Quelques améliorations à la segmentation d'images bayesienne
59
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Quelques ame´liorations a` la segmentation d’images bayesienne Xavier Descombes, Robin Morris, Josiane Zerubia. N˚ 2916 Juin 1996 THE`ME 3. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8) ! "$#%
(9) '&(
(10) )* + ,(-/.021/35451/687:9<;$=>1?6?@BAC9D=B0FEHGI9<3J3J026?@LKM9<6N0F-<EB1POQ1?3JR=B0STVUXWY[Z \] ^`_:abZcbdfe!ahgjik_lUXifYCY[Znm`YCdfeoUpgj_XZfq gjYCdfrkZstqvuXik_p_XwtZstqMetik_p_vdxgjshsbdx_XetZs y>czif{%Za|y<}~pTV^~ |dfpDikcauXZ chZeoUXZtczeoUXZ_ f pN] fpgj_N k k] k*vdfrfZts 5/JB+|ifXsQupwaodgjif_Xsuvdx_XsQeZ|chdfX<ikcza>jZtsQupgjDwtczZt_:abZsVwabdf<ZtsLuXZ|dszZtrkY[Z_ aodxazgik_ VdJkZszgjZt_X_XZ/Y[i/uXwgjsbdxazgik_qxZszahgjYCdxahgjik_ qxikpazgY gjsbdxazgik_¡k¢+d|Y[i/uXwgshdxahgjik_ Zsza dfXXczwtUXZ_XuXwtZ shikpsF£¤df_prfZCuXZs*¥UvdxYCps uXZ§¦ldfcz¨fiN©<¡ªikXsYCif_?ahchik_psjZtsjgjY gjahZts uX5Y[iupWjZ«uXZ«yBifazabseikXchdfY[YCZ_:a ZtY[pjiNkw¬Z!aVXczikDifshik_XsQX_5_Xifp©kZtdf5Y[iupWjZ*2jZ eoUpgZ_m`Y[i/uXWjZN®¬<ZtczYCZ!ahabdf_:aupZ etik_:abcz¯fjZtc°d§jik_XrfXZtXcupZts etik_:ahikXchs Z!a uXZtsgrk_pZts uvdf_Xs F£±gjYCdfrkZshZrkY[Zt_:abwZf¡Q|ikXs[XczwtszZtcz©fik_Xs§dxg_pszg jZts[szahchXe!abXczZts ²X_XZts[XczwtshZ_:abZts uvdf_Xs+ZsBupik_X_XwZtst¡x|ifXsdf³DifchuXik_psZ_XshgjahZQjZQXczik³pjWtY[ZLuXZLF£±ZtszazgYCdxazgif_ uX_XikY ³pchZ uXZ edfshszZtsZa uXZs vdfcbdxYCW!abczZts ´?pgµjZtXczsszik_:adfshszie!gwst¡|ifXsXchifDikszik_XsX_pZCY[wn abUXi/uXZpahggshdf_:aLF£±U?/<ifabUpWtshZ|etik_:ahZ!¶/abXZ!jjZ|gj_XUXwchZ_?ahZ¬df/¶ gYCdfrfZts>DifXc>upgszetcgY gj_XZtc ZsQupgDwtchZ_:abZtsQedfshszZtsVuXdf_Xs>ZªeJdfsLuXZupgjszahczgj³Xpahgjik_XsL·¸ikczahZtY[Zt_:aQY[wdf_XrkwZtst¡pyBikpc>² _pgcq?_XikXsQetikY[vdfczik_Xs>ZseczgabWtczZtsV¦lyL¦¹Za ¦(}¬yºeik_f{%ifgj_:abZtY[Z_?a df¶ dxjrkikcgjahUXY[Zts ´/g»DZchY[ZazabZ_?auXZ jZtsikahgjY[gjshZct¡+¢Zts upgDwtchZ_:abs chwshpaodxahs shik_:a ik³pahZt_?XsshXcupZts gYCdfrkZssz/_:abUXw!ahgj´/pZts¬Z!a|upZts gYCdfrfZts|~pyL¼T¬¡ ½¿¾vÀ8nÁoÂ:ø ~ZtrkY[Z_?abdxahgjik_[u £ÄgYCdfrfZtstq:¥UvdfY[Xs»uXZ¦(dfch¨xi8©<q:Å»sahgjY dahgjik_ q?¦(w!°dx_XrkZ uXZ upgsabcg³Xahgjik_XstqD¥cgjahWtchZs«dNfZtsgZ_Xs ÆÇ»ÈÊÉ`ËÌFÍ!ÎËÐÏxÑxËÐÒÊÓ ã¤×LÔÔBõDÔtöÕbÕbÖ/×z÷áV×zè«ØBÙnݤêxÙ!ãjÚNëú:ÛFÚû ×zÜ ÍoÚ8ü ãjÜSì ØݤýSáVþÛFÝÞÙ!×hØFí!ëß8×LêßNïN×zètßtݤøÙÛùÿ Ý àß8ç ÜFÜ2ݤ×hÙáÿ Ü ×zÜSâ%ݤ×zÜã¤×äåNæçåfèté+êëtÚ8Ü+ãì ݤáVÙní×LØF×LØ2îNßtÛFï8ðzØF×»ñ/òó Ù!ݤß8ØFÝôJÚN× . Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 93 65 77 77 – Te´le´copie : (33) 93 65 77 65.
(11) [ D B* [ +
(12) ª)
(13)
(14) [
(15) ! À
(16) XÂfÀ: ZCupZaodgj»gj_ahUpgjsczZt<ikcza abUpZCugjDZtczZt_:a saodfrfZts g_:©kixj©fZtu$gj_$dNfZtsg°df_ gYCdfrkZlshZtrfYCZ_:aodxazgik_$Y[iupZjgj_XrXqZtsahgjYCdxahgjik_ df_Xu ikahgjY[gjsbdahgjik_ ¡ Z etik_XsgupZtc YCi/uXZ!jg_pr ³?º¦ldfcz¨fiN©ºchdf_XuXifY ²XZjuXst¡ Z5uXZtY[ik_pszabchdxabZ abUXZ§gjY[gaodahgjik_Xs*if· ahUXZ yBifazabsªYCi/uXZ!+etXczchZt_:azj ZtY[pjiNkZu q df_pu(Xczik<ikshZdC_pZ Y[i/uXZL¸abUXZeoUpgjZt_ Y[i/uXZ°® gYCUpdfgeorkU Zstdx¡ i ZsCdxXszs i abipchetZtikszZt_:cab©kczZ(if ²Xab_XUpZZ(sz³<abikczXXe_XahuXXdfchczZºsCjgjZt__pabrfUXabUZuvdfd_Xaou dp¡ jgj_XªZsCZ!¶/gja _ ahUXZ(Z dfuXshZtuXrfczYCZtszZs[_:abahZtUXu Z Xchik³ZY if·»ZtsahgjYCdxahgj_Xr ahUXZ_/pY ³<Ztc¬if·edfshszZtsdx_Xu(ahUXZ dxshshi/egdxahZtule!°dxshs«XdfcbdfY[Zn abZtczst¡ $Z>XczikDifshZQdY[Z!abUXi/u Xsg_pr|abUpZLeik_:abZn¶ahvdx?gj_p·¸ikchYCdxazgif_gj_XUXZchZt_:aBg_ gYCdfrfZts abilugszetczgjY g_XdxabZ ³<Za QZtZ_ ahUXZ5upgDZtchZ_:a edfshszZts*gj_$abUpZ5eJdfszZ5if· Y g ¶/abXczZ upgsabcg³X/ ahgjik_Xs gabUlszabczik_Xrf Y g¶Ztu e!°dxshshZst¡ g_vdjk q ZetikY[vdfczZahUXZ[¦lyL¦ 2Y d8¶gjY gszZtc if· abUXZ <iksabZtcgifc*YCdfchrfgj_vdxjso®*dx_Xu ¦(}¬y FYCd¶/gjY XY d8m`<ikszahZtczgjikcgЮ etczgabZczg d UXZt_ XshZ u gabU(ahUXZdxrfikczgabUXY[supgjsheXshszZtuPdf³<iN©kZf¡VªZshpabs«dfchZ XczZtshZ_:abZtulik_ls_:ahUXZazge gYCdfrkZsªdf_Xul~pyL¼ TIgYCdfrfZtczf¡ !#"%Á $*&¾ 'Bf ^`YCdfrkZ shZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_ qD¦ldfcz¨fiN© |dx_XuXik(Y gZ!uXsq<Å>sahgjYCdxahgjik_ qD¦ g ¶? abXczZtstqMdNfZtsg°df_ ·¸cbdfY[)Z ikcz¨.
(17)
(18)
(19) . %. 7. #. H R. \.
(20) & "
(21) À 8¾ 'ÂfÀ"!2¾ # f¡j ¢d[shZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_ldNfZtsgZ_X_XZ dJ©kZep_XZifgdCXcgifczg¦ldxch¨fiN©?gjZt_X_XZ ¡ $ f¡ y>czwtszZt_:aodxazgif_luXZsªgjYCdfrkZts ¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
(22) v/ .0!2
(23) -1& 2 &' ¾ ')(/Ã
(24) +* !¸&¾ ,!
(25) '
(26) -*ÀJ /¡j ¢gjY gjahZtsªuX YCi/uXW!Z uXZyBixahabs ¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ 3 /¡ ¢+Z¥UpgjZt_/m`Y[iupWjZ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ 4$ ¡ /¡j ¥ik_pszabczXeazgif_luX Y[iuXW!Z ³pgj_vdxgjchZ ¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ 4$ ¡ /¡ Ŷ/abZ_Xszgjik_ 5 X_ Y[iuXW!Z Y*m%dgczZ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡H6 /¡¤\ ªwshpaodxaªik³abZt_?Xsªvdfc jZtsuXZ¶ Y[iuXW!Zs ¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡H . '¾ 9 / 8 "À !2
(27) "À !2¾ ' ¾ '9(/Ã ';:
(28) pÀtÀ
(29) v <
(30) X) % 2 \¡j ¦(wahUXiupZuXZF>£ =gsabikrfcbdfY[Y[Z uXZ°@d ?Ldfczgdf_XeZ¥ik_Xupgahgjik_X_pZZ§ =A?|¥ ® 3 \p¡jf¡j y»czgj_Xe!g<Z ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡Hf \p¡jf¡ B«w!abZeahgjik_ uXZsY[i/uXZtsQvdfc>X_XZ«df_vdx/shZ«u£ÞX_§ZtshXdfetZ|u £ÞweoUXZjZ \p \p¡jf¡¤\ B«ifY dg_XZ§uXZ ©xdxgugjahw§uvdf_psjZ§eJdxs u £±X_ºY[wdf_XrfZ§uXZ uXZt¶ r:dxXshsgZ_X_XZts ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ \: \¡ y>cg_pegjDZuXZts|dxjrkikcgjahUXY[ZtsuXZa`/DZÅL¦ Z!aªchwtszpaodxahs ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ \3 * C¾ *»¾< 'B  <D¾ !E. 'B ¾ ')(/à 'F:
(31) pÀJÀ
(32) v <
(33) v/ . '+¾ G #/H $p¡j Å>_:ahchZ ifg ³vdJkZtsgZ_X_XZ*Z!aªchZd¶pdxazgik_uXZdf³<Zjs¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡I ¡ $? $p¡ ^`K_ JvXZ_XetZshXc jZtschwshpaodxahs|pcbdxazg´?XZs ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡I ¡ $: * 8C¾ *»¾< 'P, <+D¾ !L. 'P ,!ÐMÀ ( :À '*ÃN:
(34) vLÃ 1M ¾ !Ð"À < 'F: C¾ *"À !2O !F
(35) p"À !¸¾ P#Q S ¾ Â:ÃF4 !¸¾ HD%. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z.
(36) $. . .
(37) X
(38) -
(39). D[+C"L. . ! "#$ %&! '&)(+*% ,- ./ )(+ %0%1
(40) 2/3 45%5 6+*7(8 90:)(*/:)( ; /:)<'* 2=( %5%5 ªikXs*_pikXs*pd?> ik_Xs*uvdx_Xs*X_ºeik_:abZn¶ahZVdJkZszgjZt_ ¡L¥ik_pszgjuXwtczik_Xs X_XZ§upgsabcg³X/ ahgjik_(upZXczik³vdf³gjgjahw´?XZ!eik_X´?XZA@CBEDF szXcªX_lZshvdfeZ uXZs«eik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_ps|_XixabwH¬G ¡ |ikXs»upw²v_pgjshszik_Xsdxifchs»X_XZ ·¸ik_peahgjik_[uXZeti?pI a>Zt_:abczZuXZt¶ etik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_XsJKBED1LMDNO!F ¡. ¢>£±ZtsahgjYCdxahgjik_ VdJfZtszgjZt_p_XZ[etik_XsgsabZ dikczs 5§Y gj_pgjY[gjshZc«jZ*czgjsh´?XZ dNfZtsgZ_ q ef£±Ztsa 5 upgczZ 5lczZteoUXZcheoUXZc*°d etik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_º´?pgY[gj_pgjY gszZ§S£±ZtszDwcbdf_petZ uXZC°d(·¸if_Xeazgik_ uXZ etPi Ipa Q DSR dfchrUTKVXW \ JKBED1LMDNOFM@CBEDF+]PD^ 8® Y[Z Y TchdxgjahZtc X_Xchif³pWY[ZCuXdf_Xs Z[eJdxuXchZ[uXZ F£ÞZszahgjYCdxahgjik_ VdJkZszgjZt_X_XZ§chZ©?gjZt_:auXik_Xe 5 uXw²v_gc _ @CBEDFQszXc S£±ZtszvdfetZuXZtseik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_p5s G _a` _XZ upgjszahczgj³Xpazgikb _a` _XZ·¸ik_peahgjik_uXZ et?i Ip5a JKBED1LMDNOF _a` _ dxjrkikcgjahUXY[ZupZY gj_pgjY[gjsbdahgjik_ ¥ik_XszgjuXwchik_XsBYCdxg_:ahZt_vdf_:aZLetif_?ahZ!¶/abZLuXZ>°dshZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_ u £ÄgjY dxrkZts¡x¢ZLeoUvdfY[ upZts uXik_X_XwZtsZsza_Xixabw cdReBEfhgiFg+jlk?i mon czZtXczwtszZt_:abZ d§abcbdxYCZuXZ F£±gjYCdfrkZ 2Zt_XszZtY³pZ uXZts sgjahZtso® Z!a Zs upgwchZt_:ahKs fhgshik_:a 5l©xdxjZtXc uvdf_Xs*F£ÞZshvdxetZu £±waodKa p 2Zt_XszZtY³pZ uXZts _pg©kZtdf¶uXZ rkcgsb®!¡+¢»£ÄgYCdfrkZ szZtrkY[Z_?ahwtZCZtsa_pifabwCZ qeRUBsrPgMFMgtjkXqDZsugjDwtczZt_:abs rPg>waodx_?a 5 ©fdZXc uvdf_Xs u FZ_XshZY ³pjZ uXZts e!°dfszshZso®!¡M¢+d*Y[i/uXwgshdxahgjik_ ¦ldxch¨fk iN©?gjZt_X_XZ DZchY[Za§uXZ(upw²v_pgjc§p_XZ(jifg
(41) wvx X shXc[S£±ZtszvdfeZ uXZts etik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_XCs u q>_XifahwtZ @yBsqFn"¡ B £¤dxpabczZQvdxczaJqNp_XZ>YCi/uXw!jgjsbdxazgif_ uXZsBuXif_X_XwtZs¸abZn¶ahXchZxq8³XchpgaJq¡¡j¡¤®+<Ztk czY[ZauXZ uXw²v_gcVp_XZ¬ixgu £ÞdxazaodfeoUXZ dx¶5upik_X_XwZts shpcS£±ZtszvdfeZupZtsVeik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_pzs p q/_XifahwtZ @yBEc|{}q~F!¡¢>£Ägj_Xetik_p_/pZCup Xchik³WYCZ[w!aodf_:a q§qD_XikXsczZteoUXZcheoUXif_Xs 5`ikpazgY gjshZt+c d ifg
(42) vCM X X upw²v_pgjZvdfc @CBqw{ coF'R @yBEc|@C{}q~BcoFM@CF BqF ^ Sk® c w!aodf_:aªuXik_p_Xwfqv_XifXsikpahgjY gszik_XsªZt_ chwtdxjgabw @CBc {}q~FM@CBq F^ F\:® éÐöæ+é.
(43)
(44)
(45) . . +¢ Z eoUpifg¶ upZF£ÞdxrfikczgabUXY[Zu £±ikpazgY gjsbdxazgik_ ZaCeZjpguXZ °d ·¸ik_peahgjik_ uXZetiPIa[shik_:a ³pgZ_$w!©/gjuXZYCY[Z_?ajgjwts¡ªikXs cbdxXDZ!if_XsupZt¶eczgabWtczZtsetikXchdfY[Y[Zt_:a ahgjgjshws ´?XZ _XikXsetifYCXdfchZchik_Xsuvdx_Xs °d[shpgabZ uXZ eZahcbdJ©xdxgjF¡ ¢Z¬¦(}¬y ʦld8¶gjY pY M X X ®LeikchczZtszDik_pu 5°d ·¸ik_Xe!ahgjik_ uXZ«eiPIpa upw²v_pgjZ vdfc J BED1LMDNOF R
(46) Y[Z BEDFL $?® iPm *czZtXczwtshZ_:abZ*jZsY³DixZuXZchif_XZteo¨xZtct¡¢»£ÞikahgjY XY Zszadikczs«dahabZ!g_:a|DifXcªd FX_XZJ®Betif_p²vrkXchdxahgjik_[´?pgvYCd¶/gjY[gjshZVd«jifgS¡ ` _*abZ!XeczgabWtczZ Ztsa>upgCe!gjjAZ 5dxahahZgj_XuXchZ Z!a _XwteZtshsgjahZ|p_§dxjrkikcgjahUXY[Z etPi IabZt/¶[Zt_[abZYCpsLupZªetdxjetpMeikY[YCZ jZ chZetpgaLszgjY pjw|Xdfc Z!¶ZtY[pjZf¡ B«Zts dfXXcziN¶/gjYCdxahgjik_XsuXZ§eZ eczgabWchZCDZp©kZ_?a*_XwJdf_pYCixg_XsahchZCik³pabZ_?XZts vdfc uXZs«dxjrkikcgjahUXY[ZtsuXw!abZtczY g_pgjszahZts¡ ¢Z|¦lyL¦ S¦(i/uXZtsQ¦ldfczrfgj_vdxjZts
(47) M X X ®µetikczchZtszDif_Xu 5¬d ·¸if_Xeazgik_CuXZet?i Ipa uXw²v_gZvdfc J B D1LMDN F'R
(48) Y s Z B D giF^ Sk® g+jlk ¢>£±ikpazgYXY Zsza dxahahZgj_:a ikczsh´?XZ jZts[upgwchZt_:ahZts[ifgjs[YCdfchrfgj_vdxjZts Z_ p_ sgjahZshik_:a Y d8¶gjY gszwtZstF¡ B« <ifg_:a upZ5©pZdxrfikczgabUXY gj´?XZfqjZts Y[w!abUXi/uXZts upZ5a`<Z ¦(Z!abchifDix jgjsm =«dfsahgj_Xr$S¦ldfcz¨fiN©¥Uvdxgj_$¦(ik_:abZ ¥Vdfci?®«szik_:apahgjgjshwZtsDifXc ikpahgjY gszZtc X_ abZ! etczgabWchZx¡¢+Z eczgabWchZ ¦lyL¦ Y gj_pgjY[gjshZ dxjikchs5jZP_XikY³XchZPuXZPpg ¶Zjs YCdx e!°dxshshws(Z!a Ztsza*uXik_Xe dxuvdfpahw df¶aodxeoUXZts uXZ§shZtrfYCZ_:aodxazgik_¡»Å»_chZ©xdf_peoUXZfqjikczsh´?XZ <ikXc upZts etik_:abchdxgj_?ahZts uXZ5ahZtY[Xs[uXZ5etdxjetpFq»X_XZ dxXXchiJ¶/gjY dahgjik_ uX etczgabWchZ Zsza[chZeoUXZtczeoUXwtZ vdfc uXZs«dxjrkikcgjahUXY[ZtsuXw!abZtczY g_pgjszahZtsq<jZ etczgabWchZ¦(}«y Ztszaªszikp©kZ_:a«Xczw·¸wchwf¡ :! %&! & (+*%0" (M#$ /" yikXc©fdjgjuXZtc+jZtsY[w!abUXi/uXZtsBZaµdfchrkpYCZ_:abspchik<ikshwsuvdx_XsBeZQahcbdJ©xdxgjFq8_XikXsBetik_pszg uXwtczik_Xs¬abczifgjs«gYCdfrfZts«ahZtszahst¡¢ZsuXZt¶ XchZY gWchZtsgjYCdfrkZts«shik_:a uXZs¬gYCdfrkZs¬uXZ*s/_ abUXWshZ DifXcVZsh´?XZ!jjZts|_XikXsetif_X_vdxgjshszik_XsªuXik_X0e `d shifjpazgik_ [2©fifgjc²XrkXchZ N®!¡vªikXs Dik©kik_XsdxjikchsuXw!abZtczY g_XZcjZ _pikY ³XczZ upZ pg ¶Zjs*YCdx>edfszshwts ZaZsjietdxgszZtct¡¢+d XchZY[gjWtczZ etik_:azgZ_?aCuXZs*·¸ikchY[Zs[df¶$etik_:abifXchs*gszshZs dikczs ´?XZ5°d szZteik_XuXZ gjY dxrkZ etik_:ahgjZt_:aQX_XZ ·¸ikczYCZdx¶[etif_?ahikXczsLahchWts>eoUvdxU/abwtsq?etZª´/gv©fd<ZtczYCZ!ahahchZªuXZ abZtsabZc>d ²v_XZtszshZCuXZts upgDwtchZ_:absYCi/uXW!ZsupZ chwtrfp°dxczgjsbdxazgik_¡¥ZtsgYCdfrfZts shik_:a ³XczpgabwtZsXdfc X_ ³Xchgja>dxuXupgahg·DrkdfXshsgZ_ 2©kixgcµ²vrfXchZf®!¡kyikXc²X_pgcqfX_pZVabchixgsgWYCZVgjYCdfrkZV<ZtczY[Za uXZª©xdxgjuXZtcQetZ|ahcbdJ©xdxgMshXcQuXZtsQuXik_X_XwZtsVczwtZ!jjZts¡^ÊDst£Þdfrfgau£ÞX_pZ|gjY dxrkZ¬~yQ¼T 2eJdf_vd ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z.
(49) . . .
(50) X
(51) -
(52). p~ \:®+uXZQd =ªif°df_puXZ2©fifgjcB²vrkpchZV\k®!¡x¢dªsheWt_XZ czZtXczwtshZ_:abZ X_XZtik_pZVuXZXdfcheZ°dxgjchZxq Dikszshwuvdf_:a«upZtsszahchXe!abXczZtsabchWs ²v_XZtsFczikpahZtstqveoUpZtY g_pstq<eoUvdfY[Xsªwabczifgabstq¡¡j¡¤®!¡. d:®^`YCdfrkZ ³v®^`Y dxrkZ
(53)
(54) + _
(55) -1&À/À8' " À"<)(/. d:®^`YCdfrfZCf¡¤d ³XczpgjahwtZµD~p| xuv dk®^`Y dxrkZ[k¡Þ³³XczpgabwtZ~« xuv < _
(56) -1&/À/À8 x9!ÐÀN éÐöæ+é.
(57)
(58)
(59) . D\ _
(60) -1& Â
(61)
(62) vÃ
(63) 7. . ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z.
(64) 3. .
(65) X
(66) -
(67). C" !
(68) !B
(69) "
(70) +
(71) t
(72) B«df_XsLetZ«XdfcbdfrfcbdfXUpZfq:_XikpsQeik_XszgjuXwchik_XsLZªY[iupWjZ¬¦ldxch¨fiN©?gjZt_5jZ|pjXsLshik©kZt_:a eoUXifgjszgetifYCY[Zixg
(73) vx X X <ikXc[X_ Xczik³pjWtY[Z(upZ szZtrkY[Z_?abdxahgjik_»jZ Y[i/uXWjZuXZ yBifazabst¡ªikXs+Y[ik_:abchif_XsjZts+gY gabZtsuXZLetZLY[iuXW!Z>Z!aszik_YCdf_p´/pZQu £ÞdfuXw´?vdxahgjik_ dN©fZte Z>chwshpaodaBczZteoUXZcheoUXwx¡fªikXsXchifDikszik_Xsdxjikchsp_szZtetif_Xu Y[i/uXWjZª2jZ¥UgZ_m`Y[i/uXWjZN® DZchY[Zazaodf_:aªuXZ etik_:ahch¯fjZtcetZczabdxg_pZtsªXchikpczgjwabws|upZ d shifjpazgik_¡ A(#e( &) 0" 4 #$* " 6+ 0" w * & &! ªikXsLetik_pszgjuXwtczik_Xsp_ Y[i/uXWjZ|upZ|yifahahsQshdf_XsLeoUvdfY[§Zn¶/abZtcz_XZf¡¢ZtsLeg´?XZsu £±X_ abZVYCi/uXW!Zshif_?a dxjikczs etik_XsahgabXwZtsCuXZ vdxgjchZs[uXZpg¶Z!s ©kixgsg_Xs¡L¢d jifg u £±X_abZ! YCi/uXW!Z st£±wteczga¬dikczs j
(74) "!# L F:® @yBsq F/R B F
(75) ?i m%$uXwszgjrk_XZ S£±Zt_pshZtY³pjZ uXZs|e!jgj´?XZts¡ ¢ZY[iuXW!ZuXZyBifazabsªuXwt<Zt_pu uXik_Xe u £±X_(vdfcbdxYCW!abczZµ& >¡M¢+d[Xchik³Xdf³pgjgabwu £±X_XZ etik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_ Ztsa(u£¤dfaodf_:apjXs wjZ©fwtZ´?XZ Z _XifY ³XczZ uXZ eg´?XZs(UpikY[ikrkWt_pZts FvdxgjchZs upZ(©kixgsg_Xs§dJ:df_:a§jZlY YCZ °dx³DZ!Ю Ztsa gjY[Dikcaodf_:ahZf¡QÅ>_ ikpahchZfq»djifguX YCi/uXW!Z <Ztpaªst£±wteczgjchZshikpsd ·¸ikchY[Zµ @CBq~FR B F ' (*)'L ® Pi m+(*) chZtpchwtszZt_:abZZ _XifY ³XczZupZe!jgj´?XZts|UXikY[ikrkW_XZtsuXZdCeik_p²vrfXcbdxazgifb _ qC¡ }+©kZe p_ahZLY[iuXW!Zxq_XikXs <ikp©fik_XsuXik_Xe[ZtszDwchZceik_:abch¯xZc d ik_prkXZtpcupZts etik_:abifXchsikZt_petikczZ d*aodxgZ uXZsªczwtrfgjik_Xs upZtsªchwJdjgjsbdxazgif_Xsik³pabZ_?XZts¡DÅ»_szgjY °df_:a upgjDwtczZt_:abZsªFX_ rkchdf_Xu _XifY ³Xcz-Z , ®µczwJdxgshdxahgjik_XsuX[YCi/uXW!Zxqk_XikXs»<ikp©fik_Xs>dxjikczsµZtsahg YCZc °d Y[iNkZt_p_XZup(_XifY ³XczZuXZe!jgj´?XZts|UXikY[ikrkW_XZtsqv_Xifahwt*Z ./(0)21 qXZt_·¸ik_Xe!ahgjik_ uXZ5°dl©xdxjZtpc*uX vdfchdfY[Wabcz3Z >¡»¥ZazabZ eikXch³<Z5uXwDZ_Xu uXZ5°dlabdxgjjZ5uXZ5d chwtdxjgjsbd8 ahgjik_PZa uXP_XikY³XchZ[uXZ e!°dxshshZseik_XsguXwchwZtst¡ªwJdf_XY[ifgj_Xsq Z[etifYC<ikcabZtY[Z_?auXZ*d etikXcz³DZczZtsabZgupZt_:ahgj´?XZf¡ ` _ Zn¶ZtY[pjZuXZeZazabZ etikpch³<ZZtsza gXsabczwszXcVd ²XrkXchZ $p¡ ¢d eikXcz³DZ XczwtszZt_:abZ X_XZ ·¸ikcabZ§gj_Xegj_vdxgjshik_ dfpahikXc uXZ5dl©xdxZXc etcgjazg´?XZ uX vd cbdfY[Wahch5Z 4 76 8q 4±\f\ 6 ¡µ~pcd(²vrkXczZ quXZs chwtdxgshdxahgjik_Xs*u£ÞX_$YCi/uXW!Z5upZ5yBixahabs 5+9 . éÐöæ+é.
(76) .
(77)
(78) . 8000. number of homogeneous cliques. 7000. 6000. 5000. 4000. 3000. 2000 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5 beta. 0.6. 0.7. 0.8. 0.9. $ ¾< ' :Â Ã! / <+¾< C¾ 1C( / ¾ ÂfÀ"!2¾ ' ¾ '9(/Ã _'«¾MÀtÀ8 9 Â:Ã
(79) vJ /CJ 5 lÀ
(80) X 9 9. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. 1. . »¾D *.
(81) M6. . .
(82) X
(83) -
(84). e dfshszZts shif_?a*XchwshZt_:ahwtZts <ikXcupgwchZt_:ahZts*©xdxjZtXczs*uXZ >¡B¢+Z Y[iuXW!Z§uXZ yBixahabs_XZ DZchY[ZaQuXik_XeªvdfsLuXZªY[iuXw!jgjshZcQupZtsQgjYCdfrkZsQeikY[Dikcaodf_:aLuXZsik_XZtsQUXikY[ikrkW_XZtsLuX a`<Z uXZs>gjYCdfrkZs»shZtrfYCZ_:abwtZsuXwszgjchwZtst¡/Å»_[ZDZatqkDifXc»uXZtsµ©xdxjZtpchs>uXZ g_p·¸wczgjZtXczZts 5d©xdxjZtXcQetczgahgj´?XZfq/ZsVchwtdxgshdxahgjik_XsQik³pabZ_?XZtsVszik_:a·¸ikcabZYCZ_:a ³XchgjahwtZts¡XyikXcupZts ©fdZXchsVszX<wtczgjZtpchZtAs 5 eZ¬<ifg_:a eczgahgj´?XZfqXp_ uXZtsVw!aodxahsVuXZ!©/gjZt_:achdfpgjuXZtY[Zt_:aXczwtuXi Y[gj_vdf_:a Za jZts chwJdjgjsbdxazgif_Xs szik_:a etik_pszahgabpwtZts u£ÞX_ ·¸ik_XuºUXifYCifrkWt_XZ§dJ©kZte§pps*ik YCixg_XsQuXZ«³pchpgaJ¡X¥ZahahZ«czXpabpchZ¬uXZ|sz/Y[wahczgjZ¬Zt_:abczZ«jZtsVupgDwtchZ_:absVw!aodxahsetifchchZsh<ik_Xu 5§X_XZ ahcbdf_pszgahgjik_ uXZ*XUXdfshZ*up YCi/uXW!Z*upZ*yBixahabsZ!ad§w!abw dx³Dik_puvdfY[Y[Zt_:awahXupgjwtZ Zt_ XU:/szgj´?XZ saodxazgsahgj´?X+Z 4 N 6 -q 4 8 6 ¡ B«PDifgj_:auXZ*©/XZ uX ahcbdxgabZYCZ_:a uXZts¬gjYCdfrkZtsq ZZ sgrk_gj²vZ ´?XZ5jZ Y[iupWjZ5uXZyBixahabs Zsza[YCdxVdfuvdfpahw5<ikXc*rkw_XwtczZtc uXZs*gYCdfrfZts ·¸ikchY[wtZsuXZ chwtrxgik_psªUpikY[ikrkWt_pZtst¡ Å»_ Xchdxahgj´?XZfqDetZ*Y[i/uXWjZ*Zsza YCdxjrkchwabikpa|abczWts¬pazgjgjshw etifYCY[Z ahZtczYCZ czwtrk°dfcg sbdxahZtXc ¡ B¬df_Xs eZtcaodxgj_XseJdfsqpjZts chwshpaodabs shif_?aªdxetetZpaodx³pZs|etdfcjZ¬abZchY[Zu £ÞdxahabdfeoUXZ df¶$uXik_X_XwZts[Ztsa[sh!CshdfY[YCZ_:a pchwt<ik_Xupwtcbdx_?a[Z!a[DZchY[Za*u £Þif³pabZ_pgc upZts chwrfgjik_Xs UXikY[ikrkW_XZts¡¥Zte!gµczZtszahZ _Xwtdf_XY[ifgj_Xs¬©xdxdf³pjZ X_pgj´?XZtY[Z_?a sgBjZts«uXik_X_XwZts¬szik_:a¬<Zt ³XchpgabwZts¡ B«df_XsªetZeJdfsqMF£±pahgjgjsbdahgjik_lu £±X_XZY[iupwgshdxahgjik_lYCdfcz¨fiN©?gZ_X_XZDZpa¬dikczs vdfcbd °ahchZg_?pazgjjZtY[Zt_:a szikXUpgjszazg´?XwZf¡¢+ifchs§upZ(uXif_X_XwtZs§³XczpgabwtZstqLS£±pahggshdxabZXc§Zsza dxifchsdfY[Zt_XZ@c 5(pazgjgjshZtc X_XZ ©xdxjZtpc uXZ _XZazabZtY[Z_?a*shX<wtcgZXchZ 5°d©fdZXc eczg ahgj´/pZfq uXWs¬ifchs«jZtssabchpeabpchZts¬²X_XZtsuXZ*F£ÄgYCdfrkZ shik_:a<ZtczuXXZts Z!a¬°d5szZtrkY[Z_?abdxahgjik_ chwtszpaodf_:abZ Ztsa czZdxahg©kZYCZ_:a rkchifshszgjWtczZf¡~/gL_XikXsetif_XszgjuXwtczik_Xs°dshZrkY[Zt_:aodxazgif_ºchZn eoUXZtczeoUXwtZ*eikY[Y[ZdCczwJdxgjsbdxazgik_(u £±X_lY[i/uXWjZupZ yifahahs|Z!a«ZszahgjY[ik_XsªZ vdfchdfY[WahchZ dfshszie!gw|vdfcLX_5etcgjahWtczZ«uXZ|Y d8¶gjY pYupZ|©/cbdxgjshZY ³pdf_XeZfqpd©xdxjZtpcZtsahgjY[wtZ¬s£¤dJ©kWchZ ³pgZ_lgj_p·¸wtcgZXch@Z 5C°d ©xdxjZtpc«pazgjgszwtZ*Z_ Xcbdahgj´/pZ <ikXc«if³pabZ_pgc|X_XZ*szZtrkY[Z_?abdxahgjik_ Z!¶ZtY[pahZ uXZ§³XczpgaJ¡µ¢+d(²XrkXchZ§lchZXchwshZ_?ahZ X_XZ5pUXifabifrkcbdfpUpgZ§dfwtcgZ_X_XZ ³XczpgabwtZx¡ ` _XZszZtrkY[Zt_:abdxahgjik_ Y dx_/pZZ ZtsaªZDZteahXwtZC¸©kifgjcV²vrkXczZ p¡±³M®!¡M¥Z!ahahZszZtrkY[Z_?abdxahgjik_ ZtszaQdxjikczsLeik_XsguXwchwZ|eikY[YCZd czwJdxgjsbdxazgik_Cu £±X_§Y[i/uXWjZuXZªyBifazabsq:etZª´/gMetik_Xuppgjatq vdfcX_XZ§ZszazgYCdxazgik_ dx$shZ_Xs*uX$Y d8¶gjY pY uXZC©/cbdxgjshZY ³pdf_XeZfq 5 X_XZ§©xdxjZtXcuX vdfcbdxYCW!abczZ ºwr:dxjZ 5)^ 9 9X¡M¢+d ²vrkXczZ ¡ÞechZXchwshZt_:ahZ X_XZszgjY pdxazgik_(uXlY[i/uXWjZ uXZ¬yifahahsVdJ©kZe|jZ«vdfchdfY[WahchZ«ZszazgY[wf¡p|ikpsQ<ikp©fik_XsVczZtYCdfch´?XZc´?XZ|_XikXsQshikY[Y[Zts ifgj_ u £±X_XZ(gYCdfrkZ(·¸ikchY[wtZluXZlczwtrfgjik_Xs5UpikY[ikrkWt_pZtst¡V¢d XchwshZt_petZ uXZ ³pchpga5szZ chZn abchifp©kZ(dxjikchs szXcCjZchwshpaodxa uXZ dszZtrkY[Zt_:abdxahgjik_ if³pabZ_/pZts dN©fZte(X_XZ ©xdxZXc[uXZ Z!Zeazgj©fZtY[Zt_:a wtr:dxjZ 5)^ 9 9º2©kixgc dl²vrkpchZ p¡±uM®n¡µÅ»_XchZ_vdf_:a[X_XZ ©fdZXc*uX vdfcbdxYCW!abczZ pjXsª·¸ifczabZxqv_XikXsik³abZt_pik_XsªdxjikchsX_XZshZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_lrkczikshsgWchZPi muXZ _XikY ³pchZt/¶$upwaodgjjsif_?aw!abwCDZchuXXs 2²XrkXchZCp¡±ZN®n¡Å>_chwshXY[wxqjZ Y[i/uXWjZ[uXZ yBifazabs _XZlszZtY ³ZPvdfs ³pgjZt_Idfuvdxpabw 5$uXZts5abdfeoUXZs5uXZ szZtrkY[Zt_:abdxahgjik_ u £ÄgYCdfrfZts 4Ä\k\ 6 ¡Å»_ éÐöæ+é.
(85)
(86)
(87) . k. chwJdjgabwxqQeZlY[iupWjZl_XZ ·2dxgja vdfsC°dupgjszahgj_Xe!ahgjik_ Zt_:abczZ etif_?ahikXcCZa§³XchpgaJ¡L}+©kZteletZ YCi/uXW!Zxqvchwtrfp°dxczgjshZtcªszgjrk_pg²vZY g_pgjY gszZtcZ _XifY ³XczZuXZ e!jgj´?XZtsªg_XUpikY[ikrkWt_pZtstqMex£ÞZsza 5 upgjchZCY g_gY gjshZtc°dik_prkXZtpcuXZseik_:abikpchstqetZC´?pgQ_ £ÞZsza vdfs guXZ_:ahgj´/pZ 5(Y gj_pg Y[gjshZc|jZ³pchpgaJ¡ ` _(Y[iuXW!ZDifshshwuvdf_:a¬XsgZXchs«vdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsªZtsza¬dxjikchsª_XwteZtszsbdxgjchZ Dikpceik_:abch¯xZcuXZC·2?d >tif_Xs upgjszazg_peabZs d jik_XrkXZXc upZts eik_:abikpchs Z!ajZ§³pchpga uXdf_Xs Zs*chwtdxjgjsbdahgjik_Xst¡ B £ÞdfpabczZ§vdxczaJq+jZ§etifYC<ikcabZtY[Z_?a[upº_XikY³XchZ5Y[iNkZ_uXZ5e!jgj´?XZts UXikY[ikrkW_XZtsªZt_·¸ik_Xe!ahgjik_(uplvdfchdfY[WahchZ dfpahikXc uX(Dixg_:aªetcgjazg´?XZZtsa«X_gj_Xetik_/ ©kwt_gZ_?aYCdx{%ZXcVuX§YCi/uXW!Zx¡XÅ»_5ZDZatqjZtsgjYCdfrkZ/s `gj_:abZchchZshshdf_:abZt+s oqXex£ÞZszAa 5upgczZ«jZts gYCdfrkZs·¸ikchY[wtZsupZ czwtrfgjik_Xs UXikY[ikrfWt_XZseikchczZtsh<ik_XupZt_:aJqBdfshZt_psuXZ[F£ÞZszahgjYCdxahgjik_ uXZ L-q 5[upZts©fdZXchsuXZ $ahchWtsXczieoUpZts Zs|p_XZtsªuXZtsªdfabchZsFXczieoUXZs|upZ d*©xdxZXc uXº<ifg_:a eczgahgj´?XZN®n¡»¢Z§Y[iupWjZ5uXZ yifahahs*DZchY[Za*uXik_Xe5Z_Xcbdahgj´/pZ5uXZ5czwtvdfcahgjc Zs§gYCdfrfZts5Z_ abchixgs edfshszZts VjZl³XczpgaJqQjZts gYCdfrkZs5´?vdfsgmÊX_pg·¸ikchY[Zts Z!Ca `jZlczZtsabZ uXlY[ik_XupZ o¡<¢+dC©xdxjZtpc«uX(vdfcbdxYCW!abczZ_XZch Z JvWahZ uXik_pe dfpetX_XZXchifXczgjwahwgj_?ahZtczchZts% sbdf_:abZ upZS£ÄgjY dxrkZf¡fyBikXcµd C_XZtcµjZtsµczwtszpjabdxabs»upZts»shZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_Xs>u £ÄgYCdfrkZxqxgXszZtY ³Z uXik_Xe_XwteZtszsbdxgjchZ uXZuXw!©kZjikX<Ztc«uXZts|YCi/uXW!Zs«pjXs«szikXUpgjszazg´?XwsDifXc Zsh´?XZjs¬jZts upgjDwtczZt_:absvdfchdfY[WahchZts<ZtchY[Z!ahabZ_:a uXZ[e!°dfszshZcjZtsgjY dxrkZtsshpg©xdf_:auXZtsXchifXczgjwahwts uXwahZtchY gj_XwtZs>etikY[Y[Z °d«jik_XrkpZtXc»uXZs»etik_:ahikXchs¸g_:ahZtcz·2dxetZts>Z_?ahchZ pjXsgZXchs>chwrfgjik_Xs UXikY[ikrkW_XZtsb®!qM°dCXchwshZt_petZ*Z!a|dCjik_XrkpZtXcªuXZtsªjgjrk_XZs*2chwtrxgik_ps|UXifYCifrkWt_XZs«u £±wtXdxgs% shZtpcpg ¶pZ!Ю ik Zt_XeikchZ d[abdxgjjZY[iNkZ_X_XZuXZtsªchwrfgif_Xs|UpikY[ikrkWt_pZtst¡D¥Zs«Y[iupWjZts _XwteZtshsgjahZt_:a uXZ[eik_XszgjuXwchZtcuXZts e!jgj´?XZtsetik_:abZ_vdf_:appsuXZCpg ¶Zjs<ikXcjZtsh´?XZ!jjZts Zs upgDwtchZ_:abZts§etik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_XsCshik_:a chwtXdfczazgZs§Zt_ pjXszgjZtXczs§e!°dfszshZst¡ ` _ XczZtY gjZtc YCi/uXW!Zxq·¸ik_XuXw shXcuXZseg´?XZs 5Zsza Xczik<ikshw uvdx_Xs 4Þx\ 6 dxjikczs¬´? £Þp_Y[i/uXWjZ shXc X_XZ[abchdfY[Z[UXZ!¶pdfrkif_vdx>ZtsauXwteczga uvdx_Xs 4 6 ¡¥ZtsY[iupWjZtsetik_XsgupWtchZ_:a jZtsupgj·° ·¸wtchZ_:abZts eik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_ps gj_XuXwDZ_XuXZYCY[Z_?aZsX_XZsuXZs dfpahchZts¡+|ikpsXchik<ikszik_Xs uvdf_XsªZvdfchdfrkcbdxXUXZshpg©xdf_:auXZuXw²v_gc¬p_lY[iupWjZ 5 XdfczazgcªuXZts|wt_XZchrfgjZts|i/eJdxjZtsq Dikpc chZgjZtcVjZtsupgwchZt_:ahZtsªetik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_Xs ·¸ikchYCdf_:aX_eik_:abikXcikX_pZ gjrk_XZ 4Ä\ 6 6 ¡ ` _XZ©kZchsgik_l\ B¿uX(Y[i/uXWjZ Ztsa|pchwtszZt_:abwZ uvdx_Xs 4 k 6 ¡. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z.
(88) 8. . .
(89) X
(90) -
(91). d:®. R ) ^. ³M®. R ) ^ 9. eJ®. R ! ^ 9 . uM®. R ) ^ . D §
(92) XÃ!2
(93) pÀ"!¸¾ ' ¾ ')(à ' ¬¾vÀJÀ8. _. éÐöæ+é.
(94) N\.
(95)
(96) . d:®^`YCdfrkZgj_pgahgdxZ. ³M®~ZtrkY[Z_?abdxahgjik_(Y dx_/pZZ eJ® Å>eoUXdf_:ahgjjik_ dJ©fZte. uM®~ZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_ldJ©fZte R )^ 9 9 NZ ®~ZrkY[Zt_:aodxazgif_ldJ©kZe R P^ < _ 1< À
(97) pÀ"!¸¾
(98) /Â Ã l ¾ '9(/Ã '«¾MÀtÀ8. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. R ) ^ 9 9.
(99) 4$. . .
(100) X
(101) -
(102). 5( %[# * " 6 ¢Z|YCi/uXW!Z¬pchwtszZt_:abwuXdf_XsVeZ¬vdfchdfrkcbdxXUXZ«upwt<Zt_Xu uXZ|abchixgsQvdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsVczZtsh<Zten ahg©kZtY[Z_?a[_pifabwskq Za ´/g·¸ik_:a*czw·¸wchZt_petZ df¶$etik_:ahikXchs5E%ZuXrkZ®!qBdf¶ grk_pZts E `gj_XZ %®Zaªdf ³XchgjaE `_XifgjshZ ®!¡X¢+Z Xcg_pegjDZ uXZ etif_XszahchXe!ahgjik_luXY[i/uXWjZ shZuXwteikY* DikszZ Zt_pjXszgjZtXczsw!aodf<Zts¡+|ikpsXchik<ikszik_Xs Zt_PXczZtY gZcjgjZtX_PY[iuXW!Z[³pgj_vdxgjchZxq wabZ_XuXCdf etdfsµY*m%dxgjchZvdfcd¬shpgabZx¡:|ifXsµeoUXifgjszgjshszik_XsLX_ sz/sabWtY[ZuXZ e!jgj´?XZts :uXdf_Xs Z etdfsXchwshZ_?atq Zseg´?XZsszik_:a etik_pszahgabpwtZtsuXZs³pi/etsetdfchczwtsuXZ*ahchifgjspg ¶ZjsszXc abchixgs¡ ¥Z!ahabZaodxgZetikczchZtszDif_Xu 5 dCabdxgjjZ Y g_gYCdxjZ _XwetZshsbdgczZ 5Cd§uXw²X_pgjazgif_ uXZ etik_:abifXchs*Z!a uXZ5grf_XZts¡ B £ÞdfpahchZ vdfcaJqBX_XZ§abdxgjjZ5pjXs rkcbdx_XuXZ dfeetczifgja*etik_Xsgupwtcbd8 ³pZY[Zt_:a«d eikY[pZn¶/gjahw uX(YCi/uXW!Zx¡ªikXsªZDZteahXik_Xs«dxjikchsªX_XZedfshsgj²vetdxahgjik_ upZts upgjDwtczZt_:abZs etik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_XsQ³pg_XdxgczZtsV<ikszszgj³pZs DifXcQjZtsVe!jgj´?XZts eoUpifgsgZst¡X} eoUvdf´?XZ edfshszZ ZszaCdxjikczs dfshszie!gwX_XdfcbdfY[W!abchZxq©xdxjZtXc uX <ifabZ_:ahgjZ eikchczZtsh<ik_XuXdf_:aJ¡>¢Z _XikY ³pchZ uXZsvdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsik³pahZt_?Xs ZtsaZt_petikczZ*abchif rkcbdf_pu DikpcahchZ pazgjgshdf³pjZ Zt_ Xcbdxazg´?XZx¡fÅ»_*ifpabczZfq8ZLjgjZt_ Z_?ahchZQetZtsvdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsZ!ajZtsµpchikXcgw!abwsuXZsµchwtdxjgjsbdahgjik_Xs _ £ÞZszavdfsBgjY[Y[wtupgdxaJ¡f¢+d|shZetik_puXZVwabdf<Zetif_XszgjszahZVuXik_Xe 5«chZ!jgjZtcBetZsµvdfchdfY[WabczZtsdN©fZte uXZts´?vdf_:ahgabws·2dfe!gjjZtY[Z_?aBg_:ahZtchpchwabdf³pjZtsBuXZ»S£ÄgYCdfrfZLXdfcS£Äg_:ahZtchY[wupg°dgczZu £±X_XZQdf_vd j/shZuXZsªw_XZtczrfgjZtsi/eJdxjZts¡ ' (/à ! -
(103) !. %
(104) %
(105) L S ¾ !À BÂf"À !¸¾ ' ¾ 9 ¥if_XszgjuXwtczik_Xs5upik_XeZs bR
(106) etik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_XsC³pg_XdxgczZtsCDifshszgj³pjZts5szXcCX_XZ eg´?XZ|uXZ pg ¶ZjsVvdfc p¡ ` _pZ|XczZtY gjWtchZ|edfshsgj²XeJdxazgik_§ZtszaQik³pahZt_?XZ|Zt_§eik_XsguXwcbdf_:a ´/pZupZt¶ eik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_psªszik_:aªwt´?pg©fdZ_?ahZts¬sg+ZZs|szZ uXwtuXgszZt_:a«F£Þp_XZ uXZF£ÞdfpabczZ shifga¬vdxcªd§sz/Y[wahczgjZ*_Xifgjcmʳpdf_Xefq<shixgja«vdfcªX_XZ*czifaodxazgif_ ¡<|ikXs|ik³pahZt_Xik_psdxjikchs edfshszZts u £±wt´?pg©xdxZ_XetZ uXif_?aVX_ chZXchwshZt_:abdf_:aJqvZaZ¬_pikY ³XczZ¬u £±wjwtY[Zt_:ahsªupZ¬eoUvdf´?XZ edfshszZfqMshik_:aªXczwtshZ_:abwts|shXc d*²vrkXczZ ¡ } eoUvdf´?XZedfszshZ Ztsadfshszie!gwp_ XdfcbdfY[W!abchZ«uXw²v_gszsbdf_:a°d ©xdxjZtpcVuX <ifabZ_?azgZ! uXZtsQetik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_XsLuXZ|de!°dfszshZx¡}ªg_XsgSq/shifXsQjZtsQU?/<ifabUpWtshZ«u £±gjshixabchifpgZ|uX§Y[i/uXWjZ ZaQuXZ|s/YCw!abcgZ|_Xifgjcm`³°df_pefq:_XikpsdJ©kif_Xs<ikXc>X_XZªabZ!jjZªahik<ififrfgZ2eg´?XZsuXZ pg¶Z!sb®+e!g_X´?vdx_?ahZZ!aBp_ uXZrkchwsBuXZ»g³<Ztcabwx¡x¢»£±wt_XZchrfgjZLwaodx_?auXw!²v_pgjZ 5X_XZLetif_Xszabdf_:abZ XchWstq?_XikXs»gjY[Dikszik_XsLX_CDifahZt_:ahgjZ<_?pDdf¶ etik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_Xs>X_pg·¸ikchY[Zs« yB F/R :®nq etZl´?pg|cbdxYCW_XZ 5 egj_X´?vdf_:abZljZl_pikY ³XczZluXZ(uXZtrfchwts§uXZ gj³DZczabwx¡V¢+d eik_Xsabchpeahgjik_ uX Y[iuXW!ZPeik_XszgjszahZPdxjikchs 5$gjY[DikszZtc uXZs etik_:ahcbdxgj_:abZtsZ_ czZg°dx_?a jZts ugjDwtczZt_:abs vdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsZt_:abczZ Z¶D¡ª|ikXseik_XszgjuXwchik_Xs ´?XZPZs(w!aodxahs·¸if_XuvdfY[Zt_:abdf¶ Fw!aodxahs . éÐöæ+é.
(107) 8.
(108)
(109) . C(49),8. C(50),2 C(51),8. C(43),16 C(44),8 C(45),16 C(46),8. C(47),8. C(48),2. C(37),16 C(38),16 C(39),16 C(40),16 C(41),8. C(42),8. C(31),16 C(32),8 C(33),8 C(34),16 C(35),8 C(36),16. C(26),4 C(27),8 C(28),4 C(29),16. C(30),8. C(19),16 C(20),8 C(21),8 C(22),8 C(23),16. C(24),8. C(25),8. C(13),8 C(14),8 C(15),16 C(16),16 C(17),16 C(18),16. C(7),8. C(8),16 C(9),4 C(10),8. C(11),8. C(12),4. Ã
(110) vJ F' : 9!
(111) và  ' / Âk¾ 1<
(112) À"!2¾ !
(113) ! / <¾ ' /Ã2/ 8À '
(114) §Â<
(115) :Â Ã
(116) XJ C(1), 2. . _. S ;:. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. C(2),2. C(3),8. C(4),8. C(5),16. C(6),8. :À.
(117) N. . .
(118) X
(119) -
(120). u £Þw_XZtczrfgjZ¬Y g_pgjYCdxjZN®Qszik_:a uXik_X_pwtZtsvdfc¬Fdf5Y[ifgj_Xso®»ZsVetif_p²vrkXchdxahgjik_XsX_pg·¸ikchY[Zts¡ B«ZVshifczabZ ´?XZQ°d¬Y[wahUXi/uXifjikrfgjZVuXZVeik_XszahchXe!ahgjik_[uX Y[iupWjZ DZpa»shZ czwtszXY[Ztc>dxgj_Xszgf _ ¦(i/uXwgszZtcªZs«etif_?ahcbdxgj_:abZs¬shXcªZs«czwJdxgshdxahgjik_Xs«rfif³vdxjZtsªvdfc|jZts|wt_XZchrfgjZts|ix eJdxjZts»Z!a>Zt_ uXwuXpgjchZ jZts»wt´?vdahgjik_Xs>shXcµjZts»XdfcbdfY[W!abchZs»uXw²X_pgs>vdxc°d«²XrkXchZ ¡ _ ?¬wczg²vZtc d[eikUXwchZt_petZ up(ssabWYCZu £±wt´?vdxazgif_Xs|Z!aZ chwshikpuXchZx¡ _ ?¬wczg²vZtc´? £ÞdfXetp_XZczwJdxgjsbdxazgik_ _ £±Ztsa«u £±wt_pZtchrxgZ_Xwtrkdxahg©kZx¡ ¢ZªXchZY gZcLa`/<Z«uXZªetik_:ahcbdxgj_:abZtsQetik_petZtcz_XZ|d Dw_vdxgshdxahgjik_§upZtseik_:abikpchst¡/ªikXs gY[<ikshik_psVZ¬ePi Ipau £±X_etif_?ahikXcVXdfcVX_XZw_XZtczrfgjZvdfcVX_gjahwuXZ¬if_XrkXZXctqX_pifabwZ k¡ }©fZte°daodxgZªwjwtY[Zt_:abdxgczZ|eoUpifgsgZ 2abdxgjjZªupZtsLeg´?XZso®!q/_XikpsdJ©kif_XsQU?pgaQupgczZte!ahgjik_Xs Dikszszgj³pjZts ¸©kifgjc|²vrfXchZ 3:®!¡<Å»_ etif_XszgjuXwtchdf_:a¬jZ Y[iupWjZ*sz/Y[wahczgj´/pZ vdfcªchifabdxahgjik_ Dq 5 etZtsªupgjchZeahgjik_XsªetifchchZsh<ik_XuXZ_:a|ahchifgjs a`<Zts|uXZ etik_:ahikXchsDq 5CshdN©fifgjcª©fZtczazgetdxFq<if³pjgj´?XZ Za[upgdfrkik_XdxS¡µ|ikXs*gjY[Difshik_Xs 5 eoUvdx´/pZ(upgjchZeazgik_ X_XZ Y YCZw_XZtczrfgZvdxc X_pgabw uXZik_prkXZtpc Dikpc ik³pabZ_pgjcªp_ Y[i/uXWjZgszifabczik<Zf¡v}« ahchifgjs a`<ZtsuXZ eik_:abikXczsshik_:a dxifchsdfszshi/egjwtZtsªZs abchixgswt´?vdahgjik_Xsshpg©xdf_:abZstq<chZtpchwtszZt_:abwZts|shXc d[²vrfXchZ V C B F R 3:® y B F C B 9 F R F :® B PF y B F y B F R C z4 6:® ¥Zs»etik_:ahcbdxgj_:abZts»szik_:a»uXw!²v_pgjZts>DifXcjZtsµik³{%Zabs»upZ°dxchrkZXc»df Y[ifgj_Xsµwr:dx 5 ¡fyikXc Zs dfpahchZts if³p{%Zahstqµ_XifXs*uXw!²v_pgjshshif_Xs[uXZts eik_:abcbdg_:abZs szgjY gjdxgjchZts¡>yBikpc Zs ik³p{%Z!abs u £ÞwvdxgjshszZtXc fq_pikXsgj_:abcziuXgszik_Xs*X_ vdfchdfY[WabczZ§szXXpjwtY[Zt_:abdxgczZ VuXwahZtczY[gj_vdf_:a S£±wt_XZchrfgjZLvdfc+X_pgabw>uXZ>if_XrkXZXc+uXZts+jgjrk_XZstq8etZL´?pg?g_puXpgaahchifgjs+_Xikp©fZZsµwt´?vdahgjik_Xs Fe·²vrkpchZ M 6:®n¡ ¢Zts ik³p{%Zahsu £ÞwvdxgjshszZtXc Z!a szik_:a uXw²v_gs etikY[Y[Z dNkdf_:a X_XZ wt_XZchrfgjZ |vdfcp_pgjahw«uXZªif_XrkXZXcQeikchczZtszDik_puvdf_:adf¶C³<ikczuXsuXczifgaZ!aVr:dfpeoUXZf¡¢Zts wt´?vdxazgik_psªif³pabZ_/pZts«s£Þwetcgj©fZt_:adxjikczs _ DifXcVZsik³p{%Zahsª©fZtcahgjeJdf¶ 2ZaªUXikcg ik_:aodf/¶v®< C B F C B PF R zf8® 9 C B PF R zNk® éÐöæ+é.
(121)
(122)
(123) . 3 _. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. . ,! À
(124) pÀM!2¾ ' ! / '
(125) §Ã lÂ<9! Áo¾ ')(/Ã. .
(126) M3. =. +. =. +. +. =. +. +. .
(127) X
(128) -
(129). +. <
(130) À"!2¾ [Âk¾ . / *»¾ '
(131) À
(132) v/. Âk¾ À
(133) ! À/ ' Âk¾ ÀN¾< x _ DifXcVZsik³p{%Zahs|ug°dfrfik_vdf¶« zJ\:® y B F yB F yB F R C B PF C B 9 F CB PF R z $?® C B F 9 y B 9 F yB F R zNk® _ DifXcVZsik³p{%Zahs|if³pjgj´?XZts B F C B PF C B PF C B PF R y zJ:® B PF C B PF C B PF C B PF R C z ® C B PF y B F C B F R z43:® ¥Zts>upgwchZt_:ahZtsLetik_:abchdxgj_?ahZts>shZchdfY[Wt_XZ_?a 5ik_ Zwt´?vdxazgik_ps>·2dgshdf_:a»g_:abZcz©fZt_pgjcQ´?vd8 abikc tZ¬vdxcbdfY[WahchZst¡p^Ê_XikXsV·2dxpaVYCdxgj_:abZt_Xdf_:a ©kwtcgj²XZtc ´?XZ¬jZ¬sz/szahWtY[Z DifshshWuXZ³pgjZt_ uXZts*szifjpahgjik_Xs¡ B«Z¶XdfcbdfY[W!abchZs5y B F Z!aC B PFz® {%ikpZ§X_ºcz¯fjZ§vdfcahgjetpgjZtc uXdf_Xs etZ sz/szahWtY[Z ppgsz´? £±gjs«g_:ahZtcz©?gjZt_X_pZt_:a¬uvdx_Xsªd pjXvdfca|upZtsªwt´?vdxazgik_pst¡<|ikps|Zn¶ppczg YCif_Xs dikczsZsw´/Xdxahgjik_XsZt_P·¸ik_Xeazgif_$uXZCetZsuXZ¶vdfchdfY[WahchZtsDifXc ik³pabZ_pgjc jZ sz/szahWtY[Z szpgj©xdf_:a yB F R zJ :® _ 8. . éÐöæ+é.
(134) N .
(135)
(136) . =. +. +. +. +. +. +. +. +. +. Ð! À"!2¾ '/CÃ!L1 / '
(137) Ã (Â<G! Áb¾ '9(/Ã. 46 _. yB 9 F. C B PF Ê,6:® yB F R Ê/8® yB F R CB PF yB PF Êfk® yB F yB F R C B PF Êx\:® yB PF R Ê$?® yB F R C B PF Êfk® yB F yB F R C B F yB PF Êx:® yB F R CB F y B PF Ê ® |ikXschwshif©kif_Xs*etZCsz/sabWtY[Z Z_$_Xikps dfszshXchdf_:a*´? £ÞdfXeX_XZ5eik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_ rfjik³vdxjZ _ £ÞZsza u £±wt_XZchrfgjZP_Xwtrkdxahg©kZx¡|yikXcetZ ·2dxgjchZxqV_Xikps eik_XsguXwchik_ps(X_pZ shifjpahgjik_ DifXc °df´?XZ!jjZdfXetp_XZeik_p²vrfXcbdxazgif_ jietdxjZ_ £±Ztsa«_pwtr:dxazgj©fZf¡<¢Ztsªetik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_Xs_ £ÞdfXvd8. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. R. . .
(138) 6. . .
(139) X
(140) -
(141). cbdxgjshshdf_:avdxsQuvdx_XsLjZªsz/szahWtY[Z¬u £±wt´?vdxazgif_Xsszik_:aeik_XszgjuXwchwtZsVetifYCY[Z|uXw²v_gszsbdf_:ajZ ³XchpgaZ!a ik_:auXik_Xe p_XZ wt_XZchrfgjZ wtrkdxZ 5 ´/g»uXw²X_pgjajZ ahchifgjszgjWtY[Z[vdfchdfY[WabczZ*uX YCi/uXW!Zx¡ yikXc|uXZtsª©fdZXchs¬sabcge!abZtY[Z_?a¬Diksgjazgj©fZtsuXZs«vdxcbdfY[WahchZstq<_XikXs«dN©fik_Xs¬p_pg´?XZn YCZ_:a Zs uXZt¶ etik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_Xs X_gj·¸ikczY[Zts etifYCY[ZPwabdxabs ·¸ik_XuvdfY[Z_?abdf¶D¡Å»_ chZn ©fdx_XeoUXZ szg - R R pqµahikpabZ etif_p²vrkXchdxahgjik_ etikY[<ikshwZluXZ ³vdf_puXZtsCvdfchdxjjWjZts ik u £Þif³p{%Zahsªe!gczetpdxgjchZs«ZtsaªX_(w!aodxa ·¸if_XuvdfY[Zt_:abdxS¡ ¢»£Äg_petik_:©kw_pgjZt_:auXZ«eZ«Y[i/uXWjZ¬vdfcLcbdxXDifczadf§Y[i/uXWjZ«u £±^`szgj_Xr*czwtsguXZ«ZtshszZt_:ahgjZ ZYCZ_:auvdf_XsVshd*etikY[pjZ!¶/gabwx¡M¢>£±pazgjgshdxahgjik_ uXZ«eg´?XZs Zt_:ahcbdxgj_XZX_5©fifgsg_XdfrkZ uXZ §pg ¶pZ!s¡+¢Z abZYCpsupZ*eJdxjet»_XwteZtszsbdxgjchZ 5§S£±ikpazgY gjsbdxazgif_up YCi/uXW!Z Zsza uXik_XeLdfeetchvdfc+chdfX<ikcz9a 5X_szgjYCZLY[iuXW!ZLu £±^`szgj_Xr 9ik etik_p_XZ!¶Zf¡xÅ»_czZ©xdf_XeoUpZfq Z Y[i/uXWjZ XchifDikszw*Ztsa ³DZtdfXeikXPpjXs shikXZ Xgsz´/£±g»·2dxga¬°d5ugsahgj_Xeazgik_Zt_:ahchZ ³XchpgaJqjgjrk_XZs Za eik_:abikXczst¡v^ÊchZtpchwtszZt_:abZuXik_peX_
(142) vx X X XsV²X_ szXcVd*shifjpahgjik_ uXZ°d shZrkY[Zt_:aodahgjik_ qMetZ ´?pgshZcbd[uXwtY[ik_:abczw shXc jZtsªchwtszpaodxahsªZn¶DwczgjYCZ_:aodf¶D¡ %
(143) %
(144) % 8 .À 4 !¸¾ ¾ ')(/à $Á
(145) !. B«df_Xs etZ XdfcbdfrfcbdfXUpZfq_pikXs*w!abZt_puXik_Xs jZ5eoUpgjZt_mÊYCi/uXW!Z³pgj_vdxgjchZ 5 X_Y[i/uXWjZ Y m`dxgjchZf¡ B«Z|Y tY[Z«´?XZ¬<ikXc»jZ«etdfs³pgj_vdxgjchZxq_pikXsLuXw²v_gszshik_Xs p_5etPi Iaw_XZtczrkwazg´?XZ Dikpc+jZtsBetik_:ahikXchsqjZtsjgjrk_XZsBZ!aBjZ³pchpgaczZtszDZeahg©kZY[Zt_:aJ¡k}ª²v_*uXZLrkw_XwtchdxjgjshZcBjZQetdfs ³pg_XdxgczZfqvuXZ¶ dfpXchi/eoUXZtsª<Ztp©fZt_:a !abczZZ_:©/gjsbdxrkwtZst¡D¢d XczZtY gjWtchZ eik_XszgjszahZ 5 <wt_vd8 jgjshZcZupwtshifchuXczZfqpd shZetik_puXZ 5·2dJ©kikcgszZtcVF£ÞikczuXchZx¡XŶpge!gjahik_XsetZs uXZt¶ dfXXczieoUpZts shXc¬F£ÞZn¶ZtY[pjZ uXZ d5²vrkXczZ kk¡ B«df_Xs°d XczZtY gjWtchZCdfpXchi/eoUXZfqeZazabZ[etik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_ shZtchd <wt_vdxgjshwtZ«uX§·2dxgaupZtsg¶ZjsVuXZª°dvdfcahgjZ«uXczifgjahZf¡Å»_5chZ!©fdx_XeoUXZfqZZ|shZcbd·2dJ©ki czgjshwtZ[uvdx_Xs¬°d5szZteik_XuXZCdfXpchi/eoUXZ[Zt_ ©kZczabpZCupZ*S£±X_pg·¸ikchY gabw uXZ d5vdfcahgjZ r:dfXeoUXZx¡ B¬df_Xs°dlpchZtY gjWtczZ5dfXpchi/eoUXZfqBetZtcaodxgj_XZs*etik_²vrkXchdxahgjik_XsuXZ ·¸ikcabZCwt_XZchrfgjZ 2XUvdfszZts uXwtszikchuXif_X_XwtZso®§<Ztp©fZt_:a czZtXczwtshZ_:abZtc upZlXczif·¸ik_XuXs Y g_pgjYCd$i/eJdx¶ Za5<ikszZtc§upZts Xchik³WYCZs|<ikXc F£¤drkifczgabUXY[Zu £ÞifpahgjY gshdxahgjik_ ¡<Å»_(Z!Z!aJqMetZczabdxg_pZtsªetik_p²XrkXcbdahgjik_Xs shZtchdxgjZt_:auXZ ·¸ikczahZCw_XZtczrfgjZCYCdxgjs _XwteZtszszgabZtchdxgjZt_:a jZ[eoUvdf_XrkZY[Zt_:a upZ[df³<Zjs uXZ[p/ szgjZtXczs|pg ¶Zjs«<ikXcuXwetchixgjahchZZt_lw_XZtczrfgjZf¡<yBikpcªw!©?gjahZtc«u£¤dJ©kixgcªuXZtsªY g_gYCdCji/eJdf¶ abchif pchif·¸ik_puXstqv_XifXsªdfuXikpahik_XsuXik_pe gjegd shZetik_XupZ dfpXchi/eoUXZf¡ ~/ifgZ_:a c p_XZ§eik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_$shXcX_XZ§e!jgj´?XZ5uXw!²v_pgjZ5df$vdfcbdxrkcbdfpUXZ5/¡ ¡§Z!a L P Ll^X^ ^. |ZsupgDwtchZ_:absdf³<ZjsXczwtshZ_:absVuvdx_XsQdeik_p²vrkpcbdxazgik_¡p¥if_XszgjuXwtczik_Xs Zs»upgjDwtczZt_:abZsQeik_p²vrfXcbdxazgif_Xs»³pgj_vdxgjchZt's c ik³abZt_?XZs>Zt_ dfshszie!g°df_:a»F£Þw!aodxa
(146) V 5«ahikpahZts Zs*szgabZs dJ:df_:a <ikXc°df³<Z ZaS£±wabdxa ldf¶ºdfpabczZtsszgabZts¡»¢Z§<ifabZ_:ahgjZ
(147) BEc F éÐöæ+é.
(148) .
(149)
(150) .
(151) NÀ"D! k ' _ /S t¾&¾ '¾ 1<9
(152) pÀM!2¾ $Á
(153) -! Âk¾ À
(154) À* *
(155) NÀ"! 5¾& '¾ 9 :À*. *. =. +. +. +. N _
(156) vÃ!2
(157) pÀM!2¾ ' ¾ ')(Ã !
(158) !
(159) v Â
(160) vC$Á
(161) !. dfshszie!gw 5 d eik_p²vrfXcbdxazgif_ c Zsza dxjikchsetZ!pgQetifchchZsh<ik_Xuvdx_?a df eJdfsuX$Y[i/uXWjZ ³pg_XdxgczZf¡f¢+ZDifahZt_:ahgjZvdfshszie!gwV5|d¬etif_p²vrkXchdxahgjik_ c ZszaLdxjikczsuXik_p_Xw vdfcd|·¸ikczY pjZ 2©kixgc ²vrkpchZ[8k®D
(162) BEc F^
(163) BEcoF'R Ê, 3:® j ~/Xc§d$²vrkXczZºN\pqL_XikXs§XchwshZt_:ahik_XsuXZts sgYpdxahgjik_Xs uX eoUgZ_m`Y[i/uXWjZ DifXc upgjDwtczZt_:abZs|©xdxjZtXczs|upZts«XdfcbdfY[W!abchZst¡<QgjZt_ ´?XZupgwchZ_?ahZts|uXZtsªgYCdfrkZs|czwtZ!jjZts|shZtr YCZ_:abwtZstqµeZts gjYCdfrkZs ch w JvWahZt_:a eZtczabdxgj_XZts*pchikXcgw!abws*szahchXe!abXczZZs2jik_XrkXZXc upZts etik_:abifXchsqB_XifY ³XczZ5uXZ[jgjrk_XZso®<ZtczYCZ!ahabdf_:a*u £ÞdfuvdfabZtcZs vdxcbdfY[WahchZs uXºY[i/uXWjZ df¶ sabchpeabpchZtsCuXZ F£±gjYCdfrkZ abchdxgjahwtZxq»etZ´?pg_ £±Ztsza vdfs jZeJdfs[<ikXc*jZ Y[i/uXWjZuXZ yBifazabst¡ !406 &! '&S* =&! % 45 90 /: 6 5" 4
(164) # * " 6+ B«df_Xs5eZ vdfchdfrkcbdxXUXZfqL_Xikps5etikY[vdxchik_Xs Zs5uXZt/¶ Y[iupWjZts5Z_ pahgjgjsbdx_?a5X_XZ shZtrfYCZ_:aodxazgik_[szXDZcz©?gjshwtZx¡?|ikpsµetik_pszgjuXwtczik_Xs»etifYCY[Z eik_X_?XsjZV_XikY³XchZ upZVedfshszZts Za jZtsCvdfcbdxYCW!abczZts[´?pg ZXc[shik_:a dfszshi/egjwtst¡>Å»_ etZetif_XetZch_XZS£ÄgjY dxrkZ(~pyL¼ T¬q»upZts Zt_XszZtY ³Zs*u £ÞdfXXczZt_:ahgjshshdfrkZ5ik_:awahw upw²v_pgjs YCdf_?XZ!jjZtY[Z_?a*vdfc X_$Zn¶DZczaJ¡ªikXs chZtpchZt_pik_XsµdikczsBjZtsBvdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsupik_X_Xwsµuvdf_X8s 4 M 3 6 ¡fyikXceoUvdfetp_ uXZtsBuXZt¶ Y[iupWjZts . ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z.
(165) k. . 0R )^ q R P^ q bR. )^ . . . .
(166) X
(167) -
(168). R ) ^ /q R ^ pq R ) ^ . . 0R ^ pq R 9 ^ pq bR ? ^ R !^ q R!^ pq R P ^ N\ _ /!2$Ã
(169) pÀ"!¸¾ 'B Â<G! bÁ ¾ ')(Ã. éÐöæ+é.
(170)
(171)
(172) . f\. _XikXspahgjgjshif_Xs F£¤dxjrkikcgjahUXY[Z§u £±ikpazgY gjsbdxazgif_ºZaZCabZtczY[Z5u £ÞdxahabdfeoUXZ5dx¶ uXik_X_XwZts ´/g>uXik_X_XZ_:ajZts Y[ZgZXchschwshpaodxahsZ!a ´?XZ _pikXs Z!¶pge!gjahZtczik_Xsuvdf_XsdszpgabZ[uXZ etZ cbdfpDikcaJ¡ ¢+d XchZY gWchZ gjYCdfrkZPabZsza(uXik_X_XZuXZslchwshpaodabs etikY[vdfchdf³pjZts(DikpcjZts(uXZt/¶ YCi/uXW!Zs(¸©kifgjc*²vrkpchZ 4 $:®!¡»Å»_ ZDZatqµetZ!ahabZ5gjYCdfrkZ _XZ <ikszshWtupZ Xdfs uXZ szahchXe!abXczZts ²v_XZtsZ!aDZpauXik_Xe !abczZPahcbdxgabwZ etikczchZeabZY[Zt_:alXdfc§jZY[i/uXWjZ uXZPyifahahst¡ ^ÊZsza g_:abwchZshsbdx_?a uXZ _XixabZtc ´/pZjZ <ikp©kixgc czwtrkpdfcgshdxabZXc uX eoUpgjZt_mÊYCi/uXW!Z ZtsaCdfXshsg Z CeJdfeZ[´/pZ etZjpg>uXPY[i/uXWjZ[uXZ[yBifazabs¡yBikpc¬²v_pgjctq_Xifahik_Xs¬´?XZ jZ eoUpgjZt_mÊYCi/uXW!Z etik_Xuppgja 5 pg ¶Zjs5YCdxªedfshszwtsdxjikchsC´?XZl_pikXs§Z_ dJ©kif_Xs DikpcCjZ(Y[i/uXWjZ uXZyBifazabst¡<¢+d[upgjDwtczZt_XeZ XcziN©/gjZt_:a«ZtshZ_:ahgjZZYCZ_:a uXZtsªetik_:ahikXchsªuXZF£ÞweoUpg´?pgjZtc¡ ¢+d shZteik_XuXZ gjYCdfrkZVabZszaLXczwtshZ_:abZªX_XZV·¸ikczYCZdx¶[etif_?ahikXczsµabchWsLdfete!guXZ_:abwts¡/¢+Z Y[i/uXWjZ uXZyBifazabs|d[ahZt_Xuvdx_XetZ 5[gszshZcªjZtsªetik_:ahikXchsª<ikXcY g_pgjY gszZtcªZXcªjik_XrfXZtXcqvetZ´?pg etik_Xuppgja 5§,\ $?Cpg ¶Zjs«YCdxBedfshszwts ¸©kifgjc²vrkXczZ 8/¡¤d:®n¡<¢+ZeoUpgjZt_mÊY[iuXW!Z chwtrfp°dxczgjshZ sbdf_XsQabchif5Dw_vdxgszZtcVjZtsVeik_:abikpchs ZaVDZchY[ZadikczsuXZ«chwtuppgczZ¬Z«_XikY ³pchZ¬uXZ«pg¶Z!s Y dedfshszwts 5 x k 2©kixgc ²vrkpchZ[8¡±³M®!¡ yikXcC²v_pgjctq>_XikXs XchwshZ_?ahik_Xs§jZts chwshpaodxahs§ik³abZt_?Xs shXcCS£ÄgjY dxrkZ ~yQ¼T¬¡Q¢Zts edfshszZts ik_:a*w!abw5upw²v_pgjZts 5(vdfczazgcu £±Zt_XszZtY ³Zs u £ÞdfXpchZt_:azgszsbdfrkZs[uXwahZtchY gj_Xwts Xdfc X_ Zn¶DZczaJ¡¥ZsQZ_XshZY ³pjZtsVeik_XeZtch_pZt_:aZshszZt_:ahgjZZY[Zt_:a Zª´?vdfcaQszX<wtczgjZtpcQr:dxXeoUXZ uXZCF£ÄgYCdfrkZx¡¢+Zsczwtszpjabdxabsshik_:auXik_XeCshpczabifpa <Ztcahgj_XZt_:ahs uvdf_ps etZ!ahahZ ik_XZf¡ªikXs Dik©kik_XsQchZY dxch´?XZtcshXc>Zs²vrkpchZts|NZ!a« ´?XZ|jZ«eoUgZ_m`Y[i/uXWjZ¬XczwtshZcz©fZ¬Y gZ¶ ZsLsabczXeahXchZs>²X_XZts>etifYCY[Zvdfc»Zn¶ZtY[pjZjZts>eoUXZY g_XsLZt_:ahchZ Zs>upgjDwtczZt_:abs>eoUvdxYCpst¡. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z.
(173) ,$. . d:® ¦ iuXW!Z uXZyifahahs. .
(174) X
(175) -
(176). ³M®¥UpgZ_m`Y[i/uXWjZ. eN®¦(i/uXWjZ Xu ZyBifazabs XgjYCdfrkZ uXZtsªZtczchZXchs uv® ¥UpgZ_m`Y[i/uXWjZµMgYCdfrfZuXZtsªZtczchZtpchs 4$ _ §tBÃÐÀ
(177) pÀ8*¾ À *»¾<. ÃN: !2
(178) -1& ' " À"<)(/ . éÐöæ+é.
(179) k.
(180)
(181) . d:® ¦(i/uXW!Z uXZyBixahabs. ³M®¥UpgjZt_mÊYCi/uXW!Z. Ne ®V^`YCdfrkZ uXZsZtchczZtXczs|upZd vu ® ^`YCdfrfZupZtsZtczchZtpchsªuXZ ³ 8 _ §tBÃÐÀ
(182) pÀ8*¾ À *»¾<. ÃN: !2
(183) -1& ' " À"<)(/ . ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. %.
(184) f. . N _ 1< À
(185) pÀ"!¸¾ J9* 2! t ' à : !F
(186) -1& '«¾MÀtÀ8 . .
(187) X
(188) -
(189). .
(190) ºÃ ¾ '9(/à *. éÐöæ+é.
(191) .
(192)
(193) . . Â,<9!. _ <1 À
(194) pÀ"!¸¾ J9* 2! t ' à : !2
(195) -1& oÁ ¾ ')(/Ã. ææ ßFTVUXWY[Z. *.
(196) Ã.
(197) 3. . .
(198) X
(199) -
(200). t
(201) ! " C" "$#%
(202)
(203) H
(204) " B«df_Xs etZ vdfchdfrkcbdxXUXZfq _XikXs etif_XszgjuXwtczik_Xs Zs Xchik³WYCZs up eczgabWtczZ Z!a uXZ S£ÞdxjrkikczgabUpYCZu £±ikpazgY gjsbdxazgif_ chwshifjXs¡yikXc[ZDZte!abXZc dszZtrkY[Zt_:abdxahgjik_ upZ ·2d?>ik_ _Xik_mÊshX<Ztc©/gjshwZfq»gchZtsabZ dxjikchs 5 ZtsahgjY[Ztc[ZsCXdfcbdfY[W!abchZs[uX Y[i/uXWjZf¡L¥Zs Xdfcbd YCW!abczZtsshZ[upg©/gjshZ_:a*Zt_ uXZt/¶Pa`<ZtseZt¶ dxshshi/egjwtsdfPabZchY[Z u£¤dxazaodfeoUpZ dx¶PuXik_/ _XwtZsªZ!aªetZt/¶ chZjZ©xdf_:aªuX Y[iuXW!Z
(205) vx X X ¡vªikXsXchifDikszik_Xsuvdf_psªeZ vdfcbdxrkcbdfpUXZ X_XZ Y[wahUXiupZ u £ÞZszazgYCdxazgik_IuX Y[i/uXWjZ u £ÞdxahabdfeoUXZPdf/¶ uXik_p_XwtZst¡yµpszgjZtXczs Y[wn abUXi/uXZts«u £ÞZszazgYCdxazgik_PuXZs dfpahchZts«vdfcbdxYCW!abczZtsuX Y[i/uXWjZfq ex£ÞZsza 5§ugczZ etZt/¶ uXZ d ifg
Documents relatifs
Chez l’Homme, les segments de gène V H ont été classés en sept familles (la famille 7 n’est pas représentée ici car aucun segment fonctionnel n’y a été décrit) qui ont
Le Négus consacra une énergie considérable en vue de gagner cet appui international, mais, malgré la force de son discours prononcé en juin 1936 devant ses pairs à la tribune de la
In this paper, we propose a novel approach based on the barycentric coordinates of automatically tracked 2D facial landmarks from videos to objectively evaluate the facial
Dirk Obbink (dir.), Doctrine and Doxography. Studies on Heraclitus and Pythagoras, Berlin / Boston, De Gruyter, 2013, p.. et le logos auquel les hommes devraient accorder
Les exorcismes ne sont pas publics, les sœurs noires elles-mêmes sont tenues le plus possible à l’écart, et c’est chaque fois Jeanne qui force les choses pour que, finalement,
Toute- fois, d’autres marqueurs des cellules POMC tels que NeuroD1 n’ont pas été induits dans cette expérience, ce qui indique que Tpit suffit in vivo pour provoquer la
Mais elle y occupait une place modeste : il faudra la liberté et le goût de la transgression du roman en langue vulgaire pour que la situation soit renversée :
Les thèmes majeurs (tab.5.4) abordés par les îliens interrogés sont, pour la grande majorité, les mêmes sur toutes les îles : ils concernent les usages anciens
