HAL Id: hal-01567080
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01567080
Submitted on 21 Jul 2017HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Shallow techniques for argument mining
Jérémie Clos, Nirmalie Wiratunga, Stewart Massie, Guillaume Cabanac
To cite this version:
Jérémie Clos, Nirmalie Wiratunga, Stewart Massie, Guillaume Cabanac. Shallow techniques for argu-ment mining. 1st European Conference on Arguargu-mentation (ECA 2015), Jun 2015, Lisbon, Portugal. pp. 341-356. �hal-01567080�
Open Archive TOULOUSE Archive Ouverte (OATAO)
OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.This is an author-deposited version published in : http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/ Eprints ID : 16873
The contribution was presented at ECA 2015 : http://ecargument.org/?page_id=96
To cite this version : Clos, Jérémie and Wiratunga, Nirmalie and Massie, Stewart and Cabanac, Guillaume Shallow techniques for argument mining. (2016) In: 1st European Conference on Argumentation (ECA 2015), 9 June 2015 - 12 June 2015 (Lisbon, Portugal).
Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the repository administrator: staff-oatao@listes-diff.inp-toulouse.fr
&
4<,""#=&-37</*>.3$&?#+&,+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&
&
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
N/& -<*$& :,:3+& =3& :+#:#$3& -#& +3",T& -<3& +3>.*+3@3/-$& #?& ,/& ,+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&,"0#+*-<@&6S&+3$-+*7-*/0&-<3&,+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&-,$^&-#&,& -,+03-& 9,/#-<3+& ,+0.@3/-`3T:+3$$*#/& #?& #:*/*#/;& A3-37-*#/& ,/A& $-,/73& 9=<3-<3+&*-&$.::#+-$&#+&,--,7^$&-<3&-,+03-;&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&-,$^%&"3V3+,0*/0& 3T*$-*/0& "*-3+,-.+3& */& -<3& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& ,/A& #:*/*#/& @*/*/0(& P.+& 7#/-+*6.-*#/& *$& -<+33?#"AI& ?*+$-"S%& =3& 6.*"A& ,& /#V3"& A,-,$3-& 6,$3A& #/&
&
#/"*/3& 7#@@3/-$& ?+#@& -<3& M3AA*-K& $#7*,"& =36$*-3& ,/A& ,& /#*$S& ",63""*/0&
:+#73$$(& 437#/A"S%& =3& 3T:3+*@3/-& .$*/0& -<+33& $-,/A,+A& ./$.:3+V*$3A& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& ,::+#,7<3$& */& #+A3+& -#& @3,$.+3& <#=& =3""& -<3S& 7,/& ,::+#T*@,-3& -<3& $-,/73& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& :,+-& #?& -<3& ,+0.@3/-& @*/*/0& :+#73$$(& Q<*+A"S& ,/A& ?*/,""S%& =3& *@:+#V3& ,& J2NF6,$3A& 7",$$*?*3+& 6S& */7#+:#+,-*/0& 7#/-3T-.,"& 7".3$& */& ,& $*@:"3& 6.-& */-.*-*V3& =,S& */-#& -<3& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&:+#73$$(&&
N/& $37-*#/& Y& =3& A3-,*"& -<3& +3",-*#/$<*:& 63-=33/& ,+0.@3/-,-*#/%& ,+0.@3/-& @*/*/0& ,/A& */?#+@,-*#/& +3-+*3V,"%& -<.$& _.$-*?S*/0& ,/A& 7#/-3T-.,"*b*/0&#.+&,::+#,7<(&N/&$37-*#/&a&=3&3T:",*/&-<3&7",$$*?*7,-*#/& ,::+#,7<3$& -<,-& ,+3& 63*/0& 7#@:,+3A%& ,$& =3""& ,$& -<3& ,::+#,7<& =3& ,+3& :+#:#$*/0&,$&,/&*/7+3@3/-,"&*@:+#V3@3/-&#V3+&,&/,*V3&-37</*>.3&6,$3A& #/&$-+3/0-<&#?&,$$#7*,-*#/(&N/&$37-*#/&c&-<3&3T:3+*@3/-,"&@3-<#A#"#0S&*$& :+3$3/-3A%& -#03-<3+& =*-<& A3-,*"$& #?& ,& /3=& A,-,$3-%& 03/3+,-3A& ?#+& -<3& :.+:#$3&#?&-<*$&+3$3,+7<(&[*/,""S%&63?#+3&7#/7".A*/0&*/&$37-*#/&d%&$37-*#/& e&=*""&,/,"S$3&-<3&+3$."-$&?+#@&-<3&7#@:,+,-*V3&$-.AS(&
&
Y(&RC!H8MPG1X&C1X&MOBCQOX&)PMH4& &
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f,--,7^f&+3",-*#/$<*:&A3?*/3A&6S&X./0&9X./0%&Kgge;&-<3&$3@,/-*7$&#?&
+?-*8DD( ./281*--9-04%& ,/A& -#& -<3& f$.::#+-f& +3",-*#/$<*:& A3?*/3A& 6S&
!,S+#"& ,/A& B,0,$>.3F47<*3T& 9!,S+#"& ,/A& B,0,$>.*3F47<*3T%& YZZe;& -<3& $3@,/-*7$&#?&+?-*8DD(81*--9-04(&
Q<3&/33A&-#&$7,"3&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&-#&",+03&,@#./-$&#?&A,-,&+3>.*+3$& ,& $*@:"3& 7#/73:-.,"& +3:+3$3/-,-*#/& #?& ,+0.@3/-$%& $.7<& ,$& -<3& #/3& :+#:#$3A& */& J+,0@,-*7& C+0.@3/-,-*#/& Q<3#+S& 9JCQ;& 9D,/& O3@3+3/& 3-& ,"(%& Kggdh&U.-7<6S%& YZKa;(& [*--*/0& ,& 7#@:"3T& @#A3"& #?& ,+0.@3/-& =#."A& 63&7#@:.-,-*#/,""S&3T:3/$*V3&,/A&/#-&?*-&-<3&7#""#>.*,"&/,-.+3&#?&$#7*,"& @3A*,&7#/-3/-&,/A&*-&*$&-<.$&A33@3A&:+3?3+,6"3&-#&.$3&,&@#+3&,77.+,-3& ,/A&$*@:"3+&@#A3"(&
JCQ&A3?*/3$&,/&,+0.@3/-&,$&,/&#:*/*#/,-3A&:*373&#?&-3T-&=<*7<& 7,/& ,+*$3& */& -<3& :+3$3/73& #?& -=#& 3"3@3/-$I& 9K;& ,& !"#$%!%& 63*/0& $#@3& #-<3+&,7-*#/&6S&,/#-<3+&,7-#+&=<*7<&<,$&633/&7,""3A&#.-&h&9Y;&,&&!"'(%%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&
*(3(&=<3-<3+&*-&*$&$.::#+-*/0&#+&,--,7^*/0&-<3&-,+03-(&)3&6S:,$$&-<3&-,+03-& A3-37-*#/&$-3:&,/A&?#7.$&#/&$-,/73&7",$$*?*7,-*#/%&=<*7<&,""#=$&.$&-#&.$3& -37</*>.3$& ?+#@& -3T-& @*/*/0& ,/A& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& 9J,/0& ,/A& B33%& YZZi;%&7#/$*A3+*/0&$-,/73&#?&,/&,+0.@3/-&,/,"#0#.$&-#&-<3&$3/-*@3/-&#?& ,/&#:*/*#/,-3A&-3T-(&& & & ( [*0.+3&YI&N"".$-+,-*#/&#?&<#=&-<3&M3AA*-&7#@@3/-*/0&$S$-3@&?#+73$&-<3&.$3+&-#& :",73&-<3*+&7#@@3/-&./A3+&-<3&7#/-+*6.-*#/&
[*0.+3& Y& *"".$-+,-3$& -<3& =,S& -<3& $S$-3@& */7*-3$& .$3+$& -#& */$3+-& -<3*+& 7#@@3/-&./A3+&-<3&+3"3V,/-&$37-*#/&#?&-<3&A*$7.$$*#/&6S&:+3$3/-*/0&*-&*/& ,&-<+3,A3A&$-+.7-.+3%&,""#=*/0&.$&-#&-+3,-&-<3&,+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&:+#6"3@& ,$& ,& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& -,$^(& [#+& 3T,@:"3%& -<3& 7#@@3/-& :#$-3A& 6S& G$3+& a& */& [*0.+3& Y& *$& */& ,0+33@3/-& =*-<& -<3& 7#@@3/-& :#$-3A& 6S& G$3+& Y%& =<*7<& @,^3$&*-&,&$.::#+-*/0&$-,-3@3/-(& & M;%(#*169-04(9/0/01( & C+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&<,$&633/&,::+#,7<3A&*/&-<3&"*-3+,-.+3&,$&-<3&$-.AS&#?& @3-<#A$&,/A&-37</*>.3$&-#&A3-37-&,+0.@3/-,-*V3&A*$7#.+$3&./*-$%&-<3*+& +#"3& */& -<3& ,+0.@3/-,-*#/& :+#73$$& ,/A& <#=& -<3S& +3",-3& -#& #-<3+& ,+0.@3/-,-*V3& A*$7#.+$3& ./*-$& 9J3"A$b.$& ,/A& 4-3A3%& YZKa;(& O,+"S& =#+^& ?#7.$3A& #/& +3:+3$3/-*/0& ,+0.@3/-$& */& ,& +3$-+*7-3A& @,//3+& 9!#<3/& Kgij;%&6.-&-<3&?*+$-&$-3:$&-#=,+A$&,/&,.-#@,-3A&-+3,-@3/-&#?&,+0.@3/-& @*/*/0& 9J,",.& ,/A& 2#3/$%& YZZgh& 2#7<,"3$& ,/A& 2#3/$%& YZKK;& ,*@3A& -#& @*/3&"30,"&-3T-&.$*/0&$.:3+V*$3A&"3,+/*/0&-37</*>.3$(&2#+3&:,+-*7.",+"S%& J,",.& ,/A& 2#3/$& 9J,",.& ,/A& 2#3/$%& YZZg;& :3+?#+@3A& ,& -<+33F$-3:& ,+0.@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& 6S& ?*+$-"S& A3-37-*/0& ,+0.@3/-,-*V3& $3/-3/73$%&
&
$37#/A"S& *A3/-*?S*/0& =<3-<3+& -<3S& =3+3& :,+-& #?& ,& 7#/7".$*#/& #+& ,& :+3@*$3%& ,/A& -<*+A"S& 7",$$*?S*/0& -<3& +3",-*#/$<*:$& 63-=33/& -<3$3& $3/-3/73$%& -<.$& -+S*/0& -#& @*/3& ,+0.@3/-,-*V3& $-+.7-.+3& */& -<3$3& "30,"& -3T-$(& !,6+*#& ,/A& D*"",-,& 9!,6+*#& ,/A& D*"",-,%& YZKY;& #/& -<3& #-<3+& <,/A& @,A3&.$3&#?&-3T-.,"&3/-,*"@3/-&,/A&$3@,/-*7&$*@*",+*-S&?3,-.+3$&*/&#+A3+& -#&-+,*/&,&7",$$*?*3+&-#&+37#0/*b3&,--,7^*/0&,+0.@3/-$%&*/&"*/3&=*-<&X./0k$& ,6$-+,7-& ,+0.@3/-,-*#/& ?+,@3=#+^& 9X./0%& Kgge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d;(&
P-<3+& =#+^$& ?+#@& -<3& ,+0.@3/-& @*/*/0& 7#@@./*-S& ?#7.$3A& #/& 6+*A0*/0& *-& -#& -<3& ?*3"A& #?& #:*/*#/& @*/*/0& 9D*"","6,& ,/A& 4,*/-FX*b*3+%& YZKY;& ,/A& $-.A*3A& -<3& .$3& #?& +3,$#/*/0& :,--3+/$& */& .$3+F7#/-+*6.-3A& +3V*3=$(& Q<3S& A*A& /#-& <#=3V3+& A*+37-& -<3*+& $-.AS& -#=,+A$& -<3& ,.-#@,-3A& A3-37-*#/& #?& ,+0.@3/-$& -<3@$3"V3$& =*-<*/& -<3$3& -3T-.,"& +3V*3=$&,/A&*/$-3,A&?#7.$3A&#/&,&A3$7+*:-*V3&,/,"S$*$%&@,^*/0&-<3@&/#-& A*+37-"S&+3"3V,/-&-#&#.+&=#+^(&
&
M;M(N480,-(,D822/3/,84/+0(
&
4-,/73& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& 637#@3$& +3"3V,/-& -#& ,+0.@3/-& @*/*/0& 637,.$3& #?& *-$& 6*/,+S& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& /,-.+3(& U#=3V3+& @#$-& -37</*>.3$& .$3A& */& -<3& "*-3+,-.+3&6,$3&-<3*+&=#+^&#/&-+,*/*/0&,&7#@:"3T&7",$$*?*3+&.$*/0&,&",+03& /.@63+& #?& 7#@:.-,-*#/,""S& 3T:3/$*V3& ?3,-.+3$& 9R#"-.b*7& ,/A& 4/,_A3+%& YZKch&C/,/A&3-&,"(%&YZKKh&C66#--&3-&,"(%&YZKKh&4#@,$./A,+,/&,/A&)*363%& YZKZh& ),"^3+& 3-& ,"(%& YZKY,;& #+& ,+3& :3+?#+@3A& #/& ,.-#@,-*7,""S& -+,/$7+*63A& -3T-& 9),/0& 3-& ,"(%& YZKK;& #+& /#/F7#/V3+$,-*#/,"& 7#/-3/-& 9R#.$@,"*$&3-&,"(%&YZKa;&=*-<&"*@*-3A&,::"*7,6*"*-S&-#&)36Y(Z(&&&
2.7<&7"#$3+&-#&#.+&,::+#,7<%&W*/&3-&,"(&9W*/&3-&,"(%&YZKY;&.$3A&,& "#0*$-*7&+30+3$$*#/&7",$$*?*3+&-+,*/3A&#/&$#@3=<,-&7#@:"3T&?3,-.+3$&,/A& +3",-3A&-<3&/#-*#/&#?&"#7,"&,/A&0"#6,"&$-,/73$%&6.*"A*/0&-<3&0"#6,"&$-,/73& #?& ,& :#$-& 6S& 7#@:.-*/0& ,& $3>.3/73& #?& "#7,"& $-,/73$& 63-=33/& -<,-& :#$-& ,/A&-<3&?*+$-&,::3,+,/73&#?&-<3&-#:*7&#?&A*$7.$$*#/&
!,+A*3& ,/A& ),/0& 9),/0& ,/A& !,+A*3%& YZKc;& -##^& ,& A*??3+3/-& ,::+#,7<& -#& -<3& $-,/73& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& :+#6"3@& */& -<,-& -<3S& .$3A& ,/& *$#-#/*7&7#/A*-*#/,"&+,/A#@&?*3"AF6,$3A&-37</*>.3&-#&A3-37-&"#7,"&$-,/73(& U#=3V3+%& -<3S& $-*""& +3>.*+3A& ,& $*0/*?*7,/-& -+,*/*/0& :<,$3& ,/A& /33A& ,& ",+03& 7#""37-*#/& #?& *A*#$S/7+,-*7& ?3,-.+3$%& =<*7<& /30,-3$& -<3& :#+-,6*"*-S& #?&-<3*+&,::+#,7<(&
& &
M;M(N-04/9-04(808D@2/2(80.(8*169-04(9/0/01(
&
Q<3& ?*3"A& #?& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$&9J,/0& ,/A& B33%& YZZi;& ,"$#& -+3,-$& -<3& 6*/,+S& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& #?& ",+03& -3T-& 7#+:#+,& ,"#/0& -<3& ,T*$& #?& :#$*-*V*-S`/30,-*V*-S(&Q=#&@,*/&?,@*"*3$&#?&@3-<#A#"#0*3$&3@3+03I&
• )*+%#,-&%./&%'!-0%'!/"'"12&-&&*/V#"V3$&-<3&.$3&#?&$.:3+V*$3A& @,7<*/3& "3,+/*/0& -37</*>.3$& */& #+A3+& -#& :3+?#+@& $3/-*@3/-& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/(&Q+,A*-*#/,"&,"0#+*-<@$&^/#=/&?#+&-<3*+&V3+$,-*"*-S& ,/A& :3+?#+@,/73& #/& -3T-& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& -,$^$& ,+3& 2,TO/-%& 4D2%& ,/A& 1,*V3& R,S3$& 9J,/0& 3-& ,"(%& YZZY;(& Q<3$3& ,"0#+*-<@$& ,+3& -+,*/3A& #/& -+,*/*/0& A,-,& */& #+A3+& -#& :+#A.73& ,& @#A3"& ,6"3& -#& 7",$$*?S&?.-.+3&-3$-&A,-,(&
• 3%4-(5'67"&%./ &%'!-0%'!/ "'"12&-&& */V#"V3$& -<3&
"3,+/*/0`6.*"A*/0&#?&"3T*7#/$%&=<*7<&,+3&"##^F.:&-,6"3$&#?&-3+@$& =*-<&$-+3/0-<$&#?&,$$#7*,-*#/&$7#+3$&?#+&A*??3+3/-&7",$$3$%&,$&=3""& ,$&7#@6*/,-*#/&+."3$&9Q,6#,A,&3-&,"(%&YZKK;(&Q3$-&A,-,&*$&A*+37-"S& ?3A& -#& -<3& "3T*7#/F6,$3A& 7",$$*?*3+& =<*7<& .$3$& -<3& 7#@6*/,-*#/& +."3$&*/&#+A3+&-#&7#@:.-3&-<3&$7#+3$&#?&3,7<&7",$$&9:#$*-*V3&,/A& /30,-*V3;&6,$3A&#/&-<3&:+3$3/73&#?&-3+@$&?+#@&-<3&"3T*7#/(&& &
P.+&=#+^&7,/&63&:.-&*/&7#/-3T-&63-=33/&-<3&,+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&,/A&-<3& $-,/73& A3-37-*#/& 7#@@./*-*3$%& ,$& =3& ,*@& ?#+& -<3& A3-37-*#/& #?& +3",-*#/$<*:$& 63-=33/& -3T-.,"& 3/-*-*3$& =*-<& -<3& 6*:#",+& $3@,/-*7$& #?& !,S+#"& ,/A& B,0,$>.*3F47<*3T& 9!,S+#"& ,/A& B,0,$>.*3F47<*3T%& YZZe;& 6.-& A#&$#&6S&,--+*6.-*/0&A*??3+3/-&$3@,/-*7$&-#&-<3*+&+3",-*#/$(&
&
a(&4UCBBP)&QO!U1NlGO4&[PM&CM8G2O1Q&2N1N18& &
)3&+3?3+&-#&-<3&+3",-*#/$<*:&63-=33/&,&7#@@3/-&,/A&*-$&A*+37-&:,+3/-&,$& -<3& 7#/V3+$,-*#/,"& 7#/-3T-& #?& -<,-& 7#@@3/-(& P.+& 0#,"& *$& -#& -,^3& */-#& ,77#./-%& ?#+& ,""& 7#@@3/-$%& ,& :+#0+3$$*V3"S& A33:3+& "3V3"& #?& -<3*+& 7#/V3+$,-*#/,"& 7#/-3T-& ,/A& $-.AS& *-$& 3??37-& #/& -<3& #V3+,""& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& ,77.+,7S(& C$& $.7<%& =3& =*""& +3V*3=& -<3& ,::+#,7<3$& ,77#+A*/0& -#& -<3*+& "3V3"& #?& 7#/-3T-F*/?#+@3A/3$$& ,$& =3""& ,$& -<3*+& A30+33& #?& $.:3+V*$*#/(& U3+3& 7#/-3T-F*/?#+@3A/3$$& +3?3+$& -#& -<3& 3T-3/-& -#& =<*7<& -<3& ,::+#,7<& .$3$&*/?#+@,-*#/&-<,-&*$&3T-3+/,"&-#&-<3&7#@@3/-%&,/A&$.:3+V*$*#/&+3?3+$& -#&-<3&3T-3/-&-#&=<*7<&-<3&,"0#+*-<@&+3>.*+3$&,&<.@,/F",63""3A&A,-,$3-& */&#+A3+&-#&=#+^(& ( L;%(#*169-04(9/0/01(82(D-O/,+0K<82-.(,D822/3/,84/+0( & N/&*-$&@#$-&6,$*7&?#+@%&,+0.@3/-&@*/*/0&7,/&63&$33/&,$&,&7",$$*?*7,-*#/& -,$^%& =<3+3& -<3& 7",$$3$& ,+3& 3*-<3+& $.::#+-& #+& ,--,7^(& Q<*$& 6,$*7& ?#+@& 3/-,*"$& -<,-& ,/S& :*373& #?& -3T-& 7,/& 63& 7",$$*?*3A& 6S& *-$3"?& =*-<#.-& -,^*/0&
& & */-#& ,77#./-& ,/S& /#-*#/& #?& 7#/V3+$,-*#/,"& 7#/-3T-%& 6S& $*@:"S& ,::"S*/0& $-,/A,+A& -3T-& +3:+3$3/-,-*#/& -37</*>.3$& ,/A& @,::*/0& -<*$& +3:+3$3/-,-*#/& */-#& -<3& 7",$$& 7#A#@,*/(& 7#/-,*/$& $*@:"3& "3T*7#/F6,$3A& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&9+3?3++3A&-#&,$&J2NB3T;(&
&
C&$*@:"3&=,S&-#&+3"*,6"S&7",$$*?S&*/$-,/73$&*$&-<3&.$3&#?&,&"3T*7#/(& R37,.$3&-<3+3&A#3$&/#-&3T*$-&,&@,/.,""S&6.*"-&"3T*7#/&#?&"#7,"&$-,/73%&=3& 7#@:.-3& *-& #/& ,& A*$-,/-F",63""3A& A,-,$3-& .$*/0& /#+@,"*b3A& :#*/-=*$3& @.-.,"& */?#+@,-*#/& 91J2N;& ,$& ,& @3,$.+3& #?& $-+3/0-<& #?& ,$$#7*,-*#/& 63-=33/&-3+@$&,/A&-<3*+&7",$$(&& & !"#$ !! ! ! ! !"# !! ! ! !"# ! !! ! ! & !"# !! ! ! !!"#!!! !! ! ! ! ! !!!! & &
Q<*$& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& +."3& 7",$$*?*3$& ,& .$3+& 7#@@3/-& T& #/& -<3& 6,$*$& #?& ,& @,T*@*b3A& $.@& #?& ,$$#7*,-*#/$& 63-=33/& 3,7<& #?& *-$& -3+@$& -& ,/A& 3,7<& 7",$$&7(&1#-*73&-<,-&-<3&-3+@&7",$$&,$$#7*,-*#/$&7,/&/#=&63&3T:"#*-3A&,$&,& "3T*7#/(&
)<*"3& -<*$& ,::+#,7<& *$& $3/$*6"3& -#& 7+3,-3& ,& 03/3+,"& :.+:#$3& "3T*7#/%& *-& $.??3+$& $#@3& ?",=$& */& -<3& ?#""#=*/0& 7,$3$I& 9K;& *?& /#/3& #?& -<3& -3+@$& .$3A& */& -<3& 7<*"A& :#$-& <,$& ,/& ,+0.@3/-,-*V3& V,".3& #+& *$& :+3$3/-& =*-<*/& -<3& "3T*7#/%& /#& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& *$& :#$$*6"3%& ,/A& 9Y;& $#@3& -3+@$& @*0<-& 3/A& .:& =*-<& ,/& ./A3$3+V3A& $7#+3& 637,.$3& -<3S& ,77*A3/-,""S& ,::3,+& @#+3& ?+3>.3/-"S& =*-<*/& 7#@@3/-$& #?& #/3& 7",$$(& [#+& 3T,@:"3& *?& /#/F,+0.@3/-,-*V3& -3+@$& $.7<& ,$& f2#/A,Sf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
&
$*-.,-*#/& *-$& :,+3/-& :#$-(& Q<3S& A#& $#& 3*-<3+& 6S& A3-37-*/0& ,--,7^& #+& $.::#+-& ,0,*/$-& -<3& ,.-<#+& #?& -<3& :,+3/-& 7#@@3/-& 9),/0& ,/A& !,+A*3%& YZKc;&#+&6S&@#A*?S*/0&-<3&*@:#+-,/73&#?&$#@3&-3+@$&6,$3A&-<3&:,+3/-& 7#@@3/-&9-<3&:+#:#$3A&,::+#,7<3$;(&
&
L;M;%(N-04/9-04K16/.-.(9-45+.2(
&
43/-*@3/-& @3-<#A$& :+#V*A3& ,& @3,/$& -#& .$3& 3@#-*V3& 7#/-3T-& -#& */?3+& ,+0.@3/-&$-,/73%&6S&,$$.@*/0&-<3&$-,/73&#?&,&7#@@3/-&,$&3>.*V,"3/-&-#& *-$& $3/-*@3/-& #+*3/-,-*#/(& )3& 3@:"#S& ,& $*@:"3& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& ,"0#+*-<@&6,$3A&#/&,&"3T*7#/&9O$."*&,/A&436,$-*,/*%&YZZd;&-#&=<*7<&=3& =*""&+3?3+&-#&,$&4O1QBOm(&N-&#:3+,-3$&6S&"##^*/0&.:&:#$*-*V3&,/A&/30,-*V3& V,".3$&#?&-3+@$&:+3$3/-&*/&-<3&7#@@3/-&,/A&$.@@*/0&-<3@&$3:,+,-3"S& */-#&,&:#$*-*V3&,/A&,&/30,-*V3&$7#+3(&Q<3&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&+."3&*$&6,$3A&#/&,& $*@:"3& 7#@:,+*$#/I& ,& <*0<3+& :#$*-*V3& $-+3/0-<& *@:"*3$& ,& $.::#+-*V3& 7#@@3/-%& ,/A& <*0<3+& /30,-*V3& $-+3/0-<& *@:"*3$& ,/& ,--,7^*/0& 7#@@3/-(& )3& .$3& -<3& 42CMQ4C& ,"0#+*-<@& 944C;& A3V3"#:3A& 6S& 2.<,@@,A& 3-& ,"(& 92.<,@@,A& 3-& ,"(%& YZKa;& ,$& ,/& 3T-3/$*#/& #?& -+,A*-*#/,"& "3T*7#/F6,$3A& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& -37</*>.3$& -,^*/0& */-#& ,77#./-& ,AA*-*#/,"& "*/0.*$-*7& ?,7-#+$&$.7<&,$&-<3&:+3$3/73&#?&$:37*,"&-3+@$&7,""3A&@#A*?*3+$&-<,-&,"-3+& -<3& 7",$$& V,".3$& #?& -3+@$& */& -<3*+& V*7*/*-S& 6S& 3T,003+,-*/0& -<3@& 9,@:"*?*3+$;%& +3A.7*/0& -<3@& 9A*@*/*$<3+$;& #+& */V3+$*/0& -<3*+& :#",+*-S& 9/30,-#+$;(&
43/-*@3/-F0.*A3A& @3-<#A$& ,$$.@3& -<,-& 0"#6,"& $-,/73& #?& -<3& 7#@@3/-%& *(3(& <#=& *-$& ,.-<#+& ?33"$& ,6#.-& -<3& A*$7.$$*#/& -#:*7%& 7,/& 63& .$3A&*/&:",73&#?&*-$&"#7,"&$-,/73%&*(3(&<#=&*-$&,.-<#+&?33"$&,6#.-&-<3&:,+3/-& 7#@@3/-(& C$& $.7<& -<3S& :+3$3/-& $#@3& ?",=$& =<3/3V3+& 9K;& -<#$3& -=#& $-,/73$&A#&/#-&,"*0/%&9Y;&-<3&$-,/73&*$&3T:+3$$3A&*/&,&$3/-*@3/-F/3.-+,"&
)CW%& #+& 9a;& -<3& #V3+,""& $3/-*@3/-& #?& -<3& $3/-3/73& 3/A$& .:& 63*/0&
6,",/73A(&Q<3&?#""#=*/0&3T,@:"3$&*"".$-+,-3&-<3$3&?",=$I& &
9K; fP( ,+97D-4-D@( ./281*--( G/45( @+6A( 45/2( 9+?/-( G82( ?-*@( 1++.( 80.( P(
-0C+@-.( -?-*@( 9/064-( +3( /4;Q& U3+3& =3& 7,/& $33& -<,-& -<3& ,.-<#+&
3T:+3$$3$& ,& :#$*-*V3& #:*/*#/& 6S& A*$,0+33*/0& =*-<& -<3& ,.-<#+& #?& -<3&:,+3/-&7#@@3/-%&-<.$&@,^*/0&,/&,--,7^*/0&$-,-3@3/-(&
&
9Y; &fI5-*-(/2(0+45/01(/0(45-(G+*D.(4584(G/DD(98F-(9-(2--(45-(2/4684/+0(
@+6*( G8@;f& N/& -<*$& 7#@@3/-& -<3+3& *$& /#& :#$*-*V3& #+& /30,-*V3&
-3+@*/#"#0S& .$3A%& =<*"3& -<3& $3/-3/73& *$& =+*--3/& =*-<& ,/& ,--,7^*/0&$-,/73(&
&
9a; fP(81*--(4584(45-(8,4/01(G82(1++.A(<64(P(89(24/DD(./2877+/04-.(4584(
&
$3/-*@3/-$& ,+3& 3>.,""S& .$3A%& 6.-& -<3& $-,/73& $<#."A& 63& $.::#+-*/0(&
&
L;M;M("+0?-*284/+08D(,+04-O4K8G8*-(9-45+.2(
&
)3& 3T:"#+3& 7#/V3+$,-*#/,"& 7#/-3T-F,=,+3& @3-<#A$& .$*/0& -<3& G/$.:3+V*$3A&43/-*@3/-&4.+?,73&,"0#+*-<@&9G44;(&G44&*$&3T-3/A3A&?+#@& !,+A*3& ,/A& ),/0& 9),/0& 5& !,+A*3%& YZKc;& ,/A& .$3$& ,& $<,""#=& "*/0.*$-*7& ,/,"S$*$& -#& 7#@:.-3& -<3& ,V3+,03& A*$-,/73& 63-=33/& $37#/A& :3+$#/& :+#/#./$& ,/A& :#$*-*V3& #+& /30,-*V3& -3+@$(& Q<3& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& 7#@:,+3$& -<#$3&,V3+,03&A*$-,/73$%&7",$$*?S*/0&-<3&7#@@3/-&,$&,--,7^*/0&*?&/30,-*V3& -3+@$&,+3&#/&,V3+,03&7"#$3+&-#&$37#/A&:3+$#/&:+#/#./$&,/A&$.::#+-*/0& #-<3+=*$3(&G44&=#+^$&#/&-<3&*/-.*-*#/&-<,-&-<3&$-,/73&#?&-<3&7#@@3/-&*$& 7#/-,*/3A&=*-<*/&3T:"*7*-&+3?3+3/73$&-#&-<3&:,+3/-&:#$-$I&$.7<&+3?3+3/73$& 7,/& 63& ,/,"Sb3A& 6S& A3-37-*/0& $37#/A& :3+$#/& :+#/#./$& 93(0(& fS#.f%& fS#.+f%& 3-7(;& ,/A& -<3*+& :#",+*-S& 6S& $3,+7<*/0& -<3*+& 0+,@@,-*7,"& /3*0<6#+<##A&?#+&$3/-*@3/-F63,+*/0&-3+@*/#"#0S(&
[#+& 3T,@:"3%& fP( .+0R4( 81*--( G/45( @+6( 80.( P( 45/0F( @+6*( +7/0/+0( /2(
G*+01f& =#."A& 63& */-3+:+3-3A& ,$& ,/& ,--,7^*/0& $-,-3@3/-& 637,.$3& #?& -<3&
#V3+=<3"@*/0& :+#T*@*-S& #?& /30,-*V3& -3+@$& 9f.+0R4f%& fG*+01f;& /3,+& $37#/A& :3+$#/& :+#/#./$& 9f@+6f%& f@+6*f;(& Q<*$& ,::+#,7<& 7,/& ,"$#& 0*V3& ?",=3A& +3$."-$& =<3/& -<3+3& *$& ,@6*0.*-S& 7#/-,*/3A& */& -<3& -3T-& */& -<3& ?#""#=*/0I& 9K;& =<3/& ,& :#$*-*V3& 9+3$:37-*V3"S& /30,-*V3;& -3+@& *$& ,77*A3/-,""S& 7"#$3A& -#& ,& $37#/A& :3+$#/& :+#/#./& =<*7<& *$& $3@,/-*7,""S& "*/^3A& -#& ,& /30,-*V3& 9+3$:37-*V3"S& :#$*-*V3;& -3+@& 9Y;& =<3/& ,& @#+3& 7#@:"3T& $3/-3/73& $-+.7-.+3& *$& .$3A& =<3+3& -<3& :#",+*-S& #?& ,& -3+@& *$& *@:"*7*-"S& /30,-3A%& #+& 9a;& =<3/3V3+& /#& $37#/A& :3+$#/& :+#/#./$& #+& $3/-*@3/-F63,+*/0&-3+@$&,+3&.$3A(&Q<3&?#""#=*/0&3T,@:"3$&*"".$-+,-3&-<3& ?*+$-&-=#&7,$3$I&
&
9K; &fP( D/F-( @+6A( <64( @+6( 8*-( G*+01(f& U3+3& =3& 7,/& $33& -<,-& ! !"#$! !"# ! !!!"#! !"#$%!& =<3+3& A& *$& ,& A*$-,/73& ?./7-*#/%& =<*7<&=#."A&7",$$*?S&-<*$&*/$-,/73&,$&,&$.::#+-*/0&$-,-3@3/-(& &
9Y; &fP(,80(<8*-D@(4+D-*84-(4584(@+6(<-D/-?-(@+6*2-D3(4+(<-(*/154(f&U3+3& -<3& $3/-3/73& $-+.7-.+3& :.-$& @+6*2-D3& V3+S& 7"#$3& -#& */154%& =<*7<& =*""&7",$$*?S&-<3&$3/-3/73&,$&,&$.::#+-*/0&$-,-3@3/-(&U#=3V3+%&*-& *$&7"3,+&./A3+&,&<.@,/&3S3&-<,-&-<3&$3/-3/73&<,$&,&A*$,::+#V*/0& -#/3(&
&
Q<3& G44& ,::+#,7<& *$& 6,$3A& #/& -<3& ,$$.@:-*#/& -<,-& #V3+& ,& $*0/*?*7,/-& /.@63+& #?& $3/-3/73$& -<3$3& 3++#+$& =#."A& 7,/73"& 3,7<& #-<3+& #.-& ,/A& +3$."-&*/&,&0##A&#V3+,""&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&,77.+,7S(&
L;M;L("+04-O4K/03+*9-.(3-846*-(?-,4+*(-0*/,59-04(
&
Q3+@&V37-#+&+3:+3$3/-,-*#/&*$&,&7#/V3/*3/-&=,S&-#&=#+^&=*-<&-3T-&A,-,& 637,.$3& #?& *-$& $*@:"*7*-S& ,/A& V3+$,-*"*-S& 9@#+3& A3-,*"$& 7,/& 63& ?#./A& */& 92,//*/0&3-&,"(%&YZZi;;(&N-&*$&7#@:,-*6"3&=*-<&"3T*7#/F6,$3A&7",$$*?*7,-*#/& ,$&=3""&,$&@#+3&$-,/A,+A&$.:3+V*$3A&7",$$*?*3+$&,/A&3T-+3@3"S&7#@@#/& */& -3T-& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/(& N/& -<*$& $37-*#/& =3& .$3& 7#/V3+$,-*#/,"& 7#/-3T-& -#& ,"-3+&-<,-&?3,-.+3&V37-#+&#?&,&7#@@3/-&6,$3A&#/&*-$&:,+3/-&7#@@3/-(&)3& 3T:3+*@3/-& .$*/0& -=#& 6,$*7& V,+*,-*#/$& #?& -<*$& ,"-3+,-*#/(& Q<3& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&+."3&=3&.$3&*$&-#&,$$*0/&-<3&7",$$&",63"&7&-<,-&@,T*@*b3$&-<3& ,$$#7*,-*#/&$7#+3&63-=33/&,/&*/$-,/73&T&,/A&7(&Q<3&,$$#7*,-*#/&$7#+3&*$& 7#@:.-3A&A*??3+3/-"S&,77#+A*/0&-#&-<3&3/+*7<@3/-&$7<3@3(&
&
!"#$$%&%'#(%)* ! ! !"#$%!!!!""#$%&'%#()$#*+ !! ! !&
&
8'!%#&%(!-5'67"&%./ ,%(!5#/ %'#-(90%'!(& )3& .$3A& ,& "3T*7#/& 7#@:.-3A&
$*@*",+"S&-#&-<3&$*@:"3&J2N&"3T*7#/&A*$7.$$3A&*/&,&:+3V*#.$&$37-*#/%&,/A&& 7#@:.-3&-<3&,$$#7*,-*#/&$7#+3&63-=33/&,/&*/$-,/73&T&,/A&,&7",$$&7&,$&-<3& $.@&#?&1J2N&$7#+3$&63-=33/&,""&-3+@$&-&=*-<&7&=<3+3&-&*$&:+3$3/-&*/&6#-<& -<3& T& ,/A& *-$& :,+3/-& :9T;(& & !""#$%&'%#()$#*! ! !! ! ! !"#$!!! !! !!!!! ! & & :'-5'67"&%./,%(!5#/%'#-(90%'!(&)3&@#A*?S&-<3&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&+."3&,/A&
7#@:.-3& -<3& ,$$#7*,-*#/& $7#+3& ,$& -<3& $.@& #?& 1J2N& $7#+3$& 63-=33/& ,""& -3+@$& -& =*-<& ,& 0*V3/& 7",$$& 7& =<3+3& -& *$& :+3$3/-& */& 3*-<3+& -<3& */$-,/73& T& ,/A& *-$& :,+3/-& :9T;(& & !""#$%&'%#()$#*! ! !! ! ! !"#$!!! !! !!!!! ! & &
Q<3& ,"0#+*-<@& A3$7+*63A& */& [*0.+3& a& +3:+3$3/-$& -<3& 03/3+,"& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& ,"0#+*-<@& #?& #.+& ,::+#,7<3$%& =<3+3& -<3& 7<,/0*/0& :,+-& *$& -<3& =,S& -<3& */$-,/73& N& *$& 7+3,-3A& ?+#@& -<3& 7#@@3/-$& J& ,/A& !(& Q<3& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&*$&A#/3&6S&,&$*@:"3&$.@@,-*#/&#?&-3+@$%&=<*7<&*$&,&<*0<"S& $7,",6"3&#:3+,-*#/&=*-<&,&/30"*0*6"3&7#@:.-,-*#/,"&7#$-(& & ;"!"I&!<*"A&7#@@3/-&!&,/A&:,+3/-&7#@@3/-&J& <%&*1!I&C&7",$$&",63"&B& !+3,-3&*/$-,/73&N&?+#@&J&,/A&!h& #S&!&Zh& TS&!&Zh&
& =5#&I-*9&I&/0&P&.5& &&&&#S&!&#S&n&81*--9-04U8D6-9Q;h& &&&&TS&!&TS&n&./281*--9-04U8D6-9Q;h& >'./ 8?&TS&o&#S&!9%'& &&&&<%!*#'&81*--9-04&h& >1&%// &&&&<%!*#'&./281*--9-04&h& >'.// ( [*0.+3&aI&83/3+,"&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&,"0#+*-<@& & c(&OmJOMN2O1QCB&XO4N81& &
N/& -<*$& $37-*#/& =3& A3-,*"& #.+& 3T:3+*@3/-,"& A3$*0/%& ?*+$-"S& 6S& 0#*/0& #V3+& #.+&A,-,$3-$&,/A&-<3&=,S&-<3S&=3+3&7#""37-3A%&$37#/A"S&@#V*/0&#/&-#&-<3& :+3F:+#73$$*/0&$-3:$&-<,-&=3+3&:3+?#+@3A&*/&#+A3+&-#&$,/*-*b3&-<3&A,-,%& -<*+A"S&-#&-<3&@3-+*7$&.$3A&*/&#+A3+&-#&7#@:,+3&,::+#,7<3$%&,/A&?*/,""S& -#&#.+&3T:3+*@3/-,"&@3-<#A#"#0S(& & V;%(T8482-42( &
)3& :3+?#+@3A& #.+& 3T:3+*@3/-$& #/& -=#& $#7*,"& @3A*,& A,-,$3-$I& -<3& N/-3+/3-& C+0.@3/-& !#+:.$& 9+3?3++3A& -#& ,$& NC!;& ,/A& -<3& M3AA*-& 1#*$SF B,63""3A&!#+:.$&9+3?3++3A&-#&,$&M1B!;(&4-,-*$-*7$&#/&-<3&7#+:#+,&7,/&63& ?#./A&*/&Q,6"3&K(&
&
T8482-4( P#"( :WS"(
1.@63+&#?&7#@@3/-$& Kied& aZid& CV3+,03&-3+@$`$3/-3/73& cZ(a& ae& CV3+,03&$3/-3/73$`7#@@3/-& Y(g& j(i& N/$-,/73$&#?&,0+33@3/-& gYi& Keca& N/$-,/73$&#?&A*$,0+33@3/-& gYi& Keca& !#@@#/&V#7,6.",+S&$*b3& dZad&
Q#-,"&V#7,6.",+S&$*b3& YeZZc&
(
Q,6"3&KI&X3$7+*:-*V3&$-,-*$-*7$&#/&-<3&A,-,$3-&
@9%/ 8'!%#'%!/ A#$*0%'!/ B5#+*&/ C8AB;(& Q<3& NC!& 9),"^3+& 3-& ,"(%& YZKY6;&
*$&,&7#+:.$&#?&?#+.@&7#@@3/-$&@,/.,""S&",63""3A&6S&e&,//#-,-#+$&#/&,& A30+33& #?& ,0+33@3/-`A*$,0+33@3/-& =*-<& -<3*+& :,+3/-& 7#@@3/-& #/& ,& $7,"3&#?&Fe&-#&e(&C&$.6$3-&#?&-<*$&A,-,$3-&=,$&.$3A&?#+&#.+&3T:3+*@3/-%&6S& $3"37-*/0& -<3& 7#@@3/-$& -<,-& 3/$.+3A& A*$_#*/-& 7",$$& @3@63+$<*:& 9@3,/*/0&?*"-3+*/0&#.-&7#@@3/-$&=*-<&,/&,V3+,03&$7#+3&7"#$3&-#&Z;(&
@9%/<%..-!/D5-&263"7%11%./B5#+*&/C<D3BE(&Q<3&M1B!&*$&,&/3=&
7#+:.$& #?& 7#@@3/-$& 3T-+,7-3A& ?+#@& -<3& M3AA*-& ,/A& ,.-#@,-*7,""S& ",63""3A& =*-<& ,& 6*/,+S& 7",$$& .$*/0& 3V*A3/73& 7#/-,*/3A& =*-<*/& -<3& 7#@@3/-$(&OT:"*7*-&3T:+3$$*#/$&$.7<&,$&fP(X7+2/4/?-(8.?-*<Y(81*--f&,/A&fP(
X7+2/4/?-(8.?-*<Y(./281*--f&V,+*,-*#/$&=3+3&.$3A&-#&A3-37-&3V*A3/73&#?&,&
7#@@3/-&63"#/0*/0&-#&,&7",$$(&N/&-<3&7,$3&#?&-<3&:+3$3/73&#?&7#/?"*7-*/0& 3V*A3/73%& *(3(& 3T:+3$$*#/$& ,7-*/0& ,$& $-+#/0& 3V*A3/73& -#=,+A$& 6#-<& 7",$$3$%&-<3&7#@@3/-$&=3+3&/#-&7#/$*A3+3A(&M3@,*/*/0&7#@@3/-$&=3+3& ,.-#@,-*7,""S& ,$$*0/3A& -#& -<3*+& +3$:37-*V3& 7",$$& ,/A& -<3& 7#++3$:#/A*/0& $3/-3/73$& =3+3& A3"3-3A& ?+#@& -<3& 7#@@3/-$& */& #+A3+& -#& ,V#*A& ,& 7",$$& 6*,$& ,AV,/-,03(& Q<,-& ",63""*/0& :+#73$$& *$& */$:*+3A& ?+#@& A*$-,/-& $.:3+V*$*#/&"3,+/*/0&92*/-b&3-&,"(%&YZZg;&=<3+36S&<*0<"S&A*$7+*@*/,-*V3& 3T:+3$$*#/$&,+3&.$3A&,$&7",$$&",63"&:+#T*3$(&
R#-<& A,-,$3-$& =3+3& :+3F:+#73$$3A& 6S& +3@#V*/0& 7#@@3/-$& -<,-& =3+3& A33@3A& ,$& /#/F7#/$-+.7-*V3& 637,.$3& #?& -<3*+& "*@*-3A& "3/0-<(& C& -<+3$<#"A&=,$&3@:*+*7,""S&7<#$3/&6,$3A&#/&,&<.@,/$3+V,-*#/&#?&-<3& A,-,& ,/A& ,""& 7#@@3/-$& 7#@:#$3A& #?& "3$$& -<,/& YZ& =#+A$& ,/A`#+& =*-<& ,& V#7,6.",+S& #?& "3$$& -<,/& KZ& =#+A$& =3+3& 7#/$*A3+3A& ,$& /#*$3& ,/A& +3@#V3A&?+#@&-<3&A,-,(&&
1#&$-3@@*/0&=,$&,::"*3A&A.3&-#&-<3&./+3"*,6"3&V#7,6.",+S&.$3A& */&$#7*,"&@3A*,%&@3,/*/0&-<,-&,&+."3F6,$3A&:+#73A.+3&?#+&=#."A&+3./*?S& -3+@$& -<,-& ,+3& $3@,/-*7,""S& A*$-,/-& ,/A& -<.$& +3@#V3& */?#+@,-*#/& ?+#@& -<3&A,-,$3-$(&[#+&-<3&$,@3&+3,$#/&/#&"3@@,-*b,-*#/&=,$&,::"*3A%&$*/73& A*7-*#/,+SF6,$3A&"3@@,-*b3+$&=#."A&,-&63$-&63&*/3??37-*V3&,/A&,-&=#+$-& A3-+*@3/-,"&-#&#.+&,::+#,7<(&
[*/,""S%& */& -<3& ,6$3/73& #?& */?#+@,-*#/& ,6#.-& -<3& +3,"& 7",$$& A*$-+*6.-*#/%& =3& ,+-*?*7*,""S& 3/?#+73A& ,& ./*?#+@& 7",$$& A*$-+*6.-*#/& 6S& $.6$,@:"*/0&-<3&@,_#+*-S&7",$$(&
&
V;M(!?8D684/+0(9-4*/,2(80.(-O7-*/9-048D(7*+4+,+D(
&
)3& 7<#$3& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& ,77.+,7S& ,$& #.+& 3V,".,-*#/& @3-+*7& 637,.$3& 6,",/73A& A,-,& +3/A3+$& #-<3+& -<+3$<#"A& @3-+*7$& 9$.7<& ,$& [KF47#+3;& "3$$&
@3,/*/0?."&,/A&.$3A&-<3&$-,/A,+A&KZF[#"A&7+#$$FV,"*A,-*#/&:+#-#7#"&?#+& @,7<*/3& "3,+/*/0& 3T:3+*@3/-$& 9R*$<#:%& YZZd;& ?#+& 6#-<& #.+& A*$-,/-"S& "3,+/3A& ,::+#,7<3$& ,/A& #.+& ./$.:3+V*$3A& ,::+#,7<3$& */& #+A3+& -#& :+3$3+V3&,$&?,*+&,&7#@:,+*$#/&,$&:#$$*6"3(&
&
e(&MO4GBQ&C1X&XN4!G44NP1& &
Q<3&+3$."-$&$<#=/&*/&Q,6"3&Y&$<#=&-<,-&=<*"3&,&$-,/A,+A&"3T*7#/&6.*"-&#/& ,& 6,7^0+#./A& 7#+:.$& =*-<& ,& $*@:"3& 6,0F#?F=#+A$& +3:+3$3/-,-*#/& A#3$& /#-& $*0/*?*7,/-"S& #.-:3+?#+@& $-,/A,+A& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$& #+& $-,/73& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& -37</*>.3$%& 7<,/0*/0& -<3& +3:+3$3/-,-*#/& #?& -<3& */$-,/73$&
&
6S& ,AA*/0& $#@3& ?#+@& #?& 7#/-3T-& *@:+#V3$& #.+& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& ,77.+,7S& ,0,*/& 6S& ,& $*0/*?*7,/-& @,+0*/& 9ne(jp& 7#@:,+3A& -#& ,& $*@*",+& ,::+#,7<& =*-<#.-& 7#/-3T-& ,/A& nj(ip& 7#@:,+3A& -#& -<3& 63$-& 6,$3"*/3;(& &
T8482-4Z[-45+.( N-04S-O( N-04S-O( N98*4N#( >NN(
NC!& Z(eZcY& Z(eYdZ& Z(eKcj& Z(eZdK& M1B!& Z(cdjZ& Z(cddc& Z(ceYY& Z(cjKi&
& & & & &
J2NB3T& J2NB3Tn*/-3+& J2NB3Tn./*#/& Z(eadY& FGHIJJ/ Z(edgd&
Z(cica& FGHKFL/ Z(eZca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
U#=3V3+%& -<*$& A#3$& /#-& ,77#./-& ?#+& -<3& ?,7-& -<,-& -<3& ./*#/& #?& 6,0$& #?& =#+A$& #.-:3+?#+@$& -<3& $-,/A,+A& @3-<#A$& =<*"3& :#-3/-*,""S& ,AA*/0&/#*$3&*/-#&-<3&+3:+3$3/-,-*#/(&Q<*$&"3,A$&.$&-#&-<*/^&-<,-&?.+-<3+& +3?*/3@3/-& #?& -<3& @#A3"& 7#."A& 63& A#/3& 6S& .$*/0& ,& -3+@& =3*0<-*/0& $7<3@3&,$&,&@*AA"3&0+#./A&63-=33/&,AA*/0&*/?#+@,-*#/&.$*/0&-<3&./*#/& #:3+,-#+&,/A&?*"-3+*/0&*/?#+@,-*#/&.$*/0&-<3&*/-3+$37-*#/&#:3+,-#+(&
Q<3&,77.+,7S&$7#+3$&<#=3V3+&=<*"3&63*/0&,/&*@:+#V3@3/-&#V3+& -<3& 6,$3"*/3$& ,+3& -##& "#=& ?#+& ,/& #:3+,-*#/,"& 7#/-3T-(& 2#+3& =#+^& *$& +3>.*+3A& */& *@:+#V*/0& -<3& /,*V3& =,S& */& =<*7<& =3& ,AA3A& 7#/-3T-& ,-& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&-*@3(&
&
d(&!P1!BG4NP1& &
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
-<,-& -<3& $*@:"3& 6,0F#?F=#+A$& +3:+3$3/-,-*#/& 7#/-3T-.,"*$3A& 6S& :,+3/-F 7<*"A& V#7,6.",+S& */-3+$37-*#/& "3,A$& -#& $*0/*?*7,/-& *@:+#V3@3/-$& #V3+& 7#@:,+,6"3& 6,$3"*/3& ,::+#,7<3$(& [#""#=*/0& #/& ?+#@& -<3$3& +3$."-$& =3& ,*@& -#& 3T:"#+3& 7#/V3+$,-*#/,"F7#/-3T-.,"& 3/+*7<@3/-$& -<,-& 7,/& ?.+-<3+& *@:+#V3&+3:+3$3/-,-*#/&?#+&,+0.@3/-&7",$$*?*7,-*#/(&[#+&-<*$&*/&,AA*-*#/& -#&-<3&:,+3/-F7<*"A&$*/0"3&"3V3"&+3",-*#/$<*:%&=3&*/-3/A&3T:"#+*/0&?.+-<3+& "3V3"$&#?&7#/-3T-&$.7<&,$&?+#@&$*6"*/0$&-#&,/73$-#+$(&& & MO[OMO1!O4& & C66#--%&M(%&),"^3+%&2(%&C/,/A%&J(%&[#T&Q+33%&'(&O(%&R#=@,/*%&M(%&5&H*/0%&'(&9YZKK%& './3;(& U#=& 7,/& S#.& $,S& $.7<& -<*/0$qrqI& M37#0/*b*/0& A*$,0+33@3/-& */& */?#+@,"& :#"*-*7,"& ,+0.@3/-(& N/&)*+,( +3( 45-( \+*F25+7( +0( S801681-2( /0( N+,/8D([-./8&9::(&YFKK;(&C$$#7*,-*#/&?#+&!#@:.-,-*#/,"&B*/0.*$-*7$(& C/,/A%&J(%&),"^3+%&2(%&C66#--%&M(%&Q+33%&'(&O(&[(%&R#=@,/*%&M(%&5&2*/#+%&2(&9YZKK%& './3;(&!,-$&+."3&,/A&A#0$&A+##"rI&!",$$*?S*/0&$-,/73&*/&#/"*/3&A36,-3(&N/& )*+,( M0.( G+*F25+7( +0( ,+976484/+08D( 877*+8,5-2( 4+( 26<C-,4/?/4@( 80.( 2-04/9-04(808D@2/2&9::(&KFg;(&C$$#7*,-*#/&?#+&!#@:.-,-*#/,"&B*/0.*$-*7$(& R*$<#:%&!(&2(&9YZZd;(&)844-*0(*-,+10/4/+0(80.(98,5/0-(D-8*0/01(&4:+*/03+(& R#"-.b*7%& [(%& 5& s/,_A3+%& '(& 9YZKc%& './3;(& R,7^& .:& S#.+& $-,/73I& M37#0/*b*/0&
,+0.@3/-$& */& #/"*/3& A*$7.$$*#/$(& N/&)*+,--./012( +3( 45-( J/*24( \+*F25+7( +0(#*169-0484/+0([/0/01&9::(&cgFei;(&
R#.$@,"*$%&H(%&23<.%&2(%&5&J,/-*7%&2(&9YZKa;(&Q#=,+A$&-<3&,.-#@,-*7&A3-37-*#/& #?& $:#/-,/3#.$& ,0+33@3/-& ,/A& A*$,0+33@3/-& 6,$3A& #/& /#/V3+6,"& 63<,V*#.+I& C& $.+V3S& #?& +3",-3A& 7.3$%& A,-,6,$3$%& ,/A& -##"$(&P981-( 80.( U/2/+0("+9764/01%&L%9Y;%&YZaFYYK(&
!,6+*#%& O(%& 5& D*"",-,%& 4(& 9YZKY%& '."S;(& !#@6*/*/0& -3T-.,"& 3/-,*"@3/-& ,/A& ,+0.@3/-,-*#/& -<3#+S& ?#+& $.::#+-*/0& #/"*/3& A36,-3$& */-3+,7-*#/$(& N/&)*+,( +3( 45-( &]45( #0068D( [--4/01( +3( 45-( #"S'( N5+*4( )87-*2KU+D69-( M&9::(&YZiFYKY;(&C$$#7*,-*#/&?#+&!#@:.-,-*#/,"&B*/0.*$-*7$(&
!,S+#"%&!(%&5&B,0,$>.*3F47<*3T%&2(&!(&9YZZe;(&P/&-<3&,773:-,6*"*-S&#?&,+0.@3/-$& */& 6*:#",+& ,+0.@3/-,-*#/& ?+,@3=#+^$(& N/&N@9<+D/,( 80.( ^6804/484/?-( 877*+8,5-2( 4+( *-82+0/01( G/45( 60,-*48/04@&9::(& ajiFaig;(& 4:+*/03+& R3+"*/&U3*A3"63+0(&
!#<3/%& M(& 9Kgij;(& C/,"Sb*/0& -<3& $-+.7-.+3& #?& ,+0.@3/-,-*V3& A*$7#.+$3(& "+976484/+08D(D/016/24/,2%&%L9KFY;%&KKFYc(&
X./0%&J(&2(&9Kgge;(&P/&-<3&,773:-,6*"*-S&#?&,+0.@3/-$&,/A&*-$&?./A,@3/-,"&+#"3& */& /#/@#/#-#/*7& +3,$#/*/0%& "#0*7& :+#0+,@@*/0& ,/A& /F:3+$#/& 0,@3$(&#*4/3/,/8D(/04-DD/1-0,-%&__9Y;%&aYKFaej(&
O$."*%&C(%&5&436,$-*,/*%&[(&9YZZd%&2,S;(&43/-*=#+A/3-I&C&:.6"*7"S&,V,*",6"3&"3T*7,"& +3$#.+73&?#+&#:*/*#/&@*/*/0(&N/&)*+,(+3(S:!"&9D#"(&d%&::(&cKjFcYY;(& U.-7<6S%& N(& 9YZKa;(&"+03*+0484/+0( 48DF'( #*169-042A( 82@99-4*/-2A( 80.( 7+G-*( +0(
48DF(*8./+(&M#.-"3A03(&
2,//*/0%&!(&X(%&M,0<,V,/%&J(%&5&47<t-b3%&U(&9YZZi;(&P04*+.6,4/+0(4+(/03+*984/+0( *-4*/-?8D&9D#"(&K%&:(&cgd;(&!,@6+*A03I&!,@6+*A03&./*V3+$*-S&:+3$$(& 2*/-b%&2(%&R*""$%&4(%&4/#=%&M(%&5&'.+,?$^S%&X(&9YZZg%&C.0.$-;(&X*$-,/-&$.:3+V*$*#/&
&
45-(V_45(#0068D([--4/01(+3(45-(#"S(80.(45-(V45(P04D(`+/04("+03(+0(WS)(+3( 45-(#JWS)'(U+D69-(MKU+D69-(M&9::(&KZZaFKZKK;(&C!B(&
2#7<,"3$%& M(%& 5& 2#3/$%& 2(& [(& 9YZKK;(& C+0.@3/-,-*#/& @*/*/0(&#*4/3/,/8D( P04-DD/1-0,-(80.(S8G%&%a9K;%&KFYY(&
2.<,@@,A%&C(%&)*+,-./0,%&1(%&B#-<*,/%&M(%&5&8",$$3S%&M(&9YZKa;(&X#@,*/FR,$3A& B3T*7#/& O/<,/73@3/-& ?#+& 43/-*@3/-& C/,"S$*$(& N/&N[#E( b"NKN=#P& 9::(& jFKi;(& J,",.%&M(&2(%&5&2#3/$%&2(&[(&9YZZg%&'./3;(&C+0.@3/-,-*#/&@*/*/0I&-<3&A3-37-*#/%& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&,/A&$-+.7-.+3&#?&,+0.@3/-$&*/&-3T-(&N/&)*+,(+3(45-(%M45(/04D( ,+03(+0(#P(80.(D8G&9::(&giFKZj;(&C!2(& J,/0%&R(%&5&B33%&B(&9YZZi;(&P:*/*#/&@*/*/0&,/A&$3/-*@3/-&,/,"S$*$(&J+60.84/+02( 80.(4*-0.2(/0(/03+*984/+0(*-4*/-?8D%&M9KFY;%&KFKae(&
J,/0%& R(%& B33%& B(%& 5& D,*-<S,/,-<,/%& 4(& 9YZZY%& '."S;(& Q<.@6$& .:qI& $3/-*@3/-& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/&.$*/0&@,7<*/3&"3,+/*/0&-37</*>.3$(&N/&)*+,(+3(45-(#"SK]M( ,+03-*-0,-(+0(!97/*/,8D(9-45+.2(/0(WS)(U+D69-(%]9::(&jgFid;(&C!B(& J3"A$b.$%& C(%& 5& 4-3A3%& 2(& 9YZKa;(& [+#@& ,+0.@3/-& A*,0+,@$& -#& ,+0.@3/-,-*#/&
@*/*/0& */& -3T-$I& C& $.+V3S(&P04( `+6*08D( +3( "+10/4/?-( P03+*984/,2( 80.( W846*8D(P04-DD/1-0,-(cP`"PWPd%&_9K;%&KFaK(&
4#@,$./A,+,/%&4(%&5&)*363%&'(&9YZKZ%&'./3;(&M37#0/*b*/0&$-,/73$&*/&*A3#"#0*7,"& #/F"*/3& A36,-3$(& N/&)*+,( +3( 45-( W##"S( eSI( M]%]( \+*F25+7( +0( "+976484/+08D( #77*+8,5-2( 4+( #08D@2/2( 80.( =-0-*84/+0( +3( !9+4/+0( /0( I-O4(9::(&KKdFKYc;(&C!B(&
Q,6#,A,%&2(%&R+##^3%&'(%&Q#?*"#$^*%&2(%&D#""%&H(%&5&4-3A3%&2(&9YZKK;(&B3T*7#/F6,$3A& @3-<#A$& ?#+& $3/-*@3/-& ,/,"S$*$(&"+976484/+08D( D/016/24/,2%&L_9Y;%& YdjF aZj(&
D,/& O3@3+3/%& [(& U(%& 8+##-3/A#+$-%& M(%& ',7^$#/%& 4(%& 5& ',7#6$%& 4(& 9Kgga;(& M37#/$-+.7-*/0&,+0.@3/-,-*V3&A*$7#.+$3(&
D*"","6,%&2(&J(&8(%&5&4,*/-FX*b*3+%&J(&9YZKY%&43:-3@63+;(&4#@3&[,73-$&#?&C+0.@3/-& 2*/*/0&?#+&P:*/*#/&C/,"S$*$(&N/&"f[[#&9::(&YaFac;(&
),"^3+%& 2(& C(%& C/,/A%& J(%& C66#--%& M(%& 5& 8+,/-%& M(& 9YZKY%& './3;(& 4-,/73& 7",$$*?*7,-*#/& .$*/0& A*,"#0*7& :+#:3+-*3$& #?& :3+$.,$*#/(& N/&)*+,( +3( 45-( W+*45(#9-*/,80("5874-*(+3(45-(#"S'(e6980(S801681-(I-,50+D+1/-2&9::(& egYFegd;(&C$$#7*,-*#/&?#+&!#@:.-,-*#/,"&B*/0.*$-*7$(&
),"^3+%&2(&C(%&Q+33%&'(&O(&[(%&C/,/A%&J(%&C66#--%&M(%&5&H*/0%&'(&9YZKY;(&C&!#+:.$&?#+& M3$3,+7<&#/&X3"*63+,-*#/&,/A&X36,-3(&N/&S:!"&9::(&iKYFiKj;(&
),/0%& B(%& 5& !,+A*3%& !(& 9YZKc;(& N@:+#V*/0& ,0+33@3/-& ,/A& A*$,0+33@3/-& *A3/-*?*7,-*#/& */& #/"*/3& A*$7.$$*#/$& =*-<& ,& $#7*,""SF-./3A& $3/-*@3/-& "3T*7#/(&#"S(M]%V%&gj(&
),/0%& )(%& W,@,/%& 4(%& J+37#A,%& H(%& M*7<3S%& !(%& 5& M,S@#/A%& 8(& 9YZKK%& './3;(& X3-37-*#/&#?&,0+33@3/-&,/A&A*$,0+33@3/-&*/&6+#,A7,$-&7#/V3+$,-*#/$(& N/& )*+,( +3( 45-( Va45( #0068D( [--4/01( +3( 45-( #"S'( e6980( S801681-( I-,50+D+1/-2'(25+*4(787-*2KU+D69-(M&9::(&ajcFaji;(&C!B(&
)S/3+%&C(%&2#7<,"3$FJ,",.%&M(%&2#3/$%&2(&[(%&5&2*"=,+A%&X(&9YZKZ;(#77*+8,5-2(4+( 4-O4( 9/0/01( 8*169-042( 3*+9( D-18D( ,82-2&9::(& dZFjg;(& 4:+*/03+& R3+"*/& U3*A3"63+0(&
W*/%&'(%&Q<#@,$%&J(%&1,+,/0%&1(%&5&J,+*$%&!(&9YZKY%&'."S;(&G/*?S*/0&"#7,"&,/A&0"#6,"& ,0+33@3/-&,/A&A*$,0+33@3/-&7",$$*?*7,-*#/&*/&#/"*/3&A36,-3$(&N/&)*+,(+3( 45-( L*.( \+*F25+7( /0( "+976484/+08D( #77*+8,5-2( 4+( N6<C-,4/?/4@( 80.( N-04/9-04(#08D@2/2&9::(&dKFdg;(&C!B(&
