• Aucun résultat trouvé

Natural aging on Al-Cu-Mg structural hardening alloys – Investigation of two historical duralumins for aeronautics

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Natural aging on Al-Cu-Mg structural hardening alloys – Investigation of two historical duralumins for aeronautics"

Copied!
24
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)Open Archive TOULOUSE Archive Ouverte (OATAO) OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.. This is an author-deposited version published in : http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/ Eprints ID : 19733. To link to this article : DOI: 10.1016/j.msea.2017.03.003 URL : http:/dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2017.03.003. To cite this version : Cochard, Audrey and Zhu, Kailin and Joulié, Sébastien and Douin, Joël and Huez, Julitte and Robbiola, Luc and Sciau, Philippe and Brunet, Magali Natural aging on Al-Cu-Mg structural hardening alloys – Investigation of two historical duralumins for aeronautics. (2017) Materials Science and Engineering A, vol. 690. pp. 259-269. ISSN 0921-5093. Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the repository administrator: staff-oatao@listes-diff.inp-toulouse.fr.

(2)   

(3)   .                  

(4)            . 

(5)      . 

(6)  !"##   $ % &  ''('  )   !"" % &   (

(7)               &* &*  # (  (+ &* !"#,    $% &    !" #  $%. !!&%# '%!( ) * 

(8)          . 

(9)                 ! "#$%         &                              &   %  .     . 

(10)   '

(11) ()* 

(12) ()*+,              -.+"

(13)  -.-) % .               %                 ,            /  ,      0         %  - ./ %%+! ##  " $ % !"+      . +%       (  #, % -  (% !."!  %". - %  ! ! ( #  #  !"+   !  ! + /  (   !  %  %#! %% +!   "  +    ! + !  %0 +(  (!  !-" !##(12 +"/  ,,# +!    %!   !    ! -+  % % ! 3 # %" " !  4!# " " #3 % #" !!  #!!! # !-!%"   ,,# + 5#   /   " ( %#  ##  % 3 !.

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

(15)  ! +!"  H! $ ",F7G/ !129B+ #   !#!+!%!/ +!>99?,F7G9/ !   1217 +   ! %"+  (  !% " ! (   (! (!# !4 3+ /  !%    (!" (    (      ."!   # !-   ! 34! ! (  ( "" +!"("!/!((   3! % ! " ! % ! (  ! +# #, % ##    ! @( %%" " !  + % !  - ! - +!/"+!%!%!%+.   3!-!#( !  #!%"!!  (" -!! + (!   %% -! >91? @ 5 !    % #+ "# % ! !  -!  ! !@   #!(# % !  %!    +    + /+  ! +  !    +   # ( %   %!%"  +(  (! %" !/ %  +!% / !%"!%+--- - + ! )%" +-!( !* /(( % !    " " ! ( " !(% # #!%"#! #+    ( % ! /  "   ,! !   -!#  ! / ! % " " !! ! %  !!!#-  3 !!  %"       ( %  !(      ( %  )I*  -!( "!  3 !!!!" "!!!%+"!! ##!(!%" +! . -%    -%+%  3 !   % ! /  !%"    <2 + !    #   B<: J., !K),4 *   -!!J!!3!K # A 3"(/( %9C:C9C<C>96? ( //!#   ( !   % + ! ( $- .  A     # 3   ( ! ."   / "  ! ( (%& 92 + ! (   ! -    7B + !  !       #"     !#- !!-  %#! # !  !4   !   %!  #  (  !  " ! --# %.

(16) "%!  /  # % "! /  !      (    %- ( %!  ()A#9*"!-4!!!1%%3+    "  !  %%+ !  (  (!# !4   ! # ! >97? 3 ( !     = !   # (%,!  "   !   #  3 !      1  !  ! #    (  !! ( %4(  (. .   

(17)

(18) 

(19) 

(20) 

(21)     

(22)  

(23) 

(24)

(25) 

(26)  !""### $ %  &$

(27) # '!

(28) ( )*!

(29) 

(30) $

(31) 

(32) 

(33) 

(34)  

(35) 

(36) & )!

(37) 

(38) $$

(39) 

(40) 

(41)   

(42) 

(43) !

(44) . . -%-% .

(45) @-!#(! !  #% ! 5 ! " % #+ / --!!%% -! ! . ( % #"!)     ."  " " !*   !! % # ! +  !%"  % !  ( . !    ++!* ) &&)0    3/"!1 =/ ( !+   %%%"!( +!%+!!/!" ( % +@ -+" !%L8"$%!! " % + )@,8$* + $-! + G "  3 9 #-!  %!   %%"!(" ( %" ! ." %"!!(  !%+!( %A !  @66:2M(9C:B>9:?3!!  /!"" +  #%"+!"  !!( % !  !( !  (>9<?    +

(46) '

(47) '! #, '!

(48) $

(49) !

(50) (-./ %+0'!

(51) $1

(52) 

(53)  $ $ $2 3"/45$

(54) 

(55)  $ $(-6

(56) 2''2 45

(57)       .  )* 1 ** 3* 3 33 3 33 7 733 733 7333 733 733 7333 2%8945 (

(58)   3 3 3 3': 3': 3245 (

(59)  % 3%3* 3%3 3%3* 3 3 ) 13   33 3 3 3331 73 733 733 7333 7333 733 73333 2%8945 (

(60)    3 3': 3': 3': 345 (

(61)  % % 3%3* 3 33 3  = " ! !! %#!% )2=6 /N*  1 )9:6 /N*  / !/!  = ! %  ( ,F7G + / ! 1 ! %  ( ,F7G9 + A   ! ! (  # B<:     (!   !!   -   "!    ,F7G   ,F7G9 /   " ( (!#!4 !  >9B?@%!  ! /+! / #!"(! #" " ! # %(%+3+   #      +!  %%   ! 9C2C (  ,F7G >9=?     ##(9C62!( ,F7G9>9C?3 !# %#!% %" -!! #,F7G ,F7G9-%"!! + -%% +! !#  !"-+!129B 1217 / ((   %" !   )   A*.  +!! " ( %  + G/ ! #.

(62) !!" % +)G* - 1+!!% 4 +!!%" ! %!)   3 E  G*="  ++&&*&  1   @     ! -  % # !    #  ((  "!! !    "! /   #   " "    ! 3  ! (  / & )9* ."  #    )1*  !- !  # ! (     )6* 4!!.    !" #  ! E %   )E* #   )* /! +"! ( " % +"! -( !!,!! 3 % !   /!  %  ( % "   !#   % !"! 3 "!%"!/ " "  !!+( %# ".%$!"%/! %.  ".+ ! %+"! / ,   !-"" ! )!   * (  !# # % +     "!# ! / %  "!! /  9 O% "  ! 8" ! - /!      - !  % !"E4122$#/

(63)  D!!)A9% E861:% 9:%  %   18 C: %* /! ""  -#  % !   (  +   /## !" !%!  /  "%  $.%/!# % !")$*$8<7<2P" # 12 4P   5""  /  8.(  @E A$3.6  #+ !" !- Q, + !" %  )$* /! " ( %   # " "! )R 1 O%S* /   (    5( !#" 

(64) ,  A!  !!!/  % 922/N @  ! -!   " "!! "!/ !  #      ! )9  1  6* (  % "!# "  1722  ""  #           4!! ( 1: O%   !"%! /    %+ !#3",:  !"" !" #<2P! ( %       )6&9*  ,9:; 3 !   /! ! -  !#  3 !%!! $   !"+ $8 1292 " #  1224P %! %! " !!  !% " "! /   (  /  12 A$G 3$M3$ % !"  " #  122 4P   5""  /   #+ !" !- Q, + !" !"+)T. $!+!%/! (  ( % 4 * .

(65) ++ &* &   3! !"%! /     "& <  9     <  !  1   )" "    9* /#  #  " !- ! (       -  "!! !" !( !!( !/! (  !! " A#1  ## #M    !   /  (  ! !"%   12 %%   6 %% !"-+ 3 ##! /  "!  %+ "   9222 #        %  "#    !% !! !%  #  ! ( (!!! 3 4!! )  6*(!!!"%! #(91,9:%%3!!/! " ( % !  (221%%!,9 + #"" !!#3U.!%  A " =##!/ %!   .  0!

(66) $$'

(67)  '' 

(68) 

(69)  

(70)  !

(71) '

(72) . .  +++2    !!%! %!/   ! ("!#  8%%! 1922 ""+# (622#  #92!"! ! (!!!  #- !!P4 !)P*% ! . 12 1%+%  &  +!+!  &&  8! - " ( %  (  % #  -   +" !   4   % ( %! !/  A# 6   # !. #    )9  6* )1 6*"!3-!(# !! #-313+. # -   - #-!.

(73) .   ;

(74)  !(

(75) 

(76) <<<  !

(77) =  

(78)  )*$( )!

(79)  

(80) 

(81) >

(82) 

(83)     @! - #  ( !#M/ !# 1( )9 6*  )1 6*"!"! % "  ( 1( = A = !%+ !( % !!, #("  #!% !# !  )9  1* " 3! " !! --! ##  #   )!+ C2;* (   "!! >12? @  ! #    " + ( % " " !  !  ! !! %" -( %+(%/- !(!" !!9C:C + #%"#+ %!" -A 1  #   !" !%! " +1  ( /% 4 #(# !!-  .

(84) A  %   ! #-  3 1   - # !-! (  = # !   !%  + ( 1,6!1"3%.%%#!7:O%( = /! 997O%( 1    9  ?

(85) $ $

(86) )*$)!

(87)  $

(88) <<<  !

(89)   .   .  ". (  *  + ,&  *  +       !. #$ . )

(90)      #,-'       %  & & $'     )

(91)  A$     @'  @'    ). #$  '  % / /0 <<  +B: 71 371  3 7 3

(92) :

(93)   

(94)  <<  +

(95) $ 7 7  3 7*  <<  +

(96) $ 7 17*   7 3   ) #$  ' 01 % / /0 <<  +

(97) $ 1*7 7*  3 7  <<  +

(98) $ 17 7*  3 7  <<  +

(99) $ 7 17 1 3 17   A % !!%! %!! "  31 -!(= 1"!   961 P   9:2 P !"-+ 3  !   %"  ((  / . ((  "! ."    .  ! (  !" #  # " )9  1* .!/  !!-! 3!/%" #=/1"! = !!,  ".!/ # !    /   !! 3 ((   % !   ! 4    %. ( %      %  % ""    ((  ( % " " ! ) !!* ( ! %+ !  #   ((  ( %"!  .  %! ! ! #  1 " )3 9*  !  /  !!!   +!!   " "!!  +!+3 

(100)    4 . 5   0 &   6  3 )0*  A#7!/!+" ! %" !  ( %4!   %# /$ 5( /$3/+! -!%  !+(% ," ! )  9: 222" !M%%S*/" ! ##( %9O%"9=O%#.

(101) .  2/ 

(102) ! 

(103) $

(104) B( '!

(105) $

(106) 

(107) $(-0+;#(C 

(108) $

(109) 

(110)   $+<0 )*!

(111) D%2/2/E

(112) ;0 2;0/ &( )!

(113) D%2/0%2/; 2/E

(114) ;0 2;0/ . . %#   !  % " !   ! /  ! ! " "! 5 %" "!!"!! @ #   ! " !     !!   ( ! " ! ( %   # ! ( ( %%+#>19?3+   M  ! %" ! 3  ! " !   ! (          !    %( # " !! !+ !  # (     %!  +   " " #" !!(+A =")A#7* (     # + !"  # + " !  !"   ! ! " !     A      / - ! " " ! /    + $  /      +  !" F, F,)A *"!! 8 1 "   !% +"! ( " ! )F,)A ** /  (    +" ( "   A  /!!   -!" !(B1A"! !"!! ." !!" !( 1217 ,F7G9+!>11? .

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

(116) 3="!!!9/N(# 2</N(!)#!29<B/N1*  /  !" !   M#  5  7B    #M  5  97 3 " "=!! (( 1!(/#M )X9B*= , 1#" "!5!(- &+1 :1#=<!  ( %  @  = "   4 " ! ! -  + $  /  %"! ( )*#  !" !"!  +!+ . 5  &  +!++!4 0   7 0 & 0    A# : ! +" !%  " !  (  / 3$   $  ! -!#! /!  +! - (( " !"! !! .  0< !

(117) $ (

(118)

(119) $(-6+;  '!

(120) 

(121)  !

(122) <<  )*!

(123) #  ($ -!

(124) !

(125)  $0

(126) 

(127) $! 

(128) ( )!

(129) . .  ! # !!% !  ((   ,4" "! -  ( 1  ="!A 1" -#%"!!1217+ " "!- #   ,4!"/# #(62,1C2% %+%"! (    %#!+ !   #% .3!" ! ! . !" ! !  ( %   ##, % % !!#%#   -  (   / !+  !  %%  # !% (   ! %!&     M   3   !    # ! !   !!   +! - #  # # ! ( %   (- # #    !  ". !!>19?A +(1217+"/+"/#M# 51=  % !" ! !."  1216 !, "!3>19 1=?.

(130) @=" -    ,4!"" !/# / - +#( %72 122 %   ! -  ! !%    !" ! !    1    !%%! #  # " "   .! H 3$,$   !     %"! ( " !!5 #!&A  A #( @ !!  !" ! ! !""! !#&(+"  A!!/A#:)* " "#   !)!*!! - 81 ( " ! !5((  #! !,F7G+  ! # !% - = 1"! !% " !/  !"  #(: 12%  #! ! / ! - )A#<* .   30'% ?

(131) ! 

(132) $$  (

(133)

(134) $(-6+;)#+<0'!! #

(135)  !!

(136)  

(137) ! 

(138)   %"!  ( %+   ! !% !  %  " ! " "   # !!      "  + ! !% ! " !  / " -!  +.

(139)   #(% +  #%-%( !!3! +"(!%" !! - "!!( 5-%  1217 +!/36%" >: 1C? @ 1 " ),F7G9*  /! " " ! !""!       %+ - ,+" "!  #D,"!( %(!/!( !." >9 1C? (  / #+!%"   %%"    !" #37%   !# (  %! >97?  " " ! .!-+ G  / !  ! - / -3$%,   " "! %!D,"! / !""" # +" (##) !" #3< 3= %*!!/ >97 1< 1C 62?  3 6 !%% !  - ! " ! (    / "!  ((  ! - !!  #%" !/4/" "!( %     .

(140) !

(141) $

(142) 

(143) $(-0+;%+<G$6+;%+<G# '!

(144) $

(145) )*$)!

(146) . ). ) )   56 42 42 ! !   H $

(147) !

(148)  2/ 2/ DI%2/45 +B( '!

(149)  2/ 2/ D%2/45   2/; 0%2/;45 / 

(150) !

(151)  2/ ;0 2/ ;0 2/;*045   2/E

(152)  2/E

(153) 45  2/E

(154) ;0  2/E

(155) ;0  2E

(156) ; 045 < !

(157) $  2;E

(158) 0 2/; 23/;45   +!++4 &    %"  (   ! !! % !      ! +   #-     %    ! + ."   +  "   (. !!/ ! - +3$/"! !!/A#B .

(159)  /<  (

(160)

(161) $(-6+; )*$( )!

(162) . .  @  1 "   !! !    !" ! ! @  = "  /-  . !! !  +" .+!%&+" !!!+. !     % .   ! -  3! # + ""! /  ! ""   . !%!- >69?   !#(##4 (#"  (   ( . 1%-%  &  !!" ( % = 1"! - - +#  "  +( ! ! #  -! 3! ! ! -     9   ! / !    !- !1  +"  - (   #  ! ! #-  A# = 3 %!   % " " ! #-37 # / ( % -! !!!  ( A  / "!   Y# % !    "  !    5-&    <B G   9<N !"-+ /-   %"  ((  ! (   #  ! # " " !@!# ( 1( =3!# !//% !  " !    !! -! " -!+ -   !  !5   + (  1 " .!# %" " !(=.

(163)  .6

(164)  

(165)  

(166) 

(167)  )*$)!

(168) E

(169) 

(170)   !

(171) '

(172) ! 

(173) 

(174)   $

(175) <$$ 

(176) $

(177) 

(178)  

(179) 

(180)  $

(181) <. .  #  #  ! ! %  %"  (  1  (  =   ! (  #  %" " !%!( %# #  /!4/ !! ! #  !!(,+!>16? . )%3   )%+%          '        .    3 % " " ! .   ( % %! %! ( =   1 "!   !%%  37 3+ /  %"    !   .   ( %  -! %! 3 7 ! " !!!  -! %%  + #D!  (%"+9C:B #  / #(-!( !%+! "  9C:7+# !A !(  0 &- D%%>61? !  ! ( %%  129B,37 1217,37+! !#-(  ( >66?  .

(182)  2 ;

(183) ! !

(184) 

(185) $

(186) 

(187) '

(188) $ '

(189)  

(190) 

(191)  )*$)!

(192) $

(193) !$2%/%; - ! !

(194) 

(195)  '

(196) 

(197) 0$ $ 1 45J

(198) 

(199) $

(200) K2''1 435$

(201) 

(202)  $(C45   7 7 &    4 . (!  ,&  &  89 #'      ,:;,- 89 59 #' #'      ). ! . *3      , " #  65' :   && #<0/' =3>. 42 2<0?   & + 2 &@ #. '. 3331 .  . 31 . ,. 33". ( $ &. A  #<02' =1> 8+ #11.' =>      #  65'. 42. %%. %%  . %% 1 . %,. %%. 1/2.  . * .  . ,. 3". ) ! . 3 . * . 1 . ,. "3. :   && #<0/' =3>. 42 011?   & + 2 &@ #. '. 3331 .  .  . ,. 3"1. ( $ &. A  #<02' =1> 8+ #11.' =>. 42. %%. %3%  . %*% 1 . 3%,. %%. 122.  .  . *3 . 1%3,. 3". ;   

(203)        

(204)  

(205)        ! " #" $%& '  ( ) *

(206) * +.   3 ( ! ! - !   %!   +  ! #  % ! #   "  ! ( =),F7G* 1),F7G9* !!/%"+D!!  !>9<?  (."  #( ""!    !3% ! -   ( % #B<: ! !  !( 129B,37 1217,37 # #!(!"  " ! %!4/ !+(  92+ !((#! - 7B+ !(   !    !(+! ! # 4" 5  %" " ! 3! !!%"%! ! "     +# +!  + !%"  ( %  (!  ( !#(%>67? " -   .

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

(208)       !4 "  (   # B<: @ ! !%"   ," " "%/!! - !!/A#92.   <6+;%+<0'!!)*!

(209)  #

(210) 

(211) !

(212) !

(213) 

(214) 

(215) '

(216)  -!

(217) ! 

(218)  .  16+;'

(219) $ !

(220) $  )*$( 

(221) 

(222) $2%89!

(223) 

(224)  '

(225) 

(226) 

(227)  0 L3 #

(228) %!

(229) !(

(230)

(231) $  !

(232) )*. .  A  %   (   = "  !-    ! -!   !     " ."   !% # @ "   ,+" !! -  !. !  )A# B*  %"     ! ( 1 /  !!   "  +.

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

(235)    3! / 4 /! !""   + 3 )! 3%5    -* ,   3#!(  ! "  #P@" 0)##( -   !*  +   (/!" $ )( :C96*M # )( 912:6662*  #  @8" 0 + # %%@-!!!%! D-   " # %E, 99,@$Q,2221,21  ( E,92,Q,226B,E$Q3.

(236) 3 !/ 44!!(  ( & .  !"+% J #,1 "!K (  " - #  !%"!   " ! ( %     ( %5% (" " ! -$$( !!! 3$! !/ %+4/ #  . 2   45 +2 0 C

(237)  M  H

(238) %

(239) (

(240)  '' -   2 N $

(241)  J<

(242) - +$    

(243)      2$

(244) '

(245) .0<

(246) /21*1!! % 45 9+ 6

(247)  <0 ;>

(248) ?

(249)  +$   H$(C  2'' -  ;

(250)  - $ 

(251)

(252)  /J/

(253) 

(254) ; 

(255) <

(256) CC

(257) O

(258) #P C 33 45 O J

(259)

(260)   / 2

(261) 

(262) 

(263) $ 2  ;

(264)   $ 0 

(265)  6

(266)  +

(267)    )% 6

(268) '+

(269) 

(270) $%6

(271) '!

(272) 

(273) +:! 

(274) 6

(275) O2$

(276) '

(277) 

(278) A </11!  45 ; A

(279) ( C M 0

(280) # C 6

(281)  

(282) 

(283)   %  

(284)   '   

(285)   2/O; -             2 331 %1 45 />0 ;- ; A

(286)   M G 9 0 0  J

(287)  9 J? .

(288) 

(289)   

(290)  

(291) '

(292)   

(293)  '   

(294)  

(295) :

(296)  $  '(-  3 '' -      003 *%3 45 / )  ;Q '

(297)  $I

(298) $''

(299) '

(300)  !    

(301)  

(302) 

(303) '

(304)  '     $IQQ'

(305)  $

(306)   

(307) $IQ 

(308) 

(309) 

(310) $I''3%6< $

(311) I8

(312) Q$

(313)  6

(314) . O -

(315) B

(316) $

(317) 6

(318) 3 45 J   / M  9 6

(319) '!  ;

(320)  ! !

(321) 

(322)  $    (

(323)     3%6 

(324)

(325) 

(326) '-

(327) :!

(328) $ -

(329) 

(330) 

(331) $

(332) '!

(333) 

(334)  

(335) ;

(336) 

(337)    ;

(338)  .'* N;

(339)  !

(340) 

(341) 111!!1%3 4*5 O< 2

(342) :!   !C  +:!

(343) '

(344)  $ 

(345) 

(346)  $

(347)     %$

(348) $ '

(349)  ! !

(350) 

(351)  $

(352)  $     3 '' -      2<.B33**% 415N9'9;C# C)?

(353) $  36''- $

(354) '

(355) $

(356)  211*%* 435 M <

(357) <'(

(358) 

(359)  2 /$

(360)  /'!    

(361) 

(362) 

(363) $ $ ' !

(364) 

(365) :! 

(366)  

(367)       ''-   

(368)  1111%1 456

(369) 2''2 .

(370) -$

(371)  $

(372) ''! '   # ''$# ''- !""###'' "

(373)  

(374) "$  -% $ $ "''%- %3"32

(375)

(376) $2! 3  452/ $ M<A %E 

(377) MH

(378) ? ) J((M%; 

(379)   0

(380) 

(381)   

(382)  '!

(383) '

(384)  - 

(385)    

(386) '

(387)  - 

(388)   $   

(389)

(390)    

(391)  $-  

(392)  !

(393) 

(394)  

(395) 

(396)  0 I  

(397)  ;J0

(398) - +$ ;J0 '

(399)

(400)   /'( $

(401) 8

(402) -

(403)  3!!%3.

(404) 45M/- )

(405) -  

(406) )

(407)   

(408) 

(409) 13%1 

(410) ! 

(411) 

(412) $)  R

(413) /<     1%1!!%1 45 +2 0 C

(414)  M  M6 0

(415) - 2!!  '$

(416)  '' -      .     11% 456(

(417) :$

(418) 

(419) $I''

(420) $

(421) 

(422) $

(423) 'Q ' '

(424) 2.J3"/Q$L $S1; R

(425) $

(426) <Q

(427) 

(428) O

(429) 

(430) $

(431) E 

(432) 2 'Q

(433) 0

(434)  Q $I+: E 

(435) 2 'Q

(436) 2.J <

(437) 6

(438) B

(439) 

(440) .$  

(441) 

(442) Q$L$S1! 45 E

(443)  0$ $   3 

(444) 

(445)   8 

(446)  $I2

(447)  ;.O<+E % 0

(448) 

(449)    B

(450)  $

(451)   $Q

(452) 

(453)  /T

(454) 

(455) Q$EQ 

(456) 1

(457) S 

(458) 1!22/11 450

(459) 

(460) 6

(461) B

(462) $

(463) I2Q B

(464) =

(465) 2  /

(466) 6

(467) B

(468) 

(469) 

(470) /

(471) 

(472)  $

(473) <'

(474) $; Q

(475) $

(476) I2 

(477) $

(478) I+ !

(479) $ 

(480) 1 4*5H $<! 2

(481) $A'

(482) 

(483) $Q( $

(484) < '/

(485) $I 

(486) $

(487) I'' . ! IH 

(488) $

(489) I2''33% 415232''2-0

(490)

(491) $ 

(492)  ###'"'U! $ " U'

(493) "

(494) "! $ !V! $U$W13

(495)

(496) $ ;-3  435 ; J 0 >  $ 0  0 /   J 2 ;

(497)  E ' 

(498)    M < '

(499) $/'0! 

(500) .

(501)  ( 3% 450/ A;M0 C

(502) !

(503)  $

(504) '

(505) !

(506)   !

(507) !  $

(508) 2%/% ;%) (

(509) $-      ! 01331% 45MJ<  2''$''- 11;

(510)    C20;.

(511) & 45<(  0 < 

(512) '

(513) ! ! Q!$

(514) 

(515) $I''6

(516) B

(517) $

(518)  I.Q

(519)  ;311!!% 450/A;M0 C6#-!

(520) 0!

(521) !

(522) !

(523) 2=/=;-    00B331%1 45 ;M 0-

(524)  /J H  P /

(525)  2 <

(526) '!  6M  # 6

(527)  

(528) : 

(529) 

(530)   # 0 2/; !

(531) 2=/=;- "  31313%1 45 9 0 J>A ; 

(532)  G 9 / ;$$

(533)  0  J

(534)  O  

(535)   '' - 30

(536) 

(537)  

(538) $!

(539) !! 

(540)

(541)   0<31%3 45)E;$2''2- 0 

(542) $ !

(543) 

(544) 

Références

Documents relatifs

La contrainte de rupture évolue en fonction de la nature de l'atmosphère, du temps de maintien pour une température précise figure 6, de la rugosité des surfaces céramiques

The analysis of the damage mechanisms of the composite and the results of tensile mechanical tests show a similarity between accelerated aging in water at 23°C and

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

développement des agglomérations et la limitation des ressources en eaux souterraines, font que le pays a de plus en plus recours aux eaux superficielles provenant, principalement,

We consider a threshold autoregressive stochastic volatility model where the driving noises are sequences of iid regularly random variables.. We prove that both the right and the

Ces auteurs ont comparé des prédictions établies par l’expression (eq. 1) avec des mesures expérimentales de résistances obtenues avec divers plusieurs tests de compression pure.

[ 1 ] We investigate experimentally the frictional response of a thick sample of simulated fault gouge submitted to very high shear displacements (up to 40 m) in an annular simple

sinusoidal grooves in their free surface have shown that peak ejection velocities depend not. only on the groove depth and aspect ratio (which is consistent with jetting theories