Distance Learning in Higher Education in France during the COVID-19 Pandemic Chapter 4

Texte intégral

(1)Distance Learning in Higher Education in France during the COVID-19 Pandemic Chapter 4 Sebastien Jacques, Abdeldjalil Ouahabi. To cite this version: Sebastien Jacques, Abdeldjalil Ouahabi. Distance Learning in Higher Education in France during the COVID-19 Pandemic Chapter 4. Nina Tomaževič, Dejan Ravšelj and Aleksander Aristovnik. Higher Education Policies for Developing Digital Skills to Respond to the Covid-19 Crisis: European and Global Perspectives, European Liberal Forum asbl, pp.45-58, 2021, 978-2-39067-005-6 9782390670056. �hal-03214612�. HAL Id: hal-03214612 https://hal-univ-tours.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-03214612 Submitted on 3 May 2021. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9.

(4)

(5)

(6) f Ì#!9ࣅ'2!$7<'9S#&'¡&/!¡-¡<!,!#-. W 2;83&<$ধ32 DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . -2$' ;,' 9;!8; 3( T ;,' T¤T 9;<&'2;9 '283££'& -2 8'2$, <2-='89-ধ'9T £-0' !££ 9;<&'2;9 -2 <2-='89-ধ'9!83<2&;,'>38£&T,!='9''2;,'-8'&<$!ধ32;3;!££@&-98<6;'&#@;,'<268'$'&'2;'&,'!£;, $8-9-9$!<9'&#@;,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$W-2$''$'1#'8T;,'9'='8'!$<;'8'96-8!;38@9@2&831' $3832!=-8<9lf3fm,!9!ø'$;'&2'!8£@ 8'2$,6'8932-2!2&<2(38;<2!;'£@$£!-1'&;,'£-='9 3(!6683?-1!;'£@W¦3(;,39'-2('$;'&U;,-96'8$'2;!+'-93(;,'9!1'38&'83(1!+2-;<&'(38 <836'!2 2-32l m$3<2;8-'9l <836'TmW83<2&;,'>38£&T;,'@'!8>!91!80'&#@2<1'83<9 6'8-3&9 3( $32;!-21'2; !2& 9<&&'2 $£39<8'9 3( 9$,33£9 !2& <2-='89-ধ'9 l'W+W (38 ;,' )89; $32;!-21'2; 6'8-3&T(831;,''2&3(!2<!8@-2,-2!!2&3;,'89-!2$3<2;8-'9U1-&f!8$,-2139; <836'!2T 1'8-$!2T!2&-&&£' !9;'82$3<2;8-'9U!2&;,''2&3(!8$,-2139;(8-$!2$3<2;8-'9mW !$'&>-;,;,-9 9-;<!ধ32T;'!$,'89!83<2&;,'>38£&,!=',!&;3!&!6;!2&'='28'-2='2;;,'19'£='9;3&'£-='8=-8;<!£ $3<89'9T$311<2-$!;'>-;,;,'-89;<&'2;93293$-!£2';>380-2+6£!Ĥ3819T!2&931'ধ1'9£'!8232;,'/3# ,3>;3&'£-='87<!£-;@&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32l-2'8';!£WTmW 2 ;,' (!$' 3( ;,-9 <28-=!££'& ,'!£;, $8-9-9T $3<2;8-'9 !83<2& ;,' >38£& ,!=' ,!& ;3 $31' <6 >-;, !2 '&<$!ধ32!£ $32ধ2<-;@ 6£!2 !#£' ;3 #' -16£'1'2;'& !9 7<-$0£@ !9 6399-#£' l'-$, '; !£WT mW 2 ;,' '='2;3(;,';'1638!8@8'13=!£3(9;<&'2;9389$,33£$£39<8'9T6'&!+3+-$!£$32ধ2<-;@6£!29!8'&'9-+2'& ;31!-2;!-2;,'6'&!+3+-$!£$322'$ধ32#';>''2;'!$,'89!2&6<6-£9W,'1!-23#/'$ধ='-9;368'9'8=' ;,' 023>£'&+' !£8'!&@ +!-2'& #@ ;,' 9;<&'2;9>,-£' ,'£6-2+ ;,'1 !$7<-8' 2'> 023>£'&+'W,' 9;!0'9 !8' ;,'8'(38' ,-+, !2& ;,' 2''& ;3 683=-&' 7<!£-;@ '&<$!ধ32 $32ধ2<'9T &'96-;' ;,' 1!2@ &-ă$<£ধ'9 !993$-!;'&>-;,&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32T#3;,9@2$,8323<9£@!2&!9@2$,8323<9£@W,'9'-2$£<&'T#<;!8'23; £-1-;'& ;3T -99<'9 8'£!ধ2+ ;3V 6,@9-$!£ &-9;!2$' !2& 93$-3f'13ধ32!£ 9<6638;U 9<6638; (38 9;<&'2;9>,3 !8'!;8-903(&8366-2+3<;U;,'9<$$'99(<£1!9;'8@3(-2(381!ধ32!2&$311<2-$!ধ32;'$,23£3+-'9l mU !$$'99;3!9;!#£'!2&9'$<8' 2;'82';$322'$ধ32U!2&!$$'99;3!668368-!;'$316<;'8'7<-61'2;l'W+W $316<;'89T;!#£';9T91!8;6,32'9';$WmW 38'?!16£'T32;,-9£!9;63-2;T!$$38&-2+;3;,'8+!2-A!ধ32(38 $3231-$336'8!ধ32!2&'='£361'2;l mT¦3(9;<&'2;9-2>-;A'8£!2&T38>!@!2&<9;8-! ,!='!$316<;'832>,-$,;,'@$!2&3;,'-89$,33£>380U-2$32;8!9;T/<9;¦3( 2&32'9-!29;<&'2;9,!=' !$$'99;39<$,!&'=-$'l3£TU'<'8=!-2';!£WTU<£-!TmW.

(7)

(8) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. ,!209;3;,'13#-£-A!ধ32!2&<2>!='8-2+$311-;1'2;3(;,';'!$,-2+!2&!&1-2-9;8!ধ='9;!øT<2&'8 ;,'-16';<93(9;832+63£-ধ$!£-2$'2ধ='932#3;,2!ধ32!£!2&<2-='89-;@£'='£9T;,'='$;389!2&;33£9<9'& #@ '&<$!ধ32!£ ;'!19 ,!=' 1<£ধ6£-'&W ,'9' ;33£9 ,!=' -2$£<&'&V >'#9-;'9U &-+-;!£ >38096!$'9 lmU '1!-£&-9$<99-32£-9;9U&3$<1'2;9,!8-2+!2&,31'>3801!2!+'1'2;!66£-$!ধ329U+83<68'+-9;8!ধ329(38 -2;'8!$ধ='!66£-$!ধ329U!&£';f;@6'$3££!#38!ধ='>!££9!2&3;,'81<£ধ1'&-!$8'!ধ32;33£9U=-&'39U8!&-3 63&$!9;9!2&32£-2';<;38-!£9U!2&6'&!+3+-$!£$,!££'2+'9+-='2=-!93$-!£2';>3809l'W+W !$'#330T>-ħ'8m l-9;'0f,!2&£'8TmW 3&!@T!1<£ধ;<&'3(!66£-$!ধ329T6£!Ĥ3819!2&'&<$!ধ32!£8'93<8$'9!8'#'-2+<9'&-2,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32 (38#3;,9@2$,8323<9!2&!9@2$,8323<9&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32l9'' 8!6,mW!2@$£!99-)$!ধ329-2=3£=-2+ several categories have already been proposed in the literature. 99<$,T;,'(3££3>-2+£-9;T>-;,-££<9;8!ধ=''?!16£'9T-9#@231'!29'?,!<9ধ='l

(9) '28-09'2';!£WTmV j -+-;!£ £'!82-2+ 1!2!+'1'2; 9@9;'19V 32' '?!16£' -9 ;,' +£3#!££@ 9<6638;'& 36'2 £'!82-2+ 6£!Ĥ381 l>-;,138';,!2¤6!8;2'89-2;,'9-!f!$-)$8'+-32T <836'!2&;,'2-;'&-2+&31T1'8-$!T !2& (8-$!mW <8-2+ ;,' 3=-&f 6!2&'1-$T ! >-&' 8!2+' 3( !$ধ=-ধ'9 l(831 ;,' 9-16£' 9<#1-99-32 3( &3$<1'2;9T;3(38<19T32£-2''?'8$-9'9T!2&32£-2'$,!;';$Wm,!='#''23ø'8'&;39;<&'2;9W j !99-=' 36'2 32£-2' $3<89' lm 6£!Ĥ3819T $3='8-2+ ! >-&' 96'$;8<1 3( &-9$-6£-2'9 -2$£<&-2+ '2+-2''8-2+T1'&-$-2'T'$3231-$9T!8;9!2&$<£;<8'';$W<8-2+;,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$T2'!8£@,-+,'8 '&<$!ধ32$3<89'9,!='#''23ø'8'&(8''3($,!8+';39;<&'2;9!83<2&;,'>38£&W. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. ¤. j '£(f&-8'$;'& £'!82-2+ $32;'2;V 32' '?!16£' -9 ;,' ,!2$!&'1@Z9 -2;'8!$ধ=' 6£!Ĥ381T>,-$, 9-2$' ¥,!9&'£-='8'&;,3<9!2&93(32£-2';<;38-!£9$3='8-2+1!2@9$-'2ধ)$)'£&9(38<9'#@<2&'8+8!&<!;' 9;<&'2;9W<8-2+;,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$T9;<&'2;9(831!££3='8;,'>38£&,!='#''2!#£';3#'2');(831 ;,-96£!Ĥ381W j3££!#38!ধ326£!Ĥ3819;,!;9<6638;£-='f=-&'3$311<2-$!ধ32V;,8''+33&'?!16£'9!8' 33+£''';T -$8393đ'!19T!2& 331W 2(!$;T;,'9';>3£!9;;33£9>'8'>-&'£@8'£-'&32-2;,'9;<&@68'9'2;'&-2 ;,-963£-$@6!6'8W'!193ø'89$,!;T&!ধ2+T$!££-2+!2&$3££!#38!ধ32('!;<8'9#<-£;-2;3-$8393đă$' 93đ>!8'W 331T>,-$,$!2#'<9'&!9!'!19!66£-$!ধ32T-9!$£3<&f#!9'&6£!Ĥ3813ø'8-2+=-&'3!2& !<&-3 $32('8'2$-2+T $3££!#38!ধ32T $,!; !2& >'#-2!89W -0' ;,' 83$;38-3 6£!Ĥ381T ;,' <9' 3( 331 -2 <2-='89-ধ'9,!98!-9'&1!2@$32$'829T6!8ধ$<£!8£@-2 8!2$'T!#3<;#3;,;,'$32)&'2ধ!£-;@3(;,'&!;!-; 9,!8'9!2&,3>;,';33£-9<9'&T(38-29;!2$'T(38;,'8'13;'132-;38-2+3('?!19W. Graph 1: ?!16£'93(!66£-$!ধ329T6£!Ĥ3819!2&'&<$!ধ32!£8'93<8$'9<9'&(38#3;,9@2$,8323<9 and asynchronous distance learning Collaborative platforms. LIVE OR VIRTUAL SYNCHRONOUS E-LEARNING Learning takes place face-to-face and in real time Live online webinars. Virtual classrooms. Instant messaging. Videoconferences. MOOC platforms. Learning management systems. COLLABORATIVE OR AUTONOMOUS ASYNCHRONOUS E-LEARNING Learning takes place anytime, anywhere and at one's own pace Pre-recorded Blogs lectures/tutorials/demonstrations Online forums Discussion boards. E-mails. 3<8$'ª!$7<'9';!¡US .

(10)

(11) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. ,-£';,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$,!9!$$'£'8!;'&;,'&-+-;!£;8!29(381!ধ323(,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32T;,'8'!8' 1!/38-99<'9$32$'82-2+;,'7<!£-;@3(&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32T;,'£'!82-2+683$'99-;9'£(T!2&;,''=!£<!ধ323( ;,'023>£'&+'!2&90-££9!$7<-8'&3='8!&-9;!2$'W,-963£-$@6!6'8-9-2;'2&'&;3683=-&'931'!29>'89 ;3;,'9'7<'9ধ329W,'&-9$<99-329683639'&,'8'!8''96'$-!££@#!9'&32;,'7<!£-;!ধ='!2&7<!2ধ;!ধ=' results collected in engineering schools in France. ,'9;8<$;<8'3(;,-9&3$<1'2;-9!9(3££3>9W'$ধ32£3309!;;,'&'='£361'2;3(&-+-;!£90-££9-2;,' (!$'3(;,','!£;,$8-9-9W 26!8ধ$<£!8T-2;,-99'$ধ32T>'68'9'2;;,'63£-$@-2-ধ!ধ='96<;-26£!$'T'?!1-2' ;,'6'8$'6ধ323(9@2$,8323<9&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32T-2$£<&-2+=-8;<!£$£!9983319T>-;,-2<2-='89-ধ'9!2&T )2!££@T &'9$8-#' ;,' &-+-;!£ ;33£9 $<88'2;£@ -2 <9' !2& ;,' 683#£'19 !993$-!;'&>-;, ;,' !$7<-9-ধ32 !2& '=!£<!ধ323(023>£'&+'!2&90-££9W'$ধ3268'9'2;9(''&#!$032,3>;,','!£;,$8-9-9>!91!2!+'&-2. 8'2$,'2+-2''8-2+9$,33£9&<8-2+;,')89;$32;!-21'2;6'8-3&l!8$,;39;!8;3(9<11'8mW ,-9!2!£@9-9,'£69-&'2ধ(@;,'683#£'19(!$'&#@'2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9!2&;3#8-2+;,'1;3;,'£'='£3( !<;,38-ধ'9!2&<2-='89-;@63£-$-'9-238&'8;3-1683=';,'-89-;<!ধ32W'$ধ32683=-&'9T(38-££<9;8!ধ32 6<8639'9T ! $!9' 9;<&@ 3( ;,' (3££3>f<6 3( !6683?-1!;'£@ '£'$;8-$!£ !2& 1'$,!2-$!£ '2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9&<8-2+;,')89;$32;!-21'2;6'8-3&W'&';!-£;,'1';,3&'9;!#£-9,'&;3'29<8';,''ø'$ধ=' !$7<-9-ধ32!2&'=!£<!ধ323(023>£'&+'!2&90-££9!;!&-9;!2$'T!2&&-9$<99;,'1!-28'9<£;93#;!-2'&W '$ধ3268'9'2;9$32$£<9-329!2&8'$311'2&!ধ32923;;3'?;3£;,'=-8;<'93(&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32T#<; ;38'*'$;32$3113268!$ধ$'9!&!6;'&;3;,'9<9;!-2!#£'!2&#83!&£@!$$'6;'&&-+-;!£;8!29(381!ধ323( <2-='89-;@'&<$!ধ32W. W'='£36-2+3(&-+-;!£90-££9-2;,'(!$'3(;,','!£;,$8-9-9. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . WW3£-ধ$!£-2$'2ধ='9-2 8!2$' 2 8!2$'T-28'96329';3;,'<26!8!££'£'&,'!£;,$8-9-9;,!;,!9$329-&'8!#£@!ø'$;'&,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32T ;,' -2-9;8@ 3(

(12) -+,'8 &<$!ধ32T '9'!8$, !2& 223=!ধ32T (831 ;,' )89; 6'8-3& 3( $32;!-21'2;T -W'W &'$£!8'&32¤!8$,T,!91!&'9<8';,!;;,'!=!-£!#£';8!-2-2+$3<89'9!8'#<-£;;3#'&'£-='8'& 3='8!&-9;!2$'W,-96'&!+3+-$!£$32ধ2<-;@1<9;1!0'-;6399-#£';39<6638;;,'+33&$32ধ2<!ধ323( 6'&!+3+-$!£!$ধ=-ধ'9T;3'29<8'9;<&'2;9!8'23;6'2!£-A'&!2&T(38;'!$,'89T;3683=-&'+33&;'!$,-2+ $32&-ধ329W£;,3<+,;,'8',!='#''21!2@-2&-=-&<!£!$ধ329&<8-2+;,-96'8-3&T 8!2$',!91!&'!=!-£!#£' !&-+-;!£;33£#3?$32;!-2-2+;,8''1!-26-££!89;31'';;,'!#3='$,!££'2+'9V j[ 8!2$'2-='89-;Ì<1Ì8-7<'\l mV'!8'6!8ধ$<£!8£@-2;'8'9;'&,'8'-2;>3&-+-;!£6£!Ĥ3819V f !2& !16<9W -2$' T f -9 ;,' 8'2$, 6£!Ĥ381 (38 9W ; 3ø'89 ;,' #'9;3(,-+,'8'&<$!ধ3232£-2';,83<+,!8-$,$!;!£3+<'3(;8!-2-2+$3<89'9&'9-+2'&#@683('99389(831 <2-='89-ধ'9T9$,33£9!2&;,'-86!8;2'89W;<&'2;9$!2;8!-2(38(8''T!$7<-8'90-££9-2;'8!$ধ='£@!2&!#3=' !££!;;,'-83>26!$'W !16<9T-2;'2&'&(38

(13) 9T-9-16£'1'2;'&;3'2!#£';'!$,'89;3&'6£3@32£-2' $3<89'9!96!8;3(!$<88-$<£<1!2&;3-2;'+8!;'T(38'?!16£'T91!££68-=!;'32£-2'$3<89'9l9m-2;3 ;,'-8;'!$,-2+68!$ধ$'9W j-8;<!£<2-='89-;@V,'-+-;!£2-='89-;@-9!2!993$-!ধ32$31639'&3(9-?;,'1!ধ$&-+-;!£<2-='89-ধ'9 -2 8!2$'W ;96<8639'-9;3683=-&';'!$,'89!2&9;<&'2;9-2

(14) 9T!9>'££!9;,'-8+3='82!2$'T>-;,6''8f 8'=-'>'&&-+-;!£9$-'2ধ)$!2&'&<$!ধ32!£8'93<8$'9;,!;$!2#'<9'&-2&-ø'8'2;6'&!+3+-$!£(3819V;,' -2='8;'& $£!998331T '28-$,'& (!$'f;3f(!$'T $316£'1'2;!8@ 8'93<8$'9T &-9;!2$' £'!82-2+ ';$W 2 ;,' =!9; 1!/38-;@3($!9'9T;,'9'8'93<8$'9T>,-$,$3='8!>-&'8!2+'3()'£&9l'W+W!8;9T'$3231-$9!2&1!2!+'1'2;T £-;'8!;<8'!2&£!2+<!+'9T,'!£;,!2&9638;T'2+-2''8-2+9$-'2$'9T,<1!2-ধ'9!2&93$-!£9$-'2$'9';$WmT!8' '!9-£@!$$'99-#£'!2&(8''3($,!8+'W 38;,'+3='82!2$'3(

(15) 9T;,'$32$'6;3(&-+-;!£<2-='89-;@-9='8@ -1638;!2;#'$!<9'-;9,3<£&'2!#£';,'1;39<6638;;,'1-2;,'&'='£361'2;!2&-16£'1'2;!ধ323(;,'-8 &-+-;!£9;8!;'+@c63£-$@W j322'$;'&!16<9'9V£!$'9£!#'££'&[322'$;'&!16<9'9\!8'-2&-=-&<!£c$3££'$ধ='>38096!$'9>,'8' 9;<&'2;9$!2(3££3>,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32$3<89'9!;!&-9;!2$'2'!8;,'-8,31'9T>-;,£3$!£9<6638;W,'@!-1.

(16)

(17) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. ;3,'£6@3<2+6'36£'9<$$''&-2!,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32;,'@>3<£&23;2'$'99!8-£@,!='<2&'8;!0'2T#@+-=-2+ ;,'1 ;,' 1'!29 ;3 3='8$31' +'3+8!6,-$!£T <8#!2 !2& 93$-!£ #!88-'89T >-;,3<; (38+'ষ2+ 69@$,3£3+-$!£ #!88-'89l'W+W9'£(f$'29389,-6T('!83((!-£<8'TWWWmT>,-$,$8'!;'-2'7<!£-ধ'9W,-99$,'1'Z99<$$'99-9&<';3 ;,'6'8932!£-A!ধ323(;,'9<6638;V'!$,9;<&'2;-99<6'8=-9'&T13ধ=!;'&!2&9<6638;'&#@!7<!£-)'& 683('99-32!£W-0';,'&-+-;!£<2-='89-;@T$322'$;'&$!16<9'93ø'82<1'83<9&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+$3<89'9!2& $'8ধ)$!ধ329l

(18) -+,'8!ধ32!£-6£31!T#!$,'£38Z9!2&1!9;'8Z9&'+8''9m!2&!££;,'1!-2&-9$-6£-2!8@ )'£&9!8'!$$'99-#£'l'W+W£!>T,<1!2!2&93$-!£9$-'2$'9T'2+-2''8-2+9$-'2$'9T9$-'2$'9!2&;'$,2-7<'93( 6,@9-$!£!2&9638;9!$ধ=-ধ'9';$WmW,''?6'8-1'2;T>,-$,#'+!2-2T-2=3£='&$322'$;'&$!16<9'9 !$$8'&-;'&#@;,' 8'2$,-2-9;8@3(

(19) -+,'8 &<$!ধ32T'9'!8$,!2& 223=!ধ32W 2 '#8<!8@T!2'> $!££(38683/'$;9>-;,!#<&+';3( 1-££-32>!9£!<2$,'&-238&'8;3,!='$322'$;'&$!16<9'9 #@!;;,'£!;'9;T>-;,683/'$;9#'-2+9'£'$;'&W 2;3;!£T$322'$;'&$!16<9'9,!='#''2£!#'££'& !2&!8'36'2!2&>'£$31-2+9;<&'2;9-28'+-329W. WW<88'2;6'8$'6ধ323(;,'=-8;<!£$£!998331-2,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. ¥. 2' 0'@ ;3 9<$$'99(<£ &-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32 &<8-2+ ;,' 3=-&f 6!2&'1-$ -9 ;,' 1!-2;'2!2$' 3( 9;832+ -2;'8!$ধ32 #3;, #';>''2 9;<&'2;9 !2& ;'!$,'89 !2& !132+ 9;<&'2;9 ;,'19'£='9W !2@ '?6'8-1'2;9 8'$'2;£@8'638;'&-2;,'£-;'8!;<8'9,3>;,-9£'='£3(-2;'8!$ধ32-91<$,138'-2;'29'-2!=-8;<!£$£!998331T -W'W>,'2&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32-9$32&<$;'&9@2$,8323<9£@l!9-£!-!';!£WTmW,'!<;,389(<8;,'8'?6£!-2 ;,!;9;<&'2;91!@T-2;,-9$!9'T(''££'999,@;3!907<'9ধ329>,'2;,'@!8'9'6!8!;'&#@;,'#!88-'83( ! $316<;'8 ;33£W 31' !<;,389 !£93 23;' ;,!; &-9;!2$' £'!82-2+ $!2 9-+2-)$!2;£@ 8'&<$' !#9'2;''-91W

(20) 3>'='8T 931' (3819 3( ;'!$,-2+T £-0' 68!$ধ$!£ >380 !2& 683/'$;9T >,-$, 8'7<-8' 96'$-)$ £!#38!;38@ '7<-61'2;T&323;£'2&;,'19'£='9>'££;3&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+W,'9'!<;,389!£9363-2;3<;;,!;-2;,'9' $!9'9T;,'7<!£-;@3(,<1!2-2;'8!$ধ32-2!6,@9-$!£$£!998331-9&-ă$<£;;31!;$,-2!=-8;<!£'2=-8321'2;W '96-;';,'1!2@639-ধ='63-2;91!&'!#3<;-;T9'='8!£!<;,389-2&-$!;';,!;;,';'!$,-2+9;@£'3(=-8;<!£ '&<$!ধ321<9;1!0'<9'3(=!8-3<9 -223=!ধ='1';,3&3£3+-'9 ;3(<££@-2=3£='9;<&'2;9!2&,'£6;,'1 !$,-'=';,'1!-26'&!+3+-$!£3#/'$ধ='9T2!1'£@9<$$'99(<££'!82-2+!2&;,'!$7<-9-ধ323(8'£'=!2;90-££9W ,''ø38;8'7<-8'&#@;'!$,'89;3&'9-+2'ø'$ধ='=-8;<!£$£!9983319-9,<+'!2&;!0'91<$,138'ধ1' ;,!2>-;,(!$'f;3f(!$';'!$,-2+W 23;,'8'?;8'1'£@-1638;!2;63-2;!&&8'99'&-2;,'£-;'8!;<8'$32$'829;,'1!2!+'1'2;3(023>£'&+' !99'991'2;9!2&1'!9<8'1'2;3($£!996!8ধ$-6!ধ32!2&!ħ'2&!2$'W 2#3;,(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&&-9;!2$' £'!82-2+T ;'!$,'89 2''& 'ø'$ধ=' >!@9 ;3 1'!9<8' ;,'-8 9;<&'2;9Z 6'8(381!2$'W ,-9 -9 <9<!££@ &32' ;,83<+,;,'9<#1-99-323(,31'>380T;,'!&1-2-9;8!ধ323(;'9;9T'?!19!2&7<-AA'9T!2&;,'$8'!ধ323( 6!8ধ$-6!ধ3263-2;9W 2!&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+'2=-8321'2;T;!#£'f;36'?!1-2!ধ329!2&$£!9983316!8ধ$-6!ধ32 !2&Y!ħ'2&!2$'Z!8'138'&-ă$<£;;31'!9<8'W 3$32$£<&';,-99'$ধ32T&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32-923;2'>g1!2@68'9ধ+-3<9<2-='89-ধ'9!83<2&;,'>38£& l'W+W-2;,'T <836'T;,'T,-2!T 2&-!T<9;8!£-!T3<;,38'!T!£!@9-!T3<;,(8-$!m,!='#''2 68!$ধ9-2+-;(381!2@@'!89W,!;-92'>T,3>'='8T-9;,''?;'2;;3>,-$,<2-='89-ধ'9!8'<9-2+$3££!#38!ধ=' &-+-;!£ 6£!Ĥ3819 !2& 32£-2' 8'93<8$'9 ;3 ;'!$, #3;, 9@2$,8323<9£@ !2& !9@2$,8323<9£@>,-£' '29<8-2+ ;,'-89;<&'2;98'1!-213ধ=!;'&W. WW='8=-'>3($<88'2;&-+-;!£;33£9(38$32&<$ধ2+=-8;<!£$3<89'9 £;,3<+, 38-+-2!££@ -2;'2&'& (38 $311'8$-!£ !66£-$!ধ329T $3££!#38!ধ=' 6£!Ĥ3819 9<$, !9 33+£' '';T -$8393đ'!19!2& 331,!='#''2>-&'£@<9'&!83<2&;,'>38£&-28'$'2;@'!89T6!8ধ$<£!8£@(38;,' &-+-;!£;8!29(381!ধ323(,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32W 38'?!16£'T-$8393đ'!19T!=!-£!#£'32-;93>238!96!8;3( !2ă$'¤6!$0!+'T-9!$<9;31-A!#£'$3££!#38!ধ='6£!Ĥ381;,!;-2;'+8!;'91!2@('!;<8'9T-2$£<&-2+V =-&'3 $32('8'2$-2+U 9$,'&<£-2+ ;'!1 1''ধ2+9 =-! -$8393đ <;£330T !9 >'££ !9 9,!8-2+ $32;!$;9 !2& '1!-£9U )£' 9;38!+' !2& ;8!29('8 >-;, ,!8'3-2;U !2& 23;'f;!0-2+ <9-2+ 2'3;'W !2@ !66£-$!ধ329T 9<$,!9 3819!2& 331T$!2#'&-8'$;£@-2;'+8!;'&-2;3;,';33£W9!23;,'8'?!16£'T;,' 331=-&'3.

(21)

(22) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. $311<2-$!ধ32 ;33£ 683=-&'9 ! 8'13;' $32('8'2$-2+ 9'8=-$' ;,!; $31#-2'9 =-&'3 $32('8'2$-2+T 32£-2' 1''ধ2+9T$,!;T!2&13#-£'$3££!#38!ধ32<9-2+68368-';!8@!66£-$!ধ329W,-9;33£,!96'&!+3+-$!£63;'2ধ!£ !9-;!££3>9;,'$8'!ধ323(!=-8;<!£8331!$$'99-#£';3!£!8+'2<1#'83(6!8ধ$-6!2;9!2&3ø'891!2@ ('!;<8'9<9'(<£(38;,'8'!£-A!ধ323(!232£-2'$3<89'T-2$£<&-2+V;,'$8'!ধ323(!=-&'3$32('8'2$'(38! £!8+'2<1#'83(6!8ধ$-6!2;9U;,'!#-£-;@;38'$38&!=-&'3$32('8'2$'!2&$,!;T!££3>-2+9;<&'2;9;3£'!82 !;;,'-83>26!$'U!<&-3!2&$,!;-2;'8!$ধ329U9$8''29,!8-2+>-;,;'!$,'89U!9>'££!9$32;'2;9,!8-2+T 8'!£fধ1'$3f23;!ধ32T!2&!&-+-;!£>,-;'#3!8&W 32+#'(38';,','!£;,$8-9-9#83<+,;#@3=-&fT1!2@!<;,389>'8'!£8'!&@'16,!9-A-2+;,'-2;'+8!ধ32 -2;3'&<$!ধ323(;'$,23£3+-$!£-223=!ধ329-22';>380-2+!2&$311<2-$!ধ32W-$8393đ'!196'81-;9 ;,'$8'!ধ323(8-$,!2&(<2$ধ32!££'!82-2+'2=-8321'2;9>,'8'9;<&'2;96£!@!683!$ধ='!2&$329;8<$ধ=' 83£' ;,83<+,3<; ;,' £'!82-2+ 683$'99T !9>'££ !9 -2c&<8-2+ !££ -2;'8!$ধ329 -2 (<££@ -2;'8!$ধ=' $316<;'8f 9<6638;'&$3££!#38!ধ='£'!82-2+lm'2=-8321'2;9W ;9<9',!9#'$31''='2138'=-9-#£'&<8-2+;,' 6'8-3&3(3=-&fT!££3>-2+<9;3!£93;'9;;,'83#<9;2'993($316<;'82';>3809W'96-;';,-9T;,'<9' 3( -$8393đ'!19 -9 9ধ££ -2 -;9 -2(!2$@T '96'$-!££@ -2 ,-+,'8 '&<$!ধ32W 8!>(38& '; !£W 63-2; 3<; ;,!;T >-;,8'+!8&;3;,'!99'991'2;3(023>£'&+'!2&90-££9T(<8;,'89;<&@-92''&'&;3'29<8';,!;&-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32&3'923;&'+8!&'9;<&'2;6'8(381!2$'W3;,-9'2&T-;-92'$'99!8@;3$316!8'T(38!+-='29;<&@ 683+8!11'!2&>-;,$£!99'93('7<-=!£'2;9-A'T;,'6'8(381!2$'3(9;<&'2;9-2(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&&-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32W,-9-9;,'$,-'(13ধ=!ধ32(38;,'>38068'9'2;'&-2;,-963£-$@6!6'8W. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . ,' 3316£!Ĥ381,!9#''2<9'&#@1!2@<2-='89-ধ'9!83<2&;,'>38£&&<8-2+;,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$W ,-9!£-(382-!f#!9'&!66£-$!ধ32,!99''2-;92<1#'83(&3>2£3!&9+83>&8!9ধ$!££@9-2$'!8$,W '='8;,'£'99T-;-923>#'-2+$8-ধ$-A'&(38-;9£!$03(9'$<8-;@!2&9,38;$31-2+9-2;'8193(6'8932!£&!;! 683;'$ধ32W 38'?!16£'T32¤!8$,;,'1'8-$!21'&-!3<;£';-$'8'='!£'&;,!;;,'-='89-32 l66£'Z936'8!ধ2+9@9;'1m3(;,'!66£-$!ধ32,!&T<2ধ£8'$'2;£@T#''29,!8-2+931'3(-;9<9'89Z6'8932!£ &!;!>-;, !$'#330>-;,3<;-2(381-2+;,'1g!68!$ধ$';,'$316!2@-11'&-!;'£@!99<8'&-;,!&6<;!2 '2&;3W='8;,'9!1'6'8-3&T;,' $$'993>!90'& 331;36<#£-9,![;8!296!8'2$@8'638;\32 -;963£-$@(381!2!+-2+!2&9,!8-2+<9'8-2(381!ধ32Wধ££T;,'9''?!16£'9,!='23;68'='2;'&68'9ধ+-3<9 <2-='89-ধ'9 9<$, !9

(23) !8=!8&T 8-2$';32 !2& ;!2(38& (831 >-&'£@ <9-2+ 331 (38 !££ ;,'-8 9;<&'2;9T -2 6!8ধ$<£!8#'$!<9'3(-;99-16£-$-;@!2&<9'8f(8-'2&£-2'99W 2 8!2$'T-;9<9'9''19£'999@9;'1!ধ$W2! $!9'f#@f$!9'#!9-9T-;-93đ'2£'đ;3;,'&-9$8'ধ323(;'!$,'89;3>380>-;,;,';33£;,!;9<-;9;,'1#'9;T '96'$-!££@-2$£!99'968'6!8-2+9;<&'2;9(38<2-='89-;@'2;8@W';T 331-9$£'!8£@,-+,£-+,;'&32;,'93$-!£ 2';>38093($'8;!-2-29ধ;<ধ329T-2$£<&-2+;,' <9-2'99$,33£T;,'2-='89-;@3( =8@T!2&;,' 381!2&-'<9-2'99$,33£W 3 $32$£<&' ;,-9 9'$ধ32T ;,' $,3-$' 3( ! &-9;!2$' £'!82-2+ ;33£ 8'£-'9 32 ;,' #!£!2$-2+ 3( 931'ধ1'9 $32;8!&-$;38@$8-;'8-!T-2$£<&-2+V'ă$-'2$@T7<!£-;@3(9'8=-$'T&!;!683;'$ধ32T6!8!1';'8-A!ধ326399-#-£-ধ'9 (38&-ø'8'2;;@6'93(<9'8T<9'8'8+3231-$9T!2&$39;W6!8ধ$<£!8£@$8-ধ$!£63-2;$32$'829;,'38+!2-A!ধ32 3(!99'991'2;93(;,'023>£'&+'!2&90-££9!$7<-8'&#@9;<&'2;9W'='8!£7<'9ধ329!8-9'V,-$,!8';,'#'9; &-+-;!£;33£9;3<9'S

(24) 3>;3'29<8''7<-;@!132+9;<&'2;9T-2;'8193(#3;,;,'683=-9-323(,!8&>!8'!2& 93đ>!8'8'93<8$'9!2&;,''?!1-2!ধ32$32&-ধ329S,-$,1'!9<8'9!8'2''&'&;3683;'$;6'8932!£!2&c 389'29-ধ='&!;!S31!2@7<'9ধ329T!9;3>,-$,>'>-££!ħ'16;;3!29>'8-2;,'£!9;6!8;3(;,-9!8ধ$£'W. W

(25) '!£;,f$8-9-9Z-16!$;32&-9;!2$',-+,'8'&<$!ধ32-2 WW 38'>38& 2;,-99'$ধ32T>'!2!£@9';,'8'9<£;93(!9<8='@3ø'8'&;3'2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9-2 8!2$'#@;,'!ধ32!£ ă$'3(;<&'2; 2+-2''89U;,'9<8='@!-1'&!;9,!8-2+;,'-8'?6'8-'2$'!2&(''£-2+932,3>;,'3=-&f $8-9-9,!&#''21!2!+'&#@;,'¤'2+-2''8-2+9$,33£99-2$';,'@,!&$£39'&l!$7<'9';!£WTmW,' T8'96329'93#;!-2'&!8'$316!8'&>-;,8'$'2;£@6<#£-9,'& <836'!2!2&+£3#!£&!;!l8-9;3=2-0 ';!£WTmTl3=-&f3$-!£$-'2$'!#TmW 26!8ধ$<£!8T>'$316!8'3<88'9<£;9>-;,;,39'3(3<8.

(26)

(27) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. 2'-+,#3<8 '81!2@ l!£;,3<+, ;,' 2<1#'8 3( 8'96329'9 ;,'8' 9,3<£& #' ;!0'2 >-;, $!<ধ32mT <836'Z9 £'!&-2+'$3231-$63>'8T>,39'<2-='89-;@'&<$!ধ329@9;'1-9$£39';33<89W9!2-2&-$!ধ32T>'!£93 $316!8'3<88'9<£;9>-;,;,39'3#;!-2'&32;,'+£3#!££'='£T-W'W>-;,;,'!8ধ$£'#@8-9;3=2-0';!£W>,3 $32&<$;'&!9<8='@3(T9;<&'2;9(831$3<2;8-'9!2&¤$32ধ2'2;9W đ'8!&&8'99-2+;,'-99<'3(9;<&'2;9Z!$$'99;3$316<;'88'93<8$'9T#3;,,!8&>!8'!2&93đ>!8'T>' &-9$<99,3>;,'@(''£!#3<;;,'9,-đ(831(!$'f;3f(!$';3&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32W;<&'2;9'?68'99'&;,'-8 =-'>932,3><2-='89-ধ'9!2&63£-$-'99,3<£&1!2!+';,-9;8!29-ধ32W. WW$$'99;3$316<;'88'93<8$'9 !#£'9,3>9;,!;!$$'99;3;,' 2;'82';T!9>'££!9;3,!8&>!8'!2&93đ>!8'$316<ধ2+8'93<8$'9T>!9 23;32£@9!ধ9(!$;38@-2 8!2$'&<8-2+;,'6'8-3&<2&'8$329-&'8!ধ32T#<;;,!;;,')+<8'9!8'T(38'?!16£'T comparable to those of our German neighbour. !#£'9,3>9;,!;W¦3( 8'2$,9;<&'2;9('£;;,'-8 2;'82';$322'$ধ32>!93(63387<!£-;@T>,-$, ,!&!2-16!$;32;,'$32&-ধ329(38&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32UW¤¦3(9;<&'2;9&-&23;!£>!@9,!='!$316<;'8 !=!-£!#£'UW¦3(;,''2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9$329-&'8'&;,'@&-&23;,!='!££;,'93đ>!8'8'7<-8'&(38;,' 9133;,8<22-2+3(;,';'!$,-2+!$ধ=-ধ'9l-2,!£(;,'$!9'9T(38;'$,2-$!£8'!9329V-29<ă$-'2;$316<;'8 6'8(381!2$'!2&683#£'19!$$'99-2+£-$'2$'9!2&>-;,-29;!££!ধ32mW. Table 1:$$'99;3$316<;'88'93<8$'9g316!8-932#';>''2&!;!(831'2+-2''8-2+9$,33£9-2 8!2$' l!$7<'9';!£WTm!2&;,'£-;'8!;<8'l8-9;3=2-0';!£WTm. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . '8$'2;!+'3(9;<&'2;9>-;, !$$'99;3!6'8932!£T683('99-32!£ 389,!8'&$316<;'8. '8$'2;!+'3(9;<&'2;9>-;,!2 !&'7<!;' 2;'82';$322'$ধ32. '8$'2;!+'3(9;<&'2;9>-;, !$$'99;393đ>!8'2''&'&;3 $32&<$;'&<$!ধ32!£!$ধ=-ধ'9. 97.4% l'2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9-2 8!2$' lT8'96329'9$3££'$;'&mm. 87.7% l'2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9-2 8!2$' lT8'96329'9$3££'$;'&mm. 94.1% l'2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9-2 8!2$' lT8'96329'9$3££'$;'&mm. 91.0% 81.0% 98.0% l,-+,'8'&<$!ধ329;<&'2;9-2 l,-+,'8'&<$!ধ329;<&'2;9-2 l,-+,'8'&<$!ধ329;<&'2;9-2 '81!2@l#';>''2!2& '81!2@l#';>''2!2& '81!2@l#';>''2!2& 8'96329'9$3££'$;'&mm 8'96329'9$3££'$;'&mm 8'96329'9$3££'$;'&mm 84.0% l,-+,'8'&<$!ধ329;<&'2;9 >38£&>-&'lT8'96329'9 $3££'$;'&mm. 59.0% l,-+,'8'&<$!ধ329;<&'2;9 >38£&>-&'lT8'96329'9 $3££'$;'&mm. 73.0% l,-+,'8'&<$!ধ329;<&'2;9 >38£&>-&'lT8'96329'9 $3££'$;'&mm 3<8$'ª!$7<'9';!¡US . WW8!29-ধ329#';>''2(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&&-9;!2$'$3<89'9 !#£'8'='!£9;,!;W¦3(;,''2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9l9''-2!#£'m(3<2&;,'9,-đ(831&-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32;3(!$'f;3f(!$';'!$,-2+;33!#8<6;W,'8'!8';>31!-28'!9329(38;,-9W,')89;8'£!;'9;3;,' !#-£-;@;3>380!2&$32$'2;8!;'W 2&''&T2'!8£@¦3(;,'9;<&'2;9l9''-2!#£'m$329-&'8;,'@!8' £'99'ø'$ধ='-2&-9;!2$';,!2-2;8!&-ধ32!£$3<89'9W,'9'$32&8'£!;'9;3>380£3!&UW¦3(;,'9;<&'2;9 9<8='@'&l9''-2!#£'m$329-&'8;,!;;,'>380£3!&-91<$,£'99-1638;!2;>,'23='8!&-9;!2$'!2& ;,'@;,'8'(38'£39'!££13ধ=!ধ32;3$32ধ2<';,'-8;8!-2-2+W.

(28)

(29) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. '96-;'!££;,'1'!9<8'96<;-26£!$';3'29<8';,'6'&!+3+-$!£$32ধ2<-;@3(,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32-2 8!2$'l9'' '$ধ32mT9;<&'2;9(''£;,'@£!$0-2(381!ধ32(831;,'-8683('99389T<2-='89-ধ'9!2&2!ধ32!£-29ধ;<ধ329W ( ;,' '2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9 9<8='@'&T ¦ $329-&'8 ;,'@ ,!& 23; 8'$'-='& '23<+, -2(381!ধ32 !#3<; $32ধ2<-2+;,'-89;<&-'9&<8-2+;,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$T>-;,¦;,-20-2+;,'-1639'&1'!9<8'99,3<£& have been more thorough.. Table 2:8!29-ধ32#';>''2(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&&-9;!2$'$3<89'9. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . l3;+33& !;!££m. 2. 3. 4. 5 l'8('$;£@ +33&m. g

(30) 3>&-&9;<&'2;9'?6'8-'2$';,'9<&&'2;8!29-ধ32#';>''2(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&&-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32S. 7.8%. 19.6%. 35.9%. 26.2%. 10.5%. g

(31) 3>&-&9;<&'2;96'8$'-=' ;,'-8!#-£-;@;3>380!2&$32$'2trate at a distance compared to ;8!&-ধ32!£$3<89'9S. 20.0%. 38.8%. 21.4%. 15.4%. 4.4%. g

(32) 3>&-&9;<&'2;96'8$'-=' ;,'>380£3!&3(&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32$316!8'&;3;8!&-ধ32!£ $3<89'9S. 7.6%. 15.8%. 28.8%. 27.6%. 20.2%. 3<8$'9ª!$7<'9';!¡US T!ࣅ32!¡3ă$'3(9;<&'2;'2+-2''89S . W!9'9;<&@3(! 8'2$,'2+-2''8-2+9$,33£ WW'9'!8$,3#/'$ধ='9 £;,3<+, ;,' 3=-&f ,'!£;, $8-9-9 8'='!£9 ;,' $8-ধ$!£ 2''& (38 &-+-;!£ ;'$,23£3+-'9 -2 1!2@ !8'!9T 6!8ধ$<£!8£@-2,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32T;,8''0'@7<'9ধ329!8-9'T>,-$,1!@#'(381<£!;'&!9(3££3>9V j

(33) 3>$!2>''29<8';,!;;,'023>£'&+'68'9'2;'&;,83<+,!&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+$3<89'-93(9<ă$-'2; 7<!£-;@S j

(34) 3> $!2 >' 1!0' ;,' &-9;!2$' £'!82-2+ 683$'99 !9 9133;, !9 6399-#£' (38 !££ 6!8ধ'9 -2=3£='& l-W'W 9;<&'2;9!2&;'!$,'89mS j,-$,!8';,'#'9;;33£9(38!99'99-2+023>£'&+'!2&90-££9!$7<-8'&3='8!&-9;!2$'!2&,3>$!2>' +<!8!2;'';,'-88'£'=!2$'S ,-9 9'$ধ32 3( ;,' 63£-$@ 6!6'8 !-19 ;3 683=-&' ! 7<!£-;!ধ=' !2& 7<!2ধ;!ধ=' !99'991'2; 3( ;,' ;33£9 6<;-26£!$'-2'2+-2''8-2+9$,33£9&<8-2+;,'$<88'2;+£3#!£,'!£;,$8-9-9;31!0'9<8'3(;,'7<!£-;@!2& $32ধ2<-;@ 3( ,-+,'8 '&<$!ধ32 6'&!+3+@ l!$7<'9 '; !£WT mW ,' (''&#!$0 -9 $316£'1'2;'& #@ !2 !99'991'2;3(;,'9;<&'2;9Z023>£'&+'!2&90-££9W3;,-9'2&T!#3<;9;<&'2;9-2;,')'£&3('£'$;832-$ !2&1'$,!2-$!£'2+-2''8-2+(831;,'2-='89-;@3(3<89-2 8!2$'>'8'132-;38'&(389'='8!£132;,9W ,'3#/'$ধ='>!9;3&-9$<99;,'8'£'=!2$'3(;,''=!£<!ধ323(;,'023>£'&+'!2&90-££9!$7<-8'&#@;,'.

(35)

(36) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. &-9;!2$'9;<&'2;9W'!$$38&-2+£@$316!8'&;,'&-9;8-#<ধ3293(;,'8'9<£;93#;!-2'&#@;,'9;<&'2;9-2 ;,'(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&&-9;!2$'$3<89'9W -2!££@T;,'(''£-2+93(;,'9'9;<&'2;9>'8'!2!£@9'&!;;,''2&3( ;,'&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ326'8-3&!2&;,'8'9<£;9>'8'$316!8'&>-;,$<88'2;£@!=!-£!#£'2!ধ32!£&!;!W. WW';,3&3£3+-$!£!96'$;9 ,'8'9'!8$,68'9'2;'&-2;,-9$!9'9;<&@>!9$32&<$;'&>-;,;,'6!8ধ$-6!ধ323()89;fT9'$32&f!2& third-year students in electrical and mechanical engineering at the College of Engineering of the University 3(3<89T 8!2$'W,'9''2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9>'8'&-=-&'&-2;3(3<8+83<69U'!$,+83<6;330!96'$-)$ $3<89'+-='2#@&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+W 83<6l¤9;<&'2;9m!2& 83<6l¤9;<&'2;9m'!$,;330!$3<89' -2 '2+-2''8-2+ 9$-'2$'9W !$, 3( ;,'9' ;>3 $3<89'9 $329-9;'& 3( £'$;<8'9T ;<;38-!£9 !2& 68!$ধ$!£ >380U ;,' £!ħ'8 &-& 23; 8'7<-8' ;,' <9' 3( 96'$-)$ 1!;'8-!£9 !2& ;,'8'(38' £'2; ;,'19'£='9 >'££ ;3 &-9;!2$' £'!82-2+W,'¤9;<&'2;9-2 83<6;330!$3<89'-22<1'8-$!£!2!£@9-9T1!-2£@;!<+,;-2;,'(3813( 68!$ধ$!£>380<9-2+!668368-!;'$316<;'8;33£9!=!-£!#£'(8''3($,!8+'32£-2'W -2!££@T;,''2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9 -2 83<6 $!88-'& 3<; ! 683/'$; 32 ;,' &'9-+2 !2& $329;8<$ধ32 3( !2 '£'$;832-$ 9@9;'1 (38 !<&-3!66£-$!ধ329W32(832;'&>-;,;,'<268'$'&'2;'&,'!£;,9-;<!ধ32T;,'9;<&'2;9&-&23;,!='!$$'99 ;3;,'9$,33£68'1-9'9T£';!£32'!££;,'£!#38!;38@'7<-61'2;2''&'&;3&'9-+2;,'-8)2!£683/'$;W9! 8'9<£;T!ħ'2ধ32>!9(3$<9'&32!66£@-2+!2!2!£@ধ$!£!6683!$,;3;,'&'9-+23(;,'!8$,-;'$;<8'3(9<$, !2'£'$;832-$9@9;'1W,'@>'8'!£93!#£';3!66£@>,!;;,'@,!&;,'38'ধ$!££@9''2-2;,'-8;'!$,-2+3( 683/'$;1!2!+'1'2;l'W+W&')2-ধ323(1-£'9;32'9!2&&'£-='8!#£'9T;'!11!2!+'1'2;mW. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . '(38'9;!8ধ2+;,''?6'8-1'2;T!9<8='@>!99'2;;3&';'81-2';,'683638ধ323('2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9 >-;, 9<ă$-'2; $316<;'8 '7<-61'2; !2& 93đ>!8' ;3 ;!0' ;,' =!8-3<9 $3<89'9 ;,83<+, 9@2$,8323<9 &-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32W ,' 9<8='@ 8'9<£;9 9,3>'& ;,!; 32£@ ¥W¦ 3( ;,' 9;<&'2;9 ('£; ;,'@ &-& 23; ,!=' !&'7<!;'$316<;'8'7<-61'2;l'W+W6'8932!£389,!8'&$316<;'89T+8!6,-$9;!#£';9!2&91!8;6,32'9m;3 $31(38;!#£@;!0';,'9'$3<89'9!;!&-9;!2$'W'9-&'9T/<9;3='8¤W¦3(;,'9;<&'2;99<8='@'&('£;;,'@ £!$0'&1<$,3(;,'93đ>!8';,'@2''&'&;36!8ধ$-6!;'-29@2$,8323<9'f£'!82-2+W,'9')+<8'9l#'£3> ¦m!8'3(;,'9!1'38&'83(1!+2-;<&'!9;,39'3#;!-2'&32;,'2!ধ32!££'='£l9''!#£'mW ,'!6683!$,;38'13;'023>£'&+'!$7<-9-ধ32!2&!99'991'2;&'9$8-#'&-2;,-9$!9'9;<&@'2;!-£9(3<8 0'@6,!9'9l9'' 8!6,mV jPhase 1: Preparing students for distance learning. This phase consists of giving each student access to &-ø'8'2;$3££!#38!ধ326£!Ĥ3819l-W'W T-$8393đ'!19T!2& 331mT!9>'££!932£-2'!66£-$!ধ329 l 33+£'8-='m!2&96'$-)$93đ>!8'lT$-£!#mW j,!9'V,'!$;<!££'!82-2+6,!9'T&<8-2+>,-$,6<6-£9!8''?6'$;'&;3!$7<-8'023>£'&+'T&'='£3690-££9T !2&#<-£&32;,'-8!$,-'='1'2;9W,')89;;>3+83<69;'9;'&!;'!$,-2+1';,3&;,!;9''9;,'8'='89!£3( ;,';8!&-ধ32!£6'&!+3+-$!£9'7<'2$'['$;<8'9U<;38-!£9U;,'28!$ধ$!£380\W,';,-8&+83<6#'2');'& (831!;8!&-ধ32!£!6683!$,;3<2-='89-;@'&<$!ধ32W,'(3<8;,+83<6$!88-'&3<;!683/'$;U!;£'!9;T32£@ >-;,8'+!8&;3;,'(<2$ধ32!£&')2-ধ323(;,'9@9;'1!2&38+!2-A!ধ329;<&-'&l1-£'9;32'9T&'£-='8!#£'9T ;'!11!2!+'1'2;mW j,!9'V99'991'2;3(023>£'&+'!2&90-££9;,83<+,9@2$,8323<9023>£'&+';'9;9 j,!9'V;<&'2;'=!£<!ধ323(;,'&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+'?6'8-'2$';,83<+,32£-2'9!ধ9(!$ধ329<8='@9.

(37)

(38) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. Graph 2:83639'&1';,3&(38;,'8'13;'!$7<-9-ধ32!2&'=!£<!ধ323(023>£'&+' Learning management system. Digital collaborative platforms. c. Online applications and special software. Prepare students for synchronous e-learning. d Acquire knowledge, develop skills and build on achievements. e Ensuring that knowledge and skills are well acquired. f Ensuring that students are satisfied with e-learning. Online satisfaction surveys. 3<8$'ª!$7<'9';!¡US . DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. Practice quizzes, timed online exams, midterm and final exams. WW!-28'9<£;9 8!6,9,3>9;,'&-9;8-#<ধ323(£3$!£9$38'9l(831;3T>-;,#'-2+;,'£3>'9;!2&;,',-+,'9;m (38;,'(3<8+83<693('2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;9>,3;330;,'&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32l9'';,'93£-&+8''2£-2'-2 '!$,+8!6,-2 8!6,mW,'8'9<£;9(38'!$,+83<6!8'$316!8'&>-;,;,'8'9<£;93(!$£!993('7<-=!£'2; 9-A' ;,!; ;330 ;,' 9!1' $3<89'T #<; (!$'f;3f(!$' l9'' ;,' &!9,'& #£<' £-2' -2 '!$, +8!6, -2 8!6, mW '+!8&£'99 3( ;,' +83<69T ;,' 8'9<£;9 -2 8!6, 9,3> ;,!; 9@2$,8323<9 &-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32 &3'9 23; &'+8!&';,'6'8(381!2$'3('2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9W2;,'$32;8!8@T!2&;,-9-9'=-&'2;(38+83<69T !2&T;,'$329-9;'2$@3(9;<&'2;6'8(381!2$'-9$£39'8l-W'W;,'9;!2&!8&&'=-!ধ3293(;,'£3$!£+8!&' &-9;8-#<ধ329!8'1<$,91!££'8mW. -2!££@T;,'9;<&'2;9$316£';'&!9!ধ9(!$ধ329<8='@;3!99'99;,'7<!£-;@3(;,'-8&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32 l9''!#£'mW,'7<'9ধ329!90'&$32$'82'&;,';'!$,-2+-;9'£(l$£!8-;@3(;,'$3<89'T68'8'7<-9-;'9T$32;'2;T 9'£'$;'& -££<9;8!ধ329mT -;9 38+!2-A!ধ32 l$338&-2!ধ32 3( ;'!$,-2+ !$ধ=-ধ'9T 68'6!8!ধ32 (38 023>£'&+' '=!£<!ধ32mT ;,' ;'!$,'8 l&@2!1-91T 1!9;'8@ 3( &-9;!2$' £'!82-2+ ;33£9T -2;'8!$ধ329 #';>''2 ;'!$,'89 !2& 9;<&'2;9m !2& ;,' +'2'8!£ 9!ধ9(!$ধ32 3( '2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9W ,' 8'9<£;9 -2 !#£' 8'='!£ ;,-9 '?6'8-'2$'>!93='8>,'£1-2+£@639-ধ='!2&;,!;32£@¦3(;,''2+-2''8-2+9;<&'2;99<8='@'&>'8' 23;$316£';'£@9!ধ9)'&>-;,;,'7<!£-;@3(;,'-8&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32'?6'8-'2$'W,'8'9<£;9-2!#£'9,3> ;,!;¦3(;,'9;<&'2;99<8='@'&>'8'23;'2ধ8'£@9!ধ9)'&>-;,;,'1';,3&<9'&;3'29<8';,'7<!£-;@ 3( ;,'-8 '2+-2''8-2+ '&<$!ধ32 !; ! &-9;!2$'W £;,3<+, ;,'9' 8'9<£;9 !8' 3='8>,'£1-2+£@ 639-ধ='T (3<8 63-2;93(=-+-£!2$'>'8'-&'2ধ)'&#@9;<&'2;9V;,'&@2!1-913(9@2$,8323<9'f£'!82-2+T;,'$338&-2!ধ32 3(6'&!+3+-$!£!$ধ=-ধ'9T'?!168'6!8!ধ32!2&;,'-2;'8!$ধ32#';>''29;<&'2;9!2&;'!$,'89W,'£!9; 63-2;-9138'3='832';,!;,!9#''2#83!&£@-&'2ধ)'&!;;,'2!ধ32!££'='£T-W'W#@;,'T9;<&'2;9 3( ;,' ¤ 8'2$, '2+-2''8-2+ 9$,33£9 l!ধ32!£ ă$' 3( ;<&'2; 2+-2''89T mW 2&''&T &-9;!2$' +'2'8!;'99-+2-)$!2;&-ă$<£ধ'9-2$32&<$ধ2++83<6>380T9<$,!9683/'$;9T'96'$-!££@>,'29;<&'2;9&3 23;,!='!$$'99;396'$-)$£!#38!;38@'7<-61'2;W.

(39)

(40) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. Graph 3:316!8-9323(9;<&'2;6'8(381!2$'9-2(!$'f;3f(!$'!2&9@2$,8323<9'f£'!82-2+V!m 83<6 l¤9;<&'2;9mU#m 83<6l¤9;<&'2;9mU$m 83<6l¤9;<&'2;9mU&m 83<6l9;<&'2;9m. Local grades. Sample quantiles. Group 2. Sample quantiles. Group 1. Face-to-face learning Synchronous e-learning. Local grades. Face-to-face learning Synchronous e-learning. a). b). DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. Local grades. Sample quantiles. . Group 4. Sample quantiles. Group 3. Face-to-face learning Synchronous e-learning. Local grades Face-to-face learning Synchronous e-learning. c). d) 3<8$'ª<;,389$!¡$<¡!ࣅ32#!9'&32=!¡-&8'96329'9U. Table 3:!ধ9(!$ধ329<8='@8'9<£;9l8'96329'9$3££'$;'&m ħ8-#<;'9. *. *. *. *. W,'9@££!#<9(38;,-9;'!$,-2+>!9$£'!8£@68'9'2;'&. 77%. 23%. 0%. 0%. W,'68'8'7<-9-;'9(38;,-9;'!$,-2+>'8'$£'!8£@68'9'2;'&. 68%. 32%. 0%. 0%. W,'$32;'2;3(;,-9;'!$,-2+,!9#''2!&!6;'&;3@3<8 023>£'&+'. 64%. 35%. 1%. 0%. W,-9;'!$,-2+>!968'9'2;'&-2!9ধ1<£!ধ2+!2& 13ধ=!ধ2+1!22'8. 47%. 41%. 12%. 0%. W338&-2!ধ32#';>''2£'$;<8'9T;<;38-!£9!2&68!$ধ$!£ >380>!923;&-ă$<£;. 59%. 40%. 1%. 0%. ¤W ££<9;8!ধ329l-W'W'?'8$-9'9T$!9'9;<&-'9!2&68!$ধ$!£>380m >'8'9<ă$-'2;. 56%. 44%. 0%. 0%. W 29;8<$ধ329(3868'6!8-2+023>£'&+'!99'991'2;9>'8' clear. 68%. 30%. 2%. 0%.

(41)

(42) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. ħ8-#<;'9. *. *. *. *. ¥W3<,!='#''2>'££68'6!8'&(38;,'=!8-3<9023>£'&+' assessments proposed by your teacher. 44%. 52%. 4%. 0%. 9. The skills demonstrated by your teacher are <27<'9ধ32!#£'T&'96-;';,'&-9;!2$'. 64%. 36%. 0%. 0%. W'96-;';,'&-9;!2$'T@3<8;'!$,'8>!9!=!-£!#£'!2& listening. 73%. 27%. 0%. 0%. W3<8;'!$,'89''19;3,!='1!9;'8'&&-+-;!£;33£9!;! distance. 77%. 23%. 0%. 0%. W'96-;';,'&-9;!2$'T;,'-2;'8!$ধ32#';>''2;'!$,'8 !2&9;<&'2;9>!97<-;'+33&. 62%. 28%. 10%. 0%. W3<!8'+'2'8!££@9!ধ9)'&>-;,;,'7<!£-;@3(;,' '&<$!ধ32683=-&'&. 52%. 46%. 2%. 0%. Note: *V$316£';'£@!+8''UV!+8''UV&-9!+8''UV$316£';'£@&-9!+8'' 3<8$'ª<;,389$!¡$<¡!ࣅ32#!9'&32=!¡-&8'96329'9U. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. . '+!8&-2+;,'&@2!1-913(9@2$,8323<9'f£'!82-2+T;,'9;<&'2;96!8ধ$-6!ধ2+-2;,'683/'$;-29-9;'&;,!;;,-9 (3813('&<$!ধ32&-&23;£'2&-;9'£(;3&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+T'='29@2$,8323<9T#'$!<9';,'@$3<£&23;#<-£& !2&;'9;;,'(<2$ধ32-2+3(;,'-8'£'$;832-$9@9;'1W'='8;,'£'99T;,'@9;8'99'&;,!;!(<2$ধ32!£!2!£@9-9 >!9$8<$-!£#'(38'&'9-+2-2+!2&&-1'29-32-2+!2'£'$;832-$9@9;'1W-;,8'+!8&;3;,'$338&-2!ধ323(;,' &-ø'8'2; 6'&!+3+-$!£ !$ধ=-ধ'9T ;,' 9;<&'2;9 63-2;'& 3<; ;,' 931'ধ1'9 3='8£3!&'& !+'2&!9 ;,!; 1-?'& 1!2@!$ধ=-ধ'93(;,'9!1'2!;<8'32;,'9!1'&!@W-;,8'96'$;;3;,''=!£<!ধ323(023>£'&+'!2&90-££9T 32£@;,')2!£'?!19>'8'7<'9ধ32'&W 2;8<9-='1';,3&9T-2=3£=-2+8'13;'$32;83£3(9;<&'2;9Z1!;'8-!£9T >'8'='8@6338£@6'8$'-='&W,'9<8='@8'9<£;99,3>;,'9;<&'2;9!ħ!$,+8'!;-1638;!2$';3;,';8<9;6£!$'& -2;,'1#@;,';'!$,'89W2'?!1-2!ধ32(381!;>,'8';,'9;<&'2;$31639'932!;36-$(38!£-1-;'&ধ1' !2&;,'9;<&'2;1<9;,!2&-2;,'!99-+21'2;-2!&836#3?9''19;3#'!93£<ধ32;3#'(<8;,'8'?6£38'&W 3$32$£<&';,-99'$ধ32T;,')2&-2+9&'9$8-#'&-2;,-9$!9'9;<&@9,3>;,!;;,'7<'9ধ323(,3>#'9;;3 <2&'8;!0'023>£'&+'!99'991'2;!2&&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+-9!8'!£,'!&!$,'W-9;!2$'2'$'99!8-£@-16£-'9! 8'£!ধ329,-63(;8<9;>-;,9;<&'2;9#'$!<9'-;-9!£139;-16399-#£';3$32;83£;,'$32&-ধ329-2>,-$,-2&-=-&<!£ >380-9$!88-'&3<;<2£'99!8ধ)$-!£-2;'££-+'2$'-9<9'&W'='8!£!6683!$,'9!8'$<88'2;£@#'-2+'?6£38'&;3 ,'£6;'!$,'89!99'999;<&'2;6'8(381!2$'T-2$£<&-2+V9;366-2+!££!99'991'2;U(3$<9-2+329'£(f!99'991'2;U &'='£36-2+!638Ĥ3£-33(90-££9;3#'!$7<-8'&!;;,''2&3(!$3<89'U!2&&'='£36-2+32£-2'7<-AA'9l!$$'99-#£' =-!91!8;6,32'9T;!#£';9!2&$316<;'89m#'(38';,'9;!8;3('!$,$3<89'l(38'?!16£'T;,'33$£!6;33£,!9 #''21!&'!=!-£!#£'#@;,'2-='89-;@3(3<89mW. W32$£<9-32 -2$';,'#'+-22-2+3(T-2;,'(!$'3(;,'3=-&f6!2&'1-$T>,-$,23;!#£@£'&;3;,'>-&'968'!& $£39<8'3(<2-='89-ধ'9T!2&<2&'8;,'-16';<93(!$!&'1-$!2&63£-ধ$!£!<;,38-ধ'9T'&<$!ধ32!£;'!19!2& 9;<&'2;9!83<2&;,'>38£&,!='8!&-$!££@6£!@'&!1!/3883£'-2!$$'£'8!ধ2+;,'&-+-;!£;8!29(381!ধ323( ,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32W31!-2;!-2$£39'9;<&'2;g;'!$,'8-2;'8!$ধ329T=-8;<!£$£!9983319,!=';,'8'(38'#'$31' !8'!£-;@T#<;>-;,3<;!+'2<-2'$329'29<932;,'6'&!+3+-$!£68!$ধ$'9;3#'-16£'1'2;'&;3'29<8'7<!£-;@ ;'!$,-2+W,'9;<&-'9&'9$8-#'&-2;,-963£-$@6!6'8$32)81;,!;$'8;!-26'&!+3+-$!£(3819T9<$,!9£'$;<8'9 !2&;<;38-!£9T£'2&;,'19'£='9>'££;39@2$,8323<9&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+W2;,'3;,'8,!2&T68!$ধ$!£>380!2& 683/'$;91<9;#'$32&<$;'&(!$'f;3f(!$'(38#3;,1!;'8-!£l'W+W!$$'99;3£!#38!;38@3896'$-)$'7<-61'2;m !2& 69@$,393$-!£ 8'!9329 l'W+W ;3 1!-2;!-2 93$-!£ $32;!$; #';>''2 ;,' 9;<&'2;9 ;,'19'£='9T !9 >'££ !9 #';>''29;<&'2;9!2&;,'-8;'!$,'89mW.

(43)

(44) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. -;, 8'96'$; ;3 ;,' !99'991'2; 3( ;,' 023>£'&+' !2& 90-££9 !$7<-8'& #@ &-9;!2$' 9;<&'2;9T ;,' $!9' 9;<&@ 683639'& -2 ;,-9 63£-$@ 6!6'8 9,3>9 ;,!; &-9;!2$' '&<$!ধ32 &3'9 23; 8'&<$' ;,' 6'8(381!2$' 3( '2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9W 2&''&T ;,'@ !$,-'=' £3$!£ 9$38'9 9-1-£!8 ;3 ;,39' '?6'$;'& (831 (!$'f;3f (!$' ;'!$,-2+W ,' 8'9<£;9 3( ;,' =!8-3<9 9!ধ9(!$ধ32 9<8='@9 8'='!£ ;,!; ;,' '2+-2''8-2+ 9;<&'2;9 6!8ধ$-6!ধ2+-2;,-99;<&@!8'+'2'8!££@9!ধ9)'&T'96'$-!££@>,'2;,'(38193('&<$!ধ32&323;8'7<-8' 68!$ধ$!£-16£'1'2;!ধ32W -;,;,''1'8+'2$'3(=!8-!2;93(;,'=-8<9T-;-9$£'!8;,!;;,'$<88'2;+£3#!£,'!£;,$8-9-9-9(!8(8313='8W ,<9T&-9;!2$''&<$!ধ32>-££$32ধ2<';3+83>W,'>-&'£@9,!8'&3#9'8=!ধ32-9;,!;#£'2&'&£'!82-2+ $!23ø'81!2@36638;<2-ধ'9!2&;,'+8'!;*'?-#-£-;@8'7<-8'&(38;313883>Z9,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32Wধ££T-;9 -16£'1'2;!ধ32>-££23;#'6399-#£'>-;,3<;!2'ă$-'2;!2&£3$!£ ,'£6&'90l-W'W>-;,-2'!$,;'!$,-2+ $,!-8mT-26!8ধ$<£!8(38!$$'99;3$316<;'82';>3809T(38;83<#£'9,33ধ2+$316<;'8'7<-61'2;T(38!$$'99 ;3=-8;<!£1!$,-2'9T(38;,'-16£'1'2;!ধ323(2'>&-+-;!£;'$,23£3+-'9';$W. W¤'$311'2&!ধ329 ,'$,!££'2+'93(&-+-ধA!ধ323(,-+,'8'&<$!ধ32$32$'82&-+-;!£93='8'-+2;@!2&$32;83£3(£'!82-2+&!;!U 7<'9ধ329'96'$-!££@!8-9'!#3<;;,'2!;<8'3('&<$!ধ32!£$32;'2;T;,'$32;83£3(£'!82-2+&!;!!2&;,' 2'$'99!8@36'22'993(9@9;'19W,'8'!8'!£93'$3231-$-99<'9-2!>38£&-2>,-$,>'>!2;;368'9'8=' !$$'99;3'&<$!ধ32(38!££T8'+!8&£'993(#<&+';!8@$329;8!-2;9W -2!££@T;,'8'!8';,'$,!££'2+'93(&-+-;!£ ;8!-2-2+;,83<+,3<;£-('T<2&'8£-2-2+;,'-1638;!2$'3(+'2'8-$38;8!29='89!£90-££9;,!;'2!#£'6'36£';3 !&!6;T;3£'!82;3£'!82W. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. ¤. ,-963£-$@6!6'8-2;'2&9;3$32;8-#<;';3;,-9#@!$ধ='£@(381<£!ধ2+9'='28'$311'2&!ধ329+83<6'& <2&'8;,8''1!-2;,'1'9V8'9'!8$,T&-+-;!£;8!-2-2+T!2&6<#£-$!$ধ32W '$311'2&!ধ32W'='£36-2+$-'2ধ)$'9'!8$,83/'$;9V-+-;!£'$,23£3+@(38$!&'1-$<$$'99V ,'8'!8'1!2@!8'!9!83<2&!$!&'1-$!$,-'='1'2;>,'8'&-+-;!£9$-'2$'8'9'!8$,$3<£&#8-2+#'2');9T -2$£<&-2+ '2+!+-2+ 9;<&'2;9 -2 ;,' £'!82-2+ 683$'99 ;,83<+, $316<;'8f#!9'& !6683!$,'9W ,' )89; 7<'9ধ32-9,3>;368313;'!$!&'1-$9<$$'99W ;9,3<£&#'!29>'8'&#@&'='£36-2+8'9'!8$,683+8!11'9 -2$322'$ধ32>-;,$3+2-ধ='T'&<$!ধ32!£!2&&-+-;!£9$-'2$'9#!9'&-26!8ধ$<£!832 T!<;31!ধ$£!2+<!+' 683$'99-2+T 83#3ধ$9T !2& =-8;<!£c!<+1'2;'& 8'!£-;@ >-;, ! =-'> ;3 &'='£36-2+ £'!82-2+ '2=-8321'2;9 !&!6;'&;3-2&-=-&<!£$,!8!$;'8-9ধ$9!2&'='2138'$£'!8£@(386'36£'>-;,!$!&'1-$!&!6;!ধ322''&9T '96'$-!££@!$$38&-2+;3;,'-8&-9!#-£-;@9-;<!ধ32W '$311'2&!ধ32W'='£36-+383<9';,3&3£3+-'9(38;,' =!£<!ধ323(-+-;!£ &<$!ধ32V -+-;!£-2$£<9-32,!9#''2!$,-'='&>-;,3<;!2@'=!£<!ধ323(-;9-16!$;32£'!82-2+38-2'?6'8-1'2;93( ;33£-1-;'&9$36'W,'8'-9,'2$'!2''&;3&'='£361<£ধ&-9$-6£-2!8@8'9'!8$,£'!&-2+;38-+383<99;<&-'9 683&<$-2+ 83#<9; 8'9<£;9 32 ;,' 'ø'$;9 3( &-+-;!£ £-;'8!$@W 23;,'8 £-1-;!ধ32 3( 931' 8'9'!8$, 32 ;,' 'ø'$;93(&-+-;!££-;'8!$@-9-;9!639;'8-38-'=!£<!ধ32T;8@-2+;3$316!8'9-;<!ধ329>-;,!2&>-;,3<;;,'<9' 3(;'$,23£3+@W,'&'='£361'2;3('&<$!ধ32!£&-+-;!£'&<$!ধ32,!98'£-'&32;'$,23£3+-$!£&'='£361'2;9 931'ধ1'9!$,-'='&;,83<+,$3££!#38!ধ32#';>''2&-+-;!£!2&'&<$!ধ32!$;389W 23;,'863-2;-9;,''=!£<!ধ323(9;<&'2;9<9-2+8'13;'&-+-;!£;33£9W,-9-99<'8'1!-29;,'>'!063-2; -2;,'<9'3(&-+-;!£&-9;!2$'£'!82-2+T!£;,3<+,;,'-2;'+8!ধ323(!8ধ)$-!£-2;'££-+'2$'l m;'$,23£3+-'9-9 ;'2&-2+;3>!8&9!2!$$'6;!#£'93£<ধ32l&/!#-';!£WTmTl&/!#-';!£WTmW '$311'2&!ধ32W8!-2-2+'!$,'89-2;,'-+-;!£'$,23£3+-'93(313883>V ,';8!-2-2+3(;'!$,'891<9;!££3>(38;,'&'='£361'2;3(;,'-8&-+-;!£$<£;<8'!2&&'='£361'2;3(;,'-8 &-+-;!£90-££9(38&-ø'8'2;!+'+83<69!2&683('99-329W.

(45)

(46) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. '$311'2&!ধ32W3>!8&9!Y-=-$!2&36<£!8-+-;!£2-='89-;@Z!6!#£'3(8!-2-2+ ='8@32'-2;,' -+-;!£38£&V -+-;!£;8!-2-2+-9!$-=-$-99<';,!;1<9;+-='8-9';3!$ধ329!-1'&!;&'='£36-2+&-+-;!£$<£;<8'!2&90-££9W '$311'2&!ধ32 W 8'!;' 32&-ধ329 (38 ;,' '='£361'2; !2& !-2;'2!2$' 3( -+-;!£ &<$!ধ32!£ '93<8$'9!9!31132 33&V ;-92'$'99!8@;3$8'!;''&<$!ধ32!£$31132+33&9;,!;!8'13&<£!8!2&#!9'&328'93<8$'9;,!;!8'(8'' !2&!#£';3#'13&-)'&#@;,'!$;3893('&<$!ধ32W,'9'8'93<8$'91<9;#'-2&'?'&-238&'8;3(!$-£-;!;' their use by teachers. '$311'2&!ধ32 ¤W <!8!2;''-2+ ;,' 38;!#-£-;@ 3( '8932!£ &<$!ধ32!£ !;! !2& '='£36-2+ ;,' 2;'836'8!#-£-;@3(3đ>!8'3£<ধ329T!2&83=-&-2+6ধ1!£

(47) !8&>!8'3£<ধ329V ,'£'+!£!96'$;98'£!ধ2+;3;,'638;!#-£-;@3(6'8932!£&!;!-2;,')'£&3('&<$!ধ321<9;#'!88!2+'&W 2 !&&-ধ32T -; -9 -1638;!2; ;3 '29<8' ;,!; 9;<&'2;9 !2& ;'!$,'89 !8' '7<-66'& >-;, ;36f3(f;,'f8!2+' '7<-61'2;-2;'8193($316<;'89!$$316!2-'&>-;,,-+,f'2&6'8-6,'8!£9l,'!&6,32'9T£-+,ধ2+T+8!6,-$9 ;!#£';9mT9'29389l1-$836,32'9T$!1'8!9';$WmT 38'='2¤ >-8'£'992';>3809W '$311'2&!ধ32W8!29-ধ32!£83=-9-329V

(48) @#8-& &<$!ধ32@9;'1V '$;<8'9!2&;<;38-!£9>-££#'+-='23='8!&-9;!2$'T#<;683/'$;9!2&!99-+21'2;9>-££#'&32'-26'8932W. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. .

(49)

(50) -+,'8 &<$!ধ323£-$-'9(38'='£36-2+-+-;!£0-££9;3'9632&;3;,'3=-&f8-9-9V <836'!2!2& £3#!£'896'$ধ='9. W'('8'2$'9 &/!#- US<!,!#-US'2A!3<-US!$7<'9Uj kU<¡ࣅd¡3$03¡38d-2!8-A'&;!ࣅ9ࣅ$!¡ 1!+'9(38-2+¡'d!16¡' !$' '$3+2-ࣅ32U'29389SjkS£U,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a U a9 £U &/!#- US<!,!#-US'2A!3<-US!¡'#d,1'&Uj kU!9;S8'9'2;S!2& <;<8'3( !$''$3+2-ࣅ32ª'=-'>U ¡'$;832-$9S S££U,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a U a'¡'$;832-$9 £££U 8-9;3=2-0US '8ख-߳ US !=ࢳ'¡/ US31!ख'=-߳ US 1'0 U j kU 16!$;9 3( ;,' 3=-&d !2&'1-$ 32 -(' 3(

(51) -+,'8 &<$!ࣅ32;<&'2;9ª ¡3#!¡'896'$ࣅ='U<9;!-2!#-¡-;@Sj kS££U,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a U a9< ££U !9-¡!-! US =!=!&A' U j kU8!29-ࣅ32 ;3 2¡-2' &<$!ࣅ32 -2 $,33¡9 &<8-2+ ! d3d 3832!=-8<9 j3=-&dk !2&'1-$-2 '38+-!U'&!+3+-$!¡'9'!8$,SjkSdU,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a Ua68a 3¡SUj kU 2'7<!¡-;@-2,31'9$,33¡-2+&<8-2+;,'3832!$8-9-9-2;,'';,'8¡!2&9U -89;8'9<¡;9(831;,' !2'¡U ';8-'='& 68-¡ (831,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a Ua39(U-3a,(7U '<'8=!-2US'82-US1-2- US'2;AUS3@2'¡US '8,!8&9U';!¡Uj kU,'>-993832!;8'99;<&@U';8-'='& 68-¡ (831,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a Ua39(U-3a/7>¢!U <836'!2'2;8'(38-9'!9'8'='2ࣅ32!2&32;83¡S2!+'2$@3(;,' <836'!22-32Uj kU3=-&d9-;<!ࣅ32<6&!;' (38;,' a S!93(>''0S<6&!;'&¢ '#8<!8@ U';8-'='&£ '#8<!8@ (831,ħ69ªaa>>>U'$&$U'<836!U'<a '2a$!9'9d d2$3=d'<''!U

(52) '28-09'2US8''¡@ US

(53) '2&'8932Uj kU 3¡0'&!+3+-'9(38'!$,'88!29-ࣅ329ª6683!$,'9;3@2$,8323<92¡-2' '!82-2+-2;,'!0'3(3=-&dU3<82!¡3('$,23¡3+@!2&'!$,'8 &<$!ࣅ32j kS£jkS d U';8-'='&!@ (831,ħ69ªaa¡'!82;'$,¡-#U38+a68-1!8@a6a¢aU !$7<'9US<!,!#-US'7<'<Uj kU'13;'23>¡'&+'$7<-9-ࣅ32!2&99'991'2;<8-2+;,'3=-&d!2&'1-$U 2;'82!ࣅ32!¡3<82!¡3( 2+-2''8-2+'&!+3+@S j¢kS d£U,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a Ua-/'6U= -¢U¢ !$7<'9 US <!,!#- US '7<'< U j kU @2$,8323<9 d¡'!82-2+ -2

(54) -+,'8 &<$!ࣅ32 &<8-2+ ;,' 3=-&d !2&'1-$U 83$''&-2+93(;,' ¡3#!¡ 2+-2''8-2+ &<$!ࣅ3232('8'2$'j kSd68-¡ S-'22!S<9;8-!U. DISTANCE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION IN FRANCE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC. ¥. !ࣅ32!¡ă$'3(;<&'2; 2+-2''89S3=-&d9<8='@j!8$, kU';8-'='&£ '#8<!8@ (831,ħ69ªaa>>>U#2'-U(8a 1!-9d!<99-a'27<';'9a'27<';'d$3=-&daU '-$,U';!¡Uj kU'13;''!82-2+ <-&!2$'(831;!;' &<$!ࣅ32+'2$-'9&<8-2+;,'3=-&d!2&'1-$ª -89;330U ';8-'='&!@ (83139(U-3a0¢A?@aU -9;'0d,!2&¡'8UUj kU ?6¡38-2+2¡-2''!82-2+,83<+,@2$,8323<9!2&9@2$,8323<9 29;8<$ࣅ32!¡';,3&9U ¡3#!¡U,ħ6ªaa&3-ª U £a£dd£d¢dU ,'3=-&d3$-!¡$-'2$'!#S9<6638;'&#@¡3='2-!2'9'!8$,+'2$@S83+8!11'3( !$<¡;@3(<#¡-$&1-2-9;8!ࣅ32S 2-='89-;@3(/<#¡/!2!Uj kU';8-'='&£ '#8<!8@ (831,ħ6ªaa>>>U$3=-&93$¡!#U38+a+¡3#!¡d9;<&'2;d9<8='@a+¡3#!¡d &!;!#!9'aU -2'8UUS<99'¡¡UUS830'8

(55) US!$0'8US!8&US;!29)'¡&U';!¡Uj kU$,33¡$¡39<8'!2&1!2!+'1'2;68!$ࣅ$'9 &<8-2+$3832!=-8<93<;#8'!09-2$¡<&-2+3=-&dª!8!6-&9@9;'1!ࣅ$8'=-'>U,'!2$';,-¡&y&3¡'9$'2;

(56) '!¡;,SjkSd U,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a U ¢ad¢j k d <¡-!

(57) Uj kU2¡-2''!82-2+;38'='2;;,'68'!&3(!2&'1-$3832!-8<9-2 2&32'9-!U j 2+¡-9,'!$,-2+ 3<82!¡kSjkS£d¢U,ħ69ªaa&3-U38+a U¢£a';'82!¡U=-U¢ ¢£.

(58)