Méthode de gradients en optimisation combinatoire. Applications à un problème de sac à dos et au modèle d'Ising
49
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Me´thode de gradients en optimisation combinatoire. Applications a` un proble`me de sac a` dos et au mode`le d’Ising Ste´phane CRE´PEY. N˚ 2537 Avril 1995. PROGRAMME 1. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !"# $%'&(% *) !# + ,- . &(# % 0/21 ) .3 4 "&5/*%6 617 8 3.. :9<;""!
(6) =?>A@CBDEGFHJI%K L#M#NOQP RTSVUXWYS[ZY\]\^`_badcS[egfihkjl^!ejgmnS[^!oqpnZYS[Zsrkrutru^!o$vxwnZXoV^!o(yn^zyxUX{n{x|!^!o$vCSV|!o[^!ZYm~} ^jo<iojlt!\]^!oyihuojlS<huwxmn|!o RTSVU<^j( [ibc ZXpxpUYS<j(yn^`S[^!egfn^!S[egfn^Q{ YCaciS<hkrT_$XCa*CpnZYWY^!o. C! J{pnS[|!oV^!{Xjg^#yn^!ozfx^!mnS<huoj[huCmn^!op?UXmxSr¡ UYpij[hu\¢huo[Zsj[huUY{£e!UX\w~hu{nZjgUhuSV^z^!{¤ZYS<huZYwiru^!owihk¥ {nZshuS[^!o¦i§(^!ofx^!mnS<huoj[huCmn^!oo hu{no[p~huS[^!{YjTyn^byn^!o[e!^!{Yjl^!o yx^WXSVZXy~hu^!{XjgoynZY{nomn{%^!o[pxZXe!^(yn^!opnfnZYo[^!oSVZX{~¥ ynUY\%huoV|vne!UiUYS[yxUX{n{x|!^pnZYSe!UiUXSVynUY{n{n|!^¦i{ e!UX{xo<huynt!SV^zynUY{neru^pnS[UYwirut!\^y UYpij[hu\¢huo[Zsj[huUY{¨e!UY\]\^ mn{#<^!m©yn^!m~}`UXmn^!mxS[o$vsru^elfx^!S[egfn^!mnSe!UY{YjlSV^(ruZª%ZsjlmnSV^¦n{]UYwij[hu^!{Yj(mn{]ZsruWXUYS<hkjgfn\]^CmnZYynSVZjVhu~mx^ p?UXmxSru^ pnS[UYwirut!\^ynmJoVZXe© ynUYo$v ^l}~jgS[«!\]^!\^!{Yj^¬]e!ZYe!^^!{JpnSVZjVhuCmn^¦ ^]pirumnoUY{®¡UYmnS[{ihkj#mn{n^ hu{Yjl^!SVpnS[|jgZjVhuUX{pxS[UYwnZXw~hkrkhuo<jl^©#mn{ ZsruWXUYS<hkjgfn\]^(yn^R ¦i¯hk~hut!SV^p?UXmxSru^pxS[UYwirut!\]^(y <ohu{nW¨°k_! ±¡vnyxUX{Yj UY{^l}np~rkhu~mx^zZshu{no<h"r¡ ^¬]e!ZYehkjl|¦ ²´³xµA¶[·X¸¹JºUXpijVhu\%huoVZjVhuUX{^!{¨sZXShuZXwiru^!o(»s¥g_svGwnZYS<ie!^!{YjlS[^vXWXSVZXyihu^!{Yj!vnoVZXe©%ynUYo$vx\]Uiyntru^y? <o<hu{nWi¦. ¼k½¾À¿ÂÁuÃÀÄ$ÅÆÁÂÇÈAÁ¡ÉÂÊ PXËgÌÍnÎÐÏÆÑÎ Ò<ÓÍÕÔ Ö!ÎÍ. Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 93 65 77 77 – Te´le´copie : (33) 93 65 77 65.
(7) ! 8# % µ
(8) n·sµXJ^pxS[^!o[^!{YjWYS[ZYyihu^!{Yj[¥¹rkh^#fn^!mnShuo<jVhue!o(®¡UYSe!UX\w~hu{nZjgUXShuZr?»¥[_UXpijVhu\%h!Zsj[huUY{¦§(UY{no<huy~¥ ^!Shu{nW#jlfn^bUXpijVhu\%h!Zsj[huUY{%pnSVUXwiru^!\ ZXo(Z#j(U%piruZ!Y^!S[o(WYZX\^viS[^!oV^!ZXSVelfx^!SZXWYZshu{no<j ª%ZsjlmnSV^v( ^yn^!ShkX^ Z:pnfnZYo[^ o[pnZYe!^e!UX{xo<huo<jVhu{nW£Us®jlfx^Ð\¢h }x^!y o<jlSVZjg^!Whu^!o#Us®jgfihuo%WYZX\^¨ZsruUX{xW£hu{nyn^!p?^!{nynZY{Yje!UiUXSVyihk¥ {nZsjl^!oZA}x^!o$vGUY{fihuelf UY{n^`e!ZX{ yx^Õ {n^`WXSVZXyihu^!{Yjgo$¦(fihuo¯ru^!ZXynomxojlUZX{ ZsruWXUYS<hkjgfn\ ®¡UYS(jlfn^rkhu{n^!ZYS C{nZYpno[ZYe pnS[UYwiru^!\ÐvÕX^!S<^¬]ehu^!{Yjhu{nyn^!^!y?¦: ^jlfx^!{£WhkY^]Z pnSVUXwxZXwihkrkhuoj[hue#hu{Yjl^!SVpnS[^jgZjVhuUX{jgU¨R ¦ hkChut!SV^ oz°k_!s± ZruWYUXShkjlfn\ ®¡UYS(jlfx^CmnZYynS[Zsj[huewihu{nZYS<¨UYpijVhu\%h! Zsj[huUY{%pnS[UYwiru^!\¦ "¶"! ³#
(9) $ »s¥g_`UYpijVhu\%h! Zsj[huUY{vCwnZYS<ie!^!{YjlSV^viWYS[ZYyihu^!{Yj v%C {nZYpnoVZXe% pnSVUXwiru^!\vC <ohu{nW%\]Uiyx^r¡¦ 1!" !&0!.
(10)
(11) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! " +V <{zZy~huo[e!S[^jg^\ZX{ihk®¹Uruy?vjlfx^TpnShu{nehupiru^qUXS egfnZYS[ZYejl^!S?U®ihkjgo \]^jlShueS[^ruZsj[huUY{no?huoZsruS[^!ZYyi WshkX^!{hu{¢jlfn^({nUsj[huUY{U®Gjlfn^(\ZX{ihk®¹Uruy?v fn^!S[^!ZYo"hu{]Z`e!UX{YjVhu{~mxUXmno \]ZY{ihk®¡Usruy#jlfihuoq{nUsj[huUY{ fnZYo`jlU£w?^%®¹UXmn{xyº^ruoV^ fn^!S[^vÕh¡¦ ^¦qhkj%fnZXo#jgU e!UX\^%®¹S[UY\ UYmijgo<huyn^¦-,hkjgfn^!S$vjlfn^!SV^®¡UYS[^v jlfx^!S[^!ZsrkhkjÀ fihuelf mn{nyx^!S<rkhu^!o(o[pnZYe!^\mnojT®¹UXSV\Zy~huo[e!S[^jg^\]ZY{ihk®¹UruyvXUXS (^z\mnoj¯oV^!^ jlfx^ÐWYS[UYmn{ny U®`hkjlo\]^jlShueS[^ruZsj[huUY{no/.¡\]^!ZYo[mnSV^¥Æe!UY{nyihkjVhuUX{no0zUYmijgo<huyn^hkj!vhu{ wihu{xyihu{nW ®¡UYS[e!^!o f~huelf£ZYejmnp?UY{¨hkj!¦ 132 465 7 89;:<*=>8 & ?"@ A
(12) 9CBED 9 A
(13) ?%GFH
(14) I7&
(15) JK7G. A
(16) ? 2 L)NMGOPQ # D 4SR. . . . . . . . . ;"] q¨ 1 &( %. {pnS[|!oV^!{Xjg^mn{n^\]|jlfxUiyn^(pUYmnSqruZ%S[|!oVUrumijVhuUX{ZXpxpnS[Uiegfn|!^yn^pnS[UYwirut!\]^!oqy UYpij[hu\¢huo[Zsj[huUY{]e!UY\wihk¥ {nZsjlUshuS[^yn^ruZ®¡UYS[\^ TVXZ U W Y\[]_^`[ o$¦ e¦Ja []b^dcfeg^ h Ui yn|!ohuWX{n^`mn{Y^!ejl^!mnS^!{ZYS<huZYwiru^!ow~hu{nZhuSV^!o$¦x Àro$ GZYWhkjyn^#pnS[UYwirut!\]^!o(y ZsrkruUie!Zsj[huUY{ÐUYpijVhu\]Zsru^ jg^ruo] ~m? UX{ ^!{S[^!{xe!UX{YjlSV^®¡SV|!Cmn^!\]\^!{Xj(^!{ 8?!!& yn^j jXegfn^!o(^!{ S[^!egfn^!SVelfn^bUXp?|!S[Zsj[huUY{i¥ {n^rkru^vqr¡ ZYo[ohuWX{xZjVhuUX{ y mx{n^ ZXShuZXw~ru^ЩlkJUYm ©nmÐe!UYS[S[^!oVpUY{nynZY{Yjz©r¡ ZXwxo[^!{ne!^ UXm ©ruZ:pnS[|!oV^!{ne!^ y mx{n^zZYS[«jg^^!{YjlSV^yn^!m~}]o[UY\]\]^jgoy mx{ÐWYS[ZYpnfn^o~^!{ "* 7 v?ru^!o(ZYS<huZYwiru^!o(wihu{nZshuS[^!o(\]Uiyn|rkhuoVZX{Yj ruZ e!UXm~ru^!mnS(wiruZX{xelfn^#UYm{nUhuSV^#y mn{ pih }x^r yn^`r¡ |!e!S[ZY{ .¹XUshuS ° Y ±"0 oGUXm ^!{)p !8 & v"pUYmnSr¡ "|ruZYwUYS[Zs¥ jVhuUX{yn^!o p?UYS<jl^®¹^!mihkrkru^!o Õ{nZY{nehu^!S[o_.¹YUhuS(° ±"0g¦^(pirumno jgUXmijpxS[UYwirut!\]^y? UXpijVhu\%huoVZjVhuUX{`e!UX\w~hu{nZjgUhuSV^ p?^!mijToV^S[^®¹UXSV\miru^!S^!{¢ZYS<huZYwiru^!oTw~hu{nZhuSV^!o$vCCmihkjVjl^©ZYmnWY\]^!{Yjl^!S"ru^{nUY\wnS[^yn^¯ZXShuZXw~ru^!o$¦i§(UY\]\^ ru^!o\|jlfnUiyx^!oTWY|!{n|!S[Zsru^!o(^!{ e!^#ynUX\Zhu{x^e!UY{no<huojl^!{Yj(ruZXSVWX^!\^!{Xj^!{ruZ¢®¡UYS[\]Zsrkhuo[Zsj[huUY{ yn^#pnS[Uie!|!yn|!o mijVhkrkhuo[|!op?UYmnSS[|!oVUXmnyxS[^jg^r UYmjl^r e!ZYopnZYS<j[hue!m~rkhu^!S$vxUX{ oV^SV|®¡t!SV^ynZY{no(ruZ o[mihkjg^z©yn^!m~}ÐpnS[UYwirut!\]^!o qR¥Âe!UX\piru^jlo(wihu^!{¤e!UX{n{Cmnor. XUshuS¢° ss±"0 tGru^ u(*Av w!x y*" v UXm \¢hu{ihu\%huoVZjVhuUX{y mx{n^`®¡UYS[\]^`CmnZs¥ ynSVZjVhuCmn^]^!{:ZYS<huZYwiru^!owihu{nZshuS[^!ov^jru^ u(*Av l8z{%&}|~% vqUXm \%hu{~hu\%huo[Zsj[huUY{:y mn{n^®¡UYS[\^ rkhu{n|!ZshuS[^bo[UYmnoe!UY{YjlS[Zshu{Yjl^rkhu{n|!ZshuS[^^!{ZXShuZXw~ru^!oTwihu{xZhuSV^!o$¦C§(^!opnS[UYwirut!\]^!o ZYpnpnZYS[Zshuo[oV^!{Yje!UX\\]^qru^!o ZY{nZsruUXWYmn^!o^!{]ZYS<huZYwiru^!owihu{xZhuSV^!o¯yx^!o¯pxS[UYWXSVZX\\]Zsj<huUX{xo rkhu{n|!ZshuS[^!o(^j~mxZXynSVZjVhuCmn^!oTyx^r¡ UYpij[hu\¢huo[Zs¥ jVhuUX{e!UX{YX^l}x^¦ ^!mnS|jgmnyn^%p?^!S[\^jynUX{xe%y ZYpnpnS[|!fx^!{nyn^!S(ru^!o#yihk¬]e!mirkjg|!oCmn^o[UYmirutX^ru^pnZYo[o[ZYWY^ yn^#sZXShuZXwiru^!oe!UX{YjVhu{~mx^!o^!{ ZYS<huZYwiru^!ow~hu{nZhuSV^!o$v?ynZY{noyn^!m~}¤e!ZXoyn^ ÕWYmnS[^#e!UY{YjlS[ZYo<jg|!o$vxpnmihuoV~mx^#ruZ yihk¬e!mirkjl|ynm¨pxS[UYwirut!\]^(rkhu{n|!ZshuS[^bj[hu^!{YjynZY{noToVZe!UX{YjgS[Zshu{Xjg^vYruZ®¹UXSV\]^CmnZYynS[Zsj[huCmn^SV^!pnS[|!oV^!{YjlZY{Xjq© ^rkru^#o[^!m~ru^mn{n^`yihk¬]e!m~rkjl|hu\pUYS<jgZX{Yjg^¦. . . , {]pnSVZjVhuCmn^vYUX{o$ hu{Yjl|!SV^!o[oV^o[UYmiX^!{YjTZYm~}p?UrkhkjVhuCmn^!oTUYm]ZsrkruUie!Zsj[huUY{noUYpij[hu\Zru^!ovYpirumno^!{ne!UXSV^(~m? © ruZ Zsru^!mnSe!UYS[SV^!o[p?UX{xynZX{Yjg^ynm£pnSVU xj ¦G^%p~rumnor¡ UYwijl^!{YjVhuUX{ y mx{n^ZrkruUie!Zsj[huUY{ CmnZYo<hk¥ÂUXpijVhu\]Zsru^#^!o<j |!WYZru^!\^!{Yjhu{Yjg|!S[^!o[oVZX{Yjg^¦,{ Õ{:r¡ UXw~jl^!{Yj[huUY{ y mn{ X^!ejg^!mnS#Cmih\%hu{ihu\¢huo[^ZXwnoVUrumx\]^!{Yj ^!o<j]^!{ Y. %. H* QL. .
(17) !4 = 9 D . WY|!{n|!S[Zsrmn{ UYwi<^!ej[hk®jlSVUXpyihk¬]ehkru^ ©£Zsj[jl^hu{xynS[^v?ru^pnS[UYwirut!\^%|jlZY{YjCqR¥Âe!UX\piru^j. XUshuS¨° s±"0g¦{ o hu{Xjg|!S[^!oVo[^ynUX{xe¯yxZX{no e!^TjgS[Z!sZhkri©`yn^!ofn^!mnShuo<jVhu~mx^!o e!UX{nyxmihuo[ZY{Yj ©`yn^!oZsruWYUXShkjlfn\^!o Cmihne!Zsrue!miru^!{Yj v ZYm]pnSh } y mn{x^e!UX\piru^l}~hkjl|$+gS[Zshuo[UY{n{nZYwiru^L1V.¡wUYS[{x|!^¯pxZXSmn{ pUsrki{ X\^(yn^®¡Zshuwiru^yn^!WXSV|^!{%ruZ#jgZhkrkru^ ynmpnS[UYwirut!\^0lvGmn{£Y^!ejl^!mnS+go[mi¬]oVZX\\]^!{YjpnSVUielfn^L1yn^%e!^%\¢hu{ihu\mn\¦? ^X^!ejg^!mnSUYwijl^!{Cm£p?^!mij ^!{noVmihkjl^(«jgS[^mij[hkrkhuoV|e!UX\\]^ZXpnpxS[U$}~hu\]Zsj[huUY{`ynm%\%hu{~hu\mn\´S[^!egfn^!S[egfn|v UXm¢e!UX\\]^p?Ushu{Xjqyn^yn|!pnZYS<j p?UXmxS¯y? ZXmijgS[^!o(pnSVUie!|!ynmnS[^!o y UXp~j[hu\%huoVZjVhuUX{?¦. %. qUjgS[^huyx|!^TyihuSV^!ejlShue!^^!o<j yn^(SVZhuoVUX{n{x^!SojlZsj[huo<jVhuCmn^!\]^!{Yj"o[mnS"ru^(WYS[ZY{nyz{xUX\wnSV^yn^!o e!UY{ ÕWYmnSVZjVhuUX{nov oVUXmnSVe!^zyx^zruZ yihk¬]e!m~rkjl|#ynm£pnSVUXw~rut!\]^yx^\¢hu{ihu\%huoVZjVhuUX{ ( 6zu v"Z Õ{ y UYwijl^!{ihuSbS[ZYpihuyn^!\]^!{Yjmn{n^ w?UX{\¢hu{ihu\mn\ L&
(18) ¦ qjlZY{YjynUX{x{n|!^mn{x^®¹UX{nejVhuUX{ ^!{ ZYS<huZYwiru^!o(wihu{nZshuS[^!o ©%\¢hu{ihu\%huoV^!S$viUY{ hu{YjlSVUiynmihkj`ynUX{xezru^!o`\]U$X^!{n{n^!opUY{nyn|!SV|!^!oyn^ vxmx^e!UX\\]^`mn{n^®¹UX{nejVhuUX{x{n^rkY ru^#o[mnSbru^!ozegfnZY\]pno Y UYm®¡ZYe!^hu{nyn|!p?^!{nynZY{YjlooVmihkZY{Yjru^!oe!UiUYS[yxUX{n{x|!^!o w?^!S[{nUYmihkrkrkhu^!{no`yn^pnZXSVZX\tjlSV ^ .¹j[huSVZXWY^!o©¤pihkru^¨ ynm Y^!ejl^!mnS 0g¦{UXw~j[hu^!{Yjmn{pUsrki{ X\^\mirkjVhkrkhu{n|!ZhuSV ^
(19) vGZXpnp?^ru| 9 7 "7 yn^ vGZ!XZY{Yjyn^!o ] Y hu{ihu\mn\ ruUie!Zr?y
(20) Y o[mnSr¡ ^!oVpnZXe!^ pnSVUXpxS<hu|jl|!o^l}~jlSV|!\]Zsru^!oZY{nZruUYWYmn^!o©%e!^rkru^!o(yn^ txZhu{xo<h?jlUYmij¯\¢ yn^!oqpnfnZYo[^!o %vY\mn{~hnyn^o[ZjlUYpUsruUYWhu^ & z?(* zu Y vC^!o<jV¥¡hkrnZsj[jg^hu{Xjq^!{%mn{%p?Uhu{Yj©`e!UiUYYS[ynUY{n{n|!^!o?»zUYm _g.¹jgfn|!UYS[t!\]^(C¦u_A0l¦C Z#eru^®"yn^e!^jgfn|!UYS[t!\]^^!o<jqr¡ fnZYS[\]UY{ihuehkjg|y
(21) ¦n{]yn| Õ{~hkj¯ZsruUXSVoTyx^!oyn^!o¥ e!^!{Yjl^!oqyn^!oWYS[ZYyihu^!{Yjlo y
(22) ynZY{nor¡ ^!oVpnZXe!^yx^!opnfnZYo[^!ovsru^ruUY{nWzyx^!o[CY mn^rkru^!o
(23) ^!ojTyn|!e!SVUhuoVo[ZY{Xjg^ .¡pnS[UYpUYo<hkjVhuUX{i¦u_$»I0g¦ {x^®¡UYYS[\miru^byn^mxo[o[UG. XUshuS`°k_ !±"0(p?^!S[\^jy ^!oj[hu\]^!Sqyn^!oY WXSVZXyihu^!{Yjgo$vC^j(y ^!{ yn|!yxmihuS[^yn^!oZruWYUYS<hkjlfx\]^!oZYpnpnS[Uiegfn|!op?UYmnSe!^!S<jgZhu{xopnS[UYwirut!\^!or.ÂpnSVUXp?UXohkj[huUY{ x¦u_%0l¦"{ pxS[|!o[^!{Yjg^ ^!{noVmihkjl^#mn{¤ZruWYUXShkjlfn\^zCmnZYynSVZjVhu~mx^z^!{£^!oVpnZYe!^z^jrkhu{n|!ZhuSV^^!{ jl^!\pnop?UXmnS¯ru^pnS[UYwirut!\]^`ynm£oVZXe © ynUYo$v ^l}~jlSV«!\]^!\]^!{sj^¬]e!ZYe!^^!{:pnS[Zsj[huCmn^3.¡o[^!ejVhuUX{x¦ 0l¦-,T{ G{ UY{ ®¹UXmnSV{ihkj#mn{n^%hu{Yjg^!S[pnSV|jlZsj[huUY{ pnSVUXwxZXwihkrkhuojl^#©mn{ ZsruWYUXShkjlfn\^zyn^R ¦ ¯hk~hut!SV^pUYmnSbru^%pnS[UYwirut!\^zy <ohu{nW °k_!s±¡v yxUX{YjzUY{£^l}xpirkhuCmn^ Zshu{no<h"r¡ ^¬]e!ZYehkjl|$.¹YUhuSoV^!ej[huUY{¨i¦ I0g¦. . . %. Uhueh(ru^!opnShu{nehupnZsru^!o{xUjgZjVhuUX{no`^!\]p~ruU!X|!^!o#ynZY{no#ruZ£oVmihkjl^¦ ^!o<j#ruZS[^!pnSV|!o[^!{YjlZsj[huUY{£wihu{nZshuS[^ ] ^ [ yn^#r¡ ^!{YjVhu^!S v r¡ ^!{no[^!\wiru^#yn^!oS[^!pnSV|!o[^!{YjlZsj[huUY{no(wihu{nZshuS[^!oby ^!{Yj[hu^!S[o¦ !#" ^!ojr¡ ^!{noV^!\wiru^yn^!o p?Uhu{Yjgoyn ^ Cmih{ ZYpnpnZYS<jVhu^!{n{n^!{Yj¯pxZXo$ © " .¹ru^`e!UY\]piru|!\^!{XjgZhuSV^yn ^ "ynZY{no% %vGo<h"'&( $0l¦){n^ pnZYS<jVhkj[huUY{#y mn{^!{noV^!\wiru^ Q^!ojmn{n^q®¡ZY\%hkrkru^(yn^(pnZYS<jVhu^!o{nUY{zChuyn^!oqyn ^ %vYZXpnp?^ru|!o"jl^!SV\]^!ov®¡UYS[\ZX{Yj mn{SV^!\]pirkhuoVo[ZYWX^o[ZY{no(S[^!e!UYmiiS[^!\]^!{Yj{ih"ruZXe!mn{x^yn ^ %¦"C+h * ^!o<jmn{n^`pnZYS<j[hkjVhuUX{ yn ^ %vÕ^,j "-&. %v ZsruUXSVo * /10 " ^!o<jmn{n^(pnZYS<jVhkj[huUY{v!y~hkjl ^ *¥¹hu{nynmihkjg^vAyx^ "%¦s ZpnZYS<jVhkj[huUY{zhu{xynmihkjl^ /B CD?E ^!oj¢y~hkjl^]pxS[UY3[pn25S[^%4 oh¯7^^69rkru8^:<;> o[^=?8Ae!UX@ \pUYo[^yn^pnZYS<j[hu^!o`ynF ^ *v o[UshkH j G * "M0ONQP &R" 2JI [ 2LK 2 ^ruZsj[hkY^!\]^!{Yj©`mn{]\¢hu{ihu\mn\vUY{%mijVhkrkhuo[^ru^!o jl^!SV\]^!oyn^ AL&8 ^j A(8 pUYmnSmn{x^(®¡UY{nej[huUY{yn| Õ{ihu7^ ^ S oVmnSmn{ e!UY{Yj[hu{Cmnmn\vnyn^ A " M ^j ( %86z o<hu{xUX{¦u,{ Õ{ynZY{nomn{ ^!oVpnZYe!^Zs¬]{nH ^ T UX{ {nUsjl^`^!{Y [ UG^ . %. . ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(24)
(25) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! " r¡ ^!{YX^ruUYpnp?^ze!UY{YX^l}x^`y mn{n^pnZXSj[hu^ yn^ ¦. vG^jo[Cmn^r &. U. T. ru^zoV~mx^ru^j[jl^v~UXm ^!{noV^!\wiru^yn^!o(oVUX\\]^jlo. [3UG^. U. . . % q % . . ZX{noe!^j[jg^(o[^!ej[huUY{UY{]piruUY{nWY^(ru^pnS[UYwirut!\^¯e!UY\wihu{nZsjlUshuS[^ynZY{nomx{]pnSVUXwirut!\^Te!UY{Yj[hu{Cm]^!{¢yn| Õ{ihuo¥ oVZX{Yj vx©]pxZXSj[huS(yn^!oZsrkruUie!ZjVhuUX{no uz; ^!{ ZYS<huZYwiru^!o(wihu{nZshuS[^!ovnyn^!oZsrkruUie!Zsj[huUY{no $ 7 vGe!UY{no<jVhkjlmn|!^!o yn^bruUjg^!S<hu^!o hu{nyn|!p?^!{nynZY{Xjg^!oo[mxSru^!o(e!UiUYS[ynUY{n{n|!^!o ynmX^!ejg^!mnS ¦ {]jg^rÕpiruUY{nWX^!\^!{YjT^!o<j(eruZYo[o<huCmn^ ^!{#jgfn|!UXShu^Tyx^!oÕ<^!m~}?¦Y^(®¡ZshkjjlUYmijl^UYpij[hu\¢huo[Zsj[huUY{zp?^!mij«jlSV^imn] ^e!UY\]\^mn{^!m©yn^!mC}UXmx^!mnS[ov!ru^ egfn^!S[egfn^!mnSe!UY{XjgS[^ruZª%ZsjlmnSV^vnZ!Y^!ezp?UYmnS®¹UX{xej[huUY{]yn^`p^!Sjl^ . XUshuSz°k_vxelf?¦ A±"0g¦ÕimxpnpUYo[UY{noq~mx^ru^ egfn^!S[egfn^!mnSegfnUhuohkjo[Zo<jgS[Zsjl|!Wshu^yn^®¹Z bZru|!ZsjlUshuS[^vCUYm \%h }~jl^v~Z!Y X^!e`mn{n^y~huo<jlShuwnmijVhuUX { ¦G{ UYwij[hu^!{Yj Zshu{no<h(mn{{nUXm~X^!ZYmÐ^!mv pnZYS`\]U!Y^!{n{ihuo[Zsj[huUY{ UYm SVZX{xynUX\¢huo[Zsj[huUY{£ynm <^!m:pnmnS`hu{ihkj[huZsr¡v ynZX{xoru^!Cmn^r e!^rumihk¥ÂehÕ^!ojTpiruUY{nWY|tCUX{¢UXwijVhu^!{YjT©#{nUYmiX^!ZYmru^^!mhu{ihkj[huZsr^!{¢e!UX{nohuyn|!S[ZY{Yjo[^!m~ru^!\]^!{Yjru^!oo<jlSVZjg|!Whu^!o pnmxS[^!o(ynmelfx^!S[egfn^!mnS$¦ . . .
(26) . %. Z {n|!e!^!oVo<hkjg|yn^]SVZhuoVUX{n{x^!So[mxSyx^!ozoVmihkjl^!ohu{ Õ{ihu^!o#yn^e!mnw?^!o^!\w?Uhkjg|!oV.¹YUhuSoV^!ej[huUY{£i¦ 0`{nUYmno e!UY{nynmihkjZYm~}yx| Õ{ihkj[huUY{no(o[m~hkZX{Yjg^!o$¦. .
(27) .
(28) . µ ¹³ #³ Õ ~µ ¡³ ·Y C (·Y C ~ 9 #A & p z; "78 : z? Qz; \ u zuC9z;"A$ k Q \ m : zw % 7 # *( "!"V x "7 4
(29) D 9 & z?( N] S 4 & z?( %: 7z? gQz; ) k : m : Q P k m NN 4 k m P: 8 . h h A$ g k |E 9Q #"V!x z;~& Q 78#@ 4. . 9. !#" $" %!'&)(+*-,/.. ;:=<. 9. 0! 1. $" 0!. 3254 6. 32. >)?. A@ CB. @ IB. . 37'8. A@ 3B. A@. <. DB. FE. HG ?. ^!{noV^!\wiru^ yn^!o"e!mnw?^!oÕ^!oj {nUsjl| ¦{`yn| Õ{ihkj"|!WXZsru^!\]^!{YjGr¡ mn{ihuUY{zyn^!o"e!mnw?^!o $0 & k m ¦ : RZYS"^!o[pnZYe!^yn^!o"pnfxZXoV^!o %vsUX{`^!{Yjl^!{nyyn|!o[UYS[\Zhuoxhu{nyih ?|!S[^!\]\^!{Yjmn{`e!mnw?^ vAUYmr¡ mn{ihuUY{yx^!o e!mxwh !^ o ¦Õ^z\«!\]^ 6yn|!ohuWX{n^mn{fYxp?^!S[e!mxw^ vGUYm¨r¡ mx{ihuUX{ yx^!o¯fYip?^!S[e!mnw?^!o ¦ KJ. L. VU. $
(30). ML. ST. >. ONP. E. HGSR. Q. >. :. { 9 "A µ ¹³ # & z?(r 8 9z;!ML$"# g_ 98# Ag NS 4 & z?( %: x " 7 &Q "78~ & z?( &8 7 ! 78zV& 9" A SN 4 &V& z?( 4 Qz 9Q !x z;) 9" :_*z 0 k m I [ ^ I I h S 8# ;*{ : 8# 0 => Qz Qz 98* SN 4 8#I ;Q78 w[ ^ : Qz [ [0 ^7^ S
(31) *z SN 4 " 0 4
(32) " : [ ^ [ ^ [ ^ [ ^ :. . !#" $" %!'&)(W&X,/.. !#1 !. M7O8. 9. Y)Z[ \. ^<. <. ]?. @. 9. ]?. %c. G. E B. 9. `_ba. d<. 9. H* QL. D?. eN. <. gfihMj. ?.
(33) !4 = 9 D ^`e!mnw?^^!{nWY^!{nynS[|bpnZXS(ru^!op?Ushu{Xjgo ^!o<j{nUsjl| ¦ qUXo#S[|!oVmirkjlZsjlo#o |!{nUX{xe!^!{Xj#{nZsjlmnSV^rkru^!h\]Ih^!{Yjz \U!X^!{x{nZX{Yj`r¡[ hu{YhjlIS[hUiyx%mnh ej[^ huUY{Jy? mn{n^%jgUXp?UsruUXWshu^%yihkjg^ & z. (* zu o[mnSr¡ ^!oVpnZYe!^¨yn^!opxfnZXoV^!o .¹YUhuSjgfn|!UYS[t!\]^%C¦u_ 0gvUYwijg^!{~mx^]© pxZXSj[huSyn^!o#jgUXp?UruUYWshu^!o^!mxerkhk¥ yihu^!{x{n^!o(o[mnS(ru^!oe!mnw?^!o(yn^ruZ¢®¡Z !UX{ o[m~hkZX{Yjg^¦ >. . . 9Q #"rr 7 98A C zu& 6 ?! "!z;7 7*z; A µ ¹³
(34) (³ ³Õ¸¹³ ·Y " & z?( 9gA 7 9A E Lz;7 b*z; : 8 p 97. Sx9"u z;V!x z;~& z?( : zy :>Q _% M "7v : zw ;C zu& 6 4 98z; z;~& z?(C!G 98 &Q "zu : Sx ;[ % ^ )(*AG\MQ& . !#" $" %!'&)( X,. M6. %10". ". M7. R. >. >. 9. 0>. 9. & 8# 0 " 0 m 3[ ^ I [ ^ [ ^ h Q >AV*z;#ML&:P8z}z;?78 >ML& : 0 0' 0' 4 &% L ! 98!&Q #zu : [ ^ S U [ ^ " : $ ! # A 7 9A & z?(* zuE*z; : !E 98gAV 7 98A zu& 6787 ?!$*z;EA)& z?()( &( 4 >. @ >. >. J. U. >. >. 9. >. >. DB. a. P. >. P. >. >. >. i Ushkj mx{ÐfYip?^!S[e!mnw?^r.ÂSV^!o[p¦Xr¡ mn{ihuUY{ WX|!{n|!SVZrkhuoV|!^yn^!o(fYip^!SVe!mnw^!o 0lvA ru^e!mxw^Z$XZY{Xjbru^!o\]«!\]^!o oV^!ej[huUY{no k Yv m bCmn^ .¡S[^!o[p?¦sr¡ mn{ihuUY{]WY|!{n|!S[Zsrkhuo[|!^(yn^!oqe!mnw^!o 0l¦s Z`jlUYpUsruUYWhu^(e!mnwihuCmn^oVmnS ´^!o<j {nUsjl|!^ ¦"R UXmnS oVmnpnp v?UX{£{xUjg^ +* ,% .ÂSV^!o[p¦A +* -.% 0ruZo[m~hkjl^#UXw~jl^!{Cmn^#©¨pxZXSj[huSyn^,:^!{ I ^ {i¥¹hut!\]^e!UiUX# SVynUY{n{n|!^¦ # egfnZY{nWX^!ZY{Yj¯^!{wk3.¡S[^!oVp¦ ^!{lm%0[ ruZ% VU. @ CB. @ 3B. VU. c. C /. 3. "](.
(35) ³Õ ~ $ ~C· C. c. 10 , 2. &)(. 6. $4. M!#1. 37O8. 8;gSx N 9&G54 ! Lz;7 6 :. . R. 8 zu [ ^ S [ ^ :9 G& z?( !r 98Vz;{ ;% )(*A3 9"u p 9 9"u NN 4 G& z?( /L z; & z?(: AP u6z 9Q #7 - & z?()& 7 ! 78zC& 98# A NS 4 &V& z?( 4 *z #!8z;A u _z;wz 9G!x &Q # 9 V #;7MQ8 "78; <; m% #A zu [ ^ I. #8IQ " 88V"=8886z? #>88@? A Qz; : 9 rz 9G &
(36) 98[ ^ }4 7. U. 0. U. 0. <. "+" (. <. "+" "](. 0c. ]?. 0c. U. {{nUjg^. D.
(37) C . . [>Buh ^. ; B. ]?. U. r ZYej[huUY{¨ynmWYS[UYmnp?^yn^!o|!egfnZX{xWX^!o A [o mnS(r¡ ^!oVpnZYe!^yn^!o(pnfnZYo[^!o¦ncbhu{no<h 7 % m o<h 0 m 0 B {nUX{ o u h C[ B ^ S . c. J. c. c. %c. FE. " Zshuo[o[|ZXm ru^!ejg^!mnS G Ë HJILKJM N Ë. "](. ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(38)
(39) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! ". . . iUhu^!{Yjmx{n^®¹ZX\¢hkrkru^ Õ{~hu^zyn^`p?Uhu{Yjlo(yn^ %v 0 ru^#e!mnw?^^!{nWY^!{nynS[|bpnZXS%¦xcruUYS[o [ ^ : 7 k m ºo h k m UXm k m m k $0 h I I h $0 [ k hm ^I o<hu{nUY{[ h ^ I [ h ^ h%[ h ^ S I h {£Z]yxUX{ne#wihu^!{ ¦?^p~rumno$v?o h ^!ojmn{n^`®¡ZY\%hkrkru^ Õ{~hu^yx^e!mxw^!ov ^!ojru^e!mnw?^z^!{nWY^!{nynSV| pnZYS(ruZ®¹ZX\¢hkrkru^. Õ{ihu^I 0yn^!oo[UY\]\^jloqyn^!o(e!mnw^!o(yn. ^ %¦ ( ^!o#|!egfnZX{xWX^!o#y mn{x^¨e!UiUYS[ynUY{n{n|!^#|jgZX{Yjhu{YXUsrumij[hk®¹o%^!{nWY^!{nynSV^!{Xj#yn^!o#WYS[UYmnp^!o`hu{YXUsrumijVhk®¡o%pnZYS - 0 e!UY\]p?UXohkj[huUY{¦?iUshu^!{Xj - A v
(40) '0 Yv ruZe!UY\]p?UXoV|!^zyn^!o`|!egfnZX{xWX^!o [ ] u h ] ^ > I I ] <; m > jg^ruoTCmn^
(41) ¦n{]Z -,0 ¦~^pirumnopnZXS] yn| Õ{~hkB j[huUY {
(42) & o[mxpnp - & [ ^ I B ] ] [ 7 [ ] h] ^^ ? A vGe!^`~m~h \UX{YjgS[^ruZjgS[ZY{no<hkjVhkChkjl|yx^r¡ ZYej[huUY{yn^ ? A oVmnS ¨¦ oVmnpnp vnynUY{ne [ ^ B I "+" (. >. E. c. >. HG. 0c. . "+" "](. @. c.
(43) . B. >. c. 0c. @. c. a. . @. _. . R. DB. J.
(44) . c. 0c. 0c. U. 0c. c. E. G. a. >. >. c. a. . B. >. U. #³G Õµ V n¸ ¡ iµ ¹³ G~³GYµ C C >qUjgUX{no ^jZXpnp?^ruUY{noToVmnpnp?UXSj¯WY|!UY\]|¥ jgS<huCmn^%yn^ ru^]pnSVUiynmihkj`yn^%o[^!o`o[^!ejVhuUX{xo k m ¯p~ruUX{nWY|ynZY{no v UiL0 yihu\ ¦ ^!ojzru^e!mnw?^ WY|!UX\|jlShu~mx^¯^!mxerkhuyihu^!{]mnoVmn^ryx^yihu\]^!{xo<huUY{ h n¦n ^!o|!elfxZX{nWY^!o ; m $ jg^ruo¯[ C^ mn^ o[mnpxp I e!UYS[SV^!o[p?UX{nyx^!{Xj WY|!UX\|jlShu~mx^!\%^!{Yj ZYm~}o<i\|jlS<hu^!o"hu{YZYS<huZY{Yjl^!oqyn^ vCpnZYSS[ZYpnp?UXSjZXmC}fXip?^!S[piruZY[ {no^ |!CmihuyihuojlZY{Yjloyx^o[^!oq®¡ZYe!^!oUYpnp?UXoV|!^!o$¦ ? %e!UXSVS[^!oVpUY{ny#ynUY{neWY|!UX\|jlS<huCmn^!\¢^!{Xj ©#mn{WXSVUXmnp?^yn^o~¥ \|jlS<hu^!o hu{XsZXShuZX{Yjl^!oyn ^ ¦~ C|!{nUY{ne!|~¦ i¦ hkhkh¡¦xo<huWY{ih Õ^ynUY{neCm ^!{]e!UY\]p?UYo[ZY{Xjyx^jl^rkru^!oo<i\]|jgS<hu^!ov UY{p^!mijZYpnpirkhuCmn^!SjlUYmijo[UY\]\^jTyn^ o[mnS{ hu\pUYS<jg^Cmn^r"ZXmijgS[^¦ .. !. M". ^&)(. ,. +". >. $" %!. ;1. 3". E. HG. >. 37. >. c. >. >. c. >. . P. >. >. Z jlUYp?UruUYWhu^e!mxwihuCmn^%o[^¢yn|!e!S<hkj`|!WXZsru^!\]^!{Yj©r¡ Zshuyn^]yx^ruZ pnZYS<j[hkjVhuUX{ * 0' k k m m Jyn^ [ h h h ^ k m ¦ h ~ / C *¶ µ µ ¹³ [ h ^I & 0 " 0 8# S [ ^ [ ^ 3 8!& Q & : ~ 0 & : z 4 U3[ L b
(45) . z? E*z;7 7)A & 7G)& z?( L _L 7^ #?!" SSx I )(*AG8? & [ h ^ 4 7AC%PM 8 #v :: 9 V*z;#ML&$!x z;~& z?($ 0 [ ^ E 9 w l * ` A "u z;l3& z?( ( S &R : * 0 ( 9 *. E [ ^ 7 6 +: ,=! " S 9Q #7 #{ : * : L u u 64 9 * 98* #7 #~rAgQz;#ML&$!x z;l& z?(: *$# "% : % ! u u:Q. # % !Ë &s(Ò ' )!Ò K+* 'I -Ó ,JM/.!01' '203)+01465/798;:=<?>A@ @ CB. E. /GSR. >. "](. &)(. ,. >. J. 6. %
(46). $" $" %!. 37. 8. >. >. >. >. >. >. >. G. ^>. >. >. >. >. ^<. "+" (. J. 3?. "+" "](. >. 0>. " 5(. P. H* QL. Q. E. @ DB. R.
(47) !4 = 9 D s 9x (L "7 P|E 98* "#V *. { ?A 88 AC G&8 S 9!8u |Sx " 7 z;8zl& z?( *$# &% u P. P. #. $# &P % *. ( E5( . % >z;l& z?( .
(48) . &. :> E 9Q #7 #. 0. # @(. * P. >. . "!z;7 7 9. S. L u : 7 AG|. * . *. . 4. CF E " Zshuo[o[|ZXm ru^!ejg^!mnS$¦ c elfnZYCmn^#®¡Ushuo`~mx^ruZo[mihkjg^%yn^!oe!mxw^!oyx|!e!S[U jzo<jgS<huejg^!\]^!{Yj v~hkrT^!{ sZÐyx^%\]«!\^zyn^¢e!^rkru^%yn^!o yihu\^!{no<huUY{novYy ZXpxS[t!o À¦i ^!oyihu\^!{no<huUY{nopxS[^!{nZY{Yjru^!mnS[oqZsru^!mnS[oynZY{no vGe!^!ehÕ{n^p?^!mijo[^pnSVUiynmihuSV^ Cm mn{{nUY\wnSV^ Õ{ih"yn^®¡Ushuo$¦ ? Zshuo[o[|`ZYm]ru^!ejg^!mnS$¦ E { jl^!SV\]^ * ZYyn\]^joVUhkj`mn{n^#hu{ G{ihkjl|yn^¢o[^!ej[huUY{no±u»ivu_Y° v"ZXmx~mx^re!ZXoZXmxe!mn{ pUshu{Yjzyn^ 2 I { ZYpnpnZYS<jVhu^!{Yj© o~o[UshkjTmn{{nUY\wnS[^ Õ{ih?yn^o[^!ejVhuUX{xo±u»ivu_X° v~ZXmnCmn^rGe!ZXo & n¦ *^!o<jynUX{xepnS[UYpnS[^v ^j(o$ UYwij[hu^!{Yj(©#pn2 ZXSj[huSyn, ^ *Q^!{]oV|ru^!ej[huUY{n{nZY{Yjru^!ojl^!S[\^!oe!UY\]p?UXSjlZY{Xj2 mx{]{nUY\wnS[^ G{ihyn^bo[^!ej[huUY{no k m v"oVUhkj * 0 ¦?£UY{XjgS[UY{no(\]Zshu{Yjl^!{nZY{YjbCmn^#ru^! o *¥ÂpnZXSj[hkjVhuUX{no(yn^!obe!mnw^!ooVUX{YjpxS[UYpnS[^!ov : pnZYh S]SV|!e!mnS[SV^!{ne!^ o[[ mnS¢^ ruZº y~hu\]^!{nohuUX{¦Ch 0 Yv(ZsruUXSVo * 0 *vTpnS[UYpnS[^¦(~mnpnp?UXoVUX{no ] ] I yihu\ 0 kxvG^jru^#SV|!o[mirkjgZjiS[Zsh ^!{ yihu\]^!{xo<huUY{ > m¦GRZYSe!^#CmihpnSV|!e!t!yn^$ v *¦?^p~rumno$v [ 0 ^ 0 ¦s ^!o"®¡ZYe!^!oyn^ o[UY{Yjyn^!oe!mxw^!o yn^(yihu\^!{no<huUY{ msvYynUY{neru^!mnS[oI pxZXSj[hkj[huUY{no *b¥ hu{nyxmihkjl^!o"o[UY{Yj pnS[[ UYpn^ S[^!ovpnZYS"fXip?Ujgfnt!o[^ yx^S[|!e!mxS[S[^!{xe!^¦gUY{ne * 0 * *. 2 I I U3[ > ^ 2 I ^!ojze!UY{no<jVhkjlmn|`yn^#jl^!SV\]^!o(yn> ^ *#¦ iUshkj ¦"Xh Av JZYpnpnZYS<jVhu^!{Yj©¨ZYm£\]Ushu{nomx{n^#®¡ZYe! ^ I I [ ^ yn^ vGynUY{ne`©]mn{ jl^!SV\]^ * & * ¦?^#pirumx, o * ¢|jlZY{XjpxS[UYpnS[^^j ZYpnpnZYS<jg^!{nZX{Yj(© * ]UY{Z 2 I &
(49) & ¦i{ ZynUY{nemn{n^¯®¡ZY\%hkrkru^ * yn^¯jl^!S[\^!oyn^ * hu{nerumxo¯yxZX{n2 o vCS[^!e!UYmiiS[ZY{Yj ¦ 2 UX{nF e * {[ ^!^ o<j#ZXm~jlS[^¢~mx$ ^ *$# &% v Cmih(^!o<j#ynUX{xe%pnS[UYpnSV^¦"^pirumno *#¦[ UX^ {x$ e * o$ UYwij[hu^!{Y[ j#^ © pnZYS<jVhuS(yn ^ * # &% pnZYS¯ZYyUX{nejVhuUX# {yn^ vÕ^%j * ¨^!oj|!WXZsru^!\]^!{YjTpxS[UYpnS[^¦ I # e!mnw, E GCh ( ^!o<jmn{¢ ^ &. %v * ^j * o[UY{YjTpnSVUXpnSV^!o$vsy ZYpnS[t!o E¦YUY{n%e * 0 * & ( >& 2 I 2 * & H0 * ¦?RUXoVUX{x% o * 0 * & ( Y ¦ * ^!ojmn{n^`®¡ZY\%hkrkru^#yn^`jg^!S[\]^!o(yn^ 2(I 2 2(I 2 * ®¡UYS[\]ZY{Yj¯mx{n^zpxZXSj[hkj[huUY{]yx^ ( ¦GUY{ne * { ^!o<jZYmijgS[^Cmn^ruZ%pnZYS<jVhkj[huUY{¨yn^ ( hu{nyxmihkjl^pnZX% S * v Cmih ^!o<jynUY{ne`pnS[UYpnSV^vC|!WXZsru^`$ © * ¦ D. "](. "+" (. . "+" "](. 5". _. %. . " 5(. E. G. ;L. . L. P. >. Q. >. @. B. @. P. B. >. >. >. >. 0>. >. >. P. >. >. @. >. B. a. >. P. >. >. P. P. P. P. >. P. P. >. 5(. @. #". @. >. @. FB. B. a. B. a. a. . D. ZX{no(ruZpnS[UYp?UXohkj[huUY{]o[m~hkZX{Yjg^ruZ%jg^!S[\¢hu{nUruUYWshu^^!\]piruU!Y|!^z^!oje!^rkru^zy cS[{nUsruy£° ivGelf¦ ±¡¦.
(50) ³ ³Õ µ ¡³. . $ $ #%
(51). . ³ Õµ E C E ¹XµAC ~ y u 4 ( L z; & z?( &Q : ( Q (%8u $z 88 * G 9z;w z;/ 7z? . : I I. 7 9A )"!z;7 7r*z; ( 98 [ 4 [ >= ^Q^ 7 7V 7 9A )ux L !&)z? "$ zu 4 M6. "](. . /. " $" 0!g&)( ,. 6. %"+!. 3". 37'8. >. . ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(52)
(53) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! " . Q # A A 9"u 9GArML$"#A *z : 8F : #0 " @$z;97 Sx N 9& x z;!CL "I zu&Q #z; 88 Q w[ !KD " zuIAL&8A [ ^ ^H rI zu& 6 ?!$ 98[(*A^ A !)(*(*A_:\z;l # LFQ &;L " "z) 98 AML$""A$)&* 0 k m 8# # "% [ h h h ^ : h A QK!VSx 67& "78 8# # &%
(54) ; 0 ; *z &% S [ ^ : [ ^ : # " ux % z? " zuCA " ;*{rA 88 Q AL&A zu& 6 9! z$ 98# 4 [ 7^ 8 \8? 'k : ~ p ?7 > 98 7 * *z 0 [ ^ S Q#! I > h 9 x ; )(*A 0 . k [ h ^ I@[ h ^ h 0 T)U W , Qz ML )z;!(%% x 8z 88 * 4 '(L # u z;! m (%%)A !8)(*(*h A *9_ SxI 8J# 9[ %%^ CAV&!8 "78IC*z 78# [ h ^ : 4 zu)Al 7 9A }& z?(* zu $ E 9 / 7 9A J ux L z? "L 4 I 8z? & z?( I ( & %. z;!%8zL 88 Q $ [ h ^ :\ b ) 9 7V#!8z; \ 9 ux L z? #> zu 4 3 !& [ h ^ [ h ^ n ( : &;Q7 G% A8{Aw&%w&8$}N 9&wG "M !&Jzlz SN 9& : g"[ !A h 9 !h 8 u^ 8z) 9"u 8Lzu) 7 zu 888 Q 7 9A zu 4 zuPArA &8 9L*7 #l w& 9L 7g&?! : E 9 * 9Q #7 #3 ux % Hz? " [ h ^ . 0! E E $6 S&: ,= 9" &Q# " S 8~&8 9&Q 4 "+" (. >. %c. a. L. >. L. P. P. E. G. P. P. L. P. P. >. c. c. c. R. c. P. "+" "](. @. c. G %c. c B. E. 0c. @. G. E. B. a. @. c. B. c. V8. U. a. R. " 5(. . 5(. P. #"](. D. P. >. Q.
(55) C FE. (iUshkj %¦qCh <{Xj ZsruUXSVoy? ZXpnSVt!oru^ru^!\]\^%~¦ v yxUX{ne jl^r I I [ [ ^ ^ I [ ^ I(U3[ ^ Cmn^ "¦ :^!o<jyxUX{nemx{£o[UYmno<¥Âe!mnw?^#yn^ e!UY{Yjl^!{nZY{Yj v"yxUX{ne 10 ¦"S {n^p?^!mij e! U $Æ{xehuynI ^!SzZ$X^!er¡ mn{n^ yn^]oV^!oz®¹ZXe!^!o`Cmn^]o hkr[ ^!o<^ j#S[|!ynmihkj© mn{x^]e!UY{ ÕWYmnS[Zsj[huUY[ { ^ .¹ru^!\][ \^ ^%~¦ 0lv ^j p?UXmxSjgUXmij ´UY{ Z <{Yj 0 Y¦cbhu{no<hUY{:Z wihu^!{ <{Yj ] v?Cmn^r~mx^]o[Ushkj ] \]I Zshu{Xjg^!{nZY{Xj ] I ¦ [ ^![o]bj^UX^ miY^!S<j] e!UY\]\^mn{ihuUY{ yn^!ojg^!S[\]I ^!oyn[ ^#o[[ ZF^*^ ¥ÂpnZYS<j[hkjVhuUX{?vnCmih n¦"iUhkj! I oVUX{Yjyn^!o¯hu{Xjg|!S<hu^!mnSVoyn^#e!mnw?I ^!o$vxynUY{ne#yn^!oUYmiX^!Sjlor.¹ru^!\\]^#~¦ 0l¦GUX{ne#oh ( ^!ojmn{£e!mnw?$ ^ & %vGruZ jgUXp?UruUYWshu^ ^!o<je!UY{no<jVhkjlmn|!^yx^!oUXmiY^!S<jgo¯yx^ e!UX{Yjg^!{~mxo¯yxZX{no ( ¦ "](. >. >. >. >. >. L. . H* QL. J. >. @. B. %. >. >. >. >.
(56) !4 = 9 D. _$». x Zsj[ruZYo \mx{ihkjjgS<hkChuZru^!\^!{Yjr¡ ^!{no[^!\w~ru^% y? mn{n^o<jgS[mnejgmnS[^yn^(ZYS<hu|jg|ZX{xZrkCj[huCmn^ ¦C^ pirumxopnZXS(yn| G{ihkj[huUY{]yn^ ruZjlUYp?UruUYWhu^yx^ {? ^!o<jZXm~jlS[^b~mx^ ¦ ^!o<jo[|!pnZYS[ZYwiru^vCe!ZYS ^ v?o[Ushkj <{Yj 0 <{Yj 0 ' v?ZsruUXSVo(ru^!o yn^!mC} p?Uhu{Yjgoyihuo<jVhu{nejlop ^jp ?|jgZX{YjynUY{n{n|!o[ ynZYh {no% % yn^!mC}#p?Uhu{Yjlo ^j o[UY{Yj SV^!pnS[|!oV^!{Yjl|!oÕoVmnS"ruZe!ZYS<jg^ !oAoVUhkj <{Yj [ [ ^^ ^j" <{Xj [ [ ^^ oVUX{Yjyihuo¹<Ushu{Xjgo$v ZsruUXSVo
(57) L% ^j
(58) % o[UY{Xj(yn^!m~}¨e!ZXSjl^!oqyn^ynUY\]Zshu{n^!oyihuo¡Uhu{Y[ jgo¯[ e!UY^{Y^ jl^!{nZY{YjT[ SV^![ o[p?^^!^ ej[hkX^!\^!{Yj ^j # # ¦? ^!o[pxZXe!^jlUYpUsruUYWhuCmn^. ^!ojynUY{ne#o[|!pnZYS[|¦G^pirumno ^!o<jyx|!{nUX\wxS[ZYwiru^¦?,{ ^ ^j`o<h [ h ^ ^!ojyn|!{nUY\wnS[ZYwiru^vY^j ^!o<j Õ{~h o+. 0 h ^!o<jmn{e!mnw?^ ¦ u,jgZX{Yj(ynUY{n{n|mn{ ynUY\]Zshu{n^ 0 k m UYmiY^!S<j(ynZX{xo v~jl^r?Cmn^ yihu\ viUY{¨egfnUshuo<hkjmn{n^ e!ZYS<jg^ yn^ynUY\]Zshu{n^ vxZXoVo[Uiehu|!^h ©%mn{ e!mnw?^yn^yihu\]^!{nohuUX{ ]ynZY{nc o %¦ [ ^ e!UX{xo<j[hkjgmnZY{Xj I eruZYo[ohu~mx^!\] ^!{Yjmn{n^¢wnZXoV^yn^YUhuohu{nZXWY^!o`yn ^ v ^!ojmx{n^%wnZYo[^y UXm~X^!S<jgoyn^ [ ^ ¦ ^¢pirumno#o<h r¡ UY{ hu\]p?UXoV^ruZ£e!UY{nyihkjVhuUX{ v vUY{:UXwijVhu^!{Yj¢mx{n^¨wxZXoV^ yn|!{nUY\wnS[ZYwiru^¦ ,{ ^ ^j v I I ' 0 oVmnpnp & #^!ojyn|!{nUY\wnS[ZYwiru^¦ vGUi 0 : I [ ^ E ÕCh ( ^!o<jmn{e!mnw? ^ &( %vCZsruUXSVoy ZYpnSVt!o CjgUXmijpUshu{Y+j ( p?UXoVo[|!yn^qru^YUhuohu{nZXWY^ <{Yj ( v~o[mnSru^!Cmn^r?^!o<j(yn| Õ{ihGruZe!ZXSjl^
(59) % ¦iUY{ne ( ^!I o<j(mn{n^oVUXmxo<¥¹ZXShu|jl|yx, ^ %¦Õ§(UY[ \][ \^^(^ ruI Z pnZYS<jVhkj[huUY{%hu{nyxmihkjl^oVmnS ( pnZY S * ^!o<j(pn S[# UYpnSVI ^C.¹ru^!\\]^C¦ 0gvCruZ#jlUYp?UruUYWhu^yx^ZYS<hu|jg|hu{nynmihkjg^oVmnS ( pnZYS { ^!o<jZYmijgS[^Cmn^ ¦ E ^!ozynUY\]Zshu{n^!oyn^!oe!ZXSjl ^!oyx^ pnZYS<jVhkj[huUY{n{nZY{Yj %v"yn^!m~}¤p?Uhu{Yjlo :^j o[UY{Xj`S[^rkhu|!o`pnZYSmn{n^ egfnZ {n^yn^e!ZXSjl^!o oh ^j(o[^!miru^!\^!{Yj¯ohÕhkruoZYpnpnZYS<jVhu^!{n{n^!{YjZYm¨\«!\]^(jl^!SV\]^ *#¦n Zyx|!e!UX\pUYo<hk¥ jVhuUX{^!{e!UX\pUYo[ZY{Yjl^!oe!UY{n{n^l}x^!o(yn^ ^!o<jynUY{newihu^!{ ruZ *¥ÂpnZYS<jV2 hkj[huI UY{]yn ^ %¦ [ h h ^ E zXh {nUY{ p?UX{nejgmn^r¡vqZruUYS[o * e!UY{XjVhu^!{Yj¨mn{ jl^!S[\^¨{xUX{ pUY{nejlmx^r * ^!ojÐUYmiY^!S<j v 2QI S2 y ZYpnSVt!o ¦RZYS%Zshkrkru^!mnS[o ^!oj%{nUX{ e!UY\]pxZXej!v e!UY\]\]^hu\]ZYWX^huyn^!{Yj[hkjg|¨hu{YY^!S[o[^ynm pxS[Uiynmihkj%{xUX{ e!UY\]pnZYej k m & vGU? i 2 $0Qyihu\ ¦xUY{ne ZYyn\]^jmn{ SV^!e!UXmiiSV^!\]^!{YjTUYmiX^!Sj o[ZY{noo[UYmno¥ h [ 2 ^ SV^!e!UXmiiSV^!\]^!{Yj Õ{ih¡¦ cyUhuWY{nZY{Xj`© ru^!ozjg^!S[2 \^!oyn$ ^ * XvUX{:UXw~j[hu^!{Yjzmn{:S[^!8 e!UYmiiS[^!\^!{Yj UYmiX^!Sj yx^ %¦niUshu^!{Y j mn{ o[UYmno¥ÆSV^!8 e!UXmiiSV^!\]^!{sjyn^ v ru^2 SV^!e!UXmiiSV^!\]^!{Yjhu{nynm~hkjboVmnS ¦i ^!o jg^!S[\]^!o yn%^ *# b|jlZY{Xjyihuo¡Uhu{Yjgoyn^ v ^!o<jTmx{%o[UYmno<¥ÂS[^!8 e!UYmiiS[^!\^!{Yj yx^ viyxUX{nehu{ G{i2 h¡vipnZYS yn| G{ihkj[huUY{¨yx^ 2 ¦ MLQ # hkr^!{ Z%2yn^`\]8 «!\^yn. ^ ¦Gchu{noh"jlUYmijo[UYmno<¥ÂS[^!e!UYmi8 iS[^!\^!{jyn^ ^!o<j hu{ G{ih¡v?ynUY{nH e {n8 UY{ e!UY\]pnZYej ¦I,T{ SV^ZX{xelfn^`egfnZXCmn^ ^!o<j ¥Âe!UX\pnZYej vi^!{ m~j[hkrkhuo[ZY{YjruZwnZXoV^ v ynUY{ne ^!oj ¥Âe!UX\pnZYej¯e!UY\]\^mn{ihuUY{ÐZYmpirumnoyn|!{xUX\wnSVZXw~ru^y ^!{no[^!\w~ru^!o ¥Âe!UX\pnZYejlo$¦. . "+" (. >. #L. L. L. P. P. XL. "+" "](. E. G. >. >. P. . >. /T. >. VL. ML. R. U. >. ONc. R. U. c. c. ^U. . " 5(. @. FU. U. c. a. /T. B. 5"+" "](. _. VL. 5(. #"](. ". G. %. E. . @. @. B. %. B. >. ËgÖ
(60) LK!Ò Ò 0 Ò )!Ò .M Ó¡Ò ' )LI Ó . LK!Ò ' K 0 ,!. Ó¹Ò 0 Ó¡ÒM/'¹Ò Ó¹Ò1.HJM
(61)
(62) ()!Ò Ó¡Ò @. U. P. . ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(63)
(64) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! ". . . ZX{no ruZzoVmihkjl^vYUY{huyn^!{YjVh Õ^ru^!oe!UYS[ynUY{n{n|!^!o. %¦ . C ¸ / ¸ n· , pxZXS(ruZ®¹UXSV\miru^eruZYo[ohuCmn^. I. 6. `&(. ,. 0c. I6. E. ^ruZXpiruZYehu^!{£o ^l}npxS<hu\]^© jgS[Z!Y^!S[o. " !57. 0. c. ]. k m ^jqru^pnZXSVZX\|jlSVZXWY^ZYm#XUshuo<hu{nZYWX^y? mn{%p?Uhu{Yj h G. I. :. . . ZYm£YUhuohu{nZXWY^%y mx{ p?Uhu{Yj. o[mnpxp
(65) % . .[_%0 c. #.
(66)
(67) I. _Y_. ]. {]yn| G{ihkjT\Zhu{Yjl^!{xZX{Yjru^ 9 7 "7 yx^ o[mxS %vCpnZYSZX{nZsruUYWhu^Z!Y^!eruZ`jlfn|!UYS<hu^(ynmpUsjl^!{YjVhu^r . XUshuS jgfn|!UXSVt!\]^%C¦u_A0l¦ ^]pxS[UYwirut!\]^%y? UXpijVhu\%Y huoVZjVhuUX{y mn{n^¢®¡UY{nej[huUY{ oVmnS#r¡ fYxp?^!S[e!mxw^ ^!o<j%ZsruUYS[o jgS[Zshkjl|%e!UY\]\^zru^pnS[UYwirut!\^y? UXpijVhu\%huoVZjVhuUX{£yx^%o[UY{Jp?Usjl^!{Yj[hu^r
(68) Y oVmnSr¡ ^!{YY^ruUXpnp?^%e!UY{YX^l}x^ ¦ §(^!p?^!{nynZY{Yj ru^(pnSVUXw~rut!\]^e!UY{Yj[hu{CmUYwijl^!{Cm#{ ^!o<j mn{pnS[UYwirut!\^yn^(Y pnSVUXWYS[ZY\]\Zj<huUY{e!UY{YX^l}x^¦Y Z qR¥Âe!UX\piru|jlmxyn^Tyxm]pnSVUXwirut!\^hu{ihkj[huZsrÕo[^V+lSV|®¡mnWshu^L1ynZY{noqruZ#{nUX{~¥Æe!UY{YX^l}~hkjl|yxm%pnS[UYwirut!\^¯e!UY{Yj[hu{Cmv ynUY{YjruZ`S[|!oVUrumijVhuUX{ZYpnpnSVUielfx|!^^l}~huWX^mx{n^ZXpxpnS[Uiegfn^UXShuWhu{nZsru^vs®¡UY{nyn|!^o[mxSru^!ooi\]|jlShu^!o ZXm¢\%hkrkhu^!m ynme!mnw?^V. XUshuSo[^!ejVhuUX{ I0g¦ :. >. $
(69) . . . $ # . ~ p ?7. D³ iµ ¹³ Yµ ³nµ Gµ C¸¹ ³ Õµ E Õ¸¹³ n¸ :b7 AV*z;7 7$ 888 (*AG "VQz; k m #A$ zu I h * k 0 k * k m $0 ! # " m [ ^ .À0 [ h m ^ * $I 0`h m h "[ ^ # m * 8 >A) 2 8z;#"6 P 98vQ # 4 9 $&
(70) ? {( !8z;#"6 @ % ! 98 A [p ?h "78^ {A uL8z; 7 ;
(71) F0%$ 9 C u((*#K wVA}& p z; # z : S ] I , A)&
(72) 98
(73) r! 7)8z * :\%7 \" 88&CA3&8= 88 "78 k 0 m ] -* %
(74) 0 0'& X)( m # X( []_^ ] [ ^ S : 9 x N 9&)\MQ8!&Q #;
(75) =; dML Cz;lS 9& 88&Q 78 HQz; C: 9z;rAgA8AP uL8z; Y 8L7 7 :&8 9L 7P 9g& 9L 7 4 l&;Q7v V ) 98* "7& z;6 gA ML$"#ACrL g . # A > zu G,+. \?
(76) ; C:>J! 7
(77) 3 "& + " ^ : " [] [ ^^ 0 " * - S. [ I Y A)8D ?! 9!A rA ML!&Q # %zrA$&
(78) ? ( !z;"#K7 Y :b7. Y I.
(79) 0/ .Â0 Y X Y\[]_^ ] S :10 . 9. µ ¹³. !#" $" %!'&)( X,. . . 0!. $" %!. F6. ! $". 326. %"+!. 1. E. HG. c. 0c. c. 0c. E. G. 0c. c. c. c. c. R. c. c. R. 9. 8. c. c. H* QL. R. c. _. c. c. ]7. 8.
(80) !4 = 9 D. _ J 9 "A> 9 7 "7 H :bQ b 7 zu . Y 8I 4 8.
(81) ³ ³Õ µ ¡³. $
(82) . . .
(83). :A_ML!&Q "78/(L 9zu5 zu! Y. $ . . 88 7. D³ iµ ¡³ Yµ ³nµ Õµ C¸¡ ³ Õµ E £¸¹³"· x¸ z;\ 78z? . I L E(*7 A p ? :CG*z 98* g 9!A #
(84) 0 4$3 r 6z)* [ ^ [ ^ ] I [ ^ A8 98z;g z?
(85) Qz [ ^ & X)( m # -* X( % 0 .Â0 ] [ ^ S :
(86) 9 $&
(87) ? n 9!A #;
(88)
(89) L \!&)A p ?>AL& u 4 [ ^ : z;g z?. [ ^.
(90) 0 .À0 Y X Y\[]b^ ] S : #;Q
(91) %EA Q $" CAL& u *z; 4 :
(92) L z;g 986D8E$z; "#6" 8# . 4 !$&8Y 9L%8 7E 98V& 9L 7 / J[ A)h &L8^ 89 I GAL&8AY r w&8* 4. D. M6. "](. . " $" 0!g&)(+*. ,. 0!.
(93). $" 0!. <. F6. !. $". 32. 6. %"+!. 3?. 7. :. :. 0c. c. c. #:. "+" (. :. >. <. D. ?.
(94) C . L P. FE. ,T{ ^ ^j¨oh ZruUYS[o? jl^rCmn^ 0 k m UYm m k vynUY{ne$ X ( m> ] I [ ^ I [ h ] ^ [ h ^ [ h ^ [ * % #^ X( 0 kxvYyxUX{n-e* % ] 0 ,kivYo[Ushkj ] I [
(95) ^ ¦iXhn\]Zshu{Xjg^!{nZY{Xj ] I [ ^ \]Zshuo I oVmnpnp [ ^ v ZsruUXSVo X)( m, # X( 0`k 0 ms¦"UY{nep?UXmnS¯jlUYmij ^j
(96) QoVmnpnp UX{£ZH 0 [ ^ ] I [ ^ [ ^ ] * % uX ( m X( ¦ # §(:
(97) ZXS [ 0 k%^ oh y ZYpnS[t!o À¦ ] ] I [ ^ "](. :. /T. %c. c. c. _. 0c. c. c. :. :. c. c. c. :. "+" (.
(98) . ".
(99)
(100) . $ $
(101) . #³G Õµ Õµ Yµ iµ ¹³ E³Õ¸¹ C" C T³ iµ ¹³ Q ^!o(piruZY{noe!UY{Xjg^¥ {nZY{Yj5 pnZYS[Zsrkrutru^!o]ZYm~}º®¡ZYe!^!o%yn^ yn|!e!UYmnp?^!{Yjr¡ ^!oVpnZYe!^ yihu\ #
(102) % ^!{w?Uhkjg^!o%S[^!ejgZX{xWXmiruZshuS[^!ov ZYpnp?^ru|!^!o¯e!^rkrum~ru^!oyn^ TUYS[UY{nU $VvGUYm w[ Ushk^ jl^!oyn^#bhuS<huegfiru^j ¦"§(fnZYCmn^`o[UY\]\]^jyn| G{ihkjmn{n^#w?Uhkjg^vi®¹UXS¥ \|!^]yn^!op?Uhu{Yjgoyx^]r¡ ^!oVpnZXe!^ynUY{Xjhkr^!ojru^¨oVUX\\]^j`ru^¨pirumxopnS[Uiegfn^v ^!{:jg^!{nZX{Yje!UY\]pijg^%y mn{n^ u8! pUY{nyn|!SV| p?UX{xyn|!S[Zsj[huUY{ yn| Õ{ihu^pnZYSzp¦ ^]yx|!e!UXmnpxZXWY^UXw~jl^!{Cm o ZXpnp?^rkru^ *8$/ ZYo[oVUiehu|TZYm%e!mnw?^(^!, { ¦ ^!o<j ru^(XUsrumn\]^(yn^(ruZ`wUshkjl^(UYpnp?UXoV|!^© .Âe!UY{Yjl^!{nZY{Yj"ru^pUshu{YjyihuZYWXUY{nZs¥ ru^!\^!{Xj(UYpnpUYo[|yx^ 0yn] ZY{noTe!^yn|!e!UYmnpnZYWX^¦,{ Õ { ^!o<j(ru^wnZYS<i] e!^!{YjlSV^yn^ruZ®¹ZX\¢hkrkru^ X
(103) L% \mn{~hu^zyn^ruZ]p?UY{nyn|!S[Zs[ j[^huUY{ X
(104) L% 3. TUshuS ÕWXmxS[^¢_s¦ cr0g¦n UYmijwnZYS<ie!^!{YjlSV^yn^`o[UY\]\[7]_^^ jloq:y mn# { e!mnw?^`WX|!UY\]|jgS<huCmn^^!ojr¡ hu{Yjl[ ^!S[oV^!]_ej[^ huUY:{ y# mn{n^®¡ZY\%hkrkru^#y fYip^!SVpiruZY{noe!ZX{xUX{ihuCmn^!\^!{Yj¯ZYo[oVUiehu|!^z©¢ruZ p?UX{xyn|!S[Zsj[huUY{£Cmih(ru^¨yx| Õ{ihkj ¦ £Zshuoe!^!o#fXip?^!S[piruZY{no#{n^o[UY{Xj%pxZXo#pnZYS[Zsrkrutru^!oZXmC}:®¡ZYe!^!o#ynm:e!mnw^v ynUY{neUY{ { ZpnZYor¡ hu{Yjg^!S[pnSV|jlZsj[huUY{XUsrumn\%huCmn^%pxS[|!e!|!yn^!{Yjl^vxo<hqru^%egfnZX\p£yn^!opUY{nyn|!SVZjVhuUX{no{? ^!o<j .. !. M". ^&)(+*%*, /!. $6. $" %!. ". >. . >. . . F6. 0!. $" %!. 37. . %. ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(105)
(106) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! ". _$. . pnZYow?^!S[{nUYmihkrkrkhu^!{ . ÕWYmnSV^_¦ 0g¦Õ ^!oegfnZY\]pno(w?^!S[{nUYmihkrkrkhu^!{no(oVmnSmn{fYxp?^!S[e!mxw^ yn^`yihu\^!{no<huUY{ ®¹UXSV\]^!{Yjmn{n^`ZYS<hu|jg|zyn^#yihu\^!{no<huUY{?o[mnS vijgZX{xyihuoCmn^`ruZ]sZXShu|jl|#yn^`jlUYmijl^!o(ru^!obpUY{nyn|!SVZjVhuUX{no oVmnS ^!o<jyn^yihu\]^!{xo<huUY { 'm$. \]ZYo[oV^!o$vCoVUX\\]ZY{Xj©¨_0g¦i ^!oVpnZXe!^yx^!o¯egfnZY\]pnow?^!S[{nUYmihkrkrkhu^!{no ^!ojynUX{xew?^!ZXmne!UYmnppirumnop?^j[hkjCmn^`r¡ ^!o[pnZYe!^yn^jlUYmijg^!oTru^!op?UY{nyn|!S[Zsj[huUY{no¦Y Àr e!UX{Yj[hu^!{Yje!^!p?^!{nynZY{Xj jgUXmijg^!oru^!oo<jgS[Zsjl|!Wshu^!oTpnmxS[^!o$¦I,T{ Õ{e ^!o<jyn|<©%mn{e!UX{YjVhu{~mxmn\Цx{ egfnUshuo<hkjynUY{neyn^jgS[Z!sZhkrkru^!SoVmnS r¡ ^!oVpnZXe!^yn^!opnfnZYo[^!o¦ :. :. . (A). (B). . . %.
(107).
(108) %. G G. %.
(109) G
(110) % . . (*),+.-Õ_¥ !A #}( !z;""67 ?!. "! G. G $# % "!&' % . rQ !3( 8z;#"6 ? 2 *z; %8$Q A z& 4. ;<. ?. A<. ?. #
(111) /C 0
(112) · $ ¹ 21 % Vz; $"?#$z; AL&8V!x Y *z; : % \&;L 7C*z; 4 !& % bz;! 8A z;) 4 [ h ^ Y [ ^
(113) C Z ®¡UY{nejVhuUX{ Y vruUie!Zru^!\^!{Xj#\mirkjVhkrkhu{n|!ZhuSV^vq^!Y o<j%fnZYS[\UX{ihuCmn^v y ZYpnY S[t!o#r¡ ^l}xpnSV^!o[ohuUX{. ;4 C³. D. . .
(114) G
(115) G
(116) %
(117) G
(118) %. &( *C&-,. . FE. +D. 3"+!. " 6. "+!#".
(119). ,. . >. ,. . 7. 3.
(120). M(.
(121). 8.
(122). ruUie!Zsru^ynm`ruZYpiruZYehu^!{z®¹UXmxS[{ihu^q^!{^l}x^!\piru^TC¦ sI0g¦~Uhkj43 UYmiX^!Sj e!UY{Yjl^!{nZY{Yj , vso[mnS"ru^!Cmn^rYru^(pUsjl^!{YjVhu^r yn^ ^!o<j\¢hu{ihu\mn\ ^!> { , ¦ 3 e!UX{YjVhu^!{Xjmx{ÐUYmiY^!S<jyn^ ©jlSVZ!X^!SVo(r¡ ZjVruZXo vÕUi?$0 yihu\ , ¦ Y [ ^ {n^®¹UX{xej[huUY{ÐfxZXSV\]UY{ihuCmn^o[mxSmn{UXm~X^!S<jyx^ Y|!S<h Õ^ru^pnShu{nehup^ynm \%hu{~hu\mn\Ðv~^rkru^{x^p?^!mij ZYyn\]^jVjlSV^%yn^ \%hu{ihu\mn\5ruUie!Zsro[ZY{no«jlSV^]ruUie!Zsru^!\]^!{Yj#e!UX{nojlZY{Yjl^6¦ 5mihkjVjl^ © S[^!ojlSV^hu{nynS[7 ^ 3 ©£mn{ UYmiX^!Sjpirumnop^jVhkjUX{¤p^!mijyxUX{ne`o[mxpnpUYo[^!SCmnH ^
(123) ^!o<je!UY{nojlZY{Xjg^oVmn8 S 3]¦"{ p?^!mij|!WYZru^!\^!{Xj Y pnSV^!{nynSV9 ^ 3 ynZY{noruZwnZYo[^y? UXmiY^!S<jgo
(124) % yn| Õ{ihu^ynZY{noruZpxS[UYpUYo<hkjVhuUX{]C¦ C¦Õ{¨ZyxUX{ne 'k#jl^r # Cmn^ , , 3 0 3 3 0 7 , , ohu{nohUX{ I o[mnpxp [ ^ [ ^ : S h. . . P. c. H* QL. c. R. a. c. @. G. c. c B. c. E.
(125) !4 = 9 D. _$. {\]UY{XjgS[^\Zhu{Yjg^!{nZX{YjpnZXS(SV|!e!mnS[SV^!{ne!^o[mnS(yihu\ , ru^ru^!\]\^o[mihksZX{Yj vxCmih ZXegfntY^ruZ%yn|!\UX{xo<¥ [ ^ jgS[Zsj[huUY{¦. C /. 88&CAC! 7 #; &.
(126). &)(+*. 7 : . ,
(127) 0. 0
(128) 0 G
(129) Y Y I [ ^ Y YS , D CFE "ChÕy~hu\ 0 kxvCe ^!ojT|Chuyn^!{Yj ¦C~mnpnp?UXoVUX{no"ru^¯ru^!\]\]^qiS[ZshÕo<hGyihu\ , 0 }m ki¦iiUshkj , jl^riCmn^(yihu\ ,[ 0 ^ n¦ h }xUX{xo oVmnpnp , ¦C§(UY\]\^ 3'& , vYZsruUXSVo y[ ZXpx^ S[t!o ruZpnS[UYpUYo<hkjVhuUX{ [ ^ I [ ^ [ ^ C¦u_!»ivxpUYmnSjlUYmij 3 I.
(130) 0 Y X
(131) % Y\[]_^ ] S : # X iUshkj 0' m. - # -* X % ¦xcruUYS[o
(132) % * oVmnpnp E ] [ ^ G .
(133) . 3. I.
(134). >. M(. >. c. #. :. . . c. 6. ]. & Xm - # -* X % [ ^ - oVmnpnp
(135) % : # & 0 X ( m #- * X ( % -X m% - # - * X % [ ^ [ ^ h - oVmnpnp
(136) % * E : # 6 oVUhkj 0 X)( m% # -* X( % Ui ] [ ^ ]\h 7 oh 0 m X ( % m # -* X ( % 0 ] % m o h 0dk [ ^ S ] qUjgUX{no r¡ fYip^!SVpiruZX> { 0 ¦ ~Uhu^!{Yj * , % .¡S[^!oVp¦A * - % 0(ru^pnSVU<^jg|UYS<jgfnUXWYUY{nZr?yn^ , # ru^`pnS[Us<^jl|UYS<# jgfnUYWXUY{nZsrÕyn^ , o[mxS ¦ , I !^ o<j oVmnSr¡ fXip?^!S[piruZY{
(137) , .ÂS[^!oVp ¦ - 0lvx^j [ ^!{n^ o<huUY{ H [ ,^ [ ^ ynUY{nebhuyn^!{Yj[huCmn^`©%mn{fYxp?^!S[e!mxw^yx^zyihu\ m¦x^`pirumnobo<h I [ ^ 0. 0c. c. c. c. %c. c. 0c. 0c. c. c. %c. 0c. c. c. c. c. :. :. :. c. >.
(138). Y 0 0. X. oVUhkj. . X. : :. . % \Y [7]_^ #
(139) % # @6 )X ( C
(140).
(141). Y. 0. X. -. ] Y>[]_^. E. :. c. 0c. . . (
(142) % [ Y\[] #. c. . c. ]. *- . ^. X [. :. #. m.
(143). . % X( @6 0c. C. ^Y\[7]. ,. Y\[]_^![ E. c. m. *,. ^^. . c. c. ^. . c. ]\h. ]S. ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(144)
(145) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! " <{YjlSVUiynmihuoVUX{noo[mxS. ,. . yn| Õ{ihu^`pnZYS 0. m. * - % % *, % Y [7]_^ Y\[7]6# ^ [ ^?Y\[]# ^ S qUjgUX{no
(146) ruZSV^!o<jgS<huej[huUY{© yn^,
(147) ¦
(148) ZYpnpnZYS[Z jTynUY{nee!UY\]\^ru^pUsjl^!{Yj[hu^rnZYo[oVUiehu|©`ruZ ®¹UX{nejVhuUX{e!UXY\w~hu{nZjgUhuSV^ ¦GiUshkj93 0 3 Y Y ¦ 3 ^!o<j(ruZjgS[ZYe!^yn^r¡ UYmiX^!Sj 3 oVmnSr¡ fYxp?^!S[p~ruZX{ , , ZsruUYS[, ¦3 o$ huyn^!{Yj[h G^yxUX{nY e#© mn{ UYmiX^!Sjyn^ K * - ¦^pirumnobo<h. o
(149) ^!o<j I h e!UY{no<jgZX{Yjg^^j¢|!WYZsru^%©L
(150) oVmnS$3 ¦ UY{ne]y ZYpnSVt!or¡ fYipUsjlfxt!o[^%yn^S[|!e!mnSVS[^!{ne!^#ZYpnpirkhuCmn|!^Y ©ruZ , ®¹UX{nejVhuUX{
(151) o[mxS93 vG{nUsY jlZY{Xj , r¡ ^!{YX^ruUYpnp^`e!UY{XY^l}x^zyn^ Y [ ^ [ ^ ,
(152) 0. G
(153) I [ ^ Y Y S , ,{pnZXSj[hue!mirkhu^!S(oVmnS [ ^ G. ) . m. * - % *, % 0
(154) I h Y\[7] # ^ [ ^?Y\[7] # ^ Y S # Ui ^!{ yn|!S<hksZX{Yj^!{wk%pnZYS(S[ZYpnpUYS<j(©. . 0 * - % 0 +* ,% \ Y 7 [ ] 6 # ^ \ Y [ ] # ^ 7 S , vqynUY{nF , oq^!{ ^ ^j!v r¡ |!WXZsrkhkjl|J. 0#^!o<jhu{nyx|!p^!{nyxZX{Yjl^¢yn^!o{i¥¹hut!\]^!o §(^!eh G e G ] {n{nI|!^!o¦Yc[ pnp~^ rkhu~mxZX{Yjru^`' ] \]I «!\]^b[ S[Zshu^ o[UY{n{n^!\]^!{Yj G e!UiUYS[ynUY' o[mxpnp , vxUX{UYwij[hu^!{Yj Õ{nZsru^!\]^!{Yj 1I [ ^ , oVmnpnp , G * - % 0 +* ,% 0
(155) []\9h ^ I~[ [ ^ [ ^^ Y\[7] # ^ Y\[] # , ^ Y S SruZ%®¹ZX\¢hkrkru^zyx^!o|!elfnZY{nWY^!oTy? mn{n^#e!UiUXSVynUY{n{n|!^ynmo[mxpnpUYS<j(yn^ ^!o<jWY|!{n|!S[ZsjlShue!^yn^ ?
(156) % v # 0 , UY{£Z WYS[UYmnp?^y? ZXejVhuUX{jgS[ZY{no<hkjVhkX^o[mxS , . ru^!\]\^C¦ I0g¦?UY{ne%p?UXmxS[ jlUYmi^ j ] ^I ZYmÐSV[ ZX{x^ W G¦ Y\[]_^ J , ¦?§(^`Cmih \]UY{XjgS[^ru^ru^!\]\.
(157) vGpnmihu% o
(158) 0
(159) p?UXmxSjgUXmi[ j ^ Y Y Y I [ ^ c. :. . ruZ¢®¡UY{nej[huUY{. _ . [ ^. . Y. c. c. . G. c. >. E. c. c. :. >. c. c. :. E. G. c. c. c. :. c. c. :. c. . /T. :. c. c. >. :. P. :. >. %
(160) . . %
(161). . . . C &" 0 T³nµ Gµ C¸ XµÂ³ ·µ ¹³ s³ C" ~ ^!o%p?Usjl^!{Yj[hu^ruo$
(162) Y|!S<h Õ^!{Yj Y ZYS<huZYwiru^!o ynUY{ne£mx{ pnShu{nehup^ yxm \%hu{~hu\mn\Ðv(e!UY\]\^ ru^!o]®¹UX{nejVhuUX{xo]fnZYS[\UX{ihuCmn^!o¢yn^£pirumnohu^!mnS[o SV|!^rkru^!oo[mxSru^!o`UXmiY^!S<jgoS[|!^ruo¦ §(^!eh^!o<j`y£© ru^!mnSyx| Õ{ihkj[huUY{£e!UY\]\^ D ?! yn^ . XUshuS° ±"0l¦ { {nUsjl^|!WYZsru^!\]^!{YjCmn^ru^%p?Ujg^!{Yj[hu^r ^!o<j`{nUX{¤e!UX{YX^l}x^v"yxt!oCmn^%yihu\ Cv"^j#e!Y ^}+ly? ZXmijgZX{Yj [ ^ pirumxo1%Cmn^ruZ%yihu\^!{no<huUY{¨^!oj|ru^X|!^¦ &)(+*. . . , 6. ! $". ]1 . . 0!. $" %!. 4. %!#". . 37. {¨egfn^!SVelfn^b\]Zshu{Xjg^!{nZY{Xj©yn| Õ{ihuSyn^!ojlSVZ<^!ejgUhuSV^!oynZY{noqr¡ ^!o[pnZYe!^yn^!opnfnZYo[^!ov +gZjVj[huS[|!^!o1zpxZXSqru^!o e!UY{ ÕWYmnS[Zsj[huUY{noqUXpijVhu\]Zsru^!o(pUYmnS ¦ Y. %. H* QL.
(163) !4 = 9 D _. . .
(164). M.
(165) ³ ³Õ µ ¡³. ]. C. ³#
(166) . $ . ¸ £ !!³ z;C 7z? Q z;~ rz/ 9"u z; I 9[ x h "^ AL&A zGACMQ8 9 r 9 u "7 Y !x z; 88&Q z;)" ;*{" : [ ^ >
(167) Y 0 [
(168) YH^ : *z #
(169) L% S Qz #I [ ^
(170) Y 0
(171) Y 0
(172) (
(173) Y 1
(174) (
(175) YS .À0 #!
(176) (
(177) 0 k Y S cbhu{no<hUY{{nUsjl^ |!WYZsru^!\]^!{Y j >
(178) 0
(179) v(Z$X^!e ruZ e!UY{XY^!{Yj[huUY {
(180) 0 k o<h : Y [ Y ^ Y I oVmnpnp [ ^7S C &"
(181) x|!CmnZsj[huUY{l.Æ0^!o<jmn{Z!sZjgZXSy mx{n^®¹UXSV\miru^yn^`¦xmno[oVU3.¹YUhuSz°k_ ±"0l¦ D. M6. "](.
(182) )(+*,. " $" 0!. 7. . c. c. "+" (. c. 0c. c. D. %
(183)
(184) C . c. c. R. )(W&. FE. " Z®¹UX{nejVhuUXF {
(185) vGZY{nZsrk~jVhuCmn^oVmnS(ruZ%ZYS<hu|jg|ruUie!Zsru^!\]^!{YjT^!mxerkhuyihu^!{n{n^ vxZXyn\^jmn{¨WYS[ZYyihu^!{Yj ^!{¤jlUYmijzp?Uhu{Yj!¦ ^!Y o[pxZXe!^`jlZY{nWY^!{YjzZYm p?Uhu{Yj% |jlZY{Xj .¡o[UY{ pnSVUXpnSV^ynmnZsr"0lv"Ui 0 yihu\ v?ru^ [ ^ WYS[ZYyihu^!{YjZXmp?Uhu{Yj £o ^l}npxS<hu\]^o[UYmnoruZ%®¹UXSV\]^y mx{¨Y^!ejl^!mnS(yn^`yihu\^!{no<huUY{]yihu\ ¦ [ ^ iUhkj , %¦G ZYpnSVt!oTruZpnS[UYp?UXohkj[huUY{¨C¦u_!»ZYpnpirkhuCmn|!^` ©
(186) 0 o[mxpnp , v I [ ^ -* % X( m% & G <{Yj , 0 # X( 5I [ [ ^^ ] h oVmnpnp
(187) % [ ^ "](. "+" (. >. Uio[mnpnp. . ,. ^!ojruUie!Zru^!\^!{Xje!UX{xo<jlZY{Yj ¦~UY{nezoh. [ ^. . ^z\«!\]^ :. .
(188). . . 0. ,. . ] # ^!o<jruUie!Zsru^!\]^!{Yj(e!UX{xo<jlZY{Yj vCyxUX{ne . ,. [ ^ . . . 0c.
(189).
(190). 0. X X. : :. 0c. Y. . 0. % Y\[7]_^
(191). . # #.
(192). c. c. c. . (
(193) %. . , #. Y\[]_^. +* -.% c. . , #. c. ] * - % . c. #. :. . o[mnpnp I. * - % . . . ]. ,. . [ ^ ,. #. c. *, % . . ,. ] S. *, % . X : # % Y\[]_^ # ] X
(194) % \Y []_^ (
(195) : #
(196). c. . ] , #. c. *, % . ]>h. ÏÂÔ Ï¡Î.
(197)
(198) ! "#$ % #'&)(*"! " oVUhkj . ^zpirumxoo<h [o mnpxp , ynUY{ne
(199) (
(200) I
(201) 0 ki[ ¦ ^ Y.
(202) ³ ³Õ µ ¡³. D. M6. D. Y. M[ \3ZZ3\. .
(203).
(204). %c. Y. $ . , " !#". G. M(. o[mnS. >. . I. o[mnpnp. #I :. [ ^. *z . .
(205) C¸ iµ . ¹ . +" #" !. >.
(206) C (Ch FE. 0
(207) . (
(208) Y 1
(209) (
(210) YS Y ^!oj(ruUie!Zru^!\^!{Xjqhu{nyn|!p?^!{nynZY{YjTyn^ Õvxy ZYpnS[t!oruZ%pxS[UYpUYo<hkjVhuUX{]C¦u_$»xv. . %c. V² ¹ C ·X¸ Yµ] *z;A$& z?( \: 8z I$r ) 9 7
(211) )(
(212). " $" 0!. &8H!x
(213).
(214). . _ . % -z; $#?"$z; A. ] A p ? "78 4 %: 8A 5888#$. $" 37#. "+!#". [ 0[ \$ZZD\P*z;V>O<. \. ?. 0 T +* -.% *, % [ ^ Y\[]_^
(215) Y\[]# ^ h Y\[7]# ^ S ?v UY{ \ UX{YjlSV^#e!UX\\]^`ehk¥Æyn^!oVo[mnov?ruZ jlUYpUsruUYWhu^#^!{ ChuWYmn^!mnS`|jlZY{Xj :. . @. c. .s0. B. c. \. [ . .Â0 X Y 0 Y>[]# +* -.% ^ Y\[]# +* ,% ^7S { ZYpnpirkhuCmn^ZruUYS[o ruZ e!UY{nyihkjVhuUX{ yn^`mnfn{ ^j¤ mxe s^!SÐ^!{ pUYmnSmn{ \¢hu{ihu\mn\ rkhu| pnZYSyn^!o ] e!UY{YjlS[Zshu{Yjl^!oqhu{n|!WYZrkhkjg|!oynZX{xo¯mx{Ð^!oVpnZYe!^^!mnerkhuyihu^!{vxo[Ushkj 0 k
(216) ( X Y k ! ] P 0 m
(217) ( X Y~c k h ] UYm^!{ne!UXSV^ 0 T * - % *, % Y\[7]_^ Y\[7]# ^ h Y\[]# ^ S . %c. c. c. . c. c. @. %
(218) .
(219) . c. c. B. $
(220) . . C &"
(221) 10 V² ¹º C¸ iµ Yµº³ µ ¡ D YµA³ { SV^jlSVUXmiY^¨mx{n^¨{xUjVhuUX{ fnZYwihkjgmn^rkru^zyx^\¢hu{ihu\mn\0SV^ruZjVhk®pUYmnS ¦? ^!o\¢hu{ihu\]Z¢S[^ruZsj[hk®¡obyn^ o[mnS ZYpnpnZYS[Zshuo[oV^!{Yjbe!UY\]\^ yn^!o(UYpij[hu\Z#yn^RZYS[^jgU#ynm<^!m Uiru^!oe!Y UiUXSVynUY{n{n|!^!oe!UiUYpt!SV^!{Yje!UX{YjgY S[^ruZª¢ZjgmnS[^pUYmnS\%hu{ihu\¢huo[^!S.
(222) vGo[mnS \mn{ih"yn^zoVZjlUYp?UruUYWhu^b^!mnerkhuyihu^!{n{n^$.¹YUhuSz°k_Y_vGegf¦ [ À±"0g¦ Y
(223) p ?7. A / C <
(224) Q # zu zu& 6 9! 9 8A% 7!& zu& K787 ?! " Q ; [ h ^ z;!JF Q # zu Qz; 4 `n!& z; N 9& F Q " zu :G u6z{JSx N 9&. 7 9A zu 4 ( % bz;~& z?() 6: ( L S&8 9[ &Q A:Eh "IQ^ zuE$Qz;#ML& ( [ h ^ S )(. , "+!#". $". C6. $". 7. :. >. ]. '. . )(. H* QL. . C. <. 8. ?. >.
(225) !4 = 9 D. _Qs. . {£Y|!S<h Õ^Zshuo[|!\^!{Xj~mx^ruZ jlUYpUsruUXWshu^hu{nynmihkjg^o[mnSmn{ e!mnw?^ ( & 0pnZYS jgUXp?UruUYWshu^^!mnerkhuyihu^!{n{x^vijg^rkru^zCm UY{ r¡ Z%hu{YjlSVUiynmihkjl^b^!{Ðyx| Õ{ihkj[huUY{~¦ i¦. .
(226) C . . e!U $Æ{nehuyx^Z!X^!eoVZ . q UjgUX{no ruZ yihuo<jgZX{ne!^^!mxerkhuyihu^!{n{n^mnoVmn^rkru^%oVmnS#mn{ e!mnw?^ ¦ ~Uhkj . ¦ [ S h?S6^ [ h I . h I >I ^ Ch o[mnpxp vZsruUYS[o, 0 vqynUY{ne L0 kx¦qUY{ne !| WXZsru^]ruZyihuo<jgZX{xe!^ I [ [ h N ^ ^ [ ^ [ h ^ ^!mnerkhuy~hu^!{n{n^^!{YjgS[^ Ð^j ynZX{xo ¦~UY{ne [ h .h I^ D. FE. M(. >. P. >. c. c. c. c. >. . . . . [ h^. [ Ih.^ * % # [ h^ # [ h.I^
(227) "* * %
(228) &* * % # [ h ^ # [Ih.I^
(229) "* * % 0 # [ .h I^ [ h.I^ h P
(230) "* 5%. 0 0. P. P. c e!^`Cmih ynUX{x{n^r¡ hu{n|!WYZsrkhkjl|jlS<huZY{nWYmiruZshuS[^. P. . P. . . . . . [ h ^ [Ih.I^>c [ h.I^ S RZYSoVmihkjl^ yn| G{ihkjwihu^!{ mn{n^`yihuojlZY{ne!^zoVmnS% %¦?^#pirumnobo[mnSmx{ e!mnw^ ( ^jo[Z%oVmnS<®¹[ ZX h e!6^ ^ ( oVUX{Yj ¥Æe!UY\]pxZXejgo$¦. . . ( &. %v- ¦?UX{ne. . . U W #
(231) *3
(232) 5% : # [ h ^7S , :\%7
(233)
(234) N ; AG%86z? #@ #8A$ x zu "78n . I h 0 >
(235) .[_$»I0 Y 8< p bAG&!7 #J"97 # k 0 , 4 L >| 888A z;$8;Py , 4 3 _ 6z*
(236) ! [ ^ [ [ ^^ U T
(237) 0 - , Y I [ [ ^^ S. Ch. -. . [ h ^ / C <
Documents relatifs
Mais elle y occupait une place modeste : il faudra la liberté et le goût de la transgression du roman en langue vulgaire pour que la situation soit renversée :
Les thèmes majeurs (tab.5.4) abordés par les îliens interrogés sont, pour la grande majorité, les mêmes sur toutes les îles : ils concernent les usages anciens
Chez l’Homme, les segments de gène V H ont été classés en sept familles (la famille 7 n’est pas représentée ici car aucun segment fonctionnel n’y a été décrit) qui ont
Le Négus consacra une énergie considérable en vue de gagner cet appui international, mais, malgré la force de son discours prononcé en juin 1936 devant ses pairs à la tribune de la
In this paper, we propose a novel approach based on the barycentric coordinates of automatically tracked 2D facial landmarks from videos to objectively evaluate the facial
Dirk Obbink (dir.), Doctrine and Doxography. Studies on Heraclitus and Pythagoras, Berlin / Boston, De Gruyter, 2013, p.. et le logos auquel les hommes devraient accorder
Les exorcismes ne sont pas publics, les sœurs noires elles-mêmes sont tenues le plus possible à l’écart, et c’est chaque fois Jeanne qui force les choses pour que, finalement,
Toute- fois, d’autres marqueurs des cellules POMC tels que NeuroD1 n’ont pas été induits dans cette expérience, ce qui indique que Tpit suffit in vivo pour provoquer la
