The existential dialectic of Soren Kierkegaard

" i U f t I ' ' - ~ , " , , ' ",2\<£),. ~ .;. -, . . .

,Gli _ 'Y~t'IA, '" '11'U~'4't9~a

o •

.wa¥~ V~ • • Yai;J,~

II ,'A" ,At, PO,' ttL . . " O'ftE iB-QJ1IJtSftUT8

roB SIDmDE 01' OOaf' OF 'SrLOSOPIY

ax

'JlALPII _ll~l,tUfJf II. '4. ( uat ....

lt'

ot

K1Dae ..

_).'b. L.

(LaYal UDi •••• '.,)

-

.

1.

ror\_ •• , a.usa

ao014.M 1ft: !11aq~i.

fl\St8 . . UD4Ufl propoal;tma propter

t1nea

1,n

alne:rl

",e.

2. 1\.l81il1ila, lqM118 •• ~ Y'ir'us ~111e 'J):ti.rretlta.

). 1~rlDo1p1a 8111os1amorUtiper'feot0r11118UI:lt (luo,

"111e.'

4101,4. OIUl1.

at

41014.

nullo.

4. :',. ••

,rooe4enl!,11,.D

4;o.ra8"ratlvla ••

t r ••

o-luwrlu.

, . P(811)10 Carll •• ,11 , . &oQ,tl1s1~loa.·\fl,rtut1.'

I1Ore118 0011,\"4101" Y8rl'.' . . quett yl:r' . .

. . m i . f 1 t i .

eoa •• (1)udiae.

•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••

1.

_•

_{•••••••••••••••••••}

~N.th

_{••••••••••••••••••••}

pqe 1

?

1.

2.,.1 8Dl'rovldeaoe ••••••••••••••••••••••

1

I. _ . 1.' •• 'S81 178' •• IIJ,pO •• lbl.. •••••••••• I I

,. aoueh-

aJltt

It.s;1atefioe ... 26

III.

D.

,Aft *fWO, COMm1t1ICAT' '}

"hap . . .

I.

~1

• • •

1

o.

_{••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••}

1.

, . A

•• ttt.,10 "

... .

I. ... . a'h1 ••

1Sphe.. • ... .

,. 4Cr1'\\leal

Note •••••••••••••••••••••••••••

)9

64

89

90

"

99

1'%..

,~. !.file ftel1g1otll ... .,...

.105

Ill.

'a1'_

8D4tbe

A"I\I1'4 •••••••••••••••••••••••••

1.

I.

,.

1011

of HU4en,lDwarbell •••••••••••••

.

••...

~

...•...

'ree •••

~

_{•••••••••••}

'Alf ft8. . I D1UDUTIOII

or

1lIDlllBC'f COMMUNICATIOH C • • , ••

I.

'114

115

119

11,

1

lX.

Conolutl.S.-J7 ••••••••••••••••••••••••••

137

IOTIS ...

152

III' ...

170-•

-

-.

..'

P' ... , ·.: .... ','1'4.' ~ , - ". - . A. q.1" . . . 1. p.ae4 . . . ' ... . ... • ' 1 ...

1·14 ... . .

bli_,. ,4 ... 1"'· . . . , lD

-

'.

~l~

.•

~O.1J_41.1

••••

1

&11 •• opl.1 . . . .

,...M"'l't ...

~

AltllouP , .

t·.

,Be

p..,..

POle

ot

.184 . . , .

01'1...

.beN i an .1 . . . wit . . . wl . . . pau •• 8Il4 oOD.i4 ...

'-.'M.

lapo._

0"4 . . . . '

DO' .

..a

18. 41.'01"108

ot

tbe

pro'bl.,.

a.

h&DA,.I . . . 1. 'hla . , . . , . . . , . . . beD

, . 4,1 ... 1ple ot I •• 'Illoaa. (wl'h at 1 .... a 'Dorrowe4 ,,184011)

__hi, ,." ..

'108

to

.he

'bo\lIll'

aa4

'.,.'e..

of ao481'11

pt.!,l . . . ,.,:.. la 'b . . . ' of _ k 'P"\tl.' •• arKl balt-tl'Uthll

_loll

MY. t •• •• 1 _ , . . . . . t •• l"~'l

. .

t. pbllo.opn,loal

..

ta. _ .., . . .

1,-

..,111 • . . , aM

pe, ...

,.,l'b •• 11.f , . flO ...

....

l'4las

tle14.. It

II

.0 lJ.

ao'e4 . .

,

fRIO. a

reao'loa

1 •

. .

, •••••••

11' . . .

, ....

1.'.

_-

,n.

pa."

tbe

t . .

th1.

Sit

"17

,

._11 ... , . ' .•

J'

.t

1\1_.17.

aere

1,a, ho ... 80 ...

.... b1.81"',..'1... .-" . . .

pllll.'MPhf 1.· 81ap17

a tao, . .

4 ,

l '

ott . . . .

1II1tl , • • • , qlM.'l . . . _ A.Qt. R10b the , ...

1 . . . .

or

,,184 •• will , . . 1 1ae . . . . l ' 'APawla&

hi.,

he will

_ • • • . Oh&11 _ _ _ IO:}l btl _ , . . .

to.

r ... •••

10 , . b1.

ea11iq. I'

1e

tor __ • ...

'ha'

tlle p •••

1 . . •

tor1

'1081

-11 .•

IF • •

1.111 . . .

·

. f P"".'l~ tl\e . . . •

,t

,he

tol1ow-,

'- • ..,.t

Kl . . . .

...a

l\ee fa . . . wha' , . . .

pa-ob-1 . . . 1f01I14 . . . &4 . . . pllilolO'....· _1 .. t, . . . ft.

'0 ... ,.

· " . f • • DaDl." ''', • • • wlth "bat

.t

A. : " ' . , Wllraa . . la' • • •

a ...

\)7 -bleh he

..-14 . . . " Xl . .

_tJ86P4

f . . . . 'h.

11&,

ae.e.a1

, - ... ..4

'be

tla4lD.1 . f

.wa, ,.

0U'I7 . . , 'hl. plAII

... _Ik ... ' ••

1&.4 UpoII, '8

tao, . . .

18 . . .

. .

l . . .

t

11._111'1 ••

8&. _ _ ... -.111_ . . "' . . . , . aplaa'

1'.

BIt. let . . .

lae.

t • • •

t

'-he

pe ••

'lJl • ..,..

of o •

..,1D&

011' .... ...••

a.·

to . . .

,la" . .

.tittloal" •• , ... 84.

IIle . .

ltlas-

of

uW.,...a

p . . . ' ••

""II.

pe.'

a • . ,

41.,. •• -. p . . bl....0\W1 . . .

1' ,_.,' ...

Goula 0: ...

a_

. . .

_ _

18 . . .

, . . .

f

.he.

1a • •

'.10' •

. . 1 . . ' l t l . _ . . . '. WfJUlA . . a ... , &D4 tl'\al'tul

. . ft, . ,

1'\

18 'tN'tI,tul , . , tt 001114 pa ••

IM'-' . . .

1.

" ' " .t . . . .

,.,..a ..

'"

.t . . . .

prottl ••• aM ••• .,.oull . .

SO

Ill..

ftwI.. • . . . WO\lld . . . . , .

1M ltllle4 • • • , ...

_ , of • al ••• p .... l: •• wl'k l1Iel4. •• W . . t .... 08 • •

1t1.-"8-,

-

.

...

·..Ia.;, ...

aGal

wou14 . . . b ••• abaD4oatMl •

. ,'

ao,."

pes.l11111,,, _14 •••

14 •• la

'e'

•• '

lRl'

1.

110

tOl-.14-a'D1e: - _ _ _ 1140

1111

'JuI'

l ' . . . 14

e.e ..

ax _.

plWltloal ••

1-, _ 1

•• . ,

a

408 . . . . 1

41 .... '.'1...

I' eCN14

u.

the

tOPli .

. , 8ft

sa ••

llaea . . . , . . , . . . b

.t

Kl •• " • • • Jt4

t.

work •

•• t,M 1 ••• 1 . . . . t1, • • 1 . . . . 1le4 toU..-l _,

a, . .,....

1D

out-- i l l ..

,

·",." .• 10.'" . .

1 . . .

1oa"

11148 ....

• , ... • t , _ work . . . . _____ OIl

sa

'M. ... 'fbla

la

4eIlleA ••

to • . . .

-...1

to

.8'

11 •• I1....,.laa

11t-...

, ot , ____ . . .

,lIe4',.

p_ • ..,.. •• 4 40

.. ,

,..,.. •. . . '*

of, &l •• k.~. A' 'hi.

POD' we . .

'-1111.

laaa . . , . , baekwar& ~

at

0tW

.011 . . . el . .

,..s

to tpo . . ,be . _ . . . . ADA , . , WbeN

'8

a , •••

ibUt,,,

. f

aebl •• _

'be

aeal ..

, •••

Kkrll • • • N ... 1.··· )11 . . . , ___ ••

'-he

We4 •• , . f •

... . : .... , . . 1 . of , . " . . . . Il

va ...

, .

_"h ..

he other.

ia . . . k . . .

te '"' ...

&.1 •••

81,...

'ftfa

,..-10111 . .

• ut·lBl

.t

.-ok . . JIlt . . . ll .h •• , . . . .

'.'.W

1'. _ha . .

•• , • • ,' " a1'- .·.1 . . Bleil -l . . lI. . ... _H4 'he .. atI ••

'0

... :. It 1. p".1 . . 1~ '111.

b _ _

.,.att

....

whlob 1 . . .

h0s-t.

·tlle po ••

l"ttl'"

ot ..

tat.17

G . . . . b: . . . 1WJ .-1111.-.

to.·

1t

we

ea.

11114 . . . . _.al . . . . PllDft_ b~

'.be" •••

k . . . wod4 . . . e··' ..• polat at

'acaun-loh wou14 ...

1 •••

lie . . ., . . . ' i •• ot _ . . .

1 ••

v.

t'lMINoh a 1mreaA lathe

. .

" . .

' . t

lMl . . . .

o _ _

i . . " ...

• a . . 8ha11...~ la.i.," ' __ What

a

pePHD

.

-

.

• ow.

1. lIIl1.,. . . ,. t".

_t'18

.vae

a.~;

_{• •}

hAt &lakel hla

_., . . la.as., • •

, ••

." •• latl

. . .

'loa

1ft _elt a . . ,

, ".l'ewou14 1M) • allli_ of :foo4 to. 'h01l8btln

w.'

he

_41.

__

,_ita 10818&117

lab,l.

,..011 . .

1i04.

ot

oo_loa-t:loa.%'

1:8 J:~.Jfk.p.l'4bl . . .

ltt ...

,Wh. ____

1 •••

-1 . . .

,

Dl. 1I04.0t 00 _ _

lca.1ea.10b

Kl •• kepa1'4

oaU.

bl41reo'

·18 , . t l •• ' aa4

a l a i

'lttled',

ill tm4 •••

Mm4l11a wha.

be

._ .. 1', ...

'_MUla

. 7

.r

1I1 . . .

1f t

-1_1 . . .

"

00_1.a-tl

. . . . , ••

t-.1

Cl\taut1 . . 1;1 ... · ' 884 hct _.,10", 1.

w1'"

_.-t ... ,

WIll.h .1.

a1 ...

'.1" . . .

1_

ana

e"lIP8rat11c.

It ...

..'el1 . .

14 , ... , . . . .

,.~t

of

I:l ...

keput4 baa

l I _ ....

8".,., ..

t1 . . 117

tpe..a

(althOUIb eo,' OO_D,.tOI'8

'. , . , . lip

....n.. ..

1', 'l1aa 1*'1 . . . , . . .

l •• 'leu.

It 1. _he

... I I , b . " , . . . b Itt.: .. '

weN

tlper . . . ·•

4 ••

1 •••

t ...

4 . .

,.,10 .,0,

10 . . .

b tl_

\he 0. . . 41tt ... . . . Ir he 11I ___ to PM'NIl' ••

w,th_the •. , .

...

aDd.

tbere a ... _ , ...

te. .

It 1.

to.

'bi-. . . , . _

we ...

, _ _

'1 . . . b ."S-1 __ 1D1

'0

11ene-paN , _ .81'1".,081'1 ••• p . . . . , , . hi • ..." booke •

. 'c'.

118u..4, . . .

, Ill.' _

UIiti •••

to04

betoN

all el . . ""

,he

.. '

_.h

weN

.he 41tt10\11'1 ••

wh1."

lIItlue1lH4 the

IN-l ..

'

UC1

e.,.

ot .be

to11 . . 1_

.'fl".,

Aa4..·18.e ...

r,. oholoe

. . tall . . . . 1"81 . . ,

1

t

'le . .

'aurprla_

tha'

ou...

....ltloe.

81 • • _'. wblob . . . , . . . _

'Dr

'hell' ."'...

sal

1·

· ¥

-ell' •.

'._18

tbe

alllO.'

to ••

1 la.1e

of ..

8.1e.t1rla

ft~~lft· -'i.4\tM'

lDour

ddF

. o P e l . r

tollew.a I,.

sbA'

of 1.1 ••

11-...

".~

and 1'-

40el

aot

pJ'O . . .

4 ,...

'h~

more_own

'0

ua

to

,he

le..

DO",

except

1a , _ HIlS.

'bat

,1\.

·M1·.to ••

17

t),Q

ale.

lqo1ala.

to be

110..

lmowa.fte

.ery· . . .

of

&lenepar4t. end p •• elu4a4 thl.

ft.'ural.

:ppoo., •• , to!' he . . .

Dot. 80 he thoupt·, p . . . cm'~t1t

a

40etrlaet hi.

-Jot"

lntent

.... to 180.8 'be 11111

anlrtt

he o0tl14 ••• oapl11b tht:1 by

epee-alatlYe ~1l:t" •• 1.h he 4iel ··DOt

a ••

l ' . . .

'0

4.0 80. A

4t.,1ao-tlOB 11 oa11e4

to.

If . "ell \0

,..'lt1

OU. 0tII1 laok of 01'4 •••

Bet ... II 40(1).18.,1 , . . _ t a ' l . . of •

tl\tt.ll

atteapM4.

0 . . flU8,.ualBe

1)heub'

•••

1 .... ,

to

It,-

.tor

-,ul

debet

au-41 . . phllo.. 181£, . . 11"8 . . haH . . 1ft ludloc40 81 a,,41.l'lt

. O1ItHta 1' • •

1__

qu •• 1

.4ve"aa.lorua

4.12'1 ••

"'1 .... '..

ftaa. the

J)POpa,14eutlo,ott • • • ),7 a 41, "utatl98

all"

dlal •• tical

00;0814-e . . ttoap1aY8 1m • • • •

Btl.1.&1.

m

_he ' ••

oblDc

of

tJ-Uth

arut I

tb..

8tu41 of WU*loua

ph1lo.o,hara

1. tbe b •• , ....

e of

brllll-1Da

'hl. 41al.,.t1·0 lato pl81. Gtt a at\l41 .baul4 Dot be a , 08.all ••

cr.., ... ,

18

top

al,

••

1 ••

)'MPpO •••

J

it

1.'

DO' aft e1l4 1n 1 ... 1t ( 'he 'houp. ot M1·phl1olopl1e. 1.

1m-))o"aa, . .

l, 1.

'he

4' .' . .

that l '

".tap

UI '0

the

tNth) •

. ,'

torett.JmdaJPe

OUJ'

a4 ...

1ea.

Iaoh

'blue

.. baa ..

00.,.lb1lt1.11

to matce,em4 l ' ls

t1"_

,bat

we

ugftl'etul

to

each

ot

tile.,

.".n'

•••

no

~lY. U8

fIOre .pro.

'han,

trtl'b.'

Theretore.

&1-thouCh 'hi. MU4,

ot

li

••

It.pard

1.

!lOt

..018.t1t10 'PNND"

..

Oft'lque8 81ob; MY • • ealD . . ptet •• 81\11 . . lDteM'al •

• . , " ' . . . 8.0' 1.",*,e4 , . take the

plao.

of

,bat "'

. . . .

woPltJ

""I"

'he, . . . to . .

1.'. ,_

Kl ••

ke.

10

lI\teh ,...,.10". ...

M..

n14. al\o\ll4 ".'b 1fU'D. 'h . . . d •• _1 •• ' •• ld., ,more 'MD. 18 o,oate.;lJle4 1ft

'h.

8\1" ••

41""',

' •

f

au(l

lD41oa..

that the

a"ther ... ...

or

t h e l P 1

tro., •

"le.'ltl0 Yl •

.,.1Bl.

The ..• , ... , it •• 1t fall, • • • ' •••• ,..,.. The

tip.,

p ....

-. -. -. -. -. 1-.a

pae.al

w.,

ttl.

'Mo.,

of lll4Sreot

e,o_loat-loa,

at

• •

~

• ...,

·a«_rte.

'a.,

'we

1e •

bJtl.t _ ,

eoap ....

hen.ly. ',...

of Xl.,. ."

t.

11 ••

of

b1 . . .

'bOd.

TIle

ti-Dal pap, ooa81c! ••• ,be·

,·IlIme'.

la' •••• 1',*·418'1 . .

or

IDdl ..

eo'

. a_loatlea,.18

Pea... t..

401ac •• 8114

.he

11,,110at1011.

\lb.l. haa top h18

weft.

"0111'.

*18 . " . .,..1.1 1 ...

'

18

11erke,aa'" ...

hla ..

'88"''''

ot,,.

. .

l . ' l •• ,,,.. .'. h.le 4.tlal't •.

ot

t.1,11

111 . . .

of

a'blNl'tlltF . . . hl_ G • • •

aq"eatatim4

'ha'

tneoloar

18 .•

.1M111« ....

'aa4bS. , . . . .

. .

4oo'.1It..

,,,1'.

18 Ire.plac

. .,1.11

b,l.

yol1111 __

.l.t.lo

- - , 1 •• , ad Vb •• h..

ae.'1 ...

ap.

pea . .

to

4eB7 Ill. 4.mla18. _. we ... _{. --,} , , . . . .

e.

'a' ..

1 • •

.... , ..-poet ...

lui til .... ee4 lD ··'IM1'18 alli . . . .

'1-.

,

tal"",

11 . . ' 41el-" lit pro ••• bl. 91llpPl.' .

..

" OJr IIDIll

...

,

..

' . , ·V·, ' . . . .

4,., ••

1'4.- ...

well

Gal.ula"

'0

la410ate

'bal . . . .

_~cl.

to • ...

1,4 . . .

'.lal,

tall .llO~

of_1',.

~ it trcJ1'4a

,.Glrler • • •

'h' '" . . . . 1\.bla -thlm •. Mlr

'ttJU'.

real-1_{' , . ,}

*. --

_{~~ V~flI'} .~/.6 . . _{jr_ : . . .}

* ..

6_.Jt

\

,.w '" ....

8t • • •

101\

etaD4. to.

ocaee.,.1oaa,

aDd ,ttl OMte • • 'be . .

-laD ••••

.,..

••

bi.

" . , 'he . .

1'

••

1M.' .. , ..

'ne

hl."o.,

wbloh

haa

ao-" ' 8 4

'0

'll par.i.til,..'::,· . . .

,.t

lette... AD4,

,et.

brOW ..

.... 1 •• & OIl. poD4 ••••• , . , be -• • , tU1el1,

aooep' the

taot

,,'

' • • t . woplMa, 1\6y • • • • • 1'8.1, . . . . DS. _

'b.'

tbeH 11 '811

.1

. . . .

'

of 1'181£ hi,

aD,

OMloe. ~.

tittl.ttl',

lhl'o •• a

oor-,..potl4~q 1ftlNcm of ".fIOR8lltill_, Oft t . . "a4oPI 1t talls

'0 hl. '0

a_urel.. . . ,

',bo ...

'h..

sea.,

'Dl,8 WOl'48 toCOft.8,.

Vlth tlkl. la"" •

1.,

U8 lou

.at a

wor4

Bloh

.le.

p.naps,

~~--~--~--- - - -

~-'. I .

, •• . a l .

·.xl ...

!'

<aa4.

ot.(N ....

1'.

prlDolpal 4ep1 . . . 1 . . ·.xl . . . . ': ,.). Ii 1. " . . . "tbat haebMll

wb-J:.G '

to aDUIlutNal 1UIOlJa'· ot abu.. bl

No-eD'

,ears. both

'br ",

ta08.

W.

wou14

qDallt1 "

'ehel. owa

tlll.kta, a •••

I 1.'81l,tlal 804. of p1\110,aoph18_. AJ.Mm '.

,ael.

le,_'er,

80M. I~JIjIS'la

• • • , 1 . . . , ~

,

•..

41 ... 8.1 . . . '1811. •• 1 . . . w.lott baa '11ttle lIe.rlng

oa_ ••••• t.Ntl p.cibl •• of

tlua

01\001 otphl1,Q:80Ptq'. It 18

" ..

.... th.,41 __ .•• 1 . . . ot.

...1

4~1.'lDO'lon

_{be' •••}

_{n •• SMloe}

• • • •

1a\' ....

Whlah

obtai.alB

all

.reatu ...

8 "

rel ..

ant

to

So . . "O.B~

••

~1.".'1.al,

••

boole,lI.'tae,a . .

,

8ome.bat

perl.

t

ph . . . l t o p,ro"l •• •. t Il.rtfe ••• " .

:3,lno.

,_.~r 0111, lft,t ....

et

1,1 11.. ".~ . . . happily

'rea. troll ••

't.r18& 1I1to ttll. f

lat...

¥ 4180U.,1 . . , . . OIl. coaf'lee

our,.l ..

_

to ,.

pN ••

Dt&-'10D

.r

...

la» 'ueas;- 1D 'h.le . .

','..wlt11 ..

y1 ••

•• Yer1f1 . . '1011 of

t_

.AI.

When •• . . . 18 tihe

e

·0_ 4 . . . .

, ••

1.,_

Ie

Ie

.'.PIlA1,ft'I"'1s ••••• •

t.

to

aG'lu' .. lrct4, • tJPe. of ' • • • •

iaI:.

It 1a 111PO.81· , . 8.1.,.1\I\O\1t »& ••

1..

ulll •••

we . • •

'..'

t • • 1

It"

1 11l "he 100..

..n ••

of 8",·

184 ••

1. _ _

,

••••

,lt8 . .

1t,

llJtb.wm,.4

" e.t.'1a(I .';

1.14ua1 1 . . . .

4ri.e..

fM'

la-,. ear.

lle ' . . . . b

a

4.,1".. whe. ill . . . of

eal ..•• t • • • , aD 8..1 _ _

.e

100 . . 1, . .

eaUH,

t . . tMD he· 1e

Be'.

arl...

. . ' a 4,PUBkeD, ,pe . . . . ,

1$0, • • •

1 ..

,l1'.a.

'wAICD tm4 lat.'8 ,be fto ••••

tM . . . . of th . . . .

l....

To be ...

a.MII

,

"

• _ . . . . 'he:" are

,.,-p.

_ , .aA

~. .. "_ " :V'

"hat be:, . . . .

,

Miq . . 4--bS.!. _ eN" to _ . Uld tihe

. . . 1,

t.o'o. of _.

It.l'erlc' ,41,~ ~b,11o.o'P-h1, liD •• l ' 1 •

•• 1 ...

1alla

pt'e·el ••

1r

'b'_ . . .

e.,

'a 'h..ot,lGa

of

_oral

•• t • •

\\00 Matily aa4 OIl

t ....

ttl.1 •• ' •• lUft08, . . . , BOW 'that

,tte.ol·ep._.ORr80UG

11'

. . .

'!'e.'.

ot

wb1\taH"alled '. 1 _ .• 81 ••

-.,0.1 •••

< • • •

110.14-.1....

8,8t....'

Yalua,.

ill

_rae

or

_lob 11 . . .

"JK),al'e4.

he

-.x,1ete.'181

,

a4n. . . . , •• 'Aa4 all.t~hll ~J, 4,1 . . ot.4'0 . . 114.

'tn.

loa1 ot IftOW'wha"

l ' _ ••

tio' a.oept; . . .

1 lou:.

11048

of

ex18tcmoe,

boW ••

oba.tequa,11tt

•• , .

ao'.ot

Ihela41'Y14ual.

ae.

oaua. 'h18 18

8.,

out' ooaolualOD, 'bO\lii1· •• 1"1, 1. Dot

thoqbt-1 •••• \le:1Bl • • • , 80"

0D1J'

eli

tbe l1Dei

jua'

<1;\10' • •

but on

.. It ... '

'be ....

t1\ It

A

qulok. 'p ...

1

ot .... of

tne.e

text.

11111

Hrye

\)o'hto

Ju.',1t,

1,1 •• k."., "

tau"

,an4

'0

uke oleaHfl

tbe ,41atlDotlOli

lDyol,,.o4.'

J •• , •• bel 18 e.14 'ltoth.r .ub . . . . ,tial c t aoo1dat\ul \tel' , 8.0

too

18

"n.

110 _1t. ftot

oal,

or

ablolu •• ,004n • • ,.,

. ' o f ' .lbl~ 18

a ...

OUD4UII qu,S.,1 .:,. . . 11.lut tbepe 18a

,', ,t 41ft.HIt •• be" . . . .

'ile..

'110

d1vl.10n8. !tJo_thlDI~ 1.

,M14'o be, sla.p11, 'luUike . . lta"ltall'lal be1ngJ but; a tbl_ 1e 8.14

'0

lte •••

\Ift".

q\l14M.attl.

ot

the accldent,.

wblob; eoortleto

,1t_ S.o . . t ••

la,

1-11 the ,.'b.ol~l'.

"n ••

or

"he

'.'ra

t

beeau •••

r

h18wba, ••

tlal

t ...

,

1\8 18 wb1'. because

. . -~.~ i5ltiA4" A . . . 4111, a fth.,.' , . . . . , 1 : . . , ~1~

,*,,~,M'$ ;~ .¥~ "j ... v..~~ t/f .. "'*~~, :.a'lI'AW p~ii II> '~ j\

"hloh l'ltro,

nt 8,00.ti' •• lfttrJ •• ' " ,

for

betore

'b.~ geDerated,

ioo, •• 'b •• tllap17

was •• ,_

.'.t

"ho

elteratloll.

G • • • neratieD

•• olm4 •• qU1,4 • • , whlotl he lJe;301Be. Wi1,1,'8 e."al18 onll tht,

,

-,

S.o~~ate. 1,.

abeo1u'.1,

J.'

he 1'1 ,,004 0111, aeoua4.WI qu14

ln

vlrt~.

ot lila

Mm,

._ao1u'.1,.

To be

1\.

he QU,g,h,t to

be

1.

8ometbl.

a.olt4eata,l \. hI8 abeoluM

'.,.11)1;, and 1e ·theNtO". belac MO~U;aG,U.

qui4.

a_",l,

Yin"te epollatu • • • 'ltl.18 •• , Il1b1.0'"., 4101t.r

qulae.

~. 1 ••• »4UII Q\lld.sollloet

in-=:-:S:::~l::.::=-':'': ::u:~,,·

••

_'uwm

Vbi' 1. l ' that.

,.tF

_ioh flake.

s...to

be

a'b:.olu'.l, •••••

hla 8004 ODlr . . 1.,1 •• 17. ." . . . .

ab..

18 ab •• lutel, s004 1a

Yip'"e o' ....

'blI18 _1 . . . hi. be

cm1,

1ft aD aoc14ental

wa,t

w.

apeak

ota

.h·

I

.".lDS

1.

'.'Pa.

of all ab801ut..

conal-&eratlO1l, _ •. t 18,'

we -1

'b.'

l '

18 perfeoted 1D

It,.lt

when

I t . l . ' . b

y,n".

of .•••• a.1;1&1 1):.18:011'18 ... " Z:10Mllhlas

1a

. . 14'0 be 1004.'°. be AS 1- aboa14be. with ~.peo'to

80ae-'btDI otl1..

t..

1 ' •• If J S . . . . , . . . , . , be

orda'red to

flo . . thing

0' •• ".-

t).i_ . . lt 1t he 1. to be go.. Soora" •• "la:' ••

hla-•• it

t.

hl • • 84 \)7 Goqu1:P1ftC ... o14cm . • l ,.rteot1oJl'., Y·lptu •• ,

wbloh ...

t1t'b1.·0,.

. .

'1 .... Be w111

be ••

14

to

be

at.801utel,

« 0 0 4 . 0 ••• 8.4 a\toY. ttut p ••

t.otl.a orbl.

aubatantlal

. bel. • • • _ 1&014111"" 1h. ,."e14 •••• 1 pe.'.0'1080t ylrtue.

0811 OM 18 1.0", a l l , beeauH

ae

ls. Ore.tUNa h.a • • • oertain

.'00...

rollowbe

Oft 'help ·&)) • • lu'. belaaJ but the),

cartOD1,

...

,01u'.,11

C084 11l

yl .

.-.ot·

tbat

_leh.

on

the

plan.

of

.,'

.au.

ezll''''',uadera,oocl

lD

the

11 •• ke,aar41an ••

n •• ,

wl11 tie

,It.

bl.tor,

or

t~dt .04u1 . . . t of .1p't""'. abtl

tbe

stib •• que., ....

ot

tbe. l a . . ,1".011 . . . 1 •••

to our

eD4.

It

Ibe .,):.,1 talk:

la, ••

,.,'

.aln'a,iD8,

'to 1" • • 01". the

-6-our pot"'1&11'1 ••

"orr

.'1".

ao

tb~l;t . . IIaYDot 01117 be.

~iIt" ~.

a-

~:

... ' ..•..

~~.

,,.

iAllV W u ~-',_ ~w ~.

~h."

ar.

e18 ••• taPJOOD81

avold eyen a . . .

11 ••

popln.

ta.

beglOD'

\)~,~t 1t 1. well to 'leetl',mo.bal,l

In'o

aeo.plete

al,8uaie:retaHil:D tba.' whlcn

tollow..

~hat

il . . . 14 eD •• lle,

'0 . . .

uP..

tu41at1notlon or ••

,8D08

an4 8.18\;6 . . . 1.» 'thie

·oreature . ,

b, 'uegluft.liti w'lt!\ th .• llot1on

'll;. go04

we •••

a bnq.l.'t~l' 11M' .. folloW8, and what

toll0.. 18, DO' . . . , . .1o~\1 0 • • 14 . . . ·t1'*. 11 •• kesaard

)) . . . 811"4

no .,.,; ••

ot,

.thles, ..

:

••

DooM~'rl"

prweentatlcm

of

ho.

1I0ral. . . . ••

was , . be _oqul •• 4.

lIe abhorred \}le

flDall,',

a.4 au'bo:pl'la.,ltmlaa

of

Se ."

'11&ft8yat • • tlaat:l.0D .

• .,JA f'.·a .. J6A _{41'" l~,A,··.}

~;I-~, ' .. --... ~t~"vv ~~_J'

$.017 ot'lreot

a._teat1

. .

tONlba4. aUGh . .

approacb.

w.

CO oa . . . 'fjo 41 •••••

-.1;

Kl •• "e ,I't. a14 . " about hulIfUl f

act10.

aot _

Hoau . . l '

18 • . ~.ltloalltlD

l '

•• lt.

W'1

Mea...

1. will 1. \U1·'Mtte. , . 'UBde.8taD4hll t'beopY

ot

tM.1I'eot 00_10.tloa.

.... '

·0 tooll. ~'.' .•• of' _ , . . .

I&l ••

'loa

1ft ... .

_•

•

It

we ...

"811.".ll •• II • • • N,

aepllaa1 . .

b\mI' 11ke ..

0"1 • • \be ~k

.t

Ill • • • , . . . . . '1»& .... PT'hlq

wt.alt.

UBNallt, aa4 latl'u'.lq , _ Ycl., •• ak(\UJ4 t11.

t.

va,'

ODe of P-OIlPOU8

. . 1'1 ... \flllob,

t.l,

that l ' DMU tile

r.al

.'or'.k

of

th_ht

184 1t 81\4 . . . . :p . . . ' l , em; 1. 'be

lftMr-.'1...

of

atS,.,..

8'oh

M4

exMu.,.' ..

al.1 t;;, •

_.,.,.111"4

... pta.rea

'olc,.

a.'l.be

....

a.'beatlM,

aM.oat.lolu.d,

troll

','

"8:t kl44 •• tb __ hti.

ot , ..

41Y11\1'"

'0

'he •••

inc

ot'''e

a ....

U1.

tl,.

.Aa

a",·

....

'i.r~.,

••

N hl ••• 1f hd

~.4 8 • • • 'h.~.

or , .

87.',",

'MD.sl.tl ~,11;

b,.

bie

,.,lft, , .

a •• lal1.,. ' • •

"lat •• wIllon all •••• , • • b.1m . . . tbeN_

I "",

III . . .

1, , . .

aw&a117',

reall._1 . . .

"P'U;I:·,oah1,tt

'ha'

•• ht.. •••

ooaspl0Uo\lIl·1,

ab . . .

,

fro.

.b.

1,78' •• , 01' ,at

le.,'

. 1 .

NI~,l', _1.' . . . ,

hi..

With ""18 ....

.pl'10. oa_

..if,,'; ""bat

'M-ole

of Yf.~.ll" phl1o."J:~h1

v..

a

fl\D • •

,10 . .

t.pp.1 •• _lob

wou14

ab.'",oi; hta

00_))1 ••

e11

OUI

of

1.lt. 1 •• 0._ . . . ' .. ' aft4 WOD4 ••

tul ••

ft.~

.t·

:P\fN aelq •

. AM _.

,n ...

bl b _ _

,be

_le.

. ,

/

!'be t a . of . . . " . . . 0r41ms to Hegel, 18 pa4ual17 to

", ' .. ,.lat.

tD8

wi_olt

t.~,

..

llCloa ••

4 Al'b."

• •

"rlwte4

, . Ji!PO'Y14 . . .

1

Se tel' 'hl\"

tne _ _

lft,tell1pn.o,. :ba4

.,t101 . . ,1, lIl'u.4 . . . .

_.,1.,.

OP8l'l

,be

16.,

400.,

'to

SO

",084

tal ll1 6114 DOVO_ ••

a.rip."..

ba4

\WIN.

1ft dolDe

th,la, ·.11 wG'i14 _ . . . lear 884 OOIIPrebeaal'll. , . - _

. . . a.

to.

ul'1 ... '.11 l\pre.u'p . . . . 'b,G04 , . aD

0.'>''''

propor1l1 . . .

a

k h ... l.'.11.1S •••• aa4 1.

'Itt ••

Mlo,w it,_

~

wltb De • • • ,G·1"" tOf! 1ftt1lO\l14 Dew the . . . of all '·he oau ••• f

a.4 tbere oou14 "

'DO

tmto ...

»

.tf...W.

GoulA the.> • •

olio

1110UNl1.

I . .

avo . .

bit.' .... ,· ....

t,.

20 1 ••••••• 1.~ t aD4. aa4 :t

W11 k •• plt 1 , .• ' till , . . th,.

Or.

.8ae,.1

fAt'.

I', - ,

If'tc. aD.4 lJltu~.l •. t •• u,.

1s

ItO'

.. '

Vbat18,

bu, 1lM

tae,

'ba'

l ' 1e

Dot

a·.

1. abotl14

lie,

ODM

~ 1m •• _ha,1t 1 ••• 1t , . . , tte .. ,haS 1a

eo •• ,.

110\

ani 'ra.yol"

ooatr

' k . _{u • . . . • .} a'" 1,-_' \II 18 .. ,.' • I

we a180 AlGopl •• that 1. ah·ou14

Oby1oual,le ,,1 h •••• t h l . . . 1t a rathe . . . lIbi'lou. loal aa4 we . . , . . 11 VOD • • PD.- be pPopoMd to attab 111. 'Wha'

.,.

4088

'0

1 ••

'1l ' "

ki.

Goa,. .

,".le.8,

'loa'.

fQl4.

Ie_UiBl-Ie WOQ14 . . . ,

eaa

,

... ", ,,,,,a

i.' ,be

_01..

TtMtaol., ..

bow . . . . ,

t . . .

17

\k . . . ' l . l

aata ...

l q 1 ' •

• ,....'he

p ... •

t

1'., ...

,....,..

.

ftle Whole , . .

tal_,

ot ...

GoA . . e . . . u.'tS •• lmo.le4~l.

of . . .

_14 . .

ke

p . . .

lt1. . . .

e . .

o,em

lJook

_4,,*. t"e

Altfto"l\, •• ,

ot

l1te.

..te ... ,' ....

18 tM S, •••• , &D4

, . 1'. , . . . . , .

troll ••

lat •• 1 . . __ .• '

.11pe.lor

to ...

l ' 1.

"t • • l' -.'·4uII9 .:ha. £~~ . . • . '

. .

.., ••.

"'~

... u: ....

r

1ft '1 ...

1'.

"'11 . . 1 .

tllale.'l10·al

MY.lop . .

_

.t , .

.,at ••

'1 ....

-...

", •. , 1. IJOtb,lDp •• ·•• _lob &e,.l

1,.1-el ••• ' • •

e. • •••

_be ,.

....

,4.W .•.

power of 'he . . . . l.e J

1.

1.

"'~·'t

ot,..

.. · '. ·J'o.,

••• trolla

l ' 1.

lD-,..4. _ ••

'.1 ••• ,,, ',:.'.

l».oy14 •• 'the'

01" • •

0

'he

flo,l . .

• t.

whl_ ',.1

4..'

IU.

"""POPs.' •••

11.pl

va. ,

.t

•• 'lJ ...

ttl.,

·.01....1.

act

,1 ••

a

OP

.t.1

...

Sa . . .

tell

awoop, •.

,

1.

0811'

M4

Il,' the .114

of a

4S,I'laot .• - . , • • 48

aN

"011. _._ we PI , . . - 14 ••

to

l·t . .

la'.

pro ....

of 1 .... 1 t • •

lIlI.

41 •• ":*1*,

or

o_.p'.

o . . . . poa4.UaI w·l'lI'~.

41 .... ·.1t'.t'b,1.'.

kaoWII;.1tor 1.181,

.. 10 ..

"'8.1" .

all • • ftat . . . l aJl4

aplrt'ual

l1t.

:::-

.li::~~:-=,

.e

V:;::1

to::

!!iF.~

WI.·

i ' . . . '.1'1al·.. . 1. 00 • •

1'.

to

tt.

01fll

a..l.8

1'3' , . . .

~J •• , ••• 41_ •••

tln1' •

•• '1_ "....

,he, ,00.«1

tl...

.t

·aD eZ·'.PD&l

. . . 1al of ,.lY . . _ •• t . . . 810h l ' . . ,

._'ala

1..

'>0.' •.

aa4 ,be

J.o't. ot

11:., &0'1.1t,.

1'. :

,1.',1'.'"

B . . . 18b:Ra'. ,aD4 18 the

-3

•• ' ot

1'8 . . .

o,.ra'

1 .... "

.e ... awaN,fj' ••

".h. , ... , 'M

8s..t

p.o4\10 •• 1a

re-/

1:1 ... ,1-_

OIl

1'. 'b: . , . . .

0084

la',em'l, ••• ,

tbe

proper

ott,' •••

or

1_10. ~. lep1 • • • , •• .,_ would ... ~ to

.M"oe

''_It., •

4Mltotl88

'NIl ....

ala . . 1 ••••• 1.

l"

,am"'aata

_. '.'.11.',

of . . .

.Nal

ltl

all ,. ,. • . .

11.,."1

()QJt

1.

1H

MGOIIea ."""1,,.

aJI4 . . aol" ...• Mye

'0

do 'with .olfmoe

.\ . , •• \1841&, •• 0 • • • • , . . " ' __ leb 1 . . . .

1'lt'

1. ae_hlD1

•••

11 . .

, . . . .

be • •

'u • •

t . . . .

_o.b3e.t,

tb.' Whlob ••

"0'

po..

11' lMt GaD

,re'

t • • • ' -••• ,'·1_1

exl., ...

e.

To

regaN

1., •• ".

'6 "." ••

1. •. '. ,.,.1,.

'0

a1 . . . . :r .... , ,be

--,., . .

~"' ..

" '. ot

:' .~" . . . 0lIl" ". -1114'" , . . . . ,' .'" ..

0""

, . . 1" :

•••

"-lowh ••• " . . .

Sbe .P"tN.~,

. .

ot

'hele,el11m . . 'boa

be-_",flO.. .',..,

,baa lii, .1..

."ltoa'loa

··'to h18HI7.

Kle ..

t ." . '.

.ook ••

e.,'l~ to ~1.

a.peo,

_ot

nepl

18

.81ng

111_11

011 ~

-xta.-ol..

ot

the .'h1081

lite.

.Ia3\lz, ••

, . ...po.1'1 . . . of Ualy •••• l Bl,':o17 arJ.4 tbe

oova ••• po.1\10a of . " flUOb.

11 ·,.111

be thrown

Weba.e . . . _~ t.p& • • ,l, OllP . . . t-hfm·

oont·.ol1'84

wt'h bl.'o., 11

1lO~ , . 6 . .

,.n.

our ••

l.8. w!l'ha

.ap. -•

. . . 00 • • • _ Of'proY148,.0.. Bath..,., we auat Mke thle

14ea ••

110" . . . 8It4. dAJ":~1Ba" 80

tl1a.t ••

will, be able to

... ,roy

1 ' . l f ·OU' 1D,

hiB'o.,.,

~. p . . .

/

OJ).~ 1108o,hloal 4."D,,'.rfj,tl(i)ftot tile •• 410al

pea.GB-.1... .fall

'.1DS8 Ul. Ott.

at_ of

ai.torr.

, ....1'

"_lob'

10:.', ',; bnq8 vlSb

I.'. __

e.. 'la\lea, ·of 11.'0." 1. , _

.-1..

.'.toa.t

J tba' ile.lKel •.

the lit...,.e.·

.t

,he ,'J

'!la,

the blat • . ,

. , , . we '.' • ,:

',."ope. , . .

MD' ••

~ wi

'h •

. . t,10 . .

1

,1'00 •. ' ••

" ", . IlalYl ... ,

t .... •••

".1 . . .

n.1 DO'10n8, ao

\181 •••• 1 hletol7 ,,111

'ew. ,

. 1 ••• 1 . . . 1ob GOYer the

tlbol.ot ,_. 4 . . .

1 .... : ' •• •

t' , .

e • • •

realJOB.

We...

\014

,.-

....

,

.'1'." ....

11 . . . .

,._1

ePA •• •

t

ey...

but

,.'h...how

U8 '1M

'a ...

'i . . .

-1

_t

. . .

' ..

8 ~ . . . . 1'11&1 ... ,

1 ... 1 hi . . . . , "~k . . . . t.lloaal eoapftt"elcm

.0

'tba'

, _ . . . 14 la *lGb~ , . . . . , .

0'-

·tn-.l1lc"'.

aa4 Will

_at-.. '

t ••• • " .... 1 • • • • tl1a. 1 ., ••••••

let'

o.

obaD._,

wt

91111 be Heft

1. • •

11 . '

ot , .

IC ...

1l7.re was a ...

aoa

_lob lo ••

raM _ ..

wo.14 aDd.tbat

tor

tnl •

. . . . OD A:r.latoU. 11k' hl,. ,..tbe ODe

a.e.

,fI8m 111 • oJtOwd

.. 11' •

..

"1tl08 -114m he ao . . . '1M'

_I

".-~'. ,~., aB4 .

.fio!..

~.A l·~ • . ... w ·~l. '. ~~OC.·GUI

_6. ...

... :. I.Hlltiq,,' ~ .. ~ BeA-V.I!. . ' A wW O&~"A.Ut . Mft'-".~

hS_l •• 111· •••

top

we ._,

eh..

'.De wOl"klJl18

or

tbe

14 ••

a_ -~."., *, ... ' ••..•••...

ii1t;WtA._- •.

~Aftt-.-• • ·. M6-1 . . t · . . . , • . ,..f!i(.1:A1ft6.1.1.,

~ Vi:;t _~4 ... ~· ....• w.~ a,VtiiIit YV~·. . • ~ fit. Wi'lv

.w._

V~. . ,

alcab

10...

O. 11 • •

14.

<. '.' ".118

ttu'aaotbe.

approaoh to

, _ _ It • • • ,loa . ,

'be . .

, .• otp.o..-14 ...

ODtul·.

001l ....

. , 0.. _ ...

,

e.4* •• o. au .•

·t be

41reoW4

'0

the

'len

0'

'.--78

ot

. ·0.14 . . . . , ... l ' " ••• , aH ..

,he

Ille-so.t

~

•

t.

·W!i;lo". ". wmlt •• , .

Ii-::!t~ftr' ;~l:~

.=~

="~'l"l'h

.• 18 . f t

'0

fulfill , _ JalVDO'Soa or 8oJ'lp1}uNt whiah

\I . . .

01111

"0

10'1'.

t104.

_yt a18. to

DOW

'11,..

ODe. .he 84yaab - . of

tnt.

utef'1l.S.D.H OOItPHb . . . loJl

of the wa"a of' Ppov14e1lae 1. VB'

we.11

ua4, ••• ' . . " •• 11 1 't 1s . . .

sa

the M • • 14. _1, b, uM.r~4.1.

t · lD8 She " , . . . of _.11 1ft the 1fOtr'ld,

. . . ODe be

".01'&011 . 111'11

1'_

11 . . .

llloOl.1HDtrate

Oft

,be

true

_Gal or.he ·., •• 14 . . . tbe p.oa •••

of

1'.

Nall-I . . - .

""I....

tbe . . . . 1. W111

1M

OIl

,a.

pO'81t1v.,

&Bet

...111 . . . . , . __ . t l v . 41_ . . . .

,.12

.

1 . . . . pHh . . .

toa

ot

'be

loal

or

, _ . . . 148a4 ,he . . .

1." ••• _ ••••

\004

oa17 ••

runollOll.

ot

ttl,I.. tmtl, .111 _ _

le

118 to . . . the De •••• ,1., witb "bioh

h1."or,

'tIIlto14e. S, '1. 18,81 •••

th,,'1..

S,.

thl.

De •••• lv, 'Wh10h

~'''.'.''

~.

't...

Xtpl... :"¥e " I ' p.p80 . . 1 OO!P06"". &114.

'.lals,

, J

,be

w ••

laot •••

11 • .... 1*1,8108.

of «eel and. ••

'11,t.

lett

1,

tne

'0',:

tt,

aDd . . . tN't all

,

15M' . . . '111

f·aoet.

w1'h ••

e

4,ltf'1leu1',

lot 11t •• 8Il4thatt

1004 . . 4 •• 1,1 . . . . 111

.a

iaa.,.M1tl • • e

ey... ,.,

tl'O.

"81_

. . . 17, O~ ,11 •••

ooa'aUt . .

taoaloula1l1.,

'el _ _ ' vble

I . . .

'1...

1.

t ••

,uaat.. • ... " ...

"'0. __ '..

The

tao,

1s

-0'1 ,1004 . - , •• 11. 'Wba'M.;r

ottered .a an

.",1.

or

a.,., ••.

1_ 18 be,·' '01lJ' r . . . h. ODe . , . . . _411, wl t·,tt the nltark

0(\11111., .... ," '1'UlI 1.

aeael.

we . . . .

,1.,.

:41"14,84

It.''' ••

D

at1IIl,..'1ea

to.

Me ,eDl •• eat.book • •

vea

41 .• :t.

a.

Ii ....

t.1.0

. . .

__

, ••

of

airA ))1

~.,

II ... ..,14.'. , ."

.e«a ••

,of, .' 1)

coa$1V,

Obal"...

hu_

u.

.'.Doe

1

teelt •

hle.lao . . .

_. the'~ ':,ot

n."keaaa.4 •

JUt baa

"._'1 ..

e4.l:l~

" ..

1'4

8,le.mt

Ii

pea'

4

••

1

of

,bitt , . .

'h 1;'.,1.

to allllO'" 1) •. 18

IN."

ooa,rebe.8t,cm of

the

,

1'. bttg,lJDl,lDc tiM . . . la,

ta.'

betm t1;111111.4. It

...to

",1. poml whlob . . . U,

",o"rNa

1a ble OWfl . . tt1DS.,

11ktmlq ~be . , . . .

.atp1ft

a

at . . .

vinAOW" whiob rea4

'~lA"

...

Me ••• M

t.__ .'

~

0Itl,

,be

alp.... tor ..

1 ••

hw

..,.1. 884,'

. . . .

t1 . . .

pr~l . . .

0.

aM

al •• 8. 11"1_'

q.'"

.tt

. . .

_0' ••

'b.

wrt ••

l ••

OU'.

otl".

aDA , . ,

, •• tl;aft4_'al ., . . . , _ _ cht aa4. Hlq

A"

one,

·Ml1..

·tl\\'1\ 88y,,4 1.

,be 1108' lB .•

llft1tto·.'

aot1.. tmat

' - . . 1. & ' . • • ·.1\1 • • • •

pa"," ••

b.1Ui . . 4 ,~.. hl.lias

wl.4.11 pre~.t.

,.

~.

8:M'Cu8· ot )) ...

91,4.110 . . . 4

,e • •

bl~.

"la40. '.118"81 ta ... _ , pro914 ••

tlae

110.'....

It . . .

• • 1 . . . 1\\,.1 • •• 1.4 . . . .

ott •••

All,

ft,,_ ••

,.,....tU\

pro-Y14_

K.l.iPk _ _ " ,,1'11 . . .

81.

ot

bla

a"'aok on tt

• •

,at •••

ot

one

"h1J1l ••

er,

aim ·orm

_e

oerM41a: AD· 8,x18H.c1al

II,:., ••

1. 1.,. •• 1111.. fta.t wblo" . . 1 . . . .

r.oa

ki.\or, 1e

. . .

1,

Ibe

err ..

t,.

'If •••

1OB. __ 1891018-.1.

...urarr

ot

OOD801ea . . .

la.

bl44 . . . , . . . flU • • , . ••

:. 'h1 . . . 1$M' 110 INCh . , . , •• exl ••• ' D,

...

J ftor

.18 till. 1 .11M bl OUft . . .

t.loa.

~a.al1" l ' •• l t

1 • • •

,.~

.. tor

GoA,."t 1. .

...

, lie • •

,at

••

tor

aDJ' e.ll1tlq8:pl,rt' •

. . . _t1aali,'7 . . · . . . .

'0D4

'0 ...

aao'he·.,

lNtexl.

18 })reel"l1tb.fioppo.lt1J

or

ttDa11".···

Ile" ••

,

18 . .

'b,eo' . . . ICS • • •

1I8a1'4

0&111 • quan'l.tt

••

'41,,1 . .

'10, . . 4 . . 11 _."

_1."

haa _ . . 'ltacl.e

,.pop,....

1 •

.

-.

laolu4e4D 1'_ It «oe·.

DOt

aoaleY . . . .

1~.1 WIlle ... _be

ethloalr.. ..•• _

1841Yltblal

aequu.a

bla,.pl •• l lapoPhnoe

_, . .

ana ot

,.t

_lob.

'PO.

aD .'hloalpola'

ot

.1 •• , 1. 840;14 •• '181.1

$

_4 ,._. lt OD. 111"'_8 _rull to

ua4.r . . . .

Ill.'orr

tpo. . .

Ylewpou;t

ot

p~.148Do.. tbe

.'hical,

1I0rall

t, .

_O'D

tie

ove.l.ilk.A.

.. 1,.,

, • Gel"

'*-,

,'a10Dot tbe blltop1ealla

la, ,.:t.pa

Ila

_OW'

'e ot

the

s,aaoat

... ,. .08861...

ke,

b\

tM ' . · ••

,.t

. . . 'lashe • It he ( , . :b,l.'ol"l") . . . ,.-la. t ... i11IOb . . . . , •

.,'t,

he w111 • • •

'0

0 . . ' . . ' hl. , t ,w1'h "8U . . .

,ot

the liON pro ...

bleil' 1' ••• , aD4 'ill. 18 p~ol . . 1, .hat mak •• , qUBD'1 'lYe ,-. 4tle14

taotop

1ft Ute . . leo'l . . . ··

t lIh1ob18 1.~taa.,

.e

tar ••

etb10al 00.111481'.'1011.

are

OODHrae4,

1.

the ' ••

1)0"_

OBoe _.

j>urpoee

1.

determlne_,

tIl. '0\1'00 • • _114

.rt.eta are

1n41tt.'pea,.11

Jlar

tro.

ex-I ' plabl. ' • . . ,

eYil,

Unl . . . . al l'llato17 oan DeY • • •

'.1D. to •

MGO l1ltlen or go04 8D4

.y11 .a

tihe..

_xl.,

.a

ural ,,, ....

81B1m'. 1»

t.

1841.16 . . ,1.

18

t

wc.14

hl.,oJ7 1.

'h.",81 •••

p-wM . .

004

1. . . ' •• , ' . . . . I. 18 •• , •• 0·lMa ' " 1 1 . '

e •••

'

'1, .he c, .

'spa"t.'ol*,MoauH

He 1.

,,~ 081, . . . ,

MIl

1te. ~Ol,bl.

tMa'"

110

•• 1.'laS '

is's..,

.a.

& . . .

1..

It he

laaS'1aee

bl--.1f

<.,8,.0.'0.

be •• , . . .

l¥t

••

:i.' ... ,

he

, . ',1;,-,' aft&o'~r ,em the . , . ot Ghe

11'tle

, '. wbO . . . .

1 . . . .

,1' "

,tv.

l'O,el

.peete-\o~".' ",~'O.,h_~. ,,;1 1Uli. h11& 1n '1,1. l"OJal

l1Pama.

4ft\1it\

4F_u"a •

. . . 14"

Xl... aaka

1JlMJ 878' •• '& • • • plab; SOOJ"Ate •

• • 0 • • • •

111.'.. _

1f&..~ ,1tl08Dft Uldle ooaYfml . .

trl,

4.a4.

La, l ' •• plaia

ot

h i . . . be be

...

1'7 witth wbl.h H

0...

in'" betllg,

.

-,

. ·o.latl.e

pb11.a.ber4 . . . GOd em. 183u.tl •••

11

It 1·.

1B

'he . 80oal,184 , . d,latl..-1ah 1t

tft) .• the $1' . . . . , til.' 11ft f:,·· fA p.,1108Op"10.1 . , .... p, to

"tu:_

"8'8 . . 1I1t_[II.

• p •• , . • •

'0

.peak of

,.8 ...

',10»" whlon 1. 4&8"lDp18.4 , . . . 611, _.M. " . . . l~

18

ttl., it . . . .

lie'

tm"Ppo •• the

prior

.&1 ... . , tba. aloh

_.eo ..

e. '~t

la.

l t l e •

0_5.''' ••

011.-_

..

_l.~.\Qt4.r.'8Jkll_

tb •••

. ·eup,... ...

tbiq.

• lie of tal. 11184. 10n 11 Dev •• tbel •••

• a ...

be t i • • • t . .

bo.' ••

& p(l • • lbl11tl'

aM. a

.11lI!

_lob 1.

~.

.

18 aotual

'.ba.

OP

a.,ua11.,

J loth~~t t . (lUa,;Cf

1Dvol

Y8'

1Il

be-00 .•. ·.· ... 1._.' .' .... ' ' . . . . 1_,1 ...

t.·OJa ,.

••

lb111t,

to

aotUill 'IT. 2~.

I:l ••

k.'...

.,MIl •• 1£. whe.}~.. 'tll8 DAI • • • • • 7

can

00"

into

M1Di.

-J but 'he .8C •••• " o.tUmot

. . , . ' alDM "'

1.

&1..,.

"la~.4

to

It· . .

1r.

aM . .

'.'0

l" . . l t 18 the . . . . . . All·' . 111'0 be, ..

is a

8UJI£iDI

. , f l • • • • • • ..., ... ' ntl •• , l ' .IDJiO't

Slltt •• the"

autf' ••

'or , • •

,o~\l.l. whloh 1.

. "he. " ••• 1-.1. ( . . '-Gal7 , • • •

ol.e'

po •• i .

b,ll!"" bu' al.o~ tbe

A.e.reM

p() • • "blllt7) "

-",eal,.

1, •• lt.8 _0,b1 •• , . . . t

l '

'bee . . . _

aotual;

to"

I " •• 1h1,.18 _lh,11&t,,4. 1B 'the

eo-'l • • •

e.,'MII',1;u.t

0 . . _

lB' • •

1-.

p . . .

,1'8018817 '01 eo.~

lato

Mlag'.t 1t ,1.

Dot

DeO • • ...,..;

f,o"

88 • • • • 171'.

'be

01117'

ti\_

t :t4 . . , 00..

l,.t,o

'be • MGaU.. the n.Q€~8 •

• .., la.

t._

eo ..

la,,,·

btl·' t 18 . . . 1. _ ,

ao,,,allt,

18 D,O'

' . . 08 • •

lt,.

Ai

,al.

pobtt;" I l •• tc

.. 1, ..

. 1I1stake lle.1D Ill·." ..

la,

-1,. \.

'18.11'1. 'wlb"l\ ••••

,.'Il

·Wbl.~\l ••••••• IT

11 po •• l))l.. Iu

ora:..

to aye14 tiai.,l»1 t.o

-.~_._Ae....A·

.•

~'~

--...

···1.· t·· ... · a A ... ·~4···­

__ i.,f.v~r9 W~jv., o&.~~.~~ . . . w~ ." ~~,.",~.. 6" ....

,.r7,,",10&'..

alJCU~ ~'U •• ".-17, ..

e

bel}).

hi_.l.'

out

.

...,.'1113 two

.,..1.·.·

otpo ••

1-b111.,. laa'

of

41800 ••• 1ag; t

hl.

t l •• '

,.181

tt: '

11. 1~'· 81AM' •••

lJl11.' ...

ao'

'be ~lr.41

..

,"d

ot

t . . .

-17.

l.erJ . . . .

1

__

te ••

pa ..

:wl1ltf . . . 40., Dot

b,

D.eo •••

l',.

All ••

u ...

\I1,'l...

a.erl •• f.o • •

tnebet_ .• 884 . . ' ...

,

B •• ~ . . 4.1_.4 lJ7 .he . . . ,

peao .... ot

1.' ... 1 • .., oaUI •• to

whl_ Iba. 'b."'" a "OOK . 1,8 . . . IM\I'7.

as

tllothlq..,er

. ,

00._

ll1to, N, wl.b . . . S. .. , J . . . , . 1 •••••• . . . , DeYfl.

00._

tato

Mbli"

Bo'h1Da

.00._

Deo ••

'817

b, ooal.

1"'0

"_.-16

•• te-aa'"

1 .• will .. ·.·..

'0

a4rIl' • • t

"'0 ..

baa .. bl.'oJ')'

la80.tar •• "' •.• 00..

1.'0

M;l~ ., 'but

'u

1'.;'8 . . e·. ,he .... 11 •

. . '10D t»t hi.'op!oal 1ft the

.'.10' •• DM ,.

-the po •• lbll1t,

of " ••• OM l'800a, ". w1 t11l.,. f1rst betJ'o%l,tD.l ."Tb,is

be-. be-. be-.

In, w1'hin a ltecoa1_

11

du.

\0 •

relatl ••

1,

t'''e ·oau ••

Wb!:ob teI'1 ••••. 1t;111&'.1" t~ aD; &b801u\.1"

tNe

aau •••

as

pc.,

4oe' • • •

, . . .

, ' of

allie,

t ••

wbe'

haa ha,pena4

. 8 h8p,...4. but . . . , . . t;U • • toHoOD,clu4e'Uta, tbe

llU1Uta-_ill"

or

the

paat

'S

1d . .

,loal·

wi'h ,bat

or

the . . . aIT'

,,'

. t'.,

all.

tor

1t . , .88, tl8e

oa ...

1.'0'

'bel_.

'It

;he,..,

,1.

oODo.1.e4 .8 ae ••••

17, 'Ill.

oall

U,peD

081, l),

.1.0".

ot

to .. ' . ,

*t

l '

Hie

00 . .

S.'o

H'. •

.a,

be . .

o ••• a.., 1.

_._nloh

0_0'

be . , . . . .

1 •• , _, at 'he t1M or

1'.

be-oOllla,

tM

pe."

001114

bay. ' . . .

he . . 1 •• ,

thereto"

ita

..

11-11l;81.'. . . , 1t

1M ••

e

the

,a,a,

a..

..0, ... "

we _ . . .

"De ....

ot _

ru'UN,.

..4 "bU.

'..-40.

wou14

'"' • • ',.0,84. &l."II • • &I'4.fte &'1 ••• "' . . . i_loatilon of

,

,be 48 . . . . 1' ••

'.fl\,loh

ae,e1

lDYOk84.

tor _

I . . olag .. • • .,. . .

. ~ 11&17 liDe lDl_

pa.'

~. would, . . . .

'·0

t:ol1 •• tbat. tbl •

. .

o •••.

s..,

_,laue·.

'B., ...

Ill'

1.~

tn.

rut"".

,. '.Ma. .. •••••

t

.... , . . , 18 ••• - -• •

IT,

8!i1l0. 1t .... lD\O

__ '., l ' 414.0' "... . . . . , _, .. Oalll!·,·

1ft..

bJI

(.10b. I.. " . . . , •

...u.·',loaJ I

'.,11'

le ... 1.b . . . . , 'throup • _ _ t •

" .. '

aloa

of

1'_

It_pal' . . .

..

... , . , . It., , . • . '.' .f " . p •• ' WO'fl14 " • 1 . . . ·lt7 •• rmeb •• _M

.PP"_ ..

t08

=~":1".

!:!:'

t~:"O:-_::

:r:=

,beael...

Zf , . . .

~

•• ,

··.r

appJ'eh . . . 10lll. 0' . '... , la • • p . . . . ' ••

ot ".'

.M8.1on. ' , .

epp . . .

l .... 1. • . ,,' ,... '4'lIdo • • 1 . . "' . . . , . . .

l '

" _ •• i . . . ...,

'·0 _

pbll •• OJ;MItI,

a,.

'1&1Jo aad· Arlsto,l • • • • 8&14, _ , _ . . . . a. tool

.ed4_a

••••

,be . . . 17'

Aa4 _ 4 •• ,

.t _ ... , ••

1 . . . bo. aa 111&"111,\:, ,. .• paep , • . , 01 . . .

1\181"

lIe,ellaa _,

. . .

11l1", ,",l.S

.,oa4

'won4er.

11

I.,0D4

pbllo, . . _ aa4 _ _ 11:t ••

31

Be pro_l • • • 101\ 1,1 • • • 0..-4 18

,.,la.l

to . . 1101 • •

t.

, . . . . . 1al 11\ pbl1 •• " "" , I . . .

'iliac

Whleh oenbe •• fIII 1n tb •

•• 17 .\la • • •

f

pee·'

.hl • • • • , • • • • he . .

reI'.

Sa hi.

ex-po.,l.loa.

1'18

"IN.

th.'" •• 1.

IIUOh ••

1.8 lDwtm"

he • •

Mi4. • • hl0 •••• ta . . . . lD. 1 . . . ,.. ft. prOb1 •• of

• • 0 • • • l t , . . 4 . . . '1 .... :, • • t 4 . . . 1II1 . . .

tn __ . .

11 asGb

.. 19 ..

. . . . . ti.

tberet ••• ,

pa •• 0 • • ,.

bt . . .

tu'.·'loa ot

ae,81

with-' . , . . . , _ . . , ___ • 8a141. __ 11&!lt of the

aoboolot

. 11... OIl VIlloa l).

tal.lall,

1) • • • • btl .~D4t tnat

ot

Arl.':G,le.' 1\\111' •• , . . . , the

D."· ••• ",

41.t1 ••

,10..a . .

,

all, •• 1ttl . . . . lf10.I108. \fO\1.14, ofoOUl" ••

oa.P, \18

ta.

·~b.,OIl4'bAI . .

a •• , ••• ,.

.t . .

p . . . ,

work.

aut

without ••

1 ...

,

ap.o91"17

81_-

II,'

'he

40.'.:1.118 "bloh

o ... ers

'hie

. " . , " . . \lUi . . . be

,..'ltle4l

1.

gol_

011

t·o

,be

I.i.rke"u."'-I

III ...

..10'1111

,he 11pltl'oat1oaot •.

n&

.e

....

ar

7. 11 •• 11' 18 4culttl . . . ,1.8/'"

It,

\lhe' ••

lre

to 41.·

"1; lsh

olearl;, .:11 ....

_ur •• tr08Oo4. 'ortllDa,elT. 'thle

lea _lea18 18 1>1 . . . 1 • • tre4 bl 84,81.,1. of ••• 1eua k1a4, • • t ... 1.,. •• 4(" ••••

It, ..

eop1alaa;tMtth . . .

are

ex..

8.

or

801u,' ••••••

"""0

be to\l!ld

lD

o,..,u....

It

1.

'Mealile

he

tnlaka of

poe.i"ill" • • •

,.Oft,.,\18 with

OOD-'D'

'·.0, ,.,

Il

••

t.papa ...

h. •••

"uup'

the • • , . . . . , ' . ' •• 811

,r. ...

..,1.

po •• 1,.,18.

tMt

thl.llUi.' be 80

1.«1.,.,.4

ll, •••

1.'

10110.:1

.",.1. ..

_111 •• 4 etloul4 110' be

. . . .

a . .

,..1, . . .

,

of _1,1,

em ••

elt

.utf

of

an • •

arra.atq

. ..•..• " ' ' . " . . ,-." - -'." .. •• , " . ·t··D·.·.'· .' "

·10.

:I . , p o . " . ' • . *1"1.1.

t".·....

...1' ••.

&4

... 'a

,.' Mt_"'O. _ •••

of 'lilt) i.po •• lbil.. ,hat .10b •• 0 . . .

1 • •

11ft_ao;).

1.

alao

' 0 ~H COllt·,

. ,; • .a; •••.

onl,

"0

the ...

r,.

bu'

eD'

_iohaa,

01* . . , Dot . . . h t the

~

_'lDfj8ll'.

804etlDe4. will all;o be.pose4 to

tn.

.eo •••

,...,- which 18 4.f1884 ••

'u'

·whion

o_o:tao.

be.))

We ...

1~la •• 17t)b._, 4,1.,lfto,108. "hlob MV. to

'be

la4.

if

_ l a

'0

ep_.

·.,l'tt an, .. ' ..

:8¢>t

coh...

111

'M8

IB'''r.

a.

f1r.,

18

'M,"al

. . .

tlon_b.,t . . . . the

po, •• lbl. 8114, ~he lapo •• lltl..

UD4.. 'he po ••

1"1.,...

oars

UD4e.-.~ Nth the _ . , • . . , ..0, _Uti wttlo11., .1"bOui~ Dot Beo ...

I

O&t_&;:'O., ....

ot o:our •• ,eon'-, .,' ,",.'

·t.

Ii . . .

we ...

,

agala

take

•• oeptloa WlL" Ile.:rkecaaNt

top"

&41l1\

ot

eo, •• thlD"e wh1eft

eOM l11'O

N'

aM

ret ' ••

".1 • 4o

80t ooatabl

'he

D&:iaU:I

'iJl.O.8"~7 with aD ab.,.lute

. . .

1'7. I' 1 • •

0' , . . .

, .s 118._laar4

euga ••

,tl.

81.pl"UM ,,'hl 0 . . . . 1.'obelDS ,hat it 1e DOt

. . 0 • • ' • • '., 'tril,be.au . . 1.

wa.

DO' Deo . . . . rl1'p . .

oont.1D.4

1D

-

.

1'.

oaUH.

.,'

108

4101'ur au, ••

allqul,4

per lnmo a04u.

, . 8 1 ••

1

ooa.·. '..

as

hoo

8.1uII

,.04

, ... 8,1' 1.

po'ea.ta

.,t quaft4oq;ue in

. . ' u . ( ••• ) .' .. 1'0 ••

'_11.

..1

ooati , . . . «1.('4 oppcal'.1' . . . a.i0 beo 1D . . .

t10-" _ . _ , ' _ . . . . l ' . .

0....

111\14

fl •• '

.. 11 ..

All thiac. 48,.a40. the will of <loA •• OD the

tll's'

0&\1 • •

ot 'M1r

_1_. JI.1I thewl11 ~t

_God

18

no' neo, •••

,lt.,ted to

ear •• '

ot,r-le. ,MIA

tu,t

of loy'1ft, bl.,~.lt,. Vb.a 1 t 1e

que.·

tloa

. f

or ..

,uJ' •• ,

1.

1&1dt~' w111'1\8m

DO:'

.1t·1\ abaolute. but .'lth hfpo\\k\et,loal De • • • •

lt,.."

W~. will •• t\UnJlater to

" 4l80u ...

loa

ot'!\18 .800M ITI). of •• o ••

e,1t,.

btlt

tor

the

~M4lftt.·.· ~. ~1}~·t.·. ~~~~Y.~;;"'t.,.·~

~~"'~ - ~. f8~¥w., _u,,~ v"'~w

011148 a,11 ."Iolute. 11 ••••• ,1t"po. ONatures.

Illa8

aut ••

rea

elapllclter et ab.ol·~lt.

_{neo_ •••}

•• , ....1a

1'._ ....

e.' p,o ••

1l:tl11taa a4 I\OD

.'....

aut •• reI el0

8"llt •

Dflo

1 •••••

.... 'uti 1 • • aPWI Datura' slt pot.Bbl. all

. ItOD

.8n_·

4:\l1._001l'lnsl,t ••. boo qu04

. . . . lala . i • • • ;' 1a pot.1"1a

u

allaa

to ...

Ill . . . . 1M rea 1n <1\111)u,. Ytll non ••

tl": ..

, ...

1,.,

•. . t 81

eat,

D . . . . '

po..

111. a4 .11&11

tor ....

D_ .• ·· .• t · . :&1..' ftOD • • M Ii

mI"

1,1'\11'

. • _ol\1,iJ.

...1.\)1101'.1' ••

0 •••• , • • t ••••• 16

~;w.~ _{'~~.~ ~} .. , .M6 . •

..

~

~~ii-" ....~ _{____ ". . .,} ~

•

.• ~

.ill.,..

vv ~... .··-ft-"~1:ft.1··~ v.,,,Vi%·'· .~>#. '~.. ""1,· A.\i;~.lYt YW~~,,,, ',Ill: ,_ fbat 1,'

to

8

a

r.

1t . . .

ao'

._aol.-.1, .ee ... ,

.bat

.e,. "

0",.-'4,1

tbe"

.a

all ... , . . . . '111 .• '" 004

,,1*

OItll,'bfPotb..'loal DeO . . ..

811),.111' '1U8

toe.

D.'

tf~*".·

u •••

0

..

01u4;8 _btlt all abe . .

,

1\1" . . . 111' 18

""".7 ••

01.484,'ro ••••• t1lPe8,

.e

.e Mve

a' .

."D...OYer,S,_

SI

'tu

ca ••

'h.' th •••

aNln •

• 'aa...et aaaoluM_ ...

1" 1. the Hala of

belns;. aleb oonM1D theae' . . .

·s;all111,1.'"a."

_lob. 001),'.1. 18 th . . .