• Aucun résultat trouvé

Boxplot diagram

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "Boxplot diagram"

Copied!
56
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

-/.102436587:9<;=9<2

(2)
(3)

!#"$ %&%%'(&)*$*$+%!,"$.-/0123"$(14+5%&671''98:;*

< $=?>A@CB,DFEGHJICKLG0M3NPORQS GFTJI(U$MWVXIYNCZ\[]E^E?Q_Ia`)O1NYIYbRMTcICMdeORM?OUfG0KLG0M?NCghBiMfU$ICMjG)GHJICMU

ORM?k&NCZlGnm?`IPG0Mj`JGFTo;!l8p)(++ <lq r8i 2p%$6C%+$p)i8c 8]p)s8:(%Wt]1++1vuw(x1p%y

%(

q

"R%s%;z${#+"Rp)%s6Y''|%"$'i$6}%

<

^$=j>

(%'( ~Xl2?pJzf%"$'|€c)(*1W8:(%

 2323'"R%(13‚„ƒ…"$"R*$zf!

~,*1;p)* "$W% †l(0



%$p) ‡X"$'|€ˆt]p%*$pw‰ˆ-:

<

p)~Šƒ…"$p%p

‡,

<

';%p €Al

<

p

q

‡,

<

';"R%(1&€w"R+ R‹$‹

Œ †lti ‹Žyr$Ž‘Ryr$$’ 9yr

Œ “L67$p)L"R%(x1W+e2j1f1L q 23p)2?1+…”8p)%*•%0123"$(1h!

< "$%n"$  *$A†l(%W+pJ(*1f%'q 2?1;+W1!

–

{{{+8:(%1—23p%2j1+$!l8is8]13'W$0+{™˜

Œ v%+0$!j%cc:"&++2y<lq yš++2v*1;1›98œ+“%-+&"Rp)p q

1—%"$"$'q +—"$„+J3ž]0Žx1p%Ÿ;W%" < Žx1 < ^$=j!38:3J < "$%;"$''q

09x1pJ



s ¡



+Fžf{



z%Fh!X%WJ3"R2+p) p%Ÿ(p)p%$pn%

<

^$=l¢

£

2L+¤i"R2+pw¥$¥§¦‚"$%w"R%+%i+“"Rp%w67p%1%w0l"$z2?'(,L% < ^$=j{

0123"$(1¨(*1fn23p%9x^L+6Y'#+•+%%n8:•"Rp%W%*v%“2j1 q y

z1

<

^$=„"$—%p—+0f

<

^$=j!j"$3„"Rp%]©%++%"Rp%%;* 1:Ÿ-n{

Œ ‚\3+ < :"R+*$$p)"$''q +%"R+L%3"R Œ $#8:%+"R=1w"$ q 23p%$ªX1

$6#%w3zf{

Œ

1

<

c6X2?$23'n8i1'vx1•01%pc23"

q

*L6C$pw(A"$

q y

8i"

qj«

:s+1'("$¬]+*$cz$p%A2?$2?'(s++s"$Ÿ01f+p)

<

+A+-!"$W+

+2p%"$\%'(Žx1i$6?%%"R%+%{ Œ "$ˆp%p%f%'q $­"R®“'"R+ +"$ q $p%*1"$3%"R%(1

$pcx1p)%(

q ! <

:"$

<

np%"$F…"Rc%n"$'¯"$3p%%

<

'(Ž8{—€A"R%+%A+

p%"$

<

nŽ8:'(1"$“6Cp%1¬%s8]

<

%(+s+2j(ª

<

'(98n{

¡w(=l+8—"Rp)"$

xf(=l% *° q "$^{™0{™=

++2¯>_±$±9888{²*$f(%({™01“±9xl(=l% *±



*13+ R‹$‹1

(4)
(5)

!#"$ %&('*)+ -,."(' /

0 132547698!:.;=<4?>@8A2B478&CED$F*G#6H>@I-GJ2547KML*NOG#P7>@QA2 0A0

R ST2GUWVK+<X478M6NOGYP7>@Q52PKM2:B4?Z=G\[]2=KML_^$P7>@P`8MacbdK+69>@KM2=<XG 0#e

f{¥ :$%"R%(1…"$„ p)1'($* q {{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥

f{ -"$*€w"R%"$%%cf+z- {n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥0‘

f{ gfYhXi*j3k6C30%(1„{s{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥

e l85ImGnV=;=6749ZG#6T1oP3P?;G#PT>p2qST2=GXUWV=K+<478A6TNOG#P7>@QA2=PTKM2=:r[ts&SubE[ 0+v

f{¥ ¯+%;*z%s¡#"$'3(q $6}%



%)z2%(13 {{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥7w

f{ xsp)+=R"$'yzy "$'';‚ +s{s{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥3{

f{ ¤]1ª330

Œ

f+p%xR"$' {{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ R‹

f{f{¥ |$p:%nƒ„"$…"R:"“†f2j(ª3~} x^' {{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ R‹

f{f{ |$p:%€w€jp%30nt]r8i„—8iƒv"$ {s{{n{s{{s{{ l¥

 ‚ƒ;=L_4?>@F„L_GUo…g85ImF.K+6H>_P78A2‡†ˆG#Po4?>p2Q RMe

‘{¥ |};%p¢™‰}¯"$+w†l(*13(ª3"$f]€AŠ|p%0 +{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ $

‘{ =^

q

¢™Œ‹c1+%'

q

†l*1(ª3"$f‚€AŠ|p%0 +›{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ Ž‘

 S`674?Z=8MQA8A2=KMLp>_4Ž^+uS`674?Z=8MQA8A2=KMLENOGY<8AI-F*8MP7>_4?>@852*EKM2: †ZGJ>@6’‘85L_G

>p2r‚“8!:.GY6H2BCED$F*G#6H>@I-GJ2547KML*NOG#P7>@QA2 Rv

f{¥ †f+%*2Ÿ%¤]1f+p)"$+%:ƒ…"R+p) {s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ Xw

f{ ‡­$p%+671';(z-:"R%*"$3„€wp)*“¤]1z2?"Rp)+1W~X"$z23'L{{n{s{{s{{ $’

” †d•–8&V=K+<478A6…g698MP7P—Uo…L@K+P3P7>_˜„<XK4?>@852BNOG#P7>@QA2=P e0

™f{¥ —8i`|"$0+$p



s ¡



{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ l¥

™f{ —8i`|"$0+$p)c8:(%W:“-23';"R%(1Ÿ"$Ÿc

Œ

f+p)"$0%1{s{{s{{ Ž‘

™f{ |p)(L"$Ÿ:12?"Rp)"$z+p)s +\{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ™

v sšG#Po47G#:„8M6t›n>@G#6?KM6?<HZ=>@<XKAL(NOG#P7>@QA2=P eAœ

w{¥ nƒv' "$3„(%



"$'q %{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ {

(6)

L_K+47GY:rNOGYP?>_Q52P =0

’f{¥ } "R%v†lžf"Rp%



"$'

q

%]8:(%Ÿ- {s{{{s{{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ ‘

’f{  A%p+6Y'|- |30%(1i6C$p



A :¡



{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ ‘

T Y =") ‰)+ šŒ)=)Odr!#"$

œ †d•–8UˆG5G#L(VKM<478M6H>@KML(NOGYP7>@Q52P $v

{f{¥



"$'q %*\—8iRy}¯x1'!|"$0+$p)"$' €w%(*1 {{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ ‘Yw

0-…g8A2=a85;=2=:.>p2=Q! –L@8!<#"$>p2Q >p2 %$ NOGYP7>@Q52P $0

¥‹l{¥”†z23'(s¤]16C1;* {s{{{s{n{s{{{s{{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ l¥

¥‹l{Šƒ…'(%23'(A¤i16713* {{{s{n{s{{{s{{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ 

¥‹l{ 

"$'

q

%*\ti'(f)=Ÿ€w%(*1i8c(%Ÿ- {{s{{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ $

0A0†d•–8UˆG5G#L(V69K+<49>_852KALUWV=K+<478A69>@KML(NOG#P7>@QA2=P A

¥$¥R{¥



6C+p+y‹:1p) p)"$*\~#l"$z2?'( {{{s{{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ $

¥$¥R{Šƒ…"R*1"%&



…†l% q ~#l"$23'( {s{{{s{{{s{n{{s{{s{{{s{n{{ $

(7)

f{¥ t‚9l23'($%—6C$p:ti"R++p

q

}¯(6C€A"R%" {{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥3™

f{¥ -%3"$'|‡,'($% {{{s{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ ¥3{

‘{¥ =^ q ¢™Œ‹s†l€23'($w{{s{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ $

™f{¥

Œ

f+p)"$0%(1v‡,'($\{{{s{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ $

™f{ -%3"$'|‡,'(${s{{{s{{s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ Ž‘

™f{ :$p)L"$'A"$f%'(A‡,'$ {s{n{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ $

{f{¥ ƒ„"$…-+2j1+t q |"$0+$p¨{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{{s{{n{s{{s{{ R‹

(8)
(9)

r

(10)
(11)

r

¤i"R2+pn¥\Ÿ%

<

^$=j!jp)"R67+pwp%6Cp%p%Ÿ+&"$c~‚€ Ÿ$p)p:+W%"§x^

q

23*!

Až+ žf"$'%"R%(x1${



z1*v$%ps%*1! (s+%"R+%"Rs%p%"Rp%%•++23

+„0f2jp)%"$'­)(*1h! +%"Rp%%;*Ÿ8:(%•23';"$*“%0l2?pJzfw"$35*

8:(%xŽ"$'3"R%*w%—01'%1 $6?%i0f2jp)zf{}iJ"R23+p}%*$#1

+W3%%c+1z p%"$'yP8i$p)';v"R223';"R%(1:$6,%(*1v0l2?pJzf%{s-ˆ"$$

p%"$''q '(2Ÿ JŸp%${

(12)
(13)

r

]

F"R2+pA…~,€ 01)p):%23"$0:$6#"&%*1'6C"$0+$pA1›+1z\2?p)67$p+y

"$0zz"$%p)${ Œ …%Afzf!|% ªp)+w+0%(15'" q wŽ8:›+1z +p)y

1'($* q "$3Ÿ$%"R%(1—%h!$2?6Y''q L%*s016Y%1“8cW~,€ '(x1

f+& 8iv"$5% %p%L6C"$0+$p\%(*1n'"R+p{



6C+pn%"R8iL0Žx1p%"$ y

(+\8i"

q

+•p%"$."R%"$+%zf+•-{­&%(p)4+0%(1.\%&ªp)+\p%"$']z"R>

% fYhij7k\6C30%(1h{~|$ps%\23p%2j1+n$6‚++p)30%(1h!38i\+\% < "R++p q yš';(67

0l"$z2?'(A67p%1 ~,€\{

! #"$%'&(

:xR"Rp)" < '(*) 8:';' < A+L+z$+w% :.GYFG#2=:=GJ254 K+6H>@K,+„L_G { Œ LxR"Rp)(1

+%"$0!(8:';'j"$';+ < p%6Cp%p%Ÿ+L"$c%.-RIPG0Q(kŽg,H%GFTšElbRMTG/ŽO$HJIaO100QG\"$&EG0H32

4

bRHFKORM?`FG KLG%OŽT35lH+G{c >@2=:.GYF*GJ2=:=GJ254 K+6H>@K,+„L_G 8c''

<

76e{wn%%"R%+%"$'

z' 8]s)(p%A+ª—+%n"R%"

)98;:<>=@?BA:!?DC8;:

8:p%

EF< ¥HGJIJIJIKGL

M < ¥HGJIJIJIKGON

L < l

<

pi$6}p%Ž8:!$pp%2?'"R+—W"$F„6Y"$0+$p

N < l < pi$6­01'3!l$p6C"$0+$pJ

= < Žx1p)"$''|"9x1p)"R*$

£

z"$j¦

A:P< Š|p%f%"$'?—j0w"$%+f"R+„8:%.M$%v'x1'|$6Q6

C8R:P< 1%s$pp%p%$p:"$)+"R+v8:(%W%SETM$%v3"R%"zxŽ"$';

(14)

L.M{|$pc0l"$23'($!

) < £ )

? )

? ?B)

¦ L

ƒv"$f8:'($! )

8:''jp%6Cp:+%9x^p)"$''h%"$z2?'(z"$h{— w%p:$%"R%1„8i$p%%

zf%(13*A"Rp% †`l=l 6C$p 478+4?KMLP?;=I 8MaP $;K+69G#P ! l.l –< 67$p P7;=I 8Ma(P $;KM6?G#P

+*GY4 •G#G#2š<X8ALp;.I-2=P

"$3

l=l 6C$p

P7;.I 8Aa$P $;=K+69GYP‰•t>49Z=>p2<8ALp;=I 2=P

{

l.l

"Rp%nžxŽ"$'(f]+ l.lC !% G#696?8A6TP7;.I 8AaŒP $;=K+69GYP {

S !.&

|$pi1p‚23p%2j1+$!18i:)"$''%:0"$z23'( f{67p)1 ~‚€{ Œ ‚fx1+%(*1"R+‚98

<

"R y

+p q '67%‚xR"Rp q "$0$p)*z+%xl0—% q "Rp%n3+W1h{

:•ªp)+&++2 + "Rp%p

q

*41Ÿ"R%"”"$"$'

q

+&8:(%Š- !:

<

xl(1)'

q

!—+

p%"$vŸ%"R%"l{



'%1*1Ÿ-"$„"$'A3"R%"z$6X+x1p)"$'h6C$p)"R%!(—2p%6Cp)

"›%z2?'( +0f\ª3'($!}8:(%5 8i…01'3Ayw1“6C$pn%“2jfxR"Rp)" < 'L"$

"$$%p]6C$pi%A2jf#1${

Œ 6 %;,i"9xŽ"$';"

<

'($!1%A"$%+‚8—"

q

+ p%"$

L"R%"X8c(%z%Jf+f "!#.j7k]6C30%(1h{



)%*w%ª3'(—"$zccGPU$#%&$1!

%;—i%p%žf(p)& q f%"Ž|{

')(+*-,-,/.0/13254-687"2-*+9;:<,+*(=.32?>@A2CBED;:DF@<G

Œ “;L"R%pJ"$'—67$p“%vª3p)+'„ "R%"$+%&+¨$+v%…"$zL$6s%

01'3{|$pc0l"$z2?'($!%sªp)%: '—eGšU/$#%&$5"Rp%

p) xl0

¥R{’ x|¥

f{™‹ x|¥

¥R{™‹ x|¥

‘{ x

L"R+pc+%!3+A%6C1''(Ž8:*$2%(1

')(+*-,-,/.0/13254-687"2-*+9;:<,+*(=.32?>@A2CBED;:DF@/HJI2#*#9K2=7MLON+G

 A%pW%z!c8]•"

q

'("9x1501zf%W"RW%

<

*13*4$6n%•ª3'(…+

p%L›1p)+'x1A8:p%z%L"R%"„"$zL67p%1„!¯8:5s8i"$n01''(0+e"$3 +

1h{QP#1¨"$ +''#- +…*1$p%%%L01zf%! < q 1e +…=fŽ8Ž8

"$

q

']%%01zf%—%"R=1n2 {

')(+*-,-,/.0/13254-687"2-*+9;:<,+*(=.32?>@A2CBED;:DF@/HJI2#*#9K2=7MLONHSRCT0AUVLXWKG

(15)

"$p!"$W%Ÿ%n"R%" 23p%$2?p§{

- "$A98 ++$p%…% "R%"&…"$… < ©+0s"$z Mf#3!

{Œ‹w"9xf*Lp%"$

”%v"$p!i8iv"$ "$0)&"$3 8i$p%=¨1 3(xl"$'‚01'8:(%8Af/

! KXi w"$ Af#3! Kf{ z"$“"$+%"$3"Rp)xl"R%(1 $6|%

8:1'(s"R%"$+c"$ < s < %"$Ÿ8c(%W%s6C1''(Ž8:* 01"$3{

' 2-*>A(*K,#,/.30 1"2CI7"R-G

'5R+9;><(+*K,#,/.0/1"2CIK7ER-G

!

¯L < %"$W%n"$„'(6C%zw$6 13'q % < "R++p)(3+W8:(%Ÿxl0n’f!

' 2-*>A(*K,#,/.30 1"2CI7"R#"<(+*-,#, .30=1"2 9K2$#0%2 L#L @<9-2$&F@('EG

*)

(+ -,/.1032547698: <; '

y5:ªp)%,"9x1+0p)"R+w"$Ofhi\ < © 0!f8:;J 8ic3"$z>=5h+ !^8:(%z%c671';'(98y

*z01"$ {

'@?#9A 4-6 *?$F>I7"RCB 9K2 $#0%+2 H 9K*-,#* L)(+*-,-, .30/132-G

]ªp)+}"Rp%*1zf}+''}-”%"RDK: %—2jf¯xR"Rp)"

<

'(‚"$ KXi

%\2jf—1${w\+01›"Rp%*1zfc;+&+'' -+W'(^$=v67$pw%+

xŽ"Rp);"

<

'(& %›

< © 0QAf/-! 3{œ .2p)f1W%5"$"$'

q

%;“Š"¨2p%+

q

67$p)L"R!+

'5RFEG * 7FH>ID?#9AG

J LKM

=

KNPO

#fQ

KN-R i+f-!

M S-jUT R k

-i

)*V W

F! W

(

) X X YV-!

! ! VFLZ

[

7 M f-!

V-V

)F!

W!

K\ Q h#K#]

!_^UZZ Z3`a!

! !b^UZ Z3`a!

!c^Zd`e!

!f^

`g!

C^*`

#f+p) s%‚%" < '(,"Rp),"$%'q 3p)++h{}#f+p q s%,p)(*1f%z1%

01';#%1hyPxŽ"$';${

Œ 6 3++"$8i8:;%z+\++]"Ri"ªf“%(*1(ª?"$0:'(x1'P!

%" q "R%ji <‹ I™‹wRL'(x1'a!l8i"$Ÿª33W%0p)(%"$'lkxŽ"$';A8:(%

(16)

dev1 dev2 dev3 dev4 dev5 dev6 dev7 dev8

2 4 6 8 10

Boxplot diagram

|}*1p% f{¥R>‚t]9f23'$%—67$pct]"R++p q } (6C€w"R%"

'1 >F: H H AH .?-2 7:<,+*-0.LEG

UL XF YW )

:“" < 9x^&01L"$.6C$p)- %"R\8i“"Rp%Wf+p%++¨e%&‹l{™‹wR9yP%

žf"$f%'(\$6‚% k/%+p)

<

%1„8:(%&wW"$3”¥3™Ÿ*$p%n$6‚6Cp%1Ÿ{:z'"$+

"Rp%*13zf,,0pJ"$'a! < "$% <lq 6Y"$'(!^-Šp%%pJ#%wž3"$%;'(—67$p]%w'(98ip

%"$'P{



$%p6C30%(15+6Y'X 10yP6C"$0+$p "$"$'

q

+; +h"!Yh*j7k^{ Œ n"$''(Ž8:

6C$p:"zxl%"$'|01z2?"Rp)+1W$6­%"R%" < %"$Ÿ"R%nŠ|p%f]'x1'{

')(F?=U . ?K, > I7"RcB 9-2$+0 %+2 H 9-*K,#* L)(*K,#,/.30 1"2 H

*#0 L @ ?CU .?-, 9-0-*=B-7E* @AG

:1+23:6Cp%1 -ˆw%Ž8:v;n|­(*1p) f{¥R{ªp)+w 8]&"Rp%*1zf%c+

%01"$„"Rp)%%"$z"$%1++„" < 9x^s8:(%šfYhXi*j3k!l8:'w%sª3"$'

"Rp%*13zf—2p%Žxf‚%%(%'(s$6­%2?'(${ Œ "$ < n"$'(+p%„"$0$pJ*+ q 1p

2p)67p%30${

(17)

B

r

}J3"R2+p#}p%"$''

q

"$0f+)(1\+s%i2p%xl(1 1$!

<

"$+—8:x1p­8]

p)"98 6Cp%167p%30#6Cp%1 "$



A :¡



!8ic"9x1:+ F)=6|"$

q

"$%)z2%(13

"§x^ < Ÿxl(1'"R+ {,0l:+0%1„09x^p)%%s++%{ Œ 6}%n"$%)z2%(13

"Rp%w%x1p%'

q

xl(1'"R+h!l(‚L(*1f

<

A"R22p)$2p)"R+c+\"Rp%p

q

1]"\1lyP2?"Rp)"$z+p)

++{}:xsp)3+=Ž"$'(yzy "$''j++!R8:;JA "§xR"$'"

<

'­;-4; 09x^p%np)${=|­"$'' q !

8]#;'}++pJ0%(1j1Ž8 +:013++p)0 01ª?0,f+p%xR"$'{ :X"R%"$+

+ % < "R++p q ';(67z1$!}30L8i"$%%%“'‚"$n"$'(p)"$ q…<

<

'(!l"$—2jpw†f0%(1 f{f{

+S , & l, %O. (F 8 , : "

A%p%nL"$Ÿ"$%%2%(1i"$s8cŸ010%;*  s :¡  ++%"Rp)

¥R{:sp)%"$';C8R:n"Rp%2?i"$Ÿ30$p%p%'"R+ŸpJ"$1 xR"Rp)" < '({

f{:sp)%"$';C8R:n"Rp%n$pJ"$''q 3++p)< +h{

f{:sp)%"$';C8R:n"9x1s"z"$„‹"$3„"01+%"$f—xR"Rp)"$0${

sªp)%"$%%z23%(1Ÿ+3%(%(x1$!l8:3'(A%n'"R++pcr8i"Rp%\z$p%p) < +{

 y

%z2%1i¥:"$L"Rp%:%3"$''q FJ=1zxl"A*$p)"R233"$'l23'($%!8:']"$%)z2%(1

%3"$''

q

F)=^Ÿ%p%1*1Ÿ"L$p)"$'yš$p)"$'|ž3"$%;'(c2?'(${

t]67$p%\2p%f0*L8:(%„%n23'($%!?(:3"$:+ < 2?1;+v1:%3"R:%`fhi

< © 0A0p%"R+501f%"$cz$p%\%"$L©+3+c"&z%f…+W2pJf—1c%



A :¡



%" < '(${



''|%"R%"z%3"R:(—1'—"$ < ';++W8:(%W%s671''98:;*01L"$h{

' * 2-R?>ID?+97AG

(18)

M

(F

7

#+ if-!

M

7 f

\

Q N K7

M f-!

W

hQK-f= !+iKK! f-!#! K+=@

UX

=5h#-K!

:3(xl"$'j'(zf%w"$›% < "$0%+•8:(%v% “$2?p)"R+$p§{~|$p

0"$z23'($!+“'+—"$''|%sp)%"$';!f3+

'D?+97A=7E2#R-0#9EK*/.3R

X

! !! !! ! !

! !! !!

! !

V! ! !! !

!!

! !! ! !! !

! ! !! !!

!

V ) W !

! !! !! ! !

(

! !! !!

! !

F! ! !! !

!!

V !! ! !!

! !

)! XX

Y)

X Y

! !! !! ! !! ! ! !! !! ! ! !! ! !! ! !! V !! ! !! ! ! ! ! !! !! !

YV Y) YW F!

! !! !! ! !

! ! !! !!

!

!! ! !! !

!

! !! ! !! !

F! !! ! !

! !

FX F

V !! !! ! !! V ! !! !! ! ! V WX ! V V !! ! !! ! !

cŽ8!

<

"$J=›+„%z23'($%{p%z8:;''

<

‘„$6]%Ÿ!}"$ •$pJps+v%"9x1

+2?"$0„% q 8:'' < v"Rp%p)(.1z1 "5%*1'(W*$p)"R23"$'—xf0${ \8:';' <

"$F(x18:(%%i'(2\$63% "!

K-Qj7k#01"$3\;-n{R:‚6C1''(Ž8:*

01L"$i"Rp%A+ $2?Ÿ"\*$p)"R233‚xf0$!+2?'(,(if+\‘!f%&%'(0i%Aªp)+

%0p)Ÿ+ < np)"98:&1h{

' lAA > G

'5R U.30K, : R%C7E2#2>U% >D H D-G-G

Ub -X

'5R % 7E2-2>UAG

:Ÿªp)+L523'($%z"Rp%v"$';'i67$pLFJ=f;*5%„"$%%3z2%(1W¥„"$3 f{

q

01)+n$6—2?'($+%*„%Lp%%;"$'s"R*1"$3+n%“ª++4xŽ"$'!­%L6Y"$0+$pz'(x1'

"$ ”%zŸ$pJp{ :„'"$+2?'($žf(+„z"$3*1'(%z;.%

<

"R++p

q

'67

0"$z23'($!

<

nn;'›6C$p01z2?'(+%¢ %"R=1${Ÿ6C1p%%e23'($n%

$pJ"$'( q F)=j{

' U . ?K,F>ID?+97A 1"0-,-,#2+9;: $#*. EK2#R H D?#9A=7E2-R#0#9EK*.R H

*#0 L @ E2-R#0#9 E-*.RP$+R?: "0K,-,+2#9 @H Ud% I LXD #G

'5*(=.302?>IOL H .3,H LXD-G

'5R % 7E2-2>DKG

' U . ?K,F>ID?+97A D?+9K2. #9-2$#0 %+2 H D?+97A 7E2#R-0+9 EK*/.3R H

(19)

3 4 5 6 7 8

−2 −1 0 1 2

Residuals vs. Fitted

mod1$fitted.values

mod1$residuals

dev1 dev2 dev3 dev4 dev5 dev6 dev7 dev8

−2 −1 0 1 2

Residuals vs. Levels

5 10 15 20

−2 −1 0 1 2

Residuals vs. Time Order

1:24

mod1$residuals

−2 −1 0 1 2

−2 −1 0 1 2

Normal Q−Q Plot

Theoretical Quantiles

Sample Quantiles

|­(*1p)nf{¥R>,-%;"$'|‡,'($%

*-0 L @ E2-R-0+9 E-*.3R $#RF:E2 $#2.R @<G

'5R%C7"2-2> W-G

' U.?-,F> A D H D?#9A=7E2-R#0#9EK*.R H< *-0OL @ 2#R-0#9EK*/.3R $#R?: N+0 2=739K2=7 @H

Ud% I LXD #G

'5*K( .02F> I)L H .",HOL5DKG

'5R%C7"2-2>-G

'Y? 7 >@?#97A 7"2-R-0+9 E#*.R H Ud% I LXD #G

'+.02F>@?#97A 7"2-R-0+9 E#*.R#G

+S @: % %O% ;,

 Azf%(1v"Rp)'(p§!?%;cw"W1lyP23"RpJ"$z+p)n++A67$ps+\8:…% " < Žx1

"$%%z23%(1"9x1

<

¨%(*1(ª?"$%'

q

xl(1'"R+h{

Œ

ž3(+L"$

q

+›p)3©%+

r8iz'i$6­0n"Rp%nh{

'@?#9#D)4-6 TK77EKR T*/. :<,+2-R-,F>A(*K,#,/.30=1"2FCIK7"R H (+*-,-, .30/132 +9K2$+0 %2-G

'@?#9#D

M Mf#! +f-!#! fQ M =O7C

(20)

M +f-!Mf#!-!

NM

f+ X ! ! WV

) Xif-!

M

! ! )

+ (+ '. !<; , %

$ \"*) )+!ƒ5"n,‰)M Œ) )

¤]1ª30 f+p%xR"$':"$

<

013++p)0+›6C$pw"$F•$6#%z'(x^'c"RA8:3Jv%

0l2?pJzfi8i"$:"Rp%p)(W1{‚A67$pJ\3'" i*1(x1 <lq

6

! "

$# %'&

}¯ 3%"R=^&%&+pJ!#1Ÿ"Rz"›%z&67p)1 '(67\+•p)(*1f{



';',$6c% 8:''

<

Ÿp)(x1e67p)1 % =5h#

zf'i%"R 8—"$

<

'(n"Rp)'(p{5-:%p)*v+•%

0"$z23'(Ÿ1 < "R++p q '(6C$!,"$%)z„%"RL8]Ÿ8c%.+e01z2?+„%„01ª?0

f+p%xR"$'67$p

<

"R++p)}3+\1zxf;0 ™f{, 

<

%"$;* 6­ž+‚++p)"$*1+6C$p%8—"Rp)h{

' (* 7 4-6 2-*>@?#9A @?#9-2. IK7"R#"ID?+9A l?#9#2.9K2 $+0%+28L#L @<9-2$ @('EG

:w0pJ(%"$'(,xŽ"$'c"$ < w < %"$s©%+i"$]%wžf"$f%'(:67$p]% k3++p)y

< %(1W8—"$— < %"$Ÿ;v†f0%(1 f{f{]-z < p%"R%*$p%$6}67p)1

6C1''(Ž8:#%†3†l~.*$p%]$6¯6Cp%1Ÿ{X z"§x11;“"R=l*\"$

q

"Rp%'(%i;+%"R=1!

%%L6C1''(Ž8:*W01L"$ +… < %"$e%p%žf(p%ež"$f%'\+›01++p)30n"

{$)/01ª30;+p)xŽ"$'a{

'M,% 7E0K,X4-6 , > :+D H D?#9A+91:7E2#R-0#9EK*/. H . ? -2=7 : ,#*-0/. L "G

|$p

"

!38in„+Lª?„%%ž3"Rp%np%$:$6,ƒ•†#y{|†l30ƒ›†Jy ;%\%

$6‚%\)ž"Rp)$6‚%p)%"$';:(xl <fq % *$p%w$6,6Cp%1Ÿ!|%p% w"

%;z23'(w67$pJ\3'"\8]s"$…"R223'q {

'5RO4-6 R 7, > RE >#>D?+97A 7E2#R#0+9E-*.KR-G'*<D-G$+D?97A91 :7"2-R+0#9FEK*/.G

|­3"$''

q

!,%…01zi67p)1 %Al

<

p#$6 3"R%"n2j1f%,"R]%A'(x1'$6 xf0~™f{

‹cp%n—"*$p)"$'h8—" q +ª33W%—l < p§{

' 4-6 RE >ID?#9A D?#9-2. #9K2 $+0%2 L#L @<9-2$ @AG

y5\"$v2?—% "$';'h+$*$%pw+

<

%"$v%n'(Ž8ip"$„22jp:01ª?0

f+p%xR"$'i% '%"$1%'q {

' (* 7 6,% 7E0-,.- > R/+"R 7, > G#G10 (* 7 , %C7E0-,.- > R/+"R/7, > G-G

UL F!

UV

VW W

(21)

i67$pJ\3'"+np)(x1‚%01ª330i;+p)xŽ"$'}6C$pX%—Š|p%0

<

r8i 8]

z"$

£ 6

6J¦1

"

¥ %

?¥ %

†l" q 8i8:)W+Lª3„%nf+p%xR"$'|67$pc%n€jp%30 < 8i„'(x1';"Rcxl0

¥"$ef{&2?% " "$3

"§x^"$'(p%"$

q›<

e01z23+4e†f0%(1

f{f{¥R{‚sp)"$*xR"$'—"$

<

s

<

%"$;Ÿ8:(%

' @AX4-6 RFEG >ID?+97A D?+9K2. #9-2$0 %+2 L-L @<9-2$A @AG

' EDO4-6 RFEG >ID?+97A D?+9K2. #9-2$0 %+2 L-L @<9-2$WF@AG

' A#(* 7 4#6 2-*>ID?#9A D?#9-2. CI73R#"ID?+9A l?#9-2/. +9-2$0 %+2 L-L @<9-2$A @('EG

' 3D3(* 7 4#6 2-*>ID?#9A D?#9-2. CI73R#"ID?+9A l?#9-2/. +9-2$0 %+2 L-L @<9-2$WF@('EG

†l < %%(%%*\f+ %s67$pJ\3'"\8:'' q '&%p%žf(p%Wf+p%xR"$'a{

' > lA+(+* 7 6 "D3(* 7"G56,% 7E0-,.- > R - R 7, > A +DA

A +DKG#G 0 > A#(* 7

6 "D(+* 7"G , %C7E0-,.- > R - R/7, > A +DA A +D-G-G

V ))

! F FV

(22)
(23)

‚ -

~,€ 09x^p)— 8]z=l3‚$6­ '(%(2?'(0yš01z23"Rp);+1++%cW%—F"R2+piy‚23"$(p%8:;+

"$n2j1+­R{  2pJ($p)$++%­"Rp%i0Žx1p% %‚0l}F"R2+p}1\$p%%$*$1"$';( q {

~,€ 0Žx1p)‘e23"$(p%8:;+W++%{q‹:Ž8ix1p!i-3"$1'

q " 6Y0%1.67$p& =^

q

¢™

‹:1%%'q †(*1(ª3"$fw€w€jp%30

£

‹A†l€¦w+%{



'%1*15%zp)+s$6i%z++%

"Rp%$';v;›-n!h% q "$ +%'' < "Rp%p)(•1s5"W6C8 ++23{ Œ •%

!,8]Ÿ0Žx1pŽ8 + 01z23+|­%p¢™–} "$+“†l*1(ª3"$fn€AŠ|p%0

£

}}†l€¦]"$„98 +L3+s%

M

3

K J

j3kA6Y0%1h{

, 9 &' ; O !<; ;9

u}­†l€ ++w%+f%"$''q fx11'(x1i2jp%6C$p)*"“+pJ(—$6X23"$(p)8:+ —++%{ Œ

Xz2j$p%%"$f­+$+%"RX8:% }}†l€\!$8i—"§x^—+n+2j(6

q

% >p2:„>>@:.;=KML p%p%$p

p)"R+$! $w% 0f2jp)zf 8:+s1${n0l"$z2?'(\3+•v%3cF"R2+psc%

< p%$=1p—+% q {­:s"R%" "$ < A6C1W&%Aª3'(GPU"%${‹cp%s"Rp%s%s++23i+

0p%"R+ =5h+

{

')( 7 ? T 4-687"2-*#9?:<,+*( .2?>@A2=B ;:WF@H I2-*+9K2=7ML)N+G

'@?#9#D)4-6 *?$F> 0E9K2fB8(C77?CT2=7?H 9K*K,+*L)(C77?CTG

:Ž88ic"$&2p%f0W+ 0123+w%E}­†l€\{

Œ

“6C"$0!l8iw3"$“"$0%"$';'

q

01 y

23+%&}­†l€ 8: p)xf*4% 01ª30 f+p%xR"$'&6C$p„% Š|p%0

< 8i„ 8]“z"$w…†f0%(1›f{f{f{



%%np%%3"Rc8i8:;%Ÿ+Lª?Ÿ%

}}†l€ < r8i < p%$=^p) z"$vf{

' @AX4-6 RFEG >ID?+9-D D?+9K2. ( 7 ? T2 7 L-L @ ( 7 ? TDF@<G

' EDO4-6 RFEG >ID?+9-D D?+9K2. ( 7 ? T2 7 L-L @ ( 7 ? T @<G

'5R)4#6 R 7,F> RE >->ID?+9-D=7E2#R-09 EK* .3R+G *<D-G/+Yl?#9#D +9/1 : 732-R-09 E-*/.G

'M, %C7"0K,54#6 ,F>F:+D H @?#9#D#9/1:7E2-R#0#9EK*. H .?-2=7 :<,+*-0/. LEG

' 4#6,% 7E0K, -R -R/7E,F> A +@A

A +D-G

'

(24)

:'"$+— 8i'i01z23+s%u}}†€"$3Ÿ+23';" q {

: * (

';9%( & ; !<; ;9

Œ‹A†l€+%#67f+,1z%0l2?pJzfr8c+]p%p%$p#p)"R+$! K !"$3z"$%%z#%"R

%wl < p­$6hp%23';"R+#"R,"$F&'(x1'"Rp%:ž"$'P{­ 3+%6Y0%1h!^"$tfYhi

<

©+0:ip)žp%W"$%sªpJ+"Rp%*1zf{

'D?+9-D;: ,FECT2YH 4-6 NE=T2YH >D?+9-D H ?=7"9-2 7E2+9L)NG

'D?+9-D;: ,FECT2YH

M

3 = M

!/

E!#

h= Af/

hQ h

=#fQl

W

f= ! hQ -Q !+iKK!

f

h5!#Xi-!MfXi "-Q h+-K#

R ]fhi*j h= M !#f QK h 3

Jff h !k

Kh +

!K M K

Jh Kh X V !) X ! )

Jh Kh X ) ! !) XL ! )

Jh

Kh X W

YW

)LYV

! )

Jh Kh X Y YW )LYW ! )

Jh Kh V !) XLYX ! )

Jh

Kh !

YW

)L

! )

Jh

Kh X

YW

)L

! )

Jh Kh !) X W ! )

Jh

Kh

!) XL

! )

Jh

Kh X

!) XLY!

! )

-:ž+%*%3"Rc-$p)pc%€jp%30"R=1w("$ q +&p%"$h{:¤iJ=W+

+Ÿ(6c‹…6Y"$''8:(%3 %Ÿ01ª?0Wf+p%xŽ"$';n+5+p)L“6%ŸŠ|p%0

<

r8iz%:z"$#;#%(*1ª3"$f{|p%1%ªp)%­';—"$'(1$!f(#"$

<

6Cp%p%

%"R < p)$=1p) v"$¥W"Rp%W4%&)"$zW*$p%12 { Œ 6 q 148:%4+501z23+&%

‹s†l€ "R% K <‹ I™‹1z'(x1'|0l23';(%'

q

!l+s%{

'% 7E0K,X4-6 ,E=T2YH>F: H .2KB, I>D?+9-D .2$+2.3Rd"" AG'F'GH

D?+9-D+91 : 7E2#R-0+9 EK*/. H . ? -2=7 : ,#*-0/. L "G

' IR+9O4-6 % 7E0-,.-R$+3R/7E,F>#G

' IR+9

U) ! )

(25)

−5 0 5 10 15 20

brok5−brok4 brok5−brok1 brok5−brok3 brok1−brok3

95% family−wise confidence level

Differences in mean levels of broker

|­(*1p%A‘{¥R>‚}=1 q ¢™Œ‹s†l€23'($



$%pz"R +p)J= -/"$.5n+52?'($n%Ÿ01ª?0Wf+p%xŽ"$';{›c$+

%"R—%$p)p—$6}%f+p%xŽ"$';‚6C1''(Ž8:]%n)"$z'+%;*\"$:%s+0l2p)f+1{

' U.?-,F>@?#9#D;: EG

(26)
(27)

]

‚

Œ

…%z'"$+AJ3"R2+p!h~,€ 09x^p%›r8iW\3'(%(23'(0yš0123"Rp)+1W+F;ž{~‹cp%

"nz$p%cx1p)%"R%;'(—++‚;,0Žx1p%zy}$p%%$*$1"$'j01f+p)"$+%{#::0l‚+0%18:';'

09x1p%+%*z2Ÿ%s01f+p)"$+%L"R+p)|!f"R6C+p8:;J“8iw8c''j+Ar8i 0"$z23'(

67p%1 %#+0l¯+c;''++pJ"R+ %p¯+,;s-{7|$p)%"R+'q !R8i#"9x1,'(6Ch% < "R++p q

'(6Cc0"$z23'(

<

3“6C$p*$h{

7 9 & : , ' , #

~,€/+%"R+\%"R\%p%&"Rp%&

q

23"$'' q N

¥“$p%%$*$13"$'‚01f+p)"$+%8:e%p%

"Rp% N '(x1'c+W% 6C"$0+$p{+ "$

<

z"Rp%pJ"$*$•v%\p)98:c$6‚"W"R+pJj!

*1(x1W%"R% q " < ; <fq %6C1''(Ž8:*p%++p);0%(1{

¥R{:$—2p%30—$6 x^p q 2?"$(p—$6XŠ|p%f‚p%Ž8:—:‹l{

f{:$—2p%30—$6 x^p

q

p)98 8c(%W(%+'(6}¥R{

f{:) $6 %f+p)(—&"$F„p%Ž8 ¥R{



¨0"$z23'(&$6c"$.$p)%1$p)"$'i"R+pJj!X8ce%p%Ÿ"Rp%W‘•'x1'$6:%

6C"$0+$p!?i*1(x1 < '(Ž8{

¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

p%c"Rp%c01f%'()X8—"

q

X+0p)"R+w" =5f#

<

©+0];-{



](,#$,1p

"$W6C!8i%;z23'q 0Žx1p1s$6}%/p%${

(28)

: H86F: H 6F: H :-G Hg77? L Ha@%?.5L5W H (HK77? L"G

' %F?

X

U

! ! !

! ! !

(X

! ! !

! ! !

c$%0…%"RL%…01+pJ"$+%“"Rp)v++$p% 01'lyP8c+„%+"$”$6Ap%98yP8:+${

y5Ÿ"Rp%&$\'< p)"R+'q +p q ;*„+•016C3+L%“p%"$p{ Œ np%'q %"R -

2p)67p) %]01+pJ"$+%}% 8—" q {X s‚01';n"$'(8—" q 0p%"R+i%]013++p)"$+%­"R+p)(

p%Ž8—yP8:;+s"$Ÿ%Ÿ"R22?'

q

*j7k++p)"$3+2?1%n({

S * 8 '%O O& @:& '" # "

%;

y5i6C­ªpJ+¯1\%]2?$p)+671':p)"R%*c0"$z23'(${}i"R%"$+X}"§xR"$'"

<

'(,ª3'(

GšU%${



67+pcp%"$* ;W%"R%"$+!?%0l%* +L—$+ < '“%

zf'|++p)"$(*1f%"98—" q ! < ]+z+i%s01+pJ"$+]"$0$pJ* + %A"R+p)“0p)"R+

"Rp)';(p{Xf%%(x1c01L"$„ hQK-f= $j3k{

' U1 4#687E2-*+9;: ,#*(=.32F>+@A2CB F: WF@/HJI2#*#9-2 7MLONG

' %F? ,=7"*-R-,#R?>&U1 U3?=7,=17?.K0 ?#G 4-6-%?

cŽ8 8c 8i

<

'.%›zf'a!- 8:;''$+›%"R&8]›"9x1…+2j(ª "

0p%%"$;e+$6i01f+p)"$%%{]yŠe8iLfx1$=1 %e

M

==f fYhij7k z% ! 8i

"$”p)"$'']%„01f+p)"$+%z"$0$p);*•+ %(pz01'Lyz¥R! •"$”f{

Œ

z $6

*$p%"Rs01%ž30\%3"Rc%\0"$0"$z\$6#%\6C"$0+$p01'3 < +…8:

fx1$=l*\% M

= =f/ fYhXi*j3kwz%fh{ Œ Ÿ%—"$%n( – 2j$p%+671';(1˜F{

'D?+9-WO4-6 *?$ >7E*-,#0KB B U3? 7E, 1?.30? H 9K*-,#*L U1"G

'5RE *=7H : * ? $F>ID?#9#W H RAU .30-, L.30#RK, >U3?=7,=17?.0 ? L.30#RK, >

*=B#BK7E2#R-R#0$#22#R-R L9AH (*.3*@%2 L5D H 2l$+0 7 ? LXWKG#G-G

J KM = KFNPO JfQ KFN-R i+f#! M S#*jUT R k

Mh-

hK!

h X

! !! V

X XX-!

-

!

!*ZZ Z

Mh-

hK!

h>]tf

\\

K7

iKQ" * ! !!9 ! !! !! ! ! ) !*ZZ Z

Mh- hK! h>] Af#!#fYQ X V

! !! X V

! !!9

!! ! ! !

! !FV

*ZZ

Mh-

hK!

h>]QQJi

hQ !! ! ! !! XX X X ! )! VW !

[

M

f#! X V ! !! X ! !!

K \

Q

h#-7d] !/^Z Z Z3`g! ! ! c^UZZd`a! ! C^UZd`g! ! ^ `e! c^`

(29)

< %"$W6Cp%1¬%“GšU%¨ª3'(${

'X9=B 4-687"2-*#9?:<,+*( .2?>@A2=B?: F@ HI2+*#9#2 73LNG

'.2$+2.3RF> 9=B#9 77E=BG

f f Q+hQ E!Yf

/Mh

:$%;0Ÿ%"R %„'(x1'\"9x1 < ”$pJp%."$'(23" < %"$''q !#z"$*›%"R

%L$p)p)*v;€jp%fs6Cp%1 %&~‚€

<

^$=j{›}"R=l*v%3;+…"$01f!X8]

"§x^w+“+:2Ÿ%01f+p)"$%%:"R+p)(&"Rp%6Y''q "$Ÿ0$p%p%0%'q {

' %? 4#6 *-,=7E0 >% > : D& & H F:D & & 3H F: D& & 3H86F: & H86F: AH

: AEH H H 6 : F&-D H86F: F&#D H F: &A H +G H H WKG

' %?,=7E*#RK,+R?> 9=B+9/77E=BG 4#6-%F?

'@?#9)4-6 *?$F> 0 +U7 ? $#2 2,9B 9/7E B;H 9K*K,+*L59 BEG

'@?#9 %?,=7E*#RK,+R

#

M\

X

f ! ) ! )! ) ! !

f ! ) !

)! ) !

!

Q+hQ ! ) ! !! !! ! V

"!#f /+h-

!

V V! !

!! !! !

! !! !

v';"$+L01"$3 8—"$+¨J)=”%"R“%…01f+p)"$%%“"9x1

<

%&2

0$p%p%0%'q "$4%"R %“%p%Wž%%(1$6:f+p%+n"Rp) < *›"$+8ip%

£

xf"

%:01'LX$6|%cL"R+p)3¦J>}‡4x1p)%3#‡¢(!  ¥x^p)%  "$3  x1p)%3#:1y  {

:Ž8 8i"$„"$+=Ÿ- +“+23'(]%††t 6C$p:{

'5RFEG * 7FH: * ?$ >@?#9 H R U.30-, L.30#RK,F>9/7E B)L.0-R-,F>+@ $+R?:=@ L AH

@ lA $+R?:3DF@ LXD H)@ $#RF: ? 6 @ LXWKG#G-G

J KM = KFNPO JfQ KNPR i+f#! M S#*jUT R k

+ M \

X

! !! X )

X XX ) V V )P!

!! !

!

ZZ Z

+

M \

] Sqi F5S ` V V) V V) FX X XP! !! V ! -ZZ

+

M \

] iF ! !! ! !! ! ! ! !P! X) )Y))

+ M \ ]i FhQ

V

X XX V

X XX9YX

!V V )P!

!!YV

ZZ

[

7

M

f-! ! ! !! ! !!

K\

Q

h#K#]

!_^UZZ Z3`a!

! !b^UZ Z3`a!

!c^Zd`e!

!f^

`g!

C^*`

(30)
(31)

r

r ] B

Œ

e%2p%xl(1nJ"R23+p)!}8]“"$'(0'%x1'

q

8c(%50l2?p);zf%s8:(%513'

q

1,6Y"$0+$p{­ ;¯"*$ +%"Rp%%;*:2j1f! < ¯(*1'q p)"$'+%R{ : F"R2+p

f+p%30A%p%"$p+„0l2?p);zf%s8:(%• 8i„6C"$0+$pJ{&~‚€ p%%p)3s+„%

<

"R++p

q

'(6Cz0l"$23'("R*1"$e+…'';++p)"R+ 8]RyP8—"

q 

s ¡



++%{1%"$

%10yP6C"$0+$pn"$%$!h%\"$)%z2%1c"Rp)%›+++5"$3›"&1lyP2?"Rp)"$z+p)

++:—1++p)"R+„"$:"$v"$'(+p)3"R%(x1${

S > ; *

Œ —;++p)0%x1c+“+%"R+%n%%"R%+%"$'hzf' < 67$p)*$1*z6Yp%%p§{

) 8;:

$

<>=@? 8 ?BA : ? ? 8;: ?DC 8;:

$

8:p%

E < ¥HGJIJIJIKGL

M < ¥HGJIJIJIKGON

< ¥HGJIJIJIKG%

L < l < pi$6­p%Ž8:

N < l < pi$6X01'L

% < l < pi$6­p%23';"R+—"R"$FŸ+p%"R%zf:'(x^'

= < Žx1p)"$''h"9x1p)"R*$

£

"$?¦

18 < Š|p%f%"$'j—|0:"$%+f"R+v8c(%&% EP%Ÿp)98 6Y"$0+$p

A : < Š|p%f%"$'j—|0:"$%+f"R+v8c(%&%'M$%v01'W6Y"$0+$p

8R: < f+p)"$0%(1W—|0c"$)+"R+v8:(%W%SEš%„p%Ž8 "$ M1%„01'W6Y"$0+$p

C 8;:

$ < 1%s$pp%p%$p:"$)+"R+v8:(%W%SETM %›"R%" xŽ"$';

(32)

6Y"$0+$p!KfQ33{X3"R%"$+:;“%ª3'(LGPU/%&$1{

')(+*-,-,/.0/13254-687"2-*+9;:<,+*(=.32?>@A2CB F:DF@/HJI2#*#9K2=7MLON+G

'D?+9 )4-6 *?$ >I7"RCB 9-2$#0%+2 -M( 7E*9 H 9K*-,#*LO(+*-,-, .30/132-G

'5RE *=7H > D?+9 #G

J KYM

=

KN O

#fQ

KN-R i+f#!

M S-jUT R k

KXi

-!

! !! ! !

!! ! !

V! ! !P!

! YW *Z

fQ3 X*! 7Y! !! ! ! !) !! ! ! ! ! !P! ! FX X

KXi >] +fYQ3 V*! Y! !! ! ! ! X X X ! )X X XP! VX

[

M f#!

-!

X! ! !! ! !

! F! ! !

K \

Q

h#-7d] !/^Z Z Z3`g! ! ! c^UZZd`a! ! C^UZd`g! ! ^ `e! c^`

-ŠX+1';z+3']% – KXi

Z fQ3˜ ;+pJ"$0%(1z+p)Ÿ!f"$308:''

3's%\"$v—j0%KXi “"$ +fYQ3 <fq 6Y"$'({~‚€ˆ2j1f%1c%"R

%wf+p)"$0%(1z—|0%—"Rp%w$‚%*1(ª3"$f{=|$p‚6Yp%%p‚xf;0$!^8i:"$&p)"98

"$„;+pJ"$0%(1W23'(${

'50,#2 7"* %+,#0 ?:&U .?-,F><(+*K,+,/.0 132+9K2$#0%2 H (+*-,-,/.0/132 ( 7E*9 H (*K,#,/.30 1"2CI7"R H

,H=U 2 L @ .?@H *-0 L @*-,-,+2 7H E0 1"2 ,+2 7E*%#,+0 ? 3. ?K, @H K.3*( L

@ E2$#0%+2 @HgH.3*K( L @ ?E/7"R @/H ,=7"* %2?: .*(2.L @ (C7"*E9F@H %F?/.5L9A KG

:—ªp)+#"Rp)*1zfX+%—6Y0%(1z$+#%'x1'­%"R#8c'' < —2?'($++

1•%3yš"Žl{n +01•+'';c- 98ˆ"$

q

';:+ŸpJ"§8 1›% 23'(${

Œ

%;\"$%$!,%p%W"Rp%Ÿ‘ < p)"$3!­p%%'%*v¨‘5'{5&%(p)¨"Rp%*1zf

%zp)+2?13+$! 8:;J›8:';' < z23'($++51 %^yš"Ž{zt q 6C"$3'(!¯- 2?'($%A%

z"$4$6—"$Fe+p%"R%\01

<

"R%(1 !¯%"R\!J)98;:

{ Π%&"

<

Žx1$!­8i“"9x1

"$'%Lp%žf++…- +&23'($:';

£

<lq

© 13*z%n$%J¦J!?+&'"

<

' %n"ŽlA"$8i

"9x1+2j(ªŸ"$3Ÿ+L+A‘L3Šjp)—01'(1p){



i%



s :¡



1+23i"$“%sf+p)"$0%(1“23'($‚;|­(*1p)~™f{¥

<

$%Ÿ+

+z3"R+:%"R]%Af+p)"$0%(1“—j0—])(*1(ª3"$f!1~‚€ p%01‚2?1'y

*z%††l~ "$3…†† Œ {i"$ < s"$%'q "$F(x1W8:%

'D?+9 -*54-6 * ? $F> I7ERcBS9K2$+0 %2

(C7"*E9 HS9-*K,#* L)(+*K,#,/.0/1"2#G

'5RE *=7H > D?+9 #*-G

J KYM

=

KNPO JfYQ

KFN-R if-!

M S#*jUT R k

KXi

*!

!! ! !

!! ! V

VXP!

! !WFXLZZ

fQ3 X! Y!! ! ! !) !! ! X ! ) X ! !! W

[

M

f#! ! Y!! ! ! ! F)

K \

Q

h#-7d] !/^Z Z Z3`g! ! ! c^UZZd`a! ! C^UZd`g! ! ^ `e! c^`

(33)

17.8 17.9 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3

Battery Life Interaction Plot

Device

Hours

dev1 dev2 dev3

brand bra3 bra4 bra1 bra2

|­(*1p%d™f{¥R> Œ +pJ"$0%(1Ÿ‡,'($

(34)

17.9 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3

−0.2 −0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3

Residuals vs. Fitted

mod5a$fitted.values

mod5a$residuals

|}*1p%d™f{f>‚-:%"$'|‡‚'($

Œ :"$'(8—" q i*$…+LF)=&%sp%)"$'iW1p:z'a{*‹:p)8is1'q 3%'" q

8i&2?'($%wy: |­(*1p% ™f{Ÿ"$3&™f{f{ p%"$3*W"$ < p)"§8c…%%"$z

8—"

q

"$;Ÿ+0%(1vf{¥R{

' U . ?K,F>ID?+9 -*/130K,-,+2#9?:$#* . E-2#R H D?+9 #* 7"2-R#0#9 E-*.R H

*#0 L @ E2-R#0#9 E-*.RP$+R?: "0K,-,+2#9 @H Ud% I LXD #G

'5*(=.302?>IOL H .3,H LXD-G

' ? 7Y >ID?#9 -* 7E2#R-0+9 EK* .3R H U#% I L5D +G

' .302?>ID?#9 -* 7E2#R-0+9 EK* .3R#G

; ' , % ; P ,

; '

y %p%…"Rp%…ep%2?'"R+!i~,€ +';'z%3"RL8iv"9x1„+¨"$%%zv%p%

n„f+p)"$0%(1 "$3 +z%W†† Œ "$n%&††~{h¯…+''X- +v„%;!¯%23'q

0p%"R+"Wzf' 8:(%…1'

q

"$›—|0%{\p%+w8:';'¯'2?v8:(%…%z†3†l~

"$+1L"R%"$''q {,:s"R%"z6C$p%i0"$z23'("$ < 6C1Ÿ;W%sª3'(LGPU/%${

(35)

−2 −1 0 1 2

−0.2 −0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3

Normal Q−Q Plot

Theoretical Quantiles

Sample Quantiles

|­(*1p) ™f{f>]:$pJ"$'A"$f%'w‡‚'($

(36)

'D?+9 M4-6 *?$ >7E2#R U B

;H 9K*-,#*L*E7"2 U G

'5RE *=7H > D?+9 +G

J LKM = KFNPO JfQ KFN-R i+f#! M S#*jUT R k

*X

! !! YV

! !! ) V

!*ZZ Z

XL V V) W FV X*! ! ! ! ZZ Z

[ M f#!

V

XX X !

K \

Q

h#-7d] !/^Z Z Z3`g! ! ! c^UZZd`a! ! C^UZd`g! ! ^ `e! c^`

w"R%p)"$';'q !s%e"$%)z2%(13„%1'; < eFJ=1 xl".%4p%%3"$'!A"$

(6:% q "Rp%Ÿ+x^p)'q xl(1'"R+h!,%O|p)(L"$4123"Rp)"$z+p);L++

£

% < '(Ž8w¦

%1'

<

"Rp%p)(W1{

(+ # ." " # ; ;,

-:z < pi%"Ri%‚++—‚67$pi8i6Y"$0+$p  s :¡  8:(%1,p%23';"R%(1h{}

p%žf(p)6Y0%(1-”; #Y=fYQK7C*j7k^{ji"R%"$+­67$p­%;¯"$*1($2?'"$+

q

0"$z23'(w,;›GPU/%R{#c6C30%(1L"$

<

c"$''(&z%p%w3Šjp)X8—"

q

{



''

*1(x^%z%"$1+2?!h+Ÿ(w2?3:1•8:3"Rc6C$p)"R q 1pA"R%"$+sA { Œ

1p]"$+$!l%0—1p‚p%+2j1+‚"Rp%:"$'';"x10+$p§!8i"$&+ A$6h%:z%f

p%0%' q {

:ªp)%nz%f4fx11'x1s+2j(6

q

*Ÿ%p%+2j1+“x10+$p!}*$p%12ex^0+$p

£

8:3J 8]“8:% +…++J¦n"$4% < '(J=56C"$0+$p e%“ª3p)+v"Rp%*1zf%{ Œ

%;A0l"$z2?'($! 1p*$p)123"Rp%"$*1($23'"$+ q 3(A q 2j"$5% < '(J=fs"Rp)%

<

"$';'(^1„3'"R%(1&"R%+pw

q

2?${#:sp%+2j1+i%

<

p)%%*\2p%%%p%${

'5*-B0)4-687"2-*+9;:<,+*(=.32?>@A2CB F:UAA @HJI2-*+9K2 75LON+G

' 1#7"0-2#9 *:<,+2-R-,F> *KBE0 U"7E2#R#R H *-B0-*-B0? H *KBE0 K(+*.#.??G

R #Y=fQ +fYQ M =O=

f/+f1] fQ

\7

K7

fQ

\7 YfQ

\7

hrfQfQ

\7

=Af#!-!YhYhQ

R

#Y=fYQ

NM

fK# ! ) X Xif-!

M ! !! !Y!

:+01„%vp%ž3(p%]%s6C$p) '" "$W%n3"R%"$++L+2j(ª {

' 1#7"0-2#9 *:<,+2-R-,F>UE7E2#R-R9BS*KB0?S(+*/.-.??;H 9-*K,#* L)*KBE0-G

R

#Y=fQ +fYQ M

=O=

f/+f1] K7‡fQfQ \7 hfQ3 Af-!#!YhYhQ

R

#Y=fYQ

NM

fK# ! ) X Xif-!

M ! !! !Y!

(37)

$6c%Ÿp)+2?13+${ €A"R%" 8:;'' < „.%…01' "$0$p)3*5+ %v6C"$0+$p“8]

%(p%A++%{,sp%Ž8:i8:;''?01f%"$„%

<

'(f)=&6C"$0+$p§{

' AX4-6 *KB0d"<*KB0-*KB0? L-L @A,H U 2 @H A '

' 3DO4-6 *KB0d"<*KB0-*KB0? L-L @A,H U 2 @H A '

' 3WO4-6 *KB0d"<*KB0-*KB0? L-L @A,H U 2 @H A '

' O4-6 *KB0d"<*KB0-*KB0? L-L @A,H U 2 @H A '

'5*KBE039-*K,+*X4#6-%-(+09?> lAEH 3D H 3W H -G

'5*KBE039-*K,+*

X

U

LV*

F))FVF

(X

W *F! YV

L)*X

* **

(V

FV)LF

()

F)V*X

*)L

(W

*XF! YW

"R=l*¨"4'^$= "R&%›3"R%"$+!:8iv+›%"RW(“;Lf%"$'+4%›%" < '(

(23'" q WŸ%+0f < ^$=j{:c98œ8in"$…z1++p)"R+%ª33"$'h8—" q $6X"$''*

% +=5fQ=*j3kc6C30%(1h{

' 1+7E0#2#9G *:<,#2#RK, > *-B039-*-,+*-G

R

+=5fQ+fQ b

M

=)=

Jff1] fQ \7 f/+f

R

#=5fQ

NM

f+ F! )F

X

7Xif-!

M ! ! !!Y!

(38)
(39)

‚ i



­ªp)+X'($=?!^++%*1­'(^$=\%%"$z"$#r8iA6C"$0+$p‚%(*1{

Œ

XX0p)"$'

+LpJ+%"$W%n3Šjp)0s%1*1h{yŠ(%„r8i6Y"$0+$pc)(*1!"$Fv'(x^'|$6

6C"$0+$pt

£

%Ap%Ž8w¦,+%" q i%s%"$z"$0p)1%—"$''|'(x1'‚$6¯6Y"$0+$p  £

%s01'?¦J{

yŠp)"$8:(%e++e%(*1! %L'(x^'X$6—6C"$0+$p tˆŠ|p)"$0p)1%n6Y"$0+$p

 {

uc%;*Ÿ%0"$z23'(L67p%1 ~,€\! (6i(8ip%"vr8iŸ6Y"$0+$p0l2jp)zf!¯%L%"$z

2p%$6C%+$p:8i1';Ÿ+"$J•"$'' +%"R%+%;"$'¯23"$J=R"R*${ ‹c98ix1p§!?%30(w:"&++

%(*1h!€jp%f]2p%$6C%+$p)+"$JŸ%nŠ|p%f‚2?"$)=R"R*${

-, % % (

Œ

8c''­"$'+

<

L'("Rp67p%1 %Lzf'#%"Rn%p%Ln„f+p)"$0%(15+pJ 5"

++„zf'a{#sp%"$+1

<

*z%3"R—%n'(x1';i$6 %$p—6Y"$0+$pc"9x1

'=+L%s$%p:'(x^'i$6 %(p:"9©+$p6Y"$0+$p{

) 8;:

$

<>=@?18,?BA

8:

?DC

8;:

$

8:p%

E < ¥HG G) GJIJIJIG

M < ¥HG G) GJIJIJIG

< ¥HG G) GJIJIJIG%

< l

<

pi$6X'(x1']$6­%"9©+$p6Y"$0+$p

< l < pi$6X'(x1']$6­%;$p—6C"$0+$p

< l < pi$6­p%23';"R+i2?p

£

EGM¦—01 < ;"R%(1

ti';*s%sz'j;‚p)"$''q žf(+A++p)"$(*1f+6C$p%8—"Rp)LW-n{ Œ —i"\L"R++p—$6

+2?6

q

*A%pJ(*1fX67$p) ';"c6C$p‚- +;+p)2p%{ :"R%"$+‚67$p‚%X0"$z23'(

—eGPU %${

(40)

'D?+9 4-6 *?$ > R %? 7"2cBSR-,#*K,+R U3TKB

R-,#*-,#R U3TKB U77?/132-R-R? 7FH 9K*-,#*L5R-,FE-9-G

'5RE *=7H > D?+9 CG

J

LKYM = KFNPO JfYQ KFN-R if-! M S-jUT R k

=f

\

X*X! V X ! Y! Y! V W ! !-! ! ! W ! *ZZ

=f \ ]Kh 7h

V

V F!

X

X )

!

W

)

[

M f#!

) )

X V

)

K \ Q h#-7d]

!/^Z Z Z3`g!

! ! c^UZZd`a!

! C^UZd`g!

! ^

`e!

c^`

:sx1p+y

<

67$p)0yš+Ÿ+p)/;‚%s1s8:(%&%01'(1 { Œ —67$p)L]- %"R

%'(x1']$6 Jh

Hh+"Rp%%+Ÿ8:(%;e=+f/

\ {

(41)

r

! "$#%&')(*'+ -,./ 0&')#% '+(2143%'+516'73%98.'7:<;=?>@BA?&C EDF'+?>G3H14-353*') ?I)'

$#/IKJL'E&MA?;N-'E8O'+N EDP 9Q DJ/#*R(*AS*A?R14T 3!BA2>E&&Q!A.#*R3*');=#%NNU'@VXWY'E&CTI)'+$

14-3

SZ

B&'+I)'+$6>@A.IKJY%-A.% +[\]% BB'+?(FD$16'0>E?^,?'E6J$Q)10-3`_#% B

>@A.I7a

J/%-A./ E[cb 3*'+c16'S3%98.'2I)A?&C'S3%?:d;e?>@BA?&f ED63*'2&'+NTB'+(gM&C'+>@Aahi

"j#/&'k(*'+ -,./ l&'m#% '+(F[6nXT%>@'R16'm&'m*A?M>E&&QX*,)A.#*43*'k;=#%NNo'@VXWY'E&CTI)'+$ED

1'p3%98.'mBAqIrs.'p3*'7? #%IrW%-A.S3/03*'E&C'p M*A*DLA?&`A.%N-QS*'E,.N,.-J/N-'?D/TjB'E&a

?>@-A.HJY'Et16'E'+!3*'K;=?>@BA?&C E[K\tH#*Wo>@A.Ir%,^>G3%W%B'E&C +Douvw14TNN>@Ax8.'E&Rt1AyN-'E8.'+N

;e?>@BA?&CT?Nz(*'+ ,.% EDP143%'E&'r3% m? #%I)W/-A.d*'E'+({*A?mJL'|Ir?(*'^?%(d103*'E&')3*'

$B'E&C?>@-A.^'@}L'+>@ 0A?;~$B'E&'+ B>E?2 BTNNLJY'R'+ BTIrB'+(F[

€~-&C B3*A.#%,.3FD.143% mir "$#%&'9‚^\tz KIrB&CƒV7A?;o -„E' JXQ DO14-3

3*'7'+jB&f-'+ 0T5'+?>G3H&Ax1…?%(H>@A.N#%Ir!JL'+*,H†7BA [7‡SA?&C'EA98.'E&ˆDF'+?>f3‰X#%IpJL'E&

W%WY'+&f 4'@V*?>@N-QqA.%>@'7q'+?>G32&CA91kDL?%(S'@V*?>@N-QSA./>@'K2'+?>f3!>@A.N#%IrP[6Šw‹V$‹

'@VX?I)WYN-'R ,.-8.'+yJL'+N-Ax1k[

Œ ‹ : †

: † Œ ‹

‹ : † Œ

† Œ ‹ :

 3% 6 4y;e?>@03*'kTS "$#%&'RA.S103%>G3<3%'R8x?N-'E]aŽWY&s$T*,r#% B'R'@V*?I)W/N-'

quzv… 6JY? B'+(F[  3%'m(%? B'E4T lˆ8?NJYN-'RŽ‘ +%$ [6’`%>@'RQOA.#S3%98.'RQ.A.#*&C '+N-;i

^ "$#%&'?DX#% B'M3*'08?N#*'+ <3*'`IrB&CƒV|BA7%(%'@VrQ.A.#*&“BT% (*'+”~;=?>@BA?&+D*?%(

?(%(y3*'k&Ax1•?%(S>@A.NT#%Iry;=?>@BA?&C lBA|&C&C-8.'`lQ.A.#*&4'@V$WL'E&CI)'+$?No B'E]ah#*W[

(42)

Z

N N N Z N

N Z N

N N

Z N N Z N

N

N N N N Z

: %( l,

ŠM lI)'+$-A.*'+(y'+&fN-'E&+DX3*'kI)A$(*'+NF14TNNo*A?l%>EN#/(*'M?2$B'E&C?>@-A.yB'E&CIq[

) 8 <>=@?

8

?BA

? ?DC 8

143%'E&' EG M ?%( ?NNo&C#/<;e&A.I †`BA [zŠ0/?N-Q$ C*,p3*'k(%r "$#%-B'R TIrN&BA

3*'K(*'+ -,.% 6yW/&'E8$A.#% >f3/W%B'E&C E[

'L$#*/. EKR#2M4-687"2-*+9;:<,+*(=.32?>@A2CB &;:DF@ H I2#*#9K2=7ML)NG

'D?+9 &O4-6 *?$ >U *-,#RbB %F?-R-,

R U * %2-R

$+*.32-,#R H 9K*-,#*LL$+*.EKR-2#G

'5RE *=7H >D?+9 &-G

J

LKM = KFNPO Q KFN-R #! M S#UT R

=

X X) !

YX

W Y) X ! F! )

XW ! ! X ! ! XP) !V X ! !*ZZ Z

#!#+ XbYX W V X 9Y! WF! W ! ! !)FW ZZ

[

M #!

V F

! X

K \

Q

-7d] !/^Z Z Z3`g! ! ! c^UZZd`a! ! C^UZd`g! ! ^ `e! c^`

, b: 8: % <: <; L8 '

'E;eA?&'!IrA98X*,dA.BA &|\B\)A?;kuvKD63*'E&'516'2>@A98O'E&^ >@A.#*W/N-'2A?;k;e#/%>@-A.%

3%Ir,.3jJY'`#% B'E;=#%N/J/#*6(*Ap%A?;=?NNL$BAK?$Q| BWL'+>E"!/>0>f3%W/B'E&A?;Uuzvp[X€U&C BN-Q?D

3*'R;=#%%>@A. =

KK!; # E!+7$

>E?yJY'k#% '+(yBArN B3*'kI)'+?% 3*'k(/ƒ}L'E&C'+j

B&'+Ir'+jU>@A.IpJ/%-A./ F?%(R3*' '@}o'+>@ UA?;X3*'z(%ƒ}o'E&'+$o;e?>@BA?&~N-'E8.'+NT E[  3*'%!%&C B

&,.#/I)'+$UBAm3*';e#/%>@-A.)3%? BARJL'l3*'&C'+ #%N-UA?;FR>E?NNXBAk3*'

;e#/%>@-A.FD

?%(3*'‰ B'+>@A./( WY'+>E"!/'+ <103*'E3*'E&yQ.A.# (*'+ -&C'23*'‰I)'+?% yA?&y3*'H'+ BTIrB'+(

'@}o'+>@ E[

'D?+9K2. :<,+*( .2-RF>D?+9 & H @& 2#*('R @AG

)=E!#

=EYQl

*

#Q3 =YQ

)

(43)

C

X

W !-F! ) ) !!*W )

7

7

X

) -W !-X !-W

#!#

-!++

#!

#!

-! X -!

!

!

!*7

) PV V

'@?#9-2. : ,#*K( .32#R?>D?#9& H @<2/1#1"2 %+,#R @AG

# "!#7

=

C

X

! !

)

!!

7

7

X

X

) )

F!

)

#!#

-!++

-!

#!

#!

X -!

X ! ! ! !

 3*'SA.#%BW/#*|;e&A.I 3*'5 B'+>@A./(>E?NN0>E?JY'!$B'E&W%&'EB'+(c?>E>@A?&f(%*,{BA3*'

I)Aj(*'+N [†[  3X#% ED < Œ IŒ D#*<

† I ?/(S BA|A.P[  3*'m'+ BIrB'k;eA?& =

6,.-8.'+qy3%' !%&C BlNT*'MTy3*' !%&C B;=#%%>@A.^>E?NTN D

†[

[

 3*'l B'+>@A./(r;=#%%>@-A.)A?;F*A?B'?D E! /

Ql$

T zk"$#%>fsm19QpA?;F>G3*'+>fs$%,

3*A91 Ir?$Q|&'EW/NT>EB'+ 3*'E&'K&'m4'+?>G32N'E8.'+NFy3*'mIrAj(*'+N[ 

3*'k%W/#*6BAr3*'

;e#%/>@-A. K3*'y ?I)'y? p3%KBAH3*'

>E?NNŽ[  3*'<W%&A?WLA. B'+( I)Aj(%'+N3%? pBA

JY'^;e#/NN-Q‰ BWL'+>E"!%'+(F[  3%'<;=#%%>@-A.&'E#*&C/ KHN mA.%N-Q{-;3*'qI)Aj(%'+NT p#/jJY?Nƒa

?%>@'+(F[0'+%>@'q#% T*, F ! C "! Q $ )7 C 7

-!++

)

-!

M

/

14TNNY?NTN-A91 QOA.#yBArB'+ B4-;U3*'kI)A$(*'+NP 6JY?N?%>@'+(F[

(44)

=

7

-!++

' 0#R?: .0-R-,F> 7"2 U.30 %*K,+0 ?('ER?>&U *-,+R B%?-R-, R U * %+2#R

$#*/.32K,+R HS9-*K,+*LL$#*/. EKR#2-G#G

U

[

b -3q3/ EDX16'k>@A.I)'kBA|?q'+/(qBA &\A?;Uuvp[

(45)

6

(46)
(47)



3% >f3%W/B'E&6T|3*'MJLAOA?sy >@A./>@'E&C*'+(yW%&CTIr&CN-QK14-3^(*'+I)A.% B&C*,p3*A91 BA

>@A.I)W/#*B'R3*'R'@}o'+>@ EDYJ$Q^3%?%(FD%Tq7 16ArN-'E8.'+No;=?>@BA?&C?NP'@V$WL'E&CI)'+$E[ 0A916'E8.'E&+D

? Bs$  C#%>f3y? l%A?*,p3*'zB'+ lA?&C(*'E&ˆDX? C -,.%%,KW/NT#% ?/(^I|X#% C-,.% 6 3*A.#%NT(

JY'pB&C?% BWY&'+$lBA<3%'p#% 'E&0A?;z<,?AOA$(‰ BA?;e 1&'?Do #%>G32? k[ 0'+%>@'73% 4>G3%W*a

B'E&k `&C3*'E&k 3%A?&R>@A.I)W/&'+(HBAq3*'7B'@VXBJYAjA?sY[)b‰'|s.')3*'7A?W%WLA?&#%%-tQSBA

$B&Aj(%#/>@'M?*A?3%'E&0#% B'E;=#%NL;=#%%>@-A.qmD

"!

[

#%$'& (*),+.-0/21435),687:9;=<>@?BA?C-@D,+FEHGI;KJL30+.-NMO?P143'6Q),1

 3*'K(/? B'EM#/ B'+(5T 098x?TNJ/N-'k Ž‘R"SUT?[  3%'KN-'E8.'+NT lA?;z3%,.32?%(!N-Ax1 &'7#% B'+(

yA?&C(*'E&BAr&C'E?q3*'RB'E&CI|*A.N-A?,?Q^#% B'+(Squvp[

VXWY[Z\^]_`W\YaBb5ZYdc ed\Bf"gh\jilkBb0mHg"npoI\Ya[\jW^qsrt

VLuak^]_:Yu[vwfxWl\y{z}|~zuyZYjil\€‚zlWlƒd„"\…€†\('Iv ‡ˆyƒ ‰\Ln‚a[Y[ZY†qXWlYZ\t

V…yŠ Y W‹Ffuakt

Œ[ Žj‘Ž’ “ ! Ž’

” •—–˜–––™4•jš›:–Cœ–––™l• š›

ž" •—–˜––Ÿ –Ÿd›:–Cœ––Ÿ[ –Ÿ[›

!#d¡ˆ ¢[ •—–˜–––– š–†–Cœ–––– [š–

”

˜£

ž" •—–˜–––– š–†–Cœ–––– [š–

” ˜£¤!#d¡ˆ¤¢[ •—–˜–––––Ÿd›:–Cœ–––––Ÿ[›

ž"˜£¤!ˆ¡ˆ¤¢ •—–˜––––Ÿ–[›:–Cœ––––Ÿ[–›

”

˜£

ž"C£œ¤!ˆ¡[j¢[ •—–˜––––[›––†–Cœ––––›––

nX%>@'p3*'E&') `A./N-QSA.*')&'EWYN>EB'7R'+?>f3‰B&C'+I)'+$`>@A.IpJ/T%-A.FDF*A¥`a

8x?N#%'+ z&'`>@A.I)W/#*B'+(P[  3*'0Ir,./-#%(*'lA?;3*'4'+ BTIrB'+(|'@}o'+>@ >E?<JY'M8$'E1'+(

14-3

VLua\"e˜b'ZY[c eˆ\yBfuakLnXg5\¤¦¦\d„Zy§ght

(48)

ˆ   ˆž l

j

–˜œ––š› –˜––š›



Ÿœ––––– Ÿ–––––

ž¤

¤

–˜–[š"Ÿdš› –˜–[š"Ÿdš›



Ÿ˜œ–––––:Ÿ–––––

!#ˆ¡d ¢[

¤

–˜œ––™–˜––™



Ÿœ––– Ÿ–––

j ˜£

ž"

d ž¤

ˆj

[ ¤

¤ –˜––™ –Cœ––™

 šC––– šPœ–––

–˜––™–Cœ––™



šC––– šPœ–––

j

˜£œ !#d¡ˆ ¢[

¤!ˆ¡d¤¢

ˆj [

¤

¤  –Ÿ –Ÿ



š[–– š––

 –Ÿ  –Ÿ



š[–– š––

ž¤˜£¤!#d¡ˆ¤¢[

¤!#d¡ˆ¤¢[

ž"

–˜œ––[šš–Cœ––šš



šCœ–––– šPœ––––

–Cœ––[šš –Cœ––[šš



šCœ–––– šPœ––––

j

˜£

ž"˜£¤!ˆ¡[¤¢

¤!#d¡ˆ¤¢[

(49)

ž"

”

¤

–˜œ––[š› –˜œ––[š›

 •§–––– •§œ––––

–˜––[š›–Cœ––[š›



•§–––– •§œ––––

!#d¡ˆ ¢[

ž"

”

¤

–˜––[š›–Cœ––[š›



•§–––– •§œ––––

–˜œ––[š› –˜œ––[š›



•§–––– •§œ––––



3*'q8?N#*'+ <&'23%?N-;MA?;`143%|&C'2>@A.I)W/#*B'+(cuv JY'+>E?#% 'NW%&Ax8$(%'+

3*'d>f3/?*,?'d &'+ BWLA.% B'‰WL'E&2#%/-q>f3%?%,?'d 3*'d;=?>@BA?&5N-'E8O'+N D4143%'E&'+? q3*'

JYAjA?sW/&A98X(*'+ <3*'d>G3%?*,?'d &C'+ BWYA./ B'HWY'E&St16Aah#%%-y>G3%?*,?'d 3*'‰;=?>@BA?&

N-'E8.'+N [  ApA?J%?^KW/N-A?zA?;3*'MIr'+?<&C'+ BWYA./ B'03*'M8x&CA.#% z;=?>@BA?&N-'E8.'+N +Dj#% B'

"=¤"!

[

V zIeˆuZwb0a\yƒji 'FfW\y{z |~zuyZYjil\€‚zlWlƒd„"\…€†\('Iv ‡ˆyƒ ‰\Ln

aY[ZY†qXWlYZ\Ln Yƒ ' q glYƒ('d¦¦\d„ZydeˆuZ§ght

(50)

0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07

Main Effects Plot

Factors

mean of resp

high

low

high low

high

low

postage price env_size

€~-,.#*&' $[†

‡2'+? 4'+ BWLA.% B'Qy€%?>@BA?&

(51)

  

\t A.#%&rA?W/%A.FD 3% |>f3%W/B'E&| )143%'E&'q16'SJY'E,.T BA{ B'E'23*'SB&C#*'qJL'+?#*tQ A?;

'@V$WL'E&CI)'+$?Ni(*'+ -,.F[  3%'pJ/TN-tQ<BAq>G3*AOA. B'7143/>f32'@}L'+>@= 01'p14 C32BAq>@A.Xa

;A.#%/(^T 68.'E&Q<#/ B'E;e#/NY103*'+y16'k>E?%*A?&C#%q?NTNo3*'RB&'+I)'+$ l#%/(*'E&63*'k ?I)'

>@A.%(%--A./ E[6A.I)W/#*%,pA?;w¥`aŽ8?N#*'+ l&C'm 3*Ax14y2n$'+>@-A.†

[:$[

 3*' !%&C Bp 16A! B'+>@-A.% pA?;l3%T K>G3%W%B'E&)&'^A. >f3*AjA. *,!143%T>f3‰'@}o'+>@ )BA

>@A.*; A.#/%(?%(!/%(%T*,yA.#*K103%>G3H'@}L'+>@ )&'^>@A.*;eA.#%%(*'+(J$QHA.#*&p B'E]ah#*WP[

 A

(*A73% ED*- *'+>@'+ C &Q^BA|% B?NTNY?S?(/(XaŽA.yW/?>fsx,?'k;eA?&.k[  3% 6 (*'+ >@&f-JY'+(

*'@V$E[ l'+I)'+IpJL'E&M3/k% B?NNT-A.2*'E'+(/ 0BAqJL')>E&&C-'+(!A.#*R? `3*'7&AjA?k#% B'E&

#%%(*'E&0\ '+$8$&A.%I)'+$ ?%(S? l3%'kŠ0(%I|% BB&fBA?&6#/%(*'E&6bTU[

&2$5& 3 p-0?"!†;Q)$# ;&%p)$'3'),6

 3*' &'+"$#%-&C'+(kW/?>fsx,?'6 i>E?NN-'+(

ž¤!  [¤¤!

[  3*'%!%&C BiA?;*3*'6:4 BB'EW/ iJY'+NA91

RBA5(%A914/N-A.?(‰?%(T% B?NN~3*'|W/?>Cs,?'+ E[  3*'< B'+>@A.%(T kBA5B?>G3{3*'|*'E1

N-J%&C&CQ|;eA?&03%T 4 B'+ C-A.F[l? N-Q?DY16'm>E?!&'+?(53*'KA.%N*'k(%Aj>E#%I)'+$-A.514-3

3*'R“C‚+”pA?WL'E&CBA?&+[

V…ƒ 'IyZY"ee˜bz§Yd„)(IY”i4\ywfgh„u 'd¦˜b0a\yƒ i '˜ght

V†edƒdc WlY W‹Ff5„u('d¦b a[\yƒji'It

V+*”„u 'ˆ¦b a[\yƒji '

nXI)WYN-'>@A.*;A.#/%(%*,RA$>E>E#*&C 143*'+|A.%N-Q7A.*'4'@}o'+>@ >@A.*;eA.#%%(%'+(FDjIrW/N-QX*,

3%F3*' B&'+Ir'+j 3%ˆ8O'UJL'E'+m W/N-o$BA Œ J/N-Aj>fsX E[  3%'U;=#%%>@A.

ž ¤!  ¤"!

14NNP(%'+ >@&C-JL'p3%A91 3*'7B&'+I)'+$ ` 3*A.#/N(2JL') BW/N4?>E>@A?&C(%%,<BAq3*') BWL'+>E"!%'+(

>@A.*; A.#/%(*'+( '@}o'+>@E[ nX#*W/WYA. B'q16'S3%98.'q ŒZ ;=?>@BA?&C?Nl'@V$WL'E&CI)'+$ED143%>G3 1'

*'E'+( BA!&f#%{T Œ J/N-A$>CsX E[‰ŠM #%I)'y?N BA!3%716'^(%A!*A?)IrT%(dJL'+*,H#%%J/N'

BA2'+ BI|B'<3*'<'@}L'+>@pA?;;=?>@BA?&-,)[q\tA?3*'E&p1A?&f(% ED3%'|'@}o'+>@pA?;&, 14NTN~JY'

>@A.*; A.#/%(*'+(F[

(52)

ZjW\Y[Z \ ' Zwb&'IY \y—qs„§fgCg"ng g¤nsgghtt

• –––^–

š – •—–^–

™ –– •X–

Ÿ – ••X–

› •—––*•

••—–*•

  •—– •^•

•••^•

B'+NTN m#% K3%7B&'+I)'+$ ^†<?%() 3*A.#%NT(dJL'<&C#/J/N-Aj>fs ?%(

3*'y&'+ p{J/N-A$>Csc†[



3*' !/&C B7*W/#*mBA!3%'<;=#%%>@-A. p!8.'+>@BA?&r BWL'+>E-;QX*,

3*'|'@}L'+>@k16')14T 3HBA2>@A.*;eA.#%%(FDiH3% R>E? B' ,7[14NN~(*'+(%#/>@')3*'rX#%IpJY'E&

A?;`;=?>@BA?&C r;e&A.I 3*'E&C'?[ \tnX'+>@-A.•† [Œ JL'+N-Ax1kDz103*'+ 16'S>E&&Q A.#*|I7#%N--WYN-'

>@A.*;eA.#%%(/*,*D/3/ !%&C B0'+jB&CQS14NNPJY')yIrB&CƒVo[



3*'p B'+>@A.%(‰&,.#%Ir'+jM M3*'

X#%IpJL'E&lA?; N-'E8.'+N lA?;'+?>f3!;=?>@BA?&+[  3%&C(q 4^%?I)'K;A?&M3*'KJ/N-Aj>fsX E[l? B0A?; ?NN

>@A.I)'+ 43*'m%?Ir'+ A?;i3%'R;e?>@BA?&C +[

\t;1'714T 3!BA2>E&&Q!A.#*RW/&T?N>@A.*; A.#/%(%*,*Do16'rI)'E&'+NQ53%98.'7BA2 BWL'+>E-;eQ

3*'`(%ƒ}o'E&'+$'@}o'+>@ 16'014 3|BAp>@A.*;eA.#%%(<?%(r&f#%r3*'0;e#/%>@-A.| 'E8.'E&C?N%TI)'+ E[

& 2$ %p-œGI3p-0? !;Q)$# ;%p)$'3'),6

‡5#%N--WYN-'>@A.*; A.#/%(%*,R z>E&&C-'+()A.#%z143*'+r3*'4X#%IpJY'E&A?;oJ/NAj>fs$ I)A?&'43%?

Œ

[~\]) #%>G3p C-#%-A.% ~- T U>@&f#%>E?N$BAksX*A91 3*Ax1cIr?$Qm'@}o'+>@ zI7#% iJL'l BWL'+>E"!%'+(

?%(|3*A91cI|?jQK14NNjJL'4>@A.*;eA.#%%(*'+(77BA??N[\]Ir,.%'6%A91 16'14 C3KBAm&C#%) Œ

;=?>@BA?&C?N'@V$WL'E&CI)'+$ly‹<J/N-A$>CsX A?; B&'+Ir'+j0>@A.IKJY%-A.% 6'+?>G3F[\tSBA??N

:<'@}o'+>@ R14NNPJY')>@A.*;eA.#%%(*'+(PDL?%(!16'7? `3*'p(%'+ -,.*'E&C 0A.%N-Q53%ˆ8O'm3*')N-'E'E19Q

BAH BWL'+>E-;Q ΠA?;3%'+ B'|3*&C'E'?[5nX#*W%WLA. B'r16'rW/T>Cs!3*'|'@}o'+>@

?/(-,"! BA

3*&CA91•91ˆQ?[

V$# ]_`WIc"ƒ('laPfh„§fln%ln& n%In&tLn „§fIn4nln4n&tt

Vs„u 'ˆ¦b a[\yƒji '.f#Ln,zOq$n`cjeˆud„)(.b&'IYL\Xq g{c e (g"n

ZjW\Y[Z \ ' Zwb&'IY \y—qs„§fgCg"ng g¤nsgg"n^g('g"n…gg5tt

)

Œ

• ––––––…–

š –– •••—–…–

™ –– ••—– • –

Ÿ –––– •• –

› ––––––‘•

(53)

  –– •• – ••

––––‘•••

–l••• –––

•”– –l•—––‘•—––

•• –l•—––…– •—–

•jš –l•••…••—–

•”™ –l••• –– •

• Ÿ –l•—––‘•—– •

•j› –l•—––…– ••

• –l•••…•••

•”  •”– •—–…–––

• •”–– •…•—––

• •”–– • – •—–

š– •”– •—–‘••—–

š• •”– •—–…–– •

šš •”–– •…•—– •

š™ •”–– • – ••

š"Ÿ •”– •—–‘•••

š› ••—– • –––

š •••—–‘•—––

š  •••—–…– •—–

š ••—– •…••—–

š ••—– • –– •

™– •••—–‘•—– •

™l• •••—–…– ••

™š ••—– •…•••

 3*' !%&C BMN*'p 0BAy WY'+>E-;eQS3*'pt1A^'@}o'+>@ R23%'p;eA?&CI A?;zyIrB&C-VL[  3*'

*'@V$>@A.IrIr?%(<14NNXA.#%BW/#* 3*'M(*'+ -&C'+()J/N-A$>CsX E[~b3%'+r16'lA.%N-Q)*'E'+(<BAKNT Bz?NN

3*'p>@A.%;A.#%/(*'+(!'@}L'+>@ EDF16'7>E?‰>E?NNUA.

ž ¤!  5

?%(!W/? M3*'7'@}L'+>@ k1'

3%ˆ8O'0>G3*A. B'+^? z3*'`&,.#%Ir'+jE[~\]|3%'MJLA98O'4'@V*?I)W/N-'?D$16'4W/? ?%( -,"!

? lrIrB&C-V^?%(q3%'R;e#%/>@-A.y14NNLN 6?NTNo3*'K:7>@A.*;eA.#%%(*'+(y'@}o'+>@ E[

Vs„"u('d¦b'y\[ZHf#LnpzOq[t

•

š

™

Ÿ

›

• • • – – –

š – • • • –

™ • – • • –

&2$ ( ),+.- /21I3'),6 ^-0; E M ?P1I306),1 9 3œG



3*')B'@VXBJYAjA?sduzv (*Aj'+ k*A?m(*'+IrA.% BB&CB'|?$Q5'@VX?I)WYN-')A.d3*'rJLAx8.'?Di BA21'

3%ˆ8O'MBA<Irs.'k(*A)143q)W/#*&'+NQrWY'+(/?jT>M(/? B'EE[ \t4>E?qJL'k;A.#/%(yy3*' !/N-'

(54)

t16A^JYN-Aj>fs$ `10-323%'r>@A.*;A.#/%(*'+(!'@}L'+>@mJY'+%, -,7[  Aq&C#%!3*'rIrAj(*'+NY_#% B

&'+Ir'+IKJL'E&43/0143%'+q16'K BW/NT-3*'mB&C'+I)'+$ 0$BArJYN-Aj>fs$ +D%16'K3%98.'m? C#%I)'+(

3%`3*'E&C'7T M%AyTjB'E&f?>@-A.2JL'Et1'E'+H3%'KJ/NAj>fs2;=?>@BA?&k?%(!3*'7A?3*'E&R;e?>@BA?&f

A?;$B'E&'+ BE[  3X#% 6143*'+2 BWY'+>E;QX*,73*'k;eA?&CI7#%NXD*3%'kJ/N-A$>Csy W/#%&'+N-Q<?(/(%--8.'?[

Mˆ8X*,K&'EW/NT>EB'+ 14NTN*?NN-Ax1#% zBAK'+ BTIrB'03%'4'E&&A?&ˆ[Ub -3*A.#%-EDX?NN/(%'E,?&'E'+

A?;~;e&'E'+(*A.I 14TNN/JL'm#% '+(q#*WqA.q3*'k'@}o'+>@ E[

V†eˆƒ[c”WlYjW‹=fh„u 'ˆ¦˜b0a[\yƒ”i 'It

Va[YZ^]_`Wl\YaBb5ZY[c ed\Bfg5\ji §g¤noI\Ya\ W^q r"t

Vua ]_:YuvwfxWl\yhz}| cjeˆud„)( *€& *€ n aY[ZY:q^aY[Zt

V…yŠYjW‹=fua t

Œ[ Žj Ž"’ “ ! Ž’  

ˆž •…•§– ™ ^•§– ™ s• Ÿ[ ™™ •œ––––

•X›Cœ›š ™:›C ›š ™†›Pœ–™ ™š •œ––––

• –˜––Ÿ[– –X–˜œ––Ÿ[–– ›Cœ ™4•jšs•§œ›–™–[›

• –˜–––l•”ŸŸ[–X–˜œ–––l•”ŸŸ– •§™4• š• –C š [›l•

£

•—Ÿœ›l•™ Ÿ ›•™XŸ˜{•• ›™š •œ––––

£

•…•§h•j ™[›…•§{•” ™›^•œ– [š™l• •œ––––

£ • –˜–––– l•j–X–˜œ–––– 4•”– –˜ ™ – –CŸ4• ›™

ˆ¤  …–˜–––   –X–˜œ–––l•j– 

Ž

"!I



@žH£ – @–Cœ––l• –Cœ–l•@–˜œ–›dN–˜h• •

0A> !"#%$'&)(#*+'(#,-*$/.+!0*(1*(

-,2&"'"'&43*(#,-*56(67#87:9

(55)

w

*& *, # !$/7 *$ '(08!$/(6'( & %8( 7#*(6 '( 6 8!$ ''%$ 36"!6 %$/&%9

)%$# * #$/*5$+% *'& .!(08& ,-$*.*)+-,6"*(#)*(1!,- %$.,#*5#$/& $/'(6'(

(67 # .+""/8(#+& 567$0921"# ,*$. %$ 6& $/3!(''3%! 8& '( '&7#8&4(65 . 8(6'($

6! &4"(0 * 3*.7! 5# ¥8,:9!;'5#8&4,-*$)'(#,-%$8(639

&K&K$5& ( #{G4?PJl<=< ;%,J 1s7NJ +.3')p35),6?>A@ + p-'?

1"#+76! ,*$ '& '&#.7!(0+'& '( #CBEDSEFHG('9JI ( # 76!K5 ML '(676'3%! 8&

A0*N039O"(67P 4:91"# 7#8&4( '&JQ"RTSVU 6;0,W,$3!(''3%! 768&4(:91"#

3*(#, *5 (67#87 'X 83)3*. 8&",-$*. 6 $O'!0*(ZY7[-\^] , 9

V^Z”WlYƒ`_ ]_`Wl\YaPb'ZYdcjeˆ\wfgh\”i §bbag"npoI\Ya[\jW^q rt

V…yŠOc=cY W‹Ff0Yu[vHf W\y{z | ‘€ *€In a[Y[ZY†q^ZjWYƒb_Itt

Œ[^Ž ‘Ž"’†“

ed !

Ž"’ f

d 

hg

ji

• š Ÿ š Ÿ •”Ÿ˜œ –Cœ––4•j–™ 

• š"Ÿ š"Ÿ •§ š–C š ™™

• –˜œ™–C › ŸŸ

¤  d š– Ÿ[–– š–

Ž ¤¤!I  ž;k[ˆw£ – –˜––4• –˜–4•N–Cœ–[› d@–˜{• •

)*3 !l 76$*;! & # m *n `0+'( %$/30*( %$/.+&89o #%$)& "# "(0

!6$*7 56387 '&4'7#8( '3%; *J1"(0P;P!9pQKP '(Z)q+ 9

&K&K$ +F6K+srP35),? ( '%G %$',/t>A@ + p-0?

1"# 76! ,*$ '& & % '& 3*((#87 '(uB:D"Swv9x1"6 '&K! %$/'. 8( & ,-$*.

Q"yTS(z{5 !$ %$.,$3!('3%! 7#8&4( 9|1"# 3*(#, *5 (67#87 'X 83& !$/ 7#3G (687}e0 #

(56)

V…Yay[ZŠas]_`W\YaPb5ZYdcjeˆ\Bf"gh\”i b§g"no4\Ya[\ W^qsrt

V…yŠ3cecYjW‹=f'Yuvwf^| ‘€& *€…€&' € *€ Bn aY[ZY:qsYa[yZŠatt

Œ[^Ž " Ž’†“

Kd !

Ž’

• •”Ÿ •”Ÿ

• [šŸ [šŸ

• Ÿ Ÿ

Œ • Ÿ–4•”–– Ÿ–4•j––

• –˜–[š› –˜œ–[š›

•…•––l• •––l•

£ • • •

£ •

£ • • •

£ • –˜–[š› –˜œ–[š›

£ • •”Ÿ •”Ÿ

£ • –˜–[š› –˜œ–[š›

Œ £ • • •

£ £ • • •

£ £ • ™ ™

1)#%$ !$/ (#* ¥8,:9!;'5#8& &)6 3%(6(#*^ 8& .+! 87:9#)q98( 6*5$

# 8( $/08& '( 6 "(' & %8. * 76X %$8( ",-$*. 1"(' P;P!9pQJ498( '(C)q+n5

#30+!$/)356;40 # &. 9 I '&56& !&.! 83%G68& 764X %$8( ;'& 87 'X 83&

,-$*. 9

Références

Documents relatifs

It is the average, for all speakers in the training set, of the standard deviation of the feature, across all classes (all vowels), for a given speaker.. Let be the

However, SGS-THOMSON Microelectronics assumes no responsability for the consequences of use of such information nor for any infringement of patents or other rights of third

MCP482X devices are 2.7V–5.5V, low-power, low DNL, 12-bit Digital-to-Analog Converters (DACs) with internal band gap voltage reference, optional 2x-buffered output and Serial

avait formulé des recommanda- tions dans son mémoire : la mise en place d’un service Info médicaments (idée originale de l’Association), l’ins- cription de médicaments à la

El programa inició con la preparación de condiciones en el municipio de Yalagüina, para continuar con la convocatoria e inscripción de jóvenes, luego de ello comenzó el proceso

On sait [3] que le noyau et le conoyau d'une flèche quelconque peuvent être définis (sans que leur existence soit assurée) dans une catégorie où il existe un système de

Thus, after a description of a real data set composed of 78 individual space-speed profiles, we begin our analysis by a functional modeling of space-speed profiles with a definition

[r]