• Aucun résultat trouvé

Weak Lumpability of Finite Markov Chains and Positive Invariance of Cones

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Weak Lumpability of Finite Markov Chains and Positive Invariance of Cones"

Copied!
20
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00073889

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073889

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Weak Lumpability of Finite Markov Chains and Positive Invariance of Cones

James Ledoux

To cite this version:

James Ledoux. Weak Lumpability of Finite Markov Chains and Positive Invariance of Cones. [Re- search Report] RR-2801, INRIA. 1996. �inria-00073889�

(2)

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Weak lumpability of finite Markov chains and positive invariance of cones

James Ledoux

N˚ 2801

Fevrier 1996

PROGRAMME 1

(3)
(4)

3%#45+'678'&2+,

9:<;>=@?AB=DCFEHGJIK

L MONQPRMTSVUWUWXY&Z\[6M]_^D`baOX5]a_cDMOXedfHS MS gbgihXgbXd5jlkmS dOXedonlXnlNRpDprqXXdjmMDqXd_X5S clsXard_tldOa5hXeUWXdnl`bdOaOM_`bkDcrqXd

LJMONuXa6vwNDnlXg

x6SVfDfHNRMOa6nlXM_X5]_^DXMT]_^DXypz|{R}Q~DY*Z€<XlMO`bXMY‚Q‚RƒZYƒfHS PRXd

„2…$†e‡5ˆ ‰mŠ ‡R‹HŒX6]NRpDdO`nlXMBŽBX5S gbcDUWfHSVkD`bgb`a‘tN ’PQXp<XMTSVgm“HpD`baOXr^DNRUWNRPQXpDXeNQcDd$vSVMOQN 2]_^HS `bpDd0XQNRgl`bpDP`bp”n@`d]MOXeaOX

aO`bU•XQjmaO^HSVao`bdŽr^DXpS•gbcDUWfmX5nvSVMORN –]_^HSV`bp—Žr`baO^MOXd_fHX5]˜a2aON+S•fHSVMOa_`a_`bNQpNV’4a_^DX3`bpD`ba_`™SVgšd_aTS a_X2dOfHSR]X2`bdS gbdONwS

^DNRUWNQPRXpDXNRcDdvS M_QN o]_^HSV`bpš›ŒXJdO^DN ŽaO^mS ašŽBX5SV6gbcDUWfmS kD`bgb`baœt$`bdX5RcD`bQS gbXplaaONra_^DX$XsD`bdOa_XpH]XBN ’HSrnlX5]˜NQUWfmNQdS kDgbX

fmNQgbtl^DX5nlMS gž]˜NQpDXŽr^<`™]_^`bdrfmNQd_`a_`bQXgbtW`bplQS M_`S pla1klt•aO^DXa_MTSVpDdO`baO`bNRpfDMONRkHS k<`gb`baœt2U+SVaOM_`Ÿs2N ’$a_^DX3NRMO`bPQ`bpHSVg ]_^HSV`bpš›B¡œa

S gbgbN ŽrdBcDd5j<`pScDp<`Ÿ“mX5nwŽrSt|jRaONWnlXeMO`bQXp<XŽ¢MOXd_cDgbaOd&NQpwgbcDUWfHSVkD`bgb`aœt£N ’$MOX5n@cH]`bkDgbX3vSVMOQN W]_^HSV`bpDdoSVpHn•aON2NQk<aTS `bp

dOfmX5]a_MTSVgžf<MONQfmXM_aO`bXdoSVdOd_N@]˜`™SVaOX5n–Žr`a_^wgc<UWfHSVkD`bg`¤aœt|›

¥•¦l§¨O©ªmˆQ«J† ‹¬vSVMOQN w]_^HS `bpšjD­laS a_Xd6S PRPQMOXeP|S a_`bNQpšjlŒX5SV2gbcDUWfHSVkD`bgb`aœtRj®LFNRgtl^DXnlMTSVgž]NRpDXQjHLFNRdO`baO`bQX&`bp|QSVMO`S pm]XQ›

¯°2±

²‘³œ´µ

±

² ¶$·b³œ¸i¹º

»_¼½ž¾¿0À®ÁmÂÃrÄ ÅQÆÇ ÈJÉÈO˜ŠÊÌ˟ȜÅrÍ5ÎÏÐÍ0ÑšÈœÒ ÒQÈ_Æ ÁmÈ_Ç ÈOÓRÀ5Ô<ÕbÃ6ÂËÌÊ ÊŸÈOÇ ÖÅQÓ ×JØ_Å Ò ËŸÙeÕÚ‘ÈœÒ Ò ÈOƜÛÜݤÚßÞ®ÀØ_ËÌڑËÌÆà ÜÝÌÚOÞ

(5)

3,0B%” . ' +,

¦D†¦‹*NQcDdpDNRcDd6`bplaDqXeMOXd_dONQp<d+hS2gS2f<MONQf<MO`5qXaDqX2nÌS PRMDqXPlS a_`NRp•’iS `bkDgbX3nlX2]_^HSbpDXedonlX2vS M_QN •“HpD`bXdqXRNQgbcHSVp|a

Xep—a_XUWfDd6n@`d]MOXea5jš]Xd_aWhSWnl`bMOX2RcHS pmnwcDpDX3]_^HSbpDX”n@X3vS M_QN jHSVPQMDqXP$qXXdOXegNRp—c<pDXfHSVMOaO`ba_`NRp—nlXgXd_fHSQ]X2n_qXaS a

`bpD`ba_`™SVgœjQXd_a6Xpm]NQM_X3UwS MORN l`XepDpDX6^<NQUWNRPHhXp<XQ›*NQcDd&UWNRp|a_MONRpDd4RcDX]XaOa_X3f<MONQf<MO`5qXaDqX£XdOaqX5RcD`bQS gbXplaOXWhSgXsD`d_aOXpm]X

nc<p–]NQpDXfHNRgbt|^rqX5nlMO`RcDX3nBqX5]NQU•fHNRdTSVkDgbX RcD`FXdOa`bplQS M_`™SVpla1fHSVM6gSU+SVaOM_`™]˜X n@XdfDMONRkHS kD`bgb`baDqXd6n@XaOMS pDd_`a_`bNQp—nlX£g™S

]_^HSbpDX6NRMO`bPQ`bpHSVgXR› BXgSpDNRcDd1fmXM_UWXaj|ncDp<X6U+SVpD`ihXMOXrc<pD`¤’VqXXQjlnlXnBqXM_`RXMrnlX6pDNRcDQXS clsWMDqXdOcDgbaS aOdBdOc<Mrg!ÌSVPQMDqXeP|S a_`bNQp

n@X ]_^HSbpDXdon@X vS MORN 2MDqX5n@cH]aO`bkDgbXd&XaonNRkDaOXepD`bM6nlXdrfDM_NQfDM_`5qXeaDqXd&dOfmX5]aOMS gbXdS d_dOND]`qXXdWhS£gSVPQMDqXP|SVaO`bNQpš›

" ªm‡ †¨Š#¦—‹$B^HSbpDXnlX3vSVMOQN jR[6PRMDqXPlS aO`bNRp–nOqXeaTS a_d5j%&NQpDXfmNQgbtl^4qX5nlM_`™RcDXRjl¡œp|QSVMO`S pm]XfHNRdO`baO`bQX

(6)

; <

3$#$W. +'rB5

=XeacDd3]NRpDdO`nlXeM”Sw^<NQUWNRPQXp<XNQcDdvS M_QN —]_^HSV`bp?> jF`bp n@`d]MOXeaOXwNQM]NRp|a_`bp|c<NQcDda_`bUWXQjmNQp¬S “Hp<`a_X2dOaS aOX•dOfHSR]XQj

nlXp<NQaOXnklt@BjmŽr^D`]_^`bdoSVdOdOc<UWX5n•aON•kHXA@CBED|YGFIH4H4HJFKMLl›=XaONPBQDR*STYITFIH4H4H"FRASUVT,LkHX3S”“DsDX5nwfHSVMOa_`a_`bNQpwN ’

@ `p?UXWPK7]gS d_dOXd›šŒX3SVdOd_N@]˜`™SVaOX2Žr`baO^aO^<X2PQ`bQXp]_^HS `bpY>7aO^<XWS PQPRMOXPlS a_X5n—]_^HSV`bp%ZWj N QXMaO^<X2dOaTSVaOX2d_fHSQ]X

@MBVDlYF4HIH4HFJUELlj|nlX˜“HpDX5nwklt\[

Z7]^B`_bac >A]edfRAS_T5F’àNRM4SVpltg5›

ŒX2S MOX2`bplaOXeMOXd_aOX5n `paO^<XW`bpD`baO`S gJnl`bdOa_MO`bkDcDa_`NRpDdNV’h>7Žr^D`]_^—PR`RX”SVp SVPQPRMOXPlS aOXn^DNQU•NQPQXepDXNQc<d vS MORN ]O^mS `bp

ZW›B¡‘’dOcH]_^¢Snl`bdOa_MO`bkDcDa_`NRpXsD`bdOa_d5jBŽ1XdTSt>aO^HSVaWa_^DXw’iSVUW`bgbt—NV’£vS MORN ]O^mS `bpDd2dO^mS MO`bpDP aO^DXdTSVUWXwaOMS pDd_`baO`bNQp

fDM_NQkHSVkD`bg`baœtUwS a_MO`¤s?Sàa5›fš›T*`bdij40k l-G5›nmr^DX’àNRMOU•XMŽ1NRMONQpgbcDUWfmS kD`bgb`baœtWŽrS d3]NRpH]XM_pDX5n Žr`baO^a_^DX

.&0 oM •dO`ba_cHS a_`NRpšjJaO^mS a2`bd5jJŽr^DXep8S plt`bpD`baO`S grnl`bdOa_MO`bkDcDa_`bNQp>gbX5SQnld2a_N¬S pS PRPQM_XP|SVaOX5n ^DNRUWNQPRXpDXNRcDd

vSVMOQN 2]_^HS `bpš›R¡œaB^HS drkmXXp]_^HS MSQ]a_XMO`pXn•’àNQM0`M_MOX5n@cH]`bkDgbXvS M_QN 2]O^mS `bpDdB`pkq&XUWXplt2S pHn•­lpDXgbgnSTY‚rQƒGT1SVpHn£’àNRM

S]gSVdOdBN ’MOX5nlcm]`bkDgbXo]_^HS `bpDd0`p2[&k n@XgsßvwNRpDX`bU S pHn= XtldO`bXtXM$STY‚Q}'uvT›4mr^DX&Ž1XS gc<UWfHSVkD`bg`baœt&fDMONRkDgbXU ^HS d$kmXXp

SQn<nlMOXd_dOX5n`bp%q&XU•Xplt+SVpHn­lpDXeggeSY5‚rRƒTejD[6knlXgsOvwNQp<X`bU S pHnY= XtldO`bXtXMSY5‚Q}R{TejHxrc<kD`bpDNWS pHn­lXMO`]NRgSkSTY‚Q‚<YIT

’àNRMr`M_MOX5n@cH]`bkDgbX”vS MORN +]_^HSV`p<d5›7w*pHnlXMSVp–SRnDnl`baO`bNRpHS gš]NRpHnl`baO`bNRpšjDa_^DXSà^<NQUWNRPQXp<XNQcDdTrvS M_QN l`S pwfDM_NQfmXMOaœt•’àNRM

aO^<XoS PRPQM_XP|SVaOX5n•]O^mS `bpZ ^HSVd1M_X5]Xpla_gt•kHXeXpwfDMON RX5n2`bpWLFXpDPbSTY‚Q‚xGTJaON£kHXX5RcD`bQS gbXpla$a_NMOXQc<`M_X$Z aON£dTS a_`bdœ’àtl`bpDP

aO^<X B^HSVfDU+SVps"q6NRgbU2NQPQN M_N 3XQcmS aO`bNRpDdS pHnwa_^DXpaO^DX£dOXaNV’1S gbgš`bpD`baO`SVgžnl`bdOa_MO`bkDcDa_`bNQpDd&gXSQnl`bpDP2a_N+S pS PQPRMOXPlS a_X5n

vSVMOQN W]_^HSV`bpW`bd1X˜s@f<g`]`ba_gt2PR`bQXpš›R[6drd_^DN Žrpw`bp=XnlNQclswXa6S gœ›ySTY‚Q‚0uTjRŽ1XS WgbcDU•fHS k<`gb`¤aœtN ’$S kDd_NQMOk<`p<P”vSVMORN 

]_^HS `bpDdŽr`baO^S pNQpDgbtwNQpDX`bMOM_X5nlcH]`bkDgbX2a_MTS p<dO`bXpladOaTSVaOXW]gSVdOd5j `d]gbNRdOXgbtM_XgS aOXnŽr`baO^aO^<X3fDM_Xl`bNQcDdŽBNQMOldcDd_`p<P

SM_XdOXeaOaO`bpDP ’àM_NQU S kDd_NQM_kD`bpDP¬d_aTS a_XdwNQpa_^DXa_MTS p<dO`bXplawNQpDXdSR]]NQMnl`bpDP¬a_NaO^DXRcHS d_`sid_aTS a_`bNQpHSVMOt n@`d_aOM_`k<cDaO`bNQpF›

[6PRPQM_XP|SVaO`bNQpwN ’1SVp|t•“Hp<`a_X3]NRp|a_`bp|c<NQcDd&aO`bUWXvS M_QN +]_^HSV`bp—]S pkHXM_XfDgSQ]˜X5n`bpa_^DX3nl`bd]MOXa_X2aO`bUWX]NQpla_XsDa/S‘dOXX

=XnlNQclsYSY5‚R‚xTzT$S pmnjlaO^DXeMOX’àNRMOXQj<Žr`bgg<pDNQaBkHXnl`bd]cDdOd_X5n•`bpWaO^<X6dOXQc<Xgœ›l¡‘’žaO^<Xod_aTSVaOX6d_fHSQ]˜X9@ `bd4]NRcDplaTSVkDgbt3`bpl“Hp<`a_X

ŽBXoM_X’àXM&aON{BS gbgšS pmn|BXNSY5‚R‚:TBS pmn= X5nlNRcls%SY5‚Q‚GxTe›

[¬gS M_PQX$S U•NQcDplaDNV’DŽ1NRMO6NRpgc<UWfHSVkD`bg`baœt1vS MORN 6]_^HS `bpDdF`dš]˜NQpH]XeMOpDX5n£`bpfDMON l`bpDPBaO^DX$c<pD`]`baœt6N ’Da_^DX$aOMS pDd_`baO`bNQp

fDM_NQkHSVkD`bg`baœt2UwS aOM_`¤s”NV’ a_^DX3vSVMORN |`SVp+S PRPQM_XP|SVaOX5nw]_^HS `bpDd›mr^DXgb`bpDX5SVMrdOtldOa_XU S fDf<MON|SR]_^šjD`bpD`baO`SVg`pXn2kltW[&k nlXegs

vwNRpDX`bU SVpHn%= XtldO`bXtXMbSTY5‚R}Q{GToSVpHn’àcDgbgbtnlXRXgbNQfmX5n`bp x*cDkD`bpDNS pHn­lXM_`]NQgS}STY‚Q‚DY4Tja_N]NQU•fDcDaOXaO^<X2dOXaN ’

S gbgF`p<`a_`S gnl`bdOaOM_`bkDcDaO`bNRpDd6gbX5SRnl`bpDP2aONwS pS PRPQMOXeP|S a_X5nvSVMORN +]_^HS `bp`bd6]Xep|a_XMOXnNQpa_^D`bd6fDM_NQfmXMOaœtl›7~*N Ž1XRXM5jma_^D`bd

cDpD`]`baœtfDMONRfHXeMOaœt¬UwStpDNRa3^DNRgn’àNQM3SPQXepDXMTSVgB“HpD`baOXwvS M_QN ]_^HS `bpš›nmr^DXWf<cDMOfmNQd_X+NV’6aO^D`bdfHS fmXM2`bda_N—fDgSR]X

XU•fD^HS d_`bd$NQp•PQXNRUWXa_MO`]S g<fDMONRfHXM_aO`bXd6SVdOdOND]`SVaOX5n•Žr`baO^2a_^DXŽ1X5SV3gbcDU•fHS k<`gb`baœt]NQpmnl`baO`bNQp2Žr^DXepWŽBXoS M_X6`bplaOXM_XdOa_X5n

`bpS PQPRMOXPlS a_X5nvSVMOQN W]_^HSV`bpDd6d_^HS M_`p<P2aO^DXdS U•Xoa›fš›U—›R¡œp+fmS MOa_`]cDgS MjD`ba6]S pkHXc<dOX5nwa_N2PQ`bQXSVpcDpD`¤“HX5n•l`bXŽ

N ’6a_^DXwfDMOXe|`bNRcDd3ŽBNQM_ldWS pHna_N nlXeMO`bQXwpDXŽyMOXd_cDgbaOd’àNRM3PRXpDXMS gB“HpD`ba_X–vS MORN  ]_^HSV`bpDd5›F[r’àa_XM2MOXe|`bXŽr`bpDPdONRUWX

fDM_Xgb`U•`bpHS M_`XedšNQpfmNQgbtl^DX5nlMS g]NQpDXed5jRŽ1X6SVpHS gbtpXB`pW­@X5]aO`bNRpW{Dje’àNQMBS6PRXpDXMS g<“HpD`baOX6vS MORN 3]_^HS `bpŽr`baO^2aOMS pDd_`baO`bNQp

fDM_NQkHSVkD`bg`baœt•U+S a_MO`¤s2j<aO^DXdOXa£N ’1S gbgš`bpD`ba_`™SVgžnl`bd_aOMO`bkDc<aO`bNQpDd&Žr^D`]_^PQ`bQXS PQPRMOXPlS a_X5nvSVMOQN ]_^HSV`p<d6dO^mS MO`bpDPwa_^DX

dTSVUWXra›fF›U›5LFNQ`bplaO`bpDP£NQcDa$a_^DX6M_XgS a_`NRp2kHXeaœŽ1XXep+gbcDU•fHS k<`gb`¤aœt SVpHnfmNQdO`ba_`RXr`bp|QSVMO`S pm]XrN ’ž]NRpDXdB`bpW­lX5]a_`NRp:<jQŽBX

dO^<N ŽaO^HSVa1a_^D`bdrdOXar`bdBpDNQp•XUWf<aœt3`¤’šaO^<XMOXX˜s@`bd_aOd6S ’iS U•`gbtN ’!U fmNQgbtl^DX5nlMS g]NQpDXed6Žr^D`]_^+SVMOX€_`bp|QSVMO`S plazoc<pHnlXM

dOc<ksiUwS a_MO`]XdBN ’JU+S a_MO`¤s*2›mr^<`dBMOXedOcDgba6S gbgbN Žrd$cDdra_N3d_aTSVaOX`bp+­lX5]˜aO`bNQpkuaO^HSVa1`¤’ža_^DXfHS M_aO`baO`bNRpAN `bd4S£MOX˜“HpDXU•Xpla

N ’$a_^DXfHSVMOaO`ba_`NRpwN ’$aO^DX£dOaTSVaOXdOfHSR]X@¬`bpHn@cH]X5nwkltwaO^<XcDdOcmS g€]NQU•U2cDpD`]SVaO`bNQpX5RcD`bQSVgXepH]XM_XgS aO`bNRpšjDa_^DXpŽBX

NQk<aTS `bpS pXsDfDgb`]`ba6’‘NQMOU2c<g™S£’‘NQMaO^DX2a_MTSVpDdO`baO`bNRp—fDM_NQkHSVkD`bgb`aœt•U+SVaOMO`¤sN ’6S pltkZwjŽr^D`]_^ nlXefHXpmnld3NRpDgbtNQp}N SVpHn

2›lLJMOXe|`bNRcDdrŽ1NRMOldr]S p•kHXl`bXŽ1XnWS drnl`bMOX]a6S fDf<g`]SVaO`bNQp<d$N ’JaO^D`bdBMOXd_cDgba5›mr^DM_NQcDPR^DNQcDar­lX5]˜aO`bNQpY:SVpHnW­lX]aO`bNQpkumj

QS M_`bNQcDdfDM_NQfmXMOa_`Xed3M_XfHNRMOa_X5n `p?=XnlNQcls‚STY‚Q‚G:Tj [6knlXgsßv–NQpDX`bU S pHn?= XtldO`bXtXMSY5‚R}0uvTSVpHnLFXpDP?SY5‚Q‚GxTS M_X

XsDaOXepHnlX5nwa_N2PQXp<XMTSVg“HpD`ba_X vS MORN +]_^HSV`p<d4SVpHn•pDXŽ dOfmX5]aOMS gJMOXedOcDgbaOdSVMOXS gbdON2nlXM_`bQX5n›

ƒ $B5

mr^DX$d_XašNV’HS gbg fDMONRkHS k<`gb`baœtrnl`bdOaOM_`bkDcDaO`bNRpDdšNRp9@•Žr`bgbg kHX$nlXepDNQa_X5nkltl„W›5mr^DXJd_cDfDfmNQMOa!… N ’HSBfDM_NQkHSVkD`bg`baœt6nl`bd_aOMO`bkDc<aO`bNQp

†

`bdonlX“mpDX5nS d6a_^DXPQMOXS aOXedOadOcDk<dOXaNV’j@S fHSVMOa*’àMONRU a_^DX”n@`d_aOM_`k<cDaO`bNQpw`bdpeXMONmj`œ›XR›

†

S‡ˆT‰B¢~’àNRMoSVgg^‡ed‹ŠŒ…

S pmn

†

S‡6T$ŽB ~£’àNQM‰‡^d%…w›

{$t]NQplQXep|a_`bNQpšjeQX5]a_NQM_d1S M_X$MON ށRX5]aONRMOd› BNQgbcDU•poRX5]a_NQMOd$SVMOXB`pmnl`]S a_X5nkltUWX5SVpDdN ’Ha_^DXBaOMTSVpDdOfmNQd_XrNQfmXMTSVaONRM

SJHT81›mr^<XQX5]˜aONQMŽr`baO^S gbg`baOdo]˜NQUWfmNQp<XplaOd6XQcmS gša_N—Y‘SàMOXedOfš›~T*`bdonlXp<NQaOXnU•XMOXgbt•k|tYS‘MOXd_fš›š~Te›mr^DX£QX5]a_NQM

(7)

nlXepDNQa_XdraO^DX3‡aO^wQX]aONRMrN ’ža_^DX]S p<NQpD`]SVgkHS d_`drNV’š¡x 2›QŒXnlXp<NQaOXkltaO^<Xo`nlXep|a_`baœt2U+S a_MO`¤sWS pHn k|tWn@`™SVPSGT

S‘klt nl`SVPS

TzTa_^DXkSàkDgbND]_Tnl`S PRNQpHSVgžUwS a_MO`¤sŽr`a_^PQXp<XMO`]Wn@`™SVPQNRpHS geSàk<gND]_TXplaOM_tS‡6T‘Sàa_^DX2U+SVaOMO`¤s

Tja_^DX

n@`U•XpDd_`NRpDdBkHX`bpDP2nlX“mpDX5nwkltWa_^DX3]NRplaOXsDa5›

mr^DXw]S Mnl`bpHS gb`baœtNV’6aO^DXw]gS dOdRAS_T-`bd3nlXpDNRaOX5n kltnS_T2›FŒXWS d_dOcDU•X2aO^DX•dOaS aOXed2N ’@ NQMTn@XMOX5n d_cH]_^¬aO^mS a

R*S_T!B DnSTY4TnS_ Y4T8YGFIH4H4H"FnSTYITnS_T,L’àNQMY! _" U S‘Žr`a_^#nSi~TB~D›T

<NQM3SVpltdOcDk<dOXaR-N ’@ESàŽr^DNRdOXW]SVMTnl`bpHSVgb`aœt`d$\TS pHn

† d „ja_^DXWM_XdOa_MO`]a_`NRpN ’

†

a_N%R2j`œ›XQ›a_^DX2QX]aONRM

S†

S‡ˆT5F‡edCR3Tjm`bdonlXepDNQa_X5nklt

†&%

NRM'

%!†

›)(&paO^DXNQa_^DXM^HSVpHnjS2RX5]aONRM+*¬NRp,Ì~FY-/.1032541]SVpkmX3l`bXŽBX5n—SVd6a_^DX

RX5]a_NQM$NRp#,~yF5Y6-

nlX“mpDX5nklt\[7,5'+8"9

2

*-S‡ˆTjB ~`¤’ ‡;:d%RAS_TJS pHn<,5'=8>9

2

*-S‡6TB?*^S‡@nSTY4TA#BnS_YITzT$`¤’ ‡ dfR*S_Te›

¡‘’DC`bdoSdOc<kDdOXaNV’j„ S‘MOXd_fš›NV’ ,Ì~yF5Y6-.A0/254T*aO^DXpE'

2

C?SàM_XdOfš›"' 8"9

2

C\T6nlXp<NQaOXedoa_^DXd_XaAD

† %

0/254 : †

dFCnL$GH,~yF5Y6-.10/254

S‘MOXd_fš›nD' 8>9

2

*:$*Md<C LIG>¡x 3›T

¡‘’!RJG @>S pHn

† %

BŽ ~Dj

† %

`dBaO^<XoRX5]a_NQMrN ’^„ n@X“HpDX5n•klt

† % S‡ˆT!B

†

S‡ˆTK:DLNM@O

% †

S/PTB`¤’ ‡^dYR S pmnWkltW~£`¤’

‡;:dfR ›

Q R

#0 5+£#B5, '&2wo, ”+.TS €£ 5

UWVKX YFZD[]\_^`+Z_acb]d]\"e]f7g&a+hZ_[]\Z&ijKkNl

mr^<XkHS d_`]nlX“Hp<`a_`bNQpDd2NRpaO^DX]NQpDXed+S M_XMOXe|`bXŽBX5n ’àMONRU {0XM_U+S pSVpHn>LJgbXUWU•NQpDdSY5‚GrQ‚Te›!mr^DM_NQcDPR^DNQc<a2aO^D`bd

d_cDkDd_X5]aO`bNRpC nlXp<NQaOXed3S•dOcDkDd_XaNV’4¡Ìx

.

›š<NQMS plt#CJjš­lfHSVp\SmC\T SàMOXedOfš›F[‰t!SBC TzT6M_X’àXM_d3a_NwaO^DX2gb`bpDX5SVM3SàM_XdOfF›žSnWpDXIT

^lcDgbgBN ’ICž›^mr^DX•dOXa BNQpDX'SmC\T2nlXpDNRaOXd2a_^DX]NQpD`]SVgr^lcDgbg1NV’ R aO^mS a2`bd3a_^DXWd_XaWNV’oS gbg0“HpD`baOXwpDNRpDpDXPlS aO`bRXWgb`bpDX5S M

]˜NQU2kD`bpHSVaO`bNQpDdJNV’žaO^<XXgbXUWXep|a_d1NV’oCJ›mr^DXXgbXU•XplaOdBN ’&C—S M_X ]eS gbgbX5n2a_^DXPQXepDXMTSVaONRMOd6NV’ BNRpDX0SmC\T›l¡‘’ BNRpDX0SmC\T!BC

a_^DXppC+`bdr]S gbgbX5n•S)0 7e› BNQpl2SmC\T$`bdBaO^DX&dOXarNV’žS gbg<“HpD`baOX]NQplQX˜sWg`bpDXS M1]NRU2kD`bpHS a_`bNQpDdJN ’ša_^DX6XegXeUWXplaOdBN ’>CJ›mr^DX

1'5 .56' N ’ Sd_cDkDd_Xa]Cw`bd6nlX“Hp<X5nwkltWnl`bUSBC TB8nl`bU [Ot!SmC\T›mr^DX`bplaOXM_`bNQMrN ’&CMOXeg™SVaO`bQX&aON2a_^DXSnWpDX&dOfHSR]X+q

`bd6nlXepDNQa_X5nwklt2`bp|asr!SBC Te›

t•¦vuDw&xà‡xàªywz{/|~} -'4+J1'&J'-)' 7"C%&€

. . ˆ+-.I' Gˆ0 ., ‰O.54.J" ! 70&+-'*,o' 70 G.‰ 7‚ -'6,.ƒ

3„6„CkBVD†…fd‡€

.

:ˆ…Љ ~fLi^+-&J! d#€

.‹7Œ

„>2 -),+%)0 23./b)54.I1)0 (06., ,.I]€

. „

ŒX&MOX5]eS gbgša_^HS a6SkmNQcDpmnlX5n•dONRgc<aO`bNQp•dOXa&N ’ Sd_tldOaOXeU N ’žgb`bpDX5SVM1`bpDXQcmS gb`baO`bXdr`bd4]eS gbgbX5nwS3048,-*N ’J¡x . ›

[ ]NQplQX˜s–]NRpDX+C`bd‰0 "1`¤’oCˆŽ}SK;C\TjBED ~LS pHn}.I061&`¤’ `bplac‘GSmC\T ŽB~’<› rNRaOXaO^mS aoS2]˜NQplQXswdOcDk<dOXaIC`bd

d_cH]_^aO^mS ar`bpla

0”4

SmC\T$ŽB’D›DF`bpHS gbgbtljQS2]gbNQd_X5njDfmNQ`bplaOXnjldONRg`n•]NQplQX˜s–]NRpDX`bd4]eS gbgbX5nwSA7&J,-&1]˜NQpDXQ›

[&p`4&50mNV’*S•fmNQ`bplaOX5nfmNQgbtl^DX5nlMS g1]˜NQpDXˆC `dS pXgbXUWXplaŽr^D`]_^¬]S ppDXRXMkHX2ŽrM_`a_aOXp¬SVd3S•pDNQp<pDXP|Ss

a_`bQXgb`bpDX5SVM ]˜NQU2kD`bpHSVaO`bNQpDdBN ’BNQaO^<XMOdXegXeUWXplaOdNV’•Cž›m[ fmNQ`bplaOX5nfHNRgbt|^<X5nlMTSVg$]NQpDX`bd&“HpD`baOXgbtwPQXepDXMTSVaOX5nklta_^DX`bM

X˜s@a_MOXUwS gbd5›

t•¦vuDw&xà‡xàªywz{–z— ,oC`A)' 7]€

.

ƒ>C

9

' 71=C™˜k ieA.5 šJ)0 2.*8]C&„]›n+/)0 2IC‚.$6+10&J),e.,

C 9

' 71!C7˜@ƒ^ˆ+-j.91G5 24"J1b5!CBC

9)œ

C7˜@ƒ!B­lfHSVp\SmC

9

T)Ž2­lfmS p\SBC™˜T!BVD ~L0 71CBC

9

EC7˜@„l.5 )+Y)J' 7,.žC

9

' 71=C7˜0.0 71b0&JA10.J 7),75&0QD ~Lvƒ ˆ+- }6+/)0 2;C‚.$.I061*8bJ 1)0l-.G5„

UWVcU Ÿ \>g&¡¢as£]¤¢`!go¥!¦Kas¦c§@b¨Z©iªgJ«I[]¦¬§™\­®g&f7¡DZ°¯±hyd]g&¦K[

= Xa> BES6>

. T .7²³

kHXS2^DNRUWNQPRXpDXNRcDdrvS M_QN ]_^HS `bpwN QXM&dOaS aOX£dOfHSR]X*@BjPR`bQXpwkltW`baOd&aOMS pDd_`a_`bNQpfDM_NQkHSVkD`bgb`aœt

UwS a_MO`¤s* BVSAS‡zFcPT"T

M@O@µ

SVpHn2`baOdB`bpD`baO`S gmnl`bdOaOM_`bkDcDaO`bNRp

†W¶

Žr^<XpwpDX5]Xd_dTSVMOtwŽ1XnlXpDNRaOX`ba1kltkS

†

F3Te›=Xa*S‡zFJR3T

n@XpDNQa_XaO^DXaOMS pDd_`baO`bNQp2fDM_NQkHSVkD`bgb`aœtN ’šU•N l`p<P6`bpWNRpDX6d_aOXf•’àM_NQU d_aTS a_X ‡Ja_N3a_^DX6d_cDkDd_Xa R NV’ @BjlaO^HSVa1`bd‰AS‡zFR3T^B

L M@O

%

AS‡zF¬P'Te›=Xa‰

%

0/254

%

0·Œ;4

kmX6a_^DX+nS_T_¸¹nScºTBd_cDksœU+S a_MO`¤s3NV’  PQ`bRXpWkltbSAS‡"F¬P'TzT

O %

0/254

´

M@O

%

0·Œ;4

›lŒX6n@XpDNQa_X

a_^DXS PRPQMOXeP|S a_X5nw]_^HS `bp]NQp<dOaOM_cH]a_X5nw’‘MONQU S†

FJ T$Žr`baO^•MOXd_fHX]aaONaO^<XfHS M_aO`baO`bNRpN klt<»¼v¼S

†

F‰F8N/T›

t•¦vuDw&xà‡xàªywz{–½J} .I‚5 7)kSR

³

FJR

9

FIH4HIHFR

M

TY8.5 ,.,ˆ.fA@ .)0J1b4..56lI'&ˆ+-k yˆ0‰10.&56 6'

† ¹¾&¿\Sˆ>

³

dVR

³

Fz>

9 d R 9 F4HIH4HF">

M

dVR

M

TpÀ ~7„=Áh( `0 y‹1'.&5ˆ5 G60

†

d`„ ' 71Cb4..56‘.I‚ 5 2)J

(8)

SR

³

FJR

9

F4H4HIHFR

M

TI0&

†

ƒ!ijA)J' %1! 7 ˆ+- (0J),"0&\S

†

FJR

³

FJR

9

FIH4HIHzFJR

M

T}d „ &)5 &.5(05*

\S

†

FR

³ T B †

%

S † FJR

³

FJR

9

F4H4HIHFRIT B S S† FR

³

FR

9

FIH4H4HJFR

8>9 T"3T

%

‰ YGH

0&30 ARVd<C"ƒ „kS

†

FR3T31 74",.36+$.5 ,.,/' 10.&56 G6' .98$ˆ+-I0&5\S

†

FR

³

FIH4HIHFRFR3T„

mr^DX+SVfDfDM_N|SQ]_^>nlXQXegNRfHXn¬`bpCq&XU•Xplt SVpHn¬­lp<XgbgSY5‚rRƒTSVpHn`bp¬x*cDkD`bpDN—SVpHn­lXM_`™]˜NQgS?SY5‚R}Q‚T£]NQpDd_`bdOaOd2`bp

MOXeŽrMO`baO`bpDP•aO^DX2]NQpmnl`baO`bNQpHSVgXsDfDMOXedOdO`bNRp¡LD¿ S6>

. 9

d‹RAScºTy>

.

dCRAS_T5Fz>

. 8>9

d R . 8>9 F4HIH4HF">

³

d‹R

³

T$Sin@X“HpDX5n

’àNRM3S plt SR

³

FJR

9

F‰H4HIH5F!R

. 8>9

FRAS_TzTfmNQd_dO`bkDgbX’àNRM

†

T3SVd¡L\S6>

9

dVRASºbT"T£Žr`a_^*`B S† FJR

³

FIH4HIHFR

. 8"9 FRAS_T"Tej

aO^mS ar`bd5j<`pw`bpH]gbcHn@`p<P3a_^DXfHSVdOa6`bplaON2a_^DX`bpD`baO`SVg nl`bd_aOMO`bkDc<aO`bNQpš›l[ pDX5]XedOdTSVMOt—SVpHn•dOcAn+]˜`Xep|a]NQpmnl`baO`bNQp•’àNRM‰Z a_NWkmX

S^DNRUWNQPRXpDXNRcDdrvS M_QN W]_^HS `bpw]S pwkmXXsD^D`bkD`baOX5n•Žr`baO^<NQcDarS pltWfmS MOa_`]cDgS MrS d_dOcDU•fDaO`bNQp•NQpk>›

2¦D† #à‡†z°{ ›n+Y)+0 MZ B »v¼¼S

†

FJ‰FsC\T.Y}+-'*,o' 70 G.Y#%'&''(%),+-0 ' 71C' M _Fº d

@_ƒ ˆ+-

7&ˆ¾ S6>

9 d R*SºTzT.6+.I'*lI'&(&5ˆ*Vd „kS

†

FJRAS_T"T„†›n+.)0A*' C(00 k./ˆ+-b&J' .560

7&eI'&ˆ+-A),+-0 Z "0(05&J'Q.88l_e"A.88 º#„

‰Dˆ|8<NQMSW]_^HSV`p S†

F3Tj<aO^DXdOXea „‘S

†

FJR TrU+St•kHXXU•fDaœt|›mr^mS a`bUWfDgb`bXdBaO^HSVaoŽBX2]S pp<XQXMSQ]]XedOda_N

aO^<X3d_aTS a_XdNV’ a_^DX2]gS dOd3R Žr`ba_^

†

S d&`bpD`baO`S gšnl`bd_aOMO`bkDc<aO`bNQpš›BNRpDdOX5RcDXep|a_gbt|j\R ]SVp—kmXXgb`U•`bpHS a_X5n2NV’!N Žr`baO^—SVplt

MOXefHXM]cDd_dO`bNQpDdNRp+a_^DX3SVpHS gbtldO`bdBN ’ža_^DXS PRPQMOXeP|S a_X5n•fDMOND]XedOd5›

xrXd_cDgba4{<›u n@XaOXM_UW`bpDXd0aO^DX&aOMTSVpDdO`ba_`NRp2fDMONRkHS k<`gb`baœtUwS aOM_`¤s NV’šaO^DXS PRPQMOXeP|S a_X5nfDM_N@]˜XdOdrŽr^D`]_^WUwStnlXfmXpHn2NRp

aO^<Xo`bpD`ba_`™SVg n@`d_aOM_`k<cDaO`bNQp

†

SVdrdO^DN ŽrpwkltWa_^DX&’àNQgbgbN Žr`bpDPXsHS U•fDgbXQ›

‰ #‘¦E|`=Xarc<d6]NQpDd_`nlXM6a_^DXaœŽBN3`bM_MOX5nlcm]`bkDgbX3vS M_QN W]_^HSV`p<drŽr`a_^WM_XdOfmX5]a_`RX3a›fš›U—›

9

S pHnk&˜A[

 9 B

Y:'u Y:0u Y:R{

~ Y:Qƒ x:Rƒ

r:R} Y:Q} ~

o˜‰B

!!

Y:Qƒ Y:Rƒ Y:: Y::

Y:: Y:G: Y:Qƒ Y:Qƒ

Y:0u Y:'u Y:0u Y:0u

Y:0u Y:'u Y:0u Y:0u

#"

" H

¡œaJ^HS dFkHXeXp2dO^DN Žrp`bp/q&XUWXep|tSVpHn3­@pDXgbg2STY5‚GrQƒGTaO^mS a5je’àNRM  9

jaO^<XrdOXaJN ’S gbgl`p<`a_`S gQnl`bdOa_MO`bkDcDa_`bNQpgbX5SRnl`bpDP6a_NoS p2S P's

PQM_XP|SVaOX5nvSVMOQN ]_^HSV`pSQ]]NRMTnl`bpDPa_N6aO^<XrfHS M_aO`baO`bNQplN

9

BVDGD|Y'LvFD®{F:LGLš`bd&q

9 B D%$

9

bSTYy$2TSi~yF5Y::yFT{v::Ty:o~=

$ Y0Ll›1<NQgbgbN Žr`bpDPaO^<X—dS UWXwŽrStS dW`bpxrc<kD`bpDN¬S pHn ­lXMO`]NRgS‚STY‚Q‚<YITj0aO^DX]NQM_MOXd_fHNRpHnl`bpDP>dOXa•’àNRM ˜ SVpHn

N ˜ B DD|YGFT{-LvFD:yF"uLGL4`bd;q ˜ B D%$ STY:R{FY:R{F~F~T7'&

)(

STYW*$$& T

,+

:2~$ -$nF.& Y0Ll›=Xa$¢kmXaO^DX£U+S a_MO`¤s

nl`S PS

TS pHn N B DDlYFƒFrLF5D {F":yFu7FxGLLl›H¡œa`bd2X5S d_t¬a_N ]NRpl|`bpH]˜X+NRcDMOd_Xg¤’oa_^HS a2a_^DX]O^mS `bp »v¼¼yS

9

FJOFN/T`bd2S

^DNRUWNQPRXpDXNRcDdrvS M_QN W]_^HS `bpš›l¡œa_draOMS pDd_`a_`bNQpwfDMONRkHS k<`gb`baœtU+S a_MO`¤s2`d

/



010#2c4

B43

Y:0u :v:0u

rv:DY5{ xv:DY5{'5

H

¡œpwaO^DXdS UWX&Ž4StljlaO^<X ]_^HSV`bp‡»v¼v¼S

76

FJ‰F8N/T$`bd6S^DNRUWNRPQXpDXeNQcDd1vS MORN +]_^HSV`p•Žr`baO^wa5›fš›U—›

/

 01098K4 B 3

Y:Q{ Y:Q{

Y:Q{ Y:Q{5

H

ŒXrpDNRaOX6a_^HS a

/

 0 2

SYFYITnB Y:0u`bdrS p2X`bPQXep|QSVgbcDXrN ’šUwS aOM_`¤s*

% 09 4% 09 4

Žr^D`]_^W`bd1nl`bd_aO`bpH]a0’àMONRU aO^DX&dOfmX5]aOMS gFMTSQn@`c<d

Y:R{NV’ža_^DXpDNRpDpDXPlS aO`bRX6U+SVaOM_`Ÿsš› :

=XacDd]NQp<dO`nlXMS2f<MONQkmS kD`bgb`baœtWnl`bdOaOM_`bkDcDaO`bNRp

†

SVpHnwXgb`bUW`bpHSVaOXoSVgbgšaO^<X3]gS d_dOXdNV’$aO^DXfHS M_aO`baO`bNRpN Žr^D`]_^—]SVp

pDXRXMrkmX SR]]Xd_dOX5nklt2aO^DX]_^HSV`p}S

†

F3TjRaO^HSVar`bd1a_^DX]gS dOd_Xd R*S_TOS_nd

@!T0dOcH]_^a_^HS ae„kS

†

FRAS_TzT^B~’<›lŒX6NQk<aTS `bp

(9)

S–pDXŽ d_aTS a_XWd_fHSQ]XSVpHnSwpDXŽyfHS M_aO`baO`bNQpNV’6aO^DX•dOcDk<dOXa2NV’O@ Žr^D`]O^¬SVMOXwS P|SV`bp nlXepDNQa_X5n k|t?@¢S pmn}N ’àNQMp<NQa

UwS l`bpDPaO^DX&pDNQaS a_`NRp2^DX5Sl`bXM5›lŒ `a_^2aO^HSVarpDXŽfmS MOa_`baO`bNQpANWjDS gbgmaO^DX&dOXa_d„kS

†

FRAS_T"T$SVMOXpDNRa1XU•fDaœt2S pHn Ž1X]S p

n@X“HpDXUwS a_MO`¤s

/

 0¿ 4 `bpWaO^<X’àNQgbgbN Žr`bpDPU+SVpDpDXM4[ ’àNRMrX5SQ]_^Y_nd

@rjDgbXa;*kHXSRX5]aONRM6`bp„kS

†

FJRAS_T"TrSVpHn•dOXa

/

 0¿ 4 S_FºTB ¡ÌL S6>

9

dYRASºbT"T º d

@‰H

¡‘’]»v¼¼yS

†

FJOFN/Tr`bdS•^DNQU•NQPRXpDXNRcDdovSVMORN fDMOND]XedOdaO^DXp`ba&’àNRggbN ŽrdB’àM_NQU xrXd_cDgba {<›uWaO^mS a

/

 0¿ 4 `bdaO^DX2a_MTS p<dO`s

a_`bNQpfDM_NQkHSVkD`bgb`aœt•U+SVaOMO`¤swN ’1a_^D`bd SVPQPRMOXPlS aOXn—]_^HSV`pF› = XacDdpDN Ž n@X“HpDX2a_^DX3d_Xa5jFnlXpDNRaOX5nkltk„ S /

 0¿ 4TjmNV’4S gbg

`bpD`ba_`™SVgšnl`bdOa_MO`bkDcDa_`NRpDd;*gbX5SQn@`p<P2aONWS pS PQPRMOXPlS a_X5n•^DNQU•NQPQXepDXNQc<d6vS M_QN Wf<MOND]Xd_d»v¼v¼Sm*!F‰F8N/TrŽr`baO^a_MTSVpDdO`baO`bNRp

f<MONQkmS kD`bgb`baœt3UwS aOM_`¤s

/

 0¿ 4 [

„ S /

 0¿ 4T!B D+*Mdk„±:ˆ»v¼¼ySm*!F‰FsC TB`bd6S^DNRUWNQPRXpDXNRcDdrvS M_QN W]_^HS `bp•Žr`a_^wa5›fš›U—›

/

 0¿ 4 L

mJNgb`PR^laOXpa_^DXwfDMOXd_XplaTSVaO`bNQpšj„ Žr`bgbg4SVgd_NMOX˜’àXMWa_N%„ S /

 0¿ 4

T`¤’oa_^DXM_X+`bd2pDNS U2k<`PRcD`baœtQ›2mr^DXS `bU N ’aO^D`bd

d_cDkDd_X5]aO`bNRp`bdraONWS pmS gbtpX6fDM_NQfmXMOa_`bXdN ’ža_^D`bdrdOXa&Žr^DXpw`bar`bd1pDNRarXUWf<aœt|›

= Xa6cDd6n@X“HpDXa_^DX&’àNQgbgbN Žr`bpDPUwS aOM_`]Xd5›

<NQMrS plt_ d

@Bj7

2

nlXepDNQa_Xd6a_^DX†nS_TW¸fK dOcDk-siUwS aOM_`¤sWN ’ ‘[2SAS‡"F¬P'TzT

O %

0/254

´

M@O

›

 nlXpDNRaOXda_^DX/K ¸YU U+S a_MO`¤s+nlX“mpDX5nk|t\[ ‡d‹@Bj º d

@rj

*S‡zFºbTjBVAS‡"FRAScºT"Te›H<NQMS plt_ d

@rj<Ž1X

nlXp<NQaOXklt

 2

aO^DX†nS_TW¸YU d_cDksœU+SVaOMO`¤s2N ’

[2S

AS‡"FºTzT

O %

0/254

´Œ O ›

mr^DX3_ba_^+M_N Ž8NV’ža_^DXdOa_ND]O^mS dOa_`]U+SVaOMO`¤s

/

 0¿ 4 `bd6nlXpDNRaOX5nwklt

/

 0¿ 4

2 ›

<NQM$S gbg_nd

@*j Ž1XBdOXeaž

2 B

 2 +Y5

/

 0¿ 4

2

ScnS_T¸$UVT1SVpHn ’àNQM$S pltIP$‰ YRj ŽBX4nlX˜“HpDX6a_^DXB’àNRggbN Žr`bpDPK—¸ U M 9

kDgbND]_Wnl`S PQNRpHS gmU+SVaOM_`™]˜Xd

9 B nl`S PS

2

TF

M 97B nl`S PS

2

M T5H SYIT

ŒXSVMOX`bp+fmNQd_`baO`bNQpwaONWSRnlNQf<araO^DXgb`bpDX5SVMrdOtldOa_XU S f<fDMONlSQ]_^•’àMONRU xrcDk<`p<NWS pHnw­lXM_`]NQgSbSTY‚Q‚<YITBS pHn•`bpwaO^DXdS U•X

UwS pDp<XM5jRŽ1X£^HSQX[

„S

/

 0¿ 4 T^B

M ² 9 „ M

Žr^DXMOXQ„

M B D*MdY„ :+*>

B~yF>’àNRM ‰¢YALvH

*N ŽjlX5SQ]_^wfmNQgbtlaONQfmX$„

M

]S pwkmXdOXXpS draO^<XaOMSQ]XNRpWa_^DXdOXea„-N ’ža_^DX’àNRgbgN Žr`bpDPfmNQgbtl^DX5nlMS gš]NRpDX[

C M

B D*F‰>~ˆ:$*>

B ~F0’àNRMoYI PLvF Sœ{T

a_^HS a&`bd „ M B C M

Žk„ ’àNRM;P‰ ~fSàŽr`baO^a_^DX2]NQplQXep|a_`bNQp#C

³ B ¡x S pHnk„

³

BV„Te› BNQpDd_X5RcDXplaOgbtljmŽ1Xp<NQaOXaO^mS a

„ S /

 0¿ 4T!BC S /

 0¿ 4TŽb„-Žr^DXM_X+C S /

 0¿ 4T B M ² 9 C M

S pHn•ŽBX^HSQX

„ S /

 0¿ 4

T9ŽB?’3ac C S /

 0¿ 4

T$ŽB D®~-LvH

*N Žj`¤’|ŽBX$pDNRaOX$a_^HS a"C M 9

`bdšnlX5nlcm]X5n£’àM_NQU?C

M

kltoSVaOaTSR]_^D`bpDPraO^DXOSàXRXplaOcHSVggbtTSQn<nl`baO`bNQpHSVgQ]NQp<dOaOMS `bplaOdSm*>

M 9

B

~GTrS pHn•a_^HS a6nl`bUbSmC

9

K aO^DXpaO^DX’‘NQgbgbN Žr`p<PoX˜s@a_XpDd_`NRpN ’^mr^DXNRMOXU :D›u£’àMONRU x*cDkD`bpDN2S pHn•­lXMO`]NRgSbSTY5‚R‚DY4T$`bd

`bplaOc<`a_`bQXgbt2]gbX5S M4[

CS

/

 0¿ 4T!BC

S:T

Žr^<XMOX/K `bdBaO^DXplcDU2kmXMBN ’JdOaTSVaOXd&N ’$aO^<XoNRMO`bPQ`bpHSVg ]_^HSV`bpš›

ŒXJpDNRaOXJ’àM_NQU aO^DXrnl`S PRNQpHSVg5d_aOM_cH]aOc<MOXrN ’Da_^DX$U+SVaOM_`™]˜Xdo M ja_^HS aj’àNRM*‰ ~Dj*Md#C

M

ac4 _ d

@eFo' 8>9

2 * % 0/254

d

C M

›l¡œa6SVggbN ŽrdBcDdraONWn@XMO`bQXfHSVMOarNV’žaO^<X’àNQgbgbN Žr`bpDPgbXUWUwSD›

(10)

‰Ez{— ,/ G..I!C

M2 B ' 2C M

40&Y5(0&5_ d

@;„k+-0(06ƒjI0&k0"PN‰ Y ƒ•C

M B œ 2O '

8"9

2 C M2 i^+5&

' 8>9

2 C M2 GC

M

./$04+-10&0 )0 2]€ C M2

.3 -'4+-1'&J0 )' 7;€

.A0/254

„

Jˆ ªª{FŒXo]SVp—]_^DX5]_2’àM_NQU-aO^DXnlX˜“HpD`baO`bNQpwNV’žaO^<Xod_XaOdIC

M

S‘dOXXSYITej\Si{GT"TBa_^HS aB’àNRMDP$‰ YRj

C M2

B *Md+¡Ìx .A0/254

:=*>

2

B~-S pHn *  2

7B ~FY! PIYAH S6uT

BNQp<dOX5RcDXpla_gtljAC

M2

S‘MOXd_fš›' 8>9

2 C M2

TB`bd6SfmNQgbtl^DX5n@MTS gJ]NQp<XoNV’ž¡Ìx .A0/254 S‘MOXd_fš›m¡x Te›

mr^DXŽBXgbgsilpDN Žrp pDX5]Xd_dTSVMOt8SVpHn dOcAn+]`bXplaw]NQpHn@`a_`bNQp¬M_XfmNQMOa_X5n `p q&XU•Xplt¬S pHn>­lpDXegg STY‚rQƒGT’‘NQM2^HSl`bpDP

dOa_MONRpDPWgbcDU•fHS kD`bgb`baœt3NV’SJHF3T0Žr`a_^—S p`M_MOX5n@cH]`bkDgbX3UwS a_MO`¤s ]S pkHXXsDaOXepHnlX5naONwS2PQXepDXMTSVgJdOaOND]_^HSVdOaO`]£U+SVaOMO`¤sš›

mr^DX&NQpDgbtMOX5RcD`bMOXeUWXpla$`bdBaO^HSVa1S gbgmaO^DXS PQPRMOXPlS a_X5n2]_^HS `bpDdBdO^HSVMOX&aO^DX&dTS U•Xra5›fš›U—›

/

›R¡œpWaO^mS ar]S d_XQjlklt”nlX˜“HpD`baO`bNQpFj

aO^<XW’œS UW`bgbtYSHFJ3T N ’ovSVMOQN ¬]_^HSV`bpDd3`bdd_aOM_NQpDPRgtgbcDU•fHS k<gX`¤’„ S /

 0¿ 4TAB „ NRM†C S /

 0¿ 4 T/B ¡x

’àNRM”SVplt

†

dV„›J¡œp’iSR]a5jF`ba3`bdX5RcD`bQS gbXplaaONMOX5RcD`bMOXwa_^HS aA„

9 B „ ³ NRMˆC

9 B C ³ › rN Žj"C

9 B ¡x

`bdX5RcD`bQS gbXplaa_N

9

B8~£NQMra_NkS

2

B8~yF _\d

@^TBŽr^D`]_^S M_Xof<MOX5]`bd_Xgbt+a_^DX3]NRpHnl`baO`bNRpDd1PR`bQXpwklt2aO^DX ’àNQgbgbN Žr`bpDPaO^DXNRMOXU›

J¦lªHˆ ¦ z°{kijk&‚ &J‘ˆ+-*0ˆ+-M4o4o&o4"1?)+0 -..+-'&Jbˆ+-b.I'*b&J' .560 M7&}*&5ƒ

ˆ+- k6+^I'/3SHFJ3T$l#%0&,''(*),+-' .3..&J' o/ $9' 71' A^I'&9G)+A-'& 8/)54..I.‰RAS_T30 71

RAScºTƒ^AS‡zFJR*SºTzT/1GI,.3 7418- 71k0 b‡^dYRAS_T„

¡œpWfmS MOa_`]cDgS MjQa_^D`bd1M_XdOcDgbar`bdBpDX5]Xd_dTSVMOtwaON3n@XMO`bQXd_NQUWXrM_XdOc<ga_dr`bp2[6knlXgsßv–NQpDX`bU SVpHn= XtldO`bXtXM$STY‚Q}'uvTJa_^DNQcDPR^

aO^<X ]_^HSVMTSR]aOXM_`p5S a_`NRpXsDfDgb`]`baOgbt2cDd_X5nw`bd1a_^DX/q&XU•XpltWS pHnw­lpDXeggdBNQpDXŽr`ba_^WaO^<X`bMOMOXnlcH]`bkD`bgb`baœtWS dOd_cDUWf<aO`bNQpš›

”+./3,0B%” 3%#B5w'6

t•¦vu©w&x‘‡x‘ª7w½°{/|~} *&·q 0(0.Y)0 7!CV&¡x ('&56' 9'&/4&5·Iq ./ 20 78o4(00 Mˆ+-)' 7IC"ƒ

ˆ+-4‰i! A1 74"1Iq

”

‰ ~™ƒ!!I'&9(05&5+…bd<C 6+3(0)"0&;…yqVdªC /„6„C)qJGC „!›n+-3)0 2!C .l.I061*8bJ

4.5(A (00&60 *&5q$„

­lNRUWXrdOfmX5]a_MTSVgšfDM_NQfmXMOa_`Xed6N ’JU+SVaOMO`]Xed1gbX5Sl`bpDP3S£fDMONRfHXeM6]NQpDX`bplQS M_`™SVpla SVMOXMOXe|`bXŽBX5n ’àM_NQU {0XMOUwS pWSVpHnwLJgbXUs

UWNRpDdlSTY5‚GrQ‚GT›

2¦D† #à‡†½°{–zJ 4&5·!q '(,./$7&5&A)J' 7 C y('&560 -jˆ+- kˆ+-9.)&J'\&JG10 G.SBq TA.9' ‹o5 y(' /8

q ' 71=C )' 8' ./,h5o' (0J),"0&/8;q )0&&J,.0 210 oA"SBq

rNRaOXaO^HSVa4S£pDNRpDpDXPlS aO`bRXrU+S a_MO`¤s2`drSUwS aOM_`¤s”Žr^D`]_^WgbX5SRXdBaO^DX&fDMONRfHXM6]˜NQpDX¡Ìx

N ’ž¡Ìx `bplQS MO`SVp|a› ŒX6Žr`bgbg

nlX5SVgHŽr`ba_^W]NQpDXed1Žr^D`]_^+SVMOXrpDNRa$dONRgb`™n › BNQpDd_X5RcDXplaOgbtljQŽBX6^mSQXraONnlXMO`bRXoSŽBX5S RXMBMOXd_cDgba1a_^HS p2a_^DX6fDM_Xl`bNQcDd$NRpDXQ›

‰E½{–½J$*&5žq 0(0,.9)4.I1ƒ\0 -81)' (6)J' 7 CC (00&5ˆ0 !ˆ+- kˆ+-&J$6.ˆ.9' Y 70 y 78o'(0

o' (00 - $ Wq ., ),+k6+4&C )0 -8' ./‰5o (),8'&/ q 4..I4)5681‘i!ˆ+$>„

kM 70 2o4(0Y4&5·$q .&5&10 )5ˆ50 21M0(0.Y%).IJ1ƒ9)0 y(6 )' 7$CG ¡x

(00&5ˆ0 $ˆ+- FC

)0 "0 .$6+‰4.5(03‰5o (),8'&/)0&5&.0 71' oA8*6+$.)&J'\&J1' G.ySmq

Jˆ ªª{1vS aOM_`¤s‡q MOXf<MOXd_XplaOdaO^DXU+SVaOMO`¤sWNV’4S2gb`bpDX5SVM6NQfmXMS aONRM NQp¡Ìx Žr`a_^MOXedOfmX5]aa_N+a_^DX2]S pDNRpD`]S gFkHS d_`bd

SàŽr`ba_^aO^DXw]NQplQXep|a_`bNQpaO^mS a S

Tj ’àNQM£XQXM_tC‡$d`KjF`bdaO^<X‡a_^¬MON Ž NV’6U+S a_MO`¤s#q3jFaO^HSVa`bd S…2T/B …7qy’àNRM SVgbg

…kd¡x

›TrvSVaOMO`¤s<q `bdrpDNQp<pDXP|SVaO`bQXNRpªCUWXS pDdra_^HS a SmC\T!G?Cž›%BNQpDd_X5RcDXplaOgbtlj gbX5SRXdraO^DXgb`bpDX5S Mrd_cDkDd_fHSQ]X

B ­lfHSVp\SmC\TIG¢¡Ìx `plQSVMO`S pla6S pmn`ba6`bU•fDgb`XedraO^HSVaoa_^DXMOXd_aOMO`]a_`bNQpN ’aONwaO^DXdOc<kDdOfHSR]Xrjšn@XpDNQa_X5nk|t $j

`bd6S2gb`bpDX5SVMrNQfmXMTSVaONQM*’àMONRU>a_Nr›2mr^DX3]NRpDX+C`d6SVgbdON2`bplQS MO`SVp|aBklt S pHn–`drd_NQgb`n•Žr`a_^wMOXd_fHX5]˜aaONr›ymr^lcDd5j

aO^<Xof<MONQfmXM6]NRpDX]C`dBfmNQdO`ba_`RXgbt3`bplQS M_`S plaJk|t2a_^DXU+SVaOMO`¤s†qN ’ša_^DXNQfmXMTSVaONRM $›mr^DX&“HM_dOaBfHS M_arN ’žx*XdOcDgba‰:D›Ì{

]SVp¬kmX+S f<fDgb`Xna_NFq SVpHn]NRpH]gbcDdO`bNRpDd”SVMOXwS dOd_ND]`S aOXnŽr`baO^a_^DXWd_fHX5]˜aOMTSVgrMTSRnl`bcDd3NV’6aO^HSVaU+SVaOM_`Ÿsš›\~rN ŽBXRXM5j

aO^<XX`bPQXplRX5]aONRMOdS pHn•aO^<Xod_fHX]aOMS gJMTSRnl`bcDdrN ’ S MOXX`bPRXplQX5]a_NQM_doS pmn+Sp<NQpDpDXeP|S a_`bQXX`bPQXplQSVgc<X6N ’$a_^DX`p<`a_`S g

gb`bpDX5S MBNQfmXMS aONRM wNRpnlNQUwS `bp2¡x

jla_^HS arPR`RXdraO^<X6“mMOdOa&fHS M_arN ’JaO^DXgbXU•U+S<›

(11)

¡‘’$aO^<XpDNQp<pDXP|SVaO`bQXUwS aOM_`¤s¹q `dr`bM_MOX5nlcm]`bkDgbXQjDa_^DXpa_^DXMOXXsD`bdOa_doS pwcDp<`™RcDXAS‘cDfwaONWS2]NRpDdOaS pla6U2cDgba_`f<gX4TJgbX’àa

Xe`PRXplQX5]˜aONQMN ’;q `bp¡x

Sà`bp’iSR]a`bp—`bplaO¡Ìx

`i›XQ›m`ba`bd3S•fmNQdO`ba_`RX2gbX’àaX`bPQXplRX5]aONRMJT£Žr^D`]_^¬]NQM_MOXd_fHNRpHnld2aONwa_^DX

d_fHX]aOMS g$MSQnl`bcDdN ’Dq› *N Žjl’àNRMoSVp|t]gbNRdOX5njnS‘fHNR`pla_X5nT]NQplRXs—]NQpDX$CG¢¡Ìx j<`¤’•q

”

‰ ~ aO^DXpŽBX3nlX5nlcm]X’àMONRU

a_^DX£“HMOd_afHS M_aN ’1a_^DX3f<MONlN ’raO^HSVa6a_^DXMOX•XsD`bdOaOdS•pDNRpDpDXPlS aO`bRXgbX’àaX`bPQXplRX5]aONRMN ’1UwS aOM_`¤sªq `bp#CG¢¡Ìx

›š­l`bpH]X

a_^DXM_X3`bd6NRpDgbtWNRpDXgbX’àarX`bPRXplQX5]a_NQMN ’Dq `pw¡Ìx

jD`ba6`bdrfmNQdO`ba_`RX3S pmn+SVdOd_N@]˜`™SVaOX5nŽr`baO^waO^<X3d_fHX5]˜aOMTSVg$MTSRnl`bcDdrN ’$a_^DX

UwS a_MO`¤s¹q›mr^DXd_X5]NQpmnwfHS M_arN ’JaO^DXgbXU•U+S*^DNQgnld›

ŒXwŽrS pla2XUWf<^HS d_`peX+a_^HS a2a_^DXfmNQd_`a_`bQXw`bp|QSVMO`S pm]XWNV’ fmNQgbtlaONRfHXRj$cDd_X5n>`bp =XU•U+Sk:D›x’àM_NQU x*cDkD`bpDNS pHn

­@XMO`]NRg™S*STY5‚R‚DY4TžSVd4S&d_`U•fDgbX1d_aONRf2aOXd_ar`paO^<X`bM1`bpH]M_XUWXep|aS gH]˜NQUWf<cDaTSVaO`bNQpN ’\„ ’àMONRU aO^<X„

M

NQpDXed5jl`bd1S]Xep|a_MTSVg

PRXNQU•XaOM_`]`bp|QSVMO`S pla&N ’1a_^DX2Ž1XS gbcDU•fHS kD`bgb`baœt2fDMONRfHXeMOaœtS ddONlNQpS dŽBXWS M_X3`bplaOXM_XdOa_X5n`bpS PRPQMOXeP|S a_X5nvS M_QN 

]_^HSV`bpDdrdO^HSVMO`bpDPaO^DX£dTS U•X6a_MTS p<dO`baO`bNQp•fDMONRkHS k<`gb`baœt2U+SVaOM_`Ÿsš›

ž¦lªmˆ ¦ ½{ ›n+-.,‰„ S /

 0¿ 4TYŽB ’ '&+C S /

 0¿ 4T}ŽB D®~-L%k0 71?' Mˆ+-&Jk6.Jˆ.‘-'4+-1'&J0)' 7

C G~C

9

ƒ10 &J 5&0 D®~-Lƒ!.5 )+}6+4j

”

‰¢~?0 71$C .36+10&)e.5 v

œ 2O ' 8"9

2 C 2

i^+5&!C

2

B¢'

2

REI0&0

_nd

@;„

Jˆ ªª{o­lcDf<fHNRdOXa_^HS a$C S /

 0¿ 4

TMŽB D ~Ll› = Xa2cDd2QXeMO`¤’àtaO^mS aˆC ’‘cDg¤“HgbgdaO^<X+M_X5RcD`bMOX5n>]NRpHnl`baO`bNRpDd5›JŒX•^HSQX

C B C

’àM_NQU MOXeg™SVaO`bNQp S:Te›H­l`bpH]˜X†C

B C 9

jmŽ1X^mSQX£’àNQMS pltWRX5]aONRM+*?BHL

2O ' 8>9 2 * %

0/254 dFC

S pHn•’‘NQM

SVplt$P”d_cH]_^+a_^HS aY P† K

*>

M 9\B8~ ac _nd

@‰F*

%

0/254

 2

M B8~bS‘kltWnlX“HpD`ba_`NRpwN ’žd_tldOaOXeU M

9

T

B\c * +

M B

2

O

* %

0/254

 2

M B ~F

a_^HS a&`bd]*  dFC

›7mr^<XdOXaIC\`bd&aO^DX2nl`bMOX5]˜aod_cDU N ’B`a_d U €_fDMON5u˜X5]aO`bNRpDd" ’àMONRU M_XgS aO`bNRp?S:GT6S pmnY=XU•U+S{D›xD›

mJNNRkDaTSV`bpWaO^<X n@X5]NQU•fHNRdTSVkD`bg`baœtNV’>C8jl`ba1M_XU+SV`bpDd$aONXd_aTS k<g`bd_^WaO^mS araO^<XdOXdOXeaOdoSVMOXnl`bdOaO`bpH]˜aB’àMONRU D ~Ll›Q¡‘’JaO^DXM_X

X˜s@`bd_aOd/_ed

@d_cH]_^aO^HSVaC

2 B ' 2

C B D ~L+j aO^HSVao`bU•fDgb`XedraO^HSVaoa_^DX2NQM_`bPQ`bpHS gJ]_^HS `bp S†

FJ Tr]S ppDXeQXM3SR]]Xd_dOX5n

a_N—a_^DXwdOaS aOX]gS dOdR*S_Te›J¡œpHnlXX5n j$`¤’ „kS

†

FRAS_T"TMŽB ’a_^DXp>aO^DXeMOXXsD`bdOa_dª ‰ ~dOcH]_^a_^HS aˆ'

2,†  . -kŽB ~S pHn

' 2,†  . -Ad C 2

Žr`baO^ aO^DXwfmNQd_`a_`bQXW`bplQS M_`S pH]X•N ’IC

kltU+SVaOMO`¤sC2›nmžN]NQpH]˜gcmnlXQj$M_X5]SVggra_^HS a2a_^DX]NQp<dO`nlXM_X5n

fmS MOa_`baO`bNQp‘N ]NRp|aS `bpDdrNRpDgbt2aO^DXd_aTSVaOX]gS d_dOXd&N ’$aO^DXNRMO`bPQ`bpHSVgHd_aTS a_XdOfmSQ]X/@ Žr^D`]_^–SVMOX3SR]]Xd_dOX5nkltkS

†

F3T›

BNRp|RXMOd_Xgbt|j`¤’Ha_^DXMOXrX˜s@`bd_aOd1S*fHNRgtl^DXnlMTSVg@]˜NQpDXWC#GC

9

jŽr^D`]_^3`bdžn@`d_aO`bpH]aF’àM_NQUQD ~L4SVpHn`bdJfHNRdO`baO`bRXgbto`bplQS M_`S pla

kltk2jQd_cH]_^aO^mS a;CB

œ 2O ' 8>9

2 C 2

aO^<XpwŽ1XdO^<N Ž8kltW`bpHn@cH]aO`bNRpWaO^mS a

C G C M

yP†‰¢YH

mr^<X$“HM_dOa$d_aOXf2`bdFNQkll`NRcDd5›0= XaJcDd$S dOd_cDUWXBaO^mS a&C<G C M

Žr`a_^IP†À¢YQ› <NQMFXQXM_t†*Md<CžjVŽ1XB^HSQX;' 8>9

2 * % 0/254

d<C#GNC

M

’‘NQMrS gbg _nd

@‚S‘dO`bpH]X=C+`bd6nlX]NQU•fHNRdTS k<gX4TjRpDXsDa+,5' 8"9

2 * % 0/254

-6 B*

%

03254

 2

d<C#GC

M

’àNRM4SVgg _ d

@ S‘kHX]S cDd_X/

”

‰ ~GT›

ŒX2]NRpH]gbcHnlX2a_^HS aˆ, _Od

@‰Fs*

%

0/254

 2 M

By~-$NQM+*>

M 9 B ~<›\mr^lcDd5j Ž1X2^HSRX†CG—C M 9

›F`bpHS gbgbt|j<Ž1X2NRkDaTSV`bp

C G M ² 9 C M

BCS

/

 0¿ 4

mr^DXS kmN QX&fDMONlN ’šPR`bQXdrSdOc™n+]`bXpla6]NQpHn@`a_`bNQp’àNRMJ“HpHnl`bpDP£`p<`a_`S gHnl`bd_aOMO`bkDc<aO`bNQpDdBŽr^D`]_^2gbX5SQn aON3SVp+S PRPQM_XP|SVaOX5n

^<NQUWNRPQXp<XNQcDdrvSVMOQN W]_^HSV`bp%S‘Žr`baO^2“<s@Xnwa5›fš›U—›T

ªmˆ ª ##à‰<ˆ §½°{—

/

 ' ."I),+-.J6)A4&5·@„31G 7Aˆ+-l04+-10&0!)0 7!C

9

4..II)681bi!ˆ+

/

 ./

Sœ{TA0 71*., 4G-. ˆ+-jj. 1'. 7)25&J'QD®~-L1„lˆ+-&J36.Jˆ./$04+-10&0 )0 7 C#GC

9

i^+6),+./1)0l-.G5

œ 2O C 2

' 71‘.5 -),+ˆ+-  ”

‰~kˆ+- ˆC#GC S /

$T„

w*dO`bpDP—nlX]NQU•fHNRdTS k<`gb`baœtwfDMONRfHXeMOaœtlj mr^DXeNQMOXeU :D›u]S pkmXWM_X’àNRMOU2cDgS a_X5nŽr`a_^V€OgbND]S g]_^HS MSQ]a_XMO`bd_aO`]d5›^mr^mS a

PR`bQXdra_^DXU+S `bp2M_XdOcDgba&N ’ža_^D`bdrdOX5]˜aO`bNQpš›

Références

Documents relatifs

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP