Predictive models of toxicity in intensity modulated radiotherapy

HAL Id: tel-00855266

https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00855266

Submitted on 29 Aug 2013

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-lished or not. The documents may come from

teaching and research institutions in France or

abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

publics ou privés.

Predictive models of toxicity in intensity modulated

radiotherapy

Jian Zhu

To cite this version:

Jian Zhu. Predictive models of toxicity in intensity modulated radiotherapy. Signal and Image

pro-cessing. Université Rennes 1, 2013. English. �NNT : 2013REN1S017�. �tel-00855266�

ANNÉE 2013

1

THÈSE / UNIVERSITÉ DE RENNES 1

sous le sceau de l’Université Européenne de Bretagne

pour le grade de

DOCTEUR DE L’UNIVERSITÉ DE RENNES 1

Mention : Traitement du Signal et Télécommunications

Ecole doctorale Matisse

présentée par

Jian ZHU

Préparée à l’unité de recherche LTSI – INSERM U1099

Laboratoire Traitement du Signal et de l’Image

Université de Rennes 1, France

Laboratory of Image Science & Technology (LIST)

Southeast University, Nanjing, Chine

Modèles prédictifs de

toxicité en

radiothérapie par

modulation

d’intensité

Soutenue à Nanjing, Chine

le 18/01/2013

devant le jury composé de :

Dimitri LEFKOPOULOS

Physicien Médical, Institut Gustave Roussy / rapporteur

Zhiguo GUI

Professeur, North University of China / rapporteur

Baosheng LI

PUPH, Shandong Cancer Hospital and Institute / examinateur

Renaud DE CREVOISIER

PUPH, Université de Rennes 1 / directeur de thèse

Limin LUO

Professeur, Southeast University / co-directeur de thèse

Antoine SIMON

1

2

123456789AB3CDECF78368E2CDCEB868

A3C2EBA9C689A8235EC28

3CE67CEB8

1

1

1

3456789A1BC1

BD89EF87ED1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC11

BC2C1

AE66AAD81FA18A4D7A1F7995F7587ED1E6AA16591EF587ED1F7D8AD781A81

7FA1659175ACCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC11

BCC1

EFA169F787 1FA18E778195F7E!7DF78A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1"1

BCC5C1 #58A917D 5D81518E778195F7E!7DF78A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1$1

BCC%C1

39789A1FA157 7587ED1FA1518E778195F7E!7DF78A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1$1

BCCC1 EFA1FA169F787ED1FA1518E7781569195F7E849567A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1$1

BCC1

&A87ED1DED19EA1EDA9D5D815169F787ED1FA1518E7781AD151F'B()1A81E%*A87 1FA1

5184A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1+1

3456789A1BBC1

BFAD87 7587ED1A81E65957ED1FA1EFA1FA169F787ED1FA1518E7781,EFA1-)3./1

1

1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

BBC2C1

BD89EF87ED191A171EFA1-)3.1A81E%*A87 1F1895571A1EDA9D5D81CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

BBC2C5C1

EFA11231,145D!284A9!395D/1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

BBC2C%C1

EFA11E78!561A81EFA1FA17484A71CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1281

BBC2CC1

EFA1.E7ED1561A81EFA1FA1295D1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1221

BBC2CFC1

EFA16595A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1221

BBCC1

BFAD87 7587ED1FA1EFA16591571FA1957A%5DA1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC121

BBCC1

:E9784A1F'E6877587ED1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC121

BBC"C1

.9F787ED1FA18E77819A85A1A8175A1859F7A1AD195F7E849567A1F15DA91FA151

69E858A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC12;1

BBC"C5C1

.9EAD5DA1A819789A1F7D7ED1FA16587AD81F5D1A1895571FA184A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC12+1

BBC"C%C1

)A4D7A1FA195F7E849567A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC12+1

BBC"CC1

39789A1FA1*AAD81FA18E7781CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC12<1

BBC"CFC1

(8581CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1201

BBC"CAC1

=97 7587ED1FA1'7FAD87 7587ED1FA1659589A1A81E65957ED1FA151565781

69F787A1FA1EFA1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC11

BBC$C1

.9F787ED1FA1'>E64578A157A1AD195F7E849567A1F15DA91%9ED47A1DED1?16A878A1

AA1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1+1

1



BBC$C5C1

84EFA11A81FEDDA1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1<1

BBC$C%C1

(8581CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

3456789A1BBBC1

6877587ED1F1EFA1FA1FEA175AD8A1D7 E9A1,56/1AD1B()169E8587A1CCCCCC121

BBBC2C1

1A1EDA681F'561CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC121

BBBCC1

6877587ED1F1EFA1561AD1B()1F15DA91FA15169E858A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC121

BBBCC5C1

@%*A87 1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC121

BBBCC%C1

EDDA1A8184EFA1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC11

BBBCCC1

(8581CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC11

3456789A1B=C1

:667587ED1FA1EFA1%7EE7A1F5D1E6877587ED1FA1B()1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1;1

B=C2C1

 71A8169E%587AA18581FA1'5981CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1;1

B=CC1

:669E4A17AD87 7A1A818A4D7A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1+1

B=CC1

(8581CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1<1

3456789A1=C1

3E99A87ED1F1EFA1895F787EDDA1-)3.16591A1 58A91FA151FEA1%7EE7A1A 75A1

,35/C1

1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

=C2C1

 71A81AD*AA18581FA1'5981CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

=CC1

:669E4A17AD87 7A1A818A4D7A1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC101

=CC1

(8581CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1"81

3456789A1=BC1

3ED7ED1CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC1"1

1

1



1

123456789AB AC67DEF65DC9

3A1 456789A1 4D8487A1 A1 697D76AA1 A1 69E8EEA1 A81 A1 9BA1 FA1 51 95F7E849567A1 6591 EF587ED1

F'7D8AD781 ,12342563789ABCDE34BF EB6E36A2F 4E71 ,19//1 6E91 A1 89578AAD81 FA1 5DA91 FA1 51

69E858A1 A81 F1 6EED1 71 A979ED81 FA1 EFA1 8E951 6E91 A1 89557C1 B1 7D89EF781 AD78A1 A1

55DA1 7AD87 7A1 6E985D81 91 '8FA1 FA1 51 8E7781 95F7E!7DF78A1 FA1 871 57D1 A81 91 A1

EFA169F787 1E99A6EDF5D8C1

ABB

8D4488C69E89682C5F89E5773E5365DC9D48894379

DEF365DC9E5C68C569869F5E8943795389

1A1 9566E981 91 A1 851 FA1 E985781 F1 7D789A1 347DE71 FA1 51 75D81 ,654E54F A3ED637F 53E365365F

4A31 ,880//1 ED89A1 A1 A1 851 FA1 E985781 71 51 5DA91 51 F651 A71 FA1 6584EE7A1

59F7E5579A1 A81 FA1 6584EE7A1 9%9E!5579AC1 3A6ADF5D8A1 F'5691 A1 858787A1 FA1

'@7A1 71 A78A1 FA1 7D51 E981 F'DA1 F9E75DA1 FA1 51 E985781 6591 5DA91 AD1 59E6A1 A81

:97A1F1-E9FA1CA171A15DA919A8AD815169A79A15A1FA1E985781F5D1A1654C1

15195F7E849567AA1AA1E1E%7DA1?1DA1589A1849567AA19A69AD8A161FA1"8D1FA189578AAD81

F1 5DA91 E2FC1 5D1 A1 89A1 ;$D1 FA1 6587AD81 895781 6E91 5DA91 FA957AD81 9AAE791 DA1

95F7E849567A1 F95D81 A91 89578AAD81 EFC1 7 9AD8A1 E87ED1 8A4DEE7A1 ED81 5781 EA91 A1

89578AAD81 6591 95F7E849567AC1 151 95F7E849567A1 GEDAD87EDDAAG1 A8A9DAA1 !H()A1 51 7D89EF781 51

7587ED1 F1 89578AAD81 F1 6587AD81 75D81 FA1 7D7FADA1 ,5D89E!6E897A9A1 ,:./1 A81 5895A/1

9IA1 ?1 FA1 69E*A87ED1 6591 954ED1 HC1 :A1 A88A1 8A4D7AA1 A1 FA7D1 EDEEA1 6E57AD81

E57A915669E7587AAD81518A9A1F7DA915197ED17%A191516A51FA16587AD81A81877A91FA1

4561F'7995F7587ED19A85D579A19IA151E758A91FA15958A917D579A1, C1#7C1BC2,5//C1

3A1 EFA1 FA1 89578AAD81 51 ED8781 478E97AAD81 A1 69A7A91 *5ED1 A91 DA1 95F7E849567A1 7FA1

6591'75A1,1E4FC6B4BFEB6A34E7F1/A15195F7E95647A185DF59F1DA16A9A885D81651A161

EAD81 51 757587ED1 FA1 7%A1 8E95AA1 AA681 A1 7ED1 EAAC1151 F7897%87ED1 FA1 FEA1

D'85781FED1651ED E9587EDDAA1A811'7995F7587ED1FA187157D185781FED176E985D8AC1#58A1FD1

7%5A1E6875A1A197A1FA18E77818578189E6176E985D816E91AD75A915E91DA1A55FA1FA1FEAA1

5E91A1519A587ED1FEA!A A818578189169E%5%A1AD18A9A1FA1ED89BA1E5C1

:A1 A1 FAE66AAD81 FA1 51 8A4DEE7A1 FA1 5958A9A1 FA1 7D E9587A1 ,9A5/1 A81 FA1

7D89587ED1 F75A1 F75AA1 51 95F7E849567A1 A81 AD89A1 F5D1 9A1 FA1 51 95F7E849567A1

ED E9587EDDAA11,!3()/1F5D1A15DDA12008C13AA!719A6EA191517587ED1F189578AAD81

?16598791F'75A15DDE95647AA1A816591877587ED1FA148A11FA165D7 7587ED1FA189578AAD81

,!).7/C1J9IA1518A4D7A1FA19AED8987ED1F'75AA1518A91A81A1E95DA1?197A1ED81

E571F5D1'A65A11A81A14561F'7995F7587ED16AAD81C89A15*81AD1ED7F95D8151K1A1FA1

51 E9A1L1 ,4E5F 474F 64/1 , C1 #7C1 BC2,%//C1 1A1 ).71 6A81 C89A1 8771 6E91 E6877A91 45A1

659589A1F169EA1F'7995F7587ED1A816E915A9151F7897%87ED1FA1FEA1?151 E7191518A91A81

A1E95DA1?197AA1DE85AD8175D81DA19A69AD8587ED16591478E95A1FEA!EA1,M=/1

EA1 "FC1 151 !3()1 6A9A81 FED1 FA1 F7897%87ED1 FA1 FEA1 61 ED E9587EDDAAA1 71 659DAD81

7A1A187157D1A819ADF16E7%A1FA1A55FA1FA1FEA1F5D1518A91E$FC11

1

"

151 95F7E849567A1 6591EF587ED1 F'7D8AD781 ,123425637F 9ABCDE34BF EB6A34E7F19/1 A8A1 5691 51

!3()1G85DF59FGA1DA1DEAA19E87ED18A4D7A171A81FAE66A169E9A7AAD81?16598791

FA15DDA18881E;FC15A19A6EA191'877587ED1 FA1E758A9187!5A1,13/16E91F77A91A1

4561 F'7995F7587ED1 AD1 E!456A1 A81 5*8A1 A1 69E 71 F'7D8AD781 75D81 45A1 5DA1 AD1

ED87ED1 FA1 ED8957D8A1 FA1 FEA!EA1 FA5DFA1 6591 A1 95F7E84956A8A1 A81 5A1 6591 D1

48A1FA165D7 7587ED17DA9AC13A88A18A4D7A1566E98A1DA17995F7587ED161ED E9587EDDAA1A81

4EEDA1FA1517%A18E81AD1659D5D817A1A187157DC15A1A816598779AAD8187A1F5D1A1

51FA17%A18E95A1FA1 E9A1ED5A1,8AA1A15169E858A/189169E4A1F'E95DA157D1EAD81

FA1 E9A1EDAA1,8A1A1A19A81AD151F7995F7587ED169E8587A/1, C1#7C1BC2,//C1B1 581E7DA91

76E985DA1 FA1 85%7AAD81 FA1 51 9A587ED1 FEA!EA1 N1 8E7781 E1 ED89BA1 E51 F5D1 A1

F7 9AD8A1E57587ED18E95A17995F7A1659A1AA1ED81DA579A1?1517A1AD1>9A1FA151

65D7 7587ED1 7DA9A1 71 FE781 96EDF9A1 ?1 FA1 E%*A87 1 FE7897AC1 17D89587ED1 FDA1 75A97A1

A%59A1F5D15958A9A16A9A885D81AD1659877A9151757587ED1FA1871E1,8A91A81

871 57D/1 51EAD81 FA1 51 5DA1 F7995F7587EDA151 6A971 571 A1 FAE66AAD81891 9AD81 A81

9751 FA1 8A4D7A1 FBJ()A1 F5D1 D1 E%*A87 1 FA1 E99A6EDF5DA1 AD89A1 FEA1 65D7 7A1 A81 FEA1

F79AC11

11

1

1

1,5/111111111111111111 1 1111,%/11 1 111111111111111111111111111111111,/1

12345647585699ABCDEC2F5B5CDF2B5D22E9B5C2AB55DE2FCDE25CD5E5 5!5"# 5556$ 5

ABB

DE8947E5659E896D556

9

73E5D 5CEF5689

151 6977ED1 FA1 51 95F7E849567A1 A81 FED1 E98AAD81 59A1 FA671 1 FADD7A1 5A1 A1

FAE66AAD81 FA1 8A4D7A1 F7995F7587ED1 FA1 61 AD1 61 E6AAC1 151 95F7E849567A1 A81 DA1

84EFA1 FA1 89578AAD811 EE97ED51 FA1 5DA9A1 8775D81 FA1 95F7587ED1 6E91 F8979A1 A1 AA1

5D9AA1 8E81 AD1 659D5D81 A1 871 57D1 6976497AC1 151 95F7E849567A1 FE781 9A6A8A91 A1

697D76A1FA1*87 7587ED1A81F'E6877587EDC1151*87 7587ED1FA151F77ED1F'7995F7A919A6EA191517A1

AD1 6595A1 FA1 55D85A1 FA1 51 95F7E849567A1 5A1 A1 7DEDD7AD8A1 AD1 A1 EDF5D81 91 A1

EDD575DA1F75A159AC11'E6877587ED1AD1 95F7E849567A1A1F 7D781EA1'ADA%A1FA1

69EF9AA17A1515165915A16A9A88AD81F'E%8AD791A1A7A919566E981%D 7AN97AA1'A8!?!F79A1

6A9A88AD81FA1F79A91F5D1D18A615F5681DA1FEA1E6875A1?1518A91A8151FEA15161 57%A1

6E7%A1F5D1A187157D1A81A1E95DA1?197A169E4A1FA1518A9C1CA1A18A4DEE7A1A1

6155DA18775D81FA164E8ED1,?1A7ED1FA1A89ED1A81FA169E8ED/11DA16AAD81659DA91

8E85AAD81 A1 871 57DC1 A1 8E7781 ED81 FED1 8E*E91 E%A9AA1 AD1 659877A91 F5D1 A1

ED8A8A1FA55FA1FA1FEAC1151E694AD7ED1FA1AA!71A81975AC15A1A819ADFA16E7%A1AD1

659877A91F1 5781F19A176E985D81FA18A4D7A1F7995F7587ED1ED E9587EDDAAA1545D81EDF781

?151 E71?1DA1FA97687ED17D7A1FA1A A81AEDF579A16197E9AA1A8198E81?15D54A1FA1

5897A1FA1FEA1FAADA1615A7%AC1111

1

$

ABB3B

99

!368F795CF3C69396D556973E5D 5CEF5689

775D81A1E57587ED18E95AA1A18E7781D9A165915195F7E849567A1ED818915975%A1F5D1

A91A69A7ED17D7A1A81A917D8AD78A17675D81FED1FA157 7587ED167 7A1C11518E7781

95F7E!7DF78A1A81 ED87ED1FA1F7 9AD81 58A9171A9ED81A7AAD81F978C11A917FAD87 7587ED1

A81975A1F5D1D1E%*A87 1FA169F787ED1FA1518E778O11

ABB"B

1756789E89355365DC9E89396D556973E5D 5CEF5689

B1 A81 DA579A1 FA1 69E6EA91 DA1 FA97687ED1 85DF59F1 E%*A87A1 6E91 95FA91 5D878587AAD81 A1

F7 9AD8A18E7781FA1F7 9AD81E95DAC1:1E7DA189E714AA1FA195F587ED1FA1E67587ED1

95F7E!7DF78A1ED818169E6EA1A7AAD81F5D1A18A61P1

2C 1'4AA1()@JN5@()3169E6EA16591A1 EB6E36A2F4E7F2ADA7FACF !16E91

A18E778157A1A816591A1"CA4E2FE26#E36A2F$AF454EFE2BF4E3423FA$F%E24F

"%!16E91A18E7781859F7A1E+A1<F1O1

C 1'4AA1 15-)N7@:1 DE34F 4$$435F A$F 2AEDF 3655C45&5C'4364F A'4364F E2E4423F

E2ED736/A1 69E6EA1 AD1 200$1 E0!2FA1 71 E99A6EDF1 ?1 51 FA9D79A1 A97ED1 FA1 '4AA1

()@JN5@()316E91A18E7781859F7A1A81518169E6EA16E919A65A915169FAD8A1

4AA15@()31O1

C 1'4AA1 3)3:51 ,%AA2F 462ADA7F %6346EF $AF (B454F "4235/1 71 A81 DA1

57 7587ED1 85DF59F7A1 FA1 A A81 AEDF579A1 877A1 6E91 5A91 A1 F7 9AD81

89578AAD81F15DA91,95F7E849567A1A81F9EA/C15A15181FAE66A16591A1)E36A2EDF

%E24F125363C34C1.7A91A97ED1A1ED81FAA1F5D1D1E%*A87 1FA1FA97687ED151

61697A1A81E%*A87A1FA1A A81AEDF579AA1571E1859F7 C11151A97ED158AA1A81

51 =C"C8A1 F585D81 FA1880C1 151 665981 FA1 A571 84956A87A1 A9E6AD1A81 59757D1

877AD815*E9F471A88A14AA1E2"FC1

:D55Q1E2$F15169E6E1DA1E65957ED1FA14AA115-)N7@:1A81()@JN5@()31A8151ED891A1

'4AA1 15-)N7@:1 A81 61 697A1 6E91 9566E98A91 A1 E67587ED1 859F7A1 F1 9A81 A81 FA1 51

A7AC1MEAA91E2;F15169E6E151CA1E65957ED16E915A91518E778185DA1A8151ED891DA1

697E9781 FA1 '4AA1 15-)N7@:1 6E91 51 8E7781 859F7AC1 3A1 F7 9AD8A1 4AA1 ED81 ADE9A1

EAD81E%7DA16E919566E98A91A18E778C1

ABBB

DE89E8947E565DC9E89396D5569347973E5D62734589

:A1A1FAE66AAD81FA15195F7E849567A1ED E9587EDDAAA1FA161AD161FA1FEDDA1FA1771

7D7A1ED8181EA8AC1:16598791FA1A1FEDDA17D7A1E%7DA151FEDDA1FE7897A1

A1 FA1 58A91 69F787 1 8E7781ED81 81 9A4A941 AD1 659877A91 AD1 7D895D81 A1 478E95A1

FEA!EA1 ,M=/A1 A1 9587EDDAAD81 A81 A1 8A4D7A1 F'7995F7587EDC1 A671 A1 5DDA1 +8A1 FA1

EFA1584587A16E915169F787ED1A815157 7587ED1FA1518E7781ED818169E6EC11.1

9AAD8A1 5A1 '5DAAD81 FA1 51 95F7E849567A1 7FA1 6591 '75A1 ,BJ()/A1 A1 84EFA1 FA1

69F787ED1 FA1 51 8E7781 6E99ED81 6E8AD87AAAD81 F65A91 A1 778587ED1 7A1 ?1 '877587ED1

F'7D E9587ED1 A7AAD81 6984956A87A1 6E91 5A91 A91 FA1 EFA1 69F787 1

897F7AD7EDDA1 69AD5D81 AD1 E68A1 A1 F E9587ED1 9AD5D81 AD1 E91 FA1 89578AAD8C1 .7A91

659589A1ED818157D717DF77F57P1

1

;

1'M=16A9A81DA15D87 7587ED1A81DA1757587ED1FA11519A587ED1AD89A151FEA19ARA1A81A1

EA1F'E95DA1E99A6EDF5D8C11A1 58A91FEA!EA1ED818189159AAD818771

6E91 51 69F787ED1 FA1 51 8E778C1 3A1 58A91 7DAD81 P1 51 FEA1 575A1 ,



E*

/A1 51 FEA1

7D75A1 ,



62

/A1 51 FEA1 E4ADDA1 ,



4E2

/1 A81 A1 6E9AD85A1 FA1 EA1 9AA5D81 DA1

A9857DA1FEA1,

+

BA54

/C1

1'8FA1516159A191A1 58A915181957A17D7875AAD8165915571E2+F1AD12002A171

78A1A19A587ED1AD89A1 58A91FEA!EA1A8169F787ED1FA1$D1A81$8D1FA1DAAD81FA1

8E778A16E91<1E95DA17995F715A1D1771FA1$15DC13A6ADF5D8A1F1 5781FA11778A1FA1

8A4D7A1FA195F7E849567AA1A88A18FA1DA19A6EA1A191DA1F777ED1FA187157D1AD1

89E7165987A1,2NA1N1A811N1F1EA/1A8191FA169E%5%7781FA18E7781778A1?1$D1A81

$8DC1 1A1 8E7781 F978A1 ED81 5AAD81 EAD81 5*E9F471 6A1 E%A9AC1 3A88A1

6%7587ED1 69E6EA1 FED1 7D5AAD81 DA1 FA97687ED1 5669E7587A1 D1 6A1 F65A1 1 FA1

9A587ED1AD89A1A1 58A91FEA!EA1A818E778C1

5D1 88+A1 '::.1 ,(46E2F (55A6E36A2F A$F ,7566535F 62F 94B6624/1 A81 ':7)(@1 ,(46E2F

-A6437F$AFEB6E36A2F2ADA7/1ED8169E6E1A169E*A81&6:-)531,./(2363E364F)AEDF655C"F

AB4D5F62F34F%D626/A1714D8487A1A815857A1A19A587ED1AD89A1 58A91FEA!EA1A81

69F787ED1 FA1 51 8E7781 6E91 2<1 E95DA1 E2<FC1 3A1 895571 61 9AD81 A81 FED1 FAAD1 51

9 9ADAC1

C EA1D7 E9A1175AD8AP1

151 FEA1 75AD8A1 D7 E9A1 ,"/F "0C6ED423F /26$AF A54/1 51 81 69E6EA1 7D7875AAD81

6591 -7A7A9QE1 AD1 200+1 E20FC1 5A1 6A9A81 FA1 EDA98791 DA1 F7897%87ED1 DED1 D7 E9A1 AD1

F7897%87ED1 FA1 FEA1 D7 E9A1 545D81 A1 CA1 A A81 %7EE7A1 E1 7D7A1 ,ED89BA1

E5N8E778/C1 5D1 2000A1 -7A7A9QE1 51 69E6E1 'A8AD7ED1 FA1 '561 51 561 ,424EDF "//1

6E91F979A151FEA19ARA16591A187157D1E8FC11A151FA1'561DA19A6EA1A191D1

A1 659589AA1 DE81 aA1 F 7D71 75D81 A1 59589787A1 FEA!EA1 FA1 E95DA1 , 1

A87ED1BBBC2/C1.591AA6AA15DF1'561A81877A16E91F979A1D1E95DA1?197AA1a151DA1

5A91 6E787A1P1 6E91 A1 E95DA1 AD1 97A1 EA1 A1 9A81 E1 51 EAA1 67D79AA1

(

0

,

20

]

∈

a

A1 A1 5A91 AA1 9ADF5D81 '561 61 AD7%A1 51 6E7D81 45F1 ,DA1 FEA1

AA191D16A8781EA/1O16E91A1E95DA1AD16595AA1EA1A16EEDA1A1 E7A1E1

A1 9A7DA1

a

∈

( )

0

,

1

A1 A1 57%A1 5A91 9ADF5D81 '561 61 AD7%A1 51 SEDA1 9E7FA1 ,FA1

57%A1 FEA1 91 FA1 95DF1 EA/1 E8A1 2FC1 3ED89579AAD81 51 A71 6E985D81 91 A1

58A91 FEA!EAA1 A1 51 FA1 '561 9A6EA1 91 51 F777ED1 FA1 'E95DA1 AD1 E!D781

E897A1 A81 ED7F9A1 51 FEA1 F5D1 45D1 F'AC1 1'561 51 57D71 DA1 A7A9A1

E99A6EDF5DA1 %7EE7A1 EFC1 A1 89551 ED81 57D71 ED891 '71 A78A1 DA1 9A587ED1

7D7 7587A1 AD89A1 '561 A81 51 69E%5%7781 FA1 8E7781 EA1 "F1 A81 A1 '561 6A81 FED1 C89A1

877A1EA1 58A91F'5587ED1F197A1FA18E7781A81C89A17DE96E9A1F5D151 ED87ED1

E%*A87 16E91'E6877587ED1FA1'B()C1

C EFA1)AEDF655C4F%AD6E36A2F,AE6D6371,-)3./1P1

15169F787ED1FA1518E7781?16598791FA15A918AA1A1D

max

A1D

mean

1E1D

dose

1DA16A9A81651FA1

69ADF9A1AD1E68A1'ADA%A1FA1'478E95A1FEA!EA1A815196598787ED1FA151FEA191

'ADA%A1 F1 EA1 FA1 'E95DAC1 1A1 EFA1 -)3.1 ,)AEDF 655C4F %AD6E36A2F

,AE6D637/16A9A88AD81FA1AA91A88A1778AC1

!197847E1E$F1517D7875AAD8169E6E1AD120+<1A169A7A91EFA1584587A176A1FA1

69F787ED1FA18E7781,3.#A1AD6E36A2FAE6D637F$E3A/A171F77A1A1E95DA157D1AD1D1

1

+

ADA%A1F'AD81FA1EA17DF6ADF5D815E71?1FA16E7F19A6A87 C11515A913.#1

E99A6EDF1?151EA16EDF9A1FA1A1AD81FA1EAC11A1EFA13.#1A81D19789A1

FA157 7587ED1A816A81C89A187716E91E659A915669E7587AAD81F7 9AD81451FA1

89578AAD8C1145D1E;F1517DF71A1K1D4FAB1D4F%,2F453FC24F56D4F$A236A2FBA5483A254F

A2B334FEFD4FADC4F43F6DF453F4A22CF0C6DF354234F43E6245F625C$$65E245F42FE36CD64F

D6345F ECF $E63F 0C4F 5EF AE6D633F B4F 3A*6633F453F 2A2F A234F 43F D623E64F 42F $A236A2F BCF ADC4F

E5ADCFB4F3655CF6EB63FLC1

!11A1EFA11231,145D!284A9!395D/11A81A1EFA1-)3.1A161EDD1A81A161877C1

145D1 E+F1 A81 A1 69A7A91?1 5E791 69E6E1 51EF7587ED1 FA1 51 96EDA1 ?1 51 FEA1 6591 DA1

ED87ED17ETFA1,56A6BFBA54F45A254F -!/16E91F979A1'76581FA151FEA15691DA1

7995F7587ED1D7 E9A18E85A1E165987AAC11

!1 .591 51 78AA1 284A9A1 395D1 E<A1 0F1 A81 145D1 E8F1 ED81 69E6E1 A7AAD81 FA1

84EFA1 FA1 9F87ED1 FA1 'M=1 6E91 767 7A91 A1 EFA1 7(A1 A1 9ADF5D81 57D71 8775%A1

6E915169F787ED1FA1518E77817A1?1DA17995F7587ED1DED!D7 E9A1A8165987AA1FA1E95DAC1

!1A1CAA17484A7A1295D1A81U5QED1ED8169E6E1A7AAD81A1EFA1-)3.1

75D81P1 EFA1 1E78!561 E2FA1 EFA1 FA1 7484A71 E2FA1 EFA1 .E7ED!561 EFA1

EFA1FA1295D1EF1A81EFA16595A1E!$FC11

1A1 6E7D81 ED1 FA1 'ADA%A1 FA1 A1 EFA1 A81 FA1 66EA91 A1 A1 871 57D1 ED81

E6E1 F'D1 ADA%A1 F'AD81 FA1 EA1  75AD81 6A8781 6E91 A1 A91

7995F7587ED1 67A1 C89A1 ED7F9A1 EA1 D7 E9AC1 345A1 EFA1 E99A6EDF1 ?1 DA1

ED87ED1 FA1 FAD781 FA1 69E%5%7781 575D81 E99A6EDF9A1 DA1 69E%5%7781 FA1 8E7781 ?1 DA1

5A91 985D81 FA1 51 9F87ED1 FA1 'M=C1 345A1EFA1 9A6EA1 91 D1 DE%9A1 9F781 FA1

659589A1,FA1E189E7/171ED81F9781F5D1A1456789A1BBC1

"C :89A15669E4A1FA169F787ED1P1

5D161FA1 58A91A81FA1EFA169F787 1AD87EDD17!FAA1FA184EFA19A6E5D81

91 A1 89578AAD81 FA1 '7D E9587ED1 ED81 81 69E6E1 6E91 51 69F787ED1 FA1 51 8E778A1 5A1

DE85AD81 A1 9A51 FA1 DA9EDA1 ,DA41AD1 20001 E;F/A1 A184EFA1 FA157 7587ED1

,)45A1 AD1 88"1 E+F/A1 51 57F587ED1 9E7A1 ,51 -551 AD1 88;1 E<F/A1 FA1 84EFA1

858787A1 9A6E5D81 91 A1 75A1 5D58E7A1 ,A541 AD1 88<1 E0F/A1 A1 84EFA1 6591

DEE95A1 ,=5F5D71 AD1 8801 E"8F/1 A81 AD 7D1 A184EFA1 %5A1 585A1 9A6E5D81 91 A1

9A55A1 587A1 FA1 75A1 5DDA91 F'DA1 6E6587ED1 FA1 6587AD81 A91 D1 6587AD81 FA1

9 9ADA1 FA1 5RED1 ?1 5A91 7DF6ADF5AD81 51 AD7%7781 FA1 F7 9AD8A1 97ED1 FA1

E95DA1,:E851AD18281E"2F/C1

AB#B

$F865DC9CDC97DF89DC87C3C693947E565DC9E89396D55698C939

E%A&'9869D"(8659E89396289

U'5E915169F787ED1FA1518E7781AD195F7E849567A19A6EA191FA1EFA1E1FA184EFA1FA1

57 7587EDC1 :A1 A1 E87A1 A1 FA7D1 A81 A1 64477AD1 F751 6AAD81 69F79AA1 55D81 A1

89578AAD8A1 51 69E%5%7781 F'E99ADA1 FA1 51 8E7781 A81 57D71 E659A91 5D878587AAD81 F7 9AD81

65D1FA189578AAD8C13A6ADF5D8A171%78A1D1A9857D1DE%9A1FA1A87EDA17D5D81P1

2C 151 E65957ED1 FA1 565781 69F787A1 FA1 F7 9AD81 EFA1 -)3.C1 A1 89551

69E6EAD81 51 E65957ED1 FA1 F7 9AD81 EFA1 -)3.1 6E91 51 69F787ED1 FA1 51 8E7781

5E7A1 ?1 D1 E95DA1 FEDDC1 3A6ADF5D8A1 71 D'41 51 65A1 ?1 DE89A1 EDD575DAA1 F'8FA1

E6595D81'ADA%A1FA171EFA1E<A12!FC1

1

<

C 1'7FAD87 7587ED1 FA1 5A91 FA1 659589A1 FA1 EFAC1 5D1 A A8A1 71 A1 84EFA1

F'E6877587ED1 ED81 891 DE%9AAA1 71 D'41 51 65A1 ?1 DE89A1 EDD575DAA1 FA1 89551

E6595D81F7 9AD8A15669E4A16E917FAD87 7A91A15A91FA1659589A1FA1EFAC11

C 1'8FA1 FA1 51 565781 FA1 EFA1 69F787 1 ?1 69F79A1 67 7AAD81 51 8E7781

75AC1 B1 51 81 ED891 A1 A1 EFA1 -)3.1 ED81 69F787 1 6E91 51 8E7781 9A85A1

F5D1D1ED8A8A1FA195F7E849567A1F15DA91FA15169E858A1A81FA15A91FA1659589A1

ED81 81 69E6EAC1 3A6ADF5D8A1 ?1 DE89A1 EDD575DAA1 5D1 895571 D'51 FED891 51

56578169F787A1FA1EFA1-)3.1F5D1A151FA151A7AC1

"C 1'877587ED1FA1EFA1-)3.1A81FA1589A1 58A91%7EE7A16E91'E6877587ED1FA1

'B()C1 771 '561 51 81 %A5E61 877A1 6E91 '5587ED1 FE7897A1 A81 6E91

'E6877587ED1FA1'B()A1A1589A1 58A91%7EE7AA1EA1A1)3.1A81A1-)3.A1ED81

891 6A1 8771 F5D1 A1 658A! E9A1 EA975A1 F'B()1 A81 A1 6E7F1 9A587 1 AD89A1

58A916447A1A81%7EE7A1D'ED81651818F7C1

$C 1A1 659589A1 FA1 F7 9AD81 EFA1 -)3.1 6AAD81 F6ADF9A1 571 F'589A1

659589A1 DED1 FE7897A1 545D81 D1 76581 91 51 8E778A1 8A1 A1 FA1 89578AAD81

5E71 EA1 51 477E849567AC1 17FAD87 7587ED1 FA1 A1 659589A1 AD1 ED87ED1 FA1

89578AAD815E71DA8165185%7AC1

;C 151 E99A87ED1 FA1 EFA1 -)3.1 895F787EDDA1 6E91 A1 F7 9AD81 846A1 FA1

9587EDDAAD8C1 1A1 EFA1 -)3.1 57A1 ED81 81 85%71 ?1 6598791 FA1 51 FEA1

%7EE7A1 5%E9%A1 6591 A1 871 57DC1 3A6ADF5D8A1 71 51 6E6587ED1 FA1 6587AD81

ED7F9A1 51 81 89578A1 5A1 D1 1 9587EDDAAD81 F7 9AD8A1 A1 EFA1 57A1

FE7AD81C89A15F5681AD1895D E95D8151FEA16447A1AD1FEA1%7EE7AC11

1

1

0

1

123456789AAB

AE8C655365DC9869D43735DC9E89DE89E8947E565DC9

E89396D5569)DE89*'1+,9

3A1 456789A1 69E6EA1 '7FAD87 7587ED1 A81 51 E65957ED1 FA1 51 565781 69F787A1 FA1 F7 9AD81

EFA1 -)3.1 F5D1 A1 5F9A1 F1 5DA91 FA1 51 69E858A1 ,8E7781 859F7A1 9A85A1 A81 75A/1 A81 F1

5DA91%9ED47A1DED1?16A878A1AA1,8E778157VA1>E6457ADDA/C1

AABB

AC67DEF65DC9F798959DE89*'1+9869D"(8659EF967335989

DC87C3C69

1'E%*A87 1FA15195F7E849567A1A81FA1577A91'7995F7587ED1FA1518A918E81AD17785D81585D81A1

6E7%A1518E7781FA1E95DA157DC115169F787ED1FA1518E77816A815E791D176581F79A819151

65D7 7587ED1 F1 89578AAD81 AD1 6A9A885D81 F'A87A9A1 A81 FED1 FA1 E659A9A1 51 8E7781 7DF78A1 6591

F7 9AD8A1FEA165D7 7AC13A88A169F787ED1FA1518E77819A6EA1D95AAD8191FA1EFA1FA1

8E778A1 A1 EFA1 -)3.C1 B1 9A6EAD81 91 A1 478E95A1 FEA!EA1 ,M=/1 587 1

9A69AD85D81A1EA1F'DA18989A19AA5D81DA1FEA15A1E1697A9A1?1DA1FEA1FEDDAA1

95D8157D71DA1F7897%87ED1FA1FEA11,E7916591AA6A151 79A1BBBC2/C1771EFA1-)3.1ED81

81 69E6E1 FA671 20+<C1 B1 9A6EAD81 8E1 91 FA1 659589A1 FED81 51 5A91 FE781 C89A1 E6877A1

75D81 FA1 %5A1 FA1 FEDDA1 FA1 771 FA1 6587AD8C1 A1 89551 FA1 51 7889589A1 ED81 69E6E1 FA1

5A91FA1659589A16E91D1EFA1E16A15715D1D'51ADE9A169E6E1FA18E1A1E6877A91

A81FA1A1E659A916E91A87EDDA91A1EFA1545D8151A7A9A156578169F787AC11

1

1A1 E%*A87 1 FA1 A1 895571 857AD8A1 F5D1 D1 5F9A1 FA1 69F787ED1 FA1 8E7781 859F7A1 9A85A1 A81

75A1 AD1 51 FA1 95F7E849567A1 69E8587A1 A81 F'>E64578A1 57W1 AD1 51 FA1 95F7E849567A1 F1

5DA91%9ED47A1DED1?16A878A1AA1P1

!1F'76AD8A91'ADA%A1FA171EFA1-)3.A1

!1F'7FAD87 7A91A15A91FA1659589A1-)3.A1

!1 FA1 E659A91 'ADA%A1 FA1 EFA1 -)3.1 6E91 F8A97DA91 A71 E1 A1 FED81 51 5A91

69F787A1A8151A7A9AC11

AABB3B DE89-./9)-03C .F6287 /F73C,9

1A1 EFA1 -)3.1 A1 61 8771 A81 A1 EFA1 K1145D!284A9!395D1L1,EFA1 123/1 71 51 81

7D891 51 48A1 FA1 65D7 7587ED1 FA1 89578AAD81 ,)4E3423F ,DE2262F -7534F ,-/1 .7DD5AX1 AD1

75D81 A1 5A91 FA1 659589A1 69E6EA1 6591 395D1 E"A1 "FC1 145D1 E+F1 55781 7D7875AAD81

69E6E151EF7587ED1FA15196EDA1?151FEA16591DA1 ED87ED17ETFA1,E7916591AA6A151 79A1

BBC$/1 71 F9781 51 9A587ED1 AD89A1 51 FEA1 D7 E9A1 D1 F79A1 ?1 8E81 E1 65987A1 FA1 'E95DA1 A81 51

69E%5%7781FA18E7781P1

1

1

∞ − −

=

t x

dx

e

NTCP

22

2

1

π

1

,C12/

EY1P11

1

28

1

(

( )

)

₍

_{( )}

₎

1

1

50 50

TD

m

TD

D

t

⋅

−

=

1

,C1/

A81P1

1

( )

( )

n i n i i

d

v

D

v

D

−

2

3

4

5

6

7

⋅

⋅

=

₅₀

8

1 50

1

1

,C1/

3A1EFA1E68A1FED189E71659589A1P1

!

D

50

(1)1719A69AD8A1518E95DA1FA1'E95DA1?1'7995F7587ED1AD19A69AD85D8151FEA17A1

?1DA169E%5%7781FA1$8D1F'5E791DA18E7781O1

!

m171595897A1516AD8A1FA15196EDA1?151FEA1516E7D81D

50

(1)1O1

!

n1719A69AD8A1'A A81FA1EAC1&5DF1n1A8169E4A1FA18A1'A A81FA1EA1A81 57%A1

A81 'E95DA1 A81 EAD81 57 71 F'1K1E95DA1 AD1 97A1LA1 EA1 51 EAA1 67D79A1 E1 A1

9A81O171n1A8169E4A1FA12A1'A A81FA1EA1A8176E985D81A81'E95DA1A8157 71FA1

K16595A1LA1EA1A16EED1E1A1659E87FAC11

:169E6E1FA15A916E7%A1F1659589A12A1395D1E"F1517DF71P14F,C650C4FB45FED4C5F$E6D45F

BCFEE134F2FACFB45F3655C5FACFAE245F5E625F5626$6423FC24FB342BE24F6A3E234FBCF)%,FECF

ADC4F ACFB4F$E5A2F30C6ED4234FC24FE2B4FB342BE24FB4FDEFAE6D633FB4F3A*6633FE4FDEFBA54!F

0CE2BF2F5EA4FB4F6FDEF33AB4FB4F3BC36A2FB653AE4F$E63F0C4FDEFAE6D633F35CD3E234F

453FB3346234FEFDEFBA54FDEFDC5F3D434FB4F653AE47F.CE2BF2F453FA4FB4FDC2633FD30CE36A2F

( )

( )

n

v

v

TD

TD

1

=

⋅

F$E63F0C4F56FDEFBA54F43FD4FADC4FB4FD653AE4F5A23FAB6$635FB4F34DD4F$E5A2F0C4F

D4CFABC63F453FA2543FDEFAE6D633FB4F3A*6633F453F4DD4FEC556FA254347F(6256F0CE2BF2F453FA4F

B4F8FDEFAE6D633FB4F3A*6633F453FA3D34F9FD6233ED4FB4FDEFBA547FL1

.E91789A91519A587ED1AD89A1A1659589A1F1EFA1A815169E%5%7781985D8AA1A189E71 79A1

75D8A1ED89A1'E87ED1FA15169E%5%7781FA18E7781,6E91D1ADA%A1FA16587AD81588A7D81F'D1

5DA91FA169E858A/1AD1 575D81597A91D1A1FA189E71659589AC1

1

1

1

123456647585

%&F9AC2F559E5DF!E!292C5BC2'55(E2BEC5&ED2D5EA5B5"5EDE')CDB553EA5*5DF2C585D50(1), n et m5FAD595 'F)95+,-

45

5

AABB"B DE89-D56 129869DE89E8932F62859

1A1EFA11E78!561A81FA17484A71ED818E1FA18169E6E165917484A71AD120<1E2FC11A1

EFA11E78!561A81DA1587ED1E787A15A1DA184EFA1FA19F87ED1FA1'M=19A6E5D8191

'561P1

1

22

1

1 50

(

1

)

1

)

,

(

−

9

9

A

B

C

C

D

E

2

3

4

5

6

7

+

=

k

D

D

v

d

NTCP

1

,C1"/

EY1D1A81'"/16E91DA17995F7587ED165987AA1A817D4EEDA1P1

1

n n i i i

d

v

EUD

2

3

4

5

6

7 8

=

1

1

,C1$/

k1 A81 A1 58A91 FA1 6AD8A1 A81 D

50

(1) 51 8E95DA1 FA1 'E95DAC1 1A1 659589A1 n1 A81 7D89A1 EA1

58A91FA1EA1A A87 A1?1'587ED1FA19F87ED16E91E%8AD791'56C13A189E71659589A1ED81A1

CA1AD1A16E91A1EFA1123C1

1A1EFA1FA17484A71ED7F9A1A1'E95DA1A81E6E1FA1 N1E!D78C115169A79A1856A1

A81 FA1 5A91 A1 -)3.1 6E91 DA1 E!D781 i

1

75D81 DA1 587ED1 E787AA1 671 FA1 5A91 A1

-)3.16E91'ADA%A1FA1'E95DA1P1

1

(

)

∏

[

(

)

]

=

−

−

=

N i v v ref i ref

v

d

NTCP

v

d

NTCP

1 /

,

1

1

,

1

_,C1;/

EY1P1

1

(

)

1 50

1

,

−

9

A

B

C

D

E

2

3

4

5

6

7

+

=

k i ref i

_d

D

v

d

NTCP

1

,C1+/

3A1EFA1E6E98A1FED1FA1659589A1P1D

50

1A81kC1

AABBB DE89+D5DC9129869DE89E89.43C9

1A1 EFA1 .E7ED!561 A81 FA1 295D1 ED81 8E1 FA1 81 69E6E1 6591 295D1 AD1 2001 EFC1 1A1

EFA1.E7ED1561A81DA1587ED1FA1.E7ED15A1D1451FA19F87ED1F'M=1FA1846A1561P1

1

(

)

2 2 3 4 5 5 6 7 22 3 4 55 6 7 − −

=

50 1 exp

2

,

D EUD e

v

d

NTCP

γ

1

,C1</

EY1P1

1

n n i i i

d

v

EUD

2

3

4

5

6

7 8

=

1

1

,C10/

1A1659589A1ED81A1CA1AD1A16E91A1EFA1123C11A1FA1EFA19A6EAD8191A1CA1

451?1FA1856A1A1A1EFA11E78!561A81FA17484A7C13A6ADF5D81A1EFA1FA1295D1

5189E71659589AA1D

50

A111A81s1P1

1

₍

₎

N

[

_{( )}

]

s i v s i i

D

P

v

d

NTCP

1 1

1

1

,

F











−

−

=

_∏

= ∆

1

,C128/

AABBEB DE89437389

1A1 EFA1 6595A1 51 81 69E6E1 6591 ZE %598A1 -7A7A9QE1 A81 U5QED1 E!$F1 AD1 200C1 1'E95DA1

ED7F91 A81 66E1 C89A1 E6E1 FA1 E!D781 ED87EDDAA1 7DF6ADF5D8A1 ,2C236A2EDF

-CC2635F2-//A1E95D7A175D81DA159478A89A16595AC11518E7781566595[815E91D7AAD8171

A1DE%9A1FA1#761ADFE5A1A81697A91?1519A9A1 ED87EDDAA1F16587AD8C11515A91-)3.1

A81 51 69E6E987ED1 FA1 6587AD81 545D81 DA1 9A9A1 ED87EDDAA1 7D 97A9A1 ?1 51 9587ED1 FA1 'E95DA1

ADFE5A1P1

NTCP

=

H

( )

f

1EY1f1A8151 9587ED1FA1'E95DA1ADFE5A1A81H(f)1A8151 ED87ED1FA1

96598787ED1 FA1 51 9A9A1 ED87EDDAA1 6E91 51 6E6587ED1 FA1 6587AD8C1 1A1 EFA1 9A6EA1 91 DA1

ED87ED1FA196598787ED15A1589A1659589A1P1

1

2

!

k A1 58A91FA16AD8A171F8A97DA15178AA15A15AA15169E%5%7781F'589587ED1FA1

#7615AD8A15A151FEA d

1/2

1O

!

V50 A8 :



1P1A1EFA166EA1A151 ED87ED1FA196598787ED1FA1519A9A1 ED87EDDAA1

6A81C89A1F978A1EA1DA1 ED87ED1F'A99A91,E1 ED87ED1F'A99A91FA1J5A1FA1 E9A1

7ETF5A/1 67 7A1 6591 51 5A91 E4ADDA1 FA1 51 9A9A1 ED87EDDAA1 V

50

A81 6591 51

59A91FA151F7897%87ED1FA19A9A1 ED87EDDAA1:

F

P1

1

( )

1

(

)

9

A

B

C

D

E

₋

₋

=

=

f v v

v

v

dv

f

H

v

d

NTCP

0 2 2 50 2

exp

2

2

1

)

,

(

σ

πσ

1

,C122/

EY1P1

1

=

8

( )

i i i

p

d

v

f

1

_,C12/

A81P1

1

( )

₉

9

A

B

C

C

D

E

2

2

3

4

5

5

6

7

+

=

k i

d

d

d

p

₁

₁

12

1

_,C12/

1

1'ADA%A1FA1EFA169AD81A814D848716591A185%A517!FAEC1

1

1

E!9EA57585

./C)B5B5'F)9B5FB2DB45

1

AABB

AE8C655365DC9E89DE89437935F9E897358"3C89

1A1 5A91 FA1 659589A1 FA1 45D1 FA1 EFA1 ED81 81 7FAD87 7A1 75D81 A1 571 FA1

957A%5DAC1.E91D16587AD81iA1A81A1A1E781A1EFA1ED7F9A1515A91F1-)3.16A81C89A1

9A69AD8A16591DA1 ED87ED1F6ADF5D81FA15A91FA1A1659589A1A81FA145D87ED1FA1'M=1

F16587AD81P1

1

NTCP

_i

=

F

(

parameters

,

d

_i

,

v

_i

)

1

,C12"/

151 E!957A%5DA1 L1 A81 5E91 5A1 91 'ADA%A1 F'DA1 %5A1 FA1 FEDDA1 FA1 6587AD8C1 .E91

45A16587AD81iA1A15A91FA1FEA1d

i

A1A81A1EA15E71v

i

1ED8171FA1'M=1F7 9AD87AC13A81

1

2

478E95A1F7 9AD87A1A816955%AAD81DE9571FA18AA1 5RED1A151EA1FA1v

i

1E7815A1?1

21 A81 A1 A1 d

i

A1 5691 F777ED1 6591 51 FEA1 575A1 D

i

1 ?1 'E95DA1 ED7F9A1 57AD81 DA1 5A91

575A169E4A1FA12C1-E8ED1d

ij

1A81v

ij

1A1AD81FA1A8A91d

i

1A81v

i

A1EY1j19A69AD8A1'7DF7A1FA151

5A1FA1'M=1F7 9AD87A1F16587AD81 iC15D1'587ED17!FAEA1 R

i

\2171A16587AD81i151%71FA151

8E7781A81R

i

\817DEDC1L1A815E91F 7D716591P1

1

(

)

8

(

( )

(

)

)

−

−

+

=

i Ri i Ri i

p

p

v

d

Parameters

L

,

,

log

log

1

1

1

_,C12$/

1'E%*A87 1A81FED1FA189EA91A15A91FA1659589A16E91AAA1515A91FA1L1A817D75AC1

.E91 A1 579AA1 FA1 84EFA1 F'E6877587EDA1 FAE66A1 AD1 :)1:31 1 ,)4A1 584ZE9QA1 BDC/1 A81

F978A17!FAEA1ED8181877AC1

AAB#B

5D756289E%D4655365DC9

B1 41 FA1 95DFA1 57A1 F'5E9784A1 F'E6877587ED1P1 A1 5E9784A1 F8A97D78A1 A81 A1

5E9784A18E4587AC1

1A1 5E9784A1 F8A97D78A1 DA1 9A6EAD81 651 91 '877587ED1 FA1 5975%A1 558E79AC1 .7A91

A87ED1F'DA1CA184EFAA1?16598791F'DA17D78757587ED17FAD87AA1 E9D79ED81FED18E*E91A1

CA1 9858C1 .5971 A1 84EFA1 A1 89EAD81 DE85AD81 A1 84EFA1 F1 76AA1 ,DA1

DA785D81651FA151FA1F97A/A1F195F7AD81E1F195F7AD81ED*1,9A6E5D8191A1F97A1

65987AA1 F'E9F9A1 2A1 5A1 5D5487AAD81 E1 D97AAD8/A1 FA1 -A]8EDA1 E1 57!-A]8ED1

,9A6E5D81 91 'A87587ED1 FA1 F97A1 65987AA1 F1 AEDF1 E9F9A/C1 3A1 84EFA1 ED81 EA1

59589787A1F'C89A19567FA1571571FA197A91FA1EDA9A91A91D17D71E5C15A1ED81

5F568A1?1FA169E%A1EY151 ED87ED1?17D77A91A81EDAAC1

151 84EFA1 F1 76AAA1 69E6EA1 6591 JAE9A1 5D8S71 AD1 20"+A1 5781 65987A1 FA1 A1 84EFA1

F8A97D78AC1 5D1 %85DAA1 AA1 9A6EA1 91 51 ED7F9587ED1 F'D1 76AAA1 'A8!?!F79A1 F'D1

6E4F9A1 FA1 N+11 EA81 6E91 D1 A65A1 FA1 9A4A94A1 FA1 F7AD7ED1 N1 ,D1 8975DA1 AD1 1

F7AD7EDA1DA164957FA1AD11F7AD7EDA1A8C/C1:145A1856A1FA1519A4A94AA1D1DEA516E7D81

A81ED7F91F5D1E1515%E9F1F176AAC11515A91FA151 ED87ED1AD1A16E7D81A81E659A1?1

AA1 FA1 EA81 F1 76AA1 A8A1 D95AAD8A1 D1 FA1 EA81 A81 9A651 6591 A1 DEA51

6E7D8C1 6D1 DEA51 76AA1 A81 57D71E%8ADC1 3A1 69EA1 A81 7891 *'?1 A1 A1 A1 F7589A1 F1

76AA1E7817D 97A91?1DA18E95DA1FEDDAC13A88A15669E4A151DE85AD81EA155D85A1FA1DA1

651 DA78A91 A1 51 FA1 F97A1 FA1 51 ED87ED1 E%*A87 C1 .591 ED89AA1 85D81 FEDDA1 51 D589A1

F8A97D78AA1AA1A81AD7%A1?1ED17D78757587ED1F5D1A151EY151 ED87ED1E%*A87 1D'A81651EDAAC1

:7D7A16E91DA1CA1 ED87ED1E%*A87 1DED1EDAAA1FA1E6877587ED17D78757A1F7 9AAD81DA1

EDA9A9ED81651 E9AD81A91A1CA19858C11

151 ED87ED1?17D77A916E917FAD87 7A91A15A91FA1659589A1FA1EFA1-)3.1A8151 ED87ED1

FA1 E!957A%5DAA1 91 5AA1 71 D'41 51 651 F'EF 6A61 'AA1 E781 EDAAC1 1'877587ED1 FA1

84EFA1 F'E6877587ED1 F8A97D78A1 FE781 FED1 C89A1 69FAD8AC1 6DA1 A697ADA1 51 81 ADA1 6E91

5A91 51 D589A1 EDAA1 FA1 51 ED87ED1 FA1 E!957A%5DAC1 1A1 FEDDA1 ED7F9A1

E99A6EDFAD81 ?1 51 8E7781 9A85A1 FA1 95FA1 697A91 E1 51 ?1 A1 5A1 D1 771 FA1 $1 5D1 ,61 FA11

F8571A9ED81FEDD1F5D1A1456789A1BBB/C1

)E81 F'5%E9FA1 5184EFA1F1 76AA1 51 81A8A1 F71 E71 5A1 FA1 7D78757587ED1A87EDDA1

558E79AAD8C11A185%A511ED89A1A198581FA1F71E6877587EDC11

1

1

1

2"

)

$8

,2/1,J4/1

D1

1

1E!957A%5DA1 8A61F'A87ED1,/1

++C0+8"1

8C882+1

8C20+1

2C22+1

$C2<<1

++C0+8"1

8C882<1 8C20+821

2C22+1

+C;$;1

++C0+8"<1

8C882+1 8C20+821

2C22+1

$C"<$1

++C0+8"$1

8C882+1

8C20+1

2C22+1

;C<"1

++C0+8"<1

8C882+1 8C20+821

2C22+1

;C021

++C0+8"21

8C882<1 8C20+821

2C22+1

+C2801

++C0+8"+1

8C882+1 8C20+821

2C22+1

;C+81

;+C8""0$1

8C0$2"21 8C880$<1

;0C80001

C0+1

2C<<0801

8C8+;$1 8C20<+1

02+C822<1

2C$8$$1

++C0+8""1

8C882<1 8C20+821

2C22+1

$C82;1

E!9EA5585

0EDE')CDB52C2(2B5FAD595'F)95+,-5C5&E9ADB5(2E9B559E5(FC2F5F!1C2(5ED)B5725AC2FB559E5'CF5A5 B2'945 1

A1957587ED1FA15184EFA1,51<

7A

1A81510

7A

/198AD81AD1FA15A91F7 9AD8A1FA1589A1

E6877587EDC13A517DF7A1DA1DED!EDA781FA151 ED87ED1E%*A87 A1A81DE85AD815169ADA1F'D1

7D71E5151D7A51FA15A91ED7F9A116E91A1659589AC1.E91789A91A8156A8A151

5A91 F1 659589A1 n1 51 81 7A1 ?1 8C81 ,5A91 7FAD87 7A1 6591 'E6877587ED/1 A81 A1 FA1 589A1

659589AA1TD

50

(1)1A81m1ED8181EF7 7A1FA1 5RED1?1%554A91A9165A1FA1597587EDA1EA17891

7!FAEC13A88A1 79A1BBC1ED89A1AA171515A917D75A1FA151E!957A%5DA1E99A6EDF1?1

DA197ED18917AA1FA17D751E51D'5665957AD81FA1 5RED17FAD8A1P1

1

12345664585

3E9AD559E59F3&DE2B'!9E5FAD52((DCB5&E9ADB55TD50(1)5C5'45E&552424

5

5

1

151 79A1BBC1789A1A169E 71FA1E!957A%5DA1,9A587ED1AD89A1515A91F'D1659589A1A8151E!

957A%5DA/1 F1 659589A1 m1 58E91 FA1 51 5A91E99A6EDF5D81 ?1 TD

50

(1)=78.06 A8 n=0.02C1 5A1

1

2$

1

11111111111111111111111 1 11,5/111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 1 1 1 111,%/1

12345664"585

0DF(29559F3&DE2B'!9E5299ABCDEC59E5DB56A5'22'A'59FE95759E5(23AD5!5'FCD5A58FF'5BAD59E58F5D955 E45

1

B1 A81 FED1 6E7%A1 FA1 ED9A1 A1 51 E!957A%5DA1 A81 DED!EDAAC1 1A1 5E9784A1

8E4587A1ED81FED181697771F5D1A19A8A1FA1A1895571FA1 5RED1?159A91DA1EDA9ADA1

517D71E%5C13A6ADF5D8A1ED7F95D81A157D1FA18A61F'DA1E6877587ED1FA1846A176AAA1

AA!71 6A81 C89A1 877A1 AD1 51 9A5DR5D81 ?1 6598791 FA1 F7 9AD8A1 7D78757587ED1 FA1 5RED1 ?1 59A91 51

A87ED1F17D71E%5C13A516A9A81571DA197 7587ED19E7A1FA198581E%8ADC1

1A15E9784A1F'E6877587ED18E4587A19A6EAD8191'877587ED1FA15975%A1558E79A1F5D1A1

69EA1CA1F'E6877587ED1FA1 5RED1?1DA16519A8A91%E1F5D1FA17D751E5C1'D16E7D81

FA1 A1 858787AA1 69AA1 8E1 A1 5E9784A1 8E4587A1 6AAD81 C89A1 EDA9AD8C1 1A1

84EFA1FA19A78171E1A15E9784A1D87A1ED81FA1AA6A1FA1A15E9784AC1B1

ED81DA1%EDDA19E%8AA1A81ED818918771AD189578AAD81F17D51A81FA1'75A1A81AD17D8A7ADA1

5987 77AAC11

15184EFA1F19A78171A81DA184EFA1F'E6877587ED169E%5%778A1D97A15F568A1?1FA1

69E%A1 FA1 E57587ED1 F'DA1 %EDDA1 5669E7587ED1 FA1 'E6871 E%51 F'DA1 ED87ED1 FEDDA1

F5D1D1A65A1FA19A4A94A159AC11A1DE1FA1A88A184EFA17AD81FA15184EFA1F19A781877A1

AD1 8597AA1 71 9A6EA1 91 FA1 856A1 FA1 45 5A1 A81 FA1 9A 9E7F7AAD81 ED89BA1 F'D1

589751 5 7D1 F'5AD8A91 51 857A1 FA1 A1 97851 A81 FA1 9F79A1 A1 F 58C1 .591 5D5E7A1 5A1 A1

69EA16447AA1?145A1789587ED1FA1'E6877587EDA151E87ED1E95D8A1A819A65A16591DA1

E87ED1 558E79A1 ,4E77A1 75D81 DA1 F7897%87ED1 FA1 5DF7F58A1 D95AAD81 ED8978A1 6591

'45D87EDD5A1FA1E87ED169E4A1FA151E87ED158AA/C1151DEAA1E87ED1A815E915A68A1

5A1 DA1 69E%5%7781 71 F6ADF1 ?1 51 E71 FA1 51 F7 9ADA1 AD89A1 A1 5A91 E99A6EDF5D8A1 FA1 51

ED87ED1 ?1 E6877A91 A81 F'D1 659589A1 E%51 T ,566A1 51 8A69589A/A1 71 A81 9F78A1

95FAAAD81 51 E91 FA1 'E6877587EDC1 :7D7A1 51 A87ED1 FA1 51 DEAA1 E87ED1 A81 57AD81

558E79A15DF1515A91FA1T1A81AAA1571A195669E4A1FA151A7A9A1E87ED1,EA16E91

'5E9784A1FA1FAAD8A/1E9A1T15997A1?10C1

1'5E9784A1D87A1A815D81?171DA184EFA1FA19A4A94A1714A94A1?1778A91A169EA1

F'E87ED1D589AAC1B15665987AD81?151 57A16159A1FA15E9784A1E87EDD579AC11'E87ED1

EADA1 D95AAD81 6591 DA1 6E6587ED1 F'7DF77F1 D91 558E79AAD8C1 :1 45A1

D9587EDA1 '5F587ED

1

FA1 45A1 7DF77F1 5A1 51 6E6587ED1 A81 5A1 A81 D1 ADA%A1

F'7DF77F1 A81 A87EDD1 558E79AAD81 ,75D81 A91 5F587ED/1 A81 EF7 7A1 ,75D81 FA1

9AE%7D57ED1A81AD8AAAD811FA18587ED1558E79A/16E91 E9A91DA1DEAA16E6587EDC1

151 DEAA1 6E6587ED1 A81 5E91 877A1 ?1 '789587ED175D8A1 FA1 '5E9784AC1 1'5E9784A1 '599C8A1

1

2;

D95AAD81 E9'D1 DE%9A1 571 FA1 D9587ED1 51 81 69EF78A1 E1 'D1 9789A1

F'4EED781FA1516E6587ED15181588A7D8C1

3A1FA184EFA1ED8181877A1F71 E7191A1CA1FEDDA1A17!FAA15 7D1FA1E659A91

A91 59589787AC1 1A1 85%A51 1 ED89A1 A1 98581 E%8ADC1 151 84EFA1 FA1 9A781 71 A81

61EDE5897A1FA18A61FA151A816A8A175D81'7D78757587EDA1EDA9A91A91D17D71

E5C11'5E9784A1D87A1A81619567FA1A81E%87AD81FA198581619A69EF87%AC1

1 (A78171

)1,J4/1 D1 1 1E!7QA74EEF15A1 )A6A9589A1 )7A1,/1 ++C$";<1 8C8+1 8C2"8+1 2C2"2<1 C<1 $2+1 +<C<1 8C8"81 8C2$"1 2C2<81 2<C$1 2;$+1 +<C<;$81 8C82<1 8C2;1 2C2$1 +C0<1 $8<1 +0C0+$01 8C82"<1 8C2"0"1 2C8<1 <C+"1 0$;1 +0C8<81 8C82$<1 8C2"$1 2C"+"1 ;$C;21 "2;01 +C+$+1 8C22201 8C8<"1 2"C;<$1 08C881 28;<1 2C"8881 8C<2$1 8C80;+1 02+C822<1 288C881 8C8$1 ;0C22;1 8C20"1 8C2+";1 2$C221 08C881 28;21 ++C<<0+1 8C82001 8C2081 2C2<1 C<<1 2"08$1 +;C;$<+1 8C8;1 8C2"8;1 2C"+1 $0C8$1 $01 1 :E9784A1D87A1 )1,J4/1 D1 1 1E!7QA74EEF15A1 )7A1,/1 ++C0;""1 8C8821 8C20;1 2C22+1 ;1 ++C0$$$1 8C881 8C20+1 2C22+1 2"1 ++C0"+<1 8C8821 8C20"1 2C22+1 21 ++C0+81 8C881 8C20;1 2C22+1 1 +<C8221 8C82001 8C2001 2C22+1 8+1 +<C82$1 8C82001 8C20<1 2C22<1 2;1 ++C0<;21 8C82001 8C20"1 2C22<1 +1 ++C<0<+1 8C88;1 8C20;1 2C2201 1 +<C8$081 8C820+1 8C2"821 2C2201 801 ++C<+;<1 8C88$1 8C2081 2C2201 ;1

E!9EA5"585

BA9CECB5596FC2'2BEC2F5ED5DA2C5B2'A95D5ED5E93FD2C'53C2A45

1

.E9197 7A91A1'5E9784A1D87A1 E9D71%7AD1A17D71E%5A1DA184EFA1FA19A4A94A1

A4587A1,E184EFA16591 E9A1%98AA1ED785D81?1%554A91'A65A1FA19A4A94A175D81D1651

F'45D87EDD5A1 FEDD/1 51 81 877A1 5A1 D1 651 57%A1 ,8C821 6E91 A1 89E71 659589A/C1 3A88A1

84EFA1 51 E9D71 A1 CA1 98581 A1 '5E9784A1 D87AA1 571 5A1 D1 8A61 FA1 51

%A5E6189E61A16E91C89A1877A1AD169587AC1.9ADED1D1AA6A15A1'E6877587ED1FA189E71

659589A1 F1 EFA1 123A1 A81 FA1 FE57DA1 FA1 9A4A94A1 FA1 E$8A288FA1 E8A2F1 A81 E8A2F1 6E91 A1

659589A1TD

50

(1)A1n1A81mA19A6A87AAD8C16D1E9F7D58A915A1D169EAA91BD8AX13E9A^11E1

3.6A1 )$;+8A1 2C<8MS1 A81 JE1 FA1 E79A1 7A1 69ADF951 61 FA1 89A7SA1 *E91 ,+C<1 4A9A/1 6E91

A A8A91 A88A1 9A4A94A1 A4587AC1 3A88A1 5669E4A1 DA1 6A81 FED1 C89A1 877A1 A1 891

6ED8AAAD816E9197 7A91FA19858C1

AAB6B

+7E565DC9E896D55697863898695389637E5898C973E5D62734589

EF93C879E893947D63689

1A1 8E7781 9A85A1 A81 75A1 ED81 A1 A A81 AEDF579A1 A1 61 76E985D81 A81 7785D81 FA1 51

95F7E849567A1 F1 5DA91 FA1 51 69E858AC1 A1 DE%9A1 89551 ED81 ED891 FA1 E99587ED1

7D7 7587A1AD89A1518E77819A85A1E%A9A1A81A1659589A1FEA!EAA175D81FA1EFA1

-)3.1E1F'589A19789A1E""!"+FC11

1

2+

1'E%*A87 1FA1A189557185781F'5D54A91A81FA1E659A91A1EFA1-)3.1FA1517889589A1F5D1A91

565781?169F79A1518E77819A85A1859F7A175D81F7 9AD81F571FA177A1?16598791F'DA1%5A1FA1

FEDDA1 FA1 6587AD81 545D81 9AR1 DA1 95F7E849567A1 ED E9587EDDAA1 FA1 51 69E858A1 75D81 A1

9AE5DF587ED1FE7897A1F1J5)6J1,J9E6A1F'58FA1FA1)A9169E!JD785A/1E"<FC1

AAB6B3B +7D8C3C89869756789E5CF5DC9E8943658C69E3C989673359E896289

1A16587AD817D1F5D1A189557169EAD57AD81FA1E4E98A169E6A87A1F5D1A15F9A1FA1FA1A571

84956A87A1 95DFE71 7D89A5D81 51 95F7E849567A1 69E8587A1 P1 FDA1 65981 8FA1 J5)6J1 8;1

8A85D81 A1 %D 7A1 FDA1 A55FA1 FA1 FEA1 ,+81 J41 1 <81 J4A1 1 EE9FEDDA1 6591 =C1 3AQADFE9 /1 A81

F589A1 65981 A1 6587AD81 7D1 ?1 (ADDA1 F5D1 8FA1 7)B31 BJ()!.1 ,8A85D81 51 9ADA1 E6875A1

FBJ()A1EE9FEDDA16591(C1FA139AE77A9/C11A16587AD8169EAD57AD81571FA1FEDDA1989E6A87A1

FA16587AD81895781E781513AD89A15DA15971,(ADDA/A1E781?1BD87881J85A!(E41,=7A*7 /C1

1A16587AD81857AD81A87EDD19151F76ED7%7781FA1FEDDA1FE7897A1A817D7A1FA177C1

1

1A19789A1F7D7ED1F751ED81F978C11A16587AD8169AD85D81D15FDE597DEA1E571FA1

5169E858A169E1478EE7AAD8A1DED189578169FAAD8A1857AD8177%AC11A16587AD81545D81

FA1 EE9%7F781 76E985D8A1 6E5D81 778A91 'A695DA1 FA1 7A1 857AD81 A1 E"0FC1 3A1

EE9%7F781 857AD81 P1 DA1 446A98AD7ED1 59897AAA1 DA1 59F7E65847A1 747AA1 DA1 7D 75DA1

59F75AA1 DA1 6584EE7A1 46587A1 9AA1 DA1 6584EE7A1 6ED579A1 49ED7AA1 DA1 55F7A1

9D5A1 9AA1 DA1 55F7A1 5579A1 6976497AA1 E1 F589A1 6584EE7A1 49ED7A1 9AC1

.E91A16587AD81FA1E7D1FA1+815DA1FA1 58A91FA1EE9%7F781857AD818E9A1A81D1A16E91

A16587AD81AD89A1+81A81+$15DC11518A9169E8587A1FA5781C89A1FA185FA1)1E1)5A175D81'6B331

200+C11A1 6587AD81 545D81 DA1 8A91 FA1 85FA1 )21 857AD81 77%A1 71 A1 E9A1 FA1 JA5ED1 85781 F'51

E7D1=BB1E17151EDAD89587ED1FA1.7:185781F'51E7D128DN1C11A185FA1)%1A81)"1857AD81AC1

151 EDAD89587ED1 FA1 .7:1 FA5781 C89A1 7D 97A9A1 ?1 $8DN1C1 6D1 89578AAD81 4E9ED51 D85781 651

58E971 6E91 A1 6587AD81 7D1 F5D1 8FA1 J5)6J1 8;1 A81 6E7%A1 AED1 A1 85FA1 AD1 FA4E91 FA1

8FA1J5)6J18;11,8A91FA1458197A1AED1:7E/C11A1%75D169!84956A87A17D5781DA1

57787ED1 5DDE95647AA1 DA1 7D8795647A1 EAAA1 A81 659 E71 DA1 4645FDA8E7A1 71 A1

97A1 F'588A7D8A1 5D7EDD579AA1 75D81 A1 85%A1 FA1 .5987DA1 85781 697A91 ?1 28D1 E$8FC1 1A1

EDAD8AAD8157915181E%8AD16E918E1A16587AD81F5D1A1A57169E6A87 C1

AAB6B"B '82C5F89E8973E5D62734589

1516E787ED1FA189578AAD8185781AD1F%781FE95C11'877587ED1FA1E4AD17DF77FA1FA1ED8AD87ED1

8578157A17%9AC11A16587AD81FA57AD817FA91716E7%A1A91A7A1DA14A9A155D81'57787ED1F1

5DDA91 FA1 65D7 7587EDC1 6D1 69EF781 FA1 ED8958A1 7EF1 7D895A7DA1 85781 8771O1 '9849E95A11

85781E687EDDAC16D16A87815848A915D5185781659 E7187716E9157E9A915177%7781F15D515D5C11A1

5DDA91 FA1 65D7 7587ED1 85781 571 FA1 '5987587ED1 59E!775A1 *'51 %E9F1 7D 97A91 F1 6A8781

89E45D8A9C1151F785DA17D8A9!E6A185781FA11?1$1C111

1A1EA1857AD819AED89781918E8A1A1E6A15DDA91E6E985D81A18989A1F79AC1151

F 7D787ED1F1EA17%A1E69AD5781FA1856A1P1F5D15169A79AA1A1EA17%A17D7A13)=21

,%D626EDF3E43F+ADC4/17D57815169E858A1A81A17A17D5A1O1F5D151AEDFAA171857817781

?1 51 69E858A1 ,3)=/C1 1A1 5D7ED1 6A7AD1 D857AD81 *5571 7995F7C1 &5DF1 51 69ADA1 F'DA1

A8AD7ED1A895!56579A1857817FAD87 7A16591DA1%7E67A1E16591B(A1A13)=17D57815169E858A1A81

1

2<

DA1A8AD7ED179EE67A16E8AD87AA1FA121158E91FA1518A9C11A1EA17%A165D7 71

,,DE2262FE43F+ADC4/1.)=21A81.)=1857AD81E%8AD16591'5*E81FA159A1FA12811F5D18E8A1

A1 F79A87ED1 AA681 AD1 6E897A91 EY1 51 59A1 85781 9F78A1 ?1 $1 1 6E91 778A91 '7995F7587ED1 F1

9A81 AED1 A1 9AE5DF587ED1 F1 J5)6JC1 151 F 7D787ED1 FA1 E95DA1 ?1 97A1 85781 AA1 F1

J5)6J1 E$2FC1 1A1 ED8E91 A8A9DA1 FA1 51 A7A1 85781 8E85AAD81 5DAAAD81 F7DA1 A81 A1 ED8E91

A8A9DA1 F1 9A81 857815DAAAD81 AAD81AD1EDA91 FA11 1 5!FA1 *'?1 11 5!

FAE1F13)=2C11A1659E71FA151A7A1A81F19A81857AD81E%8ADA16591DA1A65D7ED1D587A1

979A1%7F7AD7EDDAA1FA1+116E9151A7A1A81FA1$116E91A19A8C11A18C8A1 E95A1

857AD81AAD8A1*'51%E9F17D 97A91F16A878189E45D8A9C1

151 DEAD589A1 85DF59F1 6%7A1 6591 '12342E36A2EDF %A6556A2F A2F EB6E36A2F /2635F E2BF

94E5C442351 ,B3(61 $81 5DF1 B3(61 ;/1 85781 877AC1 1A1 FEA1 51 .)=1 857AD81 67 7A1 51 6E7D81

B3(6C1)E1A16587AD81857AD81F'5%E9F1895781*?1DA1FEA1FA1";1J41F5D1A1.)=2A1?1957ED1FA11

J416591 9587ED1A816591*E9A1AD1"A;1A57DAA16591DA18A4D7A1ED E9587EDDAA185DF59F1?1589A1

4561 E1 6591 EF587ED1 F7D8AD781 8775D81 ;1 57A51 7F785D8C1 7 9AD8A1 8A4D7A1

857AD81 877A1 6E91 F79A91 A1 %EE81 51 .)=1 ,+81 J41 ?1 <81 J4/C1 5D1 51 FA1 95F7E849567A1

ED E9587EDDAA1 85DF59FA1 51 8A4D7A1 85781 %5A1 91 71 4561 ,FA1 58951 A81 589A1

E%7A/A17D14561,589A1E%7A1A81D15D897A91E16E897A9/1E1478145617F785D8C1

5D151FB()A17D1 57A51F7D7FADA17FAD87A1?15169A79A1645A1857AD8187716E91A1%EE8C1

1A1ED8957D8A1FE7897A1857AD815667A16E9151659E719A85AA1A1.)=A151659E7175A1A81

A1 91 AED1 A1 9AE5DF587ED1 F1 9E6A1 J5)6JC1 3A1 9AE5DF587ED1 857AD81 A1

75D8A1P1FEA1575A1,2A</1_1+;J41A81=+_$D16E9151659E719A85A1O1FEA17D75A

+J41A81

=+;

<$D16E91A1.)=1,69E858A/1O1FEA11575A1,2A</

+<J416E9151A7AC1.59A1'715181

FED891 'DA1 7DA9878FA1 858787A1 FA1 D1 E1 E7D1 D'5 A8A1 651 7D7 7587AAD81 A1 7DA1

7EFEAA1A1478E95A1FEA!EA1A81A17DF7A1%7EE7AA1DA18E95DA1_D1857815A68A1

E$FC11

B1 85781 FA5DF1 51 6587AD81 FA17FA91 A91 A7A1 716E7%A155D81 A1 89578AAD81 *E9D57A91 EA1

E91 F1 1 5DDA91 FA1 65D7 7587EDA1 FA1 5RED1 ?1 9F79A1 51 571 A1 F65AAD81 69E8587AC1 6D1

A91 E!FE5A1 FA1 51 65987A1 6E897A9A1 FA1 51 69E858A1 6E5781 A1 69EF79AA1571 51 697E978185781

F'78A91 51 8E778175AC1 5D1 5%ADA1 FBJ()1 ,J5)6J1 8;1 A81 E4E98A1 989E6A87A/A1 FA1 75A1

6E985A1 FA1 45A1 4561 857AD81 9A71 A1 69A7A91 *E91 FA1 89578AAD8C1 A1 75A1 E984EED5A1

857AD81 97 7A1 A1 *E91 1 A81 1 671 45A1 A57DAC1 &5DF1 DA1 F7 9ADA1 7D7 7587A1 85781

F8A8AA1 51 FEA1 FA1 75A1 6E985A1 85781 FF78A1 FA1 51 FA9D79A1 9587EDC1 5D1 51 FBJ()1 ,E4E98A1

69E6A87A1 7)B31 BJ()!./A1 A1 6E787EDDAAD81 69E8587A1 85781 ED89B1 ?1 57FA1 FA1 89E71 59A91

7D89569E8587A1757191FA175A16A96ADF7579A1,75A97A16E985A1E12=/C1151 9ADA1

FA1ED89BA1BJ()16E5781C89A1*E9D579A1E14A%FE5F579AC1

AAB6BB 1756789E89(F88C69E896D5569

1A18E77819A85A1A8175A1857AD8157 7A175D81'4AA115-)N7@:1E2A12FC11A18E7781

5A1E1697A9A15195FA11,`J95FA/1857AD81ED7F9A1EA1FA1DAAD81FA18E778C1

:1E7D1D167EFA1FA157DAAD819A85N751,a195FA12/185781ED7F91EA1D1DAAD81

FA157DAAD81F19A8NFA151A7AC13A1DAAD81ED8181AD9A789169E6A87AAD816E91A1

6587AD81 7D1 F5D1 FA1 69E8EEA1 95DFE71 ,J5)6J;1 A81 7)B3!BJ()1 69E858A/C1 1 151 84EFA1 FA1

2565D!A7A91 85781 877A1 6E91 A87A91 A81 9A69AD8A91 51 8E7781 AD1 58597AC1 151 84EFA1 FA1

1

20

99A7ED1E787A185781877A16E915A91A1851FA18E7781?1F7 9AD8A1F9A1FA1771,A1A1

"1A81$15D/C1

AAB6BEB &F6369

6D18E851FA1"+16587AD81545D819AR1DA13()16E91D15DA91FA15169E858A1E5715A1DA1FEA1

F75DA1 FA1 +<1 J41 ,FA1 +81 ?1 <81 J4/1 A81 J41 6591 9587ED1 51 81 5D541 6E91 A1 8E7781

9A85AN75AC1 1'IA1 F75D1 85781 FA1 ;+1 5D1 ,FA1 "$1 ?1 +<1 5D/C1 6D1 5D8FAD81 FA1 47997A1

5%FE7D5A1 E1 6A7ADDAA1 FA1 89578AAD81 6591 5D87E55D8A1 E1 FA1 F75%8A1 85781 E%A91

9A6A87AAD816E918DA12$D1A81;D1FA16587AD8C11A19E6A169EDE871FA18A91,57 7587ED1

FA1 '57E/1 857AD81P1 %ED1 ,+D/A1 E4AD1 ,;$D/1 A81 5571 ,<D/C1 1A1 FEDDA1 857AD81 EA8A1

69E6A87AAD81,J5)6J18;1A817)B31BJ()1./16E91"D1FA16587AD8C1

12345676389A4B85C386ADEFE6238BCF675C3867BEC38

1

.E91"+16587AD8A1A1771F75D185781FA1;81E71,FA1;1?12$"/C11A1851FA18E77819A85A1,`J95FA/1

5A1'4AA115-)N7@:1?1A1A1"1A81$15D1857AD81EA178C1:DA18E7781FA195FA1697A91

E151?1"1D'5181E%A9AC1

11 7775 )E77819A85A1,`115-)N7@:1J95FA/1 757DAAD819A851 7A15DDA1 2D1,$N"2/1b1 2<D1,++N"2/1 7A15DDA1 20D1,;$N"2/1 $D1,<$N"2/1 "7A15DDA1 D1,;+N8;/1 <D1,<$N8;/1 $7A15DDA1 D1,$<N1$+/1 8D1,+;N$+/1

E!9EA59585

EA55CF22C5DCE95F!BD&B5 F22C5DE95:5+%; <.=$>5?DE5C5BE23'C5DCE95FAD5B5BA2&2B5*5

45"4595C5@5

EB

45A5859B5&E9ADB5CD5EDC)BB5FDDBFC5EA5DEFDC5B5F'!D55EC2CB5E&5A5&'C5<5F'!D55

EC2CB5BA2&2BC5

1

1'5D54A1D7597A151ED891A1P151FEA18E85AA1A189578AAD816591B()A1=+81?1=+"1,A16E9AD85A1

FA1 EA1 FA1 9A81 9AA5D81 DA1 FEA1 `+8J4A1 `+2J4A1 `+J4A1 `+J41 A81 1 `+"J4/1 857AD81 FA1

69F78A91 7D7 7587 1 ,6

8C8$/1 FA1 51 8E7781 9A85A1 ,`J95FA/C1 1A1 F7897%87ED1 FA1 A71

FE7897AA175D81518E77819A85A1,`J95FA/16E91D1771FA1$15D1ED81F978A16591A185%A51

7!FAEC1 1'5D54A1 D7597A1 6E91 A1 57DAAD81 9A851 51 FEDD1 A1 CA1 98581 AD1 7D5D81

57151=;0C

1

A71FE7897A1 J95FA18!21 `J95FA11 b_F

FEA169A978A1 +C0;c"C<01 ++C2"c"C$$1 8C8821 =+81 22C<c28C<1 2;C8"c<C081 8C8821 =+21 <C""c28C"+1 2C$2c0C1 8C8821 =+1 +C"8c0C+$1 22C+"c<C$01 8C8821 =+1 ;C"$c<C<$1 0C$2c+C;$1 8C8281 =+"1 "C0<c+C;1 +C2<c;C;<1 8C8<1

E!9EA5@5859EC2FB5CD59B5BA29B5FB2'CD2AB5B232(2EC2(B5D596EDCC/5C59E5CF22C5DCE95*5@5EB575A5

p

5BC595

DBA9CEC5A5CBC55D3DBB2F59F32BC2A5!2E2D4

5

1

775D81 51 84EFA1 F1 571 FA1 957A%5DAA1 A1 5A91 FA1 659589A1 FA1 EFA1 -)3.1

ED81817FAD87 7A16E915169F787ED1FA1518E77819A85A1,`J95FA/1A81A157DAAD819A85A175D81

45A1 45DA1 FA1 77C1 151 5A91 F1 659589A1 n1 FA1 '561 E99A6EDF5D81 ?1 51 9A587ED1 51 61

7D7 7587A1 5A1 A1 FA1846A1 FA1 8E7781 51571 81 7FAD87 7AC1 3A15A91 ED81 9A69AD8A1 7!

FAE1 ,)5%A51 ;/1 6E91 D1 771 1 FA1 $1 5DA1 5A1 A1 7D8A95A1 FA1 ED 75DA1 ?1 0$DC1 .E91 45A1