Detecting user's interests based on the accuracy of collaborative tagging information

O

pen

A

rchive

T

OULOUSE

A

rchive

O

uverte (

OATAO

)

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.

This is an author-deposited version published in : http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/

Eprints ID : 12678

The contribution was presented at ECSCW 2013 :

https://ecscw2013.cs.ucy.ac.cy/index.php

To cite this version : Mezghani, Manel and Péninou, André and Zayani,

Corinne and Amous, Ikram and Sèdes, Florence Detecting user's interests

based on the accuracy of collaborative tagging information. (2013) In: 13th

International Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work

(ECSCW 2013), 21 September 2013 - 25 September 2013 (Paphos, Cyprus).

Any correspondance concerning this service should be sent to the repository

.$$)+.$2(03($044.-0+.#%5"(#.''%&'(

%&30+6.#%0&(

7.&"4(7"8'1.&%

9:;<

:(=&/+>(?>&%&0)

;<

:(@0+%&&"(=6"4(A.2.&%

9<

:(BC+.6(

=60)*

9D

(.&/(E40+"&$"(FG/"*

;<

(

9_{F3.H(I&%5"+*%#2:(7BJ=@K(K.-0+.#0+2:(F3.H:(L)&%*%.M(};_{?.)4(F.-.#%"+(I&%5"+*%#2:(} BJBL(K.-0+.#0+2M((

<

*)+&.6"N%+%#M3+

:(

D !"#$%&$%'()*!)+,)&#-(&.-(

!"#$%&'$()_{!" #$%&" '&()*+%" ,-$" .(" &%)+%/." .,%"}XVHU¶V0%%1$"-//(&1*02".(",*$"/,-&-/.%&*$.*/$"

3'%&$(0-+" 1-.-4" *0.%&%$.$" -01" '&%)%&%0/%$54" ,*$" /(0.%6.4" -01" ,*$" $*.#-.*(07" 80" .,*$" -&.*/+%4" 9%")(/#$"(0".,%"'&(:+%;"()"-1-'.-.*(0"<#-+*.="*0"$(/*-+"0%.9(&>$4"9,*/,"*$"-))%/.%1":=".,%" DFFXUDF\ DQG UHOHYDQFH RI WKH XVHU¶V" *0.%&%$.$7" ?,%" (&*2*0-+*.=" ()" (#&" -''&(-/," *$" .,%" SURSRVDO RI D QHZ WHFKQLTXH RI LQWHUHVWV¶ GHWHFWLRQ" :=" -0-+=@*02" .,%" -//#&-/=" ()" .,%" .-22*02" :%,-A*(#&" ()" .,%" #$%&" *0" (&1%&" .(" )*2#&%" (#." .,%" .-2$" 9,*/," -/.#-++=" &%)+%/." .,%" UHVRXUFHV¶FRQWHQWB#&"-''&(-/,",-$":%%0".%$.%1"-01"%A-+#-.%1"(0".,%"C%+*/*(#$"$(/*-+" 1-.-:-$%7"

B&#+0/)$#%0&(

F0$%.4(%&30+6.#%0&(%*(O"+6.&"&#42('+0P%&'M(@0&*"Q)"&#42:(#1"(./.O#.#%0&(O+0$"**( -"$06"*( 60+"( $06O4"HM( L1"( ./.O#.#%0&( %*( .( O+0$"**( *#+0&'42( +"4.#"/( #0( )*"+¶V( O+03%4"(60/"44%&'M(=(O+03%4"(#1.#(+"34"$#*(#1"(.OO+0O+%.#"($1.+.$#"+%*#%$*(R%&#"+"*#*:( O+"3"+"&$"*:( "#$MS( $0)4/( .50%/( $0'&%#%5"( 05"+40./( .&/( /%*0+%"&#.#%0&( 03( #1"( )*"+( P1"&(.$$"**%&'(#1"(%&30+6.#%0&(*O.$"M(B&(0)+(P0+C:(P"(.+"(%&#"+"*#"/(%&(/"#"$#%&'( #1"()*"+,*(%&#"+"*#*(#1.#(P%44(-"()*"/(%&(3)+#1"+(P0+C*(30+(.&(./.O#.#%0&(O)+O0*"M(

!"#"$#%&'( *0$%.4( )*"+¶V( %&#"+"*#*,( %*( .( &0&( #+%5%.4( O+0-4"6( R7%4%$"5%$( +.( .4M:( ;T9TSM( B&( 3.$#:( #1"( )*"+¶V( O+03%4"( -)%4/%&'( O+0$"**( *)33"+*( 3+06( #1"( 4.$C( 03( %&30+6.#%0&( O+05%/"/( -2( 1%6*"43M( B&/""/:( #1"( )*"+( '"&"+.442( /0"*&,#( '%5"( .44( #1"( %&30+6.#%0&( +"4.#"/( #0( 1%*( %&#"+"*#*M( F0( 1%*( O+03%4"( $.&( &"5"+( -"( $0&*%/"+"/( 3)442(

" "

C&0P&( -2( .( *2*#"6MB&( 0+/"+( #0( 05"+$06"( *)$1( .( O+0-4"6:( #1"( +"*".+$1"+*( 1.5"( .&.428"/( #1"( *0$%.4( "&5%+0&6"&#( 03( #1"( )*"+( *)$1( .*( 1%*( &"%'1-0)+*( R#1"( O"+*0&*( $0&&"$#"/( #0( #1"( )*"+( "HO4%$%#42( 0+( %6O4%$%#42S:( 1%*( #.''%&'( -"1.5%0)+( R#1"( $044.-0+.#%5"(.$#%0&(03(#.''%&'(+"*0)+$"*S:(0+("5"&(#1"(0-U"$#*( R#1"(+"*0)+$"*S(1"( %&#"+.$#*(P%#1(R*""(30+("H.6O4"(R=*#+.%&(+.(.4M:(;T9TSSM(

B&( #1%*( O.O"+:( P"( 3%+*#42( O+"*"&#( *06"( "H%*#%&'( P0+C*( %&#"'+.#%&'( #1"( *0$%.4( "&5%+0&6"&#(03(#1"()*"+(#0(/"#"$#(%&#"+"*#*M(L1"&:(P"(*10P(#1"(/%33"+"&$"*(03(0)+( .OO+0.$1($06O.+"/(#0(#1"(0#1"+(.OO+0.$1"*(%&(#1"(*.6"($0&#"H#M(V"(#1"&(/"*$+%-"( 0)+( O+0O0*.4( 30+( /"#"$#%&'( %&#"+"*#*( .&/( #1"( "HO"+%6"&#*( /0&"( #0( 5.4%/.#"( %#M( E%&.442:(P"($0&$4)/"(.&/(/%*$)**(*06"(3)#)+"(P0+C*M(

J"4.#"/(P0+C*(

=$$0+/%&'( #0( R=*#+.%&( +.( .4M:( ;T9TS:( %&#"+"*#*( $0)4/( -"( /"/)$"/( 3+06( #1"( *0$%.4( "&5%+0&6"&#( -.*"/( 0&( #1"( !"#$:( #1"( %&'#()* 0+( "5"&( #1"( )+,M( L1"( $044.-0+.#%5"( #.''%&'( -"1.5%0)+( %*( /"*$+%-"/( .*( #1"( $0&&"$#%0&( 03( #1"*"( #1+""( "4"6"&#*W( %#( +"O+"*"&#*(#1"(.$#%0&(03(#.''%&'(.(+"*0)+$"(R0-U"$#S(-2(".$1()*"+M(

E0+(#1"(!"#$:(%&#"+"*#*($0)4/(-"("HO4%$%#42(O+05%/"/(%&(#1"()*"+¶VO+03%4"(RA.2.&%(

+.(.4M(;TTXS:(0+(%6O4%$%#42(/"/)$"/(3+06(1%*(-"1.5%0)+(03(&.5%'.#%0&(RJ"-.%(+.(.4M:(

;T9;S(0+(-"1.5%0)+(03(#.''%&'(RY%6(+.(.4M:(;T99SM(L1"()*"+Z-.*"/(%&#"+"*#($0)4/(-"( /"/)$"/( 3+06( 0#1"+( )*"+*( %&( #1"( &"#P0+C*( R&"%'1-0)+*S( RY%6( +.( .4M:( ;T99S( RL$1)"&#":(;T9[SM(

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

E0+( #1"( )+,:( %#*( )#%4%#2( 1.*( -""&( O+05"&( #0( /"#"$#( )*"+,*( %&#"+"*#( RY%6( +.( .4M:( ;T99SM(-+,Z-.*"/(%&#"+"*#(/"#"$#%0&($0)4/(-"(/"/)$"/(-2(.&.428%&'()*"/(#.'*(R!"( 7"0(+.(.4M(;T9TS(0+(-2(.&.428%&'(#1"(*"6.&#%$(03(#.'*(RY%6(+./.4M:(;T99SM(

F2&#1"*%*(

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

?+0O0*"/(.OO+0.$1(

B&(#1%*(*"$#%0&:(P"(P%44(O+0O0*"(0)+(.OO+0.$1(30+(/"#"$#%&'(.$$)+.$2(03(#1"()*"+,*( %&#"+"*#M(L1%*(.OO+0.$1(%*(-.*"/(0&(#1"(12O0#1"*%*(#1.#(.()*"+:(P10(#.'*(.(+"*0)+$"( P%#1(C"2P0+/*(+"34"$#%&'(%#*($0&#"&#:(%*(+".442(%&#"+"*#"/(P%#1(#1"(#1"6.#%$(03(#1%*( +"*0)+$"M( L1%*( 0-*"+5.#%0&( P%44( -"( "HO"+%6"&#"/( .&/( 5.4%/.#"/( 0&( #1"( !"4%$%0)*( *0$%.4(/.#.*"#M(

!"#$%&'(&)*+

B&( 0)+( .OO+0.$1:( P"( .&.428"( #1"( #.'*( .**%'&"/( #0( #1"( +"*0)+$"*( #0( /"#"$#( )*"+,*( %&#"+"*#M(L1"(+"*0)+$"*(.+"('"&"+.442(.(*"#(03(IJK*(/"*$+%-%&'(#1"6M(V"("H#+.$#(%&( #1"(3%+*#(*#"O(#1"(#.''%&'(-"1.5%0)+(+"4.#%0&*:($06O0*"/(-2(#1"(#.'*(.OO4%"/(#0(#1"( +"*0)+$"*(-2(".$1()*"+M(`"&"+.442(#1%*(.$#%5%#2(%*(+"O+"*"&#"/(%&(.(#+%O.+#%#"(60/"4( P1%$1(/"*$+%-"*(#1"()*"+*(Iab(01&&&(2c:(#1"(+"*0)+$"*(-"%&'(#.''"/(Jab#01&&&1#%c( .&/(#1"(#.'*(Lab.01&&&.-c(W( ( ( ( ( L.''%&'(+"4.#%0&(WdI:(L:(Je( ( ( ( R9S( P1"+"(2(#1"(&)6-"+(03()*"+*:(-(#1"(&)6-"+(03(#.'*(.&/(%(#1"(&)6-"+(03(+"*0)+$"*M+ B&(#1"(*"$0&/(*#"O:(P"("H#+.$#(#1"($0&#"&#(03(#1"*"(IJK*(.&/(%&/"H(#1"6(.*(*"6%Z( *#+)$#)+"/( Rf7KS( 3%4"*:( )*%&'( #1"( K)$"&"( %&/"H%&'( #004( =?B9_{M( V"( P%44( )*"( %#( %&(}

0+/"+(#0(3%')+"(0)#(#1"(60*#(.$$)+.#"(#.'*(P%#1(+"'.+/(#0(#1"($0&#"&#(03(#1"(#.''"/( +"*0)+$"*M(K)$"&"(+"4%"*(0&(.(3%"4/Z-.*"/(%&/"H.#%0&(#"$1&%Q)"M(L1%*($1.+.$#"+%*#%$( ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((

" "

"&.-4"*(%&/"H%&'(#1"(/0$)6"&#*(.$$0+/%&'(#0(0&"(0+(60+"(3%"4/*M(])+(%&/"H.#%0&( O+0$"**(%*(/0&"(.$$0+/%&'(#0(#1"(3%"4/*W(#%#4":($0&#"&#(.&/(IJKM(=3#"+(%&/"H%&'(#1"( $0&#"&#( 03( #1"( +"*0)+$"*:( P"( .**%'&( .( +.&C( #0( ".$1( +"*0)+$"( .$$0+/%&'( #0( #1"( .**%'&"/(#.'M(L1%*(+.&C(%*($06O)#"/(3+06(.(*%6%4.+%#2(-"#P""&(#1"(+"*0)+$"(R.*(.( f7K( 3%4"S( .&/( #1"( Q)"+2( R.*( .( #.'SM( 7.&2( *%6%4.+%#2( 3)&$#%0&*( "H%*#( %&( #1"( 4%#"+.#)+"(*)$1(.*(#1"(*%6%4.+%#2(3)&$#%0&(*)OO0+#"/(-2(K)$"&";_M(

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

E%')+"M(9M(L1"(%&#"+"*#(/"#"$#%0&(O+0$"**M(

./0&,/(&)*+

V"( 5.4%/.#"/( 0)+( .OO+0.$1( )O0&( #1"( !"4%$%0)*( /.#.-.*"( #1.#( $0&#.%&*( *0$%.4( &"#P0+C%&':(-00C6.+C%&':(.&/(#.''%&'(%&30+6.#%0&M(B#(O+05%/"*(%&30+6.#%0&(.-0)#( #1"()*"+,*(3+%"&/(+"4.#%0&*1%O*(.&/(#1"(#.''%&'(+"4.#%0&(%&30+6.#%0&(dI:(L:(JeM(L1"( )*"+*( I( .+"( /"*$+%-"/( #1+0)'1( #1"%+( B!M( L1"( +"*0)+$"*( J( .+"( /"*$+%-"/( #1+0)'1( #1"%+(B!:(IJK(.&/(#%#4"M(L1"(#.'*(L(.+"(/"*$+%-"/(#1+0)'1(#1"%+(B!(.&/(5.4)"M(V"( 1.5"(#"*#"/(0)+(.OO+0.$1(0&(.(*"#(03(9TT()*"+*M(L1"*"()*"+*(1.5"(/%33"+"&#(&)6-"+( 03(&"%'1-0)+*(R5.+2%&'(3+06(9(#0(;TSM(L1"(&)6-"+(03(#.'*:(/0$)6"&#*(.&/(#.''%&'( +"4.#%0&*(%*(/%33"+"&#(30+(".$1()*"+M(L1%*(&)6-"+(6.2(+0)'142(5.+2(3+06(9T(#0(hTT( 30+(#1"(#.'*:(3+06(9T(#0(hTT(30+(#1"(/0$)6"&#*:(.&/(3+06(;T(#0(iTT(30+(#1"(#.''%&'( +"4.#%0&*M( E0+( #1"( +"*)4#( 03( #1"( #0OZC( /0$)6"&#*( +"4"5.&#( #0( .( Q)"+2:( P"( 1.5"( $10*"&(Ca9TTTTM(L1"(5.4)"(03(C(%*($10*"&(.$$0+/%&'(#0(#1"(4.+'"*#(O0**%-4"(5.4)":( .*(P"(P.&#"/(#0(#"*#(R%&(#1%*(3%+*#(*#.'"S(P%#1(#1"(6.H%6)6(03( +"*)4#*(.$1%"5.-4"( R"5"&(#10*"(P%#1(40P"+(*$0+"*SM(=4*0:(#1"($10%$"(03(#1"(C(5.4)"(%*(O+0O0+#%0&.4(#0( #1"(&)6-"+(03(+"*0)+$"*(Ri\;;i(IJK*S(.&/(#.'*(Rh[[jj(#.'*S(%&(#1"(/.#.-.*"M( 1"(2#+ (/3"+ /#+ /*+ "4/5'0"+ (6"+ (/7+ 85/(68+ /##&7*",+ 9:+ /+ ;#"%+ ()+ ,&<<"%"*(+ %"#);%$"#-+=6&#+(/7+6/#+/+6&76"%+#$)%"+/$$)%,&*7+()+(6"+%"#);%$"2#+(&(0"+8>?1+@/(68A+ B6&$6+$)*(/&*#+5/(6+%"0/(",+(6"5/(&$A+(6"*+(6"+%"#);%$"+(&(0"+8C*0&*"+!&$"+D)00"%8A+ B6&$6+,)"#+ *)(+ $)*(/&*+/*:+ &*<)%5/(&)*+ %"0/(",+ ()+(6"+(6"5/(&$-+E)A+ /$$)%,&*7+()+ (6&#+ "4/5'0"A+ (6"+ (/7+ 85/(68+ &#+ %"0"F/*(+ ()+ (6"+ %"#);%$"+ 8>?1+ @/(68-+ G<("%+ ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((

,"("$(&*7+ (6&#+ %"0"F/*(+ (/7A+ B"+ B&00+ F/0&,/("+ (6&#+ %"#;0(+ 9:+ ;#&*7+ (6"+ ;#"%2#+ *"&769);%#-+ =6"+ F/0&,/(&)*+)9H"$(&F"+ &#+()+ #6)B+&<+ (6&#+ %"0"F/*(+ (/7+&#+ /$$;%/("+ ()+ (6"+;#"%+)%+*)(-+ >*+(6&#+"4'"%&5"*(A+(KHQHLJKERXUVDUHWKHH[SOLFLWIULHQGVKLSUHODWLRQWKHXVHU¶V "7)$"*(%&$+*"(B)%3I-+=6"+5"(6),+)<+F/0&,/(&)*+;#"#+(6"+#)$&/0+"*F&%)*5"*(+)<+(6"+ ;#"%+J(6"+*"&769);%#I+()+,"("$(+&*("%"#(#-+>*+</$(+(6"+*"&769);%#+'%)F&,"+&*<)%5/(&)*+ (6/(+UHIOHFWWKHXVHU¶VLQWHUHVWV7FKXHQWH:HFDOFXODWHWKHSUHFLVLRQRIWKH GHWHFWHGLQWHUHVWVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHWDJVLQWKHQHLJKERXUV¶SURILOHV7KHSUHFLVLRQLV FDOFXODWHG DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH QXPEHU RI DFFXUDWH WDJV ZKLFK H[LVW LQ WKH XVHU¶V *"&769);%#+'%)<&0"I+/*,+(6"+()(/0+*;59"%+)<+(/7#+'%)F&,",+/#+/$$;%/("-++

7KLVSUHFLVLRQLVFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKVLQJOHXVHU¶VQHLJKERXU7KHRYHUDOOSUHFLVLRQ LV WKH DYHUDJH RI DOO WKH QHLJKERXUV¶ SUHFLVLRQ )&7;%"+ KA+ #6)B#+ (6"+ )F"%/00+ '%"$&#&)*A+<)%+(6&#+#"(+)<+;#"%#A+9"(B""*+(6"+$/0$;0/(",+%"0"F/*(+(/7#+/*,+(6"+;#"%2#+ (/7+J%"/0+(/77&*7+9"6/F&);%I-+

E%')+"M(;M(?+"$%*%0&(03(#1"(.$$)+.#"(%&#"+"*#*(/"#"$#"/(30+(.(*"#(03(9TT()*"+*M(

!&#$;##&)*+

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

G0#)A+ (6"+ /$$;%/("+ &*("%"#(#+ '%)F&,",+ 9:+ );%+ /''%)/$6+ /%"+ $)5'%"6"*#&90"+ 3":B)%,#+ B6&$6+ %"<0"$(+ %"/00:+ (6"+ %"#);%$"2#+ $)*("*(+ 0&3"+ ³("$6*)0)7:´A+ ³<);%#N;/UH´A+³6&#()%:´A+"($-+=6&#+&#+/*+/,F/*(/7"+#&*$"+(6"+(/7#+/%"+;#"%Q7"*"%/(",+ 3":B)%,#-+ C;%+ /''%)/$6+ 6/#+ <&0("%",+ (6"+ /59&7;);#+ (/7#+ J&-"M³7LV´+ (6/(+ /%"+ *)(+ $)5'%"6"*#&90"+ 9:+ )(6"%+ ;#"%#-+ =6"+ (/7#2+ /59&7;&(:+ 6/#+ ,"$%"/#",+ <%)5+ RKS+ ()+ KTS+/$$)%,&*7+()+P)%,U"(T_-(

@0&$4)*%0&(

>*+(6&#+'/'"%A+B"+6/F"+'%)')#",+/*+/''%)/$6+<)%+,"("$(&*7+/$$;%/("+;#"%2#+&*("%"#(#+ (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( [ (_{1##OWggP0+/&"#MO+%&$"#0&M"/)g(}

" "

9/#",+ )*+ (6"+ #)$&/0+ "*F&%)*5"*(-+ P"+ 6/F"+ "4'0)&(",+ (6"+ $)*("*(+ )<+ (6"+ (/77",+ %"#);%$"#+ &*+ )%,"%+ ()+ <&7;%"+ );(+ (6"+ (/7#+ %"<0"$(&*7+ %"/00:+ (6"+ (6"5/(&$+ )<+ (6"++ %"#);%$"#-+P"+6/F"+F/0&,/(",+);%+/''%)/$6+ (6%);76+(6"+(/77&*7+9"6/F&);%+)<+ (6"+ *"&769);%#+J6&#+"7)$"*(%&$+*"(B)%3I-++

>*+ <;(;%"+ B)%3#A+ B"+ B&00+ ("#(+ );%+ /''%)/$6+ )*+ /+ 0/%7"%+ ')';0/(&)*+ )<+ ;#"%#+ &*+ )%,"%+()+6/F"+5)%"+#$/0/90"+%"#;0(#-+G0#)A+B"+B&00+("#(+)(6"%+<)%5#+)<+*"&769);%#+ #;$6+ /#A+ ;#"%#+ (/77&*7+ (6"+ #/5"+ %"#);%$"#A+ )%+ "F"*+ ;#"%#+ 9"0)*7&*7+ ()+ (6"+ #/5"+ ³F)55;*&(:´-+>*+</$(A+/+;#"%+5/:+#6/%"+$)55)*+&*("%"#(#+B&(6+)(6"%+'")'0"+(6/*+ 6&#+ "4'0&$&(0:+ <%&"*,+ %"0/(&)*#6&'-+ C;%+ /''%)/$6+ $);0,+ 9"+ ;#",+ <)%+ /*+ /,/'(/(&)*+ ';%')#"+ J&-"-M+ "*%&$65"*(+ )<+ (6"+ ;#"%¶V+ '%)<&0"A+ %"$)55"*,/(&)*A+ "($-IA+ #&*$"+ &(+ '%)F&,"#+/+#)0;(&)*+<)%+,"("$(&*7+XVHU¶V&*("%"#(#-+

D"<"%"*$"#+

=*#+.%&:( kM( kM:( @0+/0-.:( =M:( l$1.+#":( EM( .&/( ^%44./.&'0*( kM( R;T9TSW( m=&( .4'0+%#16( 30+( #1"( %6O+05"6"&#( 03( #.'Z( -.*"/( *0$%.4( %&#"+"*#( /%*$05"+2mM( Fl7=?J]W( L1"( E0)+#1( B&#"+&.#%0&.4( @0&3"+"&$"(0&(=/5.&$"*(%&(F"6.&#%$(?+0$"**%&'M(;T9T:(OOM(n\ZhnM(

!"(7"0:(?M:(o).##+0&":(`M(.&/(I+*%&0(!M(R;T9TSWm=(Q)"+2("HO.&*%0&(.&/()*"+(O+03%4"("&+%$16"&#( .OO+0.$1( #0( %6O+05"( #1"( O"+30+6.&$"( 03( +"$066"&/"+( *2*#"6*( 0O"+.#%&'( 0&( .( 304C*0&062mM( I*"+(70/"4%&'(.&/(I*"+Z=/.O#"/(B&#"+.$#%0&M(;T9T:(;TR9S:(OOM(n9±jiM(

Y%6:(_MZpM:(=4C1.4/%:(=M:(F.//%C:(=M(lM(.&/(k0%(`MZFM(R;T99SW(m@044.-0+.#%5"()*"+(60/"4%&'((P%#1( )*"+Z( '"&"+.#"/( #.'*( 30+( *0$%.4( +"$066"&/"+( *2*#"6*mM( ( lHO"+#( F2*#"6*( P%#1( ( =OO4%$.#%0&*:( ;T99:(OOM(jnjj±jn\iM(

7.:( qM:( A"&':( qM:( J"&:( fM:( A10&':( pM( R;T99SW( mI*"+( B&#"+"*#*( 70/"4%&'( r.*"/( 0&( 7)4#%Z*0)+$"( ?"+Z*0&.4( B&30+6.#%0&( E)*%0&( .&/( F"6.&#%$( J".*0&%&'mM( =$#%5"( 7"/%.( L"$1&040'2( R=7LS( ;T99W(9\hZ;ThM(

7"8'1.&%:(7M:(=6"4A.2.&%:(@M(=M:(=60)*:(BM(.&/(`.+'0)+%:(EM(R;T9;SW(m=()*"+(O+03%4"((60/"44%&'( )*%&'(*0$%.4(.&&0#.#%0&*W(.(*)+5"2mMVVV(R@06O.&%0&(^04)6"S:(;T9;:(OOM(\i\Z\XiM(

7%4%$"5%$:( =M( YM:( p.&0O0)40*:( =M( .&/( B5.&05%$:( 7M( R;T9TSWmF0$%.4( #.''%&'( %&( +"$066"&/"+( *2*#"6*W(.(*)+5"2(03(#1"(*#.#"Z03Z#1"Z.+#(.&/(O0**%-4"("H#"&*%0&*mM(=+#%3M(B&#"44M(J"5M(^04M([[(&0M( [:(;T9T:(OOM(9jXZ;T\M(

J"-.%:( JMA:( A.2.&%:( @M( =M( .&/( =60)*:( BM( R;T9;SW( m=&( =/.O#%5"( p.5%'.#%0&( 7"#10/( 30+( F"6%Z *#+)$#)+"/(!.#.mM(=/5.&$"*(%&(!.#.-.*"*(.&/(B&30+6.#%0&(F2*#"6*(=!rBF(R;S:(;T9;:(OOM(;TXZ ;9hM(

F0&':( qM:( A1.&':( KM:( .&/( `%4"*:( @M( KM( R;T99SW( m=)#06.#%$( #.'( +"$066"&/.#%0&( .4'0+%#16*( 30+( *0$%.4(+"$066"&/"+(*2*#"6*mM(=@7(L+.&*M:(V"-M^04Mh:(&0M9:(=+#%$4"(n:(;T99:(OOM(9Z[9M( L$1)"&#":(!M:(R;T9[SW( m70/>4%*.#%0&("#(/>+%5.#%0&(/"(O+03%4*)#%4%*.#")+*s(O.+#%+(/"(+>*".)H*0$%.)H(

W.OO+0$1"(.(O.+#%+(/"($066)&.)#>*(/"(+>*".)H(CZ"'0$"&#+%Q)"*mM(!0$#0+.4(#1"*%*:(I&%5"+*%#2(03( L0)40)*":(;T9[M(

^.44"#:( !M:( @.&#./0+:( BM( .&/(k0*":( kM( R;T9TSW(m?"+*0&.4%8%&'( V"-( F".+$1( P%#1( E04C*0&062Zr.*"/( I*"+( .&/( !0$)6"&#( ?+03%4"*( =/5.&$"*( %&( B&30+6.#%0&( J"#+%"5.4mM( =/5.&$"*( %&( B&30+6.#%0&( J"#+%"5.4:(;T9T:(^04M(h\\[:(OOM(n;TZn[9M(

V1%#":(JM:(r.%4"2(?M(.&/(@1"&:(KM(R;TT\SW(m?+"/%$#%&'()*"+(%&#"+"*#*(3+06($0&#"H#).4(%&30+6.#%0&mM( B&#"+&.#%0&.4( @0&3"+"&$"( 0&( J"*".+$1( .&/( !"5"40O6"&#( %&( B&30+6.#%0&( J"#+%"5.4( RFB`BJS:( ;TT\:(=@7:(p"P(q0+C:(pq:(IF=:(OOM([i[±[XTM(

A.2.&%:(@M(=M:(?>&%&0):(=M:(7.+%"ZE+.&t0%*":(@M(.&/(F"/"*:(EM(R;TTXSW(mL0P.+/*(.&(=/.O#.#%0&(03( F"6%Z( *#+)$#)+"/( !0$)6"&#( o)"+2%&'mM( ?+0$""/%&'*( 03( #1"( @BJ,TX( V0+C*10O( ( 0&( @0&#"H#Z r.*"/(B&30+6.#%0&(J"#+%"5.4(@BJ(;TTX:(@lIJZVFM0+':(^04M([;iM(