• Aucun résultat trouvé

A retrospective trust-region method for unconstrained optimization

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "A retrospective trust-region method for unconstrained optimization"

Copied!
20
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)Institutional Repository - Research Portal Dépôt Institutionnel - Portail de la Recherche researchportal.unamur.be University of Namur. RESEARCH OUTPUTS / RÉSULTATS DE RECHERCHE. A retrospective trust-region method for unconstrained optimization Bastin, Fabian; Malmedy, Vincent; Toint, Philippe; Tomanos, Dimitri; Mouffe, Mélodie Published in: Mathematical Programming DOI: Author(s) - Auteur(s) : 10.1007/s10107-008-0258-1 Publication date: 2010 Document Version. Publication datealso - Date publication : Early version, knownde as pre-print Link to publication Citation for pulished version (HARVARD): Bastin, F, Malmedy, V, Toint, P, Tomanos, D & Mouffe, M 2010, 'A retrospective trust-region method for unconstrained Programming, vol. 123, no. 2, pp. 395-418. Permanent link optimization', - PermalienMathematical : https://doi.org/10.1007/s10107-008-0258-1. Rights / License - Licence de droit d’auteur :. General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ? Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.. Download date: 28. août. 2021 Moretus Plantin Bibliothèque Universitaire.

(2) 

(3)  

(4) 

(5) 

(6) !#"$%

(7) & '

(8) $()!

(9) 

(10) ! * +,!-&#.) ,/0 12+3

(11) ! 4357698:<;>8S=@TS?A8B U

(12) M>CAD BV?8EF;H;HBGLXIKW)JL85 U

(13) M>IYC E$;HB8MVEN= M>OPJ C QSR abKc>OBJdH]>]e` Z J*[M>\?0]V^>_H]>` 1. 2,3. 2. f M>IK[O?gAhBi7jkAJ*Bo k*JlBA;>p>BJLF\g=mnAh?q[JL\gJ;H?ENAM>MeBBe;>?gG \Zqr;HJG =J;>\gk R W0J[;H\?IKJ*BV? f Q#s atdH` v C IKj3O;>k*AhGxkHwy8 4f ;eJ=zBV?gAh?B\g{nJu AD \gMAGh8 GOJ IKC ENM>BVMe?BV\g?J\g;>JG|;H8 k*G ; Cf ;HB;eL; WnJ*[;>\@?gI}JBV?~MH€E;2? R J*IY;2?gAk= 6 0 o a C Z OJLJ‚ :9W \gQ„O‰ƒ J*GGhJro = BC A:Šp>J*uz‹H\†=]eA‡]>?z5ˆ] ‚M> ;H‚I);HOI)\ C O:9\ JGhieAhOI s v IY;>AhGxwyp3AhBk*J*BV?8 IY;HGLIKAIKJLA‡?g5\{0Ax8 ?g OM>BIYL;H[-B8 Me;e=ŒkH{08 4 J OC B[ LR [-A8Gh;>A[k>[8 4J>J 8 ?MeAhBV?Œ{0 OBL[-8 ;>k>8 4J C 6M>BL=LJG; Jrk J*\†k JjkAJ*BV?gA‡ŽVOJ‘76 j ‹ C Z OJL’ v i>IKM>Z Z BV?JrC=@R Jr:“;Hu†\†ak R ]eR ]>6])J*:ŠGGhM2\gO” ‰J*GGJ= C :ŠJGhie‚0AhOZ I 8 v 8 Z 8 6Š8 •8 8–j 8 — d C •peJ*B3OJ˜‘O=@v ?gIY;tp>;HJ AG|f wyM>IK\gAJ*f M>GMGAL= CAJ>68 I}uš™MeaO]VP f‹eJt^›{‘UkJMe\@Oœ;eGhMek*O==8  J \ f JrLJ‰ C 6\g;>BkJ 6M>BL=<[M>O\G;) M>\gIY;2?gAhMeBž}GŸ; Z Jk R J\gk R JL;>B=<Gx’  šBLO=z?g\AJJ?Gx’ •0i>\gAk*OGh?O\gJ ‹ C Z OJL’ v i>IKM>BV?JrC=@Jr:“;Hu†\†ak ]e]>6])J*:ŠGGhM2\gO” ‰J*GGJ= C :ŠJGhieAhOI Z R 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 4. 2,5.

(14)  

(15)    "! #$&%')(+*,-/.0!'"! 123!'( 4

(16) 53673891:  ! ;-<>=?A@CBEDGFH IJ<>KL?NMGOQPSR&TAH>KU<VKXWZY [\PNH>]"^\< _:WZD`FBSH>ab<_:WZOc?NFWZ@ dfeQg YFPihAjZjAk -l mAnop3qsrEo ‚S—,}€—™u,„ˆtv u•{€,uxu–wzySwzwzy|Ž"Š"{~}€C„|ySEƒ2uE‚S —,„¡u†‚,{€‘S "u•u:šyS‚Suˆ‚S—™‡‰Š~SwzyS 3{~}€{€Ž5‚SuxŠ‹{€w{~‘,ŠVŒu}€{€u‘S2ŽEuwzy)C|y,—fuˆ2uˆ›}~uˆ’œwzy,C{€‘,}€’œC2|}€"u•–’“ 3 {€ }w„C„‚Sy y,}”„ ,E{"wzy,yS{€Š‹Ž"‘,{~}”u–{€ C"wz„yS‘S‚,u••}~–}€‡cuCyž‡&—,{"{€uwzwŸ›z2{€›Zuˆ{€wz}”˜•‘S 3 ux{€{€u)wz„E‚,}”y–}~ 3}€{€‡>uˆ‘Sy|‘,uˆ{\uˆ}"}€2u†{€‘S|{€ C,‘,yJuu:›¢ 3}”}€ C{"uˆ,{~{€}€wz‘S‚SCuŠŒ ¬Š~y|—f‚S}€Š‹u2{~„ˆŒ{€uˆwz}€ C£¤wzysu„•›Ÿ ¥›¢Š~u«—,u®,}€„ˆ—fu•Eƒu«ys}€wz|„ˆw2{€Œ­ŠCuˆ}”{€y|,‘S{€u«Šu2}9C£C„ˆy) C}€wŸ›z{€‚S¯ wzu2„•°A ±V ›’²f—f{€³´E‘S—ƒwzu2yž}€{€EEŠ9¦,¦|›wz§‹uˆŠ9uˆ2„ˆ—ƒ{€Š}€wz£¤ wySu¨£Eu•,’“vwz‚,„•yS 3‚S„ˆ{€ySu{€,wzE{€uˆ‘sy'}† 3„{{:› C{€‘,Š~›© Š~uwzŠ‹„•{9yS u«›wŸ‡‰{€uˆ }”Š~2 3Š~{€‚Su«uE2{€ ‘S—ƒ|ª\{€-w›CCwzySŠ>¦sІ £¤›uˆ C}~yS„¥ E'y|„—ƒ£¤Cu«}€2}€uŽE›z—fwzu2uˆy,{€wwŸ„yS{€u¨wz £¤}~{€uE¥   OBkMeB=z?g\g;>AhBJLžIKAhBAIKA©¾r;2?gAhMeB C ?g\O=@?@u \gJ*i>AM>BžIKJ? R ML= C kMeB3p>J*\gi>JBkJn? R J*M>\g5 C B3OIKJ*\gAk;HG J‰[µJ*\gAh¶,IK·´J*¸-BV¹¢?†=*ºž8»&¼ƒ½ ¿ ÀZÁ- Ã&ĖÅ5Æ5Ç>Â È Ä"Á U \gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>BYIKJ? R ML=;H\gJ0”9J*GGhuGÉ3BM2”BY?gJk R BAVOJr=<AhBXBM>BGABJ;>\9BM>Bk*M>B3p>J*‰}[\gM>ie\g;>IKI}ABi C ” R MV=@JlkMeBu kJ[? R ;>=}IY;2?O\JrL$M2p>J\›IKM>\gJˆ? R ;HB ? R Ah\?z5 5>Jr;H\†=ËÊ, Me\Y;HB J*‰3?J*B=@Ap>JžkM2p>J\g;>i>J C =J*J f M>BB C ˜‘M>OGL ;HBL =@UOMeI}AhBVJr? LˆC d>?gMK]>]>4]SJ̌8X;eL šBJVO=@O;Hk ?R J‘AhIKB J*;2? R Κ?gM\LO= =@C ?M>\BJJˆi>AM>k*M>BsBÏ C =A” LRJ*\†AŸk=R ;NAŸ=IK;›MBLJ*J*AG i mR 4MeOMH\<R ? M3R M3J7L7MeMH4f

(17) ÍzJ? Rk?JAp>k*JKO\ \gOJ*BBVk?<?AA‡M>?gJ*B \†;2” ?gRJ AŸxk R 8SAŸ=›U R;>=@AŸ=u BA‡?gJ*J*A\†i ;2R ?g4AhMeM>B O\ R M3MLYAŸ=ŠM>,?JBX\gJ*[\gJ=J*BV?gJLY435ˆ;)4;HGGAhBž=@MeIKJnBMe\I C ” R MV=@J‘\g;eLAO= ∆ A=Š? R J*BžO[ L;2?gJL7 \MeI ?gM7Ah?J*\†;2?gAhMeB 435Fk*M>B=ALJ*\gAhBi M2” ”ŠJGhG [\JrLAk?g=n? J)Me4fÍzJk?Ap>J OBkŒ?gAhMeBp2;HGOJK;2? A‡?gJ*\†;2?gJ x k 8) šB\J*?\gMe=[kJrkŒ+? C 1? R AŸ=lIKAhi R ?=J*JI R OBB;H?O\†;HmGy=AhBkJ}? R JKBJ”R \†;>LAO= ∆ ”AGhGSLJ?J\IKABJ ? OR BJ0k\?JAi>M>ABFM>B};H\gAhM>BKO” BRL AŸk R ;‘[80MVmn==OAh4\0Gh;>5)AhI O[ALB ;2?? JrLKAŸ=0IK[M3;HL[J*J*G \~mAŸ=?gMˆ[A=y\gM>J*[‰Me[=JrJkŒ?;KJrL}pt;>?\MAŸ;H[BV\g?~JLM>A€k?S? ? JR J?g\p2O;>=zGh?OuxJ0\gJ*MHieAhMe? R BžJ~;>MeGhie4fM>ÍzJ\gkA‡? ?Ap>I J R R R ? R ;H?lLJ?J\IKABJ= ∆x ;>kkMe\gLABiY?gM R M2” ”ŠJGhG m [\JrLAŸkŒ?g=n? R J)p2;>GhOJ}MHy? R JKM>4fÍzJrkŒ?gAhpeJ OBk?AM>B;2? ? R J\J4V5X=@53Bk R \gM>BA©¾AhBi)? R J‘\†;>LAhO=<O[L;H?J”Ah? R ? R Jk R ;HBieJlAhBžIKM3LJ*GŸ=*8 x C U J~BJ”„IKJ*? MLYAŸ=SIKMH?gAhp2;H?JLK435K;H[[GhAŸk*;H?AM>B=yABˆ;>L;H[?gAhpeJ<?Jk BAVOJr=S” AŸk J‰[GM>Ah?y? J0AB M>\gIY;2u ? OAM>BB k?IYRAM>;>BFLkJMe;tIKp2;>[AhOGŸ;H?gR;H4?GJAM>LB-O8\gU AhBR iKJr=@? JR J?JMek [R ?BAAIKVOA©¾rJr;2=?gAh?zMe53BX[AŸ[k*\g;>MGhGk5XJr=;>=[A[B Jr;HM>\n\†LAhJ*B \<? ?gR MYJ›R p2k;HMe\gBV5ˆ?J? ‰3R ?0JM>;>R Sk*k*;YOR B\†;>M>kAŸ=5757MHM>€4™? ÍzR JR JkŒ?gMeAhpe4fJÍzJ kO?BAp>kJ u ?AM>B C ” R J\J)BM>AŸ=J)\gJLOkŒ?AM>B k*;HB4JK;>k R AJ*peJL 4O?;H?‘;ž=@Ai>BA‡Žk;HBV?nk*Me=@?8• Ž\g=@?0?g\O=@?@u \gJ*i>AM>BNIKJ*? R ML ?”MˆA‡? AR IKL[53MVB=@J);>IK;YAIKk)M3;>Lk*k*J*OG\†\g;>JkL5XOkŒA=‘?gAhMeLBNJr=Gk*;>\\A4ieJ*Jr\<LN? AR B;HBj3Jr=kŒM>?IKAM>BJI›a]O8 G‡s ?gAhM>[ GJ›f M>M> B? BR J)J?‘B;>M>G|AŸ8=@JÊ|d>J]>p2]e;H],GǑ8‘;2?gU JLNR J};2?nIK4;>M>AhB? R AL? JrR ;YJ)? k*R OJ*\\g\gJ›J*BVAŸ=? ;HBL k;HBLAL;H?JˆAh?J\g;H?Jr=*8• k J;>[J\BMeBIKM>BM>?M>BJ7;H[[\MV;>k ;>=›4JJ*B LJ*p>JGhMe[JrL AhB$? JžkM>BV?gJ‰3?›MH BM>BGhABJ;>\S=z?gMk R ;>=@?AŸk9[\Mei>\†;HIKR IKAhBin435):<;e=z?gAhB Cf Ah\gAGhGM;HBLKU

(18) M>R ABeR ?:ÊxdH]e] sNÐ Ì C ʜ=J*J~;HGŸ=Ml:<;e=z?gAhR B Cf Ah\gAGhGM;HBL UMeAhBV? C d>]>] sNÑ Ì‘I}Me\Jˆ=[JkAhŽk;HGGh5  M>\›? R JˆIKABAI}Aœ¾;H?AM>B$M>~=;>I}[GhJ7;tpeJ*\†;HieJ};>[[\gMt‰3AIY;2?gAhMeB=–Ê|j R ;H[A\M C =@dHMe]eB ]>C™,̀arb>\gbJ*Gs 53̌Ah8€BUiR M>JBˆIYEN;HMeABeBˆ?gLJuAhPf J;H\\gJGhBMk=gJ;H”IKAh[? RGAB\gi JC=[;JIKkŒ?yJ?g? MlR M3? L7R J0;H”ŠGŸ=@MeM"\«É3É)BMHM2 ”f BYM>;eB=“Bš=gÒ;HÓIKО[Ô©ÕGJAŸu =y[?;2R ? R;2?ŠM>A‡[?Š?g;>AhIKGhGM2Aœ¾”~;2=y?gAh;lMeB'\gJÊLZ OMek?4AAM>BB u MH ? R J0IKMLJ*G =@IY;>GhGJ*\y? R ;HBˆ? R JnBM>AŸ=@J0GhJp>J*Gx8€ šBˆ4M>? R k;>=J= C ? R Jn=A©¾J~MH? R J0IKMLJG\gJLOk?AM>BˆAŸ=y? R J0IY;>AhB ?kRMeOI}=[;>M>[B[J*BVGAh?<JrL?MYM>LBJ?k*R ALJ7J4M>;>BX=A?=R MHJ<L[Jr;>=@=@A\g?JLžAhB;>M>k*\gk*IKO\†;H;>?kAM>5YB M>C ;2? ?R J? R M>Jˆ4f[ÍzJr\gkŒJ*?gp3AhApeM>JnO=lOAhB?kŒJ?g\gAh;HMe?B-J w C ?\gR ;HJ? R ;eJL\l;H? [R ?;HAp>?)Jl;2IK?J? Rk R J7;>k*BOA=\I \gJ*BVAŸ=? a k. k. k. k. k+1. k+1. k+1. k+1. k+1. k. k+1.

(19) d. 

(20)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. M>BJe8)mnO\lBJ*” [\Me[MV=;>G

(21) AŸ=n? R JB IKM>?Apt;H?JrLF435 ? R J R Me[J}MHŠAhIK[\gM2p3AhBi7? R Jr=@J}?gJk R BAŸVOJ=‘4Jk;HO=J? R J IKMe=@?n\gJ*GJ*p2;HBV?nAB Me\IY;2?gAhMeBFM>B? R J}IKMLJ*Gx’ =lVO;>GhAh?z5N;2?‘? R JKkO\g\gJ*BV?nAh?J\g;H?J›”9M>OGLN4JKO=JL C AB=z?gJ;eLFMH ;2?<? U R JA[=€\[J;>p3[AhMeJO\ =<J‰A‡?g[J*G\†M>;2\g?gJJ>=8 ? J9? JM>\gJ?gAk;HGV[\Me[J\@?gAhJr=

(22) ;>BL[\g;ekŒ?AŸk*;>GeB3OIKJ\AŸk*;>Ge[MH?gJ*BV?AŸ;HG3MH? J9BJ*”$?\gO=z?u \Ji>AM>BKR ;HGi>Me\Ah? R I 28 1 J0AhBV?R \gMLOR k*J<? R J~BJ*” IKJ? R M3LKAB7j3JrkŒ?AM>B7d C ;>BLK=z?gOL5}A‡?†=“kMeB3p>J*\gi>JBkR J<ABK? R J0BJ‰3? =@kJrMekŒB?gkAhGMeOB-L8<Jj;HJBkŒL7?gAhMeJ*B ‰;>— IK[AhB\gJJ=J*[BVJ*?g\†=~=[[Jr\kŒJ?GhAAp>IKJrAh=ŠB ;HM>\g\<5ˆ B3OO?gOIK\JJ*\g\gAkJ;H=JG;>J*\g‰k [R JAh\BFAJ*Bj3Jrk*JkŒ?gM>AhMeBFB =@‹?g;>8 BL;H\†LXBM>BGABJ;>\~[\gM>4GJ*IY=831J 4 5 2à 6\ Ã&" Ä 798:6ÇV È ;"6  Ã,Æ 7´= <™à 6>"È3Ä"@ Á ?"A>"Ä"Ã&È2 B,C 1 Jk*M>B=AŸLJ*\9? R JOBkMeB=@?\†;HABJLXM>[?gAhIKAœ¾;H?AM>Bž[\Me4GJ*I Ê|d8ha¤Ì min f (x), DE ” R J*\gJ f AŸ=ˆ; ?z”Ak*JuškMeBe?gAhB3OMeO=Gh5$LAhP J*\gJ*BV?AŸ;H4GJ M>4fÍzJrkŒ?gAhpeJX OBkŒ?gAhMeB„” R Ak R IY;H[=Y  Z AhBV?gM  Z ;HBL„AŸ= 4MeOBLJrL 4J*GM2”8 U

(23) \O=z?ux\gJ*ieAhMeB I}J*? R ML=Y;>\JžAh?J*\†;2?gAhpeJ7[\gMkJr==J= C ” R AŸk R C ieAhpeJ*B ;=@?g;H\?ABi [MeAhBV? x C k;2Me?gAhBMe=zB ?g\OkŒ?‘;ˆ;X?z”=@JrAk*VJOušJ*kBMeBek*J?gAhB3(xOMe)O=Gh5žLM>A‡“P A‡J*?g\gJ*J*\†BV;2?g?gAJ;>= 4RGhJ›M>[I}JM OLGJGG5FkM>B3AŸpe=0J*\gLi>J*AŽBBiKJr?LNM ” ;7=AŸkM>GO”Š?AJM>B?\gMHO†=z?‘ÊxdAhB8aE=@̌AŸ8LJ)•9;š?lJÊ,?z;e53k [R AŸk*A‡;H?gJ*GG\5 u R R v Ok*AŸ=9GhAŸL? kJCJ;>BNBǸk4M>;>IKGhG[BO?JMHLX 43\g5š;eLʜA;>O[= [∆\gMt‰>AhIY0;2?gk*J*J*GBV5™?ÌS\gJIKL}AB;2Ah? IK? AœR ¾*J~ABkmi}O\g? \gJ*JBV?yIKA‡M?gJ*L\†J;2G ?J x AhC Bk=@;HAŸLGGhJ‘JrL? ? JlR J2?g\Ó OF=zGI?H9Ó \gJ*F«i>Ò JAM>KLB M8y•#8S=zU ?gJ*[ J R R Ah ;>mBLžM>BG5ˆAh R ? R J\g;H?AM B R s?\gA;>G[MeAhBV?  A 9 = ? * J N B > ;  k  k  J  [  ? r J ž L e ; Š = ?  J  B * J 3 ‰ ~ ? ‡ A g ? * J † \ 2 ;  ? J R R x +s x ρ C n. x∈. n. 0. k k>0. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k+1. def. ρk =. k. f (xk ) − f (xk + sk ) mk (xk ) − mk (xk + sk ). AMH=l0GŸ;e;Hk \gR i>AhJJ\‘p>Jr? RL ;>\gB JL; O=kŒIY?gAhMe;HBGGS[Ê AMVB$=@Ah? ?R Ap>J7JYM>k*4™M>ÍzBJkŒ=@?g?g;>AhpeBeJY?  ηOBkʜ?A‡?gAM>J*\†BN;2Ì?gAh?MeM B [k\JrAŸL=lAŸkŒ? ?R JrJL B \gk*J;HLGGOJkLN?AM>HOGQBPOPʜÒAhB H)H'ROA‡?†G =›Ô ÌG8YMk* š;HB GŠ? IKR JˆM3LkJ*GŸ;>G =gm=Ak*;>Ì GC AhB\g;>kIK\gJJ*;>”9=JM>L)\ˆÉ AhC ? ? R JJ›??\g\gAŸO;H=zG?[ux\gM>J*AieBeAh?SMeAŸB =S;e\g;ek*LkJAhO[=~?JrAŸLv=0OÊ,? [ L;2;H?S?AŸJ=yLA‡ ;2?0? R J›JBÌ LN;HM>B LKJrL;>Jrk Rk\gJAh?;>J=\gJ;HL)?AMHM>? B-w<J*\gAh?n”AŸAŸ=~=@JeG8J, š?lB}O? BkAŸ=SR ;>kB;>=i>J JrL ? M>J\ BJ*” p2;HGOJ ∆ R A=yk R MV=@JB›AB›? R J<AhBV?gJ*\gpt;>G R [γ ks k,ργ ks> ηk] C M>\y=M>IKJ9k*M>B=@?g;>BV?g= R 0 < γ < γ R < 1 891 C R JR B AŸ=nBJ*iV;2?Ap>J ;7VO;eL\†;2?AŸk‘Ž?‘MH ? R J)IKM3LJ*G€A=0O=@JrL ʜ;e=~AB M>BBNJ?‘;>G|8 d>]>]e] C [p>J8n\^25 `>=@™SOÌ k*C k?JrMX==@L JO?G

(24) JAh\B IK? ARBJJ ρ;K?JBV?g;2?gAhpeJBJ”C \g;eLAhO=” R Me=J[O\[Me=JAŸ=?MXJ*B=O\gJ? R ;2?~? R f J›BJ*‰3?nAh?J*\†;2C ?gAhMeBNA=0 =@JB=Jn? R ;2? ρ > η  Me\~=@MeI}J η ∈ (η , 1) 8SU R A=<p2;HGOJAŸ=<i>Ap>JBX435 θ ∆ C ” R J*\gJ Êxd8–dƒÌ (1 − η )h∇ f (x ), s i θ = . (1 − η )[f (x ) + h∇ f (x ), s i] + η m (x + s ) − f (x + s ) ?AM>B mnkO\Ê,? BR J*;2” ?~AŸ;H=Gi>;2Me?\? Ah?R R JI 4JLi>A‡P ABJ*B\†A=BAiKB7MH?  R A‡;2?g?J*\†? ;2R ?J‘AM>?B \gOk=z?+ux\g1J*ie̊AhMeMeBXB7?\†R;>JLA4O;e=9=@AŸAŸ==9OMH[ €L? R;2?gJSJLžF«Ò Ó;2FT,L?HJU¢\Ò)JP ;eÓK+k V¤R Ò=\gO;Hk*?k*AMJ=g=z OGA‡?gJ*\†;2u k. 1. k. k+1. 0. k. 1. 1. k. 0. 1. k. k+1. 2. 2. k. 1. def. 2. def. ρ˜k+1 =. x. 2. k. k. x. k. k. k. 2. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. f (xk+1 ) − f (xk+1 − sk ) f (xk ) − f (xk + sk ) = mk+1 (xk+1 ) − mk+1 (xk+1 − sk ) mk+1 (xk ) − mk+1 (xk + sk ). MHn;ek AJ*p>JrL ?gM [\gJLAk?JL„k ;>Bi>Jr= ” AGJ k*M>BV?AB3OABi?gM O=@J ?M LJrkAŸLJ ” J? J*\}? JX?g\AŸ;HG<Ah?J\g;H?J IY;t5NR4Jˆ;ek*kJ[?JrL87mnO\IKJR? R ML? R C J*\gJR  Me\JKLAŸ=z?gAhBi>OAŸ= R J=‘? R JK?zρ”ŠM \gM>GJ=‘[GŸ;t5>JLR 435R ρ RAB? R JˆkGŸ;>=g=Ak;HG ;HGi>Me\Ah? R I w ? R ;2? MHLJrkAŸLABin;ek*kJ[?g;>BkJŠMH? R J“?g\AŸ;HGVAh?J*\†;2?gJŠ;>BLl? R ;2?

(25) M>LJ*?J*\gIKAhBAhBi0? R J9\†;>LAO=-O[L;H?Je8   ?‘;>G=M7J*‰3[GhAŸkAh?JGh5ž?g;ƒÉ>Jr=~ABe?gMX;ek*kMeOBV?0? R ;2? m C BM>? m C A=nO=JLN”Ah? R AhB? R J)?\gO=@?n\gJ*i>AM>BNM>“\†;>LAO= ∆ 4357J*Ah? 8€R UJ*\0R AOB= k*C \” Jr;>R =JAhBKBi}? R ? JR J›Ah?kJO\g;H\?\gJJ*BVR ?~;e\†= ;>ŽL\†A=zO?S=<4M>J*\0JBˆGhJr;t;>pVkAkBJ*iK[?AhJ?nL OC B? Rk R ;H;H?“BAŸ=yieJ” LXR A‡J* B ρ˜ρ >>η˜η MeC \~”9LJ~Jkk*Me\IKJr;>[=OJ?A‡J<?0? M>R ? AŸR =SJ\†\;>”LAŸA=OJ>= 8  š;YBžV? OR ;>AŸL=\†GŸ;2;>?g=@A?0k‘k*Ž;>?0=J MHC  Ah?~? R AŸJ=~IK;HiVM3;HLABžJ*Gk AŸR =~MVO=@J=@JrBXLžABž;e=0? R ;>J4M2ABVpe?JnJ?g\M7p2;HLG J*[γ?J*\gksIKAhBk,Jγ;Kks?JBek]?†;28Š?gAhENpeJM>B\gJ*J*M2” peJ*\†\ ;>C L” AOR =JB ” Rρ˜AŸk R AŸ=”BAJ*GhG

(26) iV;2IK?gAh;ƒpeÉ>J J C k. k. k+1. k. k+1. k. k. 0. k. 1. k. 1. 1. k.

(27) ™  M>\l=@MeIKJ η˜ ∈ (˜η , 1) 8U R AŸ=0p2;>GhOJ}AŸ=. 

(28)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. ? R J}BJ*‰V?lAh?J*\†;2?gAhMeBFp>J\5 =Ok*k*J=g=z OG€ABF? R J}=J*B=J)? R ;H? i>Ap>JBX435 θ˜ ∆ C ” R J\J k+1. ρ˜k+1 > η˜2. 2. 1. k. def θ˜k+1 =. Êxd8 ™,Ì. −(1 − η˜2 )h∇x f (xk+1 ), sk i . (1 − η˜2 )[f (xk+1 ) − h∇x f (xk+1 ), sk i] + η˜2 mk+1 (xk ) − f (xk ). ‚ M>?U AŸkR J‘A=}? R G;HJ?;eLθ˜=?gMFO? =R JJX=9\g? JR ?gJ\MVi>=@\†[;>JLkAh?JABep>?JY;2?g?\O? R=z?Jux\gBJ*Jie” AhMeB [M>I}ABeJ*? ? C R \†M;2L ? R LJ*J\9=g? kR \gAh;>4BžJL ? R ;>J=}Me•~GLXGi>M>M>B\gJAh? ;eR =9I AhBd8Ê|a d8 d,ǍB 8 ” R Ak R ”9J GhJr;tp>J)? R JY[\JrkAŸ=@JKLJŽBA‡?gAhMeB=M>“? R JYI}MLJGxʜ;H?)jV?J[„a¤Ì‘;HBL MH>Î@=OˆkAJ*BV?\gJLOk?AM>BsÏʜ;HC ?j3?J*[ ™SÌ~ Me\ ? R JBJ‰3?~=@JrkŒ?AM>B8 k+1. ¹¢º

(29) N½˶ ºž¹A¼¶ N¶ º&¼ «ºž¶  `¹ "!  ¹Nº# $ %

(30) '&()*,+ - C¶/. 1  •~BNABA‡?gA;>G[M>ABV? ;HBL ABAh?AŸ;HG-?g\O=z?ux\gJ*ieAhMeBX\†;>LAO= ;H\gJi>Ap>J*B8 U R½ J›0%k*M> B;>=@B! ?gL ;>­BV$¼ !?g= $­η2¹ 3C  η˜ C η˜ C γ C γ ;>8 BL MexγI}[;HO\g?J›J ;HGŸ=Mˆi>Ap>;>JBB Lž;>=@BJ*? LF=g;2?gA=@ 8 5 0 <∆η <> 10C 0 < η˜ 6 η˜ < 1 0<γ <γ 616γ f f (x ) k=0 - C¶ 4A1  j3JGhJrkŒ? ; ?z”Ak*JuškMeBe?gAhB3OMeO=Gh5 LAhP J*\gJ*BV?AŸ;H4GJ IKMLJ*G m LJŽBJL AB ½ B5 8 ¹» ¶ » ¶ 67% ­2¹ 8 - C¶ 91 ½ ¶ ºž¹N ¼ V:¶ ; $#A¶ º  ¼ <ˆºž¶  ­2¹ cº !™%»  =¼ %V » ! C2¶     k = 0 C ieMn?gMjV?J[K™8

(31)    x = x C ? R J*BNk R M3Me=J ( A‡ ρ ∈ [0, η ) C Êxd8 — Ì γ ks k ∆ = A‡ ρ < 0 C min[γ ks k, max[γ , θ ]∆ ] ” R J\J θ AŸ=LJ*ŽBJLžABÊ|d8–dƒÌ8 v GŸ=@J C LJŽBJ Êxd8–‹ƒÌ f (x ) − f (x ) ρ˜ = m (x ) − m (x ) ;HBLXk R M3MV=@J  A‡ ρ˜ > η˜ C max[γ ks k, ∆ ]    A‡ ρ˜ ∈ [˜η , η˜ ) C  Êxd8 s Ì ∆ ∆ = ‡ A  C  γ ks k ρ ˜ ∈ [0, η ˜ )   A‡ ρ˜ < 0 C  min[γ ks k, max[γ , θ˜ ]∆ ] ” R J\J θ˜ AŸ=LJ*ŽBJLžABÊ|d8 ™,Ì8 - C¶ /> ½ - C¶ ?@!  @  ! `¹ 8 f MeIK[O?J;K=@?J*[ ? R ;2?VÎ=@AO Yk*AhJBV?G5Y\JrLOkJr=9? R JlIKMLJ*GÏ m ;>BL s =Ok R ? R ;2? x + s ∈ B 8 - C¶ ?B ½  @ƒ¶ % $!A ƒ¶b¹ CD $  ¶ Cº !  V2¹ E @ f MeI}[O?J f (x + s ) ;>BLžLJŽBJ Êxd8 ^|Ì f (x ) − f (x + s ) ρ = . m (x ) − m (x + s )    ρ > η C ? R JB LJ*ŽBJ x = x + s ;>BL k*M>IK[O?gJ ∇ f (x ) F M>? R J\”AŸ=@JLJŽBJ 8y šBk*\JIKJ*BV? 435a;>BL7ieM}?MˆjV?J[ a>8. . 0. 1. 2. 0. 1. 2. 0. 1. 1. 0. 2. 1. 2. 1. 0. k. k. k. k−1. 1. k. k−1. k−1. 1. k−1. 0. k−1. k−1. 1. k−1. k−1. k−1. k. k. k−1. 2. k. k−1. k. k. k−1. k−1. k. 1. k−1. 2. k. 1. k. k−1. 1. k. 0. k. k−1. 2. 1. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. xk+1 = xk. k+1. 1. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. k. x. k+1.

(32) —. 

(33)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. Ä"Á ;"6Ã>"6Á5Ç36  B,6Ä2à 1 J BM2” AhB3peJ=@?Aie;2?gJˆ? R JFkMeBVpeJ*\gi>JBkJX[\Me[J\@?gAhJr=}MHnMeO\Y;HGi>Me\Ah? R I 8 j3AhBkJNAh?Yk;HB„4JNk*M>B=ALJ*\gJL ;e= ;=@Ai>ptB;>A‡\ŽAŸk;H;HBVBV?K?)MH=nAhIK? R AGJN;>\4Ah?;eA=@JAŸ=k7Ah?B \gO? =z?J*ux\gA\}J*ie[AhMe\M3B M>œIK=*8NJ?  šR B ML ” M>;H ?›f  MeMeBGhGB„M2”~J= ?ˆ;H”9GxJ8xÊ|d>;t]>p>]>JX]SÌ ;2C ?@?g”ŠJ*JžIKJ[‰?gJ[L JkŒ?g?7MF=4AI}JXAGŸJ;H‰\K[G\AJrk*=@A‡?}OG‡M>?†=YB ;H? BL J ;>=g=@OI}[?AM>B=;>BL7[\Me[J\@?gAhJr=R C 4O??MK\J* J*\<?gM f R R ;H[?gJ*\ s MHC 

(34) ? R AŸ=R \gJ J\JBkJl” R JBJ*peJ*\<[MV==A4GhJe8 R mnO\~;>=g=@OI}[?AM>B=;>\J‘ALJ*BV?AŸk*;>G?M}? R Me=J‘O=@JrL7 Me\<? R J4;>=Akn?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>BXI}J*? R ML8   U R  k*M>BJ =@~?g;>JBe=g? =Aκ;>Bž M>=

(35) O? k R R J? MeR 4f;HÍz? JC k?MeAp>\~Jl;HGOG Bxk∈?AM>  Z B ∇C f AŸ=~OBA‡ Me\IKG574M>OBLJL C A|8 J>8“? R J\JJ*‰A=@?g=~;K[Me=Ah?Ap>J . n. xx. k∇xx f (x)k 6 κ  ..  . U R J0IKMLJ*G m A=SŽ\g=@?@u M>\†LJ\“kM R J*\gJ*BV?“”Ah? R ? R J0 OBkŒ?gAhMeB f ;2?9J;ek R A‡?gJ*\†;2?AM>B x C A|8 J>8€? R J*A\Šp2;>GhOJr= ;>BLži>\†;>LAJ*BV?g=<;>\J‘JVO;>G-;2? x  Me\~;HGG k w ;>BL g = ∇ m (x ) = ∇ f (x ). m (x ) = f (x ) U =OR k J ~? J=g;H=? A;>Bž MeM>\~

(36) ;H? GGR JIKM  LJ*G ;H∇BLˆm Me\~;HA=0GG OBAh M>\gI}G574M>OBLJL C A|8 J>8“? R J\JJ*‰A=@?g=~;Yk*M>B=@?g;>BV? κ

(37) > 1 R R C Z C k. k. k. def. k.  >. x∈. k. n. k. xx. k. x. k. k. x. k. k. k. k∇xx mk (x)k 6 κ 

(38)  − 1..  B. U [R M>J0ABVL? Jk*Ax\8 JeJr8 ;>=? J<JM>\BKJl? J*R ‰3J~AŸ=@IK?g=~M3;KLJ*kG MemB=@?g;HAŸBV=S? ;2?“GJ;e=z?9;>=yI)Ok =R Ok ;>=S?;‘ ;2\†? ;>k?M>AM>\~BK;>MHGhG  ? R ;2?“Me4?g;>AhBJLY;2?“? R J f ;>Ok R 5 R R R C kC F κ 

(39)  ∈ (0, 1) k. mk (xk ) − mk (xk + sk ) > κ . . kgk k , ∆k kgk k min βk. . ”Ah? R β = 1 + maxk∇ m (x)k 8 M>?J)? ;H?•›8 =[JrkAhŽJ=‘? JKBMH?gAhMeBMHÎ@=OˆkAJ*BV?l\JrLOkŒ?gAhMeBsÏ)O=JLAhB jV?gJ*[ ™7M>ŠM>O\‘;>GhieM>\gA‡? I ” AhGJ ?‚ R JKk R MeR Ak*JMH — m ABjV?gJ*[$R a)A=‘GAhIKAh?JrLF435N•8–dˆ;HBL•8 ™8 1J};>G=MˆBM>?J? R ;2? s 6= 0 ” R JBJ*peR J*\ gC 6=R 0 4Jrk*;>O=@JlM>€•8 — 8 def. k. x∈Bk. xx. k. k. . k. k. !"$#%'&(*),+

(40) -.&0/2134$56+7&8+#%9;:=<>+?&(-.  šB ? R AŸ=ˆ=@JrkŒ?gAhMeB ”9J [\gM2p>JX? R ;H?}? R JN\gJ?\gMe=[JkŒ?gAhpeJ7?g\O=z?ux\gJ*ieAhMeB ;HGi>Me\Ah? R I A=YieGhMe4;HGG5$kM>B3peJ*\gi>J*BV?)?M Ž[\†\gM3=z?LuxOMe\gkLJrL7J\›43k5Y\gAh? ?AŸCk*J;H;HG9G[i>MeM>\ABeAh? ?†= IC AhB d8?a‘R =gJ ;2?g=@AJ=@BŽ=JJˆ= ? R ;2?)Jp>J\5 GAhIKAh?}[M>ABV? x M>~? R JX=JVOJ*BkJ7M>0Ah?J*\†;2?gJ= (x ) R R k. ∗. Ah\g\gJ1=[JlJrkŒŽ?\†Ap>=@J‘?<ieMHAh€pe? JR ;)J4k R M>M>OAŸBkLžJ‘MHM>€BX? ?R JJ=@J?g;>\\g\@M>?gAh\9B4i)J*[?z”ŠM>AJBVJ*? BXx? Jl;HB?gLX\OAJBAhM>?4fAŸ;HÍzGJrkŒ?g?\AOp>=zJn?ux \gOJ*BiekAh?MeABˆM>B \g;eLA;>OB= Lž∆A‡?†=8 kO\g\gJ*BV?I}MLJG R8 R f 2 ;  ? ?  J  [ g \ * J 3 p  A > M  O 9 = h A  ? * J † \ 2 ; g ? J R m x ∇x f (x∗ ) = 0 0. k. k−1. 0.

(41) ‹. 

(42)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. &¶S¹Nºž¶:

(43). )*. j3O[[Me=Jl? R ;H?~•8aŒ3•›8 ™ R MeGL-8SU R J*B ”9J R ;tp>Jn? R ;H?. > . ʜ™8aEÌ. |f (xk ) − mk−1 (xk )| 6 κubh ∆2k−1. ;HBL C A‡ Ah?J*\†;2?gAhMeB. k−1. AŸ=~=Ok*k*J=g=z OG C ? R ;2?. ʜ™8–dƒÌ ʜ™8 ™,Ì. |f (xk−1 ) − mk (xk−1 )| 6 κubh ∆2k−1. ” R J*\gJ. κ

(44) = max[κ7 , κ

(45) ]. def. >M¨Bº¤G¹ 5)¹ [C \ M2peJ U ʜR™J8 d,̌48 M>:ŠOBJrLJk*;>Oʜ™=@8J~aEÌ<? R LJnAh\gM>J4fkÍz?JrG57kŒ?\gAp>J=J~O G‡O?†B=<kŒ ?g\gAhM>MeI B7;HU BR LKJ*M>? R\gJ*JnI IKs M38 L— J*8a‘G ;HAB\gJ f CM>BBž OJ*B?nkŒ?;HAM>Gx8 BÊx= dHC ]>”9]eJ~],ÌIY8 ;t1 5}J;>[? R [OG5 = ? R JXI}Jr;HB p2;HGOJY? R J*Me\JI MeB ? R J7Me4fÍzJk?Ap>JK OBkŒ?AM>B f ;>BL M>B ? R JˆIKMLJ*G m C ;>BL M>4?†;HAB  \MeI ? R ;H? x =x −s Ê|™8 — Ì f (x ) = f (x ) − hs , ∇ f (x )i + hs , ∇ f (ξ )s i Ê|™8–‹ƒÌ m (x ) = m (x ) − hs , g i + hs , ∇ m (ζ )s i  M>\~=M>IKJ ξ C ζ ABž? R J=J*ieI}JBV? [x , x ] 8 :ŠJrk*;>O=@J›MH“•8–d C ? R J)Me4fÍzJk?Ap>J OBkŒ?gAhMeB f ;HBL ? R J}IKMLJ*G m R ;tp>J? R JK=;>I}J›pt;>GhOJ);HBLNi>\†;>LAJ*BV? ;2? x 8SU R O= C =O4?g\g;ekŒ?ABiʜ™8 ‹,̓ \MeI ʜ™8 — Ì<;HBL7?g;ƒÉVABiY;H4=@MeGhO?gJlpt;>GhOJ=<53AhJGL=9? R ;H? . 2. k. k−1. k. k−1. k−1. k. k. k. k−1. k−1. k. k. k. x. k−1. k−1. 1 2. k. 1 2. k. k−1. k−1. xx. xx. k. k. k. k−1. k−1. k. k. k. 1 2 |hsk−1 , ∇xx f (ξk )sk−1 i − hsk−1 , ∇xx mk (ζk )sk−1 i| 1 2 [|hsk−1 , ∇xx f (ξk )sk−1 i| + |hsk−1 , ∇xx mk (ζk )sk−1 i|] 2 1 2 (κufh + κumh − 1)ksk−1 k 2 1 2 (κufh + κumh − 1)∆k−1 ,. |f (xk−1 ) − mk (xk−1 )| = 6. |Ê ™8 s Ì ” R J*\gJl”ŠJ=Ok*k*J=g=@Ap>JGh5ˆO=@JrLˆ? R Jl?\gA;>Bi>GJlAhBJVO;HGAh?z5 C ? R J f ;HOk R 5Vušjk R ”<;H\ˆ¾~ABJVO;>GhAh?z5 C ? R JABLOk*JL IKʜ™;H8–dƒ?Ì9\gA‡‰Yk*GhJrB;HMe\g\GhI5 [M>\gGŸM>L[=*J*8 \?AJ= C •8a C •8 ™ C ;HBLˆ? R J0œ;>k?Š? R ;2? x ∈ B AhIK[GAJ=Š? R ;H? ks k 6 ∆ 8Sj3M R 2 U R O=9? R J;HB;HGM>i›M>

(46) U R JM>\gJ*I s 8 — 8a0M> f MeBB7J*?;>G|8´ÊxdH]>]e],Ì R M>GŸL=9ABXMeO\k*;>=J C ” R J\J‘”9Jn\gJ*[GŸ;>k*J~? R J  M>\g”9•0;>=y\gLXMeOL\SAhPBJJ\” JB\†k;2J ?AfM (x O=)J=y−? mJ\g(xJLOkŒ?)AM>43B}57AB Ah?g=<\gJ?gAh\BMV=z=@?g[J;>JL}k?M>Ap>J‘? p2J;H\g\AJr;>LBeO? kf?(xAM>BKAhB ) − m (x”9J;H\g)J<8 AhBV?J\Jr=z?gJL AhBN;}4M>OBLžMeB7? R J*A\0Lρ˜AhPJ\JBkJ R C ” R AŸk R AŸ=[\gM2p3AmLJrLˆ435ˆ? R AŸ=BJ‰3R ?\gJ=OG‡?r8 m C 6. 6. k. k+1. k. V¶:

(47).

(48) ! > . k−1. C. k−1. k+1. k−1. k. . k−1. k. k. k−1. k−1. k−1. j3O[[MV=@Jˆ? R ;H?)•8aŒ•8 ™ R M>GŸL8 U R J*B ”9J R ;tp>JK? R ;2? C  Me\›Jp>J*\g5=Ok*k*J=g=z OGSA‡?gJ*\†;2?gAhMeB ʜ™8 ^|Ì | [m (x )−m (x )] − [m (x ) − m (x )] | 6 2κ 

(49) ∆ . k−1. k−1. k−1. k. k. k−1. k. 2 k−1. . k. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  o =@ABiN? R JˆIKMLJ*G<LAhPJ\JBe?gA;>4AGhAh?z5 C ”ŠJX;H[[G5 ? R JXI}Jr;HB p2;HGOJY? R J*Me\JI MeB ? R JXI}MLJG C ;HBLX”ŠJlMe4?g;>AhBX? R ;H? m Ê|™8 `,Ì ,∇ m (ψ )s i m (x ) = m (x ) + hs ,g i + hs  M>\~=M>IKJ ψ AhBž? R J=@Ji>IKJ*BV? [x , x ] 8 Z J*IKJ*I)4J\<? R ;H? ʜ™8 ‹,̓ABX? R Jl[\gJ*p3AM>O=9[\gM3MH

(50) ieAhpeJ=Š? R ;2? Ê|™8 b,Ì , ∇ m (ζ )s i m (x ) = m (x ) − hs , g i + hs . k−1. k−1. k. k−1. k−1. k−1. k−1. k−1. k. k−1. k. 1 2. k−1. k−1. xx. k−1. k−1. k. k. k−1. k. 1 2. k−1. xx. k. k. k−1. k−1.

(51) s. 

(52)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0.  M>\n=M>IKJ ζ AhBF? R J}=@Ji>IKJ*BV? [x , x ] 8njO4=@?Ah?O?gAhBiJʜ™8 `S̍;HBL ʜ™8 bSÌ<AhB=@AŸLJ? R J›GJ,?u R ;HBLF=AŸLJMH ʜ™8 ^|Ì ;>BLO=@ABiN•8 ™ ? JK?g\AŸ;HBieGhJKABJVO;>GhAh?z5 C ? R J f ;>Ok R 5euzjk R ”<;H\ˆ¾AhBJVO;HGAh?z5 C ;>BL ? R JYABLOk*JL IK;H?\gCA‡‰XBM>\gI [\gM>[J*\?C AJ=<R 53AJ*GŸLˆ? R ;2? k. k−1. k. | [mk−1 (xk−1 ) − mk−1 (xk )] − [mk (xk−1 ) − mk (xk )] |

(53)

(54) =

(55) − hsk−1 , gk−1 − gk i − 1 (hsk−1 , ∇xx mk−1 (ψk−1 )sk−1 i + hsk−1 , ∇xx mk (ζk )sk−1 i)

(56) 2. 6 ksk−1 k · kgk−1 − gk k + κ 

(57)  ksk−1 k2 .. M2” Me4=J*\gp>Jn? ;H? 4Jk;HO=JlMH€•›8 d }I‚ Jr;HBžp2;HGOJl? R JR M>\gJ*C I MeB ∇ f ;HBLXCMekg4?g;>AhBX? −R ;2g? k = k∇ f (x k−1. k. x. k−1. œÊ ™8har],Ì 8 1Jl? R JBN;H[[G5Y? R J ) − ∇ f (x )k x. k. x. ∇x f (xk ) = ∇x f (xk−1 ) +. Z. ʜ™8haeaEÌ. 1. ∇xx f (xk−1 + αsk−1 )sk−1 dα.. U R O=9? R J f >; Ok R 5euzjk R ”<;H\ˆ¾~AhBJVO;HGAh?z5 C ;>BLX•›8halieAhpeJn? R ;2? kgk−1 − gk k 6. Z. 0. 1. k∇xx f (xk−1 + αsk−1 )k · ksk−1 k dα 6. j3O4=@?Ah?O?gAhBiY? R AŸ=<4M>OBLžABʜ™8a]SÌ C ”9JlM>4?†;HAB7? R ;2? 0. Z. 1 0. κ7 ksk−1 k dα = κ  ksk−1 k.. ʜ™8hatdƒÌ. | [mk−1 (xk−1 ) − mk−1 (xk )] − [mk (xk−1 ) − mk (xk )] | 6 (κ  + κ 

(58)  )ksk−1 k = 2κ

(59) ∆2k−1 2. ” R J*\gJl”ŠJ‘ŽB;>GhG57O=@J–Êœ™8 ™SÌ C ;>BLX? R Jlœ;ekŒ?<? R ;H? x ∈ B 8 2 1 J}kM>BkGOLJ \gM>I ? AŸ=n\Jr=@OGh?~? ;2?n? J›LJ*BMeI}AB;H?M>\†=ABN? J›J‰[\gJ=g=AhMeBžM> ;>BL LA‡P J*\n435 ;7VO;>Be?gA‡?z5 ” R AŸk R AŸ=nMHS? R R J}=g;HIKJ)M>\†R LJ*\‘;>R =0? R J}J*\g\Me\04J?z”9J*JBNR ? R J}IKMLJ*Gy;HBL ? R ρ˜J}M>4™ÍzJkŒρ?gAhpeJ OBkŒ?AM>B8 \go ;e=LAhBAOiY=0? AŸR =AŸ=~=O Meˆk4=J*AJ*\gBVpt;H?G?5FAM>=@B IYC ;>”ŠGhJGSk*;>M>\IKJB[M2;H”\gJLNk*;>?[MX;H4? R GhJJKM>i> \†;>= RLM2AhJ”BeA? BC iK;HB? R L ;2?~;HGŸ?=@RMXJ›? RAh?;2J?‘\g;H? ?R AM>J}B ?\gI›OO=@?@=@u ?0\J4i>J›AM>=BFOk*\†k*;>JL=gAh=zO O= G

(60) R A‡;e =n? R ?MJ AhBk\gJ;>=J‘AhBž? R A=~k;>=J>8 k. k−1. k. &¶S¹Nºž¶:

(61). )*. > >. U R J*B Ah?J\g;H?AM>B. j3O[[Me=Jl? R ;H?~•8aŒ3•›8 — R MeGL-8“j3O[[Me=Jl O\? R J\IKM>\gJn? R ;H? g ∆k−1. k−1. k. 6= 0. k−1. ;>BLX? R ;H?.  (1 − η˜2 ) κ 

(62)  6 min 1 − η1 , kgk−1 k. (3 − 2˜ η2 ) κ 

(63) . A=~=OkkJ=g=@ OG-;HBL. . Ê|™8a™,Ì Ê|™8a — Ì. ∆k > ∆k−1 .. @=¨Oº¤k¹ kJr¹ =C =@  OG;>1 BJL}Ž? R\g=@O?0=“;H? [R [;2Gh? 5 xU R =J*Mex\JI +s 8 — s8 d)MH 6=f xMeBBNJ8S?nmn;>4G|8 =J*Ê|\gdHp>]eJ]>]SBÌSM2”„?gM7? LR Jr;2L?ŠO? kR JJ0? k*R M>;HB?0=@?gA‡?g;>J*BV\†?g;2= ?gηAh˜MeB ;HkBL −κ1 

(64) AŸ= GhAJAhBž? R JAhBV?gJ*\gpt;>G (0, 1) C ” R Ak R AI}[GhAJ=<? R ;2? ;HBLˆ? R O= κ (1 − η˜ ) < 1. ʜ™8hat‹ƒÌ 1 (1 − η˜ ) < <1 (3 − 2˜ η ) 2 (3 − 2˜ η ) U R Jnk*M>BLAh?AM>B=:ʜ™8har™,Ì C Ê|™8ar‹ƒÌ C ;>BL'ʜ™8 ™SÌ C kMeI›4ABJLK”Ah? R ? R J‘LJŽBA‡?gAhMeBˆMH β AhBX•8 — AI}[Gh5}? R ;2? ʜ™8ha s Ì kg k kg k ∆ < < . . k. k−1. k−1. k−1. 2. 2. 2. mdc. 2. 2. k−1. k−1. k−1. κ 

(65) . k−1. βk−1.

(66) ^. 

(67)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. •0=~;KkMeB=JVOJ*BkJ C •›8 — AIKI}JrLAŸ;2?JGh5Xi>Ap>Jr=“? R ;2?. ʜ™8ha2^|Ì mnB7? R JMH? R J*\ R ;>BL C ”9JlIY;t57;H[[Gh57TJ*IKIY;K™8–d);>BLžO=Jn? R Jl?\gAŸ;HBieGhJlABJVO;>GhAh?z5Y?MKMe4?g;>AhBX? R ;H? mk−1 (xk−1 ) − mk−1 (xk ) > κ 

(68) . .  kgk−1 k kgk−1 k min , ∆k−1 = κ 

(69)  kgk−1 k∆k−1 . βk−1.

(70)

(71)

(72)

(73)

(74) mk−1 (xk−1 ) − mk−1 (xk )

(75)

(76) mk (xk−1 ) − mk (xk )

(77)

(78)    

(79) 6

(80) mk−1 (xk−1 ) − mk−1 (xk ) − mk (xk−1 ) − mk (xk )

(81) 6 2κ  ∆2k−1. ;HBL7? R J\J* M>\gJ C ”Ah? R ʜ™8ha2^|Ì C ? R ;H?. |mk (xk−1 ) − mk (xk )|. > |mk−1 (xk−1 ) − mk−1 (xk )| − 2κ 

(82) ∆2k−1 > κ 

(83)  kgk−1 k∆k−1 − 2κ 

(84) ∆2k−1 .. ‚ M2”UÊ|™8a™S̓AIK[GAhJr=<? R ;H? (3 − 2˜η )κ

(85) ∆ . 2. k−1. 6 (1 − η˜2 )κ 

(86)  kgk−1 k. ;HBLX? R O=9? R ;2?. (1 − η˜2 )(κ 

(87)  kgk−1 k − 2κ 

(88) ∆k−1 ) > κ ∆k−1 > 0.. JlŽB;HGGh5ˆIY;t57;>[[G57U R JM>\gJ*I ™8ha;HBLXLJrLOk*Jl \MeI • 8–d C Ê|™8–dƒÌ C ʜ™8a`SÌ9;HBLbʜ™8harb,̓? R ;H? 1.

(89)

(90)

(91) f (xk−1 ) − mk (xk−1 )

(92) κ 

(93) ∆k−1

(94)

(95) 6 |˜ ρk − 1| =

(96) 6 1 − η˜2 .

(97) mk (xk−1 ) − mk (xk ) κ  kgk−1 k − 2κ  ∆k−1. ʜ™8har`,Ì Êœ™8harb,Ì Êœ™8 d>],Ì. U R J*\gJ Me\J C ρ˜ > η˜ ;HBLbÊ|d8 s ̊? R JBžJB=O\Jr=Š? R ;H? ʜ™8a — Ì R M>GŸL=8 2 kO\g\g  J*?BVA?9=‘Ah??RJ\gJ*;H\g?JJ MeAŸ\=<J}Bi>MHO?~;>B\g;>JBV;H\?J*k*Jr\LNAh??AŸk*R ;>;2Gh?lG5>? 8yR U JKR ?AŸ\g=OAŸ=z=<?uxJ*\gBJ*=ieOAhMe\gJBFLX\†4V;>L57AO? R =lJk*;>BBJ‰3B?<M>? ?R J4M>Jˆ\gJ*LI Jrk8 \gJ;e=@JrLFABLJŽBA‡?gJ*G5Ah“? R J )* &¶S¹Nºž:¶

(98) >  B j3O[[Me=J‘? R ;H?0•8aŒ3•›8 — R MeGL-8yjO[[Me=Jl O\@? R J*\gIKM>\gJ0? R ;2?<? R J*\gJJ‰AŸ=z?†=;)k*M>B=@?g;>Be? =Ok R ? R ;2? kg k > κ  Me\~;HGG k 8SU R JBX? R J*\gJlA=0;}k*M>B=@?g;>BV? κ ? =Ok R ? R ;H? κ Ê|™8–daEÌ ∆ > κ ?  M>\~;>GhG k 8 k. . 2. k. . k. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  U R Jl[\gM3MH€A=<? R J=g;HIKJ;>=9 M>\~U R J*M>\gJ*I s 8 — 8 ™}AB f eM BB J?0;>G|8ÊxdH]>]e],̓J‰kJ[?? R ;2? . κ .  (1 − η˜2 ) γ1 κ 

(99)  κ  = min 1 − η1 , . (3 − 2˜ η2 ) κ 

(100) . i>GM>46;>\gGVM>k*I M>B3R p>J*J\g\JieJ*M>BB k*C JS? MHR J›? [R \JM3;HM>G

(101) i>Me Me\\Ah? R? R I J)?g4M0;>Ž=AŸ\gk‘=@?@?u \gM>O\†=zL?nJ*\\Jki>\gAAhM>?BAŸk*;H;HGV[[[M>GAAJBe=?†= ”” Ah? R R J*MeB)O?‘A‡?yk ieR J*;HBBJie\g;HJ>?8J1=

(102) M>JBŽGh5l\†=@Ž?nBLA‡?gJJ*LGO5kIKJl;>? B3R 5J =@Ok*kJr==@ OGAh?J\g;H?AM>B=8 j3O[[Me=J? ;2?•8aŒ•8 M>GŸL8j3O[[Me=J O\@? J*\gIKM>\gJ? ;H?0? J*\gJ);>\JMeBG5XŽBA‡?gJ*G5 IY)* &;HB3¶S5¹Nºž=@:¶O

(103) kkJr>==@  OGVA‡?gJ*\†;2?AM>B=*R 8€U R J*B x =— xR  M>\ ;HGGV=O ˆkAJ*BV?G5R GŸ;H\gi>J k ;HBR L x R A=

(104) Ž\†=z?uxMe\gLJ*\k*\Ah?AŸk*;>G|8 2. . k. ∗. ∗.

(105) `. 

(106)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  U R J›=g;HIKJ;H\gi>OIKJBe?0;e=ABFU R J*Me\JI s 8 8 AB M>BB J?‘;HGx8 Ê|d>]>]e],̊IY;t574J);H[[GhAJL =AhBkJ ? R J<\†;>LAO=

(107) O[L;2?J<AŸ=€ALJBV?AŸk*;HGV?gMn? R ;2? MH? R J<4;e=@AŸkS—?g\— O=z? \fJi>AM>BIKJ*? R ML› M>\ OB=Ok*k*J=g=z OGVAh?J\g;H?AM>B=8 2 6

(108) AB;>GhG5 ? J~BJ‰3?y?z”ŠM\gJ=OGh?g= JB=@O\J<? Ji>GM>4;>GkMeBVpeJ*\gi>JBkJ9MH? J~;>GhieM>\gA‡? I ?gMlŽ\g=@?@u M>\†LJ\ k*\Ah?AŸk*;>G [MeAhBV?†= C 435C = R R M2”ABi7AB;7Ž\†=z?=@?J*[ ? R ;2?;2R ?lGhJr;>=@?‘MeBJK;>k*k*OI›OG;H?AM>BR [M>ABV?MHSR ? R JKA‡?gJ*\†;2?Jr=l=@JreOJ*Bk*J)AŸ= Ž\†=z?uxMe\gLJ\9k*\Ah?AŸk*;>G|8 )* &¶S¹Nºž:¶

(109) >  j3O[[Me=Jl? R ;H?~•8aŒ3•›8 — R MeGL-8SU R J*B M>BJ R ;>=9? R ;2? ʜ™8 dedƒÌ lim inf k∇ f (x )k = 0. . . x. k→∞. k. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  j3JJU R J*Me\JI s 8 — 8–‹AB f M>BBžJ?0;>G|8ÊxdH]e]>],Ì8 2 Ž\†=z?•0uxMe=)\gL M>J\)\9k*? R\AhJž?AŸk*4;>;eG|=@8 AŸkY?g\O=@?@u \gJ*i>AM>B IKJ*? R ML C ? R AŸ=)k;HB$4JXJ*‰3?J*BLJL$?M = R M2” ? R ;2?Y;HGGŠGAI}Ah?K[MeAhBV?g=K;>\J )* &¶S¹Nºž:¶

(110) >  j3O[[Me=Jl? R ;H?~•8aŒ3•›8 — R MeGL-8SU R J*B M>BJ R ;>=9? R ;2? ʜ™8 d>™,Ì lim k∇ f (x )k = 0. . . k→∞. x. k. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  j3JJU R J*Me\JI s 8 — 8 s A B f M>BBžJ?0;>G|8ÊxdH]e]>],Ì8 . . 2. !"$#%'&( "#% 4/.1  4  +

(111) &8+#%9;:=<>+&8-. JYBM2” ABVpeJ=@?Aie;H?J}? JY[Me=g=Ah4AGA‡?z5N?gMNJ‰[GM>Ah?›=@JrkMeBL3u M>\†LJ*\‘AhB M>\gIK;H?AM>BM>B? JYM>4fÍzJrkŒ?Ap>J} OBkŒ?AM>B ”A‡? R ? R J;>AhI M>€JB=O\RABiKkMeBVpeJ*\gi>JBkJ0?Mˆ=JkMeBL3u M>\†LJ*\<k\gAh?AŸk*;HG[M>ABV?g= C A|8 J>8y[M>ABVR ?g= x =Ok R ? R ;2? C ;HBL ∇ f (x ) AŸ=[Me=A‡?gAhpeJ=@JI}AŸLJ*ŽBAh?J . ∇ f (x ) = 0 m0 k*M>O\†=J ”9JBJ*JrLX?M7k*G;>\Ah 5ˆ” ;H?0”ŠJ[\JrkAŸ=@JGh5ˆIKJr;HBN435Î=@JrkMeBL3u M>\†LJ*\<AB M>\gIY;2?AM>Bfφ8 1J? R J*\gJ Me\J AhBV?g\MLOk*J‘C ? R Jl MeGhGM2”AhBi};eLLAh?AM>BR ;>G-;>=g=@OIK[?gAhMeB=w   U R JI}MLJGAŸ=S;>=53I}[?MH?gAk;HGGh5)=@JrkM>BL3uxMe\gLJ*\ykM R J*\gJ*BV?y”A‡? R ? R J~Me4fÍzJk?Ap>J9 OBk?AM>BYBJr;H\ Ž\†=@?@u M>\†LJ*\ k*\Ah?AŸk*;>G[MeAhBV?g= C Ax8 Je8 ” R J*BJ*p>J\ lim kg k = 0. lim k∇ f (x ) − ∇ m (x )k = 0   U R J 0J=g=@AŸ;HBMH<J*peJ*\g5NIKM3LJ*G AŸ=TAh[=gk R Ah?«¾YkMeBV?ABVOM>O= C ? R ;2?AŸ= C ? R J*\gJYJ‰AŸ=z?†=; kM>B=z?†;HBV? κ  m =Ok R ? R ;H? C  Me\~;HGG k C k∇ m (x) − ∇ m (y)k 6 κ  kx − yk  Me\~;HGG x, y ∈ B 8     €? R J=@IY;HGGJ=@?<JAhieJ*B3p2;HGOJ MH€? R J 0J=g=@AŸ;HBžMH

(112) ? R JIKMLJ*G m ;2? x AŸ=<BJie;2?gAhpeJ C ? R J*B τ 1. ∗. x. xx. ∗. ∗. . k→∞. xx. k. xx. k. k. k→∞. . k. xx. k. xx. k. k. . k. k. mk (xk ) − mk (xk + sk ) > κ 7.  Me\~=@MeI}Jk*M>B=@?g;>Be? κ 7 ∈ (0, ) 8 . 1 2. k. |τk | min(τk2 , ∆2k ). k.

(113) b. 

(114)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. U R J=J;>=g=@OI}[?AM>B=;>\JlAŸLJ*BV?AŸk*;>G ?MK? R Me=JlO=@JrLžAhBFj3JrkŒ?AM>B= s 8–‹);>BL s 8 s M> MeBB J?~;HGx8 ÊxdH]>]e],ÌS M>\<? R J 4 ;>=AŸkY?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>B IKJ? R ML8  šB œ;ekŒ? C ? R J =@JrkMeBL3u M>\†LJ*\}kM>B3peJ*\gi>J*BkJY[\gM>[J*f \?AJ=)MH? R JX\gJ?g\MV=@[Jk?Ap>J ?;H\gBOLX=@?@? u \JJ*i>A\~AM>[BK\gM3IKMHJœ=~? R kM3;HL7Bž;HJGŸ=g=@=@MlJBe?gO?gA\;>B7GhG57M>O4?ŠJ*?JMB 44J0MeJ*\\g‰M2;e”ŠkŒ?gJrGhLY5) ? \gR M>J‘I =;>? IKAŸJ0=0;>k=S;>=? J R MV”=@JnAh? MH ? ? R JJnJ4‰;>k=JAŸk<[??A\gM>OB =@?@M>u \JTi>J*AM>IKBKIYIK; J? R 8–‹M38 L ™C8 R R C R R s 1 J? R J\J* M>\gJ‘BJ*JLž?gMY[\gJ=J*BV?0;K[\gMVM>€M>

(115) ? R ;2?n[;H\?AŸkOGŸ;H\\gJ=OGh? M>\? R JBJ” IKJ*? R ML8<•0=0”ŠJABLAŸk*;H?J 4JGhM2 š” BFC M>;HOG\‘GMH;H? BR ;>J*Gh\9MeiY\JrMH=@SOGhT-?g=“JIKi>JIKB;J*\†s;HG8–A©‹¾8 J~™ ””9Ah? J›R Me;eO==?9Ok IKR J;>B? i>R Jn;2?0;HB? RLYJ›”9IKJ0MMeLBJG5}G

(116) \gIKJLJOBe?gkŒAh?MeAM>BYBN? R AŸ=~J*I Jp>J M>Be\“?gO? ;HR GJlG5ž=g;|=É>AhieJ0BMHAhŽk*k;>GŸ;HBe\g?nAh?zAh5>B 8 ? R JX=@JB=@Jˆ? R ;H?›A‡?}A=);2?›GJ;e=z?)MH<? R C JX=;>I}J7M>\†LJ*\;e=? R JˆJ*\g\Me\4J*?z”ŠJJ*B ? R J7IKMLJ*G9;HBL? R J7Me4fÍzJk?Ap>J  OBk?AM>B-8 1Jl? R JBž= R M2”#? R ;2?? R J‘?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>B7\†;>LAhO=94Jk*M>IKJ=;e=@53IK[?M>?AŸk*;>GhG5YAh\g\gJ*GJ*p2;HBV?<A‡

(117) ? R J=@?J[= ?JBLX?M¾*J\M8 V:¶

(118)

(119) ! >  j3O[[MV=@Jl? R ;2?‘•8aŒ3•›8 ™ C ;HBLž•›8 ‹ R M>GŸL89j3O[[MV=@J;>G=M}? R ;H?~? R J*\gJJ‰A=@?g=;Y=JVOJBkJ ;>BL ;KkM>B=z?†;HBV? κ 7 > 0 =Ok R ? R ;2? (k ) ʜ™8 d — Ì m (x ) − m (x + s ) > κ 7 ks k > 0  M>\~;>GhG i =@O ˆk*AhJBe?gGh57G;>\ieJ>8y6€AhB;>GhG5 C =O[[Me=Jl? R ;2? . . . i. ki. ki. U R J*B Ah?J\g;H?AM>B k AŸ=~=Ok*k*J=g=z OG-;>BL. ki. ki. ki. lim kski k = 0.. i→∞. i.  M>\ i =@Oˆk*AhJBe?gGh57G;>\ieJ>8. 2. . ki. ρ˜ki +1 > η˜2. ;HBL. Ê|™8–d>‹ƒÌ. ∆ki +1 > ∆ki. @=¨Oº¤k¹ kJr¹ =C =@  OG1 Me\JniŽ\g==@O?<ˆk;>[A[J*BVG5ˆ?G57T-JGŸI};H\gIYi>Je; 8 s ‚ 8–‹M28” ™C M>k* M>f BM>=ABLBXJ*\ J?~k ;HGxM>8´BÊ|Jld>]>=O]>]Sk RÌ ?gAhM}?J*L\†;2Jr?gLAhOMek*B-Jn8“? U R R ;2J?<J*JrpeVJ*O\g;25K?gAhA‡Me?gBJ*\†=2;2ʜ?™AM>8 — B Ì<k;HBAŸL = ʜ™8–‹ƒÌŠAIK[Gh57? R ;H? M>\~=M>IKJ ξ ;HBL ζ AhBž? R J=@Ji>IKJ*BV? [x , x ] C . i. i. ki +1. ki +1. ki. ki +1.

(120)

(121)

(122)

(123) f (xki ) − mki +1 (xki )

(124) |˜ ρki +1 − 1| =

(125)

(126) mki +1 (xki ) − mki +1 (xki +1 )

(127)

(128)

(129)

(130) hsk , ∇xx f (ξki +1 )ski i − hski , ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )ski i

(131)

(132) =

(133)

(134) i − hski , gki +1 i + 12 hski , ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )ski i

(135). ʜ™8 d s Ì ” R J*\gJ)”9JK;HGŸ=@MžO=JLN? R J f ;HOk R 5Vuzjk R ”9;>\«¾ABJVO;>GhAh?z5>8}:95F=@O4=z?gA‡?gO?ABi g = ∇ f (x ) ʜ4J*u \k*J;H”O=@\JXAh?@?gMHJ*nB •›;>8= d,̛”Ah? R A‡?†=}J‰[\gJ=g=@AM>B$ABXÊ|™8a>a¤Ì C ? R J LJ*BMeI}AB;H?M>\ D M>~? R JXGŸ;2??J*\} \†;>k?AM>B k;HB 4J ks k2 · k∇xx f (ξki +1 ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k

(136) ki

(137)

(138) − hski , gki +1 i + 1 hski , ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )ski i

(139). 6. 2. ki +1.

(140)  Z

(141) D =

(142)

(143) − ski , gki +. U R J*B C \J[G;ekABi D. 1. . ∇xx f (xki + αski )ski dα +. 1 2. x. ki +1.

(144)

(145) hski , ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )ski i

(146)

(147) .. 435ˆAh?g=J*‰[\Jr==AM>B7ABʜ™8 `SÌ C ”9J‘Me4?g;>AhB. 0. − hski , gki i

(148)

(149) =

(150)

(151) mki (xki ) − mki (xki +1 ) +. 1 2. hski , ∇xx mki (ψki )ski i.  Z + 21 hski , ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )ski i − ski ,. 1 0. 

(152)

(153) ∇xx f (xki + αski )ski dα

(154)

(155).

(156) a]. 

(157)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0.  M>\Y=@MeIKJ ψ AhB ? R JN=J*ieI}JBV? [x , x ] 8 U R J7?g\AŸ;HBi>GJXABJVO;>GhAh?z5 C [\gM>[J*\?AJ=}MH~? R J AhBV?gJ*i>\†;HG C ʜ™8–d — Ì C ;>BL f ;>Ok R 5Vušjk R ”<;H\ˆ¾~ABJVO;>GhAh?z5ˆi>Ap>J‘? R J*\gJ Me\J‘? R Jl M>GGhM2”ABi}GhM2”9J*\<4M>OBLžMeB D w ki. D. ki. ki +1. > |mki (xki ) − mki (xki +1 )|

(158)   Z 1

(159) 1

(160) [∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki (ψki )]ski dα − 2

(161) s ki , 0  

(162) Z 1

(163) + s ki , [∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )]ski dα

(164)

(165) 0. > κ. 7 . 2. kski k − 21 kski k −. > kski k2 (κ 7 − 12 i ). ” R J*\gJ def. i =. 1 2 kski k. Z. 1. Z. k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki (ψki )k · kski k dα. 0. Z. 1. k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k · kski k dα. 0. 1. k∇xx f (xki +αski )−∇xx mki (ψki )k dα+. U R Jl?\gA;>Bi>GJ‘AhBJrVO;HGA‡?z57BM2” AIK[GhAJ=? R ;H? 0. 1. Z. k∇xx f (xki +αski )−∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k dα.. 0. k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki (ψki )k 6 k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx f (xki )k. ;HBL C =@AIKAhGŸ;H\gGh5 C ? R ;H?. ʜ™8 dV^|Ì. + k∇xx f (xki ) − ∇xx mki (xki )k + k∇xx mki (xki ) − ∇xx mki (ψki )k. k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k 6 k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx f (xki +1 )k. j3AhBkJ”9J‘BM2” M>4=@J\peJ0? R ;2?. + k∇xx f (xki +1 ) − ∇xx mki +1 (xki +1 )k + k∇xx mki +1 (xki +1 ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k.. k(xki + αski ) − xki k 6 kski k, k(xki + αski ) − xki +1 k 6 kski k,. ʜ™8 d>`,Ì Êœ™8 d>b,Ì. kψki − xki k 6 kski k, kζki +1 − xki +1 k 6 kski k,. ”ŠJlIY;t57LJrLOkJl? R ;2?~4MH? R. H; BL k∇ f (x + αs ) − ∇ m (ζ )k kM>B3peJ*\gi>JS?gM2¾*J\M‘”A‡? R ks k 4Jrk*;>O=@J9? R J<Ž\†=z?“;>BL? R A\gL)?J\IY= M>? R J\Ai R ?u R ;>BL›=AŸLJMHʜ™8–dH`S̀;HBL ʜ™8–dHbSÌy?gJ*BLX?gM¾J*\gM›4357k*M>BV?AB3OA‡?z5YM>? R JM>4fÍzJrkŒ?gAhpeJ0 OBkŒ?AM>B’ =;>BL7IKMLJG|’ = ~Jr==A;>B= ;>BLX4Jrk*;HO=@J ?•R 8–JY‹7IK;>BAŸLLFLU GJY?JJM>\\gI J*I AB™8 ? ^3R 8lJ7•0\A=li ;7R ?@k*u RM>B;>B=JLVO=AJLBJYkJ MH“? R J=JYABJV” O;>GhJ*AhB ?AJ=A=l;>G==O M ˆkkM>AB3J*peBVJ*?\gG5Ni>JG=n;>\?gieM5J ¾J*;H\gC BM LN4? Jrk*J;H\OJ*=@ JKM>\gMHJ  kM>I)4ABAhBivR Ê|™8–d s ̊;>BLbʜ™8–de^ƒÌ C ;>BL7O=@ABiK? R C Jl ?\g6A;>Bκi> G7Jn ABJrR eO;HGiA‡?z5 C ”ŠJlM>4?g;HAB C R C k∇xx f (xki + αski ) − ∇xx mki (ψki )k. xx. ki. ki. xx. ki +1. ki +1. ki. i. |˜ ρki +1 − 1| 6 6. . 2 k∇xx f (ξki +1 ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k κ 7  2 k∇xx f (ξki +1 ) − ∇xx f (xki +1 )k κ 7 + k∇xx f (xki +1 ) − ∇xx mki +1 (xki +1 )k + k∇xx mki +1 (xki +1 ) − ∇xx mki +1 (ζki +1 )k. . ʜ™8 ™e],Ì.

(166) a>a. 

(167)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. Š: 5 ? R JX=g;HIKJˆ\gJ;>=M>BAhBiN;e= M>\Êœ™8–dH`SÌx´Êœ™8–dHbSÌ C ? R JX\Ai R ?@u R ;>BL =@AŸLJˆM> ʜ™8 ™>]SÌn?JBL=›?M'¾J*\gMN” R J*B ieMVJr=9?MˆABŽBA‡?z5 ;HBL ? J\J* M>\gJl?JBL=?gMFa>8Š  ?nAŸ=<? R O=0G;>\ieJ*\<? R ;HB η˜ < 1  M>\ i =@Oˆk*AhJBe?gGh5 i G;>\ieJ‘;>BLJʜ™8–d>‹,ÌyC MeGhGM2”~ρ˜=8 R 2 •0=AB$T-JIKIK; 8–‹8 M> M>BB J*?);HGx8VÊ|d>]>]e],Ì ”ŠJYIY;t5 ;H[[Gh5? AŸ=\gJ=OGh??M ? JˆJ*BV?gAh\gJ7=JVOJ*BkJYMH A‡?gJ*\†;2?gJ=y;HBL}LJLOk*Js ? R — ;2?“;HGGf Ah?J\g;H?AM>B=y;>\JJp>J*BVC ?gO;HGGh5)=@OkkJr==@ OG;>R BL)? R J?g\O=z?ux\gRJ*ieAhMeB›\†;>LAO= 4M>OBLJL ;t”9;t65}\gM> \gI M>I0J*¾*\gJ*J\gMM>8 B ? J? JM>\g5XAB M>BB J*?‘;HGx8 ÊxdH]>]e],Ì9ieJ*BJ\g;>GhAœ¾*Jr=<”A‡? M>O?‘=@Ai>BAhŽk;HBV?0k ;HBi>J 5VAJ*GŸLABi R R C f ? R Jl MeGhGM2”R ABi)\gJ=OC Gh?gR=8 R ki +1. 2. j3O[[Me=J? ;2?‘•›8ha3•›8 ‹ M>GŸLN;HBLž? ;2? AŸ=0;ˆ=O4=JVOJBkJ›MH ? J)A‡?gJ*\†;2?gJ=ieJ*Bu *J)*\† &;2?g¶SJ¹NL ºž¶:43

(168) 5 •0> Gh ieM>\gA‡? R I Z U Z R k*M>B3p>J\ieAhBi7R ?gM; Ž\†=z?uxMeR \gLJ*\x k\gAh?AŸk*;HG“[MeAhBV? x ” R J\JˆR ? R J 0J=g=@AŸ;HB M> ? R J}M>4™ÍzJkŒ?gAhpeJ OBk?AM>B ∇ f (x ) AŸ=0[Me=A‡?gAhpeJ)LJ*ŽBAh?Je8‘j3O[[MV=@J› O\@? R J*\gIKM>\gJ? R ;2? s 6= 0  Me\n;HGG =@AO Yk*AhJBV?G5XGŸ;H\gi>Je8ŠU R JB ? R J›k*M>IK[GJ?gJ›=@JrVOJ*Bk*JMHyAh?J*\†;2?gJ=~k*M>B3p>J\ieJ=Š?M x C ;HGGAh?J\g;H?AM>B=0;H\gJ kJ*peJ*BV?O;>GhG5ˆpeJ*\g5ˆ=@OkkJr==@ OG ;HBLX? Jl?\gO=z?ux\gJ*ieAhMeB7\†;>LAO= A=4M>OBLJLž;t”<;t5K \MeI¾*J\M8 C R ∆ ki. ∗. xx. k. ∗. ∗. k. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  j3JJU R J*Me\JI s 8–‹8–‹AB f M>BBžJ?0;>G|8ÊxdH]e]>],Ì8 2 GhJr;>=@1 ?M>JlBBJM2=”#Jk[Me\gBM3L3MHu M>?\†R L;2J*?<\<A‡k\gAh? ?R AŸk*Jl;H=@G-Jr;eVk*Ok*J*OBI›k*JnOGŸM>;2-?gA‡Ah?gMeJ*BX\†;2[?gM>JA=ŠBV\?JAIK=;>ieAhOB;H=“\†A;HBXBV?g;}J*JkL-MeI}8 [;>kŒ?<=@J*? C ? R J*BX? R J‘J‰AŸ=z?gJ*Bk*J0MH€;2? . j3O[[MV=@JF? ;H?X•8aŒ•8 ^ M>GŸL#;HBL ? ;2? ;HGG0Ah?J\g;H?J=ˆ\JIK;>AhB AB =M>IKJFkMeI}[;>kŒ? @= J*&?8¶S¹NU ºžR ¶:J

(169) BF? > R J*\g. J›J*‰3AŸ=@?g=l;2?‘GhJrR ;>=@?nM>BJ)GAhIKAh?‘R [M>ABV? x MHyR ? R JY=@JreOJ*Bk*J›MHSAh?J\g;H?Jr= x [\gMLOk*JLN435 •~Gi>Me\Ah? R I Z U Z C ” R AŸk R AŸ==JkMeBL3u M>\†LJ*\<k\gAh?AŸk*;HGx8 )*. k. ∗. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  j3JJU R J*Me\JI s 8 s 8–‹AB f M>BBžJ?0;>G|8ÊxdH]e]>],Ì8 2 :Š5 ÍzO=@?0=z?g\JBiH? R J*BABi}? R J‘\†;>LAhO=<O[L;H?J\gOGJ‘435X\JreOAh\gAhBi›? R ;2? A‡ ρ˜ > η˜ ;>BL ∆ 6 ∆ , ? R J*B ∆ ∈ [γ ∆ , γ ∆ ] ʜ™8 ™aEÌ GhAM>IK\‘A‡=@?~Me[I}M>J ABVγ?~MH>

(170) ? γ J>=JV1O;>JBBkLNJl=MHM> IKAh?J J*∆\†;2?gJ=<ie>J*B0JC\g;H”9?J›JL7IK43M>57\gJ*•~M2peGi>J*Me\\M>Ah? 4?gI ;HABNU? R J)8 =Jk*M>BL3u M>\†LJ\0k\gA‡?gAk;HGA‡?z5žMH“;>B35 R R Z Z . k. 4. k. 2. 3. max. k+1. k. 3. 4. k. max. j3O[[MV=@J)? ;2?•8aŒ3•›8–^ ;HBL‰Êœ™8 ™aEÌ M>GŸL;HBLFGJ? 4J};>B35NGhAIKA‡?[M>ABe?lMH“? R J =@Jr&VO¶SJ*¹NBºžk*:¶ Jl

(171) MH > A‡?g2J*\† ;2?Jr=*8yU R JB Rx AŸ=;Y=@JrkMeBC L3u M>\†LJ*\<k\gA‡?gAkR ;HG[M>ABV?8 x. )*. ∗. ∗. ¨º¤¹ ¹ C  j3J*JU R JM>\gJ*I s 8 s 8 `)AB f MeBBžJ?0;HGx8 ÊxdH]>]e],Ì8 2 U O=y? J0\gJ?\gMe=[JkŒ?gAhpeJ<?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>BY;HGi>Me\Ah? I = ;H\gJ=S;>GhG? JÊ ABe?gJ*\gJ=@?ABiSÌSkM>B3peJ*\gi>J*BkJ<[\gM>[J*\?AJ= MH€? R J›R 4;>=AR kn?g\O=@?@u \gJ*i>AM>BžIKJ? R MLXOBLJ*\0? R J=g;HR IKJ;eR ==OIK[?AM>BR =*81JkMeBkGOLJl? R AŸ=? R J*M>\g57=Jk?AM>B 435 BÊ [MHMe?gAh=gB=@Ai)4G? 5 R ;2A‡??gJ*? \†R ;2J?AM>;H4B M2Lp>J*Jl[kJ*MeBB3Lp>J*J*BV\g?i>Ì)JBOkBJ‘Ah \gM>J\g=IKOG‡Gh?†5 =Jr;HV\gOJ‘Ah=@p2?;>AGhGJG-Bep2?};HGBALžM>\gAhI €MeB? JJ*\\gJJ*[43GŸ;>5 kJr;H=ŠGGhM2? R”J ABv iFO[kG\gAM>L4JrGh;HJB I BMe=gk*\;>I GhAB43i5ž;H;HBB3L5 C R [\gJkMeBLAh?AM>BABi8 .

(172) ard. 

(173)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0. à 3È È3Á,?2à ÁÆ C 6ÃÈ3Ç3? AN6S8:6ÃÈ6Á5Ç36 1 JBM2”„k*M>B=ALJ*\ ? R J~B3OIKJ*\gAk;HG4J R ;tp3AM>O\yM>? R J~BJ”„;>GhieM>\gA‡? R I C AhBˆk*M>IK[;>\AŸ=@MeB›”Ah? R ? R J4;>=AŸk9?\gO=z?u ?\RJi>J7AM>a B — s ;>OGhieBM>k\gMeA‡? BR =zI?g\g;>:<AhBU JLžZ [ʜ\g=M>J*4JžGJ*[IY;>i>=JM>€a>a? Rs J MH  f  Me BB

(174) Sk*J*M>?KGGhJr;>kŒG|?8AM>ÊxdHB ]>]eÊ|=@],JÌ«J›ÌŒ8 ˜‘M>1OJXGŸL ?gC Jmn=@?}\44;HMHBN? R ;HB;>LNGhieU

(175) M>\gM>A‡A? BVR ? IYC =›dH]>Me]eB ™,Ì;>8ŠGhG<6MeMH\  ? R J[\Me4GhJIY=” R Me=JLAI}JB=AhMeBžIY;t5ˆ" 4J›+3 k R>;> + B i>JrL C ”9Jk R Me=J;K\Jr;>=M>B;>4Gh5ˆ=IY;HGG-p2;HGOJABžMe\gLJ*\BM>??M M2p>J\GMe;eLž? R J  

(176) 9AhBV?gJ*\œ;>kJ}”Ah? R 8KU R JY=z?†;H\?ABiž[MeAhBV?g=;>\J)? R JK=@?g;>BL;>\gLM>BJr=l[\M2p3AŸLJL 435Y? R J  

(177)

(178) GAh4\†;H\g5>8 6M>\7? R J 4;>=AŸkF;HGi>Me\Ah? R I ? R JF?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>B \†;>LAO=ˆO[L;H?JF”<;>=7AhIK[GJ*IKJBe?gJL#435„O=AhBi$? R J \OGJ [\gM>[Me=JLˆAB f M>BBžJ?0;>G|8 Ê|dH]e]>C ]SÌ C [-8^H`>™w  A‡ ρ > η C max[γ ks k, ∆ ]    A‡ ρ ∈ [η , η ) C ∆ ∆ = A‡ ρ ∈ [0, η ) C  γ ks k   A‡ ρ < 0 C  min[γ ks k, max[γ , θ ]∆ ] ” R J*\gJ γ AŸ=‘މJL ;H?]8 ] s de‹ C γ ;H? 0.25 C γ ;H? 2.5 C η ;H? 0.05 ;>BL η ;2? 0.9 ;HBL” R J\J θ A=i>Ap>J*B 435šÊ|d8 d,̆8SUM};tp>MeALY4A;e=@ABi? JlkM>IK[;>\AŸ=M>B ”ŠJ ;tp>J‘LJk*ALJLY?gM)IY;ƒÉ>Jn;e=Š J*” ;eL;H[?†;2?gAhMeB=Š;e=“[Me=g=Ah4GJ ?OMB=? OR k*;2k*?YJ=g\=zO OGhJ G AAxB„8 J>8MeO\K\J*?\gMe=[RJrkŒ?gAhpeJXp2;H\gAŸ;HBV?vC ʜA|8 J>8 R jV?gJ*[#d AhB#•~Gi>Me\Ah? R I d8aĚ8 U R O= C AhnAh?J\g;H?AM>B k AŸ= ;>BL kMeB=@JrVOJ*BV?G5 ”9J;HGŸ=MKLJk\gJ;e=@J‘? R J?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>BXO=@ABiK? R J ;H4M2p>J)\OGJ>8›C   C M>Bρ? R <JKkηMeBe?g\g;>\5 C A‡?gJ*\†;2?AM>B k xAŸ=l=@=OkxkJr==@ OC G C Ax8 J>8 ρ > η C ? R J)?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>BFAŸ=‘O[ L;2?gJL dlMH-;H•~BGLi>Me\Ah? R I d8ha~” R J*8

(179) \gU J”ŠJ0J0IKk R MMVLMVJ*=@GJ<”9? ;eR =“Jnk =g;HMVIK=@JJ~B p2;>AGhBYOJr4=“M>?;e=S;Hk;>4=M2Jp>= J OM>=\ AhBγiC? RγJ~[;>\BML kJrγLOC \g;>J0BL}LJr?g=;ƒk*É>\JA4η˜JrLK=AhB7ηj3?=J*[ž0.05 ?? MNJˆ4?JK\gO? R=z?J7ux\gJJ*‰ie;>AhMekB?›U

(180) ”<;t;>53=GM>k*\rM>’ =lIK=[J*\gOAh?gJrJ=‘L ?\gJOA‡? Bk*J*;H\)?JrJL‰;>?gkMF?G=@5Jrη˜kOMe==BAhBL3iηu M>? \†=LJžJ*0.9 \ ENC ;HM>B\gLquzR j3? RM>\gJˆJ*BIK=@AhJBB AhIK;HAœG¾*i>J*Me\›\R AhMH? 9I ? R CJYʜ=J*IKJ7MEFLJ*M>R GŠ\gAhqˆB=@;HAŸBLL J C j3R M>\gJ*B=@JB C abe`>™SÌ0C Me\;H[[\Mt‰AIK;H?JGh5NOR =ABiž? R JXj3?J*A R ;>OiHušRUMeAhBV?;HGi>Me\Ah? R I ʜ=J*JˆjV?gJ*A RR ;HOi C arb>`>™ C U

(181) M>ABe? C abe`aEÌ8K šB ? AŸ=k*;e=@J ? Jˆk*M>BžÍzOie;2?gJKi>\†;>LAJ*BV?A‡?gJ*\†;2?gAhMeB=;H\gJ}=@?Me[[JLA‡<? R JK?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>B4M>OBL;H\g5FAŸ= IKJ?~M>\;e==@M3R M>B ;>=9? R C JR IKMLJ*GŸ=*’i>\†;>LAJ*BV?=;H?AŸ=zŽJr=9? R Jk*M>BLA‡?gAhMeB  6A %C. 2. k+1. 1. k. k. 0. 1. k. k. 0. 2. k. 1. 2. 1. 1. 1. 2. 1. k. 2. k+1. k. 0. 2. k. 1. k. 1. k. k. k. 1. k. k. k. 2. 1. 2. @= IYJ<;>kGhGMeJ*B\=?ALR J;H\B JrLl10? R ;2?€8F? R6J9;>AhA‡G?gOJ*\g\†Jˆ;2?g”<Ahpe;>J“=[L\gJrMkkGŸJ;H=g\g=Jk*LM>B3Ahp>J? R\ieJžJLl;HG”i>M>R \gJAh?BR ? I R J Lv AL OkBGAMHL?}J;Hk*B)M>B3Bp>M>J\g\I ieJ)MH”? Ah?R R J9AhBi>\†;>? R LJ7AJ*BVIY?

(182) ;H4‰3JAkI›;HOIKI J B3OI›4J*\M>y‹>]‘]e]>])A‡?gJ*\†;2?gAhMeB=*8 M>\‘B31 OI›J4k R J*\‘MV=@MHJ‘S?g MˆOBkkŒM>?gIKAhMe[B;>\J*Jnp2;>? RGhOJ;H?BVAOM>I›B=48lJ*\~ šBM>L

(183) JAhJ?L J*\†C ;2? ?gR AhMeJ}Bk*=9Me?=@Mˆ?n[;eJ*k R\lAAhJ*?p>J*Jl\†;2k?gMeAhMeB3BFp>J*AŸ\g=~i>J? RBJYkJn=Ah;>BI}=z?gJ›J;> M>Lž\‘M>4

(184) M>? ? R R J ;Hf Gi>Q“M>o \gAh? ?R AIKIYJ = ;HBL)? R J*5}4M>? R Jp2;HGO;2?gJ<? R J~Me4fÍzJk?Ap>J< OBkŒ?A" M>BY+3 MeeB+ kJ [J*\ŠA‡?gJ*\†;2?gAhMeBK;>BLYkMeIK[O?J0M>BJie\g;eLAhJBV?y;H?“J*peJ*\g5 =@Ok*kJr==@ OGAh?J\g;H?AM>B-8yENMe\JM2p>J*\ C ?AI}ABiV=AhB ;H\gJlMH,?JBNLA ˆk*OG‡??gMYAhBV?gJ*\g[\J*?8 •~GG\gOB=”9J*\gJl[J\@ Me\IKJLXAB E;2?GŸ;H4 p 8V^8hae8 ]8har`>™ËÊ Z a — ̍j3J*\gp3Ak*J Q ;>kÉ7™KMeBž;Y™8 dK˜ R ¾ šBV?gJ*G=AhBi>GJu [kMe\g\MHJŠŽG[J\MMHk*J? =gR =@J0Me\€BVOk*M>I›IK4[J*\“O?gM>J*\ Ah”?JA‡\g? ;HR ?Ad‘M>B˜l=S: MHM>? R Z J•0?z”9E$M8H6

(185) ;HGAi>i>MeO\\AhJ ? R — IK8aŠ=\g8 J*Q [J\Jr\@=@MeJ\BeIY?†=-;H? BR kJJ<k[Me\gI}MHŽ[G;HJ\g=yA=ieM>AhpeBJ 43C 5 M>;n\S[Jp>J\@J*\gMe5 \IYσ ;>>Bk1J C ? R JŠ[\gM>[M>\?AM>B p(σ) MH3?gJ=@?

(186) [\gM>4GJ*IY=M>B” R AŸk R J;ek R kMeB=@AŸLJ\JrL;HGi>M>\gAh? R IKAŸk pt;>\AŸ;HBV? R ;>=;~[J\@ Me\IY;HBkJ ?”R A‡AŸ? =XR AŽB i>O;\Jœ;eC kŒ”Š?gM>J \ R σ;tp>MHJ‘M>? RBJG5 4É>JrJ*=z[?š?7Ê|=@? JR JFJ W0[Me\gM>G;>4B GhJIK;>B=7L  M>EN\žM>” \gq R C AŸk dHR ]e]e4d MHC ? R M>\7;HG; i>MeIK\AhMe? R \JNIYk=XMekIKM>[B3GhpeJ*J*?\gJFi>JLL AŸ=gk?gOM =g=@? AR M>J BǍ=g8 ;HIK šB J Gh%!M#%k;HG3=8(M>9GO% ?gAhMe B'%'Ê ”94J~J ‰kGO'L5Jr% L;HB <L C 3=!,#"($ %'&($ C ̌)8*  + ‘,? %-.JF =@OC 4/0[1\Me24)G* J*I 3 C AŸ0=Y4=@Me*Ghpe+ J5L " ;H5C [6[1 \g" Mt1 ‰'AhIY7 C ;H%!?J*4%G5 ) 348(M>9.? : C ;HGi>Me) \Ah? R IY=ŠC œ;H1 AGJL M>B?;C > 2 +0(61 2 A@ )C 4"%$ C  1) +6!5% 1 C  R ) 9' 0 "@5B C  ) 9' 0 ":B};HBL? ) 9' 0 "'7B8 EFM>\gC J*M2p>J\R C U œ;HAGhJrLKM>B 37 ” AŸk ”<;>=y=M>Gp>JL}435K:9U 83mnB}? J0MH? J*\ ;HBL A‡? J0=O4[\gM>4GhJI AŸ=“=M>Gp>JL JZ ‰;>Z k?G5 C 4MH? R ;H/Gi>0(M>1\g2Ah? ) R IY=

(187) C œ;HAGhR JrL›R MeB /012) 3'7‘;HBL}:<Z U Z œ;>AhGJR L}MeB R  ) R !5% 1 C C ” R R Ak R ”9;e=y=@MeGhpeJL›4V5 Z U Z 8 ‚ M>?J7;>G=M ? R J7BVOI›4J*\›M>A‡?gJ*\†;2?AM>B=BJ*JrLJL?gMF\gJ;>k R kMeB3p>J*\gi>JBkJK”Ah? R ? R J Z U Z ;HGi>Me\Ah? R I M>B? R J RkMeAi I}R [G5ˆGhJ*B?JlMeBB3kOMeIKBVpeJ*\gJA‰ k;H* G9 \g6 J>'=}OG‡;H?†=BL;H\g0 Jn(ieAh*pe+J*Bž5Ah")BN[•0\[Me[4JGhJBIYLAh=ЉžAŸ=<•›I›8 Ok RXR Ai R J*\9? R ;>B7 Me\<? R J:<U Z ;HGi>M>\gAh? R I 8yU R J k∇x mk (xk + s)k 6 min[0.1, k∇x mk (xk )k1/2 ]k∇x mk (xk )k.. 1. −5.

(188) a™. 

(189)     ! " #$%&' )(*+ ,-(.)/.0 RTR vs BTR 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2. MS−BTR MS−RTR TCG−BTR TCG−RTR. 0.1 0. 1. 1.5. 2. 2.5. 3. 3.5. 4. 4.5. 5. 6€AhieO\J — 8a>w Q J*\ M>\gIY;HBk*JS[\gMHŽGJ“k*M>IK[;H\gABi? R JŠB3OI)4J\

(190) M>A‡?gJ*\†;2?AM>B=-MH? R J Z U Z ;HBL›:9U Z ;HGi>M>\gAh? R IY= mnO\l\Jr=@OGh?g== R M2” ? R ;2?l? R JK\J*?\gMe=[JrkŒ?Ap>J};HGi>Me\Ah? R I [J*\ M>\gIY=l;>=‘”ŠJGhGS;e=n? R JYkGŸ;>=g=Ak;HG M>BJK;HBLAŸ= ÍzO=@?9;>=“\JGhAŸ;H4GhJ~Ah? R J~?\gO=@?@u \Ji>AM>BY=O4[\gM>4GJ*I AŸ=Š=M>Gp>JrL};>[[\gMt‰AhIY;2?gJ*G5>8~M2”9J*p>J\ C A‡? R J0[\Me4GhJI =Aœ¾*J M>\9=z?g\Ok?O\gJ0;>GhGM2”~=S;HBYJ*‰;>kŒ?9=@MeGhO?gAhMeB C ? R Jn\J*?\gMe=[JrkŒ?Ap>J~;>GhieM>\gA‡? R I A=S? R JB7=@Ai>BA‡Žk;HBV?G5}I}Me\J0<J ˆkAJ*BV? Ê,? J~AI}[\M2peJ*IKJ*BV?SAŸ=y?z53[AŸk*;HGG5›MHMeBGh5};‘ J*” Ah?J*\†;2?gAhMeB= 4O?9A=Sp>J*\g5)k*M>B=AŸ=z?gJ*BV?Ì ;>BL9ÍzO=@?9;>=S\JGhAŸ;H4GJ>8€• LJR ?†;HAGhJrL);>B;HG5=@AŸ=€MHM>O\y\gJ=OGh?g= = R M2”~=€? R ;H? Z U Z AŸ= AhB}i>C JBJ*\†;HG=GhAi R ?G5IKM>\gJ<kM>B=@J\p2;2?gAhpeJ“? R ;HBK:<U Z AhB ?BR J*;HiV?y;2?gA‡?Ahpe?J“JB”<L;t=€5>8-?gM0 šB}?†;|[É>;HJ9\?IYAŸk;HO\gGi>;>A\B?;HGGJŠ5lG=M>R BMei>\@J*?g\ J*\=@?=zJ*?g[J*=

(191) [M>=8:<0UM2”ŠJp>M>J,?\ JC B›? R \gAJ=y=OLG‡M3? JrA=

(192) B}B;0MH?SG;>=@\JieJ*J*I \€[?g\MlMe;>[G‡Me?g\@J*?g\ AhMe[BJ*\MH M>\gOIKB=;>OBk*kk*JŠJAh=@BK O; G A‡?gJ*\†;2?gAhMeB=†Ê ? R AŸ=<IY;t5K4JlLJLOR kJrLˆ \gM>I ? R J‘\gJ=OGh?Š?†;HZ 4GJl=@ABkJn? R JnB3OI)4J\9M>OB=OkkJ=g=@ OG A‡?gJ*\†;2?AM>B=“AŸ= i>1 Ap>JXJBX;HGŸ=@43M 5ˆB? RM>?J›JYL? AhRP ;2J*\g?J*?BR k*J7Jk4R J*Me?z”ŠAk*JJKJ*BMH~? ;HR B JBV;>OkkI›O4\†;2J*\~?gJKM>I}AhA?BJA\gIK;H?A©A¾rM>;2B?A=M>;>B BM>LX ? ‚ R J›J*”<BV?gOM>I›B-4’ =J*\~IKM>M€LieJ*\gGŠ;eAhLB AhJ? BVR ?<JYJ?gp2\;HOG=@O?;2?g\gAhJ*Mei>BAM>=ˆÌB 8 ;HGŸ=@MN;>[[Jr;H\†=‘?MF4JˆkMeB=ALJ\g;>4G5FIKM>\gJY<J ˆkAJ*BV?? R ;HB$;HB ;>[[\gMt‰3AIY;2?gJ}MeBJ ;2?GJ;e=z?AB ?J\IY=M>Š? R J B3kMeOBI›=@4JrVJ*O\ J*MHBk*A‡J?gJ*\†? ;2?gJ~AhMe\gBJ?=€\gBMeJ*=Jr[LJJkŒL›?gAhpe M>JŠ\yp2k;>Me\B3AŸ;Hp>BVJ*?y\gi>A=yJBk*kGhJrJ ;HC \gAhGh\g5)\Jr;2=@?y[A‡J?†k=y?A4p>JJ9=@?SMH” ? R J*J~B}k R? MeJ~Ak*kJŠMe4=@J?S?zMH”9C J*J*Jp2B);HG:<OU ;H?Z AB;>i‘B? L J~Z MeU 4fZ ÍzJ8Hk•0?A=yp>;J AhBOLBAkk?;2AM>?gJ~BY? ;HB;2L}?<C ie4\gR M>;e? LAhJ;>BVGh?yieM>L\gM>A‡IK? AhIYB;2=“?;HJr\g=€J~? RJr=;H=?“J*MHBV?AŸ? ;HR GGJ05)M2Op>BJ*\†L;HA=@GG3?AA‡B?gJ*ie\†O;2A?g= AhMe;>B-4R8

(193) GhJn•”LLR A‡J*?gBžAhMeBVO;HG;>?g=A‡Ju =@?SJB”<MH??SMe\gBˆJ*[;HM>[\[?R \gJrMtL ‰R AhIYJ*\g;HJ~?A;HM>GŸB=@M = R R R R R ‚ Ê|j Z aNM>\Y:<6

Références

Documents relatifs