Using game theory for the electricity market
47
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Using game theory for the electricity market Mireille Bossy — Nadia Maïzi — Geert Jan Olsder — Odile Pourtallier — Etienne Tanré. N° 5274 April 2005. N 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5563--FR+ENG. Thème NUM. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) ! "#$%
(6) &' ( )+*-,/.0*-121-.3547686!9 :<;=$> * = ) =@?#A * : B .0.C,/DE =$FHG 1-6 > .0, : GI> *-1-.KJL47M<,!D = 121-*2.0, : NOD8*-. FF .QP =$F ,8R SUTWV!XZY'r []mosu\LthY^`gie]_bvLXZadY/cfwCehgixyV!YXZg{Y/z"esujd|}kWmoXZn~j l/monqp0kWY/e ]x|W|$sumogfYmoY8#TWY!m##TWYj$ uC_|Wmin~CC_C5|}xuwuY/e ∗. †. ‡. §. ¶. /!Wuu Y'sCj}enqfY/mx5egixgonqOwCxuX5YOXZsffY!7gisfY/eimin~@Yxeo|@sugUY/ Y8¡gimonqn ghcXxmi¢uY!gUn~jK£TWnq#T S giXTWxuYeomokW¢CX|WY|}xugU mon~n~¢CY!eUYm#gigyessumieoY/¤$xxCY/go¡m]nqg#ehe'Y!¨©c~Y/dn cgigoemi«Wn~«W!¬fn¥¬fn ghjWY/cCKw¦U§ fgoTWY!xuYX#TIxup0j}k}eokW²x|Wj0ªf|Wgo£n ~gon TWn~Y/Y/Y/mLeyjWeoY!$kW±CsuWY!kWmXZwC|$n TCg{sCgyeixegon~s®|WWmi~Y/nqYuxuªWYO#xT¯¨©gkWXZej}kWn~|}gojWn~|Wn suX jIn~Y!xum8gi³s¦°|WgomiSUT}n~!TWY YuY¦XsCxfmith¢uY/Y!g/goªfn~±ugiYssu£¨TWgonqTW#T Y Xxumo ¢CYY'Y'gn~xej0qT}e±CxusZY/moeXY{gon~suwCxjx¢CgoY{goYOTWeoghsuY£(XZXsYOxu!mimoxuY!¢CeoXYY/g/e/x·d¦ min~¢fj´µjKe"gi£TWgiTWYT}YY!ejIY8«}m#esCek}gLj}|W!|WxC~/n exuY/YCeomiªWYLeUY/XY8xCxu#x¸#TcTsuWe¨<kWmigon~|}jWTW|WwZY n~eoY!Y!kW~mY/|W¡e|}gigomomi n~nqn~Y!±um#n Y/ghee"cegigosCsymijn X±CeoY/Y!xeU±C¬fgiY!n~sXZm#xXZn 7¶/Y{Xx¬fn xgin miXZeU¢u|}Yn~¶!g#moY'e!su¦«Wn gig/e ¦ ¹Iº0»7¼i½ ¾ ¿u`À xuXZYOgoTWY/sumicuªW[]xCeTY/p0kWn~~n Wmin~kWXKª@ad|$sgXxmi¢uY!gie/ª0§ Y8¡gominqn ghc^Qxmi¢uY!g. á×Ì-ÃÅËÁ³Ç¡Â¸ÏÅà ÃÅÄoÄâ/Æ7ãÈ2Ç¡Ê#È2׸ÉOähƳÑ"Ê#Ô¸Äå8ËÈ2ÃÅÊ#׸ÈÍæ"Ì2ÃÎÌ-Ê#¸ÏÅ Ñ ÐOÊ#Ë8äÈ2Ê#ÑµÔ¸Ò Ç¡ÑhÓÈ2ÓÃÅäÑhÔÐÑÆ Ê#ȸÃÅç¡Ï ÑUèÞ#Õç¡ßÑhÑhÈ©Ì Ö!Ê#×yØÏÅÄ2Ô¸ÑhÈƳÊ#Ä<Ç¡×'ÏÅÑÊÙÑ(ÊiÌ Ú²ÛÜݸÞiÃÎß#ĵÞ#àÛ<Ý/á âCÝ/ǡ˸¸ÃÎÊ éÚ³ÛêOÜ á é á"ââuë}Ø<äÇ¡êÏÅÑìë$Ô8ÕÑÄá êOÃÅ׸ÑhijԸÑíWÊ#È2ÃÅÄâè¡ç¡ç#îÈÍÇ¡å8Ì2Ñ Ô8ÑÄ ÏÅå¸ähÃÅÇ¡ÏÅÑhÄoâÝ/ǡ˸¸ÃÎÊ(á×!Ì2ÃÅËÇ¡ÏÅà Äoâ8ãÈ-Ê#׸ähÑ ÑhÏ Ò Ìà×8à ÙÑÈÍÄ-à ÌðÐ]Ç#ÒWÁfÑhäñ¸×8Ç¡ÏÅÇ¡æ#Ð!âuífò Ø"ò ó7ÇoôLõ¡ç¡ß8ö¡âè¡÷¡ç¡çÕá ï ÑhÏ Ò¥Ìoâ/Ì-Â8Ñ"Û ÑµÌ-¸ÑhÈÍÏÎÊ#×¸Ô¸Ä ééï ÛÛÜÜ éé á"á"âuâuÚ³Ø<Ø<êí$ë$Ü Õé á Û ∗. † ‡ §. ¶. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis.
(7) O ! ³ .
(8) (
(9) < <
(10) (# s|}Zmon ¬ n j0goxY/k mixu Xwunqxeom#eo[#Y!TWsuj0k@lug< ¦e"kWjl! gok}YKY/WmXZn g#sCxxuj}n~mijZe #T}k}jWljsuXymiXZl/WxusfmowufYn V! g f~YLY °f¨©suY"Y8kWtheymiY!jWk|}nqmoeoehsCeog#Y!|@xkWgis0m#n~ep0e/n ¦gokWn~Y{z"suj}T}fe5l/xu!p0Y/mokWj n~±YUx«W¨©j0sC¬Wg"kWxumijCkWjWgZjn~ei~XeoY/Y!exkWm#p0m#k}TWeoxsul]j0kWeogiXZ|@n¥gisuY!l/gUgeZkW jW l! Yl!~Y/~¨©Y/sC¡goj}gimimo¡n~nq!gin¥n gin sCgoluj l ª |}xC#moTWn ¬²Y[]¦ gisul!k}Y8e e l!go#k}T}Wxun p0sCkWj}YUe¨©sCek@kW!moj}Y8n~eieoeeoY/n~±ukWY!m8XZ¦ !Y/jC sugW~thY/Y/e¡gi/n¥xu¨³eZfkZ s " X~xY/m#eZ#TW¨©lsCkWY8moehj}g n~feieYLY/eokWxm#goe5nqeh#¨ÍT}xun Y!mim#Y#TWeoxY!j0f#g Y/X xXZj}xf¬fYn XZxukZnqeX5Y/mY/n ~Y/~Y!kWkWmime |@xmogi[]esufk}YOe{Xx$xsum##m#TWflOsuj@YegW~Ymin !V/xu±ueUY/X5s Y/j0~gLY/e~Y5¨©su/kWxumiejWsnqeoQeoY!~kWY/m#eLeU¨©su#TWkWY!mim#jW#nqTWeoeoY/Y!jCk}g mi 5e|$XY!xk}¬f±un Y!XZj0g{nqeY/¨©sumkW Y/mijWkWn~m#m{eUW|WY mosu$«W l/gi e/Y8¦ ¡gominqn golyeokWm |} k}eon~Y!kWm#eUXxm##TWl/eUsCj}k}momiY!j0gie/¦ %¾ 8 ¼ & SUTWl/sumin YOfY/eìthY!kf¬²ªW§ p0kWn~~n WmiYfY'[]xCeT ªW^Qxm##TWl/eUeo|@sug/ª}^xm##TWl{' l/ Y8¡gominqn gol.
(11) .
(12)
(13) "!#. y < ' gieoafmosZn n~j}Y/!!e/xYªW~~XgiY/TW7 xYLjd6 fcY/8WmoY/n¥.¤7wu 9kWY! miqxY!6gij0n g]sC jX|Wx"!#mimisd¢uY!!* gY/ei£ehegiTWmosuY/k}¨³moY!Ygo~kWY/eo¡mikWY/gi|WmoeU|WnqT@~n n x¸ghY/c5±umie"YY¨Í¬WxxC#|WT}|$YxY/xyj}xuwumoWY8Y/Y/)eT}nq(+eoxu* n sC,e"j@.Y/|W-0Y!mi/#jsf-n~1+Y8jW23eon 2"e go4+nqgox5 T}¦UgiY/xgXZmon~jY/su jWn~§Y/wZk}e(mogisCsCTWj|@Y!XY8x5xjxY/mijC!YOsugimikWgoxuTWj': Y && n~sC¶!jY8ZgoTWxYk}WgoY/n~sueon jZwCjXZY/su#¨"T}gixuTWjWY)n~eo6XK¦)´ñg . 9! su j}6 eonqeh g#eì"n j!#eo kW(©W|$XZs£"n gY/gon~m'jW|@w'sd}sCn~~We/e/ª ªu|$XZssC£"moY/Ym'sCYmì¬W #Y8T}eoexujW!wusuY8XZe!|Wª ~¦ n~¦~/¦ 5 x¦giY/SU²ª0T}fYY!|W|$miY!suj}WW~n Y!jWX w nqXexugimoTW¢CY Yg/f¦IY!govLY/mokWXZm n~j}xun xX gin sCn jIj°sgi¨<TWnqgoe'TWYy|}xupC|@k@Y/xm j0gonqeOn ghcgosxuj}WKY/ei|Wmimin n~$!YYOgogoT}T}xYg]@£Y/T}n~ x¸±d£n sCn jKmgisTW¨UY'goT}|WYmisf|}xY8moeogoenqsun~¨|}exuY/jC g#Y8 e ¡go(Ín~eosukWjI|WsC|}jK n~Y!gom#TWe Y 5 gieoTWkWmi|Wsu|}kW n~wCY!TymOx{s¤7ehg#Y!xm#goe{nq(suj®wCxugoX5TWYZYUxX|}x|Wmimo¢us0Y!xugO#T³x¦ |W min~Y!Y5sC¨©kWj}j}eon~¡fgiY/n sCmìj³xL¦ZXSUxuTWmoYZ¢CYmog<Y8£e|$TWsuY!j}mieoY Y Ssueo¨ kWgi|WTW|WYZ~n XZY/mixueìmoxu¢CmoYY(g{n~goj0s±Csugo~T}±uY/Y8eo²Y5¦³su§ ¤$xCY/#miT e nqWeY!XgiTWxYj}p0k}xxugjCgiXZn¥gin~n jWY8n~e'XZ$xusu³kW|WwCmiT0n~!g'Yu¨©¦ mosCX Y8xu#T eokW|W|W~n Y/m/¦QSUT}YsufthY8¡gin ±CYs¨UgoTWYXxmi¢uYg'nqegiseixgonqe¨©c®n gie XXxuxumomoz"¢C¢C~YYsCgig]eoe/Y!xu¦U~e]c[YY!mi¬f±CY!suqY!wCxmoY!gigoY/jWTWsCY/ k}Y8|}e/eoxª}e/|$ªW£Y!n~TWm#Bj e'Y/mo;xu=¸Y8mo.xu<Y ?ñeª}TW;>gi=8TWY/. moY ?UY xx£"kWj}Y5go@ TWsC;ÅsuA mij@?ñeU¦eg#nqfxSU¢CY!T}mYY!goc°goTWTWY5xYyqpCepCsIk@k@xxj0j0sCgogoj}n n gheoghcn~cfY/xCsum'e¨<Y/su|} |WxuY8gom¡n~g{giXZmosnqxu¨<n ghgocWT}nqY W|}We'mosCnqsC²|@j ¦]s0e´µY!Y8jC~Y/; sC.go?ñjKmiª$n~!gogon¥TWTWghcYY xu!sukfj}goT}eonqsufm#Y!e5mìWsCs|@Y/j}j5s}gn~WsCe j}xeoj}n~fyY/«WmZ¬yYgo¬WTWxuYgoX~c xumogo¢CTWYYQgeix~Y/XZxumoYKn~jW¢dwOn j@|W¯min~!suYU¨LxCXe<xgomiT}¢uYY!TWg5n wCXZTWY8Y/#eT}gx|WjWminqn~eo!XYª(xXZn~j suj}|@wLxmogigoTWnqYkWxuq/xm5Y/|fgoT}goY8Y!c }n~We/SU¦TWSUYTW|@Y/xc|$Y!sCmj}nqeeOnqfsuY/mimUwCx«Wj}¬fn Y/¶/Y/QfY!xCXe{x¨©suj@~ s}£kfe/g]¦5xSUqeT}sZYeX5gosfsf#fT}Y/xuìegon~nqe OffY/Y!eiXmixun $j}²Y/®¦ n~j°adY8¡gin sCj fª³gosCwuY!goTWY/m{£n goT gigiTWsIYX|Wxmi¬fsun |$XZsCn~eo¶!Y/Y5goeT}sCY! kWn~m'gon~XsujKxmi¢usuYj@g'Y!eoT}|Wxg/¦ìmiYu´µªjQ£adTWY/n~ goYn~sun~jjI5adY/£"goY'n~su!j°suj}Ieonqf£"Y!Ym(xugoj}T}xY'~cd!xu¶!Y5eoYOgo£TWYTWY!/mixuYOeoYgoT}£Y'TWeY!kWmi|}Y5|Wgo TWn~Y!Ym#ewCesCgoxumiìn ±Cn~Ye |}£(moYsu«WsCgLX5X|@xx¬fmin~YLXZ£n ¶8n goxTgon~sugoT}j Y{¦{sC´µj°mow0adxY/jWn~¶/gon~xsugoj°n~suje£(goY k@fn~j0n Y8gomisdn Wjk}goT}YZY{e|}sCmoXZY/±0Yyn~suxk@ goeY/moej@Y8x¡gogon~n~su±uj@Y e!XZ¦xuadmosC¢CX5Yg{YOsuTWmin~wCj0xgie(j}n ¨©¶8sCxmUgon~gosuTWjKY'gi/T}xuxeoYg £!suT}j}Y!!mi Y]k@fek}Y|Wn~|Wj¯~n Y/admiY/e go|Wn~mosusCj |@s0KeY£Y/n¥gi TY8¡giemosCnqXZn ghYcysCsCjX5e|@Y/x±umiY/n~mieoxusufj°XZmixuY!Xmo¢CxYmig#¢fe exmisuYj°|WgimiTWY/YeoY!ghj0£(goY8sZn mijn goadY!Y/minqxIgon~suk}j eoY/Df²¦ ªì xj@Y «}ej}sCxuXZ ~c Y |$sCeieon W~Yfn~moY8¡gon~suj@e(¨©sumU¨©kfgikWmoY£(sumi¢fe!¦ G
(14) ³ O
(15) y E F H $. IKJML. %. NPOQSRUTVQXWZY9[\R]W_^`Y'OQXa+b@c OdeaMcfQX[. WY!YKXxsuj}j@enq¨©fsuY!m m MkWj}Y!n¥g#~Y/esgomi¨n~!Y!n¥~ghY/c°¡gimoXnqxn mighc¢uY!gigiT}e/ªxg!xunqe ~Y/|W misM±dn~f,Y8·· ·dc, M eokW|WgiT}|Wx~n~gZY!m#T}ex¸!±CxY~~Y/xj¯n jWY/ª ~xCehgin~)(ðgis®|WminqY ¦ 5 d S µ ´ K j Z X C s e g s ¨ o g W T Y @ | x $ | ! Y m ( £ O Y £ n ~ C s } j o e ~ n f / Y U m o g W T ' Y / u x o e O Y s ì ¨ 5 x o e ~ n W j u w ~ Y X x i m u ¢ Y 8 g g( MS =j1=5 ¦"1,ads2,£(.YO. .T}, x¸S±uY ª gi#TWT}Y'sCeo!Y!xCjeY{goss¨ìfeoY8Y!eo±u!moY/n~mi$xuY7XZTWY!xumimoY'¢CYsug#j}e! ¦UcigoTWY/j}nqe]YO/xu¨©eosCYum¦ jW´µsj£ af£(Y/¡Ygin sCsujhj@eDZnqf£"Y!Y mU£giTWn Y'~ eoY!n ¬0jWgiwCY! j}YOXgixTWmiYy¢uY!eogUkW}/xueoY/eoYugo¦ n~sujK@Y/ s£+gos 1. M. i. j. º qpqp & r º ¸ §"xCeoxueo#sfT°nqexkWgiY/|}eL|W gon~sIY!m xSjdceop0Y!k}j}xuWj0egon xughcQj®ssu¨(¤$Y/Y!m{~Y/go¡sgimonqgoTWn Yghc Xxuª mogo¢CTWYYg{kWgoT}j}xn¥g'g |Wsuminqj@eY nqehg#e{n j°xxg|W£monqTWY5n~#T°¨©kWj@n g'¡gon~eOn~sumij Y/xCpfcI(·)giª³sKgiT}eoY!x~g q p (q) giTWnqep0k}xj0gon ghcu¦ jgk lmk l. nHo. j. j. j. ÜÜ ×s}õ¡ètiî.
(16) .
(17) * * *6
(18) K
(19) ' ". Y'eT@x~²XZxun j} ck}eY{giTWYO¨©su~ s£n~jWweo|@Y8nqx7¨©sumiXsu¨giTWYO|WmonqYO¨©k}j}¡gin sCj º r©. r ¾ l K
(20) * 6 9 * /3 "!#q * - X
(21) * "!#!m S $ &%' ()!f * " /3 $ , " 6
(22) 8 * 9*! * +!f Z,-f
(23) 6 /.0m 621 j. $. (qj , pj ). pj (·). pj (q) =. .
(24) . (+= 5. pj ≥ 0,
(25) q ≤ qj , +∞, q > qj .. * 9 4#3 5%' S
(26) 76_ *
(27) * ]K 9 .0 8!f p -9X
(28) ' :/. :%' * 9 f!q 1
(29) * ;.< 3
(30) @!m K,-f
(31) \ 6
(32) *.A3 6 !m =
(33) ?>e * 9 * m
(34)
(35) f ' **
(36) ' 6 m
(37) * ,
(38) , *
(39) f- $ (p ) j. j. j. j. afY/e¡sCgi]~n sC|}jxnqeUmo gwux¨©n~±usuj}Y/miXjaddgoY/cTWY{gon~suehgij mixDWgo¦Y!wC^In Y8sueìmiY|Wmi|WY!mi±dY/n~!sun~k}eoY!eo~ cc5x fY~«@n j}jWY/Y/x²mUª0e£(gom#Yx£goY/n wu~@cCxuªC~nqeoeUs'eXk}#xT¢CYgoT}k}xeog"YgisTW¨²YO~n |WjWmoY8nqxm(Y]eh¨©sugimimxp0goY!k}wCxn j0Y8gieìn¥ghn~jc. q. £T}Y![]miY sgoαYgoxT}j}x gìβgoTWxYmighY{£(|$ssCeeoY!n gogin~eì±uYOsu¨³|}ehxgim#mixxXZgoY!Y!wCgon Y!Y8m#e!e/ª4p(q) ¦Bop0k}x=j0giαqn¥ghc +&ñ|Wmoβ,nqYegom#xgiY!wun~Y/e7C(xuj}9Bh~n j}Y/xm"ehgimixgoY!wCn Y8eDCUxmiY Wn~eÍthsun~j0g/¦ jgk lmk j nHo º fF E º af - kW.|W- |$goTWsCeoYIY|}£(monqYYT}x¸¨©kW±Cj}Yxgon~sueoj}n~jWe wu~YXxmi¢uY!g/¦SUTWYXxumoªU¢CYxgyj@!su~T} Y8xC¡eygie gos°goT}#YTWsdsusC¤$eoY/Ymie giTWXZYIxCpCfk@Yxj0dgoc°n gogin~Y/TWe YeokW|Wgi|Ws°~n~WY!kWm#e!c ª ¨© misuYX eokWY/|Wxu|$#TKsCeoeoY"kWgi|WT}|Wx~gn Y/xum jZSxCfª XZj pn~=eieo(·),n 1,W~·Yp· #·TW(·),,suSnq¦ ·Y(·SU·sTW¨$, YOpgoT}kWY((·)j}Xn¥gxu|Wmomi¢CnqYgìYOn~|}eìxeonqk}#Tygos goT}Sxgìnqgoe TWpYW(qY!X) ¦xj}ynqe¨©kW ~qcyeixgin~e«}Y8 xgU«}jWn goY|Wmin~!Yuª - .- eok}#TgoT}xg/ª X xuj} p (q ) < +∞, ∀j. (- 5 q = d, q ≥ 0, - «@/xjW|}T}n¥gixCY!Y]j®n ghs0goc TWeh5 gYª²(ðgieo¨©TWYsugY!m j°sY¬W¨UgixTWxuXZYfXZ|WX~nqYxeoeomi£n~¢uWTWY gY/YZjZW#k}goTWTWcdsCY]e{n~!WY/giY!TWe{XYn~eOxXj}Y/xXZZ¬f|fnqn~eìXghcugixsdª sp0~k}xumox£wCj0YgiTWn¥Y/£ghjcQn¥gigisuTTW¨(moYY/Y8 efY8|$Y/¡Y/XZgimognqxuj}gon ghs cQeo!sun xgyXZj}!jWYUxus«}jgOj}x@n¥gigYY«}ei|WjWxmin gisdgon~WYe«}k}|WY8¡migin~n !sCxYuj g ª giTWsuk}wuTgoTWYO¨©kW~ fY/Xxj}nqeUjWsg]eixgin~e«}Y/³¦ 1. 2. S. j. j. j. j. j. S. j. j. j. j. j=1. IKJ I jgk jgk l. GHUR5IKJR Y9a+dZW LMJW_cmY9a+deW_[BR]W^ d0NPO QXcmY9aDHeQ nHo º fFE º . nqe¨©Yc0n~ejWk}wP|W|@(2 s05"e5 Yyª goT@xgOgoTWYZsCfthY/n~jgon~mi±uY/Y5eo|@ssC¨j}gieoTWY'YZgosXZgoxuTWmo¢CY5YsgO¤7n~Y!eLm#gie sK#T}s0s0eY5xjxufXZsunqeo¨eogon }T} Y5YZeoehkWgi|Wmix|Wgo~Y/n~Y!wum#cBe!ª²( eo - s.- xue]eixgogMs & (q 1 , · · · , q S ). p1 (·), · · · , pS (·). é ÛÜ é á.
(40) .
(41)
(42) "!#. XZ^Qn~sujWmin~YLX5|Wn~¶!miYOY/!gin~TWeoY!YO~cgosugigiTWxuY³XsCxeg/mi¢u¦ Yg|Wmisu} Y/Xn~e min. £n goT. {q j }j=1···S. . Í. ( 5. ϕM (p1 (·), · · · , pS (·), q 1 , · · · , q S ),. def. ϕM (p1 (·), · · · , pS (·), q 1 , · · · , q S ) =. eokWfthY8¡gUgos!suj}egom#xn~j0gie (2 5 ¦ º fF E l =
(43) 9 9+!f 8@>q 7 9
(44) m * "! !m: H
(45) 9
(46) 9-. S X. ©. ( 5. pj (q j )q j ,. j=1. "!# 1 ' * 1 6 6"4 X ,
(47) .
(48) ' 6 *
(49) * / 6 *
(50) "!#Z
(51) / .
(52) >q 9" 1 * 6 "!
(53) 9H
(54) K6 *
(55) +_ 9 * "! !f * 9"!3 * - %4 !m pw <>q 1 ' *
(56) $ * "! !f * -:f 9
(57) %' * 1
(58) 3/. 'V
(59) $ #, * "!#!m * 6 f 6 3
(60) 6 /h
(61) 98.A3 6 !m pw 6 9
(62) 76 *
(63) + * "! !f * f ' * "!#
(64) / .
(65) 1 <
(66) 1* 6
(67) "!# *8* * 9 "!#+ K
(68) >e = 33 g" m
(69) =
(70) 6 K
(71) .
(72)
(73) & f
(74) 6
(75) - * - m ' * * ! , >] 1 1 Z 6 * ' * * 6 f
(76) #-. º fFE j " e>
(77) 6
(78) !#
(79) 83
(80) - Z" * !9
(81)
(82) P
(83) * - f 9
(84) - 6 : / ,, *
(85)
(86) * 9<>e ,
(87) * 6 * /3"!3 6
(88) !m"
(89) 6 * - 'f 9>e * "!#!9
(90) * 6 9e 9 , * !
(91) $
(92) 7,
(93) * * 3 * "! !f 9
(94) * "! !
(95) K"
(96) "
(97) * * * f ' * * * ' ?f!
(98) P m
(99) 1 H 6 H 7, *
(100) M * ,X "!# * * f
(101) 3jgk jgk j nHo º q pqp & r º ¸ SUT}YLgh£(smin¥giY!min~x}ªf|Wmis«Wgxj@Xxmi¢uY!geT}xumoYCªd£n ~³$Y'ehgik}fn~Y/¨©sumUgiTWY'ek}|W|W~n Y/mie nHo º p ¾ ¼ TWY/jgiTWYOXZxumo¢CYgUWkWcfep0k}xj0gin¥gin Y8e q , j = 1, · · · , S, eokW|W|} n~Y!m S e(|Wmis«Wg . . . . . . gos$YXx¬fn XZn~¶!Y8nqe.
(102) . . j. j. def. £TWY!miY C (·) n~e(giTWY|Wmisffk}¡gin sCjIsCegU¨©kWj}gon~suj³¦ 8Bp r ¾ l * "!#!9
(103) * 9
(104) 3 * "!#!m S $ P!f"
(105) 6
(106) 7
(107) * C (·) * !m '>] * 6 f,, * /
(108) $ 3,-f
(109) fϕSj (p1 (·), · · · , pS (·), q j ) = pj (q j )q j − Cj (q j ),. 2. ( 5. j. C1. '. . j. j. * f
(110) 6 6"4 1
(111) >e 6 .<m H / fq
(112) * C 0 (q) * Cj j dC lim→0 dq (q − ) *
(113) MH 9 * * '8 !m
(114) 7 6
(115) / fV
(116) * 0 *
(117) m
(118)
(119) 6 m
(120) 6 " * / - M ! 4 'H K 1 +!fC j, $ 4>] * ,
(121) * Z m"C j * /_,-m
(122) m+. ÜÜ ×s}õ¡ètiî. j. . (.
(123)
(124) * * *6
(125) K
(126) ' " D. . SU]TWenqxZe"xCXeoeoxkWggoXZY/m|fgosn~¨sujZ¨Íxu«}g/giªWe"X£xn¥gimiTwun~goj}TWxuY{7!qsCxueeigieenq!xuxumo}YOegon~j}mik}mi¡Y/gixCkWemon~Y]jWsw}¨³ªdX|Wn~xY/!miwuY!£n~j}nqxe@Y'!sCsuej}gie egin xujj0gY!~Y/<¡gigiTWmoYnqn |WghmicZsfefY8k}¡goY/sCmim/e ¦ ehxug#eox¢fmoegie"XZ|WsumimisdYWY!k}~Y/n~¡jWgiw monqn~jn ghcun giª}eUgoTW#TWYyY8|Wxmi|$sdY/Weg"k}|WY/mim]sffehg#k}x¡mogigin esCjk}|K¨Íxugo!TWn ~Yyn ghcsujW(ÍY£WTWkWY!j}g{Y!#±uTWY/Y8m"x|$|$sCY/eeig]eon W|W~miY sd5 W¦<k}´ñ¡¨³gigon TWsCjY{X¨ÍxCxmin~ ¢un ghY!c g .- n~jWY8xm£sCmyn goTKxQmowCY8n ±Ce|$Y!jY/gU|Wmigosfsf|Wk}misfgofn~suk}j ¡gi¨Ín xCsCj³n~ ¦ n ghcuª<giTWY!sCeg5fY/|@Y/j}WeysujW~c°suj mis£ XxgoY/monqx-ªìxj} n~e XnHoxmiº ¢uY g8ª f F- E - º £"®Y fo Y!f«} jWº YO¼ goT}n~¨©esum5!moen gokWY/|}mo|Wn~su n~jY!m xue S ª q nqe'giTWYp0k}xujCgin¥ghc°$sukWwCT0g'¨©mosCX TWn X dcgoTWY j. j. ( D 5. def. oggoTWssCYm¶/sCY!gomidTWsy±0nqe]n~£su!k@T}moe!n xgoªgoY/WY/mo±ukWn~suY!gjmUkWªWgijWTWn¥gLmiYY/n~xp0e~k}nqj}ehxY/gij0n~ugoY8n ªueogheeicsCx mi$kWcsugokWn~gisuswCj5T0n gj0£gon~n¥mie/gisfTW¦ fsuk}kf!gY'|}xZmonq|WYmonqsCY'j}!esugom#j}xen~gojCm#g<xn~£(j0sug/kW¦ qL e]$xZYUgoXsxeogoYgogìY/mgiTWsYU¨<|W¨Íxumonqg/Y ª go TWYyYk}jWjWY!Y8n¥gLQ|Wxmonq!suYOj}nqeegom#xx~£(n~j0x¸g]cfeeUk@x#$TIsgo±uT}YLxgog/T}ª@Y¨©suXZm{xuYmo¬WwCxn XZj@x|W²~Yus0ª@ehgog8T}ª Y |Wmi¦ s«WgLn~eLjWsu9j &-jWY/wCxgon~±uYuª}sumLeok}#TIgiT}xg ϕSj (p1 (·), · · · , pS (·), q j ) = q j .. Cj0. 8B p r ¾ j X
(127) _ 9 * !#
(128) M / 4m " >e * "! !
(129) * 9 3# * 4m H
(130) + - !m V,-f
(131) L
(132) 3 * "! !f - "! !m: S * m
(133) e
(134) >e 6
(135) * f 9&%4 q - f!
(136) >e 9 - .-
(137) H 9 "!# * 9"
(138) B 6 * * 1 +!m $ * " /3 * 9
(139) ' 6* * L (q) $ $ . j. j. j. qj (q) ≥ Lj (q), ∀q.. H j}xgikWmixu$#T}sunqY¨©sCm L nqe C ªd£TWnq#TY!¬f|WmoY8eoeoY/e goT}YLk}eok}xu$!suj}egom#xn~j0g goT@xg(goTWYOkWjWn gU|WmonqY ¨Ín~e{xuxg$gosT}±uxYOggigoTWTWY'YX|Wmixsmi«}wun~gj}/xux jWj}s0sehgg8¦L@vLYjWj}Y Y!wCxsCgokWn~±uqQYC¦ xqes#T}s0s0eY L (q) = £TWn~#TY¬f|WmiY/eieY8eUgoTWY j. 0 j. j. IKJ. Cj (q) q. GPJa IMaKNb aMR. ©¨gisCsKmomosCXygoX TWkWYqxZxXZgow0Y8xux²moXZ¦¢CY{Y(g8goªgTWxY/xKj@sumi«}Ym#goxehnqg'gy!xugogo³T}n~XZ|$YsuYen~Y8jCeggosCY/suj}| ¨ìQ±0gogiTWn~n Y!YXZ£eYª@k}x5e|Wgo|WghY/£"~|°n sZY/migogiTWe5n YXZxjWXZY j}xuesugomokWY/¢Cj}|Y!g|}YmimoY/gosCxuT}WY! giY/n~myeOX sugisK£¤$Y/n gogomiTWTe Y8eS(ðYgoT}+sY¤71|WY!m#mi|WeOnqqx¸Y0cucY!¨©kWm##eUj@TW¡£sdgosCn~n~ sueoj@n j}@e wY5 gi( TW - Y - p0Xk}xx¬fj0gin~X5n¥gin n~Y8¶!eY<¨©qsCm²sugoT}¨(Y Y/ eY8k}¡|Wgo|Wminq~n Y/n ghmicIe/ª/goXZsIn~jWWn~k}X5cQn~¶!¨©miYsu¨©Xsum²giY8TWxuY#T°XexkWmi|}¢u|WY!g n~5 Y!n m8gi¦e²s§ £xCj#Tmi|}n go~Y!x¸micCn~Y!sumj{eh¨©gikWmoj}n~±uY8gon~eLsugo j sI( su|Wgon~X5n~¶!Y j= d c W | o m C s @ | / Y o m ~ c # W T d s C s o e n } j. w n i g ( e s £ j f 8 Y q n e ~ n u s j ¸ ± u x o m q n x } Y (Íe 5 ¦<SUTWYLjdkWXZY/monq!xu$sCkfϕgi!suXZ, Y] 1, · · · , S, ϕ ) Ygi8sxu#Tsujd±Cmin¥Y!gij0Y!gomin~n susCj}jxu¨©dkWsuj}|fgigon n~XZsujn~¶/£xgin n ~sC²jyn~j|}wCmosCY!WjW Y/Y/miXxu7e!Wªn~Y!jZ|$Y!£j}TWnq#suTyjKgiTWx~Y!²mifYUY/n~!en~sueon jWsC~jc'±suxuj}moYUnqxWWY/~Y/nqe"eon n~sCj0j5±CsuX~±uxuY8¢u²Y!¦m8ª´µxjKj@ysCj0£goT}m#Y!xumisueYg¨ gisCTW|@YZY/j£"gisCs5mifnqBheisC|fk}goein~eX n~suk}jX xC5j}T}xuX ek}xuej®gUkW@j@YxfX Y!«}}jWn wCY/kWsu|Wk}mieLsuXZ|$Y!Y/mixu jWcC¦n j}w}xuª²mogin~TWsuYZk@e"jWj}ssgin gosCn~suj®j@sue ¨ suB¨ suB|fsugi|fn Xgin Xx~xn gh~c n ghC5c C n jYwC¬fxunqehX5g Y8(Íe{eoY!n~Ye ;>=? 5 ¦ j. Sj. M. é ÛÜ é á.
(140) .
(141)
(142) "!#. m #,!# / i´µm j7n~kWXK;>i]=?³¦'Y!gimirTWYY'~Y/goTWxusCY5eoY5moehmigijWY/moeosk@|@gi¡YysCgoj}k}gifT}mon~Y'xjWgOsuw ¨<giY8TWgop0YTWkWYyBn ~~|Wn~Y/WxumomosCWn~WkWY!~m#X Y!eDXC¡ªn~eU - Y8mi xuY- ¨©WY/e]moemik}k}Y/e|W|Wgigos~sn Y/k}xumieoe/e Y ª³ #x TW!sdsusC X *eoY5 }mxun jWj} Y8# ,!#xu= jW jW1 * sC kW/ j}¦ Yy¨©kWj}1gon~suj}Y/e p0pkWn~ (·)n~'& ¦ gi#sT}sugonq^IT}Y Y/sCe mosY"¤7|WY!m#mieY/(pnqeoY!~(·),cuªf·Y·«@· jW, Y p {q(·))(psu(·), ¨ì£goTWn~·Yy~·²·e@kW,Y'|}pei|Wx(·)), n~nqY!m#e/sCªj|f go=- n~.X- 1,x³.x.n ¨.esC,goS} TWkWYOgon~ª¸¨©susCgojITW ~Y(ss£$¨<n Y/gij}eTWwygY'miTW|WY/sCeomi~|@su}sCWe(j}~Y!goeXmiY"kWsYu(-¨fª gi5 TW&Y"(Í X5 ¦xumoSU¢CTWYYg {p (·), q , j = 1, · · · , S} (ñ 5 q = q (p (·), · · · , p (·)), sumY/±uY!miceokW|W|W~n Y/m S ª j = 1, . . . , S xj@xuj0cxufXZnqeoeon } YO|Wmin~!Y{¨©kWj}¡gin sCj p˜ (·) £(YOT}x¸±uY . 1. j. ∗ j. 1 ∗ j. j. . . S. S. ∗ j. j. ∗ 1. ∗ S. j. j. ( 5. ϕSj (p∗1 (·), · · · , p∗S (·), q ∗j ) ≥ ϕSj (p∗1 (·), · · · , p˜j (·), · · · , p∗S (·), q˜j ),. £T}Y!miY ( 5 q˜ = q (p (·), · · · , p˜ (·), · · · , p (·)). SUWY!T}±dY{n~x[Lgon~xujWeowTkWY/jWp0n~kW~n~x~gon WY!m#mixn~kW~~X c¨©§ misup0X k}xgin gin sCeOjPY8p0( kW5 n ~n~goWY/mo qn~e(kWX`k}e(#goT}T}suxnqgUY eokW( |W|} n~Y!m 5 ¦yS[]/sxgoY5jWj}gisT}gUxgn j}n~!jmoY8gixuTWeoYY]en giY8eUsusCj@kfIgi!gosuY/XZmoX Y]dsuc ¨ §gi"TWpCYk@|Wxgomin~n~su!Y{Pj ¨©( kWj}5 ¡ªdgigon T}sCYOj xC¡gin sCjªWgosuTW¨³YgoTWXYOxXmi¢uxY!mig(¢umiY!Y/g(xCnq¡e(g#eUwun~0±ucY/jWkWdcdc n j}( pwy5 (·)¨©miìsun X ¨ S fgiY/TW±0Y'nqxp0giY/k}e"xj0¨©migisun¥ghX c p (·)n~j}edgoY8cxus¤7sY!¨ min j}w ¦ p˜ (·) S q˜ q º fF E * ,, 6 &f
(143) 6 .
(144) !m"
(145) 1 > ( 6 /.0 / 1 9
(146)
(147) +K 9 "!# m
(148) *
(149) '
(150) m- M\ 9 * 8 "!# " 3 * 1 1 ' /h 9 ;33 def. j. ∗ 1. j. . ∗ S. j. . j. ∗ j. . ∗ j. j. j. j. . . ∗ j. j. . . . %4
(151) + 8 7 .0 !f _ 8
(152) 98 33" 9 8 ;.0 < *
(153) '
(154) *
(155) 8 3 8!m >q 94 * " * "!#m! * * 9 * !f$ U,-m
(156) 3- '8 9] * q (·) * m
(157) A- %' 6 .<m 6
(158) 1 *%4
(159) $
(160) + e> *
(161) ,%'' 6 4 f, 6 h= 63 *6 )
(162) %4f' 1M' ' 96 .<* m 6* 1
(163) >@* %4
(164) "!3V" * 3m
(165) * >q>e 94 < 6 /* .0f 6 - .
(166) !f"
(167) 1 * * , !
(168) * * 1 ;.0 *
(169) '
(170) * - B@ 636
(171) meM' ,
(172) ' 6 1
(173) 3 ?f! H "!# e. * 1 ' * ,
(174) * "!#!m S 94 "
(175) * "! !f S -
(176) H $ 9 "!# m! $ " *
(177) K 6 * ]> /
(178) %4 * $ - = 9 *,* $ * m
(179) $ f , * *
(180) !# * 6#6
(181) f XM' >H 3'f! < * 9! ,9! - f
(182) e> 6
(183) *,* ' 9V , * 6#6
(184) f M' > !m
(185) >5 1 8 X 9 * "! m! : * 9Z * ' , * H,,#
(186) 7
(187) + 9"!3 * - %' .$ ! U
(188) !
(189) (
(190) '&' ( < . . . . . .
(191). . . . .
(192). ∗ j. . 1. 2. . . . . . µ´dj'c'goxuTW|Wnq|We<miesuY8|W¡gomin~n~suxj goY/£" cYU#xTWj}sdxusC eocdn~¶/jWYìwgogiTWTWYUY!|WxCmien~Y !Y £¨©TWkWY!j@mi¡Ygogin~suTWj@Y(e eokW|W|} n~Y!xm#gìe£egoTWminqn~#±uT YgigiTWs]Y!Xc xs¬f¤7n~Y!XZmn go¶/TWYY/gon T}mìY!Y/n~ mY8¡Xgimoxunqmo¢Cn ghYcgsueoT}jyxgomiTWY/Ye Xgisxuxumo¢Ce(Ygog/T}¦ Y %' Ymo Y8eh gi monq()¡!fgUsu ,kW m|}xxgn~gim Y!j0gon~sujgosZ¦ |Wmin~!Y]¨©k}j}p¡gi(·)n sCj}e p (·) wCn ±CY!jn~j ]Y!«}jWn gon~suj7=Oxj}moY!¨©Y!mimoY8 (q , p ) u s ] m o e W k W | W | ~ ~ n ! Y m ( £ ' Y f ! Y W j u s o g Y S mi!Y!moY8|}xumoY8eon ej}Y/w'jCg(£gon¥T}giTYXZmiY/xueo|$mowCY/n ¡j@gUxgi7s |WgimiTWsdYWk}pC¡k@Lgixn sCj0(·)jgon gh!cn¥sCg#eeeg/sCXZ¦ ~³n j}¦ìn z"XqxuxeiekWnq!jWxun g] ~c5|Wmigon~TW!nqYOeU¨©XZkWj}n j}¡n giXn sCxjK²gok}T}jWxn¥gg£"|WmiY'nqeoYLkW|W¨©kW|$j}sC¡eogiYOn sCjWjsuj@Xfx¸Yc & j. . j. j. j. ÜÜ ×s}õ¡ètiî. j. j.
(193)
(194) * * *6
(195) K
(196) ' ". £min g\LgoY/ejIn~jWwxue x. |}xun m. %' ()!f . (qj , pj ). kWj}WY!m. ¨©sumY8xu#T ek}|W|W~n Y/m/ª"goTWYIXxumo¢CYg|WmisuW~Y!X 2( 5 /xj @Y min. {q j ,j=1,...,S}. S X. /. pj q j ,. j=1 S X. 0 ≤ q j ≤ qj ,. (M= 5. q j = d.. SsKfY«}j}YZxkWjWnqp0kWYZmoY8xugon~sujQsu¨ goT}Y5Xxumo¢CYgL£(YZk}eoY5Y/Xxmi¢Qfª³£TWY/j®rmisu} Y/X (+=/ 5 f sdY/e{jWsg T@(Í|@x¸s0±ueoYeon~xWjd cceon jfsu«@~kfjWgin¥n gisCY!j7~c (5 - X - x£jdcTWY/eojsu~kfPgon~suj}e/q¦ < d5 sumxggoTWY sgoT}Y!mY!¬0gimoY/XZY'£TWY!jIr mosCW Y/X (M=/ 5 T}xue i]Y!j}!Y£"Y!xujWY«}jWYOgiTWYY!±xu k}xgon~suj¨©kWj}gon~sujKs¨goTWY'eokW|W|} n~Y!m#eUdc j=1. S j=1 j. im£Y/T}xCY!¡[]migiY<n ssC£gojTWY"gosTW¨|WYOgomoT}nq[]YYxCXZe¨©kWTKxuj}a0mo¡¢CgigixCYn sCg8#j¦¢uY/p $(·)Y!miw n~e eogosuTW~kfY go|}n~suxjn~m !(qxj, @pYO)eoxn XZj@ |W~qc(pY¬f|W(·),miY/ei·e·Y8·,xupe(x5(·))[]xunqe²eoTgoT}eoY su~kWkfjWginqn p0sCkWj³Yª sC - |f go- n~«}Xj@x ª ª}eosygiT}xg¨©sCmxjdceokW|W|W~n~Y!m S xj}xjdc|@xn~m u˜ = (˜q , p˜ ) £"Y u = (u , · · · , u ) u = (q , p ) T@x¸±uY JSj ((q1 , p1 ), · · · , (qS , pS )) = q j (p1 (·), · · · , pS (·)), j. ∗ def. ∗ 1. ∗ S. ∗ def j. j. ∗ j. j. 1. j. S. ∗ j. j. j. j. (M=3= 5. ˜j ), JSj (u∗ ) ≥ JSj (u∗−j , u. £T}Y!miY (u , u˜ ) fY!jWsugoY8eUgoTWYO±CY/¡gisum (u , · · · , u , u˜ , u , · · · , u ) ¦ / Bp.r ¾ * "! !
(197) * " 33 * P%' * Q
(198) j = 1, . . . , S $ * ∗ −j. ∗ 1. j. ∗ j−1. j. ∗ j+1. ∗ S. . j. Lj (Qj ) < +∞. 6. S X. j. 9. ¸. (+= 5. Qj ≥ d,. j=1. f %' * " !f" * 4 9 43# ?%' *
(199) M * "!#!m
(200) K6
(201) 9"!3 - eQ , K ] 43# !f"
(202) 6
(203) ,!9#
(204) !m,
(205) 6 , *
(206)
(207) "S/ 'f"
(208)
(209) * , * * 9Z" * !9
(210)
(211) )
(212) * " * E f 9
(213) 6
(214) 2 * '" * 9 * 9
(215) /#_, 1
(216) 6 6 4 ' * 8!m: * :/A $ º fF 1 ' .< $ f! , * . j. j. . . . . gi!n susCj}j}ee gixuLYLj0!g]suxsuj}mijeoY{n~WeesCY!gomim"X5nq¡eoYygok}~/n cj0giY/n~Y!j}eimieo±¸n mi±CxuY/Y!xC5~ec ª$n~jWxun~jw5j}goxTWj}WYLn~eijWYsCsC¬djCjCg"gigin n eojdjdkWkWkW}sCsCeok}k}Y/ee go(2n~(-suadadj}k}kWe}}eeogoY8Y/TW¡Y{gigon n~!sCsuxCjjeY8}We¦¦Å=£5 5 TW¦sCY/mUSUmoYjWTWgisunqTWe]jKY]qfxuXZeY/g{!n~jWmo/Y8n~xuXZxueoeoY xun j}@nqw e|}mogi(©nq|$TWY5sCYei¨©X5eok}n Wj}s0~eh c g& n~wCXZY!jW|@Y/sCmimxug#²xj0sugj0¨©gimin sujdX kWsCgok}T}e!Yy¦ x|}|W nq!xgon~sujI|$sun~j0gLs¨±dn~Y!£ª²eon j}!Y'£(Y s¨ðgiY!jIg#x¢CY L = C £TWnq#TQn~eLjWsugLn~j j. j. 0 j. é ÛÜ é á.
(217)
(218)
(219) "!#. KJML. Y'b aMcmY. . I a"Wcfb9QgR][ aMWT aMW_a R5Ib aMcfQ L,J_WcmY9a+dZW[. 'Y eokW|W|$sCeoYLgiTWYO¨©su~~s£n jWwZxueieokWXZ|fgon~sujTWsuqWe/ª f/,, B p/_.r ¾ "
(220) q
(221)
(222) * "! !m: S $ j ∈ {1, · · · , S}
(223) 4!f ,-m -
(224) * 6 lim L (y) = L (x) [0, Q ] R x ∈ [0, Q ] $ ¾ p ¾ rÍ r ¾ l +. j. . y→x. j. j. Lj. *e* . j. "!#!9
(225) * _ 9 ,* * '8!m
(226) 9
(227) 6A* -:f 94 * " / !f"
(228) 7.e u = (u , u , · · · , u ) ]> . * , < u = (q , p ) * , < q > 0 L (q ) = p , ∀j ∈ {1, · · · , S} . 9 q = 0 * M( =/ 5 L (0) ≥ p , ∀j ∈ {1, · · · , S}. 23-. . . ∗ j. ∗ j. ∗. ∗ 1. ∗. ∗ j. j. ∗. ∗ j∈{1,2···S} qj. ∗ 2. ∗ S. ∗ j ∗ j. ∗. Pj. = d,. = * h,%4' 1 ' - "!#!9
(229) * f,' 9
(230) " 9 * * '8!m
(231) 9
(232) 6A* ' 9 ,%'' 1 ' 33 * * 6 * - %4 $ * . j. . . . n~mi¾³eg¾ jWsugoYUgoT@xg $Y//xk}eoYUs¨7goTWYqxuegY/p0k}xgon~sujZn~j (M=/ 5 goTWY]eosu~kfgin sCjysu¨$giTWYXZn j}n XZn~¶/xgin sCj|WmisuW~Y!X susu¨}¨ gigiTWTWYYXY!±xxmi~¢uk}Yxggon~(Msu=/j 5 ¨©kWnqeìj}kW¡gijWn nqsCp0j}kWeYsu(ð¨ giTWgoT}Y]Y'eokWekW|W|}|W|W~n Y/n~miY!eìm#eeixxgimin~YOe¨©£"c'Y/Y! ¬f³xCW¡Ygi«} cjWY8giTW²Y¦ fY/XZxuj} 5 ªuxj}5TWY/j}Y(giTWY±x~kWY/e =u¦ YeoTWs£ giT}xgjWsCjWYLsu¨ giTWY'adkW|W|W~n~Y!m!xujn~j}miY/xCeYLn¥g#eU|Wmis«WgUdckWjWn~~xgoY!m#x~~cfY!±dnqxgoYL¨©misuX n¥£"g#eLYeT@gox¸m#±uxYgiY!wCc u ¦ sCmgoT@xg/ª$n g]n~eLek !n Y/j0ggoseoTWs£+goT}xg]¨©sCm]xjdc u 6= u , u = (q , p ) ª ns¨ì m#Y!eh~g<Y/jWgosumigon~Y(!n¥goghT}cx|Wg/miªsu$|$Y/sC/eoxY/k}eoY"0suc¨WgogoTWT}YyJY(eqxukW(ue|}g<|WY/ p0n~Y!,k}m#uxe/giª n ) sC- ≥j'.- n~Jj £"(MY=/(uT@ 5x¸ª±ugoY ,TWuYUX), xmi¢uY!ª$gxWj}k}cdegiTWgiY!TWj Y(gosg#xfp0k}xj0gin¥ghc ¦ #TWYsdsCj}eosY£xQYe¬Wgoxum#xX5gin~Y!jWwuY5c goT}Yygh£(sK|@s0eoeon~Wª eoY5k}gh#cdT°|$goY/T}eOxsg ¨gifTWY/Y±0nqp0xk}gixun sCjCjQgiqn¥gh¨©csC=m'eqkWnq|}e'|WY/ n~n¥Y!gimTWY!jm5ª~j}sx£"JXZY/m'Y!~(usucum ª Se)go=minqX¡qgox¸~cc q TWn~wuTWY/mUgoT}xuj q u = (q , p ) ´ñnqe¨ «}uY/ nqxueIj} ek}go#TWT+Y®goXT@xxg mi¢uqYg≤T@xueq giª{s goWT}kWY!c¯j gosuT}dYQ±dn gosCsuk}gieoxu Lc p0gik}TWxY j0gifn¥Y!ghcXxuj} gos nqeKjWsuªgTWY!xj@jdcdYQX5£(sCmoYQY°T}eix¸x±CMg Y & q S ¦ J (u , u ) = q ≤ q = J (u ) ´ñxu¨ j}u$nqY/eU/exk}k}#eoTYgosT}¨²xgig TWqY]|}>monqqY]!ª0sugij}TWeY!gojm#x@n~Y8j0!g/xª0k@£"eY]Y X Lk}enqg"eUT}ehgix¸mo±CnqY¡gi cZn~j}miY/xCen~jWw'dc]eieokWXZ|fgon~su¦jads x|}¨ðmogonqY/mY goTWY'suW¨ Y!gi±dTWn~YOxgosn~gosuT}j³Y!ª$madeokWkW|W|W|W|W~n~~Y!n Y/m mie/S]¦ i|WY/mij}su|$YCsCªdeo¨©YOmosCn¥g#X eY!go~TWY/YOgoXmin~!pxn¥migh¢uc≥Y!g(xLg]miY/xZ(qxC¡|Wgimi)n nqsC>)j YLTW(+=8n~wu (qTW5 ªfY/)£"mU=YgoT}fxupY8jKfk}goTWYY gigiT}s xg]goª pTW Y'- .X- Wxuk}mo¢CcdYeggo«}TWm#Y'ehgLp0k}WxukWjCcgin¥gighsc goT}Y'sPgiTWY!m{ekW|}|W n~Y!m#e/goª}s xj}¦"giz"TWsCY!jQj}e!Y8sup0XZkWY!|Wj0~goY~gicY£(goTWY{YyT@fx¸Y!±uXYuª xj@ S d− S q =q .
(233) . . ∗ j. ∗ j. j. ∗ −j. Sj. ∗ j. Sj. ∗ −j. ∗ j. ∗ j. j. ∗ j. j. Sj. ∗. ∗ j. j. j. j. j. j. ∗ j. . j. ∗ j. j. j. ∗ −j. Sj. . j. j. ∗ j. j. j. ∗ j. j. j. j. ∗. j. i6=j. JSj (u∗−j , uj ). ÜÜ ×s}õ¡ètiî. j. ∗. Sj. ∗ i. =. ∗ j. qj∗. ∗. j. = JSj (u∗ ).. j. j. j. ∗ j. ∗.
(234) 8.
(235) * * *6
(236) K
(237) ' ". =. f¦ im suXH]eiekWXZ|fgin sCj'xj}OLeoeokWXZ|fgon~sujO@ª!giTWY쨩kWj}gon~suj L nqe²£(Y!~ufY«@jWY/{¨©misuX [L (0), +∞] gos [0, Q ] ¦ Ysuj@enqfY!m{giTWY|Wmisu~sujWw0xgon~sujs¨(goTWnqe{¨©kWj}gon~suj (ðgiT}xg'£(Yehgin ~ fY/jWsgiY L 5 ª godsucKgixW Ys«}¤7jWY!n~jWm8wªf0Lc (p) = 0 ¨©sumOxjdc 0 ≤ p ≤ L (0) ¦ Y5!xjIj}s£ WY«}jWYZxZ¨©kWj@¡gon~suj O ª7goTWY −1 j. j. −1 j. j. −1 j. j. O : [0, +∞] −→ p −→. [0, PS. PS. j=1 Qj ] −1 j=1 Lj (p). qn exLjWsCj fY/!moY8xueon j}w]sCjCgin jdkWsCk}e ¨©kWj}¡gin sCj'g#x¢dn j}w«}jWn goY(±x~kWY/en~j'goT}Y"n~j0goY!mi±x [0, P Q [ ¦ adn~j}Ydc{]eiekWXZ|fgin sCj'U£"YìT@x¸±uY P Q > d ª!giTWY!miYìY¬fnqehg#e³xUkWjWnqp0kWY p giT}xg eosu~±uY8e7rmosCW~Y!X (+=8 5 ª - - ek@#TgiT}xg O(p ) = d ¦SUTWYpCk@xj0gon gon~Y/e q xmiY5fY!«}jWY8xCe q = L (p ) ªxj@ su¨"giTWYY!¦ ¬0giY!j}eon~sujs¨(goTWYWY«}jWn gon~suj°su¨ L ªn g'n~e ~Y/xmOgiT}xg q = 0 ª ¨©sum j ek}#T go@SUT}Y8TWx!nqgxuek}LY!ej}Y(0) }e(go≥TWYp|Wmisds¨h¦. O. j. j. j. ∗. j. ∗. ∗ j. ∗. j. ∗ j ∗ j. −1 j. −1 j. ∗. º f. . FE =
(238) A>e
(239) 6
(240)
(241) m4>B4 "m _
(242) 8 9"!3 - *
(243) M # >q 94< "!#V * e,%4' 1 ' p∗ 1 9H,%4' 1 '!m .- U
(244) m4> * "! !f 9e$ *
(245) 4 9"!3 * $ -!m L (0) ≥ p∗ 'h K m
(246) >] P "!# $ $ j * "
(247) ) "!3 -. KJ I. . deW_^QXcfb9QXRU[ a"WT. a"Wa R5I b a"cfQ. . LMJW_cmY'aMdeW[. ~nxCj}eo!eoY mokWj}Y8XZxuseo£|fn gijWxCn w@sCWj³¦fª mi[Y/eiY/e7±ugoY/TWmY"giTW|WY!mi~suY/Weie~Y!£(XHY£xuTWeiY!eomikWYìXZgiTWYQY goXZT@xn~jWgn XgiTWxuY!uc |Wmixun~mo!Y®Y쨩jWkWsuj}j}Wgon~Y/suj}mieY/xCLen~jWxuw@mo¦ Yìj} sgYj}eY/Y!gY8eogieiTWxYQmin~ ¨©c]sCe ~gosmi£nq¡n goj}~cw >] /* B
(248) p. r ¾
(249) * 6 * " ! !
(250) * 9 !f
(251) , , -f
(252) - * L "f
(253) 6 " * / $ !m 4( j. $. j. lim− Lj (y) = Lj (x). x≥0. n~n~wuwukWkW mimiY/YY |W=qxu55 sugon~T@jWmxwQxg gLeigixeoTWgoeoYUnqkWesXZ¨©c giTW|f§ Y!gon~mìp0suk}Y!j x¬0gogiIn~mosuY/dj}XZceKY"(M]gi=/TWei eY!5 kWmi¦XZYUr X|fmogisCx¸n |@sCcs0j @en Yfgon~ª|$sugosCj TWeieY/=(n~moW¨ÍYx~c'n~X~e<n~x¸jfgic®«}s'jWjW#n T}gosY/xg' m#c'$xuYXgoY/xxumojdj0n~ccy¶!Y ehehgogigiTWmimixYxgogo[LY!Y!wCwCxuccQeoT5|W|WmiY8misp0s«}kW«}~n ~Y/~Yhen~W(Í(ÍmoeoeonqY!Y!xWYY ¦ xCe(goTWsuYmUXxjdx¬dc n~Xp ≥x³0p0ªdk}£(xujCYLgifn¥ghY!c«}ejWkWY |}ρ|W (p)n~Y!m SxCegi!TWxuY{jKmosn~wu¤7T0Y!g"m!xsugj0|Wgomin~jdnqkWY suk}pe"ª n~- j0.±C- Y!m#eY]s¨ L ª0sCm"£n goTsgiTWY!m"£"sCmiWe n¥¨ nqeeok}#TgiT}xg L (0) ≤ p, (M=! 5 max{q ≥ 0, L (q) ≤ p}, j u s o g W T / Y o m £ q n e Y ρ (p) = 0, . |@i]xY!moj}goL!nqYe kWxρqxmUsC(p)j}n geoY/n~nqeUp0ekWjWY!susuj@jWg]~cfY<Y!sf|$¨fY!Y!]goj@Y!eifmieY!XZk}j0X5n gj}|WsuY/gojKn~suxdj jdc dcª gi#TWT}YsunqegoYOmin~j}k}s¨migogoY/kWTWxCmiY'eY®Y8eoe7sukW£¨'|Wn¥|WgogiT}~T n~YY!m#e!ª¸XZ¦xn~j}jWLn~XZ¨©sCxum Ox|Wjdmoc nqY®¨©kWj}ª gon~suj L ¦ ´µj ρ (p) p p ≥ 0 lim ρ (y) = ¦ ρ (p) y→x. j. j. j. j. j. j. j. j. j. y→p+. j. j. é ÛÜ é á.
(254)
(255)
(256) "!#. =#=. M(q 1). M(D−q2 ). p*. n wCkWmiY =#ì[sujkWjWnqp0kWY!j}Y/eie. M(q 1). M(D−q2 ). n~wukWmiY'-ì[sCjKY¬fn~egoY/j}Y LY!jWsugoYdc . O(·). giTWYO¨©kWj}gon~suj¨©mosCX. D. R+. gos. R+. D. fY«}j}Y/dc. ¸ O(p) giTWYI|Wminqe]n~!goYITWYysuXZj@ehxgi¬fmin xuXn j0xgi e/¦gosugiSUxTWYs¤7¨©kWY!m]j}gogoT}n~xsugLj !xujQn~e@Yy|$sCxu#eieoTWn n~WY!~±Cc Y/IfnqxeigLsu|Wj0moginqn jdY kWpsCk}de!cª"gijWTWsuYyj@feokWY/!|Wmo|WY8~xun~Y!eom#n jWew@miY/(©eoW|@kWY8g¡gojWn~jWsw g O(p) =. S X j=1. O. ÜÜ ×s}õ¡ètiî. ρj (p).. (+= 5.
(257) ¸.
(258) * * *6
(259) K
(260) ' ". =. 5 igj}T}Y/xgY8eoeixmin~ c°ehgimonq¡gi c°n~j}miY/xCen~jWw x j} eoxgonqeh«}Y8e O(sup Lj (Qj )) ≥. T}Y!j}!YLgiTWY!miYY¬fnqehg#ex5kWjWnqpCk}Y j. S X. limy→p+ O(y) = O(p). ρj (Lj (Qj )) ≥. j=1. ek@#TgiT}xg. Qj ≥ d,. j=1. p∗ ≤ supj Lj (Qj ) < +∞ O(p∗ ) =. S X. ¦ LeoeokWXZ|fgin sCj Qn~X5|} n~Y/e. S X. (M= D 5. ρj (p∗ ) ≥ d,. j=1. O(p∗ − ) < d.. ~nSUj0T}gosY"|Wxumi/nqsCY kWpj0g(mogiY/TW|WYmoY8XZeY/n j}j0n giXe²gixTW²YU|}XZmonqn jWY'n~X!suxj}de|Wgom#mixn~!n~j0Y"g/x¦ g£TWnq#T'giTWYUfY!Xxj@ sCkWq'$Y ¨©kW~~c'eoxgonqeh«}Y8g#x¢dn j}w / Bp. r ¾ q
(261) p 6 /.0f 6 1 2 $
(262) m
(263) + 9Z
(264)
(265) >] / >e
(266) 8
(267) 6
(268) h 9
(269) 6A* $ ∀ > 0,. ∗. . ∗. 23-f 9" 3# * * . - %' ¯j ∈ {1, · · · , S} * P 9 L (p ) 6= ∅ $ >q 9" L (p) = {q ∈ - M ! 4' 9"7 3# * * - %4 ¯j ∈ {1, · · · , S} * 9 [0, d], L (q) = p} 6 * f
(270) j$ 6= ¯j >e 9 L (ρ (p )) < p L (ρ (p )) = p $ $ - 5!f , p 98;33 Z
(271) %4 * "!#!m * " >
(272) >e 6
(273) !f"
(274) !
(275) * * 3 # d $ . j. ¯ j. ∗. ¯ j. . . ∗. −1 ¯ j. ∗. j. j. def. −1 j. ∗. ∗. - - PS ρ (p∗ ) = d j=1 j p r r j "! !
(276) * * * '?!f
(277) * 6 P 9
(278) 6 -V
(279) * 6 ) * " / !m"
(280) K.V u∗ = * 9 (u∗1 , · · · , u∗S ) $ u∗j = (qj∗ , p∗j ) $ / 0 . m *
(281) 4 %.
(282) 2. * 6 6 2 1. p∗ $
(283) . . . . 8. . >e q∗ = ρ (p∗) 6 *. * * * '?!f
(284) j 6= ¯j L (ρ (p∗ )) < p∗ ∗. ¾ ¾ Í ¾. $. . p∗j ∈ [Lj (qj∗ ), p∗ [. 94. j. $. $ - - * 9.
(285) . $. j. . * . ¯ L¯j (ρ¯j (p6 ∗ )) = p∗ P j = ∗j ∗ ∗ p¯∗j ∈ [p∗ , p[ j (p )) , ρ¯ j (p )], k6=¯ j qk ) , ρ¯. >e 9 * * ' 8!m
(286) >$ q 9" p *6 /.0f$ 621 . j. j. . . qj∗ ∈ [min((d −. . (+= 5. def p = min{Lk (qk∗+ ), k 6= ¯j}. = * ,%'' 1 ' º fFE f 9"< #3 * * ".0 ' 1 8
(287) M * , /3 !f"
(288) 7.e * 9 * * )
(289) 6
(290) *
(291) M8 "
(292) ,!9
(293) *
(294) 9Pm! * " 6 .<m 6 * 4 *
(295) + *
(296) * 3- = 9 * * >e @
(297) 1* , * f
(298) p m 6
(299)
(300)
(301) 6 f
(302)
(303) /h 9 * "! !f *
(304) 8/ = $ * ,%4' 1 '- K3 * "! f! \ 9
(305) .
(306) * 6 D!94 6 ' : * " / *6 * 1 6 "
(307) !
(308) *
(309) 9" * ': / * " /+f! "
(310) 7e. * = * ) %4' 1 '- =
(311) * !m,
(312) ! 6
(313) . * m
(314) V 9
(315) 6 8$ / 4m "
(316) 9m
(317) (/. "
(318) * ' / * * * * 1 H
(319) M * 3 * / 1 .4 3- H $. u∗. * . . . . ∗ j. . .
(320). . é ÛÜ é á.
(321) 8.
(322)
(323) "!# =. *
(324) h
(325) 1* 9X
(326) 3 * "! !f 9
(327) '
(328) * * >q 9 9 = * 7,%'' 1 ' * - M * 4 * >e * 9 g * = * ),%'' : 1 " ,%'' >' " *
(329) f 1 f
(330) * >, ! 4' = * ),%'' : 1 ' *
(331) * "!#!9
(332) * * "! ( !f * *
(333) 9 43# .
(334) C
(335) + 8!m,
(336) 7.V * * \ 3#
(337) f-
(338) "+!m"4( * :
(339) /P 9 %4' 1 >] \ "!# * 9" ; 33 .
(340) *
(341) ) 9
(342) .
(343) * 9 , %4' 1 $ ' 9 1 / * 9 < 4 3# m
(344) .- * < 9P,%'' : 1 $ >e
(345) - 6 " 6 ! ' 6 4 * !9
(346) *,* 1
(347) 3 * "!#!m
(348) P,
(349)
(350) * * !f" " 6 , %'' : 1 ' - h
(351) " !f" * $ >] < $ * 33 :
(352) $ 9 %4' 1 ' * 6 >] 1 $
(353) j 6= ¯j ( - - * 9 L (ρ (p∗ )) < p∗ ), q ∗ = ρ (p∗ ), p∗ = p∗ − , j. j. j. j. j. q¯j∗ = ρ¯j (p∗ ), p¯∗j = p − ,. >q , 1 6 /.0f 6 * 9 * > *
(354) m :- º fFE * * '?!f
(355) 8 * m *,*
(356) *
(357) '
(358) \
(359) +H 9 "!#A!f"
(360) 1 2
(361) 9 - %' *
(362) '
(363)
(364) * " /3 * 6 * 1 6 "
(365) ,!9
(366) *
(367) >q B,
(368) * ,%4 ' 2>e $ 6 .<m 6 * * ' ?f!
(369) 6
(370) * m
(371) 9
(372) 6 >e >e
(373) ' 6 m 6
(374) < !# 9 6#6
(375) m 6 *
(376) @M'
(377) + 9 "!# 3'm! * ,_ "! $ -f * * * 9
(378) >5 @
(379)
(380) >] /C 3 8!m e :/ '" $ ">]!3 f 9. 7. , ' % '. ' D 9 ! 4 " . !
(381) P 9. .
(382) f ,
(383) \ M ' > +
(384) . . = * 1 6 6 3 6 6 6 * S ' =V :2/ ' " $ e> _ 9 L (ρ (p )) = L (ρ (p )) = p 6 ρ (p ) + ρ (p ) > d $ >q 9" p * 9 . . . . . . . . . . 1. 1. ∗. 2. ∗. 2. ∗. ∗. 1. 2. ∗. . ∗. p* ~ p2 ~ q1. ^ d−q2. ~ d−q2. ^ q1. d. n wCkWmiYO <§ì¬WxXZ|W~Y. !f 6 .<m 6 2 3-:m ' * * * * '?!f
(385) 6
Documents relatifs
In infantile Pompe disease patients, the glycogen storage diffusely affects brainstem motor and sensory neurons, and the whole spinal cord sensory neurons, interneurons, and
Cette approche a l’avantage d’induire directement, et de façon transitoire (pendant 7 à 10 jours), l’expression dans l’épithé- lium pulmonaire et alvéolaire de cette
cosinus (en bleu à gauche) et d’une droite (en noir à droite) sur les données simulées pour 4 années à une température de 45°C, avec un bruit de fond interne réduit de 100,
Florence CARRÉ ~ Réoccupations funéraires de sépultures collectives néolithiques dans la boucle du
2 Vue plus en détails dans le chapitre 1... 2 phénomène d’agrégation des protéines amyloïdes en fibres et d’autres facteurs impor- tants doivent être pris en compte comme
In this chapter, we prove an a posteriori error estimates for the generalized overlapping domain decomposition method with Dirichlet boundary conditions on the boundaries for
Revue française d’héraldique et de sigillographie – Études en ligne – 2020-10 © Société française d’héraldique et de sigillographie, Paris,
Dans ce cas, comme les coulées du Bras de Sainte-Suzanne appartiennent au massif de La Montagne daté à plus de 2 Ma (McDougall, 1971), l’ensemble des coulées pahoehoe
