Modeling approach to multi-agent system of human and machine agents: Application in design of early experiments for novel aeronautics systems
Texte intégral
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11) %^5Lo)59GPo 1;=L=Go+PT5^=Go. &5L -5YTC9Go,VY=TIPAo. Br<[@EB~2E@O[_V_Nx~!pf_bE~. .##'1~ '[jlPlplE~ H_f~ '[H_fX<lP_[~2E@O[_V_Nx~. %_[ExtEVV~'[lEf[<lP_[<V~ j
(12) f
(13) _
(14) ~. !j@OEftEN~ ~ ~.VBE[>pfN~ $EfX<[x~. 2pf<[T<~~f[_~zE@O~0Ebp>VP@~. _jlEfV_O_Ij
(15) BE~. {'r<[
(16) )<@T_~ 8BE[ET
(17) +_f<rET~|O_[ExtEVV
(18) @_X~. $T5MGo.CVY=To. $T=;=TC9o#=A5CVo /=75VYC=Lo/95ML=II5o. lfpEjlfE<X~<Ef_jb<@E~OpX<[~ H<@l_fj~. Ef_[<plP@~<[B~ 1b<lP<V~E[lEf~ 1~ '1!~. VbO_[jjlf<jjE~ ~. ~<r`~ !
(19) ~EVP[~ ~ 2_pV_pjE~EBEv~ ~#f<[@E~. ~ %<X>pfN~$EfX<[x~. {#fEBEfP@
(20) EO<Pj~j
(21) j@<[[EVV<~|Pj<E
(22) Hf~. Hf<[T
(23) fPjlEfO<X>pfN
(24) BE~. '
(25) ~. )+'+ *#3 $3 -,-(3 *1*,"*3 $(3 ,3 -,$",$#3 /!!3 (,3 3 ,(#3 $3 ##3 ,3 %("3 $3 -"#$"%-,(3 #,(,$#3 ($"3 ,3 "*,(3 -"#2 *!.3 "#3 "$3 ,$3 "$(3 &-!(,3$$%(,$#3
(26) #3 "#13 **3 *-3 $$%(,$#3 $#*(*3 *.(!3 -"#*3 #3 $"%-,(3 *1*,"*3 $(3 /3 "-!,#,3 1#"3 $$%(,.3 *1*,"*3 (3 %%($%(,3 "$!*3 .!$%"#,3 $3 *-3 *1*,"*3 (&-(*3 .(13 %($$-#3 #!1**3 $3 "-,-!3 #,(,$#*3 #3 $#,*3 ,,3 "13 (*3 #3 *-3 *1*,"*3 ,$#!3 ,*,#3 *3 0-*,.3 #3 0%#*.3 $(3 *-3 *1*,"*3
(27) #3 ,3 *$%3 $3 ,3 $ 3 %($,3 ,*3 %($!"*3 (3 (**3 ($"3 ,3 "$!!#3 %$#,3 $3 ./3 /,3 ",$#3 ,$3 (,3 ,$$!*3 ,,3 /!!3 *"%!13 ,3 .!$%"#,3. "'/+(0/('`. 1l<[B<fB~ _bEf<lP[N~ bf_@EBpfEj~ 1./~ BEj@fP>E~ bPV_lj~ <@lQrQlQEj~ P[~ lOE~ @_@TbPl~ BpfP[N~ KPNOl
(28) ~ 2OEx~ <fE~ BEJ[EB~ l_~ _blPXPzE~ t_fTV_<B~ _H~ <~ bPV_l~ tOE[~ <bbVPEB~ <bbf_bfP<lEVx~ l_~ <~ KPNOl~ jPlp<lP_[
(29) ~ 'l~ O<bbE[j~ _ME[~ lO<l~ lOE~ @pffE[l~ jPlp<lP_[~ @O<[NEj~. >E@<pjE~. _H~. K_t~. _blPXPz<lP_[~. P[~. <Pf~. lf<I@~. X<[<NEXE[l~ 2+~ <[B~ jp>jEepE[lVx~ PXbVPEj~ <~ bPV_l~ l_~ @O<[NE~ lOE~ jlf<lENx~ OE~ O<j~ bV<[[EB
(30) ~ ~ @_ffE@l~ fE<@lP_[~ _H~ lOE~ bPV_l~ Pj~ l_~ EjlPX<lE~ lOE~ @pffE[l~ jl<lE~ <[B~ l_~ Er<Vp<lE~ <r<PV<>VE~ bf_@EBpfEj~ l_~ jEVE@l~ lOE~ X_jl~ fEVEr<[l~ _[E
(31) ~ 2OE~ jPlp<lP_[~ Pj~ lOEfEH_fE~ <@@_Xb<[PEB~ tPlO~ <[~ P[@fE<jE~ _H~ t_fTV_<B~ <[B~ >E@_XEj~ bf_[E~l_~Eff_fj
(32) ~ 2OE~BErEV_bXE[l~ P[~<rP<lP_[~ _HHEfj~ l__Vj~ l_~ jpbb_fl~ bPV_lj~ P[~. %*3 #3 (%!3 %(,*3 $3 ,3 ,*,#3 %*3
(33) #3 ,*3 %%(3 /3 #.*,,3 $""$#3 ,3 %($-(*3 $(3 /3. jp@O~. $"%-,(3 ***,#3 $-!3 3 .!$%3 3 *$/3 $/3. P[H_fX<lP_[~ P[~ <~ H_fX~ lO<l~ fEBp@Ej~ lOE~ _rEf<VV~ t_fTV_<B~ <[B~. jPlp<lP_[j~. tPlO~. <[~ <X>PlP_[~ l_~. jpbbVx~. fEVEr<[l~. $("!3 "$!!#3 $3 %($-(*3 !!$/*3 -*3 ,$3 #*%,3. H<@PVPl<lEj~lOE~ BE@PjP_[j~ <~bPV_l~ X<TEj
(34) ~ 2OE~ <X_p[l~ <[B~ H_fX~ _H~. %($-(!3 #$#**,#*3 #3 /$(!$3 % *3 $(3 ,3. BPjbV<xEB~ P[H_fX<lP_[~ Pj~ @fp@P<V~ P[~ jlfEjj~ jPlp<lP_[j~ <[B~ <~. .!$%"#,3 *,(,*3 3 *$/3 $/3 3 $"%-,(3 $#,.3. @_XX_[~ t<x~ _H~ O<[BVP[N~ lOE~ bf_>VEX~ Pj~ l_~ @fE<lE~ jErEf<V~. (,,-(3 3 .(,-!3 %!$,3 #3 *"-!,3 -"#3 %!$,3. <VlEf[<lPrEj~ lO<l~ <fE~ V<lEf~ bf_>EB~ P[~ EvbEfPXE[lj~ tPlO~ bPV_lj
(35) ~. .$-(3 #3 ,3 $%,3 ,$3 (**3 &-*,$#*3 ,1%!3 $(3. 2OE~. ,3 (!13 %*3 $3 ,3 .!$%"#,3 #!1**3 $3 ,*3. @_[jpXP[N
(36) ~ 5E~ lOEfEH_fE~ BPj@pjj~ P[~ lOPj~ b<bEf~ <[_lOEf~. &-*,$#*3 !!$/*3 -*3 ,$3 (-3 ,3 #-"(3 $3 #,*3 $(3. <bbf_<@O~ lOE~X_BEV BfPrE[~<bbf_<@O~. ,3 #!3 "%!"#,,$#3 /,$-,3 ,3 #3 $3 0%#*.3. EvbEfPXE[lj~.
(37) ~. 0%("#,*3 /,3 -"#3 %!$,*3 *3 "$!!#3 %%($3. $,3. 0%("#,!3. *,,#*3. EvbE[jPrE~. <[B~. lPXE~. ~ jxX>_VP@~ V<[Np<NE~ Pj~ pjEB~ l_~ BEj@fP>E~ lOE~ 1./j
(38) ~ @<[~ >E~ b<f<XElEfPzEB~ H_f~ @_@TbPl~ NE_XElfx~ j_~ lO<l~. -"#3 %!$,*3 #3 3 .(,-!3 %!$,3 3 &-!,13 $3 ,3 ($"3. O_tErEf~. 3jP[N~ <~ bf_@Ejj_f~ _H~ lOPj~ V<[Np<NE~ E<@O~ bf_@EBpfE~. *3 "$#*,(,3 $#3 0%("#,*3 -#(,#3 $,3 /,3 $-,$"3. <fE~. fE<@lP_[X_rEXE[l~ lPXEj~ <[B~ t_fTV_<B~ @<[~ >E~. ("#*3. BEfPrEB~ Hf_X~bjx@O_ bOxjP_V_Nx~X_BEVj
(39) ~. $#*(.3 *3 *$/#3 13 %1*$!$!3 ****"#,3 $3 %!$,3.
(40) ~. /$( !$3 /3 #3 ,-(#3 -*,*3 ,3 -*3 $3 ,3 "$!!#3. _N[PlPrE~ X_BEVj~ <~ rPflp<V~ bPV_l~ <fE~ pjEB~ l_~ jPXpV<lE~ bPV_lj~ >EO<rP_pf~ P[~ @_XbplEf~ EvbEfPXE[lj~. %%($3 $(3 ,*3 ,1%3 $3 %($!"*3. l_~ @_XbVElE~ lOE~ jEl~ _H~ b<f<XElEfj~ [EEBEB~ l_~ Er<Vp<lE~. '>a`QU<W
(41) WaWZ>Ko <>WD@N!o?D@BZ <>:Ho6\ZQK6ZDQN!o KQ<>J 86W><o 6RRUQ6:B o:Q@NDZD_>o6U:BDZ>:Z\U>o. <VlEf[<lPrE~ BEjPN[j
(42) ~ 1p@O~ <[~ <bbf_<@O~ Pj~ <bbE<VP[N~ H_f~ lPXE@_jl~ fEBp@lP_[~ <[B~ <~ b_lE[lP<V~ H_f~ H<jl~ <BSpjlXE[l~ _H~ EvbEfPXE[lj~ l_~[Et~ _f~ pbB<lEB~ fEepPfEXE[lj
(43) ~ [_lOEf~ >E[EJl~ Pj~ Plj~ <bbVP@<>PVPlx~ l_~ <[x~ bO<jE~. o bo (&&& . o.
(44) m@ P< 9<<_mqd<i Vi8_ 9ViM P< <1t^ qP1ZEj~ _H~ @_[@Ebl~. )).32;$!0;3/
(45) ~ EltEE[~ lN< { 7Mm1^{ 1 <dqmt1_. 9<AeVVmi . _fBEf~ Pj~PXb_jEB~ >x~MEf
(46) ~ U. !i P< mP<t P1i9 P< <s V1_<i8< m@ Vi@mV<lP_[~ _>l<P[EB~ Imd P d1i 1i9 8mdq <t <q<tVd<i{ i<<9{ l_~ >E~ SpjlPJEB
(47) ~. g. (P<t<@mt<<9<{VMi 5 <q<tVd<im Vi<{VM1>lOE~<>PVPlx~ _H~ 1 Vt1_ qV_m m t<q_18< P d1i qV_m{ Vi <1_ 1lP_[~ _H~ @_@TbPl~ mm_{ i PV{ q1q<t < V__ 9<{8tV7< P<t<@mt< >_lO~ <jbE@lj~ _H~. EFo do. PV{ 1qqtm18P Ft{ P< dm9<_9tV<i 1qqtm18P <[B~ jE@_[B~ <~ Ft{ <1_ 1Vmi m@ P< dm9<_9tV<i 1qqtm18P *"' . {Xdq`< {<81{< mC qm{XXmj {<a<8Xmj X`a >E~ pjEB~ P[~ lOPj~ q1q<t (P< 8m8YqV M<md< 1__m{ 1 mm_ n >E~ bV<@EB~ <l~ {<<t1_ 1^<y1V< qm{VVmi{ m<<t <18P b_jPlP_[~ X<x~ t<s Vt< 1 9V@@<t<i <@@mt @mt 8<tVE81Vmi 1i9 1Tj_~ X<x~ _HHEf~ <~. #_f~ X_BEVVP[N~ _H~ lOE~ 1./j~ <~ lpm_ P1 1__m{ Mt1qPV81_ /f_@EBpfE~! Pl_f
(48) ~ " . ~. PV8P V{ Vi P< {t1VMP V< m@ 1 qV^m tPVV~ >E~ X_jl~ { qqmtViM 7 VV^^t<s Vt<17VMM<t<Dmtm@EflPJ@<lE~ jp@O~ 1 mm_ i <_<8tmiV8 HVMP 71M 1qq_V81Vok _[~ lOE~ _lOEf~ P1i9 d1 7< <1{ m 8<tVF81< 1{ V P1{ VEjj~ <@@Ejj~ l_~ qtVd6 GVMP 9<8Y {{<d{ 7 qV^m{ V__ O<rE~ l_~ BPrEfl~ P<Vt @m8 { m t<19 V{ Vi@mtd1Vmi PV8P d1 [_l~ >E~ b_jjP>VE~ ViPVMP mtY_m19 {V 1Vmi . ><jEB~ <bbf_<@O~ O<j~ >EE[~ BErEV_bEB~ >y~!& {Vi8< .
(49) {<< H_f~ Ev<XbVE~ 9:~ 9:~ 9:~ 9:
(50) ~ 2OE~ 8mOVV< 68PV<8 t< V{ ><jEB~ _[~ lOE~ lOE_fx~ _H~ [BEfj_[j~ Ut<< 7<P1Vmt _<<_{ . / <pl_[_X_pj~ V<xEf~ l<jTj~ bf_@EjjEB~ VPm PVlYViM Vi 91V^ _bEf<lP_[j~ <jj_@P<lPrE~ V<xEf~ l<jUk~ qtm8<{{<9 7 @mtd1^ bf_@EBpfEj~ <[B~ @_N[PlPrE~ V<xEf~ l<jUk~ t<s VtViM i< q^1i{ Vi p[H<XPVP<f~ jPlp<lP_[j~ jEE~ #PN~
(51) ~ [~ 299VVmi1_ _1<t {1i9{ @mt bEf@EblP_[~ <[B~ X_l_f~ >EO<rP_pf~ <j~ <\~ Vi<t@18< m 1 {Vd ^1<9 E[rPf_[XE[l
(52) ~ 2OE~ bf_@EBpfEj~ _[~ lM< 1{{m8V1V< _1<t 1t<. 7<<<i CGsEV_bXE[l@EflP}. F81Vmi <@@mt 1i9 11V_17V^V d { 7< 1i1_{<: >EH_fE~ N_P[N~ @mt 1 8mi8<q (PV{ {<81{< 81i 7< <1{V_ <jjEjjEB~ P[~ <~ 8mdq <t <q<tVd<i m 9<dmi{1< P< calE[lP<V~ _H~ lOE~ dm9<^9tV<i 1qqtm18P . !cL[SySF <j?OSyF?y|jF 2OE~ @_N[PlPrE~ <f@OPlE@lpfE~ 11& {<9 Vi m t dm9<_. mt <1dq_< 1 i< mm^ @mt 1 qtVd1t GVMP BPjbV<x~ /#. 8mdqtmdV{<. , ''+%, - g ' *OXOSo
(53)
(54)
(55) . g eg !&#', !( !'*
(56) $ %& . ",
(57)
(58) , , . ,)-.hOi( 0j4k"l4mo+ . . . X_BEVVP[N~ _H~ jp@O~ fpVEj~ O<j~ >EE[~ 9<<`mq<9 81`a<9 #. 9V@@<t<i { qqmtm1 qV_m . 1. N1Cd)1Wg. "$*,
(59) . '(),. DB` ` .TQW:TWQ<`N? 8`QWH<`?NQ`.(*`JN;<HHDLB`. #EXbZsxi;xRbZ {sE>;sE . (P<t<@mt<. #".
(60) .. jl_fEB~ P[~ lOE~ XEX_fx~ @_Xb_[E[l~ P\~ @mtd m@ P< qt<Vm {_ BEj@fP>EB~ $1+~ fpVEj
(61) ~ l~ E<@O~ gpd<i {{<d {1< 1i9 bf_@EjjP[N~ _H~ <~ bf_@EBpfE~ @fE<lE~ lOF~ d<i1_ dm9<^ 59 1t< EvbfEjjEB~ <j~ <[~ _fBEfEB~ jEl~ _H~ N_<Vj~ 2i9 { 7Mm1_{ P1 P1< m >E~<@@_XbVPjOEB~ lOE~ j_~@<VVEB~N_<V~2M<i91 . 412 XbAEVVRZK . 576 . &1i91t9 !q<t1Vmi #tm8<9t<{ &!#{ 1t< X_BEVVEB~ <j~ <~. *DPf`[J:g. `JYPvP}B /8G . {< m@ t_<{ PV8P 9<Fi< 1 1{Y m 7< q<t@mtXEB 2OE~ fpVE~ (7GOXg. ^3iM 1M< V{ 71{<9 mi {m 81^_<9 m1^&1<<1k $1+~ fpVEj~. qra=Q9wQ~C 0:Dh . . / 18P & t_< 8mi1Vi{ 1 _<J 1i9 1 tVMP jPBE~ jEE~ <Vj_~ VM o @mt 1i<4q^<t _< . (P< _<@P1i9 {V9< 9<Fi<{ S< 8mi9VVmi1^ EVEXE[l~ tOP@O~ 8mi1Vi{ P< m1_ 1i9 P< &1<#6 18P t _? Pj~ fEjb_[jP>VE~ @mt <18^ mi< Mm1_ 1i9 81i 7< 8Pm{<i VH~ lOE~ __VE<[~ <qt<{{Vmi m@ 1 8mi9VVmi V{ t< (P< tVMPP1i; jPBE~ jbE@PJEj~ 1 d<Pm9 1i 18Vmi m 7<{1t<9 <qt<{{<9 VimOE~ +E<[j /<fl~ m@ 1 t_< (P< 18Vmi{ 3t< 9<Ae<9 m 188m i H_f~ XEX_fx~ q<t8<qVmi1i9 dmmtmq<t1Vmi{ 99VVmi1__ lOE~ V<[Np<NE~ Pj~ 17_< m {q<8V@ 9V@C<t<i <dqmt1_ t<_1Vmi{ MVrP[N~ lOE~ _fBEf~ 1i9 qtVmtVV<{ ^VY<^VPmm9{m@ P< { 7Mm1^{ 23o. DB` ` %8]<Q<;`NBLDTDZ<`Q:CDT<:TXQ<`. /f_@EjjP[N~ _H~lOE~N_<V~<NE[B<~ H_VV_tj~P<{< {<q{. mt <1dq_< S< t_< Vi VM
(62) 81i 7< Vi@mV<VVx~ >E~ fE<B~ <j~ P< 181^ Mm1^ V{ m t<t18 P< M<1t 3i9 nOE~ <Pf@f<M~ O<j~ ^V@<9 mD (. q ^^ P< M<1t ^<<t {PVJ =nnE[lP_[~ l_~ NE<f~. 1li i8V1Vmi q t{ < P< Mm1_ m 8P<8Y V@ P? NE<f~ <@lp<VVx~. U . ~ N_<V~ Pj~ f<[B_XVx~ jEVE@lEC~ Imd P< Mm1_ 1M<i91.
(63) ~. VV~ fpVEj~ @_[l<P[P[N~ lOE~ N_ 0^ Vi P<Vt m1^#6 1t<. tOP@O~@_[l<P[j~<VV~@pffE[lVx~ ~<_<817^<Mm1^{ @_VVE@lEB~ Er<Vp<lEB~ <[B~ TW>w68PV81__ mtM1iV<9 Vim. t<t18{ 1i9 1K<t1t9{ q t{ < S< Mm1_ m 81bc _pl~ lOE~ NE<f~ {1< (PV{ t_< 9<Fi<{ 1 Mm1_{ 7Mm1^ t<^<lP_[~ >EluEE[~ %0+. 3i9. { 7Mm1_{. &"(;$!0;3/~. <~fpVE~jEl
(64) ~
(65) ~. .[E~ fpVE~ Pj~ f<[B_XVx~ jEVE@lGC~ Imd S< t^< {< 1i9 JfEB~ tOP@O~ XE<[j~ lO<l~ lOE~ fmmt 1i9 q<t8<q 18Vmi{ <fE~ jE[l~ l_~ lOE~ X_l_f~ 2i9 q<t8<q 8mdqmi<i. o.
(66) t<{q<8V<^ 1i9 P< { 7Mm1^{ 1t< 199>: l_~ lOE~ N_<V~.
(67) ~. 0EV<lP_[~ <X_[N~ lOE~ fEV<lPrE~ mtY_m19 qV^m{ 18Vmi ep<VPlx~ _H~ P[H_fX<lP_[~ Hf_X~ P< { qqmtViM mm^ 1i9. 1M<i91 . pj<NE~_H~ lO<l~ P[H_fX<lP_[
(68) ~. (PX{ qtm8<{{ V{ V<t1<9 iV^ im dmt< t<{ <fE~ <bbVP@<>VE
(69) ~. 2OE~ EvbEfPXE[l~ t<j~ p[BEfl<TE[~ P\~ 1 . mt P< qt<9V8Vmi m@ 1{Y <<8 Vmi Vd<{ G=@O~ @_Xb_[E[l~. L^^GVMP. P1{ 1 q{8Pm_mMV81_ 1i9 qP{Vm^mMV81__ {mz[B~ X_BEV~ _H~. jPXpV<l_f~ <l~ )pMO<[j<~ 2f<P[P[N~ E[lgG ~ <t^Vi VS 1Vt^Vi<. VdViM 1i9 7<P1Vmt V < Vi P< d<dmt A_Xb_[E[l~ lOE~. bPV_lj
(70) ~ !<@O~ bPV_l~ LEt~ H_pf~ BPHHEfE[l~ {8<i1tVm{ P< {Vd ^1mt . t<d<d7<tViM 1i9 @mtM<ViM m@ Vi@mx1Vmi V{ Y_BEVVEB~ _f~ P[~ P< <<dmmt. pE~ l_~ VEN<V~ fEjlfP@lP_[j~ tE~ @_pVB~ r^18< P< 19V{mt {{<d. 8mdqmi<i {mqPV{V81<9 ZaBEVj~ _H~ ExE}. _[Vx~ P[l_~ _[E~ b_jPlP_[~ V_tEf~ E[NP]G~ 9V{q_1 7<<<i 7mP. dm<d<i{ 6< Vi<Mt1<9 i mt9<t m 1Y< P< d_jPlP_[j~ _H~ lOE~. bPV_lj
(71) ~ 2OE~ jp>SE@lj~ O<rE~ >EE[~ EepPeq<9 VP 1i <<t18Y<t. Vi{td<i{ @mt P< 81^8 ^1Vmi m@ P< GyG Z_rEXE[lj~ P[l_~. <j~ tEVV~ <j~ !$~ XE<jpfEXE[l
(72) ~ )R< t<^1V< mt\m19 V{. 188miQ<^m81Vmi{m@1^^Vi{t<i{1t< dm@EVVEB~ ><jEB~ _[~. BEfPrEB~ Hf_X~ !$~ XE<jpfEXE[lj~ OE=io~t1< 1tV17V^V 1<. P< mtVMVi1^ 8m8YqV ^1m 1i9 ^m19<9 Vim 1<1~ jEE~ <Vj_~. f<lP_~ Pj~ BEfPrEB~ Hf_X~ ExE lf<@TEh~. d<1{ t<d<i{. VM @mt 1 V{ 1^V{1Vmi m@ P1 Viq mt lOE~ @_XbplEf~. X_p[lEB~. 8mi{V9<t1Vmi. <q<tVd<i Q< 19V{mt {{<d 81i P<i ?E~ fE bV<@EB~ >x~. P[H_fX<lP_[~ Pj~ Er<Vp<lEB~ Hf_X~ lPXG~ 8mz<_1Vmi m@ qV^m{. {Vdq^ 8P1iMViM P<dm9<^ m@ P< 8m8]V 7,* #_fX<l
(73) ~. fE<@lP_[j~<[B~ BPjbV<xEB~ P[H_fX<lP_[
(74) ~. ExE lf<@TEf~. <[B~ bPV_lj~. P<19 m@ P<. 1p>SE@lPrE~ XE<jpfEj~ _H~ lOE~ }W1Vmi{ <t< 8m^_<8<9 lOf_pNO~ -1 2)6~ 2<jT~ )_<B~ P[DG7~ s <{Vmii1Vt<{ ./ 9:
(75) ~ 2OE~ @_XbplEf~. EvbEfPXE[l~. Er<^ 1<{. 188<{{17V^V. m@. P[H_fX<lP_[~ Hf_X~ lOE~ jpbb_flP[N~ l^m_ (P< mm^ V{ q_18<9 jp>jEepE[lVx~ <l~ H_pf~ BPHHEfE[l~ V_@<lP_^k
(76) ~ { 7<i8Pd1tY # Pj~ pjEB~ lOE[~ ![O<[@EB~ $f_p[B~ $uVd1t ,1yViM &{<d BPjbV<x~ !$/51~ !#~ _[~ fPNOl~ _H~ lO< qV^m Viq^18<m@ 718Y pb~ BPjbV<x~ <[B~ _[~ VEM~ _H~ lOE~ bPV_l~ { 1^ qm{VVmi 1t< pjEB
(77) ~ l~ E<@O~ V_@<lP_[~ 1<1~ @m_^m{ P< &!#{ 1i9 EjlPX<lEj~ lOE~ <@@EjjP>PVPlx~ tPlO~ fEjbE8 m@ Vd< P< qV^m i<<9{ l_~ BPrEfl~ OPj~ <llE[lP_[~ Hf_X~ lOE~ fENpW=i~ qtm8<9 v< m t<19 P< +. *!('+. P[H_fX<lP_[~Hf_X~ lOE~jpbb_flP[N~l__V
(78) ~. )' + + !)+ !'+ #%+ TC<` :WQQ<LT` <]<_. "!&'! +!+'+ !+ (# +&('! + ! +'+ !&'+ &toW<LT g TC<``. """` 3p 0%` +. #t<Vm { mtY P1{ {Pmi P1 &1& 8<[~ >E~ pjEB~ l_~ qt<9V8 M1< 59<< 7<P1Xm t -/ . 2OE~ <[<VxjPj~ _H~ lOE~ 2)6~ epEjlPmK1Vt<{ 8miBh<9 1 bPV_lj~ @_[jPBEfEB~ lOE~ ErE[lj~ jEVE@<9 m Vi9 8< P< t<. # %fEiRXEZx AEsRKZ (P<t< 6< m <q<tXd<i{ qt<{<i<9 m CEX_[jlf<lE~ lOE~ 7<i<E{ m@ < dm9<_9tV<i 1qqtm18P Vt{ GwbEfPXE[l~ tPlO~ P d1i qV^m{ 1{{<{{<{ P< 7<i<E{ m@ 1 { qqmnP[N~ l__V~ PljEVH ~. Er<Vp<lP_[~ _H~ bV<[j~ <j~ jlfEjjHpV~ jEE~ VM %<^1V< mtY^m19 <[<VxjPj~ jO_tEB~ <[~ P[@fE<jE~ _H~ lOE~ mtY^m19 1_ < {Pmt_ <MEf~lOE~ ErE[l~ O<bbE[EB~jEE~#PN
(79) ~
(80) ~. &<8mi9 1 8mdq <t <q<tVd<i <1^ 1<{ 1tX_pj~ bV<@EXE[l~. g. 1^<y1V<{ m@ P< mm^ Vi P< 8m8YqV mP GwbEfPXE[lj~ pjE~. . g. 9<Ae<9&!#{@mt 1 t<M_1t 1qqtm18P . co. (P<t< 1t< m q<{ m@ m 8md< Imd P< EvbEfPXE[l~. +g ,g. Pm{< t<^1<9 m P< { qqmtViM mm^ 59 P_jE~ fEV<lEB~ l_~. g ,g. 1qq^V817V_V m@ P<8mdq <t<q<tVd<i . g -g. , P< <q<tVd<i VP P d1i qV^m{ {t<{{ jPlp<lP_[j~ <fE~ Vi9 8<9 9 tViM Q< 1qqtm18P 7 i<q<8<9 kRoq<lP_[j~ jp@O~ <j~. g. g g g. 9<V8< @1V^ v< mt 1 i< 8^<1t1i8< {Pmt<iViN _H~ <r<PV<>VE~ 9V{1i8< m P< ti1 { qqmtViM mm_ V| bV<@EB~ <l~ lOE~ # 1i9 P< @m_^mViM 1{q<8{ 1t< dmiVu_fEB~ P[~ bPV_l~ 7<P1Vm t. o. . DB`
(81) ` './%5` S:NQ<` ?NQ` S:<L8QDNS` [DTCNYU` (+ #" + + )'+ Q<PH8LLDLB` $gg_g 98QS`Q<PQ<S<LT`TC<`ST8L;8Q;` $#!#+ !+'++ g "
(82)
(83) +. (Vd<{<tV<{ m@ t<^1V<mtZ^m19. 2OEfE~ Pj~ <[~ _>rP_pj~ @_ffEV<lP_[~ H^t 911 <<t18Y<t. #V^m{M1<t1Vm@mt ^mm[ViM1 P<{ qd_flP[N~l__V~. B<l<~ <[B~ ErE[l~ b_jPlP_[j
(84) ~ 2OE~ lPXE~ }=tV<{ m@ t<^1V< mtY^m19. #V^m{ 8mi{V9<t1Vmi m@ Vi@mtd1Vmicf_rPBEB~>x~ lOE~. BEfPrEB~. { qqmtViMmm^. @_XbplEf~ <[<VxjPj~ _H~1./j~ @_ffEjb_[C~ mi<m<18Q mP<t . o. Hf_X~. bOxjP_V_Nx~. XE<jpf<d<i{ 1i9 @tmd P<.
(85) P[H_fX<lP_[~ P[~ _fBEf~ !$/51~
(86) ~ j@x@VE~ !#~ _[~ fPNOl~ ""g. .
(87) ~ j@x@VE~ !#~ _[~ VEM~
(88) ~ j@x@VE
(89) ~l~ bE<T~ t_fTV_<B~.
(90)
(91)
(92)
(93) g. jPlp<lP_[j~ lPXE~ fEjlfP@lP_[j~ P[OP>Pl~ bPV_lj~ l_~ X<TE~ pjE~ _H~ !#~. !6/T]%/]6g. b_jPlP_[j~ lOE~ BPrEfjP_[~ _H~ H_@pj~ fEepPfEj~ X_fE~ lPXE~ lO<[~ <r<PV<>VE~ H_f~ <~ fEVEr<[l~ bf_@EBpfE~ jlEb
(94) ~ 2OPj~ @_[@VpjP_[~ t<j~ <Vj_~ @_[JfXEB~ >x~ <~ jPXbVE~ lEjl~ P[~ lOE~ @_@TbPl~ tPlO~ jErEf<V~ OpX<[~bPV_lj~ _pl~ _H~ j@_bE~_H~ lOE~EvbEfPXE[l
(95) ~. 'LaR5Q <9;S5Qg. '4
(96) ~ .0..('`. >I3T6/Y6g b>]?&g F6I]/Bg bMTABM/4g. 2OE~. bfEVPXP[<fx~. B<l<~. <[<VxjPj~. jpNNEjlj~. lOEfE~. <fE~. @_ffEV<lP_[j~ >EltEE[~ lOE~ t_fTV_<B~ bfEBP@lP_[j~ X<BE~ >x~ lOE~ @_XbplEf~ rEfjP_[~ <[B~ t_fTV_<B~ B<l<~ _>l<P[EB~ Hf_X~ lOE~ OpX<[~ c5g\S.2@=H9g S.\<Lg. rEfjP_[~. g
(97) g 8MTg/]]6I_MII/Bg. _H~. lOE~. EvbEfPXE[l
(98) ~. [<VxjPj~. _H~. -1 2)6~. epEjlP_[[<PfEj~ Pj~ P[~ <NfEEXE[l~ tPlO~ lOE~ B<l<~ Hf_X~ lOE~. 8M3/EY/^>MIg. bOxjP_V_Nx~ <[<VxjPj
(99) ~ VV~ lOPj~ SpjlPJEj~ lOE~ pjE~ _H~ <~ X_BEV} BfPrE[~ <bbf_<@O~ l_~ Er<Vp<lE~ BPjbV<x~ <VlEf[<lPrEj~ _f~ b_jPlP_[~ <VlEf[<lPrEj~ P[~ lOPj~ jlpBx~ EjbE@P<VVx~ P[~ <[~ E<fVx~ bO<jE~ _H~. DB` ` ` <]<TQ8:G<Q`8L;`<Z<LT`:NQQ<H8TDNLS`. BErEV_bXE[l~ tOE[~ OpX<[~ bPV_l~ EvbEfPXE[lj~ <fE~ BPHJ@pVl~ l_~. BBPlP_[<VVx~ lOE~ <[<VxjPj~ _H~ lOE~ !$~ B<l<~. jO_tj~ lOE~. jpbb_flP[N~ l__V~ fEBp@Ej~ lOE~ _rEf<VV~ t_fTV_<B~ BpfP[N~ lOE~ <bbf_<@O~jEE~#PN~
(100) ~. BEjPN[
(101) ~ 2OE~ _[ N_P[N~ B<l<~ <[<VxjPj~ jO_pVB~ <VV_t~ BEEbEf~ <[<VxjPj~ tPlO~ fEjbE@l~ l_~ PXbf_rE~ lOE~ EHJ@PE[@x~ _H~ lOE~ jpbb_flP[N~ l__V
(102) ~ 2OE~ @_XbplEf~ EvbEfPXE[l~ bf_rEB~ l_~ >E~pjEHpV~ P[~<[<VxjPj~ _H~. . @_@TbPl~ V_@<lP_[j
(103) ~ 'l~ jO_tEB~ j_XE~ _H~ lOE~ V_@<lP_[j~ jO_pVB~ [_l~ >E~ @_[jPBEfEB~ H_f~ HplpfE~ bf_l_lxbE~ BErEV_bXE[l
(104) ~ 2OE~ _rEf<VV~. . Evb<[jEj~ <[B~ lPXE~ fEepPfEXE[lj~ l_~ jEl pb~ lOE~ @_XbplEf~. . EvbEfPXE[l~ tEfE~ jPN[PJ@<[lVx~ fEBp@EB~ P[~ <>_pl~ ~ V_tEf
(105) ~. \ . 2OE~ HplpfE~ PXbf_rEXE[l~ _H~ lOE~ X_BEVVP[N~ l__Vj~ tPlOP[~. . _1~. . bf_SE@l~ tPVV~ <VV_t~ l_~ BEbV_x~ lOEX~ P[~ lOE~ X_fE~ @_XbVEv~. . EvbEfPXE[l~ jp@O~ <j~ lOE~ OpX<[~ bPV_lj~ EvbEfPXE[l~ BEj@fP>EB~. ]o. OEfE~ l_~jEE~HpflOEf~>E[EJlj~ Hf_X~ lOE~X_BEV BfPrE[~<bbf_<@O
(106) ~. . 4
(107) ~ ,-'.` ] . 6 7`. tOElOEf~ lOE~ P[jlfp@lP_[j~ bf_rPBEB~ >x~ lOE~ l__V~ @<[~ jlPVV~ >E~. ` %1;TG<` <T` 8E` &N;<HDLB` *DHNT` 8L;`QDZ<Q` <C8ZDNQ`?NQ`WJ8L` QQNQ` .DJWH8TDNL` ` ` ` %1;TG<` ` &O9WS` ` NBLDTDZ<` *DHNT` &N;<H` TN` *Q<;D:T` %<8K<;` 8Q<H<SSL<SS`?NQ` .]ST<J` <SDBL` L` ` *QDT:C<V`8L;` ` #8:GSNL` <;S` *QN:<<;DLBS` N?` TC<` LT<K8TDNL8H` NL?<Q<L:<` NL` WJ8LNJPWT<Q` LT<Q8:TDNL` DL` <QNL8WTD:S` <QN` ` /NWHNWS<` Q8L:<` =P8;W>S;DTDNLS`+(&` ` ` %1;TG<` ` QDS:C<` $*` (ST<QHNC` 38HD;8TDNL` N?` 8` DBDT8H` WJ8L` &N;<H` ?NQ` *Q<;D:TDLB` HDBCT` Q<[DQ:Q8A` N:GPDT` LT<Q8:TDNL` L` *QN:<<;DLBS` N?` ` <QHDL<Q` 4<QGST8TT` @2Q` &<LS:C&8S:CDL<.]ST<J<` . ` 3)I`3<QH8B` ` %1;TG<` !*` (ST<QHNC` /` &DN:C` ` +DST<Q` +` %NNDF<` NBLDTDZ<` &N;<HHDLB` N?` *DHNT` QQNQS` 8L;` QQNQ` +<:NZ<Q^` DL` HDBCT` &8L8B<J<LT` /8SGS` L` *QN:<<;DLBS` N?` TC<` TC` LT` 4NQGDLB` NL?<Q<L:<` NL` WJ8L` QQNQ` .8?<T]` 8L;` .]ST<J` <Z<HNPJ<LT` ..`` QWSS<HS` <HBDWJ` .<PT`
(108) ` ` #`L;<QSNL` %<8RDLB`8L;`&<JNQ^`#NCL`4DH<]` .NLS` L:` ` &&` .<P<CQ` SS<SSJ<LT` N?` .W9F<:TDZ<` &<LT8H` 4NQGHN8;` 0SDLB` './8SG` %N8;` L;<\` L` *QN:<<;DLBS` N?` TC<` TC` WQNP<8L` MLW8H` NL?<Q<L:<` NL` WJ8L` <:DSDNL` &8GDLB` 8L;` &8LW8H` NLTQNH ` `. `. >E[EJ@P<V~ PH~ bV<@EB~ <l~ BPHHEfE[l~ V_@<lP_[j~ lO<[~ /#
(109) ~ 2OE~. 9:~ .` ` 8QT` %` ` .T8Z<H8L;` <Z<HNPJ<LT` N?` './%5` /8SG` %N8;`. <[jtEf~ O<j~ PXbVP@<lP_[j~ tPlO~ fEjbE@l~ l_~ lOE~ fEjlfP@lP_[j~ lO<l~. L;<\` +<SWHTS` N?` <JPDQD:8H` 8L;`TC<NQ<TD:8H` Q<S<8Q:C` L`*` ` 8L:N:G` 8L;` '` &<SCG8TD` ;S` WJ8L` &<LT8H` 4NQGHN8;` JST<Q;8J` 'NQTC` NHH8L;`*Q<SS` `. 6 7`. DB` ` ` 98S<;`[NQGHN8;` <STDJ8T<S`4CDT<` [DTC` TC<` SWPPNQTDLB` TNNH` BQ8]` [DTCNWT`TC<`TNNH`. 2OE~ fE<@lP_[j~ _H~ bPV_lj~ tPlO~ fEjbE@l~ l_~ lOE~ jpbb_flP[N~ P[H_fX<lP_[~. <fE~. Er<Vp<lEB~. _[~. ><jPj~. _H~. 6
(110) 7`. -1 2)6~. epEjlP_[[<PfEj
(111) ~ /fEVPXP[<fx~ fEjpVlj~ jO_t~ NE[Ef<VVx~ N__B~ <@@Ebl<[@E~ _H~ P[H_fX<lP_[~ bf_rPBEB~ <l~ lOE~ /#.
(112) ~ 2OE~. 6 7`. P[rEjlPN<lP_[~ _H~ @<pj<VPlx~ >EltEE[~ jpbb_flP[N~ P[H_fX<lP_[~ <[B~ bPV_l~ >EO<rP_pf~ Pj~ [_t~ bf_@EjjP[N~ B<l<~ Hf_X~ KPNOl~ V_Nj~ <[B~ ExE lf<@TEf~B<l<
(113) ~ %<rP[N~ @_[JfXEB~ lOE~ >E[EJlj~ _H~ lOE~ jpbb_flP[N~ l__V~ P[~ lOE~. 67` 67`. EvbEfPXE[l~ tPlO~ OpX<[~ bPV_lj~ lOE~ [Evl~ epEjlP_[~ Pj~ l_~ Er<Vp<lE~. <bbVx~l_~lOE~BErEV_bXE[l~_H~ lOE~l__V
(114) ~ 2OE~ @_XbplEf~ <[<VxjPj~ _H~ _lOEf~ b_jPlP_[j~ H_f~ lOE~ jpbb_flP[N~ l__V~ jO_tj~ <~ BE@fE<jE~ P[~ EHJ@PE[@x~ _H~ lOE~ BPjbV<xEB~. o.
(115)
Documents relatifs
To this end, when it receives a message from one of its inputs informing it of a value change, a model agent recalculates the outputs val- ues of its model and informs its output
It presents a novel generic model facet for representing risk analysis and fault tree propagation in an agent model, where the goal is to simulate the behavior of a system in normal
The flux modulation, evoked previously, is a 3-D electromagnetic problem due to the intrinsic geometry of an axial-flux machine. This kind of numerical problem
From the model- checking result, we can derive such a policy rule (D p ) as ”clients, once called in the waiting room, should eventually enter the work room.” It is an instance of
The overall attenuation of the detector alarm is thus the sum of the attenuations for all rooms in the propagation path plus 10 dB for each closed door. The derivation
The antimicrobial activities of chito-oligosaccharides against four Gram-positive and seven Gram-negative bacteria were compared to chitosan and chitin with an emphasis on the
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
A ce titre, rappelons que la baisse de la consommation interne dans le pays producteurs traditionnels de pommes, permettrait, dans certains cas (comme la France ou