Etude et mise en oeuvre d'une méthode d'optimisation de forme couplant simulation numérique en aérodynamique et en calcul de structure
205
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) N°: 2008 ENAM 0039. Ecole doctorale n° 432 : Sciences des Métiers de l’Ingénieur. THÈSE pour obtenir le grade de. Docteur de. l’École Nationale Supérieure d'Arts et Métiers Spécialité “Mécanique” présentée et soutenue publiquement par. Meryem MARCELET le 10 décembre 2008. ETUDE ET MISE EN ŒUVRE D’UNE METHODE D’OPTIMISATION DE FORME COUPLANT SIMULATION NUMERIQUE EN AERODYNAMIQUE ET EN CALCUL DE STRUCTURE Directeur de thèse : Alain LERAT Co-encadrement de la thèse : Jacques PETER et Gérald CARRIER. Jury : Rapporteur M. Pierre-Alain BOUCARD, Professeur, LMT Cachan ................................................................ Rapporteur M. Jean-Antoine DESIDERI, Directeur de recherche, INRIA, Sophia Antipolis................................ Examinateur M. Pascal LARRIEU, Responsable des méthodes aérodynamiques, Airbus ................................ Examinateur M. Alain LERAT, Professeur, ENSAM, Paris ................................................................ Président M. Mohamed MASMOUDI, Professeur, Institut de mathématiques de Toulouse ................................ Examinateur M. Jacques PETER, Ingénieur de recherche, ONERA/DSNA, Châtillon ................................. Laboratoire de Simulation Numérique pour la Mécanique des Fluides ENSAM, CER de Paris L’ENSAM est un Grand Etablissement dépendant du Ministère de l’Education Nationale, composé de huit centres : AIX-EN-PROVENCE ANGERS BORDEAUX CHÂLONS-EN-CHAMPAGNE CLUNY LILLE METZ PARIS.
(3)
(4) !" $# &%('*),+-/.10324!56+-798:";2-<= !"$7"6 9!"."/>? /@A B+DC)A +4!FE$ HGI%KJ3+L;M5+-.$8 @3?6+-.N%('*.O@24.PRQSA 7"A T8U7N@!"37PV;M5;M5SW1)TXZY([V\*Y(']8N79XZ+6>2L/B^K!P_ARRA`24/R.a@;+4.O@3b?!5 c+-:":d24@!"; 89 24.5 e,!"f H24M5+47g H+4 2L!P7NT8h:"2-<i !"FWa)TXjYk.P @ @ !"@f7Pl m+-@ MPAn+-@ bO!P f7"oGB24!"% )2L!P L8O79XZ+6>2L/p.P7"2L Aq),qrL)*7Pq:";A 7".O@I7" ^K!" s`+-/.5 edb?!5* 2L.P !"I#+4 6+-)dE$+4 !$86 e:h24.P ;+-t"), 7P `A@ MP2O7P +4A2O7NsU.5+-o,b?!P ;MPuq'* t"!P 68L79XZ+6>?24/v+4:"@Aw7"3:".P7N3:5+4 @ WR`24.S^K!" sxL5XZ+47" A_?+-)`.O@f@;24!P f f.U@ 1Wy 24.5 e,!"F'*)z+-/.{E$;+4@68h:"24<= !"1Wa)kXj| [f}U'V ~8h:d24!P1+6>24 7"/ /_ARn+]@ MP6 8"+-/.P 9b?!$XZW !P w?+Lb?!P w# @w@*SA;+4)7J3+4 8U/."_A.P!"; qS[V|v\q'8U:d24!P XZ+6>2L/.56+47NA6n7N!P;+-.O@l ]@ ;24 l+-.P.PA 6xB H ]`,.U@ ]>24.U@A_?+4).O@lW @24!P@`)TXjA6b?!"/:h 7X /."_A."!P Ib?!5v^XZ+-hr4@2DsAR7N!P;+-.O@3 I@ 24, 3+-.5 I@37"2L.O@I),+]7N :d24.P/t"/)//@;AL8O),+F<i+4/)/@AR79XZ+L 3@I) 624.P /) FXj2L.O@1A@Ao:"A6!N{+4/.P vb?!XZWy@24!5 f) 17"2O@24;+4.O@ F@F @;+4_L,+-/; F7P24.O@w^XZ+-v;24 Ao),+y24!"@; %S 24!";`/.O@;+- +4t")n7"`td24.P.P`MO!"!"68B79Xj.O@ ;+-.@]7X MO!"`24!"6xB'*.57{)z+4 @68$t"!"@].P24@])+4 @68), 1% `.O@; R), S:")/!P S/.P624.P7N/@24.".5)/)`.O@f;M+-)!";!N >?24.O@FWnn+`<i+-/)/)l@1Wn F+- fb?!"24.U@ @;24!4^e24!P q !X+-:":d2L @q)f 24!"@ ,.@w)TXZ+-`24!"*7"24.O@^XZ+6>L+- wtd 24.x. .
(5) .
(6) d {¡U¢$£?¤¦¥N§D¨$©D¡ ª «¢§©D9¬¨$£§®¦¢ ¯ ° ± ©-®=¢$£?®¦²B¥5¤¦¡O³ {´?§Dµ$9¬B¡O³o¬p¶·²$§®= ®z³¥N§D®zd¢¸ m¨B¤z§®¦¬®¦³6²¤=®¦¢$¥5®¦©D¡ °ª ¹Lº/¹ »I¼4½O¾;¿&ÀU¾¿F¿¾wÁOÂUÃd¼4¾ Á5ÄÅ¿ÅVºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ¹Æ ¹LºZÇ ÈVÉ·Ê9ËÌ¿½U¾Å*Í-Î/ϼLÌ É/¾ Á"Ð`¿ÅqÑ9Òj¼LÃ"¾ É/ÐÉÅ;Í-¾ ɼ4½ÓºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFº ¹Ô ¹LºZÇNº/¹ Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿ÅqÑP¿SÌ¿ÖcÁP¿ÌÖcÁP¿SÏLμL×5Í-ο ºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ¹Ø ¹LºZÇNºZÇ Õ ¼OÑPÄοÅ*Í-ÃPÃ"̼OÖcÁPËÅwÃd¼4ÙPÌwÎTÒj¼LÃ"¾ É/ÐÉÅÍ4¾ ɼ4½ÏLμ4×Í-οRºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ÇÚ ¹LºZÇNºZÛ Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿ÅqÑP¿SÌ¿ÖcÁP¿ÌÖcÁP¿SμUÖ6Í-οܺfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ÛLÛ ¹LºZÛ Ý Òj¼LÃ"¾ É/ÐÉÅ;Í-¾ ɼ4½Ð]Ù"ξ ÉÑNÉÅÖÉ/ÃPÎ/É/½5Í4É/Ì¿RÞv½P¼4¾;Í4¾ ɼ4½PÅwÏ?˽PËÌ;Í4οŠºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ßOÇ ¹Lº ß ÈVÉ·Ê9ËÌ¿½U¾¿ÅwÐ˾ ÁP¼OÑP¼4μ4ÏLÉ,¿ÅqÑ9Òj¼4ÃP¾ É/ÐoÉ,ÅÍ4¾ ɼ4½àºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ßß ¹Lº ßPº/¹ Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿FÅÍ4½PÅqÖ¼4ÙPÃ"Î,Í-Ï¿ºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFº ßß ¹Lº ßPºZÇ Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿FÅ Ë6á?ÙP¿½U¾ É¿Î/ο~ºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFº ßOÆ ¹Lº ßPºZÛ Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿Å*âlÙ"½½PÉ/ã¿6Í4ÙäºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ßOÆ ¹Lº ßPº ß Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿ÅwÐÙ"Î/¾ É/½PÉ/ã¿6Í4ÙNÀ ºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ßOå ¹Lº ßPºZÆ »I¼4½5ÖÎ/ÙPŠɼ4½5ÅÅ Ù"ÌοÅÐ˾ Á5¼OÑ"¼4Î,¼4ÏLÉ¿Å Ñ9Òj¼4ÃP¾ É/ÐoÉ,ÅÍ4¾ ɼ4½lÑ"¿IÅ ÂUÅ ¾ÄÐ`¿ÅÖ6¼4Ù"Ã"Î,ËÅÖ¼LÐlÞ Ã"ο&À"¿ÅæºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ÆLÇ ª5ª ç è ¥5¤z£O¨B¤p¬B¡H¤z¥{²³®,§D®zd¢¸¬v¶·´Oé¨B®=¤=®zê©D¡ ¥P´O©Dh´U¤¦¥P³§®¦é¨$¡ ÇNº/¹ ÈR¿6Å ÖÌ É/Ã"¾ ɼL½ÑNÙмUÑ"ÄοRë5Ù"ÉÑ"¿ÞkÅ ¾ Ì ÙPÖ¾Ù"Ì¿fÙ"¾ É/Î/ÉÅËìºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFº ÆLÚ ÇNºZÇ íU¼4Î/ã¿Ù"Ì3ë5Ù"ÉÑ"¿ºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº Æ?Ô ÇNºZÛ íU¼4Î/ã¿Ù"ÌqÅ ¾ Ì Ù5Ö¾ Ù"Ì;¿ÓºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº Úî ÇNºZÛNº/¹ ï*Ã"Ã"Ì;¼OÖ;ÁP¿fÐ`Í-¾Ì ÉÖ¿fÑP¿Rë5¿ÀUÉ/×"É/ÎÉ/¾ËðºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº Úî ÇNºZÛNºZÇ »3Í-ÎÖÙ"ÎÑ"¿fÎ,ÍÐnÍ-¾ Ì ÉÖ6¿fÑ"¿Së5¿&ÀUÉ×"É/Î/É/¾Ë1Í4ÅżOÖÉË¿1âÙP½P¿SÃd¼LÙ"¾ Ì¿fÌ¿Ö¾É/Î/É/ÏL½5¿ñºFºFºFºfº ÚÇ ÇNºZÛNºZÛ »3Í-ÎÖÙ"ÎÑ"¿*Î,ÍfÐnÍ-¾ Ì ÉÖ6¿*Ñ"¿që5¿&ÀUÉ/×PÉ/Î/É/¾ËRÍ4ÅÅ ¼UÖÉË¿RâfÙ"½5¿qÃd¼4ÙP¾ Ì¿qÌ¿6Ö¾ É/Î/ÉÏL½P¿qÃÍ-ÌvÐ`¼4ÌeÞ Ö¿6Í-Ù"Àyá?ÙP¿ÎÖ¼4½5á?ÙP¿{ºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ÚLÆ ÇNºZÛNº ß »3Í-ÎÖÙ"ÎÑ"¿6ÅqÑ"ËÃ"ÎzÍ4Ö¿Ð`¿½O¾ÅwÉ/½PÑ"Ù"É/¾ÅwÃÍ-ÌwοFÖ;Á5Í-ÌϿп½O¾*Í4Ë̼OÑNÂU½5Í-ÐoÉ,á?ÙP¿ºFºFºfº Ú?Ô ÇNº ß Õ Ë¾ Á5¼OÑ"¿ÅqÑ"¿FÖ¼4ÙPÃ"Î,Í-Ï?¿ðºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº Ú?Ô ÇNº ßPº/¹ ò$Ì;Í-½5ÅKói¿Ì ¾qÑP¿ÅqÑ"ËÃPÎ,Í4Ö¿Ð`¿½O¾ÅqÑP¿SÎ,ÍoÅe¾Ì ÙPÖ¾ ÙPÌ¿FÍ-Ù"Àa½P¼U¿ÙPÑ"ÅqÑP¿SÃ5Í-Ì;¼4É{ºfºFºFºFºfº Úå ÇNº ßPºZÇ ôÌ;¼4Ã5Í-ÏOÍ-¾ ɼ4½gÑ"ÙmÑPËÃ"Î,ÍLֿп½O¾fÑ"¿ÅS½P¼O¿ÙPÑPÅSÑ"¿Î,ÍnÃ5Í4̼4É Í-ÙmÌ¿Å ¾¿lÑ"ÙHÐnÍ-É/Î/Î,Í4Ï¿ ÑNÙÑP¼4Ð`Í-ɽP¿Rë5Ù"ÉÑ"¿ ºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ÔLî ÇNº ßPºZÛ òB¿Ö;ÁP½"Éá?Ù5¿]Ñ"¿]Ì¿ÐnÍ-É/Î/ÎzÍ-Ï¿ÑNÙmÑ"¼4ÐnÍ-É/½P¿1ëPÙ"ÉÑP¿1ÙP¾ É/Î/ÉÅË¿ÑPÍ-½5ÅVοÖ6Í4ÑNÌ;¿]Ñ"¿Ö¿¾ ¾¿ ˾ ÙPÑP¿ ºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº ÔLÇ ÇNº ßPº ß ò$Ì;Í-½5ÅKói¿Ì ¾qÑP¿Åq¿&Êh¼LÌ ¾Å*Í4Ë̼UÑNÂO½Í-ÐoÉáOÙP¿Å*Í-ÙÐ`Í-É/ÎÎ,Í-Ï¿FÑ"¿SÎ,ÍoÅe¾Ì ÙPÖ¾Ù"Ì¿ ºFºFºFºfº ÔLØ ÇNºZÆ ô̼UÖËÑNÙPÌ¿SÉ/¾;ËÌ;Í-¾ Éã¿fÑ"¿FÖ6Í-Î,ÖÙ"ÎÑP¿SÎTÒjËáOÙ"É/Î/É/×PÌ¿FÍ4Ë̼OËÎ,ÍLÅe¾Éá?ÙP¿FÅe¾cÍ-¾ Éá?Ù5¿ ºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFº åÚ ÇNºZÚ ôÌË6Å¿½O¾;Í-¾É¼4½ÑP¿ÅqÖ6Í4Åw¾¿6Åe¾;ÅõºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº å?Ô ÇNºZÚNº/¹ ï*É/οÞkö"Ù5Å ¿Î,Í-Ï¿FöBß ºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº å?Ô ÇNºZÚNºZÇ ï*É/οFÕHÚ ºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfº Øî ÇNºZÚNºZÛ ï*É/οÞkö"Ù5Å ¿Î,Í-Ï¿F÷*Éø*¿òwò ºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºfºFºFºFºfºù¹6îî Û.
(7) ú. ûüVý3þ$ÿRÿ üû *ÿ
(8) !"$#&%' (*),+ -*.0/ 1324650785:9<;=465?>=@BADCFEG>IH67 C;=JKH<>ADL@ ;M7 5?NOC;QPRCQST7 >$ADJKU05?9V;M4<5?>=@B;IJKH<>JKU";=96465?NOCW.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q[R\ -*.^] ÿ SKH6504<ODH<CXADC_9ADJK2,CK@A;=@S_C_9AC_9A*5a`,J_H<CK@4<CQ9bEG>=@SK4<5?>=@9SQ>=@965?ADJKHVJ_C_9c.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q[Id -*.^- J_46e>AC_9A*OBSQ;MU?SKOUfADC_9hgRHV;=A*5?C_@4<9i.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/I/I/ -*.^-D.0/ jh;MU?SKODUkADC_9hgIHl;=A*5?CK@$4<9h2 ;MHmA*5a`,J_H<CK@SQC_9bn@D5?CQ9 .X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/I/I/ -*.^-D.^] JK46e>ACYADCYUpoqJ_NO ;M465?>I@rU050@ JQ;MH65?9<J_CXA*5?9<SKH<s_4<C t7uJK46e>$ADCYAD50H<C_SK4VC'vw.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/I/Q] -*.^-D.^- JK46e>ACYADCYUpoqJ_NO ;M465?>I@B;=A=xy>=50@4VCYA*5?9<SKH<s_4<C .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/I/Qz -*. ú J_46e>AC_9h504<JKHl;M4650PRCQ9ADCYSQ;=U?SKODUkADC_9hgIHV;IA*5?CK@$4<9hOD4650U?5?96JQC_9A;M@ 9hU?CYSQ;=ADH<CYACYS_CK4<4<CYJK4<OADC{.Z/Q]I[ -*. ú .0/ JK46e>ACYADCYUpoqJ_NO ;M465?>I@rU050@ JQ;MH65?9<J_CXA*5?9<SKH<s_4<C|.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q]I[ -*. ú .^] JK46e>ACYADCYUpoqJ_NO ;M465?>I@B;=A=xy>=50@4VCYA*5?9<SKH<s_4<C .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q]I-*.^z jb;=U?SKODU&ADCQ9}ADJKH<50PRJ_C_9}2 ;MH<465?CKU0U?CQ9;M22 ;MHV;M5:969V;M@$4}A ;M@9}U?C_9J_NO ;M4<5?>=@9}U050@JQ;=H65?9<J_C_9CK4b;=AMxy>I50@4<C_9R/Q]Iz -*.^zD.0/ jh;MU?SKODUkA*Or4VCKH67 C (∂X/∂X ) .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q]Iz .Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q]I~ -*.^zD.^] jh;MU?SKODUkA*Or4VCKH67 C -*.^zD.^- jh;MU?SKODUkA*Or4VCKH67 C (∂X/∂D) .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q]R\ (∂L/∂W ) ∗ (∂W /∂W ) -*.^zD. ú jh;MU?SKODUkA*Or4VCKH67 C (∂L/∂W ) ∗ (∂W /∂X) .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q-*/ -*.^zD.^z jh;MU?SKODUkA*Or4VCKH67 C .Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q-I-*.^~ jb;=U?SKODU?9AC_9hgIHV;=AD5?CK@4V9h2&>=(∂L/∂X) ODH46H<>=5?9S';=9h4<C_964<9m;=J_H<>=@ ;=OD465?NO C_9T.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q- ú -*.^~D.0/ ü 50U?CO9<CKU:;=gRCY ú .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q- ú -*.^~D.^] ü 50U?C ~.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/QzI[ -*.^~D.^- ü 50U?CO9<CKU:;=gRCY35 C ûwû .X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Qz ú $" =k &k {0 k% GQD%'#| M (*,+ ú .0/ j>I@4<C*4<CTeD5:9y4V>=H65?NO Cu.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q~R\ ú .^] C_9<SKH6502465?>=@BA*Or2H<>=DU:sK7 CXAoq>=2D4<50785?9V;M4<5?>=@ .Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q~I ú .^]D.0/ TJQ>=7 JK4<H65?CYADOSQ;=9h4VC_964.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q~I ú .^]D.^] jh;MU?SKODUkADCTUoqJ_S_>=OU?CK7 C_@4bO5?ADC .X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q~Id ú .^]D.^- H<>=U?sK7 CXAoq>=24650785:9<;=465?>=@.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/'\=[ ú .^- >$ADsKU?CQ9;=2D2DH<>$SVeJ_9hO4650U05?9<J_9.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/'\$/ ú .^-D.0/ JKgRH<C_9<965?>=@r2;MH96ODHyEp;=S_CYACTH<JK2,>=@9<CT2,>=U0L@ =785:;=U?CYA*OBADCKgIHVJYADC_O*.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/'\=] ú .^-D.^] JKgRH<C_9<965?>=@r2;MHhH<JQ96C';MO*ACT@C_ODH<>=@CQ98.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/'\=] ú .^-D.^- JKgRH<C_9<965?>=@r2;MHh7uJK46e>ACYADCX TH650gR50@Dg.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/'\= ú .^-D. ú ÿ P=;MU?O ;M465?>I@9ADC_9h2,CKHyEG>=H<7u;M@SQC_9ADC_9h7u>ADsKU?CQ9m;M2D2DHV>SVeJQ9hH<CK4<CK@$O9 .Y.X.X.Y.X.X.Z/Q ú #kk "&# (*¡ ¢ rig b. b. b. b.
(9) £ ¤¦¥ §¨ª©¬«¯®±°³²´§. µX¶ ·¸!¹º»¼|½¿¾0· ÀkÁ »´ÂÃQÄDÁ'·Šn p D α J Gk. ä·ÁQÄDÁ'·ÅÃ8åæ$Åkæ¶ Ä¹¼Ã. O (x, y, z). F FI S SI. õ·½º$¹¼|Ã_ÁQ¶Mök÷RÁ'ö¶ ¼ np Rs D ωp θp Z Zrig. Pi (xi , yi , zi ) (xrig i , yrig i , zrig i ). ÆFÇ=ÈÊÉË<ÌYÍDÌYÎ ÏMËlÏMÈ ÐKÑ<Ë<Ì_ÒÍDÌTÓGÇ=Ë6È Ì ÆFÇ=ÈÊÉË<ÌYÍDÌXÔ_Ç=Õ$Ñ6ËVÏMÖ0Õ$Ñ<Ì_Ò ×TÇIÈuÏMÖ0Õ ÌYÍDÌXÔ_Ç=ÕÔQÌKÎDÑ6Ö?ÇIÕ´Ø ⊂ Ù Ú Û Ü¿Ì_ÔKÑ<Ì_ÝDËÍÌ_ÒhÎ ÏMËVÏ=È ÐKÑ6ËVÌ_ÒÍDÌFÓGÇIË6È Ì Þ Ç=Õ ÔKÑ6Ö?ÇIÕÇ=É*ß6Ì_ÔKÑ6ÖaÓ àáÈ Ö0ÕDÖ0È8Ö:Ò6Ì_Ë Þ Ç=Õ ÔKÑ6Ö?ÇIÕÔ_Ç=Õ$Ñ6ËVÏMÖ0Õ$Ñ<ÌXà8Ò<Ï=Ñ6Ö?ÒyÓâÏMÖ0Ë<ÌuØ 1 ≤ k ≤ pÛFã G (α) ≤ 0 n. k. çFË6Ö0èIÖ?ÕÌYÍ*ÝË<ÌKÎ,ÐKË<ÌYÍDÖ0Ë<Ì_ÔKÑ mÚ Ì_Î&ÐKË<ÌYèIé?Ç=É Ï=ékÏ=Ò<Ò<ÇÔKÖ?êÏMÝrÈuÇÍDÐ_é?Ì ØépëìÏ í*Ì x Î&ÇIÖ0ÕÑ<ÌYÍ ÏMÕÒ é"ÏîÍ*Ö0ËVÌ_ÔKÑ6Ö?ÇIÕÍ*ÝrÓÝÒ<ÌKé:Ï=èRÌTïRÌ_Ë<Òhépë^ÏMË<Ë6Ö?ÐKË<ÌXÍDÌTépëìÏQïÖ?Ç=Õkð*épë^ÏMí*Ì y ÌQÒyÑmÍÏMÕ Òhé?ÌTÎDé"ÏMÕÍDÌYépë^ÏQï$Ö?Ç=ÕÌ_ÑhÎ&ÇIÖ0ÕÑ<ÌXàîé:ÏîÍDË<Ç=Ö0Ñ<ÌXÛ Í*ÝÎDÖ0é?Ç=ÑVÌIð Ì_Ñhépë^ÏMí*Ì z Ô_Ç=Ë<Ë<Ì_Ò6Î&Ç=ÕÍBàáé:ÏîïRÌKË<Ñ6Ö?ÔQÏMé?ÌÏ=Ò<Ô_ÌKÕ ÍÏMÕÑVÌ ñòÏMÖ0é0é"ÏMèRÌYÍDÝÍDÇIÈuÏMÖ0Õ ÌYÇÔ_Ô_ÝDÎ&êYÎ ÏMËhé:ÌFóÝDÖ:ÍDÌ ñòÏMÖ0é0é"ÏMèRÌYÍÌTépë Ö0Õ$Ñ<ÌKËyÓpÏ=Ô_ÌFó ÝDÖ?ÍDÌô ÒyÑ<Ë6ÝÔKÑ<ÝDË<ÌTÖ0Õ ÔKé0ÝÒ<ÌXÍÏMÕÒ é:ÌTÈuÏ=Ö0é0é:ÏMèÌ F ñòÏMÖ0é0é"ÏMèRÌYÍÌTé:Ï8ÒyÑ<Ë6ÝÔKÑ6ÝË<Ì ñòÏMÖ0é0é"ÏMèRÌYÍÌTépë Ö0Õ$Ñ<ÌKËyÓpÏ=Ô_ÌFó ÝDÖ?ÍDÌô ÒyÑ<Ë6ÝÔKÑ<ÝDË<ÌTÖ0Õ ÔKé0ÝÒ<ÌXÍÏMÕÒ é:ÌTÈuÏ=Ö0é0é:ÏMèÌ S FÆ Ç=ÈÊÉË<ÌYÍÌTÕÇÌ_ÝÍDÒÍ*ÝÈuÏMÖ?é0é:ÏMèRÌXÍDÌTé:ÏîÎ&Ç=ÝÑ6Ë<Ì ø$ù Ò6Ñ<ÐKÈuÌYÍëqêQúÝ ÏMÑ6Ö:Ç=ÕÒÍ*Ö:Ò6Ô_Ë<ÐKÑ<Ì_Òê_Ô_Ë6Ö0Ñ<Ì_ÒÒ<Ç=Ý ÒbÓGÇ=Ë6ÈuÌYÍDÌYË<ê_Ò6Ö?Í*Ý Î,Ç=ÝDËé:ÏáÈuê_ÔQÏMÕDÖ:úÝÌYÍÌ_ÒÒ6Ñ6Ë6ÝÔ_Ñ6ÝDË<Ì_Ò ûü ÏMÈ ÎÍDÌQÒÍDêKÎDé:ÏIÔ_ÌKÈ Ì_ÕÑ<Ò ûü ÏMÈ ÎÍDÌTó Ìí*Ö?Ç=ÕÒ6ÝDËé:ÏîÍ*Ö:Ò6Ô_Ë<êKÑ6Ö?ÒVÏMÑ<Ö?Ç=ÕÍÌTé:ÏîÎ&Ç=ÝDÑ<Ë<Ì ûü ÏMÈ ÎÍDÌYÑ<Ç=Ë<Ò6Ö?ÇIÕÒ6ÝDËhé"ÏîÍ*Ö?Ò<ÔKË<ê_Ñ6Ö?ÒVÏMÑ6Ö:Ç=ÕÍDÌYé:ÏáÎ,Ç=ÝDÑ6ËVÌ ñòÏMÖ0é0é"ÏMèRÌYÔQÇ=Ë6Ë<Ì_Ò6Î&ÇIÕÍÛ ÏMÕ$ÑmàáÝÕÌYÍDÖ?Ò<ÔKË<êKÑ6Ö:Ò<Ï=Ñ6Ö?Ç=ÕBÍDÌ é"ÏîÒ6Ñ6Ë6Ý ÔKÑ6ÝDË<ÌuØÎ&Ç=ÝÑ6Ë<Ì ñòÏMÖ0é0é"ÏMèRÌYÔQÇ=Ë6Ë<Ì_Ò6Î&ÇIÕÍÏMÕ$ÑmàáÝÕÌYÍDÖ?Ò<ÔKË<êKÑ6Ö:Ò<Ï=Ñ6Ö?Ç=ÕBÍDÌ é"ÏîÒ6Ñ6Ë6Ý ÔKÑ6ÝDË<ÌuØÎ&Ç=ÝÑ6Ë<Ì Û ÏQï=ÏMÕ$ÑÍDêÓâÇ=Ë6ÈuÏ=Ñ6Ö?Ç=ÕBÍ*ÝÌXÏ=Ý*íÌKý,ÌKÑ<Ò ÏIêKË<Çê_é:Ï=Ò6Ñ6Ö?úÝ Ì_Ò ÆFÇÌKÝÍÒ i ÍDÝrÈuÏ=Ö0é0é:ÏMèÌYÍDÌYé:ÏáÎ,Ç=ÝDÑ6Ë<Ì ûbÇÇ=ËVÍDÇ=ÕDÕêQÌ_ÒÍ*ÝÕÇÌKÝ Í P ÍÏMÕ Òhé?ÌTÈþÏMÖ0é0é:Ï=èRÌ Z Ìí$ÎDË<Ö0È ê_Ì_Ò Í ÏMÕÒhé?ÌYË<ÌKÎ&Ð_Ë<ÌTèIé:Ç=É ÏMé (x, y, z) ûbÇÇ=ËVÍDÇ=ÕDÕêQÌ_ÒÍ*ÝÕÇÌKÝ Í P ÍÏMÕ Òhé?ÌTÈþÏMÖ0é0é:Ï=èRÌ Z ÌKí$ÎDË6Ö0Èuê_Ì_Ò Í ÏMÕÒhé?ÌYË<ÌKÎ&Ð_Ë<ÌTèIé:Ç=É ÏMé (x, y, z) ÿ i i. rig.
(10)
(11) ω = (ωx , ωy , ωz ) θ = (θx , θy , θz ) ωp i θp i δωp i δθp i F Fij zz Fij zθy Fij zθx Fij θy z Fij θy θy Fij θy θx (Fx , Fy , Fz ) (Mx , My , Mz ) (Xi , Yi , Zi ) (FXi , FYi , FZi ) (MXi , MYi , MZi ) ω = (ωXi , ωYi , ωZi ) θ = (θXi , θYi , θZi ) E I G J LS δDS δWS Vi − → Fi −→ Mi → − FS − → MS. bdcEeKf$gih&j klRcEe9m9n9j0oqpirXs9h. nf ncell Rf. "!$#%&"! #' ( )*
(12) ,+ -.
(13) %/0(
(14) (x, y, z)
(15)
(16) . 1)#%&"! #% 0( )*
(17) %2 3+ 4-1
(18) %1/0(
(19) (x, y, z)
(20) "!$#%5(60 0 P
(21) 5(6 $ Pi
(22) 1"!$)#%#%8 i
(23) 1)#%877#'#' 0
(24) 9
(25) 91 : ;;#%#%))))#'#'//
(26)
(27) %2< : :86 0 0 Pi ( #% >2 0"!$#%/#'
(28) '#' Pi =
(29) )
(30) % -. ( #'$ *&"?, Pi #' 4(#%2)
(31) % z ( z #' P j #' 4
(32) (#% 2 )
(33) %1 )
(34) %( z 1 #' -. ( #'$ Pi *8 y Pj #' 4
(35) (#% 2 )
(36) %1 )
(37) % z 1 #' -. ( #'$ Pi *8 x #'@(P1j A -. 0 : 1#' y Pi ( *
(38) & "?,1 *( #'-14 (
(39) #'(42
(40) (-1
(41) (#'@) (
(42) % 1zA( 1#' -.P j0 : 1#' y Pi (*
(43) 8 (A-1
(44) #'(B#'(#'@2()
(45) 1 Ay ( #'-. 0P :j 1#' Pi A#'B(#'2)
(46) x ( y #' P (?,*1A8 EDF #'-1#% < :G$0(;#HI <"! #% 0( j )*
(47) %2 3+ 4 C-.
(48) %/0(
(49) (x, y, z) =-.
(50) %/0(
(51) A EDF#'-1#% < :G$0(;#HI 2 ! #' 0( )*
(52) %2 3+ 4 (x, y, z) J ,
(53) +
(54) >(
(55) K))$ # <L
(56) M) #% Pi−1 Pi
(57) ; :#%) #%)4(#%1 ?C ,1A EDF#'-1#% < :G$0(;#HI <"! #% 0( )*
(58) %2 3+ 4
(59) %$ >(
(60) (X , Y , Z ) i i i =
(61) %$ >(
(62) A EDF#'-1#% < :G$0(;#HI 2 ! #' 0( )*
(63) %2 3+ 4 (Xi , Yi , Zi ) "!$#%&"! #' ( )*
(64) ,+
(65) %$ >(
(66) (X , Y , Z )
(67)
(68) . )#%&"! #% 0( )*
(69) %2 3+ 4
(70) % N(
(71) (Xi , Yi , Zi ) :
(72) 2 ED OP - :18 i i i = AHI :4#%HI @(( 1#(A
(73) QDFR!2 0"!:#% = :
(74) 2 ED
(75) )#% #' 2-1
(76) '#%)) = AHI :4#%HI < ED 02) #%6B( )7. 4)<
(77) S = A <)1&R!:2 (-I $ 4 :G (;#%H HI#'7
(78) %
(79) '#HI
(80) ;)W TVU
(81) A7 #'0
(82) X :#%) )W#%/
(83) %2
(84) QD #'$ WYZ1 @L I S 4 > 7(#%
(85) X )A ?,) %
(86) A ) 8
(87) . . δDS [
(88) '2 ED #%: 2L S6 $ P \ ><
(89) '#%HI <(8 i P. ]
(90) '#%HI (8 0 i = P ;2 )A ?,4)A
(91) '#%H ) (i!_ $ )A 6#'
(92) '
(93) (-I S I ^ ;2 )* )
(94) '#%HI ) (:!` 0 )A :6a(#'
(95) '
(96) S(-. SI ^ t/42 2 0 )A :8(#'
(97) %
(98) (-.2 8 1(#'0 #% t/42 <
(99) '
(100) '
(101) % )A :8(#'
(102) %
(103) (-.< :8 (#% 0#% G$) < ED H0(#%1 )A :#%) ) #' )A)0)VYZ< )#% : ^ #'+ 71(*
(104) 2 A+ :6 #% .
(105) u vwx y0z {|(}~x W Wb X Xrig. Nijk (xijk , yijk , zijk ) (˜ xijk , y˜ijk , z˜ijk ). I~ x BB |(|(y y x x ~~AAz z vvy0y0x x |(|(}} ' '..x x || vv::$$y0y0|(|(w; ; w {|ti4vy} % x F I |( '{'{|.x2}~ z }~42z vx 3vy0 |(y}~ Iy0~ x2x : %M z 4 } %4|(} %v1y ~8v1w|( 'y0x ~ %x |(y}~y0x2: %z 4 } %4|(} %v1y ~8|( '{'{v1|w.x2|( 'y0}x ~ z ~ } %~4x<2|Nz v|(yx } 3"vy0v w |(} vy8~ x<|(~`x"Ex } |1 v {|} %I~ x> u vx ~ 8E 'y0: %z x (i, j, k) x{|;: %z } %|} %vy&:~8 vw| 'y x 0~ %x vv vyy >x A:~6y0vx ~ |(y *{%x2w|( %{'{|(.x X x"$ 'w x> 0 |(y *{%x2x 3 x1{%v10|({ (x,Ny,ijkz) vv vyy >x A:~6y0vx ~ |( *}4|(y Wx }Ax {|1z x wx y} x{|;W}~ z }~ x<|(~8w| '{'{|(N.ijk x X x"$ 'w>x A |(y *{xx , x21{%v0|{ 0|(vy v* {%x2vyy x 3>x Ax:1~6{%v1y00v|(x { ~ Nijk |(y *{%x2w|( %{'{|(.x Xrig x"$ 'w x> M{Qz)F|R:x<x{S|3v1~}x %}4|y z x2~6y v$x ~ N(x, y, vWx }<:~6y v$x ~ ;ijkz vv4vyy0 x ~*{|M. v1w } x2x2{|3v1~}x v v vyy >x A:~6y0vNx ~ N 0 x"$ %wy x A0|(y *{%x2x 3 x1{v0|({ (x, y, z) {|z x wx y} x x"$ %vy8 'yijk }x 3v{<|(~83v 'y$} 0 {|z x wx y} x}v1 %vy8 'y}x 3v{%@|(~63v1 'y} Nijk 0 |>Ivy8 xv10|(I|} %vy&x A {|z x wx y}4AxN{|;ijk vx"az %x y} EF|(wv} x wx y} :~64|N.vy&x4v0|(}|(}~ %z v}y ~x x A {|z x wx y}A x{|;W}~ z }~ x z %x y} EF|(wv} x wx y} x A {|z x wx y}4Ax}v1 %vy vx"|(a I %~ x V {|z x x wwx x y$y} }A| 'v}:~0x {Xy |(w; x2{Q 'y$}x WZ|1z x F I I~ '1|({%x y}|(~8 {|1z x wx y} $ '}~ x { δD x2{Q 'y}4x WZ|z>x S I 4|>| '{Xx>*S x ,v}4 L {%v1A:~& {|1z x wx y} δD u vwt x2E 'y}x WQ|z x AF vy}Ax>W} z vw3v1 x{xw| '{'F{|(Ix2~WZ|1z %I~ x I y}x WZ|1z xy$~w 4v l :~8w|( '{'{S|(.x<W~ WZ|z I~ x F I ¡ 1 ≤ l ≤ nI F 'x2 x{Q 'y$}x WQ|z x f¢ £ 'x2 x{|M0|(} %x2x2Il {Q 'y}4x WZ|z>x 'y0z {'~ x< |(y Il Vi £ |($z x y$}x2 x{Q 'y$}x WZ|1z x ¤ vv vyy >x Ax {%vy :~80I|(l $z x y$}x ~y G {|z x wx y}A '}~0x {E 'y$}x 3v1{%<|~63v %yl} G y vw|({K{Q 'y$}x WZ|1z x I l ¥ x x z z }}x x ~ ~ **~~y y ' '}4}4|(|( ' '44x l ¥x> %v1y8}4|(} I~ xx2}4x |(:y x .x z>y }x0|{Q * %y{%}xx W Q~| %z x x<Il ~*{Q 'y}x Z|z x Il ~6w| '{'{|(Ix2~WZ|1z %I~ x F I x<|vz %>x<{¦ 'y}x WZ|z x I ¥ v %w;z v1,v1 '}4<|(y:}x2y0}4||(w;yI %Ix ~0yx2} %x :{'~6{%x2 ~x % {| '}x x2~` ~ x2~A{Q l 'y}4x WZ|z>x I %z v1 '}<:y0|w; %I~0x2:~6 ~ % x<|($~& z x y}x2x2{|Mz>x {'{'~{%x@|(|z x y}4x l ¥M{Q 'y}4x WZ|z>x Il z x y$}x2 x{|;z x {'{'~ {%x<||z x y$}x<M{Q 'y}x WZ|z x I ~0||(yx} '.}2v{% ~xw;w %v1~ ~x<.|(x ~& l wx y} |~8z x y}x<x{|;z x {'{%~{%x<|1(|z x y}x< {¦§ 'y}x Z|z x I ~0|(y} '}2 xl wv1~.x wx y}Ax {vy ~x |(~&z x y}4x2x2{|Mz x {'{'~{%x@|(|1z x y}x § {Q 'y}4x WZ|z>x M ~0|(y} '}2 xIwl v1~.x wx y}Ax {vy ~y |(~&z x y}4x2x2{|Mz x {'{'~{%x@|(|1z x y}x §M{Q 'y}4x WZ|z>x ~0|(y} '}2 xIwl v1~.x wx y}Ax {vy ~z |(~&z x y}x2x2{|Mz>x {'{'~{%x@|(|z x y}4x § {Q 'y}4x WZ|z>x M. (x, y, z) (xrig ijk , yrig ijk , zrig ijk ) dijk 0 Nijk 0 , z0 ) (x0ijk , yijk ijk 0 ω θ0 r a ζ LF δDF δWF nIf Il Sl Sli Gl yl −→ δGl ~nl = (nlx , nly , nlz ) ~tl = (tlx , tly , tlz ) pl µl Vtl µc ρc → − (ρ V )c (ρu)c (ρv)c (ρw)c. Il.
(106) ¨. ©ª«¬ ® ¯°±²³¬ (ρe)c cc pc. ¼. ª1¯. Vtc. c. − → FF − → MF Cl Clp Cd Cdp. Ë@Ì0ÍSÎÏKÍPÌ ÐÑ Ò ÓÔ3Õ λf λs λkf. λks. 0¬ ³µ1¶%¬2±ª±4°(¯¬<°(²&® ¬ ±³¬2·¬2¯°M®>¬ ¯'¯'²¯%¬@°·(¸°® ¬ ±4¬<¹¯¦º ¶'±¬ ³W»Z°® ¬ ´ '¶ ±¬ ½½¬2·²8½ª&°²8® ¬ ±³¬<·¬¯°;® ¬ ¯'¯'² ¯%¬<°·¸°® ¬ ±¬<¹M¯Qº ¶'±4¬ ³W»Z°®>¬ Il ¼ ³¬>½½¶%ª18½±4°(±¶%¿I² ¬@°(²8® ¬ ±³¬<·¬¯°;® ¬ ¯'¯'² ¯%¬<°1·(¸°® ¬ ±¬<¹M¯Qº ¶'$±¬ ³W»Z°1® I¬ l ¾ ª¯'²«¬2·¬2¯°M®>¬ ¯'¯'²¯%¬@°·(¸°1® ¬ ±4¬<¹¯¦º ¶'±¬ ³»Z°® ¬ ¼ ³ª¸W¬ ® ±¶ª8· ¬¯°MÀ¶'±¬ ½½¬<°(²&® ¬ $±³¬2· ¬¯°;® ¬ ¯'¯'² I¯%l¬<°·¸°® ¬ $±¬<¹ ¯¦¾ º ¶'±¬ ³W»Z°® ¬ I ½²³A¯%¬À.¬ ® ±¬ ²³A±4°(µI¬ ± ¹;® ¬ ±±4¬2® ¬ ¯'¯'²¯%¬ ª«;«¬2·¬>½Al¬"Â,ª³±4½ °(Ãï'¶¿I² Ä ½ °²:Å_ ª$¬ ² · ½*·²6«a°(¶'¯'¯°(µI¬ F I Á ª«;«¬2·¬>½*«ª«¬ ±½ °(à ï'¶%¿I²0Ä ½ °(²:Å` ª¬ ²0·½A·:²8«°(¶'¯%¯°(µ.¬ FI Á ª¬"Ça® ¶%¬ $± °Ä ³ª$·:È °(«;¶%¿² ¬2·¬2Ã3ª³±B°( ® ¬ Æ ª¬"Ça® ¶%¬ $± °Ä ³ª$·:È °(«;¶%¿² ¬2·¬2Ã3ª³±B°( ® ¬2óª·²¶'±A²¶%¿I²0¬ «¬ ± ÃÆ °(³*¯%¬<®4É0°«;Ã8· ¬Ã³¬>½½¶%ª1 ® ¶%¬ $± °Ä ³ª$·:È °(«;¶%¿² ¬2·¬2±³4°RÊ Ä ¬ Æ ªª¬"¬"Ça Ça® ¶%¬ $± °Ä ³ª$·:È °(«;¶%¿² ¬2·¬2±³4°RÊ Ä ¬Ã ³ª·:² ¶'±*² ¶%¿I² ¬ «¬ ± ÃÆ °(³*¯%¬<®4É0°«;Ã8· ¬Ã³¬>½½¶%ª1. Il. ¬ ® ±¬ ²³ °·¸Wª¶'± ·¬±B°(¶'¯'¯%¬ ²¯¬ ³B×Vª1² (7n ) ÖZØAÙ © ×*°½½ª$® ¶%Ä ¼¹M¯°t»Zª ® ±¶ª8ªÚ¸W¬ ® ±¶Û» ¬ ± (5n cell ) Ö ´. ® ª ³ 4 ³. ¬ ½ 3 à ª. ·0°(±°(²8½È$½cell ±Ü «¬2·EºFÄ ¿I²0Á °±¶%ª ½ R J f ¬ ® ±¬ ²³ °·¸Wª¶'± ·¬±B°(¶'¯'¯%¬ °1½½ª$® ¶%Ä<¹M¯°t»ª1 ® ±¶%ª18ªÚ¸W¬ ® ±¶Û» J ¼¬ ±A® ª³³¬ ½Ã3ª0· °(±°(²8½È$½±Ü (2n p) «¬2·XºÄ ¿I² °(±¶%ª0½ R ¬ ® ±¬ ²³ °·¸Wª¶'± ·¬±B°(¶'¯'¯%¬ (5n ) Ö ²¯¬ ³B×Vª1² s(7n ) ÖZØAÙ © ×*°½½ª$® ¶%Ä ¼°²:Åa»ª1 ® ±¶ª ½A® ª1±³4°(¶'$±¬ ½ cell ´ ¬ ±A® ª³³cell ¬ ½Ã3ª0· °(± Á Gk Ý 1 ≤ k ≤ p Ý °²8½È$½±Ü «¬2·EºFÄ ¿I²0°±¶%ª ½ R f ¬ ® ±¬ ²³ °·¸Wª¶'± ·¬±B°(¶'¯'¯%¬ (2n °1½½ª$® ¶%Ä<°(²Åa»ª1 ® ±¶%ª1 ½A® ª±³4°(¶'$±¬ ½ G ¼ p) kÝ. ¬ A ±. ® ª ³ ³. ¬ ½ 3 à ª 0 . · ( ° ± ( ° 8 ² ½È$½±Ü «¬2·XºÄ ¿I²0°±¶%ª ½ R 1 ≤ k ≤ pÝ s.
(107) Þ6ßáàãâãäæåèçèéêàìëíäîß. 1.. ïãð*ñ òWó3ò4ðAôöõt÷öøtù,ð*úMû4üýîþ. ÿ
(108)
(109) ! #"$&%')(#(#$**+)
(110) -,. !
(111)
(112)
(113) 0/ (1 2 # 3""/+
(114) -
(115) 4 5
(116)
(117) (1
(118) 6/"+7 /1*)
(119) 98:"+ 5 +
(120)
(121) # 5
(122) 6/1; /*7 ! <"+ !8=> 5
(123) /?"+ #)<@> /*BACED ? "GFH
(124) /*I/* 5 J/! K
(125) "$)+L NM*%O"+!
(126) 7PQ6R S8 TAC *
(127) U VF $ !U 5 $
(128) '
(129) 6/'"+ ' (#+*+
(130) U W%NX 2020
(131) 6/# /Y / ? 8: ""+ ? [Z\X /?
(132) 6/E"$& )""/*$
(133) ]
(134) ^_ /[ (1B24 50% 80% x
(135) ` %U *
(136) + 5
(137) 6/1 Y""+ #Ab^AG &cd"GFe)(
(138) 6//+
(139) f )
(140) */
(141) 6/` g * -Q9 )h 50%
(142) _iba L G8j k (# "+)8l` " kL )<"+Y
(143) 6/*@*
(144) 5 + /E 5 *" i 2007 2008 + 105% m*m a noFH
(145) )@> 7
(146) */**+ "jL "p ) 5
(147) 6/N 3
(148) \"+ q 5 +
(149)
(150) q */N
(151) W <"+#rAb<*$L q !q 5 +)
(152) (
(153) U )""
(154) /N /N VFH "+/s/*+)
(155) ^ " N )
(156) (#$L ÿ U )
(157) cE N<@>! /*BAC!8"GFt /*(1+/*+
(158) \AC*(1!) 6 R6
(159) (1+L !\ )W"+ W Ku # a !""$ # /W"+? 3
(160) 6/ # $>+h #
(161) u*/*+ "+ v8 !
(162) */*/*\
(163) `(1vR
(164) ` "$A a jn 1! K sK k qAb*(1!w 6 R6
(165) (#+L J) /*("+ J */J
(166) x )(
(167) (Y
(168) 6/
(169)
(170) 6/\
(171) +
(172) x
(173) / "$
(174) */E */W * k"+w k"$Y
(175) /*$
(176) d VFt 5 +
(177) J/
(178)
(179) $L \ /\*
(180) +L !?iC )
(181) 6/w"+ 3 >AC(
(182) ! E) 6 R6
(183) (1+L !2 )E E (Y
(184) !k 5 "'
(185) 6/k/*h k
(186) >+<"+ ?y Ku
(187) 9 (
(188) 6/E Ab*(1 %U /*/\ *
(189) +h w )/N /N */N
(190) )w (#
(191) w U"+\ 5 >4GAb\ /U"GFH *$
(192) \ U
(193) 9 4
(194) + = ma N
(195) ! /*+)
(196) ,.""+U!Ft R6/ o""+ =*"GFt
(197) "RU >Ab*(
(198) = VF
(199) ?
(200) (E<' >4 /
(201) 6/= OAC*( = 6 a R
(202) (#$L : !"I<"+ (
(203) 6/= "+ /+
(204)
(205) ! noFH = '"$J*(E"$/+
(206) ?
(207) 6( *+L 3J"$1 )"/*+)
(208) _ J!L /+
(209) w 2"$1(1! !
(210) +L6 k Tz + wa 1
(211) _ 9**< "+2"+k 5 "+ 3 (1
(212) / ^"GFH /*+(#+/*$
(213) {
(214) 6( *+L ^ [AC*(198/*h # ( /*/ ^
(215) ]/ *(17 pFt "+ /+
(216) g { * ?
(217) /+
(218) np? < "+h (1# ? !
(219) /*+
(220) 0 */W )
(221) *+ ? \
(222) kAC)*(1?(/*K (/+L ? " W) (
(223) q*(# "D a #r
(224) ` K sK cE / (#
(225) U
(226) `
(227) (k<"$\ w u(h /* q wAC*()8 /*+(#+
(228) 6/N
(229) Ab
(230) /*$
(231) x)<@> /*BAJiC9
(232) "+ (
(233) 6/w"$/*}|+
(234) //\
(235) d/*+>Ab+
(236) /J
(237) x
(238) (k<"+E E
(239) /*
(240) / %U a Ab
(241) /*$
(242) .
(243)
(244) 6/.K< /* "+"+ (1
(245) 6/. U"Iwm
(246) q *R*/h (198) ! /*/q
(247) +h q /
(248) 6/.9 5 *
(249) N
(250) `*R*/h (W "+W pFH L u/*+
(251) q + /*+
(252) 6/T q L u/*+
(253) T7 * 5 N */*+ ""$ ~
(254) *G86 h o"+q(1"+ Y '
(255)
(256) ! 8 o+
(257) 9
(258) $ O T"$Z ~ P ~
(259) /O (1(1
(260) !a JcW/"+ !89"$ 1970 w"$E
(261) /+
(262) 7 VFt)
(263) AC!8"+ N/*+"+U \>+(k"$/*+
(264) ^
(265) (1 +L w 3U"$k( !
(266) +L \ Oz+ !N +
(267) d E * \ VFH /*(#$/*+
(268) kAC*([!)8:v)83v8!)8V ) 8V!8!) nj \ )
(269) D ) /*+)
(270) /* +! ^ /+
(271) 6/^*(# "+ i D "+^ VFt"+ !8oAC)*(1x
(272) "$
(273) 5 " /["+!Y(a 6 h "+ 7 R6
(274) 4 m Ab< "+&D "/ nj YAC*( (1+L !Y/"+ [ ^*(E"+ ["+x !(# 3*/ (
(275) 6/^ z+ x /+
(276) /^ & ) /*(Y"+ k /s+
(277) 6/?"+k / (#
(278) ! 2 E 2( /*K 6 k VFH) /*(#$/*+
(279) "+6 !"+!Ft a R
(280) 6/k*k"+ 9 +
(281) 6/Wi(1 /*K 6 ' w
(282) 6/ 4=(1 /*K6 '<+
(283) 7 / !UY !U^"+J
(284) )(k<w J s(1h / NAC)*(1J */o(1 /
(285) 6/ nj o)s m +
(286) /O oAC
(287) /*+
(288) O)<@> /*BAp /O )
(289) 6/*
(290) 6/ O O 3*/U1 4 (h /*!N9 5 *
(291) u
(292) 6/q"$EACa *(2 6 R6
(293) (1+L W !
(294) *+ )8
(295) ! J` 6 ! >q VFH) /*(1+/*+
(296) j8 /+
(297) /o 5 " . ."$\(1 /*K 6 q o B3
(298) ! D
(299) + ,.
(300) D
(301) j89* " "+q (1 */ (1
(302) /O R6
(303) (#+L &"$0AC(1d
(304) u/*$L x //[ *$[
(305) (# / a h Y"+ ^
(306)
(307) ! 8O"$0 +
(308) x ^ !"+ 4 1980 ' a "$/ Y
(309) f 9**< "+`"GF /"+/*+)
(310) `(16 h "+ [ 6 R6
(311) (#+L Y `K /7D "/iC L6/*+)
(312) pFH,."+ !8o &Zw 5 + >4>P6/Q9!1(1vR
(313)
(314) ! 3"GFH /*(#+/+
(315) f
(316) 6( *+L ` ^Ab*(1 ; (1&*G8o h m . a 83P<$ *!
(317) *Q6B4>P<$ *Q6't) v=1(#$wx Dd"$ )(#(k
(318) u/E \ 6 R6
(319) u(#+ +
(320) w VF +
(321) ". 1986. .
Documents relatifs