On the Choice of Similarity Measures for Image Retrieval by Example

Texte intégral

(1)On the Choice of Similarity Measures for Image Retrieval by Example Jean-Philippe Tarel. and. Sabri Boughorbel. INRIA, Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, BP-105 F-78153 Le Chesnay Cedex, France. Jean-Philippe.Tarel@inria.fr Sabri.Boughorbel@inria.fr ABSTRACT

(2)

(3) . &0!7 ;* 8 lP-(

(4) P+$J5. 8

(5) "P7E 1g*+, +M' ;!-. ; !! #"!$%'&( )*+, +. ! *7"

(6) ;7975."

(7) `2%_T87"

(8) . ;l?-. .7

(9) R5. %7"

(10) '&.! "

(11) "!$. '

(12) -. %! /-0 132465. 8795"!7 $:"! *"

(13) 8*+! +)' ;

(14) - . $: -. 8&0!7 ;*7E"

(15) ?9 @ ?,+M5 H ' '($:"! "

(16) . "! <!"!5. ,= ! . +1(

(17) >?@ A B(&C ' ?9 D7E"

(18) '&0 F. ;

(19) 1<"W5 l?-. ;"

(20) 3o<IJ50 <5 '>C ;X* )' ;!-. . "!G"!. 50f%-.V>C 6-0 1"7E"

(21) '&0 \I\"L$, ; - [N ;7E"! VI[+5(5.. H!>C ;1. 1.9!>.

(22)

(23) 2@465 81( IJ>0

(24) 7KA" $L-075M!. &F. & "N!795)=50 ;OIJ5+ 8H

(25) P-.%>C ="!$J&C"N>( 8*+, +. !' $, ; - <&0!7 p. '

(26) -. Q7 *>C 6 ; ;1RNI6 S1("." QKP"IG5"IG"= BP .1$: "! 5 T"!>9 ;1/ -+92DUT";I6

(27) ?5. T795"!7 " $V<

(28) "?"P1W*+! F. /5. T7"

(29) ? BPJ"!$O

(30) T.1 BP. (. P'*+! +H' ;!-. ;. +'

(31) -. X

(32) 1.T"H."!7 !> '>C = ;-+92'Y=,KP"IJ. I6 =&. "

(33) &C"

(34) ;13 q rP0st3$,"

(35) S%-'! ?2c4\I6"'1PnR ?J*F. 5. X5*75."!7 /% ;1M"Z5. /

(36) !>+++. " $L5 /! ! ;. +! +8' ;

(37) - ;[-0 ;18"

(38) 85 <!' T$, ; - &0

(39) 7E <! =-0-. ++. I[+5(G5. H!' W79,!2465 $:"!

(40) 6I\ W&. "!&C"N Z@'"P1 J" $. 7"!'&0! 1HZ J"!$Q&. 7E"!FY ;7+\1P!

(41) u"! W!

(42) .

(43) H E

(44) S. %!.1]1( ;1-.7 8@75. ' /$,"

(45) 1 ?.. 1.9!>.

(46)

(47) 2Dv6-(6!\." ,7E ;1*@q wP.x?Cyta?5. L795"!7 L"!$`* . 5 %>C ;* ^' ;

(48) - 8 E"!$6* ^' ;

(49) - ;. ' ;!-. 'X (A ;1)"Z5. !! !>(++M"!$S5. '$: -. . !-.*. A&.! !' E ,78'"P1 J" $5. 8

(50) , >+++]"!$T$, ; - . N ;79"

(51) 2\465(-.I\ <>0

(52) 1H"

(53) - L &.& "N

(54) 75W"!Z*9 7f!. +F.

(55) ;7E"

(56) OI[+5(5. \!' 679,!2D_L B(&C ' ?9 P! +1."!%" $. 2QzL

(57) '= Q"!$R&C"

(58) >( T*+! +%' ;

(59) - ;NI6 J& "

(60) &C"N. 5 T'"P1( `!01'5. T1 N 18*+! +/' ;!-. ;Q6&C $,"

(61) ' ;1. =75. ' 6$,"

(62) Q1 ?. T5 S>C \*+! +%' ;

(63) - 6%5D ;. "!@?5 7< ! "

(64) -01(Fa -(5^1. 9 >0! ;2bc0+?C$, "

(65) d"

(66) -. L BPF. $: "!{L&.! ' 7Q'"P1 EP"!$.5 \!! !>(++X" $.$, ; - 6N ;7E"! 2. &C ' P93I6 ' N ' N Q - ;"8$,"!+"Ie$:"! 5 *1( ;

(67) )" $ ! "

(68) -01(Fa -(5H1 9!>.

(69) ;J";I[. ' +!>( <7"

(70) .7E-0"

(71) .J"!85. }|P ;7E"

(72) ~?LI\ B(&C ' ?9+g5.";Ik'&. "N ' ?9%50 7 W>C = B(&C ;7E ;1/>?/I\ +f

(73) 1!&( %5. *+! +W' ;!-. T". ! 75W"!$f>C J*+! +H' ;!-. ;2. 5. <$: -. %&0!7

(74) 2fB(&C ' ?9L %(+W&C $,"

(75) ' ;1Z"

(76) @ $: -. &.

(77) 7 "!$D7" "

(78) T5("

(79)

(80) 0>-S"!5 LK?018"!$V$: -. . 1. INTRODUCTION ]! ! Z ! T. *>PG B '&

(81) [!*g!?. "!5 . 7E"

(82) '&.-( DP"

(83) / N5 [($:"! "

(84) "!$R? ;Q ;!795

(85) H'-.' h ;1)G5 W"!F7+ 1#

(86) 0-.

(87) 2g465. W " $\? "P1-.7E. 8-075A8-.'! 8L"8 1-07E X5. %!'"!-.?" $ ($:"

(88) "

(89) H"*>C =& "P7 ; ;1R2. 5(

(90) 51(' ."

(91) 0C&.

(92) 7

(93) 2DiZ ?%$: -. S&.

(94) 7 ;fI6 J& "

(95) &C"N 1 B(&C ' ?9 ++. 7"!'&0! 132. ='"P1 ."!$R! ! L ! 0 2V/|P ;7E"

(96) P?I6 S&. ; P "

(97) - J'"P1 `"!$V! ! = ! O. 2\465(S'"P1( 3 !N ;[5. 7 + "

(98) H%*+! +' ;!-. L%-0\ BP*h

(99) 2f465 /H|( ;79F "

(100) ]\I\ W&. "!&C"N ^795 ' /"A1 N /5. W>C * ' ;!-. <50 T%-.>C -0 ;1WA "!$[*+! +W' ;

(101) - ;. _SH! ! <J5(-.[ &. ; P 1H>?W%$, ; - XN 7E"

(102) J+( *W 01. &0!7 ; *,"8-0 ;1R2<465. %!. +,L"!$\5 ; ;-+9T ;l?-( . j) />C + N H5. g 0 +PF. H" $%5";Ik5."

(103) @$, ; - )&0!7 ;W A7E"

(104) '&0 ;1#8 ;l?- ;1 "Z& "

(105) ! ;M>.-(+,1P. Z>C =! !

(106) [ 2@mL$ 7E"

(107) -. !N5V!. +fV." f ;

(108) "T&C $,"

(109) WN!01<5. E$:"

(110) 6I\ $,"P7-0*"!g7E"

(111) '&0 . Z$: ;-. Z&.

(112) 7 % &. ? @G ; .7 5 !' *$,"

(113) "!M!>C"!-<! ! ;V>.-(=M1(+nR ?=I6;2 Z-075^*7!

(114) C+$Dl?-0!?h. % "

(115) L! =

(116) ."! ;13.I6"*$, ; - . !N 85. T9 7 O'"P1 R" $c5. L-0 ;1$: ;-. ;2D/5 T. EB( ;7E"!`.I\ =PN

(117) <&C"N>( <&.! !' E ,7'"P1( 6$:"

(118) L7" "! 5"!

(119) !d$: ;-. ;T$, "

(120) B(&C ' ?9V&C"!?="!$\? EI=2< |( 7E"

(121) @r8 01@xPCI\ *1( N =5. >C ;=*+! +^' ;!-. ;J$:"! I6 E+FYKP.";IJM&R1($:D-075M

(122) %z!-., `D-.(+$:"

(123) 01) B(&C"

(124) F af$:"! %1PnR ?* 9<"!$L*+! +A' ;

(125) - ;2Wj) *9 KN /

(126) 1PF !!?9! ! ="!$c5 ; =1 ! "!06"'7"!'&0! L5. '"P1( R"'%-F "

(127) .S"!Z(?5. 7T B(&C ' ?92D465 `(I6 =

(128) <"

(129) ' <7E-. "

(130) MIJ5(,75]&C ;7E+ C7"

(131) 0%@ ! "

(132) -..1(Fa -5. 1 9 >0

(133) 8%-.X$,"!+F. ";I#"<"

(134) >9/ E > 7"!07E-."!0Q5. \7!>C S-0 ;1%$,"

(135) 6" 5. 1.9!>.

(136) ;2. 2. SIMILARITY MEASURE OPTIMIZATION I\ +[KP.";IJ)50%

(137) W$: ;-. 8&0

(138) 7E

(139) D ;-+9X" $J*F ! ! ^

(140) G>C Z'& "N ;1-0/>?#>C 8795"!7 ^"!$ 5. **+! +A' ;!-.

(141) 2"! 1 ="W -) ,7X B(&C +F ' ?9?I6 T-0 T ! "

(142) -01(Fa -(5

(143) =1 9!>.

(144) ;[ 01/ +35. T EF -+96 =;N

(145) ;1"N [3l?- *! ! ;2Dbc (2Cy=5"IS\$: EI ! ! %7E! ;T$: "!d ! "

(146) -..1(Fa -5^1 9 >0

(147) X'2TT-0 ++?R.

(148) ! "

(149) -01(Fa -(5! ! J1.9!>0! 6Q7"!'&C"N ;1"!$R=\7E

(150) ;fI[5. $:" +";I[. 'I6"*&.! !' E o. 1P+nR ?SP-. V7E"

(151) ? ?926Q

(152) 75^7E

(153) S7"

(154) ?9.L<Q

(155) ;0" 5 /" 9 JP-.X>C <"!$S!

(156) X. 5 /1. 9 >0! 8*=. 2)b0"!. ¼ »C¼0½ ¾ ±(¿9À²f§kÃ ÁOÂ ± 8Æ ,Ä`Å. ?*l?-. XL"?"

(157) K<$: "

(158) 5. J1 9 >0

(159) !NI6 S ;7ED5. J<`7E"N ;

(160) ;2fj5 85 ;7"!

(161) +"

(162) WJ&C $: 7E;5 =7E"N L! ! ; +`$, "

(163) 5. 7E

(164) ["%IJ575H5. =l?- %>C "!. N2. ¼ ¾ À ². ±y². IJ5. S§Ç± ²`V5. Jl?-. X

(165) ;7E"

(166) D 01*ÀL§Ç±YÀ ²Oc5. 6$: -. N ;79"

(167) 6"*>C =7E"

(168) '&0 ;1'I[585. l?- ?2f. ·. ,\5 =1(' ."

(169) . "!$R$, ; - S

(170) ;7E"

(171) 2D465(QK?01%" $3*+! +*' ;!-. ;VI[!Q&. EF ?"

(172) -0+-0 1<I[+5*!1!!?9! ! ;c>?/q ~t"

(173) '¶\"! (

(174) [1 9 >0

(175) I[+5/7"!"

(176) \5"

(177) ! !2D.1 ;15. S-0 ;1'KN .\" $R5. J$:"

(178) ½ Ò È ¼0½ ¾ ±(¿À ²f§ÉNÊRË!ÌPÍ Î(ÏÑÐ 2VºT" ,7E 650 VIJ5 *Ó@§ÔyJ 01ÕAÖ}y! 5. S*+! +''

(179) -. . » Å ½ ¾ ±(¿9À²V ;1-.7 ;f"5. L× ¾. 1P9!07E

(180) 2. 0.48 L1 L 2 L∞. 0.46. 0.44. precision for recall=1. 8% 0.42. 4.7%. 0.4. 0.38. 4.2%. J,CO;]0%OPk@.0(';R R`8¡O¢0£`0' ¤¥9¢: YC (¡e£3¦{=8§dr g¨

(181) ©,0;(*,¢ª«. 0.36. §¬G:.0(®f( . 0.34. ¨

(182) ©,0;

(183) ¤ 0.32. 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. ¯LnR ?\ ! "

(184) -..1(Fa -5*1. 9 >0! ;Q5.

(185) S>C '-0 ;1%$,"

(186) Q"

(187) -. Q BPF &C ' P9"

(188) 0o. 0.4. 0.5 α. 0.6. 0.7. 0.8. 0.9. 1. J,RO;#Ø3)ÓOÙ¡c,.00A*,¢ª{¨N©,.;;:¨

(189) 0©×\Å Ú=×QÛZ0ÜO¡{×QÝ ¡c:¢CÜO¨

(190) (

(191) ¤ÞÓOÙ¡c,C;Cß®c©,0¢;¢ª`àPáC(;.0«®c;(¨N:;,CÜ. |7E . S1.9!>.

(192) L' °. áC(O%Ó\ÚD`;Ü`M;:©,0,¢9¦âP.O;. oV\7"

(193) .9Q"!$Os(yL7E! ;\"!$`¬*F. ! ! ;= ;

(194) 75G±Yx

(195) ~!¬!

(196) ²Ec 01@7"

(197) ?9 .=46³«> "N

(198) 17

(199) 9 !'&(

(200) ;[" $V?,1( "N&0P N2+2+2. XI6 EJKP"IJ)5. X5. /795"!7 8"!$T^ !"?"P1 bc 2[~@$:"! 8Óã§äy

(201) [5 Z-0 W" $× Û × Å. 7" "! V BP-. \¯ 9!>.

(202)

(203) 2Q¶\" "

(204) f

(205) !>+++<%

(206) 7E

(207) . |(5.!&C =¯=9!>.

(208) ' °. '& "

(209) ;%5.. 5 85.!â× Û. '&. "N 5 ;-(+98>? } EB( Gw!å/2. 1.9!>.

(210) ;2. oQJ[$:"

(211) ' 1H>?Hr 7E

(212) ;SI[5. çO K(";IJT5. '&C"! 9!.7 %" $J8 !"?"P1)795"!7 *" $6&.! !' EF <Ó\2'jA '1 .. *Ó`F1P!

(213) è

(214) 5. *7-. N %"!$J;N

(215) &. 7E+F. bc+¯= 9 >0

(216) 'T·o=7E"

(217) ?9 0x/7E

(218) ;[y¸

(219) ¸8! ! ; &C S7E

(220) <±Yx!¸!¸X! ! ;²E2Q465L1 9 >0

(221) [-0 18"

(222) (+8$,"

(223) . °. 5. /× Ý. |P*+! [ ;-(+9[I\ "!>0 N 18"

(224) H N 3"!5. [

(225) "

(226) -01PFY -(5. 2. ¬X! ! ;[&C S7E

(227) <±Yw

(228) x r%

(229) ;²E2 °. Õ}7!M'&. "N. ;-(9'>?G?åæ;N

(230) Z& ;7E"

(231) `2iW"! "N J5. W-. Z"!$. 7E

(232) L"!$D¬

(233) ;J ;!79532QYJ,[ BP !7E ;18$, "

(234) µv6 "P1.h 6 J'&C"

(235) 9 ?[50!/Z'. ¤. ! ! 8 ! S ;-(92b0"! X09 07

(236) \

(237) X5.";IJG"

(238) . 4O BP- ¯ 9!>.

(239) %'T´9oJY ! "

(240) -.&.x ¬N~*

(241) ;JP"/s!s °. »R¼0½ ¾ ÚVCÜg'. "

(242) @IJ5. ZI6 %

(243) Z&0 !' LÓg@*+! +'

(244) -. . »C¼0½ ¾. Ô±y;²E6$:"! 8@ !N GÕQ2gbc 26~ !N ;'7"

(245) '&.! "

(246) g>C I\ . &R1($O .. %

(247) J1 ;7E >C 18^|( ;79"!^wP2. ÓOF1(

(248) !6$,"

(249) [Õ@§Ôy

(250) (Õ@§â~%!.1/Õ@§âé=ê#2D4O ;9[50;N T>C . ¶\"

(251) EC¯= 9 >0! T'S oVYQ7"

(252) ?9 .6xPyS79,! ;

(253) ¸T! ! ;. 7" "! X5("

(254)

(255) W2/465. '"!>9 ;1A7- N ;& ; ?H BP%-. &C $,"

(256) ' ;1W"!^'. 2J465 % !0 - <-0 ;1HT'&(/5. <ëSzTv. ! "!-..1@¸Pì (2jA &C $:"

(257) ' 1Z 9L"

(258) Z5 X" 5. L

(259) "

(260) -01PFY -(5. &C \7E

(261) T±Y~?y;

(262) ¸<!

(263) ²E2fD,D BP

(264) 7E 1'$, "

(265) e5. L¶\"

(266) . 1.9!>.

(267) ;S'. 1.9!>.

(268)

(269) 2. 0' ´. !.1W'LC 01/I\ <"

(270) >9. ;185 <!'. K?01^"!$J5.!&C ;TI[+5)ëSzTv{7E"!"

(271) <5"!

(272) !2'iW"

(273) "N `5. &C"N+"

(274) " $=5. ZB(X-.í!! ;/++ 1( &C .1(. )" $=5.. ¹D ;7E"

(275) (FY ;7 +c1(! ! !J! TI[1( +8-. ;1'"% ! -0 T! !. 1.9!>.

(276)

(277) 2Ç465. $,"

(278) ^5. ZÓOF1P,

(279) î /+G ;1. E

(280) f 2SºT N 5. ;CI\ %1( ;7E1 ;1H"-. X"!+H5. "

(281) (+Z"/5 %-0 1Z$, ; - '&0!7

(282) 2ºT" 7 X5. < A!1 ;l?-0 XÓ. ;N !

(283) '& ;7E"

(284) A"H7"

(285) '&.! %1(+nR ?<*+! +' ;

(286) - ;2. ±Óà§æ¸(ì AI[+5gÕ«§ïy²X'&. "N ;%5 ^;N ! ! Z&. ;79,"!>P. jA /1 .. ;1A5 8;N !

(287) /&. 7E"!M"@>C '5 8;N !

(288) /"!$J5. '"

(289) L50!HsNåã7"!'&0 ;18"X5 =Q-.7E+1 ; Z1(9!.7. P-%>C =" $L E

(290) P! ! H '"

(291) . 85. / . » Å ½Û 2. N ;1A

(292) ; 465. `\I\ ^795 ;7KN ;1)50'5. W*+! +G' ;!-. H7!]>C W"

(293) &(F. "N L+`5 <lP- '! ! ;["!$V5. 1. 9 >0!

(294) 2. *h ;1$,"

(295) "!5. $, ; - 8&.

(296) 7 2Zbc 2VZ5";ISÓOF1P,

(297) jg5"

(298) -(!?@"!5. =K(";I[ 1

(299) !O5. %>C ;* @' ;

(300) - . $:"! o. 5.

(301) c">C [ ! 75. ;1XI[+5'S>. -( \$:"! 7 S!&.& "N!79532f465. [7E"

(302) '&.-(F. -. [b0"

(303) - /1 ;7 &("

(304) *$:"! EB(- 8$, ; - ;JëSzTv7" "!. \1(

(305) mT ?9 "

(306) âUS,"!

(307) ð± "!5C²^q t$,"

(308) Z5.!&C Z$: ;F. 9"

(309) 067E"N<"!$Q5 &.&. "

(310)

(311) 75@'&( ;T5. I\ %X-0 1-07E. 5"!

(312) !µ 01çc &

(313) 7E 8I6 E !5? ;18ëSzTvg7"!"

(314) J5(,"!

(315) èq ¬t. 5 / ;! 75)"@Z +[ X"!$L*+! +A' ;

(316) - ;2Zj) '5.

(317) . $:"! 67" "

(318) \$, ; - ;2f*5(,D B(&C ' ?fÕ^§Ôy

(319) ( 01%5P-0NIJ5 . 1-07E *"

(320) - N ;T"85 ' <" $[*+, +@' ;

(321) - ;TI[+55. Ó. §«y!C5. <-0 ;1^*+! +Z'

(322) -. 1H,J5. X7E

(323) 7\×\Å1PF.

(324) N 1g

(325) ;$: "!. 0.48. 0.46. I6". l?-. ;8! @

(326) ++â1PnR ?;. N ^+$D5. ; Xl?-. ;T! XZ5. X!' X7E

(327) 2v6-(;C5L& "

(328) &(F. rgb−hist laplrgb−hist four eoh. Z,"!=

(329) + 0 ;1ZIJ5. ^5. !

(330) X ! D>?Z B!'&( $:"! %-(, ;1)!H7E

(331) + C7"

(332) . &. "!> k>C ;7!-0 '5 '7E

(333) <"!$. 5. <l?- 8J." TKP.";IJ32\j) <& $: 5. E$:"

(334) !0"'>C L!(F +(h %IJ5. -.-0 ++^&C $,"

(335) ' ;1W@

(336) * ! D . 0.44 precision for recall=1. >?/ B!'&

(337) 2 0.42. -. ++?

(338) ?-0P

(339) \($:"

(340) "

(341) Xc & ; ? ;1<>?S$: -. N ;79"

(342) "! 1 3"[.7 ;! 6&C ;1< 01T"S;N Q' '"

(343) ?2OzLN Z$: ;-. H

(344) ;7E"

(345) *lP- )PDI6 W1( 0 '5. /

(346) "NS"!$=@7"!P PF. 0.4. >0! ;1M ! S è"@ E N /5 /$, ; - HN 7E"

(347) <50 ! [5 S'"

(348) fKN EX"=>C [*5 J!' S7E

(349) Q

(350) V5. Sl?-. ?2O465.. 0.38. M1P+nR 07E

(351) f7"!'&0! 1@I[+5. 7E

(352) + C7 "

(353) G!&&. "

(354)

(355) 75`V. 50LI\ %1("."!LKP.";I}5. XlP- H7E

(356) 2Sj) J-.KP.";I}50 T 0.36. [X 01"!ã ;h;"

(357) W" $O+9[7E

(358) 2\465. 3( !N 8!?'$: -. N ;79"

(359) <ÀX5 %1 9 >0

(360) !O5. X&. "!> dT"H1 ;7E1( X+$JÀ* 01. 0.34. 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5 α. 0.6. 0.7. 0.8. 0.9. J,CO;'ñ3[Ó`Ù¡c,C;CASCS¡còQ(;.ÜC¢[Y(¢O;X;®O0¨

(361) ([CÜ`¡ Õ]§y

(362) ¤)óH(¡Ô;(®c;(.ÜC¢¢;,RÜOW.;RWôT¡O.]õ',ÜC¢.¢,RÜ. 1. ! <Z5. !' X7E

(363) T"! T"!;2L$f5. P-.%>C ["!$\!'& ;J ! ! H "

(364) -. !5`V5(,l?-. ;"!]7!M>C /!.I6 ;1M>?M9,7 ;. (2fT($:"

(365) -0 +??'5 T7"!? BP6"!$3! ! L ! aPI6 "

(366) (+H5.

(367) TI\"'!'&( oQÀ 018P2. öH:¢0C;0ø÷PRªVùHYC)ª`.®VRÚORO,(¡O(;¨N:®O¢CAYC ¢(ú3¢O;CÚ/ûü8ýþ¨!C©,Cg0ÜO¡µÿQ.®c©,0¨

(368) ,CÜµX(,RªC¢(¡ûü8ý. 1000 d 11 d. ¨!C©,CHªO:¢000A

(369) ¤. 12. 900. 800. 9 07 !2=v\Z-.(. '5. &0 !' LÓ\RI6 X! %!> "/'&. "N 5 [;N

(370) J&. ;79,"!*-.&"=Nå$,"

(371) fëSzTv. 700. 7"!"! D5("

(372)

(373) e!01. '"! 50 yå«$,"

(374) Jb0"!-. S1 ;7E &("

(375) $:"

(376) [09 07 !2 b. "

(377) ï"

(378) - *$: I-. B(&C ' ?9[!G07 ;! ^"!$~!åæ"!$<;?F !

(379) & ;7E"

(380) )"!7 ; >

(381) 2HA&.! 7-(, 5 *"

(382) 1( . Z" $ 5 ' N ;1@

(383) ; '&. "N 132H465<.1(7 V5.";I '&C"! 9!?[[5 < ;! 75W" $V>C S*+, +8' ;

(384) - ;2. number. 600. 500. 400. 300. 200. 465 ) I6"G â&. "

(385) >( /I[+5â5. @ B(&C ' ?9 < &F & "N!795Z1( ;7 >C ;1/>C $:"!

(386) 2Dbc ;(+J,6"!J&C"

(387) >( <"X&C $:"! EB&C ' P9f"

(388) +C5. J&C"N> T*+! +'' ;

(389) - ;V50 \"

(390) 7!W!

(391) 05 < ;! 75^&0!7 =,J"?"*!

(392) !2L|( ;7"!0185 <>C ; *+! +' ;!-. *="

(393) >9. ;1A"!+@$:"

(394) Q

(395) "!-..1(Fa -5 1 9 >0

(396) V!.1Î\ *50;N ."H7E-. X5.";I{5T ;-(+<

(397) +h ; "X,

(398) L1.9!>.

(399) ;2 465 W 0 N /"Z5. / B(&C ' ?9 [ &.& "N

(400) 75. ,"@'"P1( .

(401) = ! O Q"% "%& "

(402) ! ;J/5. =" -("

(403) W" $ 5 ; <I6"/&. "!> 2Sb0 "!u''"P1 EV"!$D5. <"

(404) >. N ;1Z&C - F >. "

(405) .D" $R5. 6$: -. S&.

(406) 7

(407)

(408) I6 S5.";I# BPf5.";IG"<1 N 65 >C S

(409) "P7E 1Z*+! +8'

(410) -. LI[5(W* J" $f*+, + '

(411) -. 2. 3. STATISTICAL MODEL ¶\"!? ! H"Wq x;ta.I6 <>C + N 5. J! ! =

(412) c>?/ B!'&( 5"

(413) -(,1Z"!>C <'"P1( ;1^

(414) T7E! 07 "!A&. "!> W2S.1 13 79,!+$,P. @W1.9!>.

(415) / +";IS! ! '

(416) aV>.-(1"? ;=." . 100. m11 0. 0. 0.5. 1. m12 1.5. 2. `GôLú3CA®c©g0':ÜR¢;;(Ù¡c:¢0ÜO¨

(417) ÅÅ CÜO¡eÜC¢(;Ù ÅÛ ¡c:¢ ,£V`¢;,CÜOYCâûü8ý P.¢;O;eáC(¨

(418) ¢C Cþ¢;ª`¢9 ¨N©,0;(¡c:;®O©,P¦C¡:ÜâJ,`¤ g ÷¨!0¢;©,CÜO¡ cÜOP¢*;R ¢;ª` . C;(©6¡O.¢0£O.0ù;¤ J,RO;. ¡c:¢CÜO¨

(419) . b0"! '!KN 8"!$'&(+,79?fI6 W-&.&C"

(420) H50*"

(421) (+MI6"1(+nR P.

(422) JÅ8 01 [ÛH! Z;! +!>( WG5. Z1 9!>.

(423) Z 01 50 Å 2ã465. 1. 9 >0! W "g

(424) -.' 1#

(425) "

(426) -01PF -532Hj5 À/ "^>C "

(427) .

(428) " Å O5. /* )' ;!-. §C ±(¿À ²50!ZG& "

(429) >0 >+++}1( >.-("

(430) â$:-..7E"

(431) e±&R1($9² ÅÅ ± ²E2j5 }À>C "

(432) N8" Û T 1(+nR ?8&R1($ ÅÛ ± ²' "

(433) >(9 . 1}$:"!

(434) Z5";IJÔbc 2Lg"!ÔG ; I\"#7E! ; 1.9!>.

(435)

(436) 2H465. 1P,9 07 §C ±(¿9À²T>C I6 )W 01)À*< +F I[*&C"N+N ^ 01M5(-.%&R1($: ÅÅH!.1 ÅÛW Z1 .. ;1 "

(437) (+ 7E

(438) . M>C "

(439) N8". "

(440) q ¸(¿Eé=ê)ta2V-. ++?(!

(441) L

(442) 3 e\ lP-(

(443) P. &C $:"

(444) !OI6 +.

(445) f7E

(446) 7.! ! 6 ! ( ;75.l?-. 2cb0 "!. "@^"

(447) '"!. 7E

(448) + 07 "

(449) H&C"!?6"!$`? I=P

(450) L

(451) C6 /

(452) D 001PF. ! ! '"!$Q5. *1 9 >0

(453) !2465. E$:"

(454) !c !N )/1(9!.7 *5. ;5"!1. *!&.&(. %$, "

(455) 5. 1.9!>.

(456) =!

(457) J"*5 < T" $D7E

(458) >C 2)465 $:"!

(459) D$J5 *

(460) / ! J X&C $, ;7E;. X65 H N 1. N # G

(461) Z1( ;IJG$: "!ï7E

(462) . X2. +Ì[+5(. ! ! ;. _ÇK

(463) Z!1!!?9! ! " $f

(464) ! V>?W EB. '& C50L5. 2.5. distance. 5 / *" $1P,9 07 %"!$J5. 8l?-. "^ ;

(465) 75M*F. 5. =P-.X>C 6" $D

(466) ;LÀ<" ´ $ Å I[5^%";I6 T1P,9 07 =5.! "ZPc%<a'ÅÅ

(467) ± ²<§< ÅÅ!± ² 2Z'ÅÅ*>?A1 .+"

(468) 5. 7-.X- N L1( >.-("!8$,-.079"!A±a71P$9²\"!$ ÅÅ 2Q|P*+, +? 5. P-.X>C J"!$D

(469) ;ÀX"!$[Û<I[+5@";I6 =1(9!.7 X5.! ´ "^(VX ÅÛ ± ²X§µ ÅÛ ± ² 2@465P-0f5. '"!9[P-.*F >C *" $= N 1 ! ! ;%%5P-0*<±a'ÅÅ

(470) ± ²Dé*ÅÛ

(471) ± ²²E2]465..

(472) æ§ Ï ´Ò#!" Ï ´Ò !$ Ï ´:Ò 2 d 5 ;N

(473) & ;7E"

(474) /I6 L? "P1-.7 ;1'/5 T&. P"!-06 ;79"!`2 &C 7 ?9! ! Z"!$= !!?'! ! ;%. I[+5W ;&C ;79S"*¸(2D.1 ;1RPI6 =50;N !o. ±aN² 6O±)(R²f§ ~y 9: É?± ( é<~ ; ²É?± Æ (~ é=; ²>; % 2f465P-0A@

(475) O§ Æ À;`5.

(476) Q=7 ? ;1' 01 Æ À; Æ W. 465 Z BP*h; "

(477) ]"!$<;N !

(478) Z& ;7E"

(479) g'-0 1]]5. 8$:"!+F ";I[. /"87E"

(480) '&0 =I6"/1PnR ?=*+, +Z' ;!-. ;J"

(481) Z5 ' $: ;-. <&.

(482) 7

(483) 2. ?;N`§ 7"!P ?>@ § "H % 2 I[+5. ('' 7=&R1($DIJ5. ÀXLZ5. * ' %79,!T50 @P2XmTZ5.. v\-6 5. f50 5. ;5"!1*"

(484) '5. S1P,9 07 !?

(485) J ! >C E <-0 '85 ;5." 1A"

(486) @5. *P-.X>C " $[ N ;1

(487) ;2V="

(488) - 3I6"S7E

(489) ;c& "

(490) >( W;I6 D. ;1T"J - w!¸

(491) åâ" $ 5 "!9OP-.X>C 6" $c!

(492) J85 <1.9!>0!

(493) 2D$c5 ! . JÅ2}4`". '&C $, ;7E;S +L5. W

(494) ;1G! ! ;! W. E N Z . 1-07E ;6"o. }§'ÅÅ!±±a*ÅÅQéM'ÅÛ² Ê . IJ5 . X-0%>C Z795"N G#-075] ²;é*'ÅÛ

(495) ± ²f§Çy!N 01<5(-.`5. \;N ! ! [&. ;79,"!.

(496) ;65 ;5." 1. I65. D*ÅÅ!±. Å. ±y²². ±Y~!². 1"? ;/."!H!&&C ;! H!?('"

(497)

(498) 2{465//++-0 ;1#. %. &%. bc (2PwLI[+5%I\"T$ \ &0 6z -0!'&R1P$NIJ5 . ÅÅ 01. ÅÛ. =5. ' ; H" $c5. T? FQ!.18? F1(9!.7 ; ;&C ;7EN E?2 jA '.";I«. ;1@"WKA71P$'ÅÅ'!.1)'ÅÛ*"H5. '&R1P$<"!$[5. ' Ð )± (R²V§**±)(,+ %±

(499) ²²`>C \5. Q&R1($."!$.$, ; -

(500) ;7E"

(501) -(âK(";I[ M5. 7E

(502) H" $5 Al?- #P 01*V ±)R( ²^§ *±)(+ %±YÀ²²`>C Q5. 6&R1P$0"!$5. [79,!D" $RÀ\X5 [1.9!>0!

(503) 2f465 ; &R1P$J! <1( 0 ;1"

(504) 85 T$: -. <&.

(505) 7 // . (Y2 0W ( >C E"!.

(506) J"8 . 2 21. 3.æ-.-0+g@$, ; F. $,-++gKP"IJ32â_ . /1( 7-(+. %50 . À 50!Q"

(507) (+X('' 76&R1P$3I[+5 ;&C ;79.

(508) B DC C 5 5 E6 5. X? F1P9!5 07E ÅÅ 5 5. *-k"

(509) A +\7"

(510) '&C"!. ?9T" $65. ? F1(9!.7 ÅÅ 2c J5 \7E ? ?+*`5. "! e±a!015P-0 5

(511) !07E L$:"! q t:²EP5 L&R1P$F ÅÅ 7"

(512) PN ! ;Q" F

(513) -*. < 0+ S. 465. @&R1($" $5 @? F1P,9 07 L$:"! H"

(514) A7E"

(515) '&C"

(516) ? S Å Å O± Ê ± ²² Ê ± ²E2S465 &R1P$f"!$f5. ? F1P,9 07 <J5 7"

(517) (F Å Å N" -("

(518) ^"!$ O± Ê ± ²² Ê ± ²[I[5W+9 +$O·'' 2J01( ;1R. 6. I[ 1.S'z!-.!^1( >.-("

(519) `(IJ5. Z·' !"? ;["% 0(+?2D_. *+, = ;-+7 A>C %1 N ;1Z$:"! 5. ? F1P,9 07 Wq tao5.. . &R1($. ÅÛ. 7"

(520) PN

(521) ;"I6! 1HGz!-., Ô1P >-"

(522) 3LIJ5 . ·G !"? ;8"M 0(+?2«_T/!++-. "

(523) 3I[+5}X·}§. G. ? F1(9!.7. ÅÅ. . !.1^? F1(9!.7. z!-.!^1( >.-("

(524) 02. $, ; - [N ;7E"! 2cç` . &

(525) 7E7 +=,L."! ; +7%"H!-.' X5. 5 ; %&R1P$ . Æ. H. y;s!¸(. "!$Qbc 23/"?"!KWKN. ÅÛ. "!$c N ;18

(526) ;. *ÅÛ

(527) ± ~ <. ²3éM'ÅÅ

(528) ± ². - Z&0!7 W" $5 !5#1(' ."

(529) 0+?2#_L*A7E"

(530) 0 lP- 07E

(531) \5. 1P ;7EJ '&+. "!$35. ; L&R1($Q ;l?- ;6=!

(532) T(-%>C f" $O*F

(533) %!'& ;3"!&C"

(534) > X"8

(535) 75 N <^&.

(536) 79,7E

(537) 2<465P-0C5 7E"

(538) '&C"

(539) ?9S" $Q5 =$: ;-. %

(540) ;7E"

(541) T! X

(542) -' ;1H01 &C 01( ?.

(543) *±)(R²X/. $, "

(544) . ;

(545) 75"!5 2{465(8!-.'&"!#' ;!.*50 . . . . ÅÅ ± ². & "P1-.7ES"!$Jy¯{&R1P$C 018[5P-0[ ;

(546) S"!'&( !2[_Ç ;7E"

(547) 01. 21. 1P 7-+%D5. D5Q'"P1( .D+C"?"7"!'&+7 ;1%$,"

(548) [T$,"

(549) F R!. +2\_LQ7"!0 ;l?-. 07

(550)

(551) '5 L& "

(552) &C"N 1&.! ' 7. 1P9!07E. '"P1( aO5 '7"

(553) '&C"!. ?9T" $65. X$: ;-. 'N ;79"

(554) <! '!-.' ;1. %. .1 &C .1 ?6!0150;?. <5. T!' TK?01'" $c&R1($3I[+5H1P+nR ? &.! ' 2Vb0"! \'&( J1(

(555) "

(556) 0

(557) I6 S "

(558) -' 650 f5. I J$ Ê Û I . ÅÅ. %. threshold ÅÛ. . "!+H1(+nR ?J&0 !' 6,[5. T' ;!8"

(559) H

(560) 75Z7"

(561) '&C"!. ?;2 iW"! /$,"

(562) +?VI\ H!-.' '; Æ !.1MÀ; Æ À;T! '+1)I[5 !.1)À ! *5 *7"!'&C"

(563) . P9L"!$[. 87 ? ;1@&R1($6É?RIJ5 ' 01À% ;&C ;7EN E?2. 4(O2. !! >. (A1 "! ;L5 % B(&C ;799 "

(564) @"!$68 !.1"!. LK3NMZc^£VÇ.]:.0(Ç;P¢;,PáC(¡;R ¢ª3 O(¡e.A. J,RO;. ¡O¢0£O.0@cÜO¨

(565) ¢,RÜ«0¢ª3¡c:¢0ÜO¨

(566) ¢ªO;(ª`C©,¡Q¤. O. 465. <I\"&R1($. 4. OPTIMIZATION CRITERION 5(,^ ;79"!Ì6 &.&. ";BP A5 M;N

(567) . . &. ;79,"!. ]±Y~

(568) ²L"H>C E <!. +(h %+9KWI[55. *7E ? ;1&R1P$6É'" $ $, ; - <N ;7E"! J7"

(569) '&C"!. ?92 zT . +?P*+! +X' ;!-. ;V&. "!&C"N ;1%%5 \++ - L -"!$J*+! +@' ;!-. ;" $65. *7"

(570) '&C"!. ?92'465P-.`5. 0C±(¿9À²67 W>C IJ + Z!o. 1P9!07E. C±(¿À ²f§ 6 )( %. Ä Ã. 5. Á ,Ä`Å. ± Æ. À ². 7(. %. ç` O± 0²C>C f5. f&R1($("!$P5 D 01("

(571) }

(572) , > ; CO§; Æ À Æ W § Æ À 2Q|?.7 S Æ !.18À Æ À 50;N L!' S&R1($`ÉN. I[+5. 81. 6O±)(CY²c\=('' 7\$:-07E"

(573) . +Q,f." [1P '7-+D"=&. "N [50. ÅÅ. P. 01. ÅÛ. >C . /!&&. ";BP N +Wz!-0 `. 5. E! J-.' h ;1=>?=5. V' ; % 01<

(574) , 07 !2f465. 6' !. Q%^ÅÅ)Û § ÅÅ!±)@(²Z§ ±)@(² ²E2 5. "!$<5 ^? F1P,9 07 ZH'&(] !N >P Û · ± (²E2fY9[

(575) , 07 ± (² Æ ÅÅ §·.±. 5. )@. @. 5. )@. 465. Q7! Q" $? F1(9!.7 VO6+ D'"

(576) D7"!'&+7 ;1R2Oj5 . E% ! T

(577) TI[+5H &C ;7E6" @!`5 %I\"H&R1($:0ÅÅX!.1RÅÛ*! $ <!&.! ;`!.1Z5 % ! D d !N ;L&C $: ;79< ;-+92_ '"

(578) = +,7X+-0 "!^[IJ5. H % DS +OI[+5Z ;&C ;79L" 5. *9!01! 1)1( ? "

(579) )" $O@ 28465="

(580) >. ! "

(581) A ;!1.<-0T" &C $,"

(582) « 7"

(583) .1"! 1 \4cP"! \ B(&.!0"!'"

(584) ±)@ é% ²VI[+5 5 ;&C ;79S"G%Wo ±)! @ CéSW % Y²T ±)

(585) @ Y²3é<H % C ±)

(586) @ Y²3é ~y % Û C C ±)

(587) @ ² 5 5 5 5 5. T1(+nR ?J7E"

(588) '&C"

(589) ?6' ; 0 5. *9!01! 11 ? "

(590) "!$. j#+5*5D!&&. ";BP"

(591) `

(592) I6 L1 ;1(-07 65. D5. J' ;!%"!$RP F.

(593) Ä Û CC Å C ± Æ @(²J§ Æ % C Å±)Û @(§²E2= j#ÅÛ +±)@(5^² T5. Xh· 5 ±)"/@(²;"

(594) é 1ÛE U B(Ä`&0ÁÅ 0Â % "

(595) 35 `±)5@( X²O!!. 7+ F 5 07 \"!$(5. Q5 ? F1(9 07 D,F@?ÅÛVTX·.± Û ±)@(² Æ ±)@(² Û ²E2`j) fI[+ T (506+6[-W 1 7E ?["-0 "! 15 \h "X5 $,"

(596) J7"!0 ? EB&.!."!W"!$ % 2 465 I6"&R1($:X ÅÅ=!.1P ÅÛ<>C 8 &.& "BP N EWz!-.!` +6 "%+";IS6-.D"1 N S<'& D ;l?-0"!'$:"

(597) Q5. S;N ! ! & ;7E"

(598) {±Y~!²E2Çj) @1( ." !?RY ±)C( ²W§ Z Å Û\[ ÉNÊ $^ ] $ 5 1-07E ;1Wz -0!W&R1P$!.1P% _ ±)R( ²V§ Ê ] Ý RY ± ² +9[71($2%_ ±)R( ² =,"HK(";IJ!T5. X "

(599) $,-.079"!`2v\@('' 8"!$ % _ ±)R( ² 01].7 @ ÅÅ §`@ ÅÛ J!5.";IJ]gbc (2JwP\I6 Z1( ;1-.7 H50 § I " Û I J$ S5. IJ5 &_ ÅÅ ± ´ Z Ê Ia ! ²3é _ ÅÛ ± ´ ZÊ aI !J$ $ ²\§{y

(600) 2 b. "

(601) ±Y~

(602) ²E(I6 5 W1( ;1-.7

(603) o bT_%± % Å~dÛ c Æ @ Å% Å ÅÅ ² ±N² b. "

(604) ã±N²E!IJ5 X5 \c."L1(+nR .7 \%' !0Q±)% ÅÛ §% ÅÅ ²E 5 I6"87E

(605) ;5.;N < B

(606) 7E+W5 % ' X&R1P$\ 01W5P-0[5. F ! . { !N DT7"

(607) '&( E +% 01"!Ç ;-(;

(608) Y2 } §¸(ì wP2 ºL";I=?I6 S-.>.-( [5. ["

(609) >(9 . 1*' ;!.Q 01*!! !.7 ;f"!$7 ÅÅ 01

(610) ÅÛ H5 =;N

(611) =&. 7E"!M±?²Eo Û C C ±)(@ ² bTe_%±f ~ · % ² ±Yw!² 5Û ~Wg ±)( @ ² Æ ±)(@ ² Û 5 5 465([!T ;l?-. "

(612) /,6'&C"

(613) 9 ?J07 +L +";ISS-.\"*&. ;1P7E 1P9!07E 6,. °. mT. &.! !' E [&R1($:oQ¹V" "

(614) `.DB(&C"!. ? a2 °. 4\I6"J&0 !' R&R1($:oOëLP E !5`;jA >.-+a!z!'P z!-.F , `.T+$,"

(615) µ!.18ç`"

(616)

(617) "

(618) Y2. q yEtY5 f!-5"

(619) `9! ;1T"[PN ; N Q9,7 (!&&. "

(620)

(621) 75. ; $:"! L'"P1( +. *7E"

(622) ? ?FY>0

(623) 18 ! O !015. 8," PN ; N ;1MH&0 !' 7% W"!$S7E"

(624) '&C"

(625) ?<&R1($:2WºT PF 5 ;0"!-. S!&&. "N!7958-. 06"!-J"*>C = 5. S1(+nR PS1(-. "85 %$!7E<50=I6 1"8."

(626) -.' X50 +Q5 *&0 !' ! [$,-++%KP.";IJ%IJ5 X5 [ ! C {& "P7 ; ;D=l?-. ?2 465O ;!1.V-0`"T ;! 75X$,"

(627) c5 \>C ;D*+! +<' ;!-. Q 5. "% 0$:"! ã5. &R1P$["!$O5. =7"!'&C"

(628) ?9\?"X-.+$,"

(629) &R1($:2. 5 J;N ! ! [&. ;79,"!'"

(630) >9. ;1%>?X!X

(631) [ ! . W. 3@^"!$[$, ; - /

(632) ;7E"

(633) 7"!*F 2@465 5 "!$5 lP-. "

(634) ]"

(635) &C .%5. W&C"

(636) >++g" $<!. +P7 T-01P * KP"I[ W5. *&R1P$["!$[5 '1(+nR .7. &C"!. ?9D!%H$:-07E"!M"!$J5. /7"!'&C"

(637) . PX1P,9 07. "!& V*+! +Z' ;

(638) - X>.

(639) ;1W"!Z5. <$: ;-. N ;7E"! T&R1($ ÉN($:"! S-.-0`! ! = ! O. 2. '_. jA [1 ."! 6