An Energy Efficient Approach to Virtual Machines Management in Cloud Computing

Texte intégral

(1)Open Archive TOULOUSE Archive Ouverte (OATAO) OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.. This is an author-deposited version published in : http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/ Eprints ID : 15198. The contribution was presented at CloudNet 2014: http://cloudnet2014.ieee-cloudnet.org/. To cite this version : Borgetto, Damien and Stolf, Patricia An Energy Efficient Approach to Virtual Machines Management in Cloud Computing. (2014) In: 3rd IEEE International Conference on Cloud Networking (CloudNet 2014), 8 October 2014 - 10 October 2014 (Luxembourg, Luxembourg).. Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the repository administrator: staff-oatao@listes-diff.inp-toulouse.fr.

(2) )

(3) "&)

(4) $)!!" ) $ ) "$%)#) $)) %). !%$). =PKAQa SWIAYYSa ,=YWK?K=a 0YSOCa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a KCa YJAaX^XYAPa ZXAXaUWA?SUâ OK[AaPKIW=YKSQa \JK?Ja J=Xa OAXXa @S\QYKPAa >ZYa PSWAa @=Y=a YW=QXCAWa KQXYA=@a SCa USXY?SUâ OK[AaPKIW=YKSQa : ;a \JK?JaJ=XaPSWAa@S\QYKPAa>ZYaIZ=W=QYAAXa YJAa PAPSWâ YW=QXCAWa YSa >Aa @SQAa SQOâ SQ?A a 1J=Ya >AKQIa X=K@a YJAa CS?ZXa SCa YJAa 5&a P=Q=IAPAQYa =U` UWS=?Ja ZXA@a KQXK@Aa =a ?OSZ@a PZXYa >Aa UZYa SQa XA[AW=Oa USKQYXa . "&$.: 0": : $$'0#'&.: ".: 0': $&: 03&: ),'2##&!: &'1!": ,.'1,: 0': ": 1.,: &: ,1#&!: 0": '2,$$: )'3,: '&.1%)0#'&: ': 0": $'1:

(5) &: 0"#.: )),: 3: #&2.0#!0: 0":. . : $$'0#'&: &: ,$$'0#'&: #&.#: : $'1: #&: ',,: 0': .2: &,!6: 3"#$: %#&0#&#&!: 0": ,.'1,.: ,*1#,: 6:1.,.: 1": 0#'&.: "2: 0': : %: #&: ',,: 0': %#&#%#8: 0": &1%,: ': "'.0.: )'3,: '&: 3"#$: $#%#0#&!: '&1,,&0: %#!,0#'&.: ':. . 2#,01$: %"#&.: &: #&: : ,.'&$: '%)100#'&$: 0#%: : ),')'.: 0': 0#2$6: '&.'$#0: 2#,01$: %"#&.: 3#0": &: )),'": "&$#&!: 0": ,$$'0#'&: %#!,0#'&: &: "'.0: %&!%&0: ),'$%.: 1,: )),'": ".: &: #%)$%&0: #&: )&1$: &: 5),#%&0$$6: '%),: 3#0": #0.: 1$0: )),'": 74(+- $'1: '%)10#&!: #,01$: "#&: '&.'$#9 0#'&: : &,!63,: : #!,0#'&:. ! a. #

(6) $ #C. 7KYJa YJAa WA?AQYa YWAQ@Xa KQa =UUOK?=YKSQa @A?AQYW=OK_=YKSQa O=WIAOâ AP>S@KA@a >â ?OSZ@a ?SPUZYKQIa UO=YCSWPXa YJAWAaKXa =Qa KQ?WA=XA@a SCCAWa=Q@a @AP=Q@a SCa=UUOK?=YKSQXa S[AWa YJAaKQYAWQAYa =Q@a [K=a PS>KOAa @A[K?AX a 7JKOAa YW=@KYKSQ=Oa ?OSZ@a P=Q=IAPAQYa =OISWKYJPXa P=KQOâ CS?ZXa SQa J=Q@OKQIa YJAa KQKYK=Oa =OOS?=YKSQa SCa YJAa [KWYZ=Oa P=` ?JKQAXa KYa KXa KQYAWAXYKQIa YSa Y=?MOAa YJAa P=Q=IAPAQYa SCa YJAa [KWYZ=Oa P=?JKQAXa @ZWKQIa YJAKWa A]A?ZYKSQa =Xa YJAa 5&Xa @SQYa J=[Aa QA?AXX=WKOâ YJAa X=PAa @ZW=YKSQ a !Ya KXa AXXAQYK=Oa CSWa YJAa @=Y=?AQYAWXa S\QAWXa =Q@a SUAW=YSWXa YSa =XXAXXa =Q@a KPUWS[Aa YJAa UAWCSWP=Q?Aa ZXKQIa AQAWIâ ACF?KAQ?^ a 1JAa K@A=a >AKQIa YSa WA@Z?Aa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa SCa YJAa KQCW=XYWZ?YZWAa >â WA@Z?KQIa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa US\AWA@a SQ a )QAa =UUWS=?Ja YSa @^Q=PK?=OOâ WA=OOS?=YAa WAXSZW?AXa SCa =a ?OSZ@a KXa YSa Y=MAa YJAa KQKYK=Oa UO=?APAQYa =OISWKYJPa =Q@a UAWKS@K?=OOâ SWa ZUSQa A[AQYXa UWS?AA@a YSa =a CZOOa WA=OOS?=YKSQa SCa 5&X a S\A[AWa KYa PKIJYa >Aa UWACAW=>OAa QSYa YSa J=[Aa YJAa X=PAa =OISWKYJPa CSWa KQKYK=Oa =OOS?=YKSQa=Q@aCSWa?SQXSOK@=YKSQa XKQ?AaWA=WW=QIKQIaYJAa\JSOAa USSOa SCa5&Xa \KOOa ?WA=YAa =a ?SQYAQYKSQa USKQYa \JAWAa YSSa P=Qâ PKIW=YKSQXa =WAa >AKQIa @SQAa =Ya YJAa X=PAa YKPA a 1JAa KXXZAa KXa. . QAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa 1JAa WAXZOYKQIa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPU` YKSQa PZXYa >Aa OS\AWa =Q@a =??SZQYa CSWa =OOa YJAa S[AWJA=@Xa YJ=Ya ?=Qa KPU=?Ya YJAa AQAWIâ WA@Z?YKSQ a &KIW=YKSQa QZP>AWa 1JAa =KPa KXa YSa =[SK@a =a >SYYOAQA?Ma SQa YJAa QAY\SWMa >â @KPAQXKSQKQIa =Q@a OKPKYKQIa YJAa PKIW=` YKSQXa @SQAa KQa =a ?AWY=KQa YKPAa KQYAW[=O a -Z=OKYâ SCa 0AW[K?Aa 4XAWXa SWa =UUOK?=YKSQXa WAVZKWAa =a ?AWY=KQa=PSZQYaSCaWAXSZW?AaCSWaYJAKWa5&Xa =Q@aKYaXJSZO@a >Aa =??AXXK>OAa YSa YJAPa =Ya =OOa YKPA a S\A[AWa A[AQa KCa \Aa ?=Qa WAXUA?Ya YJ=Ya ?SQXYW=KQYa YJAWAa =WAa USXXK>OAa -S0a WA@Z?YKSQa @ZAa YSa YJAa YKPAa >AY\AAQa \JAQa YJAa 5&a KXa XU=\QA@a =Q@a \JAQa KYa KXa =?YZ=OOâ WZQQKQI a SPUZY=YKSQa YKPAa 1JAa XSOZYKSQa PZXYa >Aa ?SPUOAYA@a KQa WA=XSQ=>OAa YKPAa YSa >Aa AQCSW?A@a \JKOAaKYa KXaXYKOOaWAOA[=QY a. 1JAa \SWMa UWAXAQYA@a KQa YJKXa U=UAWa J=Xa >AAQa P=@Aa SQa YJAa ?SQYA]Ya SCa YJAa 0),a UWSLA?Ya YJKQMa IOS>=Oa 0AW[K?AXa CSWa UAW` X)Q=Oa ?SP,ZYAWa a !Ya =KPXa =Ya UWS[K@KQIa ZXAWXa \KYJa =Qa =OO` KQ?OZXK[Aa SCCAWa YJ=Ya =OOS\Xa YJAPa YSa >Aa =>OAa YSa ZXAa =UUOK` ?=YKSQXa KQa YJAa ?OSZ@ a !Qa YJKXa U=UAWa \Aa UWSUSXAa =Q@a XYZ@â YJAa @KDAWAQYa =XUA?YXa SCa ?SQXSOK@=YKSQa =OISWKYJPXa SQa =a WA=Oa UO=YCSWPa \JKOAa?SPU=WKQIaYJAPaYSaYJAa@AC=ZOYaSQAaUWSUSXA@a KQa )UAQ'A>ZO=: ;a =OYJSZIJa YJAa =UUWS=?Ja UWAXAQYA@a KXa QSYa XUA?KF?a YSa )UAQ'A>ZO= a 7AaXYZ@âYJAaPKIW=YKSQa>AJ=[KSZWaSQa=aXUA?KF?aUO=YCSWPaYSa >AYYAWa YZQAa YJAa ?SQXSOK@=YKSQa =OISWKYJP a 7Aa =OXSa KPUOAPAQYa =a JSXYa P=Q=IAPAQYa XYW=YAIâ YSa >Aa =>OAa YSa CZQ?YKSQa \KYJa =a U=?MKQIa >=XA@a ?SQXSOK@=YKSQa =UUWS=?J a [=OZ=YKSQa KXa P=@Aa WAI=W@KQIa >SYJa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa =Q@a 5&a ACCA?YK[Aa @ZW=` YKSQa \JKOAa PSQKYSWKQIa YJAa ACCA?Ya SCa YJAa KQCW=XYWZ?YZWAa OS=@a SQa YJAa VZ=OKYâ SCa YJAa WA=OOS?=YKSQ a 1JKXaU=UAWaKXaSWI=QK_A@a=XaCSOOS\Xa 0A?YKSQa!!a\KOOa@AX?WK>Aa WAO=YA@a \SWMXa ?SQ?AWQKQIa =OOS?=YKSQa =Q@a WA=OOS?=YKSQa SCa [KW` YZ=Oa P=?JKQAXa KQa =a ?OSZ@a ?SPUZYKQIa AQ[KWSQPAQY a 0A?YKSQa !!!a =Q@a !5a WAXUA?YK[AOâ UWAXAQYa =a UWS>OAPa CSWPZO=YKSQa =Q@a .<.*;,1.<C 9;.<.7=.-C 27C =12<C 9*9.;C 1*?.C +..7C 9*;=2*55BC />7-.-C +BC =1.C C 27C =1.C ,87=.A=C 8/C "C 9;83.,=C C.

(7) YJAa =UUWS=?Ja UWSUSXA@ a KQ=OOâ XA?YKSQa 5a \KOOa ?S[AWa YJAa A]UAWKPAQYXa =Q@a @KX?ZXXKSQa U=WY a !! a. ! #

(8) C ' C. 1JAWAaJ=[Aa>AAQa A]YAQXK[Aa XYZ@KAXaSQaJS\aYSaP=Q=IAa@=Y=a ?AQYAWa =Q@a ?OSZ@Xa KQa WAI=W@Xa YSa YJAa US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa =Q@a -S0a YW=@ASD a XUA?K=OOâ KQa YJAa 5&a =OOS?=YKSQa =Q@a ?OSZ@a WA?SQFIZW=YKSQa =WA= a 1JAa =W?JKYA?YZW=Oa G=PA\SWMa CSWa AQAWIâ AE?KAQYa ?OSZ@Xa UWSUSXA@a KQa :;a KQYWS@Z?AXa QSYKSQXa SCa 5&a UWS[KXKSQKQIa =Xa \AOOa =Xa =OOS?=YKSQa =Q@a WA=OOS?=YKSQa SCa 5&Xa SQa UJ^XK?=Oa P=?JKQAX a 1JAa=ZYJSWXaZXAaYJAa,4aWAXSZW?AaYSa@^Q=PK?=OOâ ?SQXSOK@=YAa YJAa 5&Xa YJZXa WA@Z?KQIa XKIQKF?=QYOâ YJAa IOS>=Oa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa SCa YJAa KQG=XYWZ?YZWA a &SWAS[AWa YJAa =ZYJSWXa KPUOAPAQYa =a 5&a WAUO=?APAQYa USOK?â >=XA@a SQa =a @SZ>OAa YJWAXJSO@a OS\a =Q@a JKIJa =Xa \AOOa =Xa =a PKIW=YKSQa PKQKPK_=YKSQa USOK?â KQa SW@AWa YSa OKPKYa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa PK` IW=YKSQXa CSWa KQXY=Q?Aa CWSPa =Qa S[AWOS=@A@a JSXY a 1JAâ XYZ@â YJAa KPU=?Ya SCa YJAa 0AW[K?Aa $A[AOa IWAAPAQYa @AIW=@=YKSQa SQa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa WA@Z?YKSQ a 8K=Sa AYa =O a KQa :;a UWAXAQYa =a X^XYAPa >=XA@a SQa =UUOK?=YKSQa WAVZKWAPAQYa YSa XZUUSWYa IWAAQa ?SPUZYKQIa KQa YJAa ?OSZ@ a 1JAa P=KQa \=â YSa @Sa XSa KXa >â ?SQXSOK@=YKSQ a 1JAâ KQYWS@Z?Aa YJAa ?SQ?AUYa SCa XMA\QAXXa \JK?Ja WAUWAXAQYa YJAa KP>=O=Q?Aa S[AWa YJAa @KDAWAQYa WAXSZW?Aa ?SQXZPUYKSQa SCa =a XAW[AWa =UUOKA@a KQa YJAKWa ?=XAa YSa YJAa ,4a PAPSWâ =Q@a @KXM a /A@Z?KQIa YJKXa KP>=O=Q?AaKXa=KPA@a=YaKQ?WA=XKQIaKQ@K[K@Z=OaJSXYXaZYKOK_=YKSQ a 1JAa?SQXSOK@=YKSQa=OISWKYJPaYJAâUWAXAQYaKXa>=XA@aSQa=aPZOYK` YJWAXJSO@a =UUWS=?Ja YSa @AFQAa ?SO@a =Q@a JSYa XUSYX a !Ya YJAQa WA=OOS?=YAXa5&XaYSaWA@Z?Aa?SO@aXUSYXa=Q@aPKYKI=YAaJSYaXUSYX a 1JAa=ZYJSWXa=OXSa?SP>KQAaYJKXa=UUWS=?JaYSa=a [KWYZ=OaP=?JKQAa OS=@a UWA@K?YKSQa YSa >AYYAWa UWS[KXKSQa YJAa WAXSZW?AX a =XA@a SQa YJAa S>XAW[=YKSQa YJ=Ya YJAa YÛAa SCa =UUOK?=YKSQa WZQQKQIa KQXK@Aa =a [KWYZ=Oa P=?JKQAa ?=Qa @W=XYK?=OOâ ?J=QIAa KYXa >AJ=[KSZWa @AUAQ@KQIa SQa \JAWAa KXa YJAa 5&a KP=IAa 9=QIa AYa =O a KQa :;aUWSUSXAa@KCCAWAQYa\SWMOS=@a?J=W=?YAWKXYK?=\=WAa>KQa U=?MKQIa =OISWKYJPXa YSa >Aa =UUOKA@a CSWa ?SQXSOK@=YKSQa KQa ?OSZ@a AQ[KWSQPAQY a 1JAâ UWSUSXAa KQa YJAKWa U=UAWa =a @^Q=PK?a UWS` IW=PPKQIaSUYKP=Oa =OISWKYJPa =Q@a=Qa =UUWS]KP=YKSQa JAZWKXYK?a YJ=Ya YJAâ ?SPU=WAa >AY\AAQa A=?Ja SYJAWa YJAa UAWCSWP=Q?Aa PAYWK?a >AKQIa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa ZXA@ a 1JAa =UUWS]KP=YKSQa =OISWKYJPaKXa=a>KQaU=?MKQIa=OISWKYJPa?=OOA@a0,U=?Ma \JK?Ja XY=Q@Xa CSWa XAU=W=YAa U=?MKQI a 1JAa K@A=a >AKQIa YJ=Ya XKQ?Aa KYa KXa USXXK>OAaYSa?J=W=?YAWK_AaYJAa@KDAWAQYa5&Xa=??SW@KQIaYSaYJAKWa YÛAaSCa\SWMOS=@a @=Y=aKQYAQXK[AaSWa,4aKQYAQXK[Aa YJAâJ=[Aa YSa >Aa YWA=YA@a @KDAWAQYO^ a !Qa :;a YJAa =ZYJSWXa UWAXAQYa Y\Sa =OISWKYJPXa CSWa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa WA@Z?YKSQa =Q@a PKIW=YKSQa ?SXYa PKYKI=YKSQa KQa YJAa ?OSZ@ a 1JAâ ?SPUZYAa =Qa A]=?Ya XSOZYKSQa >=XA@a SQa KQYAIAWa OKQA=Wa UWSIW=PPKQIa KQa SW@AWa YSa PKQKPK_Aa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQ` XZPUYKSQa ZQ@AWa ?SQXYW=KQYXa SCa ,4a PAPSWâ =Q@a XYSW=IAa SCa YJAa 5&X a 1JAKWa =UUWS=?Ja =OOS\Xa YSa =XXKIQa =a US\AWa >Z@IAYa YSa A=?Ja JSXYa YJ=Ya XJSZO@a QSYa >Aa S[AWW=Q a 1JAâ ?SPU=WAa KYa \KYJa =Qa AQAWI^=\=WAa >AXYa FYa JAZWKXYK? a. QSYJAWa=UUWS=?JaYSaYJAa[KWYZ=OaP=?JKQAaU=?MKQIaUWS>OAPa >â KQYAIAWa OKQA=Wa UWSIW=RKQIa KXa =OXSa UWAXAQYA@a KQa :; a 1JAa =ZYJSWXa J=[Aa \SWMA@a SQa @KDAWAQYa 5&a U=?MKQIa =OISWKYJPXa YJ=Ya =KPa =Ya WA@Z?KQIa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa PS@AOA@a =Xa YJAa ?SXYa SCa YJAa JSXYXa AOA?YWK?=Oa ?SQXZPUYKSQa =Q@a YJAa ?SXYa SCa YJAa WA?SQFIZW=YKSQ a 1J=Ya \=â YJAa =ZYJSWXa =KPa =Ya WA@Z?KQIa US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa \JKOAa P=KQY=KQKQIa =a ?AWY=KQa OA[AOa SCa UAWCSWP=Q?Aa =Q@a @KPKQKXJKQIa YJAa?SXYa SCa WA?SQFIZW=YKSQa >â OK[Aa PKIW=YKSQ a /A@Z?KQIa ?SOOKXKSQXa SCa5&a OK[Aa PKIW=YKSQa KXa P=@Aa >â UZYYKQIa =a J=W@a ?SQXYW=KQYa SQa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa 5&Xa YJ=Ya ?=Qa PKIW=YAa GSPa =Q@a YSa =a JSXY a 3=M=J=XJKa AYa =O a YJAQa @AFQAaY\Sa=OISWKYJPXa =a P=Y?JKQI>=XA@a =OISWKYJPa>=XA@aSQa IW=UJa =Q@a YJAa PS@AOKQIa SCa YJAa UWS>OAPa YJ=Ya ?SPUZYAXa YJAa SUYKP=Oa XSOZYKSQa =Q@a =a IWAA@â JAZWKXYK?a YJ=Ya ?SPUZYAXa YJAa XSOZYKSQa C=XYAW a OOa YJSXAa =UUWS=?JAXa =WAa =MKQa YSa SZWXa =Xa YJAa P=KQa CS?ZXa KXaYSaX=[AaAQAWIâ>âUS\AWKQIaSDaJSXYXaZQOS=@A@a>â?SQXSOK` @=YKSQ a S\A[AWaXP=OOa@KCCAWAQ?AXa=WAaYSa>AaXAAQaSQaYJAaXSWYa SCa KQCSWP=YKSQa YJAa P=Q=IAWa J=Xa \JAYJAWa KYa KXa ?=YAISWK_KQIa YJAa [KWYZ=Oa P=?JKQAXa >AKQIa =>OAa YSa S[AWXZ>X?WK>Aa YJAa JSXYXa =Q@a JS\a YSa P=Q=IAa [KWYZ=Oa P=?JKQAXa PKIW=YKSQa =Q@a YJAa >SYYOAQA?Ma KQ@Z?A@ a 1JAa P=KQa @KCCAWAQ?Aa >AKQIa YJAa =>KOKYâ YSa Y=MAa KQYSa=??SZQYa YJAa =?YZ=Oa S[AWJA=@aSCaUS\AWKQIa SQa=Q@a SDa JSXYX a !!! a R. C $#C. #'07&!,!'&7. 7Aa FWXYa UWAXAQYa YJAa AQ[KWSQPAQYa =Q@a YJAa UWS>OAPa \Aa =WAa YW^KQIa YSa XSO[A a 7Aa =WAaXAYaKQa=a?OSZ@a SUAW=YA@aS[AWa=a XKQIOAa @=Y=a ?AQYAWa >â =a UWS[K@AW a 1JKXa UWS[K@AWa =OOS\Xa ZXAWa YSa XY=WYa =Q@a WZQa 5&Xa S[AWa YJAa ?OSZ@a \KYJa YJAa ?SQXYW=KQYa SCa J=[KQIa UWS[K@A@a YSa YJAPa \J=Ya YJAâ J=[Aa WAVZKWA@ a 1JAa?OSZ@aJ=Xa 3UJ^XK?=Oa JSXYXa \KYJaYJAa=>KOKYâ YSaUS\AWa SQa =Q@a SDa \JAQa APUY^ a )[AWa YKPAa 5&Xa =WAa WZQa SQa YJAa ?OSZ@a CSWa =a ?AWY=KQa @ZW=YKSQ a )[AWa YJAa @ZW=YKSQa 5R SCa YJAa A]UAWKPAQYa &R 5&Xa\KOOa>AaA]A?ZYA@ a =?Ja5&aJ=XaWAXSZW?Aa WAVZKWAPAQYXa \JK?Ja \Aa ?JSXAa KQa SZWa ?=XAa YSa >Aa ,4a =Q@a /& a $AYXa QSYAa - &,3YJAaQZP>AWaSCa,4a WAVZKWA@a>â =a 5&a =Q@a - 3 YJAa QZP>AWa SCa &a SCa /&a WAVZKWA@a >â YJAa 5& a 1JAa 5&Xa \KOOa >Aa =OOS?=YA@a SQa YJAa @KDAWAQYa JSXYXa XSa YJ=Ya YJAKWa WAVZKWAPAQYXa =WAa P=Y?JA@ a 7Aa \KOOa QSYAa @MDBR R ) KCaYJAa5&a - 3KXa=OOS?=YA@aYSaYJAaJSXYa 3 @MDBR R GR SYJAW\KXA a !Ca 3 KXa YJAa ,4a ?=U=>KOKYâ =Q@a 3 YJAa &&a ?=U=>KOKYâ SCa YJAa JSXYa YJAa OS=@a SCa YJAa JSXYa KXa @AFQA@a =Xa YJAa CSOOS\KQIa. . R 0R. ' (). 5C 3%3)BR. . MD. - 35C @MDBR 5C 'R. 1JAa OS=@a SCa YJAa JSXYa S[AWa A=?Ja WAXSZW?Aa ?SQXK@AWA@a >â YJAa 5&Xa XJSZO@a QA[AWa >Aa A]?AA@A@ a.

(9) =?Ja 5&a KXa FQKYAa KQa YKPAa YJZXa \KOOa =OXSa >Aa @AFQA@a >â KYXa @ZW=YKSQa. ."3R JI=A?>R R J<FFKR R JHLER 7JAWAa JI=A?>R ?SPUWKXAXa YJAa X?JA@ZOKQIa YKPAa =Q@a YJAa YKPAa CSWa KYXa KPUOAPAQY=YKSQ a 1JAa [=OZAXa J<FFKR =Q@a JHLER WAUWAXAQYa WAXUA?YK[AOâ YJAa YKPAa Y=MAQa >â YJAa 5&a >SSYa YKPAa =Q@a YJAa YKPAa @ZWKQIa \JK?Ja YJAa 5&a KXa KQa YJAa )0&&!&7 XY=YA a !Ya =OXSa PA=QXaYJ=YaKCa=a5&aWAVZKWAXa=QaJSZWaSCaYKPAaSQaYJAa?OSZ@a KYa \KOOa ADA?YK[AOâ WZQa YJAaWAVZAXYA@a JSZWaPKQZXa YJAa YKPAa Y=MAQa YSa XU=\Qa =Q@a >SSYa YJAa 5& a

(10) R. !5 a 5&a #C : R. Qa ACCA?YK[Aa @ZW=YKSQa SCa a SCa =a U=WYK?ZO=Wa 5&a \KOOa PA=Qa YJ=YaYJKXa5&aXUAQYa a SCaYJAaWAVZAXYA@aYKPAaKQaYJAaWZQQKQIa XY=YA a 1JAa SYJAWa UAWCSWP=Q?Aa PAYWK?a \Aa S>[KSZXOâ \=QYa CSWa SZWa PS@AOaKXaYJAaAQAWIâ?SQXZPUYKSQaSCaYJAa?OSZ@ a1JAWAa=WAaY\Sa YÛAXa SCa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa YJ=Ya \Aa \KOOa IAYa SWa ?SPUZYA a 1JAa FWXYa KXa YJAa WA=Oa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa ?=O?ZO=YA@a =Xa YJAa XZPa SCa =OOa YJAa US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQXa PA=XZWA@a S[AWa =OOa YJAa JSXYX a. 1JAa SYJAWa SQAa \KOOa >Aa ZXA@a KQa XA?YKSQa5a KXa YJAa XKPZO=YA@a US\AWa?SQXZPUYKSQ a 0KQ?AaYJAaS[AWJA=@XaSCaYJAaUS\AWKQIaSQa =Q@a SCCa YJAaJSXYXa=WAa VZKYAa XKIQKF?=QYa =Xa XJS\QaKQa :;a KYa ?=Qa >AaVZKYAaJ=W@aYSaVZ=QYKCâ =XaXZ?JaYJAa KPUWS[APAQYa SCaAQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa YJ=Ya =a ?SQXSOK@=YKSQa =OISWKYJPa \KOOa >WKQI a Xa XZ?Ja \Aa ?=Qa ?SPUZYAa YJAa XKPZO=YA@a US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa =Xa YJAa =WYKF?K=Oa AOKPKQ=YKSQa SCa =OOa S[AWJA=@Xa KQ@Z?A@a >â YJAa JSXYa XY=YAXa P=Q=IAPAQYa \JK?Ja KXa YJAa PA=XZWA@a US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa \KYJa XKPZO=YA@a JSXYXa XY=YA a 1J=Ya PA=QXa YJAa =XXZPUYKSQa YJ=Ya YJAa JSXYXa US\AWa SQa =Q@a SCCa KQXY=QYOâ =Q@a \KYJa QSa ?SXY a. (& 0#7 0#)7. )UAQ'A>ZO=a =OWA=@â UWS[K@AXa =a >=XAa X?JA@ZOAWa \KYJa KYXa KQXY=OO=YKSQ a !Ya KXa =a ?SQFIZW=>OAa X?JA@ZOAWa ?=OOA@a %, 6 %"!&7 + 0#)7 SWa %%+ 7 =Q@a KXa @AX?WK>A@a KQa @AY=KOXa KQa :; a 1JAa %%+ 7 =OISWKYJPa SUAW=YAXa KQa YJWAAa XKPUOAa XYAUXa . . .

(11) ,)!+7. 7Aa @AFQA@a =a J=W@a >SZQ@a SQa JS\a YJAa @KCCAWAQYa LS>Xa =WAa YSa >Aa=OOS?=YA@a PA=QKQIaYJ=Ya=a5&a?=QYaIAYaOAXXaYJ=QaWAVZKWA@ a 1JKXa =OXSa PA=QXa YJ=Ya YSa >Aa =>OAa YSa J=[Aa =a XSWYa SCa -S0a PAYWK?a \Aa ?=QYa WA=?Ja KQXK@Aa YJAa 5&a YSa IAYa WAXUSQXAa YKPAa CSWa A]=PUOAa >A?=ZXAa YJKXa PS@AOa KXa =IQSXYK?a YSa \J=Ya MKQ@a SCa =UUOK?=YKSQa YJAa 5&a KXa WZQQKQI a 1J=YXa \Jâ \Aa \KOOa @AFQAa YJAa-S0aPAYWK?aSCaYJAa5&XaWZQaSQaYJAa?OSZ@a>â @AFQKQIa YJAa ,!17 0),!'&7 SCa YJAa 5&Xa. C.

(12) R. KOYAWa JSXYXa YJ=Ya O=?Ma YJAa WAVZKWA@a ?J=W=?YAWKXYK?Xa A Ia YJ=Ya =WAa QSYa KQa YJAa WKIJYa XY=YAa SWa @SQYa J=[Aa AQSZIJa WAXSZW?AXa a 0SWYa=OOaJSXYXa=??SW@KQIaYSaYJAaW=QMKQIaUSOK?â@AX?WK>A@a JAWA=HAW a 1JAa JSXYXa \KYJa YJAa JKIJAXYa W=QMa =WAa ?JSXAQa CSWa YJAa =OOS?=YKSQ a. 7. 1JAa KPUOAPAQY=YKSQa SCa YJAa X?JA@ZOAWa CSWa YJAa ?OSZ@a YJ=Ya \Aa @AFQA@a \KOOa CSOOS\a YJAa X=PAa CZQ?YKSQKQIa U=YYAWQa =Xa %%+ 7 7Aa \KOOa J=[Aa YJAa X=PAa UAWKS@K?a ?=OOXa YSa YJAa X?JA@ZOAWa KQa SW@AWa YSa J=[Aa =a ?SQXKXYAQYa ?SPU=WKXSQ a 1JAa X?JA@ZOAWa J=Xa YSa Y=MAa KQYSa =??SZQYa @KCCAWAQYa ?SQ` XYW=KQYX a 1JAa FWXYa KXa YJ=Ya KYa J=Xa YSa >Aa XAU=W=YA@a KQYSa Y\Sa @KXYKQ?Ya =OISWKYJPXa SQAa CSWa YJAa KQKYK=Oa =OOS?=YKSQa SCa 5&Xa =Q@a SQAa CSWa YJAa UAWKS@K?a WA?SQFIZW=YKSQa SCa YJAa 5&Xa KQa YJAa ?OSZ@a YSa >AYYAWa J=Q@OAa YJAa XZ>XAYa SCa PKIW=YKSQXa YJ=Ya J=[Aa YSa >Aa @SQAa CSWa AQAWIâ WA@Z?YKSQa \KYJSZYa J=[KQIa YSa WA=OOS?=YAa =OOa 5&X a 1JAa =OISWKYJPa =OOS?=YAXa UAQ@KQIa 5&Xa >=XA@a SQa =a >AXYFYa JAZWKXYK? a 1JAa =OISWKYJPa YSa WA=OOS?=YAa \KOOa >WKQIa YJAa PSXYa AQAWIâ X=[KQIXa >â ZXKQIa ?SQXSOK@=YKSQa YSa WA@Z?Aa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa ZXA@a >â YJAa 5&Xa \JAQa YJAa X^XYAPa ?J=QIA@a >A?=ZXAa XSPAa SCa YJAa 5&Xa J=[Aa AQ@A@a CSWa KQXY=Q?A a 7Aa ZXA@a =a PS@KFA@a [A?YSWa U=?MKQIa =OISWKYJPa @AX?WK>A@a =Xa =OISWKYJPa a YSa WA=OOS?=YAa YJAa [KWYZ=Oa P=?JKQAXa CWSPa SQAa SWa XA[AW=Oa JSXYXaYSaWA@Z?AaYJAaIOS>=OaJSXYaQZP>AW a1JAa=UUWS=?JaZXA@aKXa >=XA@aSQa YJAa =OISWKYJPaUWAXAQYA@a KQa :N(;a =Q@a KXa \SWMKQIa >â XAU=W=YKQIa YJAa JSXYXa KQa =Xa PZ?Ja OKXYa =Xa \Aa J=[Aa @KPAQXKSQXa CSWa YJAa =OOS?=YKSQ a =?Ja OKXYa ?SQY=KQXa YJAa JSXYXa \KYJa PSWAa WAVZKWAPAQYXa KQa SQAa U=WYK?ZO=Wa WAXSZW?A a !Qa SZWa ?=XAa \Aa \KOOa J=[Aa Y\Sa OKXYXa SQAa CSWa YJAa JSXYXa YJ=Ya J=[Aa PSWAa ,4a YJ=Qa &&a =Q@a SQAa CSWa YJAa SUUSXKYA a 1JAa ,4a =Q@a &&a =WAa QSYa YJAa X=PAa YÛAa SCa WAXSZW?Aa XKQ?Aa YJAa ,4a ?=Qa >Aa S[AWXZ>X?WK>A@a PSWAaA=XKOâ YJ=QaYJAaPAPSWâ =Q@aKYaKXa >AYYAWa YSa QSYa UWS[K@Aa =Qa =UUOK?=YKSQa \KYJa OAXXa PAPSWâ YJ=Qa \J=Ya KYa WAVZKWA@ a S\A[AWa \Aa YSSMa KQYSa =??SZQYa >SYJa WAXSZW?AXa =Ya YJAa X=PAa OA[AOa YSa IZ=W=QYAAa =Qa A]A?ZYKSQa YKPAa VZ=OKYâ SCa XAW[K?Aa CSWa =UUOK?=YKSQXa WZQQKQIa KQXK@Aa 5&X a 1JAQa YJAa 5&Xa =WAa =OOS?=YA@a YSa YJAa JSXYXa UWA[KSZXOâ XSWYA@a XSa YJ=Ya YJAa =OOS?=YKSQa WA@Z?AXa YJAa ?ZWWAQYa WAXSZW?Aa KP>=O=Q?A aSWaA]=PUOAaKCaYJAa5&aJ=Xa - &,3 R - 3 3 YJAQa \Aa \KOOa UK?Ma UWACAW=>Oâ =a JSXYa CWSPa YJAa OKXYa \JAWAa % 3 R %2&,31J=Ya\=âYJAaKP>=O=Q?AaSCaWAXSZW?Aa ?SQXZPUYKSQa \KOOa >Aa WA@Z?A@ a.

(13) &*,/2C SQXSOK@=YAa 5&Xa 3 a XSWYB.a OS=@a =X?AQ@KQIa 3 a 3 R 3 \JAWAa !$%

(14) 3. 7Aa J=[Aa YSa ?JSSXAa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa YJ=Ya \Aa \KOOa YWâ YSa ?SQXSOK@=YA a 1J=Ya QZP>AWa ?=Qa >Aa ?JSXAQa [K=a QZPAWSZXa \=^Xa OKMAa J=[KQIa YJWAXJSO@Xa YSa @AFQAa OS\a OS=@A@a JSXYXa YJ=Ya \KOOa >Aa ?JSXAQa YSa ?SQXSOK@=YAa SWa OKMAa \Aa @Sa KQa YJKXa U=UAWa ?JSSXKQIa YSa ZQOS=@a =a F]A@a QZP>AWa SCa JSXYX a 1J=Ya QZP>AWa PZXYa [=Wâ WAI=W@KQIa YJAa IOS>=Oa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa =Q@a 5&X a !Qa =@@KYKSQa KYa \KOOa =OXSa J=[Aa YSa @AUAQ@a SQa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa ?SQ?ZWWAQYaPKIW=YKSQXaYJ=Ya?=Qa>AaP=@AaYS\=W@aSQAaJSXYa=Q@a SQa YJAa QAY\SWMa KQCW=XYWZ?YZWA a $K[Aa PKIW=YKSQXa =WAa UZYYKQIa =a XYW=KQa SQa YJAa QAY\SWMa =Xa YJAâ YW=QXCAWa YJAa PAPSWâ U=IAXa SCa YJAa 5&a USYAQYK=OOâ PSWAa YJ=Qa SQ?Aa @AUAQ@KQIa SQa JS\a @=Y=aKQYAQXK[AaKXaYJAa=UUOK?=YKSQ a 1J=Ya>AKQIaX=K@a YJAaQZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa ?JSXAQa CSWa ZQOS=@KQIa QAA@Xa YSa >Aa ?=UUA@a YSa YJAa P=]KPZPa =PSZQYa SCa ?SQ?ZWWAQYa PKIW=YKSQa SQAa \=QYXa =Xa \AOOa =Xa >AKQIa Y=KOSWA@a YSa P=Y?Ja YJAa KQG=XYWZ?YZWAa XK_A a 7Aa \KOOa ?SPUZYAa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa YSa >Aa a SCa YJAa YSY=Oa JSXYa QZP>AWa 3 \KYJa =a PKQKPZPa SCa a 7Aa =OXSa ?JSXAa YSa PKYKI=YAa YJ=Ya QZP>AWa WAI=W@KQIa YJAa UWSLA?YA@a =PSZQYa SCa PKIW=YKSQXa =Xa \Aa \KOOa @AX?WK>Aa KQa 5*a 1JAa =OISWKYJPa a KXa UWAXAQYA@aCSWa=aQZP>AWaSCa a XKQ?AaKYXaW=YJAWaXYW=KIJYCSW\=W@a YSa A]YAQ@a KYa YSa XA[AW=Oa JSXYXa YSa ZQOS=@ a Xa \Aa ?=Qa XAAa KQa YJAa =OISWKYJPa SQAa XJSZO@a QSYAa YJ=Ya YJAa PKIW=YKSQXa =WAa SQOâ AQCSW?A@a KCa =Q@a SQOâ KCa YJAa JSXYa P=â >Aa CZOOâ ZQOS=@A@ a !Ya KXa =Qa SUYKPK_=YKSQa ?JSK?A a 1JAa =KPa KXa YSa =[SK@a PKIW=YKSQXa YJ=Ya ?SZO@a KWWAOA[=QYa >A?=ZXAa =QSYJAWa @A?KXKSQXa P=â >Aa>AYYAWaKQaYJAaQA]YaX?JA@ZOKQIaOSSUa=Q@aYJ=Ya \KOOa SQOâ IAQAW=YAa S[AWJA=@ a R. 0 ')%#(13 "C +34C 3 R 33 3 (3C /+C % 7-*2C BR ,3 R % 3 BR. 3 . , =@@a 3 YSa . *06*C =@@a 3 YSa 3 *2(C *2(C XZ??AXX1WZAa ) (3C +34*%'-C - 3 @MDCCBR CSZQ@a a =OXAa a /+C - &,3 R - 3 7-*2C CSZQ@a a 1Wâ YSa FQ@a =a XZKY=>OAa JSXYa 3 KQa 3 FWXYa YJAQa ,3 *06*C CSZQ@a a 1Wâ YSa FQ@a =a XZKY=>OAa JSXYa KQa 3FWXYa YJAQa 3 *2(C /+C %+#3 7-*2C =@@a - 33 YSa ')%#(3 ?J=QIAa OKXYa SCa 3 KCa QAA@A@a #C *06*C XZ??AXX=OXAa *2(C *2(C /+C +0++)07 7-*2C AQCSW?Aa ')%#(3 *2(C *2(C $0,34/7-1C R 0),5,a /A=OOS?=YKSQa =OISWKYJPa . . . %(#%&,!&7 &)371!&+7. 1JAWAa =WAa XA[AW=Oa \=^Xa YSa J=Q@OAa YJAa JSXYXa XY=YAa YJ=Ya KXa \JAQa YSa US\AWa SCCa =Q@a US\AWa SQa YJAa UJ^XK?=Oa P=?JKQAXa YSa >AYYAWaX=[AaAQAWIâ=??SW@KQIOâYSa\J=YaYJAa5&a?SQXSOK@=YKSQa =OISWKYJPa KXa @SKQIa :; a

(15) a !)+,%(-37 1JAa FWXYa SQAa KXa YJAa A=XKAXYa >ZYa QSYa YJAa PSXYa ACF?KAQYa KYa \SWMXa KQa =a XKPUOAa \=â X\KY?JKQIa SDaJSXYXa =Xa XSSQa =Xa SQAa JSXYa KXa APUYâ =Q@a US\AWa SQa JSXYXa \JAQa YJAa IOS>=Oa OS=@a SCa YJAa ?OSZ@a KXa S[AWa =a ?AWY=KQa YJWAXJSO@ a C !1',7 1JAaXA?SQ@aSQAa \SWMXa >â MAAUKQIa =a UK[SYa JSXY a !YaFWXYa?SPUZYAXaYJAaUWSLA?YA@aQZP>AWaSCaJSXYaYJ=YaKXaQAA@A@a YSa WZQa =OOa YJAa 5&Xa =Q@a YWKAXa YSa MAAUa YJKXa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa US\AWA@a SQa UOZXa YJAaQZP>AWa SCaUK[SYa JSXYX a 1JKXa WA[A=OXa YJAa C=?YaYJ=Ya YJAa =OISWKYJPaZXA@aCSWa?SQXSOK@=YKSQaJ=Xa YSa=??SZQYa CSWa YJAa UK[SYa JSXYa SYJAW\KXAa KYa \KOOa \KQ@a ZUa ?SQXSOK@=YKQIa YSSa PZ?Ja =Q@a J=[KQIa =Qa APUYâ JSXYa =Xa UWA[KSZXOâ XJS\Qa KQa : ; a OYJSZIJa KQa =Qâ ?=XAa KYa =OOS\Xa XSPAa OAA\=â KQa YJAa WA=OOS?=YKSQa UWS?AXXa \JK?Ja \KOOa @KPKQKXJa 5&a ADA?YK[Aa @ZW=YKSQa @AIW=@=YKSQ a. %()3#+ '3. . /3 )MD. . 'R. 3. - 3. ). C )!,!'&7 1JAaO=XYaJSXYaXY=YAaP=Q=IAPAQYaXYW=YAIâ \Aa @AFQA@aKXa>=XA@aSQaYJAa[=WK=YKSQaSCaYJAaIOS>=OaOS=@aS[AWaYKPA a !Ya MAAUXa YJAa JKXYSWâ SCa =OOa YJAa [=WK=YKSQXa YJ=Ya S??ZWWA@a =Q@a ?SZQYa JS\a P=Qâ SCa YJAa OS=@Xa =WAa ISKQIa ZUa =Q@a @S\Q a !Ca. YJAWAa KXa PSWAa @S\Qa YJ=Qa ZUa KYa \KOOa YWâ YSa US\AWa SDa =a JSXYa =Q@a [K?Aa [AWX= a. 5 a R. ( #"C. 2()!%&,#7#.')%7. !QaYJKXaXA?YKSQa \Aa\KOOa@AX?WK>AaYJAaA]UAWKPAQY=OaUO=YCSWPa =Q@a PAYJS@SOSIâ ZXA@a YSa A[=OZ=YAa YJAa =OOS?=YKSQa =Q@a WA=O` OS?=YKSQa XYW=YAIKAXa =Q@a ?SPU=WAa YJAPa =I=KQXYa A=?Ja SYJAW a 7Aa J=[Aa @SQAa YJAa A]UAWKPAQYXa SQa =a /0a YAXY>A@a : ; a !Ya ?SPUWKXAXa =a XKQIOAa ?OSZ@a @AUOSÂ@a \KYJa )UAQ'A>ZO=a S[AWa #5&a SQa a !QYAOa K -a QS@AXa a ?SWAX a ,S\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa [=OZAXa =WAa WAYWKA[A@a CSWa A=?Ja XKQIOAa UWS?AXXSWa \KYJa=a,OSIIa\=YYPAYAWaYJZXaIK[KQIaZXaYJAa=>KOKYâYSaPSQKYSWa A=?Ja JSXYa K Aa =Qa Ka XAU=W=YAO^ a !Qa WAI=W@Xa YSa )UAQ'A>ZO=a 5&a KP=IAXa =WAa XYSWA@a KQa =a XJ=WA@a '0a XYSW=IAa =Q@a A=?Ja JSXYa J=Xa =a ?=U=?KYâ SCa a ,4a =Q@a a a SCa /& a.

(16)

(17) R.

(18) , ''#'37. =?Ja A]UAWKPAQYa KXa @SQAa S[AWa YJAa @KDAWAQYa X?JA@ZOKQIa =OISWKYJPX a1JAaFWXYaKXaYJAaSQAaYJ=YaKXa@AC=ZOYaKQa)UAQ'A>ZO=a %%+ 7 \KYJa YJAa XYWKUKQIa JAZWKXYK? a 1JKXa XAYYKQIa KXa XAYa >â @AC=ZOYa >A?=ZXAa KYa KXa YJAa SQAa YJ=Ya \KOOa IK[Aa YJAa >AXYa -S0a YSa YJAa 5&Xa =Xa KYa YWKAXa YSa =OOS?=YAa A=?Ja 5&a YSa YJAa JSXYa \JAWAa YJAWAa KXa YJAa PSXYa WAXSZW?AX a 1JAa 0),5,a X?JA@ZOAWa KXa @AX?WK>A@a KQa !5 a SWa A=?Ja =O` ISWKYJPa \Aa?SOOA?YaXA[AW=OaPAYWK?X a 1JAaUS\AWa?SQXZPUYKSQa =Xa A]UA?YA@a >ZYa =OXSa YJAa PKIW=YKSQXa QZP>AWa S[AWa YKPAa =Q@a FQ=OOâYJAaWAO=YK[Aa@ZW=YKSQaSCaYJAa5&X a1JAaWAO=YK[Aa@ZW=YKSQa KXa ?SPUZYA@a =Xa YJAa =?YZ=Oa @ZW=YKSQa CWSPa YJAa PSPAQYa YJAa 5&a KXa =?YZ=OOâ WZQQKQIa SQa YJAa ?OSZ@a @K[K@A@a >â YJAa YSY=Oa @ZW=YKSQa \JK?Ja KXa YJAa @ZW=YKSQa CWSPa YJAa XU=\Qa SCa YJAa 5&a ZQYKOa KYXa @AOAYKSQ a 7Aa W=Q@SPOâ IAQAW=YAa YJAa \SWMOS=@a S[AWa YKPAa SQa YJAa ?OSZ@a >â W=Q@SPOâ XU=\QKQIa 5&Xa YJ=Ya =WAa ,4a XYWAXXA@a CSWa YJAKWa WZQQKQIa @ZW=YKSQ a 1JAa W=Q@SPa IAQAW=YKSQa KXa @SQAa CSOOS\KQIa =a ,SKXXSQa UWS?AXXa \KYJa =a C [=OZAa Y=KOSWA@a YSa IAQAW=YAa =Qa =[AW=IAa OS=@a SQYSa YJAa ?OSZ@ a 1JAa PA=Qa OS=@a SCa YJAa ?OSZ@a @AUAQ@Xa SQa YJAa PA=Qa OS=@a IAQAW=YA@a >â A=?Ja 5& a 7Aa \KOOa IAQAW=YAa A=?Ja 5&a YSa Y=MAa >AY\AAQa ) =Q@a R ,4Xa CSOOS\KQIa =a ZQKCSWPa @KXYWK>ZYKSQ a =?Ja 5&a \KOOa O=XYa CSWa =a @ZW=YKSQa >AY\AAQa . a =Q@a . a XA?SQ@Xa ZQKCSWPOâ IAQAW=YA@a \JK?Ja KXa =Qa =[AW=IAa @ZW=YKSQaSCa . aXA?SQ@X a 7Aa \KOOa =OXSa IAQAW=YAa YJAa PAPSWâ WAVZKWAPAQYa CSWa A=?Ja 5&a YSa >Aa >AY\AAQa a &a =Q@a a & a =?Ja 5&a KXa @AXKIQA@a YSa WAUWAXAQYa SQa =[AW=IAa =WSZQ@a a SCa =a XKQIOAa JSXY a 7KYJaYJSXAa[=OZAXaKQaPKQ@a \Aa?=Qa?SPUZYAaYJAa CWAVZKWA@a CSWa YJAa,SKXXSQa UWS?AXXa YJ=Ya \KOOa IAQAW=YAa =a XUA?KF?a =[AW=IAa OS=@ a =?Ja 5&a KXa XZ>PKYYA@a YSa YJAa ?OSZ@a CSWa YJAa @ZW=YKSQa SCa YJAa A]UAWKPAQYa =Q@a YJAa X?JA@ZOAWXa YJ=Ya =WAa SQa =a UAWKS@K?a OSSUa SCa a XA?SQ@Xa \KOOa =OOS?=YAa =Q@a WA=OOS?=YAa YJAP a ]UAWKPAQYXa>AY\AAQa@KCCAWAQYaX?JA@ZOAWXa=WAa@SQAaZXKQIaYJAa X=PAaIAQAW=YA@a \SWMOS=@ a =?JaXAYa SCaXAYYKQIXa KXa ZXA@a SQa =Qa A]UAWKPAQYa YJ=Ya \KOOa O=XYa a JSZWX a 1J=Ya PA=QXa YJ=Ya \A[Aa @SQAa =a YSY=Oa SCa a @KDAWAQYa A]UAWKPAQYXa \JK?Ja WAUWAXAQYXa PSWAa YJ=Qa a JSZWX a )QAa XJSZO@a QSYAa JAWAa YJ=Ya =a OSYa SCa [=WK=>KOKYâ KQXK@Aa =a XKQIOAa WZQa ?=Qa S??ZW a !Q@AA@a YJAWAa =WAa XP=OOa [=WK=YKSQXa KQa YJAa SW@AWXa SCa =?YKSQXa YJ=Ya ?=Qa Y=MAa UO=?Aa \JAQa CSWa A]=PUOAa )UAQ'A>ZO=aKXa WAXUSQ@KQIa YSaWAVZAXYa SWaA[AQaYJAa [=WK=>KOKYâ KQa YJAa YKPAa YSa >SSYa =a 5&a SWa =a JSXYa =Q@a ^KAO@a YSa =a @KCCAWAQYa WAXZOY a R. '&0))&,7

(19) !*,!'&+7. 7Aa FWXYa XY=WYa \KYJa =Qa APUKWK?=Oa A]UAWKPAQYa YSa ?=OK>W=YAa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa PKIW=YKSQXa \Aa ?=Qa @Sa XKPZOY=QASZXOâ SQa YJAa YAXY>A@ a 1Sa @Sa XSa \Aa KQXY=QYK=YAa XA[AW=Oa 5&Xa A=?Ja \KYJa aSCaPAPSWâ YJAQa \Aa?JSSXAa=aF]A@aQZP>AWaSCa5&a=Q@a PKIW=YAaYS\=W@a=aW=Q@SPaJSXY a )>[KSZXOâ YJAaQAY\SWMaO=^SZYa =Q@a YJAa =UUOK?=YKSQa KQXK@Aa YJAa 5&a UO=^Xa =a >KIa U=WYa KQa YJAa WAXZOYa >ZYa \Aa QAA@a YSa MAAUa KQa PKQ@a YJ=Ya KYa KXa SQOâ YSa @AFQAa. YJAa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYXa YJ=Ya \Aa \KOOa ZQOS=@a KQa YJAa =OISWKYJP a 1JAa /0Xa JSXYXa =WAa =OOa ?SQQA?YA@a YSa =a a >UXa X\KY?J a 1JAa O=XYa U=WYa SCa YJAa @=Y=a YW=QXCAWa \JAQa YJAa 5&a KXa XYSUUA@a SQaYJAaXSZW?Aa JSXYa =Q@a YJAa ?SWAa SCa @KWYKA@a U=IAa KXa XAQYa YSa YJAa @AXYKQ=YKSQa JSXYa : ;a KXa @SQAa \KYJSZYa >=Q@\K@YJa OKPKY=YKSQ a 1JASWAYK?=OOâ KCa =OOa YJAa PAPSWâ SCa YJAa5&a KXa @KWYKA@a @ZWKQIa YJAa UWS?AXXa SCa XAQ@KQIa PAPSWâ U=IAXa PKIW=YKQIa =a XKQIOAa 5&a \SZO@a Y=MAa ZUa YSa a XA?SQ@X a Xa \Aa ?=Qa XAAa KQa 1=>OAa !a YJAa =[AW=IAa PKIW=YKSQa YKPAa SCa YJAa[KWYZ=OaP=?JKQAXaPKIW=YKQIa?SQ?ZWWAQYOâGSPaSQAaJSXYaYSa =QSYJAWa KXa KQ?WA=XKQIa =Xa YJAa QZP>AWa SCa PKIW=YKSQa KQ?WA=XAX a 1JKXa KXa USXXK>Oâ @ZAa YSa AKYJAWa YJAa XUAA@a SCa YJAa PAPSWâ SCa YJAa @AXYKQ=YKSQa JSXYa XSPAa ?SQYAQYKSQa KQa YJAa QAY\SWMa =Q@a YJAa YKPAa )UAQ'A>ZO=a Y=MAXa YSa UWS?AA@a \KYJa YJAa PKIW=YKSQX a OYJSZIJa YJAa QZP>AWXa YJAPXAO[AXa =WAa XUA?KF?a YSa YJAa UO=YCSWPa=Q@aA]UAWKPAQY=YKSQa KYaXYKOOaYAOOXaZXaYJ=Ya=Ya=a?AWY=KQa USKQYa ?SQ?ZWWAQYa PKIW=YKSQXa YAQ@a YSa >Aa QA=Wa =a YKPAa YJ=Ya KXa ZQ=??AUY=>OA a1JKXaYKPAaKXa@AFQA@a=W>KYW=WKOâ>âYJAaUWS[K@AW a !Qa SZWa UO=YCSWPa \KYJa YJKXa U=WYK?ZO=Wa XAYZUa =Q@a 5&a XK_Aa \Aa ?SQXK@AWa YJ=Ya a ?SQ?ZWWAQYa 5&a OK[Aa PKIW=YKSQXa YS\=W@a YJAa X=PAa JSXYa KXa YJAa P=]KPZPa \Aa =KPa YSa XAY a #*+5.C C 4%)R1-+R:%3#R,+7//+3R(%8R)%"/3%,+1R +C 620;*=287<C ?0C #26.C <C. 7 !%0#,7 &)37 '&+0%(,!'&7 !Qa YJKXa A]UAWKPAQYa \Aa J=[Aa WZQa YJAa \SWMOS=@a SCa 5&Xa SQa YJAa ?OSZ@a \KYJSZYa US\AWKQIa SQa =Q@a SCCa JSXYXa >ZYa \Aa J=[Aa ZXA@a YJAa XKPZO=YA@a US\AWa *"3 @AX?WK>A@a KQa XA?YKSQa !!! a Xa \Aa ?=Qa XAAa KQa KIZWAa a \JK?Ja UOSYXa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa SQa @KCCAWAQYa ?OSZ@a OS=@X a 7Aa?=Qa XAAa YJ=YaYJAWAa KXa =a XYA=@â KQ?WA=XAa SCa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa @ZAa YSa YJAa KQ?WA=XAa KQa OS=@a =Q@a YJ=Ya 0),5,a KXa PSWAa AQAWIâ AE?KAQYa >â >AY\AAQa a =Q@a a CSWa WAXUA?YK[AOâ OS\a =Q@a JKIJa OS=@X a .

(20) . . . . . . . 20>;.C R <>69=287C. . . . . . . . 8@.;C ,87<>69=287C ?<C "B<=.6C 8*-C <26>5*=.-C .7.;0BC ,87. S\A[AWa YJSXAa [=OZAXa =WAa PKYKI=YA@a \KYJa YJAa WAXZOYXa XJS\Qa KQa KIZWAa a \JK?Ja UOSYXa YJAa ACCA?YK[Aa @ZW=YKSQa SCa.

(21) YJAa 5&X a Xa A]UA?YA@a \KYJa =Qa KQ?WA=XAa KQa OS=@a \Aa XAAa =a @A?WA=XAa KQa =[AW=IAa 5&a @ZW=YKSQ a 1JKXa KXa @ZAa YSa YJAa XUKMAXa KQa OS=@a YJ=Ya WAQ@AWa YJAa KQKYK=Oa =OOS?=YKSQa J=W@AWa YSa =?JKA[A a 7Aa ?=Qa =OXSa XAAa YJ=Ya A[AQa KCa YJAa 0),5,a KXa >AYYAWa =Ya OS\a OS=@Xa YJAa @KCCAWAQ?Aa >AY\AAQa YJAa Y\Sa @A?WA=XAXa =Xa YJAa OS=@a KQ?WA=XAXa YSa >Aa A[AQa KQa WA[AWXAa WSOAXa =Ya JKIJa OS=@Xa >A?=ZXAa P=KQOâ 0),5,a @SAXa PSWAa WAVZAXYXa YSa )UAQ'A>ZO=a YJZXa XOS\KQIa =a >KYa YJAa @A?KXKSQa >â \=KYKQIa A=?Ja YKPAa CSWa YJAa WAXUSQXAX a 7Aa ?=Qa XAAa JS\A[AWa YJ=Ya YJAa @ZW=YKSQa KXa >AY\AAQa a =Q@a a SCa =[AW=IAa 5&a @ZW=YKSQa \JK?Ja KXa W=YJAWa OS\a YJZXa PA=QKQIa AQAWIâ X=[KQIXa ?=Qa >Aa =?JKA[A@a \KYJSZYa -S0a @AIW=@=YKSQa KCa JSXYa P=Q=IAPAQYa S[AWJA=@a KXa QAIOA?YA@ a. #*+5.C C $,13R*+")+3R23/3"%1R "=;*=.0BC 7.;0BC 4C

(22) >;*=287C R. ?SQXZPUYKSQa WA@Z?YKSQa S>XAW[A@a KQa YJAa XKPZO=YA@a US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa A]UAWKPAQYXa WAP=KQX a 1JKXa YKPAa YJAa S[AWJA=@a KQa>SYJaYKPAa=Q@aUS\AWa?SQXZPUYKSQa@ZAaYSaYJAaUS\AWKQIaSQa =Q@a SCCa SCa YJAaJSXYXa KXa QSYa KIQSWA@a =Q@a KYa ?=Qa >AaXKIQKF?=QYa =Xa XJS\Qa KQa :; a 7Aa \KOOa ?SQ@Z?Ya A]UAWKPAQYXa Y\K?Aa =Xa OSQIa =Xa KQa 5a \KYJa YJAa JSXYa P=Q=IAPAQYa XYW=YAIâ %#C UWAXAQYA@a >ACSWA a. .

(23) . . . PR R . . .C. . OR

(24) . 9C. . . . . . . . .

(25) .

(26) . . 20>;.C R %C->;*=287<C ?<C "B<=.6C8*-C <26>5*=.-C .7.;0BC ,87<>69=287C. . 20>;.C R 7.;0BC ,87<>69=287C ?<C "B<=.6C8*-C ;.*5C .7.;0BC ,87<>69=287C. 7 '+,7

(27) &%&,7,),37 !Qa YJKXa A]UAWKPAQYa \Aa =WAa YW^KQIa SZYa YJAa @KDAWAQYa YÛAXa SCa JSXYa P=Q=IAPAQYa XYW=YAIKAXa =Xa @AX?WK>A@a KQa !5a =Q@a YJAKWaADA?YaSQaYJAaAQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa=Q@a=[AW=IAaADA?YK[Aa @ZW=YKSQ a 1=>OAa !!a UWAXAQYXa YJAa WAXZOYXa SCa >SYJa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa \JAWAa OS\AWa KXa >AYYAWa =Q@a YJAa ACCA?YK[Aa @ZW=` YKSQa \JAWAa =a JKIJAWa [=OZAa KXa >AYYAW a 'T &a WAUWAXAQYXa YJAa >=XAOKQAa\JAQa\Aa=WAaQSYaX\KY?JKQIaSQa=Q@aSCCaYJAaJSXYX a1JAa ,"6+2"%a KXaXKPKO=WaYSaYJAa %#C XYW=YAIâ \KYJaYJAaQZP>AWa ?AKOA@a KQXYA=@a SCa WSZQ@A@ a 1JAa [=OZAXa =WAa CSWa =a ?OSZ@a \KYJa =Qa =[AW=IAa OS=@a SCa a =Q@a YJAa X=PAa 0),5,a =OISWKYJPa \JK?Ja=XaXAAQa>ACSWAa?SQXSOK@=YAXaACCA?YK[AO^ aXa \Aa?=QaXAAa KQa 1=>OAa !!a YJAa PSXYa ACF?KAQYa XYW=YAIâ KXa YJAa UK[SYa =Xa KYa KXa YJAaPSXYaY=KOSWA@aCSWaYJKXaA]UAWKPAQYaKQaU=WYK?ZO=Wa=Q@aWA=?YXa YJAa >AXYa YSa C=XYa =Q@a XOS\a OS=@a ?J=QIAX a 7Aa ?=Qa X=[Aa ZUa YSa a SCa US\AWa \JKOAa J=[KQIa =a @AIW=@=YKSQa SCa -S0a SCa SQOâ a 7Aa ?=Qa =OXSa XAAa YJ=Ya ?SPU=WA@a YSa YJAa "##)C =UUWS=?Ja \Aa I=KQa \KYJa %#C >SYJa KQa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa a =Q@a -S0a a 1JAa & #C XYW=YAIâ ^KAO@Xa >=@a WAXZOYXa XKQ?Aa CSWa YJKXa MKQ@a SCa ?OSZ@a OS=@a KYa \KOOa X\KY?Ja SQa =Q@a SCCa JSXYXa \JAQa YJAWAa =WAa =OWA=@â =a XZE?KAQYa QZP>AWa SCa JSXYa ZX=>OA a !R. #7 &)37 '&+0%(,!'&7. !Qa YJAa O=XYa A]UAWKPAQYXa \Aa J=[Aa KPUOAPAQYA@a WA=Oa US\` AWKQIa SQa =Q@a SCCa SCa YJAa JSXYXa YSa XAAa \JAYJAWa YJAa AQAWIâ.

(28) .

(29) . . 20>;.C R %C->;*=287<C ?<C "B<=.6C8*-C ;.*5C .7.;0BC ,87<>69=287C. Xa \Aa ?=Qa XAAa KQa KIZWAa a \JK?Ja WAUWAXAQYXa YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa CSWa OS=@Xa SCa a a =Q@a a YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPA@a KXa XYKOOa >AYYAWa ZXKQIa YJAa 0),5,a =OISWKYJP a S\` A[AWa CSWa OS=@Xa SCa a YJAa AQAWIâ ?SQXZPUYKSQa @KCCAWAQ?Aa >AY\AAQa YJAa Y\Sa =OISWKYJPXa KXa OAXXa YJ=Qa \J=Ya \=Xa =?JKA[A@a ZXKQIa YJAa XKPZO=YA@a US\AWa ?SQXZPUYKSQa \JK?Ja KXa >A?=ZXAa \JAQa YJAa PA=Qa OS=@a KXa =WSZQ@a YJKXa [=OZAa KYa SX?KOO=YAXa >AY\AAQa a =Q@a a \JK?Ja PA=QXa YJ=Ya XKQ?Aa \Aa J=[Aa SQOâ a JSXYXa KYa KXa @KE?ZOYa YSa ISa \KYJa =a OS=@a ZQ@AWa YJ=Qa a JSXYX a !Ya =OXSa PA=QXa YJ=Ya KQa UWSUSWYKSQa YJAa S[AWJA=@a CSWa X\KY?JKQIa SQa =Q@a SDa =Qa JSXYa \KOOa J=[Aa PSWAa KPU=?Y a.

(30) 7Aa?=Qa=OXSaXAAaYJ=YaCSWaJKIJAWaOS=@Xa \Aa?=QaXYKOOaX=[AaZUa aa AQAWIâCSWa=aOS=@aSCa a @ZAaYSaYJAaWA=XSQXaPAQYKSQA@a =>S[Aa>ZYa=OXSaYSa=aJKIJAWaXYW=KQaSQaYJAa?OSZ@aKYaKXaA[AQaPSWAa KPUSWY=QYa YSa US\AWa SQa =Q@a SDa JSXYX a KIZWAa a UWAXAQYXa YJAa ?SWWAXUSQ@KQIa =[AW=IAa ADA?YK[Aa @ZW=YKSQa SCa YJAa [KWYZ=Oa P=?JKQAX a 7Aa ?=Qa XAAa YJ=Ya \Aa ?=Qa P=KQY=KQa WSZIJOâ YJAa X=PAa =PSZQYa SCa -S0a =Xa PP<X?JA@a >ZYa YJ=Ya -S0a KXa @WSUUKQIa =Xa YJAa OS=@a KQ?WA=XAXa \JK?Ja KXa YSa >Aa A]UA?YA@ a 1JKXa @WSUa KXa @ZAa YSa @KCCAWAQYa WA=XSQX a SWa PP<X?JA@a KYXa P=KQOâ @ZAa YSa YJAa C=?Ya YJ=Ya SQa SQAa J=Q@a \Aa J=[Aa YJAa %#C \JK?Ja P=â >Aa XZKYA@a >A?=ZXAa KYa \KOOa Y=MAa =@[=QY=IAa =O\=^Xa SCa YJAa A]YW=a JSXYa KCa =Qâ >ZYa SQa YJAa SYJAWa J=Q@aYJAaIOS>=OaOS=@aSQaYJAaUS\AWA@aSQaJSXYXa\JK?JaKXaJKIJAWa KQ@Z?AXa YJAa =OISWKYJPa YSa C=KOa YSa FQ@a XZKY=>OAa JSXYXa CSWa5&Xa \JK?Ja OA=@XaYSaUAQ@KQIa5&Xa \=KYKQIaYSa>Aa=OOS?=YA@ a 1J=YXa =OXSaYJAaWA=XSQa \Jâ 0),5,aKXa>AYYAWa=YaJKIJaOS=@Xa >A?=ZXAa YJAWAa =WAa PSWAa 5&Xa =Q@a KYa >A?SPAXa KQ?WA=XKQIa PSWAa OKMAOâ YJ=Ya PP<X?JA@a \KOOa QSYa FQ@a XZKY=>OAa JSXY a )QAa XJSZO@a QSYAa JAWAa YJ=Ya A[AQa KCa =Qa ADA?YK[Aa @ZW=YKSQa =WSZQ@a a KQa=[AW=IAaXAAPXa>=@a KYaKXaP=KQOâ @ZAaYSaYJAa C=?YaYJ=Ya\KYJa5&a@ZW=YKSQa=WSZQ@a. aXA?SQ@Xa=aX?JA@ZOKQIa OSSUa SCa Xa Xa YSa US\AWa SQa =Qa JSXYa =Q@a >AY\AAQa Xa =Q@a a PKQZYAa CSWa )UAQ'A>ZO=a YSa =?MQS\OA@IAa YJAa JSXYa =Q@a =@@a KQa YSa YJAa JSXYa USSOa \Aa ?=Qa J=[Aa =a KPUSWY=QYa KPU=?Ya SCa YJAa \=KYKQIaYKPAaYJ=YaKXa@ZAaYSaYJAaA]UAWKPAQY=OaUO=YCSWPaXKQ?AaKYa WAUWAXAQYXa =a JKIJa USWYKSQa ?SPU=WA@a YSa YJAa =[AW=IAa @ZW=YKSQ a 0Z?Ja =Qa ADA?Ya \SZO@a >Aa IWA=YOâ PKYKI=YA@a KYa \Aa YSSMa 5&Xa \KYJa JKIJAWa PA=Qa @ZW=YKSQX a 5! a. $"C

(31) C $#$ C ' "C. !Qa YJKXa U=UAWa \Aa J=[Aa XYZ@KA@a YJAa WA=OOS?=YKSQa SCa 5&Xa KQa =a ?OSZ@a KQa SW@AWa YSa X=[Aa AQAWI^ a 7Aa J=[Aa ?SPU=WA@a YJAa =OISWKYJPa \Aa UWSUSXA@a 0),5,a YSa YJAa @AC=ZOYa =OISWKYJPa UWS[K@A@a KQa )UAQ'A>ZO= a 7Aa YSSMa KQYSa =??SZQYa XA[AW=Oa KPUSWY=QYaC=?YSWXaYSa=?JKA[Aa?SQXKXYAQYa?SQXSOK@=YKSQaXZ?Ja=Xa YJAaQZP>AWaSCaJSXYXaYSaZQOS=@a @KWA?YOâWAO=YA@aYSaYJAaQZP>AWa SCaPKIW=YKSQXa\Aa=KPaYSaP=MAa>ZYa=OXSaYJAaS[AWJA=@aKQ@Z?A@a >â YJAa US\AWKQIa SQa =Q@a SDa SCa YJAa JSXYXa \JK?Ja Y=MAXa YKPAa >â KYXAOCa KQa =a WA=Oa X^XYAP a 7Aa =KPa =Ya UZXJKQIa YJAa A[=OZ=YKSQa CZWYJAWa >â Y=?MOKQIa YJAa ?SPUZY=YKSQa YKPAa \JK?Ja KXa OS\a \KYJa YJAa 0),5,a >ZYa YJ=Ya \Aa ?SZO@a KQ?WA=XAa >â =@@KQIa XYAUXa KQa O=WIAWa KQXY=Q?AXa YSa KQ?WA=XAa YJAa VZ=OKYâ SCa YJAa WA?SQFIZW=YKSQa \JKOAa MAAUKQIa =a OS\a?SPUZY=YKSQaYKPA a S\A[AWa YJKXaPZXYa>Aa@SQAaSQa PZ?Ja O=WIAWa KQXY=Q?AXa YJZXa QAA@KQIa XKPZO=YKSQ a SWa YJKXa UZWUSXAa \Aa =KPa YSa ZXAa YJAa ?7)/&0: ;a XKPZO=YKSQa UO=YCSWPa YSa PS@AOa =Q@a XKPZO=YAa YJAaA]A?ZYKSQa=Ya =a O=WIAWa X?=OA a 1JAaJSXYa P=Q=IAPAQYa XYW=YAIKAXa =WAa =OXSa ?WKYK?=Oa =Q@a PZXYa X?=OAa =Q@a >AJ=[AaUWSUAWOâ\KYJaO=WIAWaKQXY=Q?AXa=Q@a\KOOaQAA@aWAFQKQI a KQ=OOâ \Aa J=[Aa YSa X\KY?Ja GSPa =WYKF?K=Oa \SWMOS=@Xa YSa WA=Oa \SWMOS=@Xa YSa >AYYAWa P=Y?Ja WA=Oa \SWO@a AQ[KWSQPAQYX a ! "C 6 7U & U + U !CH<LU 8H;U $ U. IJ8F8HU )ILM:IJRU 98L<;U FCO98FFIIHCHAU CHU 20#%%$+/)8@ 0'@ 9*%@ @ @ ? @ +/9%5!9+0/!-@ #0/'%2%/#%@ 0/@ %/;+20/.%/98@ L<K U 1U

(32) U. +29:!-@ %=%#:9+0/@. '<PU 4IKEU '4U /,U &U.

(33)

(34) U JJ U

(35) U 67U (J<HU H<9NF8U F<QC9FIKU<?:C<HMUG8H8A<G<HMUI>U;8M8U :<HM<KLU >IKU :FIN;U :IGJNMCHAU :9:2%@ %/&@ 0.1:9@ >89@ OIF U U HI U U JJ U U &8RU

(37) U 67U 5 U 3C8IU ;R ,IHAU 8H;U * U B<HU RH8GC:UK<LINK:<U8FFI:8MCIHU NLCHAU OCKMN8FU G8:BCH<LU >IKU :FIN;U :IGJNMCHAU <HOCKIHG<HMU !4--%-@ !/$@ +892+":9%$@ >89%.8@ @ 4/8!#9+0/8@ 0/@ OIF U U HI U U JJ U

(38) U #NH@ !/$@ #+%/#%@ -0:$0.@ @ @ 9*@ /9%5!9+0/!-@ 0/'%2%/#%@ 0/@ <:U

(40) U JJ U U 67U U. BKC9CU & U !8;DCU 8H;U U 5<ABF8:BIKU :FIN;U ;8M8U :<HM<KLU Q8:MU 8FFI:8MCIHU 8H;U GCAK8MCIHU 8FAIKCMBGLU CHU -:89%3@ -0:$@ !/$@ 2+$@ 0.1:9+/)@ 2+$@

(41) @

(42) 9*@ @ /9%5!9+0/!-@ >.108+:.@ 0/@ &8RU

(43) U JJ U U 67U , U-8E8B8LBCU U -8E<>NL8U & U ,BCA<HIU ! U '8E8;8U 6R $N;IBU 8H;U U 4ILBCLIKU FIP<KU JIP<KU :IHLNGJMCIHU CHU -0:$@ 0.1:9+/)@ %#*/0-0)>@ !/$@ #+%/#%@ -0:$0.@ @ @ 9*@ /9%5!9+0/!-@ 0/? '%2%/#%@ 0/@ <:U

(44) U JJ U U 67U % U %<>=OK@:C<HMU FIN;U 0:5!-@ 0'@ :1%2#0.1:9+/)@ OIF U U HI U U JJ U U &8K U

(45)

(46) U 67U (J<HU. H<9NF8U. &8M:BU. G8ECHAU. L:B<;NF<KU. BMMJ 8K:BCO<L IJ<HH<9NF8 IKA ;I:NG<HM8MCIHK< L:BAU #NH<U

(47) U 6

(48) 7U NR %<CH9<KA<KU. U $8KRJCLU 8H;U 9R $NG8KU &0FMC:8J8:CMRU. 9CHU J8:ECHAU 8FAIKCMBGLU PCMBU 8JJFC:8MCIHLU MIU DI9U L:B<;NFCHAU NH;<KU GNFMCJF<U :IHLMK8CHMLU CHU !4--%-@ 20#%88+/)@ @ 6#%%$+/)8@ @ /9%5!9+0/!-@ 0/'%2%/#%@ 0/@ U JJ U

(49) U 6 7U U IKA<MMIU & U &8NK<KU. U 8U ILM8U " U K8H;C:U 8H;U # T. & U )C<KLIHU H<KAR<?:C<HMU 8H;U ,%P8KU "88,U FIN;LU K<ANF8KU J8J<KU CHU @ /9%5!9+0/!-@ 0/'%2%/#%@ 0/@ /%2)>(#+%/9@ 0.1:9+/)@ !/$@ %9<02,+/)@ %/%2)>@ !$2+$@ @. &U %U.

(50) U 6 7U .BK ;IEN JBJC;K<:L><8MNK<LU #NH<U

(51) U 6 7U $OGU. FCO<U. GCAK8MCIHU. BMMJ PPP FCHNQ. EOG IKA J8A< &CAK8MCIHU #NHIKU LCGNF8MCIHU I>U <H<KARU <>@:C<H:RU CHU ;CLMKC9NM<;U :IGJNMCHAU CH>K8LMKN:MNK<L U +.:-!9+0/@ 0$%--+/)@ 4#9+#%@ !/$@ *%07@ OIF U U JJ U U

(53) U.

(54)