The origin of 26Al in the Galaxy

HAL Id: tel-00145359

https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00145359

Submitted on 9 May 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-lished or not. The documents may come from

teaching and research institutions in France or

abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

publics ou privés.

The origin of 26Al in the Galaxy

Jürgen Knödlseder

To cite this version:

Jürgen Knödlseder. The origin of 26Al in the Galaxy. Astrophysics [astro-ph]. Université Paul

Sabatier - Toulouse III, 1997. English. �tel-00145359�

                !  " # $ % $ & ')(* )+ ,)() - . / 01 $ 2 % 0" $ 3  .  %  4  " 0$ 2 5 $ " 6 .  6 . % $ & 7 8 ' 9:7 ; , )+ ,<7 + = 8 = <& 97>? ) = ) 5 6 @ " 6 2  " 5 $  . / 01 $ 2 % 0" $ 3  .  %  4  " 0$ 2 A

& )(B<C 9<,)( D E *, '7 & FG *<H 8 ) ), , )BF + <H 8 ) * * & C ,<C 9)*

& C ' I J K L M N O P O J Q R ST N R N L U VW XYV Z [\ X] ZV ^_ `Xa`bV Z Vc d `efW W Vg VWXc hi `jVW ]V U fbfWVbkd flm V n o pqpr q stuv w f]bf] cV U \ x \ y z d { | U \

hh
   \ x d \ | | \ o YfVccV] Y `
b[ o ^ i w f]bf] cV o YVcaZ VW X  U { ^ ^\ WVW aV] Y ZV d Vlm VYlm V i U \ { ^ `lb`e d `_ _ fYXV] Y {  { \ x \ d o YfVccV] Y
` b[ W ajVYcaXV ZV  VW
VjV d `_ _ fYXV] Y d  x \  x aYV lXV] Y Z V d VlmVYlmV i o \  `Ylm aW \  `g aW `XV] Y   { d x U m `YV ZV d Vlm VYlm V i U \ ^d w f] bf] cV \  `g aW `XV] Y |  o d { | w  ^ U m `YV ZV d Vlm VYlm V i U | d ^ { o o `Yac \  `g aW `XV] Y  ko  d   \ ^ U m `YV ZV d Vlm VYlm V i U \ ^d w f] bf] cV \  `g aW `XV] Y ^   { U  { d o YfVccV] Y
` b[ o ^ i w f]bf] cV \  `g aW `XYalV o    | n {     ^ o YfVccV] Y
` b[ o ^ i w f]bf] cV \  `g aW `XV] Y w m V YV`cV`Ylm ZVclYa VZ aW Xmac XmV cac  `c c] _ _ fYXVZ  e Xm V \ ] Yf_ V`W U fg g ]W aXe XmYf]m Y`WX W ]g  VY \ d n z n U w h tqv 

w

        ss | ] lbV`Y { cXYf_ me calc `W Z  kY`e { cXYfWfg e                 s su   cVYj`XafW f XmV svth V  aWV                     u sq w m V d `Zaf`lXajV cfXf_ V { b                         p sqs | ] lbVfce WXm Vcac f { b                        p squ `ccajV ^X`Yc                             r sqq { ceg _XfXal  a`WX n Y`W lm ^X`Yc                   sqp U fYV U fbb`_ cV ^] _ VYW fj`V                      h sq | fj`V                                 ss sqr { b  aVbZ \ cXag `XVc                         su sq W XVY`lXafW f U fcg al d `e c  aXm Xm V WXVYcXVbb`Y V Za] g     uu sp   VlXajV f Xm V w m Vcac                            uu                ! u s accafW U fW lV_X                               u  u u o YaW la_ bV f V `c]YVg VW X                          ur u q W cXY] g VW X x VclYa_ XafW                            u uqs x VXVlXfY x VcaW                            u uqu W cXY]g VW X d Vc_ fW cV x VclYa_XafW                  uv u qus \ WVYe d Vc_ fW cV z] W lXafW                 u h u quu { W ]b`Y d Vc_ fW cV z ]W lXafW                uh u p W cXY] g VW X`b n `l"Yf] W Z   ^] _ _YVccafW                  qu u   W cXY] g VW X`b n `l"Yf] W Z   fZ VbbaW                   qq us n `l"Yf] W Z aW \ W VYe ^_ `lV                     qp u ss n `l"Yf] W Z f ZVb                     qp

u  su ^_ V lXY` f ^VbVlXVZ d VafW c                qp u  u n `l" Yf] W Z aW g `aW  x `X` ^_ `lV                 q  u  u s w m V ^X`W Z `YZ sv V n `l"Yf] W Z f ZVb        q  uu u W lVYX`aWXaVc                        qv             q s w m V WjVYcV o Yf bVg                             p s qss n `eVca`W WVYVW lV                          p s qsu { ccaW aW  o Yf ` abaXaVc                        pq q u w m V d alm `YZcfW k] le { bfYaXm g                       pr qus w m V d alm `YZcfWk] le XVY`XafW                   pr quu { _ _bal`XafW Xf U  o w \  x `X`                   p quu s { bfYaXm g g _ bVg VWX`XafW                 p quu u w m V ^Xf_ _aW  U YaXVYafW                   t quu q z b]  U `ba Y`XafW                       q quu p w m V sv V { bbk^"e `_                  q q w m V ` ag ] g \ WXYf_e VXm fZ                       r s qqs \ ^ ^u `bfYaXmg                         ru qqu o Yf_ VYXaVc f \ ^ ^ u                       rq qqq w m V sv V  { bbk^"e `_                      r q p w f `YZ c ` ] bXaYV cfb] XafW { __ Yf`lm                    rh qp s o Yf bVg c f U b`ccal`b[ d VlfW cXY] lXafW { bfYaXmg c         r h qp u w m V `jVbVX w Y`W cfYg                       t qp q fZ a l`XafW f Xm V d alm `YZ cfW k ] le { bfYaXmg          s q   x acl] ccafW f Xm V sv V ^"e `_ c                    v             p s o YaW la_ bVc f fZ Vb U fg _ `YacfW                       vq p ss n `eVca`W o `Y`g VXVY \ cXag `XafW                   vq p su w m V ` ag ]g a"Vbam ffZ d `Xaf w V cX                vp p sq n `eVc z`lXfYc                             v  p sp n `eVca`W f ZVb { jVY`aW                       vv p u { _ _bal`XafW Xf U  o w \  Z `X`                       vh

pus n `cal { bfYaXmg                            v h puu { W \ `g _bV  z aXXaW \ _ fWVW Xa`b x ac" f ZVbc           hs p q { ]bXak `jVbVWXm U fg _ `YacfW f U  o w \  sv V x `X`      stq pqs w Y`lVY `_ c                              stp p qss w m V ptv ^] YjVe                    stp p qsu { Xfg al | V] XY`b e Z YfVW
              st  p qsq w m V ^"e `X alYf `jV `jVbVW Xm c            st p qsp fbVl]b`Y eZ YfVW
                  str p qs  z`YkWY`YVZ U fWXaW] ] g \ g accafW             str p qsr z`YkWY`YVZ aW Vc                     st p qs aZ k `W Z | V`YkW Y`YVZ U fW XaW ] ]g \ g accafW      st p qsv  aca bV am X                        stv p qsh ^fX y kY`e c                         stv p qsst `YZ y kY`e c                         sth p qsss amk\ W VYe  kY`e c                     st h pqu U fg _ `YacfW f w Y`lVY `_ c                     sss p qus o YafY o Yf `abaXaV c                     sss p quu ^ecXVg `Xalc                         sss p quq w m V n V cX fZ Vb                      ss  pqq W XVY_ YVX`XafW f Xm V d Vc] bXc                     sup p qqs w m V fW a VZ W XVYcXVbb`Y VZ a]g             sup p qqu zYVVkzYVV \ g accafW                     sup p qqq \ ] aj`bVWX   cX`Y { b eaVbZ              suv p qqp ] cXa l`XafW f XmV { cc] g _ XafW c             suv p qq  w m V  YaaW f  `b`lXal { b                sqt p p o `Y`g VXVYc f Xm V { b x acXYa ]XafW                     sqs pp s w m V d `Za`b { b x acXYa ] XafW                     squ pp u w m V ^l`bV VamX f d `Z af`lXajV { b                sqq pp q w m V  `b`lXal { b `cc                        sqp pp p { fl`b { b U fg _ fW VWX                      sq !                  s w m V sv V  ^"e `XVY U  o w \                      sp s  u w m V sv V  ^"e  VfYV | w \  d {                     spq

                
       ! { s { bfYaXm g o `Y`g VXVYc                            sp  { u w m V ^Xf__ aW  U YaXVYafW                            sp { q z b]  U `ba Y`XafW                               s  u                                        !     
          
 

w mV macXfYe f YVlVWX `b`lXal W] lbVfceW XmV cac `lXaj aXe l`W  V cX] ZaVZ e g V`c] YVk g VWXc f Xm V svt h V `g g `kY`e baW V `YacaW Yfg Xm V ZV l`e f Y`Z af`lXajV { b w m V U  o w \  XVbVclf_ V ` f`YZ Xm V U fg _XfW  `g g `kd `e   cVYj`XfYe i b`] W lm VZ fW { _ Yab  i shhsi _ VYg aXc fY XmV YcX Xag V `W V XVW cajV aWjVcXa`XafW f XmV sv V Y`Za`XafW Xm Yf] mf] X Xm V VW XaYV c" e w m V `ag f Xmac Xm Vcac ac Xf aW VY Xm V `b`lXal ZacXYa ] XafW f { b Yfg Xm VcV g V`c] YVg VW Xc `W Z Xf aZVWXae XmV Zfg aW `W X cf] YlVc f Xmac Y`Zaf`lXajV acfXf_ V  w mV  YcX _ `YX f Xm V Xm Vcac ac ZVZ al`XVZ Xf Xm V YV lfW cXY] lXafW f Xm V sv V aWXVW caXe ZacXYa ] XafW Yfg Xm V g V`c] YVZ Z `X` X ac ZVg fW cXY`XVZ Xm `X Xm V ] cV f lfWjVWXafW `b ZV lfWjfb] XafW `bfYaXm g c i ba"V g `ag ]g ba"Vbamff Z fY g `ag ] g VWXYf_ e aW jVYcafW i bV`Zc Xf b] g _ e i W facVkZ fg aW `XVZ aW XVW caXe Z acXYa ] XafW c | VjVYXm VbVcc i cag ]b`XafW c l`W mVb_ Xf `ccVcc Xm V ]W lVYX`aW XaV c aW XmV YV lfW cXY] lXVZ ag `Vci  m alm _ VYg aXc Xm V claVWk Xa l V _bfaX`XafW f Xm V YVlfjVYVZ c"e g `_ c  { bXVYW `XajVbe i ` g ] bXaYVcfb]XafW `__ Yf`lm ac _ Yf_ fcVZ i  m alm b`YVbe YVZ ] lV c Xm V ] W lVYX`aWXaVc aW XmV YVlfW cXY] lXVZ sv V aW k XVW caXe ZacXYa ] XafW  W c] g g `Ye i sv V  Vg accafW ac g `aW be lfW lVW XY`XVZ Xf `YZ c XmV `b`lXal _ b`W V i  m alm lbV`Ybe ZVg fW cXY`XVc Xm `X Xm V ] b" f { b ac f `b`lXal Y`Xm VY Xm `W bfl`b fYaaW  f VjVY i ZacXaW lX Vg accafW V `X]YVc Xf `YZ c U e W ] c i U `YaW ` i `W Z XmV { ]Ya`kU `g Vbf_ `YZ`backo VYcV] c YVafW `YV aW lfW cacXVWX  aXm ` cg ffXm `b`lXal sv V Vg accafW _ Yf bV i _ faWXaW  Xf `YZ c ` g `ccajV cX`Y fYaaW f { b w mV cVlfW Z _ `YX f XmV Xm Vcac lfW cacXc f ` g ] bXak `jVbVWXm lfg _ `YacfW f U  o k w \  sv V  Z `X`  malm `ag c aW Xm V aZVW Xa l`XafW f Xm V fYaaW f `b`lXal { b  z fY XmV lfg _ `YacfW i ` YafYf] c n `eVca`W `W `be cac ac `_ _ baVZ i  m alm ac Xm V fW be lfW cacXVWX Y`g V fY" Xm `X `bbf c aW VYVW lV  `cVZ fW Xm V lfg _ `YacfW  X X] YWV Z f] X Xm `X Xm V sv V Z acXYa ] XafW fbbf c jVYe lbfcVbe XmV Z acXYa] XafW f YVV VbV lXYfW c aW XmV  `b` e  m alm ac XY`lVZ e XmVYg `b  YVg ccXY`mb] W  i f cVYj`bV aW Xm V g alYf `jV Zfg `aW  w m V cag ab`YaXe f Xm V sv V aWXVW caXe Z acXYa ] XafW Xf Xm V Xm VYg `b  YVg ccXY`m b]W  Z acXYak ] XafW ag _ baVc ` ZaYVlX _Yf_ fYXafW `baXe  VX VVW Xm V { b `W Z XmV g `ccajV cX`Y lfb] g W ZVW caXaVc i  m alm cXYfWbe c]_ _ fYXc Xm `X g `ccajV cX`Yc `YV XmV fYaaW f `b`lXal { b W _ `YXal]b`Yi  | V kW fj`V `W Z {  n cX`Yc l`W  V Vlb] Z VZ `c Z fg aW `WX { b cf]YlVc caW lV Xm VaY `b`lXal Z acXYa ] XafW ac W fX V_ V lXVZ Xf lfYYVb`XV  aXm Xm V ZacXYa ]XafW f YVV VbVlXYfW c w mV lfYYVb`XafW  VX VVW { b `W Z YVV VbVlXYfW c VcX` bacm VZ i XmV `W `becac f sv V  kY`e baW V Vg accafW l`W lfg _bVg VWX f] Y "W f bVZV ` f]X cX`Y fYg `XafW `W Z Xm V ZacXYa ] XafW f afW a VZ `c Xm Yf] m f] X Xm V VW XaYV  `b` e m abV U  o w \  g `ZV XmV  YcX cXV_ aW _Yfj aZ aW XmV  YcX `bbkc"e g `_ aW Xm V bamX f Xm V svth V  baW V i | w \  d {  i Xm V W VX VW VY`XafW  kY`e c_ VlXYfg VXVY i  abb `bbf ` ZVX`abVZ cX] Z e f l]YYVWX cX`Y fYg `XafW aW Xm V  `b` e

 [Vg accafW ZV b` Y`aV `g g ` `
sivth V i lfYYVc_ fW Z `W XV `
b` Z VlYfacc`W lV Z] Y`Zafk acfXf_ V { b i XVg faW V ZV b` ceW Xm
VcV YVlVW XV Z [VbVg VWXc bf] YZ c Z `W c W fXYV  `b`aV  WV  VX] ZV `__ YffW ZaV Z V lVXXV Vg accafW ` _ ] V
XYV YV`bacVV Y`
lV `] XVbVclf_ V U  o w \  i g ac VW fY aXV VW `j Yab s hh s \ W _ `YXal]baVY i V _ YVcVWXV Z `W c lVXXV Xm
V cV ]W V VX] ZV ZV b[fYaaW V VX ZV b` ZacXYa] XafW Z V b[{ b Z`W c b`  `b`aV  ` _ YVg a
VYV _ `YXaV Z V lVXXV Xm
VcV VcX lfW c`lYVV
` b` YVlfW cXY] lXafW ZV b[ag `V Z] laVb Z `W c b` b] g aV
YV Z V b` Y`aV `
siv V  Vc `bfYaXmg V c lfW jVW XafW W Vbci lfg g V b` g VXmf ZV Z V g `ag ] g Z [VW XYf_ aV f] ZV jY`acVg  b`W lV g `ag `bV i g
VWVW X
` Z Vc ag `Vc Y] aXVVc i Z fg aWVVc _ `Y Z Vc  ] lX] `XafW c cX`XacXa] V Z]  Y]aX ZV fW Z  {  W Z [V _bfaXVY claVW Xa ] Vg VWX lVbbVcklai ab ` VXV W VlVcc`aYV Z [V V lX] VY ZV c cag ]b`XafW c VW _ `YXal] baVY _ f] Y ZVXVYg aWVY bVc aW lVYXaX] Z Vc  x V _ b] c i ]W V `_ _ Yflm V g ] bXakYVcfb] XafW _ VYg VXX`W X ]W V YVZ ] lXafW caW a l`XajV ZV c aW lVYXaX] ZVc V cX _ Yf_ fcVV Z`W c b` Xm
VcV  b YVccfYX ZV lVXXV `W `becV i ] V b[Vg accafW `
siv V VcX lfW lVWXYV Z `W c bV _ b`W `b`lXa] V i lV ]a g fWXYV lb`aYVg VW X ] V b[fYaaWV Z V b[{ b VcX `b`lXa]V VX W fW bf l`bV  U V_ VW Z `WX i b[Vg accafW ZacXaW lX jVYc b` YVafW Z ] U e W V i b` U `Y
VW V i VX bV lfg _bV V Z ] U f lm VYk aY`Vko VYcVV VcX aW lfg _ `XabV `jVl Z Vc  ] lX] `XafW c cX`XacXa] V i aW Za] `W X bVc VXfabVc g `ccajVc lfg g V VW aXV] Yc _ YaW la_ `] ZV b[{ b  ` Z V] aV
g V _ `YXaV Z V lVXXV Xm V
cV lfW cacXV Z `W c ] WV lfg _ `Y`acfW Z Vc ZfW WVVc U  o w \ 
` siv V  `jV l Z [`] XYVc bfW] V]Yc Z [fW ZV `jV l bV  ] X Z [aZVW Xa VY b[fYaaW V ZV b[{ b `b`lXa] V  o f] Y V VlX] VY lVXXV lfg _ `Y`acfW i  [`a ] XabacV] WV `__ Yflm V n `eVcaVW W V ] a VcX b[] W a] V l`ZYV lfW cacXVWX _ VYg VXX`WX ZVc lfW lb] cafW c  `cVVc c] Y b` lfg _ `Y`acfW  U VXXV lfg _ `Y`acfW ` g fWXYV ] V b` ZacXYa] XafW ZV b` Y`aV
` siv V  YVccVg  bV fYXVk g VWX
` b` Z acXYa ] XafW ZVc VbVlXYfW c baYV c i XY`lVV _ `Y bV Y`efWW Vg VWX Z V YVaW `V XmVYk g a] V ] a VcX f cVYjV Z `W c b` Zfg `aW V Z Vc g alYffW ZVc U VXXV YV ccVg b`W lV ag _ ba] V ]W V _ Yf_ fYXafW W `baXV ZaYV lXV VWXYV b` lfbfWW V ZVW caXV Z V b[ { b VX ZV c VXfabVc g `ccajVci c]_ _ fYX`WX fYXVg VWX ] V bVc VXfabVc g `ccajVc cfaVWX
` b[fYaaW V Z V b[{ b `b`lXa]V  \ W _ `YXal] baV
YV i bV c Wfj`V  k| Vk  VX bVc VXfabVc {  n _ V] jVWX V
XYV V lb]V c lfg g V VW aXV] Yc ag _ fYX`WX Z V b[{ b i l`Y abc W V cfWX _ `c lfYYVbVc
` b` ZacXYa] XafW ZV c VbVlXYfW c ba YV c  ` lfYYVb`XafW VWXYV b[{ b VX bVc VbVlXYfW c ba YVc VX`W X VX` baV i b[`W `becV ZV b` Y`aV `g g `
` s i v V _ V] X lfg _ bVXVY W fc lfW W `acc`W lVc c] Y b` fYg `XafW c Z [VXfabVc VX b` ZacXYa ]XafW Z ] ` afW acV Z `W c Xf] X b`  `b`aV  ^a bV XVbVclf_ V U  o w \  ` _ YfZ] aX b` _ YVg aV
YV l`YXV Z] laVb Z `W c b` Y`aV `g g ` `
siv V i bV _Yf lm `aW aW cXY]g VW Xi | k w \  d {  i j` _ VYg VXXYV ]W V VX] Z V `__ YffW ZaV ZVc caXVc ZV fYg `XafW Z [VXfabV c Z `W c WfXYV  `b`aV 

   
   
   K SN  L  T  L Q    T  T  O R   L    T  L Q O Q   i fW ` cX`YYe WamXi fW V X] YW c fW Vc ` V Xf `YZc XmV  Yg `g VWXi aX ac ] W `jfaZ`bV Xm `X ` VVbaW f YVcX `W Z VXVYWaXe lfg Vc fjVY Xm V g aW Z  W ` baV i  m alm ac g `Y"VZ e XY`W cfYg `XafW c i  aYXm `W Z ZV`Xm i ef] Xm `W Z `V i Xm V cX`Yc fYg ` Z V W aXV `W Z ` cfb] XV  `cac i  malm cVVg c aWj`Ya` bV `W Z VW Z bVcc zfY ` bfW Xag V aX  `c ` _ YVj`abaW  l] bX] Y`b  VbaV Xm `X Xm V m V`jVW c YV_ YVcVWXVZ ` _ VYVlX `W Z XmVYVfYV ] W lm `WV`bV lYV`XafW e  f Z  w mV fWbe `_ _ `YVWX lm `W V aW Xm V c"e i Xm V g fjVg VWX f Xm V _b`W VXc i  `c ZVclYa VZ e _ VYVlXbe le lbal g fXafW ci aV i g fXafW c Xm `X m `jV Wf cX`YX `W Z W f VW Z  U m `W V  `c c]_ _ fcVZ Xf  V _ VYg aXXVZ fWbe fW XmV ag _ VYVlX \ `YXm i `W Z  mVW lm `W V ZaZ aW `lX fll]Y aW Xm V c" e Xm V g `XXVY  `c ZV `bX  aXm e VW c] YaW Xm `X Wf  YaXXVW YVlfYZ f aX  `c g `ZV  X ac Xm VYVfYV W fX c]Y_ YacaW Xm `X Xm V _ mVW fg VWfW f Wfj`V fY c] _ VYWfj`V l`g V jVYe b`XVbe Xf Xm V `XXVWXafW f \ ]Yf_ V`W `cXYfWfg VYc i  m VW aW s u w e lm f n Y`m V ZaclfjVYV Z ` WV [ YamX cX`Y i jaca bV fjVY sv g fW Xm c aW XmV lfW cXVbb`XafW f U `ccaf_ Va`  aXm aW lYV `caW  f cVYj`XafW `b V fYX i g fYV `W Z g fYV baV l`g V aWXf Xm V c"e  { X Xm V XY`W caXafW Yfg XmV srXm Xf Xm V s Xm lVWX] Yei Xm V  YcX j`Ya` bV cX`Yi aY`
 U VXai  `c ZaclfjVYV Z e x `jaZ z` Yala] c W s sv i \ Zg fW Z `bbVe YV lfW a VZ Xm `X cX`Yc `YV WfX  VZ fW ` c_m VYV i `c m `Z  VVW  VbaVjVZ fY ` bfW  Xag V i  ] X m `jV Xm VaY _ Yf_ VY g fXafW c fW Xm V c" e  | f `Z`e c i `  V`bXm f j`Ya` bV _ mVW fg VW ` ac f cVYjVZ aW XmV c" e i WfX fW be `X f_ Xal`b  `jVbVW Xm c  ] X Xm Yf] m f]X Xm V VW XaYV VbV lXYfg `W VXal c_ VlXY] g  { g fW  XmV cV `YV  _ ]bc`Yc i  malm  VYV ZaclfjVYVZ  YcX aW s h r e Xm VaY Y`Zaf Vg accafW i ] `c`Yc i YcX f cVYjVZ `X Y`Z af  `jVbVW Xm c aW shrq i `W Z XmV g e cXVYaf] c  kY`e  ]YcXci  m alm  VYV `llaZVW X`bbe ZaclfjVYVZ  e c`XVbbaXVk fYW V ZVXVlXfYc g V`W X Xf g fWaXfY jafb`XafW c f XmV W ] lbV`Y XVcX  `W XYV`Xe w fZ `e aX ac " Wf W Xm `X VjVW Xm V cX`Yc m `jV fW be `  WaXV baVXag V i  m alm m f VjVY b`cXc g abbafW c Xf  abbafW c f eV`Yc i g ] lm Xff bfW  fY `aW Xf  V ZaYVlXbe _ VYlV_ Xa bV Xf m ]g `W  VaW c n ] X _ m ecal`b lm `WVc Z ]V Xf Xm V Vjfb] XafW f cX`Yc  malm g `e  V `c cmfYX `c ZV l`ZV c fY lVWX]YaV c `YV YV`Zabe f cVYjVZ
` W fXalV`bV V `g _ bV ac o U eW a i

u  m alm `_ _ V`YV Z aW XmV s Xm lVW X]Ye `c ` YVZ Zacm i Y`XmVY j`Ya` bV cX`Y i  ]X Xf Z`e ac ` YVb`XajVbe lfW cX`W X eVbbf acm k m aXV cX`Y  W Xm V shut c XmV \ W bacm `cXYf_ me calacX ^aY { YXm] Y ^X`W bVe \ ZZ aWXfW  fY"VZ f] X Xm V aWXVYW `b cXY] lX] YV f XmV cX`Yc i `W Z _ Yf_ fcVZ Xm `X W ] lbV `Y VWVYe l`] cVc XmVg Xf cm aW V  W shqvi `W c n VXm V `W Z U `Yb zYaVZYalm jfW Va c`l"VY aW ZV_ VW Z VWXbe Z VclYa VZ X f W] lbV`Y YV`lXafW lm `aW c
Xm V _ _ lm `aW `W Z Xm V U |  le lbV   malm l`W _ YfjaZV Xm V W ] lbV`Y VW VYe  ] ZVX f Xm V cX`Yc  e XY`W cfYg aW  me ZYfVW aWXf mVba] g  w fZ `ei XmV Vjfb] XafW f cX`Yc ac ] W ZVYcXffZ `c XmV cXfYe f XmVaY W] lbV`Y XY`W cg ] X`XafW c `W Z Xm V lfW cV] VWX V V lXc fW Xm V cXVbb`Y cXY] lX] YV  x ] YaW Xm V cXY]bV Xf ] W Z VYcX`W Z Xm V VW VYVXalc f cX`Yc aW XmVaY j`Yaf] c Vjfb] XafWk `Ye cX`V c i `W Z Xf V _ b`aW Xm V fYaaW `W Z ` ] W Z `W lV f XmV lm Vg al`b VbVg VW Xc `W Z XmVaY acfXf_ Vc aW Xm V W ajVYcV i Xm V  VbZ f W] lbV`Y `cXYf_ me calc Vg VYVZ aW Xm V shptc Yfg Xm V g `YYa`V f Xm V fbZ claVW lV f `cXYfWfg e  aXm Xm V ef] W  Zacla_ baW V f W] lbV`Y _ me calc ^aW lV XmV V_ flm kg `" aW  _ `_ VY f n ] YaZV  
s h  i aX m `c  VVW VcX`bacm VZ Xm `X Xm V g `fYaXe f Xm V lm Vg al`b VbVg VWXc `YV _ YfZ] lVZ e W] lbV`Y YV `lXafW c aW Xm V mfX cXVbb`Y aWXVYafYc i VaXm VY Z] YaW  Xm V bfW i ] aVclVWX _m `cVc f cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW i fY aW Xm V jafbVWX c] _ VYW fj` V_ bfcafW c Xm `X g `Y" XmV ZV`Xm f g `ccajV cX`Yc w m V g `XVYa`b VVlXV Z Yfg Xm V ZeaW cX`Yc ac g a VZ aW Xm V aWXVYcXVbb`Y g VZ a] g Yfg  malm WV cXVbb`Y VW VY`XafW c `YV fYg VZ  w m V le lbV XmVW cX`YXc ``aW i _YfYV ccajVbe VWYalm aW Xm V  `b`e  aXm m V`j e VbVg VW Xc ^XVbb`Y W ] lbVfceWXm Vcac _ YfZ] lVc W fX fW be cX` bV i ] X `bcf ]W cX` bV W] lbVa  aXm baVk Xag Vc Y`W aW  Yfg cVlfW Z c Xf  abbafW c f eV `Yc w m VaY Y`Z af`lXajV XY`W caXafW c g `e ajV YacV Xf kY`e _ mfXfW c  m alm i ] W ZVY lVYX`aW lfW ZaXafW c i g `e  V ZVXVlXVZ e c]  laVWXbe cVW caXajV aW cXY]g VW Xc w m ac _ fcca abaXei  YcX c] V cXVZ  e U b`eXfW `W Z U Y`ZZ fl"
shri  f] bZ ] W `g a] f] cbe `bbf XmV Z VXV lXafW f acfXf_ Vc XmYf] m Xm VaY lm `Y`lXVYacXal  kY`e caW `X] YV  fYVfjVY i Z VXV lXafW f c_ VlaV c  aXm baVXag Vc lfW caZVY` be cm fYXVY Xm `W Xm V `V f XmV  `b`e  f] bZ lbV `Ybe cm f Xm `X W] lbVfce WXm Vcac ac cXabb `lXajV XfZ `e w m ac Xm Vcac ZV `bc  aXm Xm V f cVYj`XafW f c] lm ` W] lbV`Y XY`W caXafW baWV i `YacaW  Yfg Xm V Y`Z af`lXajV ZV l`e f { b  aXm ` baVXag V f  st eY    T N L    Q O Q    N     N ! O N w m V ZaclfjVYe f  kY`e Vg accafW `YacaW  Yfg Xm V ZVl`e f Y`Zaf`lXajV { b aW Xm V aW XVYk cXVbb`Y g VZ a] g
^   `c ` g abV cXfW V aW  kY`e `cXYfW fg e " aX  `c Xm V  YcX ZVXVlXafW f ` lfcg al Y`Z af`lXajV acfXf_ V e g V`W c f aXc  kY`e Y`Za`XafW  caW Xm V m am k_] YaXe VYk g `W a] g
 V  ZVXVlXfYc ` f`YZ Xm V \ {  kq c`XVbbaXV i `m fWVe  
shvp  f cVYjVZ `  kY`e baWV `X svtv #p h $ t#p s "V Yfg Xm V VW VY`b Z aYVlXafW f Xm V `b`lXal lVWXVY x ] V Xf Xm V mam VW VYe YV cfb]XafW f Xm V  V Z VXV lXfYc
q  "V z  i Xm V f cVYjVZ baW V lf] bZ  V ] W a] Vbe aZ VWXa VZ  aXm Xm V svtv #r $ t #t "V  baWV `YacaW Yfg Xm V Y`Zaf`lk XajV Z Vl`e f { b `X YV cX  w m V f cVYjVZ aW XYaW cal baW V  aZ Xm
z  f % q #t "V 
s&   `c lfW cacXVW X  aXm Xm V x f_ _bVY  Yf`Z VW aW V_ VlXVZ Yfg Za VYVWXa`b `b`lXal YfX`k XafW `W Z Y`W Z fg g fXafW c f Xm V ^  z Yfg XmV f cVYjVZ aW XVW caXe f
p#v $ s#t  st'(

q _m lg 'c' Y`Z ' Yfg XmV j alaWaXe f XmV `b`lXal lVWXVY i ` XfX`b `b`lXal { b g `cc f q   `c aWVYYVZ   WV eV`Y b`XVY i Xm V  kY`e c_ V lXYfg VXVY ` f`YZ Xm V ^fb`Y `ag ] g accafW
^  c`XVbbaXV _ YfjaZVZ lfWj aW laW _Yff Xm `X Xm V \ {  kq ZaclfjVYe  `c XY] be Xm V caW `X] YV f `b`lXal { b _Yf Z] lXafW
^m `YV   shv zfbbf aW  Xm ac _ Yfg acaW  Z aclfjVYei ` W] g  VY f  `bbffW  fYWV aW cXY] g VWXc  VYV cVX ]_ i `ag aW  Xf ag _ YfjV XmV c_ `Xa`b aWfYg `XafW fW `b`lXal svt h V Vg accajaXe
jfW n `bbg ffc   s h v i `lU `bb] g   s h v i `bVX   s hh s i w VV`YZVW   s hh s | fW VXm VbV cc i Xm V _ ffY `W ] b`Y YVcfb] XafW f Xm V V _ VYag VW Xc lf] bZ fW be  V`" be lfW cXY`aW _ fccabV Z acXYa ] XafW g fZ Vbc mabV `bb g V`c] YVg VW Xc VW VY`bbe `YVVZ ` f] X `W VW m `W lVg VWX f sv V Vg accafW Xf `YZ c Xm V `b`lXal lVW XVYi YVk`W `be cac f Xm V ^ sv V g V`c] YVg VWXc e ] caW XmV \ `YXm `c `W f ll] bXaW Z ac" Y] bVZ f]X ` caW bV _ faW X cf] YlV `X Xm V `b`lXal lVW XVY `X Xm V p & lfW  Z VW lV bVjVb
o ] YlVbb shvh   { ZZ aXafW `bbe i Xm V g `YaW `b Z VXVlXafW
u &  f sv V Vg accafW Yfg XmV `b`lXal _ b`WV `X bfWaX] ZVc  qq  e  d ^  `c lfW caZ VYV Z `c aW Zal`XafW f VXVW Z VZ { b Vg accafW `bfW XmV `b`lXal _ b`WV
w VV`YZVW   s hh s w mV \ {  kq ZaclfjVYe f sv V Vg accafW m `YZbe l`g V `c ` c] Y_YacV  W Z VVZ i l`bl] b`XafW c aW Xm V b`XV rtc f V _bfcajV l`Y fW  ] YWaW  aW c] _ VYW fj`V
{ YW VXX shrh m `Z cm f W Xm `X c]  cX`WXa`b `g f]W Xc f { b g `e  V _ Yf Z] lVZ aW Xm ac VWj aYfW g VWX   W XmV  `cac f Xm VcV VcXag `XVc aX  `c c] VcXVZ Xm `X XmV sv V  baW V f { b  f] bZ  V `W aWXVYVcXaW  X`YVX fY  kY`e baWV `cXYfW fg e
d `g `Xe `W Z aW VW VbXVY s h i { YW VXX sh  x ] V Xf aXc YVb`XajV bfW baVXag V f    s#tpt st  eV`Yc
z] bbVY   shvui { b Yfg cVjVY`b Xmf] c`W Z c]_ VYW fj`V cmf] bZ `ll]g ] b`XV aW Xm V  `b` e i ajaW  YacV Xf ` Za ] cV Vg accafW aW Xm V `b`lXal _b`W V  w m V  ] fW \ `YXm  `c VcXag `XVZ Xf  st'( _m lg 'c'  Yfg Xm V `b`lXal lVWXVY ZaYVlXafW i `W Z aX  `c _ faWXV Z f] X Xm `X i  Vl`] cV f aXc bfW  g V `W baV i { b  f] bZ m `jV VW f]m Xag V Xf  V Xm VYg `ba VZ aW Xm V ^ " Xm VYVfYV i aX  f] bZ ZVkVlaXV V ccVWXa`bbe `X YVcX `W Z Vg aX ` W `YYf baW V  d VlVWX g V `c]YVg VWXc e Xm V  `bbffW  fYWV  kY`e c_ VlXYfg VXVY  d ^ i mf VjVY i Y`acVZ cfg V Z f]  X ` f] X Xm V Xm VYg `ba `XafW f { b aW XmV ^  | `e`  
shhr  YV_ fYXVZ fY ` qu m f]Y  `bbffW  amX g `Z V Yfg { balV ^_YaW c
{ ] cXY`ba` Xm V ZVXVlXafW f `  Yf`ZVW VZ sv V baW V Yfg Xm V `b`lXal lVW XVY Z aYV lXafW  aXm `W aW XYaW cal  aZXm f  #p $ s#p "V   w m V ZVXVlXafW f c] lm `  aZV V `X] YV ac c]VcXajV f VaXmVY m am Zac_ VYcafW jVbflaXaV c
 pt "g c'  fY m am XVg _ VY`X] YVc
  u st   i fY  m alm i mf VjVY i W f cX`W Z `YZ clVW `Yaf l`W `llf] W X
V   i U mVW   s hh  | fXV i mf VjVY i Xm `X XmV  d ^ g V `c]YVg VW X ac aW lfW cacXVW X  aXm Xm V \ {  kq g V`c] YVg VWX `X Xm V u& lfW  ZVW lV bVjVb ^aW lV { _ Yab i s hh s i XmV ag `aW U fg _ XfW XVbVclf_ V U  o w \  ` f`YZ XmV U fg _ k XfW  `g g `kd `e   cVYj`XfYe
U  d   ac aW fY aX i _ YfjaZ aW  fY Xm V  YcX Xag V ` lfg k _bVXV c] YjVe f Xm V  kY`e c" e `X VWVYaVc  VX VVW t #   qt V   Xc ] W_ YVlVZ VW XVZ `W ]b`Y YV cfb] XafW f q v
z   aXmaW `  aZV  VbZ f j aV f ` f]X s cXVY`Z a`W `bbf c ` Z VX`abVZ g `__ aW  f Xm V sv V baWV Xm Yf] mf] X Xm V VWXaYV c"e { XVY g fYV Xm `W r eV `Yc f f_ VY`XafW i XmV _ faWX cf] YlV cVW caXajaXe `X sv V   `c _] cm VZ  Vbf

p

Mg

26

12

Al

13

26

82

%

, E

C

15

%

100

%

2

+

0

+

0.

0

8

p

s

2

.93

8

4

1.

12

97

(90

%

)

β

+

2

+

1

.80

8

7

β

+

β

+

2.

93

8

(1

0%)

0.

4

9

p

s

1.

80

86

99.

7%

0.3

%

2.4

%

2.

7 %

A

l

13

26

m

g

5

+

7.

2

1

0

y

5

6

.3

6

s

0

+

                    s#  st' _m lg 'c' 
q&  fY XmV lfg aW VZ Z `X` i cVXXaW  ` W V cX`W Z `YZ aW  kY`e baW V `cXYfW fg e n V caZVc Xm V lbV `Y Z VXV lXafW f Xm V sv V baWV i W V  kY`e baWV c  VYV Zack lfjVYV Z  aXm U  o w \   e] Z aW  
s hh p  YV_ fYXVZ Xm V f cVYj`XafW f Xm V ss  V  kY`e baWV `YacaW  Yfg Xm V Y`Zaf`lXajV Z Vl`e f ((w a Xf `YZ c Xm V U `c { c] _ VYW fj` YVg W `WXi `W Z fYYac  
shh f]W Z Vj aZVW lV fY Xm V X f _ YaW la_ `b ZV l`e baW Vc f  U f i `X vp "V  `W Z suqv "V  i Yfg Xm V Xe_ V ` c]_ VYW fj` ^| shh s w  { Z ZaXafW `b i VW m `W lVZ  kY`e Vg accafW  VX VVW q  V  `c YV_ fYXVZ e n bfVg VW  
s hh p  Yfg Xm V  YafW g fbVl] b`Y lbf] Z lfg _bV i  m alm  `c XVWX`XajVbe `XXYa] XVZ Xf W] lbV`Y ZVV laX`XafW baWV c `X p pp `W Z rsq V  Yfg `llVbVY`XVZ U `W Z   W] lbVa   !  N "  R Q    N # T Q  Q  N ur  S $ %& %$ / !    '(   )  ' '  *   w m V Yf] W Z cX`XV f { b ac ]W cX` bV Xf _ fcaXYfW Vg accafW
+ , Vg accafW " vu-  fY Xf VbV lXYfW l`_ X] YV
\ U " s-   aXm ` g V `W baV f    s#tpt st eV`Yc
z] bbVY   s h vu Xc ZV l`e VVZ c Xm V  YcX V laXVZ cX`XV f   `X svtv V i  m alm Z VkV laXVc  aXm aW tp h _ c  e Vg aXXaW  `  kY`e _ m fXfW f svtvr V  { X uuv "V ` fjV XmV Yf] W Z cX`XV i { b m `c `W ./01 2.3 /
{ b4   m alm l`W ZaYVlXbe Z Vl`e Xf XmV Yf]W Z cX`XV f    e `W `bbf VZ XY`W caXafW i  Vl`] cV  fXm cX`XVc m `jV Xm V c`g V c_aW `W Z _ `YaXe
l z a  ss w m V m `bkbaV f { b4 ac fW be rqr c  Xm ac cX`XV l`W  V XmVYg `bbe VlaXVZ
`X   u#r st5   i XmV { b Z Vl`e Y`XV lm `W Vc e ` `lXfY f Yf] mbe st  

 w mV g `aW _YfZ ] lXafW g Vlm `Wacg f { b aW `cXYf_ me cal`b VW jaYfW g VW Xc ac _ YfXfW l`_ X] YV fW    i a  V  Xm V   
_ i  { b YV`lXafW
l  z a  su   U fW cV] VWXbe i fY ` c] cX`W Xa`b _Yf Z] lXafW f { b i  200 2.3 fY 1   /.1 2.3 VWjaYfW g VWXc
fY  fXm  `YV WVV ZVZ  o YfXfW Yalm VWjaYfW g VWXc  aXm c]  laVWXbe m am XVg _ VY`X]YV c fY `W Vk VlXajV _YfZ ] lXafW f { b `YV VW lf]W XVYV Z aW me ZYfcX`Xal k ]YW aW  lfW Z aXafW c i VaXm VY aW XmV lfWjV lXajV lfYVc f g `ccajV cX`Yc
  p st   fY aW Xm V cm Vbbc `W Z VW k jVbf_ V c f bf `W Z aW XVYg V Za`XV g `cc cX`Yc
 
  h st   W ZVY Xm fcV lfW Zak XafW c i { b ac g `aW be Z VcXY] lXVZ e + , ZVl`e fY XVg _ VY`X]YV c   st  `W Z e { b
_ i   ^a `X m am VY XVg _ VY`X] YV c
cVV U fl   s hhi fY ` Zacl] ccafW f Xm V ]W k lVYX`aWXaVc f Xm V { b
_ i  ^a Y`XV  w mV lfW Z aXafW c fY { b _YfZ ] lXafW `YV `bcf g VX aW V_ bfcajV k ]YW aW  `X XmV c]Y`lV c f  m aXV Z  `Yc ] W Z VYfaW ` Wfj` V_ bfcafW
_ V`" XVg _ VY`X] YV   
s#   p st    { X Xm VcV XVg _ VY`X] YVc i Xm V ( 
_ i  { b YV`lXafW ac Y`_ aZ VWf] m Xf XY`W cVY c] cX`W Xa`b `g f] WXc f (  aWXf { b i XmYf] m Xm V  ( 
_ i    { b
+ ,   
_ i  { b lm `aW  w m V aWXVYVcX f m `jaW `W aW aXa`b lfg _ fcaXafW VWYalm VZ aW (  i  m alm ac ] c] `bbe g fYV `] W Z `W X Xm `W   i Xm VW  Vlfg Vc fj af] c w m V Z VcXY] lXafW f { b aW Xm fcV lfW ZaXafW c ac Z] V Xf { b
_ i  ^a

S

i

26

Si

2

7

S

i

28

A

l

25

A

l

27

M

g

24

25

26

M

g

M

g

Al

26

m

Al

26

g

             ! "!  # $    !" %    & ' ( ) *+, - ' . ' ( / , " -  '  ) *0, % { W VWj aYfW g VWX Yalm aW  l`W  V f] W Z aW Xm V l`Y fW `W Z W VfW cm Vbbc f g `ccajV cX`Yc i  m VYV { b l`W  V _Yfk Z] lVZ me ZYfcX`Xal`bbe
  st 5   fY V_ bfcajVbe
 
u  u#   st5   w m V   
_ i  { b YV `lXafW _ Yf lVV Zc Y`_ ak ZVbe `X Xm VcV m am XVg _ VY`X]YV c `W Z bV`Zc Xf b`YV `g f]W Xc f { bi Z Vc_ aXV XmV bf ` ]W Z `W lV f _YfXfW c VWVYk `XV Z aW Xm VcV caXVc e YV`lXafW c c] lm `c U
U i_ 1| ` W c] lm VW jaYfW k g VWXc i m f VjVY i c]  cX`WXa`b `g f] WXc f WV] XYfW c g `e  V _ YfZ ] lV Z Xm Yf] m cV lk fW Z `Ye YV`lXafW ci `W Z { b g `e  V ZVk cXYfeVZ  e { b
W i_  `W Z { b
W i2  YV`lk XafW c  W V] XYfW c `YV W fX _YV cVWX aW b`YV ] `W XaXaVc `W Z a XmV Xag Vcl`bV ac c] laVWXbe bfW 
 st 1 c i a  V  aW cm Vbb U k ] YW aW  lfW ZaXafW c i { b ac g `aW be ZVk cXYfeVZ e + , Z Vl`e
`X c] lm m am XVg k _ VY`X] YVc XmV + , ZV l`e Y`XV ac VWm `W lV Z Z] V Xf Xm V _ YV cVW lV f Xm V acfg VYal cX`XV { b4  w f  V f cVYj` bV aW kY`ec i { b m `c Xf  V VV lXVZ aW XmV ^  VfYV Z VcXY] lXafW  w m ac l`W V`cabe  V `lm aVjVZ aW Xm V l`cV f `W V_ bfcajV caXV i c] lm `c ` W fj` fY ` c] _ VYW fj`  W Xm V fXmVY m `W Z i fVlXc c] VYaW  VXVW cajV g `cc bfcc `W Z c]  laVWX aWXVYW `b g a aW i

r ba"V fbkd `eVX cX`Yc
d c i ]g aW f] c n b]V  `Ya` bV c
 n  c i fY { ceg _ XfXal  a`W X n Y`W lm cX`Yc
{  n c i lf] bZ `bcf cX`Xace Xm ac lfW ZaXafW    jaf] cbe i Xm V Za VYVWX YVag Vc f XVg _ VY`X]YV i ZVW caXe i Xag V cl`bV `W Z aW aXa`b lfg _ fcaXafW aW XmV cV `cXYf_m ecal`b caXV c ag _ be Za VYVWX g fZ Vc fY Xm V _ YfZ] lXafW `W Z Z VcXY] lXafW f { b W Xm V c]  cV] VW X cV lXafW c Xm V g fcX ag _ fYX`WX l`W ZaZ`XV caXV c Xm `X m `jV  VVW _ Yf_ fcVZ ] _ Xf W f `YV _YVcVWXVZ  $ %& %
 ' '  %    ' eZ YfcX`Xal lfYV  ]YW aW  aW g `ccajV cX`Yc l`W bV `Z Xf XmV _Yf Z] lXafW f caW a l`W X `g f] WXc f { b a Xm V lVWXY`b XVg _ VY`X] YV f Xm V cX`Y ac   
q #   p  st  i aV  i fY cX`Yc g fYV g `ccajV Xm `W  s  fW Xm V g `aW cV] VW lV  { c Xm V lfWjVlXajV cXVbb`Y lfYV Y`Z] `bbe YVXYV`Xc i  m abV XmV cX`Y cXabb  ] YW c fW XmV g `aW cV] VW lV i aX bV`jV c  Vm aW Z { b Xm `X m `c  VVW _ YVj af] cbe _ YfZ] lVZ `W Z g a VZ aW Xm V lfYV  mVXm VY fY W fX aX  abb `_ _ V`Y `X Xm V cXVbb`Y c] Y`lV ZV_ VW Z c fW aW XVYW `b g a aW  `W Z XmV g `cc bfcc { bb g `ccajV cX`Yc c] VY g `cc bfcc Z] V Xf ` cXVbb`Y  aW Z  m alm ac ZYajVW  e Y`Z a`XafW _YVcc]YV aW ` cfY_ XafW baW Vc { g fW Xm V cXVbb`Y fV lXc cmf aW  Xm V b`YV cX g `cc bfcc Y`XVc `YV fbkd `eVX
d  cX`Yc  m alm `YV lm `Y`lXVYa V Z e _ Yfg aWVW X  Yf`Z Vg accafW baWV c f WaXYfVW
| cX`Yc fY l`Y fW `W Z f eVW
U `W Z  cX`Yc aW Xm VaY c_ V lXY`  w m VcV baWVc `YV aWXVY_ YVXV Z `c YVcm be ceW Xm Vca VZ _ YfZ] lXc f lVWXY`b m eZ YfVW fY m Vba]g ] YW aW `YacaW `X Xm V cXVbb`Y c] Y`lV Z] V Xf m V`je g `cc bfcc `W Z fY aWXVYW `b g a aW
V    `W VY shv   ^aW lV { b ac _ YfZ ] lV Z Z] YaW  lfYV m e ZYfVW  ] YW aW  i aX ac V _ VlXV Z Xf cm f ] _ `X Xm V cXVbb`Y c] Y`lV XfVXm VY  aXm W aXYfVW i aV  aW | cX`Yc
o Y`WX fc `W Z U `ccV s h vr x ]YaW  XmV c]  cV ]VW X _ m `cV f lVWXY`b mVba] g ] YW aW { b ac W f bfWVY _YfZ ] lV Z  | V] XYfW c YVbV`cVZ XmYf] m 1U
2 iW  `W Z | V
2 iW  V laVWXbe Z VcXYfe Xm V YVg `aW aW  { b aW Xm V cXVbb`Y lfYV XmYf]m { b
W i2  `W Z { b
W i _  YV `lXafW c  f VjVY i { b lfWXaW ]V c Xf  V VV lXVZ Yfg XmV cXVbb`Y VWjVbf_ V i `W Z Zac`__ V `Yc fW be  m VW Xm V V ] YW aW _Yf Z] lXc `_ _ V`Y `X Xm V c] Y`lV i `X XmVaY X] YW i aW Xm V U _ m `cV  ^VjVY`b l`bl] b`XafW c f { b _Yf Z] lXafW aW d cX`Yc m `jV  VVW _ VYfYg VZ aW Xm V YV lVWX _ `cX
V    o Y`WX fc `W Z U `ccV shvr i `WVY   shh i Ve WVX   shh i `W Z YVVYVW lVc Xm VYVaW   x Vc_ aXV Z a VYVW lVc aW Xm V cXVbb`Y g f ZVbc `W Z Za VYVWX _ me cal`b aWYVZaVW Xc
g `cc bfcc i XYV `Xg VWX f lfW jVlXafW i YV`lXafW Y`XVc Xm `X  VYV ] cVZ i YV c] bXc `YVVaW  aXm aW ` `lXfY f  q `YV f] W Z fY cX`Yc f ` ajVW g `cc w mV l`bl] b`XafW c cm f Xm `X cX`Yc aW Xm V g `cc Y`W V pt    sut `W Z  aXm cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe VVlX ` V st'   st'1  f { b aW Xm V ^ i  mVYV m amVY cXVbb`Y g `ccV c bV `Z Xf mam VY { b eaVbZ c { W ag _ fYX`W X V`X] YV f Xm V _ Yf Z] lXafW f { b e d cX`Yc ac Xm V ZV_ VW Z VW lV f Xm V { b eaVbZ fW g VX`bbalaXe
o Y`WX fc `W Z U `ccV shvr   z aYcXbe i Xm V _YfZ ] lXafW f { b ac _ Yf_ fYXafW `b Xf XmV `j`ab`bV `g f] WX f    m alm ZV_ VW Z c fW                            !  "  # $% &'(                 )     *     "           "     "     

XmV aW aXa`b cXVbb`Y g VX`bbalaXe ^VlfW Zbe i Xm V aW aXa`b g VX`bbalaXe ZVXVYg aW Vc Xm V g `cc bfcc Y`XV fW Xm V g `aW cV] VW lV caW lV Xm V Y`Z a`XajV fYlV fW Xm V VWjVbf_ V ZV_ VW Z c fW Xm V `g f] WX f g VX`bbal afW c aX lfWX`aW c w maYZ be i mam VY g VX`bbalaXe YVZ ] lVc i ``aW ja` Xm V g `cc bfcci Xm V g aW ag ] g g `cc YV ]aYV Z fY ` cX`Y Xf X]YW aW Xf ` d cX`Y w m V  YcX X f ZV_ VW Z VW laV c YVc]bX aW ` _ f VY b` YVb`XafW  

  
 m VYV   u  u#u   VX VVW XmV { b e aVbZ c `W Z Xm V aW aXa`b g VX`bbalaXe

o Y`WX fc `W Z x aVm b s hh r i VeW VX   shh  w m V _ YVcVW X Z `e `b`lXal { b g `cc Z] V Xf d cX`Yc ac m VW lV Y`Xm VY cVW caXajV Xf XmV `b`lXal g VX`bbalaXe Y`Z aVWX i Xm V _ YVlacV j`b] V f  m alm ac cXabb ] W lVYX`aW  d V lVWX VcXag `XVc `g f] WX Yfg    t#p 
o Y`WX fc `W Z x aVm b s hh r Xf    t# h $ t#  
Ve W VX   shh  w mV aW ] VW lV f ` lbfcV lfg _ `W afW fW XmV { b eaVbZ c f d cX`Yc m `c YVlVW Xbe  VVW aWjVcXa`XVZ  e n Y`] W `W Z `W VY
s hh p w mVaY l`bl] b`XafW c cm f Xm `X fY g `ccajV d cX`Yc Xm V { b eaVbZ f `  aW `Ye ce cXVg g `e _ fcca be  V cg `bbVY Xm `W Xm `X fY ` caWbV cX`Y caW lV { b Yfg Xm V _ Yag `Ye ac `llYVXVZ fWXf Xm V cVlfW Z `Ye zfY bf g `cc d cX`Yc
  pt  i aW `YaXe m `c XmV _ fXVW Xa`b Xf aW lYV `cV XmV { b eaVbZ caW lV XmV cV cX`Yc bffcV g ] lm g fYV g `cc aW `W aWXVY`lXaW  aW `Ye ce cXVg Xm `W `c caW bV cX`Yc f VjVY i Xm V ] W lVYX`aWXaV c aW Xm V Y`lXafW f d  aW `YaVc `W Z aW Xm V Y`lXafW f Xm V VVlXVZ g `XVYa`b Xm `X bV`jV c Xm V cecXVg `YV Xff b`YV fY `W e g V`W aW ] b lfW lb] cafW c \ jaZVW lV f U |  kle lbVZ g `XVYa`b `X Xm V cXVbb`Y c] Y`lV i m f VjVY i ac W fX fWbe YVk cXYalXVZ Xf d cX`Yc { bXmf] m g fcX g `ccajV g `aW cV] VW lV cX`Yc m `jV W fYg `b V `W Z | ` ] W Z`W lV c
VYYVYf   s hh u i `VZ VY s hh p i `W Z YVVYVW lVc Xm VYVaW  i Xm VYV `YV g `We V lV_ XafW c fY  `W Z n cX`Yc { g fW Xm VcV `YV  a`WXc `W Z c] _ VYa`WXci aW _ `YXal] b`Y  m VW Xm Ve `YV `cX YfX`XfYc
VYYVYf   s hh u i o `] bZ Y`lm   s hh p i  n | cX`Yc i `g fW   m alm `YV g `We cmfYXk_ VYafZ  aW `YaVc
^lmfW VYW VY   s h vv i `W Z n c] _ VYa`WXc
 aVc `W Z  `g  VYX shhui VW WfW shhp   `VZVY
shv  c] V cXVZ Xm `X Xm VYV g `e  V `  a] Yl`XafW aW cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW   m abV g fcX cX`Yc fbbf Xm V XY`l"c f aWm fg fVW f] c Vjfb] XafW i ` Y`lXafW f ` f] X s  -i g `aW be lfg _ fcVZ f `cX YfX`XfYc `W Z  aW `YaV c i g `e VjfbjV mfg fVW f] cbe `W Z  V lfg V  | b] V cXY`bVYc  { b eaVbZ l`bk l]b`XafW c fY c] lm m fg fVW f] cbe VjfbjaW  cX`Yc m `jV  VVW g `ZV e `bXVY `W Z `VZ VY
shvh  m f  W Z Xm `X `  b]V cXY`bVY _YfZ ] lV c `X bV`cX X f Xag Vc g fYV { b Xm `W ` WfYk g `b g `ccajV cX`Y  d VlVWXbe i `W VY  
shhr  _ YVcVW XV Z  YcX { b e aVbZ l`bl] b`XafW c fY YfX`XaW  g `ccajV cX`Yc  VX VVW v  ut  i  m alm c] V cX `W { b VW m `W lVg VWX f `lXfYc q  st  aXm YV c_ V lX Xf W fW kYfX`XaW cX`Yc  XmV cV YVc]bXc l`W  V lfW  Yg VZ i { b _Yf Z] lXafW  e g `ccajV YfX`XaW  cX`Yc lf]bZ lfWXYa ]XV caW a l`W Xbe Xf Xm V XfX`b `b`lXal { b ] Z VX $ %& %&  '(          4    ) %    ' ^X`Yc f aWXVYg VZa`XV fY bf g `cc
% v   c_ VW Z Xm V b`cX _ `YX f XmVaY `lXajV baV fW Xm V { ceg _ XfXal  a`WX n Y`W lm
{  n  f XmV VYX c_ Y] Wkd ] ccVb Za`Y`g  { X Xm `X _ m `cV f Vjfb] XafW ` cX`Y m `c XVYg aW `XVZ V  ] YWaW  aW aXc lfYV `W Z lfW cacXc f ` Z VVW VY`XVZ `W Z aWVYX l`Y fW kfe VW lfYV i c] YYf] W ZV Z e ` Vk ] YW aW  cmVbb i ` k ]YW aW  cmVbb i `W Z

v ` kVW jVbf_ V  w mV VW jVbf_ V ac lfg _ bVXVbe lfW jVlXajV i  ]X XmV ZV_ Xm f aXc _ VW VXY`XafW aW caZV Xm V cX`Y ac _ ffYbe " W f W  w mV Z f]  bVkcm Vbb ] YW aW _ m `cV ac ]W cX` bV i bV`ZaW  Xf Xm V ZVjVbf_ g VWX f Xm VYg `b _ ]bcV c i  malm _ YfYVccajVbe V_ Vbb Xm V cXVbb`Y VWjVbf_ V fW ` Xag V cl`bV f ` V st  st eV `Yc
Z V_ VW ZaW  fW Xm V cXVbb`Y g `cci fYg aW  ` _b`W VX`Ye W V] b`  { b ac Xmf] m X Xf  V _ YfZ] lVZ aW X f YVafW c f c] lm cX`Yc z aYcXbe i { b g `e  V _YfZ ] lV Z aW XmV k ]YW aW  cm Vbb `X XVg _ VY`X] YV c   st   m abV aW cX`Yc f aWaXa`b g `ccVc    { b ac _ Yf Z] lVZ  e _ YfXfW l`_ X]YV fW _YVkVacXaW     i fY g fYV g `ccajV cX`Yc Xm V k ] YWaW cm Vbb XVg _ VY`X] YV ac mam VWf] m Xf VW m `W lV Xm V { b ` ]W Z `W lV j a` XmV  ( 
_ i    { b
+ ,   
_ i  { b lm `aW
V    z fYV cXaW a `W Z U m `Y fW WVb s hh  f VjVY i `c Xm V g V`W k] YW aW  cm Vbb XVg _ VY`X] YV aW lYV`cVc  aXm Xag V i { b  VaW c Xf  V _ `YXa`bbe ZV cXYfeVZ e { b
_ i   YV`lXafW c b`XV `bfW XmV {  n Vjfb] XafW  o VYafZal`bbe `XVY XmV Vk `cm i  m VW kcmVbb  ]YW aW  ac XVg _ fY`Yabe VXaW lXi Xm V lfW jVlXajV VWjVbf_ V Z VclVW Z c Zf W Xf XmV kcm Vbb `W Z  YaWc ] _ Xm V k ] YWaW  _YfZ ] lXc f Xm `X cm Vbb i `W Z Xm ] c { b i Xf Xm V c] Y`lV
q
Z YV ZVk] _  ^VlfW Zbe i a XmV lfWjVlXajV VWjVbf_ V YV`lm Vc Xm V k ]YW aW  cm Vbb i Xm V XVg _ VY`X] YV `X Xm V  `cV  Vlfg V c c] laVWXbe m am fY Xm V fW cVX f W] lbV`Y  ]YW aW   W cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW l`bl] b`XafW ci Xm ac m fXk fXXfg  ] YWaW 
n n  VW VY`bbe `_ _ V`Yc
fY cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe  fY cX`Yc  aXm aW aXa`b g `ccV c    
V   `ccaba`Zac `W Z ffZ shhqi n bfVl"VY shhi zfYVcXaWa `W Z U m `Y fW WVb s hh  w mV VacXVW lV f n n ac c] __ fYXVZ e f cVYj`XafW c f VW m `W lVZ a ` ] W Z `W lVc aW {  n cX`Yc
^g aXm `W Z `g  VYX s h v h  VW lV { b g am X  V ZaYVlXbe _ YfZ] lVZ aW caZ V Xm V lfWjVlXajV VWjVbf_ V e _ YfXfW l`_ X]YV fW VaXm VY _ YVk V acXaW   i fY fY c] laVWXbe m am XVg _ VY`X]YVc  m alm f ll] Y `X Xm V VW Z f Xm V {  n _m `cV fY g `ccajV cX`Yc i fW   c] __ baVZ e ( 
_ i   YV `lXafW c
V  zfYV cXaW a `W Z U m `Y fW WVb shh   ^aW lV Xm V g V `W X] YW kfjVY Xag V f Xm V lfWjVlXajV VWjVbf_ V `g f] WXc Xf fW be t   eY i { b `_ _ V`Yc `bg fcX aW cX`WX`WVf] cbe `X Xm V c]Y`lV f Xm V cX`Y Yfg  m alm aX ac V_ VbbVZ aW Xf XmV ^ e cXVbb`Y  aW Z c o YfZ] lXc f XmV Vk ] YWaW cm Vbb g `e `bcf  V g a VZ aW Xm V ]_ _ VY b`eVYc `XVY ` Xm VYk g `b _] bcV `W Z  W `bbe Xf XmV c] Y`lV i `XVY XmV W VX ZYVZ Vk] _ V_acf ZV  zfY c]  laVWXbe mam XVg _ VY`X] YVc aW XmV  `cV f XmV Vkcm Vbb
  u# st      g `e  V _ YfZ] lVZ e Xm V | V
2 i W    YV `lXafW  m alm g `e  V g a VZ aWXf YVafW c f { b _ YfZ ] lXafW i lfW caZVY` be VWm `W laW  Xm V { b e aVbZ    cVYj`XafW c i m f VjVY i Z f WfX c] _ _ fYX Xm ac aZV ` i " "   *                 "  * !                   "    !            %   "                  "   %      * !       )       " * !        "  "  * !      %        * !                      * !*  "      %     %    "  "  * !          !    " *!      * !            %          * !               * !    "  " * !        * !           * !      !            %   "            "   * !         "     %      

h caW lV cfg V f Xm V _ YfZ] lVZ   cm f] bZ `bcf  V ZYVZ V Zk]_ Xf XmV c] Y`lV i bV`Z aW  Xf _ `YXal]b`Y  acfXf_al `Wfg `baVc i  m alm m `jV W fX  VVW f cVYjV Z cf `Y
 `g  VYX shvh    W XmV fXm VY m `W Z i { b Yfg Xm V k ]YW aW  cm Vbb ac `bcf g a VZ aW Xm V aWXVYcm Vbb YVafW  m VYV aX g amX  V ZVcXYfeVZ e W V] XYfW l`_ X] YV c
`ccVY ] Y   shhp 

1

10

100

1

10

100

Final stellar mass (in M

sol

)

Initial stellar mass (in M

sol

)

WD

SN II

SN Ib/c

AGB wind

WR wind

C/O core

     
     # # !    #  #   " )#    ,% z aYcX { b e aVbZ _ YV ZalXafW c  `cV Z fW ] bb Vjfb] XafW `Ye g fZVbc  VYV YV lVWXbe _YV cVWXVZ e zfYVcXaW a `W Z U m `Y fW W Vb
shh   x ] V Xf Xm V lfg _ bV _ Yf Z] lk XafW g Vlm `W acg aWjfbjVZ i Xm V { b e aVbZ ac W fX ` g fWfXfWal ] W lXafW f Xm V cXVbk b`Y g `cc | VjVYXm VbVcc i ` VW VY`b XYVW Z VacXc fY aW aXa`bbe g fYV g `ccajV cX`Yc Xf _Yf Z] lV m amVY { b eaVbZc W _ `YXal] k b`Y i Xm VaY g fcX g `ccajV g fZ Vbc cm f ` c] cX`W Xa`b W VX ZVcXY] lXafW f (  Xfk VXm VY  aXm ` W VX _ YfZ ] lXafW f    aW Xm V k ] YW aW  cm Vbb i  m alm aW X]YW bV`Zc Xf `W VW m `W lVg VW X f Xm V { b eaVbZ Z] V Xf Xm V _ YVcVW lV f `Z ZaXafW `b cVVZ W ] lbVa  | fXV i mf VjVY i Xm `X Xm ac bV`Zc Xf c]  cX`W Xa`b `W fg `baV c aW Xm V  (     acfXf_ al ` ] W Z`W lV Y`k Xafc i  m alm m `jV WfX  VVW f cVYjVZ cf `Y
cVV `g  VYX s h v hi n `Y ] e   s hh u i `W Z YVVYVW lVc Xm VYVaW  zfYVcXaW a `W Z U m `Y fW W Vb
s hh  l`bl] b`XVZ g fZVbc fY  fXm cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe `W Z
 t #u    mabV XmVaY q  g f ZVb Yf]m be cl`bVc  aXm

 m alm aW Zal`XV c Xm `X { b  `c fW be _ YfZ ] lVZ e _YfXfW l`_ X]YV fW _ YVkV acXaW    i Xm V caX] `XafW  Vlfg V c g fYV lfg _ bal`XVZ fY XmV g fYV g `ccajV g fZ Vbc  W ZVVZ i XmVaY bf g VX`bbalaXe   g fZ Vb _ YfZ] lVc Yf] m be  ut Xag V c `c g ] lm { b `c XmV cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe g fZ Vb $ %& % @    @    '  % !         `We cX`Yc bffcV ` lfW caZ VY` bV `g f]W X f Xm VaY aW aXa`b g `cc Z ]YaW  XmVaY Vjfb] XafW e cXVbb`Y  aW Zc
l z a  sq mabV cX`Yc aW aXa`bbe bV cc g `ccajV Xm `W  v  XVYg aW `XV XmVaY bajV c `c  m aXV Z `Yci cX`Yc  aXm aW aXa`b g `ccVc ` fjV Xm ac bag aX g `e V _bf ZV `c lfYV lfbb`_ cV c] _ VYWfj`V1 n Vl`] cV f Xm VaY ag _ fYX`W X g `cc bfcci Xm V `Z j`W lVZ    %  %     "         %    "            %  %  "      $* *         '    %        "           "        %    %    )     %          %     %  " %        %     "      "        " 

st Vjfb] XafW f d cX`Yc
aW aXa`b g `cc   qt   ac Y`Xm VY ]W lVYX`aW  w mfcV cX`Yc g `e `bg fcX lfg _bVXVbe Vj`_ fY`XV Z ]YaW  Xm VaY Vjfb]XafW i bV`jaW ` _YVc] _ VYW fj` cX`Y f fWbe ` V  i  m alm _ Yf ` be V _ bfZV c `c ` Xe _ V  l c]_ VYW fj`
V   i ffcbVe   s hh q i `W Z YVVYVW lVc Xm VYVaW  w m V Vjfb] XafW f bVcc g `ccajV cX`Yc aW Xm V g `cc Y`WV v    u ac WfX g ] lm V VlXVZ  e g `cc bfcc i `X bV`cX fY aWaXa`b g VX`bbalaXaVc
%  i `W Z `YV V_ V lXVZ Xf V _ bfZV `c Xe_ V  c] _ VYW fj`V  ^] lm cX`Yc ZVjVbf_ cmVbb k] YW aW `X XVg _ VY`X]YVc  
 h  st  bV `Z aW Xf ` g fZVY`XV _ YfZ ] lXafW f { b `X Xm V  `cV f Xm V cm Vbb  ] lm g fYV ag _ fYX`W X cVVg c Xf  V Xm V _ YfZ ] lXafW f { b aW Xm V l`Y fW `W Z fe VW k WVfW ( cm Vbbci ] cX _YafY Xf Xm V c] _ VYW fj` V_ bfcafW c W Xm VcV cm Vbbci { b ac _ YfZ] lVZ e _ YfXfW l`_X] YV fW   `X XVg _ VY`X] YVc   s#  st5  fW Xag V cl`bVc f ` V eV`Yc | V] XYfW ci V ccVWXa`bbe _YfjaZ VZ  e 1U
2 iW  `W Z | V
2 iW  YV`lXafW ci `YV Xm V g `aW ZV cXY] lXafW `VWX f { b i `bfW   aXm + , Z Vl`e
Xm V + , ZV l`e Y`XV ac c] cX`W Xa`bbe VW m `W lVZ `X Xm VcV mam XVg _ VY`X] YVc Z] V Xf Xm V _ f_] b`XafW f Xm V acfg VYal cX`XV f { b  U fWjVlXafW aW Xm VcV cm Vbbc ac f _ `Y`g f]W X ag _ fYX`W lV caW lV aX l`W cag ] bX`WVf] cbe YaW  bam X YV `lX`W Xc `W Z cVVZ W] lbVa aW Xf Xm V m fX fW V Xf `aZ aW Xm V ce WXm Vcaci `W Z Xm VW YVg fjV Xm V Y`abV _ YfZ ] lX Yfg XmV m am XVg _ VY`X] YV YVafW  m VYV aX g amX fXm VY acV  V ZV cXYfeVZ  U fW cV] VWXbe i g `fY ]W lVYX`aW XaV c aW Xm V { b eaVbZ VcXag `XV c `YacV Yfg Xm V XYV`Xg VWX f Xag VkZV_ VW ZVW X lfWjVlXafW i fY  m alm W f c`Xac`lXfYe Xm VfYe ac `j`ab` bV cf `Y  m VW Xm V cXVbb`Y lfYV lfbb`_ cVc i Xm V f] XfaW  cm fl"  `jV m V`Xc Xm V aW W VY fW Vc f Xm V U `W Z  k| V cm Vbbc Xf _ V`" XVg _ VY`X] YV c   
u  q  st5  i c]  laVWXbe m am Xf aWaXV V _ bfcajV W] lbVfceW XmV cac \  _bfcajV W ] lbVfceWXm Vcac f { b aW Xm V l`Y fW `W Z WVfW cm Vbb m `jV  VVW cX] Z aVZ aW W] g VYf] c  fY" c  malm  W Z lfW caZ VY` bV `g f]W Xc _ YfZ] lVZ aW Xm V  k| V b`eVY i `W Z cg `bbVY `g f] WXc aW Xm V b`eVYc f V_ bfcajV U k] YW aW  w m V V_ bfcajV { b _ Yf Z] lXafW g `e  V ]YXm VY VW m `W lVZ e  qt-  t -Z] V Xf W V]XYaW fkaW Z ] lV Z W] lbVfceW XmV cac i `bcf YVVYVZ Xf `c Xm V k_ YflVcc
ffcbVe   s hh t W Xmac _YflVcc i `ZZ aXafW `b _YfXfW c `YV ba VY`XVZ e kc_ `bb`XafW f Xm V ` ] W Z `WX _ YVV_ bfcajV acfXf_ Vc

| V i  i 1| ` i (  i  m alm `YV l`_X] YVZ fW   Xf _YfZ ] lV { b w m V g `fY ]W lVYX`aW Xe f Xmac g V lm `W acg `YacVc Yfg Xm V ]W " Wf W W V] XYaW f c_ V lXY] g Vg aXXVZ Yfg XmV lfYV lfbb`_ cV  { b _Yf Z] lXafW aW Xe _ V  c] _ VYW fj`V m `c  VVW VcXag `XVZ  e j`Yaf] c Yf]_ c
V   w Y]Y`W `W Z U `g VYfW s h v i V`jVY `W Z ffcbVe s hh q i w m aVbVg `WW   s hh p i ffcbVe `W Z V `jVY shhi w m aVbVg `W W   shhr   w m Ve  W Z Xm `X Xm V { b eaVbZ ac WfX ` g fW fXfW al ] W lXafW f Xm V cXVbb`Y g `cc i Z V_ VW ZaW  aW ` lfg _ balX`XV Z  `e fW Xm V cXVbb`Y _m ecalc | VjVYXmVbV cci ` VWVY`b XYVW Z V acXc f aW lYV `caW  { b eaVbZ  aXm aW lYV`caW  aWaXa`b cXVbb`Y g `cc  ^VlfW Z be i Xm V { b e aVbZ Z V_ VW Zc lYaXal`bbe fW Xm V XYV `Xg VWX f cVg aklfWjVlXafW `W Z g `e j`Ye e `lXfYc f q  su
o Y`WX fc `W Z x aVm b s hh r z aW `bbe i         $%  %  ' #           " )                    "    $      '

ss XmV { b _YfZ ] lXafW g `e `bcf ZV_ VW Z fW Xm V aW aXa`b g VX`bbalaXe f Xm V _ YfVW aXfY cX`Y caW  _ `Y`g VXYa V Z l`bl] b`XafW c ffcbVe `W Z V `jVY
shvt  cm f V Z Xm `X `W aW lYV`cV f g VX`bbalaXe Yfg
 s  Xf u    bV`Z c Xf ` Z VlYV `cV aW Xm V { b eaVbZ f W V`Ybe ` `lXfY f u w m ac l`W  V ] W Z VYcXffZ Z] V Xf `W aW lYV`cVZ W V] XYfW  ]  aW Xm V b`eVYc f { b ceWXm Vcac i _ Yfj aZV Z  e YV`lXafW c fW | V i  m fcV ` ] W Z`W lV ac Z aYV lXbe _ Yf_ fYXafW `b Xf
 fYV YVlVWX l`bl] b`XafW c f ffcbVe `W Z V `jVY
s hh  fY bf kg VX`bbalaXe cX`Yc YVjV`b m f VjVY ` lfg _ bV ZV_ VW ZVW lV f { b _YfZ ] lXafW fW g VX`bbalaXe  aXm VaXm VY ZV lYV`caW i aW lYV`caW  fY VjVW  ] lX] `XaW  YVb`XafW ccm a_ c i Z V_ VW ZaW  fW Xm V aW aXa`b g `cc f XmV _ YfVW aXfY { bXm f]m W f { b _Yf Z] lXafW l`bl]b`XafW c  `cVZ fW ] bb Vjfb] XafW `Ye g fZ Vbc V acX cf `Y fY Xm V Xe_ V  l c]_ VYW fj` clVW `Yaf i Xm V { b eaVbZ fY Xm VcV fV lXc g `e  V VcXag `XVZ Yfg YVlVWX l`bl] b`XafW c fY g `cc bffcaW  m Vba]g cX`Yc  e ffcbVe  
shh   w m Ve aZVW Xa VZ Xm VcV f VlXc `c fbkd `eVX cX`Yc f aW aXa`b g `cc   qt  i lfYYVc_ fW Z aW  Xf m Vba] g lfYVc  aXm    st   z fY c] lm lfYVc i ffcbVe  
shh  ZVYajVZ { b e aVbZ c  VX VVW
p  r st'    w m ac eaVbZ cm f]bZ W fX ZV_ VW Z ZY`cXal`bbe fW XmV aWaXa`b g `cc f Xm V _ YfVWaXfY cX`Y caW lV g `cc ZV_ VW ZVW X g `cckbfcc bV`Zc Xf lfW jVYVWX _YVc] _ VYW fj` g `ccVc `Yf]W Z  p 
l z a  sq $ %& % /     w m V f] X ]YcX f W fj`V `YV c] VcXVZ Xf `YacV Yfg Xm V `llYVXafW f ` lYaXal`b g `cc f me ZYfVW kYalm g `XVYa`b Yfg ` lfg _ `W afW cX`Y  bbaW aXc d flm V bf V fW Xm V c] Y`lV f `  m aXV Z  `Y
x  i bV`ZaW  Xf ` Xm VYg fW] lbV`Y Y] W ` `e zfY Xm V _ me cal`b lfW Z aXafW c Xm `X `YV V_ VlXV Z aW Xm ac VW jaYfW g VW X
XVg _ VY`X]YV  
u  p  st  i ZVW caXe
 u st(  lg '1 i Xm VYg fW] lbV`Y  ] YW aW   abb _YflVVZ  e g V`W c f m eZ YfVW  ] YW aW  fW l`Y fW i WaXYfVW i `W Z f eVW
U |   fY m V`jaVY W ] lbVa _ YVcVWX aW Xm V cm Vbb g `XXVY U b`eXfW `W Z febV
sh p   VYV Xm V  YcX  m f c]VcXV Z Xm `X c]  cX`WXa`b `g f]W Xc f { b g `e  V _ YfZ] lVZ aW XmV V _bfcajV me ZYfVW  ]YW aW   m alm fll] Yc Z ]YaW  Wfj` f] X ]YcXc ^X] ZaVc f W] lbVfceW XmV cac aW c] lm lfW Z aXafW c cm f Xm `Xi Z V_ VW ZaW  fW Xm V lm `Y`lXVYacXal Xag Vcl`bV f XmV V _bfcafW
` V stt c i W fX fW be    ] X `bcf Xm V g fYV ` ]W Z `W X (  l`W  V XY`W cfYg VZ aWXf { b i  e ( 
_ i  { b
+ ,  
_ i  { b i _YfjaZ VZ Xm VYV ac VW f] m Xag V fY Xm V + , Z Vl`e f { b Xf X`"V _ b`lV
   st c mabV Wfj` VjVWXc  aXm mV `je VbVg VWX lfg _ fcaXafW f cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe bV`Z fW be Xf g `YaW `b { b _Yf Z] lXafW i VW Yalm g VWX f XmV VWjVbf_ V e VbVg VWXc aW Xm V Y`WV Yfg WVfW Xf `b] g aW a] g YV`Xbe aW lYV`cV c { b eaVbZ c
Vacc `W Z wY] Y`W shht i | f`Y   shhsi `W Z YVVYVW lV c Xm VYVaW   w mV _ YVcVW lV f caW a l`WX VWYalm g VWXc f U |  fY aWXVYg VZ a`XVkg `cc VbVg VWXc aW XmV VVlX` f g fcX lb`ccal`b Wfj`V c]VcXc Xm `X _ `YX f Xm V x c]Y`lV ac g aVZ aWXf XmV `llYVXVZ VW jVbf_ V g `XVYa`b  d VlVWXbe i lfW caZ VY` bV `XXVWXafW  `c Z aYV lXVZ Xf `YZ c cfkl`bbVZ  | V kYalm Wfj`V  malm cm f cXYfW  Vg accafW baW Vc f m V`j e VbVg VW Xc i aW _ `YXal]b`Y | V i aW Xm VaY c_ VlXY` i `W Z _ fccabe fYg st-  ut -f `bb `b`lXal W fj` VjVW Xc

su
aj af `W Z w Y]Y`W s hh p i `W Z YVVYVW lVc Xm VYVaW  w mV VW m `W lVg VWX f  aW Xm V k ] YW aW VWjVbf_ V Xm VW _Yfj aZ Vc `W ` ]W Z `W X YVcVYjfaY f cVV Z W] lbVa fY { b _ YfZ ] lXafW  w  f _ fcca bV clVW `Yafc  m alm g `e ajV YacV Xf  | V kYalm W fj`V `YV l] YYVWXbe Zacl] ccV Z aW XmV baXVY`X]YV   W Xm V fW V m `W Z i Xm Ve g `e `YacV Yfg XmVYg fW] lbV`Y V _ bfcafW c fW  | V  x c
` `W Z d aXXVY shvqi w Y]Y`W `W Z aj af shvr  i  m alm _ fcca be VjfbjV Z Yfg cX`Yc f aW aXa`b g `ccV c  VX VVW v    su 
V  | fg fXf shvp   z fY Xm ac clVW `Yaf i { b eaVbZc m `jV  VVW V cXag `XV Z YV lVWXbe ] caW s kZag VW cafW `b me ZYfZ eW `g al cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW lf ZVc lf]_ bVZ Xf W] lbV`Y YV`lXafW W VX fY"c
o fbaX`W f   s hhi fcV   s hh  w mV YVc]bXc Z V_ VW Z lYaXal`bbe fW g `We i fXVW _ ffYbe "W f W i _ `Y`g VXVYc f Xm V g f ZVbci ba"V XmV W ] lbV`Y YV`lXafW Y`XVc
V   U f l   shhi Xm V ] W ZVYbeaW  x lfg _ fcaXafW
V   fcV   s hh  i Xm V XYV `Xg VWX f lfWjVlXafW i Xm V g `cc `llYVXafW Y`XV i fY Xm V `g f]W X f VWYalm g VWX f Xm V W fj` VW jVbf_ V  aXm m V`j e VbVg VW Xc
V     fb `W Z o fbaX`W f shh   U fW cV] VWXbe i eaVbZ V cXag `XVc fY Za VYVWX l`bl] b`XafW c j`Ye  e ` f] X fW V g `W aX] ZV  { ZZ aXafW `bbe i `bb g fZ Vbc `ab Xf `llf]X fY Xm V b`YV VVlXVZ g `ccVc
st'(  st'1    m alm `YV f cVYjVZ fY  | V kYalm W fj`V  w m ac bV Z ^m `Y` `W Z o Ya`bW a"
s hh p  Xf _Yf_ fcV ` W V clVW `Yaf fY  | V kYalm W fj`V  w m Ve c] VcXV Z Xm `X bf kg `cc U   m aXV Z  `Yc g `e `l] aYV ` YVb`XajVbe Xmal" f] XVY b`eVY f  | V kYalm g `XVYa`b  e Y`_ aZ `llYVXafW
 st'  eY'  f me ZYfVW kYalm g `XXVY Yfg Xm V lfg _ `WafW i Xm `X  ] YW c ] aVXbe
aW Xm VYg `b V ]aba Ya] g  aWXf m Vba] g i  m alm aW X]YW ac ] YWX V_ bfcajVbe aWXf mV `j aVY VbVg VWXc aW ` cVYaVc f g abZ  `cm Vc d V lVW Xbei o Ya`baW " `W Z ^m `Y`
shh l`bl] b`XVZ Xm V  YcX cVbklfW cacXVWX  | V kYalm Wfj` g fZVb  `cVZ fW Xm ac clVW `Yaf  ^] Y_ YacaW be i ZV c_ aXV Xm V Za VYVW lVc  VX VVW Xm V clVW `Yafc i Xm V VVlX` lfg _ fcaXafW f X`aW VZ ac Y`Xm VY cag ab`Y Xf Xm V  | V  x g fZVbc f o fbaX`W f  
shh W lfW XY`cXi XmV VVlXVZ g `ccVc `YV ` f] X fW V g `W aX] ZV b`YVY Xm `W fY  | V  x g fZVbc i g ] lm lbfcVY Xf Xm V f cVYj`XafW c   fcV  
shh  cXYVcc i m f VjVY i Xm `X Xm ac clVW `Yaf YV ]aYV c `  WV X] W aW  f cfg V _ `Y`g VXVYc YVb`XajV Xf Xm V lfg _ `W afW i c] lm `c Xm V g `cc `llYVXafW Y`XV $ %& %  
  $ '     ' W z a sp i { b e aVbZ VcXag `XV c fY Xm V Zacl] ccV Z l`W ZaZ`XV cf] YlVc `YV lfg _ abVZ `c ` ] W lXafW f aW aXa`b cXVbb`Y g `cc {  n eaVbZ c  VYV X`"VW Yfg n ` `W  
s hh q `W Z z fYVcXaWa `W Z U m `Y fWW Vb
shh  i  m VYV fW be XmV b`XXVY e aVbZ c `YV XmV YVc] bX f cVbklfW cacXVW X Vjfb]XafW `Ye g fZ Vbc n ` `W  
s hh q ZVYajVZ XmVaY VcXag `XVc ] ck aW `W `be Xal V_ YVccafW c f cXVbb`Y VWjVbf_ V g f ZVbc `cc] g aW  Xm `X `bb { b ac _ YfZ] lVZ Z] YaW  m fXk fXXfg  ]YW aW   w m V lfg _ `YacfW f  fXm  fY" c abb] cXY`XVc XmV XYVg VW Z f] c ]W lVYX`aW XaV c aWjfbjVZ aW XmV _ YVZalXafW f { b _ Yf Z] lXafW Yfg {  n cX`Yc  | V  W fj` e aVbZ c  VYV X`"VW Yfg o Ya`baW" `W Z ^m `Y`
shh  i  fcV  
shh  i `W Z  fb `W Z o fbaX`Wf
shh   ^aW lV Wfj`V g `e ] W ZVYf W] g VYf] c f] X ] YcXc Z ]YaW  Xm V baVXag V f { b i Xm V ]fXVZ j`b]V c `YV XfX`b { b eaVbZ c Z] YaW  st e Y i `c ZVYajVZ Yfg   2    i  m VYV 2 ac XmV Y`Xaf f Xm V VVlXVZ g `cc Xf Xm V `llYVXV Z

sq

10

-8

10

-7

10

-6

10

-5

10

-4

10

-3

10

-2

10

Forestini & Charbonnel (1997)

Bazan et al. (1993)

José et al. (1997)

Prialnik & Shara (1995)

Kolb & Politano (1997)

Woosley & Weaver (1995)

Thielemann et al. (1996)

Meynet et al. (1996)

Langer et al. (1995)

Woosley et al. (1995)

Initial Stellar Mass (M

sol

)

26

Al yield (M

sol

)

      $  "    # $
  ),*     !   ),* "     )   ,* # "  ) ,*  "       ) !   ,% g `cci   ac XmV baVXag V f { bi   ac XmV { b `] W Z `W lV aW Xm V VVlX` `c _YVZ alXVZ e Xm V g f ZVb i `W Z  ac XmV g `cc `llYVXafW Y`XV fW Xm V x  z fY lfW cacXVW le `g fW XmV Za VYVWX l`bl]b`XafW c i { b eaVbZ c fY su   x c `YV ajVW i ] caW  2  s#u
`c c]VcXVZ e  fb `W Z o fbaX`W f shh  `W Z     u st' 
 eY ' w e _ V  c] _ VYW fj` eaVbZc  VYV X`"VW Yfg ffcbVe `W Z V `jVY
s hh  `W Z w m aVbVk g `WW  
shhr n fXm l`bl] b`XafW c Za VY aW W] g VYf] c Z VX`abc ba"V Xm V XYV`Xg VW X f lfW jVlXafW i W] lbV`Y YV `lXafW Y`XVc i fY Xm V V_ bfcafW g Vlm `Wacg
cVV ffcbVe `W Z V `jVY s hh  W _ `YXal] b`Y i ffcbVe `W Z V `jVY
s hh  fbbf VZ Xm V _ VYc] _ VYWfj` Vjfb] XafW e lf] _ baW ` b`YV YV`lXafW WVX fY"  aXm Xag V Z V_ VW ZVWX lfWjV lXafW i  mabV w m aVbVg `WW  
shhr  l`bl] b`XVZ fW be V _bfcajV { b _ Yf Z] lXafW  z fY Xe _ V  l c]k _ VYWfj`V i ` g `cc aW ZV_ VW Z VW X { b e aVbZ f r st'   `c `cc]g V Z `c c] V cXVZ e Xm V mVba] g cX`Y g fZVbc f ffcbVe  
shh zfY d cX`Yc i { b e aVbZ c  VYV X`"VW Yfg X f YVlVWX cX] ZaVc f `W VY  
s hh  `W Z VeW VX  
s hh  | fXV Xm `X V lV_ X fY XmV bf VcX g `ccV c i  fXm VcXag `XV c `YV aW `aYbe ff Z `YVVg VWXi ZVc_ aXV Xm V Za VYVW X _ me calc aWjfbjVZ aW Xm V l`bl] b`XafW c
g `cc bfcc `W Z XYV`Xg VW X f lfWjV lXafW  VeW VX  
s hh  c] V cX Xm `X Xm ac lf] bZ  V Z] V Xf ` c]  XbV  `b`W lV  VX VVW Xm V V VlX f ` lm `W V aW g `cc bfcc `W Z Xm V ag _ `lX f ` Za VYVWX g aaW  clm Vg V  w m V ]W lVYX`aW XaVc f { b _Yf Z] lXafW aW d cX`Yc g `e aW YV`baXe  V b`YVY `c XmfcV c] V cXVZ e lfg _ `YacfW f  fXm  fY" c  w mV XfX`b `g f]W X f { b _YfZ ] lV Z  e V`lm l`W ZaZ`XV cf]YlV _ VY { b baVXag V
  

sp st eY l`W  V VcXag `XV Z e Xm V V_ YVccafW     ^z d

  
 
   
ss  m VYV ^z d ac Xm V `b`lXal cX`Y fYg `XafW Y`XV i ajVW m VYV aW cX`Yc eY' i  
  ac Xm V { b eaVbZ f fW V fVlX f ` cf] YlV lb`cc
aW  cX`Y '   i  m alm VWVY`bbe ac ` ] W lXafW f XmV aWaXa`b cXVbb`Y g `cc  i 
  ac Xm V aW aXa`b g `cc ] W lXafW
 z i  m alm c_ V la Vc Xm V Y`lXafW f cX`Yc fYg V Z  aXm aWaXa`b cXVbb`Y g `cc  aXm aW Xm V aWXVYj`b     i `W Z   `W Z   `YV XmV bf VY `W Z ]_ _ VY aW aXa`b cXVbb`Y g `cc bag aXc fY XmV lfW caZ VYV Z cf] YlV lb`cc  
  ac W fYg `ba V Z mVYV Xf fW V cX`Y aW Xm V g `cc aWXVYj`b    t#tv  `W Z    stt#t  

 
   s#
su  zfY Xm V g `cc c_ VlXY]g i ` _ f VYkb`  z 
    ' 
sq  ac `_ _baV Z fY  m alm cbf_ V V cXag `XVc Y`WV Yfg    s#s Xf    u #p
V   ^ `b_ VXVY shi ] g _ m YVe c `W Z l\ bYfe shvp i  Yf] _ `   shhqi `ccVe   shh   w m V ^ z d  abb  V Z VXVYg aW VZ e l`baY`XafW f Xm V  z fW XmV f cVYjVZ eg `W lfW XaW ] ]g
 hsu { _ m fXfW _Yf Z] lXafW Y`XV 
V  V VY shvvi ] caW  Xm V YVb`XafW ^ z d   

 
 

 
   
sp   m VYV 

  ac Xm V W ]g  VY f eg `W lfWXaW] ] g
 el  _ m fXfW c _YfZ ] lVZ _ VY cVlfW Z  e `W aW Z ajaZ] `b cX`Y f aW aXa`b g `cc  i `W Z 
  ac Xm V XfX`b baVXag V f c] lm ` cX`Y  z fY 

  Xm V YVlVW X l`baY`XafW f  `ll`  
shhr   `c ] cV Z i baVXag V c  VYV X`"VW Yfg Xm V Vjfb]XafW `Ye l`bl] b`XafW c f ^lm `bbVY  
s hh u w mV `b`lXal e l b]g aW fcaXe ac V cXag `XVZ Xf   q#t st1 _m c'  fW  `cac f Y`Zaf f cVYj`XafW c f `b`lXal  YVafW c
V VY sh vi `W Z m `c YVlVW Xbe  VVW aWVYYVZ Yfg z d { ^ f cVYj`XafW c f Xm V |  lffbaW baW V `X ut   g Xf   q#  st1 _ m c'
n VWW VXX   s hh p  W Xm ac  fY" i Xm V b`XXVY j`b] V ac ] cVZ fY  m alm n VW W VXX  
s hh p  V cXag `XV `W ] W lVYX`aWXe f  t-  d Vc]bXaW  { b eaVbZ VcXag `XVc   `YV cm f W fY {  n cX`Yc i Xe_ V  `W Z Xe _ V  l c] _ VYW fj`V i `W Z fbkd `eVX cX`Yc aW w ` c ss `W Z su fY X f Z a VYVWX cVXc f W ] lbVfceW XmV cac g fZ Vb l`bl]b`XafW c `W Z fY cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe w m V X` bVc Z a VY aW Xm V `cc] g VZ g `cc bag aX   ` fjV  malm cX`Yc Vm aaX ` d _ m `cV `W Z c]  cV] VW Xbe V _bfZV `c Xe_ V  l c]_ VYW fj`
   pt  fY w `  ss `W Z    u  fY w `  su   ^X`Yc  aXmaW XmV aWaXa`b g `cc aWXVYj`b f v       VYV `cc]g V Z Xf V _bfZV `c Xe _ V  c]_ VYW fj`V i  m abV cX`Yc  aXm aW s    v  VYV `cc]g V Z Xf VVlX { b Z] YaW  Xm V XmVYg `bk_] bcV {  n _ m `cV 

s    s#si
 s   VlX     
                {  n s  v  #r st'  s#q st p#p st' t tr u #v st' q t ^|  v  pt  #u st'1 s#u st( r#r st' t vs q #h st' tt ^|  l pt  stt r #v st'( s#r st1 r#t st' t st d pt  stt r #v st'( s#r st 1 u#u st'( t qr u #p st'( tqh w fX`b t#tv  stt s#t u #q st sqq p sp
tpp    s#q i
 s    VlX     
                  {  n s  v q #s st'  u # h st q#p st' t st u #s st' rt  ^|  v  pt s#v st'1 s# st(  #v st' t  h q #  st' ttr ^|  l pt  stt s#r st'( s# st1 r#t st' t th d pt  stt s#r st'( s# st 1 u#s st'( t qu u #p st'( tqr w fX`b t#tv  stt st h # st spv rp
tpu    s# i
 s   VlX     
                {  n s  v s#q st'  h #u st u#p st' t uu s#q st' ss ^|  v  pt q # st'( u #r st( p#v st' su  u # h st' tt ^|  l pt  stt u #t st'  s#p st1 r#t st' t tv d pt  stt u #t st'  s#p st 1 u#t st'( t uv u #u st'( tqs w fX`b t#tv  stt st r #h st svq sus
tqv    u#p i
 s   VlX     
                {  n s  v u #q st'1 v # st s#p st' sut p # st' pt  v ^|  v  pt s#r st '   #v st ( q# st ' u tq u #t st ' tsu ^|  l pt  stt q #t st' s#s st1 r#t st' t t d pt  stt q #t st' s#s st 1 s# st'( t sh u #t st'( tuu w fX`b t#tv  stt st q #v st5 q ph p ssu
tqp           $       #   "  
  #    *   *  *     %
     $ * !  $
    #
   !  )  ,* !       #  "    ),*      #  "    ),*  !     #  "    ) ,    %            $
    #      ),*      # !     ),*     #       ) ,% !    # !      !          " #   ! 
" ) !  ,  !   $      #    $   ) !   !  *  ",%   $       #        !    !    ! !   # $
 %
   "      *         #     !      %

sr    s#si
 s    V lX     
                {  n s  v  #r st' s#q st p#p st' ttr u#v st' q t ^|  v  u p # st'1 s#s st( q#q st' tq u#p st' ttq ^|  l u   stt s#p st'1 q#q st1 r#t st' tut d u   stt s#p st'1 q#q st1 s#u st'( tpt s#q st'( tpp w fX`b t#tv  stt s#t u#q st sts p s
t p     s#qi
 s    V lX     
                {  n s  v q #s st' u# h st q#p st' tst u#s st' rt  ^|  v  u s#r st'1 s# st( q#s st' tpr u#u st' ttq ^|  l u  stt q #r st'( q#p st 1 r#t st' tus d u   stt q #r st'( q#p st1 s#s st'( tq s#u st'( tp s w fX`b t#tv  stt st h #  st ssp r p h
t pp     s# i
 s    V lX     
                  {  n s  v s#q st' h #u st u#p st' tuu s#q st' ss ^|  v  u q #p st'( u#p st( u#h st' tr s#h st' tt ^|  l u  stt  #u st' q#r st 1 r#t st' tuu d u  stt  #u st ' q#r st 1 h#s st ' tqq s#t st '( tq w fX`b t#tv  stt st r#h st spp su sh
tpu     u#p i
 s    V lX     
                {  n s  v u #q st'1 v# st s#p st' sut p# st' pt v ^|  v  u s# st' #r st( u#p st' sqr s# st' ttv ^|  l u   stt h # h st' q# st1 r#t st' tuu d u  stt h #h st' q# st 1 r# st' tu #r st' tuv w fX`b t#tv  stt st q#v st5 qtq p ssp
tqr        % %  #        # "        #      !  %

s w mV aW  ] VW lV f Xm V  z cbf_ V fW Xm V YVc] bXaW  { b _Yf Z] lXafW Y`XVc ac abb] cXY`XVZ e j`Ya`XafW f   VX VVW Xm V VXYVg V  f] W Z `YaVc  s#s `W Z  u#p  w fVXm VY  aXm Xm V _Yf Z] lXafW Y`XVc   i Xm V W ]g  VY Y`lXafW  

 
   i Xm V cf]YlV YV ]VW le
 ^z d
aW cX`Yc _ VY e Yi `W Z Xm V g V`W { b eaVbZ      

  
 
   

 
  
s  f V`lm cf] YlV lb`cc ac ajVW  ^aW lV Xm V cX`Y fYg `XafW Y`XV ac l`baY`XVZ fW Xm V el b]g aWfcaXe i  m alm aW X] YW `YacVc g fcXbe Yfg cX`Yc aW aXa`bbe g fYV g `ccajV Xm `W   ut  i XmV d e aVbZ ac Xm V g fcX cX` bV _YfZ ] lXafW Y`XV ] W Z VY j`Ya`XafW f   aXm cXVV_ VW aW f Xm V  z cbf_ V i XmV lfW XYa ] XafW Yfg bVcc g `ccajV cX`Yc YacV ci bV`Z aW  Xf `W aW lYV`cV f Xm V XfX`b `b`lXal { b _YfZ ] lXafW Y`XV  | fXalV Xm `X Xm V {  n cX`Yc f n ` `W  
shhq  `b `ec lfW XYa ] XV `W ]W YV`cfW ` be mam `g f] WX f { b
YVl`bb Xm `X f cVYj`XafW c f Xm V sv V  kY`e baW V c]VcX ` XfX`b `b`lXal { b g `cc `Yf] W Z  q   w m V _Yf Z] lXafW Y`XVc f zfYVcXaW a `W Z U m `Y fWW Vb
shh i  m alm aW lfWXY`cX Xf n ` `W  
s hh q `YacV Yfg cVbklfW cacXVW X Vjfb] XafW `Ye g f ZVbc i `YV `b `e c bf VY  e `lXfYc f  q   rt
zfY lfW cacXVW le aX ac  fYXm m abV Xf lfg _ `YV cfg V _ YVZ alXV Z ] `W XaXaVc Yfg w ` c ss `W Z su  aXm f cVYj`XafW c { bXm f] m Y`XmVY ] W lVYX`aW i XmV Y`XV f `b`lXal ^ | ac V ck Xag `XVZ Xf u , '  _ VY lVWX] Ye Yfg  malm vt- `YV Xm f] mX Xf `YacV Yfg lfYV lfbb`_ cV VjVWXc
VabVY `W Z ^Y`g V" shvvi `W Z YVVYVW lVc XmVYVaW  w mV YV ]VW le f lfYV lfbk b`_ cV c] _ VYW fj`V aW XmV X`bV c
lfb]g W p  j`YaVc  VX VVW s#p  r #t _ VY lVWX] Ye i  mVYV b`YVY j`b] Vc `YV fX`aW VZ fY cXVV_ VY  z cbf_ Vc W jaV f Xm V ]W lVYX`aW Xe aW  f t- i `bb j`b]V c aW XmV X` bV `YV ] W lVYX`aW e Xm V c`g V `g f] WX i m VW lV Xm V ^ | V ]VW le g ] cX  V YV`YZV Z `c lfW cacXVWX  aXm Xm V VcXag `XVc fYV lfW cXY`aW aW  i m f VjVY i ac Xm V YVb`XajV Y`XV f c] _ VYWfj`V f Xe_ V  l Xf Xe _ V  i fY  malm VcXag `XVc YV`lm Yfg t#sv Xf s#ph
] bbVY   shhui U `_ _ Vbb`Yf   shhqi j`W ZVW n VYm `W Z lU b]YV shhp i w `g g `W W   s hh p i U `_ _ Vbb`Yf   s hh  zfY ` d cX`Y g `cc bag aX f    pt  Y`Xm VY bf Y`Xafc  VX VVW t #tu  t#sq `YV fX`aW VZ i  m alm `YV aW lfW cacXVW X  aXm Xm V VcXag `XVc
l  w `  ss   f VYaW Xm V g `cc bag aX Xf `YZ c    u 
l  w `  su  aW lYV`cVc Xm V W ]g  VY f Xe _ V  l `W Z bf VYc Xm fcV f Xe _ V  ^| V i bV`ZaW Xf g fYV lfW cacXVW X Y`Xafc  VX VVW t #t  t#qt { j`b] V f    u   ac `bcf c] _ _ fYXVZ e lfYYVb`XafW cX] ZaV c  VX VVW Xm V f cVYjVZ Z acXYa ] XafW f d cX`Yc  aXm Xm `X f  kXe_ V cX`Yc
x ffg s h v i j`W Z VY ] lmX   s h vv i g fZ VYW cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW l`bl] b`XafW c
V  VeW VX   s hh  i `W Z Xm V VcXag `XVZ W ]g  VY f `b`lXal d cX`Yc i Y`W aW  Yfg sutt Xf tt
j`W ZVY ] lm X   shvvi `W Z YVVYVW lV c XmVYVaW  w m V W] g  VY f `b`lXal d cX`Yc l`W  V aWVYYVZ Yfg w ` c  ss `W Z su  e g ]bXa_ beaW  Xm V d YV] VW laVc
 aXm Xm V `jVY`V d baVXag V f  t#  eY { `aW i fY    pt Xm V YVc] bXaW  W] g  VY f `b`lXal d cX`Yc
t  vtt  ac caW a l`W Xbe bf VY Xm `W Xm V VcXak g `XVc f VYaW  XmV g `cc bag aX Xf    u  YacVc XmV W ]g  VY Xf sr  t  sv  t i  VaW lfW cacXVW X  aXm Xm V _YV ZalXafW c { bb aW `bb aX  Vlfg V c lbV`Y Xm `X    pt ac aW Z ac`YVVg VW X  aXm W] g VYf] c fk

sv cVYj`XafW `b lfW cXY`aWXc    u  ac W fX fWbe `jf] YVZ  e Xm V _ YVcVWX `W `be cac  ] X `bcf  e lfYYVb`XafW cX] ZaV c i cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW l`bl] b`XafW c i `W Z Xm V f cVYjVZ W ]g  VY f d cX`Yc { Z ZaXafW `bbe i  z cbf_ Vc cXVV_ VY Xm `W    s# bV`Z Xf Y`Xm VY bf Y`Xafc f Xe _ V  l Xf Xe_ V  c] _ VYWfj`V
 t#si  VaW  aW lfW cacXVWX  aXm V cXag `XV c Y`W k aW Yfg t#sv Xf s#ph w m] c i Xm V { b _ YfZ ] lXafW Y`XVc _ YV cVWXV Z fY    u `W Z    s#s Xf  s# aW w `  su cm f] bZ  V YV`YZV Z `c XmV g fcX lfW cacXVWX VcXag `XVc
 ] X cVV  Vbf  W Xmac l`cV i _ YfZ] lXafW Y`XVc i VW lfg _ `ccaW _ Yf `be Xm V g fcX YVba`bV l`bl] b`XafW c i bV `Z Xf r  s -f Xm V { b  ] ZVX Yfg {  n cX`Yc i q  p -Yfg Xe _ V  ^| i s   ut- Yfg Xe_ V  l ^| i `W Z uq  pt- Yfg d cX`Yc VW lV g fcX f Xm V { b  f] bZ  V _Yf Z] lVZ e lfYV lfbb`_ cV c]_ VYW fj`V  | fXalV i m f VjVYi Xm `X Xm V W] lbVfceW XmV cac g f ZVbc `YV c] VlX Xf lfW caZVY`bV ] W lVYX`aWXaVc
cVV _ YfZ ] lXafW Y`XVc
`W Z Xm V Z acl] ccafW ` fjV  i `bbf aW fY W f  Yg lfW lb] cafW fW XmV fYaaW f `b`lXal { b o Y`W X fc `W Z U `ccV
s h vr _ faWXVZ f] X Xm `X g VX`bbalaXe g `e _b`e `W ag _ fYX`WX YfbV aW Xm V VcXag `XafW f XmV `b`lXal { b  ] ZVX ^aW lV Xm V g VX`bbalaXe aW lYV`cVc  aXm 
bf
   t#t ZV " _ l ' Xf `YZ c XmV `b`lXal lVW XVY
^m `jVY   shvq `W Z { b _YfZ ] lXafW Yfg d cX`Yc cl`bVc `c  

    aXm g VX`bbalaXe
l ^VlXafW squ i Xm V d cX`Yc lfWXYa ]XafW g `e  V lfW caZVY` be aW lYV`cVZ  aXm YVc_ VlX Xf Xm V cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe l`cV  { ZZ aXafW `bbe i { b e aVbZ c Yfg Xe_ V  c] _ VYWfj`V g `e  V aWjVYcVbe _Yf_ fYXafW `b Xf g VX`bbalaXe
l  ^V lXafW sq p  i bV`ZaW  Xf ` Z VlYV `cV f Xm VaY lfWXYa ]XafW Xf XmV `b`lXal { b  ] ZVX { b _ Yf Z] lXafW Y`XVc fY aW aXa`b cXVbb`Y g VX`bbalaXaVc f
 u   i `c _ Yf_ fcVZ e o Y`WX fc `W Z x aVmb
shhr  fY Xm V `jVY`V `b`lXal g VX`bbalaXe i `YV cm f W aW w ` c sq `W Z sp fY Xe_ V  `W Z Xe _ V  l c]_ VYW fj`V i `W Z fbkd `eVX cX`Yc
Xm V g VX`bbalaXe ZV_ VW Z VW lV fY {  n cX`Yc cVVg c Xff lfg _ bV Xf `bbf fY ` cag _bV V XY`_ fb`XafW f Xm V eaVbZ c f zfYVcXaW a `W Z U m `Y fWW Vb
shh i m VW lV Wf {  n eaVbZc `YV ] fXV Z " Xe _ V  l ^ | e aVbZ c  VYV `cc] g VZ aW Z V_ VW ZVW X fW g VX`bbalaXe  w m V bf VY g `cc bag aX   fY d cX`Yc  `c lm fcVW  VX VVW u 
l w `  sq `W Z ut 
l  w `  sp  i  m VYV XmV cg `bbVY j`b]V ac c] VcXV Z  e cXVbb`Y Vjfb] XafW l`bl] b`XafW c fY mam g VX`bbalaXe cX`Yc
VeW VX   s hh  aXm YVc_ VlX Xf Xm V cfb`Y g VX`bbalaXe l`cV i Xm V ] cV f
 u  Y`acVc Xm V `b`lXal { b ] Z VX  e Yf] m be ` `lXfY f u  zfY YV`cfW ` bV  z cbf_ Vc
    s#  i g fYV Xm `W t- f Xm V { b _ YfZ ] lV Z e g `ccajV cX`Yc fYaaW `XVc W f Yfg d cX`Yci bVcc Xm `W qt- lfg Vc Yfg lfYV lfbb`_ cV V_ bfcafW c \ jVW a Xe_ V  ^ | eaVbZ c  VYV aW Z V_ VW Z VWX f g VX`bbalaXe
l  w `  su  i d cX`Yc YVg `aW Xm V Z fg aW `WX cf]YlV f `b`lXal { b  (   %     $    "         $'    "      $ '    "     $ '     "     $''             %                   "          $'      "!         %        "      $ '   % %    %               !%                   "    $ '      $'   " )        "        " %                "