المعارضة البرلمانية و التحول الديمقراطي في العالم العربي

(1)



ةشقانملا ةنجل

1 -أ.

كوربم نابضغ د

...

تنتاب تعماج

...

اسيئر

2 -أ.

دنحمأ قوقرب د

...

رئازجلا تعماج

...

اررقم افرشم

3 -أ.

هيسح يرداق د

...

تنتاب تعماج

...

اشقانم

4 -أ.

رمع يتاحرف د

...

ةركسب تعماج

...

اشقانم

لوحتلاو ةيناملربلا ةضراعملا

يبرعلا ملاعلا يف يطارقميدلا

(2)

(3)

2 



(4)

3

1

15

20

31

39

50

52

72

78

90

91

103

118

130

137

(5)

(6)

5 

1962



1989

1991

1997

(7)

6 



(8)

7 



(9)

8 



Olivier Duhamel, les démocraties, régimes,

histoires, exigences



Mohamed, Boussoumah, la parenthèse des

pouvoirs publics constitutionnels de 1992 a 1998



13 2006

(10)

9 

2000



(11)

10 





(12)

(13)

12

(14)

13

1 . 4 ( : د 2002 ) . 71 . 1 1999 87 2

(15)

14 opposition

oppose

opposite

opposition

1 56 2 2002 2003 87

(16)

15 parler

87 1 ، 16 7 2007 . <www.histgeo-ma.com/2Am/Fadaa/Edu2-4.htm -33k> - 2

(17)

16 unicaméral

bicaméral

Joseph Shombiter

Samuel Huntington

1 » « 24 06 2007

(18)

17 transition

Samuel Huntington

1 1 2004 29 2 22 2 2009 < http: www.alghad.jo ?news=93444>

(19)

(20)

19

1 -2 2006 75 2 81 3 4 81

(21)

20

(22)

21 democratic consolidation

1 2 2005 10 83 2

(23)

22 



1 16 2007 102 103 2

-"séminaire parlementaire sur les relations entre partis majoritaires et minoritaires dans les parlements africains". Consulté le 16. 02. 2007.

(24)

23 



1 2 2002 263 2 264

(25)

24

1

2

3

1 264 1 263 269 3 270

(26)

25

1 2000 87 2 2001 11 2 31

(27)

26 Wenner

1 2002 19 20 2 24

(28)

27

1 58 2 59 61 3 65

(29)

28

1 67 23 2 3 76 78

(30)

29 Huntington

1 -67 78 2 -1997 161 3 162

(31)

30

1 162 172 2 25 3 1 2005 79 80 4 1 414

(32)

31

-104 106 1 2 2 1 1989 627 3 646

(33)

32

1 -208 2 122 3 35 4 1 1992 11

(34)

33

1 1 2007 86 2 87 3 11

(35)

34

1 10 2 10 18

(36)

35

10 18 1 2 74 77

(37)

36

1

2

3

4

-74 77 1 90 2 3 20 11 2008 <http://www.marmarita.com/vb/archive/index.php/t-812.htm1>

(38)

37

5

6

1 13 2006 183

(39)

38

1 184 2 183 184

(40)

39

1 185 2 13 2006 189 3

(41)

40

1 13 2006 197 198 2 199 3 200

(42)

41

1 197 207 2 2003 84 85 3

(43)

42

1 2003 8 11 -12 2

(44)

43

1 57 2 17 3 18

(45)

44

1 -2 2006 29 3 1 2000 81

(46)

45

1 25 2 26 3 67

(47)

46

1 68 2 69 3 159

(48)

47

1 149 2 150 3 4

(49)

48

  -5 1 2

- Richard Cazenave," Le rôle de la majorité et de l’opposition dans le travail parlementaire". Consulté le 13. 7. 2008.

(50)

49 .

2

*

1

-Séminaire parlementaire sur les relations entre partis majoritaires et minoritaires dans les parlements africains, op.cit.

2

- Ibid.

3

- Olivier Duhamel, les démocraties, régimes, histoire, exigences, (Paris : édition du Seuil, 1993), pp. 25-28.

(51)

50

1 39 2 44 *

(52)

51 .

2

1

- Séminaire parlementaire sur les relations entre majoritaires et minoritaires dans les parlements africains, op.cit.

2

- Ibid.

(53)

(54)

(55)

54

1 1 1996 163 2 152

(56)

55

1 22 8 2008 <http://Ksm.maktoobblog.com/294429/%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%>

(57)

56 1938

1961

1989

1 2 3 284 4

(58)

57 1938

1938

1967

1 2 285

(59)

58 1899

1921

1939

1961

1962

1 2 2 2000 56 3 56

(60)

59 1981

1985

1986

1989

1 57 2 57 3 58 60

(61)

60 1962

25

150

1 66 2 68 3 69 75

(62)

61 1962

50

10 1990

09 1990

02

23

1 -76 82 2 10 2 2008

(63)

62

400 1962

www.pogar.org/publication/legislature/wahby 1a/section.htn> < http:// 1 1997 42 2 27 9 2007 <http:// www.undp-pogar.org/arabic/countries/compare.asp> 3 24 2 2008 <http://www.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/c5c859EB-5AA1-4E59-9844-DOE6B196FDEA.htm=0>

(64)

63 1938

1976

1986

2006

1962

50

1 1 286 2

(65)

64

60

23 1963

25 1967

23 1971

27 1975

1976

1965

1977

24 1980

23 1981

25

1 354 2 355 3 7 2 2008

(66)

65

20 1985

03 1986

05 1992

02 1990

1962

05 1992

07 1996

04 1996

17 1999

05 2003

2006

1 2 . 3 28 2 2008 <http:// www.hrcao.org/conference/2005/papers/10 ali.doc>

(67)

66

71

11

174 

1 365 2 357

(68)

67 

114 

100

101

102 

100

101

(69)

68 1992

19 1992

1992

1989

1 2 .

(70)

69 1990

1992

1996

1 2 3 16 12 2007 >www.pogar.org/publication/legislature/wahby 1a /-8k <

(71)

70

16 1998

34 1999

04 1999

107

03 1999

1996

1992

1309

1559

1996

781

111 1996

2003

1 2 . 3 4 14 6 2008 <http://www.islamonline.net/arabic/politics/2003/07/article05.html>

(72)

71

1 1999

2

80

18

12

20

03

08

06

18

05

06

1

(73)

72

06

04

46

22

50

29 2006

:

2005

340

57

249

27 :

1 2

(74)

73

35

50

29

06

27

1 2

(75)

74

10

1 7 8 2008 <http://www.aljazeera.net/nr/exeres/CF97CB16-1547-4cB0-874E-D5466EE9DE78.htm> 2

(76)

75

05

1 27 4 2008 <http://www.pogar.org/publications/legislature/salh 1a/section3.html>

(77)

76

1

(78)

77 1962

2 1962

1 52 2 54

(79)

78 1980

1 2 3

(80)

79

25

5

1 125 126 2 -17 2007 26 3 27

(81)

80 1938

1962

1986

1 2 3

(82)

81 .

1 9 3 2008 <http://www.arabgate.com/more/7/%d8%aa%d9%82%> 2

(83)

82

51

106

102

1 375 2 3

(84)

83

1 21 2 2008

<www.arabparliament.org/arabic/activitiees/lit-asp aid=10 tid=3-10k>

2

1

2001 19

(85)

84

45 1975

1999

1 2 25 4 2008 <http://mengos.net/books/ourbooks/ibnkhaldun/bycountry-a-l/kuwait b.htm>

(86)

85 .

140 2005

25

10

16 3 2008 -1 <http://alwi7da.org/forums/showthread.php?t=3433> 2 26

(87)

86

107 1962

51

52

53

106

1 27 2 22 2 2008

(88)

87

107 2006

33

29

1 15 2 2008 <http://www.pogar.org/publications/legislature/wahby.1a/section11.html> 2

(89)

88

102

1 14 3 2008 http://www.ahwar.org/debat/show.art.asp ?aid=48370 < 2 359 2008

(90)

89 1990

1 2

(91)

90 



1976

1986

1999

2006

(92)

91

(93)

(94)

(95)

94 1992

26

(96)

95 1988

1954

1956

1 20 1 2007 <http://www.altareekh.com/new/doc/modules.php?name=content&pa=showpage&pid=1306&comm=0> 2 1 2002 34 35

(97)

96 1988

23 1989



1931

2007 11 1

(98)

97 1926

1936

1927

1946

1936

1963

23 1976

94

95

11 1 2 116 3

(99)

98

39 1963

20 1963

1964

19

1 1 2003 126 105 2

(100)

99 1976

1967

1988

24 1988

1989

128 1 120 2 4 3

(101)

100 1976

1989

1991

1990

55

70

26 1991

43.72

188

25

5.81

16

3.72

2

49

60

140 141 1 2 114

3 _{- Mohamed Bussooumah,"la parenthèse des pouvoirs publics constitutionnels de}

(102)

101 1992

1994

1991

1997

1991



1

- Mohamed Bussooumah, op. cit., p. 22. 125

127 2

(103)

102 

10

156

69

19

11

4

3 1997

2002

1 14

(104)

103 2002

31

1 15 16 2 3 17

(105)

104 1954

1962

1963

1976

1 13 3 2008 <http://forum.law-dz.com/index.php?showtopic=3490> 2

(106)

105

23 1989

1991

11 1992

5 1997

60

18 1994

5 1997

1996

389

196

48

17 1 2

(107)

106

148

149 1

(108)

107 1997

1 154 204 205 2

(109)

108

1 24 8 2008 <http://www.dctcrs.org/s2632.htm> 2 3 11 2 2008

<

http://www.soutalganoub.com/home/modules.php?name=news&file=article&sid=432

>

4

(110)

109 1996

8 2000

1 4 6 2008 <http://www.islamonline.net/arabic/news/2000-11/10/article24.&html> 2 3 4 6 2008 <http://hiedge.org/iol-arabic/dowalia/alhadath2000-mar-31/alhadath5.asp>

(111)

110

17

18

17

30

18

1 17 8 2008 <www.dz.undp.org/.../etude%20relation%20entre%201e%20parlement%20et%20> 2

(112)

111

32

35

35 1992

1 2 3

(113)

112 2003

1989

1 2 3

(114)

113 1996

80

84

133

134

135

136

137 1989

160

161

1 5 6 2008 <http://www.mcrp.gov.dz/ministere-arabe/semlaid-2304 2006.htm> 2 3

(115)

114

133

130 1996

99

134

1 2 3

(116)

115

10 1989

1997

2002

2007

500

351

32

30

87

139

500

703

616

5

82

213 2002

2007

462

21

288

5

43

22

24

11

1

(117)

116

271

231

10

134

30

20 1997

2002

2007

1

(118)

117

15

(119)

118

15

30

1 2

(120)

119

109

110

111

13 5 2008 -1 <http://www.arabparliaments.org/arabic/activities/list-asp?aid=64&tid=3> 2

(121)

120

110 2002

2007

1997

2002

1 2 3

(122)

121

1 2

(123)

122 1989

1 1997 2003 2004 44 2 112 3

(124)

123 1996

1 113 116 117 123 2 3 35

(125)

124

35 1

2

(126)

125

1 1989 2005 2007 2008 96 2 1994 13 3 2005 21

(127)

126

1

37

(128)

127

62

21

105 1 1 24 7 2008 <http://www. Ahewar.org/ debat/show-art.asp?aid=86319>

(129)

128

34 2002

1997

1 1 13 12 2007 <www.hmsalgeria.net/modules.php ?name=news&file=print&sid=612-31k>

(130)

129 1991

1997

2002

1997

1991

188

48

155

199

64

15

38

69

1

34

43

21

4

19

25

19

29

11

01 1991

1997

2002

www.eljazerra.net/in-depth/algeria-election/2002/6/6-5-1.htm-50k

1 1 2006 54

(131)

130 1997

2002

1992

1 -2002 12 7 2008

<

www.aljazeera.net/in-depth/algeria-election/2002/6/6-5-1.htm-50

>

(132)

131

(133)

(134)

(135)

(136)

(137)

(138)

(139)

(140)

139 

1994



2005



1 2002



1 

1997



1 1992



1 2005



2003



2003



2 2005



2 2002

1 1996

(141)

140 

1 2006



1 2001



1 2004



1997



2003



2 2006



2006



2

1 1989



4 2002



1 2007



2 2000

(142)

141 

1 2002



2007



1997

2003

2004



2002



1989

2005

2007

2008



2000



2001

(143)

142 

2002

2003



17 2007



16 2007



13 2006



13 2006



13 2006



Boussooumah Mohamed, la parenthèse des pouvoirs publics

constitutionnels 1992

1998, Algérie : office des publications

universitaires, 2005



Duhamel Olivier, les démocraties, régimes, histoire, exigences,

Paris : édition du seuil, 1993



13 2008

(144)

143 http://www.arabparliaments.org/arabic/activities/list-asp ? aid=64&tid=3>



25

4 2008

http://mengos.net/books/ourbooks/ibnkhaldun/bycountry-a-l/kuwait b.htm>



11

2 2008

http://www.soutalganoub.com/home/modules.php?name=news&file=article

&sid=432>



7

8 2008

http://www.aljazeera.net/nr/exeres/CF97CB16-1547-4cB0-874E-D5466EE9DE78.htm>



9

3 2008

http://www.arabgate.com/more/7/%d8%aa%d9%82%>



22

2 2008

http://www.alummah.online.com/?zpage=systems&system=press

+&press=show&id=11028 *top>



21

2 2008

<www.arabparliament.org/arabic/activitiees/lit-asp aid=10 tid=3-10k>



.

28

2 2008

<http:// www.hrcao.org/conference/2005/papers/10 ali.doc>



27

4 2008

(145)

144 http://www.pogar.org/publications/legislature/salh 1a/section3.htm>



24

06 2007

<http:

www.azzaman.com azz articles 2002 01 01 -17 a99661.htm>



7

2 2008

<http://www.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/ 2 384 E

B6-BC7F-4F88-80d6-2B6486 EE0 A2.htm>



24

2 2008

<http://www.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/c5c859EB-5AA1-4E59-9844-DOE6B196FDEA.htm=0>



16

3 2008

http://alwi7da.org/forums/showthread.php?t=3433>



17 2008

www.dz.undp.org/…/etude%20relation%20entre%20le%20parlement%20et

%20>



4 2008

http://www.islamonline.net/arabic/news/2000-11/10/article24.&html>



24 2008

http://www.dctcrs.org/s2632.htm>

(146)

145 

24 2008

<http://www. Ahewar.org/ debat/show-art.asp?aid=86319>



20

1 2007

http://www.altareekh.com/new/doc/modules.php?name=content&pa=showp

age&pid=1306&comm=0>



13

12 2007

<www.hmsalgeria.net/modules.php ?name=news&file=print&sid=6>



20

11 2008

<http://www.marmarita.com/vb/archive/index.php/t-812.htm1>



5 2008

http://www.mcrp.gov.dz/ministere-arabe/semlaid-2304 2006.htm>



"

14

3 2008

http://www.ahwar.org/debat/show.art.asp ?aid=48370>



27

9 2007

<http:// www.undp-pogar.org/arabic/countries/compare.asp>

(147)

146 

16

12 2007

http:// www.pogar.org/publication/legislature/wahby 1a /-8k



10

2 2008

< http:// www.pogar.org/publication/legislature/wahby 1a/section.htn>



15

2 2008

<http://www.pogar.org/publications/legislature/wahby.1a/section11.html>



13

3 2008

<http://forum.law-dz.com/index.php?showtopic=3490>



4 2008

<http://hiedge.org/iol-arabic/dowalia/alhadeth2000-mai-31/alhadath5.asp>



2002

12 2008

www.aljazeera.net/in-depth/algeria-election/2002/6/6-5-1.htm-50>



14

6 2008

http://www.islamonline.net/arabic/politics/2003/07/article05.html>



22

8 2008

<http://ksm.maktoobblog.com/2944 9%2 D8% A7% D9% 84%D9>

(148)