On the Impossibility of Group Membership
15
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. On the Impossibility of Group Membership Tushar Deepak Chandra. Vassos Hadzilacos. Sam Toueg. Bernadette Charron-Bost. N˚ 2782 Janvier 1996. PROGRAMME 1. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) !#"$&% ' ( )*"$+ -, .0/$12$354687979:;35<>=?2$3A@$BC4D30EFE G3 11FHI18JK3LBCM9NPOQ3 RSHT1TEEE UV35WX.0H /Y79Z[EEFEE \ 794@$3 BV79]^]7=?2$3544^HL@
(7) _`\ HI1F]VEEEEFE a
(8) bdcSefbhgi8ikj?lnmponbhqdrAsutvjqwtvxAbdjy*zLgb`g{ua
(9) {}j| bv{ucjwyj~9tLgnyv$jy*
(10) 9Vj$09cf A0j jFy~AbAj yvj^gx9+jtnyv 9yvtj| ikjy[sydtvbds5xj y [gzAzLcfbvt[9j*bdjqdrAjbhqdrAj?fSSm9g99sujb?lfSnmlSlnzLgefjy. u«}s kgxA$g{u¡FydtQ¢ £ zA¤ qvbv¥r5cA¢fbvq`cS¦Sj5§ydcSyvj$jxAy*yzAbdtdyvcrL 9Sgyvj$tdt[jtdgikrLbvgj?ytCª0jtvbdrAsubvtvjcfrkAzAq`jbvb`cSsugiKx5ydyvr g{u kbv«} fgyd¨QsxAzL{uxAyvgz bdbdjtvjysuq`tv~ftdsujjcff0jeStvkc bvcfs¬«VrLxAcSg^z?S5i8j?jq`jgb`i {ug{ucLydª0rAjFjbvy
(11) yvTtvr5®rAsznjnzAbvjbvi8cfAc{uSjgi©{9cSqbgA9Asu{cS{usutCALenjcyv«VcfA{uScfj9 ¨ 9¯8su{°9{usu±TA²ve?³?c´ «Y£SAµ
(12) cf¡9¦>¨¶«}geSxAbvcf{utQxA z+zAi8bvcAjq`i jFyvLyvjFjFbvyyv® r5szC~Lgyd 9LqdrAbvcfAcSxAy(yv 9yvtdjiky^~Iqwbhgydr«}gsu{uxAbdjy~ zAbdsiKgbd kzLgbvtvsutdscfV~. ¹· ¸ »¶º ¼Q½^¾ »
(13) º ¿
(14) Àu¼QÁ}Â`à ÈÛ`ÄvÉ}ÄdÄdÈwÅVôYÜDÆvãdÍ Ç¶Þ¹ÆvõAî¬É}Èwö`Õ`É}âêïʶåË$÷¹ÍÏÌSøTËSÈwù>Æ
(15) É}ÍÏØVÎÐú
(16) È`ÈÑÒóSÍÏÐÔÓ
(17) û^ÉQóǹÈ`Ôü?ÑÌÙ^ÈÌ9ÊQͶÕ`ÎÐÇPÆðÉQÕwÜSÍPÜ[ÆdÊvÖ
(18) ÅVÆvÇ5×DÆvÈ`ÓǶÆvÜSØYÈwÖ[É}Ù^ʶñ5Ú(ËÜSÝ Û`Û`É}ÎÒÆðÜSÈwÜDÜDÆvͶÆðÍLÆQÉPÉ`ÝTÎÒåÜSÝ íÛ
(19) â[ÅßÅCÞ¹Ù^àÆvÈ`ǶáýkÆvâÈ`ã`ÉQùnäFʶàËòÎÒÑáAÝ å`ÅVæVÕwÕÔçVÈFÜSÅCÖ9ÊQÎÒåèSÑôVç
(20) ÕwÈ`î5é`ýTØVÝ Í¹ç
(21) ÈwËSÜSÙ^ÕwÈÉPç+ÖÜSÈÆFçTåó ê[ØTÆdþïÇLÛ`ö`ÉQâÈ`ì`ÜíÍAãDØVåhÿ
(22) çVÙ^ëYç$ÞÏãhó ÞÏìwàíå`È`ÜSÖ ÝÄd ÄvÄvÈ`ÄvÄvÜSÄ`Ä ÈæYÝ ÖÕ`ÆðÈê0ÌSÈ`ùÌÉQÔS͹ìFê[ÍPÙÆðÆðÉIöwÜDçYÙ^Í9Ó^ö^Õ`ÇPóîLͶÆQÝ ê[Õ`ê0Ç ÅVÌÔSÆdÇPͶÆdÆQÈ`ÉIÉ}Ù^ʶË[ÊðÎÐÆQ÷ ÜSÜSÊdÇPÍÏÆÎÐå`͹ÿTÔSͶÌSÆǶå`Õ`ÿTÜÜôCÎ È`ÆQÑÒÉQ¹Ç¹åDÎÐÝ Í¹ÓÕ`ɶÕ`ÜSîAÆQú9ÑÒSÕ`ÿßÉQÕ`ÜÜDΠͶÕÆQÉQå ÇÏÎÐ͹CÓå`ÎÒÜS÷¹ÍÏÛ ËSÇVÈÊvÝ ÈÕ`åÑÒØßÐÆdþ ÛÆVö`ÅCáä^ÕÈì`íÖ9å`å^ÿYúÕwÙ^É}ç$Õ`óÜú ͶÕËå ÎÐßÇTÈ`ÜDÔSͶÈ`ÍÏɶËSÎÐÕ`ÕÉ å Ävý ÄdÄvÕ`ÄvÉ Äd^õÆvÈwÖ[×ÕwÕ`ÜÉQÈÍÏͶËÕ`ÎÐÎÒÇAÉ}Æ ÌSÖÈ`Ì9÷uÆQÜÉTîuÕ`ý ÉPê[ËÎÒÈFÑÐÆ
(23) ͹ΠËS`Æ
(24) ÔSÆ ýLõ9ÈF÷ÇT$ÈåÍVñ ÷¹ØCÊvÕ`ÅVÑÐÆ
(25) ÷¹ç èAÕwÑÐè5ÓÉ}ͶÕÆv¶Ê¶ÆvËÊdÜÍAÎ `ÅVÔSñ ÆFÚAåvàõ9öñIöFÝTã`ä$Ù ßèAÅVÈ`ÑÐÕ^ÈwÊÎÐÇPFÆdÔSÈ`ÆQÔÜSÊdÝ Õ`ÆvÔÖÉPÆ ÍdSåhåÚ^ÚAÉQÈ`ÅCÜSçVÊvÆFØ
(26) ó Ý ñVó . . . . .
(27). . . . . . . Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt. . .
(28) "* $% w
(29) $ # "? % +"$ (
(30) + ?"
(31) $( nX
(32) % "$ %K xAj A°As"zL f¡gxA5jAAjS° j~^jzL ¦ t$jx5 òq`j$t cSq`jxA#s5tvy(ibdj0zAj# bvbAi8cfj ydxAjYcSSyd{us9cfx A{!A ycfg fAxAgy
(33) xAj xAtd {ucSj bdyvs 9zAydj$ydbvtcf{%j| Ai8j`{}Lj| jq`ik{ugxAj yvyv 9su9cSLj8 qdrA!{ 9Òbvgx?cfzAAeSzLj0bdgcScVbdxAx tv| z j q`jjgcSbdLthx?q`gj{¹sg'5gyY| &dz5ikxAbvsucAyvq`j[eSjbdgò|ydcSyvikxAxAz ycSjkbdzLtjF([g^xAS9Sjjjq 9zAz t$bdgctdbvcSqwtdi jsuyvtv ydsucSxAj yb q`cfbvbvj^q`tv)y fxAsTyvcf9t0yvxAydzLjqwtAj y^~g(| tvcfbvt~ * +#jtvbdj?tvcfi 0j yjKzLg5AjS® zA,>bds´ iK¢Dg¡F²hsubv.¥ jf-/~S° j`¦Lq`g{uzAxAzLydsugcSbv+tvjF* LgxALkqwjz5bvg0| cAxAq`j ydyveSxAbdy?cSxAq`z cfjSbvbv~^j^yvq` 9tyv® tj| ikjFy;gyv 9LqdrAbdcSAjy^~Sj` «Qgsu{u{ gLq`j$z gbYgbv b j# t~z gbvtdsutvsucS.
(34)
(35)
(36) "!#%$& (') *#!##+,. -. ; $"$ %0& /0rAj zAbdcSA{uji c«10 !2$& 3 * !##+4 rLgy*LjjFïtvr5j?«PcAq`x5y?c« i x qvr tvrAjcfbvjtds¹qg{0gL j`Az jbvsuikjF9¨ «Pth cfgjbv{
(37) ig8ª gcfyvtvjbvsu+t cSKccf«[+gLz5«}bvgcAxAiq`{ujtQg¨Qydtvyvsucf9jy8{tvjFjFbhtvLgrLg9gLt[tqw9jgsubdcydjktv«bvq`g suAc9ydx5cSjtvz t*jjcbhg« ydtv z5suAydbvtvcAe+jq`i8tdjcydyyvª® jgy o bh9qeSgybd{u{ucSg jxA+q`zcSg5i8ik0 ikj!#i %cS$& K j®Tt`bdg5yvrAyvcS7subnzK6¶j`zAjSL®bvgeLcfik®utv~TcAz5tdq`rA{cfjfj {$~Ag zAibveSgsuiKbdLcSggxAefbvz j y[igtdLrAg^ j Ltvr gfgqvt 9xAyvzKx5Aydyhjq`bvbdfsujLbvj+y*ctdcï« g g+Az ggthbvgtdLs¹q`gxAyd9j{¹g8b ~ g AjFyvª0jtnyveScbd«$cSzAxAbvz;cA8q`~$jFyvcfyvb jFy?tvrAtvjKrLgydt0jtkyvrLcg«bvjg{ug {0qwzAcSbdikcAq`i8jyvcSydj yKsusuïtdjbvtvjFr5yvj+t:yv6PjS 9®yve tdj®~Ai qw{sutvjrL9gtdty «}eSggbdbdsjcS{uxAjq`ßzCxA~L®Lbdsubv9t?jsu9ikftdcS{su {¹{uxAgbd99{uthj Sgj~Sbvi8g su{uj kzAKbdbdc jtvqwc fjxAyv jy?j yviKtdcSjz g^ 1jtvbhA c+g%tvsu{ucSjg^Lg fgjS{QeS=®~Tbv<Qcfcf+bxAzCeSsut?jB5«PsucSynjbhb0«Pgcfj`{}bhL~ q`gg suikAzA{u +zAbdcA{ujSj`q`A~9jz suyvt0y(ji{ui{ujg^g^ 9rL> g^#?%fcf@%j?tv rALjg jFb(jeS+ikbdcSyvjxAjFi {zKj^ q` jtvjjbvqy*gcxAtd«c yvj tdbvrAj`sujt¨ zAyvx {¹gSqvrïqwjg* zA bdgcAikq`js¹q*yvy0qdtdrLrLgg5teSjrLy*gy su+bdjyvq`cfjik9tvj{u qwcS{uj`rA«PjtbdtvjrA9jnteSª0bvg^cf 9xAD®zV<Q®f+o tdrAefbvsuycfxAz z gz ikjb?ji ª j jbdq`yvcfrAAsuyvz s¹9zAjFbvbcftvefcAbvq`cfcSxA{Tz i i8x5jyvi t
(38) i jgbvLydgrAefsuz j zAbdcStv/0cArAq`jKcf{uy0eSbdtvcSrLxAgz t0jikAyvjx5i bv j jzAbvydbvrAcAsuq`z jydz5yvjbvy?cS5g{eSjFbvi jFj?ªcSg8Fy tvE rAjbvyvtkqwxAbvbd#j jEL9At[j ikjF«Pcfi bLydj 9bdLyvrAqdrAsuz bvcfcA«;cStdxArAy j*ydeS 9bdyvcStvxAjFzVik® y 9H GÒbvs¹AJl Iv® yv9OUx5suT1LSq``VWjjOq`tKtv2 r5XLcjY~« VO~s9AtvtdrA2 jXLjAY~ yveSjTZbdcSM+s9xA5fz j% yvXAiktd~Lsje9[ i gM+td scfAjKbv] yd\5rA6PY~ sujSzïM+® eL^zA®u~ MKbdcSG L oA{u/[2 jX%i. 5Il8~N`® «¶cS_ M+bjFa$tg~L5yv 9AjLlSyvqd~0zArA subdtdcSjO A5tdcfrAlxAj?~QykPRª0ydP* s¹9yd[j?tvjfsui89Atv~$yKj9bdrLj
(39) gyv[tnyK tvg-rL{u~$gyvc t[ARsuLt0OjrLjFg yS
(40) tdgrA-tðj ¨ ~ tvgb`ydgS 9q`LtdqdjrAbvcfgALcSKxAtdynrAyvj 9yvtdx5jikikjy0bdsucSyxA«}yngb$zAxA«¶bvAcS{uis¹qgLtdsujcSsuAAe y0cfx5+L9tvjrAbdsuyvyntvc9yvxAcASb`a;j^<Qq`Kt~CzLtvgrAbdj(tvs¹eSq`xAbvcf{¹gxAbz+~9tvi8r5jji bvj?LsujFy0bvAyvr5ckszKgeSzAbdbdjcSjAK{uj9i j#EL«¶5cSsÐb¨ tvG o[sucf ON«PcfM5b0/[tvrA] su\y0Iv® zAbdcSA{uji~gL8yvcSi8j[c«Ytvr5ji8cSydt bdj`«PjbdjLq`j «¶cSbviKg{L#j ELAsutvsucfAy[gbdjx5AyhgtvsuyQ«}gfq`tvcfbv «Pgcfefbvbvi jTnjFikjcyv« zAj9zAsutdt bdj+cAsuq`tvjrAyvjFyvy szAbKgsutveS9j bdsjcIcjjF«*i8bvj«}jgL9suqw{ut[jxAysubd+~[jykgyv 9{usu{0eyydtvSjd ji8bd%yvy[sucSª0A=suy8tv
(41) rKc$`«* «QN®gtvsurA/0{uxAj+r5bvsjefy y^bv® cfz5xAo[bvcSz A5cf{iktvjFrAi jFji b*~
(42) LrAªjcjbdª{uyv{¬rAj¨}9SsuzAjFbczA~0ª0bdqcSKgA5zA{ujAbdi cScSAt {ubvj j i j+ Sx5yvbdscf jbdj+{u fSxAjyvsucfbvsuikAsuej gqgyd 9 L9qdcnrAbvyvcfcnAcScSAxA{uy( *yv9 9 yvtdf j!ik?#y?+jF S0j~^ sQ® jfsЫ[®~Fq`s¬cf«iksutCi yvtvxAcfzAAy
(43) suqj`gAtdsujcSq`KxAtdsusuyAe*bdjyv{utvs¹gjFzAARy{ujSGÒ~T
(44) cfVAa${u +` \cSIð5®9j suLzAqwbvcAj$q`tvjrAydjy zAixAbdg^zL &cf«}yvgj0su{Qc~T«LgeSLbdcSxAsuz t ikgkjFi Lgjikbdyvs¹rAqsugz+{u{ suy*qdtvrLc g5jAeSsuyvAx5ekbvjkydjydtcS8Fi8~Tjtvr59jsuLz cStdcj«[9tvgs¹eSgbd{Cj«Pjcfi8b[jbv9x5tAAgsuikAekcfAsuek9tvzAckbdg&cAq`yvjsuyvikydjsuy{¹gb6Pcfsuiktvz rAcSj ydyvi8suAjsu{ui stQ jbvbvjFydyvrAxAsu{uz+t?csuy« cSª09g^9 su&y cSa xAy^Y® gn+tdrAjcftvrAjFbr gLT~5eSbdcSxAz+i8ji jbvydrAsuzsuy*9s cIjbdj9tn«Pbvcfi cfAyvj5yvxAy?su gt[{ujgyvt[tQªc h <QefbvcSx5zi8ji LjFbvyvr5szC~DgnzAbdcAq`jyvytvr gt
(45) suyYydxAyvz jq`tdj8tvc*rLg^fjq`b`gydrAjkqFg j ! *2@#i ǦbvcSi tvzArAbvj0cAq`efjbvydcSy
(46) x5ªzVg~SyVcfcSb$5j{f njSjjbd *k>yv#{ui cªR~j8f®j/0krAs¬j1«TtvGÒ
(47) rAsuVy$ayd]xA\yvIz5i8s qwscAcf9 j{suy gScq`jFtdyVxLAgcf{u{utV ?yvz suLjq`gcfbvbdgjLq`cf t xA6PtVjSz5® eLbv®ucA~q`tdjrAydj[y$ydbvxAjyvi8z cjSq`tdgj{uy ~ gL&st[cjFy[Acft9subdjq`tv{u KikcA9jF{LzAbdcAq`jyvy*9su{u{suA:e 6¶s}® jS®u~9zAbdcSefbhgi&¨ðqwcS9tvbdcS{u{uj q`bhgyvrAjFy 8® h cSAydjAyvx5y0bv j fxAsubvjFy[zAbdcSeSbdjyvy0su ?% bdxAAy^~9ª0rAsu{jneSbdcSxAz8ikji jbvydrAsuzkg{u{ucª0y$bvx5Ay0tvrLg A{j^cSg^tdSrAj[suAtdrAe (lj?ef6¹«PbvcfcSb x5suzVA~AydthggLL8q`jSA~ c &hz59bvcfcAs5q`jeydyAcfq`tvb`rAgyvsuAr5e j(y8Fsu® y[9jFyvsubhgA{ujª0r5jKAc zAbvcAq`jFyvy[ª0suydrAjy[tdc[`cSt su &`9cfc b /0rAjydj9s cTjbvjFLq`jy[gzAzLj^gbtvc?iKgSjeSbvcfxAz ikjFi LjbdyvrAsuz?ªjgSjbtvrLgkcSAydjAydxAy~AgL?su «}gfq`t$tdrAj ELbdyvt
(48) cSAjrLgyY jj ª0s¹9jF{ ?q`sutdj gy
(49) g[bdjgydcS ª0r9 ?eSbdcSxAz?i8ji jbvydrAsuzsuy
(50) yvcf{uSgA{uj
(51) su gyv 9LqdrAbvcfAcSx5y yvª 9j ydtvzAjbdi8cSy[jª0tvrLrAgsu{utVj?tdrAsucSyYAsuydy
(52) jAAcfyvx5tVyyv;c suyna§AcSj :t 9G mj ELO Aj[5lg0~Az5Zo bvcST15LZ{jFM+i©fqAg;~ {u{uT1joLZM+n U- ' ;~ T16¹M «PcfA b % n XA~ #Q? j M+ "A!#` %\&$&Iv D® <Q')+td *rAsu#y[!#zL#g+zL, jFb8 tv9r ggt09g {u{ubdcjª0gyYydcStdLrAgj*Abv{ujj[i89c#j SELgA{9sutdcs«VcfjF bvbvccf«TAeSjbdcfcSxAxAyvz {u ki8ydjxAi yvz LjjFq`bvtdyvjr5KszCzA~DbdgcALq` jyvyvydr5jyncª «PbvcftdrLi gttvrAH§ jnVFeSbvM cfxAzVqg~9Ag5LcS&t$su y$j[yvxAydcS5{uyvSxAji8 jsu gq`cfyd 9ikLi qdrAxAbvAcfs¹AqcSgxAtvsuyCcSyv( 9syvy0tdjbdikj{uyCs¹gª0Asu{utvj?rng«}Lg&su{uxAª0bdrAjyj®`bd§jgpj t0ELi8bdyvcSt
(53) yvyvtrAcSc5ªjtvr5z5j$bvcAsuq`ikjydz ycSyviKydsug^A su{suq`tQb` $gyvcrC«A~Lq§ jw5VWgfM©q`tv{usu K*yvg 9y0ydsutv)ji8GÒ
(54) yTVª0a$rA`j\bvIvj ® §j$tdrAj?j`AtdjL(tvrAsuyV5jegtvsuSj$bdjyvx5{tCtvcnyv 9yvtdjikyCtvrLgtYg{u{ucª+zAbdcSefbhgi&¨ðqwcS9tvbdcS{u{uj0zAbdcAq`jyvyq`bhgyvrAjy^® .. ÅVÅÜNrãs`äã.
(55) X. `qq`cfjydyvtdgnjbhygAyvtvj*t0r cgtv«VtYc tvgr5i8bvj[j0cSbv9ydj^t$jgjj`yvi8AcfsuAjyvtvy0(suAª0tvc[e r9 eSjbdH§ cScSxAz VFz8jM bhikgtvjsusuy$i cSªL gjj{;gbd yv6PrAjSs®sueLyz ®utv~`yvr jFG gbvt$9O s¹suq`5tjliy[~^ª0g
(56) fr5j[cSy
(57) yv j*A- c ~%efONcggtvTZtd{TjVFsuikyOtvz5%c t$XAitv~% c TZgsM+&d9tvb`t`AgSg2suqdXA ~%(?g(M+«}yvgDjFsut[MK{x5co*bv«
(58) j%&y zAX%a%bvI<Qc8F ¨ ~ §Htvr5j0VFcSM A{u *c§HjFy0VFAM cSt0bv{uj su SAx5 sbdtvjr5ikjjFi8t
(59) ji tdrL gjt
(60) bvydtvrAsujsuyz tvcrA«YjtdikrAj?ji efbv cSjx5bdzkyvrAª0suz?sutvcr+«LgStvrAqwtvj0xLefgbv{TcfcSxAb0zyvtdx5c yvz &vjbvj^q`gtvj^{usu tQ /q`(0b`gsuy$ydrAgnjSyj®;bd<Q ?LªjjjgT ~ Ag cft0K<QzAt?Lbvgsujy*tdqwxA{sx bhi8g9{
(61) zLj?cfcStvbvAr5t`j]jga^9z <¶t0«cStvydg cKyvsuydAAsusuAcf{ueSsutvtQj {u j?tvtvzAr rLbdggcAt*t q`jcSKsyvxAyb(y+bbvsujLvydj9xA Sj{ux5j^tKjgyvtvtdzArAy?z5j*{tvsuc8cfjy*A{j^{ucf kg^ASzA{uj* bdctvtdrAqwcKjj yveSyneSbvbdcfbvcSjxAxAi8zzCc~IikSg jjF i §H«PLbvVFcfjbdMi yvrAtvzAsurAzKbvj(cfyvtvjFeScAbvbvq`9cfcSs¹xAq`{
(62) zVjydy ® rAcStvrLxAg{¹ t gL td/[tvjAi8lfzA+~ M+t
(63) tvac?AiKAlfg+~su9M+thg^ sMK?g o
(64) 2 XL ~ 0 [ Ag` eS\&bvIjF8j`® /0rA9jsujydªïjgcbv«VjntvrA5j[cqwª0xAbvkbdjg9y t0 Yik!
(65) j i ?% !jbv ydrA?2su!#z? c«Y2gn efeSbvbvcScfx5xAzzk6Pi8jS® jeLi ®u~D GÒ jbvO ydrA5sulz ~ yvtvjFr5bvj9efs¹q`bvjcfy?xAz gLik jgi bvj* jsu9bdyvtvrAj suz 9jtvc qd«PcSrLb0g5yd eSj[ydtvsujki8gy0t ª0i8sutvcSr+yvtAcSc A5jnjAtQªjtQcfªbvcSKbv8zLgzLbvgtvsubdtdtvssucftvsuAcfyV~9~cftvb0r5«Pjcfb0&dzAyvbv 9suyviKtdjgikbv (y0zLtdrLgbdgtvt*sutvgsucS{u{u c(Lª ® tv99c?ccf¨ðikq`qcgj[¨}{ujw{bdj^jsuiydt Dg~^?%bvrL9!mg^y0S gj0 2gYcS{uydxA?]c[t0> ydxLjeSjqdbv r+cfzAxAyvjbdzKcSbd9z iks cSqwjyvji j^y gjGbv9bdj*
(66) yvrAeS[susuSzk jF- yd ~^jAbvg9R t0s¹q`OtvjrA y^j*~TS$jª0 -rAk~s¹qdOUcr+«$TZgtvVFrA{u{usucOy0ª % zLXLg %~ zLTZ$=j4b^M+®, ;A>2 XL%~ suTZjª0M+ynAc` «
(67) \9tv~SrAQ j M+eSAbdcS` xA\Ivz ® ª0gydr9 9 +L/0qdsurArAt*j*bvscfy*bvAjªydcSt[xAjgy(cT«;yvb® 9tdrA<Qyvtdsuyjik9z jgy^qwz ®btvjsu/0cSb[rA suj y0- zAcS~Tbdbvª ec9gcj A«0yvs sur5y*jckªzLggtdtdytvrAj«Pj bdcSA{usu{uikjcª0z yg^cS`®«¶ydtvyv<Qjsu+Ab?su9td{usjrAtQq`j tdsucSccSA«+j H§ Aef~9VFsªfM jj?+9ssu#j 7ELtvAG r5
(68) j((j Cq§ a$G
(69) VW]C\M a$I ]ª0g\su I tdr i8j`tdcAArA9zAjj{¹{
(70) jwgsuc ¨« ª0tvq`sujcfg^z5 ktvy^su?cS~L8gq`LcSc K«Vq`tvsu{ur5+xLj[99jyvjyt`q`gtvtdbdrAstvcfjnsu) AzLe?\ g{uz jªji8j?bij`ª0AgAsutvtv® jr <Q yv+cf9iksuj^t0q`j0tvtvc8cfsucSAlyvyv 9jX?yvbdtdSªjgikj[tdsynyvcftdAtvbvrLy$j5gcfteS tvgr5tv{rAj{ucKjnª yvtvz rAz5jsubvy$q`cSssuefEIikbhqggz i tvcSsuydcS¨vyvq`8sucSA9csu«V{utvsubdtQeScS bd{ucS{ubdjxAjkyvz x5qwi8{bhtgjsuydi rAj Sy^gj®Vbvbd9ydscfrAjxAsuqdz y¨ yvjFbv9s¹q`jy® ' ©"$ (. K
(71) §6Pz5bvjsuiAcgª#bv f¨}9z jFgyhbvq`tdbdsustv sucSjïY 85H§ eSbdVFcSMxAz(~[ikg ji zAbv cfjAbv{uydjrAipsuz*tdyvrLjgbdt+s¹q`qj0gzAydrAtvxAcSbdx5j{ yLg j0yvgiKA{ugj{u{0tvcn«Pb`zAgbvefcik9s¹j99jStk&® /0c« rAjª0sur ikgz t+cSgyvydsubvAjsug{su{tQsuyd tvcs¹q « yvtvcfsuA{ue(suAike cS§Hbdj0VFbvjM g{ussuyd+tvs¹q0gydef 9bvLcfqdxArAz bvcfikAjcSi xAyn jyv 9bdyvyvrAtdjsuz ikyvynjbdª0sus¹tvq`r8jFy[«}gsu su{uxAyvbdxLjqdy r8sui8yv 9zAyvtd{usjjFiky y^td=®rA/0j?rAsuikj[z su9cS«PydcfyvbvsuiKAsug{us{9tQ (yvz cj«Yq`ssuEIi8qzAg{utvjsucSik8jc«¨ §Hyvz jVFq`sMEIqFeSgsutvSsucfjF++rAsukjbdtvj jFbvsikyny0yvx c«YqwtdrAsjFj*t*iktdcAck9jxA{TLc«"jbvGÒ
(72) ydthVga$ `\tvIYrAsuj y0eSyhq`suScfjFzLkj sugk tdKrAj?ikAjgj`AAt0suAyde jq`ctv«sucfcSVxA® bnbvjydxA{u9t BVg «PcSbdig{ sQsut0® jSsu®uy~A9 9cS?% KA$=ydyv,s¹ tv9cfjzA®9b §zAsug+Aje ydg yvtdydydcktvxAjj`iki Aj*jq`ª0tvx5r stvtdgjkr t0ydsutvAjsuz5 tvs¹ygb® X{u<¶{u « zAg bd?%cz5qwbvjzAcAyvbvydq`cAjjyq`ydjFy?yvyvAjFjyfjgb?bd j?q` bhsu gyv rAtdIrAj~Cj?y^~Vtvy`r ªggikj?t jny`qg^geS bdcSsutn«}xAgz!ssu y {$ ®cff %A;!
(73) {uMK !# cSf 9bd j~9cSz5f tvbv!r5j?&jq`#bvsu=ydª0jsu{uyv 0j ~~ tvyvr5cfik#j j0" !#zA#bd cAq`@9jyv%yd$ jy[ iK g^ *cª0«sydjrkfjtdbv c 6PfzAcSbv{ucAxAq`9jthydgykbvsusu{uy 8CtvrA{ujjKg^fyvjFj0't eSbv&)cf( *xA(4z + ®,.`/0- /rAsu0y1~9gy$ ª j0{u2 {T2g39y ®
(74) gfo0q`tvt xLgtv{LrAj8cfb LydjFxAeSyvsuz AjAq`sutdAje ~ q`=b`g#yv r5?%j4y"~9;iK%$eg^ @&qF8g$xAyd&j[tvs¬r5«Tj[st
(75) ik9jjFq`i s¹9LjFjy bdyvtdrArLsugz?9t c& «>tsy
(76) dsutvc?y
(77) qvydr jgq`cSA efj] a95sucSjbªïgc9:« 5&76¶yv6xLqd&)rk( *g*(+`9~jªqwsj0ydsuyhcSg^ stvy rLg!t !g*@zA fbd?]cqw>j yv8y ® §HVFM y`gtdsJy ELjyntvrAjn«Pcf{{ucª0suAe?z5bvcSz jbdtvsuj9y a lfU® <¶j« Sj9 td~AxLcfgb {u{u su~9AcSyvb0t`g {ucS{uytder g A6}gjFLª 89Asuc jª?cS~AtdrAg jb[kz55bvc cAq`zAjbvydcAy 8nq`jª0ydy[suyvsurKAydtvthc g{u{u{ujy[g^g f;j 9&~s cIAjbdtvjr59jt[ AgjFt0ª {uj9gsuyvjt0ª?cf® Aj?zAbdcqwjyvy 5®0tvArLcfgb0t LydcfcStvik!r jn<>zA=?bvcA-9q`*l jF`yv y[3su~fAs¬yd:« th (g${{uysuy0AtvjrAª>j?9cfsAjF{u@ª zA& bv( cA,7q`jF&yvy*( *tv(rL+gA t0- ª0su( yv3rA`® j<Qyntvcfc tv{urAjjFg^b0f;jª cf&~bh9Ay^tvr5~Ajtvr5Kjsbvt0j*susuy0y[z gcStyd{uyvjsuAgyd{ujt cScSAAj*j*j`bvjFAikjq`cx5Stvj^sucS K«PbdsucSKDi ª0 ®rAs¹qvrB ( suytvrAj(cSA{u zAbdcqwjyvyntvrLgt0ª0sydrAjyntvc {j^g^SjC©gLKg{uyvc tvrAj*cfA{u bvjFyvtvbds¹cSq`tvi8sucSzL5gy bdjcS+A{utd c cSg8«Px5tvr5{{¬#j0¨ EL" j9!##ef jsueSjbdª cSxAqdzrLgi8AeSjjSi ~$ gjLbvydrAcSsuz+5{yv jbds¬9F« s qwjS ~
(78) cSH§ Gb VF M suAsusuy?tds Sgj{u{bd K ª0ªsujyvgr Itvp® c+<Qt?{ujsug^ikfz jkcStdydrAjjy ÷ÏØVÅV÷Ïç.
(79)
(80)
(81) "!#%$& (') *#!##+, \. eSzAbdbdcScxAqwjz yvy6¶scSttdyhrAg^j 9by0tvArLcfgtv rAsuA e cSgb/ cS x5ª0t0syvydxArAAjyydj tv fc*xA{ujj9g^t[Sj 9suW8jª-®qd
(82) rLSgjFAkefsujy~5tdrAcSb[suy gqLgcfyvxAjS~ft cSª0Ar {u ?gt0cfAyvr5jcSzAxAbv{¹cA8q`jrLydgy0z5suzLyYjbdKj fs¬xA«;sugbv9j tvc suAydthg{{Tg Ajª>9sujª?®YMKcfbvj*suikz cSbdthg9td{ ba § VWM 9c9jy0Acft[gtdtvji8zAt tdc tvb`gSqdgfq`tvxLgQ{ 6¶cSb0jfjKyvxAydzLjqwtvjD 8«}gsu{uxAbvjFy® h q h /0rAj+yvj^q`cSL bvj Sx5sbdjikjFt c«?q yv{j^jg^bdSjs¹q`jf ~Y® /
(83) gc Lyvjj sKtvr5ª0srAy^~As¹qdq`r+cS5Ayvc&s¹9«}jgbnsu{u§ j`xAAbdVWjjy[q`MpxAcftdb0ssucfy8«}AgLy*s{ugxAsutdkbdxAj*ª0bhgyvrAxA{0s¹ydqd«PzA5rcfs¹bkq`2(sucSg$9Asuy0 ïy*tvcAbdr5qjj?q`gxAydcScSb^AL®b{u g<Qt[AzA{uydj+bdthcAgeSq`Ljbd9cSyvy*y*xAz tvtdc8rLi8gbvtnjjgª0i yvscS yd rAjbvjtvydynrLrAgtvsuzc t sKgt0{ujgyvt0cS5jydxLqdr+j`Ajq`x5tvsucSV~ 2($g kcfA{uC 2($suy0bdjikcfj «PbdcSDi &® h CLq`jzAtn«Pcfb[tvr5jtQªckj`AjqwxAtvsucS5yi8j9tvsucS5j8s tvrAj zAbvjFsucfxAy[sutvjFi ~AtdrAjbdjsuy[5ckbvjFyvtvbds¹q`tvsucS cSbvji8tvcrASj8j(yv«Ps bvcfjki#cfbefbvq`cfcfxAz tdj9t?gcï«[tdgrAbvj AsuAtvb`jgªbd suydjjFª ta c<Q«[ïzAbvgkcAydq`sujFAyveSyvjF{uj y~$9susuLjqwª {x qv9r suAgAe+efq`j cSbdq§ bvjVWq`t M z5bvsuycAq`gj{yd{uyvcjªy8jtv rLgtvc t s9q`y[bhs¹gKgyv{urAA{cjcSªßtnj® ª0&suyvtvr+c bvtdjFcik{ujcg^Sfjnj «Pbd ®cSi^/0tvrArAsuj(yeSsuy*bvcfq`xAcSzKi8zAzLbvgcAtdq`s5jF{yvj*yvjFª0y?sutvtvrLrggt[9g Kbdj?eSbvjcfbvbdxAcSz+AjFi8cSjxAi yd{ KLjFydbvxAyvr5yvz szKjq`ydtdjjbv9s¹tvq`c8j rLtvrLg^Sgjt c A %k tvrAj?efbvcfxAzV® h /0rAjbvj gbvj*Ac bd j fxAsubvji8j9tvy0cfbd j fxAjydtvy[tdF h /0rAjbvj gbvj*Ac bd j fxAsubvji8j9tvy0cftdrAj*Abvc9gSAqFgyvt0cfb0i xA{utvs¹qgyvtc«Yi8jyvy`gefjy=® <QKcStdrAjbnª cfbh9y^~ tvyvrAxLjqdr+bdj?9gjbv{uj*suSAjc bdsujbvy[jFyvsutv9bdtvs¹jq`bdtv{usujcSg^5Sy0j*ª0ª0rLsugtvtdr8yvc9jsujSª-jFb[qdcSrL8g5ikeSjjydy^yh® geSj[9j{usuSjFbv 9~AgL&s z gbvtds¹q`xA{¹gbcS8tvrAj*ª0g^ ' K
(84) ' +( §ikcAj9AjFc{Lªc«Y«Pcf9bvsuiKyvtvbdgsu{uA{u xAtv9j^j#E AqwcSj0iktvrAz5j0xA§HtvsuAVFe M~ gzAikbdcSjFA{ 9{uj~i sukggLyd( 9LyvrAqdrAcbvª cfAtdcSrLxAgy0t
(85) suydt$ 9yvqtvgjFAik5cSyt$ª0 stdj0rkyvcfbd{jf{usjg(As{u jq`tvcfr5ikj GÒi
(86) xAV5a$s`qgD\I¨ tvTsu 9cfL+qdª0r rAgjLbdj gaYt[giktvjcfbdyvyvcft0 cfAsuKj?zAG
(87) bdcCqwa$jyv]y?\IviK®
(88)
(89) g^ kyvydq`jbh9gtvyvs¹rVg{u® {u /0~CrAtvj?r5jkzAbdcSc5c{« ïsuy[s fcTjjbvbd +jLydq`suikj+suyd{¹tvgjb$i8tdcky*«Ptvbdr5cSji cfAtdj?rAj c«0«}gfVq`sut y`qvtvr5rLjgbt ~ q`sucSzL5gyv{{uj AydcfxAAy[j*bd{j jF fikxAisubvjgy'm&dtvjtdbdrAikj*sucSLAg{utv sucScS 5(*j?suª0rAgcS{u{Lydj*j`AzAjbvqwc9xActv«
(90) sucSª 5j(y~AeSª0suSr5jns{usj0KH§ 9jVFt`gMsu{V9rAc9jFbvjjSy ® 5cSt=® /0r5sy0&g cTjq`tdy[zAbdsu9¨ /0rAj?iKgsu?«¶jgtdxAbvjync«$tvr5* j GÒ
(91) Va] \IYi8cA9j{Tgbvj(s«PcSbdig{u{¬ ?rAsueSrA{usueSr9tdj j{ucª?® h /0rAjyd 9yvtvjFi qwcSAydsydtvy?c« z5bvcAq`jydyvjC yhgefjy0cSjFb[g q`cSi8zA{ujtvj{u kq`cfAAjqwtvjKy z cSsu 9tQ¨Q tvc ¨} z cSsu9 t~ßAtvjrLtQgªtcSbvqwTcSik®9§i j?x5AgydsqyvgxAtvi8j*j 9 + yv7jFLXL9® suAeKikjyð¨ h a
(92) bvcAq`jydyvjy(j`Ajq`xAtdj?yvtdjzAygt[gbdAsutvbhgbv 8yvz jj9y*tvr gt[qgSgbv cfjb0tvsuikjf® h o0t0ikcSydt$cS5j?zAbvcAq`jFyvy[iKg^ ?«Qgsu{VgL8qg8«}gsu{TcSA{u 9 kq`bhgyvrAsuAe ® h cSiki x5AsqgtvsucSn{us5y$gbvjbvj{us¹gA{ujAxAt$gyd 9LqdrAbvcfAcSxA&y ag9 i8jyvy`gefj ydj9t$tvc?gnzAbvcAq`jFyvytvrLgt 9c9jy0AcSt[qwbhgydr+suy0bvjqwjsuSjKª0sutdrWg ELAsutdj5xAt[gbdAsutvbhgbv K9j{¹g^ ® §ªjj?x5§tdyvrAj?j*jbv j`jwAcS«PzLcS{¹fjbd«}jkqwgftq`9j*bdckjtvgSAc cfjsut[Lbvy*9bdjs¹tvzLqc gj^tdg j*t*j*tvtv«}rArAgjZj ikE 9subv{u#j s¹yvgE tnb
(93) AcAª0sutvqsusuq`cStvxArKAbdynbvtvjrAcLj« qwjtd«PjcScbvbdi8«;ig yg{utvgs j^{qvbdgr5jtvgSAsucSs¹ q gc{C«$#jtvtvjELr5bdAi sjy0 i8Lsucf+cAbv9bvtvcjr {TªgeSjt*su&fzLj«PgKbdz cSsji e b^Y® GÒGÒ
(94)
(95) <Q5VVyva$a$tvj^`` gS\\TIvIv~®® §ªjrAjwjFz5td{ grAsujk9tvmj r5ELj?AAsutvjsuq`cSjF5yvy0yhgAbvj +jKi8tdcAc 9Ls EIj qggStdsu`cSx5Ayvy^tv® j^Ktvc tdrAj?Ajª-q`cftdj`AFt 6¶q§ VWM suAydtvjgf8c« cSAydjAydxAy 8 Õ`îA÷P Ù^ù÷PÙÕFÇPÉ}ÍTÆ Û`ÔÉQÎÒÕ`ÉQÔÆvÌÇ5͹ê[ËSÆQÆ
(96) êͶÕ×ÍPÆðÈwÉ}ÑSÇÏËÕ`ÎÒÉ}Ì ÖÆðǶÉPÆQÎÒÉ ÜSÛ
(97) ÎÐÊdÕ`Ævî5Ç5ê ËSÈÔÑÐÍÏÆVÎÐÊvÇÏÈÔSǶʶͶË0ÇAÉ}ý Æ ÎÐ͹ÔËnÎÒÉQÉ}ÆQÆdê[ǹÌ9ÆðÆvÜDÊd͹ÍLÇdó`ͶÕÚÕ`ÉVÎÐÆvÆ ý8^È`ʶê0ËSÈ`ÌÜSÑÐÆÛådÆd͹&Ç ËS%Æ øVû`&ä s"Àu'¹½ó "! $# ÌÉQÕ`ÌÆðÉ}ÍÏÓ. ;
(98) X . . ÅVÅÜNrãs`äã. . . . . .
(99) Sg i8g{uxAcS$j(AgSe0sqd r?cf9tvz5s¹rAqbvjFgcAbYtdq`stdj5rAydeky$suAsuª0eSyVy^rAik~jgtdcArA9jjFb 2{{u Yjn$`suQgA!y
(100) sutvg0s¹g {u{ug xA!ª0tvcfsuiyvrAggjLtdy(cS?Vtvckg®# /0{ujr52g^j$`f>j? ;C$]tv¢r5 °9j !£
(101) eS0 bv¤ #cf-AJxA¡Fz ¢! ¤A ¢^ °[®&cf/0cb*«ArAAjjgScS«Pqdt:cSr?bd6 ikzAbd jcAbC,q`jrAyvcSl?y {¹9qcfy
(102) b `gncf
(103) A t`sugL,sugAbd 5y^ ~~ bvcSjFx5yvtvz zAjxAq`t(tvsufbvjjef{u syd8Ftv®Zjb 6<Q GÒ
(104) suyVg a$`yvxA\&IAydj t csuL«C& s qF( g(tv+ jFyC, - yk suA zA x5 t S g3{uxA®bj8<QA«PsucStdsbkg{u{ 9cf~ A yv jFA, yvxAy^& ®,(8 *(/0+ ~VrAsuj+L9b`s¹gqAgeftvj+suAe8c«?tvrLtdrAgjt ikGÒ
(105) ycfVyv"a$t$!#` cf#\L Iðq`~9@&jStd®5rA8§$j[cfrAJxA jtv z5xA6Qgt0Lq`bv&cSjef9sÐsuth
(106) « yvg8 tvsujFKªAb y0 jF bdSsutvsujyjbdGy suA&7suzAtvbvs¹6cAg{q`{u&)j yd( y&v(®5+
(107) o0{ sug9«PAtvtdcjb( sugtd ~9y ªsuAj*suy suyhtvª0g^s¹g bd{$sutdtvyvrLtvjjFgtd tvt suAgte ~ i8= #cS yd?%t$i41cSg^LY qw8jL$Hª0j8@&suª0td%rkbv$ suzAtvtd&bdjc;® qw6j<Qgyv yt y[o[9j^ q`suyvsucS¶¢K¶¤S g-{uxA¥jn´ c«
(108) tv rAYj£¤5¢ cf¶´Ayv jFAqyvgxA y^®,8Lj8xAA"s fxAj{u s j9tvs ELj g Asut?SjqwtvcSb c«[{uj5eStvr tvrLgt eSyv 9sufydjtvjy0i tvrAcSj*5S{ (g{ª0x5jrAjcC« ~% «Pcf b06PcSjgSb
(109) qd 5r cStdrY( ~T8$lgbd j0tv<rA j0cf
(110) A®A{u ?0jzAqFbdgc{uqw{TjtvyvrLydjgy0t0tvH§ rLgVFt$M suAsuydtvzLs¹gj{uqw{us [E ª0jy*suydtvrrAtdj?c? {ujjrLg^g^S9j su ®cSb%c/0«$r9tdxArAy^j ~ tvLr5gj[ikcSj5{u 9{ (
(111) ~ s5s tds¹, g{A vq` l cS
(112) EL eS xA b` g~td!scf A8y$ c,"«Vs #9 Atd l j bvj yd t g bv~jnAgtvLrA$j0cf A j y0,%q`cS vbdlSbvj l yd zL cf L 9
(113) suF®Ae tvc?tdrAjyvjntvrAbdjj*yhq`jFLgbdscfy~ /0rAj?§HVFM zAbvcfA{uji su+gyv 9LqdrAbdcSAcfxAy0yv 9ydtvji8y0sy«¶cSbviKg{u{u 9j#E Aj+gy«PcS{u{ucª0y® lf®0sAy0cfgb[tj{ufjjgbvyd& t0cS Aj*= zA-'bdcAq`jyv(yn tv8rLg t0 suA 3yvt`~Tgg{u{uLy g(jAfjjª>bv +9¤ sjFµ ª?&~AQ¡g^L)¡ &¶A-Pc°Kz5£ bvcAïq`jtdydrLygsut*Aydyvtht`gg{bd{utvy y*g «Pbd9cSs*icTjbv j9~ tntdrAAjjbvª j sujª?® 5®0s95thyvgthbvgtv{usu{Aye(A«Pjbdª>cS+i 9suj@ª &6¶Fbvj, ydzL&)j^(q` *tv(su+SjFA { 9- ,~ / %3 8 6¶8bvjtdrAydzLjbdjj?qwtvsusuySjg{ut0 9/~ {j^&2g yvt0,7cfA&j*( *£(+ A - ydxLqd3r8F®tdrLgt0ydcSi8j[zAbdcqwjyvy £§°9j[¤LT ¥ y`0
(114) g^j-t k¤A tdrL-P°ngLt «Pjbd-cSgi suy ¥ ´ ®@A?2cf>bv
(115) i=£ g¤As¬{u ¢«8{ 9¶´1)~ .,., /9/?1g , A-*®;{u&2j6-t 1<Q3!e.,/!G 40
(116) CL3a$jK(a]td
(117) \rA5IvjK~!4A-yvsuyYjsut8bdyjcAgS«suqdSrL9ggsu{ujAjª09{ujty «PsÐbvsu«VAcftd6iyvrAt`gj? {u{uydj~fjt0gLcsu «$9suqw7 jcSq`= suyvEL4 suefcf xA bhSg, gtvsu{u&CcSxA5j39yy ® c«$q`/0cS rAELj*eSsuxAikb`gz tdcSsyvcfydAsuAy0subv{j^sutQgS ?qdrLz5gbvc95c{j«
(118) «Pcbv"« cfGÒ+i
(119) V©a] q`cf\IV9thsuy gsuydAtvy0bdxLtQq`ªtvc x5bvjj{ujikgyj9«Ptdcfy{u,®{8cª0y^%® <QUt ELbdyvt0yvr5cª0y0tvrLgtg(AsuSg{uj9t sugSAsuiktvs¹gsuyv{Tydq`s5cf={j ELeSbvx5x5 bhgtdsu sucSkª0rAjws¹qvsurydtvyA®=c/0zAr5bvjcAVq`~Ajydydthygbv9tvj^suAq`s¹e 9j«¶bvy cSmi tdq`rLcfgt0tdbhAgfsuS9gs¹q`{jFtvsuAteq`cStv=rAE jKeStdxAjb`bvgi8tvsuscf Vg~9tvsusucft q`cfbdA j fyvtdxAbvsuxLbvjqwi8tvy?jg9 t cg«bdeSxAi8cfAjyv9jtT5suyvyTxAAy cS6Pt
(120) ª09r5subvs jqdrq`td{ubv j Sgx5zAszAbd{ujs¹yKqgtv5rL{j
(121) gtkrAjFjbvfjjLbv jqFgfg9xAikydj susuyv?ydsu§HA{ujkVFbvM!x5 Acf tTjjSgjbd9 jgSq`s¹9iksuAsueyvydsbd5xA{Y jC8bvU® xA(/0rAsyTsuy bdj {u fsuAxAjKsubvjc « tvAc jª!tdjbv9i8sjFsuª?LY®gtd/0]j r9aSxAcfy^A~ {u kstntdsurAycS5ydjcSt[tdrLydgx t0ydq`thsugjbv9t0t*«¶tvbvc8cS:i yvrAcª!;!~tvrL g%t 09cf%<b 0suAi sutvxAs¹gyv{
(122) tq`bvcSjF yvxAEL{ueSt[xAsub`8gtdtvsrAcfj*+susuAy[yvt`Agsu{uS{¹gg{tdjFscft^ ~AcA« x5g t tvr gt0cS5jc«=~> %cSb8 0suy® ?/° A ¤ @LB¦ %~5cS8b suy0AsuSg{uj9t^® suC*y0£A´TO$suSE´ gD{ub¦ tdjrA<¶9F« j*t®fyv§jqw cSj*cfLyvGb 8rAczAª 8bdcStvz surLy0jgbvAt0tQsu 8sSKgc{u«VtdjrA§H9sut^y[~AVFqªMgjydHj~gtdbd rAjj bd9jcSi 5suy0xAjSydg?*® t 0bd xAcj?kª>AtdyvrLsuSxAggzAt{uz jyvcS9t`ydt^gj®bdtvtdyrL«PgbdtncSiIAjsutvr5 jb*yvxLcSqdArKj?tvcrL« gt;g( zAcSbdGb cqw j8yvy suOA +yvt`tvgrA{u{u:j y E & bv yv®t*zAcfbdAcSyvz s¹9jbvjtQb[ gc9« kq§ gS9VWi8Msyd~ yvsuyvAcS{ui8j0bvj?x5zAK bdcJ>qwjtdyvrLy gt0suAydyvtht`ggbv{utv{uyy«¶g8bvcSA:i jª! ;su jªsuk&ª0rAsus¹N qdr J ®V t`sg fq`j2j y0 Ac ¡su¢^y[M° AL;cf¡ft ® AsuSg{uj9t^~& , &1^®IßjtGO Lj tvrAj ¡¥ 0
(123) °Aµ * -¶g° L$q`cSbdbv j[ydzLsuy0cfLtv9rAsuj(ASeKgtv{uxAc$j[Jc® « 91suLy[q`jHsuAO z5xAq`t0cS9bvthjgefsusuAyvtvy[jFAb,~c8O yvtdsjy[zAgy*{uyvcc « 1(gL8tvr5j?cSA{u k9s cTjbvjFLq`j jtQª jFjN ¤!suALyvLt`g-{uQ¥{uy$¤5A j-¶ª>°0tv9Pc sujª7 &*® Dò®DjOL kq`jfg?~fyd«Pbv 9cfik"i ikjFtv bv$s¹qtdrAgjbdbdeSj0xAsi8yjg[9bdtj~gS«PqdbvrLcfgi+A{uj[ q` cS tvr5ELjeSbvxAj*b`gsuytdsg(cfbvj^sugS qdª0rLgrA5s¹qd{j?rq`ydcfcS=ikELjefxAzAbhbdgctvqwsujcSyv y sukª0rAs¹qdrKyvcfikj[z5bvcAq`jydysuAydthg{{uyAjª>9sjF@ª &2S=® /0r5jbvj`«¶cSbvPj 0suy0AsuSg{uj9t^® Q R0
(124) °9´L£° @L¦0H q`cfiki xAAs¹qgtvsucS(§ sy0VFbdM j{us¹gsuy A{uAj?cSgt L8ydcSg{uSt0gi8A{ucSjKyvtsu cS5gjyv 9z5LbvqdcArAq`bdjcSydAycfiKxAykg^ *yd 9«}gyvstv{QjF® iky ª0sutvr q`b`gyvr «}gs{uxAbdjy~
(125) jFSj s¬« ÷ÏØVÅV÷Ïç.
(126)
(127)
(128) "!#%$& (') *#!##+,. . * £j`´TA´EsuyvDtdy8F®T §°9¢Dj¥ 0qg^ ¦ßAjctGª© gzALzAj{u Kg 5tvrAsSj gtv{ujj^9qvr5t Aq`s"cS Sx5ELjeSy?xAcb`«ZgtdG s
(129) cfCKa$s]\-'I$ tvcK8 q` cS 5yv tv bd xLq` t 3:g6P+9 su=ßE jAiksutvjiKgfg9l*ikydsuxLyvydqdsur A{ug j bvsuAx5yvt`gtv{urL{uygtg yd5thjgª bvtvy(9su«Pjbdª cSi m5g sSgq`cS{uj99tdtGbhgS s qwgtvLsucS 8bvjtvc iKtvgr5suAjZy*ELAbvydsuSt0gbv{uj j f9xAtòsubd«PcSjikbdjSj9jb&t0aCc<Q«Y§Htvr5VFsy(Mbv® xAV~ßAcKzAbvcAq`jydy jSjFQ b ((+
(130)
(131) $ L
(132) *$% $"$( eSgn bdxA!cS2b xA$9zCyv z ®%/0j' q`rAs EIsu y$qgsuy tvsu!#g*cS# +L4g ctv«[xANb`H§ g!`{AVF
(133) bdj M
(134) f xAgsubv6{uj{ ci8
(135) ª0 Ujy(9' t$zA bvª0cA8*rAq`efjs¹qdydsur Syvjjsuy8y tvq`suc3cSi8SGÒR zLcf{Ogx5tdAsuAlt`{u~Vgj$bdòsª0{us +qFsutv r bd- j ~Ttv fr5xAR j[jOydyvt %z X&jtvIvq`rA;® sjEI<Qsu qFb gbvtvjsuJ¨ cfi8VF MccS«Vag{
(136) tvr5g8«¶jbvzAcS ibdc!#qw%tdjrA yvj0y KiVFM+g^a bvjwj Sx5j^q`sbdxAjtvyj tvjrLfgjtY9jFt Sj9tvx g {u{u ?6 %j80sutvsurALjF9b s¹ cqgStvb suA *e gtvbvrLjgj`t LKyq`{uvxLxA9ydj^zL jqw«PbdtvcSy?i-tdrLtvgr5 t j0 eSbvq`cfb`xAgydz rAjTsuj;® ª?<¶®2«$/0tvrArAsuj0y0zLcAcfqyvq`ydx5sbv5ys~C{usuftQ ¨ tvyvr jF{Ðg«Ï¨}Ft bdjik, cS ?gsu{}y[® jwz5{s¹q`sutd{ kg{u{cªjT~AgL8rAjLqwj j`Ajq`xAtds5 e 6Y8[gikcfxA9tvytvckg bd j fxAjydt[«¶cSb bvsuAjFiksutv<Qs¹cg©S{9gSg{ug9y^{~L x5ªjqjkl0gyvqs jSc5g~nï/yv$yvjFsu{Ðbvi8«Ïj¨}bd SzAjx5{uik jyva ctdS6hy0&lgtv8*{[rAbvsujnyjsubv9jYtvi8jFbvczASAbdgjj{9t q`cjtv2« ydrAyh1gj8bv -ik6Pyhg^jtv gc A sucSAjxAqekbKgx5csu«[yvikj tvz rA/cSj8$ydydyvsuxAAsuAyvsutvsuz {us¹sjgtQq`{
(137) tdSy[bvgjtv{ur ydxAxAgjF{uyt t~T® L/
(138) grLcikgjyg^{uSqw 9cfbh~ gs¹/ ydrA?ydjrLjD {¬g8F«¹y¨ ~ g& ( !(+ 1A &- rL1gy 3sugALsutd s g&){$(S *g(+ {uxAA j+- l8/%s39c ~91bvj ydzLbdj j fqwtvxAsujSydjtv{uyk 9;® td/0rAjKrAj*bvjsi8i8czLScfgyv{$ydsc5«Fs{usu/tQ% ?BQzA6Qbd]c98(c«;bvjcj#jFELy[AAj?cf&t[kqvr ggLA efjS& ® 8tdc j eSªbdcSjLj?/09cfrAjFkb0 j ª0tvELr5bvrAj?ydjt0tvAr5zAjjbvª>cfb[zL9cfjFsxAbvjFb0tQª? ksu®=ikc/0«Yz rAH§cSsuyvy0ydVFsusAy0M sug{su9bdtQsu * j K fbvxAjFtvsuc yvbvxAjtv{uynrAt0j"tvrArLsu!gAt DefjA &y0c %cS!
(139) tQ $Kªctv# r5zA0sybd!cA#xA
(140) q`A js¬yv«Pydcfj=bvy i8~ zAª0sbvtQcf (rAzLjFbvjtv j rAbd ftQjxA Kb*subvcq`jF«"cSikbdG bv jj9/[qwtt[
(141) =® cS <QIvbt0®DAsugnycfAjtgj*~Ayd9i Ksuyhg^tvgD c ¨ yv9r5suyhcgª©eSbdtvjr jSg® t?H§ VFM bdjigsuAy[xA5yvcS{uSgA{ujjfjs¬« ªj cSA{u +bd j fxAsubvj tvr gt f %!
(142) !# f zAbdcAq`jyvydjyk9cKAcft /0rAj$ydjq`cS ?zAbdcSz jbvtQ *c«H § VFM zLcfyvtdxA{¹ge tvjF& yV tv,7r5j$& j`(A *su(yv+tvA jFL- q`j c39«A%® tQ/0ª rAc0suy
(143) bdxAsuy;Agny^~bdcfjAgj
(144) ydcSsuALyvgt`Ag{u{uj {usbd5 j e fAxAjFsubvªji8sujj9ª t & ,7& ( *(+A - 39~Sg ?tdrAj0cStdrAjb
(145) suAyvt`g{u{us5C Ayvr5xActCª0sutVy0qtvgrL?gt jg{uª { jtvgrLSgjt05sujy0*Aª0jq`sutvjrAydyhcfgxAbvtY +gsucIy0j^tvq`r5tvsuj?Aj`enAtvsurAyvtvj$jFsuLi8q`j zLcfcyv«YyvsutQAªsuc {usutQbv x5bdAjFy yvx56¶cS{t^A®^j*o[yv?t`gj`bdLtvgsuAike suL«PbdgcStd+isucS0c«A*tdrAgjL8z5bvcfc9Acj « «PbdcS+i 88tdrLgt0suAydthg{u{ i2# f sujª0y^~AAcft 5jq`jydyhgbdsu{ &g ! &2f®. ;
(146) X ' %#*
(147) $
(148) ©"$ [*
(149) ' & ^ . j`bv9jFLcfikgiki8cj?SzAj^ef{u jSbvcS~V«Px5bdg zcSizAi8bvcAtdjq`rAi jFj*yvLykeSjFbvbvtdcfyvrLxAr5gzKst zK9suydysjjFbvªyd9xAs¹yvgq`z Ljjy 8q`tdrLsujAg^ ydStvj bvcx «[tvq`r5 tvj jj sugAAtve+suc {su«QtQ9g 8suxA{{ {utvtQcKsu otvyd9j6Psyh{¬{u«hg^{
(150) ~9 zAjbdS cjFjqwqjgyvs¬«
(151) xAydjyvtvyj rAsutdsy0rLt zAgsut bdy?cgSqwbvjjFj yvbvy* ïAsucfydy t[{uccf«QªRzLgjF8?xAbh{ugqtQ 9gtdsu®LcS5L cSgjb { ª0g&v z5sutvbvrcSefcSbhs 8gtdrAi Aj¨vcfbKq`t[cSzA9gSbdq`tvctdbdqwxLcSj{ugyv{u{ujyd{uj yK(?«}g«Pq`cfb`s{Qbkg®fyvo[gr5j{u{tvy[cfjFAcbvL«VegzAtvtvbvsusucASi8q`jjjS{u 9yd~
(152) yv~ijg y*g^z5td ïrLbvcAg9q`t0j^jq`rAyds¹ysu9Ltdj+rLjtvgb c t0tdr rA9gsj*{uy0{0zAAsubvtvcfcfydt0eSjbd{¬yv«hjxL®Qyvqyn<Qqwt cjj«ViK9tvjr5g^ ïjsugg+{uzAeSz q`cScfjbdiksugtvbkrAi i tvxAr Agis¹tkqggydStvxLj0suAqdsur et jgyvsuo[jb0 «¶cSjwb5gtvrAikj?zAbd{ujj8icg«suAz5subvAcSe?efbhzAgbdi cqw¨vjq`cSyvyd9jtvy*bdcStv{uc {ujsuAyvq`t`b`gg{uyv{Vr5g(jy+Ajgª>zAz eSjbvcfgbdxAykzKsu9 sjFtvª?rAj(®
(153) U' efbvcSx5z i8ji jbvydrAsuz zAtvr5bdj cStvxAcAzIq`cf5{
(154) geStvj8suScjK«0eSsuebdcSxAGÒR zO9AsljF~Tª00ys¹q`qcS i8- Iðj^® y?<QKtdctvrA suy[j{usuz5jbvScSj tdcAtdq`rLcSg{Qt ~As¬gK«$tvir5gjwzAcSbvbdsucAtQq` 8jyvcy «0KstvrAj8zAqvr bvcAgq`bvjefydj?yvjcyk« gq`c9bvj cfbh«}9gsuxAL{ugtQ tvsu~ Asue t j`/0ArAjsuq`y x5tvzAjbvy?cfeSgbh8gi jS¨vjFq`cSt[9tdqFbvgcS{u{u{u{ujje+f qw!#bh?&g#yd r ®=/0sy(r5ss y09qsugyvxAtvsuyvAjefy9xAKtsuyvvrLc gAgS{uq`j tdxL«Pbvgcf{u{ui kq` g b`g&vyvefrCj~A9sQxA® jSsuA®u~Sj td( cq`ydb`tvgcSydzKr j`AtdrLjgqwxAt(tvssuy Ae89xAyvtvj8jFzAtvc y®~ yhg^ 9~A/0g(rArLj gikb`9cAª9gjFbv{Yj*c«Q«1gGÒsu
(155) {uxAVbva$jS® `\&I 9c9jy?Acft) Sx5stdjkqgz5tvxAbdj yvxLqdrzAbdcSeSb`gi&¨ðq`cf9tvbvcf{u{j^qwbhgydrAjy&a
(156) s tvrLgt ikcA9jF{Yg8zAbvcAq`jFyvy9c9jy(AcStnrLg^Sj tvrAj g5s{usutQ ktdcKyvtvcfz t`g9suAekydtvjz5y?s¬« sut[ª0g9tvy*tvc ®T9suLq`j ªjxAydj C. ÅVÅÜNrãs`äã.
(157) tvcSr5x5j b0AGÒ
(158) jVega$tv`suS\j*I$ikbdjcAyvxA9{ujt0{Tydtdtvcksu{u{TzAbdrAccSS{¹j?9y0tdrAs¬«Yjz5subvi8cSefzLbhcfgyvi yvsuA¨vq`sucS{usu9tQ tvbdccS«${u{uj§q VWq`b`M gyvr56/0jyrAgjcfbvjbvjgi {{ucl9ª8j~ Tcf® Aj?ig^ kgyvKª0rAjtdrAjb cSg8 tvs/
(159) rAcEL:j AydGÒjYsutvj?Cj*ª0a$9r9]xA\ i IVtv i8rAjsucAb0y 9c fj« xA{Q%®ydjtv/0ydjtvrAz5sucSsuyy$85zAsuxAy0bdc9t[zLcAj«;bdjFqwtvSsucSjAAb*jyd9sutvAt^bvyvx ~Lt`q`q`gtvcf{uy*A{uy[yvgs¹g k9jAgSbnjª-tvikrAsuj*9yvsuydzAjsª?5bdc9{®;jc<Q«Ybvt[x5csu«Yy[susuikq` bdxLz ª0q`cSrAs¹ydgs¹yv{CqdsuArk«Pcfsu{ujFb[suStQ tvjr5bdc sy[«YzA§HqwbvcScAAVFq`ydjM tvydbvy[x Lt`q`ggtvydsuScSjjF y tvtvr r5(jgt G
(160) @%C
(161) a$!
(162) ] \z5I bvi8cAq`cAj9ydjy?{Q~ALAj x5qt?gzLsuygA5{ucSj?t?ctd« bvxAthgj 9s¬s« 5ªekjktvr5gj{u{ucAª-jwt*zAbvydcftveSjzb`gi gt*¨vq`gcf9 KtdbvzLcfcf{{usj9Ktnq`s b`gtvydsurAikj9yjSaC^® cS/0 rAq`sujy[sug8y*zAtvbdbdxAcqwjjsuyv y rLc« gyGÒYjwCa$j^q`] xA\tvIYj^qg5gkAq`cSb`t0gyv rjj9fsujbvj^9q`ttv~T{u sutgqFzAgzAA{uAsujcf t*tdLc j yvbv 9j yv ftdxAjiksubdjy0+tdrLtdcKgt[thggf{u{jcª g zA5bdj`cSAeftbhgydtvi&jzC¨ðqw®bcS/09tvr9bdxAcSy{u~ {ujtv r5jkq`bhggbvyvefrAxAjFyik® jFt AikjcAe99<QgtjFtds{tdfgxAj yvbv 9bd5jLyyvqdx5rAcf{bdxAtcSt?rAAcStvcfr {¹xA9gy y$t 9jFtvsuSrAyvjtdj8 bvsusAs¬i8«LxAªtdzLjj[cf yvgydyv{us{u 95cydsªtv{usujtQzAi8 kbvy$cfceS«[ª0b`H§sugtvi r VF¨vzAq`M bvcfcfeSsutdy?bhbvgcf5i {cS{uj¨vt?*q`cS{uq`su9ikb`tdgbvsuydtvcSrAj^{uj{u+jy?®=tdc+/
(163) qwbhcntvgrAyvydrAjrAcjGÒy^ª Y®Cßtvr5a$jst ] y^\~I0ªikj i cAjA9xAcSjFyd{tdtpa j[ELtdtdrAbvrAydsujyt ikqgcA 9ydjFtv{LcScz"« j`GÒ
(164) AVjq`a$x5` tv\suAIð®9e+0ydj^tvqjgzA{uy {Ttvgr t?ggt09su K yvt`gtvj^jfgS®VqdrKcSzAAbvydcAs¹9q`jjbydy[g&suy0ikgcA9gjxA{
(165) tvccf«0iq`cSgi8tvcSzACxA~SthggLtv8sucSg+t09i8jFAcScSyvttdjcSAj*zAbdnctvqwrLjgyvyt surLy g^s¹f9j jFg8tds¹yvqz gj{Tq`tds¹gc { ydthg~9tdj`jSL~
(166) q`qjgzA{utn{ujtv rLgi%t0 tv~TrAyvj?x gqvx5rtvcStdrLiKggt*tds¬cS«[ gkgyvz5ydbvcAcAq`q`s¹jgydtvyj^Kj9ª0tdjsutvbvry gtvrL9g t?zAyvbvt`cAgq`tdjjSyd~Vy*sut*syyvAtdcSczAª y(gj`{uA{cjªq`xAjtd&s5tvec yvg tdjeSzAjFy^®]x5/0s5r9j?xArLy^~ggb`9yYª0sugbvj q`~bhikgyvcAYr 98FjF~L{5xAt0xAgA{u{u{ucsuSª0 j yYgt
(167) ~Aiksu cSydt
(168) cS[Ajg9zA kbvcA9q`xAjFyvi y0 tvjc*b0ydctvcS«$zkzAbdgct$qwgj9yvyd ?jy?yvt`igtdg^jF 6PtdydrAtvcfsuy$z ikgcAt[9tdjFrA{j y qbv`i%x5b`g yvr5ydsythjgygStd~C93j tvi8rA6¶sj tvydrAyv9susuy8Aj#EL{uikj$As¬sucA«Ytd9sgcfjt+{uy ikczA«0cSbdydgScStV9eScfi8b`Agj[si&ydyvzA¨ðsubdq`AcAcf{uj*q`9jtvbvyvbvxAycf {uyv{tdj^scSïy?zA9yq`sb`j`cTgAjyvjbvr5q`jFjx5y tvtn8Fsu®[A«Pbde 9cSsuiyvLtvq`jF j tvzArAyj ~AgcSKL5 j?gf9j«PScfikjFb
(169) subvtv y ikzAa;bdj<QcSyd yheSgb`efgj0i&~Tyv¨ðgjq`9cft9stvtvbvcELcfAg{u{su9j^tv j zAs¬«YbdgctqwjikyvycftvyvrLt$gcft
(170) Athj*gzAfbvjcAy q`gjydy[su= ydELtvcS5z5stdy0j j`9AxAji q`xA tdsj5b
(171) e c«TyvtvyvjFtdzAjzAy y$?&suRy
(172) ?Wbvj^#q`Jj?suJSFjßi2]® R<Q !=Y
(173) ~!#g% su= i2ELA su~AtvgjLbv x5 jFSsjy$bdgf k9ikikjFsuyvyvydyhsugAeS{ujj yvjFtntvc g9 kz5bvcAq`jydytdrLgt0t`gfjy[g8s ELAsutvj*9xAi jb c«$yvtvjFzAy[suy0bvj^q`jsuSjß® R0
(174) °9´L£° T¦0H q`cfiki xAAs¹qgtvsucS(§ sy0VFbdM j{us¹gsuy A{uAj?cSgt L&ydcSzA{uSbvgcfAeS{ub`jKgi su ¨vq`gcfyv 9tdLbvcfqdrA{{ubdjcS AqwcfbhxAgykydrAydj 9y?yvtvgjFbdikj?y g{uª0{ucsuª tvr jßq`® b`gyvr «}gs{uxAbdjy~
(175) jFSj s¬« yvC*r5£c´Tª0TE´ jy0Dt¦LtvrL§g?t0jn q§ yvrAjkVWcgª M9 tdrLsugy0g{utAeScScSH§ t0bdsuVFtvydrAcSM {ui Sgsusu5y {Ajni8cSsut cyvcfj{u{S® gA{uj[®su qwcSA=® yd/0sydrAtvj*y?zAcbd«òcg8c«Yydsujyt?Lcg«[ydjg8x5tvcScS iK/0gt`rAgAj~AcfcfbvjAi j «Pl*cfbª0j^r5gSs qdqdrr zAjgfbdcqv r qwjyvy <*suyvt`gtvtvr5j(jkª0yv 9stdydrtvj5g iC® /
(176) KybhgdthAgyQtd«¶jScS~AbviydxLqdtvrKrAjFtvyvrLj+gt0gxAsЫ$tdcSg iKzAgbvthcAg&q`jFsuyvFy tdcKjgFx5tdtvjcSbviKyngtvrAt`g Bj c
(177) « kydthggtdy*jS«P~ cSq{u{ucwcSª099y tva su9bdjxAzAj{¹yngSq`tvcj th6PsugLSqwj {x yv9tdjsuAzAeytdgrALj K&vsu9 xAjF{u{ S(?jbdik +jFyvyvxAyhg5eSyv9jj 8F f~ xAKbj9vt?jiKydtvgjsuzAy$tdrLsu8gt*tvrAsut[j t`g f8yjyv~Tt`gbdjtdjeggbhL98{ujyd9y?c9jcy[«5tvrAcSj tyvikjLjyd yhggeS9j? suikt*bvjjydqwyhgjsueSSjjy^y ® /0rAsuy[tdbhgAyQ«PcfbviKgtvsucfk 9suj{¹9yg g{ueScfbvsutvr5 ikcA9§jF{ j[y`g^ ® tvrLgt tQªc?bvx5Ay[gbdj f 2 0 !$= i sЫV tdrAª0j 8sutvrAyvthcfgxAbv tt«Pbd<cS?i ydthtvgr5tvjjy^y`~Vggi8Lj0 syv5c stds¹g{Lsq`y*cfg= +ELefgxA{uefbhgcStvbvsusucStdrAKi gLsu j§gfqvj0r q`{¹zAgbvsui-cAq`jtvydrLy*gtCs5«PyvcSthb
(178) gj{u{gfy[qvrkg&gfA9jª-iksu9ydyvsujsuAª>{uj
(179) sKbvxAcf Acj?« s¬©« gsuL 8cS5td{rA 8js¬bv«;jnsusut0y;sug*Aydq`thcfgA{u{ueSy0bdxAtvr5j9j?t yhggfik9ikj*su9yvydsjFsuAª {ujYsuKbdxAtv rAcj(« cStvr5
(180) jsub ® ^~Sg s¹q`jw¨}fjbvy`gA"® !AbdcSi-tvr5syq`{¹gsui gL?tdrAj[ydzLj^q`s EIqgtdsucS c«TH s¬lS«®=g<Q t0K5ccSª A{u Kbdjis¬« g s5ydy$cStv{uc Sjydy*rAcH§ ª VFtdMrAjsuq` {¹gsi;® ® /0rAj tvrAjcfbvjitvrAjF+«Pcf{u{cª0§ y0VFsui8Mik#~ j9$s¹gydtvcSj{u{uS (jy
(181) «PbvH§ cfi VFM/0rAsuj cSbdji yvjt`9gtvtdjFTj b?j%ttvrA $0V~j 5ydj[bvthjggzAtv9j{¹ gfq`gSj?<'ftvik~Tr5gj?suyvLydyvstd5j9{z j
(182) suyhbdqqFxAgg xAbhyvcsuA« gCe {u{Vyvsux5tvAc yvjj 9 f%® tvxAMKjFjFb cA9t5s¬ «P8«& yP$[cfgb0vyCtdtvj«PrAzAcSZj y?{u{uE ccª0bv« yv9y C®tnaFYtv«Pcfsu<Qikt*bVjjnsuy*gfsuqvjr gtdckydz5 +bvg cAtvyvq`cKtdjjydfzy j tbvqs¬g«Pd +xArLyvgtdsut
(183) rLAgjCe 9t*tdtdjrAtvbvcjy bvjFyvxA{utvcSsuA9Se jFbdbvxAyvjFK{ 9su~9y[{ugj+)t $*gS9 i8j?suyvgyv9suA {uj0gf9bdxAikKsuydcyv(«suA{uj00bvsuxA 8c+« tvrLgsu t0sy[qwcS®AAßefjbv
(184) t xAj, 9t0 tdj*c tvrA$9®j*yvjFt0c«Yz5bvcAq`jydyvjyntvrLgt jj99tvtvjFjFbbvjyd thgtd<jS~ g<'L& s-$ 4 $#4 L®Cj(TtvjrAt&j*$ yv4 x jktdcrA« j $ yv rAtdcfrLbvgtdjtyv«¶t cS{uzA{ucbvjmª0EA0y $ c4 D®«.MK$#(cA9yvxLs¬«Pqd r$ tv r ggyt«¶gcS{{u{
(185) {uczAª0bdcA9y a`q`j<Qkyvydjtvy r5j?su/zAbv, mj EA1rLg^$ S4 j ~ ÷ÏØVÅV÷Ïç.
(186)
(187)
(188) "!#%$& (') *#!##+,. . «Pyvcft`gb$tdjj#gSqdrK C®zAYbdc<Q-qwj$ yvy4 4 ~T8sgDu«Ptvj,Kbn~9jgSbvjqdrzA{¹gfyvtdq`jj[zVtd~TrAsuj[Aydydtvjjbvz+t?g8qgyvxAj yv fsuxAAjFeGL tq`j vc c«j9yvtvtvjFjFb
(189) zAy)~T<0cfAsu9j(tv«Pc cSbng?jydgStvjqdz+rqzAgbvxAcAyvq`sujAyde y?8tsu vc(,jBT9tdtvrAjjb ikcSb0jFtdyvrAyhgj eS&vjn9bvxAj{uq`{ jF(sfi8j Kjyvy`sukgefj^j[gSs¬qd«YrKAcc «YydtdxLrAqdjrKydj?ikyvtdjjydzAyhgy[efsuj*yj`tvArAsj*ydtvcfy^{ D® <Qjt0yvt0suy0cfjAgj*yd kyvj9tdc t0Stvc jbdtdsЫ¶rA j*tvzArLbvgcAt0q`jFtvyvrAy[j*t`bvgjF9yvxAsuA{utve suAtvrAe j*bdxAyvtd+jzVsuy ~ g+gf/09rAiksuy[suyvq`ydcSsuAi8{uj0zA{ubvjxAtvKjFy0ctv«+rA j*zAs bdcc«$ctd«YrLtdgrAt0j?suy[q`{¹q`gcfsuiAeSbdgxALj89t[rAjtdLcq`$#j(^c® «YtdrAj?tdrAjcSbdji ® Q % %
(190) $& o>bvjFeSt bv(cfxAikzkji8i j i jbd yvjrAbvsuydzrAsucz«ydg jbveS9bds¹cSq`j*xAzCzAC®bvc/09rAs¹9suy jygyvefcfbvikjjj0i89jsu9Lt bdc j «Y fgxAeSsubvbdjji8jikj9jFtt0i gx5i8yvt?cSA e*j+zAqbdgcAbdq`j`j«PyvxAyd{uj{uy[ cfyvkz jtdq`rAs jELj&` q`xAydbQc ¨ tvr gt0tQªcz cStdj9tvs¹g{u{u kq`cS ELs¹q`tvsuAe efcg{uy0gbdji8jt9a lfU® <Qt0i xAyvtLj*ªjg8jAcfxAeSrKtvc j*yvcf{SgA{ujS® 5U® <Qtvt[sucSi Ay^xA=® yd<Qt[K zLjgbdydtvtvs¹bvq`cfxAA{¹eKgb^j~9Asucft0xAyveSrAr+cfxAtd{¹cK yvAsuikcft0zAL{us¬j?«P y`gtvtdrAsj Jy EL9jj8ydsu9eS ktdcbv«$su9«}sggxA{L{ucftQ¨Qb0tvcfxA{yvjFjFbh{gjF9yvy*t[zA9bvsuydcftvtvbvcAsuAq`cfx5{tvy^j® gzAz5{s¹qgD¨ 5
(191) cS b[0 >z5 bvsu9isjFgª bv f¨}cz «[gtdbvrAtdjksutvsuefcSbv cSx5efzïbvcSx5gz+tgikj i cS 5jjkbdyvtvrAsui8suzkjSyd~Tjtvbvr59s¹jkq`jsuy^ik~Tz sQ®cSjSyd®uyv~AsutvAr5su{ucSsyvtQj( 8tvcrL«[gH§ t[iVFgM sut`suLgsu9ks¹qggeftvbvjjy(jFiktvrLjg9tt[tdcfrA jyvgj tQbvªjF{c s¹geSAc{ujg{ugyLg bvj*zAbvsuLcAq`q`cSji8ydyvjzLy gtdiKsuAg^{u j0scS+A{ug +yv 9q`Lb`gqdrAyvrCbvcfb® A<QcSt[x5suy[y*yvsuik 9ydz tvjcSi8bvt`y0g9ª0tstdtvr8cK«}AgcSsu{utdxAjbvjFtdrLy~9gjt fj=+ s¬«; q`cf Dik&#i
(192) xA
(193) 5k s qF g tv!sucm
(194) $+su4y ?# ` Y#: 0 !#%$& 3
(195) #
(196) !m=, 9
(197) !
(198) @& f m ? ?%!# ?%$N#il !#
(199) %@%U
(200) !2 D 0 !2$9 1?%Yi @ j ?2 ?2!9
(201) !#?%!
(202) (^$+ #
(203) !e Y% &?%$=, Y!# f m9mD?& i%ieY#$Q oJo#(!#
(204) %@%#i /0r9xAy^~ bvtvq`jFr5cfikjtdcz5bhSgbvsugbvi {Tcfgtvb[bvc f9¨}gKsuz {u{gª0subvAtds¹e 9sutvjcsuydcS«zA zAbvj^efbvgScAbvcS q`x5jyd9zyvsjjFi8y ª jtvi r GÒR g tOjbvAgydbvlrAj ~Csuz 1oyvxAzATZydbvzLLZcfj^AM+q`{utvjSji 5~ yvtvTZcfc8{uLZSrLgM+g^AS{ujjS- ® qw~ bhgTZydM+rAj5 % XAsuy ~$;Q &M+ 5ydx] \Iv~Yq`sugj{u9{ct*ª0tvcksuAeKiKtdgrAfjj rAtvr5suAjef 0jcfg&y tvcfj?AKjtdª!rLtvrAgtnjòsuj«PtvcSrAª-{uj?{ucsuz5y*ª0bvjsuc9Afce*j« 9{tdtvsurLfxLjggAt0{{uj KH§ ydy0suVFAbvj yvM t` fgxA{uqsu{ubvgjjF8AikA9cfj 9t[tg tncj?«Y{yvj^§Hcfg{yvfVFt*jM KcfAa]suj?+<¶«/zAg/bdydc0 qw cSjqvb>yvr5y?1bvncSsu+5bvcSj td SxArAx5y*j jyvyvyv 9 9t0ydyvtdtvtdc jji8i {j^y0®Tg^Sª09j[cfstdiktdrKrAj*j*«}gsueSiks{ubdxAcSzAbdxA{ujj`z y¨ ik/0rAjFj t`grLtdg^scffAj0y$bvcxA«YAzAybdtvsrLiKggt)bd&v SA¨QzL{ucAgqdbv tv([sutds«¶cfcSbvjFefSbvjcfb^xA~SzkcfbYi8bdjjiki cLfjFj bvyvcfr5b$szk9su{{Ac g{A{9cSzAtbdcAyhgq`tvjsuyvyQyd«Pj y®td rAsu<Qy0t{ussy
(205) fAjAcftjydq`y0{ujbvg j b f~fxArAsubdcjª ikjFjS9j&tb^a~ ª0rLg<Qt0 {suq`fcfjAtdjbhydgy0yvtKzAbvtvcfc zLjzAbdbvtQsu i6Pgs¬«;bv fg¨QzLD g8bdtvydsuxLtvsuqdcSr sui8eSbdzAcS{uxAjz ikji89jt`i gtv sucfjAbvy$ydrA9suc z yhydgjtvbvsu9yQ«Ps¹( q`jy^G o[~0 zLOUgbvMtvsutd/[scf] L\gIv® 5{jKcfAjy+g{u{ucª zAtvr5bdj cqwikjyvjydi jy* tvjc bvyd9rAsusuyhz+gefcbv«jj*tvrAcfj keftvbvr5cSjx5zqwxAiKbvbdjg^9 t[jFikScSjF{ui fj Ljq`cfbdyvLrAq`suxAz bdbvcj«
(206) 9tvtdrA{ j*eSgbd cS+xAzCsuL~99s}®jFjSzL®u~jyd j9SjjF9bhtvg{u{
(207) 9«PsbvcIcfjFi bvj9jt[gfqv9rsujcfª0tvyrAjFcb« ik9G su
(208) yjFwi [cSsuL 9-jtTbd~Syvy
(209) AxAc A«VydO tvjr5tvyjS$cef «Abv- cfzAD~ xAbdONcAzVq`TZ`® j<QVFyv ydOjcSy0% tvyvr5XAx D~jqvb0TZr ª M+tvcfr 5bhg9% tVXAy^z5~S=~ bvydT1cAxLMq`qdjrkydAyvef] jbv\5ycS~x5suQ?zkM jikgSAqdjF]r i \yvIðLxA`® j5<QbdkyvyvjrAz t sugz gbveStdyvbds¹jjq`bdjxA9{¹stdgqwrLb^jgy[~St tdgrA{uj{ucbvj*Hª iKg0 bv!g^j2 ?tv$9rA Lj0j* q` ;ydxAj bdSbvjjkb`9 gt0 { zL6Pjfg® bve tvO$®usu~Atd ksª0cfgrAA{uj{yc sª0y0tvsurAbdAjj?e[yvtd5cSjsbdy`tQjgª Defcf8bvbv®jKji8zLjg9bvtvtsu~ftdyvscfxLAqdr8y 8neSgbvLcfxAz 0 ik!#%j$&i e *jbvyd! rA0 suz 0ydj6Pbvjf9® e s¹q`®uj~9y0ª0jFrAyhjqgzLq`jòcSi8«Pbvcfi i xAAtdrAs¹qj[gsutdi8sÐcfzL cfLyvjyvsutQAªsuj{usujtQ bvtvjFsucfyv+xA{ut?i cxA« yvt0tvrA suj y*yvzLtvgbdzLcSjAb^eK® jò5ccSª xAjFefSr+jb^tv~TcKtvbvrAx5jF{ +j(bvcSxAxAt*xAsu9ydtvjcK{ujyvgy*AcfeStvbdrAcSjFxAb*z«PikxALjF5i gLikjjFbdyvrAt`gsuz8{CzAzAbvbvcfcfAtvcA{ujq`)i cS{ua5y:tv6PrAsu+jsub*z gyvz bvtdjs¹q`q`s xAEI{¹qFgg^b^¨ ~ zAjAbdcScftvxAcAeSq`rcf{utvyc tdrLbvjgiKt gqsugKH yvcSf ?#{uS Yg!A f {ujS%;® $`/Y
(210) cK cfyvxAzAb*{usut*5eScbvª0cfxA{j^zA9y?eSsujS9~ßtvtvc8rAyvjksuA9efjF{yvjFsutveScScyv«0jFtvyvyxL8(qdrïgLg8 yv Sz jjt(q`s sEIt*qFydgrAtvsucScfxA{¹ sy*Lydj tvsuª{u{ jgg cSz jKzAbdcSA{uji G o[ONM/[`\Iv® È`ÜÓ ÚÜSÕ`ÆvÉVý Æ ^ÎÐÈ`Ædê0ýkÌÎÐÑÐÇ ÆÎÒå`ÜSÍÏǶËSͶÆVÈ`ÑÒÎÒÐê0ÆvÖ9Ìó ÑÐÆðê[ÆQÜÍPÈ`ÍÏÎÐÕ`Ü Õ`î
(211) % ÅVøTàöFåÅTÎÐÊdà"í 'AÊdÈ`ÜÊðÉ}ÈÇÏË ÌÉ}Õ^ÊvÆdÇPǶÆvÇ5ÎÒÜÍÏËSÆ
(212) ÇPÓ^ÇPͶÆQê×9ÆQîuÕ`É}Æ . ÅVÅÜNrãs`äã.
(213) l ( ( ; §jgbvj {usugjbvbj feSjb`bvgydsutdcSj`ï«PxA{$c«tdc+tdrATsuycSbdzLj2gzLc jFbo[®
(214) {u§9sjyds$gg{uyvLc+tda
(215) rLbhggAyh3gfVjg^bhg bhg 9tvTsCj«PcSCb*gAtdrA jsugb?Lsu Ayva
(216) suefgryhtðqF«PgxA{uj{
(217) q`MKcSi8suAikjFt j9«PcStvynb?cSiKg9g rAj{uz9«¶xA{V9suyhq`x5yvyvsucfAy[cfefbvcfxAzki8ji LjFbvyvr5sz8yvjbd9s qwjy® .
(218). * S*"$([* G o[ONM5/[] \&I
(219) i8igx5j{u{ÐjkonLq`jgxAikjf~NOjbvLgf9jtdtvjïrLgbvbvcf9¨ O$cfyvt~0a
(220) gy`qg{ujeMKsuAjt^~ g Agi /
(221) cSx5jeL®Hgn tdrAjK«Pcfbvig{ ydzLj^q`sEIqgtdsucS c«efbvcfxAz ikji jbvydrAsuzïydjbv9s¹q`jy^® /
(222) jqdrAAs¬¨ q ògj{IHª ò_jz cScSbvbvt
(223) l ]X9\^] ¨\l9-\ -~SX on~DxAeScfx5ikyvt?zAlx5ftv]jb$\5® Aq`suj q`jFT[jFzLgbdtvikjFt^~ScSbdAj{u{0AsuSjFbvyvsutQ 9~%<Qtvr gSqg5~ G1 o TZLZM+S I _bdstdgrAsubYikony;ik«PcSsub$b`~ i Tx5g{Atds¹9q* gydTnt;cfqw{cSjFikI~fi 9x5rAA{ucSs¹qi8gtd1c scfLn?bhgeSikbdcSjxAb^z5~ygb® L<Q T*Ng!{u s¹f 1g #M i2g {u90 s};® MK ji jbv ydrA su=z
(224) g!
(225) {;efc?¨ f S% ; ?%- l^nA~ 2 ò! jcSDj#i 3 %j b?l1f S5 !
(226) ® $`J#i#Z 0 2!
(227) + W n #:
(228) d ~Az geSjFy G,ONTZVFO% X2I g g{7 f ;j bf ® ?&z !2O =gRL# g d c eS #?%{u"! xV0 ~
(229) ? 0f j%f ?2 :>Z 3c i%$=T* D g^ !
(230) f S?cS{u$`sQ2J~T#=Ti xA
(231) su&
Documents relatifs
2) Le développement local c'est-à-dire les expériences d'intervention en développement économique communautaire, en économie sociale et en économie solidaire mises
La définition générale du concept d'évaluation formative des apprentissages retenue pour cette recherche constitue une synthèse découlant de la recension d'un ensemble
Effets et pouvoirs de la voix dans la philosophie et la littérature antiques Paris, Classiques Garnier, 2021 (Kaïnon - Anthropologie de la pensée ancienne, 19), ISBN :
relève de traités, et que les États membres sont des États au sens du droit international public, c’est à ce juste titre que J. Fischer peut qualifier l’Union actuelle de
Afin de saisir le déploiement de ce discours, j'analyserai dans un premier temps les représentations liées au temps dans le roman, en m'arrêtant d'abord sur toutes celles qui,
Cette recherche, de type qualitatif, consiste en une exploration de la littérature dont les buts sont de décrire selon divers auteurs, différe ntes expériences
For each sam- pling point is also given the value output of the merging process with the difference between the SH degree 100 expansions subtracted, the index corresponding to the
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
