an attempt of time calibration of the Lower Tournaisian (Hastarian Substage) based on orbitally forced sequences

0123415267158 638  763 371651 51 734 54716347 7 1742341 71515  747 7 !"#$%

&

'()

*+,

-.

.

/01.

,

23

,

.

4

0/,

5-6

4

78-.

4

2+,

23

,

.

9/,

:2;/8,

<2=8+-4

>4

-+,

?

@->.

-84

-+,

A=7>.

-B/C

,

7->/D,

2+,

2874

.

-6

6

E,

3

285/D,

>/F=/+5/>,

H

L

NO

L

P

L

VO

W

X

L

[O

\

]

^_`ab%cd%efgbh_ahghi`d%f_`jfgd%da%kljf`_dm%^_`ndop`ab%cd%q`ridm%sggbd%cl%t%fhuam%vwa`jd_a%vxym%zfoa{|`gjf_m%v%}~~~% q`rid%xm%vdgi`ljm%deha€lgif‚ƒd%„%ƒjhaad…l`_lgif‚ƒd%„%†lg`d_cd_f€dolgif‚ƒd%%

] ‡ˆG‰Š‹ŒŽ‹‘ŠG ’“”]•–—˜–™š–›]œž—˜–Ÿ”] ¡™™”—¢¡›£]˜¡]˜“”]¤¡¥”™]£š¦š—š¡›]š›]§”¤Ÿš¨]–›£]–£©– ”›˜]–™”–—]ª«¬­0]”˜]–¤®] ¯°±±²•³­´ µ ¶¬·]¸¹¹º»®]’“š™£¼¡™£”™]—”½”› ”—]–™”]¥”¤¤]¨–™¾”£]š›]˜“”]’¡™›–š—š–›]–›£]¿š—À–›]¡Á]˜“”] §”¤Ÿš–›]–¨™¼Ãš›–›˜]§–—š›]–›£]¥”™”]˜“”]ž–—”]Á¡™]˜“”]™”¦š—”£]—”½”› ”]—˜™–˜šŸ™–¢“Ä]¡Á]˜“”]Ś——š——š¢¢š–›] ¡Á]•³­´]”˜]–¤®]ª¸¹¹¸»®]ƛ¦”—˜šŸ–˜š¡›—]š›]˜¥¡]—” ˜š¡›—]š›]˜“”]ڛ–›˜]¦š š›š˜Ä]]£š—¢¤–Äš›Ÿ] ¡›˜š›¡—]¥”¤¤] ¥”–˜“”™”£]—” ˜š¡›—]¼]˜“”]™–š¤¥–Ä] ˜˜š›Ÿ]–˜]ǔ›£™¡›¼«”¤¤”—]–›£]˜“”]˜¡›—]½–™™Ä]š›]œ¢¡›˜š›]È]—“¡¥]˜“–˜] ˜“”]¤¡¥”™]’¡™›–š—š–›]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”]˜“š™£¼¡™£”™]—”½”› ”—]¯²]˜“”]—”½”› ”]¸]ªÉšŸ®¯»]–›£]˜“”]¤¡¥”™]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”] —”½”› ”]ʲ]–™”]£š¦š£”£]š›]—“¡™˜”™]—”½”› ”—®]§” –—”]¡Á]˜“”š™]™”¤–˜š¦”]™”Ÿ¤–™]£š—˜™šž˜š¡›²]˜“”š™]˜“š ¾›”——²] –›£]˜“”]Á– ˜]˜“”Ä]–™”]›¡˜]Ÿ™¡¢”£]š›]ž›£¤”—²]˜“”—”]—”½”› ”—]–™”] ¡›—š£”™”£]–—]£”]˜¡]¡›¤Ä]¡›”]¡™žš˜–¤] ¢–™–¨”˜”™] ¡™™”—¢¡›£š›Ÿ]˜¡]¢™” ”——š¡›] Ä ¤”—®]] ] ˈGÌÍΐŒ‘Ï‹‘ŠGЊŽGŽ‘΋Œ‘я‹‘ŠGÒGŒÑ‘‹ÐÓÓÔGҍŒÍŽGÎÍՏ͊ÍÎG ’“”]—”½”› ”—]¦–™™Ä]Á™¡¨]–¤˜”™›–˜š¡›—]¡Á]—“–¤”]–›£] –¤ –™”¡—]—“–¤”]ª¨–š›¤Ä]š›]˜“”]¶¡›˜]£Öי ¡¤”] É¡™¨–˜š¡›]Øɨٻ]˜¡]–¤˜”™›–˜š¡›—]¡Á] –¤ —“–¤”]–›£]¤š¨”—˜¡›”]ª¨–š›¤Ä]š›]˜“”]•–—˜šÚ™”]ɨ»²]–›£]˜¡]¤š¨”—˜¡›”] ž”£]£¡¨š›–˜”£]ª¨–š›¤Ä]š›]˜“”]¢¢”™]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”]ۖ›£”¤š”—]ɨ»®]’“”š™]˜“š ¾›”——]¦–™š”—]Á™¡¨]–ž¡˜]¹®¸]¨]˜¡]¯] ¨²]–›£]š—]—˜™¡›Ÿ¤Ä]š›Á¤”› ”£]ž¡˜“]žÄ]˜“”]—”£š¨”›˜]¢™¡£ ˜š¡›]–›£]žÄ]˜“”] ¡¨¢– ˜š¡›]š›]˜“”]–™Ÿš¤¤– ”¡—] ¤”¦”¤—]–›£]¢™”——š¡›]£š——¡¤˜š¡›]š›]˜“”]¤š¨”—˜¡›”]¤”¦”¤—®]’“”]£š—˜™šž˜š¡›]¡Á]˜“”š™]—”£š¨”›˜–™Ä]›–˜™”]Á¡¤¤¡¥—] ˜“”]—”£š¨”›˜–™Ä]”¦¡¤˜š¡›]¡Á]˜“”]˜“š™£¼¡™£”™]—”½”› ”—]¯]˜¡]Ê]£”— ™šž”£]žÄ]•³­´]”˜]–¤®]ª¸¹¹¸»®] ’™› –˜š¡›—]–˜]˜“”]˜¡¢]¡Á]˜“”]—”½”› ”—]š›£š –˜š›Ÿ]”¨”™—š¡›] –›]¡  ™]£™š›Ÿ]˜“”]¤¡¥¼—˜–›£]ªÛœ’»]–›£]˜“”] Á–¤¤š›Ÿ¼—˜–Ÿ”]—Ä—˜”¨]˜™– ˜—]ªÉɜ’»]¡Á]˜“”]˜“š™£¼¡™£”™]—”½”› ”—®]’“”Ä]–™”]›¡˜]¨–™¾”£]£™š›Ÿ]˜“”] ˜™–›—Ÿ™”——š¦”]ª’œ’»]–›£]“šŸ“¼—˜–›£]—Ä—˜”¨]˜™– ˜—]ª•œ’»²]—ŸŸ”—˜š›Ÿ]™”¤–˜š¦”¤Ä]¤¡¥]”—˜–˜š ]¦–™š–˜š¡›—]–˜]˜“”] — –¤”]¡Á]˜“”—”]—”½”› ”—®] ’“”]¤¡¥”™]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”]ǔ›£™¡›¼«”¤¤”—]—” ˜š¡›]–¤¤¡¥—]˜¡]—˜£Ä]˜“”]¡™žš˜–¤¤Ä¼Á¡™ ”£]—”½”› ”—]š›]˜“”] •–—˜šÚ™”]ɨ]ª•œ’]–›£]ɜœ’]¡Á]˜“”]˜“š™£¼¡™£”™]—”½”› ”]¯²]–›£]ۜ’]¡Á]˜“”]—”½”› ”]¸»²]–¤¨¡—˜]Á™¡¨]˜“”] ž–—”]¡Á]˜“”]’¡™›–š—š–›®]’“”]¤–˜”™]š—]¢¤– ”£]©—˜]–ž¡¦”]˜“”]¯®±º]¨¼˜“š ¾]¤š¨”—˜¡›”]ž”£]¨–™¾š›Ÿ]˜“”]ž–—”]¡Á] ˜“”]•–—˜šÚ™”]ɨ®]’“–˜]—” ˜š¡›]š—] ¡¨¢¤”˜”£]žÄ]˜“”]œ¢¡›˜š›]—” ˜š¡›]¥“š “]–¤¤¡¥—]˜¡]—˜£Ä]˜“”]—”½”› ”—]š›] ˜“”]¢¢”™]¨”¨ž”™]ª¨ž™»]¡Á]˜“”]•–—˜šÚ™”]ɨ]ªÛœ’]¡Á]˜“”]—”½”› ”]¸»²]˜“”]¶¡›˜]£Öי ¡¤”]ɨ]ª’œ’]¡Á]˜“”] —”½”› ”]¸»²]˜“”]ۖ›£”¤š”—]ɨ]ª•œ’]–›£]ɜœ’]¡Á]˜“”]—”½”› ”]¸»²]–›£]˜“”]ܦ¡š™]ɨ]ªÛœ’]–›£]’œ’]¡Á]˜“”] —”½”› ”]Ê»]š›]¥“š “]š—]—š˜–˜”£]˜“”]ž–—”]¡Á]˜“”]Ʀ¡™š–›]œž—˜–Ÿ”]ªž–—”]¡Á]Ý¢¢”™]’¡™›–š—š–›²]ž–—”]¡Á] Þßàáâãäåæçèéêßëëçãìèéêäíìãä]”»®] ƛ]˜“”]ǔ›£™¡›¼«”¤¤”—]—” ˜š¡›²]˜“”]¯®±ï]¨¼˜“š ¾]˜“š›¼ž”££”£]¤š¨”—˜¡›”]›š˜]—š˜–˜”£]©—˜]–ž¡¦”]˜“”] Ô¦¡›š–›¼«–™ž¡›šÁ”™¡—]ž¡›£–™Ä]£¡”—]›¡˜]—“¡¥]–›Ä]˜™– ”]¡Á]™Ä˜“¨š ]£”¢¡—š˜—®]’“¡—”]¡›”—]£”¦”¤¡¢]–ž¡¦”] š˜]–›£]ʯ]—”½”› ”—]¥”™”] ¡›˜”£]š›]˜“”]™”—˜]¡Á]˜“”]¤¡¥”™]¨ž™]¡Á]˜“”]•–—˜šÚ™”]ɨ®]¡›”]¥–—]™” ¡Ÿ›šð”£]š›] ˜“”]Ê®ºï]¨¼˜“š ¾]¨–——š¦”]¤š¨”—˜¡›”]¡Á]˜“”]¨š££¤”]¨ž™]¥“š “]¨–™¾—]˜“”]˜¡¢]¡Á]˜“”]—”½”› ”]¯]ªÉœœ’»®]§¡˜“] ˜“”]ǔ›£™¡›¼«”¤¤”—]–›£]˜“”]œ¢¡›˜š›]—” ˜š¡›—]—“¡¥]¯ï]—”½”› ”—]š›]˜“”]¢¢”™]¨ž™] ¡™™”—¢¡›£š›Ÿ]˜¡]˜“”]ۜ’] ¡Á]˜“”]—”½”› ”]¸®]ƛ]˜“”]œ¢¡›˜š›]—” ˜š¡›²]¸ñ]—”½”› ”—] ¡¨¢¡—”]˜“”]¶¡›˜]£Öי ¡¤”]ɨ]ª’œ’]¸»²]¸ò]˜“”] ¤¡¥”™]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”]ۖ›£”¤š”—]ɨ]ª•œ’]¸»²]–›£]¸º]˜“”]¢¢”™]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”]Á¡™¨–˜š¡›]ªÉœœ’]¸»®]ʯ] ¡¨¢¡—”]˜“”] ¤¡¥”™]¢–™˜]¡Á]˜“”]ܦ¡š™]ɨ]ªÛœ’]–›£]’œ’]Ê»]›˜š¤]˜“”]•–—˜–™š–›óƦ¡™š–›]ž¡›£–™Ä]ªÛ¡¥”™óÝ¢¢”™] ’¡™›–š—š–›]ž¡›£–™Ä»®] ]

0123415267158 638  763 371651 51 734 54716347 7 1742341 71515  747 7 !"#$

%

&

&

&

'()&

*+,-../01.,23,4567895.72:,

;<=>?@=A=BBCDE>AFAG=B>HI@F>J<@DKL<>JCM=>IEN>I@=>KBKIGGF>ADEBCN=@=N>IB>O=CEL>EDJ>KB=PKG>PD@>I>JCM=> AIGCO@IJCDEQ>RKJ>IAAD@NCEL>JD>RSTST>=J>IGQ>UVWXWYZ>J<=>?@=A=BBCDE>AFAG=B>PD@>J<=>[D\=@>;DK@EICBCIE>I@=>

IODKJ>V]>IEN>^_Q^>`IZ>IEN>CJ>CB>?DBBCOG=>JD>ADEBCN=@>VXQa>`I>IB>I>@DKL<>IH=@IL=>PD@>J<=C@>NK@IJCDEQ>bE> IEDJ<=@><IENZ>IAAD@NCEL>JD>c0S>U^__WY>\<D>AIGCO@IJ=N>J<=>J<@==>GIBJ>J<C@NdD@N=@>B=eK=EA=B>DP>J<=>fCBgIE>

JD>^Qh>iI>IEN>ADEBCN=@=N>J<IJ>J<=F>ADKGN>AD@@=B?DEN>JD>=jA=EJ@CACJF>AFAG=BZ>\=>ADEBCN=@>J<IJ>J<=> ;DK@EICBCIE>DE=B>IGBD>ADKGN>GIBJ>IODKJ>^Qh>iIQ>;<=@=PD@=>J<=>Wk>?@=A=BBCDE>B=eK=EA=B>@=ADLECl=N>CE>J<=> J<C@NdD@N=@>B=eK=EA=>^>ADKGN>@=?@=B=EJ>VQ]k>iIZ>BKLL=BJCEL>J<IJ>J<=>=@DBCDE>BK@PIA=B>MI@mCEL>J<=>B=eK=EA=> ODKENI@C=B>O=J\==E>B=eK=EA=>V>IEN>^Z>IEN>^>IEN>kZ>ADKGN>AD@@=B?DEN>JD>LI?B>IB>GDEL>IB>IODKJ>_Qa]>iI>CP> \=>ADEBCN=@>I>BCMCGI@>EKMO=@>DP>?@=A=BBCDE>B=eK=EA=B>CE>ODJ<>B=eK=EA=B>V>IEN>kQ>>

nDZ>ADEBCN=@CEL>J<=>NK@IJCDE>DP>J<=>kV>?@=A=BBCDE>B=eK=EA=B>CE>J<=>oIBJI@CIE>?I@J>DP>J<=>J<C@NdD@N=@> B=eK=EA=>VZ>CQ=Q>_Qp]]>iI>UEDJ>CEAGKNCEL>J<=>KEmED\E>JCM=>AD@@=B?DENCEL>JD>J<=>VQ]p>MdJ<CAm>KECJ>IJ>J<=> OIB=>IEN>J<=>kQap>MdJ<CAm>KECJ>IJ>J<=>JD?YZ>q>>_Qa]>iIZ>q>VQ]k>iIZ>q>_Qa]>iIZ>q>kV>B=eK=EA=B>CE>J<=> oIBJI@CIE>?I@J>DP>J<=>J<C@NdD@N=@>B=eK=EA=>kZ>CQ=Q>_Qp]]>iIZ>\=>DOJICE>hQ^^h>iI>IB>I>?DBBCOG=>NK@IJCDE>PD@> J<=>oIBJI@CIEQ>rDJ=>J<IJZ>IAAD@NCEL>JD>iSss0s>=J>IGQ>U^__VYZ>J<=>oIBJI@CIE>GIBJ=N>PD@>IODKJ>a>iIQ>

t>@=PCE=M=EJ>DP>J<IJ>M=J<DN>IEN>J<=>=jJ=EBCDE>DP>J<=>@=ADLECJCDE>DP>D@OCJIGGF>PD@A=N>B=eK=EA=B>JD>J<=> uHD@CIE>nKOBJIL=>Uv??=@>;DK@EICBCIEY>?DBBCOGF>ADKGN>ADEJ@COKJ=>JD>I>O=JJ=@>N=PCECJCDE>DP>CJB>G=ELJ<>IEN>DP> J<=>DE=>DP>J<=>;DK@EICBCIE>nJIL=Q>>>

> w/3/9/:4/x, yz{|z{}~€}~‚ƒ„{z}~…€†€‡~ˆ‰Šˆ{}‹Œ€}‹ŽŽ€‹‘’“”•”‘–‹—˜‹‘™š‹’›‘œ——ž”Ÿ’•‹˜œš ¡šŸ”š›‹—¢šœ‹‘™š‹£’œ‘™¤›‹™”›‘—œ–‹˜—œ‹ ¥’•š—Ÿ•”ž’‘š‹›‘¡¦”š›€‹§‹Ÿ”šŸš}‹¨©©ª‹«¬­§«¬¬€‹‹ ®‚¯°±}~²€}~³{‚z‰‰z¯‰}~£€‡~´°{±z„}‹µ€}‹Ž¶¶€‹·—¡¢š••š‹Ÿ™’œ‘š‹›‘œ’‘”¸œ’¥™” ¡š‹¦¡‹¹”’‘”š‹‘–¥š‹¦š‹•’‹yš•¸” ¡š€‹§‹ ’•š›‹¦š‹•’‹—Ÿ”º‘º‹¸º—•—¸” ¡š‹¦¡‹·—œ¦}‹»¼ª‹½¬½§½¶€‹ ³°±z‰}‹´€£€}‹­­Ž€‹¾œ“”‘’•‹˜—œŸ”¸‹’¦‹…”››”››”¥¥”’‹›š’‹•š¢š•‹Ÿ™’¸š‹ª‹‘”žš‹¦šœ”š›‹’’•–›”›‹—˜‹ž’œ”š‹˜•——¦”¸‹š¢š‘›‹ ”‹‘™š‹¿”›º’‹À”¦›—œ‹³œ—¡¥‹—˜‹š’›‘šœ‹®’’¦’‹’¦‹”ž¥•”Ÿ’‘”—›‹˜—œ‹³—¦Á’’‹¸•’Ÿ”’‘”—€‹§‹y¡••š‘”‹—˜‹ ®’’¦”’‹¥š‘œ—•š¡ž‹¸š—•—¸–}‹©Â‹ÃÄŪ‹ÄϧĶ€‹ µˆ¯Æz}~€}~´‚„Ç}~£€~‡€~µˆ‰„ˆ{°ˆ¯‹”‹¹zȂ¯|Éz}‹€}‹Ã£¦€Å€­­¬€~®¡œœš‘‹›‘’‘¡›‹—˜‹Ÿ™œ——›‘œ’‘”¸œ’¥™”Ÿ‹¡”‘›‹’žš¦‹ ˜œ—ž‹yš•¸”¡ž‹’¦‹’¦Ê’Ÿš‘‹’œš’›€‹§‹³š—•—¸”Ÿ’‹yš•¸”Ÿ’}‹»‹Ã§Åª‹§¬€‹‹ µˆ¯Æz}~€}~´‚„Ç}~£€‡~¹z˃lj„}‹†€Ì€}‹­­€‹š ¡šŸš‹›‘œ’‘”¸œ’¥™–‹—˜‹‘™š‹yš•¸”’‹—Ášœ‹®’œ“—”˜šœ—¡›‹§‹‹‘š‘’‘”¢š‹ Ÿ—œœš•’‘”—‹Á”‘™‹‘™š‹yœ”‘”›™‹Í›•š›€‹Î‹Íªµ°±±‰}~€¿€}~µz¯Ïz{‰‚¯}~®€…€‡~yˆÐÑz{}‹£€À€‹Ã£¦›€Å}‹®’œ“—”˜šœ—¡›‹ ’¦‹´šœž”’‹—˜‹‘™š‹À—œ•¦}‹®’’¦”’‹—Ÿ”š‘–‹—˜‹´š‘œ—•š¡ž‹³š—•—¸”›‘›}‹…šž—”œ}Ò»ª‹Ä§«€‹ …z¯¯°¯|}~…€}~ÀzÇz{}~¹€}~¹{‚ÓÏÓzԉŠ°}~³€‡~Àz¯Ï„}‹Í€}‹­­€‹…—œš‹œ’¦”—žš‘œ”Ÿ‹’¸š›‹˜—œ‹‘™š®’œ“—”˜šœ—¡›‹‘”žš‹ ›Ÿ’•š€‹‹§‹·šÁ›•š‘‘šœ‹—‹®’œ“—”˜šœ—¡›‹‘œ’‘”¸œ’¥™–}‹Ò»ª‹¬§Õ€‹ > >

0123415267158 638  763 371651 51 734 54716347 7 1742341 71515  747 7 !"#$%

&

'()

,-./+01%234567889%:;3<=>%?=@A=B<=?%CD%6;%EF%5B%6G=%HIJ%;:%6G=%6G53>K;3>=3%?=@A=B<=%LM%8;N=3%O736%;:%6G=%P7B>=85=?%QRM% H7?67357BS%TA6;B?%@A7339M%IO;B65B1%

* *