Segmentation de séquences d'images en vue du codage

Texte intégral

(1)Segmentation de séquences d’images en vue du codage Beatriz Marcotegui. To cite this version: Beatriz Marcotegui. Segmentation de séquences d’images en vue du codage. Mathématiques [math]. École Nationale Supérieure des Mines de Paris, 1996. Français. �NNT : 1996ENMP0610�. �pastel00002400�. HAL Id: pastel-00002400 https://pastel.archives-ouvertes.fr/pastel-00002400 Submitted on 5 Aug 2010. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3) ! " . #%$'& ()$+*-,/.0,01324* 5$ #$0647$+*98:$0#;5=<>1?().@& $0# $+* A 7B$ 57 8C245D.@&$. EFGIH3G JLKNMPORQSUTNMQ VWQXZY[S\T ]_^ `"ab\] QcdYZTNe b SfY ] IQ gWhLJiMPKRejQhfKRQVWQkOmlejSLQPOVLQonpY[KReqO JiYrK sutwvWxyZz|{}:~% EG J b Lh K [b TNQSLejK ] QITReTRKNQIVLQ bWa TNQhLKQSl b KNJL b\]b\ ejQolYrTRLMPYZTReqUhLQ. g b Wh TRQPSUhfQ ] Qu3XwKNe ]pk[\Lb SUTNYrejSLQ L] QkYrhVWQXZYrSUT ] QhLKR a b u J b ORM VWQ[ ll[QkYrS g `" ¡ R¢¤£¤¥|¦\§ï© ª b hLK«Y[V¬ `"¡ d®¯l¯ °d±N²\²L³r ¤©´§µW ¶ MK«YrK«V `"· ` ¸º¹ ±r»¥¼¨?±Z©>§µW K«YrSf½ b eqO ®o¾ ªmª ¯ `¿ ¸º¹ ±r»¥¼¨?±Z©>§µW QPKRK«ÀrS l mÁo·` g °d±N²\²L³r ¤©´§µW QPKRSfY[SfV l `pÂo`" ¸º¹ ±r»¥¼¨?±Z©>§µW .

(4) »%±±Z»u¥§ µW¥q£ ¸

(5) § ¥|± M a § £ w£ ¨f©>³Zï¥|³ »§¤£²f±Z R§¨f©_£±[¦[³«² © ¥ N£ ¥ ¥|±r¨ §§©¢ R±Z R¦. §© § [³rµ© ¥¼¨[³Zµ«±Z¨ ³r [ ³Zµ«±Z¨ ©

(6) !"[³Zµ ±Z N§ ¤¥$# © % ¥$# % ¥$#&±r .

(7) \QPY[S gwQKNKNY \hfe K a Q O b S YrSLSfMQ ONY L YZTReqUhLQ Y[K a Q ]jb SLQ

(8) m ^ Y V b SLSfM ] ^ bWaa Y[ORe b SQT ] QJ ] Y[ejORejKdVWQKRQPS\TNKRQPKdVLY[SfO ] ^ eSUTRMPKRQkORONYrSUTdV b YrejSLQVLQ ] Yl b KNJL b\]b\ ejQ lYrTRLMP%YrTReqUhLQ[lQPK a epJ b hLK T b hWTRQkO ] QkO ab SLSfYreqONORY[S a QkOoY[JLJLKNejORQPOoQTJ b hLK ]_^ Y aPa hLQPe ] Q a QJWTNe b SLSLQ ] VfYrSfO¡hLS a QSUTRKNQ Y a TNe SLejX[QPY[hO a ejQSUTNeiUhLQ

(9) WYreqOmYrhfONO e whLY[eS u QKNSfYrSiVlQP[QKmV ^ Y¬X b eK hfejVWMIQTmORhLejXwe VWQIJLKkO a QoTRK«Y¬XZYre ] lQK a e J b hfK¡V ^ Y¬X b ejK ORh ^ QS ab hfKNY QK PuQ \hiYrSfV ] QPO ab SiVWe TNe b SfOS ^ MTNYrejQSUTJiY[O ] QPOJ ] hfO|Y¬X b K«Y L] QPOP lQPK a e J b hLKORYuJ ] QejSLQVWeqORJ b SLe e ] e TNM[ QPKRK«ÀrSl YrK«\hfMPOP b SKRQkO J b SfONY f] Q d YrK a Q ]jb SfQ a TRM"VLQUhLeUe ] QPO T e%J b ONO e L] Q VWQ SLQIJfY\O TNKRQ¡ b \Qh nºfe ] eJfJiQ gLY ] Q eQPKdQTl b SUTNORQun Y[KNV O?UhLeºY¬X\Q a] QPhLK«O b SiOdKNMPORh ] TNYrTNOo ^ b S\T T b hZ b hfKNO¡J b hfONORM Y[uM ] e b KNQK ] QPO¡%ejQSfOP b ORM¿KRQkO J b Y¬X[Q a UhLeW ^ Yre QPhVLQPO KNh a TNhLQhiO QkOmVWejO a hiORORe b SfOP ` TRejQSLSLQQ a QS a e KNQoJ b hfK¡T b hLTP ¿LKNejO T b JLLQ ¶ K«YZTRejSmJ KNQ VWQ%QkO ab SLSfY[ejONORY[S a QkO%QS ejS b KNYZTNejUhLQ

(10) J b hfK ONY JLKNM a eQPhfO Q Y[ejVWQIJLK b QkORORe b SLSLQ ]] QIYrejSfO e UhLQ ] ^ Yr%e TNeMUh ^ e ] ^ Y "b ! QKRTRQ\ le a LQ ]3 e ]jb VWQPY[h ] ^ QS a a]b JiMkVWejQoXwejXZYrSUTRQ

(11) wT b hr b hLK«O b hLX\QKRTRQ u] Y b SLSfQoJiY Q\ mb\] Y[SfV KNM b SfVJ b hLK ORQPOoS b KNQhfORQPOdKNQ ] Q a TNhLKNQPOIVWQ%%QPOoKRMkVLY a TRe b SfOoQT ORQPO ab SfORQe ] OmY¬XweqO MkO npY[O a Y $] # YrhLKNQS Q ] YTRK«YrSfUhLe ]] eTRMuJiQPKNO b SLSfe fMPQ ?UhLe ^ YY[JLJLKNejOdJfY[K ] ^ %Q wQP%J ] Q Uh ^ e ] |Y[hWTXweXwKNQ ] Y%XweQ ONYrSfOmO TRKNQPONOP u Y KNe a Q # QP b SLSLejQKmJ b hLKO b S a & hfK b hLX\QKRTP '( # # YrbhLK«Yu] Sfb VWKNaeqYrY[OReS b K b J +a b *+hLK ORQP[O b SiO ab b SiO QPe ] O e SLQ h iYrK«)V npYZTNKRe KRe Q,K O QPJ Y[' -\. S Y\ORY\%O ¯¤/ b KNORQ,T ª b SLe ¶ Y[ORh ]j] /¿whfY[S ¶ hdgW ] XweQ [QkYrSLSLejS QPKRK«ÀrS+l YrK«\hfMPO b ORQJ Y[-[S l b KNK b O l b S\T«O Q npY[KNV %O 10oO a Y[K e QPO fn"Le ] ejJLJiQ%gWY ] Q ejQKmQT # ] hLejO ª b KRKNQPOJ b hLK ] Y b SLSLQ Yr eqYrS a QIUh ^ e ] O b S\TORh a KNMQK u] ^ ejSUTRMKNejQhLKVWhJLK b QTl b KNJLLQ ab le a LQ ] ¶ YrhLTRLejQKmQT l YrK /a 2 YrK b UhLeQPK¡J b hLK ] QPhLK b SZ b hLKVWhYZTRejS 3 # e ] eqYrSfQQT ¶ MK«YrK«VunºeJiYrh ] TJ b hfK4TNKRQ K«YrejSLQVWQ ib SLLQhfK¿QTVWQ ib SLSLQwhL%QPhLKP lQPK a e V ^ Y¬X b ejK¡KRQPuJ ] e ] Q K \] QIVWQ JfY[KRQPSUTNOmY[V b JWTNe |OP Y5|Y[%e ]j] Q76 J KNQ?KNQ T«YrSUTRQuQT8 KPKRQ:9Y[h O QPeS VWQ ] Y[UhLQ ]] Q ^ Yre QPh ] Y b SLSLQ a fY[S a Q VWQISf<Y ;jTNKRQIQT ] Q b SLLQPhLKVWQ XwejXUKNQ[ UYrejuQ

(12) pJ b hLK%Y¬X b ejK YrK«VWM ] Y a] MVWh b SLLQPhLK%JiQPSfVLY[S\T%VWQh= YrSfOQS TNLM b KRejQ bTRK eqOmYrSiO¡QTVWQPue3QSJLKNYrTReqUhLQ LONYrSfOmY¬X b ejKVLMPORQPORJiMPKRMIhLSLQORQh ] QI%eSwhWTNQ[ # b TRfY[K QK QPSQT>Ie * e 2 e eSUT b SWgwQK Q QPh a LQK,w\Y a Q * ¿e a b ? # h a dQ +a * QPK ] YrejKRQp®Q ] PSLQ"dQYrKRT ¬ ] e a Q ¶ YrhLTRLejQ,K <¿Q ? QPK ¶ b KNQS kej%e TNKRoQT ¯>KRQPSfY ¶ b K b * b Xwe * ce ab\] Q ¶ hfQ Y[SknºLe ] ejJLJ Q ¶ hLe L] ejSZlY[K a eSI¯A@¡YrS b @O * e b %ejSLeq\hfQ"[QPh ] eS,B ] Y[VLe%ejK >nIQfwY[K«KRYreTK«bVS Qb T CX ` X\\Q QP] Y[wS SLDEQ ¶ ] YrY hi VWSfFQ Y[e> KNQ] QPe GS Yr JL# fYrY[hfQ KR] QgWY[lORJ QkbORORK eqT«YrY[QOGS # lYrhLYrKNKNQeSUhiTO ? gWY¬l XZY[] KRw

(13) SfrYrnºK aejQ? KNh KR* QI g b e M]SL] QM ` V b hfYrK«VgWUhLe ]] Y a e U®h hLQPO ª Y ] b ,T ¶ e ] QKRT b ª e ]] ÀrGS b KRejSLSLQ BºY a feQPK UlYrK a BºYrS D VWK b[ QS K b Q +a * \hfe b SUT ab SUTRKNe hfM MSfMKNQhfORQ%QSUT /]_^ Yr eqYrS a QORw%JfYZTNLejUhLQVLh a QPSUTRKNQoQTUhLe b SUTKNQSfVWh b SORM b hfK %fb SUTNY[eSLQ L] QPYrhejS b h f] eqY L] Q[. H. .

(14) .

(15) xPy# arb xkz

(16) b ^ . Y %JLKNQPONO e SV ejY QLVWM%fSLeTRe b SVWhTNY[h VWQ ab %JLKNQPONO e b S I dQPOm%MTN b VWQPO a] Y[ONO eqUhLQPO¡Yrh= %MTR b VLQPO b KRejQSUTRMPQPO b[ QT4 I I H lMTR b VWQkO b KNeQPSUTRMQkO b[ QTo I I I I o I I I I H ) n ] YrSVWQ a QT TNQITR=kO Q!I o I I I I o I I I I H 1 t !r ªyZz" xkz b

(17) t#$b % xPz'&)b (*f b[y]j",b[+ -&-. z/0] t W KNY[SfOE KRYrTRe SfO¡l KRJL eqUhLQPO¿M M%QPS\T«YrejKRQkO I I I I WW #"# Yu^ 2 dK b e OR] Yre b TNSYZTNe b S I oo II II II II oo II II II II W H # Q ¶ K«Y[VLeQPS\Tl b KRJf b[]jb[ ejUhLQ0I I o I I I I 3 WW #"# Y^ ¾d hLQX\KNQ%KRTRQhLTRKNhfQ%KRQ!I oo II II II II oo II II II II 43 W ¯>SUTRQPKRJfKRMTNYZTNe b S VWQ ] ^ b hLX\QKRTRhLKNQdQTVWQ ] Y QPKR%QTRhLKNQ I I 4 W 53 # QPO a fY[JiQkYrh iYrhWTVWQ b KR%Q 6¼T b JD´fYZT 9 I I I I 4 # W QkO¡TRK«YrSiOE b KRYZTNe b SfO M b VWMkO eqUhLQPOI I I o I I I I W W # YuVLe ] YZT«YZTRe b S M b VWMPORejUhLQ/I I I o I I I I WW WW H #"# Y^ 2 K b Q ORae b b SfS O TR KNM h b a VWTNMke bO eqS UhLQ II II II II oo II II II II !!66 W H e ] TRKNQPO ab SfSLQ WQPOdI I o I I I I o I I I I !6 WW HH ee ]] TNTNKRKRQkQkO¡OmJfYrKNYrM Kmb[KN] YrQ aejKNb QPSfO O TRKNoh a TNIe b S I II II oo II II II II \ W # Y ] e SLQVWQIJfY[K T«Y QIVWQkOmQPY[h I I I o I I I I H W # Y%VWwSfY[%ejUhLQ% I I o I I I I o I I I I 7 H98#

(18) 8 yZv:! _& z x 8 ); y<_& t $bW a 8 /0 t

(19) b [ t# ] # = b b j ] ] de MKNQSUTRQkOYrJfJLK LQkOJ hLK¡TRK«YreTRQPK Y%VWej%QSfORe STRQ%J KNQ Q I 4 HH [ ?>@bw[a ª I o b I I]] I I o I I I I k4 JLJLK fQ KNejVWej%QSfORe SLSLQ QI I o I I I I bwa a H 6 HH H ## QkO H VWb e ! MPKRJLQPJLS Ka QkO¡fQQoSUTRKNKNM Q hLVWK«QO h=ejX[ QJ ] YrISfO ORIh aPa IQPON ORe |O¡IV ^ hLoSLQ ORIMP UhL QPSIa Q I II H H gUTNQ KRh a TRhLhLKNX[Q QPu MPQPSLSUMT K«Y ] IQI V I^ hf S ORWoOT %IQ VWIQ aIb VL Y QoIKR M oa hL K«ORIe b KNeQPIS\ TNM Ib\ IQ T A B kH zt /0.-( t t

(20) xPvLxPz

(21) :DC v: 8 t*; yE_& vF_& z.

(22) tG tG" vWy¬xPv:. tF t# twv:HIJ|& v:LK %M f gwej%J ] e a YZTRe b SVWQ ] ^ eY Q/o I I I I o I I I I 4 f ` wTRK«Y a TRe b SVWQIYrK«UhLQhLK«Odo I I I I o I I I I H ¯.

(23) ff H ¿ KMkbO heqOR] ONTNYrYrS TNOa QoVLVLQIQ ORQ % %Y[KNQUSUhLTNQPYrhLTRK«e bOISfoO [ I II II II oo II II II II H

(24) H H f nºf K Wb[ L ] %ORhLQKVWD M QIa fKNMPYrO SUb[TR] e hW]j]TRb e bSLS SfY QdoVW Q I] ^ ejIY QI II oo II II II II HH f W VWQPh SfeX\QPYrh= VWQ KRMkO b\] hLTRe b S I I o I I I I H f nºK b[ L] %Q ] eM %] Y KNY e ] eTRM VWQ ] YVWwSfYr%eq\hfQ o I I I I H f53 b S a] hfO e b SiO I I I o I I I I o I I I I J 1 H t .-( t

(25) xPb vLxPza

(26) b xPyZz z( t

(27) P z'

(28)

(29) t#&'|& t C v: 8 t ; y<|& v

(30) v:( z'/0 t BM W ¯>SUTRK VWh TNe S I I I o I I I I o I I I I 3 W ª KNY[SfO %eqORORe b S VLQ ]_^ eS= b KN%YrTRe b SVWhJfY[ONORM I o I I I I 3 W H ¯>S a] hfORe b SVWQIS b hfX[Q ]j] QPO¡KNM e b SiO I I I o I I I I W b S a] hfO e b SiO I I I o I I I I o I I I I A 1M z!;k z

(31) ¯>S ab SwX[MPSLeQPSUTNOmVWQ ] Y%uMTR b VWQ Y\O MPQ O hLK ] Q K«Y[VLeQPS\T I I I 3 hLTRKNQPOm%MTN b VWQPOVWQ O Q %QSUTNYrTRe b S I I o I I I I W ¿K b eqORONYrS a QIVWQIKRM e b SfO u]_^ M a fQ ]j] QVWhJLe WQ ] I I I I W ¿K b eqORONYrS a QIVWQIKRM e b SfO u]_^ M a fQ ]j] QVWQkO ?b SLQPO¡J ] YZTNQPO I I W H hfO e b SVWQ KNM e b SfOo I I I I o I I I I H dejO a hfONORe b S! I I I o I I I I o I I I I H MkO b\] hLTRe b S I o I I I I o I I I I f H nºK b[ f] PuQkOmVWQ hLeTRQkO¿ I I I I o I I I I f H H dhJLe WQ ]3u] Y ?b SLQIJ ] YZTRQ I I I o I I I I f H gwM ] Q a TNe b SVWQ Y[KNUhLQPhLKNO I I I o I I I I H ¶ MPSLMK«Y ] ejONYZTNe b S VWQ ] YuKRMPMXZY ] hfYrTRe b S VLQ ] Y%VWwSfY[ueqUhLQ; I b S a] hfO e b S I I I o I I I I o I I I I H M ~<&'.%i yZz x!+b ( t9a btP z'

(32) t 8 . z

(33) B w3 ¯>SUTRK VWh TNe S I I I o I I I I o I I I I 3ww3 H dlQPeqOO Q a KNQPeJWS TNe& b ShLXwVWKRQ Q]_^ Y I]j[ b IKReTR L %oQ VWQ8I hfIORe b SIVW Q KRM I e b oSfO II II II II \ w3 H QPJLKNMPORQSUTNYrTRe b S VLQ ]_^ eS= b KN%YrTRe b S I o I I I I \ 3ww3 HH H ¶¶ QkQkOOTNTNee bb SSVWVWQ Q YY aa KK bb D´D>KRYrM K TRe b QkSfO O I II II oo II II II II 43 w3 H ] Y[ONO QP%QSUTVWwSfYr%eq\hfQIVLQPOmYrK TNQPO¡JfY[K b K«VWKNQoVWQIXZY ] hfYrTRe b S \ w H n"ORQhiV b D ab VWQ VWQ ] ^ Y ]\b KNe TNL%Q[ I o I I I I D3 3 ` w3 WQ%J ] Q J MPVLY [b[ ejUhLQ o I I I I o I I I I D3 H = H t .-( t

(34) xP] vLa xPz

(35) b " a vWy P ]_z'^ ]j

(36) [b ty 8 . z

(37) b M= L4 JfJ e YrTRe SVWejKRQ TNQIVLQ Y KReTRL%QIVWQ hfORe S hfSLQIeY QIKRMPQ ]j] Q D3A4 4LL4 hfhfOO ee bb SSVWVWQ Q KNKNMM ee bb SfSfO¡O¡ORY¬Y[X[SfQ aOmYY aa TRTRhfhfYY ]] eqeqORONYrYZTRTRee bb SS oo II II II II D 3A4 4 L4 nºKNMTNKNY[e TNQ%QSUT I I o I I I I o I I I I 4 4LL4 WW 2ºº2 ]] ejejuuejejSfSfYrYrTRTRee bb SSVWVWhQPO¡ KNKNM hL e e T b SfIO¡ VWQIITR K«YrISi O e TRe Ib S! oo II II II II 44 H H # ab b 4L H L4L4¿ KNHW e T KNQPOm¿VWejKNONeQ ORT Y hfKNQ QIORe VWbVWQSQPO a b SUISUTN KNT Y\ OhLTNoK«Q O III III III III ooo III III III III 44#4#33 L4 H ¿KNe T KNQ VWQ ab SUTNKNY\OTNQ ]jbWa Y ] I I o I I I I J6 ¯R¯.

(38) L4 H H dejO a hiORORe b S I o I I I I o I I I I f L H ¿ KNe T KNQ VWQoTRQ wTNhLKRQ I I I I o I I I I f 4 4L b S a] hfO e b S I I I o I I I I o I I I I ;6 H t .-( t

(39) xPvLxPz

(40) t 8 /0 t

(41) [t#$jz( v:. t# " vWy Pz'

(42) ty 8 . z

(43) B ]j[b KReTRfuQ VWQ hfORe b S VWQKNM e b SfOPeSUTNK b VWh a TRe b S VWQ%Y[KNUhLQPhLK«OIQT TRK«YreTRQP%QSUTVWQIS b hfX[Q ]j] QPO¡KNM e b SiODI I I o I I I I ;6 nºKNMTNKNY[e TNQ%QSUT I I o I I I I o I I I I ;6 3 W e ] TNKNY Q YrKNM b\] Y[eKNQ o I I I I o I I I I ;6 3 W · TRe ] eqORYrTRe b S%VWQ ]_^ ejS b KNYZTRe b S%VWQ¡ b hLX\Q%QSUTpJ b hLKºY[uM ] e b KNQK ] Y ab SUTNeSwhLeTRMITNQ%J b KRQ ]] Q I I I o I I I I ;6 4 W H `º] ejuejSfYrTRe b SVWQPO¡KNM e b SfO¡VWQITRK«YrSiO eTRe b S!o I I I I [ H H ¿KNe T KNQPOmVWQ hfORe b S I o I I I I o I I I I [ H ¿KNe T KNQ VWQ ab SUTNKNY\OTNQ I I I I o I I I I [ H ¿KNe T KNQ VWQoTRQ wTNhLKRQ I I I I o I I I I [ H H ¿KNe T KNQ VWQI b hLX[QP%QSUT! I I I o I I I I [ 3 b S a] hfO e b S I I I o I I I I o I I I I

(44) xPyr xkz

(45) tF& jv:&.-i y¬z|x;+( t t k z

(46) t y 8 i. z'

(47) " vWy ( % itJK (;6 t

(48) x b v

(49) a |& v b C -J|& t ] t v:. t b : 1 l VWe YrTRe SfOmVLQ Y%ORQ %QPS\T«YZTNe S9 I I o I I I I ;6 ¶ MPSLMK«YZTNe b SVWQ ] YO Q %QSUT«YZTRe b S fSLQ! o I I I I ;6 ¶ MPSLMK«YZTNe b SVWQ ] YO Q %QSUT«YZTRe b S K b ONO eKNQDI I I I 3 ;6 l b VWe a YrTRe b SfOmVLh ab VLY QIVLQ ab SUT b hLKmI I o I I I I H ;6 H l b VWe a YrTRe b SVWQ ] Y ab %J QSfONYZTNe b SVWQ b hLX[QPuQPSUT%I I I I H

(50) H ;6 MkO h ] TNYrTNO; I I I o I I I I o I I I I H 3 ;6 i gwMkUhLQS a Q fb KNQYrS BI I I I o I I I I H ;6 i gwMkUhLQS a Q cQ%@O Do I I I I o I I I I ;6 i H gwMkUhLQS a Q Y[KRJL b SLQ

(51) I I I I o I I I I # ;6 b S a] hfO e b S I I I o I I I I o I I I I P 4 - [

(52) r xPz'

(53) b

(54) v:|&a z|x 8b ¯>SUTRK VWh TNe S I I I o I I I I o I I I I P\ [ gwhLejXwe3V ^ b[ QTNO I I o I I I I o I I I I 3 6 [ L ¶ MPSLMK«YZTNe b SVWhY[ONUhLQ I I I o I I I I 3 6 [ L gwhfeXwe3VWhY[ONUhLQ o I I I I o I I I I 3 [ L H hfO e b SiO¡JfYrKm b hfX[Q%QPS\TmQT b S a TRe b SLSfY ] eTRM I I I I 3 [ H MkO h ] TNYrTNO; I I I o I I I I o I I I I 3 [ b S a] hfO e b S I I I o I I I I o I I I I 3 :

(55) &k z

(56) a :M 1 L n QK«O J Q TRejX[QkOI I I o I I I I o I I I I 3J3. ¯ ¯R¯.

(57) . #Q. VWMX\Q ]jb JLJ Q%QPS\T V ^ Y[JLJ ] e a YZTNe b SfOTNQ ]j] QkO UhLQ ] Y+XweqVWM b TRM ] MPJL b SfeQ

(58) ] Y+XUeqVWM bwab SD MKNTRQK S POa Q bY[hOIVW] QM eTPh ] TR# ej%QPOIQPVWO eqWY O Tb PSUuT Qka OIKNMVWM Q ] aYb %SfM JLa KNQkQPORONOROeTRe bMS VWQV ^ aejb VWY QP KoQ VWb QkKNOejQORSUMPTRUMkhLO QPb\S a QkQOT,V Yr^ eJLJ Y Q ] QPMPOO YrhiORORewuMTR b VWQkO VWQVLQh We%Q MSfMK«YZTRe b SG b! KNQSUT hLSLQ¡Y ] TRQPKRSfYrTRejX[Q¿JLK b %QT TNQhfORQ¡Yrh %MTN b VWQPO a] Y\OROReq\hfQPOP5¿QkOI%MTR b VLQPOORQ%KNY[JLJLK bwa fQSUTIVLh ab %J b KRTRQPuQPSUT VLQ ] ^ & e ] whLYrejS pVWQPO TRejSfYrTNYrejKN Q fSfY ] VWQPOO WO T PuQkOVWQ ab VLY QQTVLM a KNejX[QSUThLSfQej%Y QQPS ^ [ b TRQPKR%QkO¿V QTNO¿JLKNMPORQSUTNOVLY[SfO ] YO a PSLQ[peSfORe UhfS ORwO TP%QdVWQ ab VLY Q b KRejQSUTRM b[ D QT b J KNQ QSVWQPh MTNY[JiQkO¿hLSLQJLKNQ%e KNQIMTNY[JiQV ^ Y[SfY ] WO

(59) Q fYrJfJiQ ] MPQO Q %QSUTNYrTRe b S UhLemVWM ab %J b ORQ ] ^ ejY Q QS b\ QT«7 O 6 QSiO QP L] QPOuVWQJLe WQ ] OX[MPKRe iYrSUTuhLSLQ ab SiVWe TNe b S ^V b b\ MSfMeTR,M 9 QThfSLQ ORQ ab SfVWQMTNY[JiQUhLe¿ b VWM ] eqO Q ] Y b KNuQQT ] Q ab SUTRQPSwh VWQPO b[ QTNOmORQ %QSUTRMkO # Q¿TRK«Y¬X¬Y[e ] VW]_^Q b[ a QT TNa Q¿TN=PORQ¡] QPO T ab SfONY]_^ a KRM ] YoO Q %QSUTNYrTRe b SVLQ¡ORMPUhLQPaS b a QkO V ^ ejbY QkO% a ONY fY[S\To\hfQ Q TNe iSfY QPO ToVWQ ejS\TNM KRQPKdVLY[SfOhLS O WO T %QuVWQ VfY Q KRejQSUTNM b[ QTP. c b hiO Y¬X b SfO ab %%QS a M S b TRKNQTNKNY¬XZYre ] QS+S b hfO b SfVLY[SUTORhLK ] Q JiYrK«Y[VWe %Q VWQ ORQ %QPS\T«YZTNe b SVWQ ] Y b KNJL b\]b\ ejQmYZTRfMYZTNejUhLQ\ ] Y ] e SLQdVLQJfY[K T«Y QdVWQPO¿QPY[h %VLh K«Y[VLeQPS\T JfYrKRTRejKdVLQPOY[KNUhLQPhLKNOdVWQPOKRM e b SfOdUhLQ ] ^ b SX[QPhWTQ wTNKNY[eKNQ[8¿QO a LMPY YV b SLSLM ] ejQh VWQS b KNQhfORQPOYrJLJ ] e a YZTNe b SfOY[ejOpVLYrSfO ] QV b Y[eSLQ VWh ab VLY Q

(60) a Q ] Y ab SfVWhLeT VWQkOIVWe a h ] TNMPOoKNMQ ]j] QPOP ¿QPOIVWe a h ] TRMPO O b SUTIVWhLQPO ] Y JLKNMPORQS a QVWQ VWMTNYre ] O iSf%O b h a Q%UhLe KRQPXweQPS\TIYrh ' P%Q ] Y JLKNMPORQS a QVWQu b hLX\Q%QSUTNOdK«YrJLeqVWQPO UhLe MS KNQSUTdVWQkO b[ QTNO fSfOdVLYrSiO ] ^ "Y WQ TRQPuJ b KNQ ] ` S Q ! Q,T ?VfYrSfO ] QuV b YrejSLQVLh ab VLY

(61) Q ] QPO ab SfVLe TNe b SfOV ^ M a fY[S\TNe ]j]jb SLSfY Q b KNJL b\]b\ eq\hfQ SLQO b SUTJfY\OX[MPKRe fMPQPOP #º^ YrSiY ] wORQVWb QkOVL e a h a ] TNMPOKRQPb S ab a S\TNKRMPQPO] S b hfOub Y ab SfVWhf e Tb hLS YrhWTNKRQ JfYrK«Y[VWe %QVWQ ORQ %QPS\T«YZTNe S Y[ORM QTRTRQ ejO D e O hfK Y hfORe SVWQ KRM e SfOP c b hiOY¬X b SfOY[eSfORe VWMX\Q ]jb JLJ MhLS Y ]\b KNe TNL%QVWQ3 hiO e b S VLQKRM e b SfOPm¯>%J ] M%QSUTRM ORhLK hLSLQºO TRKNh a TRhLKNQºVWQ KNY[JLLQpV b SUT ] QPO S & hfVLO QT ] QkO Yr K TNQPO O b SUT MXZY ] hLMk%O ] ^ Y ]\b KNe TNL%Q QPO T ] Y b ejOQ a Y a Q QTIO h ONYr%%QSUT

(62) iQ We f] QJ b hfKJLKNQSfVLKRQ QPS ab %JWTNQhLSLQ ] Y[K Q XZYrKNeMTRMuVWQ a KReT PKRQkO ` S JiYrKRTRe a h ] eQPK ?VLY[SfO ] Q hWT VWQKNQSiVWKRQ ] Q%O WO T PuQuVWQ ab VLY Q []jb[ Y ] Q%QSUT ab LMKNQSUTWS b hfOY¬X b SfOJLKNeqO¡QS ab uJLTRQVLY[SfO ] QPO a KReTPKRQkOmVWQ hfORe b S ] QPO a Y[JfY a e TNMPOmVWQkOmY ]j[b KReTRL%QkOVLQ ab VLY QoY[JLJ ] ejUhLMkOmYrJL K PO ] YO Q %QSUT«YZTRe b S3 ` SfS S b hfOoY¬X b SfOme ]] hfO TRKNM ] QJ b TNQSUTRejQ ] Uh ^ b ! KNQ ] YORQ %QSUTNYrTRe b S hfS ORwO TP%Q VWQ ab VLY Q[ ` SQ ! Q,T ] YO Q %QSUTNYrTRe b SejSUTRK b VWhLeT ] YS b TRe b S V ^ b\ QTmVLY[SfO ] Q ab VWQPhLKP ejSfORe ] Q%VLMX[Q ]b JLJ Q%QSUTVWQ b S a TRe b SfSfY ] e TNMPO TRQ ]] QPO\hfQ ] QORhLeXweºV ^ b[ QTNO3VWQPXweQPS\T.

(63) hLSLQoQ wTNQSfORe b SSfYZTNhLKNQ ]j] QoVWQPOY ]j[b KReTRL%QkO"VWQ ab VLY Q[ ¿QPO4 b S VLY[SfO ] Q a Y\VWKNQºVWQPO3S b hLX\QPY[h b\ Q a TRe |O)= WMPO3JfYrK ] YmS b KNuQºVLQ ab. a TRe b SLSiY ] e TNMPO¿KRQPS\TNKRQPSUT VLY QpXweqVWM b ln ` ¶ f. .

(64)

(65) ? "!$# %'&)(*(,+-. / < +!01&23/54768.5+:9*+-. / ; 9*;=< /5&> "!$# %'&)(*(,+-. M a Q%%QSUT ] Y ab %JLKRQkORORe b SdV ^ ejY Q

(66) PQT QS JfY[K TNe a h ] eQPK ] Y ab %JLKNQPONO e b SIVWQºORMPUhLQS a QPO V ^ eY QPOQkOTVWQX\QSwhLQ hLSORhZQT VLQ K«YrSfVoejS\TNMK T K a Q Yrh VWMX\Q ]jb JLJ Q%QPS\T3V ^ Y[JLJ ] e a YZTRe b SiO TRQ ]] QPO UhLQ ] Q XwejVLM b TNM ] MJL b SLQ

(67) ] Y+XUeqVWM bwab S MPKRQPS a Q

(68) QT ] QkO h ] TNe%QkVWejY+J b hLK SLQ a eTRQPKUhLQ ] QkO%J ] hiO%e%J b KRTNYrSUTNQPOP # QkO%eY QPO ab SUTRejQSLSfQSUThLSLQMS b KR%QUhfYrSUTNe TNM V ^ eS= b KN%YrTRe b S a QUhLemKNQSfV ab@? TRQPh ] QhLKO T bWa+* Y Q b h ] QhLK%TNKNY[SfORueqONO e b S O eQ ]] QPO SLQO b SUTJfY\O%JLKRMkY ] Y L] Q%QPS\T ab %JLKNQPONO MPQPOP npY[KQW Q%J ] Q J b hLKTNKNY[SfORuQT TNKRQhLSLQ ORMPUhLQS a QVWQ [IejY QkOpJfY[K¿ORQ ab SfVWQVWQ [ × \ JLe WQ ] O"Y¬X\Q a [ SLejX[QPY[h uVWQ KNejO 6 4 eTNOºJfYrKpJLe W Q ] 9 QU W ORJ Y[]jSfb OeTR]QPY K a] b QP%OJL KRQkb OR[ORQPQSfK,OZ e VW] Q| YrhfTRK«VWYrK«SiYrOeTp%hLeqORSOReVWb M S e T"UVWhLQ e O Hb SUl T JLe T«wOBWORdA ejUO QhLaQPb uSfQPVWSUQ[T i S!VWQ %eQPh+ ] e%eTRMPO b S QkOT b[ f] e M%VWQuKRQ a LQK a LQKIVWQkOIKRQkV b SfVfYrS a QPOoVWQ%%Y[SLeKNQ TRK«YrSfOR%QTRTRKNQ ] ^ ejS b KNYZTNe b S Y¬X\Q a hLS S b KNQVWQ eTNOJ ] hfO | Y[e L] Q[ # Q hWT VWQ ] Y ab %JLKRQkORORe b S V ^ eY QQkOT%VWQKNMPVLhLeKNQY[hWTNY[S\T%UhLQJ b ONO e L] Q ] QS b KNQ VLQ eTNOSLM a QPONORY[eKNQJ b hLK KNQ ab SfO TRKNhLeKNQ hLSLQ ab JLejQ3i V ] QuVWQ ] ^ eY Q b KRe ejSfY ] Q[ # YKNQJfKRMkO QPS\T«YZTNe b S a YrS b SLeq\hfQ V ^ hLSLQeY Q¿VLe e T«Y ] Q¿KNQPUhLejQKRTDCFE G × H × I e T«O% b@J N ×M O b SUT ] QPO VWej%QSfORe b SfO VWQ ] ^ ejY QoQT ] QIS b KNQoVLQ eTNO¡J b hfKmKRQPJLKRMkO QPSUTRQK¿hLSJ b eSUT ´D ej%Y Q6 hLSM a iYrSUTRe ] D ]jb SV ^ eY QO QPbKNY%Y[JLJiQ ] M JfeW Q ] \hfe QPO ThLSLQY KNMXwejYrTRe b SVWhTRQPKR%QYrS [] YreqO JLe a TNhLKNQ Q ] Q%QPS\T E9¡gWe b SQkOT a YrJfY L] QVLQ KRQ ab SiOTNKRhLejKNQohfSLQ ab JLejQVWQ ]_^ ej%Y Q JfY[K TNeKdVWQ eTNO b SVWejKNY%UhLQ ] QoTNYrh= VWQ ab %JLKRQkORORe b S b\ TRQPSwh QkOTVWQ T =. B C. n b hLKdhLS ORWOT %QVWQ ab %JLKNQPONORe b SV b SLSLM

(69) iJ ] hfO ] Q TNY[h VWQ ab %JLKRQkORORe b SQPO TdM ] QPX[M J ] hfO ]_^ ej%Y Q ab VWMQ O ^ M ]jb e SLQ VWQ ] ^ eY Q b KRe ejSfY ] Q[ gwQ ]jb S ] QkO Y[JLJ ] e a YZTRe b SiO% ] QPO TNY[h VLQ ab uJfKRQkORORe b S KNQ a fQK a LMPOmO b SUTVWe ! MPKRQPSUTNOP · SLQJLKNQ%eKNQ a] Y\ORORe a YrTRe b SVWQPO %MTN b VWQPOIVWQ ab VLY QJ QhWTTRKNQQSwXweqORY MQ JfY[K TNeKoVWQPO b\ Q a TRe |OoUhLQ ]_^ b S O Q= WQ[ %¿QQKRSUTNT Y[e]_Sf^ ejQP%OdY u Q MTRb KNbe VWeSfQkO Y ] b 8Q SU6 Td%MMTNTNMu bVLVWMfQPOpSLejONQPYrOdSiJO3b J hLQKKRTRQkTNO KR9Q #a Y[QPJfO Y TN LY[]hQP OdVWVWQ QuaKRb Q uab JfSiKROQkTNORKRORhLe bejKNSQ YZQTR LTRYQeja SUTRTNQOD SLQuVWMJfY\ORORQSUTJfY\O b h H / ¿QT TNQ ab SUTRK«YrejS\TNQ QPO ToO b hLX\QSUTmTRK b JO TRKNe a TRQ\ # QTNYrh= VWQ ab %JLKRQkORORe b S V b SUT b S Y QPO b ejS/VLYrSfO ] YJ ] hLJfY[K T VWQkOoY[JLJ ] e a YZTNe b SfO ab S a QKNSfY[S\TIVWQPO ej%Y Qk%O rQkOTO hLJ MKNejQhLK"V ^ Y[h b eSiOphLS b K«VWKNQVWQ K«YrSiVWQhLK a Q ] hLefUh ^ b ShLTRe ] eqO QdVLYrSfO ] Y ab uJfKRQkORORe b SVWQdV b SLSLMPQPO [YreqO"QPS %QTNQ%JfO¿e ] JiQPKR%QT"hLSLQdJiQTReTRQIVWejO T b KNORe b S. . .

(70) . WV Q ] ^ eS b KRYrTRe b SVLYrSiO ] YuQkO hfKRQ b@Ju] ^ & e ] Uhf%Y[eSSfQ ] YIJ QK«½ b e TºJiY[OP #"^ b\ Q a TRe QkOT VWQ%KNQPO TReTRhLQPK hLSLQ ab JLeQVWQ ] ^ b KNe eSfY ] Y¬X\Q a hLSLQ a QKRTNYrejSLQ%VWeqOT b K«O e b S Y[ejOIXweqO hLQ ]] QD %QSUTJLK bWa LQVWQ ] ^ ejY QVWQVLMJfY[K Tk¾dS/JiQPhWT b[ TRQSfeKVLQPO ejY QkOIQSYrJfJfYrKNQS a Q eqVWQSUTReqUhLQPO ] ^ b KRe ejSfY ] Y¬X\Q a hLS TNYrh= VWQ ab uJfKRQkORORe b S V ^ QSwXwejK b S ucMPY[SL b ejSfO% a QPK T«YrejSLQPOmY[JLJ ] e a YZTNe b SfO¡KRQkUhLe PKRQPSUT¡hfS T«Yrh VWQ ab %JLKRQkORORe b SJ ] hfOM ] QX\M[pn b hLK a Q a e e ] QkOTuSLM a QPONORY[eKNQV ^ Q wTRK«YrejKRQ ]_^ e=S b KN%YrTRe b S UhLeS b hiOJ QKNuQT TNKNY VWQKNM a hLJiMPKRQPKhLSLQ ej%Y Q ORe%J ] e iMQ YreqO¡KRQPJLKNMPORQSUTNYrTRejX[QdVLQ ]_^ eY Q b KNe eSiY ] Q[. ;6. . &)( !04 9 / &)($ -(*(,+ ; &)( ;=< !04 9 5 / &)( % + &). 9*4)&)( & 9 # QkOIJLKN Q%b eQPKNOIJiY[OIQSa ab %JLKNQPONO e babS V ^ ejb Y QuhLTRe ] eqO QPSUT]b ] Y TRfM b KNejQ%VLQ ] ]_^ eS= b KN%YrTRbe b S dQh K hLJ QPOVWQ"TNQ LSfejUhLQkOVLQ VfY Q SUT MTRMmVWMPX[Q JLJiMkO VLQJLhLeqO QPO YrSLSfMQPO O e D YrSUTNQdVLY[SfO a Q a Y[VWKNQ[ ] QPO¿TRQ a LSLeq\hfQPOO JfYrTReqY ] QPOU UhLe TNKNY¬XZYre ]j] QPS\T¡VWejKRQ a TRQP%QSUTY¬X\Q a] QPO XZY ] QhLK«O VWQkOM a iYrSUTRe ]]jb SiO VWQ ]_^ ej%Y QQT ] QkO %MTR b VLQPO TNKNY[SfO b KNuMPQPO3 UhLeºhWTNe ] eqO QPS\T ] YKNQJLKNMPORQSUT«YZTRe b S O J Q a TRK«Y ] QuVWQ ] ^ ejY QuQT ] Y ORejuJ ] e fQSUTk¿QPOo%MTN b VWQPO3VWM ab D J b ONYrSUT ]_^ ej%Y QQPS L]jbwa OKNM h ] ejQK«O%QTQW J ]jb eTNY[S\T ] Y ab KNKRM ] YrTRe b S ]_^ ejS\TNMKNeQPhLKVWQ a fY\\hfQ L]bWa \ VLY[SfO ] QV b YrejSLQORJfYZTNejY ]Lb hORJiQ a TNKNY ] b SUTºJfYrKRTRejQVWQ a QUh ^ b SYrJLJ Q ]j] Q ² N§»u¥ N§ #U¢¨?¢ R±r©_¥|³r¨!¦[§££ ¬£«© »%§£¦\§«³Z»² R§£«£¤¥|³Z¨ ¦ ¥¼»%± #\§ # QPO L]jbwa O%hWTRe ] ejORMPO J b hLK¿QW J ]jb eTRQK ] Y ab KNKRM ] YrTRe b S%VWQ ] ^ ejY QSLQO b SUTºJfY[O ] ejMPO O b S ab S\TNQSwh # QkO TRK«YrSD ORe TNe b SfOQPS\TNKRQ L]bWa OVWQPXUejQSfSLQSUTXweqO e L] QPOUhfY[SfV b SQkORONY¬[QV ^ YrT TRQPeSiVWKRQVWQPOTNYrh= VWQ ab %JLKRQkORORe b SM ] QPX[MkO # QkOuMTR b VWQkO b KNaeb QPSUTRMQkO b\ QT,L ] YrJLJ Q ] MQkOmYrhfONORe %MTR b VWb QkOmVWQ¦[§µ ¹ ¥ »bW§a #U¢¨?¢ R±&! © ¥|³Z¨ Y[JLJfY[KNY[ejONO QPSUT %%QhLSLQ Y TNQKNSfYZTNeX\Q[ ¿ QkO%MTN VWQPO O QK«YrJfJLK LQPSUTVLh ab %J b K TNQ%QSUTVWQ ]_^ & e ] whLY[eSVWQPO TRejSfYrTNYrejKNQ fSiY ] VWQPOORWOT %QPO%VWQ ab VfY Q

(71) ºQT VWM a KNeX\QSUT hLSfQ ej%Y Q QS+TNQKN%QPOV ^ b\ QT«O "# ^ ejY Q S ^ QkOTJ ] hfOVWM ab %J b ORMQQPS L]jbWa OmYrK eTRK«YrejKRQkO¿VLh J b ejSUTmVLQ XUhfQIVLQIO b S ab S\TNQSwhW YreqO¡QS b[ QTNO ab KNKRQkO J b SiVLYrSUT VWQkOQPS\TNe TNMPO JLKNMPORQSUTRQkOVLYrSiO ] Y O a SLQ\ #º^ eSUTNMK TVLh ab VLY Q b KNejQSUTRM b\ QTQkOT V ^ b[ TNQSLejK¿VLQPOºejY QPO"ORejuJ ] e f MQkOºYreqO ab SUTRQPSfYrSUTºhLSfQejS b KNYZTRe b S ] ejMQY[h ab SUTNQSwh VWQ ] YO a SLQ\¾dS/J QhWTQkO J MKNQKUh ^ hLSLQY[SfY ] WO QVWQ ]_^ eY Q TRK«YreTRQPK b JWTNe%eqO Q ] QPO J QK b KN%Y[S a QkO¡VWh ab VWQhfKP # QkO%MTR b VWQkOVWQ ] YJLKNQ%e KNQ MPSLMK«YZTNe b S ab VWQPS\TORe%J ] Q%QSUT ] Q ab S\TNQSwh VWQ a fY\\hfQ L]jbwa 6 ] YJ b OReTRe b SQT ] Y b KN%QVWQkO f]bWa OdQPO T ab SLSwhLQuYJLKNe b KNe 9 JiYrK ab SUTRKNQ ] QPO¿uMTR b VWQkO b KRejQSUTRMPQPO b[ QT¿V b ejX[QPSUT ab VWQPK ] YJ b ORe TNe b S ] Y b KR%QQT ] Q ab SUTRQSwhVWQ a fY\\hfQ b[ QTPdgWe hLSfQej%Y QQkOToKRQPJLKNMPORQSUTRMPQ QS VWMTNY[e ] QPY[h ab hLJV ^ eS= b KN%YrTRe b SfO X b SUT5 TRKNQSLM a QkORONYrejKRQkOJ b hLK ab VWQK ] QkO ab SUT b hfKNOVLQPO b\ QT«O% a Q UhLeIVWMPONY¬XZYrSUTNY Q ] QPO%MTR b VWQkO b KNejQSUTRMPQPO b\ QTJiYrKK«YrJfJ b K TY[h %MTR b VWQkO a] Y[ONORejUhLQkO¡npYrK ab SUTRKNQ ] QPO¡%MTN b VWQPO b KRejQSUTRMPQPO b[ QTV b SLSfQSUTVWQIuQPe ]j] QhLK«OKRMkO h ] TNYrTNO ]jb K«ORUhLQ ] Y ab %JLKNQPO D ORe b SQPO TTNKk O b KRTRQ\mQ ]j] QkOJ QKN%QT TNQSUTIhLSLQ KNY[SfVWQORejuJ ] e a YrTRe b S VLQ ] ^ ejY QQSSLQ KNQTRQPSfYrSUT%VWQ ] ^ ejY QUhLQ ] QPOTRK«YreTNO M b %MTNKReqUhLQPOORY[e ]j] Y[SUTNO Y ]b KNOUhLQ ] QPOfYrhLTRQPO KNMPU# hLQkQOpS a%QPMOmTNY[ hb L VWUQPhLO Q b ]jKR] QkejQO SU]_TN^ M& QPe O ] b[U hf%QTºY[JLeSKRMkQPO O QPTSUTRQbSUejT"SfY[OmhfORORQORSfeLORhLe fS%] Q ejSUO TRb MSUK TmTSLVWM h\] J e b MPeQPSUOPT" VWQXUhfQVWQPO YrJfJ ] e a YrTRe b SfO ] YK b[ b TNejUhLQ\ # YVWM ab %J b ORe TNe b SVWQ ]_^ eY QQPS b[ QTNO¿QPO T¡hLSJ b ejS\T VWQVWMPJfYrKRTJ b hLKORY ab %JLKRMPLQSiO e b S a QUhLe b hLXwKNQ ] QPO%J b KRTRQkO VLQPOYrJfJ ] e a YrTRe b SfO V ^ YrhWT b YZTNejOR%Q[ `º]j] Q b! KNQY[hfONO e¡hLS K«YrSiV J b TRQPSUTRejQ ] J b hLKVWMPX[Q ]b JLJiQPK ] QkO%S b hD X[Q ]] QPO b S a TRe b SLSfY ] eTRMkOºVWQln ` ¶ D rTNQ ]j] QkO"UhLQ ] Y YrSLejJLh ] YZTNe b SV ^ b\ QT«O% ] Q ab VLY Q ORM ] Q a TNe 6 ab VLQK Y¬X[Q a J ] hfO VWQuJLKRM a eqO e b S ] QuJLKNQ%ejQKIJ ] YrS JfY[KdK«YrJfJ b K T Yrh b SfV 9 ] Q ORhLeXwe V ^ b[ QTNOojj # YuOTNKRh a TRhfKRQIV ^ hLS ORWOT %QoVLQ ab VLY Q b KNejQSUTRM b[ QTQkOTmhLS ib S 5. . . . . . .

(72). . . .

(73) H ORhLJLJ b KRT¡J b hfKVWMX\Q ]jb JLJ QKmVWQkOYrJfJ ] e a YrTRe b SfO a b \S TNQSUT Y[ORQPV. . 4 9 /5&)( % +-&). 9*4)&)( & 9. (. . .

(74). # QkOouMTR b VWa QkO b KNeQPSUaTRb MQkO b[ ] QTIVWb M a KNeb X\QSUTI] hLSLb Q%eY ] QuQaS b TRQbKN%QPOIV ^ b[ ] QaTNb OoJLKNMPORQSUTN] O VLY[SfOIhLSLQO SfQuQT VWQSUT Y J OReTRe S Y KN%Q 6 QkO S\T hLK«O+9mQT Q S\TNQSwh(6 Y TRQ%w TRhLKNQ,u 9 VWQ a fY a hLS VWQPO b[ QTNO%VWMTRQ a TRMkO #º^ b[ Q a TNedS ^ QkOTJfY\O%VWQKRQkOTNe TNhLQK%hLSLQ ej%Y QuejVLQSUTReqUhLQ ] ^ b KRe ejSfY ] ?YreqOoV ^ Q% UTNKNY[eKNQ ] ^ eS b KRYrTRe b SJ QKRTRejSLQSUTNQ%VLM a KNejX¬Y[SUT ] YuO a P SLQ[ # QPO¡JLK b JfKRejMTNMPO M b %MTNKReqUhLQPO¡VWQkO b[ QTNOmO b SUTmJLKRMkO QPKRX\MQkO% a QUhLe M ] ej%eSLQ ] QPOQ ! QT«OmVWQ L]bWa V ^ hLSLQ YrJLJfK bWa LQ a] Y[ONO eqUhLQ[ · SORwO TP%QoVWQ ab VfY Q b KNeQPSUTRM b[ QT b J KNQIQS H MT«YrJ QPOP # YJLKNQ%e P KRQpMTNY[JiQpQkOT ] YmORQ %QPS\T«YZTNe b S a fY[K MQ V ^ ejVWQPSUTRe f QK ] QPO b[ QTNO JfKRMkO QPS\T«O VLYrSfO ] YO a SLQ\ · S b\ QTdQPO ToVWM%fSLe ab %%QhLS QSfORQ L] QVWQJLe WQ ] O6|hLSLQKNMD e b S19 X[MKNe i YrSUTdhfSLQ ab SfVLe TNe b S V ^ b b\ MSfMeTRM%¾dS ] hfeºY[ONO e SLQhLSLQ%MTNejUhLQT TRQ 6V b ^ ejh ]Y Y QuQ ] OR%9 Q'\ bwhfaeY O ] QPejORK QT SUT OR] hL^ eqK VWQhLSUS TNefa fQPKPYr%J/# Y V ^ JYr]JLhLJ Jf] eYra KRYZTTNe VWb QPS OJfYrY[JLK J TNe] ae a h YZ] TNeQPe b KSf Oa QV \^ YrhfSfeºY Ji] WQPORK Q D uQT¿V ^ Y[VLY[JWTRQPK ] QkO"Y ]\b KNe TNL%QPO a fY\\hfQ a Y[OºJfYrKRTRe a h ] ejQKk3npYrKºQ%W Q%J ] Qw VLYrSfO hLSLQYrJLJ ] e a YZTNe b S %MPVLe a Y ] Q b S J QhWTY¬X b ejK a LQK a LQPKuVWQkOuJfYrKRTRe a h ] QPO ab KNKRQ%D O J b SfVfYrSUT VWQkO a Q ]j] h ] QkO% b h VWQkOoTRhL%QPhLKNO3Y¬X\Q a VLQPO a KNeTKNQPOoVWQuTNY[e ]j] Q3VWQ O b b KNS\uTQ

(75) VWi M%VWf QSLejTRQPQ%OU TNVfhLYrKNSfQ O b ]hQPOVWQORJ aM b a h e ] QPa hLYZKkTRe b # SiQPOO VWa Q YrK«]_Y ^ Yra JfTRMPJ KR] eqe Oa TNYrejTRUe hLb QkS O VW#QkO Q b[a b VLQYTNO Qa LVWQQK XZa Y[LS\MkTO O ^ YrJLJ ] eqUhLQK hLSLQ KNY[SfVWQ XZYrKNejMTRMV ^ ejY QkO% ] Q a KNe T KNQVWQORM ] Q a TRe b SV ^ b[ QTNO SLQuV b eTIJiY[OohWTRe ] ejORQKVWQkOoeS b KRYrTRe b SfOIORhLK ]_^ eY Q%YJLKNe b KNe_ "# ^ ejSUTRK b VWh a TNe b S VWQ ] YORQ %QPS\T«YZTNe b S VLYrSiOIhLSLQYrJLJ ] e a YrTRe b S/VWQ ab VLY QS b hfO b[ f] e Q VWMf SfeK VWQPO a KNe T KNQPO V ^ b b[ MSLMPe TNM MPSLMK«Yrh )mXZY ] Y f] QkOJ b hLKhLSLQ eY Q V ^ QSUTNKRMPQ YrK e TNKNY[eKNQ[ L · SLQ b eqO UhLQ ] QkO b\ QT«O b S\TMTNM VWMTRQ a TRMkO VLY[SfO ]_^ MT«YrJ Q VWQ O Q %QSUTNYrTRe b S ] QPhLKNOoJ b ORe TNe b S QT b KNuQV b eX\QSUT TRKNQ ab VWMPQPOP # Q ab VLY QuVWQ ab SUT b hLKNO ab VLQ ]_^ e=S b KN%YrTRe b SKRQ ] YrTRejX[Q u] YuJfY[K TNe TNe b SVWQ ] ^ QPORJfY a Q[ H ejSfY ] QPuQPSUT ] Q ab VLY QIVWQITRQ% wTRhLKNQ ab VWQ ] Q ab SUTRQPSwhVWQkO b[ QTNOP. . . -. /5&> & 9 9*&9 )(,& # QJLK b J b OVWQ a QTRTRQ TR=k O QQPO T ] QVLMX[Q ]b JLJ Q%QSUTuV ^ hLS Y ]j[b KReTRfuQ VWQORQ %QSUTNY"D TRe b SVWQ ORMPUhLQPS a QkOmV ^ ejY QPOmONY a fY[S\TmUhLQ ]_^ b[ Q a TNe$fSfY ] QPO TVWQ ] ^ ejSUTRM KRQPKmVLYrSfO¡hfS ORwO TP%QIVLQ ab VLY Q b KRejQSUTNM b\ QTk c b hfO%Y¬X b SfO ab %%QS a M S b TRKNQ TRK«Y¬X¬Y[e ] QS S b hfO b SfVLY[SUTORhLK ] Q JfY[KNY\VWe %Q VWQ ORQ %QPS\T«YZTNe b SVWQ ] Y b KNJL b\]b\ ejQmYZTRfMYZTNejUhLQ\ ] Y ] e SLQdVLQJfY[K T«Y QdVWQPO¿QPY[h %VLh K«Y[VLeQPS\T JfYrKRTRejKdVLQPOY[KNUhLQPhLKNOdVWQPOKRM e b SfOdUhLQ ] ^ b SX[QPhWTQw TNKNY[eKNQ[8¿ QO a LMPY YV b SLSLM ] ejQh VWQS b KNQhfORQPOYrJLJ ] e a YZTNe b SfOY[ejOp VLYrSfO ] QV b Y[eSLQ VWh ab VLY Q

(76) a Q ] YSLQ VWQPO¡VWe a h ] TRMkO¿KNMQ ]] QPOP # YO b hLK a QdVWQ a QPOVWe a h ] TNMPO¡QkOT ] YJLKNMPORQS a QdVWQ VWMTNYre ] O f SiO% b h a Q%\hfe KNQXwejQSUToY[h %Q ] YJfKRMkO QPS a QuVWQ b hfX[Q%QPS\ToKNY[JLeqVWQUhLe MPS= KNQVWQkO b[ QTNO i SfO"VLY[SfO ] ^ Y"W QmTRQPuJ b KNQ ] ` SQ ! QT,U VLY[SfO ] QV b %Y[eSfQVWh ab VLY Q

(77) ] QPO ab SfVWeTRe b SiOV ^ M a fY[S\TNe ]j]jb SLSfY QI b KNJL b\]b\ eq\hfQdSLQO b SUTJfY\OmX[MPKRe fMPQPOP #º^ YrSfY ] WORQ VWQkOºVWe a h ] TRMPOºKRQPS ab S\TNKRMPQPOS b hfOpY ab SiVWhLeT hfS%Y[hWTRKNQmJfY[KNY\VWe %QVWQORQ %QSUTNYrTRe b S JfY[K hfO e b SVWQ KNM e b SfO . . . .

(78) c b hfOY¬X b SfOYrejSfO eVLMX[Q ]b JLJ M hLS'Y ]\b KNe TNL%Q VWQ hfORe b S0VWQ/KRM e b SfOPD¯>%J ] MD %QSUTRMO hfKhLSLQOTNKRh a TRhfKRQVLQ K«YrJfLQV b SUT ] QkOS & hfVfOQT ] QPOY[KTRQkOO b SUTMXZY ] hLMkO% ] ^ Y ]\b KNe TNL%Q"QPO T ] Y b ejO Q a Y a Q¿QTpO h ONYr%%QSUT fQ We L] QJ b hLKJLKNQSfVWKNQ"QPS ab %JWTRQ hLSLQ ] Y[K Q XZYrKNeMTRMVLQ a KNeTKNQPOPc b TNY[u%QPS\T, VfYrSfO ] Q hWTIVWQKNQSfVLKRQ ] QORWOT %QVWQ ab VLY Q []jb[ Y ] QPuQPSUT ab LMKNQSUT"S b hfOuY¬X b SfOJfKReqOQPS ab %JWTRQVLY[SfO ] QkO a KReTPKRQkOVWQ %hfQOReSUb TNS YrTR] e QPb O S a Y[JfY a e TNMPOVLQPOIY ]j[b KReTRL%QkOVWQ ab VLY QUhLepO b SUToYrJfJ ] eqUhLMPOoYrJfKkO ] YORQ D eSiY ] Q%QSUTS b hfOY¬X b SfOIe ]] hfO TRKNM ] QJ b TRQPS\TNeQ ] UhLQ ] YORQ uQPSUTNYZTNe b S b"! KRQ hfS ORwO TP%QdVWQ ab VLY Q[ # YO Q %QSUTNYrTRe b SejSUTRK b VLhLe T ] YS b TNe b SV ^ b[ QT¡VfYrSfO ] Q ab VWQPhLKP ejSfORe ] Q%VLMX[Q ]b JLJ Q%QSUTVW Q b S a TRe b SfSfY ] e TNMPO TRQ ]] QPO\hfQ ] QORhLeXweºV ^ b[ QTNO 3VWQPXweQPS\T b j ] ] hLSLQoQ wTNQSfORe SSfYZTNhLKNQ QoVWQPOY ]j[b KReTRL%QkO"VWQ ab VLY Q[ ¿QPO4 b S a TRe b SLSiY ] e TNMPO¿KRQPS\TNKRQPSUT VLY[SfO ] Q a Y\VWKNQºVWQPO3S b hLX\QPY[h b\ Q a TRe |)O = WMPO3JfYrK ] YmS b KNuQºVLQ ab VLY QpXweqVWM b ln ` ¶ f. .

(79) . . . $ 0

(80) . . oYrSfO ] Q a Y\VWKNQIV ^ hLSORWO T %QVWQ ab VLY Q b KNejQSUTRM b[ QT ] Y%l b KRJL b[]jb[ ejQIlYZTNLMY<D TReqUhLQdY[JLJfY[KNY<;jTºTNKkO"YrT TRK«Y a TRejX[Q a YrK a[^ QkOThLSLQoYrJLJLK bWa LQ M b %MTRKNejUhLQVWhTRK«YreTRQPuQPSUT VWh/O e SiY ] QT QS TNY[S\TUhLQuTRQ ]] Q3Q ]j] Q%J QKNuQTVWQ%%Y[SLejJLh ] QKYreqORM%QSUT VWQPO a KReTPKRQkO VWQ b KR%

(81) Q VWQTNYre ]j]

(82) Q VLQ ab SLSLQ WeTRMj # QPOJfKRQPuejQK«O ab S a QPJWTNOVWQ ] Yl b KNJL b\]b\ ejQ lYrTRLMP%YrTReqUhLQ hLKRQPSUT MPS b S a MPOQPS k L JfYrKºlejS *\b @O * e gwhLK a QT TNQ Y[ORQrlYrTRLQPK b S QTgWQKNKNY QS MT«Y L] eKNQSUT ] QPO8 b SfVWQ%QPS\T«OVLY[SfO ] QkOYrSfSLMQkO O b e LYrSUTNQ[QPJLhLeqO% a QT TRQ TRfM b KNejQO ^ QkOT ] YrK QPuQPSUTVWMPX[Q ]jb JfJiMPQ¿QTpYoMTRM¡VWe ! hfORMQmVLY[SfO ] Y ab %hLSfY[hWTRMejS\TNQKNSfY<D TRe b SiY ] Q[ # Y JLK b[] e MK«YZTRe b SVWQ ab S MKNQS a QPO\V ^ YrKRTRe a] QPOºQTV ^ Y[JLJ ] e a YZTRe b SiOºejSfVWhfO TRKNeQ ]] QPO QS/TNM b e SfQSUTP # YJLhLeqONORY[S a QVWQORQPO b hWTNe ] O ] ^ b SUT |YreTQSUTRKNQKVLYrSfOVWQS b KNQh a fY[uJiOV ^ YrJLJ ] e a YZTNe b SfOPpeY QKNeQI%MPVLe a Y ] QfO a ejQS a QPOVLQPOmYZTNMKNejY[h )WXwejORe b SK b\ ib D TReqUhLQ [TRM ] MkVWMTNQ a TNe b S \Y[SfY ] WO QT b J b[ K«YrJfLejUhL

(83) Q ZKRQ ab SLSfYreqONORY[S a Q¡VWQ a Y[KNY a T KNQPO¿j # QPO ] Q a TNQhLK«O¡ejS\TNMKNQPONO MkO¡JfYrKmhfSLQ ab SfSfYreqORONYrS a QIYrJLJLK b b SfVWejQ VWQ ] Y%l b KRJf b[]jb[ eQIlYZTNLMD YZTNejUhLQ J QhLX\QSUTORQ KR%M MKNQKYr=h b hfXUK«Y QPO ´¿oYrSfO a Q a fY[JLe TNKRQIS b hfOY ]]jb SfO ORQh ] Q%QSUTVWM a KNeKNQ ] QkOY[ORJ Q a T«OIJLK«YZTReqUhLQPO VLQ a QTRTRQTNLM b KRejQ[¯ ] O S b hfO J QKN%QT TNK b SUT VWQ %ejQh ab %JLKNQSfVLKRQ ] QIVLMX[Q ]b JLJ Q%QSUTVWQkO a fYrJLeTRKNQPO¡UhLe3ORhLejX[QPS\Tk # Yl b KRJL b[]jb[ ejQlYrTRLMPYZTReqUhLQ%QPO T hLSLQ K«YrS a LQS b S ] eSLMkYrejKRQ%VWh TRK«YreTRQPuQPSUT VWhORe SfY ] UhLewYrJLJ ] eq\hfQ ] YmTRfM b KNejQ"VWQPO QSiO QP L] QPO ] ^ Y[SfY ] WO QºV ^ ej%Y Q\ # QkO b\ QT«O3VWQ ] ^ hLSfeX\QK«OO b SUT MPSLMK«Y ] Q%QSUTTRKNejVLe%QSiO e b SLSfQ ] O%wYreqO¡e ] O¡O b SUT¡J QK«½hiO TNKNY¬X\QK«OºhLSLQ JLK b Q a TRe b S ejVWej%QSfORe b SLSLQ ]] Q%O hLK ] YKNMTRejSLQ\ ¿QT TRQuJLK b Q a TRe b SS ^ QkOTIJfY[O ] YO b %%Q VWQkO ] hL%eSfY[S a QkOVWQT b hiO ] QPOJ b ejSUTNO ] Q ]jb S V ^ hfSLQ ] e SLQVWQXUeqORe b S a Q\hfe QK«YreTdVWQ ] YXwejORe b S/hLSJLK bwa QPONO hiO ] ejSLMPY[eKNQ[ ] YJ ] hLJiYrKRTVWQPO b[ QTNOO b SUT b JfY[UhLQkO QT a Y a LQPSUT YrejSfORe a Qh UhLe O b SUToVWQPKRKNe PKRQ\8¿QTRTRQuJLK b JLKNeMTRMmhiOTNefQuhLSLQuYrJLJfK bWa LQS b S ] eSfMPYrejKNQ VWQ ] ^ Y[SfY ] WO Q%V ^ eY Q[ # Yl b KNJL b\]b\ ejQlYrTRLMPYZTReqUhLQ TRLM b KNeQ%ejS\TNKRejSfO PUhLQPuQPSUT M b %MTNKReqUhLQ?ejSUTRK b VLhLe TIS b TNYr%%QSUT ] Y S b TRe b S V ^ M ] M%QPS\TO TRKNh a TNhLK«YrSUTP #º^ M ] M%QPS\T O TRKNh a TNhLKNY[SUT QPO T hLS b[ QT3VWQ b KR%Q ab SLSwhLQ ¬UhLerQkOT a b eqO eZQPS b S a TRe b S VWQPO3JLK b JLKNeMTRMkO M b %MTNKReqUhLQPOdUh ^ b SX[QPhWTdQ% wTRK«YrejKRQVLQ ] ^ ejY Q[ #"^ ejY Q Y[SfY ] WO QPKQPO T ab %JfY[KRMPQ ]_^ M ] M%QPS\TO TRKNh a TNhLK«YrSUTP # Yl b KNJL b\]b\ ejQlYrTRLMP%YrTReqUhLQ%MTNY L] e T hLS b KNY ] ejOR%Q YZTNLMYZTNejUhLQ%J b hLK VWM a KNeKNQ%\hiYrSUTReTNYrTRejX[Q%QPS\T ] QPOIJLK b JLKNejMTRMkO M b %MTRKNeq\hfQPOoV ^ hfS b[ QTP. 6. . %#3.

(84) .

(85) !"$# &%'". ,. . %'".5("( % !0 9*+-. (. %'# 5 1+ ; &)( 4 -4 !0&). 9*+:% &)( hiYrSfV S b hfO%JfYrK ]jb SfOV ^ QSiO QP L] QPOS b hfO'| Y[ejO b SfO%KNM MPKRQPS a Q VWQkO%eY QPO # QPOdej%Y QkO TRQPeSUTRQkOIVWQ KNejOoO b SUToVWM a KNe TNQPO ab u%QuMT«YrSUTIVLQPO/ b S a TRe b SfO (. . . . . ) ixP+t * Á je SfYrejKNQPOP VWQ IR2 → IR ,-/.0-/.. 132547698 :<;!8=. g b e T hLSO b hiOED´QSfORQ L] QºVWQ 2 6|hLSLQeY Q · S M X] M%QSUT OTNKRh a TRhfKNY[S\TdQPO ToIRhLS O b hfO D QPSfO QP S b TRM B LQkOTVWM%fSLe JiYrKk. je SfY[eKNQ,9 QT B hLSM ] M%QSUTO TRKNh a TRhLK«YrSUTP L] QVWQ IR2 # QTRK«YrSfO ] YrTRMVLQ B JfYrK p~ . p. #º^ MK Lb ]ORe b S. ] ^ QPSfO QP. WV Q Q VWQPOJ. ] ^ QPSfO QP L] Q JfY[K ]_^ M ] M%QSUTO TRKNh a TNhLKNY[SUT QPO TVWMfSfeQ ab %uQ b eSUTNO p TNQ ] OmUXhLQ B 6¼TRK«YrSiO ] YZTNMIVLQ B JiYrK p~9BQkOT ab SUTRQSwhVLYrSiO X p Bp = {p + q / q ∈ B}. B (X) = {p ∈ IR2 , Bp ⊆ X} =. # QkO¡Q ! QT«O M b %MTNKReqUhLQPO¡VWQ ] ^ MPK b O e b SO b S\Tk ab b[ QTNOmY[h MTRK«YrS \] QPuQPSUTNOP • hfJLhLKNQoVWQkO. \. X−b. b∈B. ]u KRMTRKNM a eqONO QPuQPSUT¡VWQkO b[ QTNOmVWQIT«Yre ]] QORhLJiMPKRejQhfKRQ u Y T«Yre ]] Q VWQ B b ^ b\ QT«OVWQoTNY[e ]j] Q eS MPKRejQhfKRQ B • VWejORJfY[KReTRe SV #º^ Q wTN] QSfORe b S] VW^ b Q a QTRTRQdVLM fSLeTRe b S ] ^ b ] ^ QkO JfY a QVLQPO4 b S a TRe b fS O86 IR2 → IR9"QPO T \b RT QPSwh QSKNQ%J Y[½PYrSUT J MK«YZTRQPhLK ∩ JiYrK JiMPKNYrTRQhfK inf •. ∀p ∈ IR2. ,-/.0->,. B (f )(p) = {inf (f (x)), x ∈ Bp }. 1@?BAC;/D!? EF? E9;!8 =. `º]j] Q QPO TVLMfSLejQ ab %%Q ] ^ QPSfORQ f] Q WV QPO J b e SUT«O p TRQ ] O \hfQ ] ^ ejSUTRQK«ORQ a TNe b S VWQ ] _ ] ^ ] a a 6¼TNKNY[SfO YrTRM VWQ M M%QPS\TO TRKNh TRhLK«YrSUT B fJ YrK p~9¡Y¬X\Q X fS QO b e TmJfY\O¡SUh ]] Q[ δB (X) = {p ∈ IR2 , Bp ∩ X 6= ∅} =. [. X−b =. [. ˇx B. # YuVWe ] YrTNYrTRe b SQkOT ] YTNKNY[SfOE b KRYrTRe b SVWhiY ] QIVLQ ] ^ PM K b O e b 3S de ] YZTNQK ] QSUT M K b VLQKmO b S ab %J ] M%QSUT«YrejKRQ X c b∈B. #º^ Q wTN] QSfORe b S] VL^ b Q. QSKNQ%J Y[½PYrSUT. a QTRTRQVWM%fSLeTRe b S u ]_^ PQ ORJfY a Q VWQPO b S a NT e b SfO ] ^ b J MK«YZTRQPhLK ∪ JiYrK JiMPNK YrTRQhfK sup . Bp. X. QkOTmMk\hfeXZY<D. IR2 → IR. QPO T [b RT QSwhLQ. x∈X. δB (X) = (B (X c ))c. #º^ MK b ORe b S/QT ] YVLe ] YZT«YZTRe b S O b SUT ] QPO KNejUhLQkOVWQ Y[ORQJ b hLK ] Y ab SiOTNKRh a TRe b S VWQ S b KNQhfORQPO TNKNY[SfO b KN%YrTRe b SfO b KNJL b\]b\ eqUhLQPOP c b hfO Y ]j]jb SfO?JLKNMPORQSUTNQK VLY[SfO ] YmO hLeTRQ a Q ]] QPOmV b SUTS b hiOmYrhLK b SfO QPO b ejST b hWTY[h ]jb S VLQPOmJLK bWa fYrejSfO a fY[JLe TNKRQkO ∀p ∈ IR2. ˇp } δB (f )(p) = {sup(f (x)), x ∈ B.

(86)

(87) !"$# &%'" ,-/.0-. 3. 1 69?; =E 8 6

(88) 8 D!8;. # YO Q %QSUTNYrTRe b SV ^ eY QPOºSLM a QPONO eTRQ ] YUhfY[S\TNe a YZTNe b SVWQPO"XZYrKNejYrTRe b SfOpVWQ ab S\TNKNY\OTNQ QS a fY[UhLQJ b eSUTmVWQ ] ^ eY QJ b hLK%QTRTRKNQdQPSMXweqVWQS a Q ] QPO ab SUT b hfKNO¿VWQPO b[ QTNO b h a QUhLe"KRQPXUejQSUTYrh/%Q

(89) KNQJ MKNQK ] QPO ?Pb SLQkO b b\ SfQPOIVWQ ] ^ ejY Q\ # Q KNY\VWejQSUT b KNJL b\]b\ eq\hfQ WVWM iSLe JfY[K QPh a LQK ab %%Q ] QVWe ] YZTRMI b ejSfO ] ^ MK b VLM[ S b hfO/ b hLKNSLeTohLSfQ%QPORhLKNQVWh b VWh ] QuVWh K«Y[VLeQPS\ToVWQ ] Y5 b S a RT e b S(6_O hfJLJ b O MPQ a b S D TRejS ? %QSUTVWe ! MPKRQPS a eqY f] Q:9 a] Y\ORORejUhLQP%QSUT¡VLMfSLe ab %%Q[ Γ(f ) = δB (f ) − B (f ).

(90)

(91)

(92) ~

(93)

(94) grad(f )

(95) =. #Q. ∂f ∂x. 2. +. . ∂f ∂y. 2 1/2. «K Y[VWejQSUT b KNJL b\]b\ eq\hfQY[ONORe SLQ a iY[UhLQuJ b eSUT ] Y J ] hfO K«YrSfVWQVWe ! MKNQS a Q QSUTNKRQ ] QPO ] hL%eSfY[S a QkOVWQ VWQPh J b ejSUTNOmVWQO b SX b ejOReSiY Q\ ,-/.0-. 132 6FE

(96) 6

(97) . S ^ b QPSiO T O eqJfVWY[MKOIb JSibO ON] O ^ eMP LK ]b QVWMoVWQ%VWQ KRM ]_a ^ QhLSiJ O MQPKN QK L]] Q ^ QPXSfO QPJf Yr LK ] ]Q%^ M e] SfMPue TNejQPY SU] Tm O TRb KN\h Qa SLTRSihLYrK«SUYrToSUT hfBSLQ VW` e S ] YrTNYZMTNSLe MPb KNS Y ] VWe Q ] ] ^ QPSfO QP L] QMPK b VWM\ "# ^ MPK b O e b S QPO ThLSLQ YrJLJ ] e a YZTNe b S/S b SejSZQ a TRejX[Q

(98) a[^ QkOTD D´VWejKNQ%UhLQ J ] hfOReQPhLKNOIQPSfORQ f] QkO 6 X, Y, ...9oJ QhfX[QSUTY¬X b ejK ] Q%QMK b VWM 6 X B 9 # Q%J ] hfO J QTReT QSfORQ L] QTNQ ] UhLQuO b S MK b VWMQkOT X B QPO TIY[JLJ Q ] M ] ^ b hLX[QPK TIVWQ X QTIe ] QkOT b[ TRQSwh QSVWe ] YrTNY[S\TO b S MK b VWM[ # Y ab eSfY[ejO b S MK b ORe b S ORhLejXUejQVWQVWe ] YrTNYZTNe b S QkOT b hLSLQ hfX[QKRTRhfKRQ

(99) « b. #ºJ ^ Bˇ QPO T L]_] ^ QSib O QP. X ◦ B = γB (X) = δBˇ (B (X)). L ] QITRK«YrSfORJ b ORMoVWQ B Bˇ = {−x / x ∈ B} #º^ Qb SihfOX[^ bQPQ KRTRhfKRQ Q hLX\b QKNKR^JLT Qkb\O]T]b\ hLeqSfUQhLQ O ej%QPO ^ JT ] e hL Sfa QYZTRbe b hfSX[QVWKRQ TRbhf] ^KRQPQSfO Y QP] b M L ] KNQ ejUejSLhLe^Q TNejYJf]Yr KRTRe ba h ] b eKNQ[ # Q TRQPKR%QV hLX[QPK TNhLKRQO Y[JLJ ejUhLQ V YrhWTNKRQkOITRK«YrSfO KNYZTNe SfO Uh hfSLQMK ORe SO hfeXwejQ V ^ hLSLQVLe ] YZT«YZTRe b S3¯ ] QS \]b\ Q¡T b hWTNQPO ] QkOpTRK«YrSiEO b KRYZTNe b SuUhLe X[MPKRe fQPS\T ] QPO"JLK b JLKNeMTRMkO Y ]j M KNejUhLQkOORhLejXZYrSUTRQkO b b a b ]] ]_^ a] b ^ L] QPOP • TRK«YrSfO KNYZTRe S K eqORONYrSUTRQ\ Q Q JLKNMPORQKNX[Q eS hfO e SV QSiO QP X ⊆ Y ⇒ (X ◦ B) ⊆ (Y ◦ B). •. •. TRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b S YrSUTRe D´Q wTRQPSfO ejX[Q\ ] QKRMkO h ] TNYrTQPO TeS a ] fh OVLY[SfO ] ^ PQ SfORQ f ] Q VWQ VWMJfY[K Tk TRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b SejVWQP%J b TRQSUTNQ[. X ◦B ⊆X. (X ◦ B) ◦ B = X ◦ B.

(100)

(101) !"$# &%'" ,-/.0-. 1@?6. 4. E 6

(102) .

(103) . ` S ejSwX[QK«ONYrSUT _] ^ b K«VWKNQ VLQPO b JiMPKNYrTRe b SfO?hWTNe ] eqO MPQPO J b hLK VWMfSfeK ] ^ b hLX\QKRTRhLKNQPS b hfO b[ TNQS b SfO hLSLQ S b hLX\Q ]j] Q b J MK«YZTNe b S ] Y' QPKR%QTNhLKNQ[ = (δ (X)) # bY aoQKN] uQTRhLKNQQkOT ]_^ a b JX] MK«•YZBTNe b =]_S ^ b φVWhfY (X) ] QVWQ ]_^ b hfX[QKRTRhfKRQ\ #º^ Q ! QTV ^ hfSLQ5 QPKR%QTNhLKNQ QPO TV S QI%QUhLQ Q hfe VWQ hfX[QKRTRhfKRQ

(104) UY[ejOmY[JLJ ] ejUhLMY[h ab %J ] M%QSUTNY[eKNQ[ ˇ B. B. B. # QkO¡JLK b JLKNeMTRMkOY ] M KNeq\hfQPO¡VWQ ] Y' QPKR%QTRhLKNQ O b S\Tk b b a b ]] ]_^ a] b ^ • TRK«YrSfO KNYZTRe S K eqORONYrSUTRQ\ Q Q JLKNMPORQKNX[Q eS hfO e SV QSiO QP (X c • B)c = X ◦ B. L] QPOP. Si X ⊆ Y, alors (X • B) ⊆ (Y • B). •. •. TRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b S%Q% UTNQSfORejX[Q[ ] ^ QPSfO QP L] QdVLQdVWMPJfYrKRT¿QkOTeS a] hiOVfYrSfO ] QdKRMkO h ] T«YZTP TRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b SejVWQP%J b TRQSUTNQ[. X ⊆X •B. (X • B) • B = X • B. ,-/.0-. . =E

(105) 6 6 E<? E9;!8=. . D2586FE

(106) 6. . . . E. . D!? 6. E 6

(107) .

(108) . #º^ b hfX[QKRTRhfKRQ¡V ^ hLS%QSfORQ L] Q JfY[KhfSuM ] MP%QSUT"OTNKRh a TRhfKNY[S\T QkOT ] YoORhLK|Y a QKNQ ab hD X[QPK TNQJfY[K B ]jb K«OVWQO b SVWMJ X] Y a Q%QSUT ]_^ ejS\TNMKNeQPhLKVWQ ]_^ QSiO BQP L] Q[ · SLQJLK b JfKRejMTNM ORe%e ] Y[eKNQdO ^ Y[JLJ ] ejUhLQ ] Y QKNuQTRhLKNQwYreqO a QT TRQ/ b eqO D a e ] ^ M ] MPuQPSUT¡O TRKNh a TNhLK«YrSUT¿JfY[K D ab hLKRT ] Q ab %J ] MP%QSUTNY[eKNQoVLQ ]_^ QSfORQ L] Q[ npYrK ab SfO TRKNh a TNe b S ]_^ b hLX\QKRTRhLKNQoQT ] Y QPKR%QTNhLKNQoKNQPORJ Q a TNQSUT ] QkOm\hiYZTRKNQoJLKRejS a eJ QPO VWQT b hLTRQdTRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b S% b KNJL b\]b\ eqUhLQ[ ejSwXZYrKNejY[S a QJiYrKºTNKNY[SfO ] YrTRe b S ab uJiYZTRe e ] D eTRMY¬X[Q a] QPO¡ b b TNLMTNeQk%O ab SLSiYreqORONYrS a Q ]jbWa Y ] QIQT ab SUTRejSwhLe TNM[ ,-/.0-

(109). 1 :. ?. ?. . ?. . E 806. E<8 ? E. . # Q a fYrJ QPY[huiYrhWT¿VLQ b KN%QQPO T"hLSLQTRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b S%UhLefJ QKN%QT¡VWQVWMTRQ a TRQPK a QUhLQ ] ^ b Lh X[QPK TNhLKRQ86 a fY[JiQkYrh L] Y[S a 9 b h ] Y QKN%QTNhLKRQ 6 a iYrJ QPYrhS b ejK 9 b SUT$|YreTºVWejORJfY[KNY<;jTNKRQ\ ` T«YrSUTºV b SLSfM"hLSuM ] M%QSUTpOTNKRh a TRhfKNY[S\T B b SVWM%fSLeT Y[eSiO e ] Q a fY[JiQkYrhiYrhWTºVWQ b KN%Q V ^ hLSLQ b S a TNe b S f JfYrKk chapeau blanc : W T HB (f ) = f − γB (f ) chapeau noir : BT HB (f ) = φB (f ) − f.

(110)

(111) !"$# &%'". . . &)( 9,% .5("( %D!0 9*+-. ( 14) / 4)(,+ ; &)( b SUTNKNY[eKNQ%QSUTY[h TNKNY[SfO b KN%YrTRe b SfOQh a] eqVWejQSLSLQkOdUhLeY ejONO QPSUTdO hfK ] ^ QPSfO QP L] QVWQ ] ^ ejY Q

(112) ] QkO TRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b SiO M b VWMPORejUhLQkO3SfQO ^ Y[JLJ ] ejUhLQPSUT Uh ^ ] ^ ejSUTRMPKRejQhLKpVWQ ?b SLQPO JLKNMPVWMTRQPKR%ejSLMQkO% YrJLJ Q ] MQkO Y[ON\hfQPO M b VWMPOReq\hfQPOPejSfORe VLYrSiOIT b hWTRQ%TNKNY[SfOE b KRY"D TRe b S M b VWMkO eqUhLQ eSUTRQPKRXwejQSLSfQSUT3VWQh=d ej%Y QkO ] ^ ejY Q TNKNY[SfO b KNuQPK X QT ] QpY[ON\hfQ M b VWMPORejUhLQ M gwhLJfJ b O b SfOpUhLQ¡S b hfOpTRK«Y¬X¬Y[e ]j]jb SfOQS ab SLSLQ%W e TNM 1 ar^ QPO T >D Y<>D VWejKRQ

(113) ] QmX b eqO ejSfY Q¡V ^ hfS JLe W Q ] |6 e 9 QPO TP . . n b hLKKNQPO TRKNQejSfVWKNQ ] ^ Y a TRe b S VWQ ] YTRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b SY[hY[ONUhLQ M b VWMkO eqUhLQ ] Y ab SD SLQ% weTRM\hfe O ^ Y[JLJ ] ejUhLQ a iY[UhLQ JLe WQ ] S ^ QkOTJiY[O V4 (i, j) %Y[ejO V4 (i, j) ∩ M ar^ QPO T D D>VWejKRQ%Uh ^ hLS/JLe WQ ] S ^ Y[JLJfY[K TNQSfY[S\T JfY\OIYrh %Y\ORUhLQ%SLQORQK«Y JfY[O ab SfORejVWMPKRM ab %%Q X b ejORejSV ^ Yrh a hLSJLe wQ ] ¿QPOTRK«YrSfO b KNYZTNe b SfOO b SUT ] Y Y[ORQ VWQkO b JiMPKNYrTRe b SfO ] QkOJ ] hfO JiQPK b KRYrSUTNQPO ab %uQIJfY[KmQ WQ%J ] Q ] YKNQ ab SfO TRKNh a TRe b S V4 (i, j) = {(i − 1, j), (i, j − 1), (i + 1, j), (i, j + 1)}. ,->,-/.. 1@? ;/D/?"EF? E9;!8 = . 8

(114) z xPz'

(115) . 8. . ": ; . . I. 3± ¦Z¥±r©´±r©_¥|³r¨ #U¢«³P¦\¢¤£¤¥µf§/¦[§ ´© ±r¥§ ¦\§ §¨L£§» § X ¦[±r¨L£ § »±¬£µf§ M º ¨ ³r©´¢«§ δM(1) (X) ¿ §¤£¤©¦\¢ "¨f¥|§ «³Z»u»%§ ¥¼¨f©>§ «£§ ©_¥|³r¨ ¦rµ ¦Z¥±r©´¢%¦[§©>±Z¥§ . §©¦[§. M. (1). (1). ³

(116) 5C §£«© § ³r¥q£«¥¼¨?± #U§¦ ±\¦± «§¨ «§²f³ZµW ± N³r¨f¨?§ ¹ ¥¼©>¢ ³r¥q£«¥|§ # Y VWe ] YZT«YZTNe b S M b VWMkO eqUhLQVWQTNYre ]j] QS VWQ ] ^ QPSfO QP L] Q X ab SfVWeTRe b SfSLMQY[hY[ON\hfQ b[ TNQSwhLQIQSe TNMK«YrSUT n b ejO ] YVWe ] YrTNYZTNe b S M b VWMkO eqUhLQoVLQITNYre ]j] Q (n) M δM (X) fQPO T δM (X) = (δB ) ∩ M. (n). (1). (1). (1). δM (X) = δM (δM (...δM (X))) | {z } nf ois. PQ %Y[KNUh b SfOUhLQ ] YVWe ] YZT«YZTNe b S M b VLMPORejUhLQVLQTNY[e ]j] Q ] YuVLe ] YZT«YZTRe b S b KNJL b\]b\ eq\hfQoVWQIT«Yre ]] Q n Y¬X\Q a M . n. (n). S ^ QPO TdJfY\O ] ^ e SUTRQPKNORQ a TRe b SVWQ. b %%Q ab SUTRKNQ D´Q WQ%J ] Q S b hfO J b hLX b SfO?eY ejSLQK hLS QPSfORQ f] Q b KN%MºVWQpJ ] hfO ejQhfKNO ab %J b ORY[S\TNQPO ab SLSLQ% WQPO3V b SUT ] ^ hfSLQQPO T ] ^ QPSfO QP L] Q X # YVWe M] YZT«YZTNe b S M b VWMPOReq\hfQ VWQS ^ e%J b KRTRQUhLQ ]j] Q T«Yre ]] QVWQ X VLY[SfO M ORQK«YT b hZ b hLK«O ] Y ab uJ b ONYrSUTNQejSLe TNejY ] Q 6J ] Q^ QhWSfT ORaQb SU LTR]QPQSL8eK9 VLT«QPYrO¡SfJfVLY[ejO¿K TN\eQkhfOmQ V ]_^ ^ ejY[S\hWTNTRQKNK«QPO OQ a aTNb e b%SJ VWb Q ONYr] SUYTRVWQkOe ] YraTNb YZSLTNSfe b QS WQPVWOPQm T«Yre ]] Q n VWQ X Y¬X\Q a M #º^ Q wTNQSfORe b S VWQ a QT TNQTRK«YrSfO b KNYZTNe b S J b hLK ] QkOej%Y QkO TRQPeSUTNQPOVLQ KNejO%QkOT VWejKRQ a TNQ[ # YVLe ] YZT«YZTRe b S M b VWMkO eqUhLQVWQ ] 3Y b S a TRe b S f VLY[SfO ] Y b S a TNe b SY[ON\hfQ g QkOT VWM%fSLejQVWQ ] Y |Y\½ b SORhLeXZY[S\TNQ[ δM (X) 6= (δ n (X)) ∩ M. δg1 (f ) = inf (δ(f ), g) δgn+1 = inf (δ(δgn (f )), g).

(117)

(118) !"$# &%'" ,->,->,. 132547698 :<;!8=. . 8. . . :<;. !6 . . #ºb ^ MK b ORe b S M bb VWMkO eqb UhLQ] QPO T ] Y TRK«YrSi OE b KRYZTNe b S VWhiY ] QVLQ g S Q%w JfKRQkORORe SJ hLK QkO¡eY QPO ejSfY[eKNQPOQPO TP. ] Y/VWe ] YrTNYrTRe b S M b VWMkO eqUhLQ[. n nM (X) = M − δM (M − X). QTJ b hfK ] QkO¡eY QPO TRQPeSUTNQPOVWQ KReqO ,->,-. . 1@?. n ng (X) = −δ−g (−f ) . 8=: EF6. . +E9;!8= . pn YrK ab SfO TRKNh a TRe b S ] QpKNMPORh ] TNYZT3VLQ ] YmVLe ] YZT«YZTRe b S M b VWMPOReq\hfQQkOT ejS a] hfO VLYrSiO ] QºY\ORUhLQ\ npYrKY[e ]j] QPhLK«O% ] Y%VWe ] YZT«YZTNe b S QkOThLSfQ b JiMPKNYrTRe b SQ wTRQPSfOReX\Q[p b S a JfYrKRTRejKmV ^ hLSLQ a QPK D TNY[eSfQeTRMK«YZTNe b S ] YVWe ] YrTNYrTRe b S M b VWMPORejUhLQSLQ b VWe fQJiY[O ]_^ eY Q[ # Y O hLeTRQuVWQVLeD ] YZTNYrTRe b SfO M b VLMPORejUhLQkOºVWQmT«Yre ]] Q a K b eqONORY[S\TNQ36 δ(n) 9 ab SwX[QK Q¡X\QK«OphLSLQdeY QYrJfJiQ ] MPQ ej%Y QKNQ ab SfO TRKNhLeTRQ[ # YKNQ ab SfO TRKNh a TNe b S VLQ MX 6|YrK«\hfQhLK 9 ab SfVWeTRe b SLSLQ ]] Q%QPS\T ] ] b b ^ eqVWQ%J b TRQPS a Q\ M 6|# Y[ON\hf,Q ] 9QPO T Y] VLe YZaT«b YZTRe S a M b VWMPORejUhLQIVW] Q a X VL YrSiO M hfON\] h ^ QKRMkO h TNYrTdVWQ YKNQ SfO TRKNh TRe SVLY[SfO Q Y\O ejSfY[eKNQQPO T QSfORQ L] QuVWQPO ab D bJ ONYrSUTRQkO ab SLSLQ WQkO"VWhY\ORUhLQUhLe ab hLJiQPSUT ]_^ QSiO QP L] QVWQoVWMJfY[K T \Q ]] QKNQ ab SfO TRKNhLeT ] QPO¡JfY[K TNe a h ] QkOmVWQ M UhLe O b S\TmYrK«UhLMQkOJfYrK X oYrSfO ] Q a Y\OpSwhL%MKNejUhL

(119) Q ] YIKRQ ab SiOTNKRh a TRe b S%VWQ f VLYrSfO g Y ab %%QORQh ] Op<Y Wej%Y ] QPO¡JLe a OVLQ g \hfe O b S\T marqués JfYrK f c b hfO¡X[QPKRK b SiO¿J ] hfO ]b eSUhLQ a QT TNQITRK«YrSfO b KNYZTRe b S S b hiOmJiQPKR%QT TRK«Y%VWQ a fY[S QPK ] ^ b b T b JLejQ VWQ ] ^ ejY Q K«Y[VWejQSUTJ b hLK ] hLeue%J b ORQK ] QPO Q wTRKNQY O b hLiYreTRMPO QT M ] ejuejSLQPKYrejSfO e ] Y/O hfKNORQ uQPSUTNYZTNe b S QS QSiVWKRMPQ ]b KNO%V ^ hLSLQY[JLJ ] e a YZTRe b S VWejKRQ a TRQVWQ ] ^ Y ]\b KNe TNL%QVWQ ] e SLQVWQJfYrKRTNY QVWQkOQPY[h ` S b hWTRKNQ a QT TRQTRK«YrSfO b KNYZTNe b S QkOT ] Y Y[ORQVWQkO ] TRKNQPO ab SLSfQ WQPOmUhLe S b hfOJiQPKR%QT TRK b SUTVWQO ej%J ] e fQPK ] ^ ejY QONYrSiOVWM D K«Y[VLQK ] Q ab SUT b hLK, ab SfVWeTRe b S SLM a QPONORY[eKNQJ b hLK¡Y b hLTRejK hLSLQ ib SLSLQoO Q %QSUTNYrTRe b S . !. . . + 9,% &)( .5. & < &)( . oYrSfO ] YORQ a TRe b SJfKRM a MPVLQSUTRQoS b hiOY¬X b SfO"XwhUhLQ ] QkO ab ejSfYreqO b SfOV ^ MPK b O e b SiO"QT¡VWQ VWe ] YrTNYrTRe b SfO ab SfO TReTRhLQPSUT"VWQPO ] TNKRQkOp b KNJL b[]jb[ ejUhLQkO6 b hfX[QKRTRhfKRQkO QT QKN%QTNhLKRQkO 9UhLe M ] ejuejSLQPS\T ] QPO ab %J b ORY[SUTRQPO ab SLSLQ% wQkO VWQTNYre ]j] Q¡ejS MKNeQPhLKNQ oa Q ]] QmVWQ ]_^ M ] M%QPS\TºO TRKNh a D TRhfKNY[S\Tk # QPO b hfX[QKRTRhfKRQkOºQT QKN%QTRhfKRQkO"J QhLX\QSUTmYrhfONO e TNKRQ ab ejSLMQkO"J b hfK b\ TRQPSLeK VWQkO ] TRKNQPOdJ ] hfOoMX b[] hLMPOP ¿QPJiQPSfVLYrSUToT b hfO ] QPO ] TRKNQPO ab SfOTNKRhfe T«OdVWQ a QT TRQuYrSLeKNQ QS' P%QTNQ%JfO\h ^ e ] O¿M ] ejuejSLQPS\T ] QkO"J QTNe TNQPO ab %J b ORY[S\TNQPO\VWM K«Y[VWQPSUT ] QkO ab SUT b hLK«O VWQkO b[ QTNO KNQPO TNY[SUTNOP #º^ ejS\TNK b VWh a TRe b SVWQ ] YKNQ ab SfO TRKNh a TNe b S V b SLSLQhfSLQVWej%QSfORe b S ] ] b b[]jb[ ]^ ] b ab b ejORSfhL] TRY JLKN]mJ MQkM%O K % a] QQPQ SUO T« b\Yr ej]KRY QQT«Y[KRO¡Qh aQb S SfaTRObK«TNYKNKRQdh QJfa TRKRe Mkb O S3QPKRS\JfT« Om¿YrQJLT TR K QejPUO hLeqVW]Q\Q MP 7Q ] TRJfhWK«K TY k O eQISUTNKNM K Qb TNej%VWK bhLehLSfeTRX[YrQQPTRS\e QPT S S] QVWkhL QkK O ab SU%T bJ ´hLK ONYrYrb JfSUKNTRK e QkkOOD hLSLQMK b ORe b S ] QPO ab %J b ORY[S\TNQPOuUhLemS ^ Y¬X¬Y[eQPSUTJfY\O ab %J ] TNQ%QSUTVWejORJfY[KRh MTNY[eQPSUT hWTNe ] ejORMQkO ab %uQY[KNUhLQPhLKNO%J b hfKKRQ ab SfOTNKRhfeKNQ ] QPOJfYrKRTRe a h ] QPO b KRe ejSfY ] QkO ¿QT TRQ b J MK«YZTNe b S fY[JLJiQ ] MPQ b hfX[QKRTRhfKRQ JfY[KKNQ ab SfO TRKNh a TNe b S LQPO T ] QJLe b SLSfeQPKdVWQkO ] TRKNQPO ab S D SL%Q wQkO4 ¿QkO ] TRKNQPOJ b ONO kVWQSUT¡V ^ %Q a Q ]j] QSUTRQkO¿J QK b KNYrS a QPO¿\hfe?O b SUT ] ^ b KRe ejSLQoV ^ hfS ejuJ b KRTNY[SUTmVLMX[Q ]b JLJ Q%QSUTVWhTRK«YreTRQPuQPSUTV ^ ejY QPOP b %%QSi½ b SiOdJiYrKVWM a KNeKNQ ] Q a Y[O ejSfYrejKNQ[ ª b hWTORQuJiY[ONO Q ab %uQORe ] QPO ] TRKNQPO ab SLSL%Q wQkO ab SfORej=V KNQSUT a fY\\hfQ ab uJ b ONYrSUTNQ ab SLSLQ WQ eSfVLeXweqVWhLQ ]j] Q%QSUTP ¿fY\\hfQ. 3 6.

(120)

(121) !"$# &%'". \. a b %J b ORY[S\TNQ ab SLSLQ% wQ 6|O b eTuVWQ ] ^ QPSfO QP L] Q X ºO b e T%VWQO b S ab %J ] M%QPS\T«YrejKRQ X c 9 QPO TuO b eTJfKRMkO QPKRX\MQejS\TNM KNY ] QPuQPSUTpO b e T ab uJ ] TRQ%QPS\T%Q ! Y a MQ\ # QkO ab %J b ONYrSUTRQkO ab SLSLQ% wQkO O b SUTV b S a VWQkO JfY[K TNe a h ] QkOIeSiVWeXweqO e L] QPOP7¿QT TRQ a YrK«Y a TRMKNeqOTNejUhLQ%Y[ONO hfKRQ ] Y ab SfORQKNX¬YrTRe b SVWh ab SUT b hLKmVWQkO b[ QTNOmUhLe b S\TORhLKNX[M a h Y[h ] TNKNY Q[ z xPz ³r¥¼© E µW¨ §¨f£§» I §u§© P (E) ¹ §¨L£§» I §%¦[§£o£³rµw£ ! §¨L£§» I §£¦[§ ¨ N ³ f ² ¢ R Z ± > © § W µ E (E) → P (E) §£¤© «³r¨f¨ § § µf±r¨ ¦ ∀A ⊆ E¹ ±/¦Z¥ d¢ R§¨ «§ £ Z»%¢© ¤¥ µf§§¨f© R§ AΨ§ P© Ψ(A) §£«©pµW¨?§dµW¨f¥|³Z¨¦\§ «³Z»²L³Z£±r¨f©>§¤£ «³Z¨f¨?§ §£o¦[§ A ³rµ¦\§. 8

(122) '