Unstable and Unsteady Aerodynamics : Compared Information from Different Numerical Models
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Unstable and unsteady aerodynamics : compared information from different numerical models I. Abalakin, M. Braza, S. Camarri, A. Dervieux, B. Koobus, T. Kozubskaya, P. Rodes, M.-V. Salvetti. N° 4077 Novembre 2000. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4077--FR+ENG. THÈME 4. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7) !" # $
(8) %'&()$ *" &+" *,-
(9)
(10) ./
(11) $%0 1'
(12) % 42 35687:9;7:<>=@?BADCFEG3FH"I47KJL7NM4CFOF3FPQ7:RS7:ITIT=@U4C$5V3FWXDI Y=@XDZ>[]\%C H3_^`>`N6BZBacbdC8ef3F^`:JgZ$6Ba4<K7Dh>7iTC_j3Fk1`>lBXDa A*A C!EG3nmpoq3FO7:9rYXtsTsc= MuM vwyx z.{|~} gz"y (pt{ tL z.p( { x%z.{%%tz.y{*g{% _(u{ gDy Ltu { { wy{%wy{:B| ¡} ¢4£t{ z"¤y{Q¥t"} ¥(¦.y§t{% ¨ ©Bª «T¬+y®«¯° {!{ £{ ±²³´{*±S{% {%]D£{%up§(pty] ty {%L y§)µ¶F·@µ§t{¶ y g zy (pt:¸º¹Q»¼¶F½·;»¾§(y { ¶ y ¿gz"y (pt:¸º¹~ ( upT~ÀÁ {% y§ ±0tÂD.±ÃpwÄű!(ÆÅ{ ÇDK(ptSÈ¢¾Éz. {%1 z.y§V(Qy{%K(y§-wytuQp{ zÊz~Æ y4£t{ z.{%³ yup Npt F³´t§tg {%y{%{%( (³{%yp({ ¹gyyup{T Ë 4±%¹: £t£y§£t{*Áwy{ y y§yÌÈ¿³´%y± ¤N{LtNt{ tf»¼¶Fz. {% y§ Épwy{1y{³±0! T±%ÌÁ¶8Lz.y{%± ! ty {%Í£t{*qwL{ y y§Î¤N{%wy { ¼( ³´ %¹ Kz."p$³Bz"yÃpÏÆŤN Á u³´t@ÌvwL ¾y{ { ÏÆ T({ ]{%{${%{%(pwy{)g T f³$pwy{¢Ð8Ѿ¥tt.z.yzÒt§(y { wywLtyty Ì ÓBç ÔÖÔÖÕ Õ¼èyÕ~é8×(×+Õ¼ÝpØÚê*Ù+ëÛ@ìTÜÙcÝpëBÞ Ý0í:î@Û@â*ßïÃànë×4Û;á ÛÖÝ+ë×+ÙcîÕ¾ð$â Û;à(ãäñTââ*å]Ù+×4ònÝ+æ>×cÙ+ócÛ;ôuÛ@á%ØnÝ õ*õ!éâ ÙcòÚâ Ù+Û@ë*×cècîöݺì(ãäë ÷ÿ Ôø æìc>Ønê*Ô ëFî;Û@×(ØÚýºù´Þõ õºâºáïKæ>íKØnâ*Û;ÙcÝcù@×4ë ú$4ØnëÝÛ ðdDÝ*Ù+î@ãuÙ(ØÚÛÖâ â(òÚë×4Ûuû*× ücôpíLýºüFà *í:ó+Øn×4Û;Ýcõ*×cü Ôþ ùöõ ݺý0ònÞ ñTâ cØnÝ ì%ù@Ø (â òÚØ Ûu×cè+î;Ý*ì+ãäë ÔÖø Õ ìcØnÕ~ê*ë×(î;Õ¼Û@ØÚù´ØÚÞÙ+Û@âºÜï:ÝpÞ Õ¾Ý0â*Û@ì%ßù àn×4ëuá ònÝ+ØÚ×+ëî>Õ¾ÔÖâ ÔÅÛ;×ãäð>âå]ð$à×4õ æ>ûcÙ+ô*×4Û;Û@óºØná%Ý õ û!Õ¾â*ì%ù (ëòÚnØÚëî×(ݺì Ô æ>Ô F×+ècîöݺì(ãäë Óöç´ÓBç ÔÖø Õ¼ìcèyØnê*é8ëî;×+Û@ÝpØÚù´ê*ÞëìTâºÙcïKëBíKí:ØnÛ;î@Ýcâ*×4ïÃú$ëÛ;ØnÛÖÝëÙcðdîÝ*ð$î@Ù(à(ÛÖñTâ(â*×4Ù+û*ònücÝ+ôp×cýºócüFôuá%í:õ*Ønõ!Û;Ýcé×câ ÔþùöÙcݺòÚònâ Þ Ù+Û@ë*×cècîöݺì(ãäë . . . .
(13). . . . .
(14).
(15). .
(16). . . . . Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(17) ¥
(18) !" #$ %&'()+*%,-*. /0123544 6.87:9;35466.7
(19) <= >?8@46A*7B&C DEF G, *H IKJLNMO+P ¬ Q$ª¯ Ë y ¹>py¤yy{%y {¹ §t{Q{ L t¹t§ty{ { y t¹u( upT]z. Æ {% y§y¹K tz.y{ ¤y{¹ RKyÃp{¼£t yz.{ . Ô æ>Ô . .
(20) '
(21) %) *
(22)
(23) % *")
(24) %'&+$ ¼ /0 #)
(25) /' , $
(26) Q/ 1
(27) 1 B '
(28) ª
(29) ¯ »¾ K{¡{ { £y{ÎÇDy{ ÇDy{ £t{ §+pty{% µ¶F¹»¼¶F²{ {% z1 p( Vu( upÇDy{Á· { g ÇDK+pty¸{% L y{ {%¼yt§tx% %tyu_p{%z.{ { _tLp! yup { !tL] y pt y {¤yy{%F% Ãpty {% %tL { z1{ p L+ptyK{ pw %¹:T£t{ {% wy{ {ty¤y ty%Ì y{ ({%pt¡ % {"{% {~fz. p( tL¼»¼¶FÁ{ n Ly T+pt { t {~Kt%Ì)µ>{%¼{*g{ z1L { )LtNt ¼%tL%{%y{% {% wL{%z.{%p {"ty¤y ty Lpy t¤yu { ÇDy{ { {~L RK Ú { %¹ { wy{%z.{ D gy+Æ z1ÇDy{%~Lpy {y RK"z"LÃÆö%ty%Ì0 {KL { "{%u f ]{%{{% { g T 0 t ÇDy{)¢Ð8Ѿ¥ttQt§y {%Áwyyy{%L%Ì P «cª M ® ªq¯ Ë y {¹py¤yy{%y {¹]§t { upL pL{% ¹8y*py{%~§L {% ¹ z1 p( Áu( upÇL{¹:%tz.y{%¤y {(¹N£tyz.{%2Ryy .
(30) |(
(31) !" #$ %&'()+*%,-*. /0123544 6.87:9;35466.7
(32) <= >?8@46A*7B&C DEF G, *H .1F vwy{~y{ { ¾¡ zy +ptÎ ¡{%tKL ¾%y%{ Îy%{T y§Áz.t{y{ *pty ³Fyyp¤y{( yy{T -ywy{%Ltz.{%KLÌQvwL ){% (p{ pwy{.up ¡³0 §t{% ¹ z1{ %tzQ³´tu¤L {(¹N{%y u %(³rp Ì0vwy{ fDyz.{% %$z. {%wytL 4± §tg { y{ {%p(ptͳ0{ Kp+p{ ¹Byyup{% Ë 4±%¹8£ttã L§f£ttup{ºVwy{ y y§yÌ È¼pwy{.p(z1{Q z.{¹Ã)yN{T¼pwK(pwy{.T( y +ptq(³! tz.y{*Vyyup{% Ë 4± £t£y§"pwL{y{ ³d£t {%!³z.{ yz {!yt§t{%£{%à Lp ( à {T(wK¤y{)±ÃpwÁT£( ¤y{ z.{%wL{%%¹N³Ö(y¤Ly { y%{)z. {%( 4± ÃTÌ öp Tyy {%±wL{ pwL{%y( { z"y (pt ·ÖѾ¢¾L¸± ¤{ t Æ ¤y{"fpwy{y{*¾{%f{T³´tywÎL{ *pty%Ì Åy{T ¹dz(D{%wyyÇDy{%){ p { ³´t]pwy{z. { y§~(³>tz.{³´{T(y{ 0³)§tãt{%y¤Ly { Ë 4± ±wy {tz.{ pwy{ {¼y{ *p{ Ì @*< N4 A 7 , * F* A ,-*%C H 4
(33) *7 # 46A* 7·@Ⱦ¢¾L¸_ y { _pwy{y{ t1³ z1{% Ë 4± Ì8vwy{*QTQ tz"¤L y{¾(pwy{ ]{TuQ y{ºLN{%Lãt{T%y ( tQ±Ãpw1 p(wy{%%z1L {ºfz. {%y§y¹KD£tãgy§³´{ºLz.y ${ H Ë7 4 %H* 6.' H -4 70³´ÇDK(gÆ pÃp{%{ +p{ ~pwy{¼{ y{%§ ~pwy{ Ry{%¤N{ ű!{%{% y*pK( y T£t{ p§t{(Ì È'z1NtuL¤y{*(³BȾ¢{ {%t~pL¤yy{%£%ÃÅ'pwK({ y%{ wy{ { {% £{¡{ yt .Dyz"¤N{%³pwy{%z1LL( ¹0ÖÌÚ{(ÌÄpwy{ .# * :@ *< N4 A 7 .F#$*f·Öó"Dyz.{ T up RK% £ tÃÅ y± y§ {Îy{%§ { p{ ¸*¹¾ pwyz1Â{ pwy{¾ tz.yLp(pt'Nt ¤y{¹y±Ãpw 4 z.{ pwL ¹yz.{%wy{% tz~Æ yLp{ Ì 4±0{*£t{ %¹gÈ¢¾~ ¹D¤{*³´t{Ö¹tpwy{ Ë t{*pT {% §tL{ ¼y y {p{% QDyz.{ uÆ %dtgpyL y(pQy y%{ 4±£ttã y§1yyup{% y{%%¹:ywN{% py y{ %¹:typ¤y Ãp{% Ì ! F* ?AA < #5. H -4 ·@µ¶Fy¸º¹¼ ±wyw tyÿ §{ T{ z.ptG ÏÆ {%*pà z"y ({ ¹wK(y y%{ ³´z ¤N{%§ yL y§qz1 %tz.yLp(pty.pwy( ±0{ {.z"ywVz.t{.(%%Lp({~pwKVȾ¢Ì c±!{ £{% ¹$à { z( y)£{%¡{*g{ yãt{ z1{*pwy Ì Å {%{ ¹D§tg { yÃpF{y L%{ tyÃ~¤+ Ryy{z.{%wL{%%¹%{ Nt y§ p{*gLt ¾Dyz"¤N{%¾yz"ywfwy §wy{%pwKpwy{" d{ ¤L { ±wÎѾ¢Ì ÅgÆ £{%Ãt¹8Ã~{%{%z."wK("Á§t µ¶FVup qy{ { "f{%£{pwL{z1Épy¤yy{% py y{ %¹t -wy{%¼{%z. ¹$Ã)TyL¼±0¡±wy{ qtL- z.Ãp{ Dyz"¤N{%)³ . . . . . .
(34). . . . . . . . . . . Ô æ>Ô . .
(35) E7H-6 &* A .7H * A < * 46A <0 #5 7 # 46A* G . . p(wy{%t§y{ upy y{ ¾{¼tãt{ Ì ÀÁ-({%z.L)wy4£{¤N{%{ ty{. { ty{QVwy{ Ð8Ñ%tz.zyyÃÅγ´t 4 #$6 H * A , H F*7 4 @ 2 A ::Ì ÆÈ¢¾DÆŵ¶F~t]Ѷ! 0tz"¤yyy§È¢¾Q µ¶F~ ]{ ³´{%{ _Ⱦ¢DÆ䵶F ¤DÉgN{ ( {f· þ¸¼±wLfyt{ ÉÈ §{%¤y { yt QDp{ ~ÀÁ {%_±wÍ yt§{%ãt{.±Ãpw-pÑ¢¾¡¤f±!{%§twpy§wy{~pL¤yy{%){ yt { ¡wy{ {%ÇDK( tL%Ì Åwy{¾±0Â'³8gK u+ *H? ¹KQ z. yLw{ ³´{ { (Ѿ¶F¹NÑ{ pwy{ ¶ L gz"y ( td¹0 {% { .t {*p{ yt²(³wy{ÁgK uÆÅÈ z1p(~z. { · | þ¸*Ì gwL { p{ *H · þ¸~wKT£t{VytNt{ tz.{ %{ (Æp¹!tL{*Æ Å±!(Æ {%ÇDK( tz. {%pwy {%*ptÌ Æ仼¶! ÅSpwy{¡»¼§yË { ¶ y gz"y (pt (yytw · Ú¥t¥ r¸º¹pwy{z. { y§ ³´%L{ Îp y§ c± ±wy{ {.ÇDKÃÆö{ ~upy y{ z1K({%wy{ yy{T ¤{ wKT£gty Ì vwy{¾ywK({ T£t{ p§ty§· T| Ë ;¹ G%6 A r¸"(³yw Ë 4± ± dwy{%'y y%{¼·rpwy{ t{*pÏÆ TL¸N{%³´{ N{% 4±¿{ y y y§.±ÃpwÁ% yp*'pwy{)¤N4£t{ y*py{Ì vwy{0Ⱦ¢DÆ䵶F)$Ѷ!)yywwKpwy{! £((§t{_³KLyy§¾z.t{FywyuÆ pT({ z1 { pfµ¶FDÆö Â{yyw¹K¤LLz1T ywL{%Ãtz.{ p £(p§t{ ³¤Npwz.{ pwL ¹gtz.{p{%z.{ (p{pL§t{¹y%{pwy{µ¶!.z.{%wKL z {%{%z. y{ *pãt{tyÃ'±wy{%pwy{)Dyz.{%T( Ë c± (wy§twf{ y Dyz"¤N{% pyäÆ ¤yy{%T¹K±wy {)Ⱦ¢y (Lp{ 1§L { py y{ %Ì ö ¼%{T(¾³´t¾y¾wK(¼z1¡p{ {%upy§tLpLLp¼%-¤{Q{ºLN{%*p{ ³´tz wy{ 4 #$6 H -4 4 : A ::¹!±Ãpw {%z.ywy't pwL{Î{%{%*pt ³q³´{ ± t§(y { tz.Kpy y{ %¹:pwK+ ¹:±ÃpwÁQp( 1¤N{ ű!{%{%ÁywT$ DgÆ z1{ T!{ yt ~Dyz¤{ "z"LwÄwy §wy{%)pwKÉ q{*g upy§-Ⱦ¢¾Æ䵶FqtѾ¶FÌ ° w .# * !@*< N4 A 7( .F#$*±!{"p{% pwy{"{*yt Dyz¤{ ±wyw¡%täÆ {% pwL{"§tt¤K>£%ÃÅÎ{*gpy§'Áwy{~Dyz.{% %Bz. {%Ö¹ y{"p¤(pw py¤yy{%y {z. {% (p RK >LD± Ì vwL ( Nt 1± Ö¹wytN{ ³´y¹ 4±/Í L { Lp (yt¤y{%z.%¹ ±wy wVywT_{ y ¼Dyz¤{ ¼§t{ y{%f³_pwy{Qt {%³F{ £{%]z. ty ¹ . . . . . . . . .
(36) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ææ ì Lá%õ . . . . . .
(37)
(38) !" #$ %&'()+*%,-*. /0123544 6.87:9;35466.7
(39) <= >?8@46A*7B&C DEF G, *H. Q±wyw1wy{§t{ tz.{ puQ]p(wy{%] tz.y {º¹g( pwDy_³rű0{]³r{%.³NyyupL*Æ py{ ÅgN{¹y±ÃpwfQ §t{ z.ty³$Dyz.{%T(£ tÃÅtÌ »¼L±0t± dwy{%³´%ytywf~ÅN{)(³$Dyz.{ T>p{ wyytt§¹K £t£y§ K y ±( 4±³´tȾ¢z. {%y§yÌ !LF¤{*³´t{¤yL y§~»¼¶FDÆ䵶F.yyw¹±!{wKT£{(KÃg{ ³´{*± Ãpy+Æ pty!±wL{%{¾wy{%{¾z. {% Dyz.{% %z.{ wy wLty ¤{ z.yc£{ 't { p.¤(pwyyÃ'Á¤N{ p{ t Ãptypwy( £{% Ì »¾yyt§tz.z1{¾³´%tz¤y L y§»¼¶! µ¶F'wy{%Á £t£{% ·´È¼¸ {%pórÁ y{ºg{ yãt{.Ⱦ¢Áz. { pwK+±!ty y y {"y{ y¾³ £ttup%{% { K(pt'±w¡ %{ L¤L {% yp( tÌ · ¸ {%pór ±wyw % Ãptyu µ¶! z.{ pwL 1T(²¤N{Á tyy{ ±wfȾ¢z. {% t {%p1¤N{¼y{ D Lp (>Lz1{ T { %Ì ·¸È g ({ºg{% Ⱦ¢Ápwy{~T( y +ptγF% ¾³_ §t{"{ y {% ¹³´tÏÆ 4±y§1wy{»¼¶!'z.{ wy t §tÌ . . . . . . H &7( = * H &* 7. * 4 .87(H 4 A* A H * H &7 4
(40) 5H 45> -*% * >*%-* 9
(41) <84 .?> -*%* 4 +H *5#$ < # 77-4 A &7 .77-4 754 .FH .F A 7 .F# *% 7- 6.FH 74 G =.&7H 7 A H * H . * H H#$
(42) * ) 4 =*77 @4 # * 4 H *7 A * * H?*/ *%-* *
(43) . .
(44). . . .
(45). . .
(46). . . . . . . . . . . . . '
(47) #Î
(48) "
(49) &+)Ò
(50) # B¼
(51) vwy{ yyNt{¼³$wy{%*ptÁp { z.typ({¼pwK(~£{%wy{TÁ u È¢¾z. {%Ö¹+³rp{%1³´{*±¿£t{ Á §twz1 RKT+pty%¹Tf¤{ %tz.{~1p(wy{%y{ºÆ *pãt{)z. { >³${ £{%>ÅgN{%³${ Kp+p{ Ë 4±%Ì ° {)wK( %y%{ Dp({~t Qz. {%¾( z.t{y{% {%Ãftű0p(wy{%y{*DÆ { yãt{)¤y u'z. {% . . . . . . . . ! . Ô æ>Ô . .
(52) E7H-6 &* A .7H * A < * 46A <0 #5 7 # 46A* G . . Æ_wy{){ wy ±0 T± ¹ Æ_wy{¼Å±0+ÆÅ 4{% 0wy{%ÆäB+p{%z. {%ÖÌ ( ¼pwy{ L+ptQp¼pwy{ { ¾z. {%_³¼ z.Ã( 1 wy{py¤yy{% £g tÃÅ y{¼pÀÁ{ p{% Ì . . .
(53) . vwy{f% y (pt²(³¼Vy¤Ly { ¤Nty ( 4{%1z { 1%L¤D wy{Áup ¤{ wKT£gt(³%ty{£( ¤y{% Ì öp(wy{%F±0{ %{ Lp{ pwK(0y{T(0pwy{±Ö¹Lty{ºÆ {%ÇDK( tÁz. { { z.t{t¤yyu¾ z"LwÎwy{TN{%Nwyz1 {yy tz.{ z1 { F Â{pwy{gK( uÆöÈ z1_ty{¹t]pwL{ű!(ÆÅ Tt{ 0wy{ gÆä$(p{ ¼z. { ·
(54) !~¸ºÌ ° {.wK8y{Qpwy{Q ({%¼Îpwy{Q{%ÇDy{%Ö¹ V£t{ t-³´yÎ tz.K( ¤y{ ±wwy{ %tz.y{% ¤L { t§tÃpwyz. T± ¹: { RKy{ 4¦ ( Ú¥ @Ì ÐBÑS{%L§t L{%{%B{% wy{%{FpwL{! {Tpwy($wy{F{ t³´tyLy§¾È¢¾ z1 { !p¡ Ë 4± T%y ( tÄ { { {%z.y{ ¤Éwy{Dyz¤{ Q³%tL{ {%ÇDK( tL%Ì ° { y(0(§t{ {wy%Ì Åyup{% ¹D±0{%tL {%_pwK+Fwy{z1 1%! _{ºÆ ({ Qz.{%w1§{%y{ p( td¹pwK+8z. {%8 £t£y§¼±( y T±%¹tóNy{ pãt{{ yty§w¹ { ³Ö( 0z.ty§"wy{z.tu{ 1 { Dy{% Ì ° { {%%¤N{¼y4± pwy{¼{%wK 0±0 T±· " !¸*Ì µ{*$ #&%')(%ΤN{¼ytgÆ z1{ ytK(ypz.{*p{% { RKL{ (³´ 4± · c¸ # %+* #-# , ' ·@¥t¸ ( %.*0/ #-, (32 1 ±wyw #"¹ / ¹ 1 ( ({-T£t{ p§t{Îpy§t{ D (£t{ %ÃÅt¹ { yÃÅt¹z1 { %y £g tÃÅq ytz( (y%{.ppwy{Q±0]{%{ £{%ÃtÌvwy{.£t{ %ÃÅ4 #-,¹ T { ³´ *pt£t{%%ÃÅt¹: { RKy{ #-, *65 7 8 2 · ¸ vwy{){ wK( ±0 ÏÆÅ T± ·Ö{%{ {Ì §yÌ n¥(¦ ;¹ $/ ¸ 4±p1%tyL{% wy{ z.KL¤gÆ Tt{ Ë 4±¿±Ãpwfwy{) t§tÃpwyz. ty{³8pwL{¤Nty 4{% Ì öT(¡¤{ ±Ã{% . . . . . . . . . . . . ææ ì Lá%õ . . . . .
(55)
(56) !" #$ %&'()+*%,-*. /0123544 6.87:9;35466.7
(57) <= >?8@46A*7B&C DEF G, *H. ³´t 4±. . ( %
(58) 2 ( % ! ""$# &% 2 ·´|D¸ ±wyw pwy{('t z.t§t4£' typTÌ vwy ±ÏÆÅ 4± Lp¤y{fp {% ¤{¡wy{ Ë c±Ò³´t y%z1L{%¤y{V¤Nty Æ f Tt{ $ %-¤{.{%z.y4t{ pup - §twpÃÎ tz.y{ ¤y{¤Nty f Tt{ ±wytLyL{% (¤y {){%t%Ì {%wK "±0ÃÆö T±½wy)wy{ £(§{³ {%% ¤yy§¡y%{.³´t)_wy{.pwy{%{ ÅgN{%³]¤N{%wKT£t³Bpwy{)py¤yy{%¼¤Nty ( 4{% ¹£ (¹wy{" z. y Tt{ %¹wy{ t§tÃpwyz.y{"( pwL{p{%z.{ (p{" Tt{ %¹:pwK+§t{ y{%y { % ¤N{ yK(±> 4± Ì # % *. . . . +) *,* -*/. 0. 21 23 2453 67*98:
(59) .;80* < Å1¤Nw1vµ Ä ±0K T±²z1 { ¹D±!{T1LyQ Lp(ptQ³Npwy{ * H * 4 * H -4 t @¹B±wywÄ Ly{ ¤D-wy{tL{*ÆÅ{ ÇDK(ptÄz. {%_³>=twLytÍ ' y§ ±wL wwy{y¤yL { D0{%0p{ y 0yz.{ "¤N{ytptK(ypwy{ py¤yy{%)Ây{*p1{ y{%§ÎÎpwy{Qt§wyz. Q{%§tt-³_pwL{~py¤yy{%)¤tL u Tt{ %Ì ÅL à { £{%t{ ³´t.¤N{%y§qy{%{ pwy{ @? z. {%³ ° %T¹ pwy{ÀÁ{ D{%%t{ ptÁ{ { RKy{ wy{¼py¤yy{%£ tÃÅft { p.p( u³r'pwy ytNtuptKÅÌ Àt{L{% {%Ãt¹_pwy~z. {%!{%{%QtÉwy{ 0 wKT± {% (ptɱwyw { Ryy{% pwy* {£( (pt(³>pwy{p{%0p{ yt0)³´yy ³´t_pwy{y¤Ly { ÂD y{*p¾{%L{%§( 7 /BA ±wy{ { A Q typTÌ ] L ptDC K( FE p{ z.±Ãp{ C * 1
(60) G IH J( %LK { ME * / H αwywNC * E ±wy{ y{ £{%~'g%8{ ÇL ¤Lyz wyt %Ì1Dupy§'³´tz pwy{ { RLÆ y (³$wy{ Tpy¤yy{%wy{T(up{%§tãt{ Á¤'pwL{ !ty L{%Ç(Lz1gpt . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ô æ>Ô . .
(61) E7H-6 &* A .7H * A < * 46A <0 #5 7 # 46A* G . ¦ . (¡ ³´tz wy{ { RKyÃptγ]pwL{pL¤yy{%¼£%ÃÅ 1
(62) G * / ¹
(63) G & H J H K ±0{ T(Á{*Æö±{¼pwy{¼pL¤yy{%{%{%yt³´t 4± 5 C * 7 / E !~ {% RK%(pt¹D±!{ {%ãt{¾£(y{³´tBwy{%tyu A ¹D{%ÇDKgp 1wy{T({ ³]1 T{ ÇL ¤LyzÌ y§pwL{ 0 wy4±G(Lz1gpt¹>À{%p{ { { Ryy{%wy{ py¤yy{%£ tÃų´t 4± 7 * 1. . . . . . . · t¸ '
(64) H&J( % H ±w * A ' * ( '
(65) ( 1 ! " K / K vwL{)ÀÁ{%p{ z. { ]· t¸!c±!p~ t{% wy{y¤yL { D0£g tÃűwy{ 'pwy{ {.
(66) G. /. 1 *. . . . . . .¡g%0LtgÆÅ{ ÇDy ¤yyz ¤N{ ű!{%{ y¤yL { y%{y y*pt C K(pt EfÌ ° wy{% wy{f§t {%'³pwy{Áytz1£t{ %ÃÅ ¤N{% tz.{%±!{TÂ({% ¹ÖÌÚ{(Ì tg³¾wy{ ¤tL u' T{%%¹y±!{){% 4£t{%pwL{)LKy¤Ly { £%ÃÅtÌ vwL{q L t ³· t¸1pÄwy{Îvµ z. { ¾ ty{¹% t y§Ä 4¦ ;¹ ³´t 4± 5 * / · ¸ 1 G * # %A $ '& )( ' H&J( % *,+ H ±w 5 * -& . ( *0/ /54 ' / * 8:93;1<1 =; #
(67) ' 7> ' >. 3 9 2 *1+ #76 * *1+ ±wy{%{ / F¼±!{%§twpy§%{ 1%{% ·´{ { 4¦ L³´t { p ¸ wy{%t{ pt.³´yy*pty * { *1{ +RKy{ { ¤{ RK L{ * y K( Ã@"¡?BA f(fpÌ wL{0wy{ gÆä$(p{ Bz. {%Ö¹ pwy{ { y§pwÎT{ # # . . . . . . . . . . ææ ì Lá%õ . .
(68) 4 . %
(69) B !" #$ %%& F)+*%,-*.0/0 23544 6.7 9;35466.'7
(70) < > @46A*7&C D; G, *. 2*9: 8 . 1 * 1 9* L* . * 8 <78 ° {RK %Lwy{¤y ÃÅ'³ "z. { Áy{ L§{ K(p{ Ë 4±yw .u( uy Á u³´tyz.t{ { p T¤N{ ³´y ;Ì ° {%tL {%F wy §w1ór!¥Ñ Lt¤y{%z Dpwy{§t{ tz.{ QF¼Å±!(Æö¤ .¢µ t ±0%tL {%{ {*gN{% z.{%¤£( {% 0{ § t ;Ì]vwL{{ y Dyz~Æ ¤{ 2 2 wy{ÀfwÍDyz¤{ " 2 ÌÈ {% { ~³y§t{%)³+( ±0{ { Â({%³´tz { §yÌ8p { §yÌ vwy{¼T{¼ ±!{%ÂDy4±"p{ %{¼³(¶_LtN{Ty(u{%* n¥ @Ì0{%{ Ú¥ ³´t {% {% T( y +ptÌÑ up ¤ygpty ³ 8 {~4£( ¤y{¹dt§t{ wy{%¾±Ãpw¡wy{Q³r%¹ wy ! órwy4±upy§~p(pu³´0L§t { 0³+(Â1¤L §t§{%!wK { §yÌ È%% y§Á{*g{ z.{%Fz.{Ty{ z.{%p ¹]q¤y p³LÌÚ '{ % RK{ ³´t pwy{ wL³r³´z z. K(Qpy¤yy{%¤(pwz1 { Ì È tz.z1Éz.{%wÉy{ ³´t ¤wqz. {%%ÌvwyNt¤y {1y {pwL{.±0 T±/z. {%0{%{%1t ²(Kà Tt{%Qwy ÂDy{ fpwK(..y{ ¤{ ¤Äy{% y pwyty§tw-pwL{1wy ÂDy{ ~(³!wy${ Ryz.{%wÉ4± Ì ÅVwy{{%ÇDy{ @¹±0{wKT£t{ t¤y{ £{ wK(¤N{%{%L±!{%{)¤Ly{ ±Ãpw * 2 Ì ÐKt!pwy ³ Ë 4± ¹ypwy + RK§y{¾³´tLpz1{ z1 { wK'pwL{¼ty{%y{ ³´t!z1(wyy§~±wpwy{z1 y {¾³>wy+{ &4 { §t ¹y ±0{ ({wDyz1(pwL y§Qy z1 { wy{ yyN{%{ §t (³BpwL{ 6. * 4 N**Ì ° {¾y4± Lz1z1 {¼pwy{¾z.(D0{ z(ÂDpwK+ {¾³´tz½pwL{¾%tz.K(t ³Bvµ {%wK T± ±Ãpw{ N{%*1wy{ p dy{ *pt Æ!pwL{"vµ (y{%y¾¤y{py{ ¾wy{"u${ºg%{%gpóFwy{QÀ{%p{ ¾%täÆ {%*pt yL { ¹K{%{) ÁÐB§yÌ )QÂ{*pw¡(³$wy ÅN{³$T( y +pt Ú¥ @Ì ÆFwy{"µÍy({ wy{%¤y{)y{ pwL{u N%z"¤yyy§pwL{~ÀÁ{ p{%%täÆ {%*ptVT{%)tz.{. z.y4£t{%z.{ D%¹8¤yy y)1 { D)³´t ¹¤Lyy§Á§g . . . . . . . . . . . .
(71) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ô æ>Ô . .
(72) E7H-6 &* A .7H * A < * 46A <0 #5 7 # 46A* G . . ( L§t {¼L{ *pt @Ì 0{T(Ãt¹(wy{]{ £t{ D³gy¤Ly { $£%ÃÅt¹t( tpt { ¤¾pwL{0À{%p{ Å z.{% y T1 y t {)wy{"(¤y ÃųBwy{¼Å±0z1 { Ì 0wÁz. {%±¤N{ y{ wy{ { ÇL{%³´t Ë 4± ±ÃpwytLtyy { Ly{T y{ %Ì . . NLR_13.1. NLR_16.1. mach, min = 0, max = 0.766412. mach, min = 0, max = 0.476184. ÐB §y{. * A H -4 4 @ 4 H 4 C <* # 64 A* A * H * 4 %* H -4 = &* 4 H H
(73) 4 &* %H H . * &7
(74) 8 A 4 H 4 .F%H *7< 4 ! *7 H H 4 .
(75). . . . . . . .
(76). . . . . . . . . . . >8 <5. 8 873 M: < 9* & v$.{*Lz.y{ pË wy{¼yLp{% ¤N{%wKT£t³$wy{ %tL {%{ z. {%%¹y±!{ wyt{)Q{ *Æ t ÅyT( c±Ò{ºg{ z1{ p{ ¤Sµ *H · n¥ r¸º¹0S±wyw²pwL{¡{ yt Lz"¤N{% '
(77) Ì]vwy{ Ë 4± tz. K+p{ ¤1z1Çy$¥Ñ t§ty{ { y ³£t')(z1ÉÅN{ÌfvwL ~%{ {T(wK¤y{±wÄȾ¢¾V ¥(Ñ tÑ ±wfµ¶Fq·´ tѼ¸ºÌ . . . ææ ì Lá%õ . .
(78) c¥%
(79) B !" #$ %%& . F)+*%,-*.0/0 23544 6.7 9;35466.'7
(80) < > @46A*7&C D; G, *. Å c ;¹8Ã~wy~¤N{%{%Äwy4±ÍpwK+"pwL{ ~z. { @¹B%tz¤y L{ ±wÍpwy{{ºÆ wK( ± T± ¹y y%{ q(pwL{%1§tg y{ *pt ³pwy{Áyyup{T L{% ¹ ¤wÁ¥Ñ · ¦ y {%¸ tÑ T( y +pty·Ö| (|Qy {%p¸*Ì 0D£{%{%Ãt¹ T¦ @¹%tz.yg( tL¾wy4±!{ pwy(wy{ ¾z. {%Ö¹d%z"¤yy{ ±wpwy{¼vµ S¤Nty 1p{T(z.{%T¹ yy y {¼"£( y¤y{¾y{ pt³ pwy{¼£tp{ºwL{ y y§1pz1{ typp Ì ° wy{% pwy{ÁÀÁ{ p{%1%{ t 1p L%{ ¹!pwL{{%y §y RyTpà z1L4£t{ ¤N{% tz.{³0%tz.K(p¤y{% yp*t¹8óy("¤N{ p{% ¹wKVpwy{ uÆä{%wK T%y ( tdÌ '
(81) *
(82) Ê) Q % "'# % vwy{¡D y*pt ³Íµ¶F²z1 { y ¾Ly T+pty'{T Í{*£t{% yt¤L { z1 Æ0£t{ RKy{ tÑ z.{ wy{ z( ä{*gy%ÃÆÅÂ{ "pz.{~{%y¼({~y(¾Nt ¤y{ ³´t{% tytz.T>{Tty%¹ ÆFz.tu( yup Dyz.{% ³´ tz.y{ ¤y{ Ë c±{ºLwL ¤yÃytN{%äÆ p{%³]Ngt tz.K( ¤yűw¡µ¶F :Dyz.{%T(£%Ãp{%%¹pz1{ K+pt¡³ z.y z.{ £(y y§L¹ Æ]³B ty{¼Ã y(t¤y{ Q{ tãt{ pwy{¼¤Nty T{%%¹ y{¼p~pwL{¾£t{%u wy §wÁ{ y Dyz"¤N{% Ì Å ;¹·Ö{%{Î( ¾( c¥ þ¸*¹Ãwy4± wK(¤Nw²pwy{Îgz1§tt y z1 { ( wy{ gyz. { z1yqz1 { %²¤N{y %{%³´yà (Lp{ pÉ yyy*py{ ¹g z.y%Ãy± Ð8Ñ {¤.pwy{%yy y§³wy{%{z. {%F±Ãpw pwy{Q(¤4£t{~{ wK( ¾±0B T± ¹%tz¤yy{ ±Ãpw-T({ ³´L$p{T(z.{% yyy§ ³$wy{ Dyz.{%T( K(ptÌ vwy _] yp({ §.t~pwL{ 4±Æä{ y _Çy{ {% Ë 4±²±wL w1 ]Lc± %tz.yL{ ±ÃpwÎpwy{"y{ {%µ¶Ffz1{*pwy ±wVη tѾ¸z.{%wV³ 4L¹nty {% Ì È {TQ³pwy{)gz1§tyÂ'y¤gÆö§t T( {¼£ %tŧtãt{%ÁÐ$ §yÌn¥gÌ ° {¼§tãt{ .v$¤y{ ¾³´{*±²¤yL Â~Lpygp_t¤Lp L{ . §{*ÆÅ{ y Q zy (pty]±Ãpw {%{% . . . . .
(83) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ô æ>Ô . .
(84) E7H-6 &* A .7H * A < * 46A <0 #5 7 # 46A* G . . &('()*+,.&(/1024365#7489 &('()*+,.&(/1024365#7489 &('()*+,.<=?>@ACB D 74E.FHG#I &('()* D 74E.FHG!#I ^`_badcbef hgOijc1kl.mf. vB¤L { . . . . . . G. . #"$!%.
(85) !. ;:. ;:. . 1"$. !. %. J*KMLON KMPL. KMLQON RKTS.U. RKMVVONXWYKTSS. KRZPON KTWS. KMPVVON KR\[. KMUONXWYKMU. . . . . KRZL.]N KR];L. RKTWYNXWYKMQ. . . . . !. ". .F
(86) 4*on -* H7 4 H *K7 6.' * <0 GA*H *7H 7* 4 # &74 4 : A+@? .F H -4 7 @ * A H : 4 H 4 C <8*5 * C->? H * H * H * 4 % * H -4 H */ *%# * H A H- A H $4 H * 7#5. H -4 7 A*7 % * A H *( GH * H . *6 . . . . . . ææ ì Lá%õ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(87). . .
(88). . . . . .
(89) T|(%
(90) B !" #$ %%& F)+*%,-*.0/0 23544 6.7 9;35466.'7
(91) < > @46A*7&C D; G, * ¤tL u t Ãpty ¹ tz1" { §t %Ì$vwy{%{§tt¤KDK(pz.{ {%8{0ÇDyÃp{ ±0{ !{%L y%{ Íy~µ¶F $wy{z1+gz"yz{%t"Ípwy{ptywK!Dyz"¤N{%~ ³ / wK(tpwy{ p§1%{ 1 { D¾ yyTLz1(p{ ÌÈGp+p³Ö*ptu §t{ {%z.{%0wK! "¤N{%{ t¤Lp L{ ³´t]wy{{%% y (pt{%y§(pw¹D±wyw'yN{T{ pV¤{ÁV ÃpTK(pz.{ {%1 y{ £ yµ¶F ¦ È¢¾ @̲vwL 1{ yÃp . . . . . . rapp. 39 35 31 27 23 19 15 11 7 3. ÐB §y{¥. : .F H -4 4 4 4 .FABK7 6. * < GA* H -4B*H ** H * #$ F4 %7
(92) <5,&7 47H < A H * 8 7 ,&7 47H < F* $ H 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . {%{ z Á£( (p{1pwy{%tyL y§¡³¡µ¶!Vz1 { F±ÃpwÄÁÈ¢¾V±0! T± Ìfvwy %ty Lt- ¾wLc±!{ £{% z.Ãp{ ¤Å±0{%z1ÂD wy{ %tu¾ {T fwL §twd¹ wy ±0ÂDp Ttyó´t{*yt ¾Dyz"¤N{%pwK(p+pwy{ c± N³´ywy{% ¹ pwy{{ £t{ ³py¤yy{%£ tÃÅ ·@ÐB§yÌn¥t¸ yp({%.pwy{'³ÖË *QpwK+Q±0{{z.t{ t~{%. tz.yLpy§S·ÖL~£t{ %y(p{ L¸~ { ÇL£({% 4± ±Ãpw -{ yt Lz"¤N{%|~pz1{ §t{%wy{ ywg %{*yt Dyz¤{ %Ì ö wy{%D{%{% L§pQ ty { . tyyy§. '±wywÁwy{ È¢¾DÆ;Å{¼z. {% . . Ô æ>Ô . .
(93) E7H-6 &* A .7H * A < * 46A <0 #5 7 # 46A* G . . yy { - §t{%Ku¾³_pwL{ Ë 4± ¹d±wyw-z.{Ty¾wK(±0{QwKT£{"p'{ºg{% wy{ TK(¤y Ãp{%_³dÈ¢¾DÆ;ÅgN{z. { ]c±0 _yy{T Ë 4±F±Ãpw. §{t§(y { py y{ %Ì 1 y&+$ ½) % 1'
(94) % % * 23 I8. vwy{(p{% g³È¢¾DÆ;Å{z. {%8³´t8Ly{T Ë 4±²] z.Ãp{ %-4 %¤·Ö¸ 1u Ë pwy{ t'wK( {%y%tL {%yy{T y{ ¹¤yL%¹Nyup{T ¹N{T z1{% 4± ¹$( ·´¤:¸pwy{.yK]y{.³ !ty L{%ÇVyz.L Éq yup _(gÆ y T+pty%¹y±wL wp{% .y{*£t{%yy{T y{ Ì ° { ty%{ pp+p{qpwL{p ( tp{ºg~³»¾§ty{ ¶ L Ég zy (pt¹8 . . . . .
(95). . 1.8 SMOES 1.6. LES. Spectrum (lift coefficient). 1.4 1.2 1. 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0. 0.05. 0.1. 0.15. 0.2 0.25 0.3 Strouhal number. 0.35. 0.4. 0.45. BÐ §y{ 4 # %&74 4 G %H 4*on -* H 7 * H 4 6H- N* A H H # *C , * F* A C A H : ±wy w1pwy{ {{*g0.{ y{%§.N{%*pLz £t£y§~¼N{TÂ"%ty {%p(p{ t1¼KäÆ. . . ææ ì Lá%õ . . .
(96). . . . . . . . .
(97). . . . .
(98) %
(99) B !" #$ %%& F)+*%,-*.0/0 23544 6.7 9;35466.'7
(100) < > @46A*7&C D; G, * . p%y ³´{ ÇL{%y*t¹N 4±y§QytytLy%{ ÇDKÃÆö{ ¤{ wKT£ t Ì vwy z.{ wy %y³$yÃpy§1pwy{ {%L{%§(N{% yz/y{ K{%§ttyyy§ pwy{ t§y{ z. {% %twL{%{ z. t³$pwy{ Ë 4± {%z·Ö{(ÌÚ§yÌ]wy{ äÆ py ³´{%ÇDy{ y É{%ÂD"³wy{{ yz¸" pff{ %t y%¹B%{ Nt y§ p.pwy{ y twy{ {%%¹dwK(p"Ku(³BpwL{"z.ptÍ·Ö{Ì §yÌwy{ tpDyty¾y³Bwy{ N{% yz L{Twy{ {%Âg¸*Ì vwy{ RK¾y³]pwL{"N{%*pyz L{ *¤y{Q¤pwy{~Ly{T ÁtN{%(pt³8wy{ ¢T£ { uÆuDptÂ({%0{ ÇDK(pty ¹Ly4£g { )LwD % ÃyäL {4£{%§ty§±Ãpw{%{ pwy{"{ yz {% tz.ÃptÌvwy pwy{ywK{*ÆäT£{%p(§t L§y¹±wywξz.{%+Æ y¤y{QÇypÃÅ- y¾tyÃÎz1(pwL{%z1(pT(8%tL%{%gTÌ~vwy{Q tpDyty Ku ³pwy{N{% yzÊwK"¡¤{z1 { { Ì-vwy QyQ{ºp{% Q³´tz pwL{' 4±pfwy{ wy §w³´{ ÇL{%y*y§t{ à g{ 0y0{ §ttLtyÃ.pwy{wy §w±04£{%Dyz¤{ pwy{ %{ ³Bµ¶!NÌ vwy{%{ ³´t{¹Bwy{ Ãp{ tͳ upy ij0wy{upL pL{%p¤{y{ *p{ ³´tz pwyt{¤{z. { { λ ¶FÁwy{%ywT(8K(y{" y(pwL{% %{·Ö pwy{T{³µ¶!L¸*Ì { t.pwy{ {³´L z.{%pd(Lz1gpty%¹y»¼¶!. !y! gÆ T ÑG(wy{)µ¶!NÌ Å-pwL{1 z.{*Æ tz1¹pwy{Q³´y z.{%_w(pwy{ "³» ¶FÎ {% p{%z.y4 pwy{ { %tz.NtÃptV³F{Tw-yLÂLc±qÇDKpÃÅÎ H 4 %H7*¹dpwy{.tL{~¤{ L§wy{ ywK{*ÆäT£{%p(§t L§V·´±wyw- ¼1pz1{ºÆ { { { D N{% ~tN{%(ptp¸( pwy{"pwy{ pwy{ p( tz Ë y K( tdÌ vwy{%{ ³´t{pwL{"ywK({*ÆÅT£t{%§t{ ¢T£ { uÆuDptÂ({%¾{ Çy(ptywKT£t{"wy{"z.{³´tzÒ pwy{¾{ ÇDK(pty(³wy{¾u( upT>T£{%p(§t L§·@{ yt T£t{%§ty§D¸º¹yyy0pwL{¾pz1{ºÆ {%N{% {%p{ zÌ 4±0{*£t{ %¹pwy{Áywg % §y RyTy {¡³¼{%w p{ z p( {%{%³´tz pwy{ p(p %T£t{ p§ty§1{%ÇDK( y%Ì vwL{y{ ÅV³pwL{{*{%y tÄ(³pwy{%tpDyty"K"³wy{{ pyzÊ » ¶F)³´tz pwL{0c± pwL{0wy§tw"±0T£t{%Dyz¤{ Fy{ %{ " 4±8z. {%8³ywy{0y (Æ wy{%{%z.pt¤{ z.y 4y§.wDNpwL{%{ %tz.y§~³´tzpwL{¾p(p %dz. {% y§ ³By¤yL { y%{(ÌÐ:pwy{ {"{Tty ¹»¼¶F%f¤N{ £t{%u{ 1%{%³´wL §twÆä{ yt Lz"¤N{%y{ pty Ì 4±0{*£t{ %¹Kpwy{¼L{%{%%tpDyty{ pyz {%L? RK> ytKwy{¾% Ãpty0(³{ ÇL ¤Lyz { pyz¹LpwL{{ y{¼(³pwy{p(p % 'tz.t§ttc£pwy{ tÌ vwy F%z1{ F³´tz wy{z( 1ywTN{%td¹wK(]pwL{{ºg{%K.yyy { {%L{%§( . . . .
(101). . . . Ô æ>Ô . .
Documents relatifs
Results In all patients, a small volume (mean 17.6%) was found at the lateral aspects of the bladder dome in the extra- peritoneal fat tissue, whereas 82.4% of the injected
Results show that a relevant tuning of pitching variables can lead to an increase in rotational efficiency and thrust, which is found to be primarily related to the occurrence
Employing a generalized spherical harmonic representation, we analyse power spectra of orientational (2 ) anisotropic heterogeneity from seismology. We find that the
However, the assumption of steady flow is hardly valid for such floating turbines as the sources of unsteady phenomena are numerous: the inflow is unsteady
Evolution du Soutien Social de l’enseignant au cours d’une année scolaire:. Amélina GIRARD 1 , Nathalie Gal-Petitfaux 1 & Olivier
Notre objectif dans cet expos´ e sera donc double : dans un premier temps, nous ´ etendrons le concept de folding dans le cas multivari´ e ; dans un second temps, nous
(A) Comparison of solvents (THF and ACN)Refractive index GPC traces of UV polymerization of NiPAAm from bis-norbornene-3-dibenzyl trithiocarbonate RAFT initiator (B)
While the first step basically relies on a quadrature formula conditioning the formal accuracy of the whole scheme, all RD schemes differ from each other by their second step. For