• Aucun résultat trouvé

Nous pratiquons un droit d'antiquaire

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Nous pratiquons un droit d'antiquaire"

Copied!
15
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: halshs-00781315

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00781315

Submitted on 25 Jan 2013

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Nous pratiquons un droit d’antiquaire

Noé Wagener

To cite this version:

Noé Wagener. Nous pratiquons un droit d’antiquaire : Relire les notions juridiques de ” mobilier archéologique ” et de ” documentation scientifique ”, à partir de l’exemple des ” matériaux naturels et de nature biologique ”. Les Nouvelles de l’archéologie, Maison des Sciences de l’Homme, 2012, pp.6. �halshs-00781315�

(2)

123456789AB32145315C72A95CD819AB38A7E

1 7FF5F55F5F55F5 !"F5#5F5F 5 5F5F$F5#%5&5'5F5(F)F'F5F55!) 5 F5F5F5F5"F5# 12345678189 ABBACD34BEF2AE4EEEFEB4EB4E4ECDECDE4 4EB34A4 !BBB43BE4E42B4"C# $%4&E4EB4'A43B24E42B24EABE44ACD322E43EBE(4E'E44 "2B4E4)E(4'E4A42432'E4A4*42CFEBAB24CEB+'E4,-%4.A4+2FE4CD2E(4 E33E 4 A 4 EE 4 A3A 4  4 ABCE 4 C2AC3 4 A 4 A2B 4 23AB2( 4 +AE 4 A 4 24 AC2FE4 ABCE4.%4/01$$4A3A4144C2E44ABF2E424*4A42CFEBAB24A++3EBE4 423AB243ACD322E43EBE44EB4EFE445BAB4,#464EB4E43CEB4ACAB24E4 E4F2BE4A44EB4 ABCE49%4/01704EB49%4/017/44F8FE4C2E#%4&EB42C444 FE 4 A8B3 4  4 FBE 4 E 4 A 4 CBE 4 ' 4 EB 4 EE 4 E 4 3+ 4 2 4 CE 4 'EB 4 A4 *42CFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E 4 C2BB3E 4 A 4 C2 4 E 4 23AB2 4 ACD322E4 3EBE4,(4E4B2B4CA4CE4'4E4E)E%46(42BAB424E4F3BD2E43F3ABE(4 ABCE4$E4E4A8B344$74EBEF"E4099:4 *+2+(40;4EB%4099:(4%4$77;$#4BE4<4 *4CAB32E4,4E42CFEBAB24CEB+'E424E4*42CFEB4AD'E4 A(4EE3(4 FBE(4E#4,(4E4*42CFEB4D2B2AD'E4EB4A2E4,(4E4*42CFEB4 F3'E4,( 4 E 4 *42CFEB 4 3CB 4 CAEB 4 EB 4 +CDE 4 EEBEFEB 4 E 4 BEA(4 C2E2ACE( 4 A2B 4 3BE#4,( 4 E 4 *4F2AE 4 EB 4 EFEBE4, 4 EB( 4 E+( 4 E4 *4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4ECE424E423AB24,%4

0%4E4CEBAE4D3B3233B34BAE4E4CEBBE43F3AB2%4624'E4E4C'4EF)E4 CAB32E 4 AEF"EB 4 E 4 CD2E 4 ' 4 2B 4 *4C2BB3E4,( 4 A 4 E 4 2E( 4 A4 ACD322E( 4 A 4 <)FE 4 CAB32E 4 E 4 C2F2E( 4 EE( 4 33FEB 4 *4ECE4, 4 2 4 E4

- =E4EFECE46E4&DA2(4>AE4&2(4?24@EACDA4EB4AA41AA24A24ACCEB34E4EE4EB4 CB'E 4 CEB 4 ABCE 4 A 4 '6) 4 >ABDE 4 EB 4 BCEB 4 13 4 A2 4 "E 4 2( 4 E 4 FA)E 4 4 33AE(4FE4E4A4E4F3AE442B4E4ACD322E#%

(3)

23AB2 4 'E( 4 2BA3FEB( 4 E 4 32DABE 4 AAB 4 BCB 4 A2C3 4 A 4 F2"E4 ACD322'E(44A4*4ECE4,#%4>A4ABCE404E4A8B344$74EBEF"E4099:4CBE4 B2B 4 2BE42 4 E 4 3AB 4 E 4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E 4 A< 4 E 4 *42"DEB 4 BA+2F3 4 A4 ACBB34 DFAE4 ECE4 24 E4 23AB2 43ACD322E43EBE44,(4 4E 4 E<CB4 +2C3FEB4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E%

?E+(4E4E4CD2E4*4ECEE4,4A4ACD322E4E4B2E4ACAEFEB43C23%

1%4&EBBE4EFEBAB24BA+2FE4E42+2E4E4)E4ACA"E4A<4ACD32CECE4 E4A4BEE4 3FEB22E(4322E(4FC2F2D22E#4EB4E4A4E4 ACD32"2BA'E(4 ACD32E222E#%4F4E4E<'E42C4A4E4ECE4'4EB2E4G442BE4C2AACE(4 E4A43B343CB44E4DEB%46BAB4E43FE4D'E4E4ACDE4E4+2E4 A4E4 BCB#464'4ABCE4AB24E4A4BE4'A+CAB24ACDE4"'E(4E42CFEB4 AFBAB+ 4EB4 E4C3AB2 4BB3AE4EB4ABB'E464 AAAHB4 AD2D4 FAHB3(4 ABAB4 CE4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4EBE4EC2E44E<2E%4

A+,5ACE19A9-:%4.E<E24*4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4,4E4EF"E4A(44EFE4 A"2(42EE4E4++CB34BAB4E4BEFE4AAEB4A243B343ECB234AEC42%4 AE4E4*4FAB3A4,(4A"2(432BE4E42C4E4E4BE4E4*42"DEB4,4 E4FAB3A(4 CE4EAB(4E4'E'E42BE(4A4FAB)E4A42"DEB#%452'E4E4*4ABE4,(4EBE(4E2E(4 4223 44F2"E4ACD322'E(44B2B4CE4'4A4A43B34BA+2F34A4ACBB34 DFAE% 4 8<E 4 E4 *4ABE 4 "22'E4,( 4 E 4 2BE( 4 AB2E4  4 E<CE 4 B2B4 CE 4 '4 EB4 F3A2'E 4  4 E<CEB2( 4 2"A"EFEB( 4 E 4 +2E 4 AFA< 4 EB 4 33BA< 4 ' 4 2B4 "22'E464CEBE4A4E4ABE(4FA42E#%4=2E4A4C2D2CB24E4C22AB24 *4EB4,( 4 E+( 4 ABBEBE 4 E 4 A 4 22B3 4 E<E 4 CFABEFEB 4 E 4 CAACB)E 4 ABE 4 EB4 "22'E 4 ABEFEB( 4 2BE 4 'E 4 CE 4 E< 4 CAACB)E 4 E 4 2B 4 A 4 CFABEFEB4 E<342E4E4A243F2BE43F2BA"E424E<BECE4E4FAB3A<4"22'E4 ' 4 E 4 2B 4  4 *4ABE4,( 4  4 *4BA+2F3 4 A 4 ACBB3 4 DFAE4,#42 4  4 FAB3A4 *4ABE4,4FA424*4"22'E4,4 4AEB424BAA3(4A4E<EFE#4E4E)E4A4E4 A 4 2CFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E( 4 A 4 AABAE 4 ' 4 FAB3A 4 *4"22'E4, 4 FA 4 24 *4ABE4,4 4E4E4"2(4A4E<EFE#% .A4CA+CAB24E4F2"E4ACD322'E4EB4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4E4 CA'EAB(4E43+BE(44A4BCB24A2A<2E4E4AB3+ACB4EB4E43C2+ACB%4&E4 EB4EB48BE4A4B2B44+AB4E<ACB4 3C2+ACB4E43B4A<4EE4CD2E4"22'E4EB4 AB3+ACB43BE44B24E42"DEB4*4BA+2F34,4A4ACBB34DFAE4I#(4FA4CEB4E4 B2B4CA4E4CE4E4'EE4A43B34BE3B3E4E4'E'E4AE4+242J4EE4A43B34 %4?2+4 EB 4 A% 4 099K 4 2 4 1L 4 G 4 % 4 3AEFEB( 4 E 4 E( 4 E 4 *4C2F3FEB 4 A 4 CADE 4 E 4 CDAE4 CEB+'E4,43A"234A4E4ECE432A4E4ACD322E4E4.2AE#%46BEFEB4B(4 A43AAB24E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E44F2"E4ACD322'E4E4 EAB 4 A 4 EE 4 2 4 A8B3 4  4 $7 4 EBEF"E 4 099: 4 +2FAEAB 4 D'EFEB 4 E4 +2B)E43BAB4E4A4ABE4E4CD2E%

/%4>A4E<ECCE4EB+CAB24E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4E43)E4 ++CE 4 ACAB2 4 A+2#( 4 A"EAB 4 E 4 C23'ECE 4 B2D2#( 4 EB 4 AACD2'E4

(4)

EB 4 +2AFEBAEFEB#% 4 @++CE 4 ACAB2( 4 A"2( 4 CA 4 E 4 BACE 4 E4 BA+2FAB24A4ACBB34DFAE4EEB4EBE4B3E4644E4EB4A(4AF4FE4 E<EFE(4E4*4CEBAE4EE424+AM23E4FA4'42B43B34B3E4EAB44A4E4 BEF4B)4C2B4EB42B4E4BACE4AE42B4A4C23'EB4E4EBBE4,4 E<EFE4B34E4 >N2NA40990424K;K#424EC2E4E424AFA<4CEB"E4E42E4A4"E4E4 34E4EAE4'E4E48BEFEB4 E<EFE4B34E4O2AOE"4EB4BE4099/424$0#%4 6"EAB4E4C23'ECE(4EBE(4CA4CEB4F2E4E42EE4+AFEBAB24D'E4 EEF"E4CEB+'EFEB4C2D3EB4644+AAB4A(4EBE4ABE4E<EFE(4B3E4 E 4 2 4 +2E 4 2 4 E+23( 4 B3 4 A 4 CEBAE 4 3BE( 4 A 4  4 EEF"E4 D'EFEB4 BCB4E 4ABE 4 2"DEB 4+3AE4 BAB2E4 DACDE 42E(4 2BEE(4

F%# 4 E 4 A2CAB2 4 E'E 4 CE 4 2 4 E 4 B2EB 4 E<EFE 4 B3 4 E 4 @EFA 4 EB4

1EAEA4099$4247K:#%46ACD2'E4EB(4E+(4CA4CEB42"E4432E44E4 'EB24C2FFE424*44A4E4"343C2B'3(44E4C'4F3AE4E42FEBCAB24 E4C33AE(4EB44PABEP4'43CAB4E4E<4AB44E424I4,4 QD3"AB409$9424 $9#464"E+(4CEB42E4A4EFE4E4CAE4E4A4C3E4EBE4ABE4EB4CBE4 %42B% 4 @EC2A4099/4EB409$$#4EB4A43+E<244E4DA"E4 &D2'E4099$4EB40991#% R2CE4EB(4E4(4E4C2BABE4'E4A4EFEBAB24E4E4E4CD2E4ECEE4A4 ACD322E43)E4E4E<C2424CEBE(44FAB3A4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4 B)E4 A4 2CFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E4 EB4  4 FAB3A 4 E4 ABE4 "22'E4'4 EB4 A4 ABE4E)E44F2"E4ACD322'E4G4FA4'E4+AE44FAB3A4ABE4'4EB4A4 E4ABE4"22'E4I46BEFEB4B4242J4CAE4E4AEB424+AM234E4A42BBE4E4A 4 ?AFE4?2E42B4ACCFAB24EF"E42BAB4ABBEBE4E4BCBAB24E4EACE4 A 4 D2FFE 4  4 A32BD'E 4 E<EFE 4 B3 4 E 4 7AEA 4 EB 4 7AA 4 099/#( 4 4 ACD322E(4EB(4E43CE44E43EE4I

AA+,539A.A9-7% 4 >A 4 E 4 ++CB3 4  4 EB+E 4 A 4 CAB32E 4 E 4 FAB3A< 4 ABE 4 EB 4 E 4 ABE4 "22'E 4 E4 2EB 4 A 4 2CCBE 4 E 4 A2 4 F8FE 4 E 4 2 4 E<BECE% 4 SF2BE 4 CE4 ++CB3( 4 +AEFEB( 4  4 E 4 AABAE 4 'E 4 CEBBE 4 CAB32E 4 2B 4 AEB 4 E4 C23EB% 4 .A 4 + 4 DB+E 4 E 4 F2AE( 4 EB 4  4 E 4 C2BEBEA 4 3EEFEB 4 'E 4  4 A4 CAB32E4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4A43B34C33E(4CEB43C3FEB424 A42BAE4A43FE44F2"E4ACD322'E4EB424A42FEBBE(4C23ABEFEB(44 CE4E4A42CFEBAB24CEB+'E%

6( 4 ACE 4 ' 4 E 4 2B 4 A 4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E( 4 CE 4 FAB3A< 4 2B 4 A 4  4 8BE4 ABA34EBE45BAB4EB4E423BAE44BEA4 C2+2F3FEB44ABCE4.%4/01$:44 C2E44ABF2E#4EB4ACE4'42B42CFEBAB24CEB+'E(442EB48BE4EF44 5BAB4 C2+2F3FEB44ABCE4.%4/01$$44F8FE4C2E#%4842FFE(42C4DA"EFEB4 3CAB3 4 E 4 ABAE 4 6 4 CEBBE 4 A"EAB2 4 CEB+'E 4 AFEFEB 4 32C3E 4 6 4 EB 4 24 ABCEEFEB 4 3BA"E 4 E 4 A++ECBAB2 4 +2C3E 4 E 4 "E 4  4 BB3 4 "'E 4 A4 A2AB243AA"E4A45BAB464CE4+ABAFE44)CE4EB4EF4E42B44ABF2E4 CBE(4CE47AA4'E4E4E42B4E4ACDE4AAB44D'C4A2CDE%4!4+AB4F8FE4 EC2AHBE 4 'E 4 CEBBE 4 C2 4 E 4 FAB3A< 4 ABE 4 EB 4 E 4 ABE 4 "22'E 4 A 4 A4 2CFEBAB24CEB+'E42BE44A4C244ACD322E(4CE4E4CE4 E+43A3E44AAFE44CDECDE4AB'B3424CEB(4E4E++EB(4A4E42E4'E4

(5)

E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E42B4E4A4*42CFEBAB24,4CA442B4 3E3(4CE4EB4A424E<F8FE4FA424*4+2FAB24ACD322'E4,4 ?2+4 EB4A%4099K424/1#4'43DCEB%4RAEFEB(4B3E4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4 "22'E 4 A 4 A 4 2CFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E( 4 CEB 4 EDEBE 4 2BE"EFEB 4 A 4 +E4 A3E 4 E 4 2"DEB 4 ACD322'E 4 ' 4 3AAB 4 2 4 E 4 3A"2AB2 4 E 4 A 4 2 4  4 0L4 EBEF"E4$K:$4 2B4A43ACB24+AE4EB(4+AB4E4AEE(4E'E4B3AEFEB4E4 +AB44ECBE433A4E4F2FEB4DB2'E#4EB4'E4E424E4$L4DAE4099$4 EB4$E4A2TB409914EABE44ACD322E43EBE42B4A443AE%

L%4!4E4+AB4E(4A4C23'EB(424'E4242E4A4E4BABB4E4FAB3A<4ABE4 EB4E4ABE4"22'E4AE4E4CE44F2"E4ACD322'E%4!42B4D'EFEB4 CE4 'E4 E4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E4 EAB4 8BE4 24 A3DE3 4 A 4 BAE 4 E4+2FAB24 ' 4 2BEB 4  4 2B 4 E 4 A 4 *42CFEBAB24,#( 4 3"AA3 4  4 ABAE 4 EB 4 F 4  4 A4 2B24E45BAB%

;%4.E<C24E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E44F2"E4ACD322'E4 C2BBE( 4 E 4 3+BE( 4 E 4 2EE 4 EE 4  4 AFABFE 4 E 4 AFBAB2 4 24 EC2AB44E4BE3BAB24C2BCBE4E4BEFE4E4A42(4E4FBE4E4A4CBE4 EB4ABBACD3(4A4A8B344$74EBEF"E4099:(443E4ABAB4'E4+AE4E4EB43CAB4 EBE4E432C34D'E4EB4E4AAB24E4A4AB'E%4SBBE424CEA(4AE(44 2"E4'E4E<E24*4F2"E 4ACD322'E4,4AAB43C3FEB43B34B2BE424 ACCE(424E4AEAB24C2FFE( 4AB3+ACB4EB43C2+ACB424EB4AFEB4424E4 BEF 4 2J 4 =EA&AE 4 A2B 4 E 4 3D2AB 4 E 4C2BABE 4 'E 4 *4CEBBE 4AEAB2 4 A4 2EEFEB 4 AB3 4 CEE 4 P2"DEB 4 ACD322'EP( 4 ' 4 E 4EBE 4  4 B3E 4'E4 A 4 E 4 2FAE 4 D'E 4 EB 4 F32AD'E4, 4 EB 4 A++FAB 4 'E 4 CE 4 CDAEFEB4 3FAB'E( 4 *4B2B 4 E 4 +AAB 4 3+3ECE 4  4 A 4 F2"B3 4 E 4 CE 4 BAE 4 E 4 EBE( 4 3%%%4 4 BEBE4 B2B4B3E4EEF"E4E433FEB43EA"E444CDABE4244EFEB4,4EB4 *4C2E24"E4432B24E4ACD322E(44A4C2CEB24EB42C44A4+AB34BEE4 'EE42B43+E4A4A4C2EB24E4>ABE4,4 A2B4$KK;(40424111:#4I

K%493F2424$U4A4CAB32E4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4A#4E43)E4 ++CE 4 EB+CAB2 4 EB 4 "# 4 2"E 4  4 +AFEBE 4 E 4 E 4 CD2E 4 ECEE 4 A4 ACD322E4G4FA40U4243FE4D'E4E4FA'E4A4ABBAB4 C2FA34A<4)E4 A<'EE 4 E 4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E 4 E 4 B2E 4 2F#% 4 6ABAE 4 EB 4 C23EB4 3'"EB42C4424F2%

$9%4>A4AAAE4EBE44A++E%4.A4ABE4E<ACBE4EB4A42B3E43CE4E4A4EFE445BAB4 E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4F3BEB(4E4E++EB(48BE4CB3E%

R2CE 4 EB( 4 A"2( 4 AFEBBE 4 'E 4 5BAB 4 E 4 2E 4 AC 4 2B 4 E 4 23B3 4  4 E4 FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4'442B4EF424E4AB(4ACE4'E4CEBBE4 EFE4E4AB4A4BA+EB4E423B3445BAB4G4ABE4AB(4ACE4'E4E<CAB44 F2"E4ACD322'E4CE4FAB3A<(4E4FBE4E4A4CBE4A(4A4F8FE(4E2C34A4 ABAE 4 E 4 23B3 4 B3 4 E 4 ABCE 4 .% 4 /01$: 4  4 C2E 4  4 ABF2E% 4 .E 4 FAB3A<4 ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4EFEEB(4E4C23'ECE(4A423B34423BAE44 BEA4A4E'E442B43B34ECE(4A4ACAB24E4ABCE4//$4 *4B2B4CE4'4B4 EB4 C22E 4  4 A 4 CD2E4 AABEB 4 A 4 23BAE 4 3%%%44,# 4 EB4 //0 4 *4A4 23B34  4 24 EF2BE4A423B344E4EB44E2%43%%%44,#44C2E4C%4A4BE(4423ABE4

(6)

ACD322E43EBE(445BAB4E42B4DA"B344E43BE464A+(4"E4T(442"BE4 3AA"EFEB4AB2AB24423BAE44BEA%49E(4A4CAB32E4E4FAB3A<4 ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4ACC2FF2E42C4FA44B3ECB2% >A4CEB(44EC2E(4A42B3E4EBEBE4E42"AB24E4EFE4'42B48BE4A3E44 EB%484E++EB(44E<BE4A(4D24E4ACD322E43EBE(4E4EFE42"AB2E44 5BAB4E4A42CFEBAB24CEB+'E4E4BAB4'E4BEE424E4)E4ECAAB4E4+2E4 ACD322'E 4 2AFF3E 4 2EB 4 CEBBE 4 2"AB2( 4 2 4 A 4 FE 4 A2 4 'EE4 2EB4 E<BECE4 F8FE 4 E4 A4 2CFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E% 4 F( 4 E++EB4 E4 CE4 ECE4 E4 3)E4ABC)EFEB4EB2424E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4ECE4 24E4+2E42AFF3E424'E(4E4AB(4ACE42B24D'E4F2E4 E4EFE445BAB4EB4'E(4ABE4AB(4A4'A+CAB24E4F2"E4ACD322'E4E4 EB 4 3+BEFEB 4 +EF3E 4  4 F2 4 E 4 C2E 4 ' 4 E 4 A 4 A2 4 E< 4 3+B2 4 4 F2"E4ACD322'E(4E4'4E4FBEAB4A<4E42"DEB4BA+2F34A4ACBB34 DFAE4ECE424E423AB24ACD322'E43EBE(4ABE4'43BEAB44 B2BE 4 E 4 CD2E 4 ECEE 4 2 4 E 4 +2E 4 ACD322'E 4 2AFF3E#( 4 CE<C4 AAEB 4 EFEB 4 EB 4 FEFEB 4  4 CDAF 4  4 2B 4 E4 ACD322E% 4 @) 4 2( 4 E4 BABB4E4CE4FAB3A<4E4++)E44E4E4E4CE4E4A"E4AB344E4BEA4+23 4 24E4A42CDE4'E4CE4BEA4C2BEB424ACD322E4A4A4E42B4EF2BE4AEE4  4 E 4 FAB3A< 4 ABE 4 EB 4 E 4 ABE 4 "22'E 4 ' 4 ECEE 4 2 4 E 4 +2E4 2AFF3E(4A44'4E4EB4E4A4E4A"E4'4AACDE424E4A42CDE4'4 3C2E464A+(4E42EE4+2(442"BE4AB2AB24423BAE44BEA%4

$$% 4 8 4 2FFE( 4  4 A 4 A 4  4 C2FFE 4  4 )E 4 '( 4 FB2AA"EFEB( 4 EB 4 E+EF3 4  4 A4 CAB32E4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4244BABA)FE4'4A44AAHBE4 ABBAB424ACD322E43EBE4E43)E43ABE<424ACD322E42AFF3E%4 &EB42C4A4EF24'E43AB34E4CEBBE4CAB32E4EB432FA48BE4EA3E%

AAA+,5.-/8.A9-$0% 4 .A 4 ABE 4 F8FE 4 E 4 A8B3 4  4 $7 4 EBEF"E 4 099: 4 BEB 4 E 4  4 ACC2E 4 E4 C2+ACE4AEE%44A8B34E4C2BBE4DAFA4'4ACBE4AFBAB+4E4+A"E4EA(4 AC3 4 A 4 E 4 BAB2 4 E 4 3EACE 4 A 4 A2B 4 A< 4 2FE 4 ' 4  4 2B4 D3ACD'EFEB 4 3EE% 4 .A 4 'EB2 4 E 4 A 4 AB3 4 E 4 E<C2 4 E 4 FAB3A<4 ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E44F2"E4ACD322'E4EB4E4B3AB24C23ABE4E4 CE<C 4  4 A 4 2CFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E 4 F3BE 4 2C 4 8BE 4 2E3E 4 2 4 E 4 FBE 4 E4 A4 CBE 4 3BAB 4 "E 4 EBEE 4 A 4 BCBEFEB 4 A 4 2B2 4 E 4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E4 B3E44ABCE4.%4/01$:44C2E44ABF2E4EB4BE3BE4A4AEFEB4CEE4E4 2CFEBAB24CEB+'E4EF2A3E44ABCE4.%4/01$14I

$1% 4 ! 4 EAB 4 "E 4 T 4 BEBAB 4 E 4 ECDECDE 4 A 4 *422B3 4 3EE4, 4  4 3ABE 4 2 4 A(4 2'E4E4AEFEBAE43C)EB(424E4A43AAB24E4A4244$E4A2TB40991(4'E4 *4A 4 2CFEBAB2 4 A++3EBE 4  4 23AB2 4 3ACD322E 4 3EBE 4 EAB4 4 EFE 4 4 5BAB4,(4 EBEAEB 4 A4 EBEE4 CEBBE4 *42CFEBAB24, 4 A< 4 EE4 ACDE4 E4 +2E4642(4"E424E43E4A4B3E4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4 I4>A4+2CE4EB4E4C2BABE4'E4E4BAA<4AEFEBAE4EEEB4E%4&EBE(44A4A4

(7)

"E(4C4EB4(4'E'E4CE(4FA44B34'4AB4FE<4E4A4EAE4A4CEBBE4 2E424E<3ECE42E4'E(4FE3E4A4E4BEE4C2B2(4A4ECDECDE443BE4 *4EB4E4A424,4BEAB44F2B24E4EB4FE4E4243+3ECE4E2EE% $:%44+AB4EFEE4E4EACDE4C2BEBA"E424E43+B2433AE44*4ABF2E4 ACD322'E4,4B2B4E4E4B44C2E44ABF2E( 4C2AC344ACD322E(4EB4 2E4'E4*4C2BBEB4E433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E4B24E4EBE4EB4 ABE4BACE4E4E<BECE4E4DFAB3(42B4A4AEAE4EB43BE(42BAFFEB4A4E4 +2E 4 2 4 E 4 3C2EBE( 4 EFEBBEB 4 E 4 EBACE 4 E 4 3E2EFEB 4 E 4 DB2E 4 E4 DFAB34EB4E4A4EAB24AEC4E2EFEB4ABE4,4 ABCE4.%4/$9$#%4@E4A4A4 ACE 4 A 4 E 4 C2E( 4 CEBBE 4 3+B2 4 *4CDAEABE4, 4 EEF"E 4 E 4 ABCE 4 EAB+ 4 4 ACD322E( 4 E 4 2BE 4 ' 4 AAHB 4 ++CE 4 E 4 A 4 3E 4 A 4 A 4 E 4 FE 4 3CAB24 BB3AE424EE4C2BBE(443ECE(44CAE4C2CEBE4CDA34F3E4B2BE4E4 ACCEB244ABF2E4ACD322'E4'E4E4C2E4C2BEB%46BEFEB4B(4A42B24E4 *4F2"E 4 ACD322'E4, 4 2B 4 8BE 4 E 4  4 A 4 F)E 4 E 4 A 4 2B2( 4  4 33AE( 4 E4 *4ABF2E4ACD322'E4,%

6(44EB4A4A42'E4E4C23E4'E4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4E4C2BBE4E4 *433FEB 4  4 ABF2E 4 ACD322'E4, 4 A 4 E 4 E 4 ABCE 4 .% 4 /$9$ 4  4 C2E 4 4 ABF2E#4'43EBEB44CAACB)E4FE"E4 A4E4E4ABCE4/0;44C2E4C#%4 6E4A4C2BAE4'E4E43ABE4A4C2M4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4C2FFE4BCB4 E433FEB4FE"E44ABF2E4ACD322'E4EEB443BEE4'4A43"33FEB4 C2BB3 4 A 4 2B2 4 E 4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E 4 C2FFE 4 CAB32E 4 D'E 4 EEFEB4 AB22FE%4F(4DBEFEB(4CEB4E42"A"E424E4+AB4'E4ABCE4.%4/01$:44C2E44 ABF2E4EF2E4++3EFFEB4E4BEFE4*4F2"E4ACD322'E4,4EB4*4EBE4,4 3)E4E42C424E4C3E4E4CAB32E4D'E4AB22FE4 '(4ABEFEB(43EBEAB4 CEBBE43BAE4ABCAB348BE4'A+3E4E4E<4+AM2#(4FA4E43CE4CE4'4EB4EM4 644B2B4244A2464C2FFE4E43AB342"EA"E%4?E+(424E24'E4E4F2"E4 ACD322'E4E4C2BBE4E433FEB4FE"E44ABF2E4ACD322'E% $/%4>A4AFEBBE4CEBBE43'AECE4AEAB24E4EEB4A(424ABAB(44B3E4E4 FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4A4F2"E4ACD322'E424EC2E4+AB(4E4 E++EB(4'E4CE4FAB3A<4EB48BE4'A+3433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E%4VA4 E4+AB4)E4E42BE4CA4ABCE4.%4/$9$4B)E4E<E3FEB(4AF4E433FEB44 ABF2E4ACD322'E(424EEFEB4E4*4EBE4,4FA4A4E4*4ABE4BACE4E4 E<BECE4E4DFAB34,(4EB43CE4'E4*4A4AEAE4EB43BE4,4E4CE<C4EB44 EBACE( 4 2BE 4 *4E 4 3E2EFEB 4 E 4 DB2E 4 E 4 DFAB34,( 4 A 4 *4EAB24, 4 E 4 CEBBE4 E)E 4 *4AEC 4 E2EFEB 4 ABE4, 4 2 4 ABAB 4 E 4 +2FE 4 ACCEABE( 4 A4 E'EE4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4E4C2EB4A4EE%4.E4+AB4'E4 (4 CE4 +2FE 4 2B( 4 A 4 42C4 DAF2AB2 4 E4 BE<BE 4 %4 2B% 4134099L#(4 ECBEFEB 4 B3E 4 E 4 ABCE 4 $E 4 E 4 A 4 C2EB2 4 E23EE 4 2 4 A 4 2BECB2 4 4 ABF2E 4 ACD322'E 4 *4C2EB2 4 E 4 >ABE4,# 4  4 $7 4 DAE 4 $KK0 4 *+2+( 4 01 4 EB%4 $KK/(4%4$1K:L#4ACD)E4E4C2ACE424E4A2B4E<CAB+4E4CEBBE4C2EB24E(4E4 E++EB(424E43CE4'E4*4E4F2B433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E42EB4 'E 4 CE 4 E 4 2B 4 A 4 EEFEB 4 E 4 2"DEB 4 ' 4 2B 4 E 4 F2BACE4,( 4 FA 4 'E 4 *4B2B4 B3F2AE( 4 E 4 'E'E 4 ABE 4 ' 4 2B( 4 CAA"E 4 3CAE 4 E 4 A3 4 E 4 DFAB3 4 EB4 F2BAB4,%

(8)

$7% 46( 4 E 4 A2FE 4 EB 4 E 4 32AE 4 2 4 E 4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E 4 E 4 C2BBE 4 E4 33FEB4FE"E44ABF2E4ACD322'E4G42(4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4 "22'E42B4E433FEB4FE"E44ABF2E4ACD322'E4G42C4E4FAB3A<4 ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4E)EB44F2"E4ACD322'E%4@)42(4A8B344$74 EBEF"E4099:4E42AB4A4E<CE4E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E44 F2"E 4 ACD322'E( 4 A+ 4  4 2E 4 ABCE 4 .% 4 /01$: 4  4 C2E 4  4 ABF2E 4 BE4 '3CA34A4ABCE4.%4/$9$%

$L%4.EE 4EAB4 E4C2E4 'E4CE4CE4 3AB34 EBEA4 A4 C23'ECE% 4@A"2(4 ACE4'4EC24C2BEBE<4EFEE4BECD'EFEB42"E%48BE(4ACE4'4BE4 EC24AAAHB4FAB3EEFEB43CBA"E%484E++EB(4C2E4'AC4C2BEBE<4E4AHBA(4 CEB42"E4'E4CAB32E4D'E4+2FE4AB)FE(4EB4'E4C2FFE4BEE(4EE42B48BE4 AA"E4B3AEFEB424CEBE(44EB4E42"A"E4'423BAE4AE4D'4C2BEBE4 A 4 EFE 4  4 5BAB 4 E 4 3)EFEB 4 3FEBAE 4 E 4 AAB 4 E 4 3AB3 4 E 4 E4 C22AB244A42CFEBAB24CEB+'E4G4FA4'EE4EA4A42B24E4D242J44 FAB3A4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4AAAHBA4+AC)EFEB4B)4ABBACB+4 E<EFE4 AE4244CWE424'(4FE<4'E4CE4E4A42BBE4&DAEB(4A2BEAB4A4EE4 4CBE4E424A4A32BD'E#4I484AE4CA(4E4C3A24E4EE4AACE424E4 23BAE4 4 BEA 4 E4 EFAEA4E4 ABAE( 4 '44 EA4E+34'4 AB4 4 FAB3A4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4G44ABBA'EA4A43C24E4E+(4E42EAB(4A4 E<CEB2( 4 3AB3 4 E 4 A8B3 4  4 $7 4 EBEF"E 4 099: 4  4 E 4 +2EFEB 4 'E 4 CEBBE4 3C24A43B34E4G43AB34E4A8B34EA4EC2E(4E42BE4'E4AFBAB24EA4 BEE4E4A"2E42++CE4 C2+2F3FEB44ABCE4$7$4E4A4244$04A409994BEE4 'E4F2+3E4A4A42440943CEF"E4099L#%

A0+,57E.E1937E

$;%464BEFE4E4CE43E2EFEB(424EB4BEB34E4C2E4'E4A4'EB24E4A4AB34 E4C22AB24E4FAB3A<4ABE4EB4E4ABE4"22'E4A4F2"E4ACD322'E4 A8BE44E4FE4EECE4BE3BAB24E4BE<BE%4.EDE443"AB4E43AB4E4 3+BE443BEFE4'E42B(4AF4E4FE"E4'E4ACD322E4FEB4A4D2(4CE<4 '4E)EB44F2"E4ACD322'E424+AB4A4CE4B24E4FE"E4ECE4A4 ACD322E424EEFEB4E42"DEB4BA+2F34A4ACBB34DFAE4I4 $K%4>A4ABEABE4223E4EFEE43B'3E%48E4E2E4+2AFEBAEFEB443E(4 AEFEB43AE4A)4E4C2FFEBABE442B4E4ACD322E(4'E4E4F2"E4 ACD322'E43C)E4ACD322E%484E++EB(4A++FE4'E4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4E4 B2E 4 *4ECE4,( 4 *4F 4 A 4 D24, 4 2 4 *43C2EB4, 4 C2+2F3FEB 4 A< 4 2CA"E4 AFEFEB 4 EF2A3#( 4 CEB 4 3CEAEFEB 4 2BE 4 'AAB 4 F8FE 4 BEEB2 4 E4 ACD322E(44E<BAB%4.E4FE"E4ECE4A4ACD322E4E433A(4EB4E42"DEB4 BA+2F34A4ACBB34DFAE4E4ABCE(4AAEB4+AEFEB4DAFA4CE348BE424 3D 4 FE"E 4 A 4 E 4 A3( 4  4 AAEB( 4 E 4 3B 4 E4 E 4 E+2EFEB( 4 C2E34 E4 ABE4F2")E(4E4CE4E4'4EAEB4EB342A'EFEB4AB22FE443A44 BEA% 4 .A8B3 4  4 $7 4 EBEF"E 4 099:( 4 C2FFE 4 EEF"E 4  4 2B 4 E 4 ACD322E(4 E3BE4 E 43+BE4 3E4 B)4 *42F3EE4,4 24 EEE4 ADECB+ 4EF2A3 4A4 ?24@EACDA4A4A4BD)E424@EACDA4099;(4$424$1#4'E4CE4'4AAAHB44ACD322E(4 CE4EB4E4F24'E4E4A3%4.ACD322E4E2E(4A4BE(4E4C2BFE44DBCE( 4

(9)

'E 4 EAB 4 A< 4 FE"E 4 ' 4 3AE 4 E 4 F2"B3 4 *4ABEE4,( 4  4 E 4 +AB 4 'E4 3BA"4A43B34E4CD2E4 24E43+E<244A4*43B34ACD322'E4,(4%4?E2(4 &DA2@EE<4EB4@EACDA409$$#% F4C2FE(4A4CE4C2B2(4C2F"E4E4FBE4E4A4CBE4A44D3BE44'A+E4 43)EFEB43FEBAE4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4244E<B8FE42234E4*42"DEB4,(4 3CDAB24E4BEA4E<BAB4A4CA2BBAE4E4C2BBE4DAFA4'E42B244BEA4 F2"3E4A4ACD322E(4BAB4EB44"E4'242AB4E4'E44EB4FE"E(4CE4EB 4 A 4 *4A 4 ABE4, 4 ACD322E 4 E 4 E 4 3C2E 4 A 4 FE"E# 4 FA 4 *4A 4 C3AB24,4 ACD322E4E4+AB4FE"E#%4

09%4124E2(4242BE4AB(4'E43E4F8FE4'E4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4E4 8BE4BCB44BEA4A4E'E44E4B2E4BAB4E4E3EBAB24AACD2'E4E4 ACD322E4'4E4ACE4A4A4BAB24E4AB'AE4 %(4"E4T(4CDA4$KK1#%4 !424EF"E4+FEB443ABE4E4C23E4'E4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4E4EB4 A 4 A 4 A 4 ABE 4 F8FE( 4 FA 4  4 +AB 4 E 4 'A+CAB2 4 E 4 CE 4 E 4 ABB"3E 4 6 4 A4 ACD322E4EB(4E4EE4E2B(4A4E4DE4644E42B24F2"3E44BEA% 24E43F2BE(4242224E4EE4E4AB4F3BD222'E4E42E4'E4E4 F2"E4ACD322'E4E<BE4A4E42B%4.A4++CB342A4A48BE4A3DE3E4 244AE4++3EB424AB2443BA4E4AB'E4EB4+A24E++2B4E4BAE4E44 C2ECBEFEB42"E4A43AB34E4BEFE4D'E% 0$%4124E24242B4E43AB4E42"E4C2BAB4AB(4'E4E4ACD322E4E4 EE2B4A4 C+%4?2+4EB4A%4099K4G4&AE4099K4G 4@EF2E4EB4A%4099K4G4 9E+EX4EB4 ?AD4099;4G4F%#42

$% .E4BACE4FAB3EE4E42C3B34DFAE4E<FEB424A4+2FE4E4BCBE(4 AB3+ACB 4 EB 4 3C2+ACB% 46( 4 2B 4 2BE 4 +2FAB2 4 ACD322'E 4 2 4 E4 +AFEB 4 E 4 2BEE( 4 E 4 A 4 E4 F 4 2 4 E 4 "+ACE( 4 "E 4 T 4 G 4 FA 4 A4 E 4 3FEB4 *4D'43CEFFEB(4E43FEB43BAEB4'A+34E4EF"A4CA424 E4AAB4A4E4C2FEE%43Y44F43BE4E4CE4C2CDE4EEE42EB44 4E4AB'E42CAE4'E4E4BCBE4EB4E4ABE+ACB4F4A4D24,(4?2+4EB4 A%4099K4247/#%4?E+(4B2B(4A4E4BAB+CAB24ABD2'E(4EB4ACD322'EFEB4 +AB4G4ABAB(4B2B4EB4CEB"E48BE43E34A4ACD322E%

0% >A 4  4 EC2E 4 'E 4 CDA'E 4 BACE 4 FAB3EE( 4 CEB 4 E 4 AB)FE 4 'E 4 CE 4 BACE4 +2FEB 4 ' 4 EB 4 ACD322'EFEB 4 +AB 4 2 4 +2FAB2 4 ACD322'E 4 E4 B2E424EEFEB4A4E4BACE4E43EAFFEB4E4E4E4ABE(4 FA4A4A4B34'E4CE4BACE(4C2FE4E4EAB24E4E4A4A2B4A<4 ABE(4C2BBEB%

R2CE4EB4A24E4EC2AHBE4'E4A4BCB2464'4BAEE4E42B4E4ACD322E464 EBE 4 E 4 33FEB 4  4 ABF2E 4 ACD322'E( 4  4 CCB3( 4 EB 4 E 4 BEA( 4 E 4 ABE( 4 E4 C2AC4424E433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E4E4E4B2EB4A(442EFEB4 AE(4A4E4BEA4G442B4E4BEA%4124224E4A44'E4CE4EB4E4ABE4 'E 4 E 4 BEA 4 F8FE( 4  4 A 4 2 4 *43AE4, 4 ABD2'E( 4 ' 4 EB4 ACD322'EFEB4+AB%4&EB4*4EACE4FAB3E4A4E'E4E4BACE42"EA"E4E4

(10)

2C3B3 4 DFAE 4 E 4 2B 4 C2E3E4, 4 2AB 4 8BE 4 2FF3 4 *4BEA 4 ACD322'E4,4 ?2+4EB4A%4099K4241;#%

00%4!4EB(4A4C23'EB(43EB4'E4E4DBE464A4E4AE(4CEBE4CE<4'4+2B4 E42B4 E43ABE(4AFBAB2(4E4DE#4EB4CE<4'4E4C2FFEBEB4 A42CBE#464 E422B4A(42BEF4EC2E(4EBE442E4CE4'4EB4EE4E43BA"E42"DEB4 3BE 4 E 4 ACD322E 4 2 4  4 E 4 EEB 4 32FA 4 E 4 AE 4  4 EE 4 E 4 BEFE4 D'E4E4BEA4ACD322'E4F8FE(4AE4E4E4EBE%46BEFEB4B(44 E4+AB4*424,4B34C2FE<E4E4CE4'42B(4D'43EB(4+AFEB3%

?E4T(44EB4DAFA4A34E4CDAE424EA44E4CD2E%49E4E4ABBEBE4FE< 4 'E 4 E 4 CBE 4 E 4 +ACB2 4 E 4 EBCB2( 4 3AAB2 4 2 4 3B32AB2 4 4 *4BEA4C2BEAB4E4EBE4ACD322'E4,%484E++EB(4E4B2AB4CEBBE4+ACB24 A42BE42B( 4A4244$/ 4DEB4$K;94EAAA44BACEE4E4EBE4G4FA4CEBBE4 BEBABE 4 2)E 4 3CD2A42 4 +ACB2 4+B 4 F3E 4 A 4 A 4 2 4 4 00 4 DEB 4 $KK0(4 3B2BE4A4CEE4414A2TB4$KK/(44E42EA43CAB3E4A4CEE44$/4DEB4099;%4 ! 4 +AB 4 E4 AE 4 BE3BE 4 CEBBE 4 E 4 F2EFEB3E 4 C2FFE 4 E 4 E 4 E 4 22B24 BEACE 4 G 4 EE 4 EB 4 EEFEB 4 A 4 FA'E 4 E 4 2+2E 4 C2F3DE2 4 2 4 E 4 BEA4 ACD322'E4EBE4"E44CE<(42F"E<(4'E4A4+E44EBE4AEE%

01%4S24E4A4B2FE4A424A4++CB343E4A4Z4E4DBE(44'E4A4E 4 2B 4 F8FE% 4 R2CE 4 EB 4 E 4 E++EB 4 AFEBBE 4 'E 4 E 4 BEA 4 ACD322'E 4 E 4 'A+E4 A3FEB44E4A4D'E%4*4SE4E4BEA42EB4E4FFE"E4A4ABE(4CEB4E4 3ECE 4 'E 4 AEE 4 ABCE 4 /$; 4 3 4 C2E 4 C44, 4 ."CDA"E 4 099K 4 2 4 0K# 4 2 4 2E(4 322'E424ACD322'E(4E4A4"BACE4'4C2BEEB4F2BE4E%4F4EB4BEB34 AD2BE 4 'E 4 CEBBE 4 'A+CAB2 4 F2E 4 F8FE42 4 A3DEE 4 E 4 BEA 4 ACD322'E4 C2FFE 4 FFE"E( 4 BCB 4 'E 4 CDA'E 4 EBE 4  4 BEA 4 C2FFE 4 FE"E( 4 EBCE 4 A4 FEFEB4EC2AHBE4'E4D2FFE4EB44AEB4C3ABE4E4A4"BACE44BEA4A4 F8FE4BBE4'E4E4ABE433FEB4E4A4"2D)E4I4

>A44E4++B4A4E4A24'A+E4E4BEA4ACD322'E4G44C2EB4A4E4 AFE 4 B2BE 4 E 4 C23'ECE 4  4 E 4 A 4 D'E% 4 8 4 E++EB( 4 AFEBBE 4 E 4 BEA4 ACD322'E 4 F'E 4 3CEAEFEB 4 ACCEBE( 4 A 4 E 4 F8FE 4 F2EFEB(4 A3ABEFEB4D'E4E4CD2E4'4A4B2EB4C223E%42BE4E4+)CDE(424 AFA<( 4 +AFEB 4 E 4 2BEE 4 2 4 BEE 4 CBAE 4 2 4 B2 4 ABCEB 4 E 4 A 4 "BACE 4 4 BEA(4E4CE4E4'42B4E4E4AB342E424EE4E42B24E4 FFE"E% 4 5EFFEB( 4  4 2B 4 A 4 A 4 FAB3EEFEB4G 4 FA 4 A"2"3 4 A 4 E4 BEA(442B434D'EFEB424E42B4E42B44'E4FFE"E(4E42BE4'E4E4 F2"E4ACD322'E4A4A4E<BECE4D'E4BAB4'4ABCE44BEA%484CEA(4 E42B4BACB4FE<4A43AB3424B2B4C2FFE44E4BAAB4'E4ABEEFEB4A43AB344 F 4  4 E 4 AAB 4 'E 4  4 E 4 E 4 EE 4 ' 4 E 4 C2BBE( 4  4 E 4 BAA4 'FA+ABEFEB4A43AB344BEA4ACD322'E4BAB4'43EBEA44E4A4'4 44E4EBE4'4A4ABCEB% .E++2B4E4*424,4E4BEA4ACD322'E4E4EAB44EBE4A4EE4242E4EB4 3D(4E4DBE4E4BE2EB4A44E4+AB4E4A244CDA'E42E424CDA'E4A 4 E43FEB4C2234A4BEA4EB4FE"E424FFE"E4G44C2M2EB4A4EE4'E4 CE4CD2E(4ACE4'EE4ABCEB44BEA(4E3EBEB4E42B24E4FFE"E%4 K

(11)

2'24A24E4A422E4CEB4E<ECCE4*4FF2"AB24,424B24E433FEB4 4ABF2E4ACD322'E4'E4E4BEA4C2EE4I4&E4EAB4EE4ACBE4E4CE4'*44 A4A4FFE"E4'E43E4'24E4A4,4 ?A"340997424$$/#%484E++EB(4A<4AB2E4E4 3E(4*4B242)E4248BE423AB2E4,4 ."CDA"E4099K42400#(44FFE"E4'4 EB+EAB 4  4 A 4 EE 4 +<B3 4 2 4  4 2 4 F2"E 4 3ACEFEB( 4 *4E 4 2) 4 E4 C2AACE4 DFAE(4A4 E42FAE4 E4+FEB4 EBB4 C2FFE4E4 +FEB4 A(4A4F 4D2FFE4+ACE44E43B3424FF2"B34EB4'E42(4E4E4E 4 EB4DFA4'4A4"E24E4BA"B34,4 ?A"340997424$$1#(4E4CE4E4'E4FFE"E4 3BE4F24E4A4*4ABE4E4CD2E4,464'E4*4ABDEB'E4ABE4E4CD2E4EB4 3Y44A4F2"B34,4 +#464'E44DEB42"EABE% 0:%4.E4+AB4'E4E42B4E4ACD322E4AE4"EAC2448BE4E4A4FE44BEA4 ACD322'E4EAB4ACDEE4E4C2ACE42

$% EF)EFEB( 4 A 4 2B2 4 E 4 BEA 4 ACD322'E 4 3F2BE 4 CTFEB 4 E4 ++ACE 4 E 4 2BE 4 2BECB2 4 3AE% 4 8 4 E++EB( 4 CDAC 4 C2EA 4 'E 4 A4 3AAB2 4 E 4 2B2 4 E 4 FFE"E 4 2BE 4 ABBEBE 4  4 FFE"E 4 A 4 24 EEF"E424E4A4F8FE4+AM24'E4CE4'4BACE44A++B444F4E43B32E4 A4BAB4E4'E'E4"'E4EC2EBE4E4EBE4'E4E4F4E4EBE(4CE4'4 AACDE4A4BEA4E4EBE4A"HFE4A4BAB4CE4EBE4 A4C2BAE(4E4E4 E42EB424E4E4AE4BACB#4'E4E4BEA4A4A4B2BAB3%4?E+(4E42B4 3A(42""34A4E4EBE(42"E4A4BAB+CAB24EB(4E4CE4+AB(4+AB4E4ABE44 A4F2%

0% @E<)FEFEB( 4 A 4 2B2 4 E 4 BEA 4 ACD322'E 4 E 4 CA'E 4 B2BE4 ++3ECAB24E4EBE4ACD322'E4F2"E4EB4E4EBE4ACD322'E4 FF2"E4'4E4+2EAB44E4ABE4B)'E4 E4E4C2BAE(4%42B%424 9AF"EB4$KK7424$:/4EB4%4G4AD2B4099L424$L$4EB4%#%4.E<ECCE4"B4E4BCB24 EBE4E4EBE4 '42AB4E43"AB4AE4EBE4DBE44BAE4244 AB4E4'E4E34E42CAB244F2BE4E4BEEE(43C2EBE424E4 +2E(42BEE48BE4C233E4244C2FFE4E42B24E4FFE"E4'E4 C2BBE4A4F2A['E(4FA4C2FFE44FE"E44AB4EB)E4I#4A44E48BE%4 F4EAB432FA4C23E4'433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E4EBE4 FFE"E4BAB4'4EB4C2234A4BEA4EB4EEB4FE"E4)424'4E4 B2E43A3(4E4A4F8FE4FA)E4'E4*4E4FEA4A4ABE4E4FE"E4'E4A4E4 +AB4E4E<BACB24EB4C2EE4A4ABE4FFE"E4BAB4'4EB4AD3EB4A424,4 &A%(4E'%(4$/43C%4$;/L(4C256!+(4$;/K(4!(4177#% 1% Q2)FEFEB(4A42B24E4BEA4ACD322'E43CAE4244AE42EA4E4 D32F)E4A2AB2%4624'E424A++FE433AEFEB4'E4E423BAE4  4 BEA 4 EEB 4 23BAE 4 E 4 CD2E 4 '4 A4 B2EB 4 C223E 4 ) 4 24 'ACE 4 2B2 4 3ABE 4 3CAE 4 E 4 2E 4 ABEFEB#( 4  4 +AAB4 32FA 4 C23E 4 'E 4 CE 4 2B 4 E 4 CD2E 4 C223E 4 '( 4  4 +AB 4 E 4 CEBBE4 C22AB2( 4EEEB4 E4BEA( 42C4 A423B34E4 CE4 A'E4 CE4BEA4 AABEB%41242FFE4"E4T4C2CEB4'E4CEA4EEB44EE4AB4A4E4 3"AB44A4ABE442B4ACCE24EA344A4A4E<4)CE424CE42B(4WCE4 A'E4 *4B2B4 CE4 '4 B4 EB4 C22E4 4 A4 CD2E4, 4 AABEB4 A 4 23BAE(4 C2BBEB44ABB"B4E4A423B34 CE4'4F'E4E43+EE43E4'4A4

(12)

AAB4 A 4 E< 4 2B4 E4 23B34 4 E< 4 CD2E4 3E 4 E4 4 ABE(4 FA4 FEFEB4E<BE24E42"DEB4F8FE442B4E423B3(44+AB4'E4E4E4 CD2E(4E43BAB4A"2"3E4A4ABE(4A4A#4I4F4"E4C2BBEB44F2E4 AC'B24E4A423B34 CE4'4EEB442BE4'E4E423BAE4E4A4CD2E4 C22ABE4AC'EB442B4E423B344A4CD2E4C223E(4'4C2EE4 B2BE+2 4 2 4 AB3# 4 I 4 12 4 AEE2 4 FEFEB 4 'E 4 CEBBE 4 'EB2(4 E4AE4C2FE<B3(4A4A43BA"EFEB43B34BACD3E44CE4D24 *4E4FAB)E4E4 ACCE24EBE4EBE4,(4@2409994240$0#4EB4'E44E4C2FFEBABE442B4E4 ACD322E42B4AEFEB43A3E(4CEB4FEFEB4ACE4'E(4E3BAB4E4 24*42F3EE4,44EBE(44E43BAB4FAA"E4'E4CEC4A3ABE4 A4E4BEA4D'4E4EE4E4FE4C2F2ABE% 843AB3(424C2A24'E4E4DBE4EEB44EE4E4BEA4ACD322'E4 ACE4'4EBEB44A2E4E24E4CA244B324E4ABCE4L$744C2E4 C% 4 8 4 E++EB( 4 A 4 CAACB3B'E 4 F8FE 4  4 B32 4 EB 4 ' 4 EFEE 4 E 4 EBB34 BCBE44BEA4A4E'E44E4B2E4 ACB24E4CACDE424E+2464'43BAB4 2EEFEB 4  4 E 4 CB)E 4 E 4 A 4 3+B2 4  4 B32 4 6 4 F'E 4 E 4 2C 4 E4 3EE4AB22FE4E4A4CD2E4CACD3E424E+2E#(4CE4'(4A4BE(4E<'E4 2'2 4  4 C2BBE 4 E 4 3BA"E 4 E<CEB2 4 A 4 2B 4 ACCE2 4 E 4 +AB 4 'E4 ACB24E4EECAB24EFEE42EBE4A423BAE44B324E42E424E4CE4 E(4%4\EAB&ABA4EB49EEB4099;424/K#%4.E43FE44B3243242C44E4 2'E4B)4ABC)E4AAB24E4A4CD2E4A4A2B4A4BEA(4'4 A4A"2FEB4A42CAB2448BE43BEE44EEF"E44F2"E4ACD322'E%

:% SAB)FEFEB( 4 A 4 2B2 4 E 4 BEA 4 ACD322'E 4 EFEB 4 A3DEE 4 E4 FA)E43ABE4E4BAA4E4ACD322E%4&EC4E4*43C2E4,4A4E4F2"E4 ACD322'E(424A 4FE4A24'E4E4F2"E4ACD322'E4E<BE4A 4 5

'4 2 4  4 F2"E 4 E 4 2B2 4  4BEA 4 ACD322'E 4 '( 4  4 +AB 4 E 4 CEBBE4

F2"AB2( 4 EEEB 4 CE 4 'E 4 E 4 2B 4 AEE 4  4F2"E 4 ACD322'E% 4 .E4 F2"E4ACD322'E4C2BBE(4A4C23'EB(44"E4D'EFEB42EA4 4E4A4+AFEBAB244"E43E<BAB% &EB4ACBE4E4F2"AB24EB4DAFA4'E4E4+B4E4BE3BAB2424CEB4A44 ACBE4E422B34'E4ACD322E4ABB"E4E4+CAB244E42B244BEA4 EB43CE(4C23'EFFEB(4E4A4F2"E%484CEA(4*43Y44CDA'E4+2E4EB43Y44 E422B24+2C3FEB4+AE(4CA4B2B4ACBE4E43AEFEB4EB4E4AFBAB2(4 E43FAB24F+CABCE4,4 FE4099;424077#%4624'*43Y444B3E4 E 4 A 4 BEE( 4 B2B 4 +2BBE 4 A 4 3C2( 4 A 4 E 4 EB 4 8BE4, 4 +#( 4 E 4 F2"E4 ACD322'E 4 C2BBE 4 A"2 4 EB 4 AAB 4 B2B 4 E 4 2B 4 E 4 A 4 22B3 4 E4 ACD322E%4>A44EB4A(424ABAB(4"EFEB4C33424E4224C3ABE4E4 ACD322E4EB4C2B23(4E4AB(4A4A43AB34E4CE4'4E4B2E4F2"34 EB( 4 ABE 4 AB( 4 A 4 2"AB2 4 E 4 DB+E( 4 E2 4  4 C2 4 CEB+'E( 4 E4 BE3BAB2 4 EBEE% 4 8 4 3+BE( 4 B2B 4 AE 4  4 EE 4 'E 4 E 4 2B 4 EAB4 C2+FE4C2F"E4ACD322E4*4EB4EA"E4F3ABE4'(4A4E4ABEB4 BAA 4 E 4 3C2BCB2 4 EB 4 EC2BCB2 4 E 4 ACD322E( 4 BA+2FE 4 ACBE 4 E4 3BE424A24E4ACBE4E4EC2BE424E4 22#4DB2E4E4A4ABE4,4 ?2+40991424009#%

(13)

0/% 4 .E 4 +2B 4 *422 4 E<CAB+ 4 3E4, 4 6 4 2 4 EEE 4 E<E2 4 E 4 5%B%F% 4 SE4 SE4$K7:424$9(4CB34A4QEA4099K4247:$#464E4A42B24E4BEA4ACD322'E4 EAB42C4FEE44A4EC2AACE%4

24BAB24A4'2BE42AB(44EBE(4E4EECBE42M23E%46(4A4 E<EFE( 4 A 4 2B2 4 E 4 BEA 4 ACD322'E 4 3CAE 4 ++3EFFEB 4 A 4 'EB2 4 E4 A2AB24"'E4E433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E4 '4EB(4C2FFE4CDAC4 AB(4E4EECAB243CEBE4E4ACD322E424%4EC2E43CEFFEB47AE409$$424 $K1#%4RAEFEB(4EDE4EB4A4BAB4E4A2445BAB4EB4A2E4A4EFB34 E433FEB44ABF2E4ACD322'E464CE4CE4EB4AF4E4$K:$4 %4ABCE4 $$4E4A42440L4EBEF"E4$K:$(4EE4ABCE4.%4/1$$$44C2E44ABF2E#464'E 4 E43BEFE44EB4A2E4CE4ABF2E4A4E4F2"E%464CEB43A(4F2BAB4 A8B4E4A4E4&2E4]5BAB4E40:4A409$0 4 E'%4U41:7K/0(44AAHBE4A 47FF 5

.F524A++AE 4E4A42BBE4E4BD2E#46 4'4A++FE4'E(4243EE4E4CEBAE4

BAB2 4 *4BAB2E4, 4 "E 4 C2F3DE"E( 4 A 4 3C2 4 E 4 2FE 4 E 4 E 4 EBE 4 A4 23B34E4A4+ACE4EB4A423B344 ABF2E4 ACD322'E4FABE 4 54 E4 E3EBE 4 A 4 E 4 AB2 4 E 4 23B3 4 A 4 E 4 E 4 A 4 &2EB2 4 E23EE 4 E4 AEAE4E42B4E4D2FFE4EB4E4"EB34+2AFEBAE464A2BE4E43C24 B)4ABBEE%46BAB4E4'A4F2FEB4F8FE42J418&F4EB41!@9F!Q422EB4E4 *42B2 4 F2)E 4 3+AB 4 A 423B3 4 E 4 ]5BAB 4  4 E 4 "E 4 CBE 4 24 3C2EB4,4 A<4BEFE4E'EE(4EBE4ABE(4*4E4"E4CBE4243C2EB42B4 A423B34E4]5BAB(4243EE4'4E<BE4AC42B4E423B34AB3E4,#(4A4 C2C24F2E424B2BE4E4C2B242B432FA43E424ACE4E4AE4 3+2FE4E4A423B34ACD322'E%

7-3-7E11E4

?A"3(4=%R%40997%4*4@E4C22AB244ABBACDE44E3BEE4EFEE4EB4EEFEB424 3+E<244A4BCB24FE"E464FFE"E4EB44E4F3CAFE4A++ECBAB24,(4424 4!"F5&55!F55'$FF57"F54,85(4Q22E(45B24.3ABE4EB4 EE4E4EB34E4CECE42CAE4E4Q22E424$$$$1$% ?E2(4&%(4&DA2@EE<(4@%4EB4@EACDA(4?%409$$%4*4?2E4+2E4E4AAB4FEB4I4,(4 9F(4/L424:;7/% ?2+(4=%40991%4*4.A4ABE4E4F33BE4,(4-F5F(4$7L$7;4240$/007%

?2+( 4 =%( 4 6"EB@E2( 4 @%( 4 @EACDA( 4 ?%( 4 =22B( 4 R% 4 EB 4 1E=A"EB( 46% 4 099K(4

4F5( !"F5!!6F5F5FF(4A(46FA&2(41/04%

&AE(4>%4099K%48 F"5A6F"(4.2E1EX4^2N(492BEE(4099K(4:;94 %4

&D2'E( 4 7% 4 0990% 4 *4.3C2F)E 4 C2BE 4 E 4 "2F"E 4  4 +AFEBAB2 4 CEB+'E4,(4

1'F(4$4241L:;%

(14)

&D2'E(47%40991%4*4&E4EB4EC2F2B24E42"DEB424E4EDE<4E4ACD3232ADE4 64!B2CB24,(4-F5F%4$7L$7;424$11$%

@EFA(4R%4EB41EAEA(4@%4099$%4*4.BAB24E424+2E4E4A43DB2E44 32'E4A22FAE4,(47F5F554!!5'! F5$8F(4K;(4:4247K1L$/%

@EF2E( 4=%%(4 7A( 4R%(4 .ED_E++(46%4EB4 CDA(46%(4 099K% 4/F5 F5 ! F5 F 5

( !"F(4A(4.A4@3C2EBE(41)FE43%(41194%44 @EACDA( 4 ?% 4 099;% 4CF 5  5 $ 5  5 FF 5 F 5 !F 5 "' F 5 F 5  !"F5F5F(4BD)E4ACD322E4 %424=%4?2+#(4EB34A4$(4042%(4 11;4% @EC2A(4%4099/%46,F&5F5F5F(4A(47AFA(47014% @EC2A( 4 % 4 09$$% 4.(!"F 5 F 5 F 5 9 5 .( '"F 5 F 5  5 F 5 F 5  5 F(4 BEAE(45B24SAE(4$$94% @2( 4 5% 4 0999% 4.F 5 !F 5 F 5 (F 5 9 5 -!F 5 ' 5 F 5  !F 5 F 5  5 F6F5F56F(4BD)E4E42B434 %4247%472"EA<#(4EB341ACA40(4/L04 % 7AEA(4=%4EB47AA(4&%4099/%4*4.A42BBE4E4A4?AFE4?2E4 S2(46E4E4 OABE2ECE#424ABD)E4CD22BABAD'E4EB43'ECE4CBEE4A)4E4+2E4 3CEBE 4 $K;;$KKL#4,( 44 2 4 1% 4 >2E( 4 >%O% 4 >2CE( 4 =%.% 4 >2E( 4.F 5 'FF 5

'F'FF5F5E'F 5:F5F%5;;,;<5F'FF5;==>?(4=2D4A48CA4

OEE4.B424L1;/43ABCE42"E4424DBB2``DAD%ACDE2EBE%+4%

7AE( 4 =% 4 09$$% 48 !"F% 5 FF 5 F+ 5 EFF 5 6F 58F 5 .F @F$$( 46E A(46CBE44`48ACE(401L4% O2AOE"( 4 >%% 4 EB 4BE( 4 =%@% 4 %# 4 099/% 48)% 5 F6FF 5 F 5 !!(4 A(48ACE(4$K$4% ."CDA"E(49%4099K%4*4?E4,(44247!'FF56(4A(4@A2E(4:74% >N2NA( 4 =%&% 4 %# 4 0990% 4/!"F 5 F 5  5 '! F 5 A 5 ! F% 5 F F% 5 ''(4A(473234EB4EE4EBAE4E4EA(4$/$K4%

13( 4 B% 4 099L% 4 *4@FE2 4 D'E 4  4 F2"E 4 ACD322'E4,( 44 2 467&&R 6&6(46!F!5F5F5'F(46<E2ECE(4RAE424$0$;% FE(4.%4099;%4.F5F5BF55F'+54!F5F5 !"F(4A(4.E4E(419$4 % A2B(4=%&%4$KK;%4.5F655F5 !"F5957''55FF5F 5 ( FF5F55'F(4A( 4>B)E4E4A4CBE4EB4E4A4C2FFCAB2(404 2%(40004% $1

(15)

SE( 4 5%B%F% 4 $K7:% 43 5  5 ." 5 6 5 $ 5 0FC+ 5 D 5 .",6 '  5 E5(4 &AF"E(4>A%(4OAA4EBA4E(40)FE4E%4EE(4$;:4%4

9E+EX(4&%4EB4?AD4%4099;42 48 F"55959 FF%54F 556F(4.2E(4 QDAFE4A4O2(4/)FE43%(47/74%4

9AF"EB(4&%4$KK7%4.F55F5( !"F5$8F(4A(4CA(40//4%

AD2B(4&%4099L%4.F55$85F5( !"F(4A(4&DA(40)FE43%(41/04%

CDA(46%4$KK1% 4.5EF55'!+58)5"F5F5( !"F(4A(45B24 &A3(41;:4% QD3"AB(4%409$9%48 !"F5F6FFF5F553F(4A(4.A4@3C2EBE(4$LL4 % QEA(47%4099K%4*4&B'E4E4F3BA2B24+2CB2EE%4.A42B24 B2#4+2CB2EE4 E42B24+2CB2EE4,(47F6F5$8F5F55$4247:$7/0%4 \EAB&ABA(4R%4EB49EEB(4Q%4099;%4.F5F(4A(4%%R%(41)FE43%(4L/K4% $:

Références

Documents relatifs

droit 45 (2001) Une autre approche consiste à cantonner la science juridique à l’étude des aspects structurels et formels du droit. C’est la construction proposée par Bobbio

Parmi tous les modes d'expression et de communication, on peut en distinguer quatre, les plus répandus car ils sont l'expression la plus directe de la

Après Mardi Gras, la bande dessinée a été progressive- ment délaissée, au profit du texte libre, et des lettres individuelles aux correspondants. On recherche

« droit sans l’État » 3 et donc d’un droit sans le territoire. Ainsi, ce « concept-clé ayant présidé la construction du droit moderne […], non seulement

Pour tenter de remédier à cet écueil formaliste et caractéristique du droit public français, se développe un courant doctrinal plus dynamique qui fonde l’effectivité

A clear periodic variability was observed in the altitude structure during the entire data-set primarily within 8øN-22øN latitude and within the altitude region of the layer,

Photo: Agnè ès Lorin s Lorin - - juillet 2006 juillet 2006.. Notions juridiques de base Notions juridiques de