Resource egalitarianism with a dash of efficiency
31
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) Département de sciences économiques Université de Montréal Faculté des arts et des sciences C.P. 6128, succursale Centre-Ville Montréal (Québec) H3C 3J7 Canada http://www.sceco.umontreal.ca SCECO-information@UMontreal.CA Téléphone : (514) 343-6539 Télécopieur : (514) 343-7221. Ce cahier a également été publié par le Centre interuniversitaire de recherche en économie quantitative (CIREQ) sous le numéro 03-2007. This working paper was also published by the Center for Interuniversity Research in Quantitative Economics (CIREQ), under number 03-2007.. ISSN 0709-9231.
(3) &1?;A>/1 13-85@->5-:5?9 C5@4 - 0-?4 ;2 1M/51:/E ,B1? '<>A9;:@ !-E . ,-+ +1 ?@A0E @41 <>;.819 ;2 01G:5:3 5:1=A-85@E-B1>?1 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3? ;B1> @41 ?<-/1 ;2 -88;/-@5;:? 5: - 9A8@5/;99;05@E 1:B5>;:91:@ C41>1 5:05B50A-8? 05N1> ;:8E 5: @415> <>121>1:/1? +1 2;>9A8-@1 :;@5;:? ;2 13-85@->5-:5?9 .-?10 ;: @41 -D5;9 @4-@ -:E 0;9 5:-:/1 .1@C11: @41 /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? ;2 @C; 5:05B50A-8? ?4;A80 .1 >10A/10 (45? (&#'' / +,#(' >1=A5>191:@ 5? /;9<-@5.81 C5@4
(4) (', ',., - C1-7 B1>?5;: ;2 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 ?-E5:3 @4-@ -: -88;/-@5;: 5? .1@@1> @4-: C41:1B1> 1B1>E.;0E G:0? @4-@ 1B1>E;:1I? .A:081 -@ 5? .1@@1> @4-: -@ +1 501:@52E @C; 2-95851? ;2 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3? ?-@5?2E5:3 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: -:0 ;:?1:?A? +1 -8?; 05?/A?? C1-71> 2;>9? ;2 13-85@->5-:5?9 .-?10 ;: :1C 01G:5@5;: ;2 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1
(5) %,,#4 -#(' 20(+ , 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 5:1=A-85@E 81D595: ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1. . '-+( . -"('. (45? <-<1> 5? -: -@@19<@ @; 01G:1 :;@5;:? ;2 13-85@->5-:5?9 @4-@ C;A80 .1 -01=A-@1 2;> 3A505:3 /;881/@5B1 /4;5/1? 5: - 9A8@5/;99;05@E /;:@1D@ 3-85@->5-:5?9 -? A:01>?@;;0 41>1 5? @41 B51C @4-@ -: A:1=A-8 @>1-@91:@ ;2 5:05B50A-8? 5? ?;/5-88E 01?5>-.81 ;:8E 52 5@ . O<->@191:@ 01 '/51:/1? /;:;95=A1? -:0 &% ):5B1>?5@O 01 !;:@>O-8 $ ?A//A>?-81. 1:@>1B5881 !;:@>O-8 % -:-0-
(6) @4-:7 !-:5=A1@ !;A85: -:0 + (4;9?;: 2;> /;991:@? -:0 05?/A??5;:? (45? >1?1->/4 C-? ?A<<;>@10 .E @41 ';/5-8 '/51:/1? -:0 A9-:5@51? &1?1->/4 ;A:/58 ;2 -:-0-.
(7) 5? 6A?@5G10 .E ?;91 >181B-:@ 05N1>1:/1 .1@C11: @419 =A-8 @>1-@91:@ ?4;A80 <>1B-58 .E 012-A8@ (41 ?<1/5G/ <>;.819 C1 -:-8EF1 5? @4-@ ;2 -88;/-@5:3 /;99;05@51? -9;:3 5:05B50A-8? C5@4 :; <>;<1>@E >534@? ;.61/@5B18E 1=A-8 :110? .A@ <;??5.8E 05N1>1:@ <>121>1:/1? #A> 3;-8 5? :;@ 6A?@ @; ?181/@ - 2-5>1?@ -88;/-@5;: .A@ @; /;:?@>A/@ - 2A88 ;>01>5:3 ;2 -88 /;:/15B-.81 -88;/-@5;:? 5:/8A05:3 @4;?1 @4-@ ->1 :;@ 1M/51:@ ;> 1B1: 21-?5.81 (45? 5? 1??1:@5-8 5: ;>01> @; 9-71 /;:?5?@1:@ ?;/5-8 /4;5/1? 5: -: 1:B5>;:91:@ C41>1 /;:?@>-5:@? ->1 /4-:35:3 (41 5??A1 5? @; 501:@52E C45/4 /;:?A9<@5;: 5:1=A-85@51? ->1 6A?@5G10 .E 05N1>1:/1? 5: <>121>1:/1? +1 C-:@ ;A> ?;/5-8 /4;5/1 ;>01>5:3 @; .1 -B1>?1 @; -88 A:6A?@5G10 5:1=A-85@51? 5: /;:?A9<@5;:. . '" "& ',"('% %"-+"' +"- +". 3-85@->5-:5?9 5? C188 A:01>?@;;0 5: @41 .1:/49->7 /-?1 ;2 - ?5:381 /;99;05@E ?-E C1-8@4 '5:/1 -88 <>121>1:/1? /;5:/501 L 9;>1 5? .1@@1> L 5:05B50A-8? ->1 2A88E 501:@5/-8 -:0 :; 5:1=A-8 5@E 5? 6A?@5G10 =A-8 05B5?5;: 5? @41>12;>1 @41 .1?@ -88;/-@5;: !;>1;B1> 5@ 5? 01?5>-.81 @; >1 0A/1 -:E 1D5?@5:3 5:1=A-85@E (C; 2;>9-8 5:@1><>1@-@5;:? ;2 @45? 501- ->1 ;N1>10 5: @41 85@1>- @A>1 : - ?;/51@E ;2 5:05B50A-8? /;:?501> - C1-8@4 -88;/-@5;: " " " " C41>1 ?-E 5:05B50A-8 5? ?@>5/@8E <;;>1> @4-: " " (41 -+', + )+#' #)% $53;A -8@;: ?@-@1? @4-@ -:E @>-:?21> ;2 C1-8@4 2>;9 @; C45/4 0;1? :;@ 9-71 <;;>1> @4-: L - ?;/-8810 $53;A-8@;: @>-:?21> L 5? ?;/5-88E 01?5>-.81 " " " " 5? .1@@1> @4-: C41:1B1> " " . " . " (41 #' *.%#-2/ +,#(' )+#' #)% . -0-<@10 2>;9 -99;:0 ?-E? @4-@ >10A/5:3 @41 C1-8@4 05N1>1:/1 .1@C11: -:0 5? 01?5>-.81 1B1: 52 @45? 5:B;8B1? 01?@>;E5:3 C1-8@4 # # " " 5? .1@@1> @4-: C41:1B1> " # # " (41?1 <>5:/5<81? ->1 @41 /;>:1>?@;:1? ;2 @41 @C; 2A:0-91:@-8 13-85@->5-: />5@1>5- 2;> >-:75:3 -88;/-@5;:? 5: @41 ?5:381/;99;05@E /-?1 (+ '3 (&#'' -:0 @41 % 1#&#' (+ + #'! : -88;/-@5;: ;>1:F0;95:-@1? -: -88;/-@5;: 52 2;> 1B1>E :A9.1> @41 <;;>1?@ 5:05B50A-8? -@ ->1 6;5:@8E -@ 81-?@ -? >5/4 -? @41 <;;>1?@ 5:05B50A-8? -@ >1?A8@ ;2 ->0E 5@@81C;;0 -:0 $P8E-
(8) ?@-@1? @4-@ ;>1:F0;95:-@1? 52 -:0 ;:8E. -99;:0 ?@-@1? @45? <>5:/5<81 C45/4 41 /-88? *.#-2 2;> A@585@E >-@41> @4-: C1-8@4 #A> -:-8E?5? 5: @45?. <-<1> 5? 1:@5>18E ;>05:-8 :; A@585@E 5:2;>9-@5;: 5? -B-58-.81.
(9) 52 /-: .1 ;.@-5:10 2>;9 .E - ?1=A1:/1 ;2 $53;A-8@;: @>-:?21>? -:0 <1>9A@-@5;:? ;2 5:05B50A-8 C1-8@4? (41 81D595: ;>01>5:3 C45/4 5? -: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 @41 ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1 >18-@5;: 0119? .1@@1> @4-: 52 2;> ?;91 :A9.1> 1-/4 ;2 @41 <;;>1?@ 5:05B50A-8? 4-? 501:@5/-8 C1-8@4 -@ -:0 C4581 @41 @4 <;;>1?@ 5? >5/41> -@ -99;:0 ?4;C10 @4-@ @45? 5? @41 ;:8E ;>01>5:3 ?-@5?2E5:3 @41 5:1=A-85@E-B1>?5;: <>5:/5<81 @41 ?@-:0->0 -:;:E95@E /;:05@5;: <1>9A@5:3 5:05B50A-8 C1-8@4? 81-0? @; -: 1=A-88E 3;;0 -88;/-@5;: -:0 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 5:/>1-?5:3 ;:1 5:05B50A-8I? C1-8@4 E5180? - .1@@1> -88; /-@5;: '11 0I?<>19;:@ 2;> - 01@-5810 05?/A??5;: (4A? @C; ?59<81 <>5:/5<81? 81-0 :-@A>-88E @; @C; 1D<85/5@ />5@1>5- 2;> >-:75:3 -88;/-@5;:? *1>E 59<;>@-:@8E .;@4 />5@1>5- ?-@5?2E @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 (45? <>5:/5<81 4;C1B1> 5? :;@ B1>E 019-:05:3 .1/-A?1 -88 5:05B50A-8? 4-B1 501:@5/-8 <>121>1:/1?. . .%-" "& ',"('% %"-+"' +"- +". (41 <5/@A>1 5? >-05/-88E 05N1>1:@ 5: - 9A8@5/;99;05@E /;:@1D@ G>?@ ?@>1-9 ;2 85@1>-@A>1 5:5@5-@10 .E ;89 53:;>1? <>121>1:/1? @ -59? -@ -:?C1>5:3 @41 =A1?@5;: C41: 5? -: -88;/-@5;: 9;>1 1=A-8 @4-: -:;@41> #:1 <;??5.585@E 5? @; 01/8->1 -: -88;/-@5;:. 9;>1 1=A-8 @4-: 52 /-: .1 >1-/410 2>;9 @4>;A34 - ?1=A1:/1 ;2 <1>9A@-@5;:? ;2 5:05B50A-8 /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? -:0 @>-:?21>? .1@C11: 5:05B50A-8? 1-/4 @>-:?21> 5:B;8B5:3 - ?5:381 /;99;05@E -:0 .15:3 - $53;A-8@;: @>-:?21> 2;> @41 -88;/-@5;: ;2 @4-@ /;99;05@E 81->8E 5? 9;>1 1=A-8 @4-: 5: @45? ?1:?1 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 @41 -88;/-@5;: ;2 1B1>E /;99;05@E -@ ;>1:F0;95:-@1? @41 /;>>1?<;:05:3 -88;/-@5;: -@ #@41> 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 :;@5;:? ;2 ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1 C1>1 ?@A0510 .E @75:?;: -:0 ;A>3A53:;: ;1 -:0 *1>0A//5 -:0 ;?41B;E ;9<81@1 >-:75:3? ;2 -88;/-@5;:? C1>1 <>;<;?10 .E (?A5 -:0 -60;? -:0 +1E9->7 '11 +1E9->7 2;> - ?A>B1E 88 @41?1 />5@1>5- >18E ;: ?;91 1D@1:?5;: ;2 @41 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 (; @41 .1?@ ;2 ;A> 7:;C81031 :15@41> -99;:0I? 5:1=A-85@E-B1>?5;: <>5:/5<81 :;> @41 81D595: ;>01>5:3 C1>1 31:1>-85F10. (45? 4;80? 52 -33>13-@1 C1-8@4 5? 501:@5/-8 -@ .;@4 -88;/-@5;:? (41 >1?A8@ 1D@1:0? 1-?58E @; ->.5@>->E. -88;/-@5;:? 31:1>-85F10 ;>1:F0;95:-@1? 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 /-: .1 ;.@-5:10 2>;9 @>;A34 - ?1=A1:/1 ;2 $53;A-8@;: @>-:?21>? <1>9A@-@5;:? ;2 5:05B50A-8 C1-8@4? -:0 5:05B50A-8 C1-8@4 5:/>1-?1? '11 '4;>>;/7? .
(10) @; @41 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 /;:@1D@ (41 />5@1>5- 01B18;<10 5: @45? 85@1>-@A>1 ->1 A?12A8 5: @41 -.?1:/1 ;2 5:2;>9-@5;: ;: <>121>1:/1? .A@ /-: 81-0 @; /;881/@5B1 /4;5/1? @4-@ ->1 A:-<<1-85:3 @; - C1885:2;>910 13-8 5@->5-: <8-::1> ;:?501> @C; 5:05B50A-8? C5@4 85:1-> <>121>1:/1? ;B1> -<<81? -:0 .-:-:-? ;:1 -<<81 5? C;>@4 @C; .-:-:-? @; 5:05B50A-8 @C; -<<81? ->1 C;>@4 ;:1 .-:-:- @; 5:05 B50A-8 //;>05:3 @; -88 @41 ?@-:0->0 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 5:1=A-85@E />5@1>5- @41 -88;/-@5;: C41>1 5:05B50A-8 /;:?A91? -<<81? -:0 .-:-:-? -:0 5:05B50A-8 /;:?A91? -<<81? -:0 .-:-:-? 5? 81?? 1=A-8 @4-: @41 -88;/-@5;: A@ $->1@;0;95:-@1? +41: <>121>1:/1? ->1 7:;C: @41 <>;<1> 3;-8 ;2 -: 13-85@->5-: <8-::1> 5? :;@ @; >10A/1 -88 5:1=A-85@51? .A@ ;:8E @4;?1 @4-@ ->1 :;@ 6A?@5G10 .E 05N1>1:/1? 5: <>12 1>1:/1? : @41 /A>>1:@ 1D-9<81 @41 05N1>1:/1? 5: /;:?A9<@5;: -@ ->1 1-?58E 6A?@5G-.81 9;>1 >1/1:@ ?@>1-9 ;2 85@1>-@A>1 >1B51C10 .E !-:5=A1@ ?117? @; 01G:1 5:1=A-85@E -B1>?1 >-:75:3? ;2 -88;/-@5;:? @4-@ A?1 5:2;>9-@5;: -.;A@ 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? (41 -< <>;-/4 /;:?5?@? ;2 /;9.5:5:3 C1-7 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 B1>?5;:? ;2 @41 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 C5@4 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 -: -88;/-@5;: <>121>>10 @; -:;@41> .E -88 5:05B50A-8? 5? ?;/5-88E <>121> -.81 @; 5@ : 1D-9<81 5? 81A>.-1EI? 0121:?1 ;2 @41 $-F:1> -:0 '/4915081> 13-85@->5-:1=A5B-81:@ ;>01>5:3 5B1: -: -33>13-@1 1:0;C91:@ ;2 >1?;A>/1? -:0 -: -88;/-@5;: /;9<A@1 2;> 1-/4 5:05B50A-8 @41 2>-/@5;: ;2 @41 -33>13-@1 1:0;C91:@ @4-@ 9-71? 459 1D-/@8E 5:05N1>1:@ @; @41 .A:081 41 >1/15B1? " : -88;/-@5;: 5? /;:?50 1>10 .1@@1> @4-: 52 0;95:-@1? -//;>05:3 @; @41 81D595: />5@1>5;: (41 A?1 ;2 @41 81D595: />5@1>5;: 59<851? - 8595@10 2;>9 ;2 5:1=A-85@E -B1>?5;: 52 @41 /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? ;2 5:05B50A-8? -:0 4-<<1: @; .1 <>;<;>@5;:-8 @; @41 -33>1 3-@1 1:0;C91:@ @41: -:E @>-:?21> >10A/5:3 @41 05N1>1:/1 .1@C11: @415> /;:?A9<@5;:? 5? 01?5>-.81 ,1@ C1 /;:@1:0 @4-@ />5@1>5- ?A/4 -? @41 $-F:1>'/4915081> ;>01>5:3 ->1 :;@ /;9 <81@18E 2-5@42A8 @; ;A> B51C ;2 13-85@->5-:5?9 @41E 9-E >1/;991:0 A:6A?@5G10 5:1=A-85@51? ;:?501> -3-5: ;A> @C; 5:05B50A-8? C5@4 85:1-> <>121>1:/1? ;B1> -<<81? -:0 .-:-:-? -:0. B1: 5: @41 -.?1:/1 ;2 <>1/5?1 5:2;>9-@5;: ;: <>121>1:/1? 5@ 5? :;@ ;.B5;A? @4-@ >10A/5:3 5:1=A-85@E 5?. -8C-E? 01?5>-.81 5? @41 -88;/-@5;: >1-88E .1@@1> @4-: -B1:I@ C1 >10A/10 @41 JC>;:3K 5:1=A-85@E.
(11).
(12) ?A<<;?1 @4-@ @41 -33>13-@1 1:0;C91:@ 5: ?;/51@E 5?
(13)
(14) +1 ->3A1 @4-@ @41 -88;/- @5;:
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
(16) .-:-:-? -:0 5:05B50A-8 /;:?A91? -<<81? -:0 .-:-:-? 5? .1@@1> @4-: -88;/-@5;:. .1/-A?1 @41 2;>91> 5? ;.@-5:10 2>;9 @41 8-@@1> .E @>-:?21>>5:3 -<<81? -:0 .-:-:-? 2>;9 @41 >5/41> 5:05B50A-8 @; @41 <;;>1> 2 @41 5:05B50A-8? ->1 ?18G?4 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 59<851? @4-@ ?;/51@E ?4;A80 .1 5:05N1>1:@ .1@C11: -88;/-@5;: -:0 -88;/-@5;: A@ @41 0;95:-:/1>10A/5:3 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 @188? A? @4-@ 5? .1@@1> @4-: C45/4 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 0119? 1=A5B-81:@ @; @41 -88;/-@5;: C1 ?@->@10 2>;9
(17) #:1 >1-/@5;: @; @41 5:/;9<-@5.585@E 6A?@ 01?/>5.10 5? @4-@ .A:081 0;95:-:/1 5? -2@1> -88 - 6A?@5G-.81 2;>9 ;2 5:1=A-85@E 5@ /-::;@ .1 -B;5010 52 C1 5:?5?@ ;: @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 8@1>:-@5B18E L -:0 @45? 5? @41 >;A@1 C1 @-71 L ;:1 9-E ->3A1 @4-@ @41 0;95:-:/1>10A/5:3 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 -:0 0;95:-:/1 -B1>?5;: ->1 2A:0-91:@-8 />5@1>5- ;2 2-5>:1?? (41 :-@A>-8 =A1?@5;: 5? @41: C41@41> @41E /-: .1 /;9.5:10 C5@4 C1-71> B1>?5;:? ;2 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 (41>1 ->1 >1-?;:? 2;> =A1?@5;:5:3 @41 B1>?5;: A?10 ?; 2-> (41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 -? A?10 5: ?;/5-8 /4;5/1 @41;>E ?@5<A8-@1? @4-@ - ?;/5-8 -8@1>:-@5B1 5? .1@@1> @4-: -:;@41> C41:1B1> -88 5:05B50A-8? <>121> @41 2;>91> @; @41 8-@@1> @C; -8@1>:-@5B1? .15:3 1=A-88E 3;;0 52 @41E 81-B1 -88 5:05B50A-8? 5:05N1>1:@ : @41 <->@5/A8-> /;:@1D@ ?@A0510 41>1 ?;/5-8 -8@1>:-@5B1? ->1 -88;/-@5;:? '@>5/@8E ?<1-75:3 @41>12;>1 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 >19-5:? ?581:@ -? 8;:3 -? 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? ;B1> /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? 4-B1 :;@ .11: 1D@1:010 @; <>121>1:/1? ;B1> -88;/-@5;:? #2 /;A>?1 @45? 5? @>-05@5;:-88E 0;:1 -? -.;B1 @4>;A34 @41 31:1>-88E 59<85/5@ -??A9<@5;: ;2 ?18G?4:1?? 1-/4 5:05B50A-8 >-:7? -88;/-@5;:? .E -<<8E5:3 41> <>121>1:/1 ;>01>5:3 @; @41 .A:081? ?41 >1/15B1? -@ @4;?1 -88;/-@5;:? A@ ?18G?4:1?? 5? <>;.819-@5/ 2;> -@ 81-?@ @C; >1-?;:? 5>?@ 5@ 5? :;@ - @1?@-.81 >1?@>5/ @5;: 5: - /8-??5/ 9->71@ 1D/4-:31 1:B5>;:91:@ 5:05B50A-8 /4;5/1? >1B1-8 <>121>1:/1? ;B1> /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? :;@ ;B1> -88;/-@5;:? 2 C1 C-:@ @; >-:7 -88;/-@5;:? ;: @41 .-?5? ;2 >1/;B1>-.81 5:2;>9-@5;: ;:8E C1 ?4;A80 >18E ;: 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? ;B1> /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? C5@4;A@ -??A95:3 @4-@ @41E 1D@1:0 @; -88;/-@5;:? 5: -:E <->@5/A8-> C-E ?18G?4 ;> ;@41> ;>9-88E @45? >1:01>? @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 5:-<<85/-.81 '1/;:0 @41>1 5? ?;91 9;?@8E 1D<1>591:@-8 1B501:/1 @4-@ 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? ;B1>
(18). (; 711< @41 ->3A91:@ ?59<81 C1 A?10 -: 1D-9<81 5:B;8B5:3 5:05N1>1:/1? (41 5:/;9<-@5.585@E <1>?5?@?. A:01> @41 B1>?5;: ;2 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 .-?10 ;: ?@>5/@ <>121>1:/1? ;:8E. .
(19) -88;/-@5;:? L 52 C188 01G:10 L ->1 <>;.-.8E :;@ ?18G?4 @ 81-?@ 5: ?;91 1:B5>;:91:@? 5:05B50A-8? ?119 @; /->1 -.;A@ 5:1=A-85@E ??A95:3 5:1=A-85@E-B1>?1 5:05B50A-8? C;A80 :;@ :1/1??->58E -B;50 @41 5:/;9<-@5.585@E .1@C11: @41 0;95:-:/1>10A/5:3 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 -:0 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 .A@ 5@ C;A80 01G:5@18E /4-:31 @41 59<85/-@5;:? ;2 @41 8-@@1> 5B1: @41?1 05M/A8@51? 5@ 9-E .1 C5?1 @; -0;<@ - 9;>1 :1A@>-8 B51C ;2 <>121>1:/1? ?18G?4:1?? ?4;A80 :;@ .1 >A810 ;A@ .A@ 5@ ?4;A80 :;@ .1 -??A910 15@41> '5:/1 C1 9A?@ >-:7 -88;/-@5;:? C5@4;A@ - 2A88 7:;C81031 ;2 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? ;B1> @419 C1 <>;<;?1 @; >1<8-/1 @41 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 C45/4 5? 5:-<<85/-.81 C5@4 - /;:05@5;: @4-@ >1@-5:? ?;91 ;2 5@? ?<5>5@ (45? $->1@;8571 /;:05@5;: C45/4 C1 /-88 (', ',., ?-E? @4-@ -: -88;/-@5;: 5? .1@@1> @4-: -: -88;/-@5;: C41:1B1> 1B1>E;:1 G:0? 1B1>E.;0EI? .A:081 -@ .1@@1> @4-: -@ <;??5.81 5:@1><>1@-@5;: 5? @41 2;88;C5:3 +4581 C1 53:;>1 @41 01@-58 ;2 <>121>1:/1? ;B1> -88;/-@5;:? C1 -??A91 @4-@ 5:05B50A-8? ->1 :;@ 9-81B;81:@ @;C->0? ;@41>? .A@ 4-B1 <;;> 5:2;>9-@5;: >13->05:3 @415> <>121>1:/1? (41E /;A80 .1 ?18G?4 .A@ ->1 <1>4-<? -8@>A5?@5/ 2 @41E ->1 @41: 5@ 5? 59<;>@-:@ @; /;:?501> 1B1>E;:1I? ;<5:5;: C41: 9;052E5:3 @41 .A:081 -88;/-@10 @; -:E 5:05B50A-8 1/-A?1 ;2 @415> 8595@10 5:2;>9-@5;: 5:05B50A-8? A?1 @415> ;C: <>121>1:/1? @; 1B-8A-@1 @41 /;:?A9<@5;: ;2 ;@41>? ;:?1:?A? ?-E? @4-@ C1 ?4;A80 >1/;991:0 -:E J?A>1 $->1@; 59<>;B191:@K :-918E -:E ?;/5-8 /4-:31 @4-@ 5? - $->1@; 59<>;B191:@ 2;> -88 <;??5.81 :;:9-81B;81:@ .A@ <;;>8E 5:2;>910 1D@1:?5;:? ;2 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? ? 5@ @A>:? ;A@ @41 /;:?1:?A? -D5;9 5? /;9<-@5.81 C5@4 .;@4 @41 0;95:-:/1>10A/5:3 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 -:0 0;95:-:/1 -B1>?5;: - 0-?4 ;2 1M/51:/E /-: .1 -0010 @; >1?;A>/1 13-85@->5-:5?9 1@C11: @41 <>121>1:/12>11 -<<>;-/4 ;2 @41 5:1=A-85@E 91-?A>191:@ 85@1>- @A>1 -:0 @41 ?@-:0->0 $->1@5-: -<<>;-/4 ;2 @41 >1/1:@ 85@1>-@A>1 ;: 5:1=A-85@E-B1>?1 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3? @41>1 5? >;;9 2;> :1C 01G:5@5;:? ;2 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 13-85@->5-:5?9 #A> 9-5: >1?A8@? >18E ;: ;A> ?@>;:31> 05?@>5.A@5;:-8 -D5;9 0;95:-:/1 -B1>?5;: '<1/52 5/-88E C1 <>;<;?1 -:0 0121:0 @C; 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 31:1>-85F-@5;:? ;2 @41 /8-??5/ 81D595: ;>01>5:3 C45/4 ?-@5?2E 0;95:-:/1 -B1>?5;: -:0 /;:?1:?A? +1 -8?; ;N1> <->@5-8 >1?A8@? -.;A@ ;A> C1-71> 05?@>5.A@5;:-8 -D5;9 @41 0;95:-:/1>10A/5:3 @>-:?21> <>5:/5<81 -:0 .>51HE 05? /A?? ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3? ?-@5?2E5:3 @45? <>5:/5<81 -:0 @41 /;:?1:?A? -D5;9 .
(20) . ! &( % ' -! &"' (' "-"(',. (41>1 5? - GD10 G:5@1 ?1@ ;2 5:05B50A-8? -:0 - GD10 G:5@1 :A9.1> ;2 3;;0? (41 /;99;05@E ?<-/1 5? -/4 5:05B50A-8
(21) 4-? - /;:@5:A;A? -:0 ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ <>121>1:/1 ;>01>5:3 ;B1> 5B1: @41 GD10 <>121>1:/1 <>;G81 C1 ?117 @; /;:?@>A/@ - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ;B1> @41 ?1@ ;2 /;:/15B-.81 -88;/-@5;:? (41 <>;<1>@51? ;2 - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 C1 ->1 /451HE /;:/1>:10 C5@4 ->1
(22) (', ',., -:0 (&#'' / +,#(' ;:?1:?A? 5? - $->1@5-: -D5;9 2 01:;@1? @41 ?@>5/@ <>121>1:/1 >18-@5;: -??;/5-@10 C5@4 -:0 @41 ?@>5/@ ?;/5-8 <>121>1:/1 -??;/5-@10 C5@4 @41 ?@-:0->0 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 5: 5@? C1-7 2;>9 ?@-@1? @4-@ # # " " C41:1B1> # " 2;> -88
(23) ? 1D<8-5:10 1->851> @45? 9-E :;@ .1 -<<>;<>5-@1 52 <>121>1:/1? ;B1> -88;/-@5;:? ->1 :;@ 7:;C: @; .1 ?18G?4 ;:?1:?A? 5? - C1-71> /;:05@5;: ?-E5:3 @4-@ -: -88;/-@5;: 5? .1@@1> @4-: -:;@41> 52 -88 5:05B50A-8? G:0 @4-@ 1B1>E;:1 31@? - .1@@1> .A:081 5: @41 2;>91> @4-: 5: @41 8-@@1> (', ',., ;> -88 " " # #
(24) # " 2;> -88
(25) . # # " " ?8534@8E ?@>;:31> /;:05@5;: >1=A5>1? 5: -005@5;: @4-@ # # " " C41:1B1> # " 2;> -88
(26) +1 /-88 @45? B->5-:@ .%%
(27) (', ',., G>?@ 5:@1><>1@-@5;: ;2 ;:?1:?A? C-? ;N1>10 5: @41 5:@>;0A/@5;: ?;/51@E ?4;A80 ?A<<;>@ -:E /4-:31 C45/4 5? - $->1@; 59<>;B191:@ 2;> 1B1>E <;;>8E 5:2;>910 .A@ :;: 9-81B;81:@ 1D@1:?5;: ;2 <>121>1:/1? ?1/;:0 <;??5.81 5:@1><>1@-@5;: 2A:0-91:@-88E >1?;A>/5?@ 3;1? -? 2;88;C? ;99;05 @51? 4-B1 5:@>5:?5/ B-8A1 C45/4 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? >1H1/@ -<<>;D59-@18E 3;;0 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ?4;A80 A?1 @41?1 <>121>1:/1? @; 1?@59-@1 @41 J/;>>1/@K >18-@5B1 B-8A1 ;2 /;99;05@E .A:081? 2 -88 5:05B50A-8? 8571 - .A:081 .1@@1> @4-: -:;@41> @41: ?;/51@E ?4;A80 .1 /;:G 01:@ @4-@ @41 2;>91> 5? 5:0110 9;>1 B-8A-.81 @4-: @41 8-@@1> L 5@ 4-? :; >1-?;: C4-@?;1B1> @; ?A<<;>@ @41 ;<<;?5@1 B51C 2 1-/4 .A:081 /;9<;?5:3 -: -88;/-@5;: # # 5? 011910 9;>1 B-8A-.81 @4-: @41 /;>>1?<;:05:3 /;9<;:1:@ ;2 -:;@41> -88;/-@5;: " " @41: ?;/51@E ?4;A80 <>121> # # ;B1> " " .
(28) )?5:3 @41 :;@-@5;:
(29) 2;> B1/@;> 5:1=A-85@51? - 05>1/@ /;:?1=A1:/1 ;2 @41 -D5;9 5? @4-@ # # " " C41:1B1> #
(30) " 2;> -88
(31) 9;>1 2;> -88 5? -8C-E? .1@@1> 1B1: 52 >1?;A>/1? ->1 <1>4-<? 9A/4 9;>1 A:1=A-88E 05?@>5.A@10 (45? ?4;C? @4-@ ;:?1:?A? 0;1? 8595@ @41 ?/;<1 ;2 13-85@->5-:5?9 "1D@ C1 @A>: @; ;A> 9-5: 05?@>5.A@5;:-8 -D5;9 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: ?-E? @4-@ >10A/5:3 .A:081 0;95:-:/1 5? -8C-E? 01?5>-.81 (&"'' / +,"(' ;> -88 " " # #
(32) -:0 -88
(33) "
(34) # #
(35) " -:0 # " 2;> -88
(36) # # " " 1@ A? >1<1-@ @4-@ <>121>1:/1? ->1 @41 ;:8E ?;A>/1 ;2 41@1>;31:15@E 5: ;A> 9;018 :05 B50A-8? ->1 ;@41>C5?1 501:@5/-8 (41E /-::;@ .1 05?@5:3A5?410 -//;>05:3 @; /8-59? -? 5:05 B50A-8 1:0;C91:@? ->1 A:?<1/5G10 ;> :110? -? A@585@51? ->1 -.?1:@ : ?A/4 - ?59<85G10 /;:@1D@ C1 .1851B1 @4-@ ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: 5? - >-05/-8 .A@ 1@45/-88E /;>>1/@ /;>;88->E @; @41 B51C @4-@ .A:081 0;95:-:/1 5? A:6A?@5G10 C41: -88 <>121>1:/1? ->1 ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ @ 5? @41 <>;<1> 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 1D@1:?5;: ;2 -99;:0I? 5:1=A-85@E-B1>?5;: <>5:/5<81 (41 (&#'' . #'! +', + +#' #)% C45/4 >1?@>5/@? @41 -<<85/-@5;: ;2 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: @; @4;?1 /-?1? C41>1 :; >1?;A>/1? ->1 8;?@ C41: ?C5@/45:3 2>;9 " " @; # # C588 .1 05?/A??10 5: '1/@5;: . . (', ',.% %"-+"'",&. +1 01?/>5.1 - G>?@ /8-?? ;2 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3? C45/4 C1 ?;91@591? 6A?@ /-88 ;>01>5:3? 2;> .>1B5@E @4-@ ?-@5?2E @41 /;:05@5;:? 6A?@ 01G:10 &1/-88 @4-@ @41 <>;G81 ;2 5:05B50A-8 <>12 1>1:/1? 5? GD10. 1@ .1 - /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 ;B1> @41 /;99;05@E ?<-/1. C45/4 !+ , C5@4 5: @41 ?1:?1 @4-@ 2;> -:E @C; .A:081? " #
(37) # " 2;> -88
(38) # " (45? ;>01>5:3 5? :;@ - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5: @41 @1/4:5/-8 ?1:?1 L 5@ 0;1? :;@ >-:7 -88;/-@5;:? &-@41> 5@ 1D<>1??1? ?;/51@EI? 1B-8A-@5;: ;2 @41 >18-@5B1 B-8A1 ;2 /;99;05@E .A:081? (45? 1B-8A-@5;: 5? /;:?1:?A-8 5: @41 ?1:?1 @4-@ 5@ >1?<1/@? 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? C41:1B1> @41E 0; :;@ /;:H5/@ (41>1 5? - ?59<81 C-E @; /;:?@>A/@ ?A/4 -: ;>01>5:3 52. 1/-A?1 5? /;:@5:A;A? -:0 ->1 ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ 5@ 2;88;C? @4-@ 2;> -88 . 2;> -88 . .
(39) ! ! ->1 ->.5@>->E :A91>5/-8 >1<>1?1:@-@5;:? ;2 @41 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? - 2A:/@5;: " !" ! " ! " >1<>1?1:@? -: ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 52 5? ?@>5/@8E 5:/>1-?5:3 5: -88 5@? ->3A91:@? ;> -:E -88;/-@5;: " "
(40) 01:;@1 .E " " -:E -88;/-@5;: ;.@-5:10 .E >1->>-:35:3 @41 .A:081? " " 2>;9 C;>?@ @; .1?@ -//;>05:3 @; ?; @4-@ " " " . 3'"-"(' ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5? - (', ',.% 0%,#' ;>01>5:3 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 @41>1 5? - /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 ;: C45/4 -3>11? C5@4 ?A/4 @4-@ 2;> -88 -88;/-@5;:? " " # #
(41) # " # # " " +1 ?-E @4-@ 5? .-?10 ;: : C;>0? - /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 1B-8A-@1? -: -88;/-@5;: ;: @41 .-?5? ;2 5@? C;>?@ /;9<;:1:@ -//;>05:3 @; - /;:@5:A;A? <>121>1:/1 @4-@ -3>11? C5@4 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? +41: @41>1 ->1 9;>1 @4-: @C; 5:05B50A-8? :;@ 1B1>E /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 ?-@ 5?G1? ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: (45? 5? .1/-A?1 ?A/4 -: ;>01>5:3 :110 :;@ <-E -@@1:@5;: -@ -88 @; @41 /;9<;:1:@? ;2 -: -88;/-@5;: @4-@ ->1 :;@ 95:59-8 -//;>05:3 @; @41 <>121>1:/1 5@ 5? .-?10 ;: (41 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3? -B;50 @45? 05M/A8@E (41 % 1#&#' 1- ' ,#(' @; ;2 -: ;>01>5:3 ;: 5? @41 ;>01>5:3 ;: 01G:10 -? 2;88;C? # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 15@41> @41>1 1D5?@?
(42) ?A/4 @4-@ # " 2;> -88 -:0 # " 5: C45/4 /-?1 C1 C>5@1 # # " " ;> 18?1 # ". 2;> -88
(43) 5: C45/4 /-?1 C1 C>5@1 # # " " 3'"-"(' ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5? - (', ',.% % 1#&#' ;>01>5:3 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 @41>1 5? - /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 ?A/4 @4-@ 2;> -88 -88;/-@5;:? " " # #
(44) # # " " # # " " ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5? - ,#&)% /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 5@ 5? @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 ?;91 ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 @4-@ 5? 81->8E 1B1>E /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 5? - /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 +4581 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 :110 :;@ >1?<1/@ @41 5:05N1>1:/1 >18-@5;: -??;/5-@10 C5@4 @41 ;>01>5:3 5@ 5? .-?10 ;: - ?59<81 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 :1/1??->58E 0;1? (41 >1?@ ;2 @45? ?1/@5;: 5? -: -D5;9-@5/ ?@A0E ;2 @41 ;>01>5:3? 5:@>;0A/10 5: 1G:5@5;:? .
(45) -:0 +4581 @41 .-?5/ -D5;9? C1 A?1 ->1 ;:?1:?A? -:0 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: C1 0; >18E ;: -005@5;:-8 <>;<1>@51? +1 0; :;@ >13->0 @41?1 -AD585->E <>;<1>@51? -? 2A:0-91:@-8 -?<1/@? ;2 - 01G:5@5;: ;2 <>121>1:/1?1:?5@5B1 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 13-85@->5-:5?9 (41E ->1 05?<A@-.81 /;:05@5;:? @4-@ 418< A? ?181/@ ?-851:@ 1D-9<81? ;2 13-85@->5-: ;>01>5:3? +1 .135: C5@4 @C; >1=A5>191:@? ;2 5:@1>:-8 /;41>1:/1 ;2 @41 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 C45/4 0; :;@ 59<;?1 -:E >18-@5;:?45< .1@C11: @41 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 -:0 @41 <>;G81 ;2 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? (41 G>?@ 5? C4-@ C1 /-88 '-+#',# (&#'' >;9 - >1?;A>/5?@ <1>?<1/@5B1 /;9<->5:3 @C; 2A88E 13-85@->5-: -88;/-@5;:? 5:B;8B1? :; 5??A1 ;2 05?@>5.A@5B1 6A?@5/1 -@ -88 (41>12;>1 - ?@-@191:@ ?A/4 -? # #" " ?4;A80 >1H1/@ ?;/51@EI? 1B-8A-@5;: ;2 @41 >18-@5B1 5:@>5:?5/ B-8A1? ;2 @41 .A:081? " -:0 # (41 -D5;9 ?-E? @4-@ 52 ?;/51@E 0119? 1-/4 ;2 @41 .A:081? " " 5:@>5:?5/-88E -@ 81-?@ -? B-8A-.81 -? .A:081 " @41: @41 -88;/-@5;: " " ?4;A80 .1 -@ 81-?@ -? 3;;0 -? " " : 5:@>5:?5/-88E >5/41> ?;/51@E 5? <>121>-.81 @; - <;;>1> ;:1 '-+"'," (&"'' ;> -88 " "
(46) "
(47) " " " " 2;> -88
(48) " " " " (45? -D5;9 /;9.5:1? @C; 501-? 5>?@ 8571 ;:?1:?A? 5@ 8595@? ?;/51@EI? /;:/1>:? 2;> 1=A-85@E (45? 5? .1?@ ?11: .E /;:?501>5:3 @41 /;:@>-<;?5@5;: ;2 @41 -D5;9 2 -: 13-85@->5-: -88;/-@5;: " " 5? 6A0310 ?A<1>5;> @; -:;@41> -88;/-@5;: " " 5@ /-::;@ .1 6A?@ .1/-A?1 @41 2;>91> 5? 13-85@->5-: @41 /;99;: .A:081 " >1/15B10 .E -88 5:05B50A-8? ?4;A80 .1 011910 5:@>5:?5/-88E 9;>1 B-8A-.81 @4-: -@ 81-?@ ;:1 ;2 @41 .A:081? /;9<;?5:3 @41 ;@41> -88;/-@5;: '1/;:0 5: 711<5:3 C5@4 @41 >1?;A>/5?@ B51C :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 -??A91? @4-@ @41 5: @>5:?5/ B-8A1 ;2 /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? 5? 1:;A34 5: ?<1/5G/ /-?1? @; 01@1>95:1 @41 ?;/5-8 >-:75:3 ;2 -88;/-@5;:? 52 1-/4 ;2 @41 .A:081? " " 5? 6A0310 5:@>5:?5/-88E -@ 81-?@ -? B-8A-.81 -? " @41: '2 -88;/-@5;: ;2 @41?1 .A:081? @; @41 5:05B50A-8? 5? -@ 81-?@ -? 3;;0 -? " " L ?;/51@E :110 :;@ C;>>E -.;A@ C4; 31@? C4-@ :0110 52 " " " " 2;> -88
(49) -:0 5? -: ->.5@>->E <1>9A@-@5;: ;: @41: " " " " 2;> -88
(50) -:0 :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 59<851? " " " " (45? 0;1? :;@ 91-: @4-@ 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? /-::;@ .1 @-71: 5:@; -//;A:@ : <-> @5/A8-> C1 19<4-?5F1 @4-@ :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 5? /;9<-@5.81 C5@4 @41 ?@-:0->0 B1>?5;: ;2 .
(51) @41 C1-7 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 .-?10 ;: @41 ?18G?4:1?? 4E<;@41?5? ;> 5:?@-:/1 01G:1 2;> 1-/4 5:05B50A-8 - :A91>5/-8 >1<>1?1:@-@5;: ! ;2 -:0 81@ # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 ! # ! " (41 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ?-@5?G1? :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 -:0 @41 ?@-:0->0 C1-7 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 # # " " C41:1B1> # " 2;> -88
(52) #A> ?1/;:0 -AD585->E /;:05@5;: 5? - C1-7 2;>9 ;2 /;:@5:A5@E ;2 @41 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 $
(53) ('-#'.#-2 >1=A5>1? @4-@ @41 ?;/5-8 >-:75:3 ;2 2A88E 13-85@->5-: -88;/-@5;:? .1 /;:@5:A;A? $ ('-"'."-2 ;> -:E " #
(54) -:0 -:E ?1=A1:/1 # 5: /;:B1>35:3 @; # # # " " 2;> -88 # #" " '5:/1 13-85@->5-: -88;/-@5;:? ->1 5: - ?59<81 ;:1@;;:1 /;>>1?<;:01:/1 C5@4 .A:081? - 05?/;:@5:A;A? ?;/5-8 >-:75:3 ;2 ?A/4 -88;/-@5;:? C;A80 ?119 -@ ;00? C5@4 /;:@5:A;A? 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? +1 ->1 :;C >1-0E @; ?@-@1 ;A> G>?@ >1?A8@ +()(,"-"(' ,( #% (+ +#'! ,-#,4 ,
(55) (', ',., (&#'' / +,#(' '-+#',# (&#'' ' $
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
(57) -:0 1B1>E <1>9A@-@5;: ;: " " " " (45? -D5;9 5? - <A>18E >1?;A>/5?@ B->5-:@ ;2 @41 2-9585-> <>;<1>@E ;2 -:;:E95@E +4581 '@>;:3 'E991@>E 5? /81->8E - B1>E 019-:05:3 <>;<1>@E L 5@ >A81? ;A@ -:;:E9;A?8E <>121>1:/1 ?1:?5@5B1 ;>01>5:3? L 5@ 5? 59<;>@-:@ @; ;.?1>B1 @4-@ -88 /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? 0; ?-@5?2E - B1>E /8;?18E >18-@10 /;:05@5;: 2 -//;>05:3 @; @41 C;>?@ .A:081 5: # # 5? ?@>5/@8E .1@@1> @4-: @41 C;>?@ .A:081 5: " " @41: -:E /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 .
(58) .-?10 ;: 0119? # # ?@>5/@8E .1@@1> @4-: " " 5>>1?<1/@5B1 ;2 C4; 5: 1-/4 -88; /-@5;: >1/15B1? @45? C;>?@ .A:081 (45? 91-:? @4-@ 2;> -88 " " # #
(59) -:0 1B1>E <1>9A@-@5;: ;: # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 # # " " D@1:05:3 @45? <>;<1>@E @; ?;/5-8 5:05N1>1:/1 59<851? '@>;:3 'E991@>E '59<81 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3? -8?; ?-@5?2E - ?1<->-.585@E <>;<1>@E 2 " "
(60) -:0
(61) 01:;@1 .E "
(62) @41 ?A.-88;/-@5;: " -:0 52 #
(63) C>5@1 # " 2;> @41 -88;/-@5;: ;.@-5:10 2>;9 " " .E >1<8-/5:3 " C5@4 # '- +'% )+"%"-2. 1@
(64) -:0 81@ " " # #
(65) .1 ?A/4 @4-@ " " " " .
(66) " $ " $ # $ # $ -:0 # # # # (41: 2;> -88 $ $ . 1/-A?1 ?;/51@E 0119? .A:081 " 5:@>5:?5/-88E 6A?@ -? B-8A-.81 -? " 5@ 9-E 53:;>1 5: 571C5?1 5@ 9-E 53:;>1 5:05B50A-8 C41: 05B50A-8 C41: /;9<->5:3 " $ @; " $ (41>12;>1 @41 ?;/5-8 >-:75:3 ;2 @41 -88;/-@5;:? " $ -:0 /;9<->5:3 # $ @; # $ ?4;A80 .1 @41 ?-91 -? @41 >-:75:3 ;2 # $ -:0 # $ ?5:/1 53:;>5:3 @41 " $ ?A.-88;/-@5;:? @; .1 /;9<->10 ->1 @41 ?-91 5: .;@4 /-?1? :-918E $ -:0 $. (41 -D5;9 5? >18-@10 @; 8195:3I? ?1<->-.585@E -D5;9 (41 1??1:@5-8 05N1>1:/1 5? @4-@ 5:05B50A-8 5? 53:;>10 :;@ .1/-A?1 41 5? 5:05N1>1:@ .1@C11: " -:0 " -:0 .1@C11: # -:0 # .A@ .1/-A?1 ?;/51@E 6A031? @4-@ @41 .A:081? 41 >1/15B1? ->1 1=A-88E B-8A-.81 5: .;@4 /-?1? 2 <>121>1:/1? ->1 :;@ ?18G?4 8195:3I? -D5;9 5? 8;35/-88E @;; 019-:05:3 (41 2;88;C5:3 <>;<;?5@5;: /4->-/@1>5F1? @41 ?59<81 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3? +()(,"-"(' ,( #% (+ +#'! ,-#,4 ,
(67) (', ',., (&#'' / +,#(' $
(68) ('-# '.#-2 -+('! 2&& -+2 ' '- +'% )+ #%#-2 # ' ('%2 # #- #, ,#&)% (', ',.% % 1#&#' ,( #% (+ +#'! ";@5/1 @4-@ :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 0;1? :;@ -<<1-> 5: @45? <>;<;?5@5;: 5@ 5? 59<8510 .E @41 /;9.5:-@5;: ;2 ;:?1:?A? +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E -:0 :@1>:-8 '1<->-.585@E (41 <<1:05D /;:@-5:? @41 <>;;2 ;2 $>;<;?5@5;: -? C188 -? 1D-9<81? ?4;C5:3 @4-@ -88 GB1 -D5;9? ->1 5:01<1:01:@ +1 /;:/8A01 @45? ?1/@5;: C5@4 @C; >19->7?. .
(69) 5>?@ ?59<81 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3? >19-5: ->3A-.8E @;; />A01 : <->@5/A8-> .1/-A?1 @41E ?-@5?2E '@>;:3 'E991@>E @41E B5;8-@1 @41 2;88;C5:3 /;:05@5;: +&.--"(' + -( +"' ")% ;> -88 " "
(70) -:0 1B1>E <1>9A@-@5;: ;: " " 2;> -88
(71) " " " " (45? -D5;9 5? - >1?@>5/@10 2;>9 ;2 @41 ?@-:0->0 C1-7 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 @ ?-E? @4-@ 52 <1>9A@5:3 .A:081? >1?A8@? 5: -: -88;/-@5;: C41>1 1B1>E 5:05B50A-8 <>121>? 41> :1C .A:081 @; @41 ;80 @45? :1C -88;/-@5;: ?4;A80 .1 >13->010 -? .1@@1> (41 59<;>@-:@ <;5:@ 5? @4-@ @41 :1C -88;/-@5;: 5? 31:1>-@10 2>;9 @41 ;80 @4>;A34 - B1>E ?<1/5G/ @E<1 ;2 1D/4-:31 <1>9A@-@5;: ;2 /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081? 'A/4 - <1>9A@-@5;: 5? 05?@>5.A@5;:-88E :1A@>-8 5: @41 ?1:?1 @4-@ 5@ <>1?1>B1? -:E /;:?A9<@5;: 5:1=A-85@51? ;>535:-88E <>1?1:@ '5:/1 @41>1 5? :; >1-?;: @; 2-B;> 15@41> -88;/-@5;: ;: 05?@>5.A@5B1 3>;A:0? - 0-?4 ;2 1M/51:/E ?4;A80 @5< @41 .-8-:/1 5: 2-B;> ;2 @41 :1C -88;/-@5;: (41>1 5? - ?59<81 C-E @; 31:1>-@1 - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 @4-@ ?-@5?G1? @45? /;:05@5;: -8;:3 C5@4 ;A> @C; 2A:0-91:@-8 -D5;9? ;:?1:?A? -:0 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: ? .12;>1 GD /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 ;: -3>115:3 C5@4 -:0 81@ .1 @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 @; "1D@ 81@ .1 - ,-' + 0 $%2 + -#' ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ;: 5: @41 ?1:?1 @4-@ # " 2;> -88
(72) # # " " ;:?@>A/@ .E 81D5/;3>-<45/ -<<85/-@5;: ;2 -:0 # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 # # " " ;> # # " " -:0 # # " " (41 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5? - /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 @ ?-@5?G1? ;:?1:?A? -:0 ;9 5:-:/1 B1>?5;: -? C188 -? +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E .1/-A?1 0;1? ?11 @41 <>;;2 ;2 $>;<;?5@5;: (; /41/7 @41 $1>9A@-@5;: $->1@; $>5:/5<81 :;@1 @4-@ " " " " 2;> -88 " "
(73) -:0 1B1>E <1>9A@-@5;: ;: (41>12;>1 " " " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 " " " " (41 /8-59 :;C 2;88;C? 2>;9 @41 2-/@ @4-@ 5? - ?@-:0->0 C1-78E $->1@5-: ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 #A> ?1/;:0 >19->7 .1->? ;: .;@4 $>;<;?5@5;:? -:0 : 15@41> >1?A8@ @41 ;:8E -D5;9 85:75:3 @41 ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ;2 -88;/-@5;:? @; 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? 5? ;:?1:?A? (41 2;88;C5:3 C1-7 2;>9 ;2 @4-@ -D5;9 2;A:0 5: @41 85@1>-@A>1 ;: 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 5:1=A-85@E 91-?A>191:@ -.?@>-/@? 2>;9 <>121>1:/1? -8@;31@41>.
(74).
(75) ('(-('" "-2 ;> -88 " " # #
(76) #
(77) " 2;> -88
(78) . # # " " &1<8-/5:3 ;:?1:?A? C5@4 !;:;@;:5/5@E E5180? <>121>1:/12>11 B1>?5;:? ;2 ;A> 1->851> >1?A8@? : <->@5/A8-> C1 ;.@-5: @41 2;88;C5:3 B->5-:@ ;2 $>;<;?5@5;: +1 ;95@ @41 <>;;2 C45/4 5? - ?@>-534@2;>C->0 9;05G/-@5;: ;2 @41 <>;;2? ;2 $>;<;?5@5;:? -:0 +()(,"-"(' ,( #% (+ +#'! (' ,-#,4 , ('(-('# #-2 (&#'' / +,#(' $
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
(80) -:0 "
(81) 81@ " #
(82) " # 01:;@1 @41 8;C1> /;:@;A> ?1@ ;2 -@ .A:081 " ;> " -:0 C>5@1 # #
(83) 1-/4 -88;/-@5;: " "
(84) 81@ " " . " " 52 2;> 1-/4 "
(85) " " @41>1 1D5?@? #
(86) # # ?A/4 @4-@ #
(87) " (45? <>;<1>@E 59<851? @4-@ # # " " 3'"-"(' ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5? - + # % 0%,#' ;>01>5:3 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 2;> -88 -88;/- @5;:? " " # #
(88) # #
(89) " " # # " " C;>0 ;2 5:@1><>1@-@5;: 5? 5: ;>01> '5:/1 @41 8;C1> /;:@;A> ?1@? " " ->1 :1?@10 2;> 1-/4 5:05B50A-8 @41 ?1@ " " 5? 6A?@ @41 5:@1>?1/@5;: ;2 @41 ?9-881?@ 8;C1> /;:@;A> ?1@? ;2 -88 5:05B50A-8? @ /;:@-5:? @41 .A:081? @4-@ -88 5:05B50A-8? /;:?501> -@ 9;?@ -? 3;;0 -? @415> 81-?@ <>121>>10 /;9<;:1:@ ;2 @41 -88;/-@5;: " " : -88;/-@5;: .1/;91? ?;/5-88E .1@@1> C41: @45? ?1@ 1D<-:0? .
(90) >-05/-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 /-: .1 B51C10 -? @41 >1?A8@ ;2 @41 2;88;C5:3 G/@5@5;A? @C; ?@-31 <>;/10A>1 5>?@ ;: .14-82 ;2 ?;/51@E 1-/4 5:05B50A-8 1B-8A-@1? -88;/-@5;:? A?5:3 &-C8?5-: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 41> ;C: <>121>1:/1 @41 8;C1> /;:@;A> ?1@ -@ @41 C;>?@ .A:081 5: -: -88;/-@5;: >1H1/@? 41> -??1??91:@ ;2 @41 B-8A1 ;2 @4-@ -88;/-@5;: L ;> >-@41> ?;/51@EI? @1:@-@5B1 -??1??91:@ .-?10 ;: 41> 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1 '1/;:0 @41?1 -??1??91:@? ->1 -33>13-@10 A?5:3 @41 A:-:595@E />5@1>5;: @41 5:@1>?1/@5;: ;2 @41 5:05B50A-8 8;C1> /;:@;A> ?1@? >1H1/@? ?;/51@EI? G:-8 1B-8A-@5;: ;2 @41 -88;/-@5;: E /;9<->5?;: @41 /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? ;2 @41 <>1B5;A? ?1/@5;: >1?A8@ 2>;9 <>;/10A>1 C41>1 @41?1 @C; ?@-31? /;91 5: >1B1>?1 ;>01> (41 A:-:595@E />5@1>5;: 5? -<<8510 G>?@ @; /;:?@>A/@ - ?;/5-8 <>121>1:/1 ;B1> .A:081? C45/4 -3>11? C5@4 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? -/4 -88;/-@5;: 5? @41: 1B-8A-@10 A?5:3 @41 &-C8?5-: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 @45? -33>13-@1 <>121>1:/1 (; 588A?@>-@1 @41 05N1>1:/1 .1@C11: @41 @C; -<<>;-/41? /;:?501> -3-5: ;A> @C;5:05B50A-8 @C;/;99;05@E 1D-9<81 C41>1 ->1 @41 85:1-> <>121>1:/1? >1<>1?1:@10 .E ! -:0 ! +41:1B1>
(91) C1 4-B1
(92)
(93)
(94) 41:/1
(95)
(96) 2;> 1B1>E >-05/-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 E /;9<->5?;: /;:?501> @41 /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 .-?10 ;: @41 <>121>1:/1 >1<>1?1:@10 .E ! C45/4 -3>11? C5@4 //;>05:3 @; @45? ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3
(97)
(98) C41:1B1> !;>1;B1> 2;> -:E /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 .-?10 ;: -:E <>121>1:/1 -3>115:3 C5@4 C1 4-B1
(99)
(100) 52
(101) 5? ?9-88 1:;A34 (4-@ 5? @41 /8-?? ;2 /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? 5? 05?6;5:@ 2>;9 @41 /8-?? ;2 >-05/-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? 2;> @41 <>121>1:/1 <>;G81 A:01> /;:?501>-@5;: 1/-A?1 @41E :110 :;@ <-E -@@1:@5;: @; @41 /;9<;:1:@? ;2 -: -88;/-@5;: @4-@ ->1 :;@ C;>?@ -//;>05:3 @; 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? >-05/-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? 9-E B5;8-@1 ;95 :-:/1 B1>?5;: +1 :;C 01?/>5.1 - ?A./8-?? ;2 ;>01>5:3? C45/4 1B-8A-@1 -88;/-@5;:? .E /;: ?501>5:3 @41 C;>?@ .A:081? G>?@ .A@ -8?; @-71 45341>>-:710 .A:081? 5:@; /;:?501>-@5;: 5: 81D5/;3>-<45/ 2-?45;: 5B1: -: -88;/-@5;: " " 01:;@1 .E " " -:E >1->>-:31 91:@ ;2 5@ 2>;9 C;>?@ @; .1?@ -//;>05:3 @; ?; @4-@ " " +5@4 @45? :;@-@5;: " " " "1D@ 2;> -:E 01G:1 " " " . . @45? 5? @41 ?1@ ;2 .A:081? @4-@ 1B1>E;:1 G:0? -@ 9;?@ -? 3;;0 -? @415> @4 C;>?@ .A: .
(102) 081 -9;:3 " " : <->@5/A8-> " " " " (41 ;>01>5:3? C1 ->1 -.;A@ @; 01G:1 1B-8A-@1 -: -88;/-@5;: .E 8;;75:3 ?A//1??5B18E -@ @41 ?1@? " " " " ;> ?59<85/5@E C1 >1?@>5/@ ;A> -@@1:@5;: @; <>121>1:/1 <>;G81? C41>1 " 5? .;A:010 41:/1 /;9<-/@ 5: B51C ;2 ;A> 1->851> -??A9<@5;: ;2 /;:@5:A5@E ;2 <>121>1:/1? 2;> 1-/4
(103) -:0 "
(104) 3'"-"(' ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 5? - + # % % 1#&#' ;>01>5:3 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 5@ 5? /;: ?@>A/@10 -? 2;88;C?. 1@ .1 - /;:@5:A;A? -:0 ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ <>121>1:/1 ;>01>5:3. ;B1> -:0 81@ ! .1 - /;:@5:A;A? :A91>5/-8 >1<>1?1:@-@5;: ;2 1@ ! " " !" "
(105) " " -:0 C>5@1 !" " ! " " ! " " ;> -88 " " # #
(106) 81@ # # " " !# # !" " C41>1 5? @41 A?A-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 ;: @ 5? 1-?E @; /41/7 @4-@ 1B1>E >-05/-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3 ?-@5?G1? ;:?1:?A? -:0 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: : 5:@1>1?@5:3 5:01<1:01:@ <>;<1>@E 5? @41 2;88;C5:3 52 -88 5:05B50A-8? <>121> /1>@-5: .A:081 " @; @415> ;C: /;:?A9<@5;: .A:081 -@ - 35B1: -88;/-@5;: @41: @41 13-85@->5-: -88;/-@5;: C41>1 1B1>E;:1 31@? " 5? .1@@1> @4-: @41 /A>>1:@ -88;/-@5;: %"-+"' + -( +"' ")% ;> -88 " "
(107) "
(108) " " 2;> -88
(109) . " "" " (45? /;:05@5;: 5? 5: @41 ?-91 ?<5>5@ -? @41 $1>9A@-@5;: $->1@; $>5:/5<81 @; 2;88;C @41 >1/;991:0-@5;:? ;2 @41 ?@-:0->0 $->1@; <>5:/5<81 C41: 5@ 0;1? :;@ /;:H5/@ C5@4 13-85@-> 5-: /;:/1>:? E /;:?@>A/@5;: -88 >-05/-8 81D595: ;>01>5:3? ?-@5?2E @41 3-85@->5-: $->1@; $>5:/5<81 #A> 1->851> 1D-9<81 ?4;C? @4-@ /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? @E<5/-88E B5;8-@1 5@ (41 2;88;C5:3 >1?A8@ <>;B10 5: @41 <<1:05D 5? - <->@5-8 0121:?1 ;2 >-05/-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? +()(,"-"(' - ,( #% (+ +#'! ,-#,4 , .%%
(110) (', ',., (&#'' / + ,#(' -+('! 2&& -+2 -" !%#-+#' + -( +#' #)% ' $
(111) ('-#'.#-2 -" ' #- #, + # % 0%,#' (+ +#'! . : @4;?1 0131:1>-@1 /-?1? C41>1 -88 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? /;5:/501 /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? /;5:. /501 C5@4 >-05/-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3? 41:/1 ?-@5?2E @41 -D5;9. .
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
(113) -:0
(114) ?A/4 @4-@ 5 "
(115) # " " #
(116) " -:0 55 # " 2;> -88
(117) ";@1 @4-@ @41 /;99;05@E @>-:?21>. >10A/1? @41 0;95:-:/1 .1@C11: @41. .A:081? ;2 5:05B50A-8? -:0 .A@ <>1?1>B1? @415> /;9<->-.585@E (&"'' . "' +', + +"' ")% ;> -88 " " # #
(118) # # " " # # " " ?@>;:31> B1>?5;: 5? :-@A>-8 1G:1 @41 >18-@5;: .E # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 @41>1 1D5?@
(119) -:0.
(120) ?A/4 @4-@ 5 "
(121) # "
(122) " 55 "
(123) " . #
(124) " -:0 555 # " 2;> -88
(125) 1>1 @41 /;9<->-.585@E ;2 @41 .A:081? ;2 5:05B50A-8? -:0 5? :;@ <>1?1>B10 .E @41 /;99;05@E @>-:?21>. .A@ .;@4 5:05B50A-8? ?@588. 1:0 A< <;;>1> @4-: @41 ;>535:-88E >5/41> 5:05B50A-8 -:0 >5/41> @4-: @41 ;>535:-88E <;;>1> ;:1 -+('. (&"'' . "'. +', + +"' ")% ;> -88 " " # #
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
(127) -88;/-@5;: ?A/4 -? . ;>1:F0;95:-@1? -//;>05:3 @; -:E ;2 @41. 1D5?@5:3 01G:5@5;:? .A@ 5@ 5? ;.B5;A?8E :;@ @>A1 @4-@ +4581 C1 0; :;@ 4-B1 - A?12A8 /4->-/@1>5F-@5;: ;2 @41 >18-@5;: C1 0; <>;<;?1 - :1C 01G:5@5;: ;2 9A8@50591:?5;:-8 ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1 C45/4 5? 2-5>8E @534@8E >18-@10 @; 5@ 5D -: -88;/-@5;: " "
(128) ;> -:E 3>;A< ;2 5:05B50A-8? 81@ .1 @41 ?5F1 ;2 -:0 01:;@1 .E " " @41 -33>13-@1 /;99;05@E .A:081 -88;/-@10 @; @41 919.1>? ;2 '-E @4-@ - ?A.?1@ ;2 5:05B50A-8? 5? - )((+ ,- !+(.) - " " 52 :; 3>;A< ;2 1=A-8 ;> 8->31> ?5F1 5? -88;/-@10 21C1> >1?;A>/1? @4-: 2;> -88 "
(129) "
(130) ;> 1-/4 81@ " " 01:;@1 @41 ?1@ ;2 <;;>1?@ 3>;A<? ;2 ?5F1 -@ @41 -88;/-@5;: " " 3'"-"(' : -88;/-@5;: # # .' % (+ '3 (&#'- , -: -88;/-@5;: " " C45/4 C1 C>5@1 # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 2;> 1B1>E -:0 1B1>E
(131) # # @41>1 5? ?;91
(132) " " ?A/4 @4-@ # " ?;/5-8 ;>01> 5:3 ?-@5?G1? @41 .' % (+ '3 (&#'' +#- +#(' 52 # # " " C41:1B1> # # " " : C;>0? # # .A:081 ;>1:F0;95:-@1? " " C41: 1B1>E <;;>1?@ 3>;A< -@ # # 5? -88;/-@10 -@ 81-?@ -? 9A/4 >1?;A>/1? -? ?;91 <;;>1?@ 3>;A< ;2 1=A-8 ?5F1 -@ " " A:081 ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1 5? /81->8E @>-:?5@5B1. @ 4;80? 2-5>8E J>->18EK. 5: <->@5/A8-> @41 -88;/-@5;: # # 0;1? '(- .A:081 ;>1:F0;95:-@1 " " ?5:/1 5? - <;;>1?@ 3>;A< ;2 ?5F1 -@ # # -:0 @41>1 5? :; 5: 05B50A-8 ?A/4 @4-@ # " (41 .A:081 ;>1:F0;95:-:/1 />5@1>5;: 5? @41>12;>1 >18-@5B18E C1-7 +41: @41>1 ->1 ;:8E @C; 5:05B50A-8? 5@ 5? 1-?E @; /41/7 @4-@ - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ?-@5?G1? @45? />5@1>5;: 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 5@ ?-@5?G1? @41 '@>;:3 ;95:-:/1&10A/5:3 (>-:?21> $>5:/5<81 '@>;:3 'E991@>E -:0 @41 9;05G10 B1>?5;: ;2 !;:;@;:5/5@E -?75:3 @4-@ # # " " C41:1B1> # " 2;> -88
(133) (45? 1=A5B-81:/1 :; 8;:31> 4;80? C41: @41>1 ->1 9;>1 5:05B50A-8? ,1@ 5: ?<5@1 ;2 .15:3 9A/4 C1-71> @4-: @41 />5@1>5- .-?10 ;: 1D5?@5:3 01G:5@5;:? ;2. ;>1:F 0;95:-:/1 @41 .A:081 ;>1:F0;95:-:/1 />5@1>5;: 0;1? 59<8E @41 ;95:-:/1. &10A/5:3 (>-:?21> $>5:/5<81. .
(134) +()(,"-"(' / +2 ,( #% (+ +#'! ,-#, 2#'! -" .' % (+ '3 (&#'' +#- +#(' ,-#,4 , -" -+('! (&#'' . #'! +', + +#' #)% (41 1-?E <>;;2 5? 5: @41 <<1:05D +1 /;:/8A01 C5@4 -: 1D<85/5@ <>;/10A>1 2;> /;: ?@>A/@5:3 ;>01>5:3? C45/4 ?-@5?2E .;@4 @41 '@>;:3 ;95:-:/1&10A/5:3 (>-:?21> $>5:/5<81 -:0 ;:?1:?A? #A> <A><;?1 5? @; 588A?@>-@1 @4-@ @41 @C; /;:05@5;:? ->1 2-> 2>;9 59<8E5:3 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: 1@ 01:;@1 @41 ?1@ ;2 ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ <>121>1:/1 ;>01>5:3? ;: 4-B5:3 - :A91>5/-8 >1<>1?1:@-@5;: 5: !
(135) " #
(136) " # !" !" !# !# (41 ?1@ 5? B1>E >5/4 2;> 5:?@-:/1 5@ /;:@-5:? 1B1>E ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ <>121>1:/1 ;>01>5:3 4-B5:3 - @C5/1 05N1>1:@5-.81 >1<>1?1:@-@5;: ! ?A/4 @4-@ 2;> ?;91
(137)
(138) !
(139) ! ! 2;> -88 <;??5.8E 501:@5/-8 /;99;05@51? (45? C1-7 /;:05@5;: 0;1? :;@ 59<8E @4-@ 5? /;:B1D $5/7
(140) !
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
(142) . )) ' "1 )+(( ,. +(( ( +()(,"-"(' : ;>01> @; <>;B1 @41 G>?@ ?@-@191:@ 81@ .1 - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ?-@5?2E5:3 ;:?1:?A? ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 -:0 +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E 1G:1 @41 .5:->E >18-@5;: ;: -? 2;88;C? 2;> -88 " #
(143) #" # #" ". . '5:/1 5? -: ;>01>5:3 -:0 ?-@5?G1? +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E 5? - /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 ;: !;>1 ;B1> -3>11? C5@4 52 # " 2;> -88
(144) ;:?1:?A? 59<851? # #" " 41:/1 # " .E ";C GD @C; -88;/-@5;:? " " # # ?A/4 @4-@ # " . . +1 /8-59 @4-@ # # " " 'A<<;?1 .E C-E ;2 /;:@>-05/@5;: @4-@ " " # # . . +5@4;A@ 8;?? ;2 31:1>-85@E -??A91 @4-@ " " E # " 2;> -88
(145) 1/-A?1 5? /;:@5:A;A? @41>1 1D5?@? - .A:081
(146) ?A/4 @4-@ # " 2;> -88
(147) .
(148) . 1@ "
(149) " 2;> -88
(150) -:0 /4;;?1 - .A:081 ?A/4 @4-@ E ;:?1:?A? " " "" " 41:/1 .E " " "# # E >1<1-@10 -<<85/-@5;: ;2 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: " " " " " " 41:/1 " " " # # . . E 01G:5@5;: ;2 # # # # 2;> -88
(151) E :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 # # # # 1:/1 .E " " " # # C45/4 .E 01G:5@5;: ;2 91-:? " # - /;:@>-05/@5;: @;
(152) .
(153) : ;>01> @; <>;B1 @41 ?1/;:0 ?@-@191:@ 5: $>;<;?5@5;: 81@ .1 @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 ?;91 /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 (; /41/7 ;:?1:?A? ?A<<;?1 # " 2;> -88
(154) (41: # " 2;> -88
(155) -:0 ?5:/1 -3>11? C5@4 # " E 01G:5@5;: ;2 # # " " (; <>;B1 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: ?A<<;?1 "
(156) # #
(157) " 2;> ?;91
(158) -:0 # " 2;> -88
(159) 1/-A?1 -3>11? C5@4 C1 4-B1 " # # " -:0 # " 2;> -88
(160) '5:/1 5? @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 5@ 2;88;C? @4-@ # # " " (; <>;B1 :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 GD " "
(161) "
(162) -:0 ?A<<;?1 " " " " 2;> -88
(163) E 01G:5@5;: ;2 " " 2;> -88
(164) 1:/1 .E 01G:5@5;: ;2 " " " " +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E ;2 2;88;C? 05>1/@8E 2>;9 /;:@5:A5@E ;2 +(( ( +()(,"-"(' +1 4-B1 ?4;C: 5: @41 <>;;2 ;2 $>;<;?5@5;: @4-@ -88 ?59<81 /;:?1:?A-8 81D595: ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3? ?-@5?2E @41 G>?@ @4>11 -D5;9? 5: $>;<;?5@5;: @ 5? ?@>-534@2;>C->0 @; /41/7 @41 8-?@ @C; '@>;:3 'E991@>E -:0 :@1>:-8 '1<->-.585@E ;:B1>?18E 81@ .1 - ?;/5-8 ;>01>5:3 ?-@5?2E5:3 @41 GB1 -D5;9? 5: $>;<;?5@5;: +1 .135: .E ?4;C5:3 @4-@ ?-@5?G1? :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1. 1@ " "
(165) -:0 "
(166) . .1 ?A/4 @4-@ " " " " 2;> -88
(167) E +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E @41>1 1D5?@ .A:081?
(168) ?A/4 @4-@ " " " " 2;> -88
(169) . . )?5:3 >1<1-@10 -<<85/-@5;:? ;2 :@1>:-8 '1<->-.585@E E5180 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " . " " " " E ;:?1:?A? " " " " 1:/1 " " " " .E @>-:?5@5B5@E ;2 (45? 1?@-.85?41? :@>5:?5/ ;95:-:/1 "1D@ 01G:1 @41 .5:->E >18-@5;: ;: -? 5: (41 <>;;2 ;2 $>;<;?5@5;: ?4;C? @4-@ 5? -: ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 -:0 @4-@ 5? - /;:?1:?A-8 &-C8?5-: ;>01>5:3 .-?10 ;: 2;> -88 " " # #
(170) # " # # " " . .
(171) +1 /8-59 @4-@ 5: 2-/@ 5? @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 @4-@ 5? (; ?4;C @45? C1 GD " " # #
(172) -:0 <>;/110 5: @C; ?@1<? - ) +1 ?4;C @4-@ # # " " # # " " 2 # # " " @41: # " 2;> -88
(173) E # # " " . 2;> -88
(174) (41>12;>1 ?@->@5:3 2>;9 @41 2-/@ @4-@ # # # # -:0 -<<8E 5:3 :@1>:-8 '1<->-.585@E @591? # # " # # " " # " " 1:/1 # # " " :B;75:3 '@>;:3 'E991@>E # # " " . - ) +1 ?4;C @4-@ # # " " # # " " 2 # # " " @41>1 1D5?@?
(175) ?A/4 @4-@ # " 2;> -88 -:0 # " . . 2 91-:? @4-@ # " -:0 59<851? # # " " 2
(176) 59<851? @4-@ # # " " 2;> . . 4;;?1 .A:081? $ $
(177) ?A/4 @4-@ $ # 2;> . . 5B1: -:0 ?5:/1 @>5B5-88E $ $ $ $ 2;> -<<8E5:3 :@1>:-8 '1< ->-.585@E @591? E5180? # # " " $ $ # # $ $ " " . . 1G:5:3 $ $ " " -:0 $ $ # # -:0 59<8E @4-@ " # -:0 (41>12;>1 .E @4-@ 5? $ $ # # $ $ " " E # # " " E '@>;:3 'E991@>E # # # # -:0 " " " " 41:/1 # # . " " (41 2;88;C5:3 1D-9<81? ?4;C @4-@ @41 -D5;9? 5: $>;<;?5@5;: ->1 5:01<1:01:@ : ;>01>5:3 B5;8-@5:3 ;:8E ;:?1:?A? 5? @41 A:5B1>?-8 5:05N1>1:/1 >18-@5;: # # " " 2;> -88 " " # #
(178) .
(179) : 1D-9<81 B5;8-@5:3 ;:8E ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: 5? @41 2;88;C5:3 ?59<81 /;:?1:?A-8 % 1 #&1 ;>01>5:3 81@ .1 - /;:@5:A;A? ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 -:0 01G:1 # # . " 2;> -88
(180) " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 15@41> @41>1 5?
(181) ?A/4 @4-@ # " -:0 # . ;> # " 2;> -88
(182) ;> -: 1D-9<81 B5;8-@5:3 ;:8E +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E /4;;?1 - #, ('-#'.(., ;>01>5:3 -3>115:3 C5@4 -:0 81@ .1 @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 ;> 5:?@-:/1 /;A80 .1 81D5/;3>-<45/ >1G:191:@ ;2 ?-E 5: @41 /-?1 2;> 5:?@-:/1 01G:1 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 ;> -:0 ;> -: 1D-9<81 B5;8-@5:3 ;:8E '@>;:3 'E991@>E 81@ .1 - /;:@5:A;A? <>121>1:/1 -3>11 5:3 C5@4 -:0 81@ # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 # # " " ;> # # " " -:0 # " ;> -: 1D-9<81 B5;8-@5:3 ;:8E :@1>:-8 '1<->-.585@E /4;;?1 -3-5: - /;:@5:A;A? <>121> 1:/1? -3>115:3 C5@4 2 81@ .1 @41 81D595: 1D@1:?5;: ;2 2 4;C1B1> 81@ .1 @41 J&-C8?5-: 1D@1:?5;:K ;2 @4-@ 5? # # " " 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 # " +(( ( +()(,"-"(' . 1@ ?-@5?2E A88 ;:?1:?A? ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: '@>;:3. 'E991@>E @41 3-85@->5-: $->1@; $>5:/5<81 -:0 +1-7 ;:@5:A5@E +1 .135: C5@4 - 2-/@ @4-@ 0;1? :;@ 01<1:0 ;: @41 >1?@>5/@5;: - ) ?-@5?G1? @41 2;88;C5:3 /;:05@5;: '#.,-"3 ' *.%"-2 / +,"(' ;> -88 " " # #
(183) " # # " 2;> ?;91
(184) -:0 -88
(185) -:0 # " 2;> -88
(186) . # # " " (41 <>;;2 A?1? ;:8E @41 -??A9<@5;:? @4-@ ?-@5?G1? A88 ;:?1:?A? -:0 ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;:. 1@ " " # #
(187) 'A<<;?1 " # # " 2;> ?;91
(188) . -:0 -88
(189) -:0 # " 2;> -88
(190) +5@4;A@ 8;?? ;2 31:1>-85@E 81@ 'A<<;?1 /;:@>->E @; @41 /8-59 @4-@ " " # # . . '5:/1 # # 2;> -88
(191) A88 ;:?1:?A? 59<851? # # # # # # # # .
(192). .
(193) 1/-A?1 # " 2;> -88
(194) -:0 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? ->1 ?@>5/@8E 9;:;@;:5/ #
(195) E /;:@5:A5@E ;2 5:05B50A-8 <>121>1:/1? # " 2;> -88
(196) -:0 -:E ?9-88 1:;A34 .A:081
(197) E A88 ;:?1:?A? -:0 >1/-885:3 @4-@ # " 2;> " # # # " " 1:/1 .E " # # # # # C45/4 /;9.5:10 C5@4 E5180? " # # # # # # # .
(198) . "1D@ /4;;?1
(199) 8->31 1:;A34 @; 3A->-:@11 @4-@ #
(200) " # E ?@>5/@ 9;:;@;:5/5@E ;2 <>121>1:/1? # " 2;> -88
(201) E A88 ;:?1:?A? # # # # " # # # 41:/1 .E
(202) # # # # # # # # (45? /;:@>-05/@? ;95:-:/1 B1>?5;: ?5:/1 #
(203) #
(204) # >;9 :;C ;: C1 >1?@>5/@ -@@1:@5;: @; @41 @C;5:05B50A-8 /-?1 ;> -:E 81@ .1 @41 ?1@ ;2 J$->1@;A:0;95:-@10K .' % , 5: 2;> -88 "
(205) "
(206) 52 -:0 ;:8E 52 "
(207) -:0 2;> -88 #
(208) # " 2;> # " 2;> - ) ;> -88 " "
(209) -:0 -88 "
(210) " " " " " " 2;> -88
(211) . . 5D " "
(212) -:0 "
(213) " " 1<1:05:3 ;: @41 <>121>1:/1 <>;G81 ;B1> " " 05?@5:3A5?4 2;A> /-?1?
(214) , $>121>1:/1? ->1 ?@>5/@ -:0 -3>11 ?-E " " 2;> : @45? /-?1 " " " " #.?1>B1 @4-@ " "" " . . :0110 ?5:/1 "
(215) " " C1 4-B1 " " 2;> '5:/1 "
(216) " " -:0 "
Documents relatifs
The signs of the coefficients appear appropriate for the expected dependence of the probability of default on the selected macroeconomic variables. Positive increases in the
We obtain a similar conclusion and emphasize that in economies with a frictional labor market, changes in the equilibrium unemployment rate provide an additional mechanism by
We start off by estimating the effect of the Basel III liquidity regulations on monetary policy transmission using historical individual bank data for a sample of banks covering
For example, since a 3 percentage point decrease in interest rate was given only to individuals with high behavior scores and low utilization rates (cell 9), we cannot generalize
The behavioural and time preference traits again show up as having an important impact on the incidence of financial distress, though the size of the coefficients on these variables
Overall, the higher participation in the mortgage market for all age and income categories in the US than in the euro area, albeit the gap being more significant for the higher
This paper uses three different household surveys which link wealth holdings to migration histories and analyses the relative wealth position of immigrant and native
We add to this literature the aspect of studying individual wealth mobility over the entire working life cycle, exploiting long individual time series of household wealth.. We use
