Joint evolution of morphologies and controllers for realistic modular robots

(1)

O

pen

A

rchive

T

OULOUSE

A

rchive

O

uverte (

OATAO

)

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and

makes it freely available over the web where possible.

This is an author-deposited version published in :

http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/

Eprints ID : 18944

The contribution was presented at AROB 2017 :

https://isarob.org/symposium/index.php?main_page=arob22

To cite this version :

Akrour, Djouher and Cussat-Blanc, Sylvain and

Sanchez, Stephane and Djedi, Nouredinne and Luga, Hervé Joint

evolution of morphologies and controllers for realistic modular

robots. (2017) In: 22nd Symposium on Artificial Life And Robotics

(AROB 2017), 19 January 2017 - 21 January 2017 (Beppu, Japan).

Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the repository

administrator:

staff-oatao@listes-diff.inp-toulouse.fr

(2)

! " # ! " $ % &" ' $ ( ) * * ( * " ++ ' * * ' , " , ! ( ! * ! " " , + " , - + + ( + + " * ( ' . ! ! * + " ' ! * , / # * + " ," / + ( , , ! ' ," + ' , 0 * * ! 1 * ( , . " * / , + + , * 12+ * ( + " ' ++ * + , ! ( * + * + ( ! . 2+ ! , ( " * , * , , + " ' ' * , ! " , * ,

!"#

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

$ %

" & '

C , 0 + ," ) * * ! ! 3 5 # , 0 , " ( - ( ( + + ' , 0 * + + ' + "+ ! ' *

(3)

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

(4)

+ ? ' ( * * "+ ( + ( " * + "+ # * , ++ ( + "+ , ( * " , ++ , ' * + . , , ! ( "+ . 2+ * 8 8<G ' , * + ( # ! " ( H :4G $)$ # + # " * ( , ! " * + ," ++ " ? 1 * ( , > " F + A> F= 3H5 -* + + * ! , ' * * + ( ! * > ** ( ! ' * * *, ** # ' , , ! ' , * ' * , , ( , ! 2 *+ ' , " * ' "+ ! ! * *, ' + " # ! + ' * ' * , ** ( ! 2+ ' + "+ * *, * " ! " + ' + " " * # *, ' " *, ' " '' @ + " ' + , ' ! * - ! * * ** 2 * , ( , ' + ' * ' * ! # " * , ' , # A> F= + * - + , " " * + A ! " * += # + 0 + - + ! ' * ' * * ' * , , ' 2 *+ * *, ' * # ( " , ! 2+ ! * A ++ ' , = * + " ' , - 0 ' 2 " ' " * " ! '' , 0 , ! ! * *+ 2 1 * *+ " ' ' * ' 2 ( ( A ' * ' = " 4 B • • ? • * ! " • * A" ( + = • * ' • A ' ( ( = 1'' # , 0 '' ++ ? # ? ++ ' # ' ' + " *+ + ( ) ,) , ( ' + +

,

-% &"

1! ' ! , ( * ' ' ! + * ! ! . / * ! ! , 0 * + ( # * + * * + " ( + * , ++ + *, 1! " + ! " " ' * ( ! A '' + = + # ! ( *+ + + ' 2 $ + + ' "+ * " ( ' ( + * B + ' * 9 ! * 2 * * 8 ' ! ! C , ++ + 7 * (

(5)

' , ++ + 9 * / "+ 2+ + + + "+ - ! A+ "+ , = ! * ! * ,) . / + "+ ! ' ! , "+ + * , '' ," + > '' , * + " , * * ! + , , " ( * ! + * ! A , ! ' ! = . *, ' ++ ' ! ' ! # ' * ( ' + "+ A = , * ' ' C ' * , $ ( * + "+ + * A* + 2 = #( ( , ' * * ( , 0 "+ A + = ' * + + . ( * ' * ! ' 3 5 C , ( ( * * ( H * ,)$) -. *+ ! ," , ! + ' * , " + ' * C , ( ! ! * ' 87 ' * * # + ' , ' , A ' 8 =

/ - %

0-C , ( ! ," / , * - 2 ( ( + ' * ( ( + " , * ' * /) ) . 1 . " * / , + + , * ' * , A * ( , = @ ' " *+ ' * + ' * ' * + * ( " * ' * ( + " - + ! ' ! * * , * + " , ( + ( ! ! # + " + ' ! * * , , I> ' ( $ ' * A * + $ * = > '" * * ? ' # " + * ( JJ ' , 0

/)$)

2 # , * * * A! , ! = " + + " , ( ! " • > * B " ' * : * 7 * - * 3 H ;5 • > * B * ' * ! * ' * " > ! " ' ( • > * * ' B * * ' * '' " ' * , - * ' + * , ! * • $ B ( ++ * ' ++ ' ' ! , ( ++ ( ! ! , * ! . * ' ' 7 : ( ' 7 • K *+ B + ! " *+ ( " + # ! , * ! * ' ! 2+ * ( 7 7 • K ? B ? ' * * * ( , + ( ! ( ? * H: * • K ! "B * 2 * * ! " ( : L + * ( * 2 * * + , " " + ! , , ! . + ' * ( * B B # ? ++ , * * B # * ? , , * " ! , B # ? , ' + " , ' + , * ! ," ( # ( * + * ' * - ( ' *+ , ! ! ' ! , , ! ' , 2+ ' # * * + " + * * ( * * ' + ( !

(6)

3 -42-

0-

& -+"& +

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

(7)

' + , " ! '' ! , ! ( * - ' ( , ! , * ++ + ' ! ( " + ! " ? ' ( ) 5) 1! ! , 2 *+ 1 ! + " *

5 # #&"+

- + + ( ! " * * , 8 ! * - " * / , ! + * + " + * , * . 2+ ! , ( " * , * , , + " @ " * , ' * ! - ' ( ( *+ ! * , *+ 2 *+ 2 ! * ( , $ ( ( " * + ( ( *+ * * '' ( ( + ,

-(- - #-+

3 5 * ) A <<9= 1! ! ! F ' -//C F ( M <<9 ++ : 3 5 * ) A <<9= 1! ! 8 * + " , ! ," *+ ' ' -N F >-# F *, <<9 ++ ; 8< 385 K " ! ) ! K * > A 7 := 1! ! , * + " ' ! ' * " ! ! , " /1 @ F > 7 : ++ < 84 395 ++ ) " ! ) ! K A 7 4= > + * " , ! ' , , ! " ( *, ' ! * ' $ C , - 8A:<= 3:5 M * > .> * C > > + ) ! 1 / A 77H= > ' ' , , " * -111 C , O * > 9A = ++ 98 : 345 / + ) C A 7 7= > , " * -111 C , O * > HA8= ++ 8;P:: 3H5 ># * > A <<4= ( F. F , *+ " 3;5 , 1 * K A 7 := $ * ! " *+ ! ' : ++ 9H4 9; 3<5 + F K A 777= * * ' ' , ' ' * 974 ++ <H9P<H; 3 75 ) F A 77H= 1! ! ! ! /1 @ 07H F ' < ' / ! " *+ > ( M ++ 89 3 5 ) ( A 779= + * ' / , + * , * - -111LC K - ' - C , " * K + + 779 ++ 9< :9 3 5 , K " > ) ( F ( # / $ F ! - " $ A 7 9= C , / B , ' ! ' ' 9B -' " * ' ! " * ( M M K " 87 7 9 3 85 , A 77H= ( + ' ' - F ' -111 ' ' ' ++ 98 9< 3 95 * 1 C * A 77H= 1! ' ! + ' ' 8A = ++ 8<P :H 3 :5 , " / F K A 77 = 1! ! " * ! *+ / + :A4= ++ 79 79; 3 45 $ A 777= 1! " , >-# F > 3 H5 ! " K )( M * > A 7 = 1* ' ' , , ' >@C1 " * - C , " * 7 ++ 9949 994< 3 ;5 F K A 7 = , ! +* * , * + -F ' 7 / ! " *+ ' A/1 @= ++ :9< ::4