To cite this document:
Mohd Zawawi, Fazila and Prothin, Sebastien and Lv, Peng and
Benard, Emmanuel and Morlier, Joseph and Moschetta, Jean-Marc Numerical and
experimental study on flexible blade for tilt-body drones. (2013) In: 21ème Congrès
Français de Mécanique - CFM 2013, 26-30 Aug 2013, Bordeaux, France.
O
pen
A
rchive
T
oulouse
A
rchive
O
uverte (
OATAO
)
OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.
This is an author-deposited version published in: http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/
Eprints ID: 9318
Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the repository administrator: staff-oatao@inp-toulouse.fr
!"#$%&'( ')* #+,#$%"#)-'( .-!*/ 0) 1#+%2(# 2('*# 30$
-%(-420*/ *$0)#.
!"#$! %&'()*+,+,- !". /01!23#04 56&7'-8 . 5049 :; . <==!4>0$ ?<8+6( . @A20BC %&6:-<6". @0!4)%!DE %&/F'<77+ ! <=>?6 @$(;,;3; A3B0&,.3& -. CD=0&#$*3;,23. .; -. CD>(B*1. "! </A/6 @$(;,;3; A3B0&,.3& -. CD=0&#$*3;,23. .; -. CD>(B*1.!"#$! %
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
&'"()*+( %
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
,-(" +./0" %
!"#$%&'( ')&*+, - ./"+ 0+1!%"+ - 23/**+) #)!'!4+*,!&**+" - 5*#6)/3#!&* 7"8!'+,$,#)83#8)+1 23()-4#+(5-3
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
!"#$%&!'%()* +#,% #" )'$-( ,.')( '/'0%'%1#! %(.2!13&(, '$( !#% %$'!,"($$'4)( %# ,+')) ,.')( $#%#$ 4',(/ /$#!(,5 6! %2( 0$(,(!% ,%&/* ' 0',,17( %81,% .#!%$#) 1, .#!,1/($(/ ', ' 0#%(!%1') 8'* %# 1+0$#7( %2( #7($')) 91-2% (:.1(!.* #" /$#!( 0$#0$#%#$5 ;2( 0$#0$#%#$ 4)'/( +'/( #" .#+0#,1%( +'%($1') 1, 0$("($$(/ %# 4( &,(/5 6% 1, /&( %# %2(1$ 0#%(!%1') 4(!(<%, ,&.2 ', '($#()',%1. %'1)#$1!-= '41)1%* %# +'!&"'.%&$(= +#$( $(<!(/ '($#/*!'+1. /(,1-!,= ,1-!1<.'!% (!2'!.(+(!%, 1! "'%1-&( 0($"#$+'!.( '!/ /'+'-( %#)($'!.( #" %2( 4)'/(5 ;2( 4)'/( 1, (>0(.%(/ %# 4( /("#$+(/ 1! %#$,1#!, &!/($ /1?($(!% '1$)#'/, '!/ ,%$&.%&$') )#'/5 ;21, 0'0($ 1, '1+(/ '% /(7()#01!- '! (7')&'%1#! #" /(,1-! %(.2!13&(, #" ' .#+0#,1%( 9(>14)( 0$#0$#%#$5
!"#$%&'() *+,$)
-. /$%+,01(#&' *+,$) 2345647
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e < 70, 000N= OPQ6R= '! '1$"#1) /(,1-! '!/ '!')*,1, .#/( /(7()#0(/ 4* S$()' FTH 8', 1!%(-$'%(/ 1!%# %2( /(,1-! 1%($'%17( 0$#.(,,5 ;2( %&$4&)(!.( (?(.% 8', ()1+1!'%(/ 4* &,1!- 9'% 0)'%( FUH5 6! %21, $(,0(.%= %2( V.$1% 0'$'+(%($= &,(/ %# /(<!( %2( %&$4&)(!.( )(7() 1! OPQ6R= .'! 4( ,(% ', W5X "#$ 4#%2 91-2% +#/(,5 C YK4)'/(/ $#%#$ 81%2 $(.%'!-&)'$ 0)'!"#$+ MR = 0.1m, c = 0.02mN= 9'% 0)'%( 4)'/( 0$#<)( 81%2 %21.D!(,, t/c = 2.5% '!/ 4)'/( 01%.2 #" 25Z 8', &,(/ "#$ 7')1/'%1#!M2#7($ .',(N= 1! P1-5 XM'N5 B('!821)(= %2( 0$#0())($ C[\ ]>U 8', &,(/ %# 7')1/'%( %2( P[LQ[ "#$ "#$8'$/ 91-2% .',(5 ;2( 1!9#8 7()#.1%* 8', 16m/s5 P$#+ %2( 7')1/'%1#! $(,&)% ', ,2#8! 1! P1-5 XM4N= 1% 1, "#&!/ %2'% %2( /(7()#0(/ @AB; +(%2#/ 81%2 %2( 1!%(-$'%1#! #" OPQ6R ,2#8, 4(%%($ '-$((+(!% 81%2 %2( (>0($1+(!%') +(',&$(+(!% .#+0'$(/ %# %2( )1!('$ +#/() ^[LQ[5 C ,)1-2% 1!.$(',( 1! %#$3&( #4,($7(/ 1! %2( (>0($1+(!%') $(,&)% .'! 4( /&( %# %2( 2('7* +'%($1') M')&+1!1&+N &,(/ 1! %2( 4)'/(5
- 89%"'9"%() *+,$) 23:;/*7
;2( ,%$&.%&$') '!')*,1, 1, 4',(/ &0#! %2( &,( #" '!1,#%$#01. 4('+ <!1%( ()(+(!% +#/() %# /(%($+1!( %2( 4)'/( /(9(.%1#!, /&$1!- #0($'%1#!5 ;2( P@ACB .#!,1,%, #" '! 1!%(-$'%(/ ,(% #" 0$#-$'+,= 821.2 0($"#$+ ' %8#K/1+(!,1#!') .$#,,K,(.%1#!') '!')*,1, #" %2( 4)'/(= "#))#8(/ 4* ' #!(K/1+(!,1#!') <!1%( ()(+(!% #" ' 0$#0$#%#$ 4)'/(5 C -)#4') .##$/1!'%( ,*,%(+ 1, &,(/ "#$ %2( /(,.$10%1#! #" %2( 4)'/( -(#+(%$* '!/ %2( .').&)'%1#! #" %2( )#'/,5 @A\C_ F`H= ' .$#,,K,(.%1#!') '!')*,1, %##) 821.2 1, /(7()#0(/ '% S(!+'$D ;(.2!1.') !17($,1%* MS; N 8', 1!.#$0#$'%(/ 1! %21, ,%$&.%&$') '!')*,1, 0$#-$'+5 ;2( +#%17'%1#! #" (+0)#*1!- @A\C_ 1, /&( %# %2( "'.% %2'% @A\C_ 2', '41)1%* %# /(%($+1!( %2( .$#,, ,(.%1#! ,%1?!(,, 0$#0($%1(, 821)( '..#&!%1!- "#$ ')) %2( -(#+(%$1.') '!/ +'%($1') 1!/&.(/ .#&0)1!-,5;2( )1!('$ $()'%1#! 4(%8((! -(!($')1a(/ "#$.(, F '!/ %2( $(,&)%1!- ,%$'1!, '!/ .&$7'%&$(, q 1, 8$1%%(! 1! ' +'%$1> "#$+ ', "#))#8, b Kq = F MXN 82($( K 1, %2( ,(.%1#!') ,%1?!(,, +'%$1>5 ;2( <!') "#$+ #" ()',%1. (!($-* '!/ D1!(%1. (!($-* '$( 8$1%%(! 1! A35 Y5 Ke= Z L 0 BTSBdz; Me= Z L 0 NTMsN dz MYN 82($( Ms ,(.%1#!') +',, +'%$1>= B 1, %2( ,%$'1!K/1,0)'.(+(!% +'%$1> '!/ N 1, %2( 0#)*!#+1') +'%$1>5 ;2( /(%'1), #" (3&'%1#! &,(/ 1! %2(,( $()'%1#!,210, '$( /(,.$14(/ 1! F]H5 c)#4') ,%1?!(,, #" %2( 4)'/( 1, #4%'1!(/ %2$#&-2 ,0'!81,( 1!%(-$'%1#!5 C, "#$ %2( #!(K/1+(!,1#!') <!1%( ()(+(!%= %2( .)',,1.') ;1+#K ,2(!D# 4('+ %2(#$* 1, &,(/ "#$ .#!,1/($1!- <!1%( ()(+(!% '!')*,1,5 d1%2 %2( #4%'1!(/ ,2'0( "&!.%1#!= %2( 0$1!.10)( #" 71$%&') /1,0)'.(+(!%, 1, &,(/ %# /($17( %2( ()(+(!%') ,%1?!(,,5 P#$ ,%$&.%&$') +#/() 7')1/'%1#!= ' ,%'%1. '!')*,1, #! ' $(.%'!-&)'$ 0)'!"#$+ 81%2 /1+(!,1#! MXeW5T++>XY5`++>G5X`T++N 8', 0($"#$+(/5 B'%($1') 0$#0($%1(, #" -$'021%(K(0#>* '$( b
µ = 0.3 and ρ = 1550kg/m3
!"# $%& '()%# *+," -#.$#/, ,0 $+,/" '1+. *'. 234 !"# -#.5%, 06,'+(#7 +( 89:;< *'. ='%+7',#7 6& <>/ ?'.,-'(@ +( 8+) 2
!" #$%&'()*+(,$*-.,%/.%,( 01234
A( 0-7#- ,0 /0B$5,# ,"# 6%'7# 7#C0-B',+0(@ ,"# /05$%#7D'#-0D.,-5/,5-# EF;>G B07#% +. 7#=#%0$#7 !0 6#)+( *+,"@ ,"# 6'.+/ )#0B#,-& EH#-0 7#I#/,+0(.G +. '..5B#7 !"#( ,"# 89:;< /'%/5%',#. ,"# 6%'7# 7#C0-B',+0(. !"# 7#C0-B#7 6%'7# ."'$# +. 5.#7 ,0 5$7',# ,"# '#-07&('B+/ B07#% !"# '#-07&('B+/ %0'7. '-# ,-'(.C#--#7 ,0 ,"# 6#'B (07#. '. /0(/#(,-',#7 C0-/#. ; (#* .,-5/,5-'% '('%&.+. +. $#-C0-B#7 ,0 /'%/5%',# ,"# 7#C0-B#7 ."'$# 0C ,"# 6%'7# 5(7#- ,"# +(I5#(/# 0C '#-07&('B+/ '(7 /#(,-+C5)'% %0'7. !"# '#-0D.,-5/,5-'% +(,#-'/,+0( +. -#$#',#7 5(,+% #J5+%+6-+5B 6#,*##( 7#C0-B',+0( '(7 %0'7+(). +. '/"+#=#7 !"# '$$-0'/" 7#./-+6#7 '60=# *'. '$$%+#7 ,0 ,"# /0(.,'(, /"0-7 5(,*+.,#7 KD6%'7#7 .&.,#B C0- 7-0(#.D.+H#7 $-0$-0,0- B'7# 0C %'B+(',# /0B$0.+,# !"# 7#I#/,+0( -#.5%,. +( 6#(7+() '(7 ,0-.+0( !"# #L#/,. 0C /'B6#- /"'()#. '-# (0, +(/%57#7 +( ,"+. .,57& 75# ,0 %+B+,',+0( +( ,"# B07#%+() A,#-',+0( M 7#(0,#. ,"# 7#I#/,+0( 75# ,0 /#(,-+C5)'% %0'7. 0(%& '(7 ,"# -#., +(/%57# ,"# '#-07&('B+/ %0'7. !"# 7+L#-#(/# 6#,*##( .+()%#D.,#$ E>>G .+B5%',+0( '(7 /05$%#7D'#-0D.,-5/,5-# .+B5%',+0( *'. +(=#.,+)',#7 '(7 ,"# -#.5%, +. +%%5.,-',#7 +( 8+) N !"# .%+)", #L#/, 0( 7#C0-B',+0( +. 06.#-=#7
" 35&(,67(8.+' 9(.%&
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`3K !"# 7+.,'(/# 0C -#C#-#(/# +. `33BB@ '(7 ,"# -'()# 0C B#'.5-+() /'( 6# 6#,*##( DK`3BB ,0 `33BB !"# .'B$%+() C-#J5#(/& 0C ,"+. %'.#- *'. .#%#/,#7 '. M3@333PH A( 0-7#- ,0 7#,#-D B+(# ,"# 0=#-'%% 5(/#-,'+(,& Ulaser 0C ,"# #1$#-+B#(,'% -#.5%,@ ,"# 6+'. '(7 $-#/+.+0( %+B+,.@ Blaser '(7
Plaser@ B5., 6# /0B6+(#7 !"+. +. '//0B$%+."#7 5.+() ,"# a00,D>5BD>J5'-# Ea>>G B#,"07@
Ulaser = (Blaser+ Plaser)1/2 E2G
; -#C#-#(/# .5-C'/# *'. B#'.5-#7 [-., ,0 7#,#-B+(# ,"# $-#/+.+0( %+B+,.@ ,"#( ,"# ,0,'% 5(/#-,'+(,& +. 06,'+(#7@ ± 0.1% \U> -#/0-7. ,"# b /00-7+(',#. *"+/" +. ,"# 7+.,'(/# C-0B ,"# $0.+,+0( 7#,#/,#7 0( 6%'7# .5-C'/# ,0 -#C#-#(/# $%'(# <#'(*"+%#@ .J5'-# *'=# +( ,+B# 70B'+( +. B#'.5-#7 6& aR< .#(.0- !"#(@ '=#-')# aR< '(7 '()5%'- .$##7 ', #'/" 6%'7# .#/,+0( /'( 6# #1,-'/,#7 C-0B ,"# .J5'-# *'=# 85-,"#-B0-#@ *+," ,"# 'H+B5," 0C C#',"#-+()@ $0%'- /00-7+(',#. +. $0..+6%# ,0 6# ,-'(.C#--#7 ,0 F'-,#.+'( /00-7+(',#. c '(7 ^ F0B6+(+() /00-7+(',#. c@ ^ '(7 b@ ' $0%&(0B+'% .5-C'/# [,,+() +. $#-C0-B#7 ,0 06,'+( ,"# 6#(7+() '(7 ,0-.+0( 0C -0,',+() 6%'7# !0 #='%5',# ,"# I#1+6%# 6%'7# $#-C0-B'(/#@ ,"# ,"-5., '(7 ,0-J5# *#-# B#'.5-#7 5.+() ,*0 ,-'(.75/#-.
: ;(-%'.- <+'6)+.6$8
!"# ='%+7',+0( -#.5%,. +( $#-C0-B'(/# '-# ."0*( +( 8+) ` ;. /'( 6# .##(@ ,"# 8RaOR ')-##. *#%% *+," #1$#-+B#(,'% 7',' 0C ,"-5., P0*#=#-@ +, 0=#-D$-#7+/,. ,"# ,0-J5# 8+) d ."0*. ,"# )007 ')-##B#(, 6#,*##( ,"# 8;: .+B5%',+0( '(7 ,"# #1$#-+B#(,'% 7',' '. 06,'+(#7 C-0B \U> B#'.5-#B#(,. !"+. +. ,"# -#.5%, 06,'+(#7 C0- ,"# 6%'7#. /%'B$#7 ', /0%%#/,+=# $+,/" 2`4 !"# I5/,5',+0(. ,"', /'( 6# 06.#-=#7 2!"#$%! &'( )")* +,# #- *)-#".( /#0& (") !) ")&$, & 12 !) +"),/./0("2 +#& 3+"#')&&/0% .) !#*4 50 !/& .) !#*6 !) *)-#".( /#0 7(& )8 "(' )* !"#$%! !) *( ( /0 )"+#,( /#0 ( )('! &)' /#04 9/0') !) :/1"( /#0 #- "# ( /0% 1,(*) +"#1(1,2 %)0)"( )* $0')" (/0 2 # !) ;<9 *( ( /0 &+(07/&)6 !)0')6 !) *)-#".( /#0 )8!/1/ & $0&.## !0)&& /0 !) +,# &4
!"#$%&'("#'
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
)**+#,(-20000 2500 3000 3500 4000 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 Rotational speed, Ω (rpm) Thrust, T (N) Experimental QPROP FPROP !" #$%&'( 20000 2500 3000 3500 4000 1 2 3 4 5 Rotational speed, Ω (rpm) Torque, Q (N.cm) Experimental QPROP FPROP )" #*%+&,!"#$% G H I#.+("/� #- JKL@ &/.$,( /#0 (0* '#"")&+#0*/0% .)(&$").)0 & -#" !#:)" MNOPQ
4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 Rotational Speed, RPM Thrust, T (N) FPROP QPROP Experimental !" #$%&'( 40000 6000 8000 10000 12000 2 4 6 8 10 Rotational Speed, RPM Current, I (Amp) FPROP QPROP Experimental )" #*%+&,
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 −14 −12 −10 −8 −6 −4 −2 0 2x 10 −3 Spanwise position (m) Flapwise deflection, u y (m) MSc.NASTRAN FBEAM !" #$%&'%( 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Spanwise position (m) Torsion, θz (°) MSc.NASTRAN FBEAM )" *+,-'+% !"#$% ! "#$%& '()*+(,*-. /0 &123 4%156%4 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 0.035 Spanwise position (m) Flapwise deflection, u y (m) Single−step Coupled−aero−structure !" #$%&'%( 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 −6 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 Spanwise position (m) Torsion, θz (°) Single−step Coupled−aero−structure )" *+,-'+% !"#$% 7 ! 589 9:92, -; 11 (.+ <%1 =*>?)(,*-. -. ,89 /)(+9 +9;-@>(,*-.= 1000 1200 1400 1600 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 RPM Thrust, N Experiment FPROP !" *.,/-0 1000 1200 1400 1600 0 2 4 6 8 10 RPM Torque, N.cm Experiment FPROP )" *+,1/$ !"#$% A ! 58@?=, (.+ ,-@B?9 -; @*C*+ (.+ D9E*/)9 F@-F@-,-@ (, +*:9@9., @-,(,*-.() =F99+ GHIJK A
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 Spanwise position (m) Flapwise bending, u y (m) Experimental Fit (Experimental) FAE !" #$%&'%( 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 −8 −7 −6 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 Spanwise position (m) Torsion, θz (°) Experimental Fit (Experimental) FAE )" *+,-'+%
!"#$% ! "#$%&'()#* #+ ,-. )($/0&1(#* 2(13 134 5#''4)%#*6(*7 $4&)/'4$4*1)
!"!#$%&$'
89: ;3<&'&=4>? ;@? A#)53411& B@A@? C&1&(004? C@ DEEF -4'#6=*&$(5 64)(7* #+ $(5'# &(' >43(504) +#' >4'1(5&0 G(731@ <#3&$*= #> ?,&1&*>; ! 9H9IJ9HDK
8D: L(M#*? A@N@ 9OFF P$%'#>4$4*1) 1# 1(01J'#1#' %4'+#'$&*54 13'#/73 %&))(>4 Q&064 12()1 5#*1'#0@ @?A? B.1C$,1*= /.D#&*$-3D !99EF8 9JO
8R: S4()3$&*? T@ DEE U40(5#%14' &4'#6=*&$(5)@ "*DG&,-%. ?.&#(H*1. A.&,.(6 $- .-,;,#$
8K: -6<(*)? "@L@ 9OOE V4)(7* #+ #%1($/$ %'#%4004')@ <#3&$*= #> I&#H3=(,#$ *$- I#J.& "# H J FD 8I: V'40&? A@ 9OFO -* &*&0=)() &*6 64)(7* )=)14$ +#' 0#2 W4=*#06) */$Q4' &('+#(0? 0#2 W4=*#06)
*/$Q4' &4'#6=*&$(5@ AH&,$%.&K.&=*%6 @.J L#&M 9J9D
8 : U4(*? C@ W@?"3#%'&? P@ DEEH U#>4' %4'+#'$&*54 #+ & $(5'# &(' >43(504 X '#1#' &1 0#2 W4=*#06) */$Q4'@ <#3&$*= #> ?D.&,1*$ N.=,1#H;.& A#1,.;O !$ DIKJD D
8H: C0&)Y/4)? B@Z@? S&[&'#>? C@ DE9D C."-; \D? - 5'#))J)451(#* &*&0=)() 1##0 +#' &*()#1'#%(5 &*6 (*3#$#74*4#/) Q4&$ )451(#*) #+ &'Q(1'&'= 74#$41'=@ P,(QB.1C$,1*=P.H#&;P,(QRP !SFE6B.1C$,1*=TR $,U.&(,;O #> V.$D*&M
8F: ]($? ^@? C'&**4'? ]@? U&*)4*? -@ A@ DE99 V4>40#%(*7 &*()#1'#%(5 Q4&$ 404$4*1 +#' 64)(7* 5#$%#J )(14 2(*6 1/'Q(*4 Q0&64)@ W$ I..-,$%( #> ;C. !F;C W$;.&$*;,#$*= "#$>.&.$1. #$ "#DH#(,;. /*;.&,*=6 <.X36 Y#&.*
8O: N(00(&$)? V@ "@ 9OOR _%1(5&0 A413#6) (* .*7(*44'(*7 A41'#0#7=@ "C*HD*$ *$- N*==
89E: ,04$(*7? T@ -@? T#'1#* ;@ 9OOF A4&)/'4$4*1 #+ W#1#'5'&+1 C0&64 V4+#'$&1(#* `)(*7 Z'#a451(#* A#('4 P*14'+4'#$41'=@ I..-,$%( #> ;C. BC,&- W$;.&$*;,#$*= "#$>.&.$1. #$ K,G&*;,#$ /.*(3&.D.$;( GO Z*(.& B.1C$,23.( [ ?-U*$1.( *$- ?HH=,1*;,#$(6 AIW\];C. W$;.&$*;,#$*= A#1,.;O >#& ^H;,1*= \$%,R $..&,$%6 ?$1#$*6 W;*=O I9KJIDH
899: ;53$(61? ^@? ^=)#*? B@? T&0&*/0()? ]@ DEER ,/00J,(406 V=*&$(5 V()%0&54$4*1 &*6 ;1'&(* A4&)/J '4$4*1 `)(*7 -6>&*546 RV P$&74 "#''40&1(#* Z3#1#7'&$$41'= X Z&'1 9@ \5H.&,D.$;*= B.1C$,23.( $% KHJIE
89D: A(53&40? ;@? S&2)#*? B&=&*1? ;@ DE99 A4&)/'4$4*1 #+ V4+#'$&1(#* #+ W#1&1(*7 C0&64) `)(*7 V(7(1&0 P$&74 "#''40&1(#*@ E $- ?W??_?A/\_?A"\_?NA_?A" A;&31;3&.(6 A;&31;3&*= VO$*D,1( *$- /*;.&,*=( "#$>.&.$1.6 V.$U.&6 "#=#&*-# &'&& $#""(")%* 9J9I