Phenoscape: Use Cases and Anatomy Ontology Requirements for Linking Evolutionary and Model Organism Phenotypes

(1)

**!"#$%&'()#*+**

,&#+-(&#&+($.+/$(0%12+3$0%4%52+6#789:#1#$0&+;%:+

<9$=9$5+>?%4809%$(:2+($.+@%.#4+3:5($9&1+!"#$%02)#&+

!"#$%"&'"()*%^+,-,&."/0#&1"%(233^-,4,&5$%/"6&7"88^-,&90:06&;$)326)^-,&

<2))&=$#$2>^-,4,&;2>:0&!0#:063$0%)^?,&9"*%"&;"@00^+&

+A>$B06#$:C&23&D2*:(&'"E2:",&=06/$%%$2>,&D',&ADFG&^-H":$2>"%&IB2%*:$2>"6C&DC>:(0#$#&J0>:06,&'*6("/,&ADFG&

4A>$B06#$:C&23&H26:(&J"62%$>",&J("80%&5$%%,&ADFG&^?A>$B06#$:C&23&K60L2>,&I*L0>0,&ADF&

<(0&>":*6"%%C&2MM*66$>L&8(0>2:C80#&)2M*/0>:0)&

326& L62*8#& 23& #80M$0#& $>& :(0& #C#:0/":$M#&

%$:06":*60& "60& 60M26)0)& $>& 3600& :0N:& O($M(,&

"%:(2*L(&*#03*%%C&860M$#0&">)&0N860##$B0,&$#&>2:&

"/0>"@%0& :2& M2/8*:":$2>"%& 862M0##$>LP& <($#&

860B0>:#& $:#& *#0& 326& %"6L0Q#M"%0& ">"%C#$#& 26&

$>:0L6":$2>&O$:(&:(0&L0>0:$M#&E>2O%0)L0&:(":&$#&

"B"$%"@%0& 326& #$>L%0& #80M$0#& $>& /2)0%& 26L">$#/&

)":"@"#0#& R+,-SP& A#$>L& 2>:2%2L$0#,& 9(0>2#M"80&

)0B0%280)& "& E>2O%0)L0@"#0& T9(0>2#M"80U1G&

E@P8(0>2#M"80P26LV& :(":& M2>>0M:#& 8(0>2:C80#&

326& 3$#(& #80M$0#& O$:(& L0>0:$M"%%C& M("6"M:06$W0)&

8(0>2:C80#&326&:(0&W0@6"3$#(,&!"#$%&'('$%,&362/&

:(0&XYZH&)":"@"#0&TW3$>P26LVP&<(62*L(&2>:2%2LCQ&

@"#0)& 60"#2>$>L& 2B06& 0N806:& E>2O%0)L0& $>&

:"N2>2/C,& M2/8"6":$B0& ">":2/C& ">)&

)0B0%28/0>:"%& L0>0:$M#,& :(0& 9(0>2#M"80U1& $#&

)0#$L>0)& :2& 0>"@%0& :(0& )$#M2B06C& 23& M">)$)":0&

L0>0#& 326& :(0& >":*6"%& )$B06#$:C& 23& 8(0>2:C80#&

"M62##&:"N",&">)&:(0&"LL60L":$2>&23&8(0>2:C80#&

"M62##& #C#:0/":$M#& #:*)$0#& :2& 0>"@%0& "& L%2@"%&

B$0O& 23& 8(0>2:C80& )":"& "B"$%"@%0& $>& %"6L0&

M%")0#P& <(0#0& *#0& M"#0#& >0M0##$:":0)& :(0&

)0B0%28/0>:& 23& :O2& /*%:$#80M$0#& ">":2/C&

2>:2%2L$0#[&2>0&326&3$#(0#&T\4],]]]&#80M$0#V&">)&

60M0>:%C& 2>0& 326& "%%& B06:0@6":0#& T\^],]]]&

#80M$0#V,& O($M(& O$%%& 3"M$%$:":0& :(0& 0N8">#$2>& 23&

9(0>2#M"80&:2&"%%&B06:0@6":0#&@C&M2>>0M:$>L&:2&

2:(06& 0N$#:$>L& B06:0@6":0& 2>:2%2L$0#& ">)&

)":"@"#0#& T"/8($@$">,& /2*#0,& 362LVP& <(0#0&

2>:2%2L$0#& "60& 60_*$60)& :2& 3*%%C& 60860#0>:& :(0&

)$B06#$:C&23&#:6*M:*60#&860#0>:&$>&:(0#0&0N:$>M:&

">)& 0N:">:& #80M$0#P& Z:& "%#2& 60_*$60)& @6$)L$>L&

"M62##&/*%:$8%0&#M"%0#&23&@$2%2L$M"%&26L">$W":$2>,&

362/& M0%%#& :2& ">":2/$M"%& #C#:0/#P& !0& )$#M*##&

:(0&$/8%$M":$2>#&:(":&:(0#0&60_*$60/0>:#&("B0&

326&2>:2%2LC&)0#$L>P&

!0& )0B0%280)& :(0& /*%:$#80M$0#& <0%02#:&

F>":2/C& K>:2%2LC& T<FKV& R4S,& O$:(& 300)@"ME&

362/&:(0&$M(:(C2%2L$M"%&M2//*>$:C,&:2&60860#0>:&

:(0&)$B06#$:C&23&#:6*M:*60#&$>&:0%02#:&3$#(0#&">)&

326& :(0& 8(0>2:C80& M*6":$2>& 23& :(0& 3$#(&

#C#:0/":$M#& %$:06":*60& R?SP& <FK& O"#& )06$B0)&

362/,& ">)& $#& E08:& #C>M(62>$W0)& O$:(,& :(0&

#80M$0#&#80M$3$M&X0@6"3$#(&F>":2/$M"%&K>:2%2LC&

TXYFV,&O($M(&$#&*#0)&:2&)0#M6$@0&8(0>2:C80#&326&

:(0& /2)0%& 26L">$#/&!"#$%& '('$%& $>& XYZHP& Z>&

0N8">)$>L&"&#$>L%0&#80M$0#&2>:2%2LC&:2&2>0&:(":&

$#& "88%$M"@%0& :2& /">C& #80M$0#,& 0N$#:$>L& :06/&

)03$>$:$2>#& O060& @62")0>0)& :2& @0& *>$B06#"%%C&

"88%$M"@%0& :2& "%%& :0%02#:#P& H0O& :06/#& O060&

"))0)&326&#:6*M:*60#&860#0>:&$>&:0%02#:#&@*:&>2:&

$>& W0@6"3$#(,& ">)& :($#& 60_*$60)& :(0& "))$:$2>& 23&

L62*8$>L& :06/#& :2& <FK,& O($M(& 3"M$%$:":0&

_*06$0#& 2>& #$/$%"6& #:6*M:*60#& 326& "%%& 3$#(0#P&

D2/0&23&:(0#0&L62*8$>L&:06/#&O060&*>>0M0##"6C&

IRU=)$HJ¶WRRWK·DVDJURXSLQJWHUPZDVQRW 60_*$60)& $>& XYF& @0M"*#0& W0@6"3$#(& 2>%C& ("B0&

2>0& :C80& 23& :22:(,& 60860#0>:0)& @C& :(0& :06/&

¶FHUDWREUDQFKLDO WRRWK· 6RPH UHODWLRQVKLSV

@0:O00>& :06/#& $>(06$:0)& 362/& XYF& O060&

60/2B0)& 362/& <FK& @0M"*#0& :(0C& O060& >2:&

"88%$M"@%0& :2& "%%& :0%02#:#& T0PLP,& :(0& "##06:$2>&

¶YHUWHEUD·LVBD¶:HEHULDQYHUWHEUD·LVYDOLGIRU&

XYF& @*:& >2:& 326& <FK& @0M"*#0& >2:& "%%& :0%02#:&

B06:0@6"&+&"60&#*@:C80#&23&!0@06$">&B06:0@6"VP&

<(0#0& :"N2>2/$M"%%C& B"6$"@%0& 60%":$2>#($8#&

("B0& $/8%$M":$2>#& 326& )06$B$>L& "& #$>L%0& #80M$0#&

2>:2%2LC&362/&"&/*%:$#80M$0#&2>:2%2LC,&">)&B$M0&

B06#",& @0M"*#0& 60%":$2>#($8#& :(":& /$L(:& @0&

60_*$60)&326&"&#$>L%0&#80M$0#&/"C&@0&$>B"%$)&$>&"&

/*%:$#80M$0#& M2>:0N:P& !0& "60& 0N8%26$>L& (2O& :2&

60860#0>:& :(0#0& 60%":$2>#($8#,& 82##$@%C& "#&

">>2:":$2>#& O$:(& $#)*"+%#& 60%":$2>#($8#& :2&

:06/#&362/&"&:"N2>2/C&2>:2%2LCP&

<2&$>$:$":0&:(0&0N8">#$2>&23&9(0>2#M"80&:2&

"%%& B06:0@6":0#,& O0& $>B$:0)& 0N806:#& :2& "&

O26E#(28& :2& 600B"%*":0& ">)& 60)03$>0& 0N$#:$>L&

#E0%0:"%& :06/#& TM0%%#,& :$##*0#,& )0B0%28/0>:,&

">":2/$M"%& #:6*M:*60#V& 326& :(0$6& "88%$M"@$%$:C&

"M62##& B06:0@6":0#,& ">)& :2& M60":0& :06/#& 326&

M2>M08:#& >2:& C0:& 60860#0>:0)& $>& 0N$#:$>L&

,&%2,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ%LRPHGLFDO2QWRORJLHVā%XIIDOR1<86$

)DFLOLWDWLQJ$QDWRP\2QWRORJ\,QWHURSHUDELOLW\:RUNVKRS-XO\

(2)

!"#!$!%&'()* +,&(* -!./* .'(0$#'1* &"* #,'*

2'.#'3.4#'* 5"4#!67* 8"#!$!%7* 9258:;* -,&<,*

-&$$*('.='*4(*4*.'>'.'"<'*!"#!$!%7*>!.*"'-*4"1*

'?&(#&"%*='.#'3.4#'*(03!"#!$!%&'()*258*4<<!6@

6!14#'(* #,'* =4.&!0(* -47(* #,4#* 3&!$!%&(#(*

<$4((&>7* 3!"'(* 4"1* <4.#&$4%'(;* ')%);* 4(* 1&(#&"<#*

'$'6'"#(* 4"1* #&((0'* #7A'(* 4"1* 34('1* !"*

1'='$!A6'"#4$*4"1*$!<4#&!"4$*<.&#'.&4)**+'?#04$*

1'>&"&#&!"(* 4.'* &"<$01'1* >!.* 4$$* #'.6(;* 4"1* 4"*

'>>!.#*&(*<0..'"#$7*0"1'.-47*#!*#.4"($4#'*#,'('*

#'?#* 1'>&"&#&!"(* &"#!* <!6A0#43$'* $!%&<4$*

1'>&"&#&!"()*B!%&<4$*1'>&"&#&!"(*4((&(#*&"*!"#!$!%7*

64&"#'"4"<'* 4"1* '..!.* <,'</&"%* 3'<40('* 4*

.'4(!"'.* &(* 0('1* #!* 40#!64#&<4$$7* <$4((&>7*

#'.6()*B!%&<4$$7*1'>&"'1*#'.6(*#4/'*#,'*>!.6*!>*

%'"0(@GLIIHUHQWLDGHILQLWLRQVLQZKLFK´;LVD*

WKDW'µZKHUH;LVWKHW'.6*3'&"%*1'>&"'1;*C*&(*

#,'* %'"0(;* 4"1* D* &(* #,'* 1&>>'.'"#&4)* E"* #,'*

H[DPSOH EHORZ ¶UHSODFHPHQW HOHPHQW· ; LV D

#7A'*!>*(/'$'#4$*'$'6'"#*9C:*#,4#*A4.#&<&A4#'(*&"*

¶UHSODFHPHQW RVVLILFDWLRQ· ' WKLV WHUP ZLOO EH .'F0'(#'1* >.!6* #,'* C'"'* 8"#!$!%7* 4"1*

&6A!.#'1*&"#!*258:G*

!"#$%&'

()*'+,-*..../01'

23%#*'$#4536#%#27'#5#%#27'

' )#8*'9:;#5#735'#5#%#27'7<37'8=$%>'' '' 3>'3'$#4536#%#27'=$'>?@>7(7?7(=2'

=8'32=7<#$'#5#%#27'=$'7(>>?#A9'

!+,-*6?$37=$&' (27#$>#67(=2B=8*''

+,-*..../CD'E'>;#5#735'#5#%#27' (27#$>#67(=2B=8*'43$7(6(437#>B(2''

+,-*..../F.'E'$#4536#%#27'

=>>(8(637(=2'

H7"#,'(&(* 4"1* 1&(<!='.7* &"* <!63&"'1*

%'"'#&<;* 1'='$!A6'"#4$* 4"1* '=!$0#&!"4.7* 14#4*

.'F0&.'(* 4"4#!67* #'.6(* #!* 3'* .'$4#'1* 4<.!((*

(<4$'(* !>* 3&!$!%&<4$* !.%4"&I4#&!")* +,'* 258*

'"43$'(* #,&(* 1&(<!='.7* 37* .'$4#&"%* #&((0'(* #!*

<'$$(* 9')%);* ¶!(#'!<7#'·* A4.#J!>* ¶<'$$0$4.* 3!"'*

WLVVXH· DQG VWUXFWXUHV WR SURFHVVHV HJ

¶.'A$4<'6'"#* '$'6'"#·* A4.#&<&A4#'(J&"*¶.'A$4<'@

6'"#* !((&>&<4#&!"·:)* K0##&"%* &"* A$4<'* #,'('*

.'$4#&!"(,&A(* #!* 3&!$!%&<4$* 14#4* 4#* 1&>>'.'"#*

(<4$'(* -&$$* (&%"&>&<4"#$7* &"<.'4('* #,'* A!#'"#&4$*

>!.*1&(<!='.7*!>*<4"1&14#'*%'"'(*4"1*#4?4*>.!6*

F0'.&'(*!"*4"4#!6&<4$*(#.0<#0.')**

!"#"$"%&"'(

L) M43'';* K)* M);* C)* 5..4#&4;* M)* N!30.";* M)*

O4'"1'$;* P)* Q)* O&$#!";* Q)* C)* B0"13'.%;* R)* B)*

M471'";* S)* R&!(;* 4"1* M)* T'(#'.>&'$1)* UVVW)*

N!""'<#&"%* '=!$0#&!"4.7* 6!.A,!$!%7* #!*

%'"!6&<(* 0(&"%* !"#!$!%&'(G* 5* <4('* (#017* >.!6*

N7A.&"&>!.6'(* &"<$01&"%* I'3.4>&(,)* Q!0."4$* !>*

P?A'.&6'"#4$* X!!$!%7* K4.#* Y@M!$'<0$4.* 4"1*

D'='$!A6'"#4$*P=!$0#&!"*ZV[YG\]]@\\[)*

U) M43'';*K);*M)*5(,30."'.;*^)*N.!"/;*C)*C/!0#!(;*

M)* O4'"1'$;* P)* H'%'.1'$$;* N)* M0"%4$$;* 4"1* M)*

T'(#'.>&'$1)* UVVW)* K,'"!#7A'* !"#!$!%&'(G* #,'*

3.&1%'*3'#-''"*%'"!6&<(*4"1*'=!$0#&!")*+.'"1(*

&"*P<!$!%7*_*P=!$0#&!"*UUGZ`]@Z]V)*

Z) D4,10$;*T)*M);*Q)*C)*B0"13'.%;*K)*P)*M&1>!.1;*Q)*

K)*Y4$,!>>;*O)*B4AA;*+)*Q)*2&(&!";*M)*5)*O4'"1'$;*

M)* T'(#'.>&'$1;* 4"1* K)* M)* M43'')* UVLV)* +,'*

+'$'!(#* 5"4#!67* 8"#!$!%7G* 4"4#!6&<4$*

.'A.'('"#4#&!"*>!.*#,'*%'"!6&<(*4%')*H7(#'64#&<*

Y&!$!%7*]aGZ\a@Z[Z)*

`) D4,10$;* T)* M);* Q)* K)* Y4$,!>>;* Q)* P"%'64";* +)*

C.4"1';*P)*Q)*O&$#!";*N)*b!#,4.&;*O)*B4AA;*Q)*C)*

B0"13'.%;* K)* P)* M&1>!.1;* +)* Q)* 2&(&!";* M)*

T'(#'.>&'$1;* 4"1* K)* M)* M43'')* UVLV)*

P=!$0#&!"4.7* <,4.4<#'.(;* A,'"!#7A'(* 4"1*

!"#!$!%&'(G* <0.4#&"%* 14#4* >.!6* #,'* (7(#'64#&<*

3&!$!%7*$&#'.4#0.')*KB!H*8SP*]G'LVWV[)*

*