Sur la modélisation structurelle markovienne en fiabilité du logiciel

Texte intégral

(1)Sur la modélisation structurelle markovienne en fiabilité du logiciel James Ledoux. To cite this version: James Ledoux. Sur la modélisation structurelle markovienne en fiabilité du logiciel. [Rapport de recherche] RR-2714, INRIA. 1995. �inria-00073977�. HAL Id: inria-00073977 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073977 Submitted on 24 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Sur la mode´lisation structurelle markovienne en fiabilite´ du logiciel James Ledoux. N˚ 2714 Novembre 1995. PROGRAMME 1. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4)

(5) !"

(6) #$% '&( ( ) +*,.-// / 102 53 47698;:2<8>=?A@B.C DFEHGJIKEMLNNPO.QSRUTVEMWHX7Y[Z\OWMZ\]>EHO^`_aLbEcLbd[dfOe dgOîhkjaL^\O^ml;Ol;GKn>nSOpo O^hAE>Opo ^HOLb]kqrOZS^Hsk^HZOe NOp^mlkYg^HZ\EHYgj>]SOpo ^ DFE\GtMOZù"G>lkOd vVL_7_aGJEHZVlkOÈHOiWHX7OEcW\X>Own#xyKz>Qp{.R}|SG~JON2j>EHO1QJKRyKz#_aLIJO^. > F 1 > LS^K]> EHOpZ>OSo lkOFGJnaWMZHYgGJn>n>ONPOnkZ5O^HZ]>n>OSK]ALdgYgZ>OFo O^H^\OnkZHYgOdgdgOEHOiK]7Y[^\O_AGK]7E]>n.^\sk^HZOpe NOE>Oo _aLEMLj>dgOKi|SGJ]>^ lOo ~KOpd[GJ_>_AGKn>^FYWMY>]>n1NG>l5Ope d[OF^\ZHEH]AWMZH]>E\Od5NLbEHJG~YgOn`lOo lkYiOVo Lb]kq.^Hsk^HZOe NO^d[GJIKYWMYgOdg^pfdk_aOE\NOZFdgOSWLdWM]>dOMqaLKWZcFlkO lkYg~KOE\^HO^NOo ZHE\YK]7O^lkO^K]> EHOpZ>Omo l;OGJnaWMZ\Y[GJn>n>ONPOnkZOn1ZHOpnaLnkZWMGJN_>Z\OlkO^2Oo ~KOnkZ\]>Odg^ZHOpN_>^FlkOSEHOWGK]>~kEHOpNOnkZlkO lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO^>Op^SY[nAlkYWMO^S^HGJnkZSGKj>Z\Onk]>^V^\GK]>^S]>n7OVGKEHNPOVLnaLbdgsZ\YK]7OVOn"]>Z\Y[dgYg^cLbnkZdgO^S_>E\GK_>E\YOo Z>Oo ^`lkO^'_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^ NLE\KG~kYgOn>îha_7]>Yg^%n>GJ]>^2lkGKn>n7GKn>^.dgO^1NGsJOn>^%l;ONOpZHZHE\O2On`]>~kE\OdgO]7EOo ~KLdg]aLbZHYgGKn nk]>NOo EHYJ]>OK ONPG>l¡Oe dgO lOo WME\Y[ZSOp^HZ^H]k¢^MLNNPOnkZFIOo nSOpo EcLd5_AGK]7EYgnaWMdg]>E\OVdL`N"LtMGKE\YgZ>OVo lkO^NG>l5Ope d[Op^^\ZHEH]AWMZH]>E\Odg^SNLbEHKG~kYgOn>^WMGKn>nk]>ÔZOn _aLE\ZHYWM]>dgYgOESWMOdg]>Yl;O YgZHZHdgO£GkG>l5¤'Yg~KOpEH^HOp^VK]7O^HZ\Y[GJn>^S^HGJnkZOo ILbd[OpNOnkZLbjaGJEclOo Op^¥L#e _aLE\ZHYgE¦l§ Oq;OpN_>dgO^^HYgN_7d[Op^V¨ d§\Oo ~KLbdg]aLZ\Y[GJnfL"_>E\Y[GJEHY1lkOdf§ YgN_aLJWMZ`^H]>E1dL"^K]> E\OZ>O/o lkO2GJnaWMZ\Y[GJn>n>ONPOnkZ%lk]©d[GJIKYWMYgOdl;ONPG>lkY«ª¡WLZ\YgGKn>^`dgG>WLdgO^ l5§¬LEcW\X>YgZ\OWMZH]7EHO2lk]"^Hsk^HZOe NO.OpZml5§¬LKWZHYgGKn>^Vl;O.NLbY[nkZ\OnaLnAWMOmlkO1WMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZ\^VfLKWMZ\Y^VGK]rlkO#EHOWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZcpaOWMY Y[nAWMdg]>ZhkOn"_aLbEHZ\Y®W]>dgY[OpEhkdL`_>E\Y[^\O.OnrWMGJN_>Z\OVlkO`d®L1WME\GKYg^H^MLnaWMO1lkO'ª¡Lj>YgdgYgZ>OVo lkO.WMOpEHZcLbYgn>^mWMGJN_AGK^MLnkZHî¯Fn;ªanh>n7GK]>^ lkGKn>n7GKn>^VJ]>OdJ]>O^'_>EHGJ_>EHYiOo Z>Oo ^mLb^HskN_7ZHGKZ\YK]7O^¦l;]_7EHG>WMO^\^H]>^.lkO.lOMo fLYgdgd®LbnaWMOK °²±a³ ´Mµ¶ / ¸· ]7 EHOZ>O%o lkO`GJnaWMZ\Y[GJn>n>ONPOnkZh>u"G>l5Ope d[O.lkO YgZHZ\d[Op£GkG>l5h>DFE\G;WO^H^\]>^.u"TmDFhADFEHG>WMO^\^H]>^1lkO.WMGKNP_>ZcLbIKOKh ¹Sn>Y«GJEHNYg^MLZHYgGJnhKEHGJYg^H^cLbnaWMO.lkO`ª5Lj>YgdgYgZ>OKo hJTV_>_7EHGiq>YgNLZ\YgGKn1_aGJY[^\^HGJn>n>YgOn>n>O. º»F¼f½f¾g¿ÀpÁf¾gÂ;ÃÄ¾ÆÅÇ È5ÉKÊÌËKÍMÎÏÆÐÊÑÊFÒ\ÊÏÆÎfÍcÓMÍMÐ¬ÔKÍ1ÊHÕ ÏiÊÕ ËÎÄÊ\Õ ÖÊ×ÉÄÏiÊHÕ ÊÍØ ÔÍÙÊ×ÉKÒHÚMÉÏÆÎÊ5ÙÊHÒÛKÊfÎfÒÛKÊfÜÝgÉÑiÞKÖÏgÎÐÊAÖÆÞÎ5ÔÊHÖ5ßVÚiÑkÊfØ ÔÊ\ÖkËÎfÚMàKÍMàÐ¬Ô¬ÐÖÏÊ\ÖÊ\Ï5ßÊ\Õ ÏÛKÚiÑÊHÖ Öê ÏÍÏÆÐÖÏÆÐáÞKÊ\Ö>ÊfÉ`âKÍMàÐ¬Ô¬ÐÏiÊÕ ÑiÞ'ÔÚãMÐÒ×ÐÊfÔäåAÊHÏÏÊaæÚMÞÎÉÊHÕ ÊVÊ\Õ ÏÍÐÏ5ÒHÚMÜÚMÎfãÍMÉÐÖÊHÕ ÊAËKÍMÎ5Ôç èÖÖÚiÒfÐÍÏÆÐÚMÉËÚMÞÎ5ÔÍVéiÏÍÏÆÐÖÏÆÐáÞKÊ5Ê\Ï5ÖÊ\ÖÈÏÐ¬Ô¬ÐÖÍÏÆÐÚMÉKÖ èFéiÈë5Ê\ÏAÔç Ýì`èírÑÊíÎfÊfÉKÚàÔÊÊfÉ.î\ÞÐ¬Éïððñiä CJò ÊfÜgßVÍMÐ¬ÔÔÊ\ÑÚMÞKóôõcÞÉÐÓÜ«ÎÊ×ÉÉÄÊ\Öïpä öÎH÷pø õ\Ð¬ÎÐÖÍä ö¬ÎH÷. Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rennes IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – Te´lećopie : (33) 99 84 71 71.

(7)

(8) .$1 '&r1 "S1

(9) i0

(10) F # .-/M .

(11) ³ µ ³ X>O.lkO_AOnal>Lbj>YgdgY[ZfsPO~KLdg]aLbZHYgGKn2Yg^SL.jAL^HYW`WMGJN_AGKn>OnkZGFZHX>O.J]aLdgYgZfs1GÌL1E\O_aLbY[EMLj>dgO'^Hsk^HZ\ON, O l;O~KOdgGJ_2X>OEHO.L`NPG>lkOd>£SX>YW\XYg^j7]>Ygd[ZÌEHGJN L#urLE\KG~kYLn2lkO^cWEHYg_>ZHYgGJnGZ\X>OVjAOXaLi~kYgGKEGL#^HGZf£¦LbEHOKfZ¦Lbdgd[G£S^ Z\X>O1OMqaLJWMZcSWMGJN_>]7ZcLZ\YgGKn1G~KLbEHYgGK]7^lkO_AOnal>Lbj>YgdgY[Zfs2NPOZHE\YWM^ZMLkYgn>I.YgnkZHG2LKWWGK]>nkZSZHX7OVEHOiWMG~KOE\srlkOdLisk^ X>O^HO NPOL^\]>EHOp^ÌLbEHOIKYg~KOpn.jaGJZHX1Ygn¥Lbn%LnaLbdgsZ\YWLnal1LdgIJGKEHYgZ\X>NYgW5GKEHN/ V]7O^HZ\Y[GJn>^GbaYgnZ\OEHOp^HZLbEHOSLdg^HG`lkYg^cWM]>^\^HOl#EHGKN ^\YgN_>dgOOMqaLN_7d[Op^¨5X>G£ NYgn>GKENG>lkY«ª¡WLbZHYgGKn7^GbLEMWHX7Y[Z\OWMZ\]>EHO`GKENLbYgnZ\OnaLbnaWMOSLKWMZ\Y[GJn>^GKn"LJWMZHYg~JOVGKEEHOWMG~JOEHs> WGKN_AGKn7OnkZH^%L ¡OWZ%Z\X>O2IKdgGKjALdlkO_AOnal>Lbj>YgdgY[Zfs/GSZHX7O^Hsk^\ZHON/ XaLbZ.YgnaWMdg]alkOp^.Ygn _aLE\ZHYWM]>dLEihZ\G,WLb_>ZH]>E\OZ\X>O E\OdgYLj>YgdgYgZfs2IKEHG£SZ\XrGZHX>O1^Hsk^HZ\ON EHGKN Z\X>O%WMGJN_AGKn>OpnZ\^VGJn>OK YgnaLdgdgsh>Lb^HskN_7ZHGKZ\YWmLbnaLdgsk^HYg^SGbZHX>O2WMGJ]>nkZHYgn>I _7EHG>WMO^\^mYg^SLdg^HGLJl>lkE\O^H^\Ol5 5´ ± "! b ¤'O_AOnal>Lbj>YgdgY[Zfskh YgZHZHOpd[£GkG>l5§ ^SNG>lkOdfh>u"T`D9_>EHG>WMOp^H^hFGK]7nZ\Ygn>I2_>EHG>WMOp^H^h¹Sn>Y«GJEHN$Y #LbZHYgGKnhv!&O % dgYLj7Y[dgYgZfs.IJEHG£SZHXh>DGJYg^H^HGJnrL_>_>E\Giq>Y[N"LZ\Y[GJn.

(12)

(13) !"#$ %

(14) &' )( * + -,.'/01 2 "3)4 . 5. 1 Ì /! 2 L%WGKN_7d[Oq;YgZ>OVo lkO^V^\sk^HZOpe NO^SYgnkGJEHN"LZHYJ]>O^LJWMZH]>Opd[^Sn7Om_AOE\NOZ_aL^Vl§ Op^H_SOo E\OEV]7nWMGJnZ\EÄGJ d[O`^MLZHYg^×LYg^cLbnkZlkO d[Op]>E`^b]> E\OZ>Oo lkOGKnaWZHYgGKn>n7ONOnkZ2L2e _aLbEHZHYgE`lkO%dL1^\O]>dgO%E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZMLZHYgGJn jaG8[Z\&O %fn>GKYgEHO2lkO.dgO]7EWGKN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZ: 9'n _aO]7ZmWMGJn>^HZMLZHOpE¥L1e ZHEMLi~KOE\^mWMOpEHZcLbYgn>O^rOpo ZH]alkOp^m_7]>j>dgYOo O^VJ]>O.dL#NLtMOp]>EHO'_aLE\ZHYgO%lkO^SNPG>l¡Oe dgO^VlkO`Zfsk_aO#jaG8[Z\&O %fn>GKYgEHO _AGK]>E']>n>O%lkOp^cWME\Y[_7ZHYgGKn WMGKNP_>dOe ZHO`~JGKYgES_aLE'OMq>ON_7d[+O ;=<>Hh ; yJ >Hh ;gQK?Q >Hh ; {ky >Æn7O%lkGKn7n>O._aLb^VZHGJ]tMGJ]>EH^']>n>O Oo ~KLbdg]aLZ\Y[GJn ZHEOpe ^._>E>Oio WMYg^HOl;O^.NOp^H]>E\O^`^HZcLbnal>LbEclk^%l;O2^b]> E\OZ>Oo lkO1GKnaWMZ\YgGKn>n>OpNOnkZ O^È>Oo ^\]>dgZcLZ\^.GKj7ZHOnk]>^._AO]>~JOnkZ.ZHGJ]>Z.lkO N,O NPOmO Z\EHO`^H];¢^cLnkZ\^S^HY5GKnP^HGJ]>XaLYgZ\OV^HYgNP_>dgONOnkZFL_>_>E>Oo X>OnAlkOEV]7n>O,Oo ~KGJd[]7ZHYgGKnlkO`WMO^SYgnalkYWMOp^VlkOSª¡Lbj>YgdgY[Z>OSo ^cLbn>^ n¦Oo WMO^\^cLbY[E\ONOpnZ'On"EHOW\X>OpEcW\X>OE.]7n>OÒ^HZ\Y[N"LZ\Y[GJnZ\EOe ^'_>E>Oo WY[^\OKAfd5^§¬LIJYgZ¦l5§ ]>n7Om^\YgZH]aLbZHYgGKnP]>^H]>Opd[dgO`dgGKE\^VlkO^V_7XaL^\O^ _>E>Oo dgYgNYgnaLbYgEHO^`lkO%dLP~kYgO¥l5§ ]>n/dgGKIJY®WY[Opd LE>Oo ]>^\^HYgZHOlkOpÔo Z\]alkO^1lkO2^K]> E\OZ>O"o lkO1GJnaWMZHYgGJn>n>ONPOnkZml5§ ]>n/dgGKIKYWMYgOdVL e d§¬LbY®l;O¦lkO'NG>l5Oe dgO^lkOVZfsk_AOSjaG8[Z\&O %fn>GKYgEHO'_>EHG~kYgOnkZIOo nSOo EMLdgONOpnZlkOVdL`WMGKN2j7Y[nALYg^HGJn%lkO^VlkOp]kq Opo ZcL_AO^S^\]>Yg~KLnkZHOî 9Vn(&O ¡OiWMZH]>O1]>nrZ\EcLbY[Z\ONOpnZ_>E>Oo LdLj7d[O1lkO^ml;GKn>nSOpo O^mlkO1lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO^S_AGK]>E'Y®l;OnkZHY«ªaOE`lkO^V_7d®LbIKO^Vl;O%WMEHGJYg^H^cLbnaWMOKh lkOlOo WME\GKYg^H^MLnaWOOpAZ @GJ]lkO^\ZcLbj>Ygd[YgZ>O¥o lkO2dLª¡Lbj>Ygd[YgZ>BO o ;gQ C>HDÌ]>Yg^.GKn ^>Oo dgOWMZHYgGJn>n>OdgO2NPG;l5Oe dgO¥WMGJn>nk] _aGJ]>EO Z\EHOPd[O _>dg]>Ô¢WLKWMO`_AGK]>EEHOp_>EHG>lk]>YgE\Omdf§¬LNP_>dgO]>ElkO'd®L#ZHOpnal>LnAWMO`NYg^HOSOnOo ~kYlkOnaWMO`_aLbEdgO^Vl;GKn>nSOpo O^SdgO^_7d[]7Ê>Oo WMOnkZHOp^ fd5O^HZ'Y[NP_aGJEHZMLnkZlkO.n7GKZHOpEVK]7OmZ\GK]>Z\O^mWO^mLbnaLdgsk^HO^SGJnkZOo Z>O.o E>Oo LdgYg^>Opo O^V_AGK^\Z %fNGKE\ZHON/ DFLbE¦LbY[dgdgO]>E\^hkGJn2^HGK]7XaLYgZHO'E>Oo J]>ONPNOnkZFGKj>Z\On>YgE]>n>O`YgnkGKE\NLbZHYgGKn.N"LKWME\GK^MWMGK_>YJ]>O'^H]>ES^\GKn^\sk^HZOpe NO¥L#e _aLbE % ZHYgEVlkO.WMGKn7naLYg^H^MLnaWO^VNPY®WEHGK^MWMGK_7Y®J]>Op^VfW¬L>¬l5>L]Pn>Yg~KOLb]lk]rWMGJN_AGK^MLnkZcp¯Fn"_aLbEHZ\Y®W]>dgY[OpEhkGKnrlOpo ^HYgEHO.WMGJn>naL8gZ\EHO d§ YgN_ALKWMZ'^H]>E1dgO2^Hsk^HZOe NO2IJd[GJjaLdl5§HOo ~KOnkZ\]>OdgdgO^¥LJWMZHYgGJn>^%lkO2N"LYgnkZHOnaLbnaWMO2GJ]lkO2NYg^HOrL.e tMGJ]>E%lkO"WMGKNP_aGJ^cLbnZ\^ O2Zfs_AOl5§¬LZ\ZHOnkZ\O2O^HZ.diOo IJYgZHYgNO.dgGJEH^cJ]>O2dgO1dgGKIKYWMYgOdFO^\Z%Opn,_>XAL^HOPGK_SOpo EcLZ\YgGKn>n>Opd[dgOK5DFLE#OMq>ON_>dgOKhAGJn ^HGK]7XaLYgZHO ~KLdgYlkOE1]>n>ONPG>lkY«ª¡WLZ\YgGKn dgG>WLdgOlkO"^HZ\EH]aWZH]>E\OlkOp^2GK_SOo EMLZ\Y[GJn>^2lkO"EHOWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZl5§¬LKWMZ\Yg~YgZ>Oo lk]©^Hsk^HZOe NO"GK] lOo ZHOpEHNYgn>OpE.dgO2n>Yg~KOLb]lkO2_AOE×GKE\NLnAWMO2nSOo WMOp^H^cLbYgEHOLPe ]>nWMGKNP_aGJ^cLbnZ`_AGK]>E1LNOpo d[YgGJEHOE'^HOn>^\Ygj>dgONOnkZ.dLP^K]7 EHOZ>O o lkO`GJnaWMZHYgGJn>n>ONPOnkZSIKdgGKjaLbdgO%OZV_ALEVdHL e %N,O NOS^>Oo dgOWMZHYgGJn>n>OE.dgO^'_aLE\ZHYgO^`lk]rdgGKIJY®WY[OpdK]7YÌl;GKYg~KOnkZ.O Z\EHO1_>EHYgGJEHYgZcLbY % EHONPOnkZmE\O~k]>O^M O2_>dg]>^`YgN_AGKE\ZcLnkZih>On/_aLE\ZHYWM]>dgYgOE._AGK]7El;O^._>E\GKj>dfOe NPO^.lkO¥WG]> Zih5O^HZ1lkO2_aGJ]>~KGJYgEV&O 5OWMZ\]>OE WMO^"Oo ~KLbd[]ALZHYgGJn>^L#_>EHYgGKE\YfhW§ O^\Z%L%e l;Y[E\OV_>E>Oo LdLbj>dgONOnkZmL#e ZHGJ]>ZHO'NG>lkY«ª¡WLbZHYgGKn1&O 5OWMZ\Y[~JO%lk]P^Hsk^HZOe NOK>¤'O'_>dg]>^hJdgO^ WMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZ\^l;O^%IJEcLbnalk^.^\s^\ZOe NPO^1d[GJIKYWMYgOdg^È>Oo ~5Oe dgOnkZ1IOo nSOo EcLbd[OpNOnkZ.lkO^2WMGKNP_aGJEHZ\ONOnkZ\^l;OlOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO2ZHEOe ^ lkY mOo E\OnkZHîDLbE.OMq>ONP_>dgOKh5dgGKE\^cJ]§ Ygd[^`^\GKnkZ._>dLKWAOo ^¥l7Ln>^.]7nOnk~kYgEHGKn7n>ONOpnZ.lkOPZfsk_aO2_>XAL^HOPGK_SOpo EcLZ\YgGKn>n>Opd[dgOKhY[dg^ EHO_>E>Oo ^HOpnZ\OnkZ"]>n On>^\ON2j>dgOl5§ OnkZ\Y[Z>Oo ^1^HGK]7NYg^HO^"L,e lkOp^¥WMGJnalkYgZHYgGJn>^%lkO"^HGJdgd[YWMYgZMLZHYgGJnrZHGJZcLdgONPOnkZ%lkY mOo EHOnkZ\O^lkO WMOdgdgO^%YgNP_aGJ^>Oo O^.l>Lbn>^1d[Op^._>XaLb^HO^1_>E>Opo d[YgNPY[nALYgEHO^`l5§ YgnZ>Oo IKEMLZ\Y[GJnDFLE1WMGKn>^>Oo J]>OnkZhFdgO2_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^lkO"lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO lk],^\sk^HZOpe NO.O^\Z`GJEHZHOpNOnkZmlOo _aOpnal>LnkZ.lkO1dL2^HZ\EH]aWZH]>E\OYgnkZHOE\n>O¥l§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJnlk]/dgGKIJY®WY[OpdkfdlkOp~YgOnkZ.LdgGJEH^VnAL% ZH]>E\Od¦l§ YgnkZHE\G>lk]>YgEHO1]>n>O"WMGKn>nALYg^H^MLnaWMO2^\]>E1^cLP^HZ\EH]aWMZ\]>EHOrLÄªanlkO2NYgO];q(Lb_>_>E>Oo X>Onal;OE%^\GKnWMGJN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZ L WMGKnkZHE\&O %f_aLE\ZHYgO,Oo ~kY®l;OnkZHOVOp^HZSdL`nSOo WO^H^\Y[Z>O%o lkO`WMGKdgdgOWMZ\OEVlkO^SlkGKn7n¦Oo O^SjAOL]AWMGK]>_"_>dg]>ÊHYW\X>O^VJ]>Oml7Ln>^dL`_>EHOpNYOe EHO L_>_>E\G>WHX7O_AGK]>E Opo ~KLdg]>OE.]7n ZHOdNG>l5Oe dgOKOZHZ\OL_7_>EHG>W\X>OjAGÄ8gZ\&O %j7d®LbnaW\X>O2_AOEHNPOZ%lkO2_>E\OnalkE\O"On WMGJN_>Z\O¥l;O^ lOo _AOnal>LbnaWMO^POnkZHEHO"WMGKNP_aGJ^cLbnZ\^%lkOPZfs_AO1GJnaWMZHYgGJn>n>OdgdgO^2fL^H^\G>WMYOo O^Le d®LP^\ZHEH]AWMZH]>E\O,lk] ^\s^\ZOe NPO#OZ%lkOPZfs_AO ^HZHG>W\XaLb^HZHYJ]>O^`dgYOo O^%L1e dL1^K]7 EHOZ>O¥o lkO'GJnaWMZ\Y[GJn>n>ONPOnkZ L1NG>lOo dgYg^cLbZHYgGKn2_aLbESIKEML_>X>O1l5§HOo ZcLbZH^h7Onr_aLbEHZ\Y®W]>dgY[OpES_aLE lkO^mW\XaLi8gn>O^VlkO%u(LEHJG~"Surph>E\O^HZ\O.dL1NOo Z\X>G>lkOVdL#_>dg]>^VWMGK]7EcLnkZ\O.OZVdL#_>dg]>^VLKl7L_>Z>Oo O`_aGJ]>EVZ\On>YgEVWMGKNP_>ZHO`lkO WMO^.lkO]kq/Zfs_AO^.lkO2lOo _AOnal>LbnaWMOD^ ; 5J >Ha¯FdgdgO%LWGKn>nk]r]>n(O^H^\GKE%WMGJn>^HYlOpo EcLj7d[O1OnrEMLYg^HGJn,lkO1^cLIKEcLbnalkO%WpL_aLJWMYgZ>O o lkO.EHOp_>E>Oo ^\OnkZcLbZHYgGKn lk],WMGJN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZ¦lkO#n>GKN2j>E\O]kq"^Hsk^HZOe NO^'NLbZ>Oo E\Y[Opd[î O.NPG>l¡Oe dgOVN"LEHJG~kY[OpnO^\ZV]>nrGJ]>ZHYgd EHOdLZ\Yg~KONPOnkZ5^HYgN_>dgOF_AGK]>EFdgOJ]>Od>GJn%lkYg^H_AGK^\O¦l;On>GJN2j>EHOp]kq.E>Oo ^\]>dgZcLZ\^FZHXSOo GJEHYJ]>OÔpZdgGJIKYWMYgOdg^Mfdk_AO]>Z2Oo IkLdgONPOnkZ O ZHE\O.]>ZHYgdgYg^>OSo _AGK]>ESE>Oo LdgYg^HOpEVlkO^VLnALdgsk^HO^SlkO.WMG]7 Z`NOp^H]>E\OmlkO`_AOEfGJEHN"Lj>YgdgYgZ>EO o ; C>k¯FnkªanhkYgd5n§ O^\Z_AL^SYgnk]>ZHYgdgOVlkO EcL_7_aOdgOE1K]7O.jaGJn,n7GKN2j>E\Ol;O%NPG;l5Oe dgO^mlkO1Zfsk_aO1jAGÄ8gZH&O %fn>GJY[E\OdgO^`NG>l5Oe dgO.G| F'DD_ALEÒMq>ON_7d[OiSEHOp_aGJ^HOnkZ.^\]>E d[O.WLbEcLJWMZOe E\O%N"LE\KG~kYgOn¥l;]n7GKN2j>E\OmlkO%lOMo LYgdgdLnaWO^GJj>^HOpEH~Oo O^`GK]rlkO'Lb]>ZHOp^SE>Oo ^\Y®l;]>OdgdgO^.~KGKYgEE ;gQKQ >Hh ; {"y > §¬LKlkGJ_>ZHYgGKn2l5§ ]>n>OSNPG>lOo dgYg^cLZ\YgGKn.^\ZHEH]AWMZH]>E\OdgdgOmE\O_AGK^HO.LbY[n7^HY>^\]>E¦l;O]kqL_>_AGKE\ZH^SLZHZ\Onalk]7^¦l5§ ]>n2Z\Od5WHX7GKY«q¨b]>n>O Y[n;GKE\NLZ\YgGKnWGKdgdgOWMZ>Opo O,Le _ALEHZ\YgEl;O%^\GKn NG>l5Ope d[O.lkO2NPOYgdgd[Op]>EHO%J]aLbdgY[Z>O.o IKELK WMO,Le ]>n>O2_>dg]>^ÌJEcLnAlkO%E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZMLZHY % ~YgZ>Oo lk] WMGJN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZl;] ^Hsk^HZOe NO2E>Oo OdSOZ1]>n ILbYgn ^HOn>^\Ygj>dgOOnJ]aLbnZ\YgZ>Oo l5§ YgnkGJEHNLbZHYgGKn"IJEÄLK WOL"e ]>n IJEcLbY[n lkO"NG>lOo dgYg^cLbZHYgGKnLÄ¢n¦OKo § GJjKtMOZlkOrWMOZ\ZHO/_>E>Opo ^HOnkZcLbZHYgGKn9O^\ZlkO(NGKnkZ\EHOE2J]>O"d[O"NPG;l5Oe dgO_>E\GK_AGK^>O"o E>Oo _aGJnal L e WMO^2LZHZ\OnkZHO^1^HGJ]>^1E>Oo ^\OEH~JOJ]§ Ygd^HGJY[Z.LJl>L_>Z>Oo Lb],^\s^\ZOe NPOWMGKn7^HYlOo E>OKo GKNPNO`n>GK]7^.n>GK]7^.YgnZ>Oo EHOp^H^HGJn>^2YWMYLb]kq NG>l5Oe dgO^'NLE\KG~kYgOn>^Vlk]/WMGKNP_aGJEHZHOpNOnkZml§ ]7nr^Hsk^HZOe NO1dgGKIJY®WY[Opdhkn7GK]>^`_>E>Oo ^HOnkZ\GKn>^2l>Ln7^VdL2_>E\G>WHXALYgn>O1^HOWMZ\YgGKn K]7OdK]7O^mWMGJn>^>Oio K]7OnaWMO^2l5§ ]>n"ZHOpdÌW\X>GJY«qhAJ]>O.df§ ]>ZHYgdgYg^cLZ\O]>E_aGJ]>EHEMLWMGJnkE\GKnkZHOEL1e dL1E>Oio LdgYgZ>O%o lkO#^HGKn(^Hsk^HZOe NOK L n 5(_>EHGJ_aGJ^HO"]>n>OOo ZH]AlkOrEHOpd®LbZHYg~KOpNOnkZ%WMGJN_>dfOe Z\Ol5§ ]>nNPG>l¡Oe dgO2^HZ\EH]aWMZ\]>EHOpdVNLbEHJG~YgOn lOo ~JOdgGK_>_SOo l7Ln>^ · OWMZ\Y[GJH ; yb{ >H>O%lkOE\n>YgOEVYgnaWMdg]>îh>On(_aLE\ZHYWM]>dgYgOEh7dgOmNPG>l¡Oe dgOVN"LEHJG~kY[OpnlkO YgZ\ZHdgO£GG>I l ;¬yKz >K]7Y5EHO^\ZHO1d[O`_>dg]>^`WMYgZ>O%o l7Ln>^ 6. 7. ÙÙ É.JGK4LïM.

(15) {. ) ' . dL#dgY[Z\Z>Oo EMLZ\]>EHOK5|!GK]>^Sn§¬LbjaGJEclkGJn>^S_aL^'YWMY5df§ Lb_>_>E\G;W\X>O#^HZHE\]aWMZ\]>EHOdgdgO%lOpo ~KOdgGK_7_¦Oo O2L] T'T · ;¬yKy>Hh;[Qi>H · GJn,L_7_aGJEHZ Op^H^HOpnZ\YgOd^HO#^HYgZH]>O1l>Ln>^SdL1_>E\Yg^HO.On/WMGKNP_>ZHO.lkO.dL2WME\GKYg^H^MLnaWO¥lkO'ª¡Lbj>YgdgY[Z>O.o lk]r^Hsk^\ZOe NPOL1e _ALEHZ\YgEmlkO%WOdgd[O1lkO.^HOp^ WGKN_AGK^MLnkZHî OPNG>l5Oe dgOrL e Opo ZcLZ\^%Op^HZ1IOo nSOpo E>O"o _aLE1]>n GJ]>ZHYgdSlkONPG;lOo dgY[^MLZ\Y[GJnr^HZMLnal7LEcl²L"e ^cLi~JGKYgE`dgO^¥v"Oo ^HOiL]kq l;O%DOZHE\Y /Oo nSOpo EcLdgYg^>Opo ^5¯Fn · OiWMZHYgGKn({ah>n7GK]>^'~KOE\EHGKn7^J]§ Ygd5O^\ZmZ\GK]>Z2L#e LYgZS_AGK^\^HYgj>dgO%lkO1EHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZHOEihl>Lbn>^Vn7GKZHE\O NPG>l¡Oe dgOKhi]>n2ZHOpd5_>XSOo n>GJN,Oe n7OLè _ALEHZ\YgElkOSdf§¬L_>_>E\G>WHX7OVlkOVZ\EcLn7^fGJEHNLbZHYgGKn1lkO Lb_>EHYgOSOZSLdf Te _ALEHZ\YgElkOS^HYgZ\]aLZ\Y[GJn>^ ^\YgN_>dgOîhdL · OWMZHYgGJn2{%L_>_AGKE\ZHOEML%l;Y[~JOEH^WMGKNPNOnkZcLbYgEHO^F^H]7EdL`^HOn7^HYgj>YgdgY[Z>OVo lkOSdL`^K]7 EHOZ>Omo lkO!GKnaWZHYgGKn>n7ONOnkZl5§ ]>n ^\sk^HZOpe NO%Lè WMOE\ZcLYgn>Op^NPG;l;Yª5WLZ\Y[GJn>^NPYWMEHGJ^cWMGJ_>YK]7O^FOZ^H]7Edf§ Lb_>_>E\Giq;YgN"LZHY«GKnhM^\]>IKIOo E>Opo Oml>Lbn>G^ ;¬yKz >HhKlk]1_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^ l§ G>WW]>EHE\OnaWMO2lkO^`lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO^_aLES]>n"NPG;l5Oe dgOV_AGKYg^H^\GKn>n>YgOn F` 2+

(16) .$1 '&r r §HOpo ~KLdg]aLZ\YgGKnlkOPd®L(^K]7 EHOZ>O,o lkOPGKnAWMZHYgGKn7n>ONOpnZ1l5§ ]>n^\s^\ZOe NPO_aLb^H^\OrZHEOe ^2^HGJ]>~KOnkZ2_aLbE%df§¬LKl;GK_>Z\Y[GJnl5§ ]>n>O E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZMLZHYgGJnNLbEHKG~kYgOn>n7O¥lkO"^\GKn WGKN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZ.GK]9lkOÔo ~KOnkZ\]>OdgdgO^WLEMLKWMZ>Oo EHYg^\ZHYJ]>OÊ\OZHOpn]7O^_AGK]>E2dgO WpLdWM]>dlkOp^SY[nAlkYWMO^VlkO'ª¡Lbj>Ygd[YgZ>OKo |!GK]>^VLbdgd[GJn>ÊML_>_AOdgOEVj7EHYOe ~KOpNOnkZd[Op^VWMGKnkZHEMLYgnkZHO^SYg^\^H]>O^Vl§ ]7nZHOpdW\X>GKY«qk|SGK]7^ ^\]>_>_AGK^\OEHGJn>^"Y®WYmJ]>OrdgOr^\s^\ZOe NPOrGK]9dgO^PIKEcLbnalkO]7EH^rl5§ YgnZ>Oo EOp ZOo ~JGKdg]>OnkZ2OnZ\ON_7^WMGJnZ\Ygn]hdgO"ZHONP_>^ Oo ZcLbnkZ E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZ>Oro _aLE#d§ On7^HON2j>dg O ;

(17) ;AdgO]>E Oo ZMLZrLPe d§ Ygn>^\ZcLnkZ .O^HZ2lOo WEHYgZ%_ALE.]>n7O~KLE\YLj>dgO2LdOo LZ\GKYgEH O 9'nrî§ Y[nkZ>Oo EHO^\^HOLbd[GJEH^`L]r_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^.^\ZHG>W\XaL^\ZHYJ]> O H ¦Afd^HOEMLWpLEcLJWMZ>Opo EHYg^>O2o _aLbE`d[O#ZHONP_>^S_aL^\^>O2o l>Ln7^ W\XaLJJ]>OOo ZcLbZOZdgO^NOo WLbn>Yg^HNPO^lkOSZ\EcLbn>^HYgZHYgGJn%OnkZ\EHOVdgO^lkY mOo EHOpnZ\Ôpo ZcLZ\^ §\Oo ~JGKdg]>ZHYgGJn%lk]2_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^ Lb]¥WGK]>E\^ l;]%Z\ON_>Ô^HZNLE\KG~kYgOn>n>O^HYL'e ZHGK]7ZHOSl>LZ\O hdgO_aL^\^>OVo lk]1_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^n§ Yg"n !A]>OOpn%E\Y[Opn%^\]>E^HGJn.]>ZH]>EiTV]7ZHEHOpNOnkZ l;Y[ZihOpo ZcLnkZSlkGKn7n¦Oò ^HGKnOo ZcLbZ¦LJWMZH]7O#d hkdgO!]>ZH]7E¦lk]P_>EHG>WMOp^H^H]7^.dgO^~KLdgO]7EH^Slk$O &%2_AGK]>(E '*)+cO^\ZSYgnalOo _AOnal>LbnkZ l;OmdL2WMGJn>naLbY[^\^cLbnaWMO%lk$O %_AGK]>$E '*,- § OMq>ONP_>dgOGKnal7LNOpnZMLd5J]>Y^\OEcL2lOpo ~KOdgGK_7_¦O.o On · OWZHYgGKn 5P~KGJY[EE ;¬yKz > Op^HZWMOpd[]7Yal5§ ]>n1^Hsk^HZOe NOSdgGKIJYWMYgOdlOio WMGKNP_aGJ^cLj7d[OOn2]>n7OLbNYgdgdgOlkOSNPG;l;]>dgO^) 9'n%^\]>_>_AGK^\OmJ]§LVe W\XaLJK]7OVl>LZ\.O ]>n ^\O]>dFNG>lk]7d[O'^§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHOK 9'n,lOMo ªan>YgZVLdgGJEH/^ _aLE'd§ YlkOnkZ\Y[Z>O.o lk]rWMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZVLJWMZHY«mL1e df§ Ygn>^\ZcLbn0Z 1 EHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZHO l;GKnaWd§\Oo ZMLZ%WGK]>EMLnkZ¥l;]_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^l5§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn¤`Ln7^%]>n Z\OdVWMGJnZ\OMq>ZHOKhF^\(Y O^HZ1^H]>_7_aGJ^>O"o NLbEHKG~kYgOn WMOdL YgNP_>dgY®J]>O1K]7O2d§ YlkOnkZ\Y[Z>O¥o l;O^%NPG>lk]>dgO^.J]>Y^\OEHGJnkZ%G>WWM]7_¦Oo ^,LPe _aLE\ZHYgE2l5§ ]>n>Ol>LbZH2O '3)4.O^HZ1YgnalOo _AOnal7LnkZHO"lkO df§ YlkOnkZHYgZ>O¥o lkOp^.NG>lk]>dgO^'OMq¦Oo WM]>Z>Oo ^LnkZ>Oo EHYgO]>E\ONOpnZ"L e 1Yf OLPe ]>n Ygn>^\ZcLbn5Z '+,6cp¹SnLb]>ZHE\O2OMq>ON_7d[O2WMGJn>^HYg^HZ\O L2e Lb^H^\G;WY[Op/E L]"n>GKN2j7EHOml;O%lOMo LbYgd[dLbnaWMO^SE\OWMOn>^>Oo O^StM]>^MK]§®L#e dL2l>LZ\$O a¹!n>O.Xksk_aGJZHXOpe ^HO.N"LEHJG~kY[Opn>n>OVE\O~kYgOnkZ L(e WMGKn>^\Yl¡Oe EHOpEK]7OdgOn>GJN2j>EHO2lkO"lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO^%J]>OPd§ GJnL]>EMLrWMGKdgdgOWMZ>Oo L"e ]7n>Ol>LbZH7O '8)9hFWMGJn>naLYg^\^cLnkZ.df§\Oo ZMLZ LJWMZH]7Odlk],WMGJN_>Z\O]>EhkOp^HZ`YgnalOo _AOnal>LbnkZmlkO^`~KLbd[Op]>EH^VlkO1WMO¥WGKN_7ZHO]>E%L1e ]7n>O%l>LbZHO%LbnZ>Oo EHYgO]7EHOr:L e aurLbY[nkZ\OnaLnkZih GJn_AO]>Z9Oo ZMLj>dgYgE%lkOp]kq¸WMdLb^H^HOp^lkONPG;l5Oe dgO^%N"LE\KG~kYgOn>â¨FdgO^2W\XaL8gn>Op^¥lkOrurLbEHJG~,X>GJNGJIaOe n>Op^2S2 u F'1OZ1d[Op^ W\XaLi8gn>O^Sn>GJn %X7GKNGJIaOe n7O^VfSurG| F' . . ; <>=. ?A@/B1CD>EFHGF6IJBLKM.N#OP@/N0QRN.SFUT E/F. u F²Ygn>YgZHYLbd[Yg^>Oo O^l>Lbn>^S]>nOo ZcLbZª>q¦OVo ^HGJnkZ^\ZHG>W\XaL^\ZHYJ]>ONOpnZSYlkOpn% GK]7ZHO^SdgO^_>XaLb^HO^Vl5§ GJj>^HOE\~KLZ\Y[GJnl5§ ]>n7OmS2 Z\YK]7O^1Yf O%lkO]kqr_AOEH^\GKn>n7O^%GJj>^HOpEH~KLnkZ'd®LPSu2F L2e _aLbEHZ\Y[E`lk]rN,O NO/Oo ZMLZ`NLbY[^_aLb^l;O.dL2N,Op NOml7LZHO1~KOpEHEHGJnkZ ^\ZHG>W\XaL^\ZHYJ]>ONPOnkZdLVN,O NOWHX7GK^HOikTV]7ZHEHOpNOnkZlkYgZihZHGJ]>ZHO`l>LZ\O ÌOp^HZ]>n>OVl>LbZHOml;OSE>Oo IOo nSOo EMLZHYgGJnrGJ]lkOSEHOpn>GK]% ~JOdgdgONOnkZMlk]"_>EHG>WMOp^H^H]7^5OZHZ\O`_>EHGJ_>EHYiOo Z>O%o l5§¬Lj>^\OnaWMO.lkO`NOo NGJY[E\OZ\ON_AGKE\OdgdgOVYgN_>dgYJ]>OSK]7Om^\Y5GKn"WMGKNPNOnaWO L1e GJj>^HOpEH~KOpEVdgO`_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^#_aOnAl>LnkZmJ]>O.WMOpd[]7Y %HWMY^>Oo tMGJ]>EHn7O%l>Ln7^V]>n²Oo ZMLZml;GKn>nSOJo h>dL%l;]>E>Oo O2lk]"^>Oo tMGK]>E`J]>O`d§ GJn~KL NPO^H]7EHOEÒ^\Z.^HZ\G;W\XaLb^HZ\Y®J]>OpNOnkZVYlkOpnZ\YK]7OLPe WMOdgdgOK]7O%df§ GKnrL]7EcLYgZ'GKj>^\OEH~Oo OP^HYFdLl>LbZHO1Y[n7Y[Z\YLdgO.l5§ GKj>^\OEH~KLbZHYgGKn Li~KLbYgZ¦WMG V8gnaWMYlO%o Li~JOW.WMOdgdgO%lkO#d§ OnkZ\E>Oo O%l;]r_>EHG>WMOp^H^H]7^l7Ln>^'d§\Oo ZMLZi L2l;Y[^\ZHE\Y[j7]>ZHYgGKnrlk](ZHONP_>^VlkO.^>Oo tMGK]7E W9l>Ln7^ ]7n Opo ZcLZS_AGK^\Ôe l;O¥lkGJnaW'dL._>E\GK_>E\YOo Z>O%o Wd®Lb^H^\Y®J]>O.lkYgZ\Ol§ Lbj>^HOpnaWMO%lkO#NOo NPGKYE\O D!X WZY-13'\[WZ)-cL D!X WZY]'A_ ^ DGJ]>EVZ\GK]>Z\O%S2 u FP`\^HZMLnal>LbEc"l aWOWMYYgN_7d[YJ]>OVJ]>O.dL2lkYg^\ZHEHYgj>]7ZHYgGKnrlkO W©O^HZ`nSOo WO^H^MLYgEHONPOnkZÒMq>_aGJn>OnkZHYgOdgdgO.OZih _ALESWMGKn>^>Oo J]>OnkZhAJ]>O`d[O'ZcLb]kqlkO`^HGJEHZHYgO.lkO'd§\Oo ZMLZO^HZS]7n>O.WMGKn>^\ZcLbnZ\O.K]7Y5n>OmlOpo _aOnAlrJ]>OmlkO`df§ YlkOnkZHYgZ>OVo l;Omdf§\Oo ZMLZ G>WW]>_SOKo A¯FnZ\OEHNPO^VlkOV^K]> EHOpZ>O%o lkO!GKnAWMZHYgGKn7n>ONOpnZ]>n>O.WMGKn7^>Oo J]>OnAWMO.GKnal>LbNOnkZMLdgOOp^HZVJ]>OV^\Y5]>nW\XaLbn>IKOpNOnkZ l§HOpo ZcLZ`_AO]>ZO ZHE\OdgYOo L"e df§ G>WWM]>E\EHOnaWOl5§ ]>n>OlOMo LYgdgdLnaWOKhAd[O1ZcLb]kql5§ G;WpWM]>EHE\OnaWMO"lkOWMOdgdg&O %HWMYO^HZ.nSOo WMO^\^cLYgE\ONOnkZ ÝcbÙÝÆè.

(18)

(19) !"#$ %

(20) &' )( * + -,.'/01 2 "3)4 . . ]>n>O%WMGJn>^HZMLnkZHO1YgnalOo _AOnal7LnkZHO%l;]rZHONP_>^>GJNNPOSZHGK]7ZHO%l>LbZHO.Op^HZV]7nr_aGJYgnZVl;O.E>Oo IOo nSOo EMLZ\Y[GJnr_AGK]>E']>n>O%Su2F#h n>GK]>^S_AGK]7~KGKn7Ôo ILbd[OpNOnkZOn"ZHYgEHOE`l5§¬L]>Z\EHO^VWGKnaWMdg]>^\YgGKn>î · YAGKnPGKj>^\OEH~JO.dL.W\XaL8gn>O'^HO]7d[OpNOnkZd[GJEH^SlkO^VW\XaLbn>IKONPOnkZH^Sl5§HOo ZcLbZh>W\XaLJWM]>n>O.lkO`WMO^ml7LZHOpÔo ZcLbnZ]>nP_aGJY[nkZ lkOE>Opo IOo nSOpo EcLZ\YgGKnhdL!_>EHGJjaLj>YgdgYgZ>Oo l;OZ\EcLn7^HYgZHOEl5§ ]>n Oo ZMLZ A~JOEH^F]>nOo ZcLbZ VO^HZ]7n>O¦WGKn>^\ZcLnkZ\OVK]7Yn7OVlOo _AOnal J]>O.lkO^'YlkOnkZHYgZ>Opo ^ FOZ 2lkO^ml;O]kq Opo ZcLZ\^ O^rlk]>E>Opo O^,lkO^(^>Oo tMGJ]>EH^(^H]aWWO^H^\Y^,l>Ln7^]7n Oo ZMLZrlkGJn>nSO(o GKE\NOnkZ2]>n>O ^\]>YgZHO lkO/~KLEHYLbj>dgO^LbdOio LZHGJYgEHO^ YgnalOpo _aOnAl>LnkZHOp^hSOio K]7Y®l;Y[^\ZHE\Y[j7]¦Oo O^S^\OdgGKn]7n>O`d[GJY>OMq>_AGKn>OnkZ\Y[Opd[dgO.lkO'_aLEMLN,Ope ZHEHO'n>OmlOo _aOpnal>LnkZVJ]>O.lkO'd§\Oo ZMLZ G>WWM]7_¦OKo hAOZSOdgdgO^S^HGJnkZSY[nAlOo _AOnal>LbnZ\O^.lkO^SZ\ON_>^Vl;Om^>Oo tMGJ]>Eml>Lbn>^S]>nrL]7ZHEHO/Oo ZMLZi · Yan7GK]>ÊHO_7EHOn>GJn>^VWMGJNNOOMq>ON_>dgOVlkO'NG>l5Oe dgOSN"LEHJG~kY[OpnhdgOV_7EHG>WMO^\^H]>^`l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJnl5§ ]>n2dgGJIKYWMYgOd>NPG;l;]>dLYgEHO lOMo ªan>Y_aLE YgZHZHdgO£GkG>l5hkYgd5_aGJ^HÔie lkO%LdgGJEH^SdgO^VlkO];qWLbEcLKWZ>Oo E\Y[^\ZHYJ]>O^`^H]7Y[~KLbnkZHOî L.^>Oo dgOWMZHYgGJn,lk]"_>EHG>W\XaLbY[n"NPG;l;]>dgO%L1e OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\OE`n>O.lOo _AOnalrJ]>O.lk]"NG>lk]7d[O`LKWMZ\]>OdgdgONOpnZSLKWZHYg~OKo O^%Z\ON_7^l§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJn l5§ ]>n NPG;l;]>dgO.n>OlOo _aOpnalkOnkZJ]>OlkOPd§ YlkOnkZ\Y[Z>O¥o l;]NG>lk]7d[OJafdg^.^\GKnkZ.YgnalOpo _aOn % l>LbnkZH^lkOp^SZHONP_>^l5§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHYgGKnLb^H^HG>WMYiOo ^VLb]kq2NG>lk]>dgO^F_>E>Oo WAOo lkOpNNOpnZLKWMZ\Y[~Oo ÔZSlkGKnAWSOnP_aLE\ZHYWM]>dgYgOELb]kq NPG;l;]>dgO^¦LiskLnkZOo ~KOnkZ\]>OdgdgONOnkZ_>EHG~JG>K]SOmo df§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHYgGKnrlk]"NG>lk]7d[OVLJWMZHY«c T'Ygn>^HYfh>df§ X>GJNGKIOo nSOo YgZ>Omo lkO.dL2W\XaLi8[n7O%lkO2urLE\KG~^\]>IKIaOe EHO1]>n>O#^HZcLbj>YgdgY[Z>Oò ZHONP_aGJEHOdgdgO.lkO%Z\GK]>^'dgO^V_aLbEcLbN,Oe Z\EHO^ E>Oo IJY[^\^cLbnZ`dgO^`ZHOpN_>^`lkO.^>Oo tMGK]>E.l>Lbn>^`dgO^,Oo ZcLbZH^ÒZ`dgO^VNOo WLn7Y[^\NO^Vl;O%Z\EcLn7^HYgZHYgGKn(OnkZHEHO9Opo ZcLZ\^1_aLbEmWMGJn>^>Oo J]>OpnZ ]>n>O^\ZcLbj>Ygd[YgZ>O¥o lkOPZHGJ]>^.dgO^1_aLEMLN,Ope ZHEHOp^%lkOlOMo fLYgdgd®LbnaWMO^MFOZHZ\OWMdLb^H^HO"lkO2NG>l5Ope d[O1O^\Z¥lkGJnaWLb_>_>E\GK_>E\YOpo O_AGK]>E lOo WME\Y[E\O]>n/^Hsk^\ZOe NPO%On/^HYgZ\]aLZ\Y[GJnl;O.ª¡Lbj>YgdgY[Z>O.o ^HZMLj>YgdgYg^>Oo 2 O ;¬y7Q >ÌOpZ.GK_SOpo EcLnkZ.l>Lbn>^`]>n,Opn~kYgEHGJn>n>ONPOnkZ`X>GKNPGKIaOpe n>O Li~KOW'dgO`ZHONP_>^ ;<;. ?A@/BUCD>EFHGF6IJBLKM.N O EN.E @/N.Q N.SF1T EF DGJ]>EV]>n7O%Sur|GF#h>^\Y#V O^\ZVdL2l>LZ\O%WMGJ]>EcLbnZ\O%l5§ GKj7^HOE\~KLZHYgGJnhkdf§ YgnkGKEHN"LZ\YGKn2nSOo WMO^\^cLYgE\OL1e dL2lOo Z\OEHNPYgnaLZ\Y[GJn. lk]9]>Z\]>El;]_>EHG>WMOp^H^H]7^lOpo _aOnAl lkO(d§ YlkOnkZ\Y[Z>O,o lkOrdf§\Oo ZMLZLJWMZH]7Odgd[OpNOnkZ2G>WWM]>_SO,o OZrlk] ZHONP_>Ôo WGK]>diO,o lkOp_>]>Yg^ d§ Ygn>YgZHYLbd[Yg^MLZHYgGnVlk]`_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^SLe ^cLi~KGJYgElkOLcpfd^§¬LIJYgZlkGKnaWlkOFNG>l5Oe dgO^lkGJnkZ5d[Op^_aLbEcLN,Oe ZHE\O^Lb^H^\G;WYOpo ^L];qmZHOpN_>^ lkO^>Oo tMGK]>EFOZFL]kq.Z\EcLn7^HYgZHYgGKn7^5OnkZHEHOPOo ZMLZH^F_AO]>~JOnkZÌlOo _aOpnalkEHOVl;]mZ\ON_7^.Oo WMGJ]>dOo lkO_7]>Yg^df§\Oo ZMLZ5Ygn>YgZHYLdgONPOnkZ>G>WWM]>_SO o _aLE2dgO"_>EHG>WMOp^H^H]7^,Yf *O ifdg^2ZHEcLJlk]>Yg^HOpnZ2]7n>Orn>GJn %X7GKNGJIOo nSOo YgZ>Oo lkO^P_aLEMLN,Oe ZHE\O^2E>Oo IJYg^H^cLbnkZ2d®L/lksknaLbNYJ]>O lk]NPG;l5Oe dgOKOpd®L(_aLbEcL8gZ1ZHGJ]>ZLe LbY[Z2LZ\ZHEMLKWMZ\Y.lk]_AGKYgnkZ2lkO"~]7OlkO"dL"NG>lOpo d[Yg^MLZHYgGJn,_AGK]>E2E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZ\OE"]>n>O n>GKn %f^HZMLj>YgdgYgZ>OKo h_aLE1OMq>ON_7d[OJhlkOp^%_aLbEcLbN,Oe Z\EHO^2lkOlOMo LYgdgdLnaWO"WME\GKYg^H^MLnaWMOJhlOo WME\GKYg^H^MLnaWMO/lkO2ª¡Lbj>YgdgY[Z>Oo `GJ] ]>n>O n>GKn %fX>GJNGKIOo nSOo YgZ>O¥o lkOPdf§ Opn~kYgEHGJn>n>ONPOnkZ.l>Ln>^1dgOJ]>OdOo ~KGJdg]>O2dgO2^Hsk^HZOe NOKOp_aOnAl>LnkZhFGJn O^HZ1ZHEOe ^2~kYgZHO2dgYgNYgZ>O o _aGJ]>EVOMq>_>dgGJY[Z\OEVLnALdgskZHYJ]>ONOpnZOZ'n]7NOo E\Y®J]>OpNOnkZ]>nrZHOpdNG>l5Ope d[O.l>Lbn>^SZHGJ]>ZHO#^cL2IOo nSOo EMLdgYgZ>OKo ADGK]>E`K]7OdK]7O^ LNPY[dgdgO^%l;OW\XaLi8[n7O^hGKn9_AO]>Z"ZHGJ]>Zl;OrN,O NPOGJj>ZHOn7Y[EP]>n>O lkO^MWMEHYg_>Z\Y[GJn L^\^HO # WMGJN_>dfOe Z\O,lkO^PIKEcLbnalkO]7EH^rlkO ^b]> E\OZ>O,o l;O"GKnAWMZHYgGKn7n>ONOpnZi · YSn>GK]>^2E\O_>E\On>GKn7^df§ OMq>ON_>dgOlk]WMGJN_>Z\O]>ElkOrlOo LYgdgdLnaWMOp^¥WMGJNNPO2_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^ NLJG~kY[OpnhFdL/_>dg]>_aLE\ZrlkO^"NG>l5Oe dgO^PjaG8gZH&O %fn>GKYgE\O^"]>ZHYgdgYg^>Oo ^P^HGKnkZrlkO^"_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^ lkO,DGKYg^H^\GKn²n>GKn %X>GJNGJIaOe n>Op^ G| F'DDPK]7YSOnkZHEHOpnZrl>Lbn>^2dL,Wd®Lb^H^\O,lkO^"SurG| F ; {y >HDFLEWGKnkZHE\OKhZ\GK]>Z2E\O^HZ\O¸Le LYgE\O_AGK]7E2d§ OMq>ONP_>dgOlk] _>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^"l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\YgGKnl5§ ]>n>O2^\ZHE\]aWMZH]7EHOrNPG;l;]>dLYgEHOKADFLE2WMGKn>^>Oo J]>OnkZhl7Ln>^.dgOWMGJnkZHOMq>ZHOrl5§ ]>n7O2NG>lOo dgYg^cLbZHYgGKn NLE\KG~kYgOn>n>OVl;O.Zfsk_aO`jAGÄ8gZH&O %fj>dLnAWHX7OKh>dgO^S_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^`^HGJnZVJ]aLb^HY %f^Hsk^HZ>Oo NLbZHYJ]>ONOpnZ^H]>_>_AGK^>Oo ^`X>GKNPGKIaOe n>Oî$ 9'n _aO]7Z.ZHGJ]>Z.lkO%N,O NO`YgnkZHE\G;l;]>YgEHO2WMOEHZMLYgn>O^GKE\NO^`lkO2n>GKn %X>GJNGJIOo nSOpo Y[Z>Oò ZHGK]7ZmOpnWMGJn>^HOpEH~KLnkZ.df§ O^\^HOnkZHYgOdlkO2dL _>]>Yg^H^MLnaWMO1l5§¬LnaLbd[sk^\OmlkO^`S2 u F ¨ ]>n7On>GJn %X7GKNGJIOo nSOo YgZ>O2o lkO^1Y[nAlkYWMO^2lkO^K]> EHOZ>O,o lkOGKnaWZHYgGKn>n7ONOnkZ.Li~KOiWh_ALE1OMq>ON_>dgOKhd®LNOo Z\X>G>lkOlkO Z\EcLn7^fGJEHNLbZHYgGKn ;¬yKy >Sl5§ ]>n>O2WHXAL8gn>O2lkOurLE\KG~"X>GJNGKIaOe n>O.E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZMLnkZ%dgOWMGJN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZVlk] ^Hsk^HZOe NO On"E>Oo IKYgNO`lkO'ª¡Lj7Y[dgYgZ>O'o ^HZMLj>YgdgYg^>Oo .O ¹!n>O`n>GKn %fX>GJNGKIOo nSOo YgZ>Omo l>Lbn>^Sdf§ Opn~kYgEHGJn>n>ONPOnkZ_AGK]>EVlkOp^V^Hsk^\ZOe NPO^VLKWMZ\Y«^S^H]>EVl;O^VYgnkZHOE\~KLdgdgO^SlkO.NYg^\^HYgGKn ; {

(21) >Hh ;=5{ >Hh ;gQiz >H ÙÙ É.JGK4LïM.

(22) ) ' C. ; <. ?A@/B1CD>EF"F1Q QRBLKMLN#O>FUE/EF. 9'nr_AO]>Z/Oo IkLdgONOpnZ^HGJ]>XaLbY[Z\OEmWGKn>^\OEH~JOE`d[O1WLEMLKWMZOe EHO2N"LEHJG~kY[Opnlk]r_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^5 L]kq"^HO]7d[^'Ygn>^HZMLnkZH^`lkO Z\EcLbn>^HYgZHYgGJnOpnZ\EHOOo ZcLbZHî¡OiWMYF_aOE\NOZVl;O.EHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZHOE2lkO^'ZHONP_>^mlkO#^>Oo tMGJ]>Eml7Ln>^']>n Oo ZcLbZrOo J]>YlkYg^HZ\EHYgj>]SOpo ^m^\OdgGKn ]7n>OdgGJY;J]>Opd®WGKnaJ]>OOZFn>OSlOo _AOnal>LbnZK]7O¦lkOdf§ Y®l;OnkZHYgZ>Oo l;Odf§HOo ZcLbZG>WWM]7_¦OSo OZlk]1_>EHG>W\XaLYgnOo ZcLbZF~Yg^\Y[Z>OKo )9'n%GJj>ZHYgOnkZ LbYgn>^HYF]>n>O1WHXAL8gn>O1^HONPY %fNLbEHJG~Y«On>n>OJ>OZHZ\O¥WMdLb^H^HOl;O._>EHG>WMOp^H^H]7^%O^\Z`]>ZHYgdgYg^>Oo O1_aLE YgZHZ\dgO£GkG>lrl>Lbn>^+;¬y'<>_AGK]7E E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZ\OE`d§\Oo ~JGKdg]>Z\Y[GJn¥l;]_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^ml5§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn"l5§ ]>ndgGJIKYWMYgOdalOio WMEHYgZSOn"lOo j>]>ZVl;OV^HOiWMZHYgGKnkfd5OnE>Oo ^H]>dgZ\Om]7n>O Z\GKZMLdgO2IOo nSOo EcLbd[YgZ>Oo lkOPd®L"lkYg^\ZHEHYgj>]7ZHYgGKnlkOp^%Z\ON_>^1l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn lkOW\XaLJJ]>ONPG;l;]>dgO¥Lb] _>EHY«ql5§ ]>n>OWGKN_7d[Oq;YgZ>O o l;O2d§\Oo ~KLbdg]aLZ\Y[GJnrLnaLbd[skZ\Y®J]>OPOpZ.nk]>NOo E\YK]7O'_>dg]>^`Y[NP_aGJEHZMLnkZHO%J]>OWOdgd[O2_7E>Oo ^\OnkZ>Oo O"On · OiWMZHYgGKn 5P_AGK]>E#d[O2WLb^ N"LE\KG~kYgOn X7GKNGJIaOe n7O · LKW\XaLnkZ%J]>OJhZ\X¦Oo GKE\YK]7ONOnkZih_>EHO^MJ]>O1ZHGJ]>ZHOl;Y[^\ZHE\Y[j7]>ZHYgGKnl;O_>E\GKjaLbj>Ygd[YgZ>O%o ^\]>&E EHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZcLnkZ2]>n7Olk]>E>Opo O._AO]>Z"O Z\EHOLb_>_>E\G;W\XSOpo O_aLbE.]>n>OlkYg^\ZHEHYgj>]7ZHYgGKn lkOZfsk_AO2_>XaLb^HOD FfW¬L>¬l55_ALE.dLPdgGKY l;]2ZHONP_>^l5§¬Lj7^HGKE\_>ZHYgGJnl5§ ]>n>OVWMOE\ZcLbY[n7OmS2 u F ;=5Ky >hGJn2_aOp]>ZE\ON_7d®LJWMOEdf§\Oo Z\]alkOml§ ]7n2NG>l5Oe dgO^HONPY %fNLbEHJG~Y«On _ALESWMOdgdgOl§ ]7n>O.S2 u F.>¯Fn"IOo nSOo EMLdfhkdgOV_>E\GKj>dfOe NPOmlkO`dL`^>Opo d[OiWMZHYgGKnrlkOp^rOo ZMLZH^SGJ]_>XAL^HOp^mlkO'd®L1S2 u F²_AOEHNPOZHZMLnkZ l§ Lb_>_>E\G;W\X>OpE.]>n>O2lkYg^HZ\EHYgj>]>Z\Y[GJnl;GKn>nSOpo O2O^HZ.lkY«¢WMYgdg.O AY[dFO^\Z.df§ GKjKtMOZ`lkO2n>GJN2j>EHO]7^HO^/Oo Z\]alkO^P~JGKYgEV_aLbEÒMq>ON_>dgO ;=5

(23) >×h ;¬"z >ÆJ]>YAGKnkZlOo tJL% e lkGJn>nSOò lkO^SLdgIKGJEHYgZHX>NPO^lkOmWGKn>^\ZHEH]AWMZHYgGKn"E\OdLZHYg~JONOnkZF^HZMLj>dgOîh>L]PNGKYgn>^l>Lbn>^dgOmWpL^SlkO l;O]kq%_>XAL^HOp^kOZHZ\OSY®lOo OOp^HZmL'e dLSjaLb^HOVlkOp^Xks_AGKZ\XOe ^\OÊHOpZHOnk]>OÔn · OiWMZHYgGK+n 5'_aGJ]>EFdgO^FZHONP_>^lkOE\OWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZ l;O¦lOo LYgdgdLnaWMOlkGKnkZdgO^lkYg^\ZHEHYgj>]7ZHYgGKn>^F^\GKnkZF^HGK]7~KOnkZF_aOp]¥lkYg^\_aOE\^>Oo Op^VfWMGkOM¢WMYgOnkZlkO~KLE\Y®LbZHYgGK n , Qp YgnaLbd[OpNOnkZh ^\YFd[O1WMGKNP_aGJEHZHOpNOnkZVlk]/^Hsk^HZOe NO#GK],lkOp^mIJEcLbnalkO]>E\^.WMGKn>^\YlOo E>Opo O^%Op^HZ.WMdLYgEHOpNOnkZSn>GJn %N"LE\KG~kYgOnhk]>nr_7EHG>WAOo lO o Wd®Lb^H^\Y®J]>O2_AGK]7EmGJj>ZHOpn>YgE.]>n/NG>l5Oe dgO%Li~JOW1]>n>O2NPOYgd[dgO]7EHO%LJlOo J]aLZ\YgGKnLe df§ Xksk_aGJZHXOe ^\O%N"LE\KG~kYgOn>n>OKh5WMGJn>^HYg^\ZHO,L e YgnaWd[]7EHO`_>dg]>^Vl5§ YgnkGJEHNLbZHY«GKn2l>Ln>^SdL1lOMo ªan7Y[Z\YgGKnl;Omdf§\Oo ZMLZSlk]"_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>î5¹Sn"OMq>ON_7d[O`lkOÈHOlOMo ªan>YgZHYgGJnl;O^rOo ZMLZ\^ l7Ln>^2dgOWGKnkZHOMq>Z\Ol;] NPG>l¡Oe dgO2NLbEHKG~kYgOn lkO YgZHZ\dgO£GkG>l Op^HZlkYg^cW]>Z>O,o l7Ln>^ ;¬'y C>HFfdS^§¬LIJYg^H^cLbYgZ%lkO"^H]>E\NGJnZ\OE dgO^.lkY«¢WM]7d[Z>Oo O^ÒMq>_AGK^>Opo O^.On · GK]7^ %f^HOWMZ\YgGKn y>gQKhAlkY«¢WM]>dgZ>Oo Op^l;]>O^LPe d§¬LJlkGK_>Z\YgGKnl§ ]7n>O%Xksk_AGKZHXOe ^HO1NLbEHKG~kYgOn>n7O _AGK]7EdgOS_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^ml5§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn § YgnaWGKnk~Oo n>YgOnkZNLptMO]>ElkO`WMOVZfsk_AOmlkO'ZHEcLbn>^fGKEHN"LZ\Y[GJn%Op^HZd®L'IOo nSOo EMLZHYgGJnl5§ ]>n n7GKN2j>E\O2Y[NP_aGJEHZMLnkZ%l5§\Oo ZMLZH^WOJ]>YVLb]>IKNPOnkZHO2dL/WMGKNP_>dgOMq>Y[Z>Oo lkO"dLrZLK W\X>Orl5§ O^HZ\YgNLZ\YgGKn lkO^2_aLbEcLN,Oe ZHE\O^lk] NPG>l¡Oe dgOK.

(24) P S ©

(25) .$1 '&r · Yd[Op^mZ\EcLi~KLb]kq,lkO2Zfsk_aO1jaG8gZHO&%fn>GKYgE\O%^\GKnkZ.df§ GKjKtMOZ`lkO2ZHEOe ^.n>GJN2j>EHOp]kq,LEHZ\YWMdgO^h5df§¬L_7_>EHG>W\X>O1^HZHE\]aWMZ\]>EHOdgdgO2n§¬L Opo Z>Oo LjAGKEMlOo OJ]>O2l>Ln7^.]>n>O1~kY[n7IKZcLbYgn>O%lkO2_>]7j>dgY®WpLZHYgGJn>^V_>E\YgnaWMYg_aLdgONPOnkZVE>Oo _aLE\ZHYgO^.OpnZ\EHOPd®L¥ªan lkO^%Lbn>nSOo O^1z

(26) OpZmdgO2lOo j>]7Zl;OWMOZHZ\OlOo WMOpn>n>YgOKF¹Sn Oo W\XaLnkZHYgdgdgGKn"EHOp_>E>Oo ^\OnkZcLbZHY«mE\OIKE\GK]>_A2 O ;=5>×h ;=5'<">Hh ; 5J >Hh ;gQ{ >_aGJ]>E`]>n>O9Oo ~JGKdg]>ZHYgGJn l;Y[^MWMEOpe ZHO%lk]"Z\ON_>^SOpZ ; yJz >Hh ;¬y <>Hh ;¬y

(27) >Hh ; 57#Q >Hh ;gQ <">Hh ;g?Q >Hh ;¬yJy >Hh ;¬'y 5">_AGK]>ES]>n7O,Opo ~KGKdg]>Z\YgGKnWGKnkZHYgnk]>OK ¤`Ln7^S]>n"_>EHONPYgOEZ\ON_7^hkEcLb_>_AOdgGKn>^'^H]aWWY[nkZ\ONOnkZSdgO.WMGKnkZ\OMq>ZHO%lkO.lOpo ~KOdgGK_7_aONPOnkZVlk]"NG>l5Oe dgO'NLE\KG~kYgOn l;O YgZHZ\dgO£GkG>I l ;¬yKz >ÌJ]>YO^HZ.WMGJNN2]>n,L1e dL1_>dg]>_ALEHZ`lkO^`L]>Z\EHO^`ZHEMLi~KL]kqrWMYgZ>Oo ^'_>E>Oio WaOo lkONPNOnkZiaOWMYFYgnkZHE\G;l;]>YgEcL l;O2NLn7YOpe EHO2naLbZH]>E\Odgd[O2dg2 O + ) 0lOo ~JOdgGK_>_SO"o l>Ln7^.dL_7EHG>W\XaLYgn>O2^\GK]>^ %^\OWMZHYgGJn § OnkZHYgZ>O o Oo dOo NOnkZMLYgEHO Op^HZ"dgONPG>lk]>dgOK L/^\ZHE\]aWMZH]7EHOlk]dgGJIKYWMYgOdSO^\ZE\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZ>Oo O _aLEPdgOrIKEML_>X>O/l5§¬L_>_AOd¥L/e df§ On>^\ON2j>dgO l;O,WMO^ NPG>lk]>dgO^ § Y[nkZ\OEcLJWMZHYgGKn9OnkZ\EHO WMO^NPG>lk]>dgO^WMGJEHEHOp^H_AGKnal L e lkO^PZHEcLbn>^fOEHZ\^l;] WMGKnkZ\EÄGK dgO,l;Ordf§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJn OpZL e W\XaLJJ]>O`Y[n7^HZcLbnkZh>WMO%WGKnkZHEGK dgOÒ^HZ`L^H^\]>E>O#o _aLES]>n"OZS]7n^\O]>dNG>lk]>dgOmJ]>Y5^\OEcLPL_>_AOdiOò dgOmNPG>lk]>dgO '" kT _aLE\ZHYgE l§ ]7n>O2ZHOdgdgOE\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZMLZHYgGJn lk]©^Hsk^HZOe NOKhn>GJ]>^%WMGJnZ\EH]>Yg^\GKn>^1]>n _>E\G;WO^H^\]>^^\ZHG>W\XaL^\ZHYJ]>OKh^H]>_>_AGK^>O"o NLE\KG~kYgOn ;¬yJz >GK]9Oo ~JOnkZH]>OdgdgONPOnkZ^HONPY %N"LEHJG~kY[Op

(28) n ;¬y <>ÆphlOo ^HYgIKnALnkZmL1e WHXALKJ]>OSYgn>^HZMLnkZd[OSNPG>lk]>dgO¦LJWMZHY«OZNG>lOpo d[Yg^MLnkZdL ^\ZHE\]aWMZH]7EHOl§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJn,lk]/d[GJIKYWMYgOdfa|!GK]>^'GKj>Z\On>GJn>^.LYgn>^HYF]>n/GKjKtOZ`NLZ\XSOo N"LZHYJ]>O'_aGJ^H^>Oio l>LnkZ.lkO^`_>E\GK_>E\YOpo Z>Oo ^ j7Y[OpnWMGKn>nk]>Op^GKNPNO`n>GJ]>^.df§¬Li~KGKn7^m^\YgIKnaLbdO2o Opn · OWMZ\Y[GJn y7hWMOWMYSYgnaWd[]7Z.dgO^%lkO];q WLEMLKWMZ>Oo EHYg^HZ\YK]7O^2^H]>Yg~KLbnZ\O^ _AGK]7ESd®L1lksknaLbNYJ]>OVlk*] !a]kqrlkO%WMGJnZ\EÄGJ d[OJ L1W\XaL8gn>OL#e ZHONP_>^VlkYg^cWEHOZ`lkGKn>nALnkZdf§ YlkOnkZHYgZ>Omo lk]"NG>lk]7d[OSG>WW]>_SO%o Lb_>EOe ^`W\XaLKJ]>O`ZHEMLn>^\YgZHYgGKnPO^HZ'NLE\KG % ~kYgOn>n>OK L.~KLbdgO]>ESlkO`d®L_>EHGJjaLj>YgdgYgZ>OVo lkO`Z\EcLn7^HYgZHYgGKn"l5§ ]>nNPG>lk]>dgO ~KOE\^S]>n"NG>lk]>dgO .O^HZVl;GKnaW'YgnalOo _AOn % l>LbnZ\O.lkO`ZHGK]7^Sd[Op^VNG>lk]7d[Op^G>WWM]>_SOpo ^LbnkZ>Oo E\Y[Op]>EHONPOnkZ%L e H L(lk]>E>Opo O,l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\YgGKn l§ ]7nWMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZ.Op^HZ2]>n>O"~KLbEHYLj>dgOLbdOio LZHGJYgEHOlkO"lkYg^HZHE\Ygj>]>ZHYgGJnOMq>_AGKn>OnkZ\Y[Opd[dgOPn>O lOo _AOnal7LnkZmJ]>O%l;O%WMO%WMGJN_AGK^MLnkZ>¯FdgdgOÒ^HZ'YgnalOo _AOnal>LbnkZHO2lkO^VZ\ON_7^Vl5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn,lkO`ZHGJ]>^VdgO^'NG>lk]>dgO^ _>E>Oo WAOo lkOpNNOpnZSLKWZHYg~Oo ^ . .

(29) . . ÝcbÙÝÆè.

(30)

(31) !"#$ %

(32) &' )( * + -,.'/01 2 "3)4 . z. O^WMGJnalkYgZHYgGJn>^2^HGJnZ2Z\EOe ^GKE\ZHOî OrlOo WLbdLIKO"OnkZ\EHO/d[O"^\s^\ZOe NPO"E>Oo OdÒZP^HGJn NPG>l¡Oe dgON"LEHJG~kY[Opn n§ O^HZP_aL^ ^H_SOo WYª5K]7O%LVe df§¬L_7_>dgY®WpLZHYgGJnmdgGJIKYWMYgOdgdgOOpZ^HOSE\OZHE\GK]>~JOKh_aLbEOq;OpN_>dgOKhl>Lbn>^F_>EHO^MJ]>OVZ\GK]>Z\O^dgO^%Oo ZH]AlkO^Sl5§HOo ~KLdg]aLbZHYgGKn lkO%_AOE×GKE\NLnAWMO^.lkO^.^\sk^HZOpe NO+^ ;gQy >H5|SGJ]>^`_>EHGJ_aGJ^HGKn7^%l>Ln7

(33) ^ ;¬y C>Ì]7n>O%Z\OW\X>n>YJ]>OWMdL^\^HYJ]>O1_aGJ]>E`GKj>Z\On>YgE`]>n>O NOYgdgdgO]>EHO`LKlOio K]ALZHYgGJn L1e ]7nrNG>l5Oe dgO'NLE\KG~kYgOnV¨7Y[nAWMdg]>EHO`]>n>O#Y[n;GKE\NLZ\YgGKn2_>dg]>^SE\Y®W\X>O1l>Ln>^'dL%lOo ªan>YgZHYgGKnrl5§ ]>n Oo ZcLbZh5WMO%J]>YFWMGKE\EHO^\_aGJnalrN"LZ\X¦Oo NLbZHYJ]>ON2OnkZmLPe L]>IJNOnkZ\OESdf§ Op^H_aLJWMO%l5§\Oo ZMLZAO._AGKYgnkZSn>O.^HOpEcLP_aL^VlOo ~KOdgGJ_>_SO o l>Ln>^VWO%J]>Y5^H]>YgZi ¹!n>OV^\OWMGJnalkO,Oo ZcLb_aO`WMGKn7^HYg^HZ\OL#e LKltMGJYgnalkEHOSdgO^Xsk_AGKZ\XOe ^HOp^Vl5§ GG>WM]7EHEHOpnaWMO.lkOmlOMo LYgdgdLnaWOVL]2NG>l5Ope d[OSl5§ OMqSOo WM] % ZHYgGKnk|SGJ]>^GKj>Z\On>GKn7^¦Lbd[GJEH^]>nNPG>l¡Oe dgOVlk]WGKN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZlk]^\s^\ZOe NPOVZ\OdJ]§ Y[dAO^\Z_AOE W]r_aLE^HGKnP]>ZHYgdgYg^cLbZHO]>Ei § On>^\ON2j>dgO¥WGKn>^\ZHYgZH]>OWOJ]>O2n>GJ]>^.L_>_AOdgOEHGJn>^1_aLE`dLP^H]>YgZHO2]7n

(34) A ): ¤mLbn>^.dgO2WMGKnkZHOq;Z\Olk] NG>l5Oe dgOml;O YgZHZHdgO£GkG>l5hK]7n_7EHG>WMO^\^H]>^.lkO^VlOMo LYgdgdLnaWO^SO^HZVLb^H^\G;WYO"o L%e W\XaLJK]7OmZfsk_AO.l5§HOo ~Oo n>ONPOnkZVlk]"_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^ l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJnhaWb§ Op^HZ¥L1e lkYgEHO`]>n7O.ZHEMLn>^\NYg^H^\Y[GJnlkO%WMGJnkZHEÄGJ dgOmOpZS]>n>O.OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKnrlkO1lk]>E>Opo O%LdiOo LbZHGKYgE\Oml5§ ]>n"NG>lk]7d[OJ On>GKN2j7EHOl;O^lOo LYgdgdLnaWMOp^5On>EHOpIKYg^HZ\E>Oo O^lk]>EcLbnkZ5]>n.^>Oo tMGK]>EFl>Ln7^5d[ONG>lk]>dgO \hOp^HZl;GKn>nSOo _aLE5]>n#_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^ lkO.DGKYg^\^HGKnrlkO`ZML]kq c L2K]ALnkZHYgZ>Oò _AGK^\Y[Z\Yg~KO 5 > Kh>_AGK]7E > hAlOo ^HYgIJn>O.dL._7EHGKjALj>YgdgYgZ>O.o J]§ ]>nZ\EcLn7^fOE\Z.lkO.WMGKnkZHEGK dgO.OnkZ\EHO dgO^SNPG;l;]>dgO^ ÌOZ ¥^\GKYgZSlOMo LbY[dgdLnkZi YgnaLbdgONOnkZih YgZHZHdgO£GkG>l Oo Z\]alkYgOVdgOS_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^`

(35) WMGJN_>ZMLj>YgdgYg^cLnkZ5dgOSn>GJN2j>EHOSl5§ YgnaWMYlkOnkZHÊHOWMOpn>^>Oo ^2L'e ZHGK]7ZHO l>LZ\/O · Y5d[Op^SZHONP_>^¦l§ YgnkZHOpE %HlOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMOSGKnkZZHOnal7LnaWMO"Le O Z\EHO.jAOLb]aWMGK]7__7d[]7^SY[NP_aGJEHZMLnkZH^J]>O`dgO^SlOo dLYg^SOnkZ\EHO d[OpÔo W\XaLn>IJO^ml;O%WMGKnkZ\EÄGK dgOKhkYgd5NPGKnkZHE\OmLdgGJEH^VJ]>O ^H]7Y[ZS]7n>O.lkYg^HZHE\Ygj>]>ZHYgGJnlkO%DGJY[^\^HGJnl;Om_ALEcLbN,Oe Z\EHO 4 ; 5 > K >

(36) . . . . . G] e lOpo ^HYgIKn>O#d®L2l;Y[^\ZHE\Y[j7]>ZHYgGKn"^\ZcLZ\YgGKn>naLbYgEHO%Lb^H^HG>WMYiOo O2L]"_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^.N"LEHJG~kY[Opnl5§ G>WWM]>_ALZHYgGJn,lkO^'NG>lk]>dgOî O N,O NP OZfsk_AOmlkOÈ>Opo ^H]>dgZcLbZ¦L Oo Z>Oo lOo NGJnZ\E>OSo _AGK]>ESlkO^Vl;Y[^\ZHE\Y[j7]>ZHYgGKn7^J]>OdWMGKnAK]7O^VlkO`ZHONP_>^lkO'^>Oo tGK]>ESOZn>GJn_>dg]>^ OMq>_aGJn>OnkZHYgOdgdgO^ ;¬y <>×>¤'O];qEHOpNLEMJ]>O^S^§ YgN_AGK^\OnkZ L2lksknaLNPY®J]>O`lk]r_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^%l5§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn(n§ O^HZ`_aLb^V_AOEHZ\]>EHjSOpo O2_aLESdf§ G>WWM]>E\EHOnaWOl5§ ]>n>O%lOo LYgdgdLnaWMOJ O dgGKIJYWMYgOdSEHOl;O~kY[OpnZPYgn>^HZMLnkZcLbn¦Oo NOpnZ2GJ_SOo EMLZHYgGJn>n>Od#Li~KOiW_7EHGKjALj>YgdgYgZ>O o Q1N,O NO2^\YmWMOE\ZcLbY[n7O^PGKE\NO^2lkO E\OWMGK]7~E\ONOpnZ.l5§ OE\EHO]7EH^.^\GKnkZ`NYg^HO^SOpn,`]>~kEHO2_AGK]7EmWMOdL7 O.NPG>l¡Oe dgO.O^\Zl;GKnaW#YlkOnkZHYJ]>OL"e WMOdg]>Yl5§ ]>n ^\s^\ZOe NPOmlkGJnkZdf§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\YgGKn^\]>YgZnALZH]7EHOdgdgONOpnZ^HGJnWMGJ]>EH^SN,O NOSLi~KOiWVdf§ G>WWM]>E\EHOnAWMO%lkO`lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO^kOWMY n>O.WMGJEHE\O^H_AGKnal(_aLb^%L.e ]>n"NPG;l5Oe dgOVGK_SOo EcLbZHYgGKn>n7OdZ\EOe ^'E>Oo Lbd[Yg^\ZHOK OVNG>lOpo d[Yg^MLZHOp]>En7OmlkYg^H_AGK^\O.L._>E\YgGKEHY5l5§¬L]AWM]>n>O`YgnkGJEHNLbZHYgGKn1K]7Y5_aOE\NOZ\ZHO`lkOtM]>IKOpE¦lkO`dL.J]aLbd[YgZ>Omo l5§ ]>n>O Oo ~JOnkZH]>Opd[dgO`]>Z\Y[dgYg^cLbZHYgGKn"lkO`df§ Lb_>_>E\Giq;YgN"LZHY«GKn1_aGJYg^H^HGJn>YgOn>n>OJ L · GJ]>^ %f^HOiWMZHYgGKn 5>= 5'_>EHGJ_aGJ^HO']>n>OrOpo ~KLdg]aLZ\YgGKn1ZHEcLbn>^HYgZ\GKYgEHOKh5Lè dL!GKYg^LbnaLdgskZHYJ]>OOZSLdgIKGJEHYgZHX>NPYK]7OKhl5§ ]>n2NPG>l¡Oe dgO GK_SOo EMLZ\Y[GJn>n>Od7NLE\KG~kYgOnV_7d[]7Ê\YWHX7OK' 9'n%n7OVWMGKn>^\Yl¡Oe EHOSYWMY>J]§ ]>n>OPOo ~JGKdg]>ZHYgGJn.On1ZHONP_>^WMGJnkZHYgnk]' 9'n%^\OE\O_AGKEHZ\OEcL L e ;¬y{ >>_AGK]>Ed[OZHEMLYgZHOpNOnkZlk].NPG>l¡Oe dgOOn.Z\ON_7^lkYg^cWEHOZi ONG>l5Oe dgOF]>Z\Y[dgYg^>Oo O^HZF^H];¢^cLNPOnkZ5IOo nSOo EcLbd>_aGJ]>EYgnaWd[]7EHO d§¬LbnaLdgsk^HO2Z\EcLn7^HYgZHGJY[E\Orlk]_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^rlkOrWMGKNP_>ZcLbIKOLb^H^HG>WMYiOro L]9NPG;l5Oe dgOlkO YgZHZ\d[Op£GkG>l5FOEHZMLYgn>O^2_>E\GK_>E\YOo Z>Oo ^ L^HskNP_>ZHGJZHYJ]>O^^HOE\GKnkZrOo IkLdgONPOnkZ¦lkYg^MWM]>Z>Opo O^ml>Lbn>^SdL · OWMZHYgGJnr{a (<>=. 8EPQRN(G FT >F+E/N.Q>E/B . L _>E\ONYfOe E\O Oo ZcLb_aO l>Ln7^2]>n>O,Lb_>_>EHG>W\X>O/^HZ\EH]aWMZ\]>EHOpd[dgO/_aGJ]>EOpo ~KLdg]>OE2dL/^K]7 EHOZ>Oo lkO"GJnaWMZHYgGJn>n>ONPOnkZ¥l5§ ]>n ^Hsk^HZOe NO2dgGKIJYWMYgOdWMGKn>^\Yg^HZHO L"e lOMo ªan>YgE.]7n NG>l5Oe dgO2l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJnWMGKN2j7Y[nALnkZVlkO^1YgnkGKE\NLbZHYgGKn>^SGJ]WGKn>naLbYg^H^cLbnaWMO^ ^H]>E'd®L#^HZ\EH]aWZH]>E\OKh5dgO^VlkGJn>nSOo O^'_aGJZHOnkZ\Y[Opd[dgONPOnkZ¦l;Y[^\_aGJn>Ygj>dgO^SOZ'd[Op^SNO^\]>EHO^2L e Opo ~KLdg]>OEiaDGK]>ESdgO`_>E\ONYgOES_AGKYgnkZh n>GK]>^'^H]>_7_aGJ^HOE\GKn>^.J]§ ]>n"^Hsk^HZOe NO#_aO]7Z%O Z\EHO.~k],WMGJNNPOS]>nrOn>^\ON2j>dgO.lkBO ) ) SYgnZ\OEcLbIKYg^H^MLnkZAXaLKJ]>O WMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZO^HZSdg]>Y %fN,O NPO]7n^\sk^HZOpe NOKh7OZcWAOZHZ\O%WMGJn>^HZ\EH]aWMZ\YgGKnrE>Oo WM]>E\^HYg~KO.Op^HZV^\ZHGJ_>_SOo O.dgGJEH^cJ]>O`dgO`^Hsk^HZOe NOÒ^\Z WMGKn>^\YlOo E>Oro WMGJNNPO¥LbZHGKNPYK]7OKh5^HGJYgZ._aLE1naLbZH]>E\O^\GKYgZ1_aLEMWMOrK]§ ]7n>OlOo WMGJN_AGK^\Y[Z\YgGKn ^H]7_>_>dOo NOpnZMLYgEHOPO^HZStM]>IOo O ÙÙ É.JGK4LïM.

(37) ) ' <. Ygnk]>Z\Y[dgOKAO%WMGJnaWMO_>Z.lkO2WMGJN_AGK^cLbnkZSd[GJIKYWMYgOd5O^\ZÈHO_>E\Yg^l;O ;¬y'5>H5|SGK]7^V^H]7_>_aGJ^HOE\GKn>^.J]>O1dgO^VYgnkZHOEMLKWMZ\YgGKn>^'OnkZHEHO WGKN_AGK^MLnkZH^F^\GKnkZ¦Lb^H^\G;WYOpo O^¦Lb]kq2^HO]>dg^ZHEMLn>^×OEHZ\^VlkOVWMGJnZ\EÄGJ d[OSOpZGJn2Y[NP_aGJ^HOEML`K]§®Lè W\XaLJK]7OVYgn>^HZMLnkZhbd[OVWGKnkZHEGK dgO l;O2d§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn/O^\Z.dL2_>E\GK_>E\YOpo Z>Oo l5§ ]>n/]>n>YJ]>O2WMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZi LPnaLZ\]>EHOlkOp^.YgnZ\OEcLJWMZHYgGJn>^Ò^HZ%l;GKnaW1YlkOnkZ\Y®J]>OrL e WOdgd[O.lk]PNG>l5Oe dgOVlkO Y[Z\ZHdgO£GkG;l|!GK]>^SWMGKn7^HZcLbZHGJn>^VJ]>O`d®L#lOMo ªan>YgZ\Y[GJnl5§ ]>n"WMGKNP_aGJ^cLbnZO^HZS]>n7OmZLK W\X>OÈHOp~KOnaLbnkZ LPe df§ ]>ZHYgdgYg^cLbZHO]>E`GJ]Lb]WMGJnaWMO_7ZHO]>EihJ]§ Odgd[O2lOo _AOnal©lk] ^Hsk^\ZOe NPO¥LbnaLdgsk^>O2o OZ1lkO2df§ GJ_>_AGKEHZ\]>n>YgZ>O2o lkOWMGJdgd[OiWMZHOE#d[Op^ l;GKn>nSOpo O^2EHOJ]>Yg^\O^2_aGJ]>E%WMGJn>^HZ\EH]>YgE\O]7n>OZ\Odgd[OP^HZ\EH]aWMZ\]>EHOrl5§ YgnkZHOEMLKWMZ\YgGKnfdOp^HZWMdLYgE%J]>O2dL"_7EHONPYOpe EHOYlOpo OO^\Z l§ YlkOpnZ\Y«ªaOE`dgO^%WMGJN_AGK^cLbnkZH^mLb]WGKnaWMOp_>Z%^\ZcLbnal>LEMl lk2 O + $ 'On IOo n7Y[O1dgGKIJY®WY[OpdÌWGKNNPO.l>Ln>^#d[O1NG>l5Ope d[O1lkO Y gZHZHdgO£GkG>lrOZVdL#_>dg]>_aLbEHZVlkO^.Lb]>ZHE\O^V_>]7j>dgY®WpLZHYgGJn>^cp>DF]>Yg^VGJn]7ZHYgdgY[^\O`d[OÌJEcL_7X>O%l5§¬L_7_aOd5_AGK]7EVEHOp_>E>Oo ^\OnkZHOE#d[Op^ YgnkZHOpEcLKWZHYgGKn>^SOpnZ\EHO`dgO^VlkYg~KOpEH^SNG>lk]7d[Op^kurLYg^d[Op^SXsk_AGKZ\XOe ^HOp^VNLbEHJG~YgOn7n>O^Lb^H^HG>WMYiOo Op^Lb]NPG;l5Oe dgOVl5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn l;O~kY[Opn>n>OnkZmLbdgGKEH^^HGJ]>~KOpnZ'jaOiL]aWMGJ]>_"ZHE\GK_"YgEHE>Oio LdgYg^HZHOp^ |!GK]>^.^\]>_>_AGK^\OEHGJn>^hFl>Ln7^.dL2^H]7Y[Z\OKhJ]>O2n>GJ]>^%lkYg^\_aGJ^HGKn7^l§ ]7n>O2EHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZcLZ\YgGKnlk] _>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^2l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn WGKNNPO]>n2_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^SNLbEHJG~YgOn`X>GJNGJIaOe n>O.Lè Z\ON_>^WMGJnkZHYgnk] § On7^HON2j>dgO Q ^^ ^VlOo ^HYgIJn>OSdf§ Op^H_aLJWMO l§HOpo ZcLZVl;]_7EHG>WMO^\^H]>5^ O^`lkGKn>nSOo O^V^\GKnkZVWMGJnZ\YgZH]SOo Op^l;]IOo nSOo EMLZ\O]>E`Ygnkªan>YgZ>Opo ^HYgNLbd 6 1 b\ OpZVlkO dL2lkYg^\ZHEHYgj>]7ZHYgGKnrYgn>YgZ\Y®Lbdg

(38) O + ^^ ^ O%WMGkOM¢WMYgOnkZ 1 b'O^\ZmdgO.ZML]kq,lkO1ZHEMLn>^\YgZHYgGKn,l;],WMGKNP_aGJ^cLbnZ ~JOEH^ ;7fdO^\ZrOo IkLdFL]"_aLEMLN,Oe ZHE\Ol;OmdL2lkYg^\ZHEHYgj>]7ZHYgGKn"OMq>_AGKn>OnkZ\Y[Opd[dgO.lkO.dL1lk]>E>Oo O¥l§ ]7nJ]>Opd®WGKnaJ]>O.^>Oo tMGJ]>EVl>Ln7^ df§\Oo ZMLZ \hK_AGKnAlOo E>Oò _aLbEdL`_>E\GK_AGKEHZ\YgGKnlkOSE\GK]>ZMLIKO'~KOE\^df§\Oo ZMLZ .OnPd§¬Lbj>^HOnAWMOmlkOSZ\GK]>Z_>XSOpo n>GKN,Oe n>OVlkO`lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMOK L`_>E\GKjaLbj>Ygd[YgZ>O o EHOp_>E>Oo ^\OnkZHO.dL'_>E\GK_AGKEHZ\YgGKnlkO`WMs>WMdgO^¦l§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJnlkOV_>E\ONYgOEWMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZLKWZHY« \kGKNNPOFd[Op^ Ws;Wd[Op^^\GKnkZ5E>Oo J]>ONPNOnkZAYgn>YgZHYLdgYg^>Oo ^5_ALEdf§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHYgGKn%l§ ]7nmn7GKN2j>E\OZ\EOe Ê>Oo lk]7Y[ZFlkOWMGJN_AGK^MLnkZHîhWMO^F_>E\GKjaLbj>YgdgY[Z>Oo ^ ^\GKnkZ_>E\O^cJ]>O`Z\GK]>Z\O^nk]>dgdgOî § ]>Z\Y[dgYg^cLbZHO]7EOp^HZOnIOo nSOo EMLdAd[OS_7EHYgnaWMYg_aLbd>EHO^\_aGJn>^cLbj>dgOmlkO'dLV^>Oo dgOWMZ\Y[GJnlkOp^lkGKn7n¦Oo O^ l§ OpnZ\E>Oo O2_7E>Oo ^\OnkZ>Oo O^Lb],dgGJIKYWMYgOdf5|SGK]7^Lb_>_AOdgOEHGJn>^ h5dgO A ?, . '#0 # )l;O^%WMGJN_AGK^cLbnkZH^.lk]/d[GJIKYWMYgOdf O _7EHG>WMO^\^H]>$^ )O^HZS^\]>_>_AGK^>O%o YgEHE>Oo lk]aWZHYgj>dgOK. <;. &F. QRN(G F T > F+NFU KB .N E/EF. LlkO^MWMEHYg_>Z\YgGKn,lk](_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^1lkO%lOMo fLYgdgd®LbnaWMO.WMGJn>^HZ\Y[Z\]>O1d®L1^\OWMGJnalkOWMGJN_AGK^cLbnkZHO.lk]rNPG;l5Oe dgOVGK_SOo EcLbZHYgGKn>n7Odf !| GK]>^.lkYg^\ZHYgn>IK]7OEHGJn>^.lkO]kqWd®Lb^H^\O^¥l;O¥lOo LYgdgdLnaWMOp^VOn(GKnAWMZHYgGKn lkO1dgO]>EH^.WMGJn>^>Oio K]7OnaWMO^2^\]>E`dLlksknaLbNYJ]>O%lk] _7EHG>WMO^\^H]>^"l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn L(_>E\ONYfOe E\OO^\ZWMGKNP_aGJ^>Oo O"_aLbE%dgO^2lOMo LbYgd[dLbnaWMO^2lkYgZHO^ 40 +)0 O]>E2G>WWM]7EHEHOpnaWMO _7EHG~KG>J]>OP]>n>OrYgnkZHOE\EH]>_7ZHYgGKn9lkO"d§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKnJ]>YSO^\Z2EHOlOo NLbEHE>Opo OKh_aLbE2OMq>ON_7d[OJh¦L(e _aLE\ZHYgEl5§ ]>n©_aGJY[nkZ2lkO"EHO&% _7EHYg^HOPGK] J]>YO^\Z%E>Oo Ygn>YgZHYLdgYg^>Oo O,L(e _aLbEHZHYgE%l§ ]7n WMGJN_AGK^cLbnkZl§ OpnZ\E>Oo Orlk]©dgGKIKYWMYgOdf GK]>^2WMO^©Oo ~Oo n>OpNOnkZH^2^\OEHGJnkZ J]aLbdgYªVOo ^%l5§ ( 40 +)% |SGK]7^.EHO~kYgOnal;EHGKn7^2_>dg]>^.dgGKYgn/^H]>E1dL"EHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZcLZ\YgGKnlkOÔo ~KOpnZ\]>Odg^2lOo dLYg^ Opn>IKOnAlkE>Oo ^#_aLE`WMO^%LbEHEOp ZH^ L2^HOiWMGKnal;OWMdL^H^\O¥l;O¥lksk^×GKnaWZHYgGKn>n7ONOnkZ\^mlk]r^\sk^HZOpe NO.E\OIKE\GK]>_AO%dgO^/Oo ~Oo n7ONOnkZ\^ l;Y[Z\G^ ) )0 k¤'OVNLbn>YOe EHOIOpo n¦Oo EcLbdgOKh>WMO`^HGJnZlkO^SYgnaWMYlkOnkZ\^¦lkGJnkZdgOÔ ¡OZ\^V^\]>EdL.l;snALNYJ]>OSlk]2_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^ l§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJnr^HGJnZ'nSOo IJd[YgIJOLj>dgO^SGJ]"n¦Oo IKdgYgIOpo ^>fd^§¬LIJYgZh>_ALESOMq>ONP_>dgOKhal5§ ]>n7O%lOMo LbYgd[dLbnaWMOml;GKnkZVdgO^`WMGKn>^>Oo J]>OnaWO^ ^\GKnkZ`^H]k¢^MLNPNOnkZSNYgn>Op]>EHO^`_AGK]>E`^\]>_>_AGK^HOpE¥J]>O1dgO2_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^2l5§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHYgGKn/EHO_ALEHZ\OYgn>^\ZcLnkZMLnSOo NPOnkZml5§ G],e Ygd ^\OZ\EHGK]7~KLYgZ5¹Sn9L]>Z\EHO9Oo ~Oo n7ONOnkZ.^\OWMGJnal>LYgE\OOp^HZ.]>n7OOE\EHO]>ElOo ZHOWZ>Oo O"n>GJn EHOWMGJ]>~KOpEHZHO"OZ#n>OIOo nSOo EMLnkZ%_AL^ ]7n,^\OEH~kYWMO2YgnaLKWpWMO_>ZMLj>dgO1_aGJ]>E`d[Op^V]>Z\Y[dgYg^cLbZHO]7EH^TV~KOiW.dgO.^\GK]aWMYlkO%n7O%_aLb^.LdgGK]>EMlkYgEVdL2lkYg^cW]>^H^\Y[GJnh5n>GJ]>^`_aLE\dg&O % E\GKn>^Y[nAlkYg^HZHYgnaWZHONPOnkZÌl§HOpo ~Opo n>ONOpnZFGJ]¥lkOVlOMo LYgdgdLnaWO^\OWMGKnAl>LYgEHOSj7Y[OpnK]§ ]7nOo ~Oo n7ONOnkZF^HOiWMGKnal7LYgEHO'n>OS_>]>Yg^H^\O _ALÔ Z\EHO"^Hsk^\Z>Oo N"LZHYJ]>ONPOnkZ.L^H^\G>WMYOo L"e ]>n7OlOMo fLYgdgd®LbnaWMO2lk] _AGKYgnkZ%lkO~k]>Ol;Odf§ ]>ZHYgdgYg^cLZ\O]>EiO^2lkO]kqWMdL^\^HO^ l§ YgnaWY®l;OnkZH^VL 5OWMZ\OnkZ`d[Op^VlkO]kqrNG>lkOp^Vl5§HOo ~KGJd[]7ZHYgGKnlk](_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^.l5§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn.¨7OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\YgGKn,l5§ ]>nrWMGJN_AGK^MLnkZOpZ Z\EcLbn>^fOpEHZml;OWGKnkZHEGK dgO.l5§ ]>nrWMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZ~KOE\^S]>nrL]>Z\EHOK |!GK]>^VlkYg^\_aGJ^HGKn7^N"LYgnkZHOnaLbnkZlkOml;GKn>nSOpo O^mlkO'EHOWGK]>~kEHOpNOnkZVlk]P_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^.l5§ OMqSOo W]>ZHYgGKn"WMGKdgdgOWMZ>Oo O^`L]WGK]>E\^ l;O^mlkYg~JOEH^\O^VYgnkZHOE\EH]>_7ZHYgGKn>^Vl;O.^HOE\~kY®WO%WMGKn7^HZcLbZ>Oo Op^m_ALESdgO^S]>Z\Y[dgYg^cLbZHO]7EH^Vlk]"dgGKIJY®WY[OpdJfdALb]>ZVJ]>O`d[O`NPG;l5Oe dgOVGK_S&O o % EMLZ\Y[GJn>n>Od5n7GK]>^S_AOEHNPOZHZ\O.lkO`NO^\]>EHOESdL1J]aLdgYgZ>Oò lk]"^HOE\~YWMO#G 5OEHZS_aLbESdgOm^\sk^HZOpe NO`_aLEEcLb_>_AGKEHZ%L1e df§¬LdgZ\OEHnaLbnaWMO WGKnkZHYgnk]>YgZ>&O o %f^H]7^H_AOn>^HYgGJn¥lk]1_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^¦l§ Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJnhiY OKidLSlkYg^H_AGKn7Y[j7Y[dgYgZ>Oo lk]1^Hsk^\ZOe NPOKiT dL!d[]7NYOe EHOlkOSWMOSJ]>Yk_>E>&O o % WOe lkOKhkYgd>^\ON2j>dgOSnaLZ\]>EHOpd¡l5§ Onk~kYg^cLbIKOEl;O^¦lOo dLYg^WMGJn>^>Oo W]>ZHY«^VLb]kq%^HOp]>dgO^SG>WWM]>E\EHOnaWO^mlkOp^¦lOo LYgdgdLnaWMOp^_>EHYgN"LYgEHO^ dgO^ Oo ~Oo n>OpNOnkZH^#^HOWMGJnal>LbY[E\O^1_aO]7~KOnkZO Z\EHO2YgnaWMdg]>^1l>Ln>^`dL"lkYg^cWM]7^H^HYgGJn NLYg^VWMOpd®Ln§¬L_>_AGKE\ZHO2L]aWM]7n Oo WMdLYgEcLbIKO _ALEHZ\YWM]>dgYgOES^H]>E'df§ LbnaLdgsk^HOVl;O.dL._>E\G>WHXALYgn>O.^\GK]>^ %^\OWMZHYgGJnaA¤%§¬Lb]>ZHE\O^VNPO^H]>E\O^VlkO.dL1lkYg^H_AGKn>Ygj>YgdgYgZ>Oò l5§ ]>n^\s^\ZOe NPO L1e EML_>_7EHG>W\X>OEml;O^S_>E>Opo ^HOnkZHOp^%WMGKn7^HYlOo EMLZHYgGJn>^S^HGJnZVl;GKn>nSOpo O^ml>Lbn>^ ;¬ >OZ ;=5 C>× |!GK]>^1^H]>_7_aGJ^HGKn7^K]7OdgO^1ZHONP_>^%lkOPEHO_>E\Yg^HOrl5§ ]>n>OPOMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn9^HGKnkZ.E\O_>E>Oo ^HOnkZ>Oo ^"_aLE1]>n>O"lkYg^HZHE\Ygj>]>ZHYgGJnlkO Zfsk_AO`_>XaL^\O.fW\c · GJ]>^ %f^HOWZHYgGKn>^Vy7= 5ÒGZ 5>= 57hK¯q>ON_7d[EO 5KJ]>Ya_AOE\NOZSlkO`NG>lOo dgYg^HOpElkO^Vlk]7E>Oo O^`lkOVE\OWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZ ÝcbÙÝÆè.

(39) .

(40) !"#$ %

(41) &' )( * + -,.'/01 2 "3)4 . lOo _AOnal>LbnZl;]WMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZ.LisLbnkZ.OnkZHEML8gnSOo df§ YgnkZHOE\EH]>_>Z\YgGKn lkOdf§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\YgGKnF¯FnO ¡OZihFdgO^.ZcLb]kq lkO"lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO lOo ^HYgIJn>OnkZdgO^FZcLb]kq%lkOSZHEMLn>^\Y[Z\YgGKn%l5§ ]>n2WMGJN_AGK^cLbnkZ5~KOE\^dg&O `\_>EHONPYgO>E a"Oo ZMLZS_>XaLb^HOl;OE>Oo _aLEMLZ\Y[GJn L'^HZ\EH]aWZH]>E\O lkOdL!NLZ\EHYWMOn7GKZ>Opo O %hlkOp^ZML]kq2lkOZ\EcLbn>^HYgZHYgGJn.OnkZHE\OSd[Op^%Opo ZcLZ\^ZHEMLn>^\YgZHGKYgE\O^lkO¦WOZHZ\OVlkYg^HZHE\Ygj>]>ZHYgGJn%D F.hÄª>q>O¦Lbd[GJEH^ d[O2W\X>ONPY[n(n¦Oo WMO^\^cLbY[E\OLb],E\OZHGJ]>E%l>Lbn>^`]>n Opo ZcLZ#GK_SOo EMLZ\Y[GJn>n>Odf § On7^HON2j>dgO E\OIKE\GK]>_AOWMO^ Opo ZcLZ\^.ZHEMLn>^\YgZHGKYgE\O^ OZVWMGKn7^HZHYgZ\]>O.WMO.K]§ GJnLb_>_aOpd[OpEcL1df§ On>^HOpN2j>dgOVlkO^ ? )( l5§¬LKWMZ\Y[~kYgZ>Oò lk]^\skZOe NPOKkT WMOWMY^§¬LtMGJ]>ZHO d®LP_>]7Y[^\^cLbnaWMOlkO2E\O_>E>Opo ^HOnkZcLbZHYgGKnl;O^¥l;Y[^\ZHE\Y[j7]>ZHYgGKn7^D F.¯Fn/&O 5OZhYgdO^\Z.j>YgOn WMGKn>nk]9~KGKYgE ; 5 5>_aLbEmOq;OpN_>dgO K]7OVdf§ On>^HOpN2j>dgO¦lkOp^dgGKYg^D F O^HZSlkOn7^HO.l>Ln7^df§ Opn>^HON2j7d[OSlkO^SlkYg^HZ\EHYgj>]>Z\YgGKn>^.Lè ^H]7_>_aGJEHZYgnaWMdg]>^l>Lbn>^¬v S · Y¡WOZHZ\O EHON"LEcJ]>OO^HZl§ ]7n.YgnZ>Oo EOp Z_>dg]>ZÄGJ ZZ\X¦Oo GKE\YK]7OKhYgdkO^HZWd®LbYgEJ]>OSWMOZHZ\OLNPYgd[dgOO^HZF^H];¢^cLNPNOnkZ5dLE\IKO_AGK]7EÌlOo WMEHYgE\O L^H^\O #`^HYgN_7d[OpNOnkZlkOVn7GKN2j>E\O]kq¥WMGJN_AGKE\ZHONPOnkZH^k¯FnP_aLE\ZHYWM]>dgYgOEhJGKnP_aOp]>ZZ\EOe ^Sj7Y[OpnEHOp_>E>Oo ^\OnkZHOE`]>n7OVdgGKY5Li~KOW ]>nWMGkOM¢WY[OpnZSlkO'~KLEHYLbZHYgGKn._7d[]7^_AOZHYgZJ]>O1QVLi~KOiWVlkO^SlkYg^HZ\EHYgj>]>Z\YgGKn>^¯ÌEHdLn>I#_aLEOMq>ON_7d[OJhKWMOmJ]>YAEHYg^MK]7Oml5§gO Z\EHO ]>n>O`^HYgZH]ALZHYgGJn]7^H]>OdgdgO`_aGJ]>EVlkO^'ZHONP_>^SlkO.EHOpd®LbnaWMO.l5§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHYgGKn O,_7EHG>WMO^\^H]>^/n>GKNPYgnaLdSO^\Z,LYgn>^\YÈHONP_>dLKWAOro _ALE"]>n²_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^/NG>lOpo d[Yg^MLnkZ%Oq¦Oio WM]>ZHYgGJn OZ"EHOWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZ l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJn L(^HOp]>dgO,WMGKnAlkYgZHYgGKn E\OJ]>Yg^HOrO^\ZJ]>O"d§¬Lbd[Z\OEHnALnaWMO"WMGKnkZ\Y[nk]>YgZ>&O o %YgnkZHOpEHEH]7_>ZHYgGKn9lkO"^HOE\~kY®WOr^HGJY[Z1_AG % ZHOnkZHYgOdgdgONPOnkZmYgnkªAn>YgOK O^._AGKYgnkZH^cQphFyJh 5JÒZ2{'^H]7Y[~KLbnkZH^ÈcLb^H^HOpN2j>dgOnkZmdgO^#Xsk_AGKZ\XOe ^HOp^%N"LZHXSOo NLbZHYJ]>O^ L^H^\G>WMYOo O^.L]kql;Y Òo E\OnkZH^rOpo ~Opo n>ONOpnZ\^VOZS_7XaL^\O^mlkO#EHOWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZ QKS¤']>EMLnkZ]7n^>Oo tMGK]>EVl;]_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^.l5§ OMq¦Oo WM]>Z\Y[GJnl>Lbn>^Sdf§HOo ZcLbZ Hh7]>n>O`lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMOV_>E\YgNLYgE\O^\OmN"Ln>Y«Op^HZHO`Li~KOW ]>n"ZML]kqWMGJn>^HZMLnkZ >¹Sn>O._7XaL^\Ol;O.EHOWGK]>~kEHOpNOnkZSO^\ZmLdgGJEH^SYgn>YgZHYLdgYg^>Opo OK Omn7GKN2j>E\Oml5§ YgnaWMYlkOnkZ\^^\OWMGKnAl>LYgEHOp^l;]>EcLbnZVWOm^>Oo tMGJ]>ESO^HZ`lkGKn7n¦Oò _aLES]>n"_>E\G>WMO^H^\]>^.lkO.DGKYg^H^\GKnrlkO`ZcLb]kq >O^ml;O]kqZfsk_AO^ml§HOpo ~Opo n>ONOpnZ\^S^H]>E\~kY[Opn>n>OnkZVYgnalOo _aOpnal>LNPNOnkZdf§ ]>n"lkO.df§¬L]>Z\EHOK y>S¹!nOo ~Oo n>OpNOnkZS_>E\Y[N"LYgEHOSGJ]"^HOWMGJnal>LbY[E\O`_aO]7ZS^H]>E\~KOn>YgE'd[GJEH^Sl5§ ]>n>O`ZHEMLn>^\NYg^H^\YgGKnlkO.WMGJnZ\EÄGJ d[OÒnkZ\EHO.lkO]kq WMGJN_AGK^MLnkZHî · § Y[d5î§¬LIKYgZSl5§ ]>n>O.lOMo fLYgdgd®LbnaWMOKhkGJn"_aLE\d[O.Lbd[GJEH^Vl5§ ]>n7O%lOMo LbYgd[dLbnaWM

(42) O 0 3 4%

(43) 0 GK] ) )0 Op^%J]aLnkZHYgZ>Oo ^ 5 > b¥EHOp^H_ F KH`lOpo ^HYgIKn>OpnZ#d[Op^m_7EHGKjALj>YgdgYgZ>Oo ^.l5§ G>WWM]>E\EHOnAWMOl5§ ]>n Oo ~Oo n>O % NPOnkZ._>EHYgN"LYgEHOPE\O^H_F^\OWMGJnal>LYgE\O1dgGKEH^2l5§ ]>n Z\EcLn7^fOE\ZlkOrWMGKnkZ\EÄGK dgOl5§ ]>nwOo ZcLb Z '~JOEH^2]>nwOo ZcLbZ > GKE\^ l5§ ]>n7O.G>WWM]>E\EHOnaWO^HYgN2]>dgZMLnSOo O.lkOp^l;O]kqrZfsk_aO^.l5§ YgnaWMYlkOpnZ\^.fLi~KOW#_>EHGJjaLj7Y[dgYgZ>O o K F > KHh^HO]>dFdf§HOo ~&O o % n>OpNOnkZF_>EHYgN"LYgEHOOp^HZ_>EHYgÔnWGKN_7ZHOK O^_aLEMLN,Ope ZHEHOp^ 5 > KFOZ F KF~KLdgOnk.Z

(44) '_aGJ]>E]>n>OSZHEMLn>^\YgZHYgGKn1n>O WMGJEHE\O^H_AGKnal7LnkZV_aLb^L#e ]>n"ZHEMLn>^×OE\ZVlkO.WMGKnkZHEGK dgOK § YgnZ\EHG>lk]aWZHYgGKnlkO`_aLbEcLbN,Oe Z\EHO^VlkO`lOMo LbYgd[dLbnaWMOml;Y[^\ZHYgnaWMZ\^ _AGK]>E]>n2ZHEMLn>^×OEHZSlkO`WMGKnkZHEGK dgOSOZ]7n>OmlOo LYgdgdLnaWM O `HYgnkZHOpEHn>_O a#O^HZnSOo WMOp^H^cLbYgEHO`^HYAdgO^lkGJn>nSOo O^SlkO`lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMO _AGK]>ESW\XaLKJ]>O.WMGJN_AGK^MLnkZn>O'^HGKnkZ_aL^SWMGJd[dgOWZ>Oo O^`l>Ln7^]>nPOnk~kY[E\GKn>n7ONOnkZEHO_7E>Oo ^\OnkZcLZ\Y«l;Omdf§ YgnkZHOEMLKWMZ\Y[GJn OnkZ\EHO.dgO^VWMGJN_AGK^MLnkZHî 5> · Yk]>n1YgnaWMYlkOnkZF_>E\Y[N"LYgEHOF^\]>EH~kYgOnkZlk]>EMLnkZdf§ OMqSOo WM]7ZHYgGKn2lk]2WMGKNP_aGJ^cLnkZ AGK].dgGKE\^l5§ ]>n.ZHEMLn>^×OE\ZlkOVWMGJnZ\EÄGJ d[O L/e _aLbEHZ\Y[El;]¸WGKN_AGK^MLnkZ Hh > KlOo ^\YgIKn>OrdL(_>EHGJjaLj7Y[dgYgZ>OPo _aGJ]>EJ]>O ^\GKYgZ2dgO"_>EHONPYgOE Oo ZcLbZlkO E\OWMGK]7~E\ONOpnZS~kYg^HYgZ>OKo {a · GJYgZS dgOV_>E\G;WO^H^\]>^mlOpo ^HYgIKnaLbnkZL#e ZHGJ]>ZSYgn>^HZMLnk.Z hJ^HGJYgZdgOmWGKN_AGK^MLnkZLJWMZHY«^\GKYgZd§\Oo ZMLZSlkOVE\OWMGJ]>~kEH&O % NPOnkZLZ\ZHOYgnkZ · GJnO^\_aLKWOl§HOpo ZcLZ O^HZGJEHNOVo lkO`d®LE>Oo ]>n7Y[GJnrlkOVdf§ On>^\ON2j>dgO lkO^"Opo ZcLZ\^VL^\^HG>WMYOo ^%L#e ]>n>O LJWMZHYg~kYgZ>O.o l5§ ]>nWGKN_AGK^MLnkZOZVlkO.df§ On>^\ON2j>dg O , ¯FZMLnkZVlkGJn>nSOo O.]7n>O.ZHEMLtMOWZHGKYgE\O%lk5O h>dgO^S_7EHG>WMO^\^H]>^%l;OlOMo LYgdgdLnaWOWGKn>^\Y®lOo E>Oo ^.LbY[n7^HYJ]>O.dgO^'_>EHG>WMO^\^H]>^ lkO1lOMo LbY[dgdLnAWMOÒZ.lkO.EHOiWMGK]>~kE\ONOnkZ.l5§ OE\EHO]>E\^.^HGJnkZVYgnalOo _AOnal7LnkZH^`dgO^V]7n>^mlkOp^Lb]>ZHE\O^|SGK]7^V^H]7_>_aGJ^HGJn>^ lkGJn>nSOo O#d®L1N"LZ\EHYWM5O WlkO^'ZcLb]kq,lkO.ZHEMLn>^\YgZHYgGKn"OnkZHE\O%]7n Oo ZcLbZmlkO#EHOWMGJ]>~kEHONPOnkZÒZV]>n Oo ZcLbZVGK_SOo EcLbZHYgGKn>n7Od ^MLKW\XaLnkZJ]>O#X W `p Q

(45) H

(46) 7 §¬LdgZHOE\naLnAWMOSOnkZHE\Om_SOo EHYgG>lkOVGJ_SOo EMLZHYgGJn>n>OdgdgOSOZ_¦Oo EHYgG>lkO'n>GKn %fGK_SOo EcLbZHYgGKn>n7Odgd[O O^\ZVE>Oo IKYgO`_aLESdgOÌOpo n¦Oo EcLbZHO]7EV^H]7Y[~KLbnkZ¡¨ K 1 KMM Q 5 > b\ ^HY wOZ J > 1 ^HY J K ; ¥ > 5 >> > K ^HYF > K A K . > K ^HY A K W > K ^HYF > K J^ . ÙÙ É.JGK4LïM.

(47) Q