ."45=Z{z|%7:45?4 #9UŽA #*.$&%' .";Y%K$;7;'A .$&%'51Z|%'U%':45x6"!;Y%'($& ."%;3$"!ZwŒ(V+:4 ):"4*.z

$"<$Z4$,-%' .Ž5x%75/,5=(7$&% T (75‘6 T *)Z/5}$Z-51 T $&%'5o('p%W;'55=<;5%Y%75("/9($&,4:<6*#(' ."49| ."!;^%$&"!5=;=o

'p%/ );R"!&%/!$Z" ?> <[$&"Z .;R%7:45N51;^%/" ?> <[$"!Z $D?@-* 23V+:!5(75C #%

;'*. #9:%7*#zP T %7,5=(YwŒ('<;+>@A@M+SR/BTo

ŠN6"6*

T

Z-52>@A@,+SR/BAT );%':45/~5=;Y%wŒ( E &wW%':45 [ ."!;^%$&"!5=;|$&"Zd;'55=/;%7$&*.V?$ z-;U9 .Ž5

9AAZy(75=;

T

*#%7;‘fh"/%':!5};Y #qR,!('51;Y5="%75=Zy ."!;^%$&"!5=;iƒo…‘*#%':!

T

9:y"!&%(75,~('%'51ZR ."/%':!5+%7$4*#51;$Ž52

%7:45/;^%$&"!Z4$(7ZZ45ŽA .$&%' ."‰wu%':!5R6;^%;}-%7$ #"!5=ZAz>@@,+SR/BTC );}95"45=(7$*#*.zCŽ5(7z[;'<$&*.*c2GV+:4 ):

."!Z- )$&%'51;%7:!$%< #%< .;{Y(' T ;Y%uƒo ;K #"!$*#*.z2%':45N(75=; T *#%7;/;Y5=5 %7 "-v(' %7:!$% T ;' #"!9 >@A@,+R/BT

);B(75*.5Ž$"%CV+:45" %7:45 T ;'5([$" 5=$;' .*#z‡v!"!Z $ Vx$&*.X†*#5="49&%7: P / #"4 ./ #0= #"!9 %':45 6;^%PV+:! #*.5

<$ #"%7$ #"! #"49<"!;Y%7$"% N P fh;'55|5"!Z[w 51ƒ%' ."

o"

iƒo

- . /#0|H+L21 JI43

>@A@ $&" 5 ŽA #5=VW51Z‹$;C$;' #/,4*. tv5=Z‹Ž5(;Y ." fh"4‡(';';'Ž5=(<,~5($%7(ƒi/&w$;eŽf`}| ‚&„hV

œa`cbAW j

S

noBŠx:!5[`cbe±œb&„Ø ‚§~`}<$&*.9(' #%':4 j

F

n$&"!Z ~$&*.9(' #%':4 j"

n$('5/*.-$&*u;'5=$(7:

:!5 T (7 .;Y%' );{!$;'5=Z " $[%7:4('51;Y:!*)Zo4'" ~&%': $*#9(7 t%7:4<;2$N(7$"!Z- V?$*#Xd .;,~5('wŒ(7/5=Zo[…?%

51$://Ž52&%':!5+%':4(75=;':4*.Z<=$&"/9Z4V+"yV+ #%':C$|9 .Ž5"/,4(7$&4 .*# #%^zorŠx:45­„65ƒ`Њœx%'51:4"4 21 T 5

);<$& ."4*.z T ;'5=ZdwŒ({9*.!$*,-%7 #/ .0=$&%' ."ˆfŒŽ5=(|%':45P('51$&*);7iRj

XF

nV+:!5(75< t%{-%7$ #"!;{Ž5(7z‰9-Z

(75=;T *#%7;=o('p%?<$&"!$95=;${,, T *)$%' ."B$"!Zy/5=:!$"4 .;'<;$('5+,4(7ŽA .Z45=ZRwŒ($ Ž )Z- ."49%':45U9(7 T ,4 ."49

w,Y,!$(Y%7 .*#51;ƒo

7 8

JFCO9/=M KQ6JF

 5N:!$ Ž5[Z-5=;' .9"451Z‡$d:Az!(' )Z$*#9(7 t%7:4 $&*.*.5=Z>@A@,+-/.d ."%'(7AZ T 6 ."498*.-$*x;'5=$(7: #"%' %7:45

P t%7:%':45R #"!"45(;}$*#9(7 t%7:4Nox…}" #";^%$&"!5{&w%7:4 .;U;':!5/52~$&*.*.5=Z>@A@M+SR/BT2-:!$;}5=5"

Z456v!"451Zo >@A@,+SR/BAT <$&"$&951;

E

,!$&($&/5%'5(;<$&"Z†$ v(7;Y%C$%'%'5=y,4%B%'k% T "45%7:45 :!$;B5=5"

Z45=;76(7 #~5=Zo Šx:45[<$&"!$95=y5="%R&w}%':45C%':4(75=;':4*.ZkwŒ(R(75=$*# );Y%' )B,4(74*.5<;R:!$;R~55"ˆ;Y% T Z- .5=Z€o

Šx:!5/$&q- # T " T R5=(D &wrŽ );' t%75=Z["45 .9:A~(;+$&*.*#V‘;x>@A@,+R/BT/%'<<$&X5,4(79(75=;7;?Z-V+"%'

%7:45/51;^%{;'*T %' .";}V+:4 .*.5y5q- t%7 #"49[*.A=$&*r/ #"! #<$4o'p% .;|6( T .$*K ."8,!(7$ƒ%' )65/$&"Z8;'55<;U%'N~5

$4*.5U%7<5|% T "451ZC ."!Z-5=,5="!Z-5="%7*#zo

>@A@,+SRBT|:!$;r-%7$ #"!5=ZRŽ5(7z9A-Z{(75=; T *#%7;r"R9(7$,4:R*.(7 #"49$&"!Zy65=*.$(r,4('4*.5<;o S "4*.z$

wŒ5=Vk&%':!5(€,-%' ./ #01$%' ."|:45 T (7 .;Y%' );€=$&"(75=$:}%7:45=;'5u~ T "!Z!;"|%7:45%'51;^%75=Z| ."!;Y%7$&"65=;=o3>@A@,+R/BT

T

;Y51;x"4/%'51:4"4 21

T

5(+5"!-Z- #"!9yV+:! .:[ .;};Y,~5= tvU%7/%':45|%^zA,~5&w,!('4*#5=No

(14)

"%7$ #"! #"49/:!$(7ZC6"!;^%7(7$ #"%;o

Šx:!5<9A-Z85qA,~5(7 .y5="%7$&*('51; T *#%7;|-%7$ #"!5=Z Azd>@A@M+SR/BT‰;Y5=5 %7‰6"-v!(7 %':$%%':!5B .Z45=$

T

;Y51Z8Az‰95"45%' )y$*#9(7 t%7:4<;U"!;' );^%7 #"49[ ." 5q-,4*#(' ."49P%':45B;'5=$(7:8;',!$65/ #" ,!$(7$*#*.5*r );|9A-Zo

#}VW5=Ž5=(=2%':!5|wh$ƒ%x%7:!$%}>@A@,+R/BT<:!$;x"!/(';';YpŽ5(W,~5($%7(x*#51$Z4;?%7<;Y5=Ž5($&*$Z-Ž$&"%7$95=;=“

0

Šx:45$&*.9(' #%':!’ .;x51$;' #5=(?%'<~5|%

T

"451Zo

0 ."!65}%':45"45= #9:~(7:4A-ZB$;',~5=ƒ%?&w€*.-$&*G;'5=$&(:< );W,!('51;Y5=('Ž5=Z2 #"!('5=/5"%7$*~Z4$&%7$R;^%7( T 6

% T ('51;+$&"[~5 T ;Y51Z[V+:45"[,!$;7;' #"49ywŒ(7 $/"-v!9 T ($%' ."P%'/ #%7;+"45= #9:A(=o

0

Šx:45$&*.9(' #%':! $"C~5{Z-5Ž5*.,~5=ZC"N$/;'$y5|,4*)$%756wŒ(' $;x*#-=$&*€;'5=$&(:C$*#9(7 t%7:4<;o

…U;/5="%7 #"45=Z‡$%R%':45[5"!Z&w 51ƒ%7 #"

2r%7:45[9(755=Z4z Z-51;'5"%RwU>@A@M+SR/BT8ŽA #*.$&%'51;{%7:45

T "4 twŒ(' Z4 .;Y%'(7 # T %' ." &w,$&('%' )6*.5=; #" $C"4"!5=ƒ%75=Zd('5=9 ."fcZ- );^%7(' . T %7 #"8" V+:4 ):‰%7:45/*#-$*

5q-,!$&"!;' ."†,4(',5=(Y%^z .;< T #*#%i6o Šx:45=('5wŒ(75[$"ˆ #"%'5=('51;^%7 #"!9 );7; T 5 );/%7k%':45=(756%' )$*#*.z (<56qA

,~5(7 .y5="%7$&*.*.z‰5=;Y%7$4*# );': $"4&%7:45(;T )B6 .5"%{6"Z- t%7 #"8wŒ(|%':45B; T =65=;7;&wx>@A@,+SR/BAT2G5o9!o.2%7:45

T "4 twŒ(' Z- .;Y%'(7 . T %' ."‡&wU%':45N,!$(Y%7 .*#51;[‚&`­ŽU `„Ø„Kw‘%':!5N"4"!5=ƒ%75=Z†6y,~"!5"%7;=o

Šx:! .;WVW T *)Z/ #"!Z4 .=$%'5‘%':45U #"%'5=('51;^%W&w T ;' #"49y$*.A=$&*~;Y51$&(:RV+ #%':4 ."C>@A@,+-/.|wŒ(V+:! .:<,!$(Y%7 .*#51;

$('5|"4%x%'($&,4,~5=Z[ ."%7/*#-$*/ #"4 .<$4o

. (+I ‘FPO

j n o!…}*.Z4 T ;+$"!Zu$&0 ."!$(' !{o <V+ #%':[%7:45V+ #"!"45(;+$&*.9(' #%':4<;=o(' "ñå±

÷r2

AXE

o

j n %$;7;Y ./ #*. )$&"4k8?$&($&/ .$U$&"!Z : $&*#Z-5*.*3S *.yo4…‡wh$;Y%$"!Zy;Y ./,4*#5x*.-$&*-;'5=$(7:wŒ(r9($&,4:

6*.(7 ."49!o'"„©_J‘&24" T R5=( R #" 8 24,!$951;

"

"A

2

A

o

j"

n{Š351Z8?$&(;Y"/$"!Z R T ;7;'5*.* ' /,!$&9*# )$&0=0o rq-,~5(7 #/5"%$&*.*#z/Z-56%75(7/ #"4 ."49{(759 #"!;wG(75*)$%75=Z

;Y*T %7 #"!;wŒ(9(7$,4:<4 );Y51ƒ%' ."<,!('4*#5=<;o,' "”<B3Y\i[:7b`

W/‚eƒbhf„ü7‚œF

Š„#‚}e’Ž‚„ØY~`}qWY1‚`y|2

o

jE n o€Š|o}8W"!"4*.*#zo{…‘" #/,4(7Ž51Z‰$&"!"45=$*# ."49N;':45=/5wŒ(}%7:4551$,€o95`±D7‚D5`œ~‚&„©

DŽ'‚`y|G‚„JœŽ‚6b2fE iƒ“" FAF 2 AF o

j n

o?Z45  .Ž(7z2 yo5=(Ywh$ #*.*# .52U$&"!Z Š|o

:4 .56qo ?

T

"!Z- ."49 %7:458,-%' .

T w6";^%7(7$ #"%

,-%7 #/ .0=$%7 #"C,!('4*#5=<;o' "ñå:å2"

T

~5( ""F #" ~8

2 lAo

j&n{Š$;';';} ./ t%7(' . T o8W:$&($ƒ%75(7 #0= #"!9<%':45/;',!$5&w?6*. 1 T 51;} ."d($&"Z- 9($&,!:!; T ;' ."4969

V+ t%7:C%7:45V+ ."4"45(; o' "!ˆ3ƒ2

FFA

o

jl n{Š$;';'; } ./ t%7(' . T $&"!Z R T ;7;Y5=*#*/' /,!$9*. .$00oŠVx$&(Z4;3$"R$&"$&*.zA;' );3w*.A=$&*A,4%' .y .0=$&%' ."

$&*.9(7 #%':4<;=o('"ñå:

÷K2

4o

j&n{Š$;';'; U #/ #%'(7 # T $&"Z R T ;7;Y5=*#*'/,!$&9*# )$&0=0!o V+ #%':<%7:45‘V+ ."4"45=(7;uwŒ(9(7$,4:/4 );Y51ƒ%' ."3o

' "„å±"Ë$#32A,!$&95=; F XF 2 !o

j n R‘$&,4:$&%* U(7"45<$&"!Z' #"-)($&$#}$!oRŠK$& T ;'5=$(7:8wŒ(|9($&,4: 6*#(' ."49!2~%'p*.(7 #"49;U$"!Z

;Y5%+%Y6*.(7 ."49;=o'"$'ƒo#{o S ;Y<$" o;7;2 o%$(Y%75*.*#<$"!Z 8Uo R+ T $& .(7*251Z- #%'(;=2*ñ6` ‚V

b#5`œÖ`y|Š

3 ‚fŠ‚<

Žf

:7‚&„‚6b­+‚'‚e {W’/ŠYK`yqW­1‚`y|2,$&951;

ll+ A o,(|*

T

VW5=(x…+=$Z-5=/ . :T

!*# );Y:!5(;2 4o

(15)

#"49R; T ,~5(7 .(%7;Y . T *.$&%'5=Z<$"4"451$&*. #"49oD5`œ~‚„<­©WU 5-` ‚`y|~‚&„FWbAU¡œ|Š2 AF “ l 2

AF o

j n :

:4 .*# .,4,~5 |$*# ."4 .5(U$"!Z' #"-)($&4#U$&o7#‘zA4(7 .ZN5=Ž*

T

%7 #"!$&(7zC$*#9(7 t%7:4<;xwŒ(U9($&,4:‰*#

(7 #"49oD5`œ~‚„w‘©WœG‚`Мh‚&„åK~`}qWY1‚`y|!2 " fE iƒ“" l "A l-2 A o

j n '4oD#}*.*.$"!Zou…+Z4$,-%7$&%' ."[ #"["!$%

T

($&*€$&"Z[$(Y%7 tv~6 )$&*;Yz-;Y%'5=/;=2 l o

j

"

n o (| #(7,!$&%'(7 .XG2 8UoRo 5*)$%'%=2!$"!Z=%ko: o 51:4 o S ,-%' ./ #01$%7 #"CAzP;' # T *)$%'51ZC$"4"451$&*. #"49o

<Ž|Š<±2

AXF

“l F 2

" o

j

*E

n{…{o(U*.5"€oW… 95="456%7 .$*#9(7 t%7:4 wŒ(xwŒ(751 T 5="!6z[$;7;Y .9"!y5="%=oŠ5=:4"! .=$&*(75,~('%=2 !}"4 #Ž5('

;Y #%'5= t% %$$;Y%'(7 .:%12

A

o

j

n{…{o(U;Y%'5=(=28Uo u$&" #}51;Y5=*c2r$&"Z …o(U*.5"€o *.ŽA #"!9NwŒ('51 T 5"!zd$;7;' #9"4/5"%,4('4*.5<;

Ž )$R%'(755pZ-516y,~;' #%' ."€orŠ351:4"4 )$* R+5,~('%



FDA

2 !‘"4 .Ž5=(7;' #%'5 #%7%$$;^%7(' ):%=2

o

j &n o%N ."%'"€2% o"':4"!;Y%'"€2r…{o : :4 #*. .,!;2$"!Z : o 3$ #(Zo=%N #"! #/ .0 ."4986" 5! )ƒ%1“y$N:45 T (7 .;Y

%' )('5=,!$& .(B/56%7:4-ZˆwŒ(C6";^%7(7$ #"%P;7$%' );Ywh$ƒ%7 #"‹$&"!Zˆ;7:45=Z

T

*# ."49 ,!('4*#5=<;o0Jƒ`yOŽh‚„

œ!`Єa„{eŽf2 !“ XF 2 o

j l n8W(7$ #9&%N(795="!;^%75(7"€o U );^%7(' .

T

%75=ZN6*#(7$&%' ."B"45= #9:A(':4A-ZP;'5=$(7:3o}' " U$ ŽA )Z

o':!"-

;Y" $&"!Z %N ):!$&5=*|…o+Š3(7 .XG2U5=Z- #%'(7;=2ˆr„#5FœÄ&„Øœ‚< G‚`yÖW‚œa„a`oU

<<

#J ˆ­";mW}~„Ø*W‘Ž!` ‚`y| KbA‚„a„üŠe

§&2}Ž*T /5

!2x,!$&95=;

"" "

l-o…‘/5(7 .=$&"

%$%7:45<$%7 .=$&* - #5%^z2

A

!o

j &n W5=(Y%7(7$"!Z ‘5=Ž5 T $&"Z  .*#*.5=;xŠ('~56%Y%7"4 o!}"454 #!*# .&%7:1 T 5|Z-5('51:45(:45‘*.-$&*.5, T (

*3,-%7 #/ );'$&%' ."N64 ."!$%7 .('5o('"ñJ6`Њ_ eJ­H# §2

FF"

o

j

n Uo 5*.<$&"€2,#o 35Ž51;_1 T 52$"!Z RoM%N #%7:!5*.*co}… "45=V /5%':4-ZwŒ(U;'*.ŽA #"49<:$&(Z;'$&%' );^v$&

4 #*. #%^zB,4(74*.5<;=o'"ñå±F24,!$&95=; EAEAF EE 42 o

jXF n{…{o…{oŠ(7"€o *#!$&*?,-%7 #/ .0=$&%' ."$;R$d6R4 ."!$%7 #" &w‘9*#!$&*x$&"!Z *#-$*?;'5=$(7:3o '"

å:û„©WU 5-`Њ fqW 5-„#‚&`}| ­J~‚„U`}|‚„$<„5-`}|D"Š5œfŠB‚f ûfXW­|

: §„æƒ2!,$&951; D F 42 l " o

j n8W:4(' );Y%';

T

Z-

T

(' );<$&"!Z uZ-Vx$&(Z†Š;7$&"49o

*.ŽA #"49 %7:45(7$Z- .d*. #"!X wŒ(751

T

5"6z$;';' #9"-

y5="%x,!('4*#5=

T

;' #"!9<9

T

)Z-5=ZC*.A=$&*€;'5=$(7:€o'"‚&`É UWU`5W #5FŠ<mU’÷±œ{§ V

W‘Ž!` !b-‚œh[‚< „©FŽŠ ‚`y|ÄU¡`Ð*W’|­ `­ 2 A !o

Références

Documents relatifs

In the extended framework, beliefs and intentions are organized in a so-called belief-intention database: a belief is a propositional formula indexed by time points and an intention

If C = mod(H) is the category of finite-dimensional representations of a finite-dimensional Hopf algebra H, then the Brauer-Picard group is known as the strong Brauer of H [8], which

Solving the graph edit distance problem with variable partitioning local search.. Mostafa Darwiche, Donatello Conte, Romain Raveaux,

2.3 Conflict Analysis and Implication Graph Now, we introduce a fundamental data structure, called implication graph, used by complete CDCL solvers (Con- flict Driven Clause

This model fits well for LS methods such as hill climbing, tabu search, iterated local search, variable neighborhood search. For large scale instances, intensive computation

Fast electrophoresis in conventional capillaries by employing a rapid injection device and contactless conductivity detection.. Received: 26 October 2004 / Revised: 21 December 2004

Jr [19] hybridized BA using different DE strat- egies and applied them as a local search heuristic for improving the current best solution and directing the swarm towards the

In 2007, Wang [29] proposed a hybrid algorithm combining with chaotic discrete Hopfield neural network and genetic particle swarm optimization, while in 2011, Wang [30]