1
Current Trends in the Research
on Physical Education Teacher
Education (PETE)
Marc Cloes
Department of Sport sciences - University of Liège (Belgium)
ECSS – Lisbon – July 08-12, 2008
Symposium “Physical Education and Teacher Preparation - Present and Future”
2
Introduction
Students fail to thrive and achieve in schools
Teachers and teacher educators internationally have
come under enormous scrutiny in recent years
Teacher education seems to fail to prepare teachers
for the realities and challenges of contemporary
schools
A high priority is given to sustain the quality of
teacher education within a career-long perspective
(EU, 2007)
3
Introduction
PE is considered as a part of the rising tide of
overweight and inactive youth around the world
PETE needs to meet the current standards of
teachers professional development
Focusing on current research in PE teacher
professional development could help to determine how
higher education is reacting to the society
requirements
4
Content of the presentation
Presentation of the lifelong professional development
model
Comparison of the official missions of (PE) teacher
education
Teachers’ perception about the acquisition of their
professional competences
Illustration of current questions research
5
Teachers’ lifelong learning
X
The teaching profession should be seen as a
continuum which includes
Initial teacher education
Induction
Continuing professional development
European Commission (2005)
6
A developmental model of teacher education
Socialization
phase
Initial teacher
education
Induction
Continuing
professional
development
Professional
continuum of
lifelong
learning
European Commission (2005)
The Teacher Career Cycle Model
Several
phases
during the
in-service
period
Stroot & Ko (2006)
Two
influencing
sets of
variables
Socialization
X
It refers to “the process by which people selectively acquire
the values and attitudes, the interest, skills and knowledge – in
short, the culture current in the groups of which they are, or
seek to become members”
Merton et al. (1957, p. 287)
X
Professional socialisation is therefore a process “in which an
individual is taught and learns what behaviours and perspective
are customary and desirable within a professional role”
Van Maanen & Schein (1979, p. 212)
X
Student teachers reproduce behaviours of the teachers who
taught them and have strong representations when they enter
into PETE
9
Initial teacher education
X
Educating teachers is more than providing them specific
knowledge; it means to make them significant change agents
in the lives of young people
Teacher education should be multidisciplinary and focus on:
Extensive subject knowledge
Good knowledge of pedagogy
Skills and competences to guide and support learners
Understanding of the social and cultural dimension of
education
European Commission (2005)
O’Sullivan (2007)
X
In physical education, it means preparing teachers “knowing more
than how to teach basketball, hockey, tennis, and swimming,
regardless of how complex that might be. It means
understanding the curriculum, the learner, and teaching within
both local and global contexts”
10
Initial teacher education
Student
teacher
Supervisor
Students
Master
teacher
Knowledge
XSubject
knowledge
XTeaching and
learning methods
XPedagogy
XPsychology
XOrganisational
approaches
XTheories and
practices
European Commission (2005)11
Induction
X
During their first years of employment newly qualified teachers
are provided with additional support (mentoring, training, advice)
X
More must be envisaged in that critical phase of
professionalization
European Commission (2007)
12
Continuing professional development (CPD)
X
CPD corresponds to all learning experiences that occur after
completion of initial teacher education by in-service teachers
Armour and Yelling (2004)
X
As they cannot be expected to possess all the necessary
competences on completing their initial teacher education,
teachers need to be involved in continuing professional
development
Continuing professional development (CPD)
PE teacher
Personal and
interpersonal
Ministry of
Education
Inspection
Teachers
education
programmes
Sport
context
Professional
associations
In conclusion: Professional development
X
Consists of all natural learning experiences and those conscious
and planned activities which are intended to be of direct or
indirect benefit to the individual, group or school and which
contribute through these, to the quality of education in the
classroom.
X
Is the process by which, alone and with others, teachers review,
renew and extend their commitment as change agents to the
moral purposes of teaching; and by which they acquire and
develop critically the knowledge, skills and emotional intelligence
essential to good professional thinking, planning and practice
with children, young people and colleagues through each phase of
their teaching lives
Day (1999)
15
Purpose of teacher professional development
X
The content of initial and continuous professional development
programmes should reflect the importance of interdisciplinary
and collaborative approaches to learning
European Commission (2005)
X
Teaching and education add to the economic and cultural
aspects of the knowledge society and should therefore be
seen in their societal context. Teachers should be able to:
work with others
work with knowledge, technology and information
work with and in society
16
Required professional development programs
Brau-Anthony & Grosstephan (2006)
X
Need to prepare more professional teachers defined as:
having a knowledge basis
assuming a mission of knowledge transmitter
being able to act in emergency and to decide in uncertainty
being able to think about ones’ teaching and to analyse it
showing autonomy and responsibility
having a professional ethics compatible to the values of the
public educational service
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
X
Public policies
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Origin
Ministry of
Education
Ministry of
Education
Ministry of
Education
Ministry of
Education
Professional
association
(NBPTS)
Date
2001
2006
2001
2005
2001
Involvement of
practitioners
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Number of
competences/
standards
13
10
10
12
5
Specific PE
No
No
No
No
13
Information
No
Knowledge
Skills
Attitudes
Meaning
Components
Level at the
end of
pre-service
Descriptor
Statements
Indicators
Knowledge,
skills and
understandings
Knowledge
Dispositions
Performance
•Interstate New Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium (INTASC) •National Council for Accreditationof Teacher Education (NCATE)
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
Teachers’ personal skills
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
Teaching skills
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
Co-operation
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
ICT for the teacher
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
ICT for the learning
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
Comparison of the teaching competences or
standards
Wallonia
France
Quebec
Queensland
USA
Knowledge (human sci.) Teacher citizen behavior Knowledge (culture) Learning sit. (dev.new) Focus on stud. learning Instit. co-operation Language Language Dev. basic stud. comp. Know. (sub. mat. + did.) Knowledge (admin.) Know. (sub. mat. + cult.) Teach/learn. sit. (dev.) Learning sit. (dev.mot.) Organ. stud. learning Knowledge (subj. mat.) Teaching sit. (dev.) Teach/learn. sit. (man.) Learning sit. (dev.real.) Reflection Knowledge (didactics) Class management Assessment (learning) Learning sit. (dev.involv) Inst. and ped. Co-op.
Knowledge (culture) Individualization Class management ICT (learning) Relational competences Assessment Individualization Assessment (learning)
Knowledge (ethics) ICT (teaching/learning) ICT (teaching/learning) Focus on stud. soc. dev. Pedagogical co-operation Inst. and ped. Co-op. Instit. co-operation Learning sit. (dev.safe) Teaching sit. (dev.) CPD Pedagogical co-operation Instit. co-operation Knowledge (scientific) Pedagogical co-operation
Teaching sit. (man.) Prof. commitment
Reflection and CPD
Reflective practice and CPD
26
Where the PE teachers acquire their
competences?
X
Research project focusing on the PE graduates’ preparation in
Wallonia
X
Questionnaire mailed to all the primary and secondary level
schools
X
2,525 answers coming from 1,091 different schools (40.9 %)
X
Comparison of two groups of teachers
188 graduated since 18 to 20 years
156 graduated since 6 to 8 years
X
Teachers had to determine in which context (pre-service
preparation, in-service training, professional activity and
other) they acquired each of 21 competences. They had to
assess the proportional role of each context (%)
Cloes, Laraki & Piéron, 2004)
Role of pre-service teacher education in teaching competencies acquisition (%) 47,9 47,3 45,2 38,3 34,9 32,7 32,5 29,4 25,1 24,8 23,9 12,6 12,5 12,3 12,2 11,1 10,2 6,6 4,6 4,4 53,4 54,4 53,1 50,5 40 42,4 38,7 34,3 55,8 27,7 32,6 17,3 15 18,4 22,3 16,3 17,4 7,5 10,2 10 0102030405060 To explain f actors inf luencing
performance
To master the teaching contents
To apply theoretical know ledge to the practise
To minimize injuries’ risks
To be fit
To emphazise f actors of health and w ell-being
To have animation skills
To manage the group
To know and to be able to apply f irst aid skills To have a good sense of
communication To def end ethical aspects of sport
and physical activity To establish relationships w ith top
level sport To critically analyze sporting
media To adapt him/herself to pedagogical novelties
To manage stress and anxiety
To establish relationships w ith leisure sport To establish relationships w ith
youths
To w ork w ith colleagues
To establish relationships w ith medias and political authorities
To manage violence at school
A B
X
Pre-service preparation was
considered as fundamental for
the acquisition of the contents
to teach and to develop
theoretical knowledge (Graber,
1995; Rovegno, 1995).
X
They gave greater credence
to that period than their oldest
colleagues as pointed out by
significant higher ratios
p<.001 .001<p<.01 .01<p<.05
X
Improvement of PETE
programmes by
organizing more applied
contents (first aid)
X
Younger teachers
would be less
influenced by their
professional experience
Cloes, Laraki & Piéron, 2004)
X
Professional experience was
seen as a determining factor
for the acquisition of relational
competencies.
p<.001 .001<p<.01 .01<p<.05
Role of professional experience in teaching competencies acquisition (%) 70,4 66,6 55,1 49 44,4 39,2 38,8 37,8 34,4 33,7 33,4 32,3 31,4 30 29,2 24,2 21,6 21,5 20,5 14,5 73,4 62,4 49 42,3 38,3 34,7 34 40,7 25,9 32,5 31,2 26,1 31,1 26,2 25,8 24,8 15 21,9 22,6 12,7 01020304050607080 To w ork w ith colleagues
To manage violence at school
To establish relationships w ith youths
To manage the group
To have a good sense of communication
To manage stress and anxiety
To have animation skills
To adapt him/herself to pedagogical novelties
To minimize injuries’ risks
To establish relationships w ith medias and political authorities To def end ethical aspects of sport and
physical activity To emphazise f actors of health and w
ell-being To establish relationships w ith leisure
sport
To master the content to be taught
To apply theoretical know ledge to the practise
To critically analyze sporting media
To know and to be able to apply first aid skills To explain f actors inf luencing
performance To establish relationships w ith top level
sport
To be f it
A B
X
More similarity
between both groups
X
Most experienced
teachers provided a
largest place to their
experience (they could
have had less
opportunity in their
pre-service preparation than
their youngest
colleagues).
Cloes, Laraki & Piéron, 2004)
X
Except for the adaptation to
teaching innovations, in-service
training took a limited place
p<.001 .001<p<.01 .01<p<.05
Very short in-service
preparation sessions were (1
to 3 days/ year)
Most official in-service
sessions concern the
implementation of new
programme instructions
Group A teachers paid
more attention to in-service
training (younger teachers
could have received a more
practical field preparation)
Cloes, Laraki & Piéron, 2004)
Role of in-service training in teaching competencies acquisition (%) 37,7 21,3 14 13,7 13 12,8 11 10,6 10 9,2 9 8,5 7,8 7,7 5,8 5,2 4,8 4,6 4,3 3,1 30,6 16,1 15 10,2 9,8 9,8 9,1 8,1 10,4 11,9 8,7 10,3 6,6 8,1 5,5 5,7 3,7 3,7 3,6 4,5 0510152025303540 To adapt him/herself to pedagogical
novelties To know and to be able to apply first aid
skills
To manage stress and anxiety
To master the content to be taught
To apply theoretical know ledge to the practise
To explain factors inf luencing performance
To minimize injuries’ risks
To establish relationships w ith leisure sport To emphazise factors of health and w
ell-being
To manage violence at school
To have animation skills
To establish relationships w ith top level sport
To w ork w ith colleagues
To defend ethical aspects of sport and physical activity
To have a good sense of communication
To establish relationships w ith medias and political authorities
To manage the group
To establish relationships w ith youths
To be fit
To critically analyze sporting media
A B
X
“Others contexts” (personal
practice, for example) was
mainly identified as
contributing to the citizenship
action of the teacher and its
involvement in the society
p<.001 .001<p<.01 .01<p<.05
PE teachers find a
concrete part of their
competencies in their
personal life
Role of other contexts in teaching competencies acquisition (%) 60,2 58 56,2 47 46,3 34,7 34,3 31,2 30,1 25,1 25,1 20,2 20 17,9 16,9 16,7 15,4 12,4 12,1 9,1 55,6 49,9 51,6 44,4 44,1 28,7 27,9 13,1 30,1 27,9 20,9 15,9 19,1 14,9 19,7 14,4 12,4 10,3 11,5 9,2 0 10203040506070 To critically analyze sporting media
To establish relationships w ith top level sport To establish relationships w ith medias and
political authorities To establish relationships w ith leisure
sport
To be f it
To defend ethical aspects of sport and physical activity
To manage stress and anxiety
To know and to be able to apply f irst aid skills
To establish relationships w ith youths
To have a good sense of communication
To emphazise f actors of health and w ell-being
To manage violence at school
To have a good sense of communication
To explain factors inf luencing perf ormance
To manage the group
To minimize injuries’ risks
To w ork w ith colleagues
To adapt him/herself to pedagogical novelties To apply theoretical know ledge to the
practise
To master the content to be taught
A B
Some current research focuses in PD-PE
X
The Handbook of Physical Education
R. Tinning – Theoretical orientations in PETE
C. Collier – Models and curricula of PETE
D. Behets & L. Vergauwen – Learning to teach in the field
S. Stroot & B. Ko – Induction of beginning physical educators
P. Doods – PETE policy
Kirk, Macdonald & O’Sullivan (2006)
X
Exploring Mentoring in Physical Education (JTPE - 2005)
L. Griffin and colleagues
X
Professional Development in Urban Schools (JTPE - 2006)
P. Wards, M. O’Sullivan and colleagues
X
La formation aux études supérieures dans le secteur élargi
de l’éducation… (Res Academica – 2006)
E. Kalinova, C. Borges and colleagues
X
Continuing PD for Experienced PE Teachers (SES – 2004)
K. Armour & M. Yelling
Some current research focuses in PD-PE
Journals
JTPE
SES
EPER
PESP
Proceedings (AIESEP)
Jyväskylä 2007
Lisbon 2007
A Coruna 2004
X
Analysis of the
literature
X
2004 to 2008
Journals
STAPS
eJRIEPS
Res Academica
Proceedings (ARIS)
Besançon 2008
Louvain-la-Neuve 2005
Rennes 2004
X
Research papers
X
English + French
X
n = 93
Some current research focuses in PD-PE
X
Socialization
Biographies of student-teachers
Motives of PE students
X
Analysis of pre-service education
Selection of applicants
Analysis of the content and/or learning strategies
Supervision, mentoring and pre service experiences
Impact on students teachers
X
Induction
X
Continuing professional development
Usual strategies
Implementation of new teaching programs
Analysis of the content and/or learning strategies
Supervision and mentoring
Impact on teachers
Impact on pupils
Analysis of teachers’ career
Burnout
How many papers according to the year?
Almost 20 papers per year
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008Where the papers are published?
8 11 23 12 11 13 0 7 6 2 0 5 10 15 20 25 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 69,9 30,1 English French
More papers in journals
70% 30%
Journals Proceedings
Where the papers are published?
21,5 9,7 14,0 16,1 1,1 3,2 4,3 4,3 2,2 2,2 2,2 7,5 11,8 0 5 10 15 20 25 JTPE SES EPER PESP eJRIEP STAPS Res Academica AIESEP-Jyväskylä AIESEP-Lisbon AIESEP-A Coruna ARIS-Besançon ARIS-LLN ARIS-RennesWhat is
the
purpose
of the
studies?
X
Socialization: 5.4%
X
Pre-service: 54.8%
X
Induction: 11.8%
X
CPD: 28.0%
Which
research
design are
used?
48,4 28,0 14,0 9,7 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Qualitative Intervention Quantitative/qualitative QuantitativeX
Qualitative
approach
X
Intervention
X
Quantitative
approach
X
Systematic
observation
44,8 25,5 17,7 10,4 1,6 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Interview Questionnaire Other Qualitative observation Systematic observationX
3+ instruments: 36.6%
Who are the subjects?
X
One type of subject: 72.2%
37,5 26,7 14,2 10,0 10,0 1,7 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 PE Students In-service teachers
Mentor (non university supervisor) Teacher educator (university supervisor) Others (pupils, authorities, parents …) Cooperating teacher
X
Early graduated + experienced teachers
X
Overlapping according the country!!!
In which country PETE’s studies
are done?
X
FRA, USA
and GBR:
65.6%
X
Multicultural
studies: 2.2%
23 22 16 5 4 3 3 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 0 5 10 15 20 25 FRA USA GBR FIN POR AUS IRE QUE HKG ISR SWE BUL GRE SIN CYP NOR Multicult. Undeterm.41
Questions: Describing PETE programmes
X
Few updated description of PETE programmes are available.
The more recent was proposed in the USA by Ayers &
Housner (2008):
How does PETE faculty develop and update existing curricula in
response to school needs?
How do curricular models translate into practice?
How do the integration of technology experiences affect
candidates’ and faculty members’ knowledge and pedagogical
skills?
How do PETE programmes address multicultural issues through
minority faculty and student recruitment?
What effect do these experiences have on the social and
cultural perceptions of faculty and prospective teachers?
42
Questions: Long term studies in the area of
reflection
X
Focus on teaching and learning to guide teacher educators
and teachers themselves as proposed by Behets &
Vergauwen (2006):
Are reflective PE teachers better teachers?
What is the relationship between the teaching and learning
style of PE student teachers and their reflection skills?
How can they develop the required reflection skills?
How can we assess or stimulate this learning process, how can
we intervene?
Which personal and contextual variables influence reflectivity
43
Questions: Mentoring and induction
X
Even if such programmes are not so disseminated the
research emphasis would be less settled on theories, models,
and suggestions as proposed by Cothran et al (2008):
What is the real effectiveness of these programmes?
How do these theories, models, and programmes work?
44
Questions: Continuing professional
development in PD-PE
X
Some specific research questions for CPD in PE were listed
by O’Sullivan (2007):
What exactly do teachers learn from PD experiences?
What aspects of PD work facilitate teachers’ learning: how
teachers learn?
What are meaningful measures of teacher learning? of student
learning?
What are appropriate time frames within which to expect
teacher change? student learning?
45
Questions: The communities of practice
X
Its necessary to instil among teachers the belief that they
are life long learners
X
Communities of practice resulted in PE teachers forming
strong identities as teaching professionals
X
Some questions remain as pointed out by O’Sullivan (2005):
How are professional learning communities developed?
How are professional learning communities established at a
scale that can truly have an impact on teaching environments
(leadership at the school level)?
46
Conclusions
X
To present the literature in such field than PETE would need
a whole congress
X
This speech underlined the large diversity of topics that are
developed
X
The current trend is a focus to a socio-constructivist
conception of teaching/learning
X
Integration and competences’ development are becoming the
priorities of the teacher education programmes
X
There is a need of scientific information supporting the
process of change the traditional approach
X
Teacher educators should first acquire the competences
that their students have to develop
47
Thank you for your
attention
The speaker
preparing this
presentation
Aster : www.dessindepresse.comD-Day-2
49
References
Armour, K. & Yelling, M. (2004). Continuing Professional Development for Experienced Physical
Education Teachers: Towards Effective Provision.
Sport, Education and Society
, 9, 1, 95-114.
Ayers, S. & Housner, L. (2008). A Descriptive Analysis of Undergraduate PETE Programs.
Journal
of Teaching in Physical Education
, 27, 1, 51-67.
Behets, D. & Vergauwen, L. (2006). Learning to teach in the field. In, D. Kirk, D. Macdonald & M.
O’Sullivan (Eds.),
The handbook of physical education
(pp. 407-424). London: Sage.
Benhaim-Grosse, J. (2007). Image du sport scolaire et pratique d’enseignement au collège et au
lycée 2005-2005. Les dossiers. Enseignement scolaire, 190. Paris: Ministère de l’Education
nationale, Direction de l’évaluation, de la perspective et de la performance. Consulté le
22/02/08 sur Internet: http://media.education.gouv.fr/file/95/6/6956.pdf
Cloes, M., Laraki, N. & Piéron, M. (2004). PE teachers’ competencies: which ones are considered as
the most important and where are they acquired? In, V. Klissouras, S. Kellis & I. Mouratidis
(Eds.), Proceedings of the 2004 Pre-Olympic Congress. Sport Science through the Ages.
Volume II – Posters. Thessaloniki: SYMVOLI. 143.
Collier, C. (2006). Models and curricula of physical education teacher education. In, D. Kirk, D.
Macdonald & M. O’Sullivan (Eds.),
The handbook of physical education
(pp. 387-406). London:
Sage.
Commission of the European Communities (2005). Proposal for a Recommendation of the European
Parliament and of the Council on key competences for lifelong learning. COM(2005)548 final.
2005/0221 (COD). Consulté le 21/06/08 sur Internet:
http://ec.europa.eu/education/policies/2010/doc/keyrec_en.pdf
Council of the European Union (2007). Conclusions of the Council and of the Representatives of
the Governments of the Member States, meeting within the Council of 15 November 2007, on
improving the quality of teacher education.
Official Journal of the European Union
,
12.12.2007, C 300/6-C 300/9.
Cothran, D., McCaughtry, N., Smigell, S., Garn, A., Kulinna, P., Martin, J., & Faust, R. (2008).
Teachers’ preferences on the qualities and roles of a mentor teacher.
Journal of Teaching in
Physical Education
, 27, 2, 241-251.
Dodds, P. (2006). Physical education teacher education (PE/TE) policy. In, D. Kirk, D. Macdonald &
M. O’Sullivan (Eds.),
The handbook of physical education
(pp. 541-561). London: Sage.
50
Education Queensland (2005). Professional Standards for Teachers. Guidelines for Professional
Practice. Brisbane: The State of Queensland (Department of Education). Consulté le 14
/06/08 sur Internet: http://education.qld.gov.au/staff/development/pdfs/profstandards.pdf
European Commission (2005). Common European Principles for Teacher’ Competences
and Qualifications. Bruxelles: Commission européenne. Consulté le 16/06/08 sur
Internet: http://ec.europa.eu/education/policies/2010/doc/principles_en.pdf
Graber, K.C. (1995). The influence of teacher education programs on the beliefs of
student Socialization into Physical Education: Learning to Teach (pp
Interstate New Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium (2008). Consulté le
24/06/08 sur Internet: http://www.ccsso.org/
Kalaja, T. (2007). Success of Applicants in the Entrance Examinations of the Finish
Physical Education Teacher Education Program. In, P. Heikinaro-Johansson, R.
Telama, & E. McEvoy (Eds.). The Role of Physical Education and Sport in Promoting
Physical Activity and Health. Research Reports N° 4 (pp. 190-196). Jyväskylä:
Department of Sport Sciences.
Lecomte, J., Carlier, G. & Renard, J-P. (2002). Impact d'un dispositif centralisé de
formation continue en éducation physique sur les pratiques et les identités
enseignantes. STAPS, 59, 71-87.
Martinet, MA., Raymond, D. & Gauthier, C. (2001). La formation à l'enseignement. Les
orientations. Les compétences professionnelles. Doc. 00-1152. Québec : Ministère
de l’Éducation. Consulté le 14 juin 2008 sur Internet :
http://www.mels.gouv.qc.ca/dftps/interieur/PDF/formation_ens.pdf
Matanin, M. & Collier, C. (2003). Longitudinal Analysis of Pre service Teachers’ Beliefs
About Teaching Physical Education.
Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,
22,
153-168.
Merton, R., Reader, G. & Kendal, P. (1957). The Student Physician. Boston: Harvard
University Press.
51
Ministère de la Communauté française (2001a). Décret définissant la formation
initiale des instituteurs et des régents. D. 12-12-2000/M.B. 19-01-2001. [Decree
regarding basic education on primary school teachers and on lower secondary
school level]. Retrieved from the internet:
http://www.cdadoc.cfwb.be/RechDoc/docForm.asp?docid=2003&docname=200012
12s25501.
Ministère de la Communauté française (2001b). Décret définissant la formation
initiale des agrégés de l’enseignement secondaire supérieur. D. 08-02-2001/M.B.
22-02-2001. [Decree regarding basic education on higher secondary school level].
Retrieved from the internet:
http://www.cdadoc.cfwb.be/RechDoc/docForm.asp?docid=2033&docname=200102
08s25595.
Ministère de la Communauté française (2002). Décret relatif à la formation en cours
de carrière dans l'enseignement spécialisé, l'enseignement secondaire ordinaire et
les centres psycho-médicosociaux et à la création d'un institut de la formation en
cours de carrière. D. 11-07-2002/M.B. 31-08-2002. [Decree regarding in-service
preparation in specialised education, ordinary secondary education and
psycho-medical centres and creation of a institute for career-long education]. Retrieved
from the internet: http://www.ifc.cfwb.be/documents/deccoor_sospcpms.pdf
Ministère de l’Education Nationale, de l’Enseignement supérieur et de la Recherche
(2006). Arrêté du 19 décembre 2006 portant cahier des charges de la formation
des maîtres en institut universitaire de formation des maîtres. NOR :
MENS0603181A. Version consolidée au 28 décembre 2006. Journal officiel de la
République française, 28 décembre 2006, texte 25 sur 134. Consulté le 15/06/08
sur Internet : http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/
52
National Board for Professional Teaching Standards (1999). NBPTS Physical
Education Standards for teachers of students ages 3–18+. Arlington, VA : NBPTS.
Consulté le 14/06/08 sur Internet:
http://www.nbpts.org/for_candidates/certificate_areas1?ID=25&x=69&y=9
O’Sullivan, M. (2005). Creating and Sustaining Communities of Pratice Among Physical
Education Professionals. Invited keynote delivered at the
AFRAPS – ARIS – EDPM
Conference « Intervenir dans les activités physiques, sportives et artistiques. Pratiques,
Recherches, Formations ». Louvain-la-Neuve.
O’ Sullivan, M. (2007). Teachers Matter: A Framework for Professional Development
in Physical Education. In, P. Heikinaro-Johansson, R. Telama, & E. McEvoy (Eds.).
The Role of Physical Education and Sport in Promoting Physical Activity and
Health. Research Reports N° 4 (pp. 45-57). Jyväskylä: Department of Sport
Sciences.
Rovegno, I. (1995). Theoretical perspectives on knowledge and learning and a student
teacher’s pedagogical content knowledge of dividing and sequencing subject
matter.
Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,
14, 284-304.
Stroot, S. & Ko, B. (2006). Induction of beginning physical educators into the school
setting. In, D. Kirk, D. Macdonald & M. O’Sullivan (Eds.), The handbook of physical
education (pp. 425-448). London: Sage.
Tinning, R. (2006). Theoretical orientations in physical education teacher education.
In, D. Kirk, D. Macdonald & M. O’Sullivan (Eds.), The handbook of physical
education (pp. 369-385). London: Sage.
Van Maanen, J. & Schein, E. (1979). Toward a theory of organisational socialisation. In,
B. Staw (Ed.). Research in Organisational Behaviour. Greewich, CT: JAI Press.
Wallonia
X
To mobilize knowledge in human sciences toward a right interpretation of the
situations lived within and around the class and for a better adaptation to the
school publics
X
To keep efficient partnership relationships with the institution, colleagues and
students’ parents
X
To be informed about ones’ role within the school institution et carry on the
profession as defined in official texts
X
To master specific scholarship that justify pedagogical action
XTo master specific didactics that guide pedagogical action
X
To demonstrate an important background to arose students’ interest to the cultural
world
X
To develop relational competencies linked to the requirements of the profession
XTo measure the ethical stakes associated to ones’ daily activity
X
To work in team within the school
X
To conceive teaching devices, to test, access and adapt them
XTo keep a critical and autonomous relation to the past and coming scientific
scholarship
X
To plan, manage and access teaching situation
X
To bring a reflexive view to bear on ones practice and to organise ones career-long
professional preparation
Ministère de la Communauté française (2001a,b)
France
X
To act as state employee in an ethical and responsible way
XTo master French language to teach and communicate
XTo master subjects matter and have a good general knowledge
XTo conceive and operate his/her teaching
X
To organize the work of the class
XTo take into account the students’ diversity
XTo evaluate the students
X
To master information and communication technologies
XTo work in team and cooperate with the parents and school partners
XTo train him/her self and innovate
Ministère de l’Education Nationale, de l’Enseignement
supérieur et de la Recherche (2006)
Québec
X
To act as a professional who is inheritor, critic and interpreter of knowledge or culture when
teaching students.
X
To communicate clearly in the language of instruction, both orally and in writing, using correct
grammar, in various contexts related to teaching.
X
To develop teaching/learning situations that are appropriate to the students concerned and
the subject content with a view to developing the competencies targeted in the programs of
study.
X
To pilot teaching/learning situations that are appropriate to the students concerned and to
the subject content with a view to developing the competencies targeted in the programs of
study.
X
To evaluate student progress in learning the subject content and mastering the related
competencies.
X
To plan, organize and supervise a class in such a way as to promote students’ learning and
social development.
X
To adapt his or her teaching to the needs and characteristics of students with learning
disabilities, social maladjustments or handicaps.
X
To integrate information and communications technologies (ICT) in the preparation and
delivery of teaching/learning activities and for instructional management and professional
development purposes.
X
To cooperate with school staff, parents, partners in the community and students in pursuing
the educational objectives of the school.
X
To cooperate with members of the teaching team in carrying out tasks involving the
development and evaluation of the competencies targeted in the programs of study, taking
into account the students concerned
Martinet, Raymond & Gauthier (2001)
Queensland
X
Structure flexible and innovative learning experiences for individuals and groups
XContribute to language, literacy and numeracy development
X
Construct intellectually challenging learning experiences
X
Construct relevant learning experiences that connect with the world beyond
school
X
Construct inclusive and participatory learning experiences
X
Integrate information and communication technologies to enhance student learning
XAssess and report on student learning
X
Support the social development and participation of young people
XCreate safe and supportive learning environments
X
Build relationships with the wider community
XContribute to professional teams
XCommit to professional practice
Education Queensland (2005)
USA - NBPTS
X
Teachers are committed to students and their learning
XTeachers know the subjects they teach and how to teach
those subjects to students
X
Teachers are responsible for managing and monitoring student
learning
X
Teachers think systematically about their practice and learn
from experience
X
Teachers are members of learning communities
NBPTS (2005)
USA - INTASC
Content Pedagogy
Student Development
Diverse Learners
Multiple Instructional Strategies
Motivation and Management
Communication and Technology
Planning
Assessment